Decomposing Partial Wh-Movement in Shona
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Introduction Bantu Wh-Questions Island Effects Shona Islands Composite Derivation Conclusion References Decomposing partial wh-movement in Shona Jason Zentz Yale University Queens College March 16, 2015 1 / 37 Introduction Bantu Wh-Questions Island Effects Shona Islands Composite Derivation Conclusion References Wh-questions scopal thematic (1) What do Youyou think I found mywhat phone yesterday.? The what is interpreted in two positions: I It fulfills the thematic role of the “findee.” I It takes scope over the whole sentence, turning it into a question. 2 / 37 Introduction Bantu Wh-Questions Island Effects Shona Islands Composite Derivation Conclusion References Wh-question formation strategies (2) Full wh-movement in English What do you think [cp we found ]? (3) Wh-in-situ in Mandarin Chinese Huǎngróng xiāngxìn [cp Guójìng mǎile shěnme]? Huangrong believe Guojing bought what ‘What does Huangrong believe that Guojing bought?’ (Cheng 2009: 770 (9)) (4) Right-peripheral wh-phrase in American Sign Language IX2 BUY YESTERDAY WHAT you buy yesterday what ‘What did you buy yesterday?’ (Abner 2011: 25 (5a)) 3 / 37 Introduction Bantu Wh-Questions Island Effects Shona Islands Composite Derivation Conclusion References Wh-question formation strategies (5) Wh-copying in Romani Kas o Demìri mislinola [cp kas i Arìfa dikhla ]? who the Demir think who the Arifa saw ‘Who(m) does Demir think Arifa saw?’ (McDaniel 1989: 569 n.5 (ii)) (6) Partial wh-movement in Singaporean Malay Kamu percaya [cp ke mana Mary pergi ]? you believe to where Mary go ‘Where do you believe Mary went?’ (Cole & Hermon 1998: 225 (3b)) 4 / 37 Introduction Bantu Wh-Questions Island Effects Shona Islands Composite Derivation Conclusion References Main idea Question: In a language that has several wh-question strategies, are they all derived in different ways, or can we reduce the number of independent mechanisms neededto explain them? Claim: In Shona, a Bantu language spoken by about 14 million people in Zimbabwe and Mozambique, partial wh-movement is a composite of wh-in-situ and full wh-movement. 5 / 37 Introduction Bantu Wh-Questions Island Effects Shona Islands Composite Derivation Conclusion References Roadmap Bantu wh-questions Island effects as a diagnostic for movement Island sensitivity in Shona Composite derivation of Shona partial wh-movement Conclusion 6 / 37 Introduction Bantu Wh-Questions Island Effects Shona Islands Composite Derivation Conclusion References Outline Bantu wh-questions Island effects as a diagnostic for movement Island sensitivity in Shona Composite derivation of Shona partial wh-movement Conclusion 7 / 37 Introduction Bantu Wh-Questions Island Effects Shona Islands Composite Derivation Conclusion References Croatian Russian Russian Russian Asturian Occitan French Croatian Bosnian Serbian Russian Serbian Bulgarian Croatian Serbian Aranese GasconFrench Croatian Serbian Balkan Romani Galician Serbian Balkan Romani Bulgarian Catalan-Valencian-Balear Gheg Albanian Balkan Romani Osetin Aragonese Bulgarian Corsican Serbian Osetin French Serbian Catalan-Valencian-Balear CroatianArbereshe Albanian Gheg Albanian Gheg Albanian Macedonian Osetin Galician Italian Macedonian Bulgarian Mirandese Bohtan Neo-Aramaic Corsican Aromanian Bulgarian Armenian Judeo-Tat Megleno Romanian Sassarese Sardinian Aromanian Ladino Muslim Tat Gallurese Sardinian Pontic Sassarese SardinianGallurese Sardinian Greek Aromanian Armenian Slavic Aromanian Logudorese Sardinian Tosk AlbanianAromanian Northern Kurdish Northern Kurdish Northern Kurdish Fala Spanish Aromanian Greek Northern Kurdish Aromanian Armenian Catalan-Valencian-Balear Northern Kurdish Campidanese Sardinian Greek Portuguese Kirmanjki Extremaduran Northern Kurdish Arbereshe Albanian Armenian Ta ly sh Dimli Northern Kurdish Northern Kurdish Arvanitika Albanian Armenian Barranquian Greek Arvanitika Albanian Ta ly sh Arbereshe Albanian Arbereshe Albanian Arvanitika Albanian Sicilian Turoyo Assyrian Neo-Aramaic North Mesopotamian Spoken Arabic Gilaki Arvanitika Albanian Mesopotamian Spoken ArabicNorth Mesopotamian Spoken Arabic Gurani Kabatei Northern Kurdish Northern Kurdish Mazanderani Chenoua Northern Kurdish Armenian Kabyle North Levantine Spoken Arabic English Maltese Mesopotamian Spoken Arabic Assyrian Neo-Aramaic Northern KurdishNajdi Spoken Arabic Koy Sanjaq Surat Ta rifi t Maltese Central Kurdish Central Kurdish Ta ch aw i t Tunisian Spoken Arabic Greek Cypriot Spoken Arabic Armenian Najdi Spoken Arabic Algerian Spoken Arabic Greek North Levantine Spoken Arabic Alviri-Vidari Ta rifi t Vafsi North Mesopotamian Spoken Arabic Najdi Spoken Arabic Western Farsi Moroccan Spoken Arabic Mesopotamian Spoken Arabic Northern Luri North Levantine Spoken Arabic Southern Kurdish Laki Shilha Western Neo-Aramaic Judeo-Moroccan Arabic Shilha Southern Kurdish Moroccan Spoken Arabic Te ma c ine Ta ma z ig ht Laki Central Atlas Tamazight South Levantine Spoken Arabic Levantine Bedawi Spoken Arabic Northern Luri Central Atlas Tamazight Tumzabt Najdi Spoken Arabic Dezfuli Bakhtiari South Levantine Spoken Arabic Central Atlas Tamazight Tagargrent Nafusi Mesopotamian Spoken Arabic Domari Najdi Spoken Arabic South Levantine Spoken ArabicHebrewLevantine Bedawi Spoken Arabic South Levantine Spoken Arabic Greek Western Egyptian Bedawi Spoken Arabic Levantine Bedawi Spoken Arabic Mesopotamian Spoken Arabic Egyptian Spoken Arabic Southern Luri Algerian Saharan Spoken Arabic Tachelhit Central Atlas Tamazight Gulf Spoken Arabic Ghadames Najdi Spoken Arabic Eastern Egyptian Bedawi Spoken Arabic Gulf Spoken Arabic Western Farsi Korandje Najdi Spoken Arabic Tachelhit Ta zn at it Sawknah Awjilah Siwi Gulf Spoken Arabic Libyan Spoken Arabic Moroccan Spoken Arabic Tidikelt Tamazight Moroccan Spoken Arabic Tidikelt Tamazight Gulf Spoken Arabic Gulf Spoken Arabic Baharna Spoken Arabic Baharna Spoken Arabic Saidi Spoken Arabic Najdi Spoken Arabic Gulf Spoken Arabic Hassaniyya Arabic Nobiin Tahaggart Tamahaq Hijazi Spoken Arabic Tahaggart Tamahaq Nobiin Tedaga Hassaniyya Hasanya Arabic Tedaga Ta ma s he q Tahaggart Tamahaq Bilma Kanuri Bedawiyet Kenuzi-Dongola Gulf Spoken Arabic Bilma Kanuri Tigre Gulf Spoken Arabic Ta ma ja q Algerian Saharan Spoken Arabic Ta ya rt Ta m aj eq Koyraboro Senni Songhay Dazaga Zenaga Wolof Ta sa w aq Tadaksahak Dazaga Hassaniyya Arabic Zaghawa Tigre Pulaar Koyra Chiini Songhay Tedaga Mehri Bedawiyet Sanaani Spoken Arabic Bilen Hadrami Spoken Arabic Tiemacewe Bozo Wolof Zarmaci Ta w al la mm at Ta ma ja q Humburi Senni Songhay Ta ma ja q Libyan Spoken Arabic Pulaar Soninke Zaghawa Nara Laalaa Soninke Soninke Bondum Dom DogonTo ro Teg u D o go n Tigrigna Pulaar Jenaama Bozo Central-Eastern Niger Fulfulde Noon Soninke Jenaama Bozo SonghaySonghay Shuwa Arabic Amdang Midob Kunama Saho Saafi-Saafi Kagoro Jamsay Dogon Shuwa Arabic Kagoro Kunama Kolum So DogonNortheastern Burkina Faso FulfuldeSonghay Chadian Spoken Arabic Ta ma Serer-SineSerer-Sine Xaasongaxango Kagoro Hausa Tumari Kanuri Adamawa Fulfulde Kagoro Maasina Fulfulde Jenaama BozoTene Kan Dogon Songhay Manga Kanuri Maba Mararit Saho Soninke Kagoro Ta ma Serer-SineWolofGambian Wolof Tieyaxo BozoTo mo Ka n D og on Koromfe Koromfe Zarma Western Maninkakan Kagoro Kanembu Assangori Tigrigna Gambian WolofPulaar Hainyaxo Bozo Western Niger Fulfulde Central Kanuri Afar Taizzi-Adeni Spoken Arabic MandinkaPulaar MarkaPanaMaya Samo MandjakMandinka Kagoro Buduma Kendeje Sudanese Spoken Arabic Western ManinkakanWestern Maninkakan Bomu Matya Samo Masalit Manga Kanuri Yedina Mpade Masmaje Karanga Masalit Pulaar Northern Bobo MadareMarka Surbakhal Jola-Fonyi Gourmanchema Duwai Shuwa Arabic Naba Mubi Karon Mandinka Bedik Northern Bobo MadareSouthern Samo Moore Tedaga Dar Sila Daju Fur Qimant Pulaar Oniyan Kita Maninkakan Bade Kano-Katsina-Bororro Fulfulde Dar Daju Daju Karanga Adamawa Fulfulde Jola-KasaMankanya Mandinka Mamara Senoufo Zarma Wamey JalungaJalunga Konabere Marka Lyele Zarma Sinyar Dair Xamtanga Jola-KasaBayotMandjak Gourmanchema Hausa Mpade Jaya Migaama Kajakse Dar Fur Daju Pulaar Bassari YalunkaPular Marka Northern Nuni Gourmanchema Central Kanuri Mser Morom Dar Sila Daju Kadaru Ta go i Tingal Awngi Jola-Felupe Jalunga Bolon Hausa Zarma Birgit KarkoAma Afar Balanta-Kentohe Shuwa ArabicLagwan Central Kanuri Bidiyo Sinyar El Hugeirat Kadaru Te ga li Bamanankan Nanerige Senoufo Buamu Winye Hausa Gwamhi-Wuri Karekare Kenga PapelMankanyaPular Dagaari Dioula Dendi Ngizim Wali Koalib Amharic Afar Supyire Senoufo Zarma Dendi Kano-Katsina-Bororro FulfuldeChadian Spoken ArabicMogum Fongoro Ghulfan Ta go i BidyogoBidyogo Biafada Pular Southern Bobo Madare Southern Nuni Bissa ut-Ma’inClela Kibet Gaam Gumuz Landoma Dendi Ngamo Wandala Central Kanuri Sokoro Dar Fur Daju KeigaHeiban PhuieSissala Kasem Moba Gourmanchema Shanga DiriWarji Marghi Central Saba To ram Fur Borna Somali Bidyogo NaluNalu Sicite SenoufoSeeku Ninkare Central Kanuri Bagirmi TulishiKeiga Aka Northern Dagara Gourmanchema Mokole Hun-Saare Kudu-CamoMiya Bole CibakPutai Adamawa Fulfulde Tira Berta NaluNalu Eastern Maninkakan Duungooma Kasem Kusaal Musgu Barein BolgoChadian Spoken Arabic Katcha-Kadugli-Miri Logol Kelo Gumuz Awngi Landoma Viemo Farefare Biali Borgu FulfuldeBokoCishinginiTsuvadiBaangi Lame Siri Maaka Marghi South MoloBurun Nalu Kakabe Senara SenoufoTurka Jula Moba Mala GeraDeno Adamawa FulfuldeMusgu Sarua Koke Zan GulaBon Gula Runga Shatt Tumtum Ko Borna Argobba Baga Sitemu Kakabe Southern Dagaare Buli Waama Reshe Eastern Acipa Bura-Pabir Krongo Syenara Senoufo Kurama AmoNigerian FulfuldeGiiwo