Volume 2, Issue 4, December 2005 of Otakus and Fansubs
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Volume 2, Issue 4, December 2005 Of Otakus and Fansubs: A Critical Look at Anime Online in Light of Current Issues in Copyright law Jordan S. Hatcher, JD, LLM * Abstract The advent of digital technology and increased global connectivity has, to put it mildly, caused some ripples for the entertainment industry specifically and copyright law generally. In the aftermath, many are searching for new ways to incorporate the benefits of digital copies and the internet while minimizing the harms. To some, the anime industry and its fans offer examples of how an industry can benefit and even grow from allowing copyright infringement. This article examines the anime industry in-depth with this suggestion in mind and places the industry among current copyright policy debates, such as those suggested by Lawrence Lessig. DOI: 10.2966/scrip.020405.514 © Jordan S. Hatcher 2005. This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 2.5 Scotland License .+ * Jordan S. Hatcher, JD, LLM, recently graduated from the University of Texas School of Law and the University of Edinburgh, Scotland. He specializes in legal issues surrounding technology and intellectual property. He currently resides in Austin, Texas, where, among other things, he serves as on the board of EFF-Austin, and is collaborating with local activist groups on an open government amendment to the Austin city charter. He can be contacted at jordan _at_ twitchgamer dot net and at his corner of the web, http://twitchgamer.net No article ever comes into existence without some help, and the author would especially like to thank Dr. Andres Guadamuz, Bob Rietjens, and the entire AHRC Research Centre for studies in Intellectual Property and Technology law for their assistance. + This article is available in book form. Readers in the United States who would like a copy may purchase directly from Lulu.com at http://www.lulu.com/content/200908 . Readers outside of the US may request a copy directly from the author by contacting him at jordan at twitchgamer dot net. (2005) Vol 2:4 SCRIPT-ed 515 “Sailor Moon is like a gateway drug” 1 - Janet Varela, referring to her daughter’s new obsession with anime “Too many otaku are just wanting fansubs for a cheap anime fix” 2 - Rei-kun, member of fansubbers Kodocha Anime, describing digisubs 1. Introduction: Between Dojinshi and P2P The excesses of copyright law—from the legalities of peer-to-peer (p2p) networks to the intrusion of copyright law into the human body—have been a topic of great recent interest to both the legal world and the general public. 3 Scholars, such as Lawrence Lessig, have been propelled into celebrity for their work discussing the perceived excess and illogic of certain aspects of modern copyright law. 4 Under the term Free Culture , Lessig states that the re-working of culture—remix—is necessary to cultural growth, and that a healthy public domain and freedom from burdensome copyright restrictions facilitates this process. 5 He points to the hindrances in a digital world that copyright laws pose for creative works that, while technically infringing, should perhaps be valued and allowed. 6 Certain features of digital technologies and the internet, 7 according to Lessig, can permit greater restrictions on remix than were allowed in the past. 8 He puts forth the theory that by rigidly applying our copyright laws to the new digital environment we increase the restrictions on remix and thus threaten this Free Culture. 9 Lessig and other legal scholars such as Mehra have pointed to dojinshi in Japan as an example of how permitting more “remix” can contribute to a vibrant cultural 1 Melissa Hung, Tooned Into Anime Houston Press (Texas) (Aug. 2, 2001). 2 Holly Kolodziejczak, The Volatile World of Fansubs: An Inside Peek! Animefringe Online Magazine @: <http://www.animefringe.com/magazine/01.07/feature/2/index.php3 > 3 See e.g., the recent case and associated commentary over peer-to-peer (p2p) file sharing in the U.S. Supreme Court, MGM Studios v. Grokster, Ltd. , 125 S. Ct. 2764 (2005); Marisa Kakoulas, The Great Tattoo Controversy , December 8, 2003, BMEzine @: <http://www.bmezine.com/news/guest/20031208.html > (concerning copyright in tattoos). 4 Lessig was recently featured in the hit US television show The West Wing . See Lawrence Lessig, West Wing Lessons February 10, 2005 @: < http://www.lessig.org/blog/archives/002421.shtml > (Lessig’s blog entry on the show); NBC, The West Wing , @: <http://www.nbc.com/The_West_Wing/index.html > (official site).Though they haven't appeared on prime-time network television, Siva Vaidhyanathan and Jessica Litman are both popular authors in this area that have reached a non-legal audience. 5 Lawrence Lessig, Free Culture: how big media uses technology and the law to lock down culture and control creativity (Penguin Books 2004) [hereafter Free Culture ]. 6 See e.g., Lawrence Lessig, The Future of Ideas: the fate of the commons in a connected world (Vintage Books 2001) [hereafter The Future of Ideas ]; Lessig, Free Culture . 7 For capitalization of the word “internet”, see Tony Long, It’s Just the ‘internet’ Now , Wired News (Aug. 16 2004) @: < http://www.wired.com/news/culture/0,1284,64596,00.html > 8 Lessig, Free Culture at 161 (“This change in the effective force of the law is caused by a change in the ease with which in can be enforced”). 9 Lessig, Free Culture . (2005) Vol 2:4 SCRIPT-ed 516 industry. 10 Dojinshi refers to self-published manga (Japanese comics) that involve famous characters created by someone other than the character’s creator, i.e., fan fiction. 11 So for example, a dojinshi author will take a popular character such as Harry Potter and create new adventures for the young sorcerer. 12 Unlike other jurisdictions such as the United States—what commentators such as Lessig point to—fans in Japan are free to create dojinshi through a combination of custom and certain features of the Japanese legal system. 13 Because of this freedom, the dojinshi business has grown enormously, to the point where some artists make a living off producing dojinshi. Comiket, a twice-yearly comic convention in Tokyo, attracts a massive 350,000 fans and artists to buy, sell, and trade dojinshi in one place. 14 Dojinshi-like practices are, of course, not isolated to Japan. In the west, Star Wars and Star Trek fans (among many others) routinely produce fan fiction and fan films based on the shows they love. 15 Some of these films may even find official sanction through fan film competitions in such places as online entertainment site Atom Films. 16 But unless authorized, these activities usually violate copyright law. 17 In the west, fans of anime , the term for Japanese animation, behave much like fans of Star Wars and Star Trek : they “remix” the characters and ideas from the stories they watch. 18 Especially in the United States, avid anime fans refer to themselves as otaku , much like avid Star Trek fans refer to themselves as Trekkies .19 Like other fans, otaku practice a wide variety of activities; all of which potentially infringe the copyright of the shows and films they love. 20 They create dojinshi. 21 They use captured graphics from shows to 10 Lessig, Free Culture at 25-29; Salil Mehra, Copyright and Comics in Japan: Does Law Explain Why All the Cartoons My Kid Watches Are Japanese Imports? , 55 Rutgers L. Rev. 155 (2002) [hereafter Copyright and Comics in Japan ]; Sean Kirkpatrick, Like Holding a Bird: What the Prevalence of Fansubbing Can Teach Us About the Use of Strategic Selective Copyright Enforcement , 21 Temp. Envtl. L. & Tech. J. 131, 147-48 (2003) [hereafter Like Holding a Bird ]. Dojinshi is also often spelled doujinshi . Wikipedia, Dojinshi @: < http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dojinshi > 11 Wikipedia, Dojinshi ; Mehra, Copyright and Comics in Japan , at 155. See also Chilling Effects Clearinghouse, FAQ about Fan Fiction, @: < http://www.chillingeffects.org/fanfic/faq.cgi > 12 See e.g., House of Black, HouseOfBlack.net Doujinshi , @: <http://www.houseofblack.net/doujinshi/_dj_.html > ; DrMM, Addiction: A Harry Potter Doujinshi Website , @: < http://www.fuuko.com/doujinshi/ > 13 See Lessig, Free Culture at 25-29; Mehra, Copyright and Comics in Japan . See also discussion in The Legality of Fansubs, infra . 14 Wikipedia, Comiket , @: < http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Comiket >; Comiket, Welcome to the Official Comic Market Site , @: < http://www.comiket.co.jp/ > (mostly in Japanese). 15 E.g. Atom Films, Star Wars Fan Film Awards , @: <http://www.atomfilms.com/af/spotlight/collections/starwars/ >; John Borland, Star War fan films get Lucas nod , CNET NEWS.com @: < http://news.com.com/Star+Wars+fan+films+get+Lucas+nod/2100- 1026_3-5683654.html > 16 Atom Films, Star Wars Fan Film Awards . 17 See The Legality of Fansubs, infra . The exception to authorization is, of course, fair use or fair dealing . 18 For a scholarly look at “participatory culture”, see Henry Jenkins, Quentin Tarantino’s Star Wars?: Digital Cinema, Media Convergence, and Participatory Culture , @: <http://web.mit.edu/21fms/www/faculty/henry3/starwars.html > 19 The use of the word “otaku” in Japanese is different, but outside of Japan, most anime fans identify themselves by this term. Wikipedia, Otaku , @: < http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Otaku > . For more on the term, see resources collected at Lawrence Eng, Lawmune’s Anime Page , @: <http://www.cjas.org/~leng/anime.htm > 20 See 17 U.S.C.S. §106 (1), (2) (2005) [reproduction and derivative work rights]; Melville Nimmer & David Nimmer, Nimmer on Copyright § 3.01 (Matthew Bender 2005). Nimmer on Copyright ,. This is, of course, barring any fair use/fair dealing defenses. 21 See American Comiket, @: < http://amcomik.hakaze.com/about.html > (2005) Vol 2:4 SCRIPT-ed 517 create fansites and to make wallpaper for their computer desktops.22 They attend conventions and other events dressed as characters from their favorite shows; an activity known as cosplay .23 They create “Anime Music Videos”, or AMVs for short, which involve editing scenes from one or more anime series and setting the final product to music.