DECLASSIFIED-PUBLIC DISCLOSURE IMSM-0462-02 DECLASSIFIE-MISE EN LECTURE PUBLIQUE A N IN DA W i ETN, PI 1$67 APRIL ■WGi MEETING, CHAIRMAN * CHAIRMAN1 INTRODUCED.SITUATION .GROUP BY REPORT CEPS P 67 APR f >. IN' RES IN' PON >. PR S. O T A N TO RUEPDA/NAMILCOM MCREPFM BT TDE AND THAT WOULD THaY STUDIES FORM OF.EXAMINATI PART EEECS () F7 WD/4 lB> (WGDD/14 GFU7) (A) REFERENCES: ACEX. lOT A BE OETK B EVENTS,. CHAIRMAN BY GROUP HAD CAPS SEVAN OF OVERTAKE BAENRlPORT OF, S.EVAK>• -(REFV,(A) OSBa ESRS HC CUD A.AE, HP RP STATED MEASURES WHICH COULD RAP. BA SHAPE.TAKEN, POSSIBLa A D D O C RF ( ), DE TA SAE TF WR I PROCESS ADDED WARE IN THAT STAFF SHAPE E )),,H (B WARDED (REF. TO MC DEVELOPEDy THAT GROUP OF REPLIED THA REPLIED NO REFPSH/ INFO H T MNMM IIAY EIEET HAD ‘ RETIREMENT DEVELGPED ANDTHAT MINIMUMBAEN FOR­ A MILITARY . • UBJE I ORI S 15-00 C T I ; RaÜUIRJEMENT ; AL FOR IS T 1 ‘ M W ‘ * V ^ Y- A T S S IIAY TDE B AFCENT AND HAD FURTHER BY SHAPE STUDIES MILITARY R C A O .. RPS QUE RAP’S U.S., TOA ACEUÏÏ A COO 7894tCiOCOM A O UCLA L C NATOU FOR C SCLOSURE R U S O L C IS D IC L B U P R O F D E V O R P P A S IT* T I l VN A CNIEIG HS MILITARY WAS CONSIDERING THESEEVEN ■ - f T û ? l | | RAE A LTIA FR CEPS,, FOR I AS ILIT ERNATE FAÇ S uy= IN AD WHETHER TOTION S HAPTO 3902 ■y a a ERDDNT ASED SPE LA C N NATOU REGRADED : (Approved (Approved for Piio^t. Disclosure) : TF CMUIAIN DIV COMMUNICATIONSSTAFF --- «»ElüSli *■ d / f " ’ " f / d O 1 - O CERTAIN OF N S ITUATION. I SION DECLASSIFIED-PUBLIC DISCLOSURE IMSM-0462-02 DECLASSIFIE-MISE EN LECTURE PUBLIQUE o U. o. j !j n FACILITIES, FOR MOVEMENT FACILITIES, BOTH OF CRUDE PRODUCTS, AND STATED,! FINISHED n ' J _ ' ' C PG''0 SI CM S PAGl'5'`0F j f f . . ■ î • ■ . , . | ` ANALYSING ALTuE ERN AT GROUP BYI IV OF ES . j . f Y ____ l d T IÇ iJy N WE IN 'iSJSy SINÇE MAIN-ROHRLEITUNG AND WANTED LINE tRMü) TO KNOW WHETHER THI INFCNE ONT AD TA AL TES NY AR CUE I. ! TO'NATO ANDSIGNIFICANCE .THAT OTHERS ALL ONLY CARRY CRUDE OIL. CONSIDEREDWAS GROUP ONLY AND ONE BY SEVEN OF NATO BlING ILI M T UHRTE A BIG US BEINGAUTHORITIES AS iPID HT R IE S ONLY ONE WHICH,, THAT R IS RiiPLIED MR LINE CAN CARRY ` PRODUCTS O PSIL CAM GIS FAC AD HT UJC SOL,E | CLAIM AGAINST FRANCE AND SHOULD,BE POSSIBLE FOR THAT SUBJECT EWS UPRE B UK RP WHO REP, ADDED, HE'WAS SUPPORTED U.K. THAT BY ONLY WGl ROUGH NEEDS E rL THAT Fr.LTHE RWR OFFER H ü. AO -HS ,OT POL M, ! ORDER MAGNITUDE OF COST OF TO CONSTRUCT ALTERNATE FACILITIE WHlür.. NATO'-'HAS.,MOST.PROBLEMS, .. E, AND ADDED REP, THA U.K. THAT COULD WGi MATTER FiLT NOT GERMAN FURTHER THIS PURSUE 4. tP, R » ICSE I DTI B I R/OREN US RP AGREED WITH REP, IN FRA/FOURTEEN. BY U.S. DETAIL INDISCUSSED M I NEAR FUTURE, MCO IN A MJR OTO O SStS lEOPD IC 159 A REN | HAT MAJOR. 1S5PORTION DlVELOPPED WAS 9 SINCE RHEIN-'OF SYSTtMS 4 , 1 T R A P S . R tP ., REFERRING lû lû REFERRING ., tP R . TU S E N EUROPETERN A ATION REPORT ON C A . FOR L B U P R O F D E V O R P P . S POTEN l T FUL NATTONS OTHER THAN SHOULD SEVEN 'RECEIVE S O AO CARA CP GOP F EE j TO NATO. CHAIRMAN GROUP CEPS SEVEN OF At&T N ET O AT PARAGRAPH LAST TO NEXT IN ÏAÎtM&NT T S AIISJ AO N COSS RA | NATO; JO AND CROSSES AREAIALITIES REGARDS CAPACITY AND .REFINERY I O SCLOSURE R U S O L C IS D C SDRBE PROGRESNSIDERABLE S V N ANDEVEN WOULD FORWARD THEM ] mi / a ia Îm ^ S EN NADE BEING cns vi i is iv d s n ' ;c S IE | LINE S ! . C

a | Ba T R ; ARY o n | 1 Î DECLASSIFIED-PUBLIC DISCLOSURE IMSM-0462-02 DECLASSIFIE-MISE EN LECTURE PUBLIQUE j INFORMaD DAVELOPMANTS OF AS j -■| ! INVOLVED | | QOE W AE CONCERNED LAST THE ONk OF WITH ARE WE QUOTE: HlRE , : GROUP. S OF A U B. EE UE NTOS H NTFE HIMN G TA 1 ■ NOTIFIED HE NATIONS, USER CHAIRMAN BY. SEVEN UP THATSAX WGi CHAIRMAN ADDED GROUP SEVEN OF CEPS GROUP 5, .THAT WAS WHEN HIS LE TMEIG A O WS WR E SE) H SAE I WS AE | WAS PAPER IT STATED HAD WAS HE AT.MEETING AWARE OR EX ELSE 1STED), S M ■ ’ UHRTE CUD RCS TER EURMNS HOG NRA ; REQUIREMENTS COULD THROUGH THEIR AUTHORITIES PROCESS NORMAL a THAT 'AGREE- FELT HE HOST WITH AND NATIONS SEVEN. TO REPORT BACK . S RP TA MD FLOIG SAEET HC H DSRBTD ! MAMBER MEETING:TO ALL AFTER THAN MADE FOLLOWING. REP, STATEMENT .S. DISTRIBUTED U WHICH HE w. | AUTHORITIESNATO - MILITARY | CONTAINED PROPOSALS TO.EXAMINE THEREIN FORWARD PUT Hi'HAD FOR AND HAD HE INVITED SEVEN THAT^DISCUSSION OF ÜUATION ON WHAT RAP'S WA U.S. TO REPLY TECHNICAL IN SUB-GROUP. NORWEGIAN R INTEREST. INFRASTRUCTURE;PROCEDURE. AND FUND OBTAIN E T F SR AIN WUD E EURD EOE AO IIAY | NATO NATIONS BEFORE WOULD MILITARY REQUIREDMENT USER OF BE TES S HY AE P H ADD HT RU O SVN A NT ^ ADDED HE THAT WAS NOT GROUP CAME A THaY SEVEN UP. OF AS ATTERS AU O- NEI MAUE R HR TR PA PPR WIH O N | TATUS OF- ONE (WHICHNO MEASURE OR SHORT TERM PAPER INTERIM PLAN ' ' j ' ' ' , . ' i ' ' . ■ ÏH c RBES ] PROBLEMS V a WUD EOT O G O BDGAY N IFATUTR ! WOULDN ON BUDEGTARY WGI TO REPORT AND INFRASTRUCTURE ^ a P, STATEDTHAT FOURTEEN SHOULD St. T ! ' A i WR PLTCL IMPLICATIONS HARiL POLITICAL WlRE S - | , i ■ ' j ' r M JR READJUST- AJOR K a PT ' S | 1 j \ i i DECLASSIFIED-PUBLIC DISCLOSURE IMSM-04S2-Q2 DECLASSIFIE-MISE EN LECTURE PUBLIQUE DA T ■ t , ■ ' `ARi QObiCiRHtQ' HiRù QObiCiRHtQ' `ARi O NATOFOR ^T RWIE A A C A AS RtWUIRED l^NTS N E . i ANCE-. m AND BECAUSE RtADdUSTMENT THI IN T IIAY EURMNS Y HP AD H MLTR CMITE' N HS ! THIS COMMITTEE.' IN AND MILITARY SHAPE REQUIREMENTS THE BY MILITARY PROGRAM,.' MU I READJU m COMMUNICATIONS DIVISION STAFF DISCLOSURE PUBLIC FOR ARMY OFTHE DEPARTMENT APPROACHES TO THIS PROBLEM NOW UNDERWAY' ARE'-BASED ON THE MILITaI MILITaI PROBLEMAPPROACHES NOW THIS TO UNDERWAY' ARE'-BASED ON THE LSL RLTDT ASS RELATED'TOCLOStLY EIL QUESTION AT GENIAL ilXPLOREP BEF REQ.UIREMENTS WHICH1 NATIONAL. COMMUNICATE AUTHORITIES TO XSIG R LNE CMECA FCLTE SOL B CRFLY J CAREFULLY SHOULD BE OR PLANNED COMMERCIAL EXISTING FACILITIES . H FRT TP HUD E TOOG REAUTO O | THOROUGH A SHOULD REEVALUATION OF BE STEP FIRST THE 1. CONNECTI | ■ • l • ■ E FA HE AO W BLV, 'WVR TA AL OSSIBILITIE H'QWEVERj PO THAT ALL BELIVE, NATO, WE UHRTE TIK HT H LGCL EUNE F.U j SEQUENCE THAT OF LOGICAL THINK THE.OUR AUTHORITIES n 150027 C S IL IT IE S REQUIRED WILL' ALMOST WILL' CERTAINL REQUIRED S IE IT IL TMENT WI O N U SE OF P IP lL lN t t lN lL IP P OF SE , 1 UNDER .1 T O E tFFECTiVlNcS HE S 1 WE -COMMITRE LONG CONSTRUCTION OURSELVES TO A 'TIME -MHSZ TA -H US HS O OIIN N HS | THAT ONT-EMPHASIZE HAS' THIS NO.-THE POSITION U.S. T RSET O O FCLTE' I FACILITIES' TO POL RESPECT H WITH S S AE IL NOV MKN, E ARNEET j MAKING, INVOLVE NEW WILL CASE ARRANGEMENTS FOR C SCLOSURE R U S O L C IS D IC L B U P R O F D E V O R P P A T AD Ta TE IIAY STUDIE TAND,THaT MILITARY THE O HI NSEQUENCE FRENCH.' THL OF INITIATIVE, U E AALBLT O PiiTR OF AVAILABILITY RED S IE j TIME/ A AI RAJSMN O TEH'HS IMPORT• READJUSTMENT THE'Hl'GHEST OF BASIC S OA E AIIIS USD FRANCE, OUTSIDE TORAGE FACILITIES S F U MLTR F OUR OF MILITARY Y IPDHS AE O E CON BE HAVE TO S ‘PAtjE" 4- A 0 O RC..S IS IS RC..S lM PRODUCTS, WE LlüM S i . S ! FOLLOWS: F LENTV | ALTERNATIVE OF S F TLZN i UTILIZING OF S S AE I HAPE. O S S TRUCTED` M O j OME OF DECLASSIFIED-PUBLIC DISCLOSURE IMSM-04S2-Q2 DECLASSIFIE-MISE EN LECTURE PUBLIQUE ■ i ■ • : - < J . ' | . ' . . 1 REQUIREMENT I I A m m A, I RQIEET i .1 REQUIREMENTS ji | DI J MUMS'OF ALTERNATIVE ALL OF ' I ■ ‘CHANGES- THINGS, OïHtR WHI f I FCLTE I TER COUNTRIES, j -THEIR IN NATO TO'MEET STORAGE AND DISTRIBUTION j FACILITIES j . IN COLLABORATION PRIVATE NETHERLANDS'TO WITH PREPARE. STUDIES j J t ' ■ t j CONS OF ID ARAD MOREOVER, TO, THAT POSSIBILITY WA DATE. THE THINK MAKa TÜ SOM I ADJUSTMENT AUTHORITIES, a | NaAD F THE I I r _

.. ______...... BRI HT HS RÉÉVALUATION SH THAT THIS E V IE R ‘B aA. HOWEVER REQUIREMENTS REEVALUATION THE MAYSaVAN. OF WE,THINK SUGGE A S• A EONZ MC PEIIAY TD O ATRAIE HS i MAN HAS WA • RECOGNIZE MUCH ALTERNATIVES OFIS STUDY PRELIMINARY LE D BE UDRAE'Y H MLTR ATOIIS AND GROUP THE | OF AUTHORITIES ALREADY UNDERTAKEN'BY BAEN MILITARY THE . A'RPS TA WRIG RU OE NIE HS CUTIS | WA COUNTRIES THAT'PROPOSE THOSE A. WORKING GROUP ONE INVITE IH OMRIL ERLU ITUtT>N EMN, EGU AD H j COMMERCIALWITH GERMANY, AND THE BELGIUM PETROLEUM INTiUïtSTS>IN X MN DAD EPOOE HS E OE N THE DONE EXAMINED-AND IN BE THIS WE.PROPOSE EATET ' Ti AM APPROVED PUBLI SCLOSURE T- C STA-, E R U S O L C IS D IC L B U P R O F D E V O R P P A ARMY Tri- O'- DEPARTMENT MAKING .MAXIMUM, U 3 N ATRAIE O N MLTR CON AN'A3 ANY MILITARY TO ALTERNATIVE S RBTR.N H FAIIIY F EMPLOYING OF FEASIBILITY THATRIBUTORS.ON ...... S C N , SE, EeIV, SHOULD Be ECOND, WEBeLIEVE, STEP, O S Tl RU O SVN I CLAOAIN IH H MLTR : COLLABORATION MILITARY IN THE WITH GROUP SAVEN, OF THl R WERE DEVELOPED, ™~ . S .. OF. PLANNEDE OR PR0^ ACTED COMMERCIAL FA . ^* FOR C DI E R U S O L C IS D IC L B U P R O F D E V O R P P A C HV ARAY eN AE IC THE MADE HAVa ALRaADY BeENH SINCE S TSYN, CURRENATISFYING, ^ . — - O ' L TK IT ACCOUN INTO TAKEULD S N H ALTERNATIVE THE IN S R CIN HUD E UTE | TRUCTION FURTHER SHOULD BE a

THOROUGH EXAMINATION F T L O IG ANR j OLLOWING MANNER: C AND REQUIRE PROJECTED - M E CA. ! OMMERCIAL. 0 1CAT10NS^ IVIS N D U m ¥ T . S C HY AE | HAVE THEY AMONG LI ES | S IE IT IL IO " N S jT I \ DECLASSIFIED-PUBLIC DISCLOSURE IMSM-04S2-Q2 DECLASSIFIE-MISE EN LECTURE PUBLIQUE . NQRÜAL-JI’-RQ.C.EDU.RE ^ i ^ • ..S«. ,U LÏS OF THLSi. STUDIES, = STUDIES, BE CQULD THLSi. OF LÏS ,U ..S«. A N 1 IN DA REQ I HOP^-THAT WE CAN ALL REE ON THIS PROCEDURE. I ALSO SUGGEST SUGGEST ALSO I PROCEDURE. THIS ON REE ALL CAN WE HOP^-THAT I MILITARY REQUIREMENTS. Wl'WOULD THEN SUBMIT' OUR RECOMMENDATI.ONS TO THE THE RECOMMENDATI.ONS TO OUR SUBMIT' THEN Wl'WOULD REQUIREMENTS. MILITARY THAT WE IN V IT E SHAPE TO B R IE F US IN DETAIL AT AN EARLY MEETING ON THE THE ON MEETING EARLY AN AT DETAIL IN US F IE R B TO SHAPE E IT V IN WE THAT C OL REAUT AE EURMNS S HS A UDRTO T BE TO UNDERSTOOD WAS THIS AS REQUIREMRNTS ACE REEVALUATE WOULDMC NOTE: aÜ N1| SC FACI TI GL CNEUNL HV T B N OF‘ ONE BE TO HAVE CONSEQUENTLY WGULÖ S IE IT IL C A HaRÜENI1>|G F SUCH VARIOUS CONSIDERATIONS THAT ENTER■IWTO THE MILITARY ASSESSMENTIOF ASSESSMENTIOF MILITARY THE ENTER■IWTO THAT CONSIDERATIONS VARIOUS | HAS CONSIDERATION SOME THAT E LI2 EA R I S E I T I L I C A F COMMERCIAL G IN ILIZ T U EYN ON RELYING ALREADY BEEN GIVEN TO THIS UUESTION AND ALSO R EA LIZE THAT THERE THERE THAT LIZE EA R ALSO AND UUESTION THIS TO GIVEN BEEN ALREADY FOURTEEN. ; THAT SEVEN OF I E•GROUP TO: TH GROUP'COULD IONS T THAT RECG&MiNDA pKEPARIN'G AND ALTERNATIVES R HGL VLEAL T N^ ATO*.TE BI TY OF^ECONOMICALLYj F O Y IT IL IB S A E F ACTION*-. THE TOaNE^Y VULNERABLE HIGHLY ARE ALTERNATIV O MIIAY OSRCIN j I STRESS IN CONSTRUCTION. ILITARY M FOR N RCNIIG H. VROS AINL EOMNAIN O CMECA | COMMERCIAL ON RECOMMENDATIONS NATIONAL THi.* VARIOUS RECONCILING AND OP o.' THE THIRD PHASE WOULD . BE FOR THIS ;’GROUP TO CONSIDER THE THE CONSIDER TO ;’GROUP THIS WOULD FOR . BE PHASE THIRD THE o.' s n o i t a t i m i l FOüKïitiN ETI IPRAT OSDRTOS HC LI T TE BI TY O ! OF Y IT IL IB S A E F THE IT IM L WHICH CONSIDERATIONS IMPORTANT CERTAIN IMPORTANT .FACTORS `TAKEN INTO. ACCOSNT. INTO. .FACTORS`TAKEN IMPORTANT .°r TH. C ji .N U N£D DO CMXTn C NAT COMMXTTün. tND£.D ADHOC ALICU CF IREM EN TS» UNQUOTE. TS» EN IREM .S. U ` i ` ' 5 OO XO XO 27 MG EIIAE PRIN F TTMN WIH ONE OT THAT OUT POINTED WHICH STATEMENT OF PORTION ELIMINATED . P E R t. ' 'i ' ' `t CMECA FACI TI O NT WRIE SE,' N O TEE { THESE OF ' ONE , US E WARTIME NATO FOR S IE IT IL C A F COMMERCIAL MEANS DEVELOPED BY THE GROUP OF 'SEVEN OF MEETING THE. THE. MEETING OF 'SEVEN OF GROUP THE BY DEVELOPED MEANS / . H DESI LI F TDIG BI TI F j OF S IE IT IL IB S S O P STUDYING OF Y IT IL B A IR S E D THE Bsl or fo

CONV£Ni-D S _ ____ M H FRS NST IN ST FIR THE e l p m a ______A A , , P __ T NATO IN uUNE WITH WITH uUNE IN NATO T IS D C I L B U P R O F D E V O R P s i ______. e h t

t c a f A ------C, EG' AG WEIGH' NCE,

TH t a h t RE a S MIJTJ BM SU N PR ES LNT C

- E R U S O L r i erc m m o c ---- A ® I R VI £W VI SAF COMMUNICATI rSTAFF 1 ------* j ■* A AT NT RPSL; j PROPOSALS; INST ü 1V i-.S CF T AN TO )

al TO

. ------s e i t i l i c a f à NI G IN IN ààM THE - O S DIVISION NS THE THE A j E i RE ---- -i j | DECLASSIFIED-PUBLIC DISCLOSURE IMSM-0462-02 DECLASSIFIE-MISE EN LECTURE PUBLIQUE A N I | IN JA | ■£ il W RC D R POOE B US WL B RQIE WE TI SBET S DISCUSS REQUIRED PROCEDURE BE IS WHEN SUBJECT WILL THIS PROPOSED U.S. BY . MCREP COMVENTi 9. MCTO OF POSITION MILITARY AUTHORITIES TO WITH RESPECT WGS NOTED . S SITUATION REPORT. BTR EN DOBEEN STATEMENT, OUT THAT POINTEJ CONSIDERABLE A AMOUNTENOUGH CHAIRMAN TASK. TO OF RESEARCH DO THIS REFERRING GROUP TO HAD CEPS U.S. SEEN, ALREAD GF T . INFRA/FOURTEEN, 0 NAMiLCOM N ;

my. £ ) O SALS ANOLHER,£j) TO ESTABLISH GROUP INFRA/ AS FOUR TEEN WERE CAPABLE 5 N OO -Y SEVEN COLLECTIVELYE-BY AND INDIVIDUALLY. 27

HU» A E UEU BT ETTEE WA FELT'THERE USEFUL BUT ES L D PUBL B U P R O F ED V O R P P C scfi COMMUN F F A T S E R Ü S iO f c is p IC L B U P I SCLOS O L C IS D C U E R PAGE 7 IC TOS DIVISION ATIONS S DECLASSIFIED-PUBLIC DISCLOSURE IMSM-0462-02 DECLASSIFIE-MISE EN LECTURE PUBLIQUE MESSAGE C FORM SCD MY 62 MAY J 35 etn te ltr rqieet. e ol te sbi our submit then We would requirements. ilitary m the meeting of studies ilitary m the SHAPE by and requirements ilitary m osdrtos ht ne it te ltr assmn of assessment ilitary m the into enter that considerations ge o ti poeue I lo ugs ta b ivt SHAPE invite be that suggest also I procedure. this on agree SHAPE. to communicate authorities lentv apoce t ti polm now are underway problem this to approaches alternative CIN NAM ACTION: U.S. by proposed procedure to respect with O E CORRECTIONS UNDERLINEDNOTE: 1 the made been since already have which changes NR NATO SECRET ee coleci y ad individually. that and out ly e pointed ctiv lle statement, o c Seven U.S. CEPS to Chairman task. referring SEEN, this do of group to enough capable were Fourteen h n hs ujc i dsusd by discussed is subject this when h atraie en dvlpd y h Gop f ee of Seven of Group the by means developed alternative the MCREPFROM: cnieal aon o rsac hd led be dn by done been already had research amount of considerable a t hr ws o ne t e a ish nte gop as group !i es s to tab another h need not was there lt e f PRIOR A N I INDA évlain hud ae int take should réévaluation eomnain t te oren I oe ht e a all can we that hope I Fourteen. the torecommendations o re U i dti a a ery etn o te various the on meeting early an at requi rements*11 detail in US brief to the onbased eurmns ee developed. were requirements ) ! i l H Ä s M I ® P M mmm : APp^d^i?^öRWifeT4Pe®©LosioRE OO 79 1 LOCOM 7894 I TY . emn e wloe US pooa as sfl but a_s useful proposal German welcomed Rep U.S. 7. . CE Cmet Psto o NT miiay authorities NATO ilitary of m MCREP Position Comment^ 9. . h tid hs wud e o ti gop o consider to group this for be would phase third The 3. lae orc pg 7 pr 7 o ed s follows: as read to 7 para 7, page correct Please lae orc pg 4 sbaa t ra a follows: as read to î subpara 4, page correct Please lae orc pg 6 sbaa t ra a follows: as read to 3 subpara 6, page correct Please lae orc page correct Please 5 . h fi tp hud e hog réauto of réévaluation through be should step t s ir f The 1.

OO 27 -.S I LCOM 1 6 miigf rqieet wih national which requirements fy ilitg m 966 FOR C SCLOSURE R U S O L C IS D IC L B U P R O F D E V O R P P A SUPPLEMENTA ‘

SUPPLEMENTARY COPY 1, o aa t ra a follows: as read to 9 para con, mn ohr things, among other account, R . COPYY I Infra/Fourteen. eiv ta this that believe n i f 40920 will e requied be AR 67 APRZ 966

I

nfra/