united nations secuirty council
Berkeley Model United Nations Welcome Letter Hello! My name is Marine Fujisawa, and I will be your Security Council head chair for BMUN LXIV! I am currently a senior studying Political Science and Economics at UC Berkeley. I grew up in Southern California, so some of my favorite pastimes include hiking and going to the beach. I also recently got into cooking during my free time in quarantine- if anyone has good recipes, please let me know! started off my journey in BMUN as a vice chair in Security Council when I was a freshman, so being able to chair this committee now is very sentimental to me. Security Council had been one of my favorite committees to participate in as a delegate, as it discussed some of the most pertinent issues of the world at the time. SC is arguably the most powerful UN committee due to its power to mobilize peacekeepers and make binding resolutions, pushing the delegates to explore a wide range of solutions. I am so excited to hear about all of your ideas, and cannot wait to chair this committee in March! Here is a bit about your vice chairs: Sora Kanosue is currently a sophomore studying Computer Science and Economics here at Berkeley, and will be serving as a Vice Chair on this year’s Security Council. As a child of a UN employee, he grew up all over the world, but went to high school in New York and is happy to call the city home. His hobbies include tennis and squash, and in his free time enjoys playing video games. This is Sora’s sixth year doing Model UN, and his second chairing at BMUN. With its unique structure and the dynamics surrounding its P5 members, he always enjoyed participating in Security Council committees as a delegate. As one of the most powerful UN bodies, debate never failed to feel meaningful and consequential. He can’t wait to see what kind of solutions delegates come up with and is looking forward to the lively debate that is sure to happen in March! (although not so Yasamine Durali is a new member to BMUN. She is currently a senior studying legal studies and human rights, and is one of the Security Council Vice Chairs this year. After graduation, Yasamine hopes to incorporate my passions for international human rights, global peace and security, and immigration / refugee resettlement into a career in D.C. She grew up in Pennsylvania for the majority of my childhood, but then moved to Southern California when she was ten years old and she hasn’t BERKELEY MODEL UNITED NATIONS 1 left since! Outside of school, Yasamine loves spending time outdoors, cooking and baking, reading, Capitol Hill experience and join a community of fellow Berkeley students equally as passionate about IR as me. As a Muslim woman, Sudan Uprising was a huge issue in my community. Last summer on that delivered humanitarian assistance to Sudan, which eventually gained bipartisan support. She is very passionate about foreign policy in the MENA, so working in the Security Council this semester on Sudan’s Transition to Democracy feels like a full circle moment for her. She is very excited to be a part of BMUN this year and to make so many new friends!
BERKELEY MODEL UNITED NATIONS 2 Topic A: Sudan Transition to Democracy
Image 1: Celebrations for the Aug. 4 Deal, https://www.bbc.com/news/world-africa-49425702
In April 2019, Sudan experienced a revolution that led to the removal of former president tipped over the tensions that were rising due to the increasingly deteriorating economic conditions at the time. These protests quickly spread from the origin city of Atbara to the capital city of Civil War, called the Second Sudanese Civil War, began in 1983 when an army battalion led by Colonel John Garang de Mabior formed the SPLA to overthrow the government at the time due to of then-President Nimeiri. Afterwards, Bashir, who was a lieutenant general at the time, seized power and became the President of Sudan in 1993. During his presidency, he oversaw long and endless periods of violence- from the Civil War that killed around 2 million people during the beginning of
BERKELEY MODEL UNITED NATIONS 3 which started as a revolt against the cruel treatment of the non-Arabs of the region, soon escalated including charges of genocide and crimes against humanity, for the government’s actions in the arrest warrant, although this did not prevent him from regaining the seat of President in the following elections. Although mass protests against former President Bashir started in December of 2018, tensions had been mounting since January of that year, after the price of bread began to rise due was spent on security, and Bashir’s poor humanitarian track record made debt relief and obtaining Although the government cracked down on these prior protests, the protests that began in late 2018 spread rapidly. Footage and interviews from Sudan during this time revealed that this protest such as Facebook and Twitter, young activists in Sudan have used these platforms to spread video footage of brutality from security personnel on peaceful protests, further showcasing the cruelty of While many predicted that the Sudanese revolution would prove unsuccessful due to the numerous years of oppression and dismantling of civil society, the protesters were determined. The 2019 uprising was unprecedented in terms of scale- people from all regions and classes took to including doctors, lawyers, teachers, and journalists, soon became the driving force behind the movement. The SPA, along with several other groups, signed the Declaration of Freedom and Change on January 1st, 2019. This called for the removal of Bashir, to be replaced by a transitional BERKELEY MODEL UNITED NATIONS 4 as strikes and sit-ins among these professionals and other Sudanese citizens garnered widespread support, and soon the state declared a state of emergency in February of 2019. Bashir responded with both intimidation and violence- the government made sweeping arrests, and many protesters were shot. Bashir also moved to sack members of his cabinet as well as regional governors and rulers reached the military headquarters in Khartoum, where protesters sat in and demanded for the removal of Bashir. Five days later on April 11th, the military complied- and Bashir was overthrown this military council took power after the removal of the former President. The Transitional Military military generals. There have been violent clashes between the protestors and the TMC; the military that followed, and 181 people were hurt during this pro-democracy protest against military rule, protest to occur since Bashir lost power. Although negotiations continued between the military and civilians, issues of trust and power-sharing loomed large. With shutdowns of the SPA’s press conferences and violence towards protesters, civilian leaders remained wary towards the military After long talks, the FCC and the military signed a constitutional declaration on August 4th to form a transitional government in Sudan. The agreement entails a 39-month long power sharing arrangement, ensuing elections and the formation of a sovereign council, cabinet, and legislative body, among other things. The head of the sovereign council will be chosen from the military for sure there is adequate time to ensure free and fair elections. BERKELEY MODEL UNITED NATIONS 5 The Transitional Government
The transition has not been an easy one. The transitional government that the constitutional declaration established includes the sovereign council, a cabinet of ministers that are to be appointed by the sovereign council, the legislative council, and new judicial bodies. The Sovereign this body is currently chaired by Lt. Gen. Burhan. The composition of the legislative council has yet There have already been steps of progress under the transitional government. In the judicial system, Justice Minister Nasredeen Abdulbari has been working tirelessly to reform Sudan’s laws in government. The constitutional declaration signed allocates around 40 percent of council seats for women. Women played a key role in the Sudanese revolution, rushing to the streets to protest Bashir’s rule, and this was seen as a victory for the advancement of women’s rights and opportunities Despite this, there is still a long path ahead. Power-sharing within the transitional government still remains a struggle between the military and civilians, which comes as little surprise considering the role of leading Sudan towards a democratic future. He was formerly an economist working with his expertise would allow Sudan’s economy to rebuild itself and head towards a peaceful future. However, he has faced multiple obstacles, with opposition from pro-Bashir forces and from the still lies within the political sphere of Sudan. Power-sharing also remains a sensitive issue between the military generals and civilian leaders in positions of power outside the sovereign council. In particular, Sudan’s foreign minister raised concern about Gen. al-Burhan’s meeting with the Israeli prime minister, as foreign affairs
BERKELEY MODEL UNITED NATIONS 6 between the military and the civilian government, as they disagree on how the virus should be Furthermore, a coalition of Sudanese Women’s Rights Groups criticized the transitional government for not upholding the constitution to implement participation of women in the it is important that there are practical ways to select and elect these women legislators, as well as ensuring that they wield the same authority as their male counterparts in government. It would behoove the transitional government to have a clear methodology in achieving their goals. of forming a Legislative Council and appointing civilian governors after a meeting with the FCC that the revolution worked for. While the transitional government has been trying to make progress in various areas of Sudan, it still needs strong support and direction. Meeting the aims of the government would require a build-up of actionable items and plans while meeting challenges that may arise during the transitional period. It is important that the transitional government is able to lay the groundwork for the coming elections and ensuing Sudanese democracy.
International Response
While most African and Western countries supported the protesters and the ensuing civilian- led government, it appears that Saudi Arabia, Egypt, and the United Arab Emirates backed the with the crown prince of Saudi Arabia in June 2019 about their support of the Saudis in Yemen. After the June 3rd massacre, the African Union suspended Sudan’s membership in its BERKELEY MODEL UNITED NATIONS 7 organization. It called for the establishment of a civilian-led transitional government, and after the military and the FCC came to an agreement with mediation from the AU and Ethiopia, Sudan was The United Nations Security Council has made clear commitment to helping the Sudanese Lacroix, expressed that much peacekeeping aid would be necessary to stabilize the situation in Darfur, or UNAMID, resides in Sudan. UNAMID was set to depart Sudan in October of 2020, but the would be helpful in the near-future for a peacekeeping presence to not only assist Darfur but also a safe and nonviolent transition in Sudan. Furthermore, the UNSC adopted resolution 2524 in June 2020. This establishes a new United aims to achieve a myriad of objectives- from assistance in the Constitution drafting process to Security Council hopes to implement this body by January 1st, 2021. Additionally, the exact geographical location of deployment for members in UNITAMS is still to be determined. The divided support in Sudan for this new mission could complicate its operations. While Sudan’s UN ambassador, on behalf of Prime Minister Hamdok, penned a letter to the UN Secretary- General expressing enthusiasm for UN cooperations with implementing the Constitutional generals prompted a new letter- which did not include anything about the reforms outlined in the previous letter. To make matters worse, even power struggles exist within the military also. The New York Times reports that the regular military has long tried to diminish Hemeti’s power, as he has division within the Sovereign Council on the exact policies Sudan will pursue.
BERKELEY MODEL UNITED NATIONS 8 Current Obstacles in Sudan Economic Crisis
Sudan currently faces an immense economic crisis. Its cost of living has been rising steadily, with commodities such as bread and fuel soaring to unaffordable levels. Furthermore, the amount Furthermore, the economic crisis has enlarged the pool of people needing humanitarian assistance International actors have intervened to aid Sudan. At a meeting sponsored by the United Nations, the European Union, and German government in June 2020 called the “Partners Forum for the lifting of subsidies, which can be a wildly unpopular move for the government considering government lifted some subsidies on commodities. Furthermore, the United States still lists Sudan of funds is detrimental to Sudan’s progress. Funds are necessary to investigate the human rights violations committed against protesters, to foster stability, and to implement institutional changes in the government. Sudan’s Information Minister Faisal Salih attests that outside aid is critical to Some forces in the FCC, however, argue that Sudan can overcome this crisis by focusing on internal structures- such as reversing the money lost to corruption under Bashir and greatly reducing its own people, leaders hope to see spending cut and reinvested into other sectors of life to improve the economy. This would be a tough challenge to face, seeing as how many members of the military
BERKELEY MODEL UNITED NATIONS 9 The wave of COVID-19 sent a struggling Sudan into a deeper spiral. COVID has disrupted within the government to start solidifying economic reforms (https://www.worldpoliticsreview.com/ pushing back much needed reforms within Sudan could be detrimental to the success of the transitional government and the eventual elections.
Extradition
Protesters have called for justice on the numerous counts of senseless violence that both direction, as sudanese leaders such as Prime Minister Hamdok have expressed their commitment to cooperating with the ICC to bring Barshir to justice. However, the process as a whole is complicated by the fact that the forces who had committed other crimes still remain in power today. General Mohamed Hamdan Dagalo, also known as Hemeti, has a seat on the Sovereign Council and leads partook in the atrocities committed at Darfur. Furthermore, this group was responsible for the June 3rd massacre mentioned previously; thus, demands for reparations and justice for victims are directed to those still in power also. The RSF is responsible for the nation’s COVID response, and The New Humanitarian, this complicates the work of human rights lawyers who already operate on low funds to investigate the massacre from last year. Sudan has a lack of experience in ensuring an independent and transparent trial, especially for human rights violations committed by those who accountability much more complicated.