BUILDING a REVOLUTION Chinese Architecture Since 1980
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
BUILDING A REVOLUTION Chinese Architecture Since 1980 Charlie Q. L. Xue "' "' :!« '# "' W- ""- • H ONG KO G U NI VE RSI TY PRESS Hong Kong University Press 14/F Hing Wai Centre 7 Tin Wan Praya Road Aberdeen Hong Kong ©Hong Kong University Press 2006 ISBN 962 209 744 8 ~u..u.~i.:;-~i!.Ir~ ~1.Ur~ l:V-.3V All rights reserved. No portion of this publication may be reproduced or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopy, recording, or any information storage or retrieval system, without permission in writing from the publisher. Secure On-line Ordering http://www.hkupress.org British Library Cataloguing-in-Publication Data A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library. Printed and bound by United League Graphic & Printing Co. Ltd., in Hong Kong, China CONTENTS Acknowledgments vi Preface viii Map of China and Highlighced Areas xv Part I Cultural Transformation Chapter I Evaluation Criteria for Contemporary Chinese Architecture 2 Chapter 2 '·National Form·· and Chinese Identity: Burden or Chance? 12 Chapter 3 The Impact oflntemational Architecture 30 Part II City and Dwelling Chapcer 4 Survival Strategies: Beijing, Shanghai, and Guangzhou 50 Chapter 5 Urban Design as a Tool for Better Living 70 Chapter 6 Form Follows Policy: The Evolution of China's Housing 86 Part III Architects and Creations Chapter 7 Portraits of Chinese Architects 104 Chapter 8 Experimental Architecture: The Rising of the Younger Generation 130 Chapter 9 Behind the Building Revolution: Private Practice Unleashed 156 Chapter 10 Chinese Architecrure in the Twenty-first Century: An Epilogue 16-l Appendix l Chronicle of Chinese Architecture Since 1980 171 Appendix fl Architectural Education and Publication 182 Bibliography 191 Illustration Credits 197 Index 199 CHAPTER ONE EVALUATION CRITERIA FOR CONTEMPORARY CHINESE ARCIDTECTURE The c1ite1ia for evaluating architecture are multifaceteJ People's under... tanding of architedure as a symbol of and vary according to the. social and cultural context. in culture bas hecorne increa~ingly innuenced by almost all China and in other countries. aspec1s of society. including aesthetics. re ligion, l t is widely accepted that social l'Ontext has a institutions, and "ocial behavior. As a result. architeclural profoundly impo1iant influence on architecture (Musgrcwe tlesign tends to be diversified: al the same time, the criteria J987: Rapoport L969: Norberg-Schulz. 1975 ). Thi:,, chapter for judgment have become more complicated and varied. analyzes contemporary Chinese architecture from a variety Jn ancieni times, the practice, theory, and evaluation of perspectives, including ideology, culwre, and social of architecture placed greater emphasi" on aesthetic valuel'. based on tradition, economy. the market. and concerns !>UCh a1> !>Cale, proportion, balance, a nd technology. Environmental protection and sust.ainability composition (Pevsner t 976). The Modern Movement and are dis~ussed. as they are global focal points in the twenty other ·'-isms" o f' the twentieth cen1ury not only gave futther fir<;t century. Jn this regard, they give new me:rnjng to weight to architectural ontology but also endowed it with traditional aesthetic principles and play a o;pecial role in soc:ial and cultural connotation!>, adding human dimensions the evaluation of architecture. to archi tectural evaluation. By examining the prevailing architectural theorie in Modern nrchitectural movements that emphasi1..e China, thjs chapter po~e~ question1> about various aspects spatial effecrs and "lightness." in contrasr co the load of China's architecture and serves as a general survey of bearing walls and heavy forms of' traditional architecture. Chinese architecture today. have created a new set of architectural lerms and language. Thi:. reform has changed both traditional formularions of architecture and way" of looking a t architecrure. In his ARCHITECTURAL EVALUATION: A book Space. Ti111e and Ar1.:hirecl11n.> ( 1941 ). Sigfried RETROSPECTIVE Giedion argued that the concept of space "ihould be regarded as a criterion to judge architecture. Other In hi" The Ten Bnoks 1111 Ar<'hirect111'f:', Vitruvius.. an ancient architects, for example. Bruno Zevi. continued to o;upport Roman military engineer, as~erted that "firmness, and reaflim' the: dominan1 role of the sµatial model in applicability, and delight" are Uic fundamental p1inciples architectural Jt!sign and criticism I 1980). of architecture. He also defined am.l analyzed aspects of In the 1960s. Venturi !-Uggested '·complexity and an:hitectural design. <;uch as site. l)fientation. column order, contradiction in architecture·· ( 1966) as an antidote 10 the scale. and so forth ( 1999). From then on. his theorie~ "munotnnous'' singulaiity of Moderni<;tarchitecture, while became the first set of crite1ia for how to judge architecture. also <1dvocating that popular culture he cited in de'>i.gn Eva1uat1on Criteria for Contemporary Chinese Architecture I 3 critique. Challenging the modernist orthodoxy. this so colorful and appealing doctrine. Thi ~ conference had a called postmodern theory represented another significant profound influence upon Chinese architecture. milestone in architectural design and evaluation. From lhen In keeping with the bar~h economic realitit!!l ol' 1he on, Aldo Ro~si conceived "city architecture.. from typology late 1950s. the government enunci:ned the guiding (I 972): Christian Norberg-Schutz put forwnrd principles of China·s architectural design. ~tating thar ir '":i rchitectural phenomenology:· which injected the idea mui.1 be ··functional. economical. and delightful if of ge11im loci into lheOJ'ies of pace. place, and s.ite ( J 980); conditions permit," as well as erving to "create a new and Peter Eisenman devoted himself to the explication of soc iali!>t architectural style in China.'' The principle deconstruction architecture (2003). Geoffrey Broadbent e~sentially conformed to universally accepted evaluation explored the symbolic meaning of architecture from the criteria from the time ofYitruvius through 10 Gropiui; and per pective of semiotic theory. addressing minimalist reflected the economic and financial situation of China iu architecture. which insists on rarefied techniques and thal period. The principle Wa'> adhered to in the com:ision uf space am! materials (] 980). Moreover. constnictiun of the 1960s and is followed even to this day. architectural hi i< torian and theorist Manfredo Tafuri has As far as aesthetics is concerned, the school of the refened to the importance of ideology. poli1ic.:~. and the Beaux Art!. wa3 U1e leading artistic style in those dec:ide~ . economy in architectural critiques ( 1986), whereas Kostof In his artide Beyond ReMl11tin11: Nntcs on Cr111/e111porary understood and demonstrated historical architecture from Chinese Archir~l'lur<' ( 1998). Zhu Jianfei looked at the "rituals and sertings" ( 1985). 1' ubtlc influence Beaux Arts exerted on architectural Among the thoughts aboul architecture mentioned creation. "Despite Lhc political changei. and elaborate above. some are ae~ thcti c explorations of theories of space, ideological theoriLaLion, Lhe Beaux Arts model Lha1 was whereas others analyze the meaning and culcural symbolic introduced in the 1920s had survived and wa now serving influences of architecture in deplh, using the knowledge a new political project". In 1956, Mao Zedong encouraged of '>uch disciplines as philosophy, sociology. and linguistics new ideas in social cultme. arts. and science. wir.h this as reference points. These theories complement. revise. proclaimation: '"Let a hundred flowers blossom and a and extend the original concepts and play an inspiring role hundred schools of thought flourish." However. Mao· · in developing c1iteria for architecture. ideas were not carried out to any signifkant extent in ;1rchi1·ectw·al design during those years when the radical left wing prevailed. CHINA IN THE 1950s TO J970 s: During the 1950s, :ideology. national form. China's POLITICALLY ORIENTED weak economy. and the single Beaux Arb aestheti c model ARCHITEClURAL DESIGN AND formed the criteria for architectural design and evaluation. EVALUATION In the late 1950s. "ten grnnd national projects" in Beijing powerfully embodied the policy-oriented content of Under the constraints of ideology. economy. and t·he social Chinese architecrure. epitomiling the climax of the ~ tyle . !'ystem, architectural cre:nion wa reM1icted to some extent. Constrnction activities stagnated during the years 1966- Chinese archit·ects had to endure ideological and political 7.,i becau'ie of co ntinuou ~ political upheavab .~ pressures that might not have been apparent to ob~ervers in Western countries. In the early 1950!., post-wa r construction wa~ in full FROM 1980 TO THE PRESENT: ... wing in China. With enormous enthusiasm. 1he Chinese ARCHlTECTUREAND SOCIAL people started to rebt1ild their :.ocialist coumry under Mao TRANSFORMATION Zedong·s leadership. Tn 1953. a conference of arc hitect~· as<;ociation~ wa~ held in War!\aw. Poland, at a time when A favorable development occum:d 111 Lhc lale 1970s. ln the whole w0rld wal> under the doud of the Coltl War. 1980. Deng Xiaoping, China·s patriarch after Mau Zetlong, Architects from almost all socialist count1ics anended the issued a st;llement on cO~l.ltruction and housing projects, conference. The panicipants agreed 10 "'oppo e pointing 0u1 thm building construction should be one uf structuralism" simply because slrucruralism wa: the