DOCSLIB.ORG

FRAMING ANALYSIS on the NEWS of INDONESIAN CLASSIFIED DOCUMENTS in WIKILEAKS Study on Traditional Media (Kompas Newspaper ) and Online Media (

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
FRAMING ANALYSIS on the NEWS of INDONESIAN CLASSIFIED DOCUMENTS in WIKILEAKS Study on Traditional Media (Kompas Newspaper ) and Online Media ( 1 FRAMING ANALYSIS ON THE NEWS OF INDONESIAN CLASSIFIED DOCUMENTS IN WIKILEAKS Study On Traditional Media (Kompas Newspaper ) and Online Media (www.detik.com) By Alila Pramiyanti Lecturer on Communication Department Telkom Institute of Management Bandung - Indonesia ABSTRACT Mass media is a channel of mass communication. The definition of mass communication is a process in transmitting of an idea, information, and messages to the audience simultaneously. The characteristics of mass media are publicly, universal, periodic, continuously and actual. Globalization and modernization have influenced the evolution of mass media. The need of information, even from other parts of the world, requires every people to become more creative in using the media. The history of the emergence of mass media has the stages of growth in technology that can be divided into the print media, electronic media, and digital media or new media. The appearance of online media has also create the practice of online journalism. Online journalism becomes different from traditional journalism that already recognized earlier (print, radio, TV). Online journalism is not merely distinction because it taking a different venue, but because this journalism is carried on a new media which has different characteristics either in format, content, mechanisms and the relationship process between publishing and users or readers. Although these journalism, either traditional media (traditional journalism) and new media (online journalism) have differences in practice but each of them certainly has an ideology to frame the news. Framing analysis is an approach to analyzed media text. The concept of framing has used to understand the ideology of the media when their constructing the facts. This perspective tried to determine which facts is retrieved, which section is highlighted , or removed and how the media rearrange the story behind the news. This paper will discuss how the traditional media (Kompas newspapers) and online media (www.detik.com) in framing a news story. Unit of analysis on this research is the issues on March 11, 2011 about the Indonesian government Fakultas Ilmu Komunikasi – Universitas Mercu Buana www.mercubuana.ac.id 1 2 classified documents that was leaked by WikiLeaks. The news would be analyzed by using the model of Pan and Kosicki framing analysis which the framing of the news is divided into four structures, syntactic, scripts, thematic, and rhetoric. Key words: news, framing analysis, newspaper, online media Fakultas Ilmu Komunikasi – Universitas Mercu Buana www.mercubuana.ac.id 2 3 I. INTRODUCTION Actually, news is the result of written reconstruction of social reality in our life. That is why one can consider that writing news is only a task of reconstructing social reality than a representation of the reality itself. I do agree with this opinion. According to Nancy Nasution, news is the report of the events that happen, want to be known by the people, actual, take place in reader‟s area, talk about public figures, and has influential consequences to the reader. Basically, the framing analysis assumes that when the news or report is released, the mass media always have certain framing. The framing is the one that being investigated when we analyze the news. As in this case, the audience only receives the final result of a journalism process. Meanwhile the frame that has been used „is left on editorial desk‟. It happens properly, as when we shoot an event, it is impossible to keep details everything that is happening on the camera. What we note down is the event based on where we are standing. And clearly the camera frame also restricted the views. Same with news, because the space on printed media pages and the show time in electronic media are restricted, so the framing is important. In this case, presumption and prejudice are unavoidable. It makes the framing becomes subjective depend on the policy of each media. II. RESEARCH METHODOLOGY The unit of analysis which is used in the research utilizes four important structures of framing tools based on Zhongdan Pan and Gerald M. Kosicki. According to them, the four structures are syntactical structure, script structure, thematic structure, and rhetoric structure. The following is the analysis of each structure: 1. Syntactical Structure. The framing tool is news scheme. Units of the scheme: Headline: indicates the preference of the news and influences how the story is understood. Lead: indicates certain perspective of the news which is being reported. Background information: background determines to where the viewpoint of the public will be taken and can influences the meaning that wanted to be shown. Source citation: It has three functions, claims the validity of statement based on academic authority‟s claim; relates certain point by comparing it to majority opinion. Statements Closing Fakultas Ilmu Komunikasi – Universitas Mercu Buana www.mercubuana.ac.id 3 4 2. Script Structure. The framing tool is the news completeness. Units of the completeness of how to tell the story: how the story is processed becomes meaningful scenario. The way how the event is understood depends on how the reporter put the parts of the event in certain order. What, who, where, when, why, how, can be the main frame or usually called the elements of news completeness. 3. Thematic Structure. The framing tools are detail, coherence, sentence form, and pronoun. Units should be analyzed: Paragraph Preposition: the preposition that is placed on the beginning or in the end shows the one that want to be emphasized by the public, thus influences the meaning that emerged. Sentence: active sentence is used in order to make somebody becomes the subject of statement, meanwhile passive sentence is used in order to make somebody becomes the object of statement. Correlation between sentences: to see how someone strategically uses coherence to explain certain fact or event as separate, interrelate, or causal relationship. 4. Rhetoric Structure. The framing tools are lexicon, graphic, metaphor. Units should be analyzed: Word: the selection of certain words portrays how someone gives meaning to reality. Idiom Image Graphic: intensively controls the attention and anxiety, shows whether the information is considered as important and interesting so that it should become the focus. Table 1 The Framing Model of Pan & Kosicki UNIT SHOULD STRUCTURE FRAMING TOOL BE ANALYZED SINTACTICAL 1. The News Scheme Headline, The reporter‟s way of Lead, arranging the news Background information, Fakultas Ilmu Komunikasi – Universitas Mercu Buana www.mercubuana.ac.id 4 5 Source citation, Statements, Closing SCRIPT 2. The News Completeness 5 W + 1 H The reporter‟s way of telling facts THEMATIC 3. Detail Paragraph, The reporter‟s way of 4. Purpose of the sentence preposition writing facts 5. Nominalization between sentence 6. Coherence 7. Sentence form 8. Pronoun RHETORIC 9. Lexicon Word, idiom, The reporter‟s way of 10. Graphic picture/image, emphasizing facts 11 .Metaphor graphic. 12. Assumption Source: Sobur (2001:176) The Development of Validity In order to guarantee and develop the validity of data, the researchers choose to use triangulation data technique in the form of triangulation theory. Triangulation theory is used by doing check and recheck on the online journalism theory which is used with journalism practices in each media. III. LITERATURE REVIEW The revolution of journalism relates with the way how to convey the ideas in written form. For a long time, the process of writing news is dominated with classic concept of 5W +1H (what, when, where, why, who, and how) which refer to facts in the field. In modern journalism, the classic concept is developed by Roy Peter to narrative form of writing by changing the pattern 5W+1H. Who develops into character. What develops into plot. When develops into chronology. Who develops into character. Why develops into motive. And How develops into narration. Therefore, the process of writing news is narratively similar to the process of making documentary movie (Santana, 2001). Fakultas Ilmu Komunikasi – Universitas Mercu Buana www.mercubuana.ac.id 5 6 News Value According to Julian Harriss, Kelly Leiter and Stanley Johnson, news value contain eight elements, those are conflict, progression, important, close, actual and unique, humanely, and influential (Harriss, Leiter dan Johnson 1981:29-33). It means that those criteria should be confirmed before we report an event. Conflict Progression Important Close Actual Humanely Influential The numbers of elements of news value that need to be filled in every event before it becomes the news are variously different in every press release. Some newspapers maintain only five elements of news value. Fakultas Ilmu Komunikasi – Universitas Mercu Buana www.mercubuana.ac.id 6 7 News Structure Generally, the news always presents the structure of: headline, lead, and body (Basuki 1983:22-25). Headline. Use to be called a title. It is often completed with sub-title. It is used to: (1) help the reader to immediately know the news that is being reported; (2) emphasize the news by supporting it with graphic technique. Lead. Use to be called news core. It is usually written on the first paragraph of the news. It is the most important part of the news, which decides whether the news will be read or not. It is the centre of the news, which briefly depicts whole content of the news. Body Or news body. Its content tells the event that is reported by using brief, compact and explicit language. Therefore, the body is the development on the news. The news structure is determined by the form of the report that will be written. The direct news structure is different with minor news and the story one. In direct news, according to Bruce D. Itule and Douglas A. Anderson, there is only one common structure, an inverted pyramid (Itule dan Anderson 1987: 62-63). Lead shows the beginning part which is the most important in the news.
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Sudargo Gautama and the Development of Indonesian Public Order: a Study on the Application of Public Order Doctrine in a Pluralistic Legal System
    Sudargo Gautama and the Development of Indonesian Public Order: A Study on the Application of Public Order Doctrine in a Pluralistic Legal System Yu Un Oppusunggu A dissertation submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy University of Washington 2015 Reading Committee: John O. Haley, Chair Michael E. Townsend Beth E. Rivin Program Authorized to Offer Degree School of Law © Copyright 2015 Yu Un Oppusunggu ii University of Washington Abstract Sudargo Gautama and the Development of Indonesian Public Order: A Study on the Application of Public Order Doctrine in a Pluralistic Legal System Yu Un Oppusunggu Chair of the Supervisory Committee: Professor John O. Haley School of Law A sweeping proviso that protects basic or fundamental interests of a legal system is known in various names – ordre public, public policy, public order, government’s interest or Vorbehaltklausel. This study focuses on the concept of Indonesian public order in private international law. It argues that Indonesia has extraordinary layers of pluralism with respect to its people, statehood and law. Indonesian history is filled with the pursuit of nationhood while protecting diversity. The legal system has been the unifying instrument for the nation. However the selected cases on public order show that the legal system still lacks in coherence. Indonesian courts have treated public order argument inconsistently. A prima facie observation may find Indonesian public order unintelligible, and the courts have gained notoriety for it. This study proposes a different perspective. It sees public order in light of Indonesia’s legal pluralism and the stages of legal development.
    [Show full text]
  • 1146/III/IV/2021 Ÿ April 2021
    Buletin Nomor 1146/III/IV/2021 April 2021 Pembangunan Infrastruktur Surakarta Harus Mampu Pulihkan Ekonomi 3 Bandara Taufiq Kiemas 4 Azis Syamsuddin Diharapkan Tingkatkan Dukung Kesejahteraan Pembentukan BULETIN Masyarakat Satgas BLBI BULETIN Parlementaria Pembangunan Infrastruktur Surakarta Harus Mampu Pulihkan Ekonomi DEWAN PERWAKILAN RAKYAT REPUBLIK INDONESIA im Kunjungan Kerja Reses Komisi V DPR RI menekankan bahwa sejumlah infrastruktur yang Tdibangun di Kota Surakarta, Provinsi Jawa Tengah harus mampu mendorong pertumbuhan ekonomi dan penyerapan tenaga kerja lokal di seluruh daerah. Wakil Ketua Komisi V DPR RI Arwani Thomafi mengatakan, kondisi ekonomi nasional saat ini sangat terdampak akibat pandemi Covid-19, sehingga harus dilakukan refocusing atau penghematan dalam tahun anggaran 2021, serta rincian program kerja setelah penghematan tersebut. “Kita telah meninjau ke sejumlah titik rencana pembangunan yang Tim Kunker Komisi V DPR RI meninjau pembangunan infrastruktur di Kota Surakarta, Jawa Tengah. Foto: Jaka/Nvl akan dibiayai APBN di antaranya jembatan layang (flyover) Purwosari, pengembangan Plaza sangat penting untuk melestarikan dalam kerja dengan para menteri untuk Ngarsopuro, revitalisasi Taman budaya, pengembangan pariwisata dan usulan dari Kota Surakarta. Mudah- Budaya Balekambang sebagai pusat juga sebagai tempat bermain untuk mudahan pemerintah pusat dan daerah kebudayaan Kota Surakarta, rehabilitasi masyarakat. “Untuk rehabilitasi Kawasan ini melaksanakan programnya dengan Kawasan Bendung Tirtonadi dan Bendung Tirtonadi, kita harapkan selain baik,” harap legislator dapil Jateng III ini. bantuan perumahan di Kelurahan sebagai fungsi untuk air baku dan Dalam kesempatan yang sama, Wali Semanggi. Saya kira dari masterplan pengendalian banjir, tapi kita harapkan Kota Solo Gibran Rakabuming Raka dan kesiapan lainnya sudah cukup, juga dipercantik sebagai fungsi wisata. mengatakan, pihaknya ingin secepatnya hanya perlu pengawasan dari seluruh Kemudian juga untuk penataan Kawasan mengakselerasi pemulihan ekonomi di pihak agar berjalan dengan baik.
    [Show full text]
  • Joint Communique
    ASEAN Inter-Parliamentary Organization JOINT COMMUNIQUE 24TinH GENERAL ASSEMBLY 7-12 SEPTEMBER 2003 JAKARTA, INDONESIA ASEAN Inter-Parliamentary Organization 24th General Assembly 7-12 September 2003, Jakarta, Indonesia 24GA/2003/JC JOINT COMMUNIQUE INTRODUCTION 1. Pursuant to the decision of the 23rd General Assembly of the ASEAN Inter-Parliamentary Organization (AIPO) held on 8-13 September 2002, in Hanoi, and in accordance with the Statutes of AIPO, the 24th General Assembly was held on 7 - 12 September 2003, in Jakarta wit participatioe hth eighf no t member countries: Cambodia, Indonesia PDRo La , , Malaysia e PhilippinesTh , , Singapore, Thailand d Vietnaman , o speciatw ; l observer countries: Brunei Darussalam, and Myanmar; and seven observer countries: Canada, People's Republic of China, Japan, Republic of Korea, New Zealand, Russian Federation, anEuropeae dth n Parliament. 2. The Women Parliamentarians of AIPO (WAIPO) met on 7 September 2003 prior to the opening ceremony of the 24th General Assembly. 3. H.E. Akbar Tandjung, Speake e Housth f f Representativeo o er e Republith f o s f o c Indonesia in his capacity as President of AIPO, presided over the 24th AIPO General Assembly. 4. The Leaders of AIPO Member Delegations, Special Observers, Observers and the Secretary Genera ASEAf o l Guess Na Honof to r pai dcourtesa Presidene y th cal n o l f o t AIPO. 5. All participants to the 24th AIPO General Assembly were cordially invited to a dinner hosted by H.E. Megawati Soekamoputri, President of the Republic of Indonesia and Hon. Taufiq Kiemas. 6 AIPO delegate d theian s r spouses also attended dinner receptions hoste y Honb d .
    [Show full text]
  • Sosok Megawati Sebagai Kandidat Presiden 2009 Dalam Bingkai Harian Koran Tempo Dan Rakyat Merdeka
    SOSOK MEGAWATI SEBAGAI KANDIDAT PRESIDEN 2009 DALAM BINGKAI HARIAN KORAN TEMPO DAN RAKYAT MERDEKA Skripsi Diajukan untuk Memenuhi Persyaratan Memperoleh Gelar Sarjana Sosial Islam (S.Sos.I) Oleh : M. Yowan Zulfikar NIM : 104051101945 KONSENTRASI JURNALISTIK PROGRAM STUDI KOMUNIKASI PENYIARAN ISLAM FAKULTAS ILMU DAKWAN DAN ILMU KOMUNIKASI UNIVERSITAS ISLAM NEGERI SYARIF HIDAYATULLAH J A K A R T A 1432 H/2011 M 1 2 3 4 KATA PENGANTAR ﺑِِِِﺴْﻢِ اﷲِ اﻟﱠﺮ ﺣْﻤَﻦِ اﻟﱠﺮ ﺣِﯿْﻢِ Puji syukur senantiasa dipersembahkan ke hadirat Allah SWT. Hanya berkat rahmat, anugerah dan kasih sayang-Nya, penulis mendapat kekuatan sehingga bisa menyelesaikan skripsi ini. Shalawat beriring salam semoga tetap tercurah kepada insan pilihan yang pernah ada di muka bumi ini, yakni Muhammad SAW., keluarganya, sahabatnya, pengikutnya dan para penggemarnya yang setia hingga hari pembalasan. Dalam penulisan skripsi ini tidak sedikit kesulitan dan kendala yang dihadapi penulis, baik yang menyangkut pengumpulan bahan maupun pembiayaan, dan sebagainya. Namun, berkat kemauan keras dan kesungguhan hati, disertai dorongan dan bantuan dari berbagai pihak, maka segala kesulitan dan kendala dapat diatasi dengan baik. Oleh karena itu, penulis mengucapkan terima kasih yang sedalam-dalamnya dan penghargaan yang setinggi-tingginya kepada semua pihak yang telah terlibat dan membantu dalam penyelesaian skripsi ini, terutama sosok Ibunda tersayang Mu’awanah M.Pd dan Ayah tercinta Mulyono yang (subhana allah) dengan segala keikhlasan, kesabaran dan doa tulusnya menunggu penulis dalam menyelesaikan kuliah. Kemudian dosen pembimbing skripsi, Tantan Hermansyah, M.Si yang telah membimbing penulis dalam menyusun skripsi ini. Selanjutnya penulis sampaikan rasa terima kasih kepada: 1. Dr. Arief Subhan, M.Ag Dekan Fakultas Ilmu Dakwah dan Ilmu komunikasi.
    [Show full text]
  • 09/07/2005, 23:19 WIB - KOMPAS Cyber Media - Hiburan
    Presiden Bangga Jadi Mertua Annisa - 09/07/2005, 23:19 WIB - KOMPAS Cyber Media - Hiburan Free E-Mail | Chat | Ad Info | About Us | Contact Us Hiburan Updated: Sabtu, 09 Juli 2005, 23:19 WIB HIBURAN Rubrik Komunitas Kolom Presiden Bangga Jadi Mertua Annisa Surat Kabar Majalah Jakarta, Sabtu CARI Presiden Susilo Bambang Yudhoyono pada Kirim Teman | Print Artikel Sabtu petang terlihat ’sumringah’ saat melaksanakan perhelatan putera pertamanya, Lettu Infantri Agus Harimurti Yudhoyono yang pada Jumat (8/7) resmi menikahi bintang iklan dan presenter televisi, Annisa Larasati Pohan. Ketika memberikan sambutan singkat sebelum resepsi pernikahan yang bertempat di halaman Istana Kepresidenan Bogor itu dimulai, Yudhoyono mengatakan dirinya bangga atas perkawinan yang terjadi antara puteranya dengan Annisa Pohan. "I’m just the proud father of Agus and father-in-law of Annisa," kata Yudhoyono yang menyampaikan sambutan selamat datang dalam dua bahasa, Indonesia dan Inggris. Resepsi pernikahan itu, selain oleh kerabat dan tokoh dalam negeri, juga dihadiri oleh sejumlah tamu asing, termasuk Menteri Luar Negeri Timor Timur, Jose Ramos Horta. Dengan mengenakan beskap hijau tua dan kain warna coklat dan ’blangkon’ warna senada, Yudhoyono selain meminta doa restu dari hadirin bagi Agus dan Annisa, juga meminta maaf kepada para tokoh dan masyarakat karena mau tidak mau harus membatasi jumlah undangan dengan alasan keterbatasan tempat. Sementara itu, sebelumnya dalam jumpa pers menjelang resepsi, Yudhoyono saat menjawab pertanyaan wartawan mengatakan dirinya yakin Annisa mampu menjalani kehidupan sebagai isteri Agus Harimurti, yang memiliki kehidupan keprajuritan yang disebutnya khas. "Annisa adalah pilihan yang tepat dari anak saya, bisa menyesuaikan diri dengan kehidupan keprajuritan yang memerlukan banyak pengorbanan karena sering ditinggal bertugas atau latihan," kata Yudhoyono.
    [Show full text]
  • Indonesia Backgrounder: a Guide to the 2004 Elections
    INDONESIA BACKGROUNDER: A GUIDE TO THE 2004 ELECTIONS 18 December 2003 Asia Report N°71 Jakarta/Brussels TABLE OF CONTENTS EXECUTIVE SUMMARY AND RECOMMENDATIONS................................................. i I. INTRODUCTION .......................................................................................................... 1 II. ELECTORAL REFORM .............................................................................................. 2 A. THE OLD SYSTEM .................................................................................................................2 B. DIRECT ELECTION OF THE PRESIDENT ...................................................................................2 C. ELECTION OF LEGISLATURES ................................................................................................4 D. MORE OF THE SAME?............................................................................................................5 III. PARTIES .........................................................................................................................6 A. PDI-P ...................................................................................................................................6 B. GOLKAR................................................................................................................................7 C. PKB .....................................................................................................................................9 D. PPP.......................................................................................................................................9
    [Show full text]
  • Indonesia: a Guide to the 2004 Elections (2003)
    INDONESIA BACKGROUNDER: A GUIDE TO THE 2004 ELECTIONS 18 December 2003 Asia Report N°71 Jakarta/Brussels TABLE OF CONTENTS EXECUTIVE SUMMARY AND RECOMMENDATIONS................................................. i I. INTRODUCTION .......................................................................................................... 1 II. ELECTORAL REFORM .............................................................................................. 2 A. THE OLD SYSTEM .................................................................................................................2 B. DIRECT ELECTION OF THE PRESIDENT ...................................................................................2 C. ELECTION OF LEGISLATURES ................................................................................................4 D. MORE OF THE SAME?............................................................................................................5 III. PARTIES ......................................................................................................................... 6 A. PDI-P ...................................................................................................................................6 B. GOLKAR................................................................................................................................7 C. PKB .....................................................................................................................................9 D. PPP.......................................................................................................................................9
    [Show full text]
  • Lamenting the Fate of Indonesian Migrant Workers Overseas
    Volume V, No. 8 - Desember 2010 ISSN 1979-1976 Monthly Review on Economic, Legal, Security, Political, and Social Affairs Main Report: Lamenting the Fate of Indonesian Migrant Workers Overseas The Economics Currency War and Rupiah . The Benefits and Costs of “Hot Money” . Politics BUMN: Between Economic and Politic Entities . Official Overseas Visits of Parliament Members: Costs vs Benefits . Re-arranging Coalition: Golkar Exits, PDI-P Enters, Is it possible? . Social Issues Disaster Management . ISSN 1979-1976 CONTENTS Foreword ................................................................ 1 MAIN Report Lamenting the Fate of Indonesian Migrant Workers Overseas ............................... 2 THE ECONOMICS Currency War and Rupiah ................................................ 6 The Benefits and Costs of “Hot Money” ............................ 8 POLITICS BUMN: Between Economic and Politic Entities .................. 10 Official Overseas Visits of Parliament Members: Costs vs Benefits ............................................................. 13 Re-arranging Coalition: Golkar Exits, PDI-P Enters, Is it possible?............................ 16 SOCIAL ISSUES Disaster Management ...................................................... 19 CompanY PROFILE ..................................................... 22 RESEARCH AND TRAINING PROGRAMS .................... 23 Advertorial INDONESIA 2009 ................................. 25 Contributors : Anies Baswedan (Executive & Research Director), Endang Srihadi (Coordinator), Aly Yusuf, Antonius
    [Show full text]
  • Election Update Issue 2, Oct/Nov 2008
    Election Update Issue 2, Oct/Nov 2008 The Multi-Choice Elections 2009 will be an important year for reformasi in Indonesia, which began in 1998 after the downfall of the dictatorial Suharto regime. On 9 April 2009, elections will be held for the Indonesian Parliament, the DPR (Dewan Perwakilan Rakyat, People’s Representative Assembly), the DPD (Dewan Perwakilan Daerah, Regional Representatives Council) and provincial assemblies. Three months later, the first round of direct elections will be held for the President and Vice-President. No fewer than 38 political parties will participate in the legislative elections. Just ten years ago, Indonesia emerged from what was in effect a one-party system. The bicameral system of Indonesian Parliament became increasingly powerless. governance is only five years old, following the creation of the DPD, first elected in 2004. The MPs were only allowed to rubber-stamp new DPD is composed of four representatives from laws. Serious discussions were seen as a each province, all non-party independents. It hindrance to authoritarian rule. has the right to make proposals and submit opinions on legislative matters and monitor the As is the case under the US presidential implementation of laws, but it does not yet system, members of the government are have the revising function of second chambers appointees of the President. In Indonesia, they in other countries such as the (unelected) are not directly answerable to parliament House of Lords in the UK or the US Senate. though they can be, and frequently are, There is growing unease about what some summoned to give an account of their policies lawyers and politicians regard as the and actions to parliamentary committees.
    [Show full text]
  • Cambridge University Press 978-1-107-12303-8 — the Unforgettable Queens of Islam Shahla Haeri Index More Information
    Cambridge University Press 978-1-107-12303-8 — The Unforgettable Queens of Islam Shahla Haeri Index More Information Index abangan, 187 succession and, 23, 50, 51–52, Abbasi, Safdar, 168 54–57 Abbasid caliphate, 14 ʿUthman and, 58–59, 60–62, 71–72 Abbott, Nabia, 14, 56, 59, 63, 65, as wife and daughter, 57–60 73–74 Aitegin, Malik Ikhtiyar al-Din, 117, Abish Khatun, 7–8 122–123 Abu Ali Hasan ibn Ali Tusi. See Nizam ʿAli (caliph), 54–55, 62, 70 al-Mulk ʿAʾisha opposing, 2, 51, 55, 58, 60, 61–68 Abu Bakr (caliph), 57, 59 in Shiʿism, 54, 169 Abu Bakra, 51, 73–75 Ali, Jam Sadiq, 163–164 Aceh, Sultanate of, 6–7 ʿAli b. Muhammad al-Sulayhi, 82–84, Adam and Eve, Quranic story of, 75 101–102 Adopt a Queen class project, xiv Allen, Brooke, 165, 174, 176, 179 al-Afdal b. Badr al-Jamali, 97, 98–99 Altunia, Ikhtiyar al-Din Afghanistan, 161–162 Razia and, 106–107, 117–118, 121–124, for girls, education struggle in, 5 125, 130, 133–134 Pakistan and, 156–157, 161 Yaqut and, 117–118, 121–124, 133–134 US in, 170 Al-Zulfikar Organization (Pakistan) (AZO), Afsaruddin, Asma, x–xi, 6 160, 161–163 Ahmed, Durre, 151, 175 Amir b. Sulayman al-Zawahi, 92 Ahsan, Aitzaz, 155–159, 160, 168 al-Amir bi-Ahkam Allah, 79–80, 98–101, ʿAʾisha, 58, 60, 63, 67 102, 103 Caliph ʿAli opposed by, 2, 51, 55, 58, 60, Anderson, Benedict, 199 61–68 Anwar, Raja, 160, 161, 167 in Battle of the Camel, 1–2, 19, 23, 50, ʿaql (wisdom), 47 51, 54–57, 58–67, 68, 69–70, 184 Arab military leaders, female, 65 defeat of, 19, 67–68, 71 Arab Spring, ix female political authority and, 51, 54–57, Arwa
    [Show full text]
  • Mereka Bicara Pancasila... (Alm) TAUFIQ KIEMAS
    1 2 | TATAP REDAKSI PANCASILA TIDAK RUMIT alahkah Obama menafsirkan Pancasila dengan cara memaksakan kehendaknya ke Sukarno. Spandang liberalisme kentalnya? Sukarno hanya bersyukur, bahwa Pancasila menurut Salahkah kalau Putin juga berusaha menafsirkan kehendak seluruh anggota Panitia Sembilan itulah Pancasila dengan realitas yang terjadi di negaranya? Atau, yang harus diterima sebagai kehendak bersama untuk salahkah juga kalau SBY menafsirkan Pancasila dengan memutuskan sebuah dasar negara. caranya sendiri? Kalau kemudian dia memimpin negara dengan dasar Atau salahkah Sukarno ketika di sidang Badan Pancasila maka dia akan konsekuen melaksanakan Pancasila Penyelidik Usaha-usaha Persiapan Kemerdekaan sesuai dengan cara pandangnya sendiri, Gotong Royong. Indonesia (BPUPKI) mengatakan Pancasila itu bila Kalau kemudian Soeharto memimpin negara dengan diperas akan menjadi Trisila. Dan Trisila kalau dasar Pancasila maka dia akan menggunakan diperas lagi akan menjadi Ekasila atau Gotong Pancasila sesuai dengan pemahamannya. Royong? Kalau kemudian Abdoel Kahar Moezakkir Sukarno ternyata tidak marah ketika idenya ternyata memimpin negara ini, maka dia diubah dan dirombak oleh Panitia Sembilan. akan menggunakan Pancasila sesuai dengan Sukarno ternyata tidak marah, dia justru penafsirannya sendiri. bernapas lega. Karena perbedaan cara pandang, Jadi jangan pernah marah kalau Pancasila cara pikir, cara bersikap dan cara berbudaya ditafsir berbeda oleh setiap penduduk yang tinggal setiap manusia yang ada di Panitia Sembilan itu di negeri ini. Karena Pancasila bukan pernyataan ternyata bisa terakomodasi dengan tawarannya: tentang realitas. Tapi tempatkan Pancasila sebagai sebuah draf dasar negara, Pancasila, Trisila atau dasar menuju realitas. Itulah yang terpenting. Ekasila (Gotong Royong). Pancasila tidak rumit. Dasar negara ini tidak rumit. Sukarno ternyata juga tidak marah meski ide aslinya Pedoman negara ini tidak rumit.
    [Show full text]
  • Shall We Dance? Defining Sexuality and Controlling the Body in Contemporary Indonesia
    religions Article Shall We Dance? Defining Sexuality and Controlling the Body in Contemporary Indonesia Okky Madasari Department of Malay Studies, National University of Singapore, Singapore 119077, Singapore; [email protected] Abstract: This article examines how Indonesia, the world’s third-largest democracy, came to define sexuality for its general population once intimacy was brought into the public sphere. However, its Islamic version had predominantly been based on interpretations pushed by politically hardline Islamist groups. The influence of this lobby (to be referred to as belonging to the stream of ‘con- servative Islam’) grew steadily after the downfall of the Suharto regime in 1998 and culminated in the passage of an antipornography law ten years later. Focusing on the definitions of sexuality and pornography forwarded by these groups, this article analyses their limitations as well as the power contestations behind the passage of the antipornography legislation. It argues that such narrow interpretations of sexuality have had a marked impact on the nation, in particular the curtailment of Citation: Madasari, Okky. 2021. its popular culture and creative industry. This has resulted in the arbitrary persecution and banning Shall We Dance? Defining Sexuality of cultural products considered to violate Islamic morality and propriety. The condemnation of and Controlling the Body in Contemporary Indonesia. Religions dangdut singer Inul Daratista, and her ‘drill dance’, is one of many examples of such suppression. 12: 264. https://doi.org/10.3390/ rel12040264 Keywords: pornography law; intimacy; sexuality; Islam; popular culture Academic Editors: Maznah Mohamad and Terry Lovat 1. Introduction Received: 8 March 2021 Homosexuality is not illegal in Indonesia, except in Aceh, which has applied strict Accepted: 7 April 2021 sharia laws since 2001.
    [Show full text]