Measuring the Impact of Open Access on Your Institution's Collections

Measuring the impact of Open Access on your institution’s collections

The Web of Science™, Journal Citation Reports™, and InCites Benchmarking & Analytics™

Marisa Ruccolo, MLIS

July 9, 2020 Agenda • OA fundamentals, available versions and their definitions in Web of Science

• Use Journal Citation Reports to evaluate Gold and Hybrid OA journals beyond the Impact Factor

• InCites B & A’s Local Journal Utilization Report can help you determine the most relevant journals to your institution’s research community

3 million papers 42,500 scholarly 14,785 open access 13,000 “predatory” per year1 journals1 journals2 journals3

12018 STM Report 2Listed in DOAJ June 16, 2020 3May 2020 Economist article

Find journals Ensure your library Make data-driven consistent with your collections support decisions about values to showcase rigorous research and your open access your research teaching strategy

© 2020 Clarivate Analytics 5 Web of Science Platform Multidisciplinary research experience across the sciences, social sciences, and arts and humanities 34,000+ 87 million Journals across the Patents for over 43 platform million inventions 21,000+ 8.9 million+ Total journals in the Data Sets and Data Core Collection Studies 1.8 billion+ Backfiles to 1900 Cited references With cover-to-cover indexing 166 million+ 218,000+ Records Conference proceedings 12.6 million 111,000+ Records with funding data Books

Statistics as of February 2020 © 2020 Clarivate Analytics 6 Web of Science Core Research with confidence using a publisher-neutral Collection citation index Science Citation Index Expanded 21,000+ journals Powerful citation Social Sciences Citation Index indexed cover-to-cover network with complete Arts & Humanities Citation • Multidisciplinary cited reference search, cited reference linking Index • International and navigation Emerging Sources Citation • Influential Index Conference Proceedings Unbiased journal Source data for Citation Index selection and curation Journal Impact Factor Book Citation Index

Comprehensive and transparent curation and selection criteria for high-quality research remain applicable for all OA journals

✓ Discover and access trusted, peer-reviewed Web of Science indexes ALL quality OA versions–both Green and Gold. OA with confidence– and find non- “predatory” OA journals to publish in. ✓ Extend your full text budget with seamless access to millions of OA articles. ✓ Understand the impact of your institution's investment in Open Access.

Web of Science Group provided grant funding to OurResearch (formerly Impactstory), a non-profit, to improve their OA detection and versioning technology for both Web of Science users and the Image from Else, H. (2018). How Unpaywall is transforming open science. Nature, 560(7718), 290- community as a whole. 291. doi:10.1038/d41586-018-05968-3

© 2020 Clarivate Analytics 9 Supporting your Web of Science Web of Science VIVO Services Open Science Web of Science Core Collection Web of Science Group is a initiatives with helps you find full Our Journal Selection corporate sponsor of VIVO, text from quality Policy helps your and we serve on the trusted data & Open Access leadership group. journals, and researchers find & publish scalable tools measure the impact content in reputable Open View our demo VIVO site of your institution’s Access journals. investment in Open View our Master Journal List Access. Open Access publications

Open peer review Kopernio Data Citation Index Publons Delivers Open • 90% of repositories in Publons provides you with Open data Access content to the Data Citation Index infrastructure to make your students and provide free access to open peer review possible.. Open ScienceOpen Open source code faculty when content, so that you can Read about our subscription acquire data instantly. partnership with Wiley Ethical issues content is • We are DataCite See it in action unavailable. • “Open Science” is an umbrella term members, and endorse Article used to represent all forms of openness Learn more the Force 11 joint • Open Peer Review History in the scholarly research environment. declaration on data in Publons citation.

DOAJ Gold Green Published 100% of the articles published within a journal are open Papers are final published articles available without charge access. from a repository.

Other Gold Green Accepted a.k.a. “Hybrid” Individual articles that are available at no Papers are peer-reviewed, accepted manuscripts available charge from otherwise subscription-based journals. These without charge from a repository. papers have been identified by Impactstory as having a Creative Commons (CC) license that are not in DOAJ journals.

Bronze A freely accessible final version of an article on a publisher's website. Bronze OA on Web of Science can contain free-to-read copyrighted "public access" versions and free-to-read versions where license information was unidentifiable.

✓ Integrate full text access into your researchers’ existing discovery workflows. ✓ Increase the value of library subscriptions by making them an implicit component of ALL discovery paths. ✓ Stretch the library’s budget by making it easy to identify OA full-text when an article isn’t part of your subscription.

Install in Chrome Firefox Extension Browser Plug-in Learn more

The JCR is an annual report that distills citation trend data from the Web of Science Core Collection to help you understand journal performance.

• View Journal Impact Factor and other metrics. • Data represents a snapshot in time: the 2020 edition reflects citations from literature published in 2019. • All journals in JCR are sourced from two indexes: ̶ Science Citation Index Expanded ̶ Social Sciences Citation Index

• Citations are sourced from all indexes in the Web of Science Core Collection. Learn More about the 2020 edition: Product Release Notes 2020 Journal Citation Reports 2019 Data

Quickly obtain a concise 12,171 236 83 view of each journal’s journals categories countries recent citation impact alongside 1,658 7,487 351 descriptive statistics on Gold OA Hybrid new journals contributing authors and journals journals added to the open access JCR this year

33 15 9.41% journals Editorial average increase suppressed Expression of in Journal Impact Concern on 15 Factor additional titles

Conduct research Find the best-fit Ensure that your Obtain the evaluation more journals for your library collections transparency you need responsibly with manuscript using with support rigorous to make data-driven multidimensional a tool that helps you research and teaching decisions about your journal indicators and consider audience, using publisher-neutral open access strategy context for the topical relevance, open data produced by with ease and speed numbers access and citation objective experts using an intuitive tool impact

✓ Assess journals with multiple indicators and visualizations that provide you with context for the numbers

✓ Quickly and easily distinguish the difference between article versus journal metrics

For more information, see ISI’s Profiles, not Metrics Report

© 2020 Clarivate Analytics 17 Help your institution conduct research evaluation more responsibly • Recognize the extent to which outlier papers may be driving a journal’s JIF • See the difference between paper versus journal level citations • Understand how citation rates vary for articles versus reviews

✓Identify reputable journals that can make your article available as open access at the time of publication

✓Understand how journals’ access models impact the scholarly discourse within your community

✓Make data driven decisions about your organization’s open access policies

Gold OA Citable* Papers tagged as either DOAJ Citable items Gold or Other Gold in Web of All materials indexed as articles or reviews Science are counted as Gold OA in Web of Science and counted as Citable Citable in JCR. Items in the denominator of the JIF.

Other Incidental items, such as editorial Subscription and free to read material, correspondence, news, meeting Papers identified as Bronze, abstracts, that are not counted in the JIF Green Published and Green denominator. Accepted in Web of Science are counted as part of the Unlinked Subscription and Free to Read Citations to a journal that have incomplete Citable content in JCR. data at the paper level, but are still included in the JIF calculation.

*The data are current as of the time of JCR extraction from the Web of Science. © 2020 Clarivate Analytics 20 Make confident collections management decisions Easily understand how open access articles contribute to hybrid journals

View OA status at the article level for the full list of citable items, and export the data as a CSV file to use in your analytics projects

Insert footer 22 Local Journal Utilization Report Identify the most relevant journals to your institution’s research community with ready-made analyses Tile 1: In which journals do my organization's authors outperform the average journal citation rate?

Tile 2: In which journals do my organization's authors publish most frequently?

Tile 3: Which journals are your organization's authors citing?

Tile 4: Are your authors citing recent or older material from that journal?

data from Tile 5: Which journals are citing your organization's authors? 2006-present Tile 6: Are your authors being cited by recent or older material?

© 2020 Clarivate Analytics 25 Save time analyzing your institution’s OA research footprint with customizable tiles in LJUR • View your institution’s data from 2006-present • Add OA indicators • Refine by Research Area and Publisher • One click to export 50K lines of data to Excel

For librarian-specific tasks: http://clarivate.libguides.com/incites_ba/library

Managing Journal Collections: http://clarivate.libguides.com/ld.php?content_id=26996283

Open Access Analysis: http://clarivate.libguides.com/ld.php?content_id=27010518

Easily access over 11.4 Quickly determine how Direct your users to million OA articles from much your institution is trusted, legitimate both publishers and likely paying in APCs sources of full-text repositories, in addition with comprehensive articles– regardless of to the content you data on the gold and whether or not your subscribe to. hybrid journals your library has a researchers have subscription. published in.

Integrate OA status Inform your collections metadata into your management decisions institutional repository by analyzing by all with Web of Science types of OA (gold, APIs. hybrid, green) to understand where your researchers are publishing.

Insert footer 28 Thank you

Marisa Ruccolo, MLIS [email protected]

© 2020 Clarivate. All rights reserved. Republication or redistribution of Clarivate content, including by framing or similar means, is prohibited without the prior written consent of Clarivate. Clarivate and its logo, as well as all other trademarks used herein are trademarks of their respective owners and used under license. Appendix

Insert footer 30 Customer examples Geological Survey of Canada and CanmetMATERIALS libraries (Both divisions of Natural Resources Canada)

Yongtao Lin (Calgary, AB) and Alana Pollock-Greenwood (Hamilton, ON), Library Managers

Using WoS Core Collection and InCites B&A to identify government researchers’ OA publication trends

Poster presented at the Ontario Library Association Superconference, Jan 2020

31 Customer examples University of Wisconsin Milwaukee Library Korolev, Svetlana, "Finding Open Access Publications by UWM Authors" (2018). UWM Libraries Other Staff Publications. 12. https://dc.uwm.edu/lib_staffart/12

32 Emerging Sources Citation Index

More than 43% of the content in ESCI is available as open access

1.4 M OA records (including Bronze)

Total content: + 3.4 M records in these top 10 categories Statistics as of June 24, 2020

Insert footer 33 Open Access repositories

DOI detection “View PDF” You click Kopernio delivers best Button appears “View PDF” available version Publisher websites

PDF search DOI found

Aggregators, such as JSTOR

Your personal Kopernio locker

Watch the video Kopernio authenticates at 2 points in this process: 1. PDF search 2. PDF download Publisher websites

DOI detection “View PDF” You click Kopernio delivers best Button appears “View PDF” available version

Open Access repositories

PDF search Publisher website DOI found

Your personal Kopernio locker

Your logo

Aggregators, such as JSTOR

35 Kopernio’s commitment to privacy

What Kopernio knows What Kopernio doesn’t know ✓ Who you are (your name & affiliation) X Your login credentials ✓ Where you are (your IP address) These are encrypted, and stored locally in your internet browser. ✓ What you have already stored in your X Your current library holdings/subscriptions Kopernio locker Your access is checked in real time.

Our Data Principles: https://kopernio.com/data-principles

Privacy Policy: https://kopernio.com/terms Leading innovation in OA discovery, access, and assessment Web of Science indexes ALL quality OA versions–both Green and Gold.

Because some citation databases exclude Green OA, and others lack stringent selection criteria, Web of Science remains the only publisher-neutral citation database that comprehensively covers editorially controlled and versioned OA.

Else, H. (2018). How Unpaywall is transforming open science. Nature, 560(7718), 290-291. doi:10.1038/d41586-018-05968-3