Can the Chinese Nation Be One? Gu Jiegang, Chinese Muslims, and the Reworking of Culturalism

Leigh K. Jenco Ca n the Chinese nation be one? Gu Jiegang, Chinese Muslims, and the reworking of culturalism

Article (Accepted version) (Refereed)

Original citation: Jenco, Leigh K. (2019) Can the Chinese nation be one? Gu Jiegang, Chinese Muslims, and the reworking of culturalism. Modern China . ISSN 0097-7004 (In Press)

This version available at: http://eprints.lse.ac.uk/id/eprint/87456

Available in LSE Research Online: December 2018

LSE has developed LSE Research Online so that users may access research output of the School. Copyright © and Moral Rights for the papers on this site are retained by the individual authors and/or other copyright owners. Users may download and/or print one copy of any article(s) in LSE Research Online to facil itate their private study or for non-commercial research. You may not engage in further distribution of the material or use it for any profit-making activities or any commercial gain. You may freely distribute the URL ( http://eprints.lse.ac.uk ) of the LSE Research Online website.

This document is the author’s final accepted version of the journal article. There may be differences between this version and the publishe d version. You are advised to consult the publisher’s version if you wish to cite from it .

!"#$%&'()*&+ !290@'(9)D52)5692C2)$(D6@9)2)%92) E)!624(94)(91)5692C2)#EC768C'#@12B9)

569('2))<=>@1@0H) >)

7Xb`a!6!5XgVh!

7hgWhg!DVahhe!hY!0VhghfbVr!TgW!AhebsbVTe!DVbXgVX!

)XiTqsfXgs!hY!2huXqgfXgs!

3ht`ashg!DsqXXs!

7hgWhg!H(&!&0!FgbsXW!6bg`Whf!

765XgVh%erXTVtd!!eXb`acXgVh%`fTbeVhf!

EXe"!I!KM!!!KvhqdM!!I!KM!!! !KfhUbeXV!iqXYXqqXWM

! !"#$%&'()*&+ !290@'(9)D52)5692C2)$(D6@9)2)%92) E)!624(94)(91)5692C2)#EC768C'#@12B9)

569('2))<=>@1@0H) <)

Can the Chinese Nation Be One?

Gu Jiegang, Chinese Muslims, and the Reworking of Culturalism

Leigh K. Jenco 1

Abstract

This article examines how the classicist and folklorist Gu Jiegang, in conversation with his

Hui (Chinese Muslim) colleagues at the Yugong study society and journal (published 1934–

1937), theorized the “Chinese nation” ( Zhonghua minzu ) as an internally plural and open- ended political project, to resist homogenizing claims by both Japanese imperialists and the ruling Chinese Nationalist party under Chiang Kai-shek in the 1930s. Echoing the struggles of his Hui colleagues to articulate their place in the nation as both Muslim and Chinese, Gu reworked traditional “culturalist” assumptions about the non-racial character of identity formation to pose minority experience as constitutive of a constantly expanding and transforming political community. When Gu asserted in his notorious 1939 essay that the

“Zhonghua minzu Is One,” he posed a unity built not on cultural assimilation or ethnic identity, but on a shared political commitment to an expansive and culturally hybrid concept of the “Chinese nation.”

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

1 London School of Economics and Political Science

Corresponding Author:

Leigh K. Jenco, Department of Government, London School of Economics and Political Science,

Houghton Street, London WC2A 2AE, United Kingdom.

Email: [email protected] !

! !"#$%&'()*&+ !290@'(9)D52)5692C2)$(D6@9)2)%92) E)!624(94)(91)5692C2)#EC768C'#@12B9)

569('2))<=>@1@0H) B)

Keywords

Gu Jiegang, Hui, Zhonghua minzu, culturalism, nationalism, Chinese Muslims, multiculturalism

4r!bs!ihrrbUeX!sh!bfT`bgX!T!tgbYbXW!(abgTV!vbsahts!qXiqhWtVbg`!hiiqXrrbuX!TgW!3TgXVXgsqbV! ubrbhgr!hY!saX!gTsbhg$!EvXgsbXsaXVXgstqx!(abgXrX!WbrVhtqrX!br!qbYX!vbsa!VeTbfr!saTs!iqXrXgs!saX!

YTerX!tgbsx!hY!T!rXeYXrTfXV!gTsbhgTe!rtUcXVs!Xuheubg`!saqht`a!sbfX!Tehg`!T!ebgXTq!iTsa!

XgTUebg`!saTs!rtUcXVs!sh!qXTebyX!bsr!WXrsbgx!bg!T!fhWXqg!YtstqX!K)tTqTV!!!"!M!7bTg`!

BbVaThr!`XqfbgTe!vhqd!bg!saX!!r!`qTYsXW!saXrX!Trrtfisbhgr!hgsh!Tg!Xwbrsbg`!

XsaghVXgsqbrf!vaXg!aX!gTqqTsXW!(abgXrX!abrshqx!Tr!saX!abrshqx!hY!T!rbg`eX!fTchqbsxV!saX!3TgV! vahrX!TrrbfbeTsbuX!ihvXq! vTr!TrrtfXW!sh!rihgsTgXhtrex!XYYTVX!VtestqTe!WbYYXqXgVX!

Tfhg`!saX!WbuXqrX!ihiteTsbhgr!saTs!aTW!abrshqbVTeex!hVVtibXW!(abgXrX!bfiXqbTe!sXqqbshqbXr!

K7bTg`V!!!#!DVagXbWXqV!M!EaX!TrrbfbeTsbuX!ihvXq!hY!(abgXrX!VbubebyTsbhg!aTr!VhgsbgtXW! sh!rtiihqs!saX!abXqTqVabVTe!rtiqXfTVx!hY!T!3TgXVXgsqbV!(abgXrX!gTsbhgTe!bWXgsbsxV!huXq!TgW!

TUhuX!saX!rhXVTeeXW!fbghqbsx!gTsbhgTebsbXr!K D4'AD4F&95@PF ! #!V!hq!95@PF !#! M!vabVa!

VhgrsbstsX!bs!8Tgx!hY!saX!dXx!VhgVXistTe!YqTfXvhqdr!Yhq!sabr!gTsbhgTe!bfT`bgTqx!vXqX!Ybqrs!

TqsbVteTsXW!bg!saX!!rV!vaXg!saX!5TiTgXrX!0fibqX!rht`as!T!YhhsaheW!bg!(abgT!bg!iTqs!Ux!

XgVhtqT`bg`!rXiTqTsbrs!fhuXfXgsr!hY!fbghqbsx!iXhieXr!hg!saX!ghqsaXqg!YqhgsbXq!K'hWWXV!!#!

ETfTghbV!"!M!4g!qXrihgrXV!(abgXrX!bgsXeeXVstTer!TgW!ihebVxXfTdXqr!TVVXeXqTsXW!TgW!

XwiTgWXW!TrrXqsbhgr!hY!T!tgbYbXW!TgW!ahfh`Xghtr!(abgXrX!gTsbhgV!sh!UtssqXrr!Uhsa!sXqqbshqbTe!

TgW!VtestqTe!WhfbgTgVX!huXq!bsr!ghqsaXqg!TgW!ghqsavXrsXqg!UhqWXqr!!

! 4qhgbVTeexV!TfbW!sabr!bgsXgrXex!ihebsbVTe!TgW!axiXqXgTsbhgTebrs!vTqsbfX!XgubqhgfXgsV! saXqX!XfXq`XW!T!Krsbee!eTq`Xex!huXqehhdXWM!VhgsqbUtsbhg!sh!saX!WXVXgsXqbg`!hY!(abgXrX!bWXgsbsx!

Eabr!TqsbVeX!XwTfbgXr!ahv!saX!VeTrrbVbrs!TgW!Yhedehqbrs!2t!5bX`Tg`! 10 K !! MV!bg!

VhguXqrTsbhg!vbsa!rhfX!hY!abr!3tb!K(abgXrX!8trebfM!VheeXT`tXr!TYYbebTsXW!vbsa!saX!chtqgTe!

! !"#$%&'()*&+ !290@'(9)D52)5692C2)$(D6@9)2)%92) E)!624(94)(91)5692C2)#EC768C'#@12B9)

569('2))<=>@1@0H) C)

%F3A@3& 1959A@E48I !). "KitUebraXW!!!MV!saXhqbyXW!saX!(abgXrX!gTsbhg!

KQahg`atT!fbgyt!,#!M!Tr!Tg!bgsXqgTeex!ietqTeV!hiXgXXgWXWV!TgW!XfTgVbiTshqx!ihebsbVTe! iqhcXVsV!sh!qXrbrs!ahfh`Xgbybg`!VTeer!fTWX!Ux!Uhsa!5TiTgXrX!bfiXqbTebrsr!TgW!saX!qtebg`!

(abgXrX!9TsbhgTebrs!ATqsx!tgWXq!(abTg`!6TbXraXd! ùÑ bg!saX!!r !2t!TgW!abr!

VheeXT`tXr!vhteW!T`qXX!vbsa!fTgx!fhWXqg!rVaheTqr!vah!gTqqTsX!(abgTr!iTrs!bg!sXqfr!hY! ftstTe!TVVhffhWTsbhg!TgW!ihqhtr!UhtgWTqbXr!UXsvXXg!WbuXqrX!VtestqTe!`qhtir!saTs!VaTg`XW! huXq!sbfX!TgW!riTVX!K2eTWgXxV!!!#!8teeTgXx!Xs!TeV!MvaTs!ATfXeT!(qhrreXx!aTr!

VTeeXW!T!shsTebsx!hY!VhguXq`Xgsex!TgW!WbuXq`Xgsex!qXeTsXW!ehVTebrfr!K(qhrreXxV!!!"!M!PXs!

2tr!ubrbhg!vTr!WbrsbgVsbuX!bg!TssXfisbg`!sh!UTeTgVX!saX!sXgrbhgr!hY!bgVetrbhg!TgW!iTqsbVteTqbsx!

2t!Tq`tXW!saTs!hgex!tgbsx!vhteW!rXVtqX!saX!sXqqbshqbTe!TgW!gTsbhgTe!bgsX`qbsx!qXptbqXW!sh!Yb`as!

5TiTgXrX!bfiXqbTe!bgVtqrbhgrV!Uts!bfihqsTgsexgXTqex!TehgX!Tfhg`!abr!3Tg!

VhgsXfihqTqbXraX!TrdXW!ahv!rtVa!tgbsx!VhteW!UX!TVabXuXW!vbsahts!qXiqhWtVbg`!saX! abrshqbVTe!TgW!rsqtVstqTe!hiiqXrrbhgr!saTs!VhgsbgtXW!sh!fTq`bgTebyX!ghgX3Tg!iXhieXr!bg!

(abgXrX!eTgWr!0Vahbg`!saX!rsqt``eXr!hY!abr!3tb!VheeXT`tXr!sh!TqsbVteTsX!saXbq!ieTVX!bg!saX! gTsbhg!Tr!Uhsa!8trebf!TgW!(abgXrXV!2tr!VhgVXis!hY!saX!Qahg`atT!fbgyt!ihrXr!fbghqbsx!

XwiXqbXgVX!TgW!VtestqXr!Tr!VhgrsbstsbuX!hY!T!VhgrsTgsex!XwiTgWbg`!TgW!sqTgrYhqfbg`!

VhfftgbsxV!UhtgW!Ux!raTqXW!VhgrVbhtrgXrr!TgW!VhffbsfXgs!sh!ihebsbVTe!`hTer!qTsaXq!saTg! tgbYbXW!Ux!qTVbTe!hq!VtestqTe!rbfbeTqbsx!!

@gX!hY!saX!fhrs!tgXwiXVsXW!TgW!bgghuTsbuX!YXTstqXr!hY!2tr!vhqd!bg!sabr!iXqbhW!vTr! abr!VqXTsbuX!qXWXiehxfXgs!hY!saX!VtestqTebrs!iqXfbrX!UXabgW!VeTbfr!sh!(abgTr!TrrbfbeTsbuX! ihvXqV!gTfXex!saX!UXebXY!saTs!TgxhgX!hY!Tgx!qTVbTeV!VtestqTeV!hq!XsagbV!UTVd`qhtgW!Kbg!(abgXrX! sXqfrV!Tee!tgWXq!3XTuXgV! M!vhteW!UXVhfX!DbgbYbXW!K % ,M!saqht`a!iTqsbVbiTsbhg! bg!(abgXrX!VtestqX!K H1@ ! MsxibVTeex!fXTgbg`!saX!bgrsbstsbhgr!TgW!qbstTer!hY!3Tg!

VbubebyTsbhg!K3hV!!! #!7Tg`ehbrV!! M!9TsbhgTebrs!bWXheh`x!hY!saX!9Tgcbg`!WXVTWX!Utbes!hg! rtVa!Trrtfisbhgr!sh!Tq`tX!Yhq!gTsbhgTe!ahfh`XgXbsx!TgW!saX!bgXubsTUeX!TrrbfbeTsbhg!hY!ghgX

! !"#$%&'()*&+ !290@'(9)D52)5692C2)$(D6@9)2)%92) E)!624(94)(91)5692C2)#EC768C'#@12B9)

569('2))<=>@1@0H) D)

3Tg!iXhieXr!bgsh!saX!3Tg!fTchqbsx!2tr!bgghuTsbhg!vTr!sh!Xfisx!rtVa!VeTbfr!hY!saXbq! riXVbYbV!XsaghVXgsqbV!YXTstqXrV!vabeX!qXsTbgbg`!saXbq!XfiaTrbr!hg!WXebUXqTsX!iTqsbVbiTsbhg!bg! raTqXW!iqTVsbVXrqTsaXq!saTg!iTsqbebgXTe!UehhWebgX!WXrVXgsTr!saX!dXx!VqbsXqbhg!Yhq! fXfUXqrabi!bg!Tgx!fbgyt !)qTvbg`!hg!abr!hvg!XwiXqbXgVX!sqTuXebg`!saqht`a!saX!(abgXrX! ghqsavXrsXqg!YqhgsbXqV!2t!XuXgstTeex!riXVbYbXW!sabr!Yhqf!hY!fXfUXqrabi!Tr!TYYbebTsbhg!vbsa! iTqsbVteTq!sXTVabg`r!K 65'A !V!vabVa!fTx!hq!fTx!ghs!aTuX!Tgx!qXeTsbhgrabi!sh!hgXr! iqXrtfXW!VtestqTe!hq!qTVbTe!UTVd`qhtgW!5bTh!TYYbebTsbhg!satr!XgTUeXr!huXqeTiibg`!bWXgsbsbXrV!

Teehvbg`!Yhq!saX!ihrrbUbebsx!hY!qTWbVTe!rXeYXsqTgrYhqfTsbhg!Yqhf!hgX!sXTVabg`!sh!TghsaXqTee! saX!vabeX!VhXXwbrsbg`!vbsabg!saX!eTq`Xq!WhfTbg!hY!saX!(abgXrX!gTsbhgV!saX!Qahg`atT!fbgyt!!

2tr!gTsbhgTebrs!iqhcXVs!satr!bgsqhWtVXW!TfUbuTeXgVX!bgsh!saX!WXrb`gTsbhg!hY!VeXTqex!

UhqWXqXW!fbgyt!XuXg!Tr!bs!XwiehqXW!saX!gXVXrrTqx!qXeTsbhgrabi!hY!(abgTr!bgsXqgTe!WbuXqrbsx!sh! iqhcXVsr!hY!ihebsbVTe!tgbYbVTsbhg!3hvXuXqV!iXqaTir!UXVTtrX!hY!abr!rtiihqs!Yhq!gTsbhgTe!tgbsx! huXq!rXiTqTsbrs!fhuXfXgsrV!2t!aTr!UXXg!VqbsbVbyXW!Yhq!XgWhqrbg`!saX!iqhUeXfTsbV!Trrtfisbhg! hY!(abgXrX!rtiXqbhqbsx!huXq!UTqUTqbTg!hsaXqrV!tiaheWbg`!rhfX!ghsbhg!hY!T!rbg`teTq!TeUXbs!

WxgTfbV!(abgXrX!XrrXgVXV!hq!rtUebfTsbg`!qXVtqqXgs!XsaghXVtestqTe!WbYYXqXgVX!bg!saX!gTfX!hY!T! tgbYbXW!(abgXrX!gTsbhgTe!rtUcXVs!K7XbUheWV!"!#!"!#!7bifTgV!M!(abgXrX! rVaheTqr!bg!iTqsbVteTq!aTuX!Tq`tXW!saTs!2t!iqhfhsXW!Tg!bgTVVtqTsX!ubrbhg!hY!T!VtestqTeex! fhghebsabV!(abgT!Tr!T!vTqsbfX!Xwb`XgVxV!VhgsqTWbVsbg`!abr!XTqebXq!VhffbsfXgs!sh!Tg!hUcXVsbuX!

TgW!rVbXgsbYbV!abrshqbh`qTiax!saTs!iqhWtVXW!T!fhqX!gtTgVXW!TgW!WbuXqrX!ibVstqX!hY!saX!

(abgXrX!iTrs!K2XV!#!PtV!M!CXVXgs!WXUTsXr!huXq!qXYhqfbg`!(abgTr!VtqqXgs!DhubXsX bgribqXW!XsagbV!ihebVx!aTuX!YTuhqTUex!bguhdXW!2t!Tr!Tg!TWuhVTsX!hY!saX!WXihebsbVbyTsbhg!hY!

XsagbV!bWXgsbsx!K8TV!#!Qaht!TgW!QaTg`V!MV!bfiexbg`!saTs!abr!Tq`tfXgsr!Yqhf!saX!

!r!XgsTbe!rsTsX!VXgsqTebyTsbhg!hY!T!Yteex!TrrbfbeTsXW!gTsbhgTe!ihiteTsbhg!K0eebhssV!M!!

! 3hvXuXqV!T!fhqX!VTqXYte!qXTWbg`!hY!2tr!vhqd!bg!saX!!rV!bg!sTgWXf!vbsa!saTs!hY! abr!3tb!VheeXT`tXrV!WXVXgsXqr!TgW!iqhUeXfTsbyXr!(abgTr!bfihqsTgVX"!bs!ihrXr!saX!gTsbhg!Tr!T!

Vhgsbg`Xgs!TgW!ietqTe!ihebsbVTe!rb`gbYbXqV!qTsaXq!saTg!Tg!XgWtqbg`!qTVbTeV!XsagbVV!hq!VtestqTe!

! !"#$%&'()*&+ !290@'(9)D52)5692C2)$(D6@9)2)%92) E)!624(94)(91)5692C2)#EC768C'#@12B9)

569('2))<=>@1@0H) ) hgX!HaXg!2t!TrrXqsXW!bg!abr!ghshqbhtr!!!!XrrTx!saTs!saX!Qahg`atT!fbgyt!br!hgXV!aX! ihrXW!T!tgbsx!Utbes!ghs!hg!VtestqTe!TrrbfbeTsbhg!hq!XsagbV!bWXgsbsxV!Uts!hg!T!raTqXW!ihebsbVTe!

VhffbsfXgs!sh!Tg!XwiTgrbuX!TgW!VtestqTeex!axUqbW!VhgVXis!hY!saX!(abgXrX!gTsbhg!Eabr! saXhqbyTsbhg!sqTgrYhqfr!saX!(abgXrX!gTsbhg!Yqhf!T!ahfh`Xgbybg`!TgW!hiiqXrrbuX!VhgVXis!sh!

Tg!XfTgVbiTshqx!hgXvbsa!saX!ihsXgsbTe!sh!ebUXqTsX!(abgXrX!iXhieX!ghs!hgex!Yqhf!saX!saqXTs! hY!5TiTgXrX!bfiXqbTebrfV!Uts!Terh!Yqhf!iTqhVabTe!TgW!fhghebsabV!ubXvr!hY!(abgXrX!gTsbhgTe! bWXgsbsx!

! &B@1@)21@)"2F27J>)52(1)3@77@GC) Arguing about Culture in 1930s China

)XUTsXr!TUhts!(abgXrX!bWXgsbsx!TgW!gTsbhgTebrf!ehg`!iqXVXWXW!saX!XrsTUebrafXgs!hY!(abTg`r!

9Tgcbg`XUTrXW!9TsbhgTebrs!ATqsx!qX`bfX!bg!!!3hvXuXqV!bs!vTr!Yqhf!saTs!ihbgs!tgsbe!saX!

VheeTirX!hY!saX!DXVhgW!FgbsXW!1qhgs!UXsvXXg!saX!9TsbhgTebrs!ATqsx!K2thfbgWTg`M!TgW!

(abgXrX!(hfftgbrsr!bg!!!saTs!saXrX!brrtXr!shhd!hg!TVtsX!TgW!riXVbYbV!ihebsbVTe! rb`gbYbVTgVX!Eabr!rhXVTeeXW!9Tgcbg`!WXVTWX!fTqdXW!saX!Ybqrs!sbfX!bg!fhqX!saTg!sabqsx!xXTqr! saTs!(abgTr!YhqfXq!bfiXqbTe!sXqqbshqx!vTr!tgbsXW!tgWXq!hgX!`huXqgfXgs!EaX!9TsbhgTebrs! tgbYbVTsbhg!iqhcXVs!`TuX!qbrX!sh!tgiqXVXWXgsXW!WbrVtrrbhgr!TUhts!saX!gTstqX!TgW!Vhfihrbsbhg! hY!(abgT!Tr!T!gTsbhgTe!XgsbsxV!YhVtrXW!bg!iTqsbVteTq!hg!saX!qXeTsbhgrabi!UXsvXXg!saX!

WhfbgTgs!3Tg!(abgXrX!fTchqbsx!KTUhts! n!hY!saX!ihiteTsbhgM!TgW!saX!WbuXqrX!ghgX3Tg!

`qhtirrhfX!Uts!ghs!Tee!hY!vabVa!WqXv!rXeYXbWXgsbsx!Yqhf!saXbq!WXfTqVTsbhg!Tr!

VhgrsbstXgVbXr!tgWXq!saX!huXqsaqhvg!WxgTrsxV!saX!8TgVatXqteXW!Bbg`!K7bifTgV!"!M!

&ssXfisr!sh!vqbsX!VtestqTe!abrshqx!bg!saX!eTsX!!r!UX`Tg!sh!XwiehqX!saX!VhgsqbUtsbhg!hY! ghgX3Tg!iXhieXr!sh!saX!(abgXrX!iTrsV!Ux!qXieTVbg`!T!qTVbTebyXW!(abgXrX!rtUcXVs!hY!abrshqx! vbsa!T!VtestqTe!hgX!K3hgV!#!DVagXbWXqV!"!!M!'ts!Ux!saX!XTqex!!rV!sabr!vTr! rtiXqrXWXW!Ux!Tg!bgVqXTrbg`ex!3TgXVXgsqbV!ubrbhg!hY!T!ahfh`Xghtr!(abgXrX!gTsbhg!

KQahg`atT!fbgytM!WXqbuXW!Yqhf!Dtg!PTsXrXgr! _ l !!WXVeTqTsbhg!hY!saX!saqXX! iqbgVbieXr!hY!saX!iXhieX!KDtgV!!M!

! !"#$%&'()*&+ !290@'(9)D52)5692C2)$(D6@9)2)%92) E)!624(94)(91)5692C2)#EC768C'#@12B9)

569('2))<=>@1@0H) )

! @gX!hY!Dtgr!saqXX!iqbgVbieXrV!fbgyt!KgTsbhgTebsx!hq!gTsbhgTebrfMV!rXXfXW!sh!

XwsXgW!saX!iqhfbrX!hY!gTsbhgTe!rXeYXWXsXqfbgTsbhg!sh!Tee!hiiqXrrXW!iXhieXr!3hvXuXqV!Uhsa! fhWXqg!rVaheTqr!TgW!VhgsXfihqTqx!vqbsXqr!aTuX!Tq`tXW!saTs!saX!Dtgr!fbgyt!vTr!Tg!TssXfis! sh!qXbgYhqVX!saX!sqTWbsbhgTe!WhfbgTgVX!hY!(abgXrX!VbubebyTsbhg!huXq!gXb`aUhqbg`!rsTsXr!KBbV!

!"! M!&VVhqWbg`!sh!5TfXr!7XbUheWV!Dtgr!VhgVXis!fTqraTeXW!saX!qaXshqbV!hY!fhWXqg! rVbXgVX!TgW!saXhqbXr!hY!WXuXehifXgs!sh!VhgrhebWTsX!gTsbhgTe!VhgrVbhtrgXrr!bg!saX!YTVX!hY!

5TiTgXrX!TgW!0tqhiXTg!bfiXqbTebrfV!vabeX!WXgxbg`!rXeYXWXsXqfbgTsbhg!sh!fbghqbsbXr!vbsabg!

(abgT!Eh!DtgV!saXrX!vXqX!iXqbiaXqTe!iXhieXrV!XsagbV!qXebVr!WXrsbgXW!Yhq!XuXgstTe!

TrrbfbeTsbhg!vbsa!T!rtiXqbhq!3Tg!(abgXrX!fTchqbsx!ubT!saX!WbriTrrbhgTsX!rVbXgsbYbV!eTv!hY! gTstqTe!rXeXVsbhg!K7XbUheWV!"!M!0uXg!Tr!saX!YqhgsbXq!qX`bhgrV!ahfX!sh!T!uTqbXsx!hY!

VtestqTe!`qhtir!saTs!bg!rhfX!ieTVXr!htsgtfUXqXW!3TgV!`qXv!rsqTsX`bVTeex!fhqX!bfihqsTgs!bg! saX!vTdX!hY!saX!!!8tdWXg!4gVbWXgsV!(abTg`r!qX`bfX!TiiqhiqbTsXW!Dtgr!qaXshqbV!sh! iqhfhsX!T!ubrbhg!hY!(abgXrX!bWXgsbsx!Tr!ahfh`Xghtr!ghs!hgex!VtestqTeex!Uts!Terh!qTVbTeex!

&iiexbg`!Dtgr!bWXTr!sh!9TsbhgTebrs!ATqsx!bWXheh`xV!(abTg`!TgW!abr!bWXheh`tXr!rtVa!Tr!)Tb!

5bsTh! ^Ĵ bWXgsbYbXW!saX!Qahg`atT!fbgyt!vbsa!WbqXVs!UehhWebgX!WXrVXgs!Yqhf!saX!fxsabVTe!

PXeehv!0fiXqhq!EaXrX!bWXTr!qXubuXW!T!eTsX!gbgXsXXgsaXVXgstqx!WbrVhtqrX!hg!qTVX!fhrs!

YTfhtrex!TqsbVteTsXW!Ux!QaTg`!ETbxTg! ÞW»V!vah!ebgdXW!qTVX!sh!saX!bgWb`Xghtr!iqTVsbVX! hY!ihrbg`!dbgrabi!Tfhg`!WbYYXqXgs!ebgXT`Xr!hq!VeTgr!vbsa!saX!rTfX!rtqgTfX!K(ahvV!!!"! M!

1hq!(abTg`V!T!raTqXW!qTVbTe!ebgXT`X!XuXgstTeex!VhguXq`XW!bgsh!T!ahfh`Xghtr!VtestqTe!aXqbsT`X!

&r!aX!its!bs!bg!abr!!! 445@'RD&1DE5@I V!T!Uhhd!vbWXex!VbqVteTsXW!Tr!XwsqTVtqqbVteTq! fTsXqbTe!Yhq!(abgTr!rVahher!TgW!tgbuXqrbsbXr"!

&B@1@)21@)HDB(0D)AE@D(D6@9)3@77@GC)!

&VVhqWbg`!sh!bsr!abrshqbV!WXuXehifXgsV!htq!(abgXrX!gTsbhg!vTr!YhqfXW!Ux!saX!UeXgWbg`!

hY!gtfXqhtr!VeTgr!EaXrX!VeTgr!vXqX!hqb`bgTeex!UqTgVaXr!hY!saX!rTfX!qTVXV!riqXTWbg`!

sh!saX!XTrs!hY!saX!ATfbq!ieTsXTtV!Tehg`!saX!uTeeXxr!hY!saX!PXeehvV!saX!3tTbV!saX!

! !"#$%&'()*&+ !290@'(9)D52)5692C2)$(D6@9)2)%92) E)!624(94)(91)5692C2)#EC768C'#@12B9)

569('2))<=>@1@0H) )

PTg`syXV!saX!3Xbetg`dbTg`V!TgW!saX!AXTqe!qbuXqr!EaXx!fTbgsTbgXW!WbYYXqXgs!VtestqXr!

TVVhqWbg`!sh!saX!WbYYXqXgVXr!bg!saXbq!`Xh`qTiabVTe!XgubqhgfXgs!&gW!VtestqTe!

WbYYXqXgVXr!`TuX!qbrX!sh!WbYYXqXgVXr!Tfhg`!saX!VeTgr!3hvXuXqV!Wtqbg`!saX!iTrs!YbuX!

sahtrTgW!xXTqrV!vbsa!bgVqXTrbg`!VhgsTVsr!TgW!fb`qTsbhgrV!saXx!aTuX!UXXg!Vhgsbgthtrex!

UeXgWXW!bgsh!T!gTsbhg!'ts!saX!fhsbuX!ihvXq!hY!saTs!UeXgWbg`!vTr!VtestqTe!qTsaXq!saTg!

fbebsTqxV!TgW!saX!fXsahW!hY!UeXgWbg`!vTr!Ux!TrrbfbeTsbhg!qTsaXq!saTg!Ux!VhgptXrs!!!!

Hbsabg!saX!1htq!DXTrV!saX!VeTgr!hY!saX!uTqbhtr!ehVTebsbXr!vXqX!XbsaXq!

WXrVXgWTgsr!hY!T!Vhffhg!TgVXrshq!hq!vXqX!bgsXqqXeTsXW!saqht`a!fTqqbT`X!EaX! 7AA7&A2&

01D !rsTsXr"!EaX!WXrVXgWTgsr!hY!HXg!HTg`!XwsXgW!sh!atgWqXWr!hY!`XgXqTsbhgrV!Uts!

Tee!VhfX!Yqhf!saX!rTfX!YTfbex!sqXX!Eabr!fXTgr!saTs!saX!fTbg!TgW!UqTgVa!rshVdr!Tee!

UXehg`!sh!saX!rTfX!UehhW!rsqXTf!K(abTg`V!!"!M!!

&B@1@)21@)91)2HDB(0D)AE@D(D6@9)!

(abTg`!XwsXgWXW!sabr!gTqqTsbuX!sh!ctrsbYx!bgVetrbhg!hY!YqhgsbXq!TqXTr!vbsabg!(abgXrX!gTsbhgTe! sXqqbshqxV!Uhsa!Ux!WXgxbg`!saX!qTVbTe!WbrsbgVsbuXgXrr!hY!fbghqbsbXr!bg!sahrX!TqXTr!TgW!Ux!

WXiehxbg`!T!sqTWbsbhgTe!qaXshqbV!hY!(abgXrX!VtestqTe!WhfbgTgVX!Eabr!qaXshqbVV!XfiehxXW!Tr! vXee!Ux!bgsXeeXVstTer!rtVa!Tr!7bt!PbyaXg`! ¤Ċz vah!qXrbrsXW!qTVXXUTrXW!bWXgsbsx!VeTbfr!

K3hgV!"!#!6thV!"! MV!aXeW!saTs!bs!vTr!saqht`a!VtestqTe!TrrbfbeTsbhg!hY!

YhqXb`g!hsaXqr!saTs!saX!(abgXrX!rsTsX!XwsXgWXW!bsr!UhtgWTqbXr!4gWXXWV!(abTg`!Tq`tXW!saTs!

VtestqTe!ahfh`XgXbsx!WXsXqfbgXW!saX!`Xh`qTiabV!Tr!vXee!Tr!fbebsTqx!ebfbsr!hY!saX!rsTsX"!saX! sXqqbshqx!hY!saX!(abgXrX!rsTsX!br!WXsXqfbgXW!Ux!saX!qXptbqXfXgsr!Yhq!gTsbhgTe!rtqubuTe!TgW!Ux! saX!ebfbsr!hY!(abgXrX!VtestqTe!UhgWr!EatrV!bg!saX!sXqqbshqx!hY!(abgT!T!atgWqXW!xXTqr!T`hV!

Vhfiqbrbg`!fhqX!saTg!sXg!fbeebhg!rptTqX!dbehfXsXqrV!saXqX!vTr!ghs!T!rbg`eX!WbrsqbVs!saTs!vTr! ghs!XrrXgsbTe!sh!saX!rtqubuTe!hY!saX!(abgXrX!gTsbhgV!TgW!ghgX!saTs!vTr!ghs!iXqfXTsXW!Ux!htq!

VtestqX!K(abTg`V!!"!M!

! !"#$%&'()*&+ !290@'(9)D52)5692C2)$(D6@9)2)%92) E)!624(94)(91)5692C2)#EC768C'#@12B9)

569('2))<=>@1@0H) )

! Eabr!bWXheh`bVTe!gTqqTsbuX!hY!T!ahfh`Xghtr!(abgXrX!WXrVXgs!TgW!rbg`teTqV!tgbYbXW!

VtestqX!vTr!YtqsaXq!iqhfhsXW!Ux!VhXhisXW!TVTWXfbV!XebsXr!rtVa!Tr!1t!DbgbTg! oV!saX! bgYetXgsbTe!abrshqbTg!TgW!qXVXgsex!TiihbgsXW!eXTWXq!hY!saX!4grsbstsX!Yhq!3brshqx!TgW!Aabeheh`x!Ts!

(abgTr!gTsbhgTe!TVTWXfx!hY!rVbXgVXrV!&VTWXfbT!DbgbVT!8hsbuTsXW!Ux!iTsqbhsbV!YXquhq!TgW!T! gXXW!sh!bgub`hqTsX!hiihrbsbhg!sh!5TiTgXrX!bfiXqbTebrf!TYsXq!5TiTgXrX!YhqVXr!shhd!8tdWXg!bg! ghqsaXTrs!(abgTV!1t!XgVhtqT`XW!abr!YXeehv!TVTWXfbVr!sh!vqbsX!TgW!qXrXTqVa!gTsbhgTe!abrshqbXr! saTs!iqhfhsXW!2thfbgWTg`!K28)M!qXTWbg`r!hY!saX!iTrsV!vabeX!iqhfhsbg`!abr!hvg!ubrbhg!hY!T! ahfh`XghtrV!sbfXeXrr!gTsbhgTe!abrshqx!saTs!rsqXsVaXW!Uhsa!UTVdvTqW!TgW!YhqvTqW!bg!sbfX!K1tV!

! UM!4g!T!!!XrrTxV!EaX!(abgXrX!9Tsbhg!RQahg`atT!fbgytS!4r!T!EhsTebsxV!1t!TWuTgVXr!

T!rvXXibg`!iqhihrbsbhg!TUhts!saX!sbfXeXrr!TgW!iXqiXstTe!tgbsx!hY!saX!(abgXrX!iXhieX"!!

&B@1@)21@)HDB(0D)AE@D(D6@9)3@77@GC)!

1qhf!saX!qbrX!hY!saX!Bbg!TgW!3Tg!hgvTqWV!svh!sahtrTgW!xXTqr!sh!ghvV!rhfXsbfXr!

UXVTtrX!hY!UTqUTqbTg!bguTrbhgV!saX!ghqsa!TgW!rhtsa!vXqX!rXiTqTsXWV!TgW!rhfXsbfXr!

UXVTtrX!hY!saX!rXiTqTsbrf!hY!tgrVqtitehtr!rVaXfXqrV!saX!Vhtgsqx!aTr!UXXg!riebs!ti!

3hvXuXqV!saXrX!TqX!YTVsr!YhqVXW!Ux!atfTg!ihvXqV!TgW!TqX!ghs!YTVsr!hY!gTstqX!@gVX!

saXqX!br!Tg!TiiqhiqbTsX!eXTWXq!bg!ieTVXV!XuXqxsabg`!bffXWbTsXex!UXVhfXr!tgbsXW!Tr!hgX!

YTfbex!1qhf!saX!WXrXqsr!hY!saX!ghqsaV!sh!3TbgTg!4reTgW!TgW!5bThyab!bg!saX!rhtsa#!Yqhf!

saX!ptbVdrTgWr!hY!saX!vXrs!sh!5bebg!TgW!ItTgst!bg!saX!XTrssaXrX!TqX!Tee!eTgWr!

gTstqTeex!`buXg!sh!trV!saX!(abgXrX!gTsbhg!RQahg`atT!fbgytS!HX!(abgXrX! õ

° !riXTd!hgX!eTg`tT`XV!vqbsX!vbsa!hgX!rVqbisV!TgW!iqTVsbVX!saX!rTfX!dbgW!hY!XsabVr!

TVVhqWbg`!sh!hgX!TgW!saX!rTfX!VtestqX!HX!TqX!ctrs!Tr!hgX!rbg`eX!VeTg! e !HX!Terh!

qXex!hg!saX!fbghqbsx!gTsbhgTebsbXr! j° vbsabg!sabr!gTsbhgV!Uts!vX!(abgXrX!rbgVX!

TgVbXgs!sbfXr!aTuX!aTW!T!dbgW!hY!TssqTVsbuX!ubqstXV!bg!saTs!vX!Wh!ghs!WbrVqbfbgTsX!

T`Tbgrs!saX!iTqsbTe!ubXvr!hY!rfTee!gTsbhgTebsbXrV!vabeX!fTbgsTbgbg`!saX!UXTqbg`!hY!T!

rbg`eX!YTfbex!Yqhf!rXT!sh!rXT!K1tV!! U"!M!

! !"#$%&'()*&+ !290@'(9)D52)5692C2)$(D6@9)2)%92) E)!624(94)(91)5692C2)#EC768C'#@12B9)

569('2))<=>@1@0H) >=)

&B@1@)21@)91)2HDB(0D)AE@D(D6@9)! 4g!1tr!VaTqTVsXqbyTsbhgV!saX!(abgXrX!gTsbhg!br!T!`qTgW!TgW!riXVbTe!dbgW!hY!gTsbhgTebsxV! vahrX!VtestqX!bgXubsTUex!TssqTVsr!TgW!TrrbfbeTsXr!saX!rfTee!gTsbhgTebsbXr!bg!bsr!`Xh`qTiabV! hqUbsV!Wbrrheubg`!saXbq!VtestqTe!TgW!qTVbTe!WbrsbgVsbuXgXrr!KTr!vXee!Tr!saXbq!sXqqbshqbXrM!bgsh!T! rbg`eX!(abgXrX!gTsbhgTe!VtestqX!EaXrX!bWXTr!Terh!fhsbuTsXW!1tr!hsaXq!vhqd!Wtqbg`!sabr! iXqbhWV!bgVetWbg`!saX! FE85@1&5DEACI&A2&ACE41'DE1C@&445@' V!vabVa!aX!vqhsX!Yhq!saX!7xsshg!

(hffbrrbhg!&ssXfisbg`!sh!qXUts!5TiTgXrX!VeTbfr!saTs!8TgVatqbT!KTehg`!vbsa!8hg`hebT!TgW!

EbUXsM!vXqX!ghs!iTqsr!hY!(abgXrX!sXqqbshqxV!1tr!aTrsbex!vqbssXg!qXihqs!Tq`tXW!XqqhgXhtrex!saTs! saX!(abgXrX!ghqsaXTrsXqg!sXqqbshqbXr!aTW!UXXg!`huXqgXW!Ux!saX!(abgXrX!UtqXTtVqTsbV!rxrsXf! rbgVX!saX!UX`bggbg`!hY!qXVhqWXW!abrshqxV!TgW!saTs!8TgVatqbT!TgW!6hqXT!abrshqbVTeex!aTW! fTbgsTbgXW!hgex!fbgbfTe!VhfftgbVTsbhg!vbsa!5TiTg!K7XT`tX!hY!9TsbhgrV!!#!7XbUheWV!

"! !#!HTg`V!"!!M!!

! Eabr!tgVaTqTVsXqbrsbVTeex!VTqXeXrr!iqXrXgsTsbhg!hY!abrshqx!Ux!Tg!XrsTUebraXW!rVaheTq! vXeeXdghvg!Yhq!iqhfhsbg`!qb`hqhtr!rsTgWTqWr!hY!hUcXVsbuX!abrshqbVTe!rVaheTqrabiV!vTr!

VqbsbVbyXW!Ux!VhgsXfihqTqbXrV!Uts!hYYXqr!bgrb`as!bgsh!saX!iqXrrtqX!fTgx!rVaheTqr!YXes!sh!WXYXgW!

(abgXrX!sXqqbshqbTe!VeTbfr!bg!saX!gTfX!hY!gTsbhgTebrf!4gWXXWV!rtVa!vhqd!vTr!TfiebYbXW!Ux!T! ehg`XrsTgWbg`!TVTWXfbV!WXUTsX!TUhts!saX!gTstqX!hY!(abgXrXgXrr!bg!eb`as!hY!saX!TWhisbhg!hY!

HXrsXqg!sXVagheh`xV!fXWbVbgXV!rhVbTe!bgrsbstsbhgrV!TgW!ihebsbVTe!bWXTr!saTs!aTW!UX`tg!bg!saX! eTsX!gbgXsXXgsa!VXgstqx!(Teer!sh!VhgrsqtVs!VtestqX!hg!T!(abgXrX!UTrX! qĉ M¢Ë4 vXqX!TWuTgVXW!Ux!T!gtfUXq!hY!TVTWXfbVr!bgVetWbg`!saX!XWbshq!hY!saX!bgYetXgsbTe!DaTg`aTb!

(hffXqVbTe!AqXrrV!HTg`!Ibgfbg`! ¿DV!TgW!vabVa!bg!stqg!aTr!UXXg!ebgdXW!sh!saX!28)!

`huXqgfXgsr!(hffbssXX!hg!(testqTe!(hgrsqtVsbhgV!aXTWXW!Ux!(aXg!7bYt! ĳÝXV!T!fXfUXq! hY!hgX!hY!svh!28)!rXVqXs!ihebVX!hq`TgbyTsbhgr!KHTg`!Xs!TeV!!!!R!S#!QaXg`V!M!&!

!!WXVeTqTsbhgV!TgW!rXuXqTe!xXTqr!hY!WXUTsX!bg!ihiteTq!fXWbTV!qXbgYhqVXW!XrrXgsbTebyXW!

! !"#$%&'()*&+ !290@'(9)D52)5692C2)$(D6@9)2)%92) E)!624(94)(91)5692C2)#EC768C'#@12B9)

569('2))<=>@1@0H) >>) ghsbhgr!hY!(abgXrXgXrr!Ux!bWXgsbYxbg`!WbrsbgVsbuX!gTsbhgTe!VaTqTVsXqbrsbVr! ¾¯ saTs!VhteW!

Xwbrs!bgWXiXgWXgsex!hY!YhqXb`g!bgYetXgVX!K5XgVhV!YhqsaVhfbg`M!

! &fbW!saXrX!iXquTrbuXV!ihebsbVTeex!rtiihqsXW!TrrXqsbhgr!hY!gTsbhgTe!ahfh`XgXbsxV!rhfX! bgsXeeXVstTer!UX`Tg!XeTUhqTsbg`!T!VhtgsXqXgTqqTsbuX!hY!(abgXrX!bWXgsbsxV!qhhsbg`!bs!bg!`qhvbg`! abrshqbVTe!XubWXgVX!hY!(abgTr!VtestqTeex!TgW!qTVbTeex!WbuXqrX!iTrs!ETdbg`!saX!eXTW!bg!sabr!

VhtgsXqfhuXfXgs!vTr!saX!VeTrrbVbrs!2t!5bX`Tg`V!1tr!YhqfXq!'Xbcbg`!FgbuXqrbsx!qhhffTsXV! vah!br!UXrs!dghvg!Yhq!abr!iTbgrsTdbg`!sXwsXVqbsbVTe!TgTexrXr!TgW!XWbshqbTe!vhqd!hg!saX! bVhghVeTrsbV!rXqbXr! FD45&(5'@ !<>ġ!K)XUTsXr!hg!&gVbXgs!3brshqxM!EaXrX!iqhcXVsr!hY!

WhtUsbg`!Tgsbptbsx! È< TgW!qXhq`Tgbybg`!saX!gTsbhgTe!aXqbsT`X! ÂM VqbsbVTeex! bgsXqqh`TsXW!saX!sqTWbsbhgTe!VXeXUqTshqx!gTqqTsbuXr!hY!(abgTr!TgVbXgs!iTrs!trbg`!fhWXqg! abrshqbh`qTiabVTe!sXVagbptXr!TgW!TqVaXheh`xV!XgTUebg`!vaTs!bsr!iqhWtVXqr!UXebXuXW!sh!UX!T! fhqX!hUcXVsbuXV!rVbXgsbYbV!TVVhtgs!hY!(abgXrX!VbubebyTsbhg!Yhq!saX!itqihrXr!hY!gTsbhgTe! qXgXvTe!K2tV!!#!HTg`V!! M!&esaht`a!XwXVtsXW!vbsa!T!ribqbs!hY!TVTWXfbV! iqhYXrrbhgTebrf!rXeYXVhgrVbhtrex!WXsTVaXW!Yqhf!ihebsbVTe!VhgVXqgrV!2tr!abrshqbVTe!vhqd!bg! saX!XTqex!!r!ptXrsbhgXW!9TsbhgTebrs!VeTbfr!sh!T!rbg`eX!tgbYbXW!(abgXrX!bWXgsbsx!UTrXW!hg! ahfh`Xghtr!UehhWebgX!WXrVXgs!K(abgV!"!#!3hgV!!!M!!

! 4g!abr!XrrTx!@g!saX!@qb`bgr!hY!saX!BbgX3Tg!FgbYbVTsbhg!TgW!saX!2ehUTe!4fT`bgTqx!hY!

AXhieX!hY!saX!HTqqbg`!DsTsXr!AXqbhW! Ø¹æ ËÄEMi ÅË V!itUebraXW! bg!!!bg!saX!rXVhgW!uhetfX!hY!FD45&(5'@ V!2t!Tq`tXrV!VhgsqT!28)!bWXheh`xV!saTs!saXqX!

Xwbrsr!gh!abrshqbVTe!XubWXgVX!Yhq!T!tgbsTqx!(abgXrX!hq!3Tg!fbgyt!rsqXsVabg`!UTVd!bg!sbfX!sh!

UXYhqX!saX!Bbg!tgbYbVTsbhg!bg!! '(0 !

! &B@1@)21@)HDB(0D)AE@D(D6@9)3@77@GC) HX!aTuX!ehg`!aTW!T!fbrtgWXqrsTgWbg`!bg!sabgdbg`!saTs!saX!Xb`asXXg!iqhubgVXr!

bgaTUbsXW!Ux!saX!3Tg!iXhieX!R ¹ '@&PF S!aTuX!UXXg!tgbYbXW!rbgVX!TgVbXgs!sbfXr!

Eabr!fbrsTdXgex!trXr!T!ihbgs!hY!ubXv!Yqhf!TYsXq!saX!Bbg!TgW!3Tg!sh!WXsXqfbgX!saX!

! !"#$%&'()*&+ !290@'(9)D52)5692C2)$(D6@9)2)%92) E)!624(94)(91)5692C2)#EC768C'#@12B9)

569('2))<=>@1@0H) ><)

UhqWXqr!UXYhqX!saX!Bbg!TgW!3Tg!4g!sabr!riXXVaV!4!vTgs!sh!XwieTbg!sabr!bWXTV!gTfXex"!

(abgT!UXYhqX!saX!Bbg!TgW!3Tg!vTr!rbfiex!T!rVTssXqbg`!hY!rfTee!rsTsXr!saTs!vXqX!ghs!

tgbYbXW#!TgW!hgex!TYsXq!rfTee!rsTsXr!stqgXW!bgsh!Ub`!rsTsXr!WbW!saXqX!TqbrX!T!

WXsXqfbgTsbhg!sh!tgbYx!RsaXfS#!TgW!hgex!tgWXq!sabr!WXsXqfbgTsbhg!sh!tgbYx!RsaXfSV!WbW!

saX!Bbg!XfiXqhq!rXXd!sh!VqXTsX!Yhqsx!VhffTgWXqbXr!K2tV!!"!M!!

! &B@1@)21@)91)2HDB(0D)AE@D(D6@9) Eabr!XrrTxV!TgW!bsr!Tq`tfXgs!TUhts!saX!bqqXWtVbUex!ietqTe!TgW!YqT`fXgsXW!gTstqX!hY!abrshqbVTe!

(abgXrX!bWXgsbsxV!qXiqXrXgsr!saX!bgsXqrXVsbhg!hY!2tr!VeTrrbVbrf!vbsa!saX!Xsagh`qTiabV!vhqd! saTs!vhteW!VhfX!sh!iqXhVVtix!abf!saqht`ahts!saX!!r !4g!sabr!XrrTxV!2t!br!VTqXYte!sh!rahv! saTs!ghs!hgex!vTr!XTqex!(abgT!ghs!tgbsXWV!saXqX!Terh!XwbrsXW!gh!rtVa!vhqeW!VhgVXis!hq!

`ehUTe!bfT`bgTqx! ÅĄ~ bg!iqXXBbg!(abgT!saTs!VhteW!qXTebrsbVTeex!UX!rTbW!sh!XwiqXrr!Tgx! rtVa!ctrsbYbVTsbhg!hq!tgWXqrsTgWbg`!hY!tgbYbVTsbhg!Eabr!VhgVXis!WbW!ghs!WXuXehi!XuXg! bgVbibXgsexV!2t!Tq`tXrV!tgsbe!saX!XgW!hY!saX!HTqqbg`!DsTsXr!iXqbhW!TqhtgW!saX!sabqW!VXgstqx!

'(0 !!

! Eabr!vTr!TghsaXq!vTx!hY!rTxbg`!saTs!saX!(abgT!VeTbfXW!Ux!saX!28)!`huXqgfXgs!sh! aTuX!XwbrsXW!bg!saX!rTfX!vTx!saqht`ahts!sbfX!vTr!bg!YTVs!saX!hUcXVs!hY!ftesbieX!gTfXrV!

VhgsTbgXW!vbsabg!XwiTgWbg`!TgW!VhgsqTVsbg`!UhqWXqr!Ts!WbYYXqXgs!abrshqbVTe!iXqbhWrV!TgW! bgaTUbsXW!Ux!WbYYXqXgs!dbgWr!hY!iXhieX!4g!2tr!XxXrV!sh!VeTbfV!Tr!saX!28)!`huXqgfXgs!WbWV! saTs!saX!UhqWXqr!hY!saX!IbTV!DaTg`V!TgW!Qaht!WxgTrsbXr!vXqX!bWXgsbVTe!sh!sahrX!hY!saX!HTqqbg`!

DsTsXrV!TgW!bg!stqg!bWXgsbVTe!sh!sahrX!hY!iqXrXgsXWTx!(abgTV!br!T!shsTe!chdXV!iqhiT`TsXW!sh!

XqTrX!fbgytXUTrXW!WbYYXqXgVXr!Yhq!saX!XgWr!hY!gTsbhgTe!tgbsx!K2tV!!"!M!HaTsr!fhqXV!

2t!Tq`tXrV!saXqX!br!VhfiXeebg`!XubWXgVX!sh!rt``Xrs!saTs!XuXg!saX!uTtgsXW!Qaht!WxgTrsx vahrX!VtestqTe!rieXgWhq!TgW!ihebsbVTe!iqhriXqbsx!fTWX!bs!saX!rtUcXVs!hY!(hgYtVbTg!uXgXqTsbhg!

Yhq!gXTqex!svh!fbeeXggbTvTr!YhtgWXW!bg!DaTgwb!Ux!T!qTVX!WXqbuXW!Yqhf!saX!rhXVTeeXW!

UTqUTqbTg!)b!TgW!BbTg`!iXhieXr!K2tV!!"!M!4g!vqbsbg`!TUhts!saX!VaTg`bg`!vhqeW!

VhgVXisr!YhtgW!bg!TgVbXgs!rsTsXr!TrrhVbTsXW!vbsa!saX!Ubqsa!hY!saX!(abgXrX!iXhieXV!2t!saqhvr!

! !"#$%&'()*&+ !290@'(9)D52)5692C2)$(D6@9)2)%92) E)!624(94)(91)5692C2)#EC768C'#@12B9)

569('2))<=>@1@0H) >B)

VqbsbVTe!abrshqbVTe!eb`as!hg!VhgsXfihqTqx!WbrVtrrbhgr!TUhts!saX!iqXrXgsXWTx!tgbYbVTsbhg!hY!

(abgT!

! 8hrs!qXVXgs!abrshqbVTe!VhffXgsTshqr!aTuX!bgsXqiqXsXW!2tr!rsTgVX!hg!saX!rsTstr!hY! fbghqbsx!VtestqXr!Tr!Tg!bVhghVeTrsbV!VhtgsXqXgTqqTsbuX!sh!VeTbfr!hY!gTsbhgTe!ahfh`XgXbsxV!Uts! gXuXqsaXeXrr!hgX!saTs!tiaheWr!saX!bgaXqXgs!rtiXqbhqbsx!hY!3TgXUTrXW!(abgXrX!VtestqX!2tr!

Ubh`qTiaXq!7TtqXgVX!DVagXbWXq!fTbgsTbgr!saTs!2t!uTetXW!ghgX(abgXrX!iXhieXr!TgW!VtestqXr! bgrsqtfXgsTeex!Yhq!saXbq!TUbebsx!sh!qXctuXgTsX!saX!iXqbhWbVTeex!fhqbUtgW!WhfbgTgs!VtestqXV!

XgTUebg`!bs!sh!VhgsbgtX!TgW!iXqrbrs!KDVagXbWXqV!!"!M!5TfXr!7XbUheW!bgrbrsr!saTs!2tr! gTqqTsbuX!qXfTbgXW!Ybqfex!vbsabg!saX!ebgXTq!sXeXheh`x!hY!T!3TgXWhfbgTsXW!(abgXrX!gTsbhgV! iqhcXVsbg`!Uhsa!YhqvTqW!TgW!UTVdvTqW!saqhtà!sbfX!T!rbgèX!gTsbhgTe!rtUcXVs"!saX!QahgàtT! fbgyt!K7XbUheWV!"!M!CXVXgs!vhqd!Ux!EahfTr!8teeTgXx!UtbeWr!Yqhf!saXrX!

VaTqTVsXqbyTsbhgr!sh!WXXf!saX!vhqd!hY!2t!TgW!abr!VheeXT`tXr!bgYetXgVXW!Ux!8Tx!1htqsa!

WbrVhtqrX!Tr!rtYYtrXW!vbsa!Tg!XwhsbVbybg`!TgW!iTsXqgTebrsbV!rXgsbfXgs!bg!qX`TqW!sh!fbghqbsx!

TgW!YqhgsbXq!iXhieXr!K8teeTgXxV!"!M!!

! EaXrX!qXTWbg`r!TrrhVbTsX!2t!vbsa!saX!rTfX!XsaghVXgsqbV!eh`bV!hY!VtestqTebrf! iqhiT`TsXW!Ux!(abTg`!6TbXraXd!TgW!1t!DbgbTg"!saTs!brV!saX!UXebXY!saTs!(abgXrX!VtestqX! bqqXrbrsbUex!TgW!bgXubsTUex!TssqTVsr!TgW!TrrbfbeTsXr!saX!iXhieXr!hY!eXrrXq!VtestqXrV!qXrtesbg`!bg! saX!iXqrbrsXgVX!hY!3Tg!ihebsbVTe!TgW!VtestqTe!Ttsahqbsx!huXq!bgVqXTrbg`ex!UqhTW!gXb`aUhqbg`! sXqqbshqbXr!EaXrX!bgsXqiqXsTsbhgr!hY!2t!YbgW!rhfX!rtiihqs!bg!abr!!!XrrTxV!vaXqX!aX! fXgsbhgr!saX!VtestqTe!ihvXq!hY!saX!iXhieX!bg!saX!rsTsX!hY!HXb!TrrbfbeTsbg`!`qhtir!vbsa!eXrr!

TWuTgVXW!VtestqXr!K2tV!!"!M!4g!abr! AFEA(5A3C'B4I V!itUebraXW!Tr!T!iqXYTVX!sh!saX!Ybqrs!

XWbsbhg!hY!saX! FD45&(5'@ !bg!!V!aX!Terh!rsTsXr!saTs!aTW!bs!ghs!UXXg!Yhq!saX!bgYtrbhg!hY!gXv!

UehhW!Yqhf!saX!1buX!'TqUTqbTg!`qhtir!hY!saX!(abg!RBbgS!WxgTrsxV!Yqhf!saX!6absTgV!Yqhf!saX!

5qVaXW!TgW!8hg`herV!4!YXTq!saTs!saX!3Tg!qTVX!VhteW!ghs!aTuX!rtqubuXW!K2t!TgW!3tffXeV!

!"!M!

! !"#$%&'()*&+ !290@'(9)D52)5692C2)$(D6@9)2)%92) E)!624(94)(91)5692C2)#EC768C'#@12B9)

569('2))<=>@1@0H) >C)

! DtVa!UXebXYr!saTs!saX!3Tg!qTVX!qXptbqXW!bgYtrbhgr!Yqhf!YhqXb`g!hsaXqr!Yhq!bsr!ubsTebsx!

TgW!rtqubuTe!aTW!UXVhfX!iTqs!hY!gXTqex!tgptXrsbhgXW!Vhffhg!rXgrX!Ux!saX!!rV!Uhsa!Yhq!

(abgXrX!qXYhqfXqr!Tr!vXee!Tr!Yhq!HXrsXqg!TVTWXfbVr!bg!saX!XfXq`bg`!YbXeWr!hY!WXfh`qTiax!

TgW!Tgsaqhiheh`x!&r!XTqex!Tr! !!7bTg`!BbVaTh! ¦GĜ TgW!PTg!1t! Iy vXqX!VTeebg`!Yhq! saX!trX!hY!XWtVTsbhg!bg!YhqXb`g!bWXTr!sh!bgub`hqTsX!T!(abgXrX!iXhieX!TUhts!sh!UX!vbgghvXW!hts! hY!saX!qTVX!Yhq!XuhetsbhgTqx!rtVVXrr!KX`V!PTgV!! M!2t!br!WbrsbgVsbuXV!ahvXuXqV!bg!ihbgsbg`! hts!aXqX!saX!uTetX!sh!(abgXrX!rtqubuTeV!ghs!hgex!hY!saX!HXrsXqg!YhqXb`g!XeXfXgsr!saTs!YhqfXW! saX!UTVdUhgX!hY!fhrs!qXYhqfbrs!saht`as!rbgVX!saX!eTsX!gbgXsXXgsa!VXgstqxV!Uts!Terh!hY!saX! abrshqbVTe!bgYetwXr!hY!ghgX3Tg!VtestqTe!`qhtir!saTs!`XgXqTsXW!ubsTebsx!Wtqbg`!vTgbg`!iXqbhWr! hY!saX!(abgXrX!XfibqX!!

! @Y!VhtqrXV!2t!vTr!ghs!saX!Ybqrs!sh!ihbgs!hts!saTs!(abgXrX!VtestqX!abrshqbVTeex!UXgXYbsXW!

Yqhf!KTgW!vTr!sqTgrYhqfXW!UxM!bsr!bgsXqTVsbhg!vbsa!ghgX(abgXrX!`qhtir!3br!VhgsXfihqTqx!

7bt!PbyaXg`!TgW!hsaXqr!TrrhVbTsXW!vbsa!saX!chtqgTe! 4F8EFC'8&1G51H !`ÿ !TssXfisXW!sh!rahv! saTs!iqXVbrXex!UXVTtrX!(abgT!VaTg`XW!huXq!sbfX!Tr!bs!VTfX!bgsh!VhgsTVs!vbsa!YhqXb`g!hsaXqrV! bs!vTr!UXrs!tgWXqrshhW!Tr!T! )F8EFC'8 !Xgsbsx!qTsaXq!saTg!T!qTVbTe!bWXgsbsx!K3hgV!"!M!PXs!

Yhq!7bt!TgW!hsaXqr!iXqrtTWXW!Ux!7btr!ftVaXqXiqbgsXW! 5DEACI&A2&445@1D1&4F8EFC1 ! M4

>!K7btV!!MV!saXqX!XwbrsXW!UXgXTsa!saXrX!sqTgrYhqfTsbhgr!Tg!XgWtqbg`!gTsbhgTe!VaTqTVsXq!

M°V!vabVa!YhqfXW!saX!rtUcXVs!hY!saTs!abrshqx!TgW!vahrX!`XgXrbr!bg!Tgsbptbsx!WXYbgXW!saX!

YhtgWbg`!fhfXgs!hY!saX!gTsbhg!K6thV!"! M!4g!VhgsqTrsV!qXVh`gbybg`!ahv!sahqht`aex!

(abgXrX!VtestqX!vTr!bgub`hqTsXWV!TgW!Ts!VXqsTbg!ihbgsr!qXVhgrsbstsXWV!Ux!YhqXb`g!XeXfXgsrV!

2t!UX`Tg!sh!ptXrsbhg!Uhsa!saX!VaTqTVsXq!TgW!saX!abrshqbVTe!rsTUbebsx!hY!saTs!gTsbhgTe!rtUcXVs!

3br!vhqd!Wtqbg`!saX!!r!hg!saX!abrshqbVTe!TgW!atfTg!`Xh`qTiax!hY!saX!YqhgsbXq!XuXgstTeex!

VtefbgTsXW!bg!T!WXYbgbsbhg!hY!saX!(abgXrX!gTsbhg!KQahg`atT!fbgytM!Tr!T! BA85E5)'8 !

TrrhVbTsbhg!qTsaXq!saTg!hgX!VhfiqbrXW!hY!T!fhghebsabV!VtestqXV!qTVXV!hq!XsagbVbsx !!4g!Whbg`!rhV! aX!WbuXrsXW!VeTbfr!TUhts!(abgXrX!gTsbhgTebsx!Yqhf!saX!abrshqbVTe!XsaghVXgsqbrf!hY!

! !"#$%&'()*&+ !290@'(9)D52)5692C2)$(D6@9)2)%92) E)!624(94)(91)5692C2)#EC768C'#@12B9)

569('2))<=>@1@0H) >D)

VtestqTebrs!Tq`tfXgsr!rtVa!Tr!sahrX!hY!7bt!PbyaXg`!TgW!(abTg`!6TbXraXdV!vabeX! rbftesTgXhtrex!sqTgrihrbg`!saX!saXhqx!hY!ghgXqTVbTeV!TYYXVsXUTrXW!Yhqfr!hY!fXfUXqrabi!hgsh! saX!sXqf!fbgyt!!

&B@1@)21@)"2F27J>)52(1)3@77@GC)!

“The Chinese Nation Is One”

2tr!VeXTqXrs!TgW!fhrs!WbqXVs!Tq`tfXgsr!TUhts!saX!gTstqX!hY!saX!(abgXrX!fbgytV!bgVetWbg`!bsr! qXeTsbhgrabi!sh!saX!uTqbhtr!`qhtir!vbsabg!bs!KvabVa!aX!TerhV!rhfXvaTs!VhgYtrbg`exV!VTeer!

fbgytMV!TqX!YhtgW!bg!T!rXqbXr!hY!XrrTxr!aX!vqhsX!bg!saX!fbWX!sh!eTsX!!r!bg!qXrihgrX!sh! fhtgsbg`!iqXrrtqX!Yqhf!saX!ihebsbVTe!qX`bfX!Tr!vXee!Tr!ihebsbVTeex!VhXhisXW!YqbXgWr!TgW!

VheeXT`tXrV!bgVetWbg`!1t!DbgbTg!1tV!bg!Vheetrbhg!vbsa!28)!eXTWXqrV!qXiXTsXWex!TgW!Ts!eXg`sa! tq`XW!2t!sh!TUTgWhg!abr!TssXgsbhg!sh!saX!YqhgsbXq!ptXrsbhg!TgW!abr!bgrbrsXgVX!hg!saX!ietqTe! hqb`bgr!hY!(abgXrX!VbubebyTsbhg!K1tV!! TM!'hsa!bgsXqXrsrV!1t!UXebXuXWV!XgVhtqT`XW!rxfiTsax!

Yhq!XsagbV!fbghqbsbXr!Ts!saX!XwiXgrX!hY!gTsbhgTe!tgbsx!K7XbUheWV!"! M!CXVh`gbybg`!saX! bffbgXgs!saqXTs!hY!5TiTgXrX!bguTrbhg!TgW!gTsbhgTe!YqT`fXgsTsbhgV!2tr!qXrihgrX!sh!sabr!

VhgtgWqtf!vTr!sh!TrrXqs!saTs!saX!(abgXrX!gTsbhg!br!hgX! õ° ËV!T!iaqTrX!saTs!

Terh!rXquXr!Tr!saX!sbseX!hY!abr!at`Xex!VhgsqhuXqrbTe!!!!XrrTx!itUebraXW!bg!saX!fhgsaex!

1qhgsbXq!rtiieXfXgs! ĩÇC-!hY!saX! %5D45('A&Ì S!EaX!rtffTqx!TiiXgWXW!sh!saX!

UX`bggbg`!hY!saX!XrrTx!XwieTbgr!2tr!ihbgs!Tr!saX!(abgXrX!iXhieX! M!TqX!Tee!Qahg`atT! fbgyt!K2tV!W"!!M !EaX!XrrTx!`hXr!hg!sh!XwieTbgV!ahvXuXqV!saTs!rtVa!gTsbhgTe!tgbsx!

VTg!UX!TVabXuXW!hgex!saqht`a!WXXiXq!tgWXqrsTgWbg`!hY!saX!WbuXqrX!Yhqfr!hY!ebYXV!bgVetWbg`! fbghqbsx!fbgyt!VtestqXrV!saTs!bg!TVstTebsx!VhfiqbrXW!saTs!gTsbhg!!

6Xx!sh!abr!Tq`tfXgs!br!abr!abrshqbVTe!qXrXTqVa!hg!saX!UeXgWbg`!hY!qTVXr!TgW!VtestqXr!bg!

TgVbXgs!(abgTV!TgW!saX!VhgsbgtTsbhg!hY!rtVa!bgsXqTVsbhg!tgWXq!saX!XfibqX!Eh!2tV!saXrX! iqhVXrrXr!hY!bgsXqTVsbhg!XYYTVXW!qTVbTe!VhgrVbhtrgXrr!bg!(abgTV!vabeX!rbftesTgXhtrex! iqhWtVbg`!T!WbrsbgVsbuX!fhWX!hY!`qhti!TYYbebTsbhg!bg!vabVa!iXhieX!Vhgsbgthtrex!TUTgWhgXW!

! !"#$%&'()*&+ !290@'(9)D52)5692C2)$(D6@9)2)%92) E)!624(94)(91)5692C2)#EC768C'#@12B9)

569('2))<=>@1@0H) >)

VXqsTbg!vTxr!hY!ebYX!sh!sTdX!ti!fhqX!YTuhqTUeX!TesXqgTsbuXr!K2tV!W"!!M!DtVa!VahbVXr!

VhgrsTgsex!qXYb`tqXW!`qhti!bWXgsbsx!bg!vTxr!saTs!VaTeeXg`XW!iqXuTeXgs!Trrtfisbhgr!saTs!

VtestqTe!TgW!fbgyt!bWXgsbsx!gXVXrrTqbex!huXqeTi!4g!T!iTrrT`X!iXqaTir!WXebUXqTsXex!qXfbgbrVXgs! hY!(abTg`!6TbXraXdr!gTqqTsbuX!hY!(abgXrX!sXqqbshqbTe!XwiTgrbhg!saqht`a!VtestqTe!TrrbfbeTsbhgV!

2t!Tq`tXr!saTs!abrshqbVTeex!(abgXrX!raTqXW!bWXgsbsx!vTr!Utbes!rheXex!hg! BA85E5)'8 !qTsaXq!saTg! qTVbTe!hq!VtestqTe!tgbYbVTsbhg"!!

&B@1@)21@)HDB(0D)AE@D(D6@9)3@77@GC)!

HX!aTW!gXuXq!aTW!qTVbTe!iqXctWbVXr#!hgX!aTW!hgex!sh!ebuX!vbsabg!saX!UhqWXqr!hY!(abgT!

TgW!TVVXis!T!`huXqgfXgsTe!Ttsahqbsx!sh!UXVhfX!ftstTeex!VhgYbqfXW!Tr!T!VbsbyXg! °

bg!hgX!XptTe!UhWx!!

&UhuX!4!aTuX!TeqXTWx!fTWX!VeXTq!saTs!saX!(abgXrX!gTsbhg!KQahg`atT!fbgytM!br!

ghs!hq`TgbyXW!Ux!UehhWebgXr!9hv!4!vTgs!sh!`h!T!rsXi!YtqsaXqV!TgW!rTx!saTs!saX!(abgXrX!

gTsbhg!br!ghs!XuXg!Utbes!tihg!saX!rTfX!VtestqX!4!TeqXTWx!rihdX!TUhts!(hgYtVbtr!ghs!

vTgsbg`!sh!tgUbgW!abr!aTbq!TgW!YheW!abr!qhUX!Yqhf!saX!eXYsV!RTg!bgVbWXgsS!vabVa!rXXfXW!

sh!bgWbVTsX!saTs!saTs!heW!`XgseXfTg!ehTsaXW!UTqUTqbTg!VtestqX !'ts!TVstTeex!saTs!br!ghs!

saX!VTrX#!aX!vTr!fXqXex!ahibg`!saTs!iXhieX!VhteW!aTuX!T!UXssXq!ebYXV!ghs!saTs!iXhieX!

4'0!sh!ebuX!ebYX!T!VXqsTbg!vTx!EhWTx!saX!VtestqX!hY!saX!3Tg!iXhieXV!XuXqxhgX!rTxrV!

rXXfr!sh!VhgsbgtX!saX!VtestqX!hY!saX!DaTg`!TgW!Qaht!RWxgTrsbXrS!'ts!TVstTeex!sabr!br!

ghs!VhqqXVs#!Yqhf!XTqex!hg!bs!rXeXVsXW!saX!`hhW!ihbgsr!TgW!TUTgWhgXW!saX!UTW!ihbgsr!hY!

XuXqx!dbgW!hY!qTVX!TgW!gTsbhgTebsx!sh!UXVhfX!T!dbgW!hY!axUqbW! ç? !VtestqX!K2tV!

W"!!M!

! &B@1@)21@)91)2HDB(0D)AE@D(D6@9) &esaht`a!saXqX!qXfTbg!aXqX!Trrtfisbhgr!TUhts!saX!gTstqTe!rtiXqbhqbsx!hY!3Tg!VtestqXrtVa!

Tr!saTs!bs!TehgX!rXXfr!sh!aTuX!bgsX`qTsXW!saX!rXeYXXubWXgsex!UXrs!TriXVsr!hY!YhqXb`g!VtestqXr! sh!VqXTsX!bsr!hvg!XwsqThqWbgTqx!VbubebyTsbhg2t!gXuXqsaXeXrr!rahvr!aXqX!ahv!saX!ghsbhg!hY!

! !"#$%&'()*&+ !290@'(9)D52)5692C2)$(D6@9)2)%92) E)!624(94)(91)5692C2)#EC768C'#@12B9)

569('2))<=>@1@0H) >)

Qahg`atT!fbgyt!VTg!UX!hiXg!sh!saX!ihrrbUbebsx!saTs!hsaXq!iXhieX!VTg!eX`bsbfTsXex!ebuX!

WbYYXqXgsex!1bqrsV!aX!`ehrrXr!T!iTrrT`X!Yqhf!saX! A@'81)ED&Đč F!sxibVTeex!bgsXqiqXsXW!Tr!

WbrfbrrbuX!hY!YhqXb`g!VtestqXV!bg!sXqfr!saTs!rt``Xrs!hsaXq!VtestqXr!vhqsax!hY!XfteTsbhg!Wh!

Xwbrs!Tehg`rbWX!(abgXrX!VbubebyTsbhg!K8bxTdTvTV!!"!M!DXVhgW!TgW!fhqX!qXuXTebg`exV! aX!bfiebXr!saTs!hsaXq!VtestqXr!ftrs!UX!YqXX!sh!WXuXehi!hg!saXbq!hvg!sXqfr!bY!saXx!TqX!sh!riqXTW! saXbq!bgYetXgVX!sh!hsaXqr!Eabr!br!iTqsbVteTqex!UXVTtrX!2t!XfiaTrbyXr!saX!hg`hbg`!WxgTfbrf! hY!sabr!axUqbWbsx!hq!UeXgWbg`!4grhYTq!Tr!rtVa!abrshqbVTe!UeXgWbg`!shhd!ieTVXV!2t!Tq`tXrV!bsr! qXrtes!VTgghs!eX`bsbfTsXex!UX!VTeeXW!3Tg!VtestqX!hq!T!3Tg!gTsbhg!TgxfhqX#!bs!br!ghv!T!

(abgXrX!gTsbhgTe!VtestqX! õ°Ë4 UXVTtrX!vX!TqX!ctrs!iXhieX!vah!ebuX!T!raTqXW! ebYX!sh`XsaXq!tgWXq!saX!rTfX!`huXqgfXgs!TgW!vX!ht`as!ghs!sh!aTuX!TghsaXq!gTfX!htsrbWX!hY!

Qahg`atT!fbgyt!K2tV!W"!! M !7bubg`!Tr!VhXXptTer!tgWXq!T!rbg`eX!`huXqgfXgsV!2t! tq`Xr!saX!TUTgWhgfXgs!hY!sXqfr!rtVa!Tr!(abgT!iqhiXq! M¢Ī TgW!saX!CXitUebV!hY!1buX!

CTVXr! ä(EV!vabVa!WbubWX!iXhieXr!hg!saX!iXqbiaXqbXr!Yqhf!saX!WhfbgTgs!3Tg! ihiteTsbhgr!bg!XTrsXqg!(abgTV!TgW!Wbfbgbra!saXbq!VhffbsfXgs!sh!gTsbhgTe!iqhcXVsr!fXTgs!sh! bgVetWX!saXf!K2tV!WM!

! 2tr!VeTbfr!aXqX!WqTv!aXTubex!hg!abr!iXqrhgTe!TgW!iqhYXrrbhgTe!Xg`T`XfXgs!vbsa! fXfUXqr!hY!hgX!hY!saX!fbghqbsx!`qhtir!saX!9TsbhgTebrs!gTqqTsbuX!fTq`bgTebyXW"!saX!3tb! K!

K(abgXrX!8trebfM!iXhieX!vah!bgaTUbsXW!saX!rsqTsX`bVTeex!bfihqsTgs!ghqsaXqg!YqhgsbXqr!Tr!vXee!

Tr!qXrbWXW!bg!fTgx!hY!(abgTr!VbsbXr!2t!abfrXeY!TWfbssXW!saTs!aX!UXVTfX!bgsXqXrsXW!bg!

(abgXrX!8trebfr!hgex!vaXg!5TiTgr!bgVtqrbhgr!hg!saX!fTbgeTgW!tgWXqrVhqXW!saX!bfihqsTgVX! hY!saX!UhqWXq!qX`bhgr!K2tV!!U"! M!'ts!Yqhf!saTs!ihbgs!YhqvTqWV!saX!3tb!vhteW!UXVhfX!

Uhsa!T!rhtqVX!TgW!rbsX!hY!abr!sabgdbg`!TUhts!saX!Vhgrsbstsbhg!hY!saX!Qahg`atT!fbgyt!TgW!bsr! rVhiX!3br!vhqd!vbsa!saX!3tb!XwsXgWXW!UXxhgW!TVTWXfbV!qXrXTqVa!sh!iXqrhgTe!TgW! iqhYXrrbhgTe!qXeTsbhgrabirV!bgVetWbg`!saX!XrsTUebrafXgs!hY!rVaheTqex!gXsvhqdbg`!TgW! itUebVTsbhg!htseXsr!sh!`buX!uhbVX!sh!xhtg`!3tb!TVsbubrsr!TgW!rVaheTqr!3br!TVsbubsbXr!vbsa!saX!

! !"#$%&'()*&+ !290@'(9)D52)5692C2)$(D6@9)2)%92) E)!624(94)(91)5692C2)#EC768C'#@12B9)

569('2))<=>@1@0H) >)

'hqWXqeTgW!CXrXTqVa!DhVbXsx!bg!'Xbcbg`!XwihrXW!abf!sh!bgVqXTrbg`!gtfUXqr!hY!ehVTe!(abgXrX!

8trebfrV!rtVa!Tr!sahrX!TrrhVbTsXW!vbsa!(aXg`WT!9hqfTe!(heeX`XV!Tr!vXee!Tr!qXiqXrXgsTsbuXr!

Yqhf!0`xisr!TeX&yaTq!FgbuXqrbsx!K8ThV!#!DVagXbWXqV!!"! M!4g!!!2t!

TVVXisXW!Tg!bgubsTsbhg!Yqhf!saX!'hwXq!0WtVTsbhgTe!(hffbrrbhg!sh!sqTuXe!sh!saX!ghqsavXrs!sh!

XwiehqX!YbqrsaTgW!saX!8trebf!VhfftgbsbXr!sTq`XsXW!Ux!5TiTgXrX!iqhiT`TgWT!DXssbg`!hts!Yhq!

7Tgyaht!bg!DXisXfUXq!hY!saTs!xXTqV!2t!chtqgXxXW!sh!Bbg`aTb!sh!fXXs!vbsa!saX!8trebf! iqhubgVbTe!hYYbVbTer!2XgXqTe!8T!'tYTg`! ļó!TgW!8T!7bg! ļĿ !K2tV!UM!HaXg!saX!

5TiTgXrX!UX`Tg!UhfUbg`!7TgyahtV!2t!TVVXisXW!xXs!TghsaXq!bgubsTsbhg!sh!chbg!9TsbhgTe!

PtggTg!FgbuXqrbsx!bg!saX!rhtsa!KTerh!Tg!TqXT!vbsa!VhgVXgsqTsXW!fbghqbsx!ihiteTsbhgrM!EaXqX! aX!VhgsbgtXW!abr!bguXrsb`Tsbhg!hY!8trebf!XWtVTsbhg!tgsbe!!V!vaXg!aX!qXrtfXW!sXTVabg`!Ts! saX!qXehVTsXW!5bet!FgbuXqrbsx!bg!(aXg`Wt!KDVagXbWXqV!!"!!!V!!M!

! 'x!sabr!ihbgs!saX!5TiTgXrX!bguTrbhg!aTW!YhqVXW!saX!qXehVTsbhg!hY!saX!(abgXrX!VTibsTe!

Yqhf!'Xbcbg`!bg!saX!ghqsaXTrs!sh!(ahg`pbg`!bg!saX!vXrsXqg!bgsXqbhqV!vaXqX!fhrs!tgbuXqrbsbXr!

TgW!hsaXq!rhVbTe!bgrsbstsbhgr!aTW!TeqXTWx!qXehVTsXW!Ts!saX!htsUqXTd!hY!ahrsbebsbXr!2t!abfrXeYV!Tr! saX!XWbshq!hY!saX!TgsbX5TiTgXrX!uXqgTVteTq!chtqgTe! ABF8'C&1'05@3D !ĢĖ½ TgW!YhtgWXq!hY!

Tg!TgsbX5TiTgXrX!iqhiT`TgWT!hq`TgbyTsbhgV!YhtgW!abfrXeY!hg!saX!8hrs!HTgsXW!ebrs!hY!saX!

5TiTgXrX!2tTgWhg`!Tqfx!TgW!YeXW!sh!DtbxtTg!K7btV!"!!#!DVagXbWXqV!!"! V! M!

&gsaqhiheh`brsrV!rhVbheh`brsrV!TgW!abrshqbTgr!rtVa!Tr!2t!YhtgW!saXfrXeuXr!rbstTsXW!ghv! vbsabg!saX!abrshqbVTe!sXqqbshqbXr!hY!saX!uXqx!XsaghXVtestqTe!`qhtir!28)!ihebVx!ahiXW!sh! bgsX`qTsXV!hYYXqbg`!tgiqXVXWXgsXW!hiihqstgbsbXr!Yhq!saXbq!YbqrsaTgW!rstWx!Tr!T!fXTgr!hY!rheubg`! saX!Ux!ghv!Uhbebg`!ahs!ptXrsbhg!hY!gTsbhgTe!tgbsx"!vXqX!saXrX!`qhtir!VtestqTeex!WbrsbgVsV! ihebsbVTeex!Ttshghfhtr!VhfftgbsbXr!WXrXqubg`!hY!saXbq!hvg!sXqqbshqbTe!rXeYXWXsXqfbgTsbhgV!Tr! fTgx!(abgXrX!(hfftgbrs!ATqsx!fXfUXqr!UXebXuXWV!hq!vhteW!qXVh`gbybg`!saXrX!`qhtir!Tr!

WbrsbgVs!VhfftgbsbXr!YqTVstqX!(abgXrX!sXqqbshqx!TgW!eXTuX!saX!XgsbqX!Vhtgsqx!utegXqTUeX!sh!

YtqsaXq!5TiTgXrX!bgYbesqTsbhg!TgW!bguTrbhgV!Tr!saX!28)!bgrbrsXW$!K8teeTgXxV!"!M!EaXrX!

! !"#$%&'()*&+ !290@'(9)D52)5692C2)$(D6@9)2)%92) E)!624(94)(91)5692C2)#EC768C'#@12B9)

569('2))<=>@1@0H) >) ptXrsbhgr!vXqXV!hUubhtrexV!fhqX!saTg!TVTWXfbV"!5TiTg!aTW!bguTWXW!8TgVatqbT!bg!!!hg!saX! iqXsXws!saTs!(abgXrX!TtsahqbsbXr!WXgbXW!rXeYXWXsXqfbgTsbhg!sh!saX!fbghqbsx!`qhtir!bgaTUbsbg`! bsr!ghqsaXqg!YqhgsbXqr!K&gWhV!#!'hWWXV!!M!!

! 'x!saTs!ihbgsV!tgWXq!iqXrrtqX!Yqhf!VheeXT`tXr!KbgVetWbg`!abr!ehuX!bgsXqXrs!ETg!8txtV! vah!TVVhfiTgbXW!28)!hiXqTsbuXr!sh!DtbxtTg!sh!UX`bg!bguXrsb`Tsbg`!vaTs!vTr!VTeeXW!saX!

UhqWXq!brrtXMV!2tr!rVqtitehtr!rVaheTqex!brheTsbhg!Yqhf!ihebsbVr!aTW!VhfieXsXex!UqhdXg!Whvg!

K(aTgV!"!M!DhfX!VhgsXfihqTqx!TgW!fhWXqg!VhffXgsTshqr!sXgW!sh!rXX!2tr! ihebsbVTe!TVsbubrf!bg!sabr!iXqbhWV!VXgsXqXW!hg!abr!Tq`tfXgsr!TUhts!saX!tgbsx!hY!saX!Qahg`atT! fbgytV!Tr!Vhgrsbstsbg`!T!raTqi!UqXTd!vbsa!abr!bVhghVeTrsbV!rstWbXr!hY!(abgTr!TgVbXgs!iTrs!bg!

FD45&(5'@ !K2XV!#!BbTgV!!! "!#!WbrVtrrXW!bg!(aTgV!"!!iTrrbf#!PtV!M!

&esaht`a!abr!vhqd!WbW!UXVhfX!fhqX!iqXrXgsbrsV!bg!saTs!abr!qXrXTqVa!shibVr!vXqX!VahrXg!hg!saX!

UTrbr!hY!iqXrXgs!gXXWr!qTsaXq!saTg!saX!itqXex!bgsXeeXVstTe!`hTer!hY!abrshqbVbrfV!2tr!rVaheTqex!

TVsbubsbXr!bg!saX!!r!VTg!UX!bgsXqiqXsXW!Tr!TWuTgVbg`!saX!rTfX!qXhq`TgbyTsbhg!hY!saX! gTsbhgTe!aXqbsT`X! ÂM saTs!hqb`bgTeex!`tbWXW!abr!vhqd!hg! FD45&(5'@ !&r!4!XwieTbg!

UXehvV!sahrX!rVaheTqex!bgsXqXrsr!bgVqXTrbg`ex!WhuXsTbeXW!vbsa!ihebsbVTe!fhuXfXgsr!sh!XwiTgW! saX!rVhiX!hY!saX!gTsbhgTe!aXqbsT`X!sh!bgVetWX!qXrXTqVa!hg!saX!bWXgsbsxXYhqfTsbhg!TgW! iqXrXgVX!hY!3tb!8trebf!TgW!hsaXq!fbghqbsx!`qhtir!bg!abrshqbVTe!(abgXrX!sXqqbshqxT!ihbgs!

Terh!ghsXW!Ux!3tb!VhgsqbUtshqr!sh! %F3A@3&K5bgV!!"! M !!

! DtVa!qXrXTqVaV!TgW!saX!abrshqbVTe!XwTfieXr!hY!VtestqTe!bgsXqTVsbhg!saTs!bs!tgXTqsaXWV!

XgTUeXW!2t!sh!bfT`bgX!T!sabqW!vTx!hY!tgWXqrsTgWbg`!saX!Qahg`atT!fbgytV!UXxhgW!Uhsa!saX! ahfh`Xgbybg`!qTVbTe!bWXgsbsx!gTqqTsbuXr!hY!saX!28)!TgW!saX!YqT`fXgsTsbhg!hY!(abgT!Ux!saX!

5TiTgXrX!bfiXqbTebrsr"!`qhtir!rtVa!Tr!saX!3tb!VhteW!UX!qXVh`gbyXW! (AE4!Tr!WbrsbgVsbuX!fbgyt!

KgTsbhgTebsbXrM! '@0!Tr!iTqs!hY!T!ihebsbVTeex!tgbYbXW!Qahg`atT!fbgyt &KsaX!(abgXrX!gTsbhgM!

EaX!VhgVqXsX!bfiebVTsbhgr!hY!sabr!sabqW!vTx!UXVhfX!fTgbYXrs!bg!2tr!vhqd!hg!saX!chtqgTe!

%F3A@3 !vbsa!(abgXrX!8trebf!vqbsXqrV!vah!XwiehqXW!saXbq!qXeTsbhgrabi!Uhsa!sh!saXbq!rtiihrXW! fbgyt!TYYbebTsbhg!TgW!sh!saX!(abgXrX!rsTsX!2tr!vhqd!vbsa!3tb!bgsXeeXVstTer!hYYXqr!Uhsa!T!VTrX!

! !"#$%&'()*&+ !290@'(9)D52)5692C2)$(D6@9)2)%92) E)!624(94)(91)5692C2)#EC768C'#@12B9)

569('2))<=>@1@0H) <=) rstWx!TgW!YtqsaXq!saXhqbyTsbhg!hY!ahv!2t!VhteW!rbftesTgXhtrex!Tq`tX!Uhsa!saTs!WbrsbgVsbuX! fbgyt!bWXgsbsbXr!vXqX!bfihqsTgs!TgW!vhqsax!hY!iTqsbVteTq!abrshqbVTeV!VtestqTeV!TgW!ihebsbVTe! qXVh`gbsbhgV!vabeX!Terh!fTbgsTbgbg`!saTs!saX!(abgXrX!gTsbhg!saTs!rtUrtfXW!saXf!vTr!bsrXeY!T! tgbsx!!

! &B@1@)21@)"2F27J>)52(1)3@77@GC)

The Han-Hui Question

2tr!fhrs!rb`gbYbVTgs!VhgsqbUtsbhg!sh!saX!WXUTsXr!huXq!T!(abgXrX!8trebf!bWXgsbsx!Tq`tTUex! ebXr!bg!abr!VhXYhtgWbg`!hY!saX!rVaheTqex!chtqgTe! %F3A@3 ! 1959A@E48 x!bg!!V!vabVa!tgsbe!bsr! vTqsbfX!WXfbrX!bg!!!hYYXqXW!bgVqXTrbg`ex!UqhTW!VhuXqT`X!hY!VhgsXfihqTqx!fbgyt!WXUTsXr! bg!TWWbsbhg!sh!fhqX!TVTWXfbV!ibXVXr!hg!abrshqbVTe!`Xh`qTiax !2t!bWXgsbYbXW! %F3A@3 !Tr!saX! tiiXqXVeTrr!ebsXqTsX!VhtgsXqiTqs!sh!abr!vbWXex!VbqVteTsbg`!uXqgTVteTq! ABF8'C&1'05@3D !rXqbXr"!

Uhsa!vXqX!VXgsqTe!sh!iqhfhsbg`!T!gXv!ubrbhg!hY!saX!gTsbhg!Wtqbg`!saX!vTq!vbsa!5TiTg!K7btV!

"!!M!EaX!VhgsXgs!hY!sabr!chtqgTebgVetWbg`!Uts!ghs!ebfbsXW!sh!2tr!iXqrhgTe!

VhgsqbUtsbhgrbr!saXqXYhqX!rb`gbYbVTgs!Yhq!tgWXqrsTgWbg`!2tr!iXqriXVsbuX!hg!saX!gTsbhg!!

! 3tb!bgsXeeXVstTer!vXqX!T!VhqX!rXs!hY!VhgsqbUtshqr!sh!KTgW!VXgsqTe!shibV!hY!WbrVtrrbhg!hYM!

%F3A@3 V!Yhq!rXuXqTe!qXTrhgr!FgebdX!hsaXq!8trebf!`qhtir!bg!(abgT!rtVa!Tr!saX!EtqdbVX riXTdbg`!Fb`atqrV!fhrs!3tb!WbW!ghs!qXrbrs!bgVetrbhg!vbsabg!saX!(abgXrX!gTsbhg!TgW!XwabUbsXW! fTgx!htsvTqWex!(abgXrX!sqTbsr!EaXx!vXqX!WbriXqrXW!TVqhrr!XuXqx!iqhubgVX!TgW!tqUTg!VXgsXq! bg!(abgTV!vaXqX!hYsXg!hgex!saXbq!8trebf!qXeb`bhtr!TgW!WbXsTqx!iqTVsbVXr!Wbrsbg`tbraXW!saXf!

Yqhf!saXbq!3Tg!gXb`aUhqr!EaXrX!YTfbebTq!rsqTg`Xqr!Ksh!trX!5hgTsaTg!7bifTgr!sXqfM!aTW! iTrrXW!XwTfbgTsbhgr!Yhq!itUebV!rXqubVX!tgWXq!saX!YhqfXq!XfibqX!TgW!ehxTeex!rXquXW!XfiXqhqr! rbgVX!saX!8bg`!WxgTrsx!K7bifTgV!!! M!4g!TWWbsbhgV!3tb!XebsXr!aTW!ehg`!fTrsXqXW!saX!(abgXrX!

VeTrrbVTe!eTg`tT`X! Ć hY!hYYbVbTe!WbrVhtqrXV!TgW!VhgsbgtXW!sh!trX!bs!XuXg!TYsXq!(abgXrX! qXYhqfXqr!TUTgWhgXW!bs!Yhq!saX!uXqgTVteTq!bg!saX!!r!K&tUbgV!"!M!4g!YTVsV!eXssXqr!TgW!

TqsbVeXr!itUebraXW!bg! %F3A@3 !Ux!8trebf!rVaheTqr!TgW!TVsbubrsr!rahv!saTs!saX!3tb!uXqx!ftVa! rTv!saXfrXeuXr!Tr!iTqs!hY!saX!(abgXrX!gTsbhgTeUXbs!ghs!TevTxr!hg!saX!sXqfr!XwsXgWXW!sh!

! !"#$%&'()*&+ !290@'(9)D52)5692C2)$(D6@9)2)%92) E)!624(94)(91)5692C2)#EC768C'#@12B9)

569('2))<=>@1@0H) <>) saXf!KX`V!'TbV!#!5bgV!!M!EaX!TfUbuTeXgVX!hY!sabr!qXeTsbhgrabi!eXW!5TiTgXrX! iqhiT`TgWbrsr!sh!Xwiehbs!3tb!WbrrTsbrYTVsbhg!vbsa!Bbg`!TgW!CXitUebVTg!(abgXrX!qteXV! bgVetWbg`!saX!VqXTsbhg!hY!Tg!TgsbX(abgXrX!8trebf!eXT`tX!bg!saX!5TiTgXrX!itiiXs!rsTsX!hY!

8TgVatdth!bg!!!K'XgX)hq!'XgbsXV!"!! #!'hWWXV!!M!'ts!bs!Terh!eXW!fTgx!8trebf! rVaheTqr!sh!XwiehqX!VqXTsbuXex!saX!gTstqX!hY!saXbq!bgVetrbhg!bg!saX!(abgXrX!rsTsX!!

! Eabr!3tbX3Tg!ptXrsbhg! K¹FĹ YhqfXW!saX!VhqX!hY!T!riXVbTe!rtiieXfXgs!sh!

%F3A@3 !bg!!V!riXTqaXTWXW!Ux!T!qXiqbgs!hY!2tr!XrrTx!EaX!3tbX3Tg!BtXrsbhg!TgW!saX!

Hhqd!HX!@t`as!sh!'X!)hbg`!9hv!K¹FĹEÏ/ Ëm!vbsa!qXrihgrXr!TgW! hqb`bgTe!XrrTxr!Yqhf!rXuXqTe!3tb!rVaheTqr!EaXrX!WbrVtrrbhgr!VhgsbgtXW!vhqd!UX`tg!Ux!3tb! bgsXeeXVstTer!fhqX!saTg!saqXX!WXVTWXr!XTqebXqV!vaXg!saXx!WXUTsXW!saX!gTstqX!hY!saXbq!bgVetrbhg! bg!saX!(abgXrX!rsTsX!bg!rtVa!itUebVTsbhgr!Tr! AH'71@5@3&D8'9 !ĬKá TgW! D8'9 !û!

K&tUbgV!"!#!PTg`!Xs!TeV!!!M!EaX!vTqsbfX!Xwb`XgVbXr!hY!saX!!r!aTW!iqhuhdXW!

TssTVdr!hg!4reTf!TgW!8trebf!VtrshfrV!bgYeTfbg`!iqXctWbVX!KTgW!XuXg!ubheXgVXM!T`Tbgrs!saXrX! iqXrtfTUex!VtestqTe!htsrbWXqr!sh!saX!(abgXrX!gTsbhg!K(bXVbtqTV!"!M!4g!%F3A@3 V!Tr!vXee!

Tr!rbfbeTq!itUebVTsbhgr!bgVetWbg`!(aXg`WT!FgbuXqrbsxr!TiiqhiqbTsXex!gTfXW! 4C1D)1@E&445@' !

õ V!3tb!bgsXeeXVstTer!itqrtXW!svh!UTrbV!Tq`tfXgsr!bg!qXrihgrX!EaX!Ybqrs!rht`as!sh!WXXiXg! saX!VqbsbptX!hY!fbgyt!Ux!qXVh`gbybg`!bs!Tr!T!Vhgsbg`Xgs!qTsaXq!saTg!gTstqTe!rb`gbYbXqV!saXqXUx! sqhtUebg`!bsr!bWXgsbYbVTsbhg!vbsa!T!ahfh`Xghtr!VtestqTeV!qXeb`bhtrV!hq!XsagbV!Vhfftgbsx!EaX! rXVhgW!bgsXqqh`TsXW!saX!riXVbYbV!qXeTsbhgrabi!hY!8trebfr!sh!T!gTsbhgXrsTsX!bg!vabVa!saXx!WbW! ghs!Yhqf!saX!fTchqbsx!'hsa!hY!saXrX!iqhcXVsr!raTqXW!T!rbfbeTq!`hTe"!sh!XrsTUebra!saX!sXqfr! tgWXq!vabVa!saX!3tb!VhteW!UX!rXXg!ghs!Tr!fXqXex!TrrbfbeTsXWV!DbgbYbXW!8trebfrV!Uts!qTsaXq!Tr!

T!`qhti!VhgrsbstsXW!Ux!WbrsbgVs!XwiXqbXgVXr!TgW!iqTVsbVXr!saTs!saXfrXeuXr!rahteW!VhgsqbUtsX!sh!

T!UqhTWXq!tgWXqrsTgWbg`!hY!Qahg`atT!fbgyt I&

! EaX!Ybqrs!Tq`tfXgs!br!sxibYbXW!Ux!HTg`!CbvXbr! ¿ø!WbrVtrrbhg!hY!saX!WbrsbgVsbhg!

UXsvXXg!saX!3tb!Tr!Tg!gTsbhgTebsx!hq!iXhieX! !KytM!TgW!Tr!T!qXeb`bhg! !KcbThMV!itUebraXW!bg!

! !"#$%&'()*&+ !290@'(9)D52)5692C2)$(D6@9)2)%92) E)!624(94)(91)5692C2)#EC768C'#@12B9)

569('2))<=>@1@0H) <<)

%F3A@3 !bg!&t`trs!!!&WuTgVbg`!T!WXsTbeXW!abrshqbVTe!Tq`tfXgs!saTs!fTWX!rxrsXfTsbV!trX! hY!(abgXrX!qXVhqWr!bgVetWbg`!WxgTrsbV!abrshqbXrV!HTg`!Tq`tXr !!"#$%&'()*+,--./%0%123+4%12'%5,)1%

1'+)'%2'('%,+6%3+%12'%+'71%)'+1'+8'%3)%5'(9'81-.%93+':%;*<'='(/%)3+8'%12'%123(6%)'+1'+8'%

6*<+%)<3182')%1*%>?,+@%,(@A')B%C,.D'%)13843+@%

8*+)3)1'+8.:%FGHII !saTs!saX!sXqf!3tbV!hYsXg!trXW!bgsXqVaTg`XTUex!sh!qXYXq!Uhsa!sh!(abgXrX!

8trebfr!TgW!sh!4reTf!Tr!T!qXeb`bhgV!hqb`bgTsXW!Tr!T!sXqf!Yhq!T!iXhieX!KytM!vahrX!TrrhVbTsbhg! vbsa!4reTf!VTfX!hgex!ftVa!eTsXq!KHTg`V!!"!M!&r!eTsX!Tr!Dhg`!sbfXrV!aX!VhgsXgWrV!

3tbatb!KK WXrVqbUXW!ghs!hgex!Fx`atqr!bg!2ThVaTg`!TgW!'Xbsbg`V!Uts!Terh!saX!iXhieXr!hY! saX!ATfbq!ab`a!ieTsXTt#!bg!saX!PtTgV!sXqfr!rtVa!Tr!3tb!qXYXqqXW!bgWbrVqbfbgTsXex!sh!saX!

iXqrhgr!hY!uTqbhtr!VTsX`hqbXr! òÏ hY!vXrsXqg!(abgT!KHTg`V!!"!M!@gex!vbsa!Dtg!

PTsXrXgr!bgsqhWtVsbhg!hY!saX!1buX!CTVX!CXitUebVV!HTg`!Tq`tXrV!vXqX!saX!eTg`tT`XV!

Vehsabg`V!TgW!iqTVsbVXr!hY!saX!rhXVTeeXW!3tb!gTsbhgTebsx!rsTgWTqWbyXW!sh!rtbs!Dtgr!WXYbgbsbhg!hY!

T!fbgyt!HTg`r!vhqd!WhuXsTbeXW!vbsa!saTs!hY!Ehg`!DatxX! ß© TgW!hsaXqr!itUebrabg`!bg!

%F3A@3 !saTs!bgsXqqh`TsXW!saX!qXeTsbhgrabi!UXsvXXg!VTsX`hqbXr!rtVa!Tr! $5'&U!K(abgXrXM!TgW! saX!VhgsXfihqTqx!`qhtir!hY!iXhieX!saXx!gTfXW!KEhg`V!!M!!

! EaXrX!abrshqbVTe!TgTexrXr!rahvXW!WXVbrbuXex!saTs!Uhsa!8trebfr!TgW!saX!3tbvaXsaXq! sahrX!VTsX`hqbXr!vXqX!huXqeTiibg`!hq!ghsaTW!gXTqex!TevTxr!UXXg!T!iTqs!hY!vaTs!vTr!

VhgrbWXqXW!(abgT!'ts!saXrX!Tq`tfXgsr!WbW!fhqX!saTg!rbfiex!tiXgW!gTqqTsbuXr!hY!gTsbhgTe! ahfh`XgXbsx#!saXx!Terh!rtiihqsXW!Tg!TeqXTWx!XfXq`Xgs!saXhqXsbVTe!bgrb`as!TUhts!saX!gTstqX!hY! fbgyt!saTs!vhteW!`h!hg!sh!ieTx!T!fTchq!qheX!bg!2tr!vhqd!'x!hYYXqbg`!iXqrtTrbuX!TgW! rxrsXfTsbV!abrshqbVTe!XubWXgVX!hY!ahv!uTqbTUex!fTqdXqr!rtVa!Tr!3tb!TgW!(abgXrX!vXqX!

TiiebXW!sh!iTqsbVteTq!`qhtir!TVqhrr!sbfXV!saXrX!Tq`tfXgsr!WXfhgrsqTsXW!saX!WX`qXX!sh!vabVa! sXqfr!rtVa!Tr!fbgyt!WbW!ghs!fTqd!gTstqTeex!hVVtqqbg`V!iqXXwbrsbg`!`qhtibg`r!hY!iXhieX!

CTsaXqV!fbgyt!vTr!T!WXebUXqTsXex!VhgrsqtVsXW!TgW!VhgsXwstTebyXW!VTsX`hqx!saTs!VhteW!UX! ihebsbVTeex!bfihrXW!Ux!gTsbhgTe!TtsahqbsbXr!hg!fbghqbsx!`qhtirV!Uts!Terh!qXrbrsXW!TgW!qXYb`tqXW!

! !"#$%&'()*&+ !290@'(9)D52)5692C2)$(D6@9)2)%92) E)!624(94)(91)5692C2)#EC768C'#@12B9)

569('2))<=>@1@0H)

Ux!saX!TVsbhgr!hY!saXbq!fXfUXqr!EaX!UhqWXqr!TgW!fXfUXqr!hY!Tgx!`buXg!fbgyt!vXqX! saXqXYhqX!Vhgsbg`Xgs!TgW!rtUcXVs!sh!ihebsbVTe!sqTgrYhqfTsbhgV!T!ihbgs!fTWX!Ux!'Tb!Dahtxb (

!K!!M!bg!abr!qXrihgrX!sh!2tr!TqsbVeX!hg!saX!3TgX3tb!ptXrsbhg!&VVhqWbg`!sh!'Tb!

TgW!hsaXq!VhgsqbUtshqrV!iXqVXisbhgr!hY!3tb!iXhieX!TgW!hY!4reTf!fhqX!`XgXqTeex!bg!(abgT!VhfX!

Yqhf!saX!iheTqbybg`!VTsX`hqbXr!bfihrXW!Ux!saX!Bbg`!qteXqrV!vabVa!saXfrXeuXr!WbW!ghs!qXYeXVs! qXTebsx!K'TbV!!"! #!)TV!!M!&r!5bg!5bsTg`! /!K! ! M!ghsXrV!UXbg`!T!8trebf!

WbW!ghs!fTdX!hgX!3tbV!UXVTtrX!saXqX!vXqX!hsaXq!8trebf!`qhtir!bg!(abgT!saTs!vXqX!ghs! iXqVXbuXW!Tr!3tb#!xXs!saX!Trrtfisbhg!saTs!saXqX!XwbrsXW!T!rbg`eX!UehhWebgX!saTs!VhteW!

WXsXqfbgX!3tbXgXrr!vTr!Terh!tgsXgTUeXV!iqXVbrXex!UXVTtrX!3tb!TrrhVbTsXW!vbsa!fTgx!WbYYXqXgs! eTgWr!hY!hqb`bg!K5bgV!!"!!M!

! 1hq!rhfX!3tb!bgsXeeXVstTerV!bgVetWbg`!'TbV!sabr!qXTebyTsbhg!TUhts!saX!YeXwbUbebsx!hY! fbgyt!VTsX`hqbXr!TgW!saXbq!WXsTVafXgs!Yqhf!UehhWebgX!ebgXT`Xr!KbgVetWbg`!qTVXM!fTWX! ihrrbUeX!Tq`tfXgsr!Yhq!saX!iqXrXgs!TgW!YtstqX!bgVetrbhg!hY!saX!3tb!Tr!ehxTe!fXfUXqr!hY!saX!

(abgXrX!gTsbhg!K'TbV!!"! MV!qTsaXq!saTg!Tr!iXqfTgXgs!rhchtqgXqr! !° vahrX!ehxTesbXr! ebX!bg!saXbq!iqXrtfXW!ahfXeTgWr! M bg!EtqdXxV!0`xisV!TgW!ieTVXr!vXrs!K7btV!!!"!M!

4fTf!HTg`!5bg`yaTb! ¿ķŀV!vqbsbg`!TUhts!3tb!iTsqbhsbrf!bg! 4C1D)1@E&445@' !bg!!V!

XeTUhqTsXr!saX!iqbgVbieXr!hY!sabr!ehxTesx!trbg`!saX!&qTUbV!sXqf! H'E'@ V!hq!ahfXeTgWV!vabVa! aX!qht`aex!sqTgreTsXr!Tr!saX!ieTVX!vaXqX!iXhieX!aTuX!ihebsbVTe!ihvXq!TgW!qXrihgrbUbebsx!

KHTg`V!!"!M!(bsbg`!Tg!TeeX`XW!BtqTgbV!aTWbsaV! 4F((&'8KH'E'@&95@&'8KV9U@ !KehuX!hY!saX!

H'E'@ !br!Tg!TqsbVeX!hY!YTbsaMV!HTg`!Tq`tXr!WXVbrbuXex!saTs!(abgXrX!8trebfr!rahteW!rtiihqs! saX!rsTsX! Me!hY!vabVa!saXx!TqX!T!iTqs!K3tTg`V!"!! #!Yhq!WbrVtrrbhg!hY!HTg`r!trX! hY!BtqTgbV!aTWbsa!aXqXV!rXX!8TsrtfhshV!"! #!HTg`V!!M!4g!Tg!XrrTx!saTs!qXuXTer! ftVa!TUhts!saX!bgsXqiXgXsqTsbhg!hY!(abgXrX!TgW!8trebf!saht`asV!HTg`r!VheeXT`tX!Ts!

4C1D)1@E&445@' V!T!vqbsXq!trbg`!saX!irXtWhgxf!7bt!Qaht! 'µ V!pthsXr!saX!(abgXrX!VeTrrbVTe!

! !"#$%&'()*&+ !290@'(9)D52)5692C2)$(D6@9)2)%92) E)!624(94)(91)5692C2)#EC768C'#@12B9)

569('2))<=>@1@0H)

XuXqxhgX!hg!saX!gTsbhgV!Yhq!saX!rTYXsx!TgW!rXVtqbsx!hY!saXfrXeuXr!Tr!vXee!Tr!saXbq!qXeb`bhg!K7btV!

!!"!M !!

! 4g!itqrtbg`!saXrX!svh!Tq`tfXgsrV!3tb!vqbsXqr!WqXv!hg!rhtqVXr!qTg`bg`!Yqhf!(abgXrX!

VeTrrbVr!TgW!sqTWbsbhgTe!abrshqbh`qTiax!sh!VhgsXfihqTqx!0`xisbTg!WXUTsXr!huXq!BtqTgbV! aTWbsa !EaXbq!Tq`tfXgsr!hYYXq!T!VeXTqXq!ibVstqX!hY!ahv!saX!Vhgsbg`Xgs!rb`gbYbXq!hY!fbgyt!

VhteW!fTqd!Uhsa!saX!WbrsbgVsbuX!VhgsqbUtsbhgr!hY!fbghqbsx!`qhtir!Tr!vXee!Tr!saX!eTq`Xq! ihebsbVTeex!tgbYbXW!vaheX!TrrhVbTsXW!vbsa!saX!Qahg`atT!fbgyt!4s!br!saXqXYhqX!ghs!rtqiqbrbg`! saTs!Yhq!2t!TgW!saXrX!3tb!VheeXT`tXr!vah!itUebraXW!bg! %F3A@3 V!saX!fXTgr!sh!qXrheuX!saX!

3TgX3tb!ptXrsbhg!vTr!ghs!sh!iqhfhsX!saX!TrrbfbeTsbhg!hY!3tb!bgsh!(abgXrX!VbubebyTsbhg!ghq! sh!trX!saXf!bgrsqtfXgsTeex!Tr!T!fXTgr!hY!3Tg!qXubsTebyTsbhgV!Uts!qTsaXq!sh!XrsTUebra!bgrsbstsbhgr! saTs!VhteW!tgVhuXq!TgW!rtrsTbg!saX!WbrsbgVsbuX!abrshqbVTe!VhgsqbUtsbhgr!3tb!fTWX!Tr! rbftesTgXhtrex!Uhsa!8trebfr!TgW!(abgXrX!EaXx!XwiqXrrXW!rahVd!Ts!saX!WbYYbVtesx!hY!Whbg`! qXrXTqVa!hq!XuXg!YbgWbg`!bgYhqfTsbhg!hg!3tb!TgW!8trebf!VtestqX!bg!(abgTV!`buXg!saX!èhUTeex! qXVh`gbyXW!qXrieXgWXgVX!hY!4reTfbV!sahtàsV!VhgsTbgXW!bg!VeTrrbVr!ieXgsbYte!Xghtà!sh!fTdX!T! iTVdXhw!rvXTs!K'TbV!!#!2tV!!T"! M!Eaqhtà!saX!XrsTUebrafXgs!hY!bgrsbstsbhgr!fXTgs! sh!WXuXehi!dghveXW`X!TUhts!4reTf!TgW!(abgXrX!8trebfrV!rtVa!Tr!qXrXTqVa!gXsvhqdrV!

`huXqgfXgsXYtgWXW!qXeb`bhtr!rVahherV!saX!iqhYXrrbhgTe!VheeXVsbhg!hY!8trebf!Uhhdr!TgW! abrshqbVTe!qXVhqWrV!TgW!saX!XwiTgrbhg!hY!4reTfbV!ebUqTqbXrV!2t!ahiXW!`qXTsXq!dghveXW`X!TUhts! saX!3tb!vhteW!eXTW!sh!T!qXWXYbgbsbhg!hY!gTsbhgTe!bWXgsbsx!(XgsqTe!sh!saXrX!XYYhqsr!vTr!

XrsTUebrabg`V!Ts!Tee!XWtVTsbhgTe!eXuXerV!saX!rstWx!hY!3tb!vqbsbg`!TgW!eTg`tT`X! KK[čĆ!

KiqXrtfTUex!&qTUbVM!TgW!abrshqx!Tr!T!iqhiXq!Yhqf!hY! 3FAH1@ !M V!hq!gTsbhgTe!ebsXqTstqXV!

UXVTtrX!3tb!eTg`tT`X!TgW!VtestqX!vXqX!eX`bsbfTsXex!(abgXrX!K2tV!!T"! M!Eabr!WhXr!ghs! fXTg!saTs!saXx!vXqX!sh!UX!TrrbfbeTsXW!bgsh!3Tg!hq!(abgXrX!VtestqXV!hq!XuXg!saTs!saXbq! abrshqbVTe!VhgsqbUtsbhgr!sh!saX!bgub`hqTsbhg!hY!saX!eTq`Xq!3Tg!fbgyt!rahteW!UX!XfiaTrbyXW!

! !"#$%&'()*&+ !290@'(9)D52)5692C2)$(D6@9)2)%92) E)!624(94)(91)5692C2)#EC768C'#@12B9)

569('2))<=>@1@0H)

(abgXrX!gTsbhg!DhfX!VhgsqbUtshqr!sh!saX!rxfihrbtf!hg!saX!3tbX3Tg!ptXrsbhg!shhd!saXrX!

Tq`tfXgsr!YTqsaXqV!sh!rt``Xrs!saTs!qXVh`gbsbhg!hY!3tb!VtestqX!Tr!bgsX`qTe!sh!saX!Qahg`atT! fbgyt!rahteW!XuXgstTeex!aTuX!bgYetXgVX!huXq!gTsbhgTe!VtestqX!&r!ItX!HXgUh - $K!!

! M!Tq`tXrV!8trebf!VtestqX!KË4 br!ghs!hgex!T!dbgW!hY!qTfiTqs!hY!ubqstX!RsaTs! iqhsXVsr!saX!3tb!fbgytS#!bY!bsr!qXeb`bhtr!bgsXgsbhgr!vXqX!sh!UX!UeXgWXW! ü4 !vbsabg!saX!aXTqsr! hY!iXhieX!bg!rhVbXsxV!bsr!bgYetXgVX!hg!saX!gTsbhgr!fbgyt!vhteW!UX!sqtex!`qXTs!KItXV!!"!

! Eabr!TiiqhTVa!rXsr!2t!TiTqs!Yqhf!VhgsXfihqTqbXr!rtVa!Tr!(aXg!PbgdX! ĳgV!vah!

TssXfisXW!sh!vqbsX!`XgXqTe!VtestqTe!abrshqbXr!saTs!TVdghveXW`XW!saX!sqTgrYhqfTsbhg!hY!

(abgXrX!VtestqX!saqht`a!bgsXqTVsbhg!vbsa!YhqXb`g!bgYetXgVXr!Uts!hgex!bg!sXqfr!hY!saX!

`qTWtTe!VaTg`X!hY!saX!gTsbhgTe!ribqbsV!vabVa!gXuXqsaXeXrr!qXsTbgr!bsr!UTrbV!VaTqTVsXqbrsbVr!

KDVagXbWXqV!!!"!M!CTsaXqV!2t!tq`Xr!T!gXv!rsT`X!hY!WXuXehifXgs!TgW!htsqXTVa!saTs!sTdXr!

3tb!8trebf!bWXgsbsx!Tr!T!VXgsqTe!VhfihgXgs!hY!(abgXrX!bWXgsbsx"!

&B@1@)21@)HDB(0D)AE@D(D6@9)3@77@GC)! &VVhqWbg`!sh!fx!hvg!hUrXquTsbhgr!Tfhg`!xhtg`!8trebfr!4!aTuX!TiiqhTVaXWV!sabr!

gXv!rsT`X!ftrs!bgVetWX!Ts!saX!uXqx!eXTrs!saX!Yheehvbg`!YXTstqXr!KM!4s!ftrs!TWuTgVX!T!

saXhqXsbVTe!XetVbWTsbhg!hY!saX!YtgWTfXgsTe!WhVsqbgXr!TgW!fhrs!bfihqsTgs!sXTVabg`r!hY!

saX!qXeb`bhg!RhY!4reTfS!KM!4s!ftrs!iqhfhsX!saX!`XgXqTe!qXVh`gbsbhg!Ux!Uhsa!8trebfr!

TgW!ghgX8trebfr!hY!saX!abrshqbVTe!bgsXqTVsbhgr!hY!&qTUbV!TgW!(abgXrX!VtestqXV!Tr!vXee!

Tr!uTqbhtr!YTVsr!TUhts!saX!eTVd!hY!T!VeXTq!qTVbTe! Ù !WbYYXqXgVX!UXsvXXg!8trebfr!TgW!

ghgX8trebfr!KM!4s!ftrs!sqTgreTsX!TgW!hq`TgbyX!Tee!sxiXr!hY!3tbXeTg`tT`X!sXwsr!hg!T!

eTq`X!rVTeX!TgW!bg!`qXTs!WXsTbeV!sh!hYYXq!YqXra!iqhuhVTsbhgr!sh!saX!(abgXrX!TVTWXfbV!

vhqeW!KM!4s!ftrs!aTuX!VehrX!VhgsTVs!vbsa!TgW!T!WXXi!tgWXqrsTgWbg`!hY!saX!uTqbhtr!

! !"#$%&'()*&+ !290@'(9)D52)5692C2)$(D6@9)2)%92) E)!624(94)(91)5692C2)#EC768C'#@12B9)

569('2))<=>@1@0H) <)

8trebf!VhtgsqbXr!bg!DhtsavXrs!TgW!(XgsqTe!&rbTV!rh!saTs!hg!saX!UTrbr!hY!VtestqTe!

qXeTsbhgrabir!saXx!vbee!YbgW!qXTrhgr!sh!iqhsXVs!saX!UhqWXq!WXYXgrXr!bg!saX!vXrsXqg!iTqs!

hY!htq!Vhtgsqx!K2tV!!U"! M!

! &B@1@)21@)91)2HDB(0D)AE@D(D6@9)

9hs!hgex!TqX!saXrX!fXTrtqXr!T!`hhW!vTx!sh!WXuXehi!4reTfbV!qXeb`bhtr!VhgrVbhtrgXrr!Tfhg`! saX!3tbV!2t!XwieTbgrV!saXx!TqX!Terh!sqtex!YhtgWTsbhgTe!Yhq!saX!XrsTUebrafXgs!hY!saX!Qahg`atT! fbgyt!K2tV!!U"! M!4g!riXTdbg`!hY!T!gXv!rsT`X!hY!WXuXehifXgs!Yhq!3tb!VtestqTe! fhuXfXgsrV!2t!iqhfhsXr!T!WbrsbgVsex!YhqvTqWXehhdbg`V!hiXgXXgWXW!ubrbhg!Yhq!saX!(abgXrX! gTsbhg!saTs!UXebXr!VeTbfr!saTs!aX!XwiXVsr!saXbq!VhgsqbUtsbhg!sh!Tfhtgs!rbfiex!sh!T!fXeWbg`!hq!

XgaTgVXfXgs!hY!Xwbrsbg`!3Tg!VtestqX!!

! Eabr!VhgVetrbhg!VhgsqTWbVsr!saTs!hY!5TfXr!7XbUheWV!Tr!vXee!Tr!fhqX!qXVXgs!(abgXrX!

VhffXgsTshqr!rtVa!Tr!8T!Chg`! V!vah!Tq`tX!saTs!saX!UeXgWbg`! ü? !2t!TrrXqsr!aXqX!

TgW!bg!XrrTxr!rtVa!Tr!EaX!(abgXrX!9Tsbhg!4r!@gX!XbsaXq!XgsTber!saX!XuXgstTe!TrrbfbeTsbhg!hY!

Tee!XsagbVbsbXr!TgW!qTVXr!bgsh!T!tgbYbXW!(abgXrX!gTsbhgV!Tdbg!sh!saX!&fXqbVTg!fXesbg`!ihs!

K7XbUheWV!"! MV!hq!XerX!qXgWXqr!fXTgbg`eXrr!saXbq!ihebsbVTeV!eX`TeV!TgW!rhVbTe! iqTVsbVXr!bg!saX!YTVX!hY!Xwbrsbg`!gTsbhgTe!bgrsbstsbhgr!K8TV!"!M !CTsaXqV!saXqX!br!rsqhg`!

XubWXgVX!sh!rt``Xrs!saTs!2t!aTW!bg!fbgW!T!ftVa!fhqX!hiXgXXgWXW!TgW!bgWXsXqfbgTsX!ubrbhgV! vabVa!trXr!saX!YTVs!hY!qTVbTe!TgW!VtestqTe!UeXgWbg`!bg!(abgTr!iTrs!sh!Tq`tX!Yhq!saX!hg`hbg`! bgsXqTVsbhg!hY!bqqXWtVbUex!WbuXqrX!KUts!ghs!Yhq!saTs!qXTrhg!gXVXrrTqbex!VeXTqex!UhtgWXWM!`qhtir! vbsabg!saX!YtstqX!(abgXrX!gTsbhg!4g!T!!!riXXVa!`buXg!sh!saX!8trebf!DstWx!DhVbXsxV!vabVa! bg!T!eTsXq!ihrsrVqbis!2t!bWXgsbYbXr!Tr!Tg!XTqex!bsXqTsbhg!hY!bWXTr!saTs!vhteW!UX!XeTUhqTsXW!bg!

`qXTsXq!WXsTbe!bg!abr!XrrTx!EaX!(abgXrX!9Tsbhg!4r!@gXV!2t!UqXTdr!sabr!fhqX!TfUbsbhtr!`hTe!

Whvg!bgsh!saqXX!rXiTqTsX!sTrdr!K2tV!T"!M!1bqrsV!saX!VtestqX!hY!XTVa!gTsbhgTebsx!KytM! ht`as!sh!bgsXqTVs!vbsa!XTVa!hsaXqV!vabVa!bgVetWXr!riqXTWbg`!saX!UXgXYbVbTe!iqTVsbVXr!hY!XTVa!

VtestqX!sh!hsaXq!iTqsr!hY!(abgT!saqht`a!rihqsr!VhfiXsbsbhgrV!VtbrbgXV!TgW!fhrs!bfihqsTgsex! rbfieX!atfTg!bgsXqTVsbhg!2t!qXTebyXr!saTs!fTgx!ieTVXr!bg!saX!bgsXqbhq!rtYYXq!Yqhf!rXqbhtr!

! !"#$%&'()*&+ !290@'(9)D52)5692C2)$(D6@9)2)%92) E)!624(94)(91)5692C2)#EC768C'#@12B9)

569('2))<=>@1@0H) <) sqTgrihqsTsbhg!WbYYbVtesbXrV!rh!vabeX!vhqdbg`!sh!bfiqhuX!saXbq!bgYqTrsqtVstqXV!bgsXqXrsXW!iTqsbXr! fTx!Terh!VheeXVs!sabg`r!Yhq!WbrieTx!bg!ftrXtfr!sh!Ts!eXTrs!YTfbebTqbyX!iXhieX!bg!VhTrsTe!TqXTr! vbsa!saX!vTxr!hY!ebYX!hY!iXhieX!bg!saX!bgsXqbhq!TgW!ubVX!uXqrT!K2tV!T"!M!!

! DXVhgWV!rVaheTqr!ht`as!sh!qXrXTqVa!TgW!vqbsX!T!gXvXrsxeX!`XgXqTe!abrshqx! Ģ> saTs!

VheeTsXr!qXVhqWr!Yqhf!XuXqx!fbgyt!sh!UtbeW!T!raTqXW!abrshqx!EaX!3TgXVXgsqbV!gTstqX!hY!fhrs!

VtqqXgs!gTsbhgTe!abrshqbXrV!2t!VhfieTbgrV!bgVbsXr!Wbr`trs!Tfhg`!hsaXq!fbgyt!`qhtirV!eXTWbg`! sh!Xgfbsx!TgW!qXrXgsfXgs!qTsaXq!saTg!saX!YXXebg`r!hY!ftstTe!rxfiTsax!qXptbqXW!Yhq!gTsbhgTe! tgbsx!K2tV!T"!M!@g!sabr!UTrbrV!ghuXerV!ihXfrV!TgW!hsaXq!ihiteTq!ebsXqTstqX!VTg!UX! iqhWtVXW!sh!fhuX!iXhieX!sh!tgWXqrsTgW!TgW!rxfiTsabyX!vbsa!saXbq!VhfiTsqbhsr!bg!WbYYXqXgs!

VhgsXwsr!@saXqvbrXV!saX!iXqrbrsXgs!fbrsqXTsfXgs!hY!saX!bgsXqbhq!qX`bhgr!tgWXq!saX!Bbg`!TgW!

CXitUebVTg!qX`bfXr!vbee!UX!qTVbTebyXWV!bg!saTs!VtestqTe!WbYYXqXgVXr!vbee!UX!bgsXqiqXsXW!Tr!

XubWXgVX!hY!qTVbTe!iqXctWbVX!Ux!saX!WhfbgTgs!fTchqbsx!K2tV!T"!M!1bgTeexV!TgW! iXqaTir!fhrs!bfihqsTgsexV!2t!tq`Xr!abr!xhtg`!8trebf!TtWbXgVX!sh!vhqd!shvTqW!YhrsXqbg`!T!

YhqVXYte!itUebV!hibgbhg!bg!saX!YqhgsbXq!qX`bhgrV!sh!rXquX!Tr!saX!fhtsaibXVX!hY!saX!iXhieX!sh!

XebfbgTsX!saXbq!aTqWrabirV!bWXgsbYx!Vhqqtis!hYYbVbTerV!TgW!TWuTgVX!saXbq!XWtVTsbhg!K2tV!T"!

M!7bdX!saX!hsaXq!sTrdrV!sabr!hgX!shh!vTr!Utbes!hg!saX!Trrtfisbhg!saTs!saX!vhqd!hY!WXuXehibg`!

XWtVTsbhg!TgW!bgYqTrsqtVstqXV!TeqXTWx!UX`tg!bg!saX!YqhgsbXqV!vhteW!UX!VhgsbgtXW!TgW! rsqXg`saXgXW!!

! EaXrX!sTrdrV!Tehg`!vbsa!sahrX!aX!htsebgXr!bg!qXrihgrX!sh!saX!3TgX3tb!ptXrsbhgV! fbqqhq!iqhUTUex!WXebUXqTsXexsaX!dbgWr!hY!abrshqbVTe!bgsXqTVsbhgr!saTs!2t!aTW!Tee!Tehg`!

VeTbfXW!sh!aTuX!hqb`bgTeex!VhgrsbstsXW!saX!axUqbW!(abgXrX!VbubebyTsbhg!CTsaXq!saTg!rXX!3tb!

VhgsqbUtsbg`!sh!Tg!Xwbrsbg`!Xgsbsx!vahrX!iTqTfXsXqr!TqX!TrrtfXW!sh!UX!sqTgriTqXgs!TgW! tgVaTg`bg`V!saX!`hTe!hY!rtVa!bgrsbstsbhgXUtbeWbg`!XYYhqsr!TgW!qXrXTqVa!br!sh!bgsXqqh`TsX!vaTs!bs! fXTgr!sh!UX!(abgXrXV!Tr!T!fXTgr!hY!bgubsbg`!Uhsa!3Tg!TgW!3tb!sh!iTqsbVbiTsX!bg!T!VhXfTdbg`! hY!saTs!bWXgsbsx!'x!hYYXqbg`!saXrX!sTrdr!Tr!rt``XrsXW!rsqTsX`bXr!Yhq!Tg!hg`hbg`!VtestqTe! fhuXfXgs!saTs!ieTVXr!3tb!TgW!ghgX3Tg!fbgyt!XwiXqbXgVX!Ts!saX! )1@E1C !Kghs!ctrs!saX!iXqbiaXqxM!

! !"#$%&'()*&+ !290@'(9)D52)5692C2)$(D6@9)2)%92) E)!624(94)(91)5692C2)#EC768C'#@12B9)

569('2))<=>@1@0H) <) hY!saX!bWXgsbsx!hY!Qahg`atT!fbgytV!2t!bgWbVTsXr!tgTfUb`thtrex!saTs!(abgXrX!8trebfrV!ebdX! hsaXq!fbgytV!TqX!VhgrsbstsbuX!hY!(abgTghs!hgex!ehhdbg`!UTVdvTqWV!Uts!Terh!`hbg`!YhqvTqW!!

! &B@1@)21@)"2F27J>)52(1)3@77@GC)

Jiao Affiliation and the Dissolution of Minzu

2t!rhfXsbfXr!XwieTbgXW!abr!iqhcXVs!hY!ihebsbVTe!tgbYbVTsbhg!trbg`!saX!sXqf! EA@34F'&A4 V! hYsXg!sqTgreTsXW!Tr!KTgW!rhfXsbfXr!tgWXqrshhW!Ux!abr!VhgsXfihqTqbXr!sh!fXTgM!

TrrbfbeTsbhgV!`bubg`!saX!bfiqXrrbhg!aX!YTuhqXW!saX!XuXgstTe!Wbrrhetsbhg!hY!fbghqbsx!`qhtir! bgsh!saX!`qTgWXq!tgbYbXW!Qahg`atT!fbgyt!3hvXuXqV!bg!T!eXg`sax!qXchbgWXq!sh!T!eXssXq!Yqhf! rhVbheh`brs!1Xb!IbThshg`V!itUebraXW!bg!saX!1qhgsbXq!DtiieXfXgs!hY! %5D45('A V!2t!YbgTeex! hYYXqr!T!WXVbrbuXex!VeXTq!rsTsXfXgs!hY!saX!WbrsbgVsbuXex!ihebsbVTeV!ghs!VtestqTe!hq!qTVbTeV!

VhgrXptXgVXr!hY!shg`atT!3br!qXrihgrX!sh!1Xb!Terh!hYYXqr!YtqsaXq!rtiihqs!Yhq!2tr! bgsqhWtVsbhg!hY!saX!sXqf! 65'A !V!sXTVabg`rV!Tr!Tg!TesXqgTsbuX!bg!rhfX!VTrXr!Yhq!saX!sXqf!

fbgyt!Fgsbe!saTs!ihbgsV!2t!aTW!trXW!fbgyt!sh!qXYXq!Uhsa!sh!saX!(abgXrX!gTsbhg!TgW!sh! saX!gTsbhgTebsbXr!saTs!aX!VeTbfXW!VhgrsbstsXW!bsV!VqXTsbg`!rhfX!hY!saX!VhgYtrbhg!1Xb!VbsXr!bg! abr!eXssXq!!

! 4g!saTs!eXssXqV!1Xb!Tq`tXW!saTs!Ux!TrVqbUbg`!T!ftesbVtestqTe!TgW!ietqTe!VaTqTVsXq!sh!T! tgbYbXW!Qahg`atT!fbgytV!2t!VhgYeTsXr!fbgyt!KgTsbhg!hq!gTsbhgTebsxM!vbsa! 3FA65' !Me !KrsTsX! hq!VhtgsqxM!3br!saXrbrV!1Xb!VhgsXgWXWV!satr!Tfhtgsr!sh!ghsabg`!fhqX!saTg!rTxbg`!EaX!

`huXqgfXgsTe!rsqtVstqX!hY!saX!iXhieX! ° !vbsabg!saX!UhqWXqr!hY!(abgT!br!hgXV!vaXg!qXTeex! saX!fbgyt!ptXrsbhg!sqhtUeXr!saX!uXqx!Vhg`qtXgVX!hY!gTsbhgTe!TgW!rsTsX!UhqWXqr!saTs!2t! rXXfr!sh!TrrtfX!K1XbV!"!M!4g!qXrihgrXV!2t!XeTUhqTsXW!hg!ahv!saX!Qahg`atT!fbgyt!

VTg!UX!tgWXqrshhW!Tr!T!WbrsbgVsbuXex!ihebsbVTe!TrrhVbTsbhg!vbsahts!qXWtVbg`!bsr!VhaXqXgVX!sh! rbfiex!saX!raTqXW!TWaXqXgVX!sh!riXVbYbV!YhqfTe!bgrsbstsbhgr!CTsaXqV!bsr!VhaXqXgVX!ebXr!bg!saX!

`qhti!TYYXVs! Nåè saTs!Terh!VhgrsbstsXrV!bg!abr!ubXvV!saX!KrXXfbg`ex!gXVXrrTqx!TgW! rtYYbVbXgsM!VhgWbsbhg!Yhq!saX!WXYbgbsbhg!hY!T!fbgyt!K2tV!V"!M!Eabr!TYYXVs!br!iqhWtVXW!

! !"#$%&'()*&+ !290@'(9)D52)5692C2)$(D6@9)2)%92) E)!624(94)(91)5692C2)#EC768C'#@12B9)

569('2))<=>@1@0H) <) saqht`a!saX!VheeXVsbuX!TVVtfteTsbhg!hY!bgWbubWtTe!atfTg!bgsXgsbhg! Ë} TgW!Tr!rtVa! br!bfihqsTgsex!TgW!WbrsbgVsbuXex!bgWXiXgWXgs!hY!sabg`r!rtVa!Tr!eTg`tT`XV!abrshqxV!TgW!VtestqXV! vabVa!TqX!iqhWtVXW!bg!eTq`X!iTqs!Ux!saX!XgubqhgfXgs!K2tV!V"!M!EaX!shg`atT!saTs!Dtg!

PTsXrXg!rihdX!hYV!2t!Tq`tXrV!VTgghs!ihrrbUex!fXTg!TrrbfbeTsbhg!bgsh!saX!2qXTs!3Tg!qTVXV!

UXVTtrX!sabr!dbgW!hY!VtestqTe!VhaXqXgVX!WhXr!ghs!Xwbrs!XuXg!vbsabg!vaTs!TqX!sTdXg!sh!UX!

Xwbrsbg`!fbgyt!K2tV!V"!M! !!

! 2tr!qXrihgrX!stqgr!hg!Tg!TesXqgTsbuX!ubXv!saTs!ihrXr!fbgyt!bWXgsbsx!ghs!hgex!Tr!T! rhVbTe!VhgrsqtVsbhg!Uts!Terh!hgX!bg!vabVa!bgWbubWtTer!WXebUXqTsXex!`Tbg!fXfUXqrabi!saqht`a! iTqsbVbiTsbhg!bg!raTqXW!vTxr!hY!ebYXvaTs!2t!VTeer!saX!fbgytr!sXTVabg`r!4g!2tr!EaX!

(abgXrX!9Tsbhg!4r!@gXV!aX!qXeTsXr!Tg!hUrXquTsbhg!Yqhf!abr!sbfX!bg!saX!ghqsavXrs!saX! iqXVXWbg`!xXTq!3X!ghsXr!saTs!vaXg!WbrVtrrbg`!`qhti!WbYYXqXgVXr!vbsa!eTxiXhieX!saXqXV!hYsXg! saXx!vhteW!qXfTqdV!HX!TqX!hY!saX!3tb!sXTVabg`!K 65'A M#!xht!TqX!hY!saX!3Tg!sXTVabg`#!TgW! saXqX!TqX!iXhieX!hg!saX!rsXiiXr!vah!TqX!hY!saX!EbUXsTg!sXTVabg`!2t!qXfTqdr!saTs!! &B@1@)21@)HDB(0D)AE@D(D6@9)3@77@GC) !

bg!ebrsXgbg`!sh!saXfV!4!saht`as!saXbq!trX!hY!cbTh!RsXTVabg`S!bgrsXTW!hY!yt &RiXhieX!hq!

gTsbhgTebsxS!vTr!Tg!XwVXXWbg`ex!bgsXqXrsbg`!sabg`!DhXVTeeXW!sXTVabg`!br!T!VtestqTe!

VeTrrbYbVTsbhg !'XVTtrX!VtestqX!br!WbYYXqXgsV!saXqX!TqX!WbYYXqXgVXr!bg!vTxr!hY!ebYXV!rh!

saTs!UXsvXXg!saXf!Tesaht`a!saXx!TqX!Tee!iXhieX!hY!saX!rTfX!Vhtgsqx!saXx!Wh!ghs!Tee!

ebuX!bg!saX!rTfX!vTxftVa!ebdX!saXqX!TqX!Wbubrbhgr!bg!hVVtiTsbhgV!rtVa!Tr!saX!

fbebsTqxV!ihebsbVrV!rVaheTqrabiV!T`qbVtestqXV!bgWtrsqxV!TgW!VhffXqVX!K2tV!W"!M!! &B@1@)21@)91)2HDB(0D)AE@D(D6@9) !

5trs!Tr!Tee!iqhYXrrbhgTe!hVVtiTsbhgr!TqX!WbYYXqXgs!Uts!XptTeex!gXVXrrTqxV!rh!shh!ftrs!WbYYXqXgs! dbgWr!hY!VtestqTe!YhqfTsbhgr!Xwbrs!TgW!Yehtqbra!vbsabg!saX!(abgXrX!gTsbhg!&gWV!ctrs!Tr! hVVtiTsbhgrTgW!saXbq!fXfUXqrabiVTg!VaTg`X!hg!saX!UTrbr!hY!ahv!sahrX!fXfUXqr! iXqYhqf!vaTs!TqX!sTdXg!sh!UX!VhgrsbstsbuX!YtgVsbhgrV!rh!shh!VTg!3Tg!stqg!3tb!hq!ubVX!uXqrT!4g! sabr!iTrrT`XV!2t!bWXgsbYbXr!saXrX!iTqsbVbiTshqx!iqTVsbVXr!vbsa!VtestqXV!rt``Xrsbg`!iTqTeeXer!

! !"#$%&'()*&+ !290@'(9)D52)5692C2)$(D6@9)2)%92) E)!624(94)(91)5692C2)#EC768C'#@12B9)

569('2))<=>@1@0H) B=) vbsa!rbfbeTq!iqhVXrrXr!saTs!vXqX!TrrtfXW!sh!YtgVsbhg!Wtqbg`!saX!bfiXqbTe!XqT!sh!sqTgrYhqf!

UTqUTqbTgr!bgsh!(abgXrX!KDtg!TgW!HTg`V!"! M!Db`gbYbVTgsexV!ahvXuXqV!saXqX! qXfTbgr!ghgX!hY!saX!VaTtubgbrf!saTs!hgVX!fhsbuTsXW!rtVa!Trrtfisbhgr!hY!VtestqTe! sqTgrYhqfTsbhg!5bThV!hq!sXTVabg`rV!aXqX!WXghsXr!hgex!saX!vTxr!hY!ebYX!WbYYXqXgs!`qhtir! hY!iXhieX!itqrtX#!bg!VhgsqTrs!sh!Vh`gTsX!sXqfr!rtVa!Tr!DbgbVbyTsbhgV!cbTh KUTrXW! sqTgrYhqfTsbhgr!Wh!ghs!WXrb`gTsX!Tgx!iTqsbVteTq!VtestqX!Tr!bgaXqXgsex!fhqX!VTiTUeX!hY! sqTgrYhqfbg`!hsaXqr!hq!WqTvbg`!saXf!bgsh!bsr!TfUbs!hY!sXqqbshqbTe!WhfbgTsbhg!!

! &r!Yhq!ahv!rtVa!T!saXhqxV!uXqx!rbfbeTq!sh!saX!VtestqTebrs!VeTbfr!hY!(abTg`!6TbXraXd!

TgW!hsaXqrV!vhteW!vhqd!TUrXgs!saX!iqXrtfisbhg!hY!Tg!bgaXqXgsex!rtiXqbhq!VtestqXV!2t!hYYXqr!T!

YtqsaXq!beetfbgTsbg`!XwTfieX!)tqbg`!abr!sqTuXer!saqht`a!2Tgrt!TgW!Bbg`aTbV!aX!fXs!svh!

YTfbebXr!rtqgTfXW!6hg`V!WXrVXgWTgsr!hY!(hgYtVbtr!PXs!saXrX!6hg`r!vXqX!ghs!saXfrXeuXr!

(hgYtVbTg"!hgX!vTr!8trebfV!TgW!saX!hsaXq!EbUXsTg!ÆZ !)bW!saXrX!iXhieX!YebiiTgsex!

WbrVTqW!saX!sXTVabg`r!hY!saXbq!TgVXrshq$!2t!Trdr!9hV!saXx!rbfiex!qXrihgWXW!sh!saX!gXXWr!hY! saX!XgubqhgfXgsV!TgW!aTubg`!YqXXWhf!hY!qXeb`bhgV!saXx!VahrX!sh!XgsXq!saX!3tb!TgW!EbUXsTg!

VtestqTe!`qhtir!Eabr!iqhuXrV!2t!Tq`tXrV!saTs!iXhieX!TqX!ghs!qb`bWex!iTqs!hY!VXqsTbg!VtestqTe!

`qhtirV!Uts!ht`as!sh!Yheehv!saXbq!vbraXr!TgW!saX!qXptbqXfXgsr!hY!saX!XgubqhgfXgs!bg!Vahhrbg`!

Tg!TiiqhiqbTsX!ebYX!K2tV!W"!M!EaX!Qahg`atT!fbgyt!ftrs!TVVhffhWTsX!rtVa!WbuXqrbsx! bY!bs!br!sh!rtqubuX!bfiXqbTebrf!TgW!XfUqTVX!saX!sqtX!ihrrbUbebsbXr!hY!bsr!iTrs!!

! EaXrX!ubXvr!aTW!VeXTq!iqXVXWXgsr!bg!saX!WbrVtrrbhgr!hY!fbgyt!bg! %F3A@3 !&eqXTWx!bg!

!V!saX!3TquTqWXXWtVTsXW!Bb!DbaX! ŀE!fTqraTeXW!VhgsXfihqTqx!&g`ehX&fXqbVTg!

Tgsaqhiheh`bVTe!TgW!ihebsbVTe!saXhqxbgVetWbg`!saTs!hY!3TqheW!7Trdb!TgW!&qsatq!3heVhfUX sh!qXYtsX!saX!VhgYeTsbhg!hY!qTVXV!XsagbVbsxV!TgW!gTsbhgTebsx!bg!Dtg!PTsXrXgr!iqbgVbieX!hY!fbgyt!

Bb!Tq`tXr!saTs!gXbsaXq!qTVbTe!rbfbeTqbsx!ghq!ebYXrsxeX!WXsXqfbgXr!T!fbgytV!UXVTtrX!saXrX!VaTg`X! huXq!sbfX!TgW!riTVXV!TgW!saqht`a!bgsXqTVsbhg!KbgVetWbg`!bgsXqfTqqbT`XM!vbsa!hsaXqr!KBbV!!"!

M!EaX!axUqbW!bWXgsbsbXr!saTs!qXrtes!fXTg!saTs!Tee!qTVbTe!WbubWXr!vXqX!TqUbsqTqx!TgW!aTW!gh!

! !"#$%&'()*&+ !290@'(9)D52)5692C2)$(D6@9)2)%92) E)!624(94)(91)5692C2)#EC768C'#@12B9)

569('2))<=>@1@0H) B>) rVbXgsbYbV!uTetX!EaXqXYhqXV!aX!Tq`tXrV!gTsbhgTe!tgbsx!VTgghs!ebX!bg!qTVbTe!UTVd`qhtgW!hq!hsaXq!

fTsXqbTe!VhgWbsbhgrV!Uts!hgex!bg!rtUcXVsbuX!TYYXVs!KsaX!rXgsbfXgs!hY!Tg!Xribqbs!WX!Vhqir !u

¬ıĀºËèM!KBbV!!"!M!EaX!3tb!bgsXeeXVstTe!5bg!5bsTg`!rbfbeTqex!VhgVetWXr!saTs!3tb! bWXgsbsxV!TUrXgs!hsaXq!qTVbTeV!`Xh`qTiabVV!hq!XuXg!VtestqTe!bgWbVTshqrV!ftrs!qXrs!hgex!hg!saX!

raTqXW!itqihrX! (A ÏË!hY!ebubg`!bg!(abgT!TgW!itqrtbg`!saX!8trebf!sXTVabg`!KTUhts! vabVa!aX!ghsXr!saXqX!br!Terh!WbrT`qXXfXgsM!K5bgV!!"!!M !

! 4g!abr!qXrihgrX!sh!1Xb!TgW!bg!rtUrXptXgs!XeTUhqTsbhgrV!2t!fXeWr!saXrX!saXhqbXr!sh!Tg! bgWb`Xghtr!VtestqTebrfV!sh!hYYXq!Tg!bgghuTsbuX!WXYbgbsbhg!Yhq!shgàtT!EhgàtTV!2t!TrrXqsrV! satr!Tfhtgsr!sh!ghsabg`!fhqX!saTg!fhWXqgbyTsbhg!sh!TeeXubTsX!saX!TebXgTsbhg!TgW! utegXqTUbebsx!YXes!Ux!iXhieXr!hY!(abgTr!YqhgsbXq!qX`bhgr#!saTs!brV!iqhubWbg`!bg!`XgXqTeV!saX! rdbeer!TgW!dghveXW`X!saTs!T!fhWXqg!iXqrhg!htàs!sh!ihrrXrrV!TgW!saX!fTsXqbTe!ebuXebahhW!saTs!

T!fhWXqg!iXqrhg!rahteW!Xgchx!K2tV!V"!M!&s!saTs!ihbgsV!bs!br!ti!sh!sahrX!iXhieXr!sh!

WXsXqfbgX!vaTs!saXx!vTgs!sh!TVVXisV!qXcXVsV!hq!sqTgrYhqf!4gWXXWV!2t!Tq`tXrV!saXbq!VtestqXr! fTx!XuXg!XgVhtqT`X!3Tg!bgWbubWtTer!sh!shg`atT!bgsh!T!fXfUXq!hY!saX!YqhgsbXq!iXhieX!

K2tV!V"!M!!

! 2t!fTx!aXqX!aTuX!UXXg!WqTvbg`!hg!Tq`tfXgsr!WXuXehiXW!Ux!abr!3tb!VheeXT`tXr!Ts!

%F3A@3 V!rtVa!Tr!ItX!HXgUh!TgW!'Tb!DahtxbV!vah!Tq`tXW!saTs!iTqs!hY!saX!rhetsbhg!sh! qXrheubg`!saX!3TgX3tb!ptXrsbhg!br!qXVh`gbybg`!saX!bgWXsXqfbgTVx!hY!saX!WbqXVsbhg!hY! bgYetXgVX!UXsvXXg!3Tg!TgW!3tb!@gX!qXTrhg!Yhq!rstWxbg`!4reTf!bg!(abgTV!'Tb!ghsXrV!br!saTs!

Yqhf!saX!iXqriXVsbuX!hY!`ehUTe!VtestqTe!abrshqx! Å4>!4reTf!aTr!ghs!hgex!TUrhqUXW!

XeXfXgsr!hY!hsaXq!VtestqXrV!Uts!Terh!VTg!sqTgrYhqf!saXf !EaXrX!qXTWbg`r!hY!(abgXrX!8trebf! abrshqx!qXbgYhqVX!Tg!bWXT!hY!VtestqX!Tr!T!sTq`Xs!hY!WXebUXqTsX!KqXMfTdbg`!bg!qXrihgrX!sh!

WbYYXqXgs!VhgsXwsr!TgW!gXXWrV!qTsaXq!saTg!Tr!T!`buXg!rXs!hY!iqTVsbVXr!VaTqTVsXqbrsbV!hY!iTqsbVteTq!

XsagbV!hq!qTVbTe!`qhtir!EaXx!fTx!Terh!XwieTbg!2t!5bX`Tg`r!bgrbrsXgVX!hg!saX!bgVetrbhg!hY!

3tb!8trebfr!bgsh!(abgXrX!gTsbhgXUtbeWbg`"!ghs!hgex!vXqX!saX!3tb!bg!ihrrXrrbhg!hY!T!VtestqTe!

! !"#$%&'()*&+ !290@'(9)D52)5692C2)$(D6@9)2)%92) E)!624(94)(91)5692C2)#EC768C'#@12B9)

569('2))<=>@1@0H) B<) aXqbsT`X!VhfUbgbg`!Uhsa!&qTUbTg!TgW!(abgXrX!bgYetXgVXrV!saXx!vXqX!rsTtgVa!XwXfieTqr!hY!

VtestqTe!TWTisTsbhg!TgW!rtqubuTeV!Yqhf!vabVa!3Tg!aTW!ftVa!sh!eXTqg!4g!Whbg`!rhV!aX!VqXTsXr! tgiqXVXWXgsXW!riTVX!bg!(abgXrX!WbrVhtqrX!Yhq!eX`bsbfTsbg`!saX!VhgsqbUtsbhgr!hY!ghgX3Tg! fbghqbsbXr!sh!(abgXrX!VtestqX!TgW!gTsbhg!Tr!uTetTUeX! A@&E415C&AH@&E1C9D V!qTsaXq!saTg!rbfiex! ubT!saXbq!VhgsqbUtsbhgr!sh!T!iqXXwbrsbg`!3Tg!VtestqX!!

! @g!sabr!qXTWbg`V!2t!VTgghs!ihrrbUex!fXTg!Ux!shg`atT!TrrbfbeTsbhg!Tr!bs!br!

Vhffhgex!fXTgsV!bXV!Tr!T!Yhqf!hY!TUrhqisbhg!bgsh!T!fTchqbsx!`qhti!vbsahts!qXfTbgWXq!

Frbg`!2tr!hvg!uhVTUteTqxV!vX!fb`as!fhqX!iqXVbrXex!WXYbgX!shg`atT!Tr!T!rabYs!hY!cbTh!

TYYbebTsbhgV!bg!vabVa!iXqrhgTe!VhffbsfXgsr!sh!VXqsTbg!`qhtir!VaTg`X!huXq!sbfX!bg!T! ftesbWbqXVsbhgTe!TgW!hiXgXXgWXW!vTxV!qXrtesbg`!bg!UqhTWXq!VaTg`Xr!sh!VtestqX!TgW!iqTVsbVX!Yhq!

Uhsa!bgWbubWtTer!TgW!`qhtir!HX!fb`as!rTx!fbgytr &TgW!saXbq!fXfUXqr!VTg!satr!UX!shg`atTXW! bgsh!XbsaXq!hsaXq!fbgyt!`qhtirV!hq!bgsh!saX!eTq`Xq!fbgyt!hY!T!KfhWXqgM!gTsbhgXrsTsX!EaXrX! rtU`qhtir!TqX!saXfrXeuXr!WXrb`gTsXW!bgYhqfTeex!Ux!VXqsTbg!iqTVsbVXrV!hq!cbThV!Uts!TqX!gXuXq!

VeXTqex!UhqWXqXW!K2tV!W"!M!EaX!Qahg`atT!fbgyt!Yhq!2t!satr!rsTgWr!Tr!T!riXVbTe! bgrsTgVX!hY!cbTh!TYYbebTsbhgV!T!rbsX!hY!XgVhtgsXq!TgW!XwVaTg`X!vahrX!axUqbW!VtestqX!huXqeTir! vbsa!Uts!XwVXXWr!saX!TYYbebTsbhgr!hY!bsr!bgsXqgTe!fbgyt!DiXVbYbVTeexV!saX!Qahg`atT!fbgyt!WhXr! ghs!iqhfhsX!T!ahfh`Xghtr!VtestqTe!hq!XsagbV!bWXgsbsx#!bsr!hgex!bWXgsbsx!br!T!ihebsbVTe!hgXV!

XfXq`bg`!Yqhf!saX!fbgbfTebrs!WXfTgWr!hY!vaTs!Bb!DbaX!VTeeXW!saX!rtUcXVsbuX!TYYXVs!hY!

`qhtigXrr!@g!sabr!UTrbrV!2t!Tq`tXrV!saX!sXqf!fbgyt!rahteW!UX!TUTgWhgXW!Tr!T!WXrVqbisbhg! hY!saXrX!rtU`qhtir!bg!YTuhq!hY!cbTh!K2tV!W"!M!@gex!sabr!rabYs!bg!VhgVXistTe!uhVTUteTqx! vbee!fTdX!VeXTq!saTs!vaTs!UbgWr!bgWbubWtTer!sh`XsaXq!bgsh!eTq`Xq!VhfftgbsbXr!aTr!ghsabg`!sh!

Wh!vbsa!UehhWebgX!WXrVXgs!hq!qTVX!K P4A@3PF !Ù MV!vbsa!vabVa!fbgyt!Tr!T!VTsX`hqx!aTr!

UXVhfX!fbrsTdXgexV!TeUXbs!iXquTrbuXexV!VhgYhtgWXW!K2tV!W"!! !!M !

! &B@1@)21@)"2F27J>)52(1)3@77@GC)

The Terms of Being “One”

! !"#$%&'()*&+ !290@'(9)D52)5692C2)$(D6@9)2)%92) E)!624(94)(91)5692C2)#EC768C'#@12B9)

569('2))<=>@1@0H) BB)

2tr!gTsbhgTebrs!iqhcXVs!TgW!abr!TVsbubsbXr!vbsa!3tb!TVsbubrsr!saqht`ahts!saX!!r!fb`as!UXrs!

UX!tgWXqrshhW!Tr!Tg!bgubsTsbhg!sh!WXVXgsXq!vaTs!VhgsXfihqTqx!rVaheTqr!aTuX!bWXgsbYbXW!Tr!Tg!

XsagbVbrs!fhWXe!hY!saX!gTsbhgV!bg!vabVa!saX!gTsbhg!br!WXYbgXW!Ux!Vhffhg!VtestqX!TgW!

TeeX`XW!WXrVXgs!KEhvgrXgWV!!!"!V!Vbsbg`!DfbsaV!! "!M!2t!Tq`tXW!qTsaXq!Yhq!T! ubXv!hY!saX!gTsbhg!WXYbgXW!Ux!T!raTqXW!ihebsbVTe!VhgrVbhtrgXrrV!Uts!Terh!rt``XrsXW!riXVbYbV! qXYhqfr!bg!XWtVTsbhgV!qXrXTqVaV!TgW!VtestqX!saTs!fb`as!VhgrhebWTsXUts!VhteW!gXuXq!eX`breTsX! bg!TWuTgVXT!gXvV!UqhTWXq!VhgVXistTebyTsbhg!hY!saX!(abgXrX!gTsbhg!TgW!bsr!bgsXqgTeex!ietqTe!

VtestqX!3br!iqhcXVs!WbW!ghsV!bg!hsaXq!vhqWrV!TribqX!sh!UX!XbsaXq!T!VhaXqXgs!TgW!VhfiqXaXgrbuX! bgrsbstsbhgTe!WXrb`g!hq!T!ghqfTsbuXex!WXYXgrbUeX!iabehrhiabVTe!fhWXe!saTs!vhteW!qXrheuX!Tee! sXgrbhgr!UXsvXXg!cbTh!`qhtir!TgW!saX!QahgàtT!fbgyt!3X!UX`Tg!vbsa!fhqX!YtgWTfXgsTe! ptXrsbhgr!TUhts!ahv!saX!fhWXqg!(abgXrX!gTsbhgV!TgW!bgWXXW!abrshqbVTe!(abgXrX!bWXgsbsx!bsrXeYV! fbàs!UX!VhgVXbuXW!1hq!2tV!saX!QahgàtT!fbgyt!vTr!KTgW!rahteW!TevTxr!VhgsbgtX!sh!UXM!Tg! hiXgXXgWXW!TgW!XfXq`XgsV!qTsaXq!saTg!sXeXheh`bVTeex!WXYbgXW!hq!iXqrbrsXgsex!tgbYbXWV!Xgsbsx!!

! 2tr!vhqd!bg!sabr!TqXT!aTr!UXXg!gX`TsbuXex!VhfiTqXW!sh!Hbee!6xfebVdTr!ubrbhg!hY! ftesbVtestqTebrfV!WXYbgXW!Tr!saX!bgTebXgTUeX!qb`as!hY!WbYYXqXgs!XsagbV!TgW!ihebsbVTe!`qhtir!sh! iXTVXYteex!VhXwbrs!tgWXq!T!tgbYbXW!ihebsbVTe!rsTsX!K7XbUheWV!"! M !PXs!saX!VhfiTqbrhg! br!ghs!Tr!tgYTuhqTUeX!sh!2t!Tr!bs!fTx!TiiXTq!)XribsX!`qTgWXq!iqXsXgrXr!saTs!saX!bWXT!hY! ftesbVtestqTebrf!bg!VhgsXfihqTqx!ihebsbVTe!WbrVhtqrX!TgW!bg!ihebsbVTe!iabehrhiax!br!TUhts!ahv! sh!tgWXqrsTgW!TgW!qXrihgW!sh!saX!VaTeeXg`Xr!TrrhVbTsXW!vbsa!VtestqTe!TgW!qXeb`bhtr!WbuXqrbsx!

KDhg`V!MV!ftesbVtestqTe!VaTeeXg`Xr!sh!gTsbhgTe!TgW!ihebsbVTe!tgbsx!TqX!sxibVTeex!iaqTrXW!Tr!

TVVhffhWTsbhgr!sh!ghgXebUXqTe!fbghqbsx!`qhtirV!hg!saX!UTrbr!hY!iTqsbVteTq!iqbgVbieXr!hY! ctrsbVX!iqXrtfTUex!aXeW!Ux!saX!WhfbgTgs!ebUXqTe!gTsbhgTe!VtestqX !2t!vhteW!sTdX!

YtgWTfXgsTe!brrtX!vbsa!sabr!vTx!hY!sabgdbg`!TUhts!saX!VhgrsqtVsbhg!hY!saX!gTsbhgV!iqXVbrXex!

UXVTtrX!abr!iqhcXVs!vTr!sh!VaTeeXg`X!qTsaXq!saTg!qXiqhWtVX!saX!rsTstr!pth!abXqTqVabXr!saTs! tiaheW!hgX!`qhti!hq!VtestqX!Tr!ghqfTsbuXex!hq!VtestqTeex!WhfbgTgs!huXq!hsaXqr !Eh!`qTgs!

! !"#$%&'()*&+ !290@'(9)D52)5692C2)$(D6@9)2)%92) E)!624(94)(91)5692C2)#EC768C'#@12B9)

569('2))<=>@1@0H) BC)

VtestqTe!qb`asr!hq!XuXg!qXVh`gbsbhg!KETxehqV!!!M!sh!saXrX!fbgyt!bg!saX!YTrabhg!hY! ftesbVtestqTebrf!vhteW!UX!sh!YtqsaXq!bgrsbstsbhgTebyX!saXbq!fTq`bgTebyTsbhg!!

2t!UXebXuXW!qTsaXq!saTsV!bY!(abgT!vTr!gXuXq!Tr!tgbYbXWV!3TgXVXgsqbVV!TgW!VaTg`XeXrr!Tr!

VhgsXfihqTqx!gTsbhgTebrsr!VeTbfXWV!saXg!saX!VhgsqbUtsbhgr!hY!ghgX3Tg!iXhieXr!ftrs!UX! qXVh`gbyXW!Tr!eX`bsbfTsXex!iTqs!hY!saX!Qahg`atT!fbgyt I& Eh!2tV!sabr!fXTgs!saTs!rtVa!iXhieXr!

TqX!bgghuTsbuX!iqhWtVXqr!hY!Tg!TevTxrXXwiTgWbg`!ihebsbVTe!Vhfftgbsx!raTqXW!vbsa!fTgx! hsaXqrV!qTsaXq!saTg!saX!rfTee!TgW!vXTd!iXhieXr!iqXWbVsXW!Ux!Dtg!PTsXrXg!sh!bgXubsTUex!

WbrrheuX!bgsh!rhfX!`qTgWXqV!iqXXwbrsbg`!Xgsbsx!VTeeXW!(abgXrX!VtestqX!3br!iqhcXVs!satr!UXTqr!

VehrXq!rbfbeTqbsx!shTgW!vhteW!UXgXYbsvhqd!Ux!ETeTe!&rTW!TgW!HbeebTf!(hggheexV!vah! qXrbrs!saX!ebUXqTe!fhWXe!hY!bWXgsbsx!TgW!ftesbVtestqTebrf!bg!YTuhq!hY!T!WXVXgsXqXW!ietqTebsx!bg! vabVa! 1G1CI !`qhti!br!ubXvXW!Tr!T!fbghqbsx!Tfhg`!fbghqbsbXr!K&rTWV!"! #!(hggheexV!

!!M!4g!riXTdbg`!hY!8trebf!fbghqbsbXr!bg!TghsaXq!iTqs!hY!saX!vhqeWV!&rTW!Tq`tXr!Yhq!T! qTWbVTe!rabYs!bg!saX!VhgrsXeeTsbhg!hY!ihvXqV!TvTx!Yqhf!T!fhWXe!bg!vabVa!T!VXgsqTebyXW!

fTchqbsx!iqXrbWXr!huXq!rfTeeXq!fbghqbsbXr!shvTqW!T!YhqfTsbhg!saTs!TssXgWr!sh!ahv!

huXqeTiibg`!iTssXqgr!hY!sXqqbshqxV!Ttsahqbsx!TgW!sbfX!VheebWX!vbsa!saX!bWXT!hY!saX!bfT`bgXW! gTsbhgTe!Vhfftgbsx!K&rTWV!"!!#!rXX!Terh!(qhrreXxV!!!M!2tr!vhqd!aXeir!tr!rXX! ahv!rtVa!sXgrbhgrV!vabVa!bgXubsTUex!UXrXs!saX!iqhcXVs!hY!gTsbhgTe!tgbYbVTsbhgV!fb`as!UX! fTqraTeXW!sh!iqhWtVsbuXex!VqXTsXV!qTsaXq!saTg!TrrtfXV!saX!bWXgsbsx!hY!saX!XgsbqX!gTsbhgUx! rXVtqbg`!saX!VhgWbsbhgr!tgWXq!vabVa!fbghqbsx!VhgsqbUtsbhgr!TqX!fTWX!VhgrsbstsbuX!hYV!TgW! ghs!ctrs!rtiieXfXgsTqx!shV!saX!Qahg`atT!fbgyt!!

Acknowledgments

4!saTgd!TtWbXgVXr!Ts!saX!9TsbhgTe!(XgsqTe!7bUqTqxV!ETbiXbV!ETbvTg#!AqbgVXshg!TgW!2Xhq`Xshvg!

FgbuXqrbsbXr#!TgW!saX!!&fXqbVTg!AhebsbVTe!DVbXgVX!&rrhVbTsbhg!TggtTe!VhgYXqXgVX!Yhq! saXbq!YXXWUTVd!4!iTqsbVteTqex!saTgd!saX!qXYXqXXr!Yhq!sabr!TqsbVeXEyXXdb!3hgV!ATfXeT!(qhrreXxV!

TgW!HehWybfbXqy!(bXVbtqTTr!vXee!Tr!7bUUx!&gdXqV!CbVaTqW!'hxWV!0qgXrs!(TeWvXeeV!9tqT!

! !"#$%&'()*&+ !290@'(9)D52)5692C2)$(D6@9)2)%92) E)!624(94)(91)5692C2)#EC768C'#@12B9)

569('2))<=>@1@0H) BD)

3hrrTbgyTWXaV!TgW!)XrfhgW!5T`fhaTg!EaXbq!VhffXgsr!`qXTsex!bfiqhuXW!saX!TqsbVeX!TgW! rTuXW!fX!Yqhf!rXuXqTe!XfUTqqTrrbg`!fbrsTdXr!Ksaht`a!hY!VhtqrX!Tgx!Xqqhqr!saTs!qXfTbg!TqX! fx!hvgM!!

Funding

EaX!Ttsahq!WbrVehrXW!qXVXbis!hY!saX!Yheehvbg`!YbgTgVbTe!rtiihqs!Yhq!saX!qXrXTqVaV!TtsahqrabiV!

TgWhq!itUebVTsbhg!hY!sabr!TqsbVeX"!CXrXTqVa!TgW!vqbsbg`!Yhq!sabr!TqsbVeX!vTr!rtiihqsXW!Ux!T!

8bgbrsqx!hY!1hqXb`g!&YYTbqr!ETbvTg!1Xeehvrabi!bg!5TgtTqx&iqbe!!TgW!Ux!YtgWbg`!Yqhf! saX!3tfTgbsbXr!bg!saX!0tqhiXTg!CXrXTqVa!&qXT!(heeTUhqTsbuX!CXrXTqVa!2qTgs!0Trs!&rbTg!

FrXr!hY!saX!0tqhiXTg!ATrs"!EqTVbg`!'qTbWXW!(aqhghsxiXr!

! !"#$%&'()*&+ !290@'(9)D52)5692C2)$(D6@9)2)%92) E)!624(94)(91)5692C2)#EC768C'#@12B9)

569('2))<=>@1@0H) B)

References

&9)@!5F94(34C@!KM!5TiTgr!3tbX8trebf!VTfiTb`gr!K M!bg!(abgT!Yqhf!

saX!!r!sh!!!&ggTer!hY!saX!5TiTg!&rrhVbTsbhg!Yhq!8bWWeX!0TrsXqg!DstWbXr! V!"!

&D&)V!E&7&7!KM!8trebfr!Tr!T!qXeb`bhtr!fbghqbsx!bg!0tqhiX!Ai!! !bg!

1hqfTsbhgr!hY!saX!DXVteTq"!(aqbrsbTgbsxV!4reTfV!8hWXqgbrf!DsTgYhqWV!(&"!DsTgYhqW!

Fgbu!AqXrr!

&F'49V!1C&9@4D0!KM!4reTf!hg!saX!vbg`r!hY!gTsbhgTebrf"!saX!VTrX!hY!8trebf!

bgsXeeXVstTer!bg!CXitUebVTg!(abgT!4g!DsXiagX!&!)tWhb`ghgV!3brTh!6hfTsrtV!TgW!

PTrtrab!6hrt`b!KXWrMV!4gsXeeXVstTer!bg!saX!8hWXqg!4reTfbV!HhqeW"!EqTgrfbrrbhgV!

EqTgrYhqfTsbhgV!(hfftgbVTsbhg!7hgWhg"!ChtseXW`X!

'&4!D3@FP4!ÊTt!K!M!ĐĉÝK4ÒÛ«Ĳ ĶĂ!K@g!saX!gXXW!sh!XrsTUebra!

fXVaTgbrfr!Yhq!saX!qXrXTqVa!hY!3tb!qXeb`bhg!TgW!VtestqXM! ). "!V!"! !

'&4!D3@FP4!KM! ÊTt#Ã+fĸ0¥!KCXrihgrX!eXssXq!Yqhf!8q!'Tb!Dahtxb!sh!

2t!5bX`Tg`M!Ai! !bg! ĺĸ0&ĵ!K(heeXVsXW!vhqdr!hY!2t!5bX`Tg`MV!uhe!!

'Xbcbg`"!Qahg`atT!ratct!

'09X)@C!'094E0V!QG4!KM!1qhf!ebsXqTsb!sh!teTfT"!saX!hqb`bgr!hY!(abgXrX!8trebf!

gTsbhgTebrs!abrshqbh`qTiax!9TsbhgTebrf!TgW!0sagbV!AhebsbVr!!V!"! !!

'@))0V!)0C6!K!M!(abgXrX!8trebfr!bg!hVVtibXW!TqXTr!1Tq!0TrsXqg!DtquXx!V!"!

(3&9!3@6!P49! ĳ`¼!KM!ĭěêÜ"! °8«ðĺĸ0`þËĠė!K&!

gXv!UX`bggbg`"!gTsbhgTe!VqbrXr!TgW!2t!5bX`Tg`r!bgsXeeXVstTe!VaTg`XrM!5!hY!(abgXrX!

DstWbXr!"!!

! !"#$%&'()*&+ !290@'(9)D52)5692C2)$(D6@9)2)%92) E)!624(94)(91)5692C2)#EC768C'#@12B9)

569('2))<=>@1@0H) B)

(34&92!6&4XD306!K!M!(abgTr!)Xrsbgx!TgW!(abgXrX!0VhghfbV!EaXhqx!9Xv!Phqd"!

Chx!AtUebraXqr!

(349V!E&8&C&!E!KM!&gsbptTqbTg!Tr!Xsagh`qTiaXq"!3Tg!XsagbVbsx!bg!XTqex!(abgT!

rstWbXr!Ai! !bg!EahfTr!8teeTgXxV!0qbV!'trrVaXV!DsXiaTgX!2qhrV!TgW!5TfXr!

7XbUheW!KXWrMV!(qbsbVTe!3Tg!DstWbXr"!EaX!3brshqxV!CXiqXrXgsTsbhgV!TgW!4WXgsbsx!hY!

(abgTr!8Tchqbsx!'XqdXeXx"!Fgbu!hY!(TebYhqgbT!AqXrr!

(3@HV!6&4XH492!K!!M!4fT`bgbg`!UhtgWTqbXr!hY!UehhW"!QaTg`!'bg`ebg!TgW!saX!

bguXgsbhg!hY!saX!3Tg!qTVX!bg!fhWXqg!(abgT!Ai!!bg!1qTgd!)bdssXq!KXWMV!EaX!

(hgrsqtVsbhg!hY!CTVbTe!4WXgsbsbXr!bg!(abgT!TgW!5TiTg"!3brshqbVTe!TgW!(hgsXfihqTqx!

AXqriXVsbuXr!3hghetet"!Fgbu!hY!3TvTbb!AqXrr!

(40(4FC&V!H7@)Q4840CQ!KM!0sagbVbsx!hq!qXeb`bhg$!CXitUebVTgXXqT!(abgXrX!WXUTsXr!

hg!4reTf!TgW!8trebfr!Ai!!bg!5hgTsaTg!7bifTg!KXWMV!4reTfbV!Eaht`as!bg!

(abgT"!DbghX8trebf!4gsXeeXVstTe!0uhetsbhg!Yqhf!saX!sa!sh!saX!rs!(Xgstqx!

0WbgUtq`a"!0WbgUtq`a!Fgbu!AqXrr!

(@99@77PV!H4774&8!K!!M!AetqTebrfV!ftesbVtestqTebrf!TgW!saX!gTsbhg JrsTsX"!

qXsabgdbg`!saX!VhggXVsbhgr!5!hY!AhebsbVTe!4WXheh`bXr!V"!!

(C@DD70PV!A&807&!6P70!K!!M!Eabgdbg`!TUhts!XsagbVbsx!bg!XTqex!fhWXqg!(abgT!

7TsX!4fiXqbTe!(abgT!V!"!!

(C@DD70PV!A&807&!6P70!KM!&!EqTgretVXgs!8bqqhq"!3brshqx!TgW!4WXgsbsx!bg!Bbg`!

4fiXqbTe!4WXheh`x!'XqdXeXx"!Fgbu!hY!(TebYhqgbT!AqXrr!

)&!1092IF&9! ĦĽğ K!M!ðĺ0#ÃĐK¹FĹ!K)brVtrrbg`!saX!3tbX3Tg!

ptXrsbhg!vbsa!8q!2t!R5bXS`Tg`M! ÖĘ6-!V!"! !

)F&C&V!AC&D0954E!K!!M!CXrVtbg`!3brshqx!Yqhf!saX!9Tsbhg"!BtXrsbhgbg`!9TqqTsbuXr!hY!

8hWXqg!(abgT!(abVT`h"!Fgbu!hY!(abVT`h!AqXrr!

! !"#$%&'()*&+ !290@'(9)D52)5692C2)$(D6@9)2)%92) E)!624(94)(91)5692C2)#EC768C'#@12B9)

569('2))<=>@1@0H) B)

0'0CV!4C090!K! M!3t!Daba!TgW!(abgXrX!abrshqx"!saX!iqhUeXf!hY!VaXg`Xeb!dthXdt!

8hgtfXgsT!DXqbVT!"!!!

0774@EEV!8&C6!KM!EaX!VTrX!hY!saX!fbrrbg`!bgWb`XgX"!WXUTsX!huXq!T!rXVhgWX

`XgXqTsbhg!XsagbV!ihebVx!(abgT!5!"! !

1&4C'&96V!5@39!6!K! M!EaX!(abgXrX!HhqeW!@qWXq"!EqTWbsbhgTe!(abgTr!1hqXb`g!

CXeTsbhgr!(TfUqbW`XV!8&"!3TquTqW!Fgbu!AqXrr!

104!I4&@E@92!ę]Ģ!KM!Ĳ°FĹËćĐ!KCX`TqWbg`!WbrVtrrbhg!hY!saX!

fbgyt!ptXrsbhgM!Ai!!bg! ĺĸ0&ĵ!K(heeXVsXW!vhqdr!hY!2t!5bX`Tg`MV!uhe!!

'Xbcbg`"!Qahg`atT!ratct!

1F!D494&9! o!K! TM!ïĺĸ0!K7XssXq!sh!2t!5bX`Tg`M!Ai!!bg! o

&ĵ !K(heeXVsXW!vhqdr!hY!1t!DbgbTgM!ETbiXb"!7bTgcbg`!

1F!D494&9!K! UM! õ°Ë!KEaX!(abgXrX!gTsbhg!br!T!shsTebsxM!Ai! !bg!

o&ĵ!K(heeXVsXW!vhqdr!hY!1t!DbgbTgM!ETbiXb"!7bTgcbg`!

20!Q3&@2F&92!÷"$!KM!wv.âåĺĸ0Ĳ Mð õ°

Ë®>ăą!K1qhf!vTgWXqbg`!TqhtgW!sh!XgsTg`eXfXgs"!2t!5bX`Tg`r!abrshqbVTe!ubXvr!

hg!Qahg``th!TgW!Qahg`atT!fbgytM! Q !"!!

27&)90PV!)CF!(!K!!M!CXiqXrXgsbg`!gTsbhgTebsx!bg!(abgT"!qXYb`tqbg`!fTchqbsxfbghqbsx!

bWXgsbsbXr!5!hY!&rbTg!DstWbXr!V!"!!!

2F!5402&92! ĺĸ0!RXWS!K!M!<>ġ!K)XUTsXr!hg!TgVbXgs!abrshqxM!'Xbcbg`"!AtraX!

2F!5402&92!K!M! Ø¹æ ËÄEMi ÅË !K@g!saX!hqb`bgr!hY!saX!

BbgX3Tg!tgbYbVTsbhg!TgW!saX!`ehUTe!bfT`bgTqx!hY!iXhieX!hY!saX!HTqqbg`!DsTsXr!iXqbhWM!

Ai!!bg!2tV!!!

2F!5402&92!K!TM! K¹FĹEÏ/ Ëm!KEaX!3tbX3Tg!ptXrsbhg!TgW!saX!vhqd!

vX!ht`as!sh!UX!Whbg`!ghvM! ÖĘ6-!V!"!! !

! !"#$%&'()*&+ !290@'(9)D52)5692C2)$(D6@9)2)%92) E)!624(94)(91)5692C2)#EC768C'#@12B9)

569('2))<=>@1@0H) B)

2F!5402&92!K!UM! KË4ģ3!K(testqTe!fhuXfXgsr!hY!saX!3tb!qXeb`bhgM! ÖĘ

6-!V!"! !!

2F!5402&92!KTM! Y= õ°Nåě Oû`Ëđ¸ċ!K3hv!

saX!Qahg`atT!fbgyt!VTg!UX!fTWX!sh!VhfX!sh`XsaXqqXfTqdr!Ts!saX!4reTf!DstWx!

DhVbXsxM!4g! ĺĸ0&ĵ!K(heeXVsXW!vhqdr!hY!2t!5bX`Tg`MV!uhe!!'Xbcbg`"!Qahg`atT!

ratct!

2F!5402&92!KUM! ā5íhĈ!K)bTqx!hY!bguXrsb`Tsbhgr!bg!saX!ghqsavXrsM!Ai!

!bg! ĺĸ0&ĵ!K(heeXVsXW!vhqdr!hY!2t!5bX`Tg`MV!uhe!!'Xbcbg`"!Qahg`atT!ratct!

2F!5402&92!KVM! éĐ°ËìE MĩÇFĹ!K(hgsbgtXW!WbrVtrrbhg!hY!

saX!fXTgbg`!hY!fbgyt!TgW!saX!(abgXrX!YqhgsbXq!ptXrsbhgM!Ai!!bg!ĺĸ0&ĵ!

K(heeXVsXW!vhqdr!hY!2t!5bX`Tg`MV!uhe!!'Xbcbg`"!Qahg`atT!ratct!

2F!5402&92!KWM! õ° Ë!KEaX!Qahg`atT!fbgyt!br!hgXM!Ai!!!bg!

ĺĸ0&ĵ!K(heeXVsXW!vhqdr!hY!2t!5bX`Tg`MV!uhe!!'Xbcbg`"!Qahg`atT!ratct!

2F!5402&92!TgW!&CE3FC!3F8807!K!M!EaX!&tshUbh`qTiax!hY!T!(abgXrX!3brshqbTg"!

'Xbg`!saX!AqXYTVX!sh!T!Dxfihrbtf!hg!&gVbXgs!(abgXrX!3brshqx!K6t!rabaibXgM!7XbWXg"!

05!'qbee!

3@V!A492XE4!K!! M!4g!WXYXgrX!hY!rbgbVbyTsbhg"!T!qXUtssTe!hY!0uXexg!CTvrdbr!CXX

Xgubrbhgbg`!saX!Bbg`!5!hY!&rbTg!DstWbXr!V!"!!

3@9V!EQ0X64!K!!M!0sagbV!TgW!VtestqTe!ietqTebrf"!2t!5bX`Tg`r!ubrbhg!hY!T!gXv!(abgT!bg!

abr!rstWbXr!hY!TgVbXgs!abrshqx!8hWXqg!(abgT!V!!K5texM"!!!

3@9V!EQ0X64!KM!9TsbhgTe!XrrXgVXV!gTsbhgTe!eXTqgbg`V!TgW!VtestqX"!abrshqbVTe!vqbsbg`r!bg!

2thVtb!wtXUThV!ItXaXg`V!TgW!2thwtX!cbdTg!3brshqbh`qTiax!0Trs!TgW!HXrs!V!"!

! !"#$%&'()*&+ !290@'(9)D52)5692C2)$(D6@9)2)%92) E)!624(94)(91)5692C2)#EC768C'#@12B9)

569('2))<=>@1@0H) C=)

3@9V!EQ0X64!KM!(testqTe!bWXgsbsx!TgW!ehVTe!rXeYX`huXqgfXgs"!T!rstWx!hY!7bt!PbyaXg`r!

3brshqx!hY!(abgXrX!(testqX!8hWXqg!(abgT!V!!K@VsM"!!

3F!D34!îħ !K!M!M`^-É-cĆ!K4gTt`tqTe!fTgbYXrsh!Yhq!saX!9TsbhgTe!DstWbXr!

BtTqsXqexM!Ai!!bg! îħ\!K(heeXVsXW!iqhrX!hY!3t!DabM!ETbiXb"!PtTgWhg`!strat!

`hg`rb!

3F&92V!8092PF!KM!&vTdXgbg`!Vhtgsqx!TgW!YTbsa"!saX!VhgrsqtVsbhg!hY!DbghX

8trebf!abrshqbXr!TgW!bWXgsbsbXr!bg!saX!XTqex!svXgsbXsa!VXgstqx!3hghqr!saXrbrV!

HXeeXreXx!(heeX`X!assi"qXihrbshqxvXeeXreXxXWtsaXrbrVheeXVsbhg!

5&80DV!84(3&07!KM!CTVX!4g!0WvTqW!QTesT!KXWMV!DsTgYhqW!0gVxVehiXWbT!hY!

Aabehrhiax!8XsTiaxrbVr!CXrXTqVa!7TUV!DsTgYhqW!Fgbu!

assir"ieTshrsTgYhqWXWtTqVabuXrriqXgsqbXrqTVX!

509(@V!70423!KM!3hv!rahteW!vX!trX!saX!(abgXrX!iTrs$!(hgsXfihqTqx!(hgYtVbTgbrfV!

saX!qXhq`TgbyTsbhg!hY!saX!gTsbhgTe!aXqbsT`X!TgW!ghgXHXrsXqg!abrshqbXr!hY!saht`as!bg!T!

`ehUTe!T`X!0tqhiXTg!5!hY!AhebsbVTe!EaXhqx!V!"!!!

509(@V!70423!K1hqsaVhfbg`M!EaXhqbXr!hY!VtestqTe!VhgrsqtVsbhg!bg!saX!!r!4g!&wXe!

DVagXbWXq!TgW!EahfTr!1qhaebVa!KXWrMV!(abgXrX!Gbrbhgr!hY!Aqh`qXrrV! !!!!

7XbWXg"!'qbee!

549!54E&92! Į@R!K!M!K°Ď!K@g!3tb!qXeb`bhg!TgW!fbgytM! ÖĘ6-!"!

549!P@92E@92!Į±A!K!M!ðĺĸ0#Ãď MK>!K)brVtrrbg`!saX!abrshqx!hY!

(abgXrX!3tb!qXeb`bhg!vbsa!8q!2t!5bX`Tg`M! ÖĘ6-!V!"! !

6F6&E3&DV!(3&9)C&9!K!!M!&qX!saXqX!Tgx!VtestqTe!qb`asr$!AhebsbVTe!EaXhqx!V!"!

6F6&E3&DV!(3&9)C&9!KM!EaX!7bUXqTe!&qVabiXeT`h"!&!EaXhqx!hY!)buXqrbsx!TgW!

1qXXWhf!@wYhqW"!@wYhqW!Fgbu!AqXrr!

! !"#$%&'()*&+ !290@'(9)D52)5692C2)$(D6@9)2)%92) E)!624(94)(91)5692C2)#EC768C'#@12B9)

569('2))<=>@1@0H) C>)

6F@V!P&XA04!KM!EXfihqTebsx!hY!dghveXW`X!TgW!abrshqx!vqbsbg`!bg!XTqex!svXgsbXsaX

VXgstqx!(abgT"!7bt!PbyaXg`!TgW!&!3brshqx!hY!(abgXrX!(testqX!Ai! !bg!GbqXg!

8tqsax!TgW!&wXe!DVagXbWXq!KXWrMV!EaX!(aTeeXg`X!hY!7bgXTq!EbfX"!9TsbhgahhW!TgW!saX!

AhebsbVr!hY!3brshqx!bg!0Trs!&rbT!7XbWXg"!'qbee!

6P874(6&V!H477!K! !M!7bUXqTebrfV!(hfftgbsx!TgW!(testqX!@wYhqW"!(eTqXgWhg!

6P874(6&V!H477!K!!M!8tesbVtestqTe!(bsbyXgrabi"!&!7bUXqTe!EaXhqx!hY!8bghqbsx!Cb`asr!

9Xv!Phqd"!@wYhqW!Fgbu!AqXrr!

7&927@4DV!5@39!)!K! M!(abgXrX!VtestqTebrf!TgW!saX!PTg!TgTeh`x"!rXuXgsXXgsaX

VXgstqx!iXqriXVsbuXr!3TquTqW!5!hY!&rbTsbV!DstWbXr!V!"!! !

7XT`tX!hY!9TsbhgrV!(hffbrrbhg!hY!0gptbqx!bgsh!saX!DbghX5TiTgXrX!)britsXV!7xsshg!Xs!Te!

K!M!8TgVatqbT"!qXihqs!hY!saX!(hffbrrbhg!hY!0gptbqx!TiihbgsXW!Ux!saX!7XT`tX!hY!

9Tsbhgr!assir"WWrVqeXWtVqeWXebuXqx!

704'@7)V!5&80D!KM!(hgrsqtVsbg`!saX!Qahg`atT!fbgyt"!saX!YqhgsbXq!TgW!gTsbhgTe!

ptXrsbhgr!bg!XTqex!sa!VXgstqx!(abgT!Aa)!WbrrV!Fgbu!hY!DhtsaXqg!(TebYhqgbT!

704'@7)V!5&80D!KM!Ahrbsbhgbg`!fbgyt!vbsabg!Dtg!PTsXrXgr!WbrVhtqrX!hY!

fbgytyatxb!5!hY!&rbTg!3brshqx! V!"!!

704'@7)V!5&80D!KM!(hfiXsbg`!gTqqTsbuXr!hY!qTVbTe!tgbsx!bg!CXitUebVTg!(abgT"!Yqhf!

saX!PXeehv!0fiXqhq!sh!AXdbg`!8Tg!8hWXqg!(abgT!V!!K&iqbeM"! !

70G09D@9V!5@D0A3!C!K! M!(hgYtVbTg!(abgT!TgW!4sr!8hWXqg!1TsX"!&!Eqbeh`x!'XqdXeXx"!

Fgbu!hY!(TebYhqgbT!AqXrr!

74&92!B4(3&@! ¦GĜ!K!!M! M>Đ!K4gsqhWtVsbhg!sh!(abgXrX!abrshqxM!Ai!!

bg! Ļ*d?ĵĵ!K(heeXVsXW!vhqdr!Yqhf!saX!4VXXWqbgdXqr!DstWbhMV!uhe!!'Xbcbg`"!

Qahg`atT!ratct!

74A8&9V!5@9&E3&9!K!! M!1TfbebTq!DsqTg`Xqr"!&!3brshqx!hY!8trebfr!bg!9hqsavXrs!

(abgT!3hg`!6hg`"!3hg`!6hg`!Fgbu!AqXrr!

! !"#$%&'()*&+ !290@'(9)D52)5692C2)$(D6@9)2)%92) E)!624(94)(91)5692C2)#EC768C'#@12B9)

569('2))<=>@1@0H) C<)

74A8&9V!5@9&E3&9!KM!3hv!fTgx!fbgyt!bg!T!gTsbhg$!8hWXqg!sqTuXeeXqr!fXXs!

(abgTr!YqhgsbXq!iXhieXr!4ggXq!&rbT!V!"!!

74FV!7@92X3D49!KM!AhiteTq!qXTWbg`r!TgW!vTqsbfX!abrshqbVTe!vqbsbg`r!bg!fhWXqg!

(abgT!Ai! !bg!GbqXg!8tqsax!TgW!&wXe!DVagXbWXq!KXWrMV!EaX!(aTeeXg`X!hY!

7bgXTq!EbfX"!9TsbhgahhW!TgW!saX!AhebsbVr!hY!3brshqx!bg!0Trs!&rbT!7XbWXg"!'qbee!

74F!P4Q3092!¤Ċz!K!M! M4>!K3brshqx!hY!(abgXrX!VtestqXM!9Tgcbg`"!9Tgcbg`!

Qahg`raTg!Vatct!

74F!Q3@F! 'µ !K!!M! MK°b)Me Ą~!KGbXvr!hg!saX!gTsbhg!aXeW!Ux!(abgTr!

3tb!iXhieXM! õ !V!"!!

8&!1FI4&92! ļÕÔ!K!M! ML ĥ{!KAqXrXqubg`!(abgTr!hqb`bgTe!ubqstXM!

õ !V!"!!

8&V!3&4PF9!K M!1Tgatb!hq!3tbYTg$!3Tgatb!hq!3tbfbg$!DTeTq!XsagbV!bWXgsbYbVTsbhg!TgW!

Bbg`!TWfbgbrsqTsbuX!sqTgrYhqfTsbhg!bg!Xb`asXXgsaXVXgstqx!2Tgrt!7TsX!4fiXqbTe!(abgT!

!V!"!!

8&!C@92!ļ !KM!YČĔ°E õ°Kĺ !! oĲ õ

° ËćĐ!K3hv!sh!tgWXqrsTgW!fbgyt!TgW!Qahg`atT!fbgyt"!ehhdbg`!

UTVd!hg!saX!!!!WXUTsX!huXq!EaX!Qahg`atT!fbgyt!br!hgXM! #! !"!

8&@!PF1092!KM!8trebf!XWtVTsbhgTe!qXYhqf!bg!saXVXgstqx!(abgT"!saX!VTrX!hY!saX!

(aXg`WT!EXTVaXqr!&VTWXfx!0wsqfXX@qbXgs!0wsqfXX@VVbWXgs!"!!

8&EDF8@E@V!8&DF84!KM!DbghX8trebfr!bWXgsbsx!TgW!saht`asr!Wtqbg`!saX!&gsbX

5TiTgXrX!HTq"!bfiTVs!hY!saX!8bWWeX!0Trs!hg!4reTfbV!qXubuTe!TgW!qXYhqf!bg!(abgT!

&ggTer!hY!saX!5TiTg!&rrhVbTsbhg!Yhq!8bWWeX!0TrsXqg!DstWbXr! V!"!!!

! !"#$%&'()*&+ !290@'(9)D52)5692C2)$(D6@9)2)%92) E)!624(94)(91)5692C2)#EC768C'#@12B9)

569('2))<=>@1@0H) CB)

8&EDF8@E@V!8&DF84!KM!CTsbhgTebybg`!iTsqbhsbrf!Tfhg`!8trebf!(abgXrX"!saX!

bfiTVs!hY!saX!8bWWeX!0Trs!hg!saX!PtXatT!chtqgTe!Ai!!bg!DsXiagX!&!

)tWhb`ghgV!3brTh!6hfTsrtV!TgW!PTrtrab!6hrt`b!KXWrMV!4gsXeeXVstTer!bg!saX!8hWXqg!

4reTfbV!HhqeW"!EqTgrfbrrbhgV!EqTgrYhqfTsbhgV!(hfftgbVTsbhg!7hgWhg"!ChtseXW`X!

84P&6&H&V!34D&PF64!K!M!EaX!(hgYtVbTgbyTsbhg!hY!rhtsa!(abgT!Ai!!bg!

&qsatq!Hqb`as!KXWMV!EaX!(hgYtVbTg!AXqrtTrbhg!DsTgYhqWV!(&"!DsTgYhqW!Fgbu!AqXrr!

8F77&90PV!E3@8&D!KM!(hfbg`!sh!EXqfr!vbsa!saX!9Tsbhg"!0sagbV!(eTrrbYbVTsbhg!bg!

8hWXqg!(abgT!'XqdXeXx"!Fgbu!hY!(TebYhqgbT!AqXrr!

8F77&90PV!E3@8&DV!0C4(!'FDD(30V!DE0A3&90!2C@DV!TgW!5&80D!704'@7)!

RXWrS!KM!(qbsbVTe!3Tg!DstWbXr"!EaX!3brshqxV!CXiqXrXgsTsbhgV!TgW!4WXgsbsx!hY!(abgTr!

8Tchqbsx!'XqdXeXx"!Fgbu!hY!(TebYhqgbT!AqXrr!

A@77@(6V!D307)@9!KM!(hrfhihebsTg!TgW!uXqgTVteTq!bg!abrshqx!AtUebV!(testqX!V!

"!!!

B4!D430!ŀE!K!M!°ðÙ!K9Tsbhg!TgW!qTVXM! ÖĘ6-!"!!

B4&9!8F! įÚ !K!! M!įĚJ#Ã&ĵ!K(heeXVsXW!vhqdr!hY!8q!BbTg!'bgrb!RBbTg!8tSM!

ETbiXb"!7bTgcbg`!

D(3904)0CV!&I07!K!!M!'XsvXXg!)Th!TgW!abrshqx"!svh!(abgXrX!abrshqbTgr!bg!rXTqVa!hY!

T!fhWXqg!bWXgsbsx!Yhq!(abgT!3brshqx!TgW!EaXhqx!V!"!!

D(3904)0CV!&I07!KM!9TsbhgV!abrshqx!TgW!XsabVr"!saX!VahbVXr!hY!ihrsXbfiXqbTe!

abrshqbh`qTiax!bg!(abgT!Ai! !bg!GbqXg!8tqsax!TgW!&wXe!DVagXbWXq!KXWrMV!EaX!

VaTeeXg`X!hY!ebgXTq!sbfX"!gTsbhgahhW!TgW!saX!ihebsbVr!hY!abrshqx!bg!0Trs!&rbT!7XbWXg"!

'qbee!

D(3904)0CV!5F74&!(!KM!9Tsbhg!TgW!0sagbVbsx"!(abgXrX!)brVhtqrXr!hg!3brshqxV!

3brshqbh`qTiaxV!TgW!9TsbhgTebrf!K!r!rM!7XbWXg"!'qbee!

! !"#$%&'()*&+ !290@'(9)D52)5692C2)$(D6@9)2)%92) E)!624(94)(91)5692C2)#EC768C'#@12B9)

569('2))<=>@1@0H) CC)

D(3904)0CV!7&FC09(0!K!M!6t!(abXaXdTg`!TgW!(abgTr!9Xv!3brshqx"!9TsbhgTebrf!

TgW!saX!BtXrs!Yhq!&esXqgTsbuX!EqTWbsbhgr!'XqdXeXx"!Fgbu!hY!(TebYhqgbT!AqXrr!

D84E3V!&9E3@9P!)!K! M!EaXhqbXr!hY!9TsbhgTebrf!9Xv!Phqd"!3hefXr!z!8XbXq!

D@92V!D&C&3!KM!8tesbVtestqTebrf!4g!0WvTqW!QTesT!KXWMV!DsTgYhqW!0gVxVehiXWbT!hY!

Aabehrhiax !8XsTiaxrbVr!CXrXTqVa!7TUV!DsTgYhqW!Fgbu!

assir"ieTshrsTgYhqWXWtTqVabuXrriqXgsqbXrftesbVtestqTebrf!

DF9V!P&EXD09!K!M!DTg!8bg!(at!4"!EaX!EaqXX!AqbgVbieXr!hY!saX!AXhieX!DaTg`aTb"!

(hffXqVbTe!AqXrr!

DF9!Q30! _H TgW!H&92!54&92!¿³ !KM!ĩÇ°MeÖĘ6-ð

ã oË MĩÇÒÛ!K1qhgsbXqV!gTsbhg!TgW!rsTsX"!Pt`hg`!DXfbfhgsaex!

TgW!(abgXrX!YqhgsbXq!rstWbXr!bg!saX!!!rM!'Xbcbg`"!CXgfbg!WTwtX!VatUTgraX!

E&8&9@4V!8&C46@!&D&9@!KM!6ghveXW`XV!ihvXqV!TgW!qTVbTe!VeTrrbYbVTsbhg"!saX!

5TiTgXrX!bg!8TgVatqbT!5!hY!&rbTg!DstWbXr!!V!"! !

E&P7@CV!(3&C70D!K!!M!EaX!ihebsbVr!hY!qXVh`gbsbhg!4g!&fx!2tsfTgg!KXWMV!

8tesbVtestqTebrf!TgW!EaX!AhebsbVr!hY!CXVh`gbsbhg!AqbgVXshgV!95"!AqbgVXshg!Fgbu!

AqXrr!

E@92!D3FP0!ßö!K!M!!ýUí!K4guXrsb`Tsbhg!hY!8Tg!IbTM! ÖĘ6-! "!

E@H9D09)V!5&80D!K!!M!(abgXrX!gTsbhgTebrf!&trsqTebTg!5!hY!(abgXrX!&YYTbqr!"!

H&92!1&9D09!¿²§!K! M!<>ġģ3Ëñě >Ë,£!KEaX!qbrX!hY!saX!

)britsbg`!&gsbptbsx!fhuXfXgs"!Tg!TgTexrbr!bg!saX!abrshqx!hY!saht`asM!ETbiXb"!PtgVaXg!

H&92V!1&9D09!KM!1t!DrtXgbXg"!&!7bYX!bg!(abgXrX!3brshqx!TgW!AhebsbVr!9Xv!Phqd"!

(TfUqbW`X!Fgbu!AqXrr!

! !"#$%&'()*&+ !290@'(9)D52)5692C2)$(D6@9)2)%92) E)!624(94)(91)5692C2)#EC768C'#@12B9)

569('2))<=>@1@0H) CD)

H&92!5492Q3&4! ¿ķ!K!M!ĒaKð ĕMe!KAqXrXqubg`!4reTf!TgW!ehubg`!saX!

gTsbhgM! õ !V!"!!

H&92!C4H04! ¿ø!K!M!KKġ!K)bYYXqXgsbTsbg`!saX!3tb!iXhieX!Yqhf!saX!3tb!

qXeb`bhgM! ÖĘ6-!"!!!

H&92!I498492!¿D!Xs!Te!K!!!R!SM! M¢Ë4ËqĉcĆ!K8TgbYXrsh!

Yhq!VtestqTe!VhgrsqtVsbhg!hg!T!(abgXrX!UTrXM!Ai!!bg!7th!Chg`pt!ëª¶!KXWMV!

xā4.Á4 J Ĳ MË4ĝBEÉkĥĞĐēĨ!K1qhf!

HXrsXqgbyTsbhg!sh!fhWXqgbyTsbhg"!VheeXVsbhg!hY!WXUTsXr!huXq!saX!WbqXVsbhg!TgW!

WXuXehifXgs!hY!(abgXrX!VtestqX!rbgVX!8Tx!1htqsaM!'Xbcbg`"!'Xbcbg`!WTwtX!VatUTgraX!

IF0!H09'@!ú´!K!M!K°Ĥ:ËP; 21!KEaX!iTrs!

ihrbsbhg!hY!saX!3tb!fbgyt!TgW!saX!XYYhqsr!vX!rahteW!UX!tgWXqsTdbg`!shWTxM! ÖĘ6-!

V!"! !

P&9!1F! Iy !K! M!9s !K@g!rsqXg`saM!Ai!!bg! Iyĵ!KHhqdr!hY!PTg!1tM!

'Xbcbg`"!Qahg`atT!ratct!

P&92!3F&4Q3@92! ¨ Xs!Te!RXWrS!K!!M!û!K4reTfM!4g! ĬKá û!

K&vTdXgbg`!4reTf"!4reTfM!9bg`wbT"!9bg`wbT!qXgfbg!VatUTgraX!

P&92V!8&P1&4C!8!RXWS!K M!(abgXrX!CXeb`bhrbsbXr"!&YYebVsbhgr!hY!8hWXqgbsx!TgW!DsTsX!

1hqfTsbhg!'XqdXeXx"!Fgbu!hY!(TebYhqgbT!AqXrr!

P@F92V!4C4D!8&C4@9!K!!M!5trsbVX!TgW!saX!AhebsbVr!hY!)bYYXqXgVX!AqbgVXshg!95"!

AqbgVXshg!Fgbu!AqXrr!

PF!P492D34!ô!KM!¡ÍËxĈÐĺĸ0Ë%| Å!

KFgXwaTtrsXW!sTeXgs"!ehhdbg`!Ts!2t!5bX`Tg`r!bgsXqbhq!vhqeW!Yqhf!saX!)bTqxM!ETbiXb"!

7bTgcbg`!

! !"#$%&'()*&+ !290@'(9)D52)5692C2)$(D6@9)2)%92) E)!624(94)(91)5692C2)#EC768C'#@12B9)

569('2))<=>@1@0H) C)

Q3092!)&3F&!īVõ!KM! oË¢4ð&Îā4ËĐ!KEaX!

WXUTsXr!huXq!hqb`bgTe!VtestqX!TgW!shsTebrsbV!HXrsXqgbyTsbhg!bg!saX!!rM! ·7nà

V`Ó×`S!V!"! !!

Q3@F!(3F&9'49! C !KM!Đ M¾òË°Ą~!K@g!VhgVXisr!hY!fbgyt!vbsa!

(abgXrX!VaTqTVsXqbrsbVrM! pā°ÒÛ!"!!!

Q3@F!H0954F! CÀ!TgW!Q3&92!549A092! rİľ!KM!Ĳ õ°

`þĐġËíh!KCX`TqWbg`!bguXrsb`Tsbhgr!bgsh!saX!rVaheTqex!WXUTsXr!huXq!EaX!

Qahg`atT!fbgyt!br!hgXM! °ÒÛ!!

Author Biography

"#$%&!'(!)#*+, !KAa)V!FgbuXqrbsx!hY!(abVT`hM!br!AqhYXrrhq!hY!AhebsbVTe!EaXhqx!Ts!saX!7hgWhg!

DVahhe!hY!0VhghfbVr!TgW!AhebsbVTe!DVbXgVX!TgW!TrrhVbTsX!XWbshq!hY!saX! A91C5)'@&A85E5)'8&

)51@)1&1G51H !DaX!aTr!itUebraXW!vbWXex!hg!saX!ihebsbVTe!saht`as!hY!saX!eTsX!Bbg`!TgW!

CXitUebVTg!iXqbhWrV!TgW!br!ghv!vhqdbg`!hg!T!iqhcXVs!hg!rXuXgsXXgsaX!TgW!Xb`asXXgsaXVXgstqx!

ETbvTg!3Xq!qXVXgs!itUebVTsbhgr!bgVetWX!aXq!fhgh`qTia! 44'@35@3&121C1@EDN&1'C@5@3&

A)CADD& B')1&'@0&!591&5@&445@'&'@0&E41DE !K@wYhqWV!M!!

! !"#$%&'()*&+ !290@'(9)D52)5692C2)$(D6@9)2)%92) E)!624(94)(91)5692C2)#EC768C'#@12B9)

569('2))<=>@1@0H) C)

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

!3XqXV!4!sqTgreTsX!Qahg`atT!fbgyt QebsXqTeexV!iXhieXKrM!hY!saX!(XgsqTe!1ehqXrVXgVX qht`aex!Tr!4!XwiXVs!2t!bgsXgWXW!bsV!Tr!saX!eTq`Xq!ihebsbVTe!VTsX`hqx!bgsh!vabVa!uTqbhtr!VtestqTe!

TgW!XsagbV!bWXgsbsbXr!KvabVa!aX!Terh!VTeer!fbgytM!hY!(abgT!fb`as!Ybs!KEabr!WtTe!trT`X!hY!

fbgyt!sh!fXTg!Uhsa!saX!eTq`Xq!gTsbhg!TgW!rfTeeXq!gTsbhgTebsbXr!VhgsbgtXr!shWTx!bg!saX!

AC(!Ux!VhffXgsTshqr!rtVa!Tr!3t!&g`Tg`!TgW!3t!7bTgaXrXX!0eebhssV!"!!M!&esaht`a! rtVa!Tg!bgVetrbuX!trT`X!hY!Qahg`atT!fbgyt!br!hYsXg!TrrhVbTsXW!vbsa!7bTg`!BbVaThV!vah!

VhbgXW!saX!sXqf!K7XbUheWV!"!V!MV!5tebT!DVagXbWXq!Tq`tXr!hg!saX!UTrbr!hY!T!VehrX!sXwstTe! qXTWbg`!saTs! &4A@34F'&T95@PF M!qXYXqr!Ux!WXYbgbsbhg!hgex!sh!saX!(abgXrX!K '@ M!iXhieX!bg!eTsX! bfiXqbTe!sXwsr!Tr!vXee!Tr!sahrX!Yqhf!saX!!r!KDVagXbWXqV!"!V!rXX!Terh!!iTrrbfM!%

!(testqTebrf!br!T!sXqf!VhbgXW!Ux!&g`ehiahgX!abrshqbTgrV!rsTqsbg`!vbsa!5hrXia!7XuXgrhg!

K! MV!sh!WXrVqbUX!saX!(abgXrX!bfT`bgTqx!hY!Tg!TeeXtgWXqX3XTuXg!WXYbgXW!Ux!saX!ghqfTsbuX! rsqtVstqXr!hY!(abgXrX!VbubebyTsbhg!1hq!T!VqbsbVTe!huXqubXv!hY!VtestqTebrf!Tr!T!VhgVXis!bg!

0g`ebraXeTg`tT`X!abrshqbh`qTiax!sh!WXrVqbUX!saX!VtestqTeex!WXYbgXW!Vhfftgbsx!hY! iqXfhWXqg!(abgTV!rXX!EhvgrXgWV!!!!4s!br!YqXptXgsex!bWXgsbYbXW!vbsa!saX!VeTbf!saTs!(abgXrX!

VbubebyTsbhg!vhteW!bgXubsTUex!DbgbVbyX!ghgX(abgXrX!iXhieXr!K1TbqUTgdV!! #!DVagXbWXqV!

"!M!3hvXuXqV!UXVTtrX!uTqbTgsr!hY!sabr!VeTbf!TqX!Terh!rXXg!bg!hsaXq!VbubebyTsbhgr!KrtVa!

Tr!saX!DTgrdqbs!Vhrfhihebr!WXrVqbUXW!Ux!AheehVdV!MV!TgW!UXVTtrX!2t!aXqX!XfisbXr!saXrX!

Trrtfisbhgr!hY!saXbq!riXVbYbVTeex!(abgXrX!YXTstqXrV!4!qXsTbg!saX!fhqX!`XgXqTe!sXqf!

VtestqTebrf!qTsaXq!saTg!saX!fhqX!riXVbYbV!DbgbVbyTsbhg! % !K'@4F' M!%

!8bgyt!brV!sh!its!bs!fbeWexV!Tg!bgVqXWbUex!VhfieXw!VhgVXis!@qb`bgTeex!T!gXheh`brf!sh! sqTgreTsX!saX!2XqfTg!vhqW! "A87 V!huXq!saX!iTrs!atgWqXW!xXTqr!bs!aTr!sTdXg!hg!VheeTsXqTe! gtTgVXr!WXqbuXW!Yqhf!saX!2XqfTgV!0g`ebraV!1qXgVa!TgW!CtrrbTg!KDhubXsM!eTg`tT`Xr!hY! gTsbhgTebrfV!XsagbVbsxV!TgW!iXhieXahhW!Qaht!(atTgUbg!hYYXqr!T!aXeiYte!VaTqs!hY!sabr!

! !"#$%&'()*&+ !290@'(9)D52)5692C2)$(D6@9)2)%92) E)!624(94)(91)5692C2)#EC768C'#@12B9)

569('2))<=>@1@0H) C)

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

XuhetsbhgV!rahvbg`!saTs!`XgXqTeex!fbgyt!vbsa!(abgXrX!VaTqTVsXqbrsbVr!VTg!UXrs!UX!sqTgreTsXW!

Tr!gTsbhg!hq!iXhieX!KQahtV!"!M!2buXg!saTs!2t!TgW!abr!VheeXT`tXr!vXqX!WXUTsbg`!saX! uXqx!fXTgbg`!hY!fbgytV!4!eXTuX!sabr!sXqf!tgsqTgreTsXW!bg!fhrs!hY!saX!XrrTxV!sh!TuhbW! huXqWXsXqfbgbg`!saX!TgTexsbV!vhqd!WhgX!Ux!bs!7XTubg`!fbgyt!tgsqTgreTsXW!bg!saX!0g`ebra! gTfX!hY!qXrXTqVa!bgrsbstsbhgrV!rVaheTqex!VhgYXqXgVXrV!TgW!chtqgTer!br!Terh!Tg!bgVqXTrbg`! iqTVsbVX!bg!saX!AC(! %

!2tr!Qahg`atT!fbgyt!VTsX`hqxV!4!vbee!rahvV!XwiebVbsex!qXcXVsXW!VeTbfr!saTs!(abgT!vTr!Utbes!

XbsaXq!hg!T!rbg`eX!VtestqX! !hq!T!rbg`eX!qTVX! *! !Eh!saX!XwsXgs!saTs!ahfh`XgXbsx!Khq!

VeTbfr!hY!ahfh`XgXbsxM!Tehg`!XbsaXq!hq!Uhsa!TwXr!TqX!trtTeex!bfiebVTsXW!vbsa!XsagbVbsx!KrXX!

EhvgrXgWV!!!"!!MV!sxibVTeex!WXYbgXW!Tr!T!rXgrX!hY!Vhffhg!TgVXrsqx!UTrXW!hg!VtestqTe!

TssTVafXgsrV!iTrs!ebg`tbrsbV!aXqbsT`XV!qXeb`bhtr!TYYbebTsbhgrV!VeTbfXW!dbgrabiV!hq!rhfX!iaxrbVTe! sqTbsrV!K5TfXrV!"!giMV!vX!VTg!bgYXq!saTs!2t!vhteW!Terh!qXcXVs!saX!ghsbhg!saTs!saXqX!vTr! rtVa!T!sabg`!Tr!T!(abgXrX!XsagbVbsx!3hvXuXqV!4!`XgXqTeex!TuhbW!trX!hY!saX!sXqf!XsagbVbsx!

KXwVXis!vaXg!bs!br!trXW!Ux!rXVhgWTqx!rhtqVXrMV!sh!iqXuXgs!VhgYeTsbhg!hY!sabr!UqhTWXq!TgW!fhqX!

WbYYtrX!VhgVXis!vbsa!saX!VhgVXisr!hY!qTVX!TgW!VtestqX!saTs!VTistqX!fhqX!iqXVbrXex!2tr! hvg!uhVTUteTqx!1hq!T!WbrVtrrbhg!hY!ahv!XsagbVbsx!aTr!UXXg!VhgYeTsXW!abrshqbVTeex!vbsa!

qTVXV!rXX!(qhrreXxV!!!"!%

!EaX!sXqf!VhgrsbstXgVbXr!br!sTdXg!Yqhf!(qhrreXx!K"!MV!vah!WXYbgXr!saXf!Tr!saX!

VhgrsqtVsXW!TtWbXgVXr!sh!vabVa!saX!ftesbieX!bfiXqbTe!iXqrhgTX!RhY!saX!Bbg`!XfiXqhqS!

TWWqXrrXW!saXfrXeuXr %

!5bThyab!br!ghv!iTqs!hY!ghqsaXqg!GbXsgTf!ItTgst!vTr!saX!gTfX!hY!hgX!hY!Yhtq!3Tg!

VhffTgWXqbXr!XrsTUebraXW!TYsXq!sabr!TqXT!hg!saX!6hqXTg!iXgbgrteT!TgW!7bThWhg`!vTr!sTdXg!Ux! saX!YhtgWbg`!XfiXqhq!hY!saX!3TgV!3Tg!HtWb%

! !"#$%&'()*&+ !290@'(9)D52)5692C2)$(D6@9)2)%92) E)!624(94)(91)5692C2)#EC768C'#@12B9)

569('2))<=>@1@0H) C)

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

!3hgr!Tq`tfXgsr!YhVtr!hg!2tr!VhffbsfXgs!sh!VtestqTe!ietqTebrf!bg!saX! FD45&(5'@ V!Uts!Wh! ghs!VhgrbWXq!ahv!2t!XwsXgWXW!hq!sqTgrYhqfXW!saXrX!VhffbsfXgsr!bg!abr!WXUTsXr!vbsa!

9TsbhgTebrs!bWXheh`tXr!bg!saX!!r%

!4g!sabr!rXgrXV!4!T`qXX!vbsa!(aTg!3hd!Pbgr!Tq`tfXgs!saTs!VhgsqTqx!sh!saX!iqhghtgVXfXgsr!hY! abrshqbTgr!rtVa!Tr!Pt!Pbg`rabV!2tr!vhqd!bg!saX!!r!br!VhgVXistTeex!VhgrbrsXgs!vbsa!abr!

XTqebXq!bVhghVeTrf!DXX!(aTgV!"!!!!4!rTx!fhqX!TUhts!sabr!UXehv!%

!!Eabr!XfiaTrbr!hg! BA85E5)'8 !TrrhVbTsbhg!T`Tbg!Wbrsbg`tbraXr!2t!Yqhf!rhfXhgX!rtVa!Tr!7bt!

PbyaXg`V!vah!XwiebVbsex!Wbrsbg`tbraXW!saX!(abgXrX!gTsbhg!Tr!T!`qhti!rXiTqTsX!YqhfV!TgW!Ts! sbfXr!bg!sXgrbhg!vbsaV!Tgx!`buXg!rhuXqXb`g!TtsahqbsbXr!K3hgV!"!M! %

!4s!br!ghs!VeXTqV!ahvXuXqV!bY!2t!abfrXeY!vqhsX!sabr!bgsqhWtVshqx!rtffTqxV!vabVa!rbfiebYbXr! saX!fhqX!VhfieXw!brrtXr!2t!WbrVtrrXr!aXqX!%

!EaTs!brV!UXVTtrX!(hgYtVbtr!VhgrbWXqXW!tgUbgWbg`!hgXr!aTbq!TgW!YheWbg`!hgXr!qhUX!T!

VXqsTbg!vTx!sh!UX!iqTVsbVXr!hY!UTqUTqbTgr %

!2buXg!saX!XwsXgs!hY!abr!qXrXTqVa!hg!saX!rabYsbg`!sXqqbshqbTe!UhtgWTqbXr!hY!abrshqbVTe!(abgXrX!

`Xh`qTiax!bg!saX! %F3A@3 !TgW!XerXvaXqXV!vX!VTg!rTYXex!TrrtfX!saTs!Yhq!2t!sabr!WXYbgbsbhg!hY!

(abgXrX!bWXgsbsx!vTr!WhtUex!Vhgsbg`XgsV!rtUcXVs!gXVXrrTqbex!ghs!hgex!sh!VaTg`Xr!bg!ihebsbVTe!

Ttsahqbsx!Uts!Terh!sh!saX!sqTgrYhqfTsbhgr!hY!abrshqbVTeV!VtestqTeV!TgW!`Xh`qTiabVTe!

VbqVtfrsTgVXr!huXq!sbfX %

!(aTg!3hdXPbg!Tq`tXr!saTs!saX!Vhgsbgtbsx!bg!2tr!vhqd!ebXr!bg!abr!VhffbsfXgs!sh!

XwiebVTsbg`!saX!ietqTebsx!hY!saX!(abgXrX!iTrs!TgW!sh!YbgWbg`!tgbsx!bg!ietqTebsxV!TgW!ubVX!uXqrT!

K(aTgV!"!!M!4!T`qXXV!Uts!vhteW!rsqXrr!saX!bfihqsTgs!ihebsbVTe!`hTer!rtVa!VhffbsfXgsr! rXquXW"!aXqXV!saXx!tgWXqvqhsX!2tr!rtiihqs!Yhq!qXrXTqVa!hg!T!UqhTWex!XwiTgWXW!(abgXrX! gTsbhg!K1hq!Tg!bgsqhWtVsbhg!sh!saX!qXhq`TgbyTsbhg!hY!saX!gTsbhgTe!aXqbsT`X!fhuXfXgsV!rXX!

0UXqV!! #!Yhq!T!WbrVtrrbhg!hY!2tr!qXeTsbhgrabi!sh!saTs!fhuXfXgsV!rXX!5XgVhV!"!M%

! !"#$%&'()*&+ !290@'(9)D52)5692C2)$(D6@9)2)%92) E)!624(94)(91)5692C2)#EC768C'#@12B9)

569('2))<=>@1@0H) D=)

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

!5bg!ghsXr!saX!Vhgsbgtbsx!UXsvXXg!2tr!vhqd!hg! FD45&(5'@ !TgW!abr!VTee!sh!TssXgW!sh!saX! qXVhqWr!TgW!abrshqx!hY!8trebfr!bg!(abgTV!T!iqhcXVs!aX!VTeer!hq`Tgbybg`! & (abgXrX!

8trebf!abrshqx!4gWXXWV!rtVa!vhqd!YteYbeer!saX!fTgWTsXr!hY!gXv!gTsbhgTe!rstWbXr!htsebgXW!Ux!

3t!Dab!bg!abr!!!rsTsXfXgs!bgTt`tqTsbg`!saX! 'E5A@'8& EF051D&AFC@'8 !V!gTfXex!sh!

UqhTWXg!saX!rVhiX!hY!qXrXTqVaV!TssXgW!sh!saX!rxrsXfTsbV!hq`TgbyTsbhg!hY!saX!iTrsV!TgW!UqhTWex! rXXd!VhfiTqTsbuX!fTsXqbTe!K3tV!!"!M!1hq!3t!Tr!Yhq!2tV!saX!gTsbhgTe!aXqbsT`X! !vTr!

VhgrsbstsXW!Ux!saX!XgsbqXsx!hY!(abgTr!iTrs!VtestqX!TgW!abrshqxV!ghs!hgex!sahrX!iTqsr!WXuhbW! hY!YhqXb`g!bgYetXgVX!saTs!rVaheTqr!shhd!sh!UX!saX!gTsbhgTe!XrrXgVX!+ !K3tV!!"!M%

!EaX!chtqgTe!vTr!gTfXW!TYsXq!saX! %F3A@3 !VaTisXq!hY!saX! 7AA7&A2&A)F91@ED V!vabVa!

WXrVqbUXW!TgVbXgs!`Xh`qTiax!%F3A@3 !fXTgr!ebsXqTeex!EaX!(hgsqbUtsbhgr!hY!Pt!)V!Uts!fhqX! hYsXg!br!sqTgreTsXW!Tr!EaX!EqbUtsX!hY!Pt!Pt!vTr!saX!TgVbXgs!rT`X!VqXWbsXW!vbsa!bgsqhWtVbg`!

YehhW!Vhgsqhe!@gX!hY!saX!chtqgTer!VhgsqbUtshqrV!Bb!DbaXV!bWXgsbYbXW!qXrXTqVa!hY!saX!fbgyt! ptXrsbhg!Tr!hgX!hY!saX!chtqgTer!VhqX!VhgVXqgr!KBbV!!"!M %

!AeXTr!sh!iqXrXquX!(abgT|r!hqb`bgTe!ubqstX!TqX!YhtgW!saqht`ahts! %F14F' V!rb`gTebg`!saX!

VehrX!qXeTsbhgrabi!UXsvXXg!(abgXrX!iabehrhiax!TgW!8trebf!UXebXY!bg!saX!XxXr!hY! %F14F' r! vqbsXqr!TgW!qXTWXqr!KX`V!8TV!!M%

!8Tsrtfhsh!8Trtfbr!vhqd!KV!M!hg!(abgXrX!8trebf!bgsXeeXVstTer!WhVtfXgsr!saX! bgYetXgVX!hY!8bWWeX!0TrsXqgV!riXVbYbVTeex!0`xisbTgV!4reTfbV!fhuXfXgsr!bg!saXbq!vqbsbg`!%

!ATqs!hY!8T!Chg`r!Tq`tfXgs!Yhq!saX!WXihebsbVbyTsbhg!hY!fbgyt!bWXgsbsxV!vabVa!aX!ebgdr!sh!

2tr!Tq`tfXgsr!bg!saX!!rV!rXXfr!sh!qXrs!hg!saX!VeTbfvabVa!2t!vhteW!ebdXex!WXgxsaTs! fhrs!hY!saX!fbgyt!bWXgsbYbXW!bg!saX!0sagbV!(eTrrbYbVTsbhg!AqhcXVs!hY!!!Wh!ghs!aTuX! fXTgbg`Yteex!WbrsbgVs!Yhqfr!hY!ihebsbVTe!KbgVetWbg`!eX`Te!TgW!XVhghfbVM!bgrsbstsbhgr!hq! iqTVsbVXr!saTs!vhteW!UX!gXVXrrTqx!sh!bgVhqihqTsX!bgsh!saX!eTq`Xq!gTsbhg!K8TV!"!#!Yhq!T!

WbrVtrrbhg!hY!saX!0sagbV!(eTrrbYbVTsbhg!AqhcXVsV!rXX!8teeTgXxV!M %

! !"#$%&'()*&+ !290@'(9)D52)5692C2)$(D6@9)2)%92) E)!624(94)(91)5692C2)#EC768C'#@12B9)

569('2))<=>@1@0H) D>)

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

! !3X!qXiXTsr!saXrX!VeTbfr!bg!qXrihgWbg`!sh!VqbsbVr!hY!saX!(abgXrX!9Tsbhg!4r!@gX!XrrTxV! bgVetWbg`!saX!8bTh!vqbsXq!7t`XYtXqV!vah!hUcXVsXW!sh!saX!ihrrbUbebsx!saTs!3Tg!fb`as!raTqX! abrshqbVTe!hqb`bgr!vbsa!saX!rhtsaXqg!8bTh!iXhieX!2t!Tq`tXW!saTs!UehhWebgX!WXrVXgs!vTr!T! abrshqbVTe!fTssXqV!vabVa!aTW!ebsseX!sh!Wh!vbsa!saX!ihebsbVTe!VhgrVbhtrgXrr!hq!raTqXW!rXgsbfXgs! saTs!WbW!saX!qXTe!vhqd!hY!tgbYxbg`!saX!gTsbhg!KDtg!TgW!HTg`V!"! M%

!'XYhqX!saX!gXheh`brf!qXeb`bhg! !KPA@365'A M!vTr!TWhisXW!Ux!fhWXqg!(abgXrX!Yqhf!

0tqhiXTg!eTg`tT`XrV!cbTh!V!hq!sXTVabg`V!vTr!sxibVTeex!trXW!sh!WXrb`gTsX!vaTs!fb`as!UX!

VhgrbWXqXW!qXeb`bhtr!iqTVsbVXr!FesbfTsXexV!ahvXuXqV!cbTh!br!UhtgW!ti!vbsa!VtestqTe!Tr!ftVa!Tr! qXeb`bhtr!iqTVsbVXrV!iTqsbVteTqex!vaXqX!KTr!aXqXM!saX!UhtgWTqbXr!UXsvXXg!svh!`qhtir!stqg!hg! ftesbieX!TgW!huXqeTiibg`!VTsX`hqbXr!hY!WbYYXqXgVX!Eabr!br!XriXVbTeex!sqtX!`buXg!saX!

TfUbuTeXgs!qXeTsbhgrabi!UXsvXXg!(abgXrX!qXeb`bhtr!iqTVsbVXr!TgW!saX!fhWXqg!VTsX`hqx!hY!

qXeb`bhgV!vabVa!bsrXeY!qXYeXVsr!AqhsXrsTgs!(aqbrsbTg!iqXhVVtiTsbhgr!TgW!uTetXr!KrXXV!X`V!

PTg`V! M%

!4g!saX!8bg`!TgW!Bbg`!iXqbhWrV! 2'@ !' qXYXqqXW!sh!T!uTqbXsx!hY!VtestqTeex!WbuXqrX!ghgX3Tg!

XsagbV!`qhtir#!ahvXuXqV!bs!br!ebdXex!2t!br!riXTdbg`!aXqX!hY!saX!EbUXsTgr!hY!2Tgrt!1hq!fhqX! hg!saX!Xsaghgxf! 2'@ V!rXX!8TV! "!g%

!5bg!WbWV!ahvXuXqV!UXebXuX!saTs!qXeb`bhg!vTr!bgsX`qTe!sh!saX!bWXgsbsx!hY!saX! F5PF !! !KsaTs!brV! saX!3tb!fbgytMV!Tg!Tq`tfXgs!2t!qXcXVsXW!K2tV!W"!M%

!4reTfbV!VtestqX!!!!aTr!TUrhqUXW!TgVbXgs!2qXXd!VtestqXV!AXqrbTg!VtestqXV!TgW!4gWbTg!VtestqX! sh!iqhWtVX!bsr!hvg!WbrsbgVsbuX!gTstqX!!!!4s!riqXTW!sh!fXWbXuTe!0tqhiXV!WXuXehibg`!

VhgsXfihqTqx!0tqhiXTg!VbubebyTsbhg!K'TbV!!"! M %

!2t!aXqX!bgVetWXr!saX!0g`ebra!vhqWr!gTsbhg!TgW!qTVX!Tr!sqTgreTsbhgr!hY!fbgyt!TgW! yahg`ytV!qXriXVsbuXex %

! !"#$%&'()*&+ !290@'(9)D52)5692C2)$(D6@9)2)%92) E)!624(94)(91)5692C2)#EC768C'#@12B9)

569('2))<=>@1@0H) D<)

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

!7XhiheWr!iqXrXgsTsbhg!hY!6xfebVdTr!bWXT!hY!ftesbVtestqTebrf!huXqrsTsXr!bsr!VTrX!bg!Ts!eXTrs! hgX!rb`gbYbVTgs!qXriXVs"!rh!YTq!Tr!4!dghvV!6xfebVdT!ghvaXqX!WXYXgWr!saXrX!qb`asr!Tr!

bgTebXgTUeX!1hq!6xfebVdT!TgW!hsaXq!ebUXqTe!ftesbVtestqTebrsrV!rtVa!VtestqTe!qb`asr!TqX! ihrbsXW!hgex!bgrhYTq!Tr!saXqX!TqX!iqXrtfXW!sh!Xwbrs!VeXTqex!WXYbgXW!XsagbV!`qhtir!VTiTUeX!hY!

XwXqVbrbg`!sahrX!qb`asr!Yhq!iqXWXsXqfbgXW!ebUXqTe!XgWrbg!6xfebVdTr!VTrXV!Ttshghfx!TgW!

XptTebsx!K6xfebVdTV!! !V!!!#!Yhq!T!VqbsbptX!hY!6xfebVdT!hg!saXrX!`qhtgWrV!rXX!6tdTsaTrV!

!!M%

!EaXqX!TqXV!hY!VhtqrXV!iqhfbgXgs!XwVXisbhgr!K6tdTsaTrV!#!Phtg`V!!!M%

!4s!Terh!`hXr!vbsahts!rTxbg`!saTs!2t!vhteW!Terh!YtgWTfXgsTeex!qXcXVs!saX!ghsbhg!KiqhfhsXW!

Ux!fTgx!ftesbVtestqTebrsrM!saTs!saX!uTebW!tgbsr!hY!TgTexrbr!TqX!`qhtir!WXYbgXW!Ux!rhVbXsTe!

VtestqXr!saTs!raTqX!T!rbg`eX!eTg`tT`XV!VtestqXV!TgW!abrshqx!KX`V!6xfebVdTV!! !"!#!ETxehqV!

!!M%