Case Concerning Pulp Mills on the River Uruguay

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Case Concerning Pulp Mills on the River Uruguay INTERNATIONAL COURT OF JUSTICE _________________________________________________________________ CASE CONCERNING PULP MILLS ON THE RIVER URUGUAY ARGENTINA v. URUGUAY REJOINDER OF URUGUAY VOLUME I _________________________________________________________________ 29 JULY 2008 VOLUME I REJOINDER OF URUGUAY TABLE OF CONTENTS Page CHAPTER 1. INTRODUCTION AND SUMMARY OF ARGUMENT .............................................................................................................1 Section I. Further Observations on Jurisdiction ................................................7 Section II. Summary of Argument ....................................................................9 Section III. Structure of the Rejoinder ............................................................24 PART I CHAPTER 2. THE LAW APPLICABLE TO THE PROCEDURAL ISSUES .........................................................................................27 Section I. The Nature and Scope of CARU’s Involvement Under Articles 7-12 ...................................................................................................34 A. The Role of CARU ......................................................................34 B. The Timing of Notice to CARU...................................................47 C. The Relevance of the 1997 Watercourse Convention ..................59 D. The Relative Status of Procedural and Substantive Rights...........................................................................................67 E. The Issue of Argentina’s Industrial Plants ...................................72 Section II. The Issue of Implementation During Dispute Resolution..............79 A. The Veto Issue and the Consequences of a Disagreement ...........79 B. Implementation of a Project as Distinguished from “Preparatory Works”..................................................................102 C. The Importance of Environmental Protection ............................105 D. The Role of the Court.................................................................109 Conclusion ....................................................................................................113 CHAPTER 3. THE EVIDENCE REGARDING THE PROCEDURAL ISSUES .......................................................................................115 Section I. The Evidence Regarding Argentina’s Claim that Uruguay Violated the 1975 Statute by Failing to Notify CARU and Await Its Summary Determination Before Authorizing the Botnia and ENCE Projects .........................................................................................................120 A. The GTAN Consultative Process ...............................................121 B. The March 2004 Agreement ......................................................132 1. ENCE...................................................................................132 2. The Extension to Botnia. .....................................................159 C. The Timing of Notice to CARU.................................................163 Section II. The Evidence Regarding Argentina’s Claim that Uruguay Violated the 1975 Statute by Implementing the Botnia Project Before the Court Has Rendered Its Judgment in This Case. .........................180 A. Uruguay Complied with Its Procedural Obligations During Consultations. ................................................................180 1. Uruguay Participated in Consultations in Good Faith..........180 2. Uruguay Provided More Than Adequate Information .........181 3. Uruguay Engaged Only in Preparatory Works ....................185 B. Uruguay Complied with Its Procedural Obligations During Dispute Resolution.........................................................188 Conclusion ....................................................................................................191 PART II CHAPTER 4. THE EVIDENCE REGARDING START-UP AND OPERATION OF THE BOTNIA PLANT ...................................................197 Introduction...................................................................................................199 Section I. Prior to Uruguay’s Authorisation of Operations, the Botnia Plant Was Subject to Comprehensive Evaluations by Both Uruguay and the IFC to Ensure It Would Not Harm the Environment ........................204 A. The IFC’s Technology Audit for Compliance With BAT..........209 B. Environmental Management Plans.............................................212 1. Management of Hazardous Materials ..................................213 2. Emergency Preparedness and Response ..............................215 3. Transportation Management ................................................216 4. Conservation........................................................................218 5. Solid Waste Management ....................................................219 6. Social Impact Monitoring ....................................................220 C. Pre-Operational Environmental Quality Monitoring..................220 1. Pre-Operational Water Quality Monitoring .........................222 2. Pre-Operational Sediment Monitoring.................................227 3. Pre-Operational Biological Monitoring ...............................229 - ii - Section II. Monitoring Results for the First Six Months of Operation ..........231 A. The Post-Operational Monitoring Program................................234 B. The Botnia Plant’s Exceptional Environmental Performance Has Not Impacted the Uruguay River...................242 1. The Plant Effluent Complies with Applicable Regulations, Standards and Predictions ...............................244 (a) Phosphorus..............................................................246 (i) The Botnia Plant’s Superior Performance Regarding Phosphorus..............246 (ii) Uruguay’s Efforts to Reduce Phosphorus in the Uruguay River..................248 (b) Nitrogen ..................................................................253 (c) Biological Oxygen Demand....................................254 (d) Chemical Oxygen Demand .....................................255 (e) Total Suspended Solids...........................................256 (f) AOX........................................................................256 (g) Dioxins and Furans .................................................257 (h) Metals......................................................................257 (i) Acute Toxicity.........................................................259 (j) Flow ........................................................................259 (k) Other Aquatic Parameters .......................................259 (l) Air ...........................................................................260 2. The Botnia Plant Has Not Caused Any Change to Ambient Water Quality in the Uruguay River .....................261 Section III. Uruguay’s Continuing Commitment to Protect the River ..........265 A. Continued Post-Operational Monitoring ....................................265 B. Continued IFC Oversight ...........................................................266 C. Uruguay’s Ongoing Regulatory Oversight and Commitment to Prevent Unacceptable Impacts to the River ..........................................................................................267 Conclusion ....................................................................................................268 - iii - CHAPTER 5. THE APPLICABLE LAW REGARDING ENVIRONMENTAL ISSUES ...............................................................................271 Section I. The Risk Prevention Regime Created by the 1975 Statute Requires Joint and Equitable Measures to Promote the Optimum and Rational Use of the River..............................................................................274 Section II. CARU Standards Define the Content of Articles 36 and 41 of the Statute ............................................................................................290 Section III. General Principles of International Environmental Law Do Not Alter the Terms of the Statute ..........................................................294 A. Sustainable Utilisation ...............................................................295 B. Equitable and Reasonable Use ...................................................300 C. Prevention of Transboundary Damage.......................................301 D. The Precautionary Principle.......................................................304 Section IV. Uruguay Has Carried Out the Required Environmental Impact Assessment........................................................................................312 Section V. Uruguay is Not Required to Assess the Suitability of Alternative Sites............................................................................................322 Conclusion ....................................................................................................325 CHAPTER 6. RESPONSE TO ARGENTINA’S TECHNICAL CRITICISMS..........................................................................................................327 Introduction...................................................................................................329 Section I. The Evidence Shows that the Botnia Plant Will Not Cause Eutrophication or Otherwise Harm the Uruguay River.................................330 A. Argentina Cannot Show Any Risk of Increased Eutrophication in Ñandubaysal Bay From the Operation of the Botnia Plant......................................................................332
Recommended publications
  • Argentina-Marruecos. De Los Impulsos a La Convergencia Político-Comercial (1989-2007)
    View metadata, citation and similar papers at core.ac.uk brought to you by CORE provided by Repositorio Hipermedial de la Universidad Nacional de Rosario UNIVERSIDAD NACIONAL DE ROSARIO Facultad de Ciencia Política y Relaciones Internacionales DOCTORADO EN RELACIONES INTERNACIONALES TESIS Argentina-Marruecos. De los impulsos a la convergencia político-comercial (1989-2007) Mgter. Juan José Vagni DIRECTORA: Dra. Gladys Lechini 21 de octubre de 2008 Este trabajo aborda las vinculaciones de Argentina con el Reino de Marruecos, en el contexto de sus relaciones con el Norte de África y África, centrando su atención en el período 1989-2007, etapa en la cual se profundizó el acercamiento entre ambos actores y, consecuentemente, el afianzamiento de los lazos bilaterales. Se pretende explicar porqué las relaciones político-diplomáticas y comerciales con Marruecos se intensificaron y avanzaron en el sentido de una convergencia político-comercial, a pesar del descenso del perfil de las relaciones argentino-africanas en la política exterior argentina. El incremento sostenido en la relación bilateral se produjo debido a la implementación de una política por impulsos, de carácter agregativo, que se sostuvo a lo largo de estos veinte años, gracias a las respuestas e insistencia del lado marroquí y a los acercamientos desarrollados por Brasil hacia la región norafricana. Mientras en los noventa se avanzó con el enfoque comercialista, animado por las coincidencias ideológicas resultantes del alineamiento con la potencia hegemónica; en el siglo XXI el enfoque comercialista se acentuó, pero ahora bajo el discurso de la cooperación Sur-Sur. 2 Argentina - Moroco. From impulses to political and commercial convergence (1989-2007) This thesis deals with the relationship between Argentina and Morocco in the broader context of the argentine relations with Africa and North Africa specifically.
    [Show full text]
  • Ngo Documents 2007-08-06 00:00:00 Banks, Pulp And
    Banks, Pulp and People A Primer on Upcoming International Pulp Projects Published by: urgewald e.V. Editing: Lydia Bartz, Heffa Schücking, Patrick Anderson Author: Chris Lang Layout by: Kirsten Everwien, [konzept+gestaltung], Köln, Germany Printed by: Darpe Industriedruck GmbH & Co KG, Warendorf, Germany V.I.S.d.P: Heffa Schücking, Von Galen Str. 2, 48336 Sassenberg, Germany Copyright: © Juni 2007 urgewald Many thanks to the following institutions for their support 2 urgewald – Advocacy for the Environment and Human Rights urgewald is a German non-profit organization, movements, which are challenging the massive whose mission is to address the underlying causes impacts of the pulp industry in their countries. of global environmental destruction and poverty. Time and again, we have experienced that both We monitor the activities of German banks and development and commercial banks are seldom companies abroad and educate the German public aware of the environmental and social impacts of about the negative impacts of our consumption the pulp industry in these countries, when they patterns on people and nature in far-away places. make investment decisions. After years of working with consumers, our forest program has therefore urgewald works closely with affected communities begun to actively reach out to financial institutions and NGOs in the global South. Over the years, we and to encourage them to recognize indigenous have become an important contact point for anti- and local peoples’ rights as well as environmental nuclear campaigners in Eastern Europe, indigenous concerns, when making decisions, that will affect people in Brazil, whose cultures are threatened by the future of communities and ecosystems.
    [Show full text]
  • "Facebook Es Un Fogón Planetario"
    Sociedad "Facebook es un fogón planetario" Entrevista a Alberto Arébalos, director de Comunicación para América Latina, sobre las denuncias de manipulación y la privacidad de los usuarios. "Messi tiene fans hasta en Bangladesh", dice. www.tiempoargentino.com | año 5 | nº 1489 | miércoles 2 de julio de 2014 edición nacional | $ 8 | recargo envío al interior $ 1,50 | ROU $ 40 » ECONOMÍA pág. 4-5 reestructuración de la deuda La Selección Argentina Escribe derrotó 1-0 a Suiza Economía advirtió Víctor que los buitres no Hugo y clasificó para los cuartos del Mundial. quieren negociar Sobre el final, un El ministerio aclaró que sólo cabezazo de los "quieren apropiarse de la plata suizos pegó de los bonistas". Hubo otro en el palo y escrito de holdouts a Griesa. nos salvamos » POLÍTICA pág. 6 del empate. homenaje a perón e yrigoyen "Estábamos muertos", reconoció Cristina criticó el Messi después del rol de la justicia en alargue. El sábado golpes militares enfrentamos a Afirmó que "fue el único Poder MIÉ 2 MIÉ Bélgica, desde las 13. que no sufrió derrocamientos" y que siempre convalidó la doctrina de los militares. » MUNDO pág. 24 una medida sin precedentes Sarkozy, preso por sobornar a un juez francés El ex presidente declaró en la justicia y rechazó escuchas telefónicas. Peligra su posible candidatura en el año 2017. EL MESÍAS FROTÓ LA LÁMPARA Y ÁNGEL LA METIÓ » SOCIEDAD pág. 28-29 sube el agua en entre ríos Anuncian ayuda social para miles ¡Ave de inundados Se duplicará la AUH y otras asignaciones, y habrá una Di María! suma fija para los jubilados.
    [Show full text]
  • 43 Por Ayotzinapa
    43 por Ayotzinapa 43 por Ayotzinapa FONDO EDITOR COOPERATIVO LOS JUEGOS DEL TEMPS 3 43 por Ayotzinapa 43 POR AYOTZINAPA Autores Varios Primera Edición. Septiembre 2015 © Fondo Editor Cooperativo Los Juegos del Temps, 2015 Correo electrónico: [email protected] Facebook: Temps Era Temps Santa Fe - Argentina Foto de Tapa: Remigio A. Bouquet Diseño de tapa y diagramación interior: Marcelo Jourdán Correo electrónico: [email protected] 43 POR AYOTZINAPA por AUTORES VARIOS Se distribuye bajo una Licencia Creative Commons Atribución-NoComercial 4.0 Internacional. Basada en una obra en: https://www.facebook.com/pages/ Los-Juegos-del-Temps/843904265625990?fref=ts. Permisos que vayan más allá de lo cubierto por esta licencia pueden encontrarse en: https://www.facebook.com/pages/ Los-Juegos-del-Temps/843904265625990?fref=ts. 4 43 por Ayotzinapa Índice Nota Introductoria 11 Estela de Carlotto Prólogo 15 Cuando el Amor y la Solidaridad se Enfrentan al Terrorismo del Narco-Estado Entrevista con tres de los padres de los estudiantes desaparecidos y uno de los sobrevivientes de la noche del 26/09/2014 23 María Julia Magistratti “Vivos se los llevaron, vivos los queremos” 33 Martín Scalabrini Ortiz Números 39 Sergio Gioacchini A menudo nos disparan 47 Ana Cacopardo El lugar de la esperanza 57 3 43 por Ayotzinapa Ignacio Montoya Carlotto Hasta no hace mucho cuando todo parecía un poco más fácil... 65 Eduardo Anguita 43 Estudiantes Mexicanos y Latinoamericanos 71 Carlos Caillabet El Prisionero 97 Coco Domínguez Tealdi El Mariachi Guerrero de
    [Show full text]
  • Putting Environmental Injustice on the Map: Ecotestimonies from the Global South
    Studies in 20th & 21st Century Literature Volume 39 Issue 2 Testimonies of Environmental Injustice Article 2 in the Global South 2015 Putting Environmental Injustice on the Map: Ecotestimonies from the Global South Erin S. Finzer University of Arkansas - Little Rock, [email protected] Follow this and additional works at: https://newprairiepress.org/sttcl Part of the Comparative Literature Commons, French and Francophone Literature Commons, Latin American Literature Commons, and the Modern Literature Commons This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial-No Derivative Works 4.0 License. Recommended Citation Finzer, Erin S. (2015) "Putting Environmental Injustice on the Map: Ecotestimonies from the Global South," Studies in 20th & 21st Century Literature: Vol. 39: Iss. 2, Article 2. https://doi.org/10.4148/ 2334-4415.1837 This Introductory Material is brought to you for free and open access by New Prairie Press. It has been accepted for inclusion in Studies in 20th & 21st Century Literature by an authorized administrator of New Prairie Press. For more information, please contact [email protected]. Putting Environmental Injustice on the Map: Ecotestimonies from the Global South Abstract This introductory essay to STTCL 39.2 discusses the importance of testimony as a flexible literary genre that can tell the stories of environmental injustice in the Global South, which is disproportionately affected by environmental violence and less represented in the growing global environmental movement. Keywords ecotestimony, environmental injustice, Global South, testimonio, resistance literature, climate change Cover Page Footnote This special issue was compiled in fond memory of Nao Ueda, environmental activist, urban homesteader, and friend.
    [Show full text]
  • The Tales of the Grimm Brothers in Colombia: Introduction, Dissemination, and Reception
    Wayne State University Wayne State University Dissertations 1-1-2012 The alest of the grimm brothers in colombia: introduction, dissemination, and reception Alexandra Michaelis-Vultorius Wayne State University, Follow this and additional works at: http://digitalcommons.wayne.edu/oa_dissertations Part of the German Literature Commons, and the Modern Languages Commons Recommended Citation Michaelis-Vultorius, Alexandra, "The alet s of the grimm brothers in colombia: introduction, dissemination, and reception" (2012). Wayne State University Dissertations. Paper 386. This Open Access Dissertation is brought to you for free and open access by DigitalCommons@WayneState. It has been accepted for inclusion in Wayne State University Dissertations by an authorized administrator of DigitalCommons@WayneState. THE TALES OF THE GRIMM BROTHERS IN COLOMBIA: INTRODUCTION, DISSEMINATION, AND RECEPTION by ALEXANDRA MICHAELIS-VULTORIUS DISSERTATION Submitted to the Graduate School of Wayne State University, Detroit, Michigan in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of DOCTOR OF PHILOSOPHY 2011 MAJOR: MODERN LANGUAGES (German Studies) Approved by: __________________________________ Advisor Date __________________________________ __________________________________ __________________________________ __________________________________ © COPYRIGHT BY ALEXANDRA MICHAELIS-VULTORIUS 2011 All Rights Reserved DEDICATION To my parents, Lucio and Clemencia, for your unconditional love and support, for instilling in me the joy of learning, and for believing in happy endings. ii ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS This journey with the Brothers Grimm was made possible through the valuable help, expertise, and kindness of a great number of people. First and foremost I want to thank my advisor and mentor, Professor Don Haase. You have been a wonderful teacher and a great inspiration for me over the past years. I am deeply grateful for your insight, guidance, dedication, and infinite patience throughout the writing of this dissertation.
    [Show full text]
  • Catálogo De Publicaciones De Los Movimientos Sociales De
    CCaattáállooggoo ddee ppuubblliiccaacciioonneess ddee llooss mmoovviimmiieennttooss ssoocciiaalleess ddee llaa AArrggeennttiinnaa yy ddeell mmuunnddoo ((11889900--22000055)) La realización del presente Catálogo contó con el apoyo de un subsidio del Programa SEPHIS (South-South Exchange Programme for Research on the History of Developement). CeDInCI Centro de Documentación e Investigación de la Cultura de Izquierdas en la Argentina El CeDInCI es una asociación civil sin fines de lucro, cuyo objetvo es la preservación del patrimonio cultural de las clases subalternas. Ha sido declarado “de interés de la Ciudad de Buenos Aires” por la Legislatura de esta ciudad en 1999. Personería jurídica resol. IGJ nº 00235/98 Fray Luis Beltrán 125 C1406BEC Ciudad Autónoma de Buenos Aires Telefax: (54) (11) 4631/8893 [email protected] www.cedinci.org Proyecto de Catalogación del CeDInCI Responsables de catalogación: Mariana Bergerot, Laura Ehrlich, Damián López, Adriana Petra, Roberto Pittaluga y Horacio Tarcus. Coordinación general: Horacio Tarcus – 2 Graciela Karababikian (ed.) 2 / CATÁLOGO DE PPUUBBLLIICCAACCIIOONNEESS DDEE LLOOSS MMOOVVIIMMIIEENNTTOOSS SSOOCCIIAALLEESS DDEE LLAA AARRGGEENNTTIINNAA YY DDEELL MMUUNNDDOO ((11889900——22000055)) Buenos Aires 2006 – 3 Presentación El Catálogo que en esta oportunidad presentamos ofrece una descripción sistemática y organizada de las publicaciones editadas por los diversos movimientos sociales de Argentina entre 1890 y la actualidad, que forman parte del acervo del CeDInCI. Es el producto, del mismo modo
    [Show full text]
  • A Primer on Upcoming International Pulp Projects Published By: Urgewald E.V
    Banks, Pulp and People A Primer on Upcoming International Pulp Projects Published by: urgewald e.V. Editing: Lydia Bartz, Heffa Schücking, Patrick Anderson Author: Chris Lang Layout by: Kirsten Everwien, [konzept+gestaltung], Köln, Germany Printed by: Darpe Industriedruck GmbH & Co KG, Warendorf, Germany V.I.S.d.P: Heffa Schücking, Von Galen Str. 2, 48336 Sassenberg, Germany Copyright: © Juni 2007 urgewald Many thanks to the following institutions for their support 2 urgewald – Advocacy for the Environment and Human Rights urgewald is a German non-profit organization, movements, which are challenging the massive whose mission is to address the underlying causes impacts of the pulp industry in their countries. of global environmental destruction and poverty. Time and again, we have experienced that both We monitor the activities of German banks and development and commercial banks are seldom companies abroad and educate the German public aware of the environmental and social impacts of about the negative impacts of our consumption the pulp industry in these countries, when they patterns on people and nature in far-away places. make investment decisions. After years of working with consumers, our forest program has therefore urgewald works closely with affected communities begun to actively reach out to financial institutions and NGOs in the global South. Over the years, we and to encourage them to recognize indigenous have become an important contact point for anti- and local peoples’ rights as well as environmental nuclear campaigners in Eastern Europe, indigenous concerns, when making decisions, that will affect people in Brazil, whose cultures are threatened by the future of communities and ecosystems.
    [Show full text]
  • Pronunciamiento De Solidaridad Con Evo Morales Y Condena Al Imperialismo
    PRONUNCIAMIENTO DE SOLIDARIDAD CON EVO MORALES Y CONDENA AL IMPERIALISMO La Red de Intelectuales y Artistas en Defensa de la Humanidad manifiesta su indignación ante el atentado criminal perpetrado en la tarde de este martes 3 de julio contra el Presidente boliviano Evo Morales Ayma, de parte del gobierno de los Estados Unidos y con la clara complicidad de varios estados europeos. La negación de pasar por espacio aéreo o de hacer uso del derecho de un repostaje técnico del avión FAB-001 del Presidente del Estado Plurinacional de Bolivia por algunos países europeos, no solo es una ofensa contra el primer presidente indígena de América Latina, sino contra el proceso de integración y construcción de la Patria Grande que está recuperando su soberanía y dejando atrás su condición de “patio trasero” de los Estados Unidos. Bolivia, en la figura de Evo Morales, un campesino cocalero que enfrentó a la DEA en su etapa como sindicalista, y que expulsó al embajador de Estados Unidos y a USAID en su condición de Presidente, es el claro ejemplo de cómo se pueden construir procesos de cambio en favor de las mayorías populares desde posiciones claramente anticoloniales y antiimperialistas. La cobarde y criminal agresión contra Evo Morales es una señal de amenaza de lo dispuesto que está el imperialismo para acabar con los presidentes y pueblos dignos de América Latina, para destruir la dignidad y soberanía recuperadas y para volverse a apropiar de nuestros recursos naturales. Llamamos a los pueblos y gobiernos de América Latina, pero también a los pueblos de Europa que sufren la embestida de sus elites políticas y económicas, a denunciar y condenar esta actitud neocolonial de España, Francia, Portugal e Italia, colonias de una potencia decadente.
    [Show full text]
  • Worldwide Reading on September 8 Th, 2014
    © Laura Poitras Liberty and Recognition for Edward Snowden Worldwide Reading on September 8 th, 2014 Angola José Eduardo Agualusa Argentina Eduardo Sguiglia Australia Brian Castro | Richard Flanagan | Gail Jones | Mike A Manifesto for the Truth by Edward Snowden Shuttleworth | Herbert Wharton Austria Haimo L. Handl | Josef Haslinger | Elfriede Jelinek | Eva Menasse | Haralampi Oroschakoff In a very short time, the world has learned much about unaccount- Bahrain Ameen Saleh Belgium Stefan Hertmans Bosnia-Herzegovina Faruk Šehi Brazil Ricardo Azevedo Bulgaria Ilija Trojanow | able secret agencies and about sometimes illegal surveillance pro- Tzveta Sofronieva Canada Brian Brett | Michael Day | Paul Dutton | Greg Gatenby | Michael Ondaatje | Madeleine Thien | Miriam Toews grams. Sometimes the agencies even deliberately try to hide their Chile Ariel Dorfman China Xiaolu Guo | Lian Yang | Liao Yiwu Colombia Winston Morales Chavarro | Rafael Patiño Góez | Fernando surveillance of high officials or the public. While the NSA and GCHQ Rendón | Laura Restrepo Cyprus Stephanos Stephanides Denmark Christian Jungersen | Pia Tafdrup | Janne Teller Egypt Mekkawi seem to be the worst offenders – this is what the currently available Said Estonia Hasso Krull | Jüri Talvet Finland JK Ihalainen France Camille de Toledo | Abdelwahab Meddeb | Mariette Navarro | documents suggest – we must not forget that mass surveillance is a global problem in need of global solutions. Christian Salmon Germany Jan Assmann | Güner Yasemin Balci | Wilhelm Bartsch | Marica Bodroži | Thomas Böhm | Mirko Bonné | Such programs are not only a threat to privacy, they also threaten Martin Buchholz | Irene Dische | Ute Frevert | Jochen Gerz | Christian Grote | Finn-Ole Heinrich | Ulrich Horstmann | Rolf Hosfeld | Florian freedom of speech and open societies.
    [Show full text]
  • Appeal for a Worldwide Reading for Zimbabwe English
    Appeal for a Worldwide Reading for Democracy and Media Freedom in Zimbabwe on 9 th September 2007 The human rights abuses in Zimbabwe go back to the early 80s, when Robert Mugabe implemented the Gukurahundi operation - the bloody murder of more than 20.000 Ndebele people. Since 2000 he has been responsible for the eviction of white farmers from their land, actions which have led to corn shortages and, consequently, to terrible famine. During the Murambatsvina (filth removal) campaign of 2005, Mugabe responded to the opposition's demonstrations by having several slums bulldozed. Hundreds of opposition members and dissidents have been arrested, kidnapped or tortured. A general ban on demonstrations has been in force since February 2007. The freedom of the press is extremely limited and there is discrimination against foreign media. Mugabe influenced the election by means of violence and absolute control in such a way that fear was caused to everyone who voted for the opposition. In mid-March 2007 Zimbabwe's most important opposition party leader, Morgan Tsvangirai, was arrested during a protest rally and later severely beaten in custody. Only a decade ago Zimbabwe had been one of the richest and most developed countries in Africa, with the highest educational standards on the continent and a literacy rate of almost 85%. Over recent years Mugabe has led his country to economic collapse and his people into bitter poverty. Officially, Zimbabwe's inflation rate is 3700%, the highest in the world. The unemployment rate is 80%. With an average life expectancy of 34 years for women and 37 years for men, Zimbabwe has become the country with the lowest life expectancy in the world.
    [Show full text]
  • A Posthumanist Account of the Río Cruces Disaster in Valdivia, Chile
    SWANS, ECOLOGICAL STRUGGLES AND ONTOLOGICAL FRACTURES: A Posthumanist Account of the Río Cruces Disaster in Valdivia, Chile by Claudia Sepúlveda A Dissertation Submitted in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree of Doctor of Philosophy in The Faculty of Graduate and Postdoctoral Studies (Geography) THE UNIVERSITY OF BRITISH COLUMBIA (Vancouver) February 2016 © Claudia Sepúlveda, 2016 Abstract This is a dissertation on ontological struggles –that is, struggles between competing ways of performing the world. More precisely, I study the ontological opening resulting from such struggles once what I call dominant performations are exposed to revision and room is made for non-dominant ontologies, such as alternative human/nature entanglements. I analyze the ontological opening provoked by a landmark event in Valdivia, Chile: the Río Cruces ecological disaster that since 2004 has affected a protected wetland and its colony of black-necked swans. The disaster, that followed the installation of a new pulp-mill by ARAUCO, one of the world’s largest pulpwood companies, sparked an unprecedented mobilization with long-lasting effects. Staying close to the “doings” of the actors, my political ontological interpretation describes, first, how the disaster exposed ARAUCO’s environmental practices as constitutive of its way of performing the forest business and, doing so, also fractured Chile’s until then dominant business model. Second, I describe how the disaster revealed the workings of environmental procedures and the techno-scientific knowledges upon which they were based provoking the breakdown of Chile’s environmental edifice and its ensuing reform. Third, I follow the ontological struggle that the disaster unleashed around Valdivia’s identity once dominant performations tied to the city’s industrial past were confronted.
    [Show full text]