Personal copy; not for onward transmission
De Beers’ new td. pany L strategy om In what is described by its chairman, Instead, it aims to be the ‘supplier of Nicky Oppenheimer, as “one of the choice’. However, it currently sells ron & C most significant developments the dia- about two thirds of the world’s annual mond industry has seen since the supply of rough diamonds, and the Georgian House 1930s”, De Beers this week unveiled a mines that it manages contribute about oeb A 63, Coleman Street new strategy whereby it will abandon 40% of world production. Hence it L London EC2R 5BB Tel :+44 (0)20 7628-1128 its long-held role as custodian of the remains very much the dominant play- REGULATED BY THE SFA diamond market, and focus instead on er, and intends to continue to sell dia- boosting demand. Since the depression monds to selected clients through its years of the 1930s when the price of dia- regular sales or ‘sights’ held roughly monds slumped, De Beers has stock- every five weeks. piled the world’s surplus diamonds as a There will be some marked changes means of controlling supply (and though in how the sights are conducted. prices). Under the new strategy, the At present, they are characterised by stockpile is not being eliminated but it their opacity. The 125 selected will be substantially reduced – to a sightholders or diamantaires – it is esti- working level of around six months’ mated that as many as 900 diaman- supply, equivalent to some US$2.5 bil- taires are on the ‘waiting list’ – have no lion. According to Gareth Penny, the formal contract with De Beers, nor any De Beers executive mainly responsible control over the quality, quantity or the for developing the new strategy, the price of the ‘parcel’ of diamonds they working-stock level should be achieved are offered. De Beers decides what the towards the end of next year, or even market can absorb and customers are sooner. At the end of 1999, it stood at given their allocations accordingly on a US$3.9 billion. take-it-or-leave-it basis. As from July De Beers will no longer underwrite next year, legal contracts with the the market as a buyer of last resort. sightholders Continued on p.19
Establishment of the joint venture is subject to a number of conditions, of (Photograph courtesy of De Beers). Falconbridge which three are highlighted as key. First is the clarification of commercial joins in Gag arrangements with Aneka Tambang. The latter’s interest in Gag Island, a Inside The Canadian nickel producer seventh generation Contract of Work, Falconbridge Ltd is to join the Gag is currently described as 15% free-car- JOURNAL Island lateritic nickel project, in the ried and 10% loan carried, with an • Gold threat adds to eastern part of the Indonesian archipel- option to gain an additional 20% inter- Zimbabwe’s woes (p.23) London, ago, as project manager of a new joint est after 13 years of commercial opera- July 14, 2000 venture. Gag Island is currently held tion. Although publicly listed on the • Freeport’s copper shipments Volume 335 75% by Broken Hill Proprietary Co. Jakarta Stock Exchange, with a sec- No. 8591 Ltd (BHP) of Australia and 25% by ondary listing in Australia, Aneka fall (p.27) the Indonesian mining company PT Tambang is still controlled by the Aneka Tambang. Falconbridge will Indonesian Government which holds a • Analyst’s poll of forecast earn a 37.5% interest from BHP by 65% interest in the company. The gov- investing US$75 million in the project, ernment plans to dispose of a further base metal prices for 2000 with BHP retaining 37.5% and Aneka 14%, but would still retain control at and 2001 (p.30) Tambang 25%. 51%. BHP has been planning to bring in a The second condition is clarification partner experienced in the nickel busi- of the forestry classification of the land • Alcoa earnings keep rising ness, and the funds injected by on Gag Island. Commentators in (p.32) Falconbridge will be directed mainly Indonesia have expressed concern over towards completing a feasibility study, a new law which threatens to ban open- over the next two years, under the pit mining in protected forest areas 1.35% Ni and 0.08% Co. The mea- Canadian company’s management. (MJ, April 14, p.282). Thirdly, the sured and indicated portions total 12 According to BHP, the feasibility study scope of work for the proposed feasibili- Mt and 93 Mt respectively. According “may lead to development of the pro- ty study needs to be established. to Aneka Tambang, feasibility work ject”, but the company stresses that Gag Island has a total resource of carried out in 1999 envisaged potential there is no commitment to proceed 240 Mt, including both oxide and sili- production of 61,000 t/y of nickel, and Established 1835 beyond feasibility at this stage. cate zones, at an average grade of a capital cost of US$1.16 billion. ISSN 0026-5225 http://www.mining-journal.com COMMENT Editor Roger Ellis B.Sc., C.Eng. Deputy and Finance Editor Disposable assets Richard Morgan M.Sc., DIC, C.Eng. n the industrialised countries waste dis- Ok Tedi is a prime example of the range of Assistant Editor: Mineral Markets posal is a mounting problem; the millions contradictions, dilemmas and socio-political/ Andrew Thomas M.Sc., DIC Iof tonnes being generated each year by a environmental problems faced by govern- throw-away consumer society are rapidly ments, local communities and mining com- Assistant Editor: Industry in Action exhausting available landfill sites and there panies when attempting to extract minerals Dominic Mercer M.Sc., DIC, FGS is environmental opposition to creating new and metals for the greater human society sites or to the alternative, incineration. In and for the betterment of local communities Production some instances it has been deemed expedi- and national income. Commentary on these Susan Roberts ent to pay to export the rubbish to develop- issues is predominantly from non-govern- Eileen Smith ing countries where revenue from whatever mental organisations, mainly based in the Advertising source is very much to be welcomed. industrialised countries. It is instructive, Michael Bellenger For many developing nations, however, by therefore, to receive a viewpoint from the Frank Gordon far the most important source of revenues developing world and from someone with Shelley Hannan and foreign exchange is their mineral direct knowledge of the local situation (this resources. Here again, it is a convenient issue, p.19). Marketing arrangement; mines in remote parts of the Professor Bordia, head of the department Gareth Bowers world are relied upon to meet the raw mate- of mining engineering at the PNG University Carole Hoy rials needs of the affluent society of the of Technology at Lae, is forthright. He readi- Executive Director developed nations who much prefer not to ly concurs that any major development such have an unsightly mining operation on their as mining will disturb the environment but Chris Hinde Ph.D., C.Eng. doorstep. It is an imperfect solution but one argues that often it is the only source of Mining Journal, published weekly, is available only as part of a which is mutually beneficial. livelihood for the local populace. Local com- subscription with Mining Magazine and Mining Annual Review. But mining also generates waste, and munities, provincial and national govern- Annual Subscription: worldwide an estimated 3,000 Mt is pro- ments, he says, will accept such develop- £247 (US$440) duced each year from metal mining alone. ment, as long as the economic trade-offs are © Mining Journal Ltd 2000 Much of the overburden and mined waste is sufficient to compensate for environmental inert and stored safely above ground or used damage. Member of the Audit Bureau of Circulations to backfill previous mining areas (open-pit The total economic benefits and spin-offs and underground). A significant proportion, from Ok Tedi are huge by any world stan- WORLD GOLD as processed waste, is stored in tailings dards. The local town, once a hamlet of 500, Paul Burton ACSM, M.Sc., MBA Helen Payne M.Sc., DIC ponds which may or may not contain quanti- now has a population of about 10,000, and ties of heavy metals. The safe containment more than 50,000 people are estimated to MINING MAGAZINE of such waste, or lack of it in recent depend on income generated by the mine. John Chadwick B.Sc. Des Clifford B.Sc. instances, has probably generated more There is no social security net in a develop- adverse publicity for mining than any other ing country such as PNG, and Professor SUPPLEMENTS/REPORTS single issue. Bordia contends that on balance most peo- Austin Wheeler B.Eng. In Papua New Guinea, the Ok Tedi copper- ple in PNG’s Western Province (where the MINING ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT gold mine was developed controversially in mine is located) would like to see its contin- Tracey Khanna M.Sc., MCSM the mid-1980s without a tailings impound- uation. CONSTRUCTION PUBLICATIONS ment area because the steep topography at For those environmental lobbyists “who Ian Clarke B.Sc. the mine site precluded dam construction. are located far away from the real scene of Alan Kennedy B.Sc. Tailings are consigned directly into the Fly action, where their governments take Mike Smith HND (Min.) River system and the operation has been care of their livelihood”, his message is sim- RESEARCH SERVICES plagued by complaints about pollution. The ple – their efforts should be directed Iris Moncrieff majority owner, BHP, is considering selling towards forcing governments in emerging Editorial Consultant & Chairman its 53% stake or halting operations early – countries to create basic social security Michael West B.Sc., F.Eng. remaining resources are sufficient for ten support for the poor. Only when poverty is Managing Director & Publisher years – and a recent World Bank report has banished can the problems of pollution and Lawrence Williams B.Sc., C.Eng. recommended Ok Tedi’s closure on environ- environmental damage be resolved. mental grounds. The PNG Government, how- Ultimately, he argues, poverty is by far the ever, is anxious that operations continue. worst polluter. MJ LEADING INDICATORS THE MINING JOURNAL LTD Change High- 52-week Change High- 52-week 60 Worship Street on week Low Max/Min on week Low Max/Min Share Indices Jul 12 (%) (%) HSBC Indices Jul 12 (%) (%) London EC2A 2HD FT 30 3,741 0.5 38 4,103-3,521 (100 on 31/12/88 except*†) Tel: (+44 20) 7216 6060 US Dow Jones 10,784 2.9 55 11,551-9,857 Global Mining 119 3.6 26 146-109 FTSE Gold Mines 788 1.5 16 1,232-702 Global Diversified Mining 156 3.8 29 198-139 Fax: (+44 20) 7216 6050 Australian All Mining 677 2.9 46 771-597 Smaller Mining Companies 46 –0.8 20 59-43 E-mail: [email protected] South African Gold 985 –0.9 32 1,358-807 Global Base Metal Index 149 4.7 15 204-140 Toronto Met/Min 3,425 2.2 11 4,749-3,266 North American Base Metal 347 5.9 15 489-322 Subscription Dept: PO Box 10 Nikkei Dow 17,342 –0.5 27 20,833-16,044 Global Gold Index 53 0.9 8 78-51 Hang Seng 17,552 6.5 90 18,096-12,438 Global Gold Ex S Africa 60 1.7 14 85-56 Edenbridge, Kent TN8 5NE, UK North American Gold 69 1.8 17 97-63 Tel: (+44 1732) 864333 Commodity Prices Jul 12 Global Coal Mining† 141 2.5 26 188-124 Gold (London) $280.50 –2.2 38 $324-254 Other Metals/Minerals† 272 3.1 100 272-219 Fax: (+44 1732) 865747 Copper (LME) $1,790.50 1.4 68 $1,877.5-1,609 Latin American Mining* 246 0.9 61 286-182 E-mail: [email protected] Aluminium (U.S. prod.) 64.50c 0.0 44 69-61 Latin American (Ex CVRD)* 139 4.3 24 184-125 Brent Blend (dated) $30.29 0.1 93 $31.16-18.64 *100 on 31.12.89 †100 on 31/12/85 Web Home Page: www.mining-journal.com
18 Mining Journal, London, July 14, 2000 MINING WEEK
Mr Oppenheimer believes the new strate- So much for the economic benefits. On De Beers unveils gy “places De Beers and its partners in a the environmental side, the problems arise stronger position to meet the business and principally from the fact that tailings are strategy consumer challenges of the future”. disposed of directly into the Fly River Continued from p.17 De Beers sources it diamonds principally because steep topography precludes con- from its own mines in South Africa and from struction of a tailings dam. Professor will be introduced, and Mr Penny says that the mines it owns in partnerships with the Bordia outlines the options being consid- “the level of supply will be justified against governments of Botswana and Namibia. It ered to mitigate the environmental damage: evidence of marketing criteria”. A pilot sys- also purchases diamonds from Alrosa in the continuance of trial dredging in the low- tem that gives sightholders supply commit- Russia under a trade agreement which er Ok Tedi area; to dredge and move tailings ments for six months at a time is already in extends until the end of next year, and 35% by pipeline to a formed storage area; to do operation, and Mr Penny expects this to of the run-of-mine production from Ekati in neither; to close the mine early. Mine clo- “migrate in time into a much more commit- Canada. A proportion has also been pur- sure has been considered by BHP, and ted set of arrangements which will be indi- chased until recently under contract from Professor Bordia says that as the pit goes vidually tailored, reflecting market abili- SDM in Angola (a joint venture between deeper and costs rise the mine will become ties”. In order to deliver marketing state-owned Endiama, Ashton of Australia increasingly marginal as compared with improvements, Mr Penny predicts that and Odebrecht of Brazil). Negligible BHP’s other assets. Even without the envi- sightholders will have to work much more amounts of diamonds are now purchased on ronmental issues, he says, the mine is closely with retailers. the open market. becoming an economically unattractive Greater emphasis on marketing is seen as asset to manage and operate. (BHP has the key to increasing demand for diamonds already paid A$110 million in compensa- and De Beers is calling on the rest of the Ok Tedi dilemma tion in an out-of-court settlement with local industry to match its own efforts, hence the landowners in 1994, and analysts estimate preferential treatment that will be given to The environmental problems facing the Ok that early mine closure would necessitate a those diamantaires who market and distrib- Tedi copper-gold mine in Papua New write-down of A$250 million.) ute diamonds most efficiently. De Beers will Guinea have been well publicised, the eco- Since Professor Bordia prepared his spend US$170 million on international mar- nomic implications of closure for the local analysis, other options have been cited, keting this year but for the industry overall, community less so. Professor Surek Bordia, including the sale of part of BHP’s stake to the annual spend on marketing is little more Head of the Department of Mining its partners, with the balance placed in than 1% of retail sales revenue. This com- Engineering at the University of trust for local villagers affected by the mine, pares with annual expenditure of 6-10% for Technology in Lae, Papua New Guinea, has and the government has said that it has the luxury goods market as a whole. The attempted to redress this imbalance*. The received unsolicited enquiries from two luxury goods market is growing at 10% per operating company, Ok Tedi Mining Ltd resource companies interested in acquiring year and De Beers’ managing director, (OTML), is owned 53% by BHP, 17% by BHP’s stake (MJ, March 24, p.223). Gary Ralfe, says there is “a huge untapped Inmet Mining and 30% by the PNG Ok Tedi is located in the rugged Star potential” for the diamond business to Government, and produces close to 200,000 Mountains of PNG’s Western Province and match the growth rates enjoyed by leading t/y of copper in concentrates plus about Professor Bordia says that prior to its devel- luxury goods companies. He sees the brand- 400,000 oz/y of gold. In 1998, the operation opment the people in the province were liv- ing of diamonds as a catalyst for such accounted for 20% of PNG’s total exports ing in abject poverty with no access to gov- growth. and about 10% of GDP. Export sales in that ernment services because of their remote- De Beers’ London-based marketing arm, year were Kn702 million (US$1.00 = kina ness from Port Moresby. The mine, he says, Diamond Trading Co., is set to play a much 2.47) and since 1984 total export sales have has brought tremendous economic benefits more prominent role under the new strategy been well in excess of Kn6 billion. to the province, especially along the Fly and is being given a “powerful new identi- There are 81 businesses in the local area River delta. There is some opposition to ty”. Until now, the DTC has been referred employing 1,050 people, with a total mining continuing in the lower Fly River to as the company responsible for sales turnover in 1998 of Kn80.6 million, and area, and he says that most of the new eco- within the Central Selling Organisation but cumulative gross turnovers to that year of nomic and social studies should be done the perpetuation of the CSO, with its Kn625 million. OTML directly employs there to measure the extent of the damage monopolistic connotations, is no longer around 1,860 workers of whom only 163 are and the economic trade-offs against this deemed prudent. The DTC sorts and values expatriates. At the beginning of 1999, there damage. On the whole, however, Professor the rough diamonds shipped to London were 80 PNG companies servicing the mine Bordia says that the people of Western (into some 14,000 categories) and is at the with contracts valued at Kn209 million, Province would like to see the continuation interface with sightholders. and 45 overseas companies with contracts of mining operations. He believes that the To ensure continued consumer confi- worth Kn35 million. Since 1982 until the Ok Tedi dilemma mirrors real-life condi- dence, the new strategy includes the estab- end of 1998, Professor Bordia says that tions everywhere in the developing world lishment of a code of professional and ethi- some Kn429 million were paid directly to (Comment, p.18). cal standards – best practice principles – the government in taxes. *‘Metals & the Environment-Socio-Economic Dilemma and the DTC will be responsible for ensur- Total direct benefits to local communities Facing Developing Countries’ was presented during the ing that sightholders comply as a condition to the end of 1998, as calculated by the ECOW’99 workshop in Cairns. of sale. These principles are intended to PNG Chamber of Mines and Petroleum, reassure customers in the distribution amounted to Kn515 million, and included chain, as well as consumers, that the dia- royalties (Kn82.3 million), landowner com- Castromil licence monds they purchase are not, for example, pensation (Kn93 million), education and refusal confirmed so-called ‘conflict diamonds’. training (Kn22.3 million) and infrastruc- Finally, De Beers says that it is offering ture development (Kn317 million). It is Dublin-based MinMet plc announced last to sightholders an extensive package of now some 16 years since the start of produc- Friday that the Government of Portugal “world-class value-added support services, tion and it has been estimated that in excess has refused to grant the company a mining including training, marketing, business- of 50,000 people depend on income generat- licence for its Castromil gold-silver project, planning support and market research”. ed by the mine. in northern Portugal. MinMet warned last
Mining Journal, London, July 14, 2000 19 Mining Centres of the World
JOHANNESBURG
The fourth in the series of Mining Journal's special supplements on Mining Centres of the World will feature Johannesburg - the City of Gold - the centre for the huge South African mining industry. Until recently, Johannesburg has been the headquarters of (and is still the key office for) half a dozen of the world's most important mining companies, as well as a large array of associated financial, engineering and manufacturing companies. Most needs of the mining industry can be catered for within the Johannesburg metropolitan area.
Mining Journal will publish the Special Supplement on Johannesburg at the beginning of September 2000 to coincide with this year's Electra Mining Exhibition (one of the southern hemisphere's biggest mining events) being held in the city, and at which the publication will be distributed to visitors. The supplement will cover the whole spectrum of mining and mining-related companies and services located in the area. The supplement will thus follow the pattern of our previous 'Mining Centre' supplements, on London, Denver and Toronto, and will highlight major corporations and organisations. It will include maps locating key companies, details of access by public transport, accommodation etc, making it an invaluable guide for any mining executive visiting the city.
The supplement is being prepared for us by the African Mining editorial team in Johannesburg, in conjunction with our own editorial team in London. If you feel that you have relevant material to submit, please contact Paul Crankshaw in Johannesburg on (011) 622 4666 or e-mail: [email protected] or Chris Hinde in London on +44 20 7216 6060 e-mail: [email protected]
The supplement will be sent as part of the normal subscription to Mining Journal's worldwide key mining industry management readership in some 130 countries, as well as to visitors to the Electra Mining exhibition. It will also be available from our exhibit at MINEXPO 2000 in Las Vegas in mid-October.
Advertisements in the supplement are available at normal Mining Journal rates. The booking deadline is August 11th with copy required by August 18th at the latest. For details please call Mike Bellenger or Frank Gordon on +44 20 7216 6060; fax: +44 20 7216 6050 or by e-mail to [email protected] In Africa, call Bob Stephen on +27 11 952 1721 or by e-mail to [email protected] MINING WEEK month that the government had expressed Although conceding that MinMet’s Laboratory Testing environmental concerns during discussion emphasis has shifted to its South American of the details for a final mining licence for exploration projects in the past year, the Pilot Plant Testing the project (MJ, June 2, p.434), one of a company’s chief executive, Michael Nolan, number which MinMet holds in Portugal has expressed its determination to secure Consulting Services through its wholly-owned subsidiary the Castromil mining lease, via the appeal Connary Minerals. process, or to agree a compensation package MinMet notes that the government from the Portuguese Government. MinMet “appears to cite additional environmental hopes to begin talks with government offi- concerns and a delay in Connary not pro- cials in Lisbon early next week. viding expert studies on certain aspects of LakefieldResearch the Castromil mining plan by May 30”. The project lies close to residential areas. The Navan in transition INNOVATIVE THINKING FOR PRACTICAL SOLUTIONS company contends that the government’s position with regard to the apparent rea- Shares in Navan Mining plc, the successor sons for its denial of the mining licence “has company to Navan Resources plc, began no legal basis”. trading this week following the official list- The expert reports in question were being ing of the company on the London and Tel +1 705 652 2000 prepared by Knight Piésold (UK) Ltd for Dublin stock exchanges. A new UK-incor- Fax +1 705 652 6365 submission this Monday (July 10), covering porated holding company has been estab- six areas of the project’s plans: pit lining; lished, headquartered in the UK, to acquire [email protected] cyanide management; water management; the old Navan (MJ, May 26, p.419). Navan www.lakefield.com waste management; environmental man- has made considerable strides since its agement; and mine closure. MinMet notes incorporation in Ireland in 1987. It has that Connary had previously advised the grown from an explorer with activities pri- Portuguese authorities that a short delay marily in Ireland to a significant European would occur, attributed to the amount of base and precious metals producer. Ireland work required, and considers that the gov- is retained in its exploration portfolio but, ernment, in the form of the Instituto under a new management team, the main Geologico e Mineiro, has “moved with inde- focus is now on gold-copper mining and cent haste” to rescind its decision of exploration in Bulgaria, and base metals December 1999 to grant the mining lease. production and exploration in Spain. Canada • Argentina • Brazil • Chile • Peru • South Africa
People you can count on, anywhere in the world. “After 13 years here I don’t just have a lot of colleagues, I have a lot of friends.” - Ron Arlian
Technology changes constantly in our business, but people like Ron give our company a consistency that clients come to value. Solid engineering skills and a wealth of experience make Ron welcome at mining operations around the globe. Knight Piésold CONSULTING Global Expertise. Local Knowledge. www.knightpiesold.com
Mining Journal, London, July 14, 2000 21 The Geological Information System for the ANDES Geology • Deposits • Infrastructure on CDRom
GIS Andes is a homogeneous information system of the entire Andes Cordillera, covering an area of almost 4 million km2 and extending for some 8,500 km from the Guajira Peninsula in northern Venezuela to Tierra del Fuego in southern Argentina. Conceived as a tool for both the mining sector (as an aid to minerals exploration), and the academic sector (as an aid to developing new metallogenic models), GIS Andes is based on original syntheses and compilations.
The system comprises both geographical and geological layers: