The Pogrom (Farhud) of 1941, Reexamination

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

The Pogrom (Farhud) of 1941, Reexamination chapter 6 The Pogrom (Farhud) of 1941, Reexamination The pogrom of Pentecost (Shavu’ot) festival, 1–2 June 1941, known as the farhud, was not documented by the main forces that were responsible for its occur- rence, the British government and monarchic Iraq. The involved governments in fact did all in their power to prevent any information about the attacks on the Jews from reaching the public in Iraq and abroad, downplaying their sever- ity and trying to ignore them. In the present study we shall reexamine impor- tant issues in the study of the pogrom of Pentecost 1941 and its denial, in light of new sources and including archival material ignored by researchers, new testimonies which were dictated to us by witnesses to the pogrom, and mem- oirs, mostly by Iraqi Jews, some published and some still in manuscript form.1 Research on the Farhud Studies of the pogrom published in the last fifty years have therefore had to rely on sources located in the Central Zionist Archive in Jerusalem, including testimonies taken by employees of the Jewish Agency from Iraqi Jews who came to Palestine shortly after the pogrom; and on documentation, mostly in- direct, found in archives in England and the United States. To these we may add contemporary news reports as well as memoirs and testimonies published in the last twenty years. The first study of the farhud was published in English by Prof. Hayyim J. Cohen in 1966.2 Cohen’s work contains a description of the events, their back- ground and aftermath, a presentation of the main questions which they raised, and an attempt to answer them using contemporary press reports, documents 1 Zvi Yehuda, “Selected Documents on the Pogrom (Farhud),” in Al-Farhūd. The 1941 Pogrom in Iraq, eds. S. Moreh and Z. Yehuda (Jerusalem 2010), 256–367. This is an edited and updated ar- ticle of Zvi Yehuda, “The Pogrom (Farhud) of 1941 in Light of New Sources,” in Al-Farhud. The 1941 Pogrom in Iraq. Eds. S. Moreh and Z. Yehuda. Published within the book series of The Vidal Sassoon International Center for the Study of Antisemitism, The Hebrew University of Jerusalem, and The Babylonian Jewry Heritage Center (Magnes Press, Jerusalem 1910), 9–25, 250–6. 2 Hayyim J. Cohen, “The Anti-Jewish Farhud in Baghdad 1941.” Middle Eastern Studies 3, no. 1 (Oct. 1966): 2–17. © koninklijke brill nv, leiden, ���7 | doi ��.��63/97890043540��_008 250 Chapter 6 from the Central Zionist Archive in Jerusalem, and testimonies which Iraqi Jews in Israel dictated to the author. Cohen did not examine documents lo- cated outside Israel, but still succeeded in arriving at important conclusions concerning the British view on the pogrom. The relevant documents in British archives, which deal more directly with Rashid ‘Ali al-Kaylani’s rebellion and its suppression, formed the basis of Prof. Elie Kedourie’s comprehensive work in English on the pogrom, which was pub- lished eight years after that of Cohen.3 Kedourie made an extensive analysis of British policy towards Rashid ‘Ali’s rebellion and the farhud as articulated by the British military in the Middle East and India and British policy-makers in Iraq, India, and Britain. He highlighted the contradictions in that policy and the differences in the way policy makers in the British government and the British officials in Iraq assessed the situation and in the actions which they proposed. Kedourie did not have access to the documents on the pogrom in the U.S. National Archives in Washington D.C., which contain reports that American officials in Baghdad sent to the American State Department. These documents were examined by Prof. Harold Luks in a study published in English (1977).4 However, because his study dealt with a very long period of time, from the mid-nineteenth century to the end of World War II, and because of the scant amount of American documents dealing with the pogrom, his brief overview of the pogrom adds nothing to what Cohen and Kedourie put into their works. None of the above-mentioned publications used the many memoirs composed by Iraqi Jews. These are discussed in a comprehensive work by Prof. Shmuel Moreh.5 Another study by the same scholar discusses Palestinian incitement before the pogrom and the attitudes of Arab intellectuals towards the farhud in light of memoirs and other writings composed by Iraqi and Palestinian Arab politicians and writers at the time.6 Dr. Yehuda Taggar also wrote a study in which he presented the quite scarce mentions of the pogrom by Arab writers.7 The pogrom of Pentecost 1941 has also been discussed as one topic among others in studies dealing with various aspects of the history of Iraqi Jewry 3 Kedourie, “Sack of Basra.” 4 Harold Paul Luks, “Iraqi Jews During World War II,” Wiener Library Bulletin 30, no. 43/44 (1977): 30–39. 5 Shmuel Moreh, “The Pogrom of June 1941 in the Literature of Iraqi Jews in Israel,” in Al-Farhūd. The 1941 Pogrom in Iraq, eds. S. Moreh and Z. Yehuda (Jerusalem 2010), 207–49. 6 Idem, “The Role of the Palestinian Incitement and the Attitude of Arab Intellectuals to the Farhud,” in ibid., 119–50. 7 Yehuda Tagger, “The Farhud in the Arabic Writings of Iraqi Statesmen and Writers” [in Hebrew], Pe’amim 8 (1981): 38–45..
Recommended publications
  • HANAN 2 Chedet.Co.Cc February 19, 2009 by Dr. Mahathir Mohamad
    HANAN 2 Chedet.co.cc February 19, 2009 By Dr. Mahathir Mohamad Dear Hanan, 1. I think I cannot convince you on anything simply because your perception of things is not based on logic or reason but merely on your strong belief that you are always right, even if the whole world says you are wrong. 2. Jews have lived with Muslims in Muslim countries for centuries without any serious problem. 3. On the other hand in Europe, Jews were persecuted. Every now and again there would be pogroms when the Europeans would massacre Jews. The Holocaust did not happen in Muslim countries. Muslims may discriminate against Jews but did not massacre them. 4. But now you are fighting the largely Muslim Palestinians. It cannot be because of religious differences or the killing of Jews living among them. It must be because you have taken their land and expelled them from their homeland. It is therefore not a religious war. But of course as you seek sympathisers from among the non-Muslims, the Palestinians seek sympathisers among the Muslims. That still does not make the war a religious war. 5. Whether you speak Hebrew or not is not relevant. Lots of people who are not English speak English. They don't belong to England. For centuries you could speak Hebrew but remained Germans, British, French, Russians etc. 6. Lots of Jews cannot speak Hebrew but they are still Jews. Merely being able to speak Hebrew does not entitle you to claim Palestine. 7. The Jews had lived in Europe for centuries.
    [Show full text]
  • Historical Memory and History in the Memoirs of Iraqi Jews*
    Historical Memory and History in the Memoirs of Iraqi Jews* Mark R. Cohen Memoirs, History, and Historical Memory Following their departure en masse from their homeland in the middle years of the twentieth century, Jews from Iraq produced a small library of memoirs, in English, French, Hebrew, and Arabic. These works reveal much about the place of Arab Jews in that Muslim society, their role in public life, their relations with Muslims, their involvement in Arab culture, the crises that led to their departure from a country in which they had lived for centuries, and, finally, their life in the lands of their dispersion. The memoirs are complemented by some documentary films. The written sources have aroused the interest of historians and scholars of literature, though not much attention has been paid to them as artifacts of historical memory.1 That is the subject of the present essay. Jews in the Islamic World before the Twentieth Century Most would agree, despite vociferous demurrer in certain "neo-lachrymose" circles, that, especially compared to the bleaker history of Jews living in Christian lands, Jews lived fairly securely during the early, or classical, Islamic * In researching and writing this paper I benefited from conversations and correspondence with Professors Sasson Somekh, Orit Bashkin, and Lital Levy and with Mr. Ezra Zilkha. Though a historian of Jews in the Islamic world in the Middle Ages, I chose to write on a literary topic in honor of Tova Rosen, who has contributed so much to our knowledge of another branch of Jewish literature written by Arab Jews.
    [Show full text]
  • December Layout 1
    AMERICAN & INTERNATIONAL SOCIETIES FOR YAD VASHEM Vol. 41-No. 2 ISSN 0892-1571 November/December 2014-Kislev/Tevet 5775 The American & International Societies for Yad Vashem Annual Tribute Dinner he 60th Anniversary of Yad Vashem Tribute Dinner We were gratified by the extensive turnout, which included Theld on November 16th was a very memorable many representatives of the second and third generations. evening. We were honored to present Mr. Sigmund Rolat With inspiring addresses from honoree Zigmund A. Rolat with the Yad Vashem Remembrance Award. Mr. Rolat is a and Chairman of the Yad Vashem Council Rabbi Israel Meir survivor who has dedicated his life to supporting Yad Lau — the dinner marked the 60th Anniversary of Yad Vashem and to restoring the place of Polish Jewry in world Vashem. The program was presided over by dinner chairman history. He was instrumental in establishing the newly Mark Moskowitz, with the Chairman of the American Society opened Museum of the History of Polish Jews in Warsaw. for Yad Vashem Leonard A. Wilf giving opening remarks. SIGMUND A. ROLAT: “YAD VASHEM ENSHRINES THE MILLIONS THAT WERE LOST” e are often called – and even W sometimes accused of – being obsessed with memory. The Torah calls on us repeatedly and command- ingly: Zakhor – Remember. Even the least religious among us observe this particular mitzvah – a true corner- stone of our identity: Zakhor – Remember – and logically L’dor V’dor – From generation to generation. The American Society for Yad Vashem has chosen to honor me with the Yad Vashem Remembrance Award. I am deeply grateful and moved to receive this honor.
    [Show full text]
  • Jerusalemhem Volume 80, June 2016
    Yad VaJerusalemhem Volume 80, June 2016 Holocaust Martyrs' and Heroes' Remembrance Day 2016 (pp. 4-9) Yad VaJerusalemhem Contents Volume 80, Sivan 5776, June 2016 Inauguration of the Moshe Mirilashvili Center for Research on the Holocaust in the Soviet Union ■ 2-3 Published by: Highlights of Holocaust Remembrance Day 2016 ■ 4-5 Students Mark Holocaust Remembrance Day Through Song, Film and Creativity ■ 6-7 Leah Goldstein ■ Remembrance Day Programs for Israel’s Chairman of the Council: Rabbi Israel Meir Lau Security Forces ■ 7 Vice Chairmen of the Council: ■ On 9 May 2016, Yad Vashem inaugurated Dr. Yitzhak Arad Torchlighters 2016 ■ 8-9 Dr. Moshe Kantor the Moshe Mirilashvili Center for Research on ■ 9 Prof. Elie Wiesel “Whoever Saves One Life…” the Holocaust in the Soviet Union, under the Chairman of the Directorate: Avner Shalev Education ■ 10-13 auspices of its world-renowned International Director General: Dorit Novak Asper International Holocaust Institute for Holocaust Research. Head of the International Institute for Holocaust Studies Program Forges Ahead ■ 10-11 The Center was endowed by Michael and Research and Incumbent, John Najmann Chair Laura Mirilashvili in memory of Michael’s News from the Virtual School ■ 10 for Holocaust Studies: Prof. Dan Michman father Moshe z"l. Alongside Michael and Laura Chief Historian: Prof. Dina Porat Furthering Holocaust Education in Germany ■ 11 Miriliashvili and their family, honored guests Academic Advisor: Graduate Spotlight ■ 12 at the dedication ceremony included Yuli (Yoel) Prof. Yehuda Bauer Imogen Dalziel, UK Edelstein, Speaker of the Knesset; Zeev Elkin, Members of the Yad Vashem Directorate: Minister of Immigration and Absorption and Yossi Ahimeir, Daniel Atar, Michal Cohen, “Beyond the Seen” ■ 12 Matityahu Drobles, Abraham Duvdevani, New Multilingual Poster Kit Minister of Jerusalem Affairs and Heritage; Avner Prof.
    [Show full text]
  • Nd Help Pizza, Pasta & Party with Tal & Roi Local Jewish Teen Stars As
    Non-Profit Organization U.S. Postage PAID Norwich, CT 06360 Permit #329 Serving The Jewish Communities of Eastern Connecticut & Western R.I. CHANGE SERVICE RETURN TO: 28 Channing St., New London, CT 06320 REQUESTED VOL. XLV NO. 19 PUBLISHED BI-WEEKLY OCTOBER 11, 2019/12 TISHRI 5780 NEXT DEADLINE OCT. 18, 2019 16 PAGES HOW TO REACH US - PHONE 860-442-8062 • FAX 860-540-1475 • EMAIL [email protected] • BY MAIL: 28 CHANNING STREET, NEW LONDON, CT 06320 Local Jewish Pizza, Pasta & Party teen stars as with Tal & Roi Many people have asked recently if the Jewish Federation will be Anne Frank having its Harvest Supper and Emissary Welcome. We will absolutely be having our Emissary Welcome however, in this year of changes, in- WATERFORDrama, the drama club stead of the Harvest Supper we will have an evening of Pizza, Pasta and at Waterford High School, is proud to Party with the Young Emissaries. Mark your calendars for Thursday, present The Diary of Anne Frank. The Nov. 7 beginning at 6pm at Temple Emanu-El in Waterford. shows will take place Thursday-Sat- We will have salad along with the pizza and pasta and a gluten free urday, October 17 -19 at 7:00pm in alternative. And back by popular demand will be our traditional Har- the Waterford High School Audito- vest Supper Apple Cider and Cider Donuts for dessert and a few other rium. surprises. The show, which kicks off WA- th Some of you may have already met Tal and Roi so come join us for TERFORDrama’s 16 season, features an evening to get to know them even better.
    [Show full text]
  • Commentary… Descent, Is Editor-At-Large at the J'accuse Coalition for Justice
    בס״ד cannot acknowledge עש"ק פרשת בהר ISRAEL NEWS that history at the )בחקתי בא"י( 19 Iyar 5779 May 24, 2019 expense of Mizrahi Issue number 1245 A collection of the week’s news from Israel Jews, who with so many others, From the Bet El Twinning / Israel Action Committee of regardless of skin color, shared the Jerusalem 6:55 Beth Avraham Yoseph of Toronto Congregation desire for a Jewish state long before Toronto: 8:28 the establishment of Israel. The writer, an Israeli writer and activist of Iraqi and North African Commentary… descent, is editor-at-large at the J'accuse Coalition for Justice. No, Israel isn’t a Country of Privileged and Powerful White Europeans By Hen Mazzig Can Reform’s Embrace of Al Sharpton Be Justified? Along with resurgent identity politics in the United States and Europe, By Jonathan S. Tobin there is a growing inclination to frame the Israeli-Palestinian conflict in If the Rev. Al Sharpton were truly willing to repent for his past as a terms of race. According to this narrative, Israel was established as a refuge race-baiter and inciter of anti-Semitic violence, then having him speak at a for oppressed white European Jews who in turn became oppressors of Jewish event titled a “Consultation on Conscience” might be a good idea. people of color, the Palestinians. Perhaps that’s what the Religious Action Center of Reform Judaism As an Israeli, and the son of an Iraqi Jewish mother and North African and its leader, Rabbi Jonah Pesner, thought they were doing when they Jewish father, it’s gut-wrenching to witness this shift.
    [Show full text]
  • The Jewish Refugees from Arab Countries: an Examination of Legal Rights - a Case Study of the Human Rights Violations of Iraqi Jews
    Fordham International Law Journal Volume 26, Issue 3 2002 Article 6 The Jewish Refugees from Arab Countries: An Examination of Legal Rights - A Case Study of the Human Rights Violations of Iraqi Jews Carole Basri∗ ∗ Copyright c 2002 by the authors. Fordham International Law Journal is produced by The Berke- ley Electronic Press (bepress). http://ir.lawnet.fordham.edu/ilj The Jewish Refugees from Arab Countries: An Examination of Legal Rights - A Case Study of the Human Rights Violations of Iraqi Jews Carole Basri Abstract Although the issues surrounding the Palestinian refugees are frequently addressed at the United Nations (”U.N.”), in the news media, and in legal journals, very little has been written about the Jews displaced from Arab lands. In light of the little known fact that approximately 50% of Israelis are Jews from Arab lands or their descendents, this Article will use Jews from Iraq as a case study in examining the history and rights of Jews from Arab countries, who were expelled or forced to seek refuge elsewhere. Part I of this Article examines the historical legal status of Jews in Iraq and the discriminatory and prosecutorial events that triggered the expulsion of Jews from Iraq. Part II demonstrates that actions taken by Iraq against Jews violated international law stan- dards and other laws applicable now and at that time. Part III addresses the question of whether Jews from Arab lands currently have any available remedies for these violations of their rights. Finally, the Article concludes that a full accounting of the rights of Jews from Arab lands must accompany any discussions aimed at providing a regional peace agreement for the Middle East, if such an agreement is to have strength and legitimacy under international law.
    [Show full text]
  • From the Balfour Declaration of 1917 to the Farhud of 1941: Treatment of Jews in Iraq and Patterns of Jewish Emigration
    From the Balfour Declaration of 1917 to the Farhud of 1941: Treatment of Jews in Iraq and Patterns of Jewish Emigration Katharine Barr Berman Submitted for PLSC 157 and revised for the Twelfth Annual ASMEA Conference Advisor: Professor Jeffrey Macris Yale University November 2, 2019 1 Introduction: In 2008, the New York Times estimated that a total of under ten Jews remain in Iraq, yet one hundred years earlier, Jews made up nearly 25% of the population of Baghdad.1 Notably, the majority of this drastic decrease in Jewish population took place over a relatively short period of time, all within about half a century. During that time, two classes of major global transitions took place with significant ramifications for the Jews: (1) the Balfour Declaration of 1917 and formation of the state of Israel, and (2) World War II, the rise of Nazi power, and the Holocaust. Although these two major events have some overlap in cause and effect, it is interesting to consider if, how, and when either factor contributed to the increasing anti-Semitic sentiment in Iraq. Research Question: How and why did Iraqi Arab sentiment towards the Jewish population in Iraq change from the Balfour Declaration of 1917 to the Farhud of 1941? Thesis Together, the change in Iraqi leadership, the rise of Iraqi nationalism in response to British foreign power, and the development of Palestine as a Jewish state give the best explanation for rising anti-Jewish sentiment among Iraqi Arabs from 1917-1941. Ultimately, the Farhud of June 1941 stemmed from more anti-Zionist than pro-Nazi sentiment in Iraq.
    [Show full text]
  • Can the Farhud, a Slaughter of Jews by Their Longtime Arab Neighbors, Happen Again?
    Can the Farhud, a Slaughter of Jews by Their Longtime Arab Neighbors, Happen Again? by Edwin Black BESA Center Perspectives Paper No. 2,064, June 4, 2021 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY: The world just marked the 80th anniversary of the Farhud, the Arab-Nazi pogrom against the Jews of Baghdad and Basra that occurred on June 1-2, 1941. The term Arab-Nazi is entirely appropriate, not simply because these Arabs were fascist in mind and deed, but because they explicitly identified with Germany’s Nazi Party. Some of the rioters wore swastikas; more than a few marched in the Nuremberg torchlight parades. The Nazi ideology that motivated the Arab slaughterers of Jews in 1941—the desire to exterminate Jews from the face of the earth—motivates the Arabs and Muslims who assault Israelis and Jews today. The word “farhud” means “violent dispossession.” During the Farhud riots in Iraq in 1941, Arabs turned against their longtime Jewish neighbors. Jews were hunted in the streets by mobs wielding swords. When found, Jews were subjected to unspeakable torment. Girls were raped in front of their parents, fathers beheaded in front of their children, mothers brutalized in public, babies sliced in half and thrown into the Tigris River. A busload of Jewish schoolgirls was hijacked and the girls taken to a camp outside of town, where they were raped. The Baghdad Arab mobs burned dozens of Jewish stores and invaded and looted Jewish homes. Many families tell a similar story: a wild mob pushed past the furniture stacked against the door, and with swords swinging, chased the Jews up to the roof.
    [Show full text]
  • Persistence of Jewish-Muslim Reconciliatory Activism in the Face of Threats and “Terrorism” (Real and Perceived) from All Si
    Persistence of Jewish-Muslim Reconciliatory Activism in the Face of Threats and “Terrorism” (Real and Perceived) From All Sides Micah B.D.C. Naziri ORCID Scholar ID# 0000-0001-9035-1178 A Dissertation Submitted to the PhD in Leadership and Change Program of Antioch University in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy November 2019 This dissertation has been approved in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of PhD in Leadership and Change, Graduate School of Leadership and Change, Antioch University. Dissertation Committee • Philomena Essed, PhD, Committee Chair • Jon Wergin, PhD, Committee Member • Anne de Jong, PhD, Committee Member Copyright 2019 Micah B.D.C. Naziri All rights reserved Acknowledgements I would like to express my deep gratitude to my dissertation committee Professor Philomena Essed, Professor Jon Wergin, and Professor Anne de Jong, for their patient guidance, enthusiastic encouragement, and useful critiques of this research work. I would also like to thank Dr. Ashley Lackovich-van Gorp for her advice and assistance as a mentor in the pilot study that initially inspired this dissertation, and as a guide whenever I felt lost. I would like to further thank Professor Laurien Alexandre for inspiring so many aspects of the Hashlamah Project academically, and for helping realign the focus of this dissertation after serious threats to this work emerged. I additionally extend my thanks to Dr. Norman Dale, who has tirelessly and skillfully helped edit this work. My grateful thanks are also extended to my family for dealing with years of study, travel, writing, frustration, and more that all went into this work, and to unnamed friends and martial arts students who have assisted in travel when it was otherwise impossible.
    [Show full text]
  • Miscellanea 2018
    Miscellanea 2018 edited by Quest Editorial Staff Issue n. 14, December 2018 QUEST. Issues in Contemporary Jewish History. Journal of Fondazione CDEC QUEST N. 14 Editors Guri Schwarz (Università degli Studi di Genova, Editor in chief), Elissa Bemporad (Queens College of the City University of New York), Laura Brazzo (Fondazione CDEC),Tullia Catalan (Università degli Studi di Trieste), Cristiana Facchini (Alma Mater Studiorum, Università di Bologna), Gadi Luzzatto Voghera (Fondazione CDEC), Dario Miccoli (Università Ca’ Foscari, Venezia), Michele Sarfatti (Fondazione CDEC), Marcella Simoni (Università Ca’ Foscari, Venezia), Ulrich Wyrwa (Universität Potsdam). Editorial Assistants Matteo Perissinotto – Managing Editor (Univerza v Ljubljani) Sara Airoldi – Editorial Assistant (The Van Leer Jerusalem Institute) Book Review Editor Miriam Benfatto (Alma Mater Studiorum, Università di Bologna) English Language Editor Elen Rochlin Editorial Advisory Board Ruth Ben Ghiat (New York University), Paolo Luca Bernardini (Università dell’Insubria), Dominique Bourel (Université de la Sorbonne, Paris), Michael Brenner (Ludwig-Maximilians-Universität München), Enzo Campelli (Università La Sapienza di Roma), Francesco Cassata (Università degli Studi di Genova), Marco Cuzzi (Università degli Studi di Milano), Roberto Della Rocca (Dipartimento Educazione Cultura e Cultura- Unione delle Comunità Ebraiche Italiane), Lois Dubin (Smith College, Northampton), Jacques Ehrenfreund (Université de Lausanne), Katherine E. Fleming (New York University), Anna Foa (Università
    [Show full text]
  • Judaism and Jewish Philosophy 19 Judaism, Jews and Holocaust Theology
    Please see the Cover and Contents in the last pages of this e-Book Online Study Materials on JUDAISM AND JEWISH PHILOSOPHY 19 JUDAISM, JEWS AND HOLOCAUST THEOLOGY JUDAISM Judaism is the religion of the Jewish people, based on principles and ethics embodied in the Hebrew Bible (Tanakh) and the Talmud. According to Jewish tradition, the history of Judaism begins with the Covenant between God and Abraham (ca. 2000 BCE), the patriarch and progenitor of the Jewish people. Judaism is among the oldest religious traditions still in practice today. Jewish history and doctrines have influenced other religions such as Christianity, Islam and the Bahá’í Faith. While Judaism has seldom, if ever, been monolithic in practice, it has always been monotheistic in theology. It differs from many religions in that central authority is not vested in a person or group, but in sacred texts and traditions. Throughout the ages, Judaism has clung to a number of religious principles, the most important of which is the belief in a single, omniscient, omnipotent, benevolent, transcendent God, who created the universe and continues to govern it. According to traditional Jewish belief, the God who created the world established a covenant with the Israelites, and revealed his laws and commandments to Moses on Mount Sinai in the form of the Torah, and the Jewish people are the descendants of the Israelites. The traditional practice of Judaism revolves around study and the observance of God’s laws and commandments as written in the Torah and expounded in the Talmud. With an estimated 14 million adherents in 2006, Judaism is approximately the world’s eleventh-largest religious group.
    [Show full text]