Joseph De Maistre and His European Readers Studies in the History of Political Thought
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Joseph de Maistre and his European Readers Studies in the History of Political Thought Edited by Terence Ball, Arizona State University Jörn Leonhard, Albert-Ludwigs-Universität Freiburg Wyger Velema, University of Amsterdam Advisory Board Janet Coleman, London School of Economics and Political Science, UK Vittor Ivo Comparato, University of Perugia, Italy Jacques Guilhaumou, CNRS, France John Marshall, Johns Hopkins University, Baltimore, USA Markku Peltonen, University of Helsinki, Finland VOLUME 5 Joseph de Maistre and his European Readers From Friedrich von Gentz to Isaiah Berlin Edited by Carolina Armenteros Richard A. Lebrun LEIDEN • BOSTON LEIDEN • BOSTON 2011 Cover illustration by Matthieu Manche. Th is book is printed on acid-free paper. Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Joseph de Maistre and his European readers : from Friedrich von Gentz to Isaiah Berlin / edited by Carolina Armenteros, Richard A Lebrun. p. cm. -- (Studies in the history of political thought, ISSN 1873-6548 ; v. 5) Includes bibliographical references and index. ISBN 978-90-04-19394-9 (hardback : alk. paper) 1. Maistre, Joseph Marie, comte de, 1753-1821--Political and social views. 2. Maistre, Joseph Marie, comte de, 1753-1821--Infl uence. 3. Political science--Europe--History. I. Armenteros, Carolina. II. Lebrun, Richard. JC179.M28J67 2011 320.52092--dc22 2011000830 ISSN 1873-6548 ISBN 978 90 04 19394 9 Copyright 2011 by Koninklijke Brill NV, Leiden, Th e Netherlands. Koninklijke Brill NV incorporates the imprints Brill, Global Oriental, Hotei Publishing, IDC Publishers, Martinus Nijhoff Publishers and VSP. All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, translated, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording or otherwise, without prior written permission from the publisher. Authorization to photocopy items for internal or personal use is granted by Koninklijke Brill NV provided that the appropriate fees are paid directly to Th e Copyright Clearance Center, 222 Rosewood Drive, Suite 910, Danvers, MA 01923, USA. Fees are subject to change. CONTENTS Acknowledgments .....................................................................................vii List of Contributors ....................................................................................ix Introduction .................................................................................................1 Carolina Armenteros and Richard A. Lebrun Memento .....................................................................................................17 Jean-Louis Darcel PART I: MAISTRE IN THE UNITED KINGDOM Berlin, Maistre, and Fascism ....................................................................29 Cyprian Blamires PART II: MAISTRE IN NINETEENTH-CENTURY FRANCE Le mystique de la tradition: Barbey Worships at the Altar of Joseph de Maistre ....................................................................59 Kevin Michael Erwin Auguste Comte’s Reading of Maistre’s Du pape: Two Theories of Spiritual Authority ............................................................................75 Tonatiuh Useche Sandoval PART III: MAISTRE’S GERMAN READERS The Correspondence of Friedrich von Gentz: The Reception of Du pape in the German-speaking World ......................................95 Raphaël Cahen “All Evil is the Cancellation of Unity”: Joseph de Maistre and Late German Romanticism ........................................................123 Adrian Daub Maistrian Themes in Walter Benjamin’s Sociology .............................151 Ryohei Kageura A Dialectical Reading of Joseph de Maistre by Herbert Marcuse ................................................................................................171 Michael Kohlhauer vi contents PART IV: MAISTRE’S ITALIAN POSTERITY Joseph de Maistre and Italy ....................................................................189 Marco Ravera PART V: MAISTRE’S RUSSIAN FATE Preparing the Russian Revolution: Maistre and Uvarov on the History of Knowledge .............................................................213 Carolina Armenteros Epilogue: The Reception of Maistre’s Considérations sur la France ............................................................................................ 249 José Miguel Nanni Soares Conclusion ...............................................................................................265 Carolina Armenteros Bibliography .............................................................................................277 Index .........................................................................................................293 Acknowledgments Most of the essays contained in this volume were first presented at Reappraisals/Reconsidérations, the Fifth International Colloquium on Joseph de Maistre, held at Jesus College, Cambridge on 4 and 5 December 2008. We would like to thank most warmly Pierre Glaudes and Michael Kohlhauer for the invaluable advice they offered at the beginning of our editorial venture. We are likewise extremely grateful to Sally-Ann Hopwood for her exceedingly helpful copyediting of the English version of the essays that were originally written in French. LIST OF CONTRIBUTORS Carolina Armenteros is Rosalind Franklin Fellow, Faculty of Arts, University of Groningen, and Visiting Fellow, Wolfson College, University of Cambridge. She is coeditor of Joseph de Maistre and the Legacy of Enlightenment, The New enfant du siècle: Joseph de Maistre as a Writer, and Historicising the French Revolution. She has published articles on Maistre in the Journal of the History of Ideas, the Journal of Political Science and Sociology, and History of Political Thought. Cyprian Blamires acquired two Bachelor of Arts degrees (Modern Languages and Theology) at Oxford and returned there later to study for a doctorate in History under the supervision of Sir Isaiah Berlin. His thesis was entitled “Three critiques of the French Revolution: Maistre, Bonald, and Saint-Simon” (1985). He then spent some years as Research Fellow at University College London working on the publica- tion of the papers of Jeremy Bentham. He has co-edited Political Tactics (Oxford University Press, 1999) and Rights, Representation, and Reform: Nonsense upon Stilts and Other Writings on the French Revolution (Oxford University Press, 2002). More recently he has operated as an independent editor and translator while producing several publica- tions, notably World Fascism: a Historical Encyclopedia (ABC-Clio, 2006)—the first ever survey of fascism as a global phenomenon from its origins to the present day—and The French Revolution and the Creation of Benthamism (Palgrave-Macmillan, 2008). He is currently working on a study of the ideological connections between the Holo- caust and secularist thought. Raphaël Cahen studied Law, History and Political Ideas at the University Paul Cézanne, the Ludwig-Maximilians-Universität and the Università degli Studi di Perugia. After obtaining a Master’s Degree in the History of Institutions and Political Ideas featuring a thesis on the political ideas of W.A. Rehberg and E. Brandes, he started a Ph.D. under the joint supervision of Henning Ottman (LMU) and Michel Ganzin (Université Paul Cézanne) entitled “Friedrich von Gentz, political Thinker and Actor of the European Counter-Revolution (1764–1832).” For his research, he visited archives all around Europe. He is the author of “Friedrich Gentz and the creation of Maritime Law,” x list of contributors Jahrbuch junge Rechtsgeschichte/Yearbook of Young Legal History, 5 (2011), and, with Thomas Landwehrlen, of “De Johann Gottfried Herder à Benedict Anderson: Retour sur quelques conceptions savantes de la nation,” Sens public: Revue internationale (2010–2011), http://www.sens-public.org/spip.php?article794. Raphaël is currently finishing his Ph.D. at the Max Planck Institut for European Legal History in Frankfurt am Main after having been employed as a teach- ing and research assistant at the Université de La Rochelle and having taught “The History of Private Law” in La Rochelle, “The History of Public Institutions” in Aix-en-Provence and “Political Thought during the French Revolution” in Munich. Adrian Daub is Assistant Professor of German Studies at Stanford University. He is the author of Uncivil Unions: The Metaphysics of Marriage in German Idealism and Jena Romanticism, forthcoming from the University of Chicago Press. Ryohei Kageura is a doctoral student in Philosophy at the Université de Strasbourg. He is writing his Ph.D. thesis on secularisation in the thought of Walter Benjamin and his major field of research is the theo- logical politics of modernity. His recent works are “La doxa comme base de la pensée: Une lecture de Joseph de Maistre,” in Doxa: Études sur les formes et la construction de la croyance, ed. Pascale Hummel (Paris: Philogicum, 2010), 219–30, “Walter Benjamin and Psychoanal- ysis: On Dream and Revolution in Benjamin,” The Journal of Social and Psychological Sciences, 2, 1 (2009): 8–23, and “Collective Memory of War and the Redemption fo the Individual Experience in Walter Benjamin,” Interculture: An Interdisciplinary Journal, 5, 3 (2008): 171–80. Michael Kohlhauer is Professor of French and Comparative Studies at the Université de Savoie. After having graduated from the University of Marburg in French, English and Philosophy, he qualified in 1997 for a post as Professor at the University of Kiel by concluding