Archival Copy. This information is out of date. For current information, see the OSU Extension Catalog:https://catalog.extension.oregonstate.edu
EM 8838 • October 2003 $4.00
PROMOTING THE SAFETY OF NORTHWEST FRESH AND PROCESSED BERRIES
C.K. Bower, S. Stan, M. Daeschel, and Y. Zhao Archival Copy. This information is out of date. For current information, see the OSU Extension Catalog:https://catalog.extension.oregonstate.edu Contents
Introduction ...... 1 Berries and the Northwest economy ...... 1 Food-borne illnesses ...... 2 Providing safe berries ...... 3 Preharvest ...... 7 Risks of contamination in the field ...... 7 Producing safe berry crops ...... 8 Harvest Risks during harvest ...... 10 Harvesting safe berries ...... 11 Postharvest Food safety hazards in berry processing ...... 16 Keeping berries safe during processing ...... 18 Guidelines for preparing an HACCP plan for berry juice ...... 27 Resources ...... 31 References ...... 31 Glossary ...... 31 Resources and useful Web sites ...... 33
Prepared by Yanyun Zhao, associate professor and Extension specialist; Mark Daeschel, professor and Extension specialist in fruit and vegetable safety; Cindy K. Bower, former assistant professor in food science and technology; and Silvia Stan, graduate student in food science and technology; all of Oregon State University.
Partial funding for this publication was provided by USDA Cooperative State Research, Education, and Extension (Award # 2002-51110-01959). Archival Copy. This information is out of date. For current information, see the OSU Extension Catalog:https://catalog.extension.oregonstate.edu Promoting the Safety of Northwest Fresh and Processed Berries
Fresh and processed berries are a favor- Berries and the ite Northwest food. They contain many Northwest economy beneficial compounds, including vitamins, Oregon and Washington are major U.S. minerals, phytochemicals, and antioxi- producers of fresh-market and processed dants. They also are rich in dietary fiber. berries. Northwest raspberries, strawber- Berries of commercial importance for ries, grapes, blackberries, and blueberries Oregon and Washington include strawber- generated over $250 million in the year ries, raspberries, blueberries, blackberries, 2000 (including processed and value-added and grapes. Less common berry varieties products). The figure below illustrates the are gaining in popularity (e.g., huckleber- percentages of berries produced in a typi- ries, boysenberries, loganberries, black cal year in Oregon and Washington. raspberries, elderberries, chokecherries, Some berries are sold fresh, but most are gooseberries, lingonberries, salal, and destined for processing. Berries can be numerous blackberry hybrids). frozen in the container (straight pack), Technically, a “berry” is a stoneless, individually quick frozen (IQF), canned, pulpy fruit that contains one or more drum-dried, freeze-dried, prepared as embedded seeds. Using this botanically single strength or concentrated juices, or correct definition, grapes and blueberries crushed and pasteurized into purée. There would be considered true berries, while also is a market for berry essence (flavor- strawberries, blackberries, and raspberries ing), seeds, and seed oil. Popular value- (all aggregate fruits consisting of clusters of added products for Northwest berries either achenes or drupelets) would not. include jams, jellies, syrups, candies, and However, for the purpose of this publica- pastries. tion, the definition of a berry will be more loosely interpreted and will include all of 72% the above. Grapes
11% Raspberries 1% 6% 6% Other berries 5% Blackberries Strawberries Blueberries Berry production in the Pacific Northwest. Archival Copy. This information is out of date. For current information, see the OSU Extension Catalog:https://catalog.extension.oregonstate.edu
Food-borne illnesses (3.0–4.0), there is concern that berry juices American consumers enjoy one of the could carry food-borne illness. safest food supplies in the world, and Laboratory studies have shown that berries and processed berry products berry juices and purées can support generally have been considered safe from growth of bacteria such as E. coli O157:H7 pathogenic (disease-causing) bacteria and Salmonella spp. These findings suggest because of their high acid content. How- that berries and berry products, if contami- ever, fresh fruits have occasionally been nated, might harbor pathogenic organisms implicated in food-borne illnesses. Bacterial long enough to cause food-borne illness. pathogens such as Salmonella and Listeria The issue of product contamination is of monocytogenes have been isolated from special concern in the Northwest because fresh strawberries and frozen blueberries, manure fertilizers are being promoted for respectively. use in berry production by Oregon and Also, recent disease outbreaks caused by Washington farms. Escherichia coli O157:H7 and Salmonella spp. Viruses also can contaminate raw agri- in apple and orange juices have challenged cultural produce through contaminated the belief that high-acid foods cannot water and employees who do not observe harbor viable pathogenic bacteria. Due to good personal hygiene. Viruses can sur- the acidic similarity of berry juice (pH 3.0– vive in the soil for months and contami- 4.5), apple juice (3.0–4.0), and orange juice nate raw produce such as raspberries and strawberries. Examples of food-borne viruses are Hepatitis A and Norwalk virus.
Contamination of raw fruit Sources of contamination • Irrigation water • Soil/plants • Compost/ manure Vectors for contamination • Sewage • Animals (birds, insects, rodents) • Humans (harvesting, handling, and processing) Potential food-borne illnesses • Bacterial • Protozoal • Viral • Fungal
2 Archival Copy. This information is out of date. For current information, see the OSU Extension Catalog:https://catalog.extension.oregonstate.edu
8
7
6 ChardonnayChardonnay Juice juice PinotPinot NoirNoir Juice juice
Log CFU/ml RaspberryRaspberry Juice juice 5 StrawberryStrawberry Juice juice RaspberryRaspberry Puree purée Strawberry Puree 4 Strawberry purée 012345 Time (days) Survival of E. coli in berry fruit juice and purée.
Protozoan parasites such as Cyclospora, allergen, since patients with sensitivities to Giardia, and Cryptosporidium have been mold display a high frequency of specific found as contaminants on raw fruits. Fresh IgE antibodies to Botrytis (Karlsson-Borga raspberries and blackberries were the et al., 1989). suspected source of two Cyclospora Table 2 (page 5) shows reported food cayetanensis outbreaks (FDA, 2001b). safety hazards associated with fresh and Most people eventually recover from processed berries as well as juice. Note that food-borne illnesses. However, some indi- not all hazards are biological; contamina- viduals (e.g., children, the elderly, and the tion by chemicals or other materials also is immunocompromised) may suffer severe possible. These hazards are discussed complications, sometimes resulting in further under “Postharvest.” death. Table 1 (page 4) summarizes the illnesses Providing safe berries of most concern caused by microbial infec- A strategy that prevents the initial micro- tion in produce. bial contamination of berries is safer than Fungi are typical postharvest spoilage relying on corrective actions after contami- agents of fruits. Yeast and molds can con- nation has occurred. Because it is not taminate fresh produce. Some yeast may practical to eliminate all potential hazards start a fermentation process and produce associated with fresh produce, berry pro- alcohol, while molds can trigger human ducers and processors must rely on risk allergies or produce mycotoxins that can reduction rather than risk elimination. This lead to illness. Botrytis cinerea has been publication contains recommendations for isolated from soils of berry fields and is minimizing the risk of contamination responsible for “gray mold” and during the three key stages of production postharvest damage in a wide range of and processing—preharvest, harvest, and fruits (Samson and van Reenen-Hoekstra, postharvest. 1988; Williamson et al., 1992). Additionally, The Food and Drug Administration Botrytis has been classified as a human (FDA) has taken a leadership role in
continues on page 5 3 Archival Copy. This information is out of date. For current information, see the OSU Extension Catalog:https://catalog.extension.oregonstate.edu
Table 1.—Illnesses of most concern from microbial infection in fresh produce. Microorganisms Nature Contamination Food-borne illness E. coli O157:H7 • First recognized as human • Wild or domestic • Severe cramps, bloody (bacteria) pathogen in 1982. animals. diarrhea, vomiting, • Outbreaks often associated with • Improperly dehydration. undercooked ground beef. composted animal • Severe complications can • Outbreaks have involved lettuce, manure. include kidney failure, unpasteurized apple cider and • Fruits and vegetables strokes, seizures, and juice, radish sprouts, and alfalfa dropped on the sometimes painful death. sprouts. ground and contami- • Onset 3–9 days; lasts • Naturally exists in animals nated by manure. 2–9 days, unless there are without symptoms–cattle, sheep, • Water may carry and complications. deer, dogs, cats, other animals. spread organisms. • Can contaminate/grow on fresh • Farm and packing produce such as minimally house workers, any processed cantaloupe, water- food handlers, may melon cubes, shredded lettuce, contaminate produce. sliced cucumbers, and mesclun lettuce.
Salmonella • Comes from intestinal tracts of • Similar to E. coli • Nausea, vomiting, abdomi- species poultry, pigs, birds, and insects. nal cramps, diarrhea, fever, (bacteria) • Can be carried by humans. and headache. • Infective dose—a few cells to • Symptoms occur within millions. 12–48 hours and last • Isolated from many types of 2–6 days in healthy people. raw fruits and vegetables—not • May last weeks in a frequent event. immunocompromised • Outbreaks linked to tomatoes, people. bean sprouts, melons, and • Secondary problems such as unpasteurized orange juice and reactive arthritis or peri- apple juice. carditis may result in some patients.
Listeria • Widely distributed in nature: • Common environmen- • Flulike symptoms in healthy monocytogenes – In soil, sewage, freshwater tal contaminant. people. (bacteria) sediments Unlike most microor- • May progress to meningitis, – In silage, decaying plant ganisms, it grows blood poisoning, abortion in matter at refrigeration pregnant women, or death. – In animal intestinal tracts temperatures. Floor • Symptoms appear within • Animal carriers may not be sick. drains and wheel 1 day to 3 weeks. • Found in raw foods: condensate collects are • Duration depends on – Meats, unpasteurized milk frequent sources of treatment. – Vegetables contamination. • High fatality rate in immunocompromised individuals.
Hepatitis A • Excreted in feces by infected • Viruses can be trans- • Causes fever, nausea, (virus) individuals. mitted to plants and vomiting, abdominal • Can be carried by raw produce, fresh fruits and cramps, extreme fatigue, uncooked food. vegetables by people, jaundice. • Persists for weeks or months on tractors, equipment, • Onset 15–50 days after crops or soils. clippers, and insects. ingestion. • Hepatitis A on lettuce, raspber- • Lasts 1–2 weeks to months ries, and strawberries. in severe cases. 4 Archival Copy. This information is out of date. For current information, see the OSU Extension Catalog:https://catalog.extension.oregonstate.edu
Table 2.—Reported food safety hazards associated with fresh and processed berries. Type Hazard of hazard Product Reference Salmonella Biological Fresh strawberries Recall, 2000 (FDA Web site) Listeria monocytogenes Biological Frozen blueberries Recall, 1998 (FDA Web site) Hepatitis A Biological Frozen strawberries Recall, 2000 (FDA Web site) Hepatitis A Biological Frozen raspberries FDA, 2001 Calicivirus Biological Frozen raspberries FDA, 2001 Mold contamination Biological Cranberry–raspberry drink Anderson, 2001 Raspberry drink Cyclospora Biological Fresh raspberries (likely) FDA, 2001 cayetanensis Fresh blackberries (suspected) Triadimefon (pesticide) Chemical Fresh blackberries Recall, 1998 (FDA Web site) Cleaning solution Chemical Berry juice Anderson, 2001 Poisonous plant parts Chemical Elderberry juice Anderson, 2001
reexamining how fresh fruits are grown, Wildlife, pest, and vermin control harvested, stored, and processed. A Worker hygiene and field sanitation warning label is now required for nonpas- teurized fruit juices, and a guidance docu- Good Manufacturing Practices (GMPs) ment entitled “Guidelines to Minimize These guidelines describe practices for Microbial Food Safety Hazards for Fresh the safe manufacture of foods. They are Fruits and Vegetables” has been released. required by law (section 21 of Code of Below is an overview of some of the guid- Federal Regulations, part 110) and apply to ance documents available for food produc- all food manufacturing companies. GMPs ers and processors. are prescribed for four main areas of food processing: Good Agricultural Practices (GAPs) Personal hygiene to prevent the spread These voluntary practices for fresh fruits of illness were published by FDA (volume 63 of the Adequate buildings and facilities Federal Register, page 18029) to protect Sanitary food-contact surfaces raw agricultural commodities. The USDA (e.g., equipment and utensils) Federal–State Audit Program offers GAPs Process controls to prevent cross- audits, based on the Food and Drug contamination Administration’s “Guidelines to Minimize Microbial Food Safety Hazards for Fresh Sanitation Standard Operating Procedures Fruits and Vegetables.” Issues addressed (SSOPs) include: These are mandatory for all food pro- Site selection and adjacent land use cessing plants (21 CFR 120.6) subject to Purity of water source HACCP (see page 23). Although specific Fertilizer usage and pesticide protocols may vary from facility to facility, monitoring SSOPs provide step-by-step procedures to ensure sanitary handling of foods. These
5 Archival Copy. This information is out of date. For current information, see the OSU Extension Catalog:https://catalog.extension.oregonstate.edu
documents describe procedures for eight finished products. HACCP involves seven sanitation conditions: principles: Safety of water Identify possible food safety hazards. Cleanliness of utensils and equipment Determine critical control points. Prevention of cross-contamination Establish preventive measures. Hand-washing and toilet facilities Monitor the manufacturing process to Protection of food from contaminants detect hazards. Labeling, storage, and use of toxic Plan corrective actions. compounds Prepare a method to verify that the Monitoring employee health HACCP plan is working. Pest control Document the HACCP system by main- taining records. Hazard Analysis and Critical Control Points (HACCP) Good agricultural practices (GAPs) and These regulations are being developed good manufacturing practices (GMPs) by FDA to establish safety standards during growing, harvesting, washing, throughout the food industry. For berries, sorting, packing, and transporting of fresh they are required for juice products. The berries will minimize the microbial food program focuses on preventing hazards safety hazards. Developing specific step- that could cause food-borne illnesses. It by-step SSOP protocols and implementing relies on the application of science-based an HACCP program will further ensure the controls at all steps, from raw material to safety of fresh and processed products, from farm to market.