DOCSLIB.ORG

Pre-Clovis Mastodon Hunters Make a Point

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Pre-Clovis Mastodon Hunters Make a Point NEWS&ANALYSIS ARCHAEOLOGY Pre-Clovis Mastodon Hunters Make a Point The experienced hunter hurled or thrust his animals in Beringia, the land now partly of Clovis-fi rst advocates remain skeptical. spear at the left side of the 3-ton adult male submerged in the region around the Bering They say that so far all the evidence, includ- mastodon. The bone point passed through Strait. The first Americans likely migrated ing that from Manis, has problems. “There 25 to 30 centimeters of hide and muscle, from Beringia as the last ice age gave way to may have been a period of ‘pre-Clovis’ then pierced a rib bone. That wound alone warmer temperatures and glaciers retreated. human presence in North America, but I likely did not kill the massive animal, but For many archaeologists, the debate over wish I could see a solid demonstration of under the onslaught of a group of hunters, whether pre-Clovis peoples roamed the that presence somewhere that doesn’t have the mastodon eventually fell on its left side. Americas is over. “Manis is another pre- or nagging problems,” says archaeologist Gary The victorious hunters then retrieved most non-Clovis site on the map,” says anthropol- Haynes of the University of Nevada, Reno. of their weapons and butchered the animal’s ogist Tom Dillehay of Vanderbilt University He questions whether the bone point was right side. But the valuable spear point in Nashville, who announced his really a human-shaped weapon, saying that remained inaccessible, buried under own pre-Clovis site in Chile it might have been a piece of bone acci- the giant carcass. back in 1997. dentally driven into the rib. Archaeologist That ancient hunter’s loss is a Megafauna like the mast- Stuart Fiedel of the Louis Berger Group Inc. gain for researchers on a different odon and its relative the mam- in Richmond, Virginia, praises the team’s kind of hunt: the search for clues moth disappeared quickly after sophisticated techniques but questions the to the peopling of the Americas. the arrival of Clovis points dating. He notes that the mastodon’s envi- Back in the 1970s, archaeologists 13,000 years ago, prompting ronment had sources of “old” carbon, found the mastodon’s remains, some scientists to speak of a including the ocean and geothermal pools, complete with rib bone and embed- that could give a falsely ancient date ded point, at the Manis Mastodon site if the mastodon ingested food or on March 12, 2012 on Washington’s Olympic Peninsula, water from those sources. Waters near the Juan de Fuca Strait. Now on calls this a “red herring,” however, page 351 of this issue, researchers led because the surrounding sediment by Michael Waters of Texas A&M Uni- age closely matches the bone dating. versity in College Station use DNA Haynes adds that the oldest Clovis and radiocarbon dating to demonstrate sites are “only” 8 centuries younger that the point came from a mastodon than Manis. Thus the rib “may actu- bone shaped into a weapon by humans ally indicate the earliest beginning www.sciencemag.org and used a startling 13,800 years ago. of the Clovis era, or an immediately That’s nearly 1000 years before the proto-Clovis stage of human disper- Clovis culture, known for its distinctive sal,” he says. “Proto-Clovis” peoples stone spear points and long considered in small numbers may have fi ltered to be the fi rst culture in the New World. south from Beringia as early as The fi nd adds to the wave of recent com- 14,000 years ago, he says, although pelling evidence demonstrating an earlier, their impact was negligible until pre-Clovis settling of the Americas (Science, the arrival of Clovis technology. To Downloaded from 25 March, p. 1512). Although a few Clovis- Waters, such talk of “proto-Clovis” fi rst holdouts remain unconvinced, the early amounts to “grasping at straws.” bone point also suggests that the extinction Sandweiss says the implications of large mammals such as mastodons and Big game. Archaeologists say that pre-Clovis hunters in of the paper in fact go beyond the mammoths may have begun long before the Washington state used a bone spear point (seen above Clovis–pre-Clovis wrangling. Many Clovis people came on the scene. “This is embedded in a rib) to pierce a mastodon. scientists argue that pre-Clovis peo- signifi cant because we have so few widely ple moved south along the Pacific accepted pre-Clovis sites,” says anthropolo- “blitzkrieg”: a rapid hunting of these giant Coast, possibly by boat (Science, 4 March, gist Daniel Sandweiss of the University of animals to extinction. But combined with p. 1122). In his view, the location of Manis Maine, Orono. The solid dating combined evidence of pre-Clovis mammoth hunting near the ocean is an intriguing hint favor- with the strong evidence for pre-Clovis hunt- at two other North American sites, Waters ing this idea. “The Manis site supports early ing on a site near the coast make the results argues that human hunters were already at occupation of the coastal zone,” he says. particularly important, he adds. work on killing megafauna before the debut Waters, who has reported pre-Clovis inte- Waters’s team subjected the rib and bone of Clovis-style weapons. Other researchers rior sites as well, is cautious. “We can’t say barb to a battery of tests, from DNA sequenc- agree: “The notion of the blitzkrieg move- these were coastal folks,” he says of the ing and protein analyses to radiocarbon dating ment died with the Clovis-fi rst paradigm,” Manis hunters. But the paper’s findings, and a CT scan. They determined that the barb Dillehay asserts. Sandweiss says, “point to a more wide- comes from another mastodon and appears to Although a well-dated point embedded in spread and complex early settlement system resemble the sharpened bone points used to a mastodon rib seems like a smoking gun— than some might have suspected.” –ANDREW LAWLER kill mammoths, mastodons, and other large or spear—for the pre-Clovis case, a handful CREDITS: CENTER FOR THE STUDY OFTHE FIRST AMERICANS, TEXAS A&M UNIVERSITY 302 21 OCTOBER 2011 VOL 334 SCIENCE www.sciencemag.org Published by AAAS.
Load more

Recommended publications
  • The Manis Mastodon Site
    The Manis Mastodon Site Raven Taylor Division - Junior History Paper Word Count - 1562 Since I was little, I’ve wanted to help animals. Naturally, for me as a five-year-old, my dream job was to become a vet. There was something about helping more than just the dogs and cats, so my enthusiasm for becoming a vet turned into my enthusiasm of becoming a zoologist. Around age 9, I met a lady named Iesha while my mom and I were on our way to Arizona. We started talking and then Iesha told us she had just been Hawaii helping leatherback turtles. The stranger sitting next to me quickly became the coolest person I had ever met. She went on to explain that she was going to Arizona to help the bats at a festival so they wouldn’t go extinct from a fungus. All I knew at that point was that I wanted to do what she did. She got to travel the world and save animals, and I thought that was really fantastic. So, yet again, my dream job changed to becoming a zoologist that traveled around the world and saved endangered species. Due to a recent assignment, I’ve found that the job I truly want to do, and that is under the label of Endangered Species Biologist. Since then my heart has been set on saving African Elephants from going extinct. Oddly enough, one of the topics to do for my project was to write about the mastodon, which is an animal that has gone extinct.
    [Show full text]
  • Development of Redmond's Cultural Resources Management Plan Preliminary Draft Prepared for the City of Redmond Prepared By
    Development of Redmond’s Cultural Resources Management Plan Preliminary Draft Prepared for the City of Redmond Prepared by DOWL May 2017 Table of Contents 1 Introduction ..................................................................................................................................................................... 1 1.1 Cultural Resources: An Overview .................................................................................................................. 2 1.2 Vision ......................................................................................................................................................................... 4 1.3 Purpose and Layout ............................................................................................................................................ 5 1.4 Process for Development .................................................................................................................................. 6 2 Regulatory Context ........................................................................................................................................................ 7 2.1 Laws and Regulations ......................................................................................................................................... 8 Federal 8 Washington State ......................................................................................................................................................... 10 King County ...................................................................................................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Richard D. Daugherty
    DEPARTMENTOF ANTHROPOLOGY SPRING1991 RichardD. Daugherty:A Faculty Biography A few sayit's all luck, but But that was to be delayed someof us know better. for a few years. Richard Daugherty is In 1946-47, the Columbia one of thoserare individu- River Basin surveys were als who have an uncanny being organizedin the cen- ability to choosethe best tral Washingtonplateau, and placesto look for the best archaeologicalsurveys were archaeologicalsites and the being funded for areasto be bestplacesto dig inthe sites impactedby dam construc- they have chosen.He fol- tion and by the proposed lows a simple, seemingly Columbia Basin irrigation unrealistic philosophy to project. A handful of Uni- ". surroundyourselfwith versity of Washington good people,and let them graduate students-includ- Richard Daugherty shows ofl his new tee shirt (il the 1990 Society.fbr do their thing." Somehow, American ArchtLeoktgymeeting in Lus Vegus,Nevado. Flunking him ure ing Dick-were "drafted" to he makesit work. "daughters" (1.to r.) Ruth Ann Knudson, StephanieRodefler, Le,sLie conduct most of the initial grew in Aber- Wildesen,Lorraine Heurtfield, und Jutet Frietlmtm. See "Alumni News," surveys. Dick up poge 5. deen, Washington, at the To sive someideaof what easternend of GraysHarbor on the Olympic Peninsulahe archaeologywas like in those days, three graduate lovesso well. Theareaisbeautiful, withitsruggedcoastline, studentssurveyed the entireMcNary Dam region.In a the rain forest,and the majesticOlympic Mountainsin the secondsurvey, Dick andone other student were respon- distance.During World War II, Dick pilotedblimps ofTthe sible for surveying l4 reservoirsites in Washington, Washingtoncoast, searching for enemyships and subma- Idaho, and Montana. In Dick's words, these surveys rines.Hoveringlazily in the sky day after day must have were basedon "little knowledge,almost no time, and given him a uniqueperspective on the Olympic Peninsula they were extremely inadequate."Inadequate as they and the peoplewho lived there.
    [Show full text]
  • Dr. Brett R. Lenz
    COLONIZER GEOARCHAEOLOGY OF THE PACIFIC NORTHWEST REGION A Dissertation DR. BRETT R. LENZ COLONIZER GEOARCHAEOLOGY OF THE PACIFIC NORTHWEST REGION, NORTH AMERICA Thesis submitted for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy at the University of Leicester By Brett Reinhold Lenz Department of Archaeology and Ancient History University of Leicester June 2011 1 DEDICATION This work is dedicated to Garreck, Haydn and Carver. And to Hank, for teaching me how rivers form. 2 Abstract This dissertation involves the development of a geologic framework applied to upper Pleistocene and earliest Holocene archaeological site discovery. It is argued that efforts to identify colonizer archaeological sites require knowledge of geologic processes, Quaternary stratigraphic detail and an understanding of basic soil science principles. An overview of Quaternary geologic deposits based on previous work in the region is presented. This is augmented by original research which presents a new, proposed regional pedostratigraphic framework, a new source of lithic raw material, the Beezley chalcedony, and details of a new cache of lithic tools with Paleoindian affinities made from this previously undescribed stone source. 3 ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS The list of people who deserve my thanks and appreciation is large. First, to my parents and family, I give the greatest thanks for providing encouragement and support across many years. Without your steady support it would not be possible. Thanks Mom and Dad, Steph, Jen and Mellissa. To Dani and my sons, I appreciate your patience and support and for your love and encouragement that is always there. Due to a variety of factors, but mostly my own foibles, the research leading to this dissertation has taken place over a protracted period of time, and as a result, different stages of my personal development are likely reflected in it.
    [Show full text]
  • Newsletter Volume 11 No 4/5 October 1977
    .l SOCIETY FOR CALIFORNIA ARCHAEOLOGY NEWSLETTER VOLUME 11 NO 4/5 OCTOBER 1977 NORTHERN DATA-SHARING ~INGS OCTOBER 22 A panel discussion on "Archaeology in the Priva te Sector" and an open discussion on problems of site The SCA 1 s annual Northern California Data- Sharing classification and possible solutions to these session is scheduled for Sonoma State College on problems, will conclude the meetings about 5:00 P.M. Saturday, October 22 , 1977. Registrat~on will start at 8:30 A.M. in Stevenson Hall 1002, with meetings An inforinal gathering sponsored by the Sonoma beginning promptly at 9:00 A.M. State Anthropology Department, to which everyone is invited, will take place at the Valparaiso Recreation David Fredrickson, organizer of the sessions as Center following the day's activities. Northern Vice-President, has set up a tentative program for the morning session during which people from various colleges will speak on Current Projects EXECUTIVE BOARD MEETING OCT . 21 and Substantive Results. The next SCA Executive Board meeting will again Arrangements will be made with a local be at David Fredrickson's house in Berkeley (1940 restaurant for lunch. In the afternoon. the session Parker St.), on F'riday night, October 21, from beginni~ at 2 P.M. , will include talks by Victoria 7:00 t o 10:00 P. M. preceding the Sonoma State Roberts lNa.tive American Heritage Commission): "The Data Sharir.g Meetings set fer October 22nd. Role of the Archaeologist in the Native American Community," and Arnold Cleveland (Big Valley Rancheria, Clear Lake): "MAHPA- Native American ~: SCENES FROM SCA ANNUAL MF.El'INGS, 1977 Historic Preservation Association,", to be followed A=iving, meeting and imbibing- SCA members at 3:00 by Ray Krause (Sonoma County Planning Dept.), and officers in San Diego.
    [Show full text]
  • Holocene Subsistence and Settlement Patterns
    Archaeology in Washington, Vol. 13, 2007 HOLOCENE SUBISTENCE AND SETTLEMENT PATTERNS: MOUNT RAINIER AND THE MONTANE PACIFIC NORTHWEST Greg C. Burtchard1 ABSTRACT landscapes, to prehistoric people, however, has only recently become widely recognized The last two decades have witnessed in the Pacific Northwest. Perhaps because of increased interest regarding the role of elevation, unpredictable weather and rugged mountain landscapes in regional subsistence terrain, places like Mount Rainier have been and settlement systems, and the manner in regarded by many as marginal to subsistence which those systems changed through time. and settlement strategies that focused instead The 1998 report (revised 2003) Environment, on lowland settings east and west of the Prehistory and Archaeology of Mount Rainier Cascades. National Park, Washington deals with these issues as they apply to Mount Rainier, with The mountain locally known as Takhoma1 was implications for the Cascades generally. This renamed Mount Rainier by George Vancouver paper extracts key arguments from that report, during his Puget Sound explorations (Morgan updated and refined through recent research, 1979:8). It is the highest and most massive of to address long-term land-use processes as the stratovolcanos that form the eastern spine they apply to Mount Rainier and Cascade of the Cascade Range, which extend from Mt. landscapes; and to consider the capacity of Baker in northern Washington to Mt. Lassen the archaeological record to improve our in northern California. For at least the last understanding of these processes. This paper 75,000 years (Harris 1988:240), Rainier has first introduces Mount Rainier’s basic loomed above the surrounding western environmental characteristics, and addresses Cascade peaks, dominating the landscape the capacity of this, and other mountain from the Puget Trough to the Cowlitz River landscapes, to attract and sustain precontact valley on the west, and from the Kittitas to hunters and gatherers.
    [Show full text]
  • Manis Mastodon Collection: an Exciting Donation to the Washington State Historical Society
    FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE: June 12, 2019 MEDIA CONTACT: Julianna Verboort, Marketing and Communications Director, Washington State Historical Society, 253-798-5902 or [email protected] Manis Mastodon Collection: An exciting donation to the Washington State Historical Society Tacoma, WA – Imagine standing beside a mucky pit in your yard on the Olympic Peninsula and hearing “This is the most important archaeological discovery in the world today.” Those words were spoken by Washington State University professor and researcher Dr. Richard Daugherty to Clare and Emanuel Manis on a sweltering Sequim afternoon more than 40 years ago. A dig on their property turned up the remains of an ancient mastodon, and some major surprises, leading to a re-write of North American history. Recently, Clare Manis Hatler decided to donate the collection of over 50 cartons including bones, ivory, teeth, soil samples, stone tools, photographs, field notes, educational materials and more, to the Washington State Historical Society. "I dedicate this gift to two great men,” Hatler remarked. “This gift would not have happened without Emanuel Manis, who made the effort to share the site with the public. He wanted everyone to participate in and learn about the wonderful discoveries made daily during the dig. Secondly, to Dr. Carl E. Gustafson, a dedicated professional, investing over 30 years of his life into revealing the site’s mysteries, without expectation of accolades or financial gain. Both men are gone now, Emanuel in 2000 and Carl in 2016, but never to be forgotten.” “We are thrilled to receive the Manis mastodon collection as a donation from Clare Manis Hatler.
    [Show full text]
  • Prehistory of the Northwest Coast ROY L
    CHAPTER 1 Prehistory of the Northwest Coast ROY L. CARLSON n the beginning there was ice ... in the end there were ice. Sub-arctic and then temperate fauna spread into this approximately 100,000 Indian people living along the new found land. Man was part of this fauna; he preyed IPacific coast from southeast Alaska to the mouth of on the other animals for food and used their hides for the Columbia River in Oregon ... in between is the pre­ clothing. He arrived by different routes, and brought historic period, the time span of the unknown, between with him different cultural traditions. By 10,000 years the retreat of the last continental glacier and the arrival ago ice only existed in the mountain top remnants we of the first Europeans with their notebooks and artist's still see today. sketches who ushered in the period of written history. The Northwest Coast (Fig. 1:1) is a ribbon of green, The prehistoric period here lasted from perhaps 12,000 wet forested land which hugs the Pacific coast of North years ago to the late 1700's when Cook, Vancouver, America from the mouth of the Copper River in Alaska Mackenzie and others began writing about the area and to just below the mouth of the Klamath River in northwest its inhabitants. Glacial geology suggests that the coast California. It was part of the "Salmon Area" of early was ice free by 12,000 years ago, but there remains the ethnographers and its cultures were clearly different possibility of even earlier movements of peoples whose from those of the California acorn area, the agricultural traces were wiped out by the last glacial advance.
    [Show full text]
  • Summary of the Proposal
    4.13: Archaeological and historical 4.13.1: Existing conditions Archaic – 10,500-4,400 BC consisting of highly Archaeological and historical resources may be mobile small groups subsisting on marine, categorized into 3 major types: shoreline, and terrestrial resources with stone, bone, antler, and perishable technological Archaeological - resources that represent materials illustrated by Olcott points. important evidence of past human behavior, including portable artifacts such as arrowheads Early Pacific – 4,400-1,800 BC consisting of or tin cans; non-portable features such as increased sedentism in seasonal villages cooking hearths, foundations, and privies; or subsisting on shoreline resources, expanded residues such as food remains and charcoal. marine resources harvesting camas and Archaeological remains can be virtually any age, shellfish with an increase in ground stone, bone, from yesterday's trash to prehistoric deposits antler, and perishable technological materials thousands of years old. illustrated by Cascade points. Ethnographic - sites, areas, and materials Middle Pacific – 1,800 BC - 500 AD consisting of important to Native Americans for religious, winter villages of plank houses and seasonal spiritual, or traditional uses that can encompass camps subsisting on marine and riverine the sacred character of physical locations (e.g., resources with food storage technologies with a mountain peaks, springs, and burial sites) or decrease in stone tools, diversification of tools particular native plants, animals, or minerals of bone, antler, perishable technological that are gathered for use in traditional ritual materials and canoes. activities. Also included are villages, burials, rock art, rock features, and traditional hunting, Late Pacific – 500 – 1775 AD consisting of large gathering, and fishing sites.
    [Show full text]
  • Cultural Resources
    CULTURAL RESOURCES EASTSIDE RAIL CORRIDOR REGIONAL TRAIL MASTER PLAN PROJECT FEBRUARY 2016 The Eastside Rail Corridor Regional Trail Master Plan Project develops a baseline inventory and planning guidelines for portions of the Eastside Rail Corridor owned by King County and Sound Transit. A variety of uses is possible for the corridor in the future, and various agencies and jurisdictions have ownership interests in the corridor. This document is an internal work product supporting a study for future development of a shared use trail in the corridor. For more information please visit the King County Parks Eastside Rail Corridor – Regional Trail webpage at: http://www.kingcounty.gov/erc King County Parks. 2016. Eastside Rail Corridor – Regional Trail Master Plan Project Cultural Resources. Prepared for: King County Department of Natural Resources and Parks. Prepared by: ESA, Alicia Valentino and Katherine F. Wilson. Seattle, Washington, February 2016. EASTSIDE RAIL CORRIDOR - REGIONAL TRAIL MASTER PLAN PROJECT FEBRUARY 2016 TABLE OF CONTENTS 1. INTRODUCTION .................................................................................................................... 1-1 1.1 Master Plan Alternatives .............................................................................................................. 1-1 1.1.1 On-Railbed and Off-Railbed Alternatives ..................................................................... 1-1 1.1.2 No Action Alternative ..................................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Cultural Resources Management Plan Context
    Exhibit E: Cultural Resources Management Plan Context Redmond’s Cultural Resources Management Plan Context Prepared for the City of Redmond Prepared by DOWL, May 2018 Refinements by the City of Redmond, June 2019 Advisement and Contributions by Steven Mullen-Moses, Tribal Historic Preservation Officer, Snoqualmie Tribe Kerry Lyste, Tribal Historic Preservation Officer, Stillaguamish Tribe of Indians Laura Murphy, Archaeologist, Muckleshoot Indian Tribe Richard Young, Cultural Resources Manager, Tulalip Tribes Table of Contents 1. Introduction ..................................................................................................................................................................... 1 1.1 Cultural Resources: An Overview .................................................................................................................. 2 2. Regulatory Context ........................................................................................................................................................ 4 3. Cultural Resources in Redmond .............................................................................................................................. 6 3.1 Setting and Environment .................................................................................................................................. 6 3.1.1 Geology and Climate ................................................................................................................................... 6 3.1.2 Fauna ................................................................................................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • 42 Papers Human Origin Sites and the World Heritage Convention In
    42 World Heritage papers42 World Heritage papers HEADWORLD HERITAGES 5 NIO M O UN IM D R T IA A L • P • W L O A I R D L D N H O E M R I E TA IN G O E • PATRIM United Nations World Educational, Scientific and Heritage Cultural Organization Convention Human Origin Sites and the GOBIERNO DE World Heritage Convention in the Americas PUEBLAACCIONES QUE TRANSFORMAN In support of UNESCO’s 70th Anniversary Celebrations United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization VOLUME I Human Origin Sites and the Heritage World in the Convention Americas. I Volume For more information contact: UNESCO World Heritage Centre papers NIO M O UN IM D R T IA A L • P • W L O A I 7, place Fontenoy R D L D N H O E M 75352 Paris 07 SP France R E I TA IN G O Tel: 33 (0)1 45 68 24 96 E • PATRIM Fax: 33 (0)1 45 68 55 70 United Nations World Educational, Scientific and Heritage 9 789231 001406 http://whc.unesco.org HeritageWorld Cultural Organization Convention Human Origin Sites and the World Heritage Convention in the Americas HEADS 5 VOLUME I Published in 2015 by the United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization, 7, place de Fontenoy, 75352 Paris 07 SP, France and the UNESCO Office in Mexico, Presidente Masaryk 526, Polanco, Miguel Hidalgo, 11550 Ciudad de Mexico, D.F., Mexico. © UNESCO 2015 ISBN 978-92-3-100140-6 This publication is available in Open Access under the Attribution-ShareAlike 3.0 IGO (CC-BY-SA 3.0 IGO) license (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/3.0/igo/).
    [Show full text]