In Creole Languages a Study on Guadeloupean Creole and Other French-Based Creoles
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
LAURA TRAMUTOLI ‘Abstract Objects’ in Creole Languages A Study on Guadeloupean Creole and Other French-based Creoles IL SEGNO E LE LETTERE Collana del Dipartimento di Lingue, Letterature e Culture moderne dell’Università degli Studi ‘G. d’Annunzio’ Direzione Mariaconcetta Costantini Comitato scientifico Università “G. d’Annunzio” di Chieti-Pescara Brigitte Battel - Claudia Casadio - Mariaconcetta Costantini Mariapia D’Angelo - Paola Desideri - Persida Lazarević - Maria Rita Leto Lorella Martinelli - Carlo Martinez - Marcial Rubio Árquez - Anita Trivelli Atenei esteri Antonio Azaustre (Universidad de Santiago de Compostela) Claudia Capancioni (Bishop Grosseteste University, Lincoln) Dominique Maingueneau (Université Sorbonne) Snežana Milinković (University of Belgrade) Comitato editoriale Mariaconcetta Costantini - Barbara Delli Castelli Elvira Diana - Luca Stirpe I volumi pubblicati nella Collana sono stati sottoposti a doppio referaggio anonimo. L. Tramutoli , ‘Abstract Objects’ in Creole Languages. A Study on Guadeloupean Creole and Other French-based Creoles Milano, LED, 2021 - ISBN 978-88-7916-955-4 - https://www.ledonline.it/Il-Segno-le-Lettere/955-Creole-languages.html ISSN 2283-7140 ISBN 978-88-7916-955-4 Copyright © 2021 Via Cervignano 4 - 20137 Milano www.lededizioni.com - www.ledonline.it - E-mail: [email protected] I diritti di riproduzione, memorizzazione e archiviazione elettronica, pubblicazione con qualsiasi mezzo analogico o digitale (comprese le copie fotostatiche, i supporti digitali e l’inserimento in banche dati) e i diritti di traduzione e di adattamento totale o parziale sono riservati per tutti i paesi. Le fotocopie per uso personale del lettore possono essere effettuate nei limiti del 15% di ciascun volume/fascicolo di periodico dietro pagamento alla SIAE del compenso previsto dall’art. 68, commi 4 e 5, della legge 22 aprile 1941 n. 633. Le riproduzioni effettuate per finalità di carattere professionale, economico o commerciale o comunque per uso diverso da quello personale possono essere effettuate a seguito di specifica autorizzazione rilasciata da: AIDRO, Corso di Porta Romana n. 108 - 20122 Milano E-mail [email protected] <mailto:[email protected]> sito web www.aidro.org <http://www.aidro.org/> Volume pubblicato con il contributo dell’Università degli Studi ‘G. d’Annunzio’ di Chieti-Pescara Dipartimento di Lingue, Letterature e Culture moderne In copertina Picture by Laura Tramutoli Les Saintes from Les Trois Rivières (Guadeloupe) Videoimpaginazione: Paola Mignanego Stampa: Logo L. Tramutoli , ‘Abstract Objects’ in Creole Languages. A Study on Guadeloupean Creole and Other French-based Creoles Milano, LED, 2021 - ISBN 978-88-7916-955-4 - https://www.ledonline.it/Il-Segno-le-Lettere/955-Creole-languages.html CONTENTS Abbreviations Used in the Glosses 9 Introduction 11 1. NPs’ Genericity and Referentiality 15 1. Genericity (p. 15) – 1.1. Kind-referring NPs (p. 15) – 1.2. The taxonomic and quantitative function of generic NPs (p. 16) – 1.3. Kinds and ‘abstract objects’ (p. 18) – 2. Reference to ‘abstract objects’ in natural languages (p. 20) – 2.1. Referentiality and non- referentiality (p. 20) – 2.2. Prototypical and non-prototypical NPs (p. 21) – 3. ‘Abstract objects’ as we mean them (p. 23) 2. The Collection of Creole Data 33 1. Data for case study 1 (p. 33) – 2. Data for case study 2 (p. 35) – 3. Data for case study 3 (p. 36) 3. Case Study 1: The Semantics behind the Reanalysis 39 of French Articles in French-based Creoles 1. The article agglutination (p. 39) – 2. Phono-morphology of the article agglutination: from French to Creole (p. 41) – 3. Alternations (p. 43) – 4. Previous studies (p. 44) – 4.1. A complex phenomenon (p. 44) – 4.2. The substrate influence hypothesis (p. 46) – 5. The lexical-semantics aspect (p. 49) – 6. The morpho-syntax of NPs denoting ‘abstract objects’ (p. 50) – 7. An attempt of classification: semantically and formally related agglutinated nouns in French creoles (p. 53) – 7.1. Semantic and formal correspondences (p. 53) – 7.2. Class 1 (p. 54) – 7.3. Unique referents (p. 56) – 7.4. Class 2 and 3 (p. 58) – 8. A noun-class principle (p. 60) – 9. African lan- guages (p. 62) 4. Case Study 2: The Encoding of Non-prototypical Adjectives 65 in French-based Creoles 1. The lexical reiteration constructions and TAM system in Carib- bean French-based creoles (reiteration vs. reduplication) (p. 65) – 5 L. Tramutoli , ‘Abstract Objects’ in Creole Languages. A Study on Guadeloupean Creole and Other French-based Creoles Milano, LED, 2021 - ISBN 978-88-7916-955-4 - https://www.ledonline.it/Il-Segno-le-Lettere/955-Creole-languages.html Contents 2. Predicate reiteration in Haitian and other Lesser Antillean creoles (p. 67) – 2.1. Syntactic types of predicate reiteration (p. 67) – 2.2. Predicate-cognate objects (p. 69) – 2.3. The multifunctionality of verb-cognate reiteration constructions (p. 70) – 2.4. The aspec- tual-evaluative function (p. 72) – 3. Compatibility of reiteration con- structions with adjectival predicates (p. 74) – 3.1. Verbs and adjec- tives (p. 74) – 3.2. Individual-level properties and stage-level proper- ties (p. 76) – 3.3. Semantic types of properties (p. 77) – 4. Degree achievement with imperfective marker (p. 78) – 5. Compatibility of individual-level properties ‘adjectives’ with intensive reiteration constructions (p. 80) – 5.1. Intensification of ‘adjectives’ (p. 80) – 5.2. Compatibility with intensive modifier bon (p. 81) – 6. Com- patibility of individual-level properties ‘adjectives’ with attenuative reiteration constructions (p. 83) – 6.1. Strategies to express attenu- ation of a property (p. 83) – 6.2. Yon ti (p. 84) – 6.3. Reiteration constructions with yon ti to express completion and attenuation (p. 85) – 6.4. Compatibility of yon ti with property predicates (p. 86) 5. Case Study 3: The ‘Fact Type’ Complementizer 89 in Guadeloupean Creole 1. Complementizers in Creole languages (p. 89) – 2. Complement types and complement-taking predicates (p. 91) – 2.1. Fact type, activity type and potential type complements (p. 91) – 2.2. The complement-taking predicates (p. 94) – 3. The syntax of the fact- type and potential-type completive clause in Guadeloupean Creole (p. 97) – 3.1. The distribution of the forms of complementizers (p. 97) – 3.2. The distribution of TAM markers on the main and completive verbs (p. 102) – 3.3. Subject coreference (p. 104) 6. Conclusions 107 Bibliography 109 Acknowledgements 129 6 L. Tramutoli , ‘Abstract Objects’ in Creole Languages. A Study on Guadeloupean Creole and Other French-based Creoles Milano, LED, 2021 - ISBN 978-88-7916-955-4 - https://www.ledonline.it/Il-Segno-le-Lettere/955-Creole-languages.html For Giovanna, Roberto and Chiara L. Tramutoli , ‘Abstract Objects’ in Creole Languages. A Study on Guadeloupean Creole and Other French-based Creoles Milano, LED, 2021 - ISBN 978-88-7916-955-4 - https://www.ledonline.it/Il-Segno-le-Lettere/955-Creole-languages.html L. Tramutoli , ‘Abstract Objects’ in Creole Languages. A Study on Guadeloupean Creole and Other French-based Creoles Milano, LED, 2021 - ISBN 978-88-7916-955-4 - https://www.ledonline.it/Il-Segno-le-Lettere/955-Creole-languages.html ABBREVIATIONS USED IN THE GLOSSES COMP complementizer COND conditional COP copula DEF definite DEM demonstrative DET determiner f feminine FUT future HAB habitual/continuative I.OBJ indirect object IMPV imperfective INDEF indefinite LOC locative m masculine NEG negation OBJ object POSS possessive PL plural PST past tense PFT perfective PROG progressive REL relative SG singular SPEC specific SUBJ subject SUBJv subjunctive 9 L. Tramutoli , ‘Abstract Objects’ in Creole Languages. A Study on Guadeloupean Creole and Other French-based Creoles Milano, LED, 2021 - ISBN 978-88-7916-955-4 - https://www.ledonline.it/Il-Segno-le-Lettere/955-Creole-languages.html L. Tramutoli , ‘Abstract Objects’ in Creole Languages. A Study on Guadeloupean Creole and Other French-based Creoles Milano, LED, 2021 - ISBN 978-88-7916-955-4 - https://www.ledonline.it/Il-Segno-le-Lettere/955-Creole-languages.html INTRODUCTION The abstract/concrete distinction is still an open challenge for contempo- rary philosophy. There is no doubt that this couple of opposite concepts constitutes one of the essential instruments through which the human mind categorizes reality, but it is difficult to put a finger on what it is exactly that determines such dichotomy, or, in other words, by which epis- temological, metaphysical or cognitive basis an entity can be categorized as concrete or abstract. For instance, although it seems straightforward to sort items such as man, chair or ball as concrete, and items such as unicorn or numbers as abstract, the decision can be more contentious for entities such as wind, music or the colour white, with the result that their categori- zation is mainly played on intuition. In the metaphysical research, abstract has been described on various accounts. In the first place, Frege envisages abstractness as a negative con- cept since it only exists as the lack of concreteness. Concrete objects are those belonging to the physical and sensory world and they are of immedi- ate knowledge and conceptualization, while an abstract object is charac- terised by the absence of one or more properties which paradigmatically define a concrete object, such as spatiality (boundedness in time and space) or causal efficacy, being able to be only conceived without being experi- enced. Secondly, for Quine, abstract is paired with the concept of universal, as its counterpart