sign in sign up
<<
Home , Aush, Denkard, Hushang, Magi, Tahmuras

NUTRITION WERE ANCIENT ZOROASTRIANS & ARYANS VEGETARIAN?

K. E. Eduljee

First Aryan jashn, feast, in legend. King & the Feast of celebrating the discovery of fire. . manuscript of 's

(Metropolitan Museumof Art). Image: In In Tahmasp Image: Attributed to Artist Sultan Muhammad, , c. 1530 CE

NUTRITION WERE ANCIENT ZOROASTRIANS & ARYANS VEGETARIAN?

(ABRIDGED)

K. E. Eduljee

Zoroastrian Heritage Monographs

First edition published, September 2014. This second edition published, March 2015 by K. E. Eduljee West Vancouver, BC, Canada

This monograph is dedicated to the memory of my mother Katayun Eduljee née Katayun Kaikhoshro . Her brother, Darius Kaikhoshro Irani’s exemplary life-style choices inspired its writing.

The monograph has been published in two versions: 1. Complete version with notations and source texts, 2. Abridged version without notations and source texts.

For further enquiries and pdf or printed copies: [email protected] www.zoroastrianheritage.com

This pdf copy in full form may be distributed freely.

© K. E. Eduljee No part of this book may be reproduced in any other form without permission from the author, except for the quotation of brief passages in citation.

Zoroastrian Heritage Monographs

CONTENTS

GLOSSARY ...... vi IS THE TERM ‘ZOROASTRIAN’ ZOROASTRIAN? ...... 1 THE MAGI ...... 2 PART I RESEARCH & DISCUSSION...... 3 1. WAS ZARATHUSHTRA A VEGETARIAN? ...... 3 A. Zarathushtra’s Diet of Cheese ...... 3 (i) Cheese, No Meat, Moderation, Self-Control & Shunning Gluttony ...... 3 B. Zarem Raoghna – Soul Food ...... 4 C. Mid-Spring Milk, Clarified Butter & Cheese...... 4 D. Cheese & – an Ancient Tradition Survives ...... 5 (i) Unleavened Bread from Barley ...... 6 E. Sustenance in Winter ...... 6 (i) Gahanbars & Jashns – Mutual Help and Caring ...... 7 F. Zarathushtra’s ...... 9 (i) King Jamsheed as the Originator of the Sin of Meat Eating ...... 9 (ii) Lament of Geush Urvan & Animals...... 9 (iii) Tradition of Aryan/Iranian Poets & Gathic Poetry ...... 10 (iv) Allegory in the Geush Urvan Gatha...... 10 (v) Geush & Gospand...... 11 (vi) Soul of Animals...... 11 2. ANCIENT ARYANS WERE GATHERERS. BUT WERE THEY HUNTERS?...... 12 A. Legends Preserved in Ferdowsi’s Shahnameh...... 12 (i) Aryan Stone Age – Age of Gaya Maretan & Gathering Foods...... 12 (ii) Aryan Metal Age – Age of Hushang & Agriculture ...... 12 (iii) Seduction of by ’s Cooking ...... 14 3. INTRODUCTION OF MEAT EATING AFTER THE ARAB CONQUEST ...... 16 4. STAGES OF CONSUMPTION AT THE BEGINNING & END OF HUMAN HISTORY ...... 17 5. ACHAEMENID ERA PRACTICES OF THE MAGI ...... 17 A. Different Norms for Different Orders of the Magi ...... 17 B. Changing Mores ...... 18 6. CALL TO BE VEGETARIANS IN SASANIAN ERA MEDIEVAL ZOROASTRIAN TEXTS ...... 18 A. Sasanian Head Priest Adarbad Mahraspandan...... 18 B. Hudinan Peshobay Head Priest Adarbad Emedan ...... 19 (i) Beneficent Vegetarian Animals & Nature’s Bounty...... 19 7. MODERN NORMS...... 19 A. Shift in Norms ...... 20 8. PRINCIPLE OF MODERATION ...... 20 9. PRINCIPLES OF CIRCUMSPECTION, RIGHTNESS & BENEFICENCE ...... 20 PART II REFERENCES...... 21 1. ZOROASTRIAN SCRIPTURES & TEXTS...... 21 2. OTHER SCRIPTURES & RELIGIOUS TEXTS ...... 21 3. CLASSICAL & MEDIEVAL TEXTS...... 22 4. SCHOLARLY TEXTS ...... 22

5. HEALTH & COOKING REFERENCES ...... 24 6. ZOROASTRIAN HERITAGE WEBPAGE REFERENCES ...... 25 A. General Pages ...... 25 B. Health & Healing Pages...... 25 PART III APPENDICES...... 26 1. PANEER & ROGHAN IN ARYANA’S HISTORY & TRADITIONS...... 26 A. & Butter ...... 26 B. Traditional Iranian & Afghan Milk Processing...... 27 C. Clarified Butter as Payment in Medieval Iran...... 27 D. Milk Products in Kafiristan ...... 27 E. Ghee in Hindu Tradition...... 29 (i) Ghee in the Panchamritha Foods of Immortality ...... 29 (ii) Ghee in the Homa Ceremony ...... 29 (iii) Ghee in Ayurvedic Healing...... 29 2. MILK’S COMPOSITION ...... 30 A. Milk – a Food Designed by Nature...... 30 B. Milk Vitamins...... 30 C. Milk Minerals ...... 30 D. Milk Proteins...... 31 (i) Make-up of Proteins. Amino Acids ...... 31 (ii) Essential Amino Acids. Milk has all Nine...... 31 (iii) Digestion of Proteins...... 31 (iv) Solubility of Proteins...... 32 (v) Classification of Milk Proteins ...... 32 (a) Caseins...... 32 (b) Whey proteins ...... 32 (c) Enzymes ...... 32 E. Milk Fats...... 33 (i) Composition of Milk Fats...... 33 (ii) Fat Digestion ...... 33 iii) Fats’ Ability or Inability to Mix with Water...... 34 3. CREAM, CHEESE & CLARIFIED BUTTER ...... 35 A. Cream ...... 35 B. Cheese – Paneer/Panir ...... 35 (i) Making Paneer. Curds...... 35 (ii) Rennet/Rennin...... 35 (iii) Whey...... 36 (iv) Using Cream, , Whole or Skimmed Milk ...... 36 (v) Straining ...... 36 (vi) Squeezing out the Water...... 37 (vii) Topli nu Paneer ...... 37 (viii) Lactose in Cheese...... 37 (ix) in Cheese ...... 37 (x) Plain Paneer ...... 38 C. Butter & Buttermilk ...... 38 D. Clarified Butter – Roghan ...... 38 (i) Healing Properties of Clarified Butter ...... 39

E. Clarified Butter – Ghee...... 39 4. HEALTH RISKS & BENEFITS...... 40 A. Milk Fats. Fact & Myth. Risks & Benefits ...... 40 (i) Fat Facts ...... 40 (ii) Harvard & National Inst. for Health. Study on Fats’ Risks ...... 40 (iii) Benefits of Fats with Butyric Acid Residues...... 41 B. Cheese/Paneer. Risks & Benefits ...... 42 (i) Risks...... 42 (ii) Benefits ...... 43 (a) Study: No Rise in LDL ...... 43 (b) Nutrient Content & Benefits ...... 43 (c) Dental Health...... 44 (d) Appetite Suppression. Help to Avoid Overeating? ...... 44 (e) Cheese Improves Sleep & Reduces Stress...... 44 C. Mediterranean Diet & Cheese...... 44

()

TIPS USING ADOBE READER

Using Read Mode Using the Drop Down Menu Using Keys (PC) Task & Mouse Press Start Read Mode View > Read Mode Ctrl and H Change pages Mouse over center-bottom of PgDn screen to reveal control bar PgUp

Change and zoom pages Mouse over center-bottom of Enlarge: Ctrl and + screen to reveal control bar Shrink: Ctrl and - Go to first page Ctrl and Home Go to last page Ctrl and End Exit Read Mode View > Read Mode Esc

Using Full Screen Mode Using the Drop Down Menu Using Keys (PC) Task & Mouse Press Start Full Screen Reading View > Full Screen Mode Ctrl and L Next page Left click mouse or advance PgDn scroll wheel Previous page Right click mouse or retreat PgUp scroll wheel Enlarge page Ctrl and advance scroll wheel Ctrl and + Shrink page Ctrl and retreat scroll wheel Ctrl and - Exit Read Mode View > Read Mode Esc

Were Ancient Zoroastrians & Aryans iv K. E. Eduljee Vegetarian? July 2011-March 2015

ABOUT THIS MONOGRAPH

This monograph is part of a set of works by this author on nutrition, health and healing as described in ancient and medieval Zoroastrian texts. It is based on his blog posted in 2011. Links to his other nutrition, health and healing pages are provided in Part II of this monograph.

()

Were Ancient Zoroastrians & Aryans v K. E. Eduljee Vegetarian? July 2011-March 2015 Glossary

GLOSSARY

Achaemenian - See Achaemenid.

Achaemenid - The dynasty of Persian kings who became the king- of-kings, the overlords, of Aryana and then established the largest empire the world had known until then, the Persian Empire. The Achaemenids ruled Persia from sometime in the 7th century BCE to the 4th century BCE when they were defeated and overthrown by Alexander. The dynasty is named after its founder Achaemenes – a Greek-based westernized version of his actual name Hakhamanishiya. The dynasty is more authentically called Hakhmanish.

Ahriman - The devil incarnate (for the purposes of these texts). Otherwise, the devil or an evil person.

Ahura Mazda - God in the language of the Zoroastrian scriptures, the . The two words are used together or individually. Over the centuries, the name evolved to Ahurmazd, Hormozd and eventually Ormozd. Also see Khoda.

Aryana - Ancient Iran. Also spelt Airyana or Ariana.

Aryan - Person/people from Aryana. Person claiming Aryan descent. Also spelt Arian. atash - Fire.

Avesta - Zoroastrian scriptures. At one time, the Avesta consisted of 21 nasks or books dealing with philosophy, , rituals, prayers, hygiene, medicine and the medicinal properties of a thousand plants and herbs, history, astronomy, geography and other forms of knowledge. Today only five books and some fragments survive.

Avestan - Language of the Avesta, the Zoroastrian scriptures. The language consists of dialects, the oldest being the language of the Gathas, the hymns of Zarathushtra. Also the script used in the Avesta.

Were Ancient Zoroastrians & Aryans vi K. E. Eduljee Vegetarian? July 2011-March 2015 Glossary

Bundahishn - A (Pahlavi) Zoroastrian text based on older works that discusses creation, geography, history, and mythology. It is also called the Zand-Akash meaning knowledge of the Zand (see below). The surviving texts are frequently referred as the Greater Bundahishn (based on the older 16th century compilation) and the Lesser Bundahishn (based on a later 18th century compilation).

Denkard/Dinkart/Dinkard - A 9th century CE text written by Zoroastrian priests after the Arab invasion of Aryana. The name means ‘Acts of Religion’. div/deev/dev - Evil incarnations, individuals and demons. Devils.

Farsi - The Arabic version of Parsi (see below).

Ferdowsi - 10th-11th century Persian poet who wrote a shah- nameh (chronicle of kings, the popular history of Aryana) today called the Shahnameh. gav - Bovine, beast of burden. Also life (cf. jiv/jun in modern Hindi/Persian). gaya - Life. Related to jaya/gav/jivya, modern jiv meaning life.

Gaya Maretan - Mortal life (gaya = life, mare-tan = mortal/body which can die). geush - Kine/bovine, earthly life, creation.

Geush Urvan - Soul of the kine/bovine, earthly life, creation. gospand - (Called gosfand in Farsi). Beneficent animals. This author proposes that Middle Persian ‘gospand’ is derived from the ‘gao-spenta’ – ‘gao’ meaning ‘cow’, and ‘spenta’ meaning ‘beneficent’ in this context. While in New Persian ‘gosfand’ means ‘sheep’, in the Middle Persian context of our references, ‘gospand’ appears to mean all useful/beneficent animals that could be domesticated as livestock – those that provided food as milk and cheese, fiber, transportation, labour as beasts of burden and for tilling, threshing and other such tasks. The category may have included fowl as well.

Were Ancient Zoroastrians & Aryans vii K. E. Eduljee Vegetarian? July 2011-March 2015 Glossary

[*The New Persian replacement of ‘p’ with an ‘f’ in ‘gospand’ is likely part of the Arabization of the as in the transformation of ‘Parsi’ to ‘Farsi’.]

Greater Bundahishn - See Bundahishn. haoma - Avestan word for the chief of the medicinal plants in Zoroastrian-Aryan healing practice. The ephedra and ephedra-like family of plants (Also see hom).

Hapta-Hindu - The land of the seven Indus rivers in the Avesta, i.e. today’s Northern Pakistan and Punjab (from Panj-ab, meaning the five rivers – the five eastern Indus tributaries).

Haurvatat - An and Avestan word (later Khordad) meaning wholeness, holist and healthy living, excellence.

Hind/Hindu - Ancient in Zoroastrian-Aryan texts. More precisely, the Indus River and the lands surrounding the Indus River, namely present-day Pakistan and Punjab. The name ‘India’ is derived from Hind i.e. Ind. Ironically, today’s Pakistan has better claim to the modern name India than does India. The Vedic equivalents of Hind and Hindu are Sindh and Sindhu respectively. hom - Modern word derived from haoma and currently used to mean the ephedra and ephedra-like family of plants.

Hormozd - Evolved version of Mazda (see ).

Iran - Modern nation and name derived from Airan and Airyana (Aryana).

Khoda, Khodai - Common Aryan word for God (see Ahura Mazda) derived from an attribute of God, Khvada/khvadai (cf. khvadata, self-governed, sovereign or lord). The word has been used in the past to also mean a temporal lord. Sasanian King Shapur I’s (who reigned from 241 to 272 CE) inscription at Naqsh-e Rustam states in Parthian, “Aryan-khshatra khvatwy khvyem,” in

Were Ancient Zoroastrians & Aryans viii K. E. Eduljee Vegetarian? July 2011-March 2015 Glossary

reconstructed Sasanian, “Iran-shahr khvadai ahem” and in Greek, “tou Aryanon-ethnous despotes eimi” meaning “I am lord of the nation of the Aryans.”

Khwaday-nameh - See Khodai-nameh below.

Khodai-nameh - New Persian version of the Middle Khwaday-nameh. Khoda (New Persian) or Khwada (Middle Persian) means lord either divine or temporal. Some authors feel the name Khwaday- nameh is synonymous with Shah-nameh, both meaning book of lords or kings.

Lesser Bundahishn - See Bundahishn.

Magus/Magi - Magi, and its singular Magus, are Greek-based Western terms for Aryan-Zoroastrian priests, the maga, more recently known as the mobeds.

Mazda - Zoroastrian word for God. See Ahura Mazda and Khoda.

Media - First Aryan nation to enter Western history. Its native name was Mada. Its kings were overlords of Aryana from around the eight(?) to the 6th century BCE when they were displaced by the Persians led by Cyrus the Great.

Middle Persian - The Persian-Aryan language as it emerged after the end of Macedonian rule in the 2nd century BCE, first as Parthian and then from the third to the seventh centuries CE, as Sasanian. There are therefore three versions of Middle Persian: Parthian, early Sasanian and late Sasanian. While some authors make distinctions between the three versions, others use this terms Middle Persian and Pahlavi to include all three. Evolving Eastern Aryan dialects such as Sogdian, Khwarezmian and Saka/Khotanese were also current during this time. Arabic writers used the names Farisiya (Farsi/Arabic for Persian) and Fahlawiya (Pahlavi) to mean all the Middle Persian dialects. Since Middle Persian was commonly written using the Parthian or Pahlavi script, it is also called Pahlavi (see below).

Were Ancient Zoroastrians & Aryans ix K. E. Eduljee Vegetarian? July 2011-March 2015 Glossary

Mithra - Friend, friendship, bond, loyalty. Also in , the guardian angel of these qualities and related virtues, and a pre-Zoroastrian Aryan deity or god Mitra as found in the Hindu scriptures, the Rig Veda. Also a woman’s name in Iran.

Mobed - Zoroastrian hereditary priest called maga in the more ancient language of the Avesta. They were called magoi by the Greek. Magus (singular) and Magi (plural) are derivatives. nameh - Persian word meaning account, chronicles, letters, book. Derived from the Middle Persian (also called Pahlavi) word namak or namag. Also spelt nama.

New Persian - Modern Persian language as revived by the poet Ferdowsi, properly called Parsi though currently called Farsi, the Arabic version of the name. Also see Persian.

Old Persian - Language of the Achaemenid Persia era (700-300 BCE). A member of the Indo-Iranian language family.

Ormozd - Evolved version of Ahura Mazda (see Ahura Mazda).

Pahlavi - From Pahlav earlier known as Parthav (see below), one of the Aryan nations (as was Persia/Pars/Parsa). The name is also loosely used to mean the Middle Persian languages written in the Pahlavi/Parthian script – languages which range from the older language of Parthian times (Arsacid Pahlavi) to the language of Sasanian times (Sasanian Pahlavi also called Parsik). Some authors advocate that the term ‘Pahlavi’ should only be used for the script and not the language. In Iran, the Pahlavi script was displaced by the Arabic script after the Arab invasion in the 7th century CE, while the spoken Middle Persian language evolved into New Persian.

Pars - An Aryan kingdom in the southwest of Greater Aryana, today called the province of Fars in Iran. Fars is the Arabic version of Pars.

Were Ancient Zoroastrians & Aryans x K. E. Eduljee Vegetarian? July 2011-March 2015 Glossary

Parsi - Persian. Belonging to, of, or from Pars. The Zoroastrians who fled from Arab rule to India in the 8th and 9th centuries CE called themselves Parsees (). Farsi is the Arabic version of Parsi and is commonly used as the name of the modern Persian- Aryan language, New Persian, otherwise the language of Iran. Parsi is the more authentic name (than Farsi) of the Persian language.

Parthia - The Aryan kingdom whose native name is Parthav and which lay in and around the mountains called the Kopet Dag (bordering Iran and Turkmenistan) today.

Parthian - Belonging to , the westernized version of the native name Parthava.

Parthav, Parthava - See Parthia, Parthian, Pahlavan.

Persia - Western/English version of Pars (see above). A name given by the classical writers to Aryana since Pars was at one time the dominant kingdom of Aryana. Pars was earlier known as ‘Parsa’ and Arabized to ‘Fars’ since Arabic does not have the letter ‘p’.

Persian - Persian mean ‘from Persia’ such as its people and language. However, ‘Persian’ is commonly used to mean ‘belonging to all of Aryana’. Persian was known locally as ‘Parsi’ and Arabized as ‘Farsi’ since Arabic does not have the letter ‘p’.

Rig Veda - Oldest Veda (see below) written in a language similar to the language of the Avesta.

Rivayet - A collection of epistles (formal instructive letters or dispatches) documenting correspondence about a wide variety of topics related to orthodox Zoroastrian customs and practice. Changa Asa (1450 to 1512 CE), a community leader of the Parsi-Zoroastrians of Navsari, Gujarat, India, organized the sending of a representative to the Zoroastrian High Priest in , Iran with a set of questions on orthodox religious practice. The first representative was

Were Ancient Zoroastrians & Aryans xi K. E. Eduljee Vegetarian? July 2011-March 2015 Glossary

Hoshang who returned to India with answers to the community’s questions in 1478 CE. A series of missions followed for the next two hundred years, and the answers brought have been collected and named the Rivayats. Some of the representatives who travelled to Iran were Kama Bohra (1528 CE), Shapur Bharuchi (1570 CE), Kaus Kama (1594 CE), and Kamdin Shapur (?). Persecution of Zoroastrians forced a pause in the visits until the mid 1700s when Mulla Kaus made the last such visit to Yazd and Kerman, only to be trapped in Kerman by the Qajars.

Sasanian, Sasanid - The Persian dynasty that displaced the Parthian Arsacids as the king-of-kings, the overlords, of Aryana in the 3rd century CE. They were named after the eponymous founder of the dynastic line, Sasan. Author Tabari claims they were descendants of the Achaemenids. The Sasanians were the last Zoroastrian kings of Aryana and were deposed when Aryana was conquered by the Islamic Arabs in the mid-7th century CE. The last Sasanian king was Yezdegird III. Also spelt Sasanian. shah-nameh - General meaning in Persian: ‘chronicle of kings’. Specifically: the 10th-11th century CE Persian poet Ferdowsi’s work in verse titled the Shahnameh. The poet ’s shah-nameh is one of many that preceded Ferdowsi’s work. Most of the earlier shah- nameh were in prose.

Vedas - Hindu scriptures of which the Rig Veda, the oldest, is written in a language similar to the language of the Avesta.

Vendidad - A book of the Zoroastrian scriptures, the Avesta. The name is a later form of Videvdat, which is in turn a contraction of Vi-Daevo-Data, the law against devas or evil. The Vendidad’s verses are used by priests in purification ceremonies. The Vendidad is also a store of Zoroastrian history. It contains the list of the nations of Old Aryana as well as an account of the deeds of King Jamsheed including his expansion of

Were Ancient Zoroastrians & Aryans xii K. E. Eduljee Vegetarian? July 2011-March 2015 Glossary

Aryan lands.

Yasht - A book of the Zoroastrian scriptures, the Avesta. It is said to contain pre-Zoroastrian-information. Each (commonly translated as worship) is a hymn dedicated to Zoroastrian-ideals together with the related angel (such as the ideals of friendship, the word as bond, and kindness, and the guardian of these ideals – the angel ). Originally, there were thirty , one dedicated to each named day of the month. Today only twenty-one survive.

Yasna - A book of the Zoroastrian scriptures, the Avesta, which contains the liturgy for the preparation of the ab-zohr/haoma extract, as well as the Gathas or hymns of Zarathushtra. (also spelt izeshne in later texts) means service, prayers and dedications – i.e. words of worship (cf. Sanskrit yajna and yana). Priests recite the Yasna as part of the liturgy when performing their priestly duties and functions.

Zand - Classical (primarily Middle Persian) translations, explanations, interpretations and commentaries of the scriptures, the Avesta, are called the Zand or . The Avesta accompanied by the Zand is called the Zand-Avesta. For our purposes, we use the term Zand to include all the Middle Persian religious texts that seek to complement the Avesta in its full extent of 21 books. Well-known works of the Zand are the Bundahishn and .

Zartosht - Middle Persian version of Zarathushtra.

Zartoshti - Middle Persian version of Zarathushtrian.

Zarathushtra - Founder of the Zoroastrian/Zarathushtrian creed/faith/religion and its core philosophy. Zarathushtra is the English transliteration of the original name in the Avestan language and is also spelt Zarathustra.

Zarathushtri - Name for a Zoroastrian, that some feel is more authentic since it is based on the original Avesta name Zarathushtra and not on the Greek-based

Were Ancient Zoroastrians & Aryans xiii K. E. Eduljee Vegetarian? July 2011-March 2015 Glossary

corruption .

Zarathushtrian - See Zarathushtri.

Zoroaster - Western version of the name Zarathushtra.

Zoroastrianism - Western name for the religion, faith and philosophy based on the teachings of Zoroaster/Zarathushtra. Authentically called Mazdayasni (Worship of God) and Behdin (Good-Religion).

()

Were Ancient Zoroastrians & Aryans xiv K. E. Eduljee Vegetarian? July 2011-March 2015

IS THE TERM ‘ZOROASTRIAN’ ZOROASTRIAN? ‘Zoroastrian’ & ‘Zoroastrianism’ are modern English terms used in English language communications such as this monograph. These terms are not found in ancient ‘Zoroastrian’ texts. If not, then by what name was the religion known previously?

The internal name: the Avesta calls the religion ‘Mazdayasna’ and ‘Mazdayasna Zarathushtrish’. Some modern writers use ‘Mazdean’.

The external name: classical European writers called Zoroastrianism the Religion of the Magi – ‘Magiæ’ or ‘Magian’ if you will. To this day Arabs call Zoroastrians ‘’ (i.e. Magian). Islamic writers called Zoroastrian lands ‘Mughistan’ (from ‘Mugh/Magha’).

In Alcibiades I, Greek philosopher, cites the Magism (or Magianism) of Zoroaster (his original name being Zarathushtra). In his Lives of Eminent Philosophers, Diogenes Laertius calls Zoroaster the first Magian. Similarly, Agathias in his calls Zoroaster the founder of the Magian religion, i.e., the founder of the Magi’s doctrine. The terms ‘Religion of the Magi’, ‘Magian Religion’ and ‘Magism’ are therefore synonymous with ‘Zoroastrianism’.

Classical authors and Strabo knew of only one Persian religion. Albert de Jong in Traditions of the Magi: Zoroastrianism in Greek and Latin Literature states, “There is no trace of a plurality among the Iranians. On the contrary, in the (Greek and Latin) classical texts, only one religion is recognized: the religion of the Persians. This religion is often connected with the name Zoroaster, who enjoyed a wide reputation in the ancient world as the founder of the order of the Magi, and by extension as the founder of the wisdom and religion of the Persians.”

‘Persia’ was the name classical Greco-Roman authors used for ancient Iran, Aryana, because Persia was then the dominant Aryan nation. Persia was to Aryana what England is to Britain today. At its start, Zoroastrianism was not a ‘Persian’ religion since the kingdom of ‘Persia’ had not been formed when Zoroaster/Zarathushtra lived. It was then an Aryan or Iranian religion with Kayanian (in today), the dominant Aryan nation, as its center. After the formation of Persia and the Persian Empire, Persia became the center of Zoroastrianism until the Arab invasion around 645 CE.

Were Ancient Zoroastrians & Aryans 1 K. E. Eduljee Vegetarian? July 2011-March 2015

THE MAGI & HEALTHY LIVING The disciples and successors of Zoroaster, the Magi, are an order of seers who are dedicated to the service of the Divine. They are found among the Persians, , Chaldeans, Parthians, (H)areians, Bactrians, Chorasmians, and the Saka.

Since their profession as the Magi makes it incumbent on them to observe strict rules of life, the Magi have strong constitutions and live to a great age.

Lucian of Samosata (2nd century CE)

Were Ancient Zoroastrians & Aryans 2 K. E. Eduljee Vegetarian? July 2011-March 2015 I Research & Discussion

PART I RESEARCH & DISCUSSION

1. Was Zarathushtra a Vegetarian? A rare reference to Zarathushtra’s (Zoroaster’s) diet is contained in classical Roman author Pliny’s . We also have comments related to diet in Zarathushtra’s hymns, the Gathas, as well as in the Gathas’ Middle Persian (Pahlavi) Zand translations. Given that Zarathushtra composed the Gathas, we may reasonably surmize that any allusion to diet or the killing of animals in the Gathas reflects Zarathushtra’s own principles. A. Zarathushtra’s Diet of Cheese (23 – 79 CE) in his Natural History noted:

“It is reported that Zoroaster lived in the deserts (wilds) on cheese so temperately (moderately/frugally) for twenty years that he did not feel the effects of old age.” (KEE – all translations in this monograph are by K. E. Eduljee unless otherwise stated.)

J. Bostock translates the last words in the passage as, “…that he was insensible to the advances of old age.”

(i) Cheese, No Meat, Moderation, Self-Control & Shunning Gluttony [It would be unreasonable to expect that Zarathushtra subsisted for twenty years on cheese alone. More likely, cheese consumed frugally was central to his diet as it was with the Magi’s diet that comprised, as we will read later, of cheese, and bread.]

The short statement by Pliny above contains a number of values, qualities of character, guiding principles and life-style choices that lie at the heart of the Zarathushtrian ethos. A life-style choice and diet such as this would not be possible without a firm ethic, will power and exemplary self-control.

Pliny’s passage further states that Zarathushtra consumed cheese, a simple food, in a temperate or moderate manner, implying first that he consumed cheese in small amounts, and second that he did not engage in gluttony or the eating of rich foods. We can A portrait of Zarathushtra infer that he ate what his body needed to function in an - an artist's impression.

Were Ancient Zoroastrians & Aryans 3 K. E. Eduljee Vegetarian? July 2011-March 2015 I Research & Discussion optimal manner – not more and not less.

A further implication reiterated in Zoroastrian texts is that rich, indulgent foods are harmful to health, longevity and the soul as well. Other classical Greco-Roman and Zoroastrian texts amplify Pliny’s statement. B. Zarem Raoghna – Soul Food There is a diary product closely related to cheese that bears mention here. Called zarem raoghna in the Avesta and roghan in later texts, it is extolled in Zoroastrian texts as the “best food”. ‘Zarem’ means ‘spring’ (season). The Avestan ‘raoghna’ evolved to ‘roghan’ in Middle Persian, which in turn translates as ‘oil’ or ‘butter’ in English.

The Avestan Hadhokht Nask, which is concerned with the fate of the soul after a person’s passing away, states, “Their food is the exalted zaremyehe raoghnahe; for them who from youth are of good thoughts, of good words, of good deeds, of good faith – (it is like) the food of the after life….” (KEE). The Middle Persian text Dadistan-i Denig, which we cite further below, also notes that zarem raoghna is the earthly representative of the soul’s heavenly food.

This author proposes that in Zoroastrian texts ‘raoghna’/‘roghan’ means ‘clarified butter’1 – similar to the Vedic ‘ghart’ meaning ‘ghee’2. [In old Iran, clarified butter was a valued commodity used to make payments.3] Therefore, we can translate zaremyehe raoghnahe (zarem raoghna for short) as ‘spring clarified butter’.

Cheese (paneer in Middle and New Persian) and clarified butter are made from milk. All three play a significant role in Zoroastrian-Aryan tradition – milk in health-giving and healing haoma extracts and cheese in diet. In turn, zarem raoghna – clarified butter made in spring – is extolled as the best food in the world, the earthly representative of soul food. C. Mid-Spring Milk, Clarified Butter & Cheese The Middle Persian Dadistan-i Denig (Religious Decisions) further develops the concept of zarem raoghna by calling it maidyo-zarem roghan in the Middle Persian language. Since ‘maidyo’ means ‘mid’, we can translate ‘maidyo-zarem roghan’ as ‘mid-spring clarified butter’.

The Dadistan adds that the most efficacious of all dairy products is maidyo-zarem roghan made from milk drawn in the second month (Ardwahisht/Ardibehesht) of the year, i.e., when Mihr (the Sun) was in the constellation Tora (Taurus) – a month scripturally designated as part of

1 See Appendix III.1. 2 See Appendix III.1.E. 3 See Appendix III.1.C.

Were Ancient Zoroastrians & Aryans 4 K. E. Eduljee Vegetarian? July 2011-March 2015 I Research & Discussion spring (zarem), i.e., April-May in today’s Gregorian calendar or mid-spring.

[Since the Sun appears to ‘move’ through twelve constellations in its celestial ‘path’, the Zoroastrian-Aryan method of specifying a month by the Sun’s position in a constellation is dynamic and the description holds true for a specific era only – in this case the Age of Varak (varak meaning lamb/ram) i.e. the Age of Aries. The Sun would have resided for the entire second month of spring within the star constellation Tora (Taurus) sometime between 2,100 and 1,700 BCE. This may be an indication of when the Dadistan’s original ancient source text was composed.]

The Middle Persian Menog-i Kharad reiterates that maidyo-zarem roghan (mid-spring clarified butter) is the most beneficent of foods and the Avestan ’s Pahlavi commentary confirms that spring milk is “the best”.

It stands to reason that cheese (paneer) made from spring milk should also be the best among cheeses made throughout the year.

One reason for the remarkable Simple paneer. Image credit: Wikipedia. health-giving efficacy of clarified butter or cheese made from mid- spring milk could be that cows feeding on fresh spring grasses ate (and pre- digested for us) wild herbs growing amidst the grass. D. Cheese & Herbs – an Ancient Tradition Survives Today, if mid-spring cheese made from free-ranging cows’ milk is not available, the next best alternative is to eat herbs and vegetables with the cheese.

Diogenes Laertius, a 3rd century CE Greek biographer from Alexandria, , citing 2nd century BCE biographer Sotion of Alexandria, states that the diet of the Magi of his time was “cheese (tyros), vegetables and coarse bread” and that the Magi ate cheese by piercing bits of it with a stick they carried with them.

It would be reasonable to expect that the Magi followed the example of Zarathushtra in their diet. Diogenes Laertius

Were Ancient Zoroastrians & Aryans 5 K. E. Eduljee Vegetarian? July 2011-March 2015 I Research & Discussion

During this author’s stay in Iran, he was introduced to the popular tradition of dining on a simple meal of cheese (paneer), flatbread (naan) and herbs or vegetables that can be eaten raw (sabzi khordan) – herbs and vegetables such as tarragon, basil, mint and together with, say, , radish, and even .

The amount of cheese consumed in this manner is moderate and in keeping with the Zarathushtrian principle of moderation. A morsel of paneer, walnuts and sabzi khordan (here mint, spring , basil and radish) wrapped in naan. It would seem that unbeknownst to Image credit: Nazderavian. most, an ancient Zarathushtrian dietary tradition survives to this day in the guise of daily fare.

(i) Unleavened Bread from Barley Unleavened flat bread made from ground whole grain barley may be closer to the original Zarathushtrian/Magian diet than today’s leavened bread made from refined flour.

nd 2 century CE Syrian author A sabzi khordan selection – tarragon, mint, radish and spring of Samosata4 stated, “The Chaldean onions. Image credit: Nazderavian. (Magi) are said to live to above a hundred years in age. This is attributed in part to their custom of feeding on barley bread, which they say sharpens the sight. By this kind of diet their senses in general are said to be quicker and stronger than those of other people.” E. Sustenance in Winter In those climate zones that did not permit year-round agriculture, plant foodstuffs that lent themselves to drying and storing would have provided a year-round source of food – plant foods such as dried grains, rice, , , herbs, fruits and nuts. When fresh herbs and vegetables were unavailable to eat with barley bread and cheese, nuts such as walnuts may have been eaten as substitutes.

4 Samosata stood on the east bank of the River Euphrates in what a region that is part of modern-day .

Were Ancient Zoroastrians & Aryans 6 K. E. Eduljee Vegetarian? July 2011-March 2015 I Research & Discussion

The Iranian tradition of storing dried herbs, fruits and nuts is associated with yet another noble tradition – that of sharing and ensuring those unfortunate enough not to have a store of foods would not go hungry.

(i) Gahanbars & Jashns – Mutual Help and Caring Instituted by scripture, gahanbars are six seasonal festivals or high feasts when Zoroastrians assemble to eat and share food communally. Partaking in the feasts with their attendant rituals brings enjoyment and comfort to mind, body and soul. Traditionally, each feast lasted for five days.

A jashn (called jashn in Iran and jashan in India) celebrates a joyous occasion such as a thanksgiving, some other important event or a significant day of the calendar. Jashns can include gahanbar-like feasts and the very first jashn recorded in legend is Jashn Sadeh (see frontispiece), instituted to celebrate the discovery of fire by King Hushang, the first formal king of the Aryans in the Avesta.5

For the people engaged in the procurement, preparation and distribution of food at gahanbar and jashn feasts, their efforts stand as a service to the community. In addition to sustaining its members, the preparation of the food and its communal sharing helps in building and maintaining the health and spirit of the community.

A hot vegetarian called aush/aash is often served at a traditional Iranian Zoroastrian jashn. Dried fruits and nuts called khushk baar/meevayh6 (known commonly as ajil or lork/lorg) are also distributed.

One common variety of aush is aush-e reshte, a stew- like soup made with whey (kashk), finely chopped herbs and previously soaked dried and lentils. Persian (reshte) complement the soup. Besides providing balanced nutrition, the soup is said to have healing powers that help restore those who Aush-e Reshte. Image credit: Wikipedia. are ill to good health.

5 The poet Ferdowsi in his Shahnameh names Hushang’s grandfather Gaya Maretan/Gayomard as the first king. 6 ‘Baar’ means ‘fruit’ or ‘meevayh’, ‘produce’, ‘load’ and ‘tree output’.

Were Ancient Zoroastrians & Aryans 7 K. E. Eduljee Vegetarian? July 2011-March 2015 I Research & Discussion

Khushk baar/meevayh (ajil/lork), nuts and dried fruits mixture. Image credit: Nazanin Niknam at vcn.

Khushk baar/meevayh (ajil/lork) is a mixture of seven (seven being an auspicious number for Zoroastrians) dried nuts and fruits: , roasted chic peas, almonds, , figs, apricots, and raisins (pasteh, nakhudsheek, baudom, fandook, anjeer, zardauloo and keshmesh respectively). Some substitutions are made according to locale, availability, taste (salty or sweet) and family preferences. Roasted squash seeds, roasted melon seeds, walnuts, cashews, and dried mulberries (tokhmeh kadoo, tokhmeh hendooneh, gardoo, kaushu and tut respectively) are possible substitutes.

This author noticed that towards the close of community gatherings in Iran, the hosts invariably distributed dried fruits and nuts (often blessed by a prayer) to all the guests as a take-away. Everyone, regardless of their station, accepted the offering with thanks. Praying the Afrinameh over Gahanbar foods. Yazd, Iran. Image credit: Nazanin Niknam at vcn. Beneficence – mutual helpfulness and caring – has always been the central pillar on which Zoroastrian communities have been built over the centuries.

Were Ancient Zoroastrians & Aryans 8 K. E. Eduljee Vegetarian? July 2011-March 2015 I Research & Discussion

F. Zarathushtra’s Gathas (i) King Jamsheed as the Originator of the Sin of Meat Eating Verse 32.8 of the Gathas, the hymns of Zarathushtra, starts with a condemnation of legendary King Jamsheed – a great and noble king turned sinner. Modern authors translate the remaining lines differently.

The verse’s Middle Persian Pahlavi translation – as well as the Sanskrit translation by 12th or 13th century CE Parsi scholar Neriosangh Dhaval – support the following English translation:

“Among the sinners we hear of Yima Vivanghat (King Jamsheed’s ancient Avestan name), who taught humans the enjoyment (craving) of our (beneficent) animals eaten in portions (butchered?). From all such, may I (Zarathushtra) stand apart in Your ultimate discernment O Mazda.” (KEE)

The once great Aryan King Jamsheed on his throne being elevated by divs. There are several implications conveyed by this mythical scenario: first, the divs supported Jamsheed’s kingship and elevated him to the status to a demi-god. The divs themselves are portrayed as being demonic, the antithesis of a righteous person.

Image details and credit: This image is part of a Timurid (Ebrahim Soltan) Shahnameh manuscript created in and dated to c.1435–1440 CE. The manuscript folios are presently at the Fitzwilliam Museum, University of Cambridge, UK.

To be fair, we have found one reference in a Pahlavi Rivayet that seems to imply that Jamsheed tried to prevent the sin of meat eating, a practice initiated by the divs. Regardless to whom legends assign the blame, since eating meat is consistently associated with the killing of beneficent animals, the practice of meat eating is uniformly decried by implication.

(ii) Lament of Geush Urvan & Animals The Gathas’ second chapter opens with the lament of Geush Urvan seeking a protector from violence, death and evil. ‘Urvan’ means soul in the

Were Ancient Zoroastrians & Aryans 9 K. E. Eduljee Vegetarian? July 2011-March 2015 I Research & Discussion

Avestan languages. ‘Geush’ has two primary meanings: the ‘kine’ (cattle) and ‘creation’ or ‘life’.

In his Essays on the Sacred Language, Writings, and Religion of the Parsis 19th century Sanskrit scholar noted, “Geush Urva means the universal soul of the earth, the cause of all life and growth. The literal meaning of the term, ‘soul of the cow’ implies a simile; for the earth is compared to a cow.” Gaus, notes Haug, conveys two meanings in Sanskrit, ‘cow’ and ‘earth’.

(iii) Tradition of Aryan/Iranian Poets & Gathic Poetry Zarathushtra stands first amongst a long line of illustrious ancient Iranian poets who developed the tradition of composing verses that conveyed several meanings in layers. They perfected the art of using allegory, metaphor and the simile.

(iv) Allegory in the Geush Urvan Gatha It is, therefore, quite possible that Zarathushtra intended both meanings of ‘geush’ – kine and earthly life – to apply in the Geush Urvan Gatha as primary meanings that produce observable truths: the indiscriminate killing of animals and an abuse of nature. He may have intended secondary meanings as well. The flock of Geush Urvan could be a metaphor for Zarathushtra’s community of followers who were being harassed and murdered for their beliefs. Yet another meaning could be the utter depravity that existed in Zarathushtra’s homeland prior to his ministry.

The master poet will ensure that the discovery of less apparent meanings do not invalidate primary meaning(s). All meanings remain valid.

If the Gathas do indeed take a multiple meaning approach for even the primary or apparent meaning(s), the Middle Persian Pahlavi translations of this Gathic chapter explicitly decry the killing of beneficent animals as the primary meaning. One Pahlavi translation of the chapter has Geush Urvan saying, “The indiscriminate slaughter makes my life in all things hateful”. The statement is followed by a plea for safe pastures for the gospand7, beneficent animals.

7 This author proposes that Middle Persian ‘gospand’ is derived from the Avestan ‘gao- spenta’ – ‘gao’ meaning ‘cow’, and ‘spenta’ meaning ‘beneficent’ in this context. While in New Persian ‘gosfand’ means ‘sheep’, in the Middle Persian context of our references, ‘gospand’ appears to mean all useful/beneficent animals that could be domesticated as livestock – those that provided food as milk and cheese, fibre, transportation, labour as beasts of burden and for tilling, threshing and other such tasks. The category may have included fowl as well. [*The New Persian replacement of ‘p’ with an ‘f’ in ‘gospand’ is likely part of the Arabization of the Persian language as in the transformation of ‘Parsi’ to ‘Farsi’.]

Were Ancient Zoroastrians & Aryans 10 K. E. Eduljee Vegetarian? July 2011-March 2015 I Research & Discussion

In a Pahlavi rendition of the Geush Urvan Gatha, Geush Urvan is identified as the gospands’ (beneficent animals’) ruban (soul). ‘Gospand’s’ modern rendition means ‘sheep’. The ‘vasta’, the protector of the herd or flock, in Gatha Y. 29.1’s “noit moi vasta Khshmat Anyo” can thereby be read as “there is no shepherd/pastor other than You (Mazda/God)”. The last line “moi sansta vohu vastrya” can read as “lead me to good (and safe) pastures.” Compare these lines with the Judeo-Christian Psalm 23 (of David) “the Lord is my shepherd” “He leads me to green (and safe) pastures” “He restores my soul”. Scholars of comparative religion inform us that Zoroastrian concepts influenced Jewish (and thereby later Christian) theology especially during the exile of Jews to Babylon and immediately after their liberation by King Cyrus the Great.

(v) Geush & Gospand The Middle Persian Zoroastrian translations and texts equate ‘geush’ with ‘gospand’, the latter meaning ‘beneficent herd or livestock animals’ in context.

Neriosangh Dhaval also translates ‘geush urvan’ as the ‘soul of the herds’ – herds of all beneficent animals.

(vi) Soul of Animals The concepts in the Gathic chapter that contains the lament of Geush Urvan are further amplified in verse 39.1 of the Yasna, which states:

“(Know) this that we revere Geush Urvan and all our forms as well as the souls of animals who are living as we are. They are to us as we are to them.” (KEE)

The passage states that ‘we’, i.e. Zoroastrians, revere the souls of animals in the same manner as we revere the souls of humans. These sentiments lead us to the distinction between life forms that have a soul (perhaps sentient), and organisms such as plants that are organic and living, but which do not have a soul.

The further implication is that eating plants that do not have a soul is acceptable while killing/eating beneficent animals that have a soul is unacceptable to the tenants of the faith. 

Were Ancient Zoroastrians & Aryans 11 K. E. Eduljee Vegetarian? July 2011-March 2015 I Research & Discussion

2. Ancient Aryans Were Gatherers. But Were They Hunters? A. Legends Preserved in Ferdowsi’s Shahnameh Legends preserved in the poet Ferdowsi’s epic, the Shahnameh, offer us a possible answer to the question: Prior to the advent of Zoroastrianism, were ancient Aryans vegetarian? Ferdowsi’s principal source of information and legend was the Middle Persian (Pahlavi) Zoroastrian work, the Khvatay-Namak, later known as the Khodai-nameh.8

(i) Aryan Stone Age – Age of Gaya Maretan & Gathering Foods The Shahnameh informs us that during the Aryan Stone Age – the Age of Gaya Maretan (Gayomard, Kaiumars) – people sustained themselves by gathering fruits and other plant foods. Later in the Stone Age, people began to domesticate animals and the concept of domesticated livestock – herds of beneficent animals – developed. Ferdowsi

(ii) Aryan Metal Age – Age of Hushang & Agriculture The Shahnameh’s legends then say that during the Age of King Hushang – the Aryan Metal Age – the planting Archaeological finds at the base of the Kopet and harvesting of crops began. Dag Mountains’ (bordering today’s Iran and The legends do not mention Turkmenistan and which in ancient times were hunting until later in history. What in Parthava/Parthia) northern slopes, have we read is that before the advent of provided evidence of what might be some of farming, Aryans were gatherers of the oldest settled agrarian communities known plant foods. Nevertheless, do these to humankind. Early Aryans also developed an legends say anything about the underground system of water irrigation called advent of eating animal flesh? The kareez. The system prevented evaporation and lines in the next section translated pollution of water as it travelled from the rain from Ferdowsi's Shahnameh give us a catchment area of the foothills to the plains. possible answer.

[The information supplied by Ferdowsi is consistent with the sentiments regarding meat eating in surviving Zoroastrian texts – with one difference. While Zoroastrian texts see pre-Zarathushtra King Jamsheed as the monarch who introduced meat eating, Ferdowsi transfers that blame to King Jamsheed’s antagonist, the ‘foreign’ King Zahhak who overran ancient Iran.]

8 Ferdowsi wrote the verses of the Shahnameh in New Persian when the language had just evolved from Middle Persian – and was fast becoming contaminated with Arabic words. Ferdowsi expunged as many Arabic words as possible in the New Persian lexicon he employed.

Were Ancient Zoroastrians & Aryans 12 K. E. Eduljee Vegetarian? July 2011-March 2015 I Research & Discussion

Gaya Maretan (Gayomard, Kaiumars) with the people and animals of ancient Iran living in harmony.

Image: In Shah Tahmasp manuscript of Ferdowsi's Shahnameh. Attributed to Artist Sultan Muhammad, Iran, Tabriz c. 1530 CE (Metropolitan Museum of Art).

Were Ancient Zoroastrians & Aryans 13 K. E. Eduljee Vegetarian? July 2011-March 2015 I Research & Discussion

(iii) Seduction of Zahhak by Ahriman’s Cooking In one of the earlier legends of the Shahnameh, King Zahhak (perhaps Assyrian but who Ferdowsi ‘Arabized’) overthrew Aryan King Jamsheed and conquered ancient Iran, Aryana. In this legend, Ahriman9, the devil incarnate and leader of the evil divs who plagued the life of the good Aryans, brings Zahhak under his control by becoming his cook and then seducing him with a taste and fondness for meat. What follow are the overthrow of King Jamsheed by Zahhak and the completion of the first great Aryan tragic cycle – Aryan lands that had risen to great glory during the reigns of King Hushang, and Jamsheed’s early reign, now fell on evil times.

The following is this author’s rendition of the Arthur and Edmond Warners’ translation of Zahhak’s seduction by Ahriman in the Shahnameh:

Ahriman plotted. “Let me,” he mused, “Present myself as a famed and noted cook, And with my cooking, find favour with the king.” Foods then were few, yet people did not kill to eat But lived on the earth’s produce of vegetal. Scheming the evil-doing Ahriman designed To slaughter and serve both bird and beast. Zahhak would thus by his appetite be seduced And when possessed by a carnal lust for blood and flesh, Would as a slave obey and do all Ahriman’s bidding yet.

In youth form well-spoken, clean, and clever, With fawning words of praise and promise, Ahriman presented himself to Zahhak Who commanded his faithful minister To give the div the royal kitchen’s keys.

Ahriman prepared first a meal of yolk, Whose flavour the monarch relished so That he praised the wily Ahriman, who replied thus, “Illustrious monarch! Forever live! Tomorrow I will serve yet more and please you well.”

All night the evil div pondered, What strange repast to proffer on the morrow.

When the azure vault brought back the golden orb Ahriman presented the monarch a lavish meal Of partridges and silver pheasants as never seen.

9 Iblis, the Islamic word for the devil, is used in place of Ahriman in some Shahnameh manuscripts.

Were Ancient Zoroastrians & Aryans 14 K. E. Eduljee Vegetarian? July 2011-March 2015 I Research & Discussion

The Arab monarch gorged himself, and lost His diminutive wits in awe and admiration.

On the third day, Ahriman served lamb and fowl, And on the fourth a flavoured joint of veal With rosewater, musk and rare old wine. The evil one then counselled the king, ‘Tis blood that gives muscle and strength And will make the monarch lion-fierce.

When Zahhak had feasted on blood and flesh, In wonder of his cook’s ability said, “Worthy friend! Ask now your recompense.” His scheme fulfilled, the Darkness answered, “Live, O king! In wealth and power. My heart does throe with your favour of my soul’s food. Yet if could I ask one boon above my station ‘Tis leave to kiss and lay my eyes upon your shoulders.” Surprised Zahhak replied, “I grant it; it may do you grace.” Permission thus received, Ahriman kissed The monarch’s shoulders and swiftly vanished. A marvel followed, For from the monarch’s shoulders Sprouted two demonic black snakes.

Distraught, Zahhak sought a cure. Finding none, he excised them, But lo! They grew back again! Like strange branches from a tree. The ablest leechers summoned gave advice in turn And used their curious arts, though all in vain. Then in leech form Ahriman himself appeared “This was your destiny,” said he. “Cut not the snakes but let them live. Give them men’s brains and gorge them till they sleep. Such food may kill them. It is the only means.”

The purpose of the foul div pray shrewdly scan; Had he conceived perchance a secret plan To rid the world of all trace of man?

The words above are fairly clear. Before Zahhak’s seduction by Ahriman, people did not eat meat. In other words, they were vegetarian. The legend does not end with that answer. When Ferdowsi’s legend made Ahriman the initiator of eating slaughtered animal flesh, he could not have made his

Were Ancient Zoroastrians & Aryans 15 K. E. Eduljee Vegetarian? July 2011-March 2015 I Research & Discussion point about the ethics of eating animal flesh for food more emphatically. Since the practice of meat eating requires killing life, it is not hard to see why he placed the practice under the domain of Ahriman, the lord of death, the lord of not-life.

Further, once gripped by the taste of meat and blood, Zahhak became a slave to Ahriman. Perhaps Ferdowsi was trying to say that meat eating is an addiction to which people become enslaved.

The philosophical underpinnings of this symbolic mythology are profound. They establish the place and role of human beings in the scheme of creation. They also make respect and reverence of animal life an ethical imperative – the antithesis of which is deemed evil. The implication that killing, tasting blood and eating meat are addictive, harkens to an implied subversion of free will and objectivity – that once enslaved by addiction, the human mind becomes a victim to base desires and ambitions represented mythically by Ahriman and Zahhak’s relationship. By extension, overcoming carnal temptations for dead flesh is a triumph of right- mindedness over base desire – a lesson for any form of addiction.

When read in conjunction with other references to nutrition and health found elsewhere in Zoroastrian texts, what we gather is that the type of food we consume is directly manifest in our health holistically – not just in the health, vitality and longevity of our mortal frames, but in that of our minds and spirit as well. The ancient Avestan wisdom contained in the Zahhak- Ahriman legend as retold and preserved by Ferdowsi in his Shahnameh, profiles meat eating as being one of the principal negative influences on the human body, mind and spirit. 

3. Introduction of Meat Eating after the Arab Conquest Author E. W. West informs us that in Chapter 39 of a Bundahishn manuscript belonging to Tehmuras Dinshawji Anklesaria of Bombay, he found a notation stating, “The Arabs rushed into the country of Iran in great multitude... and their own irreligious law was propagated by them and many ancestral customs were destroyed, and eating of dead matter was put into practice. ...From the original creation until this day, evil more grievous than this has not happened....”

Perhaps the poet Ferdowsi had a purpose in the Arabization of Zahhak.

Were Ancient Zoroastrians & Aryans 16 K. E. Eduljee Vegetarian? July 2011-March 2015 I Research & Discussion

4. Stages of Consumption at the Beginning & End of Human History The stages in which humankind began consuming water and foodstuffs (together with the prediction that the stages will be reversed at the close of human history) are outlined in the Middle Persian Bundahishns. They tell us that at the outset of history, humans first consumed water, then vegetables, then milk, and lastly meat. Close to the end of human history, the stages will be reversed. People will desist first from eating meat, then vegetables and then milk – finally existing on water alone until the end of the present existential phase and the beginning of everlasting peace.

This event will occur when a coming saviour will lead the world to an ideal existence and death will be no more. It stands to reason that this includes the death or killing of animals – possibly the Bundahishns’ answer to the lament of Geush Urvan beseeching God for a saviour and safe pastures. 

5. Achaemenid Era Practices of the Magi A. Different Norms for Different Orders of the Magi According to 3rd century CE Phoenician-Tyrian philosopher & vegetarian advocate Porphyry in his work De Abstinentia, “The first and most learned order of the Magi neither eat nor slay any thing animated, but adhere to the ancient abstinence from animals. The second order (of the Magi) uses some animals indeed (for food) but do not slay any that are tame*. Nor do those of the third order, similarly with other men, lay their hands on all (tame) animals.” (Adapted by this author from the translation by T. Taylor.)

[*Likely the gospand of Middle Persian texts.]

We note here that it was only the highest order of the Achaemenid era Magi (say, the dasturs of today) who adhered to the ancient practice Porphyry of abstinence from killing animals or meat eating. Porphyry notes that while the lower orders of the Magi hierarchy did eat meat they did not kill “tame” animals, which we presume included domesticated, livestock or herd animals i.e. the gospand. One scenario is that the higher orders of the Magi maintained Zarathushtra’s exemplary lifestyle and dietary choices as part of their strict code even when large segments of the population had become meat eaters.

Were Ancient Zoroastrians & Aryans 17 K. E. Eduljee Vegetarian? July 2011-March 2015 I Research & Discussion

B. Changing Mores Perhaps unaware of the finer distinctions that Porphyry would note, 5th century BCE Greek author Herodotus generalized by stating in his Histories that the Magi were required to pray over the cooked flesh of an animal slaughtered by a member of the Persian laity.

In reading the various Greco-Roman reports collectively, what we gather is that by the time the Persian Achaemenids ruled Aryan lands – from, say, the 7th century BCE onwards or perhaps even following Median rule from, say, the 9th century BCE onwards – ‘Persians’ (Zoroastrians) no longer uniformly adhered to the “ancient abstinence from (eating) animals”. Herodotus The desire to restore the ancient practice of a vegetarian diet amongst Zoroastrians nevertheless continued to persist as late as the Sasanian era (3rd to 7th century CE). That desire is evidenced by the explicit admonitions of Sasanian era high priests we cite next – admonitions that are today either forgotten or ignored. 

6. Call to be Vegetarians in Sasanian Era Medieval Zoroastrian Texts A. Sasanian Head Priest Adarbad Mahraspandan Perhaps the most explicit call for Zoroastrians to be vegetarian is found in the Sayings of Adarbad Mahraspandan10, which states:

“Abstain rigorously from eating the flesh of kine and all beneficent animals (gospandan) least you be made to face a strict reckoning in this world and the next; for by eating the flesh of the kine and other domestic animals, you involve your hand in sin, and (thereby) think, speak, and do what is sinful; for though you may eat but a mouthful, you involve your hand in sin, and though a camel be slain by (another) person in another place, it is as if you (who eat its flesh) had slain it with your own hand.”(Translation by R. C. Zaehner and adapted slightly for consistency.)11

10 Zoroastrian high priest (mobed-i mobedan/mobed of mobeds) and prime minister during the reign of Sasanian King Shapur II (309-379 CE), Adarbad Mahraspandan is said to have ‘purified’ the Avesta and fixed its number at 21 nasks (books), 21 being the number of words in the Ahunavar prayer. Highly regarded and considered a saint, he is likely the Adarbad Mehersafand mentioned in the Qissa-e Sanjan. 11 We are grateful to Zaneta Garratt for bringing this passage to our attention.

Were Ancient Zoroastrians & Aryans 18 K. E. Eduljee Vegetarian? July 2011-March 2015 I Research & Discussion

B. Hudinan Peshobay Head Priest Adarbad Emedan In addition, Hudinan Peshobay12 High Priest Atrupat-e Emetan (Adarbad, son of Emedan) who officiated after the Arab invasion states in Book 6 of the 9-11th century CE Middle Persian (Pahlavi) Denkard:

“Be plant-eaters (urwar khwarishn i.e. vegetarian), O you people, so that you may live long. And stay away from the body of beneficent animals (gospand). As well, deeply consider that Ohrmazd the Lord has for the benefit of useful animals (and humans) created many plants.” (KEE)

(i) Beneficent Vegetarian Animals & Nature’s Bounty High Priest Adarbad’s admonition to deeply consider the scheme of God, Ahura Mazda’s creation, leads us to ponder if the definition of gospand, beneficent animals, includes animals that are themselves vegetarian. The digestive systems of these animals allow them to efficiently digest plant foods that humans would not normally ingest. In doing so, these animals convert coarse matter into another food, milk, intended for less developed digestive systems such as their young. Milk thus contains plant materials converted to protein and other concentrated nutrients formulated by nature to foster nutrition and growth.

In contemplating the scheme of life, we need include to the earlier example of Zarathushtra’s frugal consumption of a milk product, cheese. The scheme of nature and our resultant dietary norms can be upset when the beneficent animals are fed unnaturally or if their milk and its derivatives are consumed excessively, immoderately and without due measure. 

7. Modern Norms Today, other than individuals or a group such as the Parsee Vegetarian & Temperance Society, we have no consistent practice of community-wide Zoroastrian vegetarianism. The Indian-Zoroastrian bastions of Irani-Parsi food, the Irani cafés, are noticeably non-vegetarian. Nonetheless, this author has heard Iranians state that according to tradition, consuming an excess of red meat and fats results in evil thoughts and makes a person selfish.

12 The Hudinan Peshobay (meaning ‘leaders of the people of Good Religion’) were leaders of the Zoroastrian community who from the 9th century CE were required by the ruling Arabs to act as representatives for the entire (shrinking) Zoroastrian community.

Were Ancient Zoroastrians & Aryans 19 K. E. Eduljee Vegetarian? July 2011-March 2015 I Research & Discussion

A. Shift in Norms The records we have just Where Aryan Vegetarianism examined indicate that over the Survives millennia, there has been a dramatic shift in Zoroastrian norms Aryan vegetarianism survives in some forms on the issues of slaughtering of Hinduism, Jainism and Buddhism. Buddhism animals, cooking meat over an originated in the eastern Gangetic state of open fire as in barbequing, and Magadha. Some scholars postulate that the eating (dead) flesh. Magi, the Magha, established Magadha. Their kings used the title ‘Arya’. The Indian Aryans as Hopefully, one Zoroastrian well as the Bon who spread their faith from the guiding principle that still survives Pamirs into Western Tibet, use the swastika in practice (if at times neglected) is symbol – though that is another story. the principle of moderation. 

8. Principle of Moderation The Zoroastrian guiding principle for many life-style choices (not moral or ethical choices) is moderation between the extremes of too much and too little. This guiding principle applies to food and drink as part of one’s life- style choices. 

9. Principles of Circumspection, Rightness & Beneficence The principle of moderation does not preclude the need to apply the tests of rightness, goodness and beneficence to every choice – to check if something or an act is helpful or harmful – and then to desist from that which is harmful.

The ethical imperative for Zoroastrians is to engage in acts of beneficence – acts of goodness and helpfulness.

()

Were Ancient Zoroastrians & Aryans 20 K. E. Eduljee Vegetarian? July 2011-March 2015 II References

PART II REFERENCES 1. Zoroastrian Scriptures & Texts Avesta – Transliterations to the Roman script by this author based on transliterations by I. J. S. Taraporewala (citing Christian Bartholomae), T. R. Sethna, K. F. Geldner, H. Humbach, P. Ichaporia, M. C. Monna. Transliterations to the Devanagari script by J. M. Chatterji13. Translations to English by I. J. S. Taraporewala, T. R. Sethna, F. Rustamji, M. F. Kanga, J. M. Chatterji, J. Darmesteter, C. Bartholomae, L. H. Mills, A. Jafarey, H. Humbach, J. H. Moulton, M. C. Monna, K. E. Eduljee.

Bundahishn – Translations to English by B. T. Anklesaria14, E. W. West15, R. C. Zaehner, S. H. Nasr, M. Aminrezavi.

Dadistan-i Denig – Translation to English by E. W. West in Sacred Books of the East Vol. 18 (Oxford, 1882).

Denkard – Translations to English by R. E. Kohiyar, B. Sanjana, D. M. Madon, E. W. West, S. Shaked.

Menog-i Kharad – Translation to English by E. W. West in Sacred Books of the East Vol. 18 (Oxford, 1885).

Sayings of Adarbad Mahraspandan – Translation to English by R. C. Zaehner in The Teachings of the Magi (London, 1956) pp. 110 ff. 

2. Other Scriptures & Religious Texts Hebrew Bible – The Holy Scriptures According to the Masoretic Text. Hebrew text and translation to English. Jewish Publication Society (Philadelphia, 1917).

Manu Smriti (Laws of Manu) – Translation to English by W. Jones (Calcutta, 1796). 

13 J. M. Chatterji’s The Hymns of Atharvan Zarathushtra (Calcutta, 1967). 14 Zand-Akasih – Iranian or Greater Bundahishn (Bombay, 1956). 15 Pahlavi Texts in Sacred Books of the East, Vol. V, F. Max Müller ed., (Oxford, 1880).

Were Ancient Zoroastrians & Aryans 21 K. E. Eduljee Vegetarian? July 2011-March 2015 II References

3. Classical & Medieval Texts De Abstinentia/Abstinence (from Animal Foods) – Porphyry. Translated to English by T. Taylor in Selected Works of Porphyry (London, 1823).

Histories – Herodotus. Translation to English by George Rawlinson (New York, 1875); George Macaulay (London, New York, 1890), Henry Cary (Oxford, 1847) & Alfred Godley (Cambridge, 1920).

Library of History – Diodorus Siculus. Translation to English by C. H. Oldfather (Vols. 1-6); C. L. Sherman (Vol. 7), C. Bradford Welles (Vol. 8), R. M. Geer (Vols. 9 &10), F. R. Walton (Vol. 11), (Boston, 1933).

Lives of Eminent Philosophers – Diogenes Laertius. Translation to English by R. D. Hicks (London, 1925).

Lucian of Samosata – (1) W. Tooke from the German translation by C. M. Wieland (London, 1820), Vol. 2. (2) The Works of Lucian from the Greek translation to English by T. Francklin (London, 1780) in three volumes. (3) Works of Lucian of Samosata translated to English by H. W. and F. G. Fowler (Oxford,1905).

Naturalis Historia (Natural History) – Pliny the Elder. Translations to English by (1) J. Bostock & H. Riley (London, 1855), (2) H. Rackham, W. Jones & D. Eichholz (London, 1949-54).

Shahnameh – Ferdowsi. Translation by Arthur and Edmond Warner, The Shahnama of Firdausi, 9 vols. (London, 1905-1925) & selected verse translations to English by K. E. Eduljee . 

4. Scholarly Texts Boyce, M. – A History of Zoroastrianism: Under the Achaemenians Vol. 2 (Leiden, 1982).

Boyce, M. – Zoroastrians (London, 1979).

Brunnhofer, H. – Urgeschichte der Arier in Vorder- und Centralasien (Prehistory of the Aryans in West- and Central-Asia) Vol. 1 (Leipzig, 1893).

Buckingham, J. S. – Travels in Assyria, Media and Persia Vol. II (London, 1830).

Eduljee, K. E. – Immortal Cypress Companion (West Vancouver, 2012-13).

Elphinstone, M. – An Account of the Kingdom of Caubul and Its Dependencies in Persia Vol. II (London, 1839).

Were Ancient Zoroastrians & Aryans 22 K. E. Eduljee Vegetarian? July 2011-March 2015 II References

Geiger, W. – Civilization of the Eastern Iranians in Ancient Times Vols. 1 & 2 tr. Dastur Peshotan-Sanjana, (London/Bombay, 1886).

Hall, M. E. – ‘Towards an Absolute Chronology for the Iron Age of Inner Asia’ at Antiquity Vol. 71 (1997, pub. online 2015).

Harmatta, J. – History of Civilization of Central Asia Vol. 2 (New Delhi, 1999).

Harris, D. R. – Origins of Agriculture in Western Central Asia: An Environmental-Archaeological Study (Pennsylvania, 2011).

Haug, M. – Essays on the Sacred Language, Writings, and Religion of the Parsis (London, 1878).

Humbach H. – King of Paradise (Mainz, 2005).

Jamaspji, H. – An Old Zand-Pahlavi Glossary (Stuttgart, 1867).

Kanga, N. M. – The Pahlavi Vendidad (Bombay, 1900).

Lambton, A. – Landlord and Peasant in Persia (New York, 1991).

Lambton, A. – ‘Land Tenure and Revenue Administration’ at The Cambridge History of Iran Vol. 7 (Cambridge, 1991).

Malandra, W. – ‘Geush Tashan’ at Iranica (online, 2001).

Mills, L. H. – A Study of the Five Zarathushtrian (Zoroastrian) Gathas (Oxford, 1892).

Moulton, J. – Early Zoroastrianism (London, 1926).

Pumpelly, R. – Explorations in Turkestan - Expedition of 1903 (Washington, 1905).

Pumpelly, R. – Explorations in Turkestan - Expedition of 1904 Vols. 1 & 2 (Washington, 1908).

Schmid, W. – ‘Die Kuh auf die Weide’ at Indogermanische Forschungen (Stassburg,1958).

Taraporewala, I. J. S. – The Religion of Zarathushtra (Madras, 1926).

Tucci, G. – The Religions of Tibet tr. G. Samuel (Los Angeles, 1980).



Were Ancient Zoroastrians & Aryans 23 K. E. Eduljee Vegetarian? July 2011-March 2015 II References

5. Health & Cooking References Brown, A. – Understanding Food: Principles and Preparation (Manao, 2010).

Donohoe, Garge, Zhang, Sun, O’Connell, Thomas, Bunger, Bultman, Scott – ‘The Microbiome and Butyrate Regulate Energy Metabolism and Autophagy in the Mammalian Colon’ at the US National Library of Medicine, National Institutes of Health (online, 2011).

Ichaporia, N. King – My Bombay Kitchen: Traditional and Modern Parsi Home Cooking (California, 2007).

Månsson, H. – ‘Fatty Acids in Bovine Milk Fat’ at the US National Library of Medicine, National Institutes of Health (online, 2008).

Parker-Pope, T. – ‘Confusion about Mediterranean Food’ (New York Times, 2009).

Various – ‘Low-Fat Dietary Pattern and Risk of Cardiovascular Disease’, ‘Low-Fat Dietary Pattern and Risk of Colorectal Cancer’ and ‘Low-Fat Dietary Pattern and Risk of Invasive Breast Cancer’ at Journal of the American Medical Assn. (online, 2006).

Various – ‘Low-Fat Diet Not a Cure-All’ and ‘Fats and Cholesterol: Out with the Bad, In with the Good’ at Harvard School of Public Health (online, c. 2012).

Zhang, Poplawski, Yen, Cheng, Bloss, Zhu, Patel, Mobbs – ‘Role of CBP and SATB-1 in Aging, Dietary Restriction, and Insulin-Like Signalling’ at the US National Library of Medicine, National Institutes of Health (online, 2009).



Were Ancient Zoroastrians & Aryans 24 K. E. Eduljee Vegetarian? July 2011-March 2015 II References

6. Zoroastrian Heritage Webpage References A. General Pages Airyana Vaeja at Zoroastrian Heritage – http://www.heritageinstitute.com/zoroastrianism/aryans/airyanavaeja.htm

Aryans at Zoroastrian Heritage – http://www.heritageinstitute.com/zoroastrianism/ aryans/index.htm

Aryan Connections with Western Tibet at Zoroastrian Heritage blog – http://zoroastrianheritage.blogspot.ca/2011/07/iranian-aryan-connections- with-western.html

Bon Theology & Philosophy at Zoroastrian Heritage blog – http://zoroastrianheritage.blogspot.ca/2011/07/bon-zoroastrianism- dualism_20.html

Kareez at Zoroastrian Heritage – http://www.heritageinstitute.com/zoroastrianism/kareez/index.htm

Magi at Zoroastrian Heritage – http://www.heritageinstitute.com/zoroastrianism/priests/index.htm

Nisaya/Anau at Zoroastrian Heritage – http://www.heritageinstitute.com/zoroastrianism/nisa/anau.htm

Parthava/Parthia at Zoroastrian Heritage – http://www.heritageinstitute.com/zoroastrianism/parthia/index.htm B. Health & Healing Pages Were Ancient Iranians & Zoroastrians Vegetarian? at Zoroastrian Heritage blog – http://zoroastrianheritage.blogspot.ca/2011/07/were-ancient-iranians- zoroastrians.html

Zoroastrian Heritage and Healing at Zoroastrian Heritage blog – http://zoroastrianheritage.blogspot.ca/2010/07/zoroastrian-heritage-and- healing.html

Health & Healing at Zoroastrian Heritage – http://www.heritageinstitute.com/zoroastrianism/healing/index.htm

()

Were Ancient Zoroastrians & Aryans 25 K. E. Eduljee Vegetarian? July 2011-March 2015 III.1 Appendices – Paneer & Roghan in Aryana’s History & Traditions

PART III APPENDICES 1. Paneer & Roghan in Aryana’s History & Traditions A. Saka & Butter The Saka were an Aryan group of whom the famed legendary heroes, the pahlavans Rustam and , were members and from whom the Parthians had likely descended. During Achaemenid times, say 700 to 330 BCE, the Saka lived around the Aral Sea and east of the Syr Darya (Jaxartes) River – the Saka Para-Sugd meaning the ‘Saka beyond Sogdiana’ or alternatively Saka Para-Darya meaning the ‘Saka beyond the River’ (Syr/Jaxartes). In the Mahabharata, the Saka nation is mentioned together with several regional nations including Chin (China). Saka lands extended up to the borders of China.

Various Saka archaeological sites dating to between c.1000 BCE and 500 CE have been discovered east of the up to the Tarim Basin and Mongolia. One of these sites is located in the region the Saka Tigrakhauda (who were also called Saka with the pointed hats) inhabited. The site, which is currently located in south-eastern Kazakhstan close to the ancient town of Issyk has yielded some well preserved artifacts that include clothing and armour that may have been worn by a prince or princess – and a very tall pointed cap. The artifacts date to between the 4th and 3rd centuries BCE.

Among the artifacts is a silver chalice with an inscription that archaeologists describe as being related to the Kharoshthi script. A tentative translation of the inscription includes the words “cooked fresh butter”, which if correct would mean clarified butter. In addition, Jeannine Davis-Kimball notes that “wooden beaters for koumiss (fermented mare’s milk) were also found in the tomb.” Beating milk leads to the production of cream and butter. Similar beaters have been found in the Ukok Plateau in the Altai Mountains dating to the 5th century Wooden butter churn. Image BCE. We wonder if the wooden beaters found in the Saka sites credit: Bazin & Bromberger in were forerunners to the wooden butter churns described by Iranica. Marcel Bazin and Christian Bromberger as being used in Iran and Afghanistan. If the identification of butter beaters/churns is correct, we wonder if the custom had any connection to the Avestan concept of roghan (clarified butter) being the earthly representation of soul food. Besides the Avestan and Vedic references to clarified butter (that would have preceded

Were Ancient Zoroastrians & Aryans 26 K. E. Eduljee Vegetarian? July 2011-March 2015 III.1 Appendices – Paneer & Roghan in Aryana’s History & Traditions the site date), the Issyk and Ukok artifacts are among the earliest physical artifacts found that relate to butter or clarified butter. B. Traditional Iranian & Afghan Milk Processing According to Bazin and Bromberger, in Iran and Afghanistan, milk is rarely consumed in raw form but is processed to make paneer by heating, pressing, squeezing and drying, curds (NP kashk, Pashto korot), yogurt (NP maast, Pashto maasti), butter (NP kara, maska, Pashto kuch) from churned yogurt and buttermilk (NP doogh, Pashto shlumbi) as a by-product in the making of butter from yogurt.

Making butter from yogurt by means of vigorous agitation and churning is very common amongst Iranian and Afghan herders. Most of the butter is made into clarified butter (NP rowgan, Pashto guri) while most of the buttermilk is consumed as a beverage; the remainder is transformed into curds and related products.

While Iranian nomads commonly used churns made from goatskin bags (NP mashk/keek, Pashto garchka) suspended from a tripod, the variety of equipment used to churn milk testifies to the importance milk products played in the Skin bag used to butter churn by shaking. traditional diet of the Aryans. Image credit: Bazin & Bromberger in Iranica. C. Clarified Butter as Payment in Medieval Iran We read that in medieval Iran, clarified butter formed part of the payment peasants made to their landlords. Ann Lambton writes, “In many districts the landlord exacted, in addition to a share of the crop, so many days free labour from the peasants… and dues in clarified butter….” Further, “…this is an old custom….” D. Milk Products in Kafiristan Mountstuart Elphinstone in his book An Account of the Kingdom of Caubul and Its Dependencies in Persia writes, “The food of the common people is bread, croot [our note: croûte? Crust as in pastry?], clarified butter, and occasionally flesh and cheese. The shepherds and the villagers, in spring, also use a great deal of curds, cheese, milk, cream and butter. They also eat vegetables, and a great deal of fruit. Those in camps only get melons, but the settled inhabitants have all our best English fruits.” “Their drink is sherbet, which is made of various fruits, and some kinds of it are very pleasant.” In a

Were Ancient Zoroastrians & Aryans 27 K. E. Eduljee Vegetarian? July 2011-March 2015 III.1 Appendices – Paneer & Roghan in Aryana’s History & Traditions note Elphinstone adds, “The clarified butter keeps long without spoiling. The cream is either common cream, or a preparation called kymauk, which is made from boiled milk, and is something like clouted cream.” He also writes of butter being used as a balm for sore feet.

When Elphinstone wrote his account just under two hundred years ago, there was a district in Afghanistan’s Hindu Kush Mountains just south of Badakhshan – a district known to the Muslims as Kafiristan, the district of the non-believers. The district is known today as Nuristan having ‘seen the light’ by succumbing to the pressures of the hordes around them to abandon their ancient faith. Elphinstone’s account of (spelt ‘Caufirs’ by him) is enlightening.

If time and opportunity avail themselves to this author, Kafiristan is worthy of a monograph unto itself. For the time being we will constrain ourselves and limit our observations to those of Elphinstone’s passages that relate to clarified butter: “The houses of the Caufirs are often of wood, and they have Celebrating the Chilam Josh May mid-spring festival (cf. the Zoroastrian generally cellars where Maidyozarem Gahanbar) in Kalash Kafiristan on the Pakistani side of the border. Image credit: Pakimag.com they keep their cheeses, clarified butter, wine, and vinegar.” “Their food is chiefly cheese, butter, and milk, with bread or a sort of suet pudding: they also eat flesh (which they like half raw); and the fruits they have, walnuts, grapes, apples, almonds, and a sort of indifferent apricot that grows wild. They wash their hands before eating, and generally begin by some kind of grace. They all, of both sexes, drink wine to great excess: they have three kinds, red, white, and dark- coloured, besides a sort of the consistence of a jelly, and very strong. They drink wine, both pure and diluted, out of large silver cups, which are the most precious of their possessions. They drink during their meals, and are elevated, but not made quarrelsome, by this indulgence. They are exceedingly hospitable. The people of a village come out to meet a stranger, take his baggage from those who are carrying it, and conduct him with many welcomes into their village.”

Were Ancient Zoroastrians & Aryans 28 K. E. Eduljee Vegetarian? July 2011-March 2015 III.1 Appendices – Paneer & Roghan in Aryana’s History & Traditions

E. Ghee in Hindu Tradition [Ghee is a form of clarified butter (see the next section). In Hindu scriptures, ghee is called ghart, go-ghart or ghartam. In modern Nepali, a Hindi dialect, it is called gheeu while in the old Tibeto-Burman aboriginal Nepali Bhasa it is called ghya cf. Avestan gaya.]

(i) Ghee in the Panchamritha Foods of Immortality Ghee is one of the five panchamritha (i.e. panch-amritha), the five foods of immortality. The other four are rock sugar, honey, milk, and yogurt.

(ii) Ghee in the Homa Ceremony Ghee is also a central part of the homa/havana/havan liturgy devoted to fire, Agni. In Zoroastrianism, haoma is the chief among the medicinal plants that can be pounded to extract their juice, a process ritualized in the Yasna liturgy. The Zoroastrian Yasna has a Hindu counterpart called the Yajna. In Zoroastrian ritual, havan is the mortar in which the haoma stalks are pound.

(iii) Ghee in Ayurvedic Healing In Ayurveda, ghee is considered a satvic food – foods that on the one hand promote positivity, growth and heightened consciousness while on the other hand reducing negativity, negative emotions and the start or storage of feelings that sustain a negative state of mind.

Ayurveda holds that ghee is medhya meaning intellect promoting. Ghee consumption [judiciously, we add] is said to increase dhi, intelligence, refine buddhi, the intellect, and improve smrti, the memory. Ghee is also rasayana or vitalizing to the mind and body.



Were Ancient Zoroastrians & Aryans 29 K. E. Eduljee Vegetarian? July 2011-March 2015 III.2Appendices – Milk’s Composition

2. Milk’s Composition Milk is a mixture of proteins, fats, carbohydrates, vitamins and minerals in water.

Composition of Cow’s Milk Range Average Main Ingredients (%) (%) Water 85.5 – 89.5 87.0 Solids: 14.5 – 10.5 13.0

- Proteins: 2.9 – 5.0 3.4

- Caseins (76-86%)

- Whey proteins (14-24%) - Fat (98% triacylglycerols) 2.5 – 6.0 4.0 - Carbohydrate (lactose) 3.6 – 5.5 4.8 - Vitamins & Minerals 0.6 – 0.9 0.8

A. Milk – a Food Designed by Nature Nature has designed milk as a nutritious, composite and whole food for the growth of young animals. Zoroastrian tradition sees the milk products cheese and clarified butter as foods for humans of all ages. B. Milk Vitamins The vitamins in milk are of two types: water and oil soluble – all are natural multivitamins in a natural state. Throw out milk’s watery part (whey) and you throw out the water-soluble vitamins. Throw out the cream or butter and you throw out the oil soluble vitamins.

The water-soluble vitamins include B1, B2 and B12 including small amounts of B3, B5, B6, and C. The fat-soluble vitamins include A, D, E, and K. We read that mild pasteurization does not degrade the vitamins appreciably. However, prolonged high heat will degrade some of the water- soluble vitamins. C. Milk Minerals The minerals in milk include calcium, magnesium, phosphorus, potassium, selenium, and zinc together with small amounts of copper, iron, manganese, and sodium. About half are bound within the protein casein. The remaining minerals are dissolved in the milk’s water.

Were Ancient Zoroastrians & Aryans 30 K. E. Eduljee Vegetarian? July 2011-March 2015 III.2Appendices – Milk’s Composition

D. Milk Proteins Proteins are an important part of or muscles, bones, hair and organs. Most enzymes and many hormones are proteins. Besides water, proteins are the largest components of human muscles, tissues and cells.

(i) Make-up of Proteins. Amino Acids The building blocks of proteins are amino acids. Proteins are long chains of amino acid residues strung together. By themselves, amino acids play critical roles in the human body as neurotransmitters and in biosynthesis.

(ii) Essential Amino Acids. Milk has all Nine While the human body can make (synthesize) several amino acids, it cannot make nine amino acids. These nine essential amino acids must be obtained from proteins in vegetable or animal food. Milk proteins contain all nine essential amino acid residues.

(iii) Digestion of Proteins Food Digestion Time (Approx. time in stomach before emptying into the intestine.) (Very rough guide for comparative purposes only) Water When stomach is empty, leaves immediately and goes into intestines. Fruit & vegetable juices, 15 – 20 minutes vegetable Fruits 20 – 40 minutes Vegetables, raw salad type 30 – 40 minutes Vegetables, cooked food 30 – 40 minutes type Eggs 30 – 45 minutes Fish 30 – 60 minutes Grains, beans, nuts 1.5 – 3.5 hours Milk & soft cheeses 1.5 – 2 hours Poultry 1.5 – 2 hours Red meats 3 – 6 hours

The human body does not use proteins in the original form we consume them (as food). Most proteins are broken down to their components parts during digestion. The components are then absorbed through the intestines and transported to cells where they are used to build (synthesize) new

Were Ancient Zoroastrians & Aryans 31 K. E. Eduljee Vegetarian? July 2011-March 2015 III.2Appendices – Milk’s Composition proteins needed by the human body. The newly made proteins are released by the cells into the body fluids once the synthesis is complete.

Therefore, it is critical to consume proteins in forms that can be easily broken down into components during the digestion process. Humans cannot easily digest all proteins. Further, we suspect the digestion process will slow down with increase in a person’s age making it incumbent to consume foods in a manner that aids digestion.

(iv) Solubility of Proteins Some proteins can mix with water to make a solution while others cannot mix with water without some help. In the making of paneer, the addition of lemon juice (an acid) to whole milk causes the casein proteins to separate from the milk’s water base leaving water-soluble proteins in the whey.

(v) Classification of Milk Proteins The phenomenon described above enables us to classify milk proteins as caseins and whey proteins (enzymes are yet another group of milk proteins).

(a) Caseins Casein together with milk fats separate as solids called curds when an acid or an enzyme called rennin/rennet is added to whole milk.

(b) Whey proteins The remaining liquid, called whey contains the water-soluble substances: , sugars and soluble proteins. Like the proteins in eggs, whey proteins can be coagulated by heat.

(c) Enzymes Catalysts (change agents) either stimulate or quicken a chemical reaction. Enzymes are catalysts for metabolism16 – a process by which the body breaks down or builds up compounds. Most enzymes are proteins and can be distinguished by the endings of their names.

Lipases are the main enzymes found in milk. They break down fats (lipids). When milk is agitated, the lipases can come in contact with milk fats causing them to degrade and making the milk rancid. This is particularly noticed with homogenized milk where the fat globules have been reduced in size to prevent them from rising to the top.

Proteases break down proteins. The predominant protease in milk is plasmin. While on the one hand protein break down caused by protease can lead to undesirable tastes, on the other hand the break down results in desirable tastes and textures during the ‘ripening’ of cheese.

16 Metabolic processes range from the digestion of food to the synthesis of DNA.

Were Ancient Zoroastrians & Aryans 32 K. E. Eduljee Vegetarian? July 2011-March 2015 III.2Appendices – Milk’s Composition

Heat deactivates most milk enzymes. Pasteurization deactivates lipases and a few other enzymes thereby increasing pasteurized milk’s shelf life. The deactivation of the enzyme alkaline phosphatase is used as an indicator that pasteurization of milk is complete.

The products of the enzyme breakdown of milk fats and proteins, though pre-digested and useful to the body, either smell or taste bad outside the digestive tract. E. Milk Fats (i) Composition of Milk Fats On an average, 4% of milk consists of fat. Milk fat has one of the most complex fatty acid compositions of all edible fats. Helena Månsson in her paper ‘Fatty Acids in Bovine Milk Fat’ at the US National Library of Medicine notes that while milk fat has over 400 individual fatty acids residues, 15 to 20 of fatty acid residues make up 90% of milk fat.

Månsson also notes that “the composition of fatty acid [residues] in milk fat changes during a cow’s lactation cycle” and further, “Many factors are associated with the variations in the amount and fatty acid composition of bovine milk lipids… they may be feed-related factors, i.e. related to fiber and energy intake, dietary fats, and seasonal and regional effects.” As such, spring milk extolled in Zoroastrian literature likely has a different fat and nutrition content to that of milk drawn at other times of the year. Given the discovery of a multitude of remarkable health benefits associated with fats containing butyric acid residues (see next section) this may be significant.

(ii) Fat Digestion In the digestive tract starting with the stomach, triglycerides (which make up most milk fats) are digested by the enzyme lipase. The digestion process breaks up the rather large triglyceride fat molecules into smaller components that can be absorbed through the intestine’s walls into the body.

Fats are digested more slowly than proteins or carbohydrates. The slower rate of digestion is nature’s way of maintaining an even amount of energy availability. Fats are a vital medium to long-term energy source.

Månsson continues to inform us that the digestion of milk fats starts by the action of enzymes secreted in the mouth (likely in the saliva that would increase with the chewing of say cheese over drinking milk). It continues in the stomach, where after the addition of gastric enzymes, 25-40% of the fats are digested. At this stage, the triglyceride in the milk fat globule core is partially digested. Digestion continues in first section of small intestine, the duodenum, where the enzyme lipase and bile acids complete the process initiated in the stomach. The digestion of large triglycerides is helped by bile acids that emulsify and expose the fat to the lipases.

Were Ancient Zoroastrians & Aryans 33 K. E. Eduljee Vegetarian? July 2011-March 2015 III.2Appendices – Milk’s Composition

Once the fatty acids and monoglycerides pass through the wall of the intestine, they are used to build a fresh set of triglyceride fats that are delivered to the body’s cells where they are broken down once again before being absorbed into the cell. iii) Fats’ Ability or Inability to Mix with Water Fats as oils do not normally mix with water. If a mixture of the two is left standing, the two will quickly separate – unless the fatty oil is helped to stay mixed in with the water. A mixture of oil or fat and water is called an emulsion.

Raw milk is an example of an emulsion of fat in water. In raw milk, the fats (also called lipids) are spread out in the milk’s water in the form of very tiny spheres or globules. The fat globules are coated with a thin skin of protein that keeps them apart from one another. If the fat spheres clump together, they will separate from the rest of the milk.

Raw milk is not a very stable emulsion. If milk is left standing still for some time, the fat spheres begin to clump together and the fat – being lighter than water – rises to the top of the milk as cream.

Milk & cream separation in raw milk. Image credit: PlannedResilience.net.



Were Ancient Zoroastrians & Aryans 34 K. E. Eduljee Vegetarian? July 2011-March 2015 III.3 Appendices – Cream, Cheese & Clarified Butter

3. Cream, Cheese & Clarified Butter Zoroastrian tradition sees milk products such as cheese and clarified butter as foods for humans of all ages – as long as they are consumed frugally and judiciously. To this caveat we add: and provided a person’s body has not become intolerant of a particular milk product. In Iranian tradition, other than the limited use of milk in the making of haoma extracts, raw milk is seldom consumed.

When milk’s proteins, fats, carbohydrates (also called sugars) and other substances can no longer stay dispersed in milk’s water base, many milk components separate as solids. In doing so, they form products like cream, cheese and butter. A. Cream Cream contains fats (and some proteins) that are lighter than water. If raw milk is left to stand in a refrigerator for 24 to 48 hours, a layer of cream forms on the surface. The process can be accelerated by first boiling the milk for 3-5 minutes. When the cream is removed, the remaining milk, called skimmed milk, usually has only a small amount of fat left suspended in it. B. Cheese – Paneer/Panir Cheese consists of solidified milk components (mainly proteins and fats).

(i) Making Paneer. Curds In a simple process, the addition of an acid such as lemon juice or vinegar to warmed milk, breaks down the ability of milk components such as proteins and fats to stay dispersed in water causing them to separate as solid pieces called curd. The remaining liquid is called whey. Milk curdles naturally in the human stomach because of digestive acids and enzymes.

(ii) Rennet/Rennin

A stomach enzyme found in some Curds and whey. Image credit: Susan Waughtal. young animals called rennet or rennin also curdles milk (rennet can be extracted from plants as well). In the making of topli nu paneer (Gujarati for basket paneer – see below), the lining of chicken stomach (dry chicken gizzard) is added to the milk as a source of rennet. Strict vegetarians may wish to use vegetable rennet.

Were Ancient Zoroastrians & Aryans 35 K. E. Eduljee Vegetarian? July 2011-March 2015 III.3 Appendices – Cream, Cheese & Clarified Butter

The advantage of using rennet is that there is less residual taste of lemon or vinegar in the cheese. We also read that using rennet results in a more firm cheese.

(iii) Whey Whey is the liquid that remains after the curd has coagulated. It consists of water and a few remaining water-soluble milk components such as milk carbohydrates (primarily lactose) and some proteins. Whey has its own nutrient value and is popular with athletes.

(iv) Using Cream, Yogurt, Whole or Skimmed Milk If paneer is made from whole milk or just cream, it has a higher fat content. If cream is added, the paneer Strained curds in cheese cloth. Image credit: Jordana Living becomes ricotta-like. If the paneer is made from skimmed milk, it has cottage cheese like higher protein content (since most of the fat was removed as cream).

Niloufer Ichaporia King in her My Bombay Kitchen: Traditional and Modern Parsi Home Cooking informs us that yogurt and cream can be added at the start to produce a tart, creamy paneer. Her recipe calls for 4 cups of milk and a mixture of a cup of yogurt, ½ a cup of heavy cream, and 2 teaspoons of salt. She first lets the yogurt stand at room temperature for a day to produce a more acidic paneer. She also brings the milk to a boil four times – removing the pan from the heat once the boiling milk has risen to the rim of the pot and then returning the milk to a boil. After the fifth boil, she adds the yogurt, cream and salt mixture with a vigorous whisk until the curds begin to separate. Since we did not see any acid or rennet in her recipe, we presume that the acid in the yogurt17 curdles the milk.

(v) Straining The curds are stained in a sieve or over folded cheesecloth. The curds left in the sieve or cheesecloth are essentially cottage cheese. The making of paneer requires some of the remaining water to be squeezed out leaving a compact solid mass that can be cut with a knife.

17 Yogurt is made by bacteria fermenting milk lactose to produce lactic acid, which in turn acts on milk protein to give yogurt its texture and characteristic tang.

Were Ancient Zoroastrians & Aryans 36 K. E. Eduljee Vegetarian? July 2011-March 2015 III.3 Appendices – Cream, Cheese & Clarified Butter

(vi) Squeezing out the Water Water left in the curds can be squeezed out by twisting the top of the cheesecloth to make a ball beneath, and then leaving the twisted cheese cloth standing until the water stops dripping out. The result is a cheese ball similar to mozzarella in shape. The ball can be pressed flat. Alternatively, the cheesecloth can be placed on a flat sieve with a weight placed on top to press out the water and produce a slab of paneer.

(vii) Topli nu Paneer If the cheesecloth or curds are placed and drained in a pot shaped basket of convenient size, the resulting paneer is called topli nu paneer in Gujarati, a tradition that was once very popular with Parsi & Irani Zoroastrians of India. Authentic topli nu paneer retains the indentations of the basket weave.

(viii) Lactose in Cheese Depending on the way a cheese is made, it may contain little lactose carbohydrate (which remains dissolved in the whey). We read that harder, older cheeses have lower amounts of lactose.

(ix) Salt in Cheese To increase paneer’s shelf life and taste, salt can be added to the milk before it is curdled or the paneer can be stored in brine making it a type of cheese. Making paneer. Image credit: FXcusine.com

Were Ancient Zoroastrians & Aryans 37 K. E. Eduljee Vegetarian? July 2011-March 2015 III.3 Appendices – Cream, Cheese & Clarified Butter

(x) Plain Paneer Paneer that is intended to be eaten fresh often has no added salt. The resulting paneer absorbs the flavours of a savoury Making Clarified Butter dish or it can be sweetened to make a dessert. C. Butter & Buttermilk Butter is an accumulation of milk fats. Butter is made by shaking or churning whole milk, cream or yogurt until the microscopic fat globules suspended in them break down and loose their protective protein coatings. In the process, the water in the milk, cream or yogurt further separates and is called buttermilk, a by-product like whey.

If milk was a water-in-oil emulsion, butter is an oil-in-water emulsion. Water makes up nearly 30% Skimming protein from melted butter. of traditional soft butters with the balance Image credit: Anna Maria’s Open Kitchen. consisting mainly of milk fats.

The amount of protein left in butter is relatively low – about 1% by weight. If butter is made directly from milk, the milk’s protein is largely concentrated in the buttermilk.

The water, carbohydrates and proteins left in butter can be further removed by converting the butter to clarified butter.

D. Clarified Butter – Roghan Pouring/decanting the clarified butter. Clarified butter (roghan) consists of milk fats Image credit: Anna Maria’s Open Kitchen. separated from milk proteins and carbohydrates (sugars). It is made by melting butter and skimming, decanting or otherwise separating the solids (mainly protein and some remaining sugars) from the liquid. Any water present in the butter evaporates during the process. The remaining fat is called clarified butter that is solid or liquid depending on the ambient temperature.

Clarified butter has a higher smoke point, about 252 °C, compared to regular butter’s smoke point of 163 to 190 °C, and a longer shelf life. It can be Refrigerated/hardened clarified butter. stored at room temperature like other cooking oils. Image credit: macheesmo.com.

Were Ancient Zoroastrians & Aryans 38 K. E. Eduljee Vegetarian? July 2011-March 2015 III.3 Appendices – Cream, Cheese & Clarified Butter

(i) Healing Properties of Clarified Butter James Buckingham in his 1830 book Travels in Assyria, Media and Persia, writes that when an English ship was captured by Arabs, the Arabs punished its captain by cutting off his right arm and leaving him to bleed to death. The captain warmed a tub of clarified butter and dipped the stump of his arm in the oil thereby saving his life. E. Clarified Butter – Ghee

Fresh ghee & butter on a banana leaf. Image credit: R. Shivaji Rao.

If during the making of clarified butter, the milk solids (proteins and sugars?) are heated to the extent that they brown and caramelize before being separated from the liquid fat, the clarified butter becomes ghee. The caramelized solids impart a somewhat nutty flavour to the ghee (before they are removed by straining while the ghee is a liquid).



Were Ancient Zoroastrians & Aryans 39 K. E. Eduljee Vegetarian? July 2011-March 2015 III.4 Appendices – Health Risks & Benefits

4. Health Risks & Benefits [The information included below and elsewhere in this monograph, is provided for informational purposes only. You should independently conduct research, or seek professional advice, before starting any dietary program.] A. Milk Fats. Fact & Myth. Risks & Benefits Milk and milk products such as cheese (paneer) and clarified butter (roghan) contain fats (lipids). Are these fats good or bad for humans when consumed? Should milk fats be consumed or avoided?

(i) Fat Facts The word ‘fat’ has become prejudicial and we feel compelled to come to its rescue. Life and good health would not be possible if we did not have some fat or consume what are called ‘fats’.

In keeping with Zoroastrian philosophy, fats contain and contribute to the existential duality of nature. They can be beneficial or harmful. Existential duality compels us to make choices for which we are entirely responsible.

The fats present in milk have a nutritional purpose. Yet there can be harm when fats are consumed immoderately. Fats can make us look good or ugly. They can help us survive or they can be the cause of heart diseases and cancer leading to death. With a good understanding of the nature of fats, we can make informed choices.

While we may think of fats as something to avoid in our diet or to get rid of in our bodies, fats are one of the three main food groups we need to survive and stay healthy. Humans, animals and plants all use fat as a fuel. In plants, oils (fats) are mainly found in seeds where they provide energy until the seedlings are capable of using solar energy. For us humans, fats supply the energy our bodies need to function and to see us through times when food supplies are unpredictable – even helping us survive for several weeks without food, or at least until the next meal. In addition, fat has many other functions. Milk fats are carriers of certain essential vitamins. When we consume milk fats, we consume the associated vitamins as well.

Our bodies and brains will stop functioning if we have no fat.

On the negative side, certain kinds of fat or an excess of fat in an obese body can lead to health problems.

(ii) Harvard & National Inst. for Health. Study on Fats’ Risks One of the largest and most expense studies on whether normal fat consumption had negative health consequences was funded by the National

Were Ancient Zoroastrians & Aryans 40 K. E. Eduljee Vegetarian? July 2011-March 2015 III.4 Appendices – Health Risks & Benefits

Heart, Lung and Blood Institute of the National Institute for Health. A large part of the research was conducted by Harvard University. The study cost $415 million, likely over a billion dollars in today’s money.

The randomized, controlled, primary prevention trial was conducted at 40 US clinical centers from 1993 to 2005 on 48,835 postmenopausal women, aged 50 to 79 years divided between a control group and those placed on a low-fat diet.

The study concluded that there were no evident health benefits for about 20,000 women (including women from different ethnic groups) on a low-fat diet. The study also found that these women had “virtually identical” heart, stroke and cancer (breast and colorectal) disease rates as did the 30,000 women who were not on the diet. After eight years, the women on the low fat/low calorie diet were also generally of the same weight as those women who were not on the diet.

However, other studies have shown that there is a relationship between red meat consumption and breast cancer. Further, the consumption of too many calories from fats and carbohydrates leading to excessive weight gain increases the risk of breast cancer, colon cancer, and heart disease.

As such, the study informs us that a moderate consumption of fat does not increase the risk of breast cancer, colon cancer, and heart disease. However, we also learn that an excessive intake of calories from fat and carbohydrate consumption leading to obesity increases the risk.

The Harvard School of Public Health reports, “It’s time to end the low-fat myth. For decades, a low-fat diet was touted as a way to lose weight and prevent or control heart disease and other chronic conditions, and food companies re-engineered products to be reduced-fat or fat-free, often compensating for differences in flavor and texture by increasing amounts of salt, sugar, or refined grains. However, as a nation, following a low-fat diet hasn’t helped us control weight or become healthier.” The myth nevertheless persists.

The fats in milk are essential foods for human beings when consumed temperately.

(iii) Benefits of Fats with Butyric Acid Residues About 3% of milk fats are triglycerides containing butyric acid residues. The name butyric is related to butter. Esters and salts of butyric acid are called butyrates. Triglycerides with butyric acid residues are found in milk, cheese, butter and clarified butter, with clarified butter having the highest concentration.

Were Ancient Zoroastrians & Aryans 41 K. E. Eduljee Vegetarian? July 2011-March 2015 III.4 Appendices – Health Risks & Benefits

Butyric acid is produced by the digestion of milk triglycerides containing butyric acid residues. Butyric acid is also produced in a healthy human intestine by beneficial bacteria acting on carbohydrates present in dietary fiber.

Butyric acid and butyrates have been found to contribute positively to general health and particularly to the health of the human digestive tract. The range of benefits is quite amazing and we will list only a few:

 They reduce colonization of the intestines by bad bacterial while promoting good bacteria. They also help strengthen the intestinal wall (while butyric acid does not smell particularly pleasant, rumour has it that its odour is what dogs seek to detect when sniffing other dogs during their socialization process – perhaps an indication of general health and a substitute for ‘how are you?’ and ‘I’m fine’ or otherwise);

 They aid colon health and are food for cells lining the colon without which the cells can die;

 They help inhibit intestinal inflammation, ulcerative colitis and colorectal cancer. They are also being investigated as possible treatments for parasitic and inflammatory diseases;

 Butyrates combat aging. Two butyrates, Sodium butyrate and trichostatin were found to increase the lifespan of experimental animals;

 Butyrates have for some time been used in psychiatry and neurology as mood stabilizers and anti-epileptics;

 Butyric acid inhibits absorption of fats by the small intestine into circulation. B. Cheese/Paneer. Risks & Benefits We have not yet found any studies related to spring cheese made from the milk of free-range cows in particular and gospand in general.

(i) Risks Consuming any food in excess may have health risks especially when excessive consumption of high calorie foods leads to obesity. Cheese is high in calories. Cheeses. Image credit: BerkeleyWellness.com. BerkeleyWellness.com (University of California) states, “…cheese is high in calories (about 100 per ounce, on average) and fat (6 to 9 grams per ounce, most of which is saturated), and it often contains a

Were Ancient Zoroastrians & Aryans 42 K. E. Eduljee Vegetarian? July 2011-March 2015 III.4 Appendices – Health Risks & Benefits

lot of sodium (100 to 300 milligrams an ounce). Still, small amounts can fit into most people’s diets.” [Calories, fat content (4-36%) and salt vary widely between different types of cheese.]

(ii) Benefits (a) Study: No Rise in LDL MensHealth.com: “Cheese is the new wine.” “Danish scientists found that when men ate 10 daily 1-ounce servings of full-fat cheese for 3 weeks, their LDL Image credit: BerkeleyWellness.com. (bad) cholesterol didn’t change.”

Wikipedia: “A review of the medical literature published in 2012 noted that, ‘Based on results from numerous prospective observational studies and meta-analyses, most, but not all, have shown no association and in some cases an inverse relationship between the intake of milk fat containing dairy products and the risk of cardiovascular disease, coronary heart disease and stroke. A limited number of prospective cohort studies found no significant association between the intake of total full-fat dairy products and the risk of coronary heart disease or stroke.... Most clinical studies Average cheese consumption and rates of mortality due to cardiovascular showed that full-fat natural disease or diabetes. There is no evident correlation between amount of cheese consumed and death rates due to heart problems and diabetes. cheese, a highly fermented has the highest consumption and one of the lowest death rates. product, significantly lowers France with the next highest consumption and Japan with the lowest LDL cholesterol compared consumption had the lowest death rates. Image credit: Wikipedia. with butter intake of equal total fat and saturated fat content.’”

(b) Nutrient Content & Benefits BerkeleyWellness.com: “…cheese provides calcium and protein, as well as some vitamin A, B12, riboflavin, zinc and phosphorus. It is a source of [small

Were Ancient Zoroastrians & Aryans 43 K. E. Eduljee Vegetarian? July 2011-March 2015 III.4 Appendices – Health Risks & Benefits amounts of] conjugated linoleic acid (CLA), a fat that may have anti-cancer, weight-reducing, and heart-protective effects.”

Mercola.com: “Cheese contains a synergistic blend of… vitamins K2 and D3 and calcium… powerful for protecting your bones, brain and heart.” “(According to) Dr. Kate Rheamue-Bleue, a Naturopathic Physician …Vitamin K2 plays critical roles in protecting your heart, brain, and bones, as well as giving you some protection from cancer. …K2 helps channel calcium into the proper areas of your body (bones and teeth) (and) prevents it from being deposited in areas where it shouldn’t, such as your arteries and soft tissues.”

(c) Dental Health BerkeleyWellness.com: “Cheese may help prevent cavities. In a small study from Turkey in 2008, published in the journal Caries, people who ate cheese (just 1/3 ounce) after rinsing with a sugar solution had a rapid decrease in acidity, which lowers the risk of cavities. Older studies have found a similar protective acid-buffering effect.” The Pharmaceutical Journal, January 2000, published a similar result.

(d) Appetite Suppression. Help to Avoid Overeating? MensHealth.com: “‘The combination of protein and fat in regular, full-fat cheese is very satiating,’ says Alan Aragon, a nutritionist in Westlake Village, California, and the Men's Health Weight-Loss Coach. ‘As a result, eating full- fat cheese holds your appetite at bay for hours, and I've found that it cuts down my clients’ food intake at subsequent meals.’” [Haoma (ephedra) plant extracts (that are part of the Zoroastrian Yasna ceremony) also reputedly have appetite suppression properties. The two in combination may effectively combat a tendency towards overeating or gluttony.]

(e) Cheese Improves Sleep & Reduces Stress Wikipedia: “The majority of the two hundred people tested over a fortnight claimed beneficial results from consuming cheeses before going to bed, the cheese promoting good sleep (Sleep Study, 2005, Britain). Cheese contains tryptophan, an amino acid that has been found to relieve stress and induce sleep.” C. Mediterranean Diet & Cheese Cheese, butter and yogurt are regularly included in traditional Mediterranean and Iranian diets – in low to moderate quantities. Tara Parker-Pope in a February 11, 2009 New York Times article noted that in the 1960s, while the dietary traditions of the Greek island of Crete as well as those of southern Italy included dairy products, these regions had one of the lowest rates of chronic disease in the world and some of the highest adult life expectancy rates as well.

Were Ancient Zoroastrians & Aryans 44 K. E. Eduljee Vegetarian? July 2011-March 2015 III.4 Appendices – Health Risks & Benefits

Note daily cheese consumption vs. infrequent meat consumption. Image credit: Kopiaste.

Parker-Pope continues, “The original work (a Mediterranean diet was good for you) that sparked scientific interest in Mediterranean eating habits came from researcher Ancel Keyes at the University of Minnesota. His landmark seven countries study focused on the link between eating habits along the Mediterranean and better health, despite inferior medical care in the region. Research on the diet took off in the 1990s, as scientists noted that people in Mediterranean countries lived longer and had low rates of serious disease despite high rates of smoking and drinking. Last year, the British Medical Journal published an extensive review of Mediterranean diet studies. It found that the eating plan is associated with significant health benefits, including lower rates of heart disease, cancer, Parkinson’s disease and Alzheimer’s.”

Our main interest in the Mediterranean diet was to find out whether or not diary products such as cheese resulted in all the problems speculated upon in some North America health articles.

What we discovered was that in practice, moderate to low consumption of cheese and allied diary products positively complemented traditional diets already low in meat and high in vegetables and fruit consumption.

Were Ancient Zoroastrians & Aryans 45 K. E. Eduljee Vegetarian? July 2011-March 2015 III.4 Appendices – Health Risks & Benefits

There is every indication that the Zoroastrian tradition of consuming moderate amounts of cheese and clarified butter (paneer and roghan) can contribute to good health.

Image credit: BerkeleyWellness.com.

()

Were Ancient Zoroastrians & Aryans 46 K. E. Eduljee Vegetarian? July 2011-March 2015