DOCSLIB.ORG

A Reflection on the Scale and Scope of Disaster Memories

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
A Reflection on the Scale and Scope of Disaster Memories INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL FOR HISTORY, CULTURE AND MODERNITY www.history-culture-modernity.org Published by: Uopen Journals Copyright: © The Author(s). Content is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International Licence eISSN: 2213-0624 Betwixt and Between: A Reflection on the Scale and Scope of Disaster Memories Felix Mauch HCM 7: 110–141 DOI: 10.18352/hcm.552 Abstract This paper shows that disaster memories not only develop over differ- ent circuits of time, but also involve multiple spatial layers. In the par- ticular case presented here, remembering Hamburg’s ‘Great Deluge’ of 1962 followed patterns in which national politics intermeshed with dis- tinctive local legacies and competing memory actors in changing inter- pretive frames. Tracing the flood’s multi-faceted reverberations along these intersections, this article suggests, firstly, that a long-term analy- sis of selected memory narratives can offer insights into the broader political implications as well as the unique characteristics of place- based disaster cultures. Secondly, by taking into account commemora- tion events, politics of remembrance as well as symbolic and material lieux de mémoire, the article shows that disaster memories are shaped by historical actors both ‘outside’ and ‘on site’. As a result, the article traces an eclectic panorama of co-evolving disaster memory cultures – not only local and (inter)national, environmental and social, and ‘from below’ and prescribed at the same time, but ‘betwixt and between’ them as well. Keywords: environmental history, floods, Hamburg, memory, natural disaster HCM 2019, VOL. 7 110 Downloaded from Brill.com09/27/2021 11:20:30AM via free access BETWIXT AND BETWEEN Introduction Hamburg’s Große Flut (‘Great Deluge’) is firmly anchored in German public memory.1 A wealth of monuments, high water marks and a pleth- ora of documentary films, media outlets and personal testimonies from contemporary witnesses keep the incidents that occurred in early 1962 alive. During the night of 16 to 17 February, a massive storm flood shook the young Federal Republic to its foundations. Hailing from the North Sea, storm front Vincinette, the victorious, forced massive tidal waves into the lower reaches of the Weser and Elbe for several hours, washing away vast areas along the coastline between Cuxhaven and Geesthacht and causing billions of deutschmarks of material damage. Once the tidal waves crashed through dykes and embankments, a chain of events took its course that triggered what disaster experts consider the most devastating natural catastrophe in modern German history.2 The Free and Hanseatic City of Hamburg suffered the most. More than 12,500 hectares – approximately one fifth of the entire urban landscape – were submerged. The water masses trapped more than 100,000 residents; over 15,000 lost their homes and 315 people lost their lives. One area accounted for most of the fatalities: within hours, Wilhelmsburg, a working-class district surrounded by two branches of the Elbe, was literally drowned. Here, the flood caught many local resi- dents by surprise, and transformed the river island into a watery grave. Despite unprecedented rescue efforts, help came too late for many. After the water receded, emergency services reported 222 people dead or missing.3 So much for the undisputed history of events. The figures arguably paint a picture of a mainly local event. The inundations’ physical impact and its destructive outcome were restricted to specific geographic areas located in a high-risk zone, in which natural hazards pose an enduring threat. Within the North Sea’s sphere of influence, life is and has always been shaped by the rhythm of high and low tide. Storm winds, down- pours and high waters are very common. Accordingly, Hamburg’s envi- ronmental history is that of a distinctive ‘disaster culture’.4 Municipal archives are replete with reports and popular tales of the city’s struggle with the elements that at least go back to the Middle Ages.5 However, floods are never limited to a specific place. In both their origin and their outcome, they transcend particular spaces. Like the HCM 2019, VOL. 7 Downloaded from Brill.com09/27/2021111 11:20:30AM via free access MAUCH River Elbe itself, which mutates from a small source in the Czech mountains to a river that reaches a length of 1245 km, covering a water- shed of more than 148,300 km2, the ‘Great Deluge’ had humble origins. A deep low-pressure system and strong west winds was all it took to send Vincinette on her way to Hamburg. Once there, the storm’s gusts transcended all cultural, political and national borders, as did the waves that it pushed into the German Bight and down the Elbe River. If the impact of the flood was not confined to a small segment of Hamburg, what does this mean for its history? That history has been told countless times and is well remembered, but it, too, should be explored in dimensions that transcend the immediate and the local. Looking more closely at the storm’s wider causes and impact brings some interesting new storylines to light. Many transgress the conventional dualisms that modernity has drawn between nature and culture, between memory and history, between the nation and the city, while others add the interplay between cityscape and natural environment to the human drama. These storylines have been propelled by nature’s agency as much as by dif- ferent historical voices, actors and political institutions. Varying per- ceptions, overlapping plots, counter-narratives and conflicts shape (and reshape) the catastrophe’s diverging interpretations.6 Whether in Wilhelmsburg, Hamburg or further afield, and whether fifty years ago, today or tomorrow, reckoning with the history of the flood of 1962 is a constructive practice. Who remembers the events, how and upon what grounds are crucial considerations comprising more than one layer of ambiguity. Therefore, disaster memories can only exist in the plural. Various forms of remembrance operate on dif- ferent temporal and spatial scales, ranging from the deep past to the future and from the most local to the unbounded global. The question remains, however: if every catastrophic event has ramifications much wider than its immediate context, and if differing plots and competing memory actors co-evolve over time, how exactly does this affect the scale and scope of disaster memories? Between the Tides: Northern German Cultures of Disaster A single answer does not exist; only approximations and interpretations are possible because memories relating to Hamburg’s ‘Great Deluge’ HCM 2019, VOL. 7 112 Downloaded from Brill.com09/27/2021 11:20:30AM via free access BETWIXT AND BETWEEN oscillated between heterogeneous actors and different locales, feed- ing on many sources. According to David Blackbourn, German water- scapes turned incrementally into ‘a screen on which a changing society projected its hopes and fears’.7 In that regard, well-established Northern German ‘cultures of disaster’ proved to be a common framework. Literary works such as Theodor Storm’s Der Schimmelreiter or Detlev von Liliencron’s ballad Trutz, blanke Hans are examples of narratives grounded in long-held common myths about the dangers of living in a harsh climate at the mercy of storm tides and flooding. They are testi- mony to a longstanding appreciation of the agency of nature in this haz- ard-prone area.8 Since premodern times, withstanding the seemingly untameable elements shaped the lives of many coast dwellers. Theirs was a frontier mentality: the shoreline resembled a ‘space of confron- tation’, where nature and culture literally clashed with each other.9 Heimat was the land wrested from a hostile sea. Ever since its founda- tion in the Early Middle Ages, the settlement that later became the Free and Hanseatic City of Hamburg was part and parcel of this landscape, and its cultural memory was inscribed into its geomorphology. Despite being located more than 120 km inland, its residents pictured them- selves as active constituents of a ‘coastal society’.10 The oldest and most visible memory topoi of this struggle are dykes. Building these embankments served a double purpose. On the one hand, they protected the marshlands physically and made permanent settle- ments possible. At the same time, they were of high symbolic value. Dykes drew a line between culture and mistrusted wilderness. Until the early twentieth century, every landowner in flood-prone areas was legally responsible for erecting a floodwall. Neglect would end in loss of possession. As a traditional proverb put it: Wer nicht will deichen, muss weichen (‘anyone who does not build a dyke has to leave’). A line of artificial walls that reaches seven to nine metres above sea level still surrounds Hamburg today. For the people living behind these protective barriers, however, another saying from premodern times defines their prevailing attitude towards the North Sea: ‘mind the next flood!’11 The long arm of the North Sea, the Elbe River, had simply brought too many calamities for residents to be able to forget about them. The number of both levees and memorials speak clearly of this awareness. This holds true for Hamburg in particular. The dykes never isolated the Hansestadt from its environment. On the contrary, Hamburg has HCM 2019, VOL. 7 Downloaded from Brill.com09/27/2021113 11:20:30AM via free access MAUCH always been an ‘amphibious city’.12 The Elbe, the Alster Lake and a vast network of tributaries and canals drive its history, culture and prosperity. Hamburg’s
Load more

Recommended publications
  • NORD.Regional Band 7 STATISTIKAMT NORD
    Statistisches Amt für Hamburg und Schleswig-Holstein Hamburger Stadtteil-Profile 2009 NORD.regional Band 7 STATISTIKAMT NORD Hamburger Stadtteil-Profile 2009 Band 7 der Reihe „NORD.regional“ ISSN 1863-9518 Herausgeber: Statistisches Amt für Hamburg und Schleswig-Holstein Anstalt des öffentlichen Rechts Steckelhörn 12, 20457 Hamburg Bestellungen: Telefon: 0431 6895-9280 oder 0431 6895-9122 Fax: 0431 6895-9498 E-Mail: vertriebSH@statistik-nord.de Auskünfte: Telefon: 040 42831-1713 Fax: 040 427964-312 E-Mail: enno.thiel@statistik-nord.de Internet: www.statistik-nord.de Preis: 20,50 EUR © Statistisches Amt für Hamburg und Schleswig-Holstein, 2010 Für nichtgewerbliche Zwecke sind Vervielfältigung und unentgeltliche Verbreitung, auch auszugsweise, mit Quellenangabe gestattet. Die Verbreitung, auch auszugsweise, über elektronische Systeme/Datenträger bedarf der vorherigen Zustimmung. Alle übrigen Rechte bleiben vorbehalten. Vorwort Die „Hamburger Stadtteil-Profile“ haben seit 13 Jahren ihren festen Platz in unserem Datenangebot. Die Nachfrage nach dieser jährlich erscheinenden Querschnittsveröffentlichung ist nach wie vor ungebrochen. Ein breiter Kundenkreis aus Politik und Verwaltung, Verbänden und Vereinen, Wissenschaft und interessierten Bürgerinnen und Bürgern nutzt die umfangreiche Datensammlung, sei es in der hier vorgelegten Druckfassung oder direkter und jederzeit verfügbar in unserem Internetangebot. Die Veröffentlichung bietet wie gewohnt eine Zusammenstellung von sozial-demographischen Merkmalen über Hamburger Stadtteile, Bezirke sowie ausgewählte Quartiere. Thematische Karten zu neun wichtigen Indikatoren ermöglichen einen raschen Überblick und eine Einordnung der Stadtteile. Einige Institutionen tragen regelmäßig mit ihren Daten dazu bei, dass ein umfangreiches Merk- malspektrum für Hamburger Gebietseinheiten veröffentlicht werden kann. Welche Angaben von welcher Stelle stammen, ist in den erläuternden Bemerkungen im Anhang aufgeführt. Den Ein- richtungen, die uns ihr Datenmaterial überlassen haben, sei an dieser Stelle gedankt.
    [Show full text]
  • Descrizione Storica Delle Carte (ITA)
    PRIMA DECADE I. Russian Tanks (DDR 1953) Nel maggio 1953, il Politburo del Partito di Unita’ Socialista della Germania (SED) innalzo’ le quote di lavoro dell'industria del 10 %. Il 16 giugno, una sessantina di operai edili di Berlino Est iniziarono a scioperare quando i loro superiori annunciarono un taglio di stipendio in caso di mancato raggiungimento delle quote. La loro manifestazione del giorno seguente fu la scintilla che causò lo scoppio delle proteste in tutta la Germania Est. Lo sciopero portò al blocco del lavoro e a proteste in praticamente tutti i centri industriali e in tutte le grandi città del Paese; le richieste iniziali dei dimostranti, come il ripristino delle precedenti (e inferiori) quote di lavoro, si tramutarono in richieste politiche. I lavoratori chiesero le dimissioni del governo della Germania Est che, per contro, si rivolse all'Unione Sovietica per schiacciare la rivolta con la forza militare. 1. Land Reform (DDR 19451945----1948)1948) Le riforme agrarie ("Bodenreform") prevedevano l'espropriazione di tutte le terre appartenenti agli attivisti del nazismo. Circa 500 proprietà degli Junker furono convertite in fattorie collettive, e più di 30.000 km² vennero distribuiti tra mezzo milione di contadini. Inoltre vennero costituite le prime fattorie statali, chiamate Volkseigenes Gut. 2. Forced Merger of KPD and SPD (DDR 1946) Un decreto del 10 giugno 1945 da parte delle autorità sovietiche permise la formazione di partiti democratici antifascisti; le prime elezioni vennero indette a ottobre 1946. Nel luglio 1945 si costituì una coalizione di partiti democratici antifascisti, formata da KPD, SPD, CDU, LDPD. Nell'aprile 1946 il KPD (il partito comunista tedesco e la SPD si fusero dietro grandi pressioni da parte dei sovietici, formando la SED (Sozialistische Einheitspartei Deutschlands, Partito di Unità Socialista).
    [Show full text]
  • Market Survey Commercial
    Hamburg, Quarters 1–3, 2014 Market Survey Commercial Office Letting Grossmann & Berger’s promise: Market transparency. Commercial Market Survey Hamburg Quarters 1–3, 2014 Office Letting Office Letting Key figures office Q 1–3 Q 1–3 2013 2014 Take-up of space in m² ......................... 325,000 .. 380,000 + 17 % Premium rent in €/m²/mth ................. 23.50 .......24.50 Average rent in €/m²/mth ..................13.80 .......14.50 Vacancy rate in % ................................. 6.5 ...........6.3 Total stock of office space in millions m² .....13.28 .......13.35 Take-up of space 2010–Q 3, 2014 Take-up of space (in 000s m², incl. owner-occupiers) Total take-up of office space was 155,000 m² in the 3rd quarter, making 600 it the strongest so far this year. Adding to the sound result returned in 10-year average (2004–2013): approx. 478,000 m² the 1st half of the year, which was partly due to the Deutsche Telekom 500 lease agreement for a large amount of space, the overall figure has ris- 400 en to 380,000 m², representing year on year growth of 17%. The share at- tributable to owner-occupiers was some 20%, i.e. about 73,000 m² of of- 300 Q3Q3Q3 fice space. In addition to three leases for over 10,000 m² the strong result 155 is, first and foremost, due to a large number of lets for over 1,000 m² and 200 2,000 m². 100 Rather like the situation in the previous quarter, some 36% of the space 506 540 430 440 380 0 taken up was registered in the 5,000 m² or more section of the market; alto- 2010 2011 2012 2013 Q3, gether 2014 has seen eleven such leases, three of them in the 3rd quarter.
    [Show full text]
  • THE PORT of HAMBURG FIGURES the Port of Hamburg Is Germany’S Largest Universal Port and a Major Hub for World Trade
    FACTS AND THE PORT OF HAMBURG FIGURES The Port of Hamburg is Germany’s largest universal port and a major hub for world trade. Every day, Germa- ny’s imports of goods and services are worth around 3.5 billion euros and its exports are worth around 4.2 billion euros. Foreign trade ensures our prosperity and contributes decisively to economic growth. The Port of Hamburg plays a crucial role: it is the “Gateway to the World” for the economy in Germany and many neigh- boring countries. Around 156,000 jobs depend on the port. It is also Hamburg’s biggest taxpayer, contributing over 910 million euros. Seaborne cargo Seaborne container throughput in 2018 throughput in 2018 How is cargo transported in millions of metric tons in millions of TEU between the Port of Hamburg DID YOU KNOW? Total 135,1 Total 8,7 and the hinterland? • 500 companies from the port services and industry sectors are located in the port Imports 79,7 Loaded containers 7,6 • 212 cruise ships carrying more than 900,000 passengers called at the three cruise terminals in Hamburg in 2018 Exports 55,4 Imports 4,6 48,4% • 2,100 container train connections per week link the Port of Hamburg with all parts of General Cargo 90,9 Exports 4,2 by rail Germany and important regions of Europe Bulk cargo 44,2 • One out of every eight freight trains in Germany has the Port of Hamburg as its destination or origin Only cargo handled between a seagoing vessel and land is counted as 41,4% seaborne cargo.
    [Show full text]
  • German Jewish Refugees in the United States and Relationships to Germany, 1938-1988
    UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA, SAN DIEGO “Germany on Their Minds”? German Jewish Refugees in the United States and Relationships to Germany, 1938-1988 A dissertation submitted in partial satisfaction of the requirements for the degree Doctor of Philosophy in History by Anne Clara Schenderlein Committee in charge: Professor Frank Biess, Co-Chair Professor Deborah Hertz, Co-Chair Professor Luis Alvarez Professor Hasia Diner Professor Amelia Glaser Professor Patrick H. Patterson 2014 Copyright Anne Clara Schenderlein, 2014 All rights reserved. The Dissertation of Anne Clara Schenderlein is approved, and it is acceptable in quality and form for publication on microfilm and electronically. _____________________________________________________________________ _____________________________________________________________________ _____________________________________________________________________ _____________________________________________________________________ _____________________________________________________________________ Co-Chair _____________________________________________________________________ Co-Chair University of California, San Diego 2014 iii Dedication To my Mother and the Memory of my Father iv Table of Contents Signature Page ..................................................................................................................iii Dedication ..........................................................................................................................iv Table of Contents ...............................................................................................................v
    [Show full text]
  • Bus Linie 150 Fahrpläne & Karten
    Bus Linie 150 Fahrpläne & Netzkarten 150 Cranz > Finkenwerder > Waltershof > Im Website-Modus Anzeigen Othmarschen > Bf. Altona Die Bus Linie 150 (Cranz > Finkenwerder > Waltershof > Othmarschen > Bf. Altona) hat 3 Routen (1) Airbus (kehre): 00:41 - 22:27 (2) Bf. altona: 00:38 - 23:58 (3) Estebogen: 04:26 - 23:55 Verwende Moovit, um die nächste Station der Bus Linie 150 zu ƒnden und, um zu erfahren wann die nächste Bus Linie 150 kommt. Richtung: Airbus (Kehre) Bus Linie 150 Fahrpläne 23 Haltestellen Abfahrzeiten in Richtung Airbus (kehre) LINIENPLAN ANZEIGEN Montag 00:41 - 22:27 Dienstag 00:41 - 22:27 Bf. Altona Paul-Nevermann-Platz 5, Hamburg Mittwoch 00:41 - 22:27 Große Rainstraße Donnerstag 00:21 - 23:15 Hohenesch 85, Hamburg Freitag 00:41 - 22:27 Friedensallee Samstag 00:41 - 22:53 Bahrenfelder Straße 182, Hamburg Sonntag 00:21 - 23:15 Am Born Behringstraße 11, Hamburg Kreuzkirche Ottensen Behringstraße 55, Hamburg Bus Linie 150 Info Richtung: Airbus (Kehre) Griegstraße Stationen: 23 Griegstraße 52, Hamburg Fahrtdauer: 35 Min Linien Informationen: Bf. Altona, Große Rainstraße, Behringstraße (Ak Altona) Friedensallee, Am Born, Kreuzkirche Ottensen, Jürgen-Töpfer-Straße 18 f, Hamburg Griegstraße, Behringstraße (Ak Altona), Bab- Auffahrt Waltershof, Am Genter Ufer, Bab-Auffahrt Waltershof Aluminiumwerk, Osterfelddeich, Auedeich, Dradenaustraße, Hamburg Jeverländer Weg, Emder Straße, Steendiek, Finkenwerder (Fähre), Norderschulweg, Am Genter Ufer Brunnenstieg, Kneienblick, Nordmeerstraße, Rudolf- Dradenauer Deichweg, Hamburg Kinau-Allee,
    [Show full text]
  • Der Kanzlerflüsterer
    UMFRAGEN Der Kanzlerflüsterer Kann ein Demoskop Politik machen? Forsa-Chef Manfred Güllner ist ein Vertrauter von Gerhard Schröder. Er sieht sich als dessen "Einparkhilfe". Von Matthias Geyer Der Richter des Kanzlers hat keinen Namen und kein Gesicht, er hat nur eine Stimme. Er sagt "Ja, bitte", als er sich am Telefon meldet. Niemand kennt ihn, seine Stimme kommt durch ein unterirdisches Kabel, es beginnt irgendwo im Westen Deutschlands und endet in Berlin-Mitte, im ersten Stock eines Callcenters. "Ja, bitte" ist die Stimme des Volkes. Sie hat große Macht. "Ja, bitte?" "Guten Tag, hier ist das Meinungsforschungsinstitut Forsa, wir führen eine Umfrage zu den wichtigen Themen in Deutschland durch." "Legen Sie los." "Welche drei aktuellen Themen interessieren Sie am meisten?" "Also, isch würd sagen: der Sieg von Alemannia Aachen gegen Bayern München und was der Schröder so treibt." "Wenn Sie den Bundeskanzler selbst wählen könnten, für wen würden Sie sich entscheiden? Für Gerhard Schröder oder für Angela Merkel?" "Für keinen. Also, wenn Sie zwischen Lügnern, Gaunern und Verbrechern wählen könnten, da würden Sie doch auch keinen nehmen, oder?" "Welche Partei haben Sie bei der letzten Bundestagswahl gewählt?" "SPD." "Und wenn am nächsten Sonntag Bundestagswahl wäre, welche Partei würden Sie dann wählen?" "Schwierisch. Auf keinen Fall SPD." "Und was sind Ihre Gründe dafür?" "Weil die das Vertrauen der Leute missbraucht haben. Was die uns in die linke Tasche reintun, das ziehen sie aus der rechten Tasche wieder raus. So isset doch." Das Gespräch dauert ungefähr 20 Minuten. Es geht nicht nur um Politik, es geht auch um die Fernsehsendung "Ich bin ein Star - Holt mich hier raus!".
    [Show full text]
  • Profile Persönlichkeiten Der Universität Hamburg Profile Persönlichkeiten Der Universität Hamburg Inhalt
    FALZ FÜR EINKLAPPER U4 RÜCKENFALZ FALZ FÜR EINKLAPPER U1 4,5 mm Profile persönlichkeiten der universität hamburg Profile persönlichkeiten der universität hamburg inhalt 6 Grußwort des Präsidenten 8 Profil der Universität Portraits 10 von Beust, Ole 12 Breloer, Heinrich 14 Dahrendorf, Ralf Gustav 16 Harms, Monika 18 Henkel, Hans-Olaf 20 Klose, Hans-Ulrich 22 Lenz, Siegfried 10 12 14 16 18 20 22 24 Miosga, Caren 26 von Randow, Gero 28 Rühe, Volker 30 Runde, Ortwin 32 Sager, Krista 34 Schäuble, Wolfgang 24 26 28 30 32 34 36 36 Schiller, Karl 38 Schmidt, Helmut 40 Scholz, Olaf 42 Schröder, Thorsten 44 Schulz, Peter 46 Tawada, Yoko 38 40 42 44 46 48 50 48 Voscherau, Henning 50 von Weizsäcker, Carl Friedrich 52 Impressum grusswort des präsidenten Grußwort des Präsidenten der Universität Hamburg Dieses Buch ist ein Geschenk – sowohl für seine Empfänger als auch für die Universität Hamburg. Die Persönlichkeiten in diesem Buch machen sich selbst zum Geschenk, denn sie sind der Universität auf verschiedene Weise verbunden – als Absolventinnen und Absolventen, als ehemalige Rektoren, als prägende Lehrkräfte oder als Ehrendoktoren und -senatoren. Sie sind über ihre unmittelbare berufliche Umgebung hinaus bekannt, weil sie eine öffentliche Funktion wahrnehmen oder wahrgenommen haben. Die Universität Hamburg ist fern davon, sich selbst als Causa des beruflichen Erfolgs ihrer prominenten Alumni zu betrach- ten. Dennoch hat die Universität mit ihnen zu tun. Sie ist der Ort gewesen, in dem diese Frauen und Männer einen Teil ihrer Sozialisation erfahren haben. Im glücklicheren Fall war das Studium ein Teil der Grundlage ihres Erfolges, weil es Wissen, Kompetenz und Persönlichkeitsbildung ermöglichte.
    [Show full text]
  • Central Europe
    Central Europe West Germany FOREIGN POLICY AND STATUS OF BERLIN OUBJECTS discussed during British Premier Harold Wilson's offi- cial visit to Bonn from March 7 to 9 included the maintenance of the British Rhine Army in Germany, the continuation of German currency aid for the United Kingdom, and a new approach to German reunification. When East German authorities tried to interfere with the meeting of the Bundestag in Berlin on April 7 by disrupting traffic to and from the former capital, the Western Allies protested sharply. In his opening speech Eugen Gerstenmaier, president of the Bundestag, emphasized the right of the Fed- eral parliament to meet in West Berlin and denied that the session was an act of provocation. During the Easter holidays 300,000 West Berliners were permitted to visit relatives in the Eastern zone of the divided city. About a million Berliners crossed the Berlin Wall and spent Christmas with their relatives, after the renewal of an agreement in November. Queen Elizabeth II of England and her consort the Duke of Edinburgh made an official visit to West Germany and West Berlin in May, and were cheered by the population. Attempts by Foreign Minister Gerhard Schroder to bring about an improvement in relations with the United Kingdom during this visit were viewed skeptically by Franz-Josef Strauss, chairman of the Christian Social Union (CSU), representing the pro-French wing of the coalition. French President Charles de Gaulle's talks with Chancellor Ludwig Erhard in Bonn in June were described as "positive," but did not lead to an agree- ment on a conference to discuss the reorganization of the Common Market and other matters pertaining to the European community.
    [Show full text]
  • „Das Ist Ein Wahnsystem“
    MANFRED WITT / VISUM WITT MANFRED Werner Marnette, 63, war von 1994 bis 2007 Vorstands- Juli 2008 wurde er Minister für Wissenschaft, Wirtschaft und Verkehr in vorsitzender der Norddeutschen Affinerie AG, die unter seiner Führung zum der von Peter Harry Carstensen (CDU) geführten Landesregierung von größten Kupferproduzenten Europas aufstieg. Von 1998 bis 2002 saß Schleswig-Holstein. Am 29. März trat er, aus Protest gegen den Kurs der er im Präsidium des Bundesverbandes der Deutschen Industrie (BDI). Im Regierung zur Rettung der HSH Nordbank, von diesem Amt zurück. „Das ist einSPIEGEL-GESPRÄCH Wahnsystem“ Der zurückgetretene schleswig-holsteinische Wirtschaftsminister Werner Marnette (CDU) über die Gründe seines Abgangs, die Grabenkämpfe im Kieler Kabinett und den leicht- fertigen Umgang der Politik mit den Milliardenrisiken der teilweise landeseigenen HSH Nordbank. SPIEGEL: Herr Marnette, Sie haben mehr naten anders erlebt. Ich hatte es mit Poli- ner Wiegard hatte ich den Eindruck, dass als ein Jahrzehnt lang ein großes Unter- tikern zu tun, die sich scheuten, Zahlen die gar nicht richtig an die Zahlen ran- nehmen geführt. Würden Sie einem Ihrer zur Kenntnis zu nehmen und sich damit wollten. Bloß nicht festlegen, nicht an- ehemaligen Kabinettskollegen die Leitung auseinanderzusetzen. Frei nach dem Mot- greifbar machen war deren Devise. eines solchen Unternehmens anvertrauen? to: Wer sich gründlich mit Zahlen be- SPIEGEL: Aber Carstensen und Wiegard ha- Marnette: Nein. schäftigt, wird zum Mitwisser und kann als ben sich doch – wie ihre Hamburger Kol- SPIEGEL: Warum nicht? solcher haftbar gemacht werden. legen Ole von Beust und Michael Freytag Marnette: Weil die Führung eines Unter- SPIEGEL: Wollen Sie damit sagen, dass Ihren – festgelegt und eine Eigenkapitalspritze nehmens ganz andere Anforderungen Kabinettskollegen im Zusammenhang mit von drei Milliarden Euro plus weitere zehn stellt.
    [Show full text]
  • Tafeln (Page 1)
    "Forgotten" History BERUFSVERBOTE Political Persecution in the Federal Republic of Germany 1. DEFINITION Berufsverbot? What is That? At the end of the 1960s, politicians, lawyers, police and secret Aim of Berufsverbot: Intimidation by Threat of Subsistence Deprivation services considered how to contain mass protests at universities and Political repression and political persecu- work places. The forms of repression practiced so far – surveillance, tion has happened and is still happening police raids, political trials and imprisonment – didn't seem to be in many areas of society. sufficient anymore. In particular, the state authorities were What was so special about the "Radikalen - concerned that a new generation with left-wing leanings could erlass"? Its aim was to abolish the mate- rial existence of the affected people in the permeate the governmental structures and change them from workplace. Those affected either could the inside. A working group commissioned in 1971 discussed not complete their education or could not possibilities to keep left-wing critics out of the civil service. practise their professions, because these The measures to be taken were meant to be intimidating and were monopolised by the state. Therefore, Berufsverbote have lifelong existential deterrent. On the basis of this, the Prime Ministers of the Länder consequences for those affected. under the chair of Chancellor Willy Brandt on January 28, 1972 passed what became known as the "Anti-radicals Decree*" (Radikalenerlass). The "Radikalenerlass" Violated Essential Basic and Human Rights: Hurry up, gentlemen, 1. The principle of equality and here is another radical who wants the non-dis crimination rule to get into the civil service.
    [Show full text]
  • The Reform of Higher Education Systems and the Concept of Lifelong Learning
    The Reform of Higher Education Systems and the Concept of Lifelong Learning A comparative study of German and Armenian universities in the Bologna Process Dissertation zur Erlangung des akademischen Grades doctor philosophiae (Dr. phil.) vorgelegt dem Rat der Fakult¨at f¨ur Sozial- und Verhaltenswissenschaften der Friedrich-Schiller-Universit¨at Jena von Hasmik Hunanyan geboren am 21.04.1977 in Jerewan, Armenien Gutachter 1. Prof. Dr. Martha Friedenthal-Haase 2. Prof. Dr. Elisabeth Meilhammer Tag des Kolloquiums: 12.11.2010 Contents TitlePage.................................... i TableofContents................................ iii ListofFigures.................................. vii Acknowledgments................................ viii 1 Introduction 1 1.1 ResearchTopic .............................. 1 1.2 ResearchApproach ............................ 11 1.3 RelevancetoResearchandPractice . 13 1.4 StructureoftheThesis .......................... 16 2 Methodology 18 2.1 ResearchDesign.............................. 18 2.2 Cross-CountryComparison. 19 2.3 Selection of Cases for the Cross-Country Comparison . .. 25 2.4 Interview as a Method of Qualitative Research . 28 2.4.1 Purposesofinterviews . .. .. 28 2.4.2 The type of the interviews conducted . 30 2.4.3 Selection of interviewees . 34 2.4.4 Reflexions on the limitations of interviews as research method 35 2.5 The Case-Oriented Comparative Research Scheme . 36 3 The Bologna Process 40 3.1 Introduction................................ 40 iii Contents iv 3.2 MagnaChartaUniversitatum . 41 3.3 SorbonneDeclaration(1998). 43 3.4 BolognaDeclaration(1999) . 49 3.5 Lisbon, Salamanca, G¨oteborg, or other cities that matter . .... 53 3.6 PragueCommuniqu´e(2001) . 60 3.7 BerlinCommuniqu´e(2003). 62 3.8 BergenCommuniqu´e(2005) . 68 3.9 LondonCommuniqu´e(2007) . 73 3.10 Leuven/Louvain–la–Neuve Communiqu´e(2009) . 76 3.11Conclusions ................................ 80 4 The German System of Higher Education 85 4.1 HistoricalContext ...........................
    [Show full text]