EUROPEAN PARLIAMENT
1999 2004
Committee on Foreign Affairs, Human Rights, Common Security and Defence Policy
PE/I/PV/04-04
MINUTES of the meeting of 17 February 2004, 3 pm - 6.30 pm, 18 February 2004, 9 am - 12.30 pm and 4.15 - 7.30 pm and 19 February 2004, 9 am - 12.30 pm BRUSSELS
The joint meeting opened at 3.10 pm on Tuesday, 17 February 2004, with Doug Bereuter, president of the NATO Parliamentary Assembly and Elmar Brok, chairman of the Foreign Affairs Committee, in the chair.
1. Joint meeting with the NATO Parliamentary Assembly: "EU-NATO Relations - A Partnership for Peace and Security"
Exchange of views with Admiral Rainer Feist, DSACEUR NATO, and Major General Jean-Pierre Herreweghe, Chief of EU Military Staff
Speakers: Markus Meckel (NATO PA, Germany), Philippe Morillon, Longin Pastusiak (NATO PA, Poland), Karl von Wogau, Michael Gapes (NATO PA, UK), Geoffrey Van Orden, Jozef Banas (NATO PA Slovakia), Efstratios Korakas, Vahit Erdem (NATO PA, Turkey), Bogdan Klich (observer), Jaroslava Moserova (NATO PA, Czech Republic), Pernille Frahm
2. Adoption of draft agenda PE 341.335
The draft agenda was adopted in the form shown in these minutes.
3. Exchange of views with Mr Robert Cooper, Director-General for CFSP of Council, on future ESDP missions
Speakers: Jan Marinus Wiersma, Geoffrey Van Orden, Baroness Ludford, Per
PV\520215EN.doc PE 341.344 Or. en EN EN Gahrton, Hannes Swoboda, Philippe Morillon, Efstratios Korakas, Toomas Hendrik Ilves (observer), Bastiaan Belder
* * * The meeting adjourned at 6.25 pm and resumed on Wednesday, 18 February 2004 at 9.10 am with Elmar Brok, chairman, in the chair. * * *
4. Exchange of views with Mr Ahmed Q'orei, Prime Minister of Palestine, Mr Salam Fayyad, Minister of Finance, and Mr Saeb Erekat, Minister in charge of negotiations
Speakers: Luisa Morgantini, Geoffrey Van Orden, Hannes Swoboda, Baroness Nicholson of Winterbourne, Francis Wurtz, Jan Dhaene, Marco Pannella, John Walls Cushnahan, Jannis Sakellariou, Cecilia Malmström
* * * Baroness Nicholson of Winterbourne, vice-chairwoman, in the chair. * * *
5. Annual report on human rights in the world in 2003 and the EU's human rights policy
T08162 - 2003/2005(INI) PE 329.350 Rapporteur: Véronique De Keyser - Further consideration of draft report
Speakers: Rapporteur, Karl von Wogau, Cecilia Malmström, Geoffrey Van Orden
Decision: Deadline for tabling amendments: Wednesday, 18 February 2004, at 6 pm
6. Any other business
Report by Bastiaan Belder, AFET rapporteur on Russia, on progress in the revision of the EU's Russia policy
7. The Guantánamo detainees' right to a fair trial
T08601 - 2003/2229(INI) - B5-0426/2003 PE 329.353 Rapporteur: Ole Andreasen - Consideration of draft report
PE 341.344 2/19 PV\520215EN.doc Or. en EN Speakers: Rapporteur, Arie M. Oostlander, Jannis Sakellariou, Geoffrey Van Orden
8. European Agency for the Management of Operational Cooperation at the External Borders
* T08602 - 2003/0273(CNS) - COM(2003) 687 - C5-0613/2003 PE 341.333 Draftswoman: Cristiana Muscardini - Consideration and adoption of draft opinion
Speakers: Luís Queiró (for the draftswoman), Pasqualina Napoletano
Decision: The draft opinion was adopted unopposed with 1 abstention.
9. Asylum: international protection system
T08426 - 2003/2155(INI) - COM(2003) 152 and 315 - C5-0373/2003 PE 329.366 Draftsman: Mario Mauro - Consideration and adoption of draft opinion
Amendments adopted: 1 (2nd part), 2-4, 5 (1st part)
Decision: The draft opinion, as amended, was adopted by 20 votes to 3 with no abstentions.
10. Exchange of views with Mr Heikki Talvitie, EU Special Representative for the South Caucasus
Speakers: Ioannis Souladakis, Ursula Schleicher, Per Gahrton, Reino Paasilinna, Demetrio Volcic
* * * The meeting adjourned at 12.50 pm and resumed at 4.40 pm with Elmar Brok, chairman, in the chair. * * *
11. Progress towards accession by Bulgaria
T08586 - 2003/2202(INI) - COM(2003) 676 - C5-0533/2003 PE 329.356 Rapporteur: Geoffrey Van Orden - Consideration of draft report and amendments
Speakers: Rapporteur, Elisabeth Schroedter, Jannis Sakellariou, Arie M. Oostlander, Mr Jung-Olsen (Commission)
PV\520215EN.doc 3/19 PE 341.344 Or. en EN 12. Progress towards accession by Romania
T08587 - 2003/2203(INI) - COM(2003) 676 - C5-0534/2003 PE 329.357 Rapporteur: Baroness Nicholson of Winterbourne - Consideration of draft report and amendments
Speakers: Rapporteur, Jan Marinus Wiersma, Ioannis Souladakis, Michael Cashman, Arie M. Oostlander, Mario Mauro, Gianfranco Dell'Alba, José Ignacio Salafranca Sánchez-Neyra, Mr Grillo-Paquarelli (Commission)
13. Comprehensive monitoring report on the state of preparedness of the candidate countries
T08585 - 2003/2201(INI) - COM(2003) 675 - C5-0532/2003 PE 329.354 Rapporteur: Elmar Brok - Consideration of draft report and amendments
Speakers: Jürgen Schröder, Karl Erik Olsson, Gerard Collins, Agnes Vadai (observer), Jan Marinus Wiersma, Jacques F. Poos, Andrew Nicholas Duff, Arie M. Oostlander, Geoffrey Van Orden, Elisabeth Schroedter, Mr Mirel (Commission), Toomas Hendrik Ilves (observer), Alfred Gomolka, Juris Dobelis (observer), Ioannis Souladakis, Demetrio Volcic
* * * The meeting adjourned at 7.05 pm and resumed on Thursday, 19 February 2004 at 9.15 am with Elmar Brok, chairman, in the chair. * * *
14. The Guantánamo detainees' right to a fair trial
T08601 - 2003/2229(INI) - B5-0426/2003 PE 329.353 Rapporteur: Ole Andreasen - Adoption of draft report
Amendments adopted: 1, 5, 9, COMP 1, 14, 18, 20, COMP 2, 30, 31, COMP 3, 35-37, 39, 41-44, 46, 50, LIBE amendments to paragraphs 3-5 and recitals A, B and E
Decision: The draft report, as amended, was adopted by 34 votes to 3 with no abstentions.
PE 341.344 4/19 PV\520215EN.doc Or. en EN 15. Political Dialogue and Cooperation Agreement between the EC and Central American countries
T08612 - 2003/0266(CNS) - COM(2003) 677 - C5-0658/2003 PE 329.365 Rapporteur: Raimon Obiols i Germà - Adoption of draft report
Decision: The draft report was adopted unanimously.
16. Political Dialogue and Cooperation Agreement between the EC and the Andean Community
T08614 - 2003/0268(CNS) - COM(2003) 695 - C5-0657/2003 PE 329.360 Rapporteur: José Ignacio Salafranca Sánchez-Neyra - Adoption of draft report
Decision: The draft report was adopted unanimously.
17. Progress towards accession by Bulgaria
T08586 - 2003/2202(INI) - COM(2003) 676 - C5-0533/2003 PE 329.356 Rapporteur: Geoffrey Van Orden - Adoption of draft report
Amendments adopted: 1-4, ORAL para. 3a, ORAL 1, 10-12, RETT para. 5, BUDG para. 1, AGRI para. 7 and 8, 13, 14, COMP 1, 18, COMP 2, 20
Decision: The draft report, as amended, was adopted unanimously.
18. Progress towards accession by Romania
T08587 - 2003/2203(INI) - COM(2003) 676 - C5-0534/2003 PE 329.357 Rapporteur: Baroness Nicholson of Winterbourne - Adoption of draft report
Amendments adopted: ORAL 1, 2-12, COMP 1, ORAL 2 (1st part), 16-23, ORAL 3, 24, 25, FEMM para. 5, EMPL para. 7, ITRE para. 1 and 2, BUDG para. 1, 26, ORAL 4, 27-29, AGRI para. 6, COMP para. 19, ORAL 6, 32, 33
Decision: The draft report, as amended, was adopted unanimously.
19. Comprehensive monitoring report on the state of preparedness of the candidate countries
T08585 - 2003/2201(INI) - COM(2003) 675 - C5-0532/2003 PE 329.354
PV\520215EN.doc 5/19 PE 341.344 Or. en EN Rapporteur: Elmar Brok - Adoption of draft report
Amendments adopted: ORAL para. 6, 5, 6, 10 (1st part), ORAL para. 8ea, 12-15, 16 (1st part), 17 (2nd part), 21-27, 29-33, 40, 44, 45, 47-49, 51, 53, 54, 56, 58-60, ORAL para. 38, ORAL para. 39, 65, 70, 74, 80, 81, 83 (1st part), 87, 91, 92 (2nd part), 93, 95, 96, 99, 102, 104, 107, 112, 116, 117, 121, 122 (1st part), 123, 124 (2nd part), 128-130, 132, 133, 135-139, 143-145, ORAL para. 109, 147, 148, LIBE 15, AGRI 4, AGRI 11- 12, EMPL 15, JURI 11
Decision: The draft report, as amended, was adopted unopposed with 3 abstentions.
20. Progress towards accession by Turkey
T08588 - 2003/2204(INI) - COM(2003) 676 - C5-0535/2003 PE 329.363 Rapporteur: Arie M. Oostlander - First consideration of draft report
Speakers: Rapporteur, Andrew Nicholas Duff, Christos Zacharakis,
* * * Mr Christos Zacharakis, vice-chairman, in the chair. * * *
Ioannis Souladakis, Gianfranco Dell'Alba, Véronique De Keyser, Karl von Wogau, Giorgos Katiforis, Charles Tannock, Mr Ruete (Commission)
Decision: Deadline for tabling amendments: Tuesday, 2 March 2004
21. Progress towards accession by Croatia
T08640 - 2003/2254(INI) - B5-0476/2003 PE 329.364 Rapporteur: Alexandros Baltas Consideration of draft report
Speakers: Rapporteur, Doris Pack, Demetrio Volcic, Ms Pampaloni (Commission)
Decision: Deadline for tabling amendments: Tuesday, 2 March 2004 * * *
PE 341.344 6/19 PV\520215EN.doc Or. en EN 22. Date and place of next meeting
Tuesday, 24 February 2004, 9 am - 12.30 pm and 3 pm - 6.30 pm, in Brussels
* * * The meeting closed at 12.15 pm.
PV\520215EN.doc 7/19 PE 341.344 Or. en EN BILAG/ANLAGE/ΠΑΡΑΡΤΗΜΑ/ANNEX/ ANNEXE/ALLEGATO/BIJLAGE/ANEXO/LIITE/BILAGA
DELTAGERLISTE/ANWESENHEITSLISTE/ΚΑΤΑΣΤΑΣΗ ΠΑΡΟΝΤΩΝ/RECORD OF ATTENDANCE/LISTA DE ASISTENCIA/LISTE DE PRESENCE/ELENCO DEI PRESENTI/PRESENTIELIJST/LISTA DE PRESENÇAS/LÄSNÄOLOLISTA/DELTAGARLISTA
Til stede Formandskabet/Vorstand/Προεδρείο/Bureau/Ufficio di Presidenza/Mesa/Puheenjohtajisto/J.L. Presidium: (*) Elmar Brok (P) (1,2,3), Baroness Nicholson of Winterbourne (1 VP) (1,2,3), Geoffrey Van Orden (2 VP) (1,2,3), Christos Zacharakis (3 VP) (1,2,3) Anwesend Medlemmer/Mitglieder/Μέλη/Members/Diputados/Députés/Deputati/Leden/Deputados/Jäsenet/ Ledamöter: Παρόντες Ole Andreasen (1,2,3), Per-Arne Arvidsson (2,3), Alexandros Baltas (1,2,3), Bastiaan Belder (1,2,3), André Brie (1), Philip Claeys (1,2), John Walls Cushnahan (2,3), Véronique De Keyser (2,3), Rosa M. Díez González (2,3), Glyn Ford (1), Per Gahrton (1,2), Jas Gawronski (1), Alfred Gomolka (1,2,3), Klaus Hänsch (1,2), Efstratios Present Korakas (1), Catherine Lalumière (2,3), Armin Laschet (1,2,3), Cecilia Malmström (1,2,3), Franco Marini (2), Hugues Martin (1,2), Emilio Menéndez del Valle (1,2,3), Philippe Morillon (1,2), Pasqualina Napoletano (1,2), Jean-Thomas Nordmann (2,3), Raimon Obiols i Germà (1,2,3), Arie M. Oostlander (1,2,3), Jacques F. Poos Presentes (1,2,3), Luís Queiró (2), Jannis Sakellariou (2,3), José Ignacio Salafranca Sánchez-Neyra (2,3), Jacques Santer (1), Amalia Sartori (1), Jürgen Schröder (1,2,3), Elisabeth Schroedter (2,3), Ioannis Souladakis (1,2,3), David Sumberg (1,2,3), Ilkka Suominen (1,2), Hannes Swoboda (1,2), Charles Tannock (3), Joan Vallvé (1,2), Paavo Présents Väyrynen (1,2,3), Luigi Vinci (2), Demetrio Volcic (1,2,3), Karl von Wogau (1,2,3), Jan Marinus Wiersma (1,2,3)
Stedfortrædere/Stellvertreter/Αναπληρωτές/Substitutes/Suplentes/Suppléants/ Presenti Membri supplenti/Plaatsvervangers/Membros suplentes/Varajäsenet/Suppleanter: Joseph Daul (1), Michael Cashman (2,3), Gérard Caudron (2,3), Gerard Collins (2), Andrew Nicholas Duff (1,2,3), Olivier Dupuis (1,2), Jonathan Evans (1), Hélène Flautre (3), Pernille Frahm (1,2), Vasco Graça Moura Aanwezig (2), Ulpu Iivari (2), Giorgos Katiforis (2,3), Christoph Werner Konrad (2), Jo Leinen (1,2), Baroness Ludford (1,2), Jules Maaten (2,3), Mario Mauro (2,3), Hans Modrow (1,2,3), Reino Paasilinna (1,2), Doris Pack (2,3), Marco Pannella (2), Bernd Posselt (3), Michel Rocard (2), Lennart Sacrédeus (2), The Earl of Stockton (1,2,3), Läsnä Antonios Trakatellis (2), Johan Van Hecke (1), Francis Wurtz (2)
Närvarande
Gianfranco Dell'Alba (3), José María Gil-Robles Gil-Delgado (3), Elisabeth Jeggle (3), Minerva Melpomeni Malliori (3), Helmuth Markov Art. 153,2 (3), Karl Erik Olsson (2), Ursula Schleicher (2), Patsy Sörensen (3), Peder Wachtmeister (3) Konstantinos Alyssandrakis (2), Gianfranco Dell'Alba (2), Jan Dhaene (2), Dieter-Lebrecht Koch (2), Luisa Morgantini (2), Bill Newton Dunn (1), Art. 166,3 Roy Perry (2), Encarnación Redondo Jiménez (2), Ilka Schröder (2), Patsy Sörensen (1) Mihaly Balla (2,3), Eiki Berg (1,2), Adam Bielan (1,2), Doros Endv. deltog/Weitere Teiln./ Christodoulidis (1,2), Andrzej Chronowski (3), Zygmunt Cybulski (1,2,3), Συµµετείχαν επίσης/Also present Juris Dobelis (1,2,3), Bernard Drzezla (1,2), Jozsef Ekes (2), Genowefa Participaron igualmente/ Grabowska (1,2), Zita Gurmai (2), Toomashendrik Ilves (1,2,3), Jelko Participaient également/ Kacin (2), Michaltomasz Kaminski (1,2), Andras Kelemen (2,3), Hanno partecipato altresi΄/ Aleksandrs Kirsteins (1,2), Bogdan Klich (1), Waclaw Klukowski (2), Andere deelnemers/ Katerina Konecna (2), Daniel Kroupa (2,3), Kestutis Kuzmickas (3), Outros participantes/ Vytautas Kvietkauskas (2,3), Arminas Lydeka (2,3), Eugenijus Maldeikis Muut osallistujat/ Dessutom deltog (3), Jeno Manninger (2), Jiri Mastalka (2), Eleni Mavrou (1,2), Miroslav Ouzky (2), Alena Paleckova (3), Alojz Peterle (1,2), Rihards Piks (1,2), Jiri Pospisil (1,2,3), Krzysztof Rutkowski (1), Jozsef Szajer (1,2), Aleksander Szczyglo (1,2), Georgios Tasou (1), Agnes Vadai (1), Antanas Valys (1,2), Egidijus Vareikis (1,2,3), George Varnava (1,2), Edmund Wittbrodt (3), Marian Zenkiewicz (1,2,3)
(Dagsorden/Tagesordnung Pkt/Ηµερήσια ∆ιάταξη Σηµεί/Point OJ/Punto OG/Agenda Punt/Ponto OJ/punto orden del dia/ Esityslistan kohta/Föredragningslista punkt): * (P) =Formand/Vorsitzender/Πρόεδρος/Chairman/Président/Presidente/Voorzitter/Presidente/Puheenjohtaja/Ordförande (VP) =Næstform./Stellv. Vorsitz./Αντιπρόεδρος/Vice-Chairman/Vice-Président/Vice-Presidente/Varapuheenjohtaja Ondervoorz./Vice-Pres./Vicepres/Vice ordförande.
Til stede den/Anwesend am/Παρών στις/Present on/Présent le/Presente il/Aanwezig op/Presente em/Presente el/Läsnä/Närvarande den. (1) Tuesday, 17 February 2004 (2) Wednesday, 18 February 2004 (3) Thursday, 19 February 2004
PE 341.344 8/19 PV\520215EN.doc Or. en EN
Efter indbydelse fra formanden/Auf Einladung d. Vorsitzenden/Με πρόσκληση του Προέδρου/At the invitation of the Chairman/Por invitación del presidente/Sur l'invitation du président/Su invito del presidente/Op uitnodiging van de voorzitter/A convite do Presidente/Puheenjohtajan kutsusta/ På ordförandens inbjudan: Admiral Rainer Feist, NATO DSACEUR; Major General Jean-Pierre Herreweghe, Chief of EU Military Staff; Mr Ahmed Q'orei, Prime Minister, Palestine; Mr Saeb Erekat, Minister in charge of negotiations, Palestine; Mr Salam Fayyad, Minister for Finance, Palestine; Mr Heikki Talvitie, EU Special Representative for South Caucasus
Radet/Rat/Συµβούλιο/Council/Consejo/Conseil/Consiglio/Raad/Conselho/Neuvosto/Rådet: (*) Cooper, Garabello (F)
Kommissionen/Kommission/Επιτροπή/Commission/Comisión/Commissione/Commissie/Comissão/Komissio/ Kommissionen: (*) Hack, Hester, Sommerschield, Servantie, Jung-Olsen, Grillo Pasquarelli, Mirel, Ruete, Pampaloni (F)
Cour des comptes:
C.E.S.:
Andre deltagere/Andere Teilnehmer Επίσης Παρόντες/Also present Otros participantes/Autres participants/Altri partecipanti Andere aanwezigen/Outros participantes Muut osallistujat/Övriga deltagare
Gruppernes sekretariat PPE-DE Salafranca, Hartmann, Mazza Sekretariat der Fraktionen PSE Lüddecke, Marasa Γραµµατεία των Πολ. Οµάδων ELDR Lecarte Secretariat political groups Verts/ALE Bergamaschi, Gülcher Secr. de los grupos politicos GUE/NGL Losa, Schüttpelz Secr. Groupes politiques UEN Locati, Borges de Freitas Segr. dei gruppi politici EDD van Schothorst Secr. van de fracties NI Atzori Secr. dos grupos politicos Poliittisten ryhmien sihteeristö Gruppernas sekretariat
Cab. du Président
Cab. du Secrétaire Général
Generaldirektorat I De Buyst, Perez Navas Generaldirektion II Γενική ∆ιεύθυνση III Harris, Pfitzner, Subhan Directorate-General IV Fiss, van den Broeke Dirección general V Direction générale VI Direzione generale VII Directoraat-generaal VIII Direcção-Geral Contrôle financier Service juridique Pääosasto Generaldirektorat
Udvalgssekretariatet Huber, Gresch, Fialho, Fernandez, Opacic, Sourander, Stutzmann, Ausschußsekretariat Jarecka-Gomez, Rupp, Meskeleviciute Γραµµατεία επιτροπής Committee secretariat Secretaria de la comisión Secrétariat de la commission Segretariato della commissione Commissiesecretariaat Secretariado da comissão Valiokunnan sihteeristö Utskottssekretariatet
Assist./Βοηθός Schneider, Gössling-Wilcke * (P) =Formand/Pres./Πρόεδρος/Chairman/Président/Voorzitter/Puheenjohtaja/Ordförande (VP) =Næstform./Vize-Pres./Αντιπρόεδρος/Vice-Chairman/Vice-Président/Ondervoorz./Vice-pres/Varapuheenjohtaja/Vice ordförande. (M) =Medlem./Mitglied/Μέλος/Member/Miembro/Deputado/Membro/Lid/Membro/Jäsen/Ledamot (F) =Tjenestemand/Beamter/Υπάλληλος/Official/Funcionário/Fonctionnaire/Funzionario/Ambtenaar/ Functionαrio/Virkamies/Tjänsteman
PV\520215EN.doc 9/19 PE 341.344 Or. en EN
JOINT MEETING / REUNION CONJOINTE
DEFENCE AND SECURITY, ECONOMICS AND SECURITY, AND POLITICAL COMMITTEES
COMMISSION DE LA DEFENSE ET DE LA SECURITE, COMMISSION DE L’ECONOMIE ET DE LA SECURITE, ET COMMISSION POLITIQUE
Brussels / Bruxelles
Palais d’Egmont, 15 - 16 February 2004 Palais d’Egmont, 15- 16 février 2004
European Commission, 17 February 2004 Commission européenne, 17 février 2004
European Parliament, 17 February 2004 Parlement européen, 17 février 2004
LIST OF PARTICIPANTS LISTE DES PARTICIPANTS
International Secretariat Secrétariat international
PE 341.344 10/19 PV\520215EN.doc Or. en EN MEMBER DELEGATIONS / DELEGATIONS MEMBRES
Belgium / Belgique
Senate / Sénat Member / Membre Jacques DEVOLDER (Libéral) Secretary of the Delegation / Secrétaire de la délégation Frans VAN MELKEBEKE
Canada
Senate / Sénat Members / Membres Raynell ANDREYCHUK (Progressive Conservative Party) Saskatchewan Jane CORDY (Liberal) Nova Scotia Joseph A. DAY (Liberal) New Brunswick Pierre Claude NOLIN (Progressive Conservative Party) Salaberry Chairman of the Science and Technology Committee / Président de la Commission des sciences et des technologies
House of Commons / Chambre des Communes Head of the Delegation / Chef de la délégation David PRICE (Liberal) Compton-Stanstead, Québec Member / Membre Bill BLAIKIE (New Democratic Party) Winnipeg-Transcona, Manitoba Secretary of the Delegation / Secrétaire de la délégation Denis ROBERT Accompanying the Delegation / Accompagnant la délégation Wolfgang KOERNER
Czech Republic / République tchèque
Chamber of Deputies / Chambre des Députés Head of the Delegation / Chef de la délégation Pavel SEVERA (Christian Democratic Union) Pardubice Member / Membre Vlasta PARKANOVA (Christian Democratic Union) Central Bohemia Alternate Members / Membres suppléants Antonin SEDA (Social Democratic Party) Zlin Pavel SVOBODA (Freedom Union) Prague Secretary of the Delegation / Secrétaire de la délégation Olga BENDIKOVA
Senate / Sénat
PV\520215EN.doc 11/19 PE 341.344 Or. en EN Member / Membre Jaroslava MOSEROVÁ (Civic Democratic Alliance) Pardubice Alternate Member / Membre suppléant Vitezslav VAVROUSEK (Civic Democratic Party) Olomouc Secretary of the Delegation / Secrétaire de la délégation Jiri KRBEC
Denmark / Danemark
Folketing Head of the Delegation / Chef de la délégation Helge Adam MOELLER (Conservative) Storstroems Deputy Head of the Delegation / Chef adjoint de la délégation Per KAALUND (Social Democratic Party) Hvidovre Members / Membres Ulrik KRAGH (Liberal) Copenhagen Morten Helveg PETERSEN (Social Liberal) Hvidovre Alternate Member / Membre suppléant Jeppe KOFOD (Social Democratic Party) Secretary of the Delegation / Secrétaire de la délégation Morten Roland HANSEN
France
National Assembly / Assemblée nationale Head of the Delegation / Chef de la délégation Pierre LELLOUCHE (UMP) Paris Vice-President of the NATO Parliamentary Assembly / Vice-président de l’Assemblée parlementaire de l’OTAN Members / Membres Jean-Michel BOUCHERON (Socialiste) Ille-et-Vilaine Loïc BOUVARD (UMP) Morbihan Jean-Luc REITZER (UMP) Haut-Rhin Secretary of the Delegation / Secrétaire de la délégation Stanislas BREZET
Senate / Sénat Member / Membre Jacques CHAUMONT (UMP) Sarthe Alternate Member / Membre suppléant Didier BOULAUD (Socialiste) Nièvre
Germany / Allemagne
Bundestag
PE 341.344 12/19 PV\520215EN.doc Or. en EN Head of the Delegation / Chef de la délégation Markus MECKEL (SPD) Brandenburg Members / Membres Lothar IBRÜGGER (SPD) Minden-Lübbecke Treasurer of the NATO Parliamentary Assembly / Trésorier de l’Assemblée parlementaire de l’OTAN Ursula MOGG (SPD) Rheinland-Pfalz Ruprecht POLENZ (CDU/CSU) Münster Andreas WEIGEL (SPD) Zwickau Alternate Members / Membres suppléants Kurt BODEWIG (SPD) Nordrhein-Westfalen Monika HEUBAUM (SPD) Lower Saxony Secretary of the Delegation / Secrétaire de la délégation Elisabeth DELFS Accompanying the Delegation / Accompagnant la délégation Johannes von AHLEFELDT
Bundesrat Member / Membre Fritz BEHRENS (SPD) Nordrhein-Westfalen Alternate Member / Membre suppléant Thomas RÖWEKAMP (CDU) Bremen Secretary of the Delegation / Secrétaire de la délégation Annemarie BÜRSCH Accompanying the Delegation Peter PATTKE Fred SCHNITTGER
Greece / Grèce
Not represented / Pas de représentation
Hungary / Hongrie
National Assembly / Assemblée nationale Secretary of the Delegation / Secrétaire de la délégation Károly TÜZES
PV\520215EN.doc 13/19 PE 341.344 Or. en EN Iceland / Islande
Althing Acting Head of the Delegation / Chef adjoint de la delegation f.f. Gudmundur Árni STEFÁNSSON (Social Alliance) South-West Member / Membre Magnús STEFÁNSSON (Progressive Party) North-West Acting Secretary of the Delegation / Secrétaire de la delegation f.f. Stígur STEFÁNSSON
Italy / Italie
Chamber of Deputies / Chambre des Députés Deputy Head of the Delegation / Chef adjoint de la délégation Paolo RICCIOTTI (Forza Italia) Lazio Members / Membres Diego CAMMARATA (Forza Italia) Palermo Marco MINNITI (Démocrates de gauche - L'Olivier) Calabria Secretary of the Delegation / Secrétaire de la délégation Mario DI NAPOLI Accompanying the Delegation / Accompagnant la délégation Stefania PEROZZI
Senate of the Republic / Sénat de la République Head of the Delegation / Chef de la délégation Giovanni Lorenzo FORCIERI (Démocrates de gauche - L'Olivier) Liguria Vice-President of the NATO Parliamentary Assembly / Vice-président de l’Assemblée parlementaire de l’OTAN Members / Membres Guido BRIGNONE (Ligue du Nord) Piemonte Lamberto DINI (Margherita - L'Olivier) Toscana Luigi MARINO (Communiste) Campania Gianni NIEDDU (Démocrates de gauche - L'Olivier) Sardegna Mario PALOMBO (Alliance nationale) Lazio Secretary of the Delegation / Secrétaire de la délégation Alessandra LAI Accompanying the Delegation / Accompagnant la délégation Laura Ellina TABLADINI Interpreter / Interprète Claudio OLMEDA Luxembourg
Chamber of Deputies / Chambre des Députés Head of the Delegation / Chef de la délégation Niki BETTENDORF (Parti démocrate) Centre
PE 341.344 14/19 PV\520215EN.doc Or. en EN Netherlands / Pays-Bas
First Chamber of the States General / Première Chambre des Etats-Généraux Head of the Delegation / Chef de la délégation Jos van GENNIP (Christian Democratic Appeal) Member / Membre Willem HOEKZEMA (Liberal)
Second Chamber of the States General / Deuxième Chambre des Etats-Généraux Deputy Head of the Delegation / Chef adjoint de la délégation Bert KOENDERS (Social Democrat) Alternate Member / Membre suppléant Luuk BLOM (Social Democrat)
Norway / Norvège
Storting Acting Head of the Delegation / Chef de la delegation f.f. Per Ove WIDTH (Progressive Party) Vestfold Alternate Members / Membres suppléants Ranveig FROEILAND (Labour) Hordaland Gunnar HALVORSEN (Labour) Aust-Agder
Poland / Pologne
Sejm Members / Membres Andrzej PECZAK (Democratic Left Alliance) Sieradz Marian PILKA (Law and Justice) Siedlce Zbyszek ZABOROWSKI (Democratic Left Alliance) Rybnik Alternate Member / Membre suppléant Pawel GRAS (Civic Platform) Chrzanow Secretary of the Delegation / Secrétaire de la délégation Mikolaj KARLOWSKI
Senate / Sénat Head of the Delegation / Chef de la délégation Longin PASTUSIAK (Democratic Left Alliance, Labour Union) Gdansk Alternate Member / Membre suppléant Andrzej CHRONOWSKI (Union for the Senate 2001) Nowy Sacz Accompanying the Delegation / Accompagnant la délégation Mariusz PERZYNA Portugal
Assembly of the Republic / Assemblée de la République
PV\520215EN.doc 15/19 PE 341.344 Or. en EN Head of the Delegation / Chef de la délégation Rui GOMES DA SILVA (Parti social démocrate) Lisboa Deputy Head of the Delegation / Chef adjoint de la délégation Jaime GAMA (Socialiste) Lisbon Members / Membres Manuel Filipe CORREIA DE JESUS (Parti social démocrate) Madeira Julio MIRANDA CALHA (Socialiste) Portalegre Alternate Members / Membres suppléants José LELLO (Socialiste) Porto Carlos RODRIGUES (Parti social démocrate) Madeira
Spain / Espagne
Congress of Deputies / Congrès des Députés Deputy Head of the Delegation / Chef adjoint de la délégation Rafael ESTRELLA (Socialiste) Granada Members / Membres Ramón COMPANYS (Convergence et Union) Lleida Jordi MARSAL (Socialiste) Barcelona Roberto SORAVILLA (Parti populaire) Madrid
Senate / Sénat Acting Head of the Delegation / Chef de la délégation f.f. Alejandro MUÑOZ-ALONSO (Parti populaire) Madrid Member / Membre Segundo BRU (Socialiste) Valencia
Turkey / Turquie
Grand National Assembly / Grande Assemblée nationale Head of the Delegation / Chef de la délégation Vahit ERDEM (Justice and Development Party) Kirikkale Members / Membres Ali Riza ALABOYUN (Justice and Development Party) Aksaray Ersin ARIOGLU (Republican People's Party) Istanbul Egemen BAGIS (Justice and Development Party) Istanbul Ömer CELIK (Justice and Development Party) Adana Ali DINÇER (Republican People's Party) Bursa Damla GÜREL (Republican People's Party) Istanbul
PE 341.344 16/19 PV\520215EN.doc Or. en EN United Kingdom / Royaume-Uni
House of Commons / Chambre des Communes
Acting Head of the Delegation / Chef de la délégation f.f. Donald ANDERSON (Labour) Swansea East Members / Membres Hugh BAYLEY (Labour) City of York Michael CLAPHAM (Labour) Barnsley West and Penistone Harry COHEN (Labour) Leyton and Wanstead Michael GAPES (Labour and Co-operative) Ilford South Cheryl GILLAN (Conservative) Chesham and Amersham Alice MAHON (Labour) Halifax Chairperson of the Committee on the Civil Dimension of Security / Présidente de la Commission sur la dimension civile de la sécurité John SMITH (Labour) Vale of Glamorgan Rachel SQUIRE (Labour) Dunfermline West Peter VIGGERS (Conservative) Gosport Chairman of the Political Committee / Président de la Commission politique Secretary of the Delegation / Secrétaire de la délégation Tracey GARRATTY
United States / Etats-Unis
House of Representatives / Chambre des Représentants
Head of the Delegation / Chef de la délégation Douglas BEREUTER (Republican) Nebraska President of the NATO Parliamentary Assembly / Président de l’Assemblée parlementaire de l’OTAN Members / Membres Michael BILIRAKIS (Republican) Florida John BOOZMAN (Republican) Arkansas Joann EMERSON (Republican) Missouri Paul GILLMOR (Republican) Ohio Chairman of the Economics and Security Committee / Président de la Commission de l’économie et de la sécurité Joel HEFLEY (Republican) Colorado Chairman of the Defence and Security Committee / Président de la Commission de la défense et de la sécurité Peter KING (Republican) New York Dennis MOORE (Democrat) Kansas John TANNER (Democrat) Tennessee Vice-President of the NATO Parliamentary Assembly / Vice-président de l’Assemblée parlementaire de l’OTAN Ellen TAUSCHER (Democrat) California Mark UDALL (Democrat) Colorado Robert WEXLER (Democrat) Florida Secretary of the Delegation / Secrétaire de la délégation Susan OLSON Accompanying the Delegation / Accompagnant la délégation Robin EVANS Charlie JOHNSON Jonathan KATZ Kay KING John LIS Vince MORELLI Marilyn OWEN Mark WELLMAN
PV\520215EN.doc 17/19 PE 341.344 Or. en EN Military Escort Brian APRILL Andre BROWN Ronda CAPELES Chris PARRY Tom SHUBERT
ASSOCIATE DELEGATIONS / DELEGATIONS ASSOCIEES
Bulgaria / Bulgarie
National Assembly / Assemblée nationale Head of the Delegation / Chef de la délégation Stanimir ILCHEV (National Movement Simeon II) Secretary of the Delegation / Secrétaire de la délégation Mariana GANCHEVA-IVANOVA
Estonia / Estonie
Riigikogu
Head of the Delegation / Chef de la délégation Sven MIKSER (Centre Party) Secretary of the Delegation / Secrétaire de la délégation Tanja ESPE
Latvia / Lettonie
Saeima Head of the Delegation / Chef de la délégation Guntis BERZINS (New Era) Members / Membres Aleksandrs KIRSTEINS (People's Party)
Lithuania / Lituanie
Seimas Head of the Delegation / Chef de la délégation Gediminas KIRKILAS (Social Democratic Coalition) Secretary of the Delegation / Secrétaire de la délégation Snieguole ZIUKAITE Romania / Roumanie
PE 341.344 18/19 PV\520215EN.doc Or. en EN House of Deputies / Chambre des Députés Head of the Delegation / Chef de la délégation Ovidiu Cameliu PETRESCU (Social Democratic Party)
Slovakia / Slovaquie
National Council / Conseil national Head of the Delegation / Chef de la délégation Jozef BANAS (Alliance of a New Citizen)
Slovenia / Slovénie
National Assembly / Assemblée nationale Head of the Delegation / Chef de la délégation Andrej VIZJAK (Democratic Party)
NATO PARLIAMENTARY ASSEMBLY INTERNATIONAL SECRETARIAT SECRETARIAT INTERNATIONAL DE L’ASSEMBLEE PARLEMENTAIRE DE L’OTAN
Secretary General / Secrétaire Général Mr Simon LUNN
Deputy Secretary General / Secrétaire Général adjoint Mr David HOBBS
Deputy for Policy Co-ordination to the Secretary General Adjoint pour la coordination politique auprès du Secrétaire général Mr Andrea CELLINO
Director of the Defence and Security Committee Directeur de la Commission de la défense et de la sécurité Mr Zachary SELDEN
Director of the Economics and Security Committee Directeur de la Commission de l’économie et de la sécurité Mr Paul COOK
Director of the Political Committee Directeur de la Commission politique Mr Steffen SACHS
PV\520215EN.doc 19/19 PE 341.344 Or. en EN