DEPARTMENT OF PLANNING KA'AINAHULL.DIRECTOR JODI A. HIGUCHI SAYEGUSA, DEPUTY DIRECTOR DEREK S.K. KAWAKAMI, MAYOR MICHAELA. DAHILIG, MANAGING DIRECTOR
MEMORANDUM
DATE: February 10, 2021 TO: Public Access, Open Space and Natural Resources Preservation Fund Commission FROM: Clerk ofthe Commission SUBJECT: 2ndAddition to the Open Space Commission 2/11/2021 Agenda
J. NEW BUSINESS (For Action)
2. Review and discuss the potential acquisition of 55.408 and 46.641 parcels located in Lihue District further identified as Tax Map Keys (4) 3-2-001:001 and (4) 3-1-001:012. g. Email list of testimony in support from Reyna Ramolete Hayashi: (see attached)
h. Additional Public Testimony in Favor received from:
(see attached)
4444 Rice Street, Suite A473 • Lihu'e, Hawai'i 96766 • (808) 241 -4050 (b) An Equal Opportunity Employer The Edith Kanaka'ole Maunalua Fishpond Heritage Foundation Center
God's Country Waimanalo Na Maka Onaona
Hawai'iAlliancefor Na Pua No'eauofKaua'i Progressive Action (HAPA) CommunityCollege
Historic Hawai'i Foundation National ParkService (HHF) Pacific Birds HabitatJoint Hawaiian Islands Land Trust Venture (HILT) PacificAmerican Foundation Hui Kaloko-Honokohau (PAF)
Kaiola Canoe Club Supportingthe Language of Kaua'i, Inc. (SLK, Inc.) Hui Malama O Kaneiolouma The Nature Conservancy Kaua'i Forest Bird Recovery Project(KFBRP) Andrea Slevin
Kauai Path,Inc. Clayton Egan Kawaikini New Century Public Charter School Gary Hofacker
Kilauea Neighborhood Hannah Kihalani Springer Association llima Hose Wai'Opae O Kohanaiki Puali'ili'imaikalani Rossi- Kamehameha Schools (we Fukino could not merge this letter Puna Aletha Kaohi into the PDF so it is attached separately) Stevan Yee 'Auamo Kua'aina Ulu (KUA) Sylvia Partridge Kumuola Science Education Kalikolehua Goo-Labuguen Center Keala Lindsey-Meyer Leadership Kaua'i
L'ihu'e Business Association
Malama Kaua'i(MK)
Malama Maha'ulepu
Malama Pu'uloa
•^* ^\. Duke Nakamatsu
From: Nani Sadora Sent: Tuesday, February 9, 2021 9:50 PM To: Duke Nakamatsu; Kaaina Hull Subject: Fw: Letters in Support of J(2) Malama Hule'ia & The Trust for Public Land's efforts to Purchase and Protect Alakoko Fishpond Attachments: Alakoko LOS_ 28 Organizations.pdf; Alakoko LOS_11 Individuals.pdf; Alakoko LOS_KS.pdf
More testimony.
Mahalo-
"Aloha begins with me" Nani Sadora Planner Countyof Kauai 4444 Rice Street, Suite A473 Lihue,Hl96766 Office #: (808) 241-4498
From: Reyna Ramolete
CAUTION: This email originated from outside the County ofKauai. Do not click links or open attachments even ifthe sender is known to you unless it is something you were expecting.
Aloha Open Space Commissioners,
Pleasesee attached a totalof40 LettersofSupportforMalama Hule'ia and theTrustforPublic Land'seffortsto Purchase and Protect Alakoko Fishpond.
As listed below, 29 are from organizational partners and 11 are from individual partners and supporters.
Organizations 1. The Edith Kanaka'ole Foundation
2. God's CountryWaimanalo
3. Hawai'i Alliance for Progressive Action (HAPA)
4. Historic Hawai'i Foundation (HHF) 5. Hawaiian Islands Land Trust (HILT)
6. Hui Kaloko-Honokohau
7. Kaiola Canoe Club
8. Hui Malama O Kaneiolouma
9. Kaua'i Forest Bird Recovery Project (KFBRP)
10. Kauai Path,Inc.
11. Kawaikini New Century Public Charter School
12. Kilauea Neighborhood Association
13. Wai'OpaeO Kohanaiki
14. Kamehameha Schools (we could not merge this letter into the PDF so it is attached separately) 'Auamo 15. Kua'aina Ulu (KUA)
16. Kumuola Science Education Center
17. Leadership Kaua'i
18. LThu'e BusinessAssociation
19. MalamaKaua'i(MK)
20. Malama Maha'ulepu
21. Malama Pu'uloa
22. Maunalua Fishpond Heritage Center
23. Na MakaOnaona
24. Na Pua No'eau of Kaua'i Community College
25. National ParkService
26. Pacific Birds Habitat Joint Venture
27. PacificAmerican Foundation (PAF)
28. Supporting the Language of Kaua'i, Inc. (SLK, Inc.)
29. The Nature Conservancy
Individuals 1. Andrea Slevin
2. Clayton Egan
3. Gary Hofacker
4. Hannah Kihalani Springer
5. llima Hose
6. Puali'ili'imaikalani Rossi-Fukino 7. Puna Aletha Kaohi
8. Stevan Yee
9. Sylvia Partridge
10. Kalikolehua Goo-Labuguen
11. Keala Lindsey-Meyer
Mahalo piha for your consideration, Reyna
Reyna Ramolete Hayashi Aloha 'Aina Project Manager
The Trust for Public Land 1003 Blshop Street, Suite 740 Honolulu, Hl 96813 P: 808.524.8562 I C: 808,983.9985
Creating parks and protecting land for people. ^Lorg ) Facebogk | Twitter | YouTybe | Lin|;edtn t d.l
Kala Mossman Febmaiy 9, 2021 The Edith Kanalca'ole Foundation 1500 Kalaniana'ole St. ffilo, Hawai'i 96720
Sara Bowen Malama Hule'ia P.0. Box 662092 Lihu'e, Hawai'i 96766
Re: Support for Malama Hule'ia and the Trust for Public Land's efforts to Purchase and Protect Alakoko Fishpond in Niumalu and Ha'iku, Kaua'i
Aloha,
The Edith Kanaka'ole Foundation strongly supports The Tmst for Public Land and Malama Hule'ia's efforts to protect and purchase the Alakoko Fishpond Property in Niuiiialu and Ha iku, Kaua'i, also known as Menehune Fishpond. Protecting Alakoko would provide impactful community benefits: restoring a healthy watershed, river, and native wetland ecosystem; preserving a beloved cultural and historic site and an outdoor classroom for students to learn the science and technology of Hawaiian aquaculture; and increasing sustainable food production and food security for Kaua'i.
The Edith Kanaka'ole Foundation is a well respected Hawaiian cultural organization based in Hilo. EKF's mission is to elevate Hawaiian intellegence through cultural education founded on the teachings and traditional practices ofEdith and Luka Kanaka'ole. We have been supporting the perpetuation ofHawaiian cultural practices throughout the State since 1990. EKF also manages Haleolono fishpond in Hilo conducting educational programs and community workdays and is an active member ofHui Malama Loko i a. The protection ofAlakoko Fishpond aligns with our mission and we feel will benefit the people ofHawai'i. Having Alakoko Fishpond 'aina-based protected restored, and stewarded by the community for education, Hawaiian cultural practice, sustainable aquaculture, food production, and as a native wetland habitat for fish and endangered water birds is the kind ofproject we as a people need to get behind.
Mahalo,
Kala Mossman Executive Officer Edith Kanaka'ole Foundation 1500 Kalaniana'ole St. Hilo, Hi 96720 POB.ix723 Wiiirnauali). 1-11 9679.') Ho'oulu a me ho'ola lahui. Propagate and the race ^()cisf()untr\'\\';ii)'nnnalo(i^^mnil,com perpetuafce WAIMANALO Sara Bowen Reyna Ramolete Hayashi Malama Hule'ia The Trust for Public Land P.0. Box 662092 1003 Bishop Street, Suite 740 Lihu'e, Hawai'i 96766 Honolulu, Hawai'i 96813
Febmary 7, 2021
Re: STRONG SUPPORT for Malama Hule'ia and The Trust for Public Land to Purchase and Protect Alakoko Fishpond inNiumalu and Ha'iku, Kaua'i
Aloha kakou,
The God's Country Waimanalo (GCW) Board STRONGLY SUPPORTS Malama Hule'ia and The Trust for Public Land to Purchase and Protect Alakoko Fishpond in Niumalu and Ha'iku, Kaua'i. Protecting Alakoko offers innumerable beneficial community impacts, including restoration of a healthy watershed, river, and native wetland ecosystem; preservation of a beloved cultural and historic site, and outdoor classroom for keiki to learn place-based STEM in a centuries old loko; and an increase of sustainable food production and food sovereignty for Kaua'i.
GCWs mission is ho oulu a me ho ola laliui, that is to propagate and perpetuate the race. We believe wholeheartedly in the proliferation ofall things Hawai i, especially those things that can propagate and perpetuate mea Hawai i. Alakoko Loko I a is one ofthose things. How better than a loko i a to propagate and perpetuate? There is no better way. It is a sustainable food source. It is a classroom. It is Hawai i. Alas, it is necessary to protect this sacred place by allowing both Malama Hule ia and The Trust for Public Land to purchase Alakoko Loko I a.
What is the alternative? Allowing a private buyer to purchase the property?! This action will only make an historic place inaccessible to the people. The action could also result in a natural and cultural resource to be built upon. There are too many occasions where this has happened and the deleterious generational impacts, including discormection from place, reduction in food sourcing, and water diversion, among others, are immeasurable.
An organization in Waimanalo on O ahu, GCW has limited access to Alakoko Loko I'a on Kaua i. Notwithstanding our limited access to Alakoko, Waimanalo has its own loko: Pahonu. GCW's Board members are also members ofPahonu's restoration team. As a result, while we have little access to Alalcoko, we have first hand knowledge and understanding ofthe benefits that come with the restoration of an accessible loko i a. We have hosted numerous schools, groups, and gatherings to teach about the place, the thought that went into the creation of a loko, and the restoration process. Allowing Malama Hule ia and The Trust for Public Land to purchase the space will do infinite good for the space, the wildlife that reside at Alakoko Loko I a, the Kaua i community, and Hawai i as a whole.
Board ofDirectors H. Illma Ho-La.stimo-^a, Bob Lasrimosa, Kcuneth Ho,Jr. Re: STRONG SUPPORT for Malama Hule'ia and The Trust for Public Land to Purchase and Protect Alakoko Fishpond in Niumalu and Ha'iku, Kaua'i Page2
The Board ofGCW wishes that Alalcoko Loko I a will be put in the hands ofthe people who will best be able to malama it: Malama Hule ia and The Trust for Public Land. Seeing this wish to fruition will be the best possible outcome for a place as fragile as it is. To reiterate, GCW offers STRONG SUPPORT for Malama Hule'ia and the Trust for Public Land to Purchase and Protect Alakoko Fishpond in Niumalu and Ha'iku, Kaua'i.
Please feel free to reach us at any of the contact information available in the letterhead above with any questions or comments. We look forward to hearing from you. Moreover, we look forward to the time when Malama Hule ia and The Trust for Public Land become the organizations with kuleana to malama Alakoko LokoI a.
Mahalo,
Kenneth K. L. W, Jr., EdD Secretary God's Country Waimanalo
Board ofDif^ctors H. liima Ho-La.sdn-io.sa, Bob LaKtimosa, Kennetii H.o,Jr. 'AWAI'I ALLIANCE m. PROGRE5SIVE ACT'ON
Febmary 9th, 2021
Reyna Ramolete Hayashi The Trust for Public Land 1003 Bishop Street, Suite 740 Honolulu,Hawai'i96813
Sara Bowen Malama Hule'ia P.0. Box 662092 Lihu'e, Hawai'i 96766
Re: Support for Malama Hule'ia and the Trust for Public Land's efforts to Purchase and Protect Alakoko Fishpond in Niumalu and Ha'iku, Kaua'i
Aloha,
Hawai'i Alliance for Progressive Action (HAPA) strongly supports The Trust for Public Land and Malama Hule'ia's efforts to protect and purchase the Alakoko Fishpond Property in Niumalu and Ha'iku, Kaua'i, also known as Menehune Fishpond.
HAPA's mission includes catalyzing community empowennent and systemic change towards 'aina. valuing people and As a part ofthis mission we are committed to the expansion oflocal food production and the restoration oftraditional food ways, mcluding the restoration of fishponds such as Alakoko.
Establishing fair and sustainable food systems that honor and revitalize native Hawaiian culture practices is HAPA's founding pillar. We also work directly on issues around coiimiunity based stewardship. We have seen the success ofmany projects across Hawaii when community members with a deep comiection to place are able to increase capacity for caring for local resources. The acquisition ofAlakoko and the work ofMalaiiia Hule'ia to restore this traditional "wins" fishpond will provide multiple for the coimnunity - growing our local food security; revitalizing native Hawaiian cultural practices and supporting community stewardship over this important site.
HAPA was founded on Kaua'i and grew out ofthe effort ofKaua'i residentswho prioritize food production, sustainability and community based resource management. Our board consists of
Hawai'i Alliance for Progressive Action, P.0. Box 1534, Kapa'a, Hawai'i 96746 Phone: (808) 212-9616 www.HAPAhi.org HAWAI'I ALLIANCEy;,r PROGRESSIVE ACTION
Kaua'i residents Pua Puali'ili'imaikalani Rossi-Fukino, Dr, Andrea Brower, Michael Miranda and former Council Member and Hawai'i State Senator, Gary Hooser.
For years now Malama Hule'ia has been restoring this site and advocating, educating, and leading coi-nmunity efforts to remove the red mangrove along the Hule'ia river, re-establish the loko i a and native wetland ecosystems through an enviromnental stewardship program honoring Hawaiian values. For the first time in over half a century, the loko i'a is clear ofadult mangrove. This has been made possible thanks to an enormous effort by hundreds of coiTununity volunteers and contractors working with Malama Hule'ia to restore this important site.
In addition to growing oiir sustainable food systems on Kaua'i, protecting Alakoko provides various additional community benefits: supporting a healthy watershed, river and native wetland ecosystem and preserving a beloved cultural and historic site as well as an outdoor classroom.
As a site of great cultural and historical significance, Alakoko provides a priceless asset to our cominunity. Estimated to be 600 or more years old, Alakolco is considered the fmest example of an inland loko kuapa (brackish water walled fishpond) in all ofHawai'i. This is one ofour island's most significant cultural sites and resources and its preservation is crucial.
The loss ofthe community access to this important site should it be sold to another private buyer for some other use or development would be egregious. HAPA believes the county should do everything they can to quickly secure the site for the betterment of our community and future generations.
HAPA supports the vision and hard work ofMalama Hule'ia. Please support The Trust for Public Land and Malaina Hule'ia's efforts to protect and purchase the Alakoko Fishpond Property.
Mahalo,
Anne Frederick Executive Director, Hawai'i Alliance for Progressive Action [email protected]
Hawai'i Alliance for Progressive Action, P.0. Box 1534, Kapa'a, Hawai'i 96746 Phone: (808) 212-9616 www.HAPAhi.org February 5, 2021 Sara Bowen Reyna Ramolete Hayashi Execudve Ditector The Trust for Public Land Malama Hule(ia 1003 Bishop Stteet, Suite 740 P.0. Box 662092 Honolulu.HI 96813 Lihu'e,HI 96766
RE; Suppott foi Purchase, Preservation and Protection of the Alekoko Fishpond 2310 Hulemalu Road, Lihu'e, Kaua'i, Hawai'i TMK (4) 3-2-001:001 & (4) 3-1-001:012 Niutnalu and Ha'iku , Kaua'i
Aloha,
On behalf of Historic Hawai'i Foundation (HHF), I am pleased to offer this lettet of suppott fot The Trust for Public Land and Malama Hule'ia effotts to acquire the historic Alekoko Fishpond, also known as Menehune Fishpond, for the purpose ofperpetual preservation, protection and stewardship as part ofthe irreplaceable historic and cultural heritage of the Hawaiian Islands.
Historic Hawai'i Foundation is a non-profit organization established in 1974 to encourage the preservation ofsites, buildings, stcuctutes, objects and districts that are significant to the history of Hawai(i. As the statewide leadet fot historic preservation, HHF works to pteserve Ha^vaii's unique architectural and cultural heritage and believes that historic pieservation is an iniportant element in the present and future quality oflife, envtcontnental sustainability and economic vitaUty o£the state.
The fishpond was designated on the National Register ofHistoric Places in. 1973. The statement of significance found that the site "is the most significant fishpotid on Kaua4, both in Hawaiian legends and folklote and in the eyes of KauaTs people today.. . Its anttquity makes it the oldest flshpond on Kaua'i. . .it is the best exanaple of an inland fishpond in the entite state." The nomination reconimended that the site be pteserved as a historical patk.
In 2009, the fishpond was Usted as one ofHawai's Most Endangeied Historic Places by HHF, in coopeiarion with the Hawai'i State Historic Preservadon Division of the Department of Land and Natural Resources and Honolulu M.aga^jne. The designation flagged the site as vulnerable to neglect, invasive species and potendal developtnent.
HHF is pleased that Makraa Hule'ia established a stewardship program to addi'ess long-tetm maintenance and restoration needs. We continue to support youi: efforts to pteserve and protect this special place, including cucrent efforts to purchase the land and protect it froiTL future developtnent.
Malatna pono,
Kiersten Faulknei Executive Dkector 680 Iwill.-l Ro,ui Suitc 690 • llulioliilu, 111 96817 • - (808) 523 2900 pi'csi-TVii [email protected] vv^'w.histoiichawaiLOfg HAWAIIAN ISLANDS Reyna Ramolete Hayashi Sara Bowen The Trust for Public Land MalamaHule'ia 1003 Bishop Street, Suite 740 P.0. Box 662092 Honolulu.Hawai'i 96813 Lihu'e, Hawai'i 96766
Boatd ofDirectots February 5, 2021 2021 Re: Support for Malama Hule'ia and The Trust for Public Land's efforts Board Chalr to Purchase and Protect Alakoko Fishpond in Niumalu and Ha'iku, M.s.ry Charles Kaua'i Vice Chair Lisa Grove Aloha, Hawaiian Islands Land Trust (HILT) is the islands-wide Hawai'i 501c3 Treasurer nonprofit land trust. HILT strongly supports Malama Hule'ia and The Trust Keith Ogata for Public Land's efforts to protect and purchase the Alakoko Fishpond property in Niumalu and Ha'iku, Kaua'i, also known as Menehune Fishpond. Secretary Protecting Alakoko would provide impactful community benefits: restoring a Jennifer Luck healthy watershed, river, and native wetland ecosystem; preserving a beloved cultural and historic site and an outdoor classroom for students to learn the Past Chair science and technology ofHawaiian aquaculture; and increasing sustainable Jonathan Scheuer food production and food security for Kaua'i. Neil Hannahs HILT protects and stewards the lands that sustain Hawai'i, and perpetuates Hawaiian values by connecting with 'aina. HILT has over Matt Beall people protected 21,500 acres throughout Hawai'i, owns and stewards 7 preserves, including Kahili Beach Preserve and Wainiha Beach Preserve on Kaua'i's North Shore, Le(ahi Hall and holds 45 conservation easements restricting private lands. Our land Larry Stevens protection priorities are Hawaiian cultural landscapes, coastlines, and lands that produce healthy food for Hawai'i's people. Jody Kaulukukui The protection effort for Alakoko is in full alignment with our mission and Marissa Harman priorities, and we wholeheartedly support these other nonprofits in this effort. Malama Hule'ia's staffare dedicated to the restoration ofthis irreplaceable 'aina Randy Vitousek fishpond, and have demonstrated great capacity in fishpond and stewardship, community engagement, and education for the current and future Jocelyn Hetbert generations ofKaua'i. Malama Hule'ia's Sara Bowen and Peleke Flores also lend their help with other community efforts. Sara serves on HILT's Kaua'i Teresa. Young Island Council and volunteers at HILT's Kahili Beach Preserve. Peleke is advising HILT's Waihe'e Refuge Steward on Maui about fishpond President & CEO restoration. Mahalo to those involved and to those evaluating the for Laura H. E. Kaakua project funding. We look forward to this integral traditional food source and wetland habitat being protected and stewarded in partnership with the Kaua'i community.
Mahalo,
ph: 808.791.0729 126Queen St, Ste. 306 Laura H. E. Kaal Reyna Ramolete Hayashi The Trust for Public Land 1003 Bishop Street, Suite 740 Honolulu,Hawai'i 96813 Sara Bowen MalamaHule ia P.0. Box 662092 Lihu'e, Hawai'i 96766 Re: Support for Malama Hule'ia and the Trust for Public Land's efforts to Purchase and Protect Alakoko Fishpond inNiumalu and Ha iku, Kaua i Aloha. Hui Kaloko-Honokohau strongly supports The Trust for Public Land and Malama Hule ia s efforts to protect and purchase the Alakoko Fishpond Property in Niumalu and Ha'iku, Kaua i, also known as Menehune Fishpond. Protecting Alakoko would provide impactful community benefits: restoring a healthy watershed, river, and native wetland ecosystem; preserving a beloved cultural and historic site and an outdoor classroom for students to learn the science and teclmology of Hawaiian aquaculture; and increasing sustainable food production and food security for Kaua'i. Oiir grassroots organization works in cooperation with the National Park Service to rehabilitate Kaloko Fishpond in Kailua-Kona on Hawai'i Island. We are invested in intergenerational 'aina cultural learning that enhances connections between and kanaka while growing cultural knowledge, rejuvenating environmental health, and supporting health and wellness of our community. Our organization will benefit from the protection, restoration, and stewardship of Alalcoko Fishpond by Malama Hule'ia. We too are cultural practitioners and aina-based educators who network with place based educators to host community events, university field schools, for profit educational opportunities, and non-profit support creating leaming opportunities for island youth. These relationships give back to community, local businesses, state sustainability initiatives, and global exchanges. Beyond this relationship, Alakoko Fishpond will make contributions to the perpetuation ofHawaiian cultural practices while supporting Hawai i's movement towards greater food independence, global trendsetter in sustainable aquaculture, and protection ofnative wetland habitat for endangered species. Spaces like Alakoko Fishpond are nonrenewable resources whose value cannot be measured monetarily. Transformation ofthese spaces for development is irreversible. Ancestral footprints are minimally recovered while enviroiimental damages are irremediable. Historically, fishponds were once a major contributor to the island diets, while too, supporting the health ofnear- and deep-shore fisheries. The contributions of fishponds to our island and global ocean systems are still being investigated and understood. Protection of this fishpond and perpetuation of care by Malama Hule'ia ensures destruction and potential threats remain at bay while aina- and community interests are upheld and maintained. Beyond the reasons mentioned above one cannot disregard the heart ofthe matter. The passing of management hands leads to the passing ofmanagement interests. The stakes ofthese transitions puts the hearts, hands, and spirits ofthose who care for these places - and the places who care for them in return - at grave risk. These systems of aloha, the interrelationship between people and place, must too be considered. Discussions - both locally and globally - are interested in creating an intentional future fostering waiwai (abundance). Fishponds like Alakoko Fishpond and those ofMalama Hule'ia are the wai to waiwai. Our wish for the property is that it be held in tmst by Malama Hule'ia for present and future generations. Mahalo. Loke Aloua Po'o, Hui Kaloko-Honokohau PO Box 583 Kailua-Kona, HI 96740 5 February 2021 Reyna Ramolete Hayashi The Trust for Public Land 1003 Bishop Street, Suite 740 Honolulu.Hawai'i 96813 Sara Bowen Executive Director MalaiTiaHule'ia P.0. Box 662092 Lihu'e, Hawai'i 96766 Re: Malama Hule'ia and the Tmst for Public Land's efforts to Purchase and Protect Alakoko Fishpond in Niumalu and Ha'iku, Kaua'i Aloha kakou, The Kaiola Canoe Club supports The Trust for Public Land and Malama Hule'ia's efforts to protect and purchase the Alakoko Fishpond Property in Niumalu and Ha'iku, Kaua'i TMKs (4)3- 2-001:001 & (4)3-1-001:012, also known as Menehune Fishpond. Kaiola Canoe Club has been paddling on the Niumalu river since the club's inception over 60 years ago. As a community partner that serves the entire island ofKaua'i, Kaiola has served hundreds of club members as a home base for traditional Hawaiian canoe, taught hundreds of keiki in its after-school programs to teach an essential Hawaiian tradition, and hosted thousands ofpeople from all over the world as they come to enjoy canoe through a race or social paddle. Alakoko Fishpond is a precious part of our environment and history. We lost much in exchange for the building ofNawiliwili harbor in 1930. This exchange seems at least somewhatjustifiable - the harbor provides essential service to the entire island, and has provided substantial economic benefit to the entire conununity ofKaua'i. By conto-ast, a private residential or poorly integrated conunercial enterprise at the fishpond would provide negligible economic impact while destroying some ofthe last remaining enviromnental and historic treasures left in the region. What's more, the Niumalu river is currently one ofthe most polluted on the island. Our paddlers and children are regularly managing bacterial infections - some extremely serious - because of the excessive levels of enterococci levels that regularly fail EPA standards for recreational water activities. We need organizations like Malama Hule'ia and the Trust for Public Land to continue stewardship ofthis property that it may be restored for its historic and cultural value, its environmental impact, and the symbol it represents for all the people ofKaua'i - a native Kaiola Canoe Club Niumalu Road, Lihue, Hl 96766 Hawaiian place that was built pre-contact, then abandoned during the plantation era, then restored again thi'ough a concerted and coordinated community effort. We would hate for the final stage ofthis symbol to be that all this community effort amounted only to free labor and resources for a private interest. 'O au iho no me ka 'oia'i o, Pomai Kane - President William Steel - Vice President Mitzi Yamamoto - Secretary Lori Parraga - Treasurer Tom Strom - Men's Representative Marcel Bourbeau - Men's Representative Doneen Stokes - Women's Representative Julie Hayward - Women's Representative Kaiola Canoe Club Board of Directors 4201-DRiceStreet Lihue HI 96766 Mitzi Yamamoto -Contact Person Kaiola CanoeClub Niumalu Road, Lihue, Hl 96766 February8,2021 Ancient Hawaiian Village Restoration Project Reyna Ramolete Hayashi Post Office Box 244 The Trust for Public Land Koloa, Hl 96756 1003 Bishop Street, Suite 740 Honolulu,Hawai'i96813 Sara Bowen Malama Hule ia P.0. Box 662092 Lihue, Hawai i 96766 Re: Support for Malama Hule ia and the Trust for Public Lands effbrts to Purchase and fl 9 Protect Alakoko Fishpond in Niumalu and Ha'ikii, Kaua'i i-i :'^ Aloha, tff^ Hui Malama O Kaneiolouma strongly supports The Trust for Public Land and Malama Hule ias eftbrts to protect and purchase the Alakoko Fishpond Property in Niumalu and Ha iku, Kaua i, also known as Menehune Fishpond. Protecting Alakoko would provide priceless community benefits: restoring a healthy •Q watershed, river, and native wetland ecosystem, preserving a beloved cultural and historic site and an outdoor classroom for students to learn the science of Hawaiian aquaculture; and increasing sustainable food production and food security for Kauai. Hui Malama O Kaneiolouma exists to perpetuate the Hawaiian culture by rehabilitating the ancient Hawaiian village located in the heart ofPo'ipu, Koloa, Kauai. Like Malama Hule ia, our mission is to protect the past —for the future —in the present. The native tenant right should be protected on all culture sites, including the Alakoko Fishpond and the Kaneiolouma Heiau. Tlie real owner of all these sites are the Kanaka Maoli, who built these fishponds over 600 years ago. What right does a private buyer have to control these culture sites? Nothing. Mahalo nui loa, ;tA.,;CiAA-/<- / Rupert H. Rowe Pob, Executive Director Hui Malama O Kaneiolouma [email protected] ph: 808-639-1239 Phone 808-639-1239 [email protected] www.Kaneiolouma.org KAUA'lFORESTBlRD S,RECOVERY PROJECT February9,2021 Reyna Ramolete Hayashi The Trust for Public Land 1003 Bishop Street, Suite 740 Honolulu, Hawai'i 96813 Sara Bowen MalamaHule'ia P.0. Box 662092 Lihu'e, Hawai'i 96766 Re: Support for Malama Hule'ia and the Trust for Public Land s efforts to Purchase and Protect Alakoko Fishpond inNiumalu and Ha'iku, Kaua'i Aloha, The Kaua'i Forest Bird Recovery Project (KFBRP) strongly supports The Trust for Public Land and Malama Hule'ia's efforts to protect and purchase the Alalcoko Fishpond Propeity in Niumalu and Ha'iku, Kaua'i, also known as Menehune Fishpond. Protecting Alakoko would provide impactful community benefits: restoring a healthy watershed, river, and native wetland ecosystem; preserving a beloved cultural and historic site and an outdoor classroom for students to leam the science and technology ofHawaiian aquaculture; and increasing sustainable food production and food security for Kaua'i. KFBRP's mission is to promote knowledge, appreciation, and conservation ofKaua'i's native birds. We research and conserve native bird populations for tlie benefit ofcurrent and future generations and the ecosystems that depend on the benefits birds provide. In doing so, we provide training for dozens of young people each year. The Alalcoko Fishpond restoration has been an integral part ofthis process, helping us educate and provide skills to young people seeking careers in conservation. It has also been an excellent location for team building exereises, since the work involved in the restoration literally takes a village. Should the property be sold to private interests, this valuable community resource will be lost forever. I supportthe efforts ofMalamaHule'ia and the Trust for Public Land to acqulre this property forthe common good and future generations and urge you to grant their funding requests. Mahalo, ^. C^-'~/C ^~ Lisa "Cali" Crampton, Ph.D. Kauai Forest Bird Recovery Project • PO Box 27 • Manapepe, Hl 96716 [email protected] • KauaiForestBirds.oFg • 808-335-5078 TommyA.Noyes :: Executive Dlrector Kauai Palh, Inc. :: P.O.BoxSI :: Lihue, Hl 96766 phone 808.639.1018 www.KauaiPa1h.org news@kauaipath,org a registered 501 (C) 3 non-profit, EIN 27-3343903 February 5, 2021 Reyna Ramolete Hayashi The Trust for Public Land 1003 Bishop Street, Suite 740 Honolulu, Hawai'i 96813 Sara Bowen Executive Director Malama Hule'ia P.0. Box 662092 Lihu'e, Hawai'i 96766 Subject: Malama Hule'ia and the Trust for Public Land's efforts to Purchase and Protect Alakoko Fishpond in Niumalu and Ha'ikO, Kaua'i Aloha Ms. Hayashi and Ms. Bowen, Kauai Path, Inc. supports The Trust for Public Land and Malama Hule'ia's efforts to protect and purchase the Alakoko Fishpond Property in Niumalu and Ha'ikO, Kaua'iTMKs (4)3-2-001:001 & (4)3-1-001:012, also known as Menehune Fishpond. As an educational non-profit, Kauai Path advances the vision of Kauai residents working togetherto preserve, protect, and extend access island-wide through the design, implementation, and stewardship of non-motorized multi-use paths. Presently, Kauai's premier multi-use project is Ke Ala Hele Makalae, a 20 mile long coastal path that will eventually connect Anahola to Niumalu. The Malama Hule'ia project is quite close to the Southern terminus of Ke Ala hlele Makalae and restoration work in that area will enhance path users' experiences. Should the land in question be transitioned to a private buyer for high-end residential or commercial use, the gains made over the last decade in restoring this culturally significant site would be lost in perpetuity. One of the benefits of Ke Ala hlele Makalae active transportation system is that people using the paths have time to appreciate and learn about the cultural landscape as they walk or bicycle through it. Protecting the restored Alakoko Kauai residents working together to preserve, protect, and extend access island-wide through the design, implementation, and stewardship of non-motorized multi-use paths. Kauai Path Page 2 of 2 Fishpond will perpetuate an essential link in the chain of educational sites celebrated along Kauai's eastern coast. Kauai Path endorses the sustained environmental restoration and protection of this treasured cultural asset through the management of the Malama Hule'ia program. Mahalo, s/Tommy Noyes Executive Director, Kauai Path, Inc. School Febmary9,2021 Reyna Ramolete Hayashi The Trust for Public Land 1003 Bishop Street, Suite 740 Honolulu,Hawai'i96813 SaraBowen Malama Hule'ia P.0. Box 662092 Lihu'e, Hawai'i 96766 Re: Support for Malama Hule'ia and the Trust for Public Land's efforts to Purchase and Protect Alakoko Fishpond in Niumalu and Ha'iku, Kaua'i Aloha, Kawaikini New Century Public Charter School ("Kawaikini") strongly supports The Trust for Public Land and Malama Hule'ia's efforts to protect and purchase the Alakoko Fishpond Property in Niumalu and Ha'iku, Kaua'i, also laiown as Menehune Fishpond. Protecting Alakoko would provide impactful community benefits: restoring a healthy watershed, river, and native wetland ecosystem; preserving a beloved cultural and historic site and an outdoor classroom for students to leam the science and technology of Hawaiian aquaculture; and increasing sustainable food production and food security for Kaua'i. Kawaikini is a kindergarten through grade twelve charter school in Lihu e, Kaua i. Our program provides educational learning through aina based curriculum grounded in Hawaiian language. Our partnership with Alakoko Fishpond is perfectly aligned with our mission to provide a learning enviromnent where indigenous cultural knowledge is valued, applied and perpetuated. Numerous grade level students have gained ike from the soil, air and water derived from projects at Alakoko Fishpond and Malaina Hule'ia staff. Kawaikini's mission incorporates partnerships with various community partners, including Malama Hule'ia, to instill in our Kaua i keiki the importance to care for, and protect, the lands we live on. If this property were to be sold to a private buyer for residential or coiTunercial use, this would be devastating for this generation and community. The restoration ofthe fishpond will not only sustain their generation but generations to come. 3-1821 J Kaumuali'i Hwy, LJhu'e, Hl 96766 kelepona: 808.632.2032 / kelepa'i: 808.246.4835 Century Public Chartei Schoot Kawaikini envisions our staff and students to be an equal partner in the long term goals for restoration of Alakoko Fishpond. Alakoko Fishpond promotes sustainability, fosters nutrition for multiple communities and enables our community members to learn and follow the sldlls of our ancestors who created and built fishponds. In a time of turmoil and uncertainty, Alakoko Fishpond restoration work through Malama Hule'ia provides our coinmunity a connection to our history, as well a way to sustain our own food production. Kawaikini strongly supports Malama Hule'ia and the Trust for Public Land's efforts to purchase and protect Alakoko Fishpond in Niumalu and Ha'iku, Kaua'i. Mahalo. 'TOAA)- ai Tanaka Po o Kula/Executive Director 3-1821 JKaumuali'iHwy, Lihu'a, Hl 96766 kalapona: 808.632.2032 / kelepa'i: 808.246.4835 itoL r<30Q C/l ce Presidei !t 'isasi fi. U ttf^ t lf\if, Febmary 8,2021 Reyna Ramolete Hayashi The Trust for Public Land 1003 Bishop Street, Suite 740 Honolulu,Hawai'i96813 Sara. Bowen Malama Hule'ia P.0. Box 662092 Lihu'e, Hawai'i 96766 Re: Support for Malama Hule'ia and the Trust for Public Land's efforts to Purchase and Protect Alakoko Fishpond in Niumalu and Ha iku, Kaua'i Aloha, Wai Opae O Kohanaiki strongly supports The Trust for Public Land and Malama Hule'ia's efforts to protect and purchase the Alakoko Fishpond Property in Niumalu and Ha'iku, Kaua'i, also taiown as Menehune Fishpond. Protecting Alakoko would provide impactful community benefits: restoring a healthy watershed, river, and native wetland ecosystem; preserving a beloved cultural and historic site and an outdoor classroom for students to leam the science and technology of Hawaiian aquaculture; and increasing sustainable food production and food security for Kaua'i. Mahalo, Reggie Lee Wai'Opae O Kohanaiki Manager, Shoreline and Public Areas Kohanaiki Service Company, LLC P.0. Box 9015 KailuaKona, HI 96740 73-2055 Ala Kohanaiki, Kailua Kona, HI96740 February 9, 2021 Reyna Ramolete Hayashi The Trust for Public Land 1003 Bishop Street, Suite 740 Honolulu, Hawai'i 96813 Sai'a Bowen Malama Hule'ia P.0. Box 662092 LIhu'e, Hawai'i 96766 Re: Support for Malama Hule'ia and the Trust for Public Land's efforts to Purchase and Protect Alalcoko Fishpond in Niumalu and Ha'iku, Kaua'i Aloha, KUA strongly supports The Trust for Public Land and Malama Hule'ia's efforts to protect and purchase the Alakoko Fishpond Property in Niumalu and Ha'iku, Kaua'i, also known as Menehune Fishpond. Protecting Alakoko would provide impactful community benefits: restoring a healthy watershed, river, and native wetland ecosystem; preserving a beloved cultural and historic site and an outdoor classroom for students to learn the science and technology of Hawaiian aquaculture; and increasing sustainable food production and food security for Kaua'i. 'Auamo "grassroots Kua'aina Ulu (KUA) means growing through responsibility," our acronym KUA means back, or backbone. We serve as a backbone organization for grassroots rural and , Native Hawaiian groups engaged in community-based natural resource management as a traditional and customary kuleana (responsibility). We employ a community-driven approach that 'aina currently supports a network ofmore than 36 malama community groups collectively referred to as E Alu Pu (move forward together), a network ofover 45 loko i'a (fishponds and fishpond complexes) called the Hui Malama Loko I'a, and a network oflimu loea (masters ofuse and propagation ofnative seaweeds) called the Limu Hui. The kia'i ofAlakoko have been active participants in the Hui Malama Loko I'a since 2017 but Alakoko has a place in the mo'olelo ofthe network from the 2012 annual gathering on Kaua'i, which was hosted by the Waipa Foundation. At that gathering, 85 participants from 4 islands camped together alongside Halulu Fishpond on the north shore, and they spent a whole day visiting other loko i's as far as the National Tropical Botanical Garden's Allerton Garden in Lawa i Kai. When the caravan stopped at Alakoko, they did not have access to the site, so the group could only marvel at the size and potential from an adjacent hillside. It was one ofthose "imagine if..." conversations that felt very far-fetched. But amazingly, in the past thi-ee decades, more and more ofthese far-fetohed loko i'a visions have 'aina come to fruition, thanks to the persistence and aloha ofgroups such as Malama Hule ia. We are proud to support their efforts and commitment to malama Alakoko for the generations to come. Pupukahi i holomua e ho'okanaka (Let's unite to better the human condition) Brenda Asuncion Hui Malama Loko I'a Coordinator Miwa Tamanaha Kevin K.J. Chang Co-Director Co-Director February 8th, 2021 Reyna Ramolete Hayashi The Trust for Public Land 1003 Bishop Street, Suite 740 Honolulu,Hawai'i 96813 Sara Bowen Malama Hule'ia P.0. Box 662092 Lihu'e, Hawai'i 96766 Re: Support for Malama Hule'ia and the Trust for Public Land's efforts to Purchase and Protect Alakoko Fishpond in Niumalu and Ha'iku, Kaua'i Aloha Kakou, Kumuola Marine Science Education Center strongly supports The Trust for Public Land and Malama Hule'ia's efforts to protect and purchase the Alakoko Fishpond Property in Niumalu and Ha'iku, Kaua'i. Protecting Alakoko would be and has already been hugely impactful for the Kaua'i community. Malama Hule'ia has been working hard restoring a healthy watershed, river, and native wetland ecosystem; preserving a beloved cultural and historic site and operating a thriving outdoor classroom for students to leam the science and technology ofHawaiian aquaculture; as well as increasing sustainable food production and food security for Kaua'i. ICumuola Marine Science Education Center is centered in the 'ili kupono of Honohononui in Waiakea, Hilo. The center focuses on motivating learners to pursue careers in 'Oiwi STEAM related fields and fulfill the needs oftheir communities. Like Alakoko, our fishponds, Waiahole, Kapalaho, and Waiopio, serve as outdoor living laboratories that build 'aina. student's knowledge and ground leamers in the value of Our collaboration with other fishponds has been one ofthe most beneficial impacts to our 'aina work. Collaborative projects bring together practioners to support and lift up the knowledge and skills ofan amazing group ofpeople across the state. This work builds resilience, sustainability, and values. We have worked with the kia'i from Alakoko on accurately measuring sea level rise, restoring fishponds from Ka u to Moloka'i, and educating leamers on top ofMauna Kea! We all hold responsibility to plan for the protection and management ofour coastal communities' treasured areas. A restored and operating Alakoko Fishpond will contribute greatly to Kaua'i and our larger community. Remember ua ola no o kai i kai, fishers live by their own effort. Please support our loko i'a partners in their effort to purchase and protect Alakoko. Mahalo, Luke Mead Director Kumuola Marine Science Education Center, Kamehameha Schools 1650 Kalaniana'ole Ave. Hilo, Hi 96720 .EADERSHIP KAUA'I Mohala i ka wai ka maka o ka pua 'lmfolded bv the water are the faccs of the Howers." 1'roin Ok'lo No 'eaa {>\ Mun. Pifkui February6,2021 Reyna Ramolete Hayashi The Tmst for Public Land 1003 Bishop Street, Suite 740 Honolulu.Hawai'i 96813 Sara Bowen MalamaHule'ia P.0. Box 662092 Lihu'e, Hawai'i 96766 Re: Support for Malania Hule'ia and the Trust for Public Land's efforts to Purchase and Protect Alakoko Fishpond in Niumalu and Ha'iku, Kaua'i Aloha, Leadership Kaua'i strongly supports The Trust for Public Land and Malama Hule'ia's efforts to protect and purchase the Alakoko Flshpond Propei'ty in Niumalu and Ha(iku, Kaua'i, also known as Menehune Fishpond. Protecting Alakoko would provide impactful community benefits: restoring a healthy watershed, river, and native wetland ecosystem; preserving a beloved cultural and historic site and an outdoor classroom for students to leam the science and technology ofHawaiian aquaculture; and increasing sustainable food production and food security for Kaua'i, Leadership Kauai's mission is to ensure a source ofqualified and committed leaders for Kauai's future. Since the beginning ofMalama Huleia project, our adult classes visit the Alakoko Fishpond for service projects such as mangrove removal and natives' plantings. Students gain a deeper understanding ofthe commonalities and differences in leadership from the ancestors to modern times. Ultimately, from being at this majestic fishpond, these leaders are given an opportunity to learn from the past to lead in the futire. The Alekoko Fishpond holds great promise " to keep all people, residents and visitors, connected to Kauai's ancestral roots. The life ofthe fishpond is an irreplacable historical and real-time teaching source for all people. The loss ofthis precious resource would be tragic and devastating for all cultures and generations to come. In beiiig pono, we trust the right decision wlll be made for the Alakoko Fishpond to be allowed flourish as it was originally intended for Kaua'i. Mahalo, !'k/li S Char Ravelo Executive Director Post Office Box 1567 ' Lihu'e, FIawai'i 96766 * * * Phone; (808) 246-8727 Fiix: (808) 246-8726 [email protected]· wn'w'.leaderslupkauai.org February 8, 2021 Reyna Ramolete Hayashi The Trast for Public Land BOARD OF DIRECTORS 1003 Bishop Street, Ste. 740 Pat Griffin, Presielent Honolulu, HI 96813 Adciison Bulosan, Vice-pres, Sara Bowen, Executive Director Malama Hule'ia Shawn Shimabukuro, Secretary P.0. Box 662092 Jusrin Ganadeni Treasurer Lihu'e, HI 96766 Neil Clendeninn RE: SuDport for efForts ofMalama Hule'ia and the Trust for Public Land to purchase and protect Alakoko Fishpond in Niumalu and Ha'iku. Kaua'i Jim Guerber LIhu e Business Association dedicates itselfto assuring a prosperous future PaImerHafdaU for the district and, by extension, the entire island ofKaua'i. We conceive Ken Hughes prosperity as embracing the overall quality oflife, an economic, cultural, and environrnental abundance enjoyed by a community committed to the Daniel Kawamura island's well-being. We like to say that the "business" in our nanie means Stephen Long we're niakins Lihue our business." One ofthe magnificent cultural treasures in the Lihu'e District is the Jim Mayfield Alakoko Fishpond, a wahi pana celebrated by generations ofinhabitants. "icebox" Jan TenBruggencaie Rigorously tended for hundreds ofyears as an for the comiTLunity—andalive with mo {olelo and mele—it had fallen into disrepair only in relatively recent tlmes. This largest flshpond on Kaua'i and finest EX OFFICIO exan-iple ofan inland fishpond in Hawai'i gained ne^v life through Malama "advocate, Michael Dahillg Hule'ia's work to educate and lead comniunity efforts" to restore and protect this site of exceptional cultural and environm.ental irnportance. Carrice Gardner The group s achievenients have been reniarkable, and several members Clyde Kodani ofLBA's board ofdirectors enthusiastically support it by participating in monthly con'miunity workdays. Mark Perriello The LBA applauds Malama Hule ia and the Trust for Public Land for its goal to purchase the Alakoko Fisbpond and protect it in perpetuity. We hope you also wiU. look favorably on this endeavor. Thank you Making Lihu FebruaryS, 2021 Reyna Ramolete Hayashi, The Trust for Public Land, 1003 Bishop Street, Suite 740, Honolulu, Hl 96813 Sara Bowen, Malama Hule'ia, P.0. Box 662092, Lihu'e, Hl 96766 Re: Support for Malama Hule'ia and the Trust for Public Land's efforts to Purchase and Protect Alakoko Fishpond in Niumalu and Ha'iku, Kaua'i Aloha, Malama Kaua'i (MK) strongly supports The Trust for Public Land and Malama Hule'ia's efforts to protect and purchase the Alakoko Fishpond Property in Niumalu and Ha'iku, Kaua'i, also known as Menehune Fishpond. Protecting Alakoko would provide impactful community benefits: restoring a healthy watershed, river, and native wetland ecosystem; preserving a beloved cultural and historic site and an outdoor dassroom for students to learn the science and technology of Hawaiian aquaculture; and increasing sustainable food production and food security for Kaua'i. Increasing local food production and consumption is at the core of MK's mission, as is ensuring our islands food sovereignty and resiliency in the face of oncoming climate change and societal emergencies. Alakoko Fishpond has incredible opportunities to support this mission as a community asset, and Malama Hule'ia has proven itself to be a pono organization with the right approach to maintain community access to, and use of, the site. This property is far too important to our past and our future as an island to allow a private buyer to get a hold of it for any purpose. We have partnered with Malama Hule'ia in dozens of projects over the last several years. We've 'aina-based worked together to increase education and job skills training for both youth and adults, engage visitors in sustainable voluntourism efforts, collaborate with community and organizations across the island. This place is not only special and sacred, and beloved by all on Kaua'i, but it is critical to a food secure future for Kaua'i. I believe that this property could not only continue its life as a community education and environmental asset, but could become one ofour mostvaluable food security assets for proteins. This is especially critical during emergencies as we have seen in the past few years. Mahalo, Megan Fox, Executive Director (808)828-0685x12 | meean(a)malamakauai.ore MALAMA MAHAULEPU Kaua i PublicAccess, Open Space, and Natural Resources Preservation Fund Commission Shaylyn Kimura, Chairperson 4444 Rice St., Suite A473 LThu'e, Hl 96766 Dear Chair Kimura and Members ofthe Kaua'i Open Space Commission, Malama Maha ulepu strongly urges the Open Space Commission to recommend that the Kaua'i County Council expend open space preservation fund monies for acquisition oftheAlakoko Fishpond property. We recognize that the 600 year-old fishpond and surrounding property is unique in all of Hawai'i and highly worthy of permanent protection. The 120 acre parcel meets all nine ofthe conservation purposesforwhich the preservation fund money may be utilized. The current availabilityofAlakoko is an unexpected and tremendous opportunity that, in the current real estate market, is also eminently threatened. Quick, decisive action in the public interest is necessary. Sometimes land is acquired without the important element of capable management being in place. This is not the case for Alakoko. Malama Maha ulepu truly reveres Malama Hule'ia for their vision and for how much they have achieved through tenacious hard work. Cultural grounding, community education and participation characterize their stewardship work. We, and other individuals and nonprofit organizations, learn from their work. We also see ourselves as sister or calabash cousin organizations who are connected by a large conservation vision for Southeast Kauai. You may know that in 2007, atthe request ofSenator Daniel Inouye, the National ParkService conducted a reconnaissance surveyto preliminarily ascertain ifthe ahupua'a of Maha'ulepu and surroundings metfederal standards ofsignificance, suitability and feasibility for further study of resource protection alternatives. Malama Maha'ulepu was surprised and inspired that the study recommended further study of a 9 mile coastal span including "the undeveloped shoreiine corridor from Makawehi northeastward through Maha'ulepu and KTpu Kai to Nawiliwili Bay; the Hule'ia Nationaf Wjldlife Refuge and historic Alekoko Fishpond along Hule'ia Stream; and parts of the Ha'upu mountain range overlooking these areas" The study stipulated that further study focus on "non-traditional management alternatives that A) involve local partners and b) include options for continued farm and ranch operation on private lands" No matter if or when such regional conservation could occur, permanent protection ofAlakoko is an immediate must. Malama Maha'ulepu sincerely hopes that the Open Space Commission and Fund play a primary role in achieving the long held public goal of preservation of Alakoko. Residents, definitely native Hawaiians, conservation advocates and people throughout Hawaii Nei will applaud your right action. With respect and aloha, ''OifitMi- U^»it^f-/Q^hLs' Napua Wong Romo President, Board of Directors of Malama Maha'ulepu PO Box 658 Koloa, Hl 96754 'Ewa, Community 501(c)3 Operating in O'ahu HOHS08.org February5,2021 Reyna Ramolete Hayashi The Trust for Public Land 1003 Bishop Street, Suite 740 Honolulu, Hawai'i 96813 Sara Bowen Malama Hule'ia P.0. Box 662092 Lihu'e, Hawai'i 96766 Re: Support for Malama Hule'ia and the Trust for Public Land's efforts to Purchase and Protect Alakoko Fishpond in Niumalu and Ha'iku, Kaua'i Aloha, Hui o Ho'ohonua strongly supports The Trust for Public Land and Malama Hule'ia's efforts to protect and purchase the Alakoko Fishpond Property in Niumalu and Ha'iku, Kaua'i, also known as Menehune Fishpond. Hui o Ho'honua is the newest member of the statewide network of Hawaiian fishpond stewards and we know what the 'Ewa ongoing restoration of Pu'uloa's fishponds means to the communities on O'ahu. Fishponds throughout Hawai'i are vital to overall watershed health, food security, job creation, education and the perpetuation ofthe Hawaiian culture. Hui o Ho'ohonua stands with Malama Hule'ia as they work with partners to protect the Alakoko Fishpond. There has been enough neglect and desecration of fishponds throughout the state over the last 100 years. As the COVID pandemic has exacerbated food insecurity throughout the state, we believe that the perpetuation of indigenous food systems such as Hawaiian fishponds is vital to economic and community recovery as sustainable sources of healthy food, centersforjob creation and communitygathering places. It istimethat Hawaii'sgovernment, atall levels, collaboratestoallowcommunitystewardsto careforourfishpondsand shoreline resources; at a time when government resources are strained, it is even more imperative that avenues through which community stewardship networks ready to finance such stewardship be allowed to move forward. We at Hui o Ho'honua view the proposed Alakoko Fishpond Property protection by Malama Hule'ia as a desperately needed stewardship model that can, and should be, replicated throughout Hawai'i. Mahaloforyourconsideration ofourinputonthis matter, Sincerely, ^t^ SandyWard Executive Director Malama Pu'uloa (Restoring Pearl Harbor) Program HOH808, Hui o Ho'ohonua 501(c) Ewa Beach, Hawaii 808-292-4291 Februaiy 9, 2021 Reyna Ramolete Hayashi The Trust for Public Land 1003 Bishop Street, Suite 740 Honolulu, Hawai'i 96813 Sara Bowen MalamaHule'ia P.0. Box 662092 Lihu'e, Hawai'i 96766 Re: Support for Malama Hule'ia and the Trust for Public Land's efforts to Purchase and Protect Alakoko Fishpond in Niumalu and Ha'ikii, Kaua'i Aloha, Maunalua Fishpond Heritage Center strongly supports The Trust for Public Land and Malama Hule ia s efforts to protect and purchase the Alakoko Fishpond in Niumalu and Ha'iku, Kaua'i. This is the famous "Menehune Fishpond"! Protecting Alakoko will bring significant community benefits. These include increased food security, a healthy watershed, preservation of a beloved cultural site and an outdoor classroom for students to learn the science of Hawaiian aquaculture. Maunalua Fishpond Heritage Center is dedicated to perpetuating our last fishponds in Maunalua, O'ahu. In 2017 we worked with the Trust for Public Land to purchase and now restore Kanewai Spring. We also are restoring Kalauha'iha'i Fishpond. These ancient fishponds are reflections of communities. We have seen the restorative effect across the community from direct stewardship and title to these ancient fishpond treasures. Loko i'a are Hawaii's pyramids. They are massive public works projects made by the ancients through laulima, the cooperative work ofthousands ofpeople. It is critical during a time offood and economic instability that Alakoko is purchased and protected. It is alarming to leam that this Hawaiian landmark is not yet protected and in community hands. We hope that changes and applaud the Trust for Public Land and Malama Hule'ia's efforts to protect and purchase Alakoko Fishpond. Mahalo, Chris Cramer Executive Director Maunalua Fishpond Heritage Center 5975 Kalanianaole Hwy. Honolulu, Hl 96821 The Menehune who built ancient fishponds and heiau were said to have come to Oahu when Kahano stretched out his hands across the ocean to Kahiki. They were masters at stone wall building. Maunalua Fishpond Heritage Center 5975 Kalanianaole Hwy. Honolulu, Hl 96821 Febmary 9, 2021 Reyna Ramolete Hayashi The Trust for Public Land 1003 Bishop Street, Suite 740 Honolulu, Hawai'i 96813 Sara Bowen Malama Hule ia P.0. Box 662092 Lihu'e, Hawai'i 96766 Re: Support for Malama Hule'ia and the Trust for Public Land s efforts to Purchase and Protect Alakoko Fishpond in Niumalu and Ha'iku, Kaua'i Aloha, Na Maka Onaona strongly supports The Trust for Public Land and Malama Hule ia's efforts to protect and purchase the Alakoko Fishpond Property in Niumalu and Ha'iku, Kaua'i, also known as Menehune Fishpond. Protecting Alakoko would provide impactful community benefits: restoring a healthy watershed, river, and native wetland ecosystem; preserving a beloved cultural and historic site and an outdoor classroom for students to learn the science and technology of Hawaiian aquaculture; and increasing sustainable food production and food security for Kaua i. Our organization, Na Maka Onaona, is a community-based nonprofit that provides culturally grounded educational programs and partnerships that support the over-aU health ofour communities; mentaUy, spiritually, emotionally, and physicaUy. Engaging and immersing into our communities is extremely rewarding and fulfilling on so many levels. We are extremely blessed and fortunate to have been able to partner with Malama Hule'ia through hands on experiences and learning opportunities as well as through presentations sharing the many layers ofHawaii traditions and knowledge contributing to healing our islands and communities. Malama Hule'ia has established such a huge positive cultural presence in Niumalu/Nawiliwili/Lihu'e area highlighting the innovation and brilliance ofour kupuna while building a strong community presence and piko (center). The impact ofthe work they have done to date is insplring on so many levels; opening up a tradltional fishpond, shedding light on sustainable place-based aquaculture, food security, watershed and ecosystem health and weUness, while honoring the rich legacy of Hawaii. Their impact on the community is not only visible in the extensive work completed at Alakoko Fishpond, but in the hundreds of volunteers that were welcomed and supported to put their hands into the earth, into the ocean, into our water systems, and into their PO BOX947. KILAUEA, HI 96754 Phone: (30S) 960-8001 community. Their nurturing of this place and the Kauai Community has set a precedence for leadership and direction towards a future we aU aspire to. We extend our support to The Trust for Public Land and Malama Hule'ia's to protect and purchase the Alakoko Fishpond Property for the continuation of the work they do and the legacy they acknowledge and build from. The work they were able to do, as weU as the community they were able to gather in such a short time is inspirational... imagine what theywiU be able to accomplish moving into the fuhire. Their commitment to this special place speaks for itselfand we at Na Maka Onaona have no doubts that their vision and care witl continue into the future. We look forward to continued partnerships and coUaborations in support of our Hawaii and Aina Momona: thriving and productive communities. Ifyou have any questions, please feel free to caU me at any time. Me ka ha'aha'a, V ^ Pelika Andrade Executive Director Na Maka Onaona POBOX947. KILAUEA, M 96754 Phone: (808)960-8001 February8,2021 Reyna Ramolete h-layashi TheTrustfor Public Land 1003 Bishop Street, Suite 740 Honolulu,Hi. 96813 Sara Bowen Malama Hule'ia P.0. Box 662092 LThu'e, Hi. 96766 Re: Support for Malama Hule ia and The Trust for Public Land's Efforts to Purchase and Protect Alekoko Fishpond in Niumalu and Ha iku, Kaua'i. Aloha kakou, Na Pua No'eau of Kaua'i Community College strongly supports The Trust for Public Land and Malama Hule'ia's efforts to protect and purchase the Alakoko Fishpond Property in the ahupua'a of Niumalu and Ha'iku, Kaua'i, also known as Menehune Fishpond. ProtectingAlakokowouldprovide impactful community benefits: restoring a healthy watershed, river and native wetland ecosystem; preserving a beloved and cherished cultural and historical site and outdoorclassroom forour entire kaiaulu (community) to learn the science and technology of an ancient Hawaiian aquaculture system; increasing sustainable food production and food security for the island of Kaua'i. Na Pua No'eau is a cultural enrichment program ofthe University of Hawai'i, that raisesthe goals and aspirations ofchildren (PreK-College) byexposing them to career and college pathways within a cultural context. Alakoko fishpond is an instrumental and indispensable learning resource to our program and to this entire community. Through the many stewardship opportunities provided by Malama Hule'ia, NPN was able to provide hundreds ofour students, ofall ages, the opportunityto learn from all the many valuable lessons that Alakoko has to offer; culture, history, math, science, engineering, geography, to name a few. The lessons learned at Alakoko have inspired our students to pursue career and college pathways in education, biology, botany and conservation. However, the most valuable lesson Alakoko has taught our students is their kuleana (responsibility) to care for their natural environment, respect and value ancestral knowledge and that through diligence and hard work, places likeAlakoko have the abilityto sustain an entire community. In the Hawaiian language, the word wahi is a place or a site and the word pono is a pulse or heartbeat. Alakoko is a wahi pana, a sacred place that reverberates the pulse of a people, of a community. Such places should NEVER be privately owned or developed or have a dollar amount placed on it's value. Doing so erases the many lessons, reminders and footprints that our ancestors left for usthat manyofour questions can be answered within the very land and ocean we came from. Thecontinued protection, restoration and revitalization ofAlakokofishpond and wahi pana throughout Kaua'i is notjust essential to the success of programs like Na Pua No'eau, it isa necessityifourcommunityseeks solutions in sustainablefood systems, on an island with limited resources. NPN'svision forAlakoko fishpond isto see it become productive once again, 'aina for it to continue to inspire the next generation of aloha (stewards) and for itto continue to be a beacon ofwhat is possible when a community is committed to working together. Mahalo nui for your time and consideration, Malia Kahale'inia Chun Program Director Na Pua No'eau Kaua'i KCC 3-1901 Kaumuali'i Hwy. LThu'e,Hi. 96766 Email: [email protected] United States Department ofthe Interior NATIONAL PARK SERVICE Interior Regions 8, 9, 10, and 12 333 Bush Sto-eet, Suite 500 San Francisco, CA 94104-2828 IN REPLY REFER TO: Date: February 8, 2021 Reyna Ramolete Hayashi The Trust for Public Land 1003 Bishop Street, Suite 740 Honolulu, Hawai'i 96813 Sara Bowen Malama Hule'ia P.0. Box 662092 Lihu'e, Hawai'i 96766 Re: Support for Malama Hule'ia and the Trust for Public Land's efforts to Purchase and Protect Alakoko Fishpond in Niumalu and Ha'iku, Kaua'i Aloha, The National Park Service's Rivers, Trails and Conservation Assistance Program (NPS-RTCA) strongly supports The Trust for Public Land and Malama Hule'ia in their efforts to protect and purchase the Alakoko Fishpond property. NPS-RTCA supported Malama Hule'ia through a technical assistance grant for approximately 4 years. Malama Hule'ia was selected as a project ofthe NPS-RTCA due to their project vision, the significance and potential ofthe project site as a community resource, the organization s ability to work with the community, the loko 'ia extended community, the conservation community, and its neighbors and govemment agencies within the project area. Malama Hule'ia has taken an important Hawaiian National Register site and saved it from its impending destruction through working collectively and intentionally. They have been successful in bringing in the expertise needed for sensitive cultural and natural areas, volunteers and staff for the excessive hard labor, and schools and community groups to support 'aina-based the work and learn about Hawaiian practices, management, and education. Malaina Hule'ia has successfally raised funds, built partnerships, and is restoring a native wetland and Hawaiian fishpond that has the potential to be a sustainable food resource and learning site for future generations. The NPS-RTCA is particularly excited for the Alakoko fishpond property to be purchased for preservation as a public resource. Alakoko Fishpond as a public resource provides the community with an inland loko kuapa that is a testainent to Hawaiian innovation in engineering, INTERIOR REGION 8 • LOWER COLORADO BASIN' INTER10RREGION 9 • COLUMBIA—PACIFICNORTHWEST* INTER10RREGION 10 • CALIfORNLA—GR£ATBAS1N INTERIORREGION 12 • PAC1FIC ISLANDS AMERICAN SAMOA, ARIZONA*. CALIFOR.NIA. GUAM, HAWAII, IDAHO, MONTANA*, NEVADA, NORTHERN MAR.1ANA 1SLANDS. OREGON, WASH1NGTON •PAIU'IAL hydrology, aquaculture and biology. It offers a place to teach the next generations ways of Native Hawaiian sustainability, food sovereignty, and natural resources management. It provides critical habitat for endangered, endemic species. It provides for a leaming and stewardship opportunity for generations, ifpreserved for the greater public trust. Our mission states that NPS cooperates with partners to extend the benefits of natural and cultural resource conservation and outdoor recreation throughout the nation and the worid.' A successful purchase ofAlakoko as such a resource in perpetuity directly supports our mission. It is our experience that the most successful projects are when those who actually live and work "own" in the area embrace and the process, the outcomes, and share in the work. Malama Hule'ia embodies that approach. Alakoko fishpond provides the opportunity for the community to continue to leam through stewardship, through 'aina-based education, and to rebuild an essential site for native species and innovative aquaculture. It is located along the Hule'ia River in its exact location for its natural properties and significance. This cannot be recreated in another location and offers a unique opportunity to learn the reasons why this particular location works as an aquacultural resource. We believe in the efforts of The Trust for Public Land and Malama Hule'ia to purchase, protect, and manage this unique resource for the benefit ofthe Kauai community, the native ecosystem, and for Hawaiian practitioners to leam and teach the science and techaology ofHawaiian aquaculture to future generations. Thank you for your consideration. Sincerely, Meredith Speicher National Park Service Rivers, Trails, and Conservation Assistance Program Pacific Islands Field Office HABITAT JOINT VENTURE Creating the Ideal Environment for Bird Habitat Conservation February9,2021 Reyna Ramolete Hayashi The Trust for Public Land 1003 Bishop Street, Suite 740 Honolulu, Hawai'i 96813 Sara Bowen Malama Hule'ia P.0. Box 662092 Lihu'e, Hawai'i 96766 Aloha, Re: Support for Malama Hule'ia & the Trust for Public Land's efforts to Purchase & Protect Alakoko Fishpond Pacific Birds Habitat Joint Venture offers our wholehearted support for efforts by Malama Hule'ia and The Trust for Public Land to protect and purchase the Alakoko Fishpond Property in Kaua'i. Habitat Joint Ventures are cooperative, regional partnershlps located in the U.S., Canada, and Mexico. In Hawai'i, Pacific Birds Habitat Joint Venture (PBHJV) focuses on wetlands, endangered wetland birds and other native species in those aquatic habitats. We help partners identify, prioritize, and implement shared conservation actions to benefit wetlands; and raise awareness about birds and conservation. Wetland habitat is a scarce and precious resource throughout Hawai'i and has great cultural and environmental importance. Malama Hule'ia'seffortsto restore and managewetland habitatas partoftheirworkatAlakoko is therefore critically important. This dynamic, grassroots organization has been caring for the Fishpond and surrounding area by removing highly invasive mangrove and replanting with native species. This is providing much needed mudflat and wetland area that is already being used by threatened and endangered (T&E) waterbirds. These birds, including the ae'o (Hawaiian Stilt) and koloa maoli (Koloa Duck), have world populations of less than 2,000 and 1,000 birds respectively so every effort to provide protected, high quality habitat counts. Alakoko is also adjacent to the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service Hule'ia National Wildlife Refuge and this connectivity of habitat is of great benefit to T&E species as well as migratory birds. The work occurring at Alakoko aligns with our organizational strategies to; i) support partners in protecting, creating and restoring wetland habitat for waterbird populations and other wetland species ii) increase the abilityofwetlandsto mitigate for dimate change through provision oflearningopportunities and sourcing human/financial resources. The cultural and ecological significance ofAlakokocannotbeoverstated -the opportunityto purchase itmight be a once in a generation event. We sincerely hope that Malama Hule'ia and partners will succeed; were this purchase to fail, the work and community collaboration that has gone into protecting the site thus far will be wasted, and without ongoing management, the habitat value for T&E birds will be lost. Thank-you for your consideration, Visit our website: www.pacificbirds.org ^^^•^^^ Monica Iglecia U.S. Coordinator monica [email protected], (805) 298 - 8081 PACIFIC February5,2021 AMERICAN FOUNDATION Reyna Ramolete Hayashi The Trust for Public Land BOARD OF DIRECTORS 1003 Bishop Street, Suite 740 Chairperson Honolulu, Hawai'i 96813 MichaefW. Beasley, Esq. Sara Bowen BOARD MEMBERS Malama Hule ia Ethan Cooper P.0. Box 662092 Alvin Pauoie Herb Lee, Jr. Lihu'e, Hawai'i 96766 ADMINISTRATION Re: Support for Malama Hule'ia and the Trust for Public Land s efforts to President & CEO Purchase and Protect Alakoko Fishpond in Niumalu and Ha iku, Herb Lee Jr. Chief Financial Officer Kaua'i Louis F. Perez II General Counsel Ethan Cooper Aloha, Pacific American Foundation Pacific American Foundation (PAF) strongly supports The Trust for Public C/0 Bay View Golf Park Land and Malania Hule'ia's efforts to protect and purchase the Alakoko 45-285 Kaneohe Bay Drlve, i»102 Kane'ohe, Hl 96744 Fishpond Property in Niumalu and Ha'iku, Kaua'i, also known as Menehune Fishpond. Protecting Alakoko would provide impactful community benefits: Phone: (808) 664-3027 www.thepaf.org. restoring a healthy watershed, river, and native wetland ecosystem; preserving a beloved cultural and historic site and an outdoor classroom for students to leam the science and technology of Hawaiian aquaculture; and increasing sustainable food production and food security for Kaua i. PAF was in a similar position in 1995 when it began to restore Waikalua Loko I'a in Kane'ohe Bay. Wewere ableto acquireherin2015. The journey ofbridging indigenous wisdom that comes with these ponds has surpassed all expectations we had in 1995. Hawaiian Loko I'a which was once prominent in Hawaii's history is on the verge ofvauishing in the 21 century. Alakoko is an exceptional site for both the island ofKaua'i, the state and world! These few remaining Loko I'a are important indicators ofthe health and vitality ofthe community in which they occupy. Its educational, research and inspirational potential for cultural preservation, revitalization, stewardship has in fact launched many new career opportunities for gifted 'Aina and dedicated youth ofHawaii to Aloha and Malama in new and creative ways that embraces and protects the essence that is Hawaii. PACIFIC AMERICAN FOUNDATION Since 1995, PAF has registered over 100,000 people that have come to learn, give back and help accelerate the need to create a new foundation for food security in these islands. Please do everything you can to protect this precious and vital cultural resource for generations to come! I am available to assist in anyway in protecting and acquiring this loko I'a for the community to malama. I can be reached at 808 927-5646 or email at [email protected]. Sincerely, [erb Lee Jr. President & CEO Pacific American Foundation FEIN 54-1696134 PACIFIC AMERICAN FOUNDATION Supporting the Language of Kaua'i, Inc. February 9, 2021 Reyna Ramolete Hayashi The Trust for Public Land 1003 Bishop Street, Suite 740 Honolulu.Hawai'i 96813 Sara Bowen Malania Hule ia Lihu'e, Hawai'i 96766 RE: Support for Malama Hule'ia and the Trust for Public Land's efforts to Purchase and Protect Alakoko Fishpond in Niumalu and Ha'iku, Kaua'i Aloha, 'Supporting the Language ofKaua'i, Inc. (SLK, Inc.), a 501(c)3 Kaua'I based non profit, strongly supports The Trust for Public Land and Malama Hule'ia's efforts to protect and purchase the Alakoko Fishpond Property in Niumalu and Ha'iku, Kaua'i, also known as Menehune Fishpond. Protecting Alakoko would provide impactful community benefits: restoring a healthy watershed, river, and native wetland ecosystem; preserving a beloved cultural and historic site and an outdoor classroom for students to leam the science and 'ofHawaiian technology aquaculture; and increasing sustainable food production aad food security for Kaua'i. SLK, Inc.'s mission to support and perpetuate the native Hawaiian language through education and cultural enrichment. As the fiscal support arm for Kawaikini New Century Public Charter School, preserving this historic cultural site plays an important part in the Kaua'i based curriculum (Manokalanipo) provided by this Hawaiian Immersion K-12 school. If this property is sold off, then it would no longer be accessible, for this place-based learning that is so essential for the stadents and ohana ofKawaikmi, or even worse, could be changed permanently. Kawaikini students benefit from Alakoko Fishpond being protected restored, and stewarded by the 'aina-based coimTiunity for education, Hawaiian cultural practice, sustainable aquaculture, food production, and as a native wetland habitat for fish and endangered water birds. Mahalo, Leilani Spencer, Exec. Director Supporting the Language ofKaua'i, Inc. P.0. Box 245, LIHUE. Hl. 967 66 T EL. 808.913-0924 / EMAIL: [email protected] WWW.SUPPORTiNGTHELANGUAGE.ORG TheNature The Nature Conservancy, Hawai i Program Tel (808) 537-4508 923 Nu'uanu Avenue Fax (808) 545-2019 Conservancy Honolulu,HI96817 nature.org/hawaii February 8, 2021 Ms. Reyna Ramolete Hayashi The Trust for Public Land 1003 Bishop Street, Suite 740 Honolulu, Hawai'i 96813 Ms. Sara Bowen Executive Director Malama Hule'ia P.0. Box 662092 LThu'e, Hawai'i 96766 RE: Malama Hule'ia and the Trust for Public Land's efforts to Purchase and Protect Alakoko Fishpond in Niumalu and Ha'iku, Kaua'i Aloha, Thankyou forthis opportunityforTheNature Conservancyto express our support ofTheTrustfor Public Land and Malama Hule ia in their effort to acquire, manage. and preserve the Alakoko Fishpond property in Niumalu and Ha'iku, Kaua'i, TMKs (4)3-2-001:001 & (4)3-1-001:012. The Nature Conservancy's Hawai'i Chapter has worked with Malama Hule'ia on Geographic Information System mapping, in supportofthe preservation and managementofthefishpond site and surrounding lands. We also have worked on conservation and preservation projects across the state with The Trust for Public Land. We are pleased to supportthe workofour non-profit partner, Malama Hule'ia, in its effortto acquire and protect in perpetuity the Alakoko Fishpond property as well as to restore the larger Hule'ia watershed. The unique Alakoko Fishpond site is an iconic archaeological gem, which also provides important environmental services that support native Hawaiian birdlife, terrestrial species, and aquaticsystems. We applaud Malama Hule'ia's environmental stewardship as it works to clear invasive mangrove, replant with coastal plants native to the region, involve students and the larger community, and plan for a future that protects and conserves this remarkable island resource. BOARDOFTRUSTEES DukeE.AhMoo Paul D. Alston (Chair) Kris Billeter Dr. C. TanaBurkert AnneS.Carter Richai-d A. Cooke III Ka'iulani de Silva DaveEadie MattEmerson Hon. Judith Epstein Dr. Alan M. Friedlander Benjy Gai-fmkle James J.C. Haynes III SeanA.Hehir Brett MacNaughton Kathy M. Matsui JanetMontag Alicia Moy. Dustin E. Sellers Peter K. Tomozawa Richai-d N. Zwem Ihupani Advisory Council: Christopher J. Benjainin Kenton T. Eldridge Eiichiro Kuwana Duncan MacNaughton Jean E. Rolles Crystal K. Rose Founders: Samuel A. Cooke Herbert C. Comuelle The Nature Conservancy, Hawai'i Program FebruaryS, 2021 Page2 The Nature Conservancy is a global conservation organization whose goal is to conserve the lands and waters on which all life depends. Our vision is a world where the diversity of life thrives, and people act to conserve nature for its own sake and Its abitity to fulfill our needs and enrich our lives. In Hawai'i we have protected more than 200,000 acres of natural lands, and our marine program has worked to protect reef ecosystems across the archipelago. The Nature Conservancy is a nonprofit, tax-exempt charitable organization under Section 501(c)(3) of the U.S. Internal Revenue Code. 'oia'i'o, Me ka Ulalia Woo'dside Executive Director The Nature Conservancy, Hawai'i Chapter Reyna Ramolete Hayashi The Trust for Public Land 1003 Bishop Street, Suite 740 Honolulu, Hawaii 96813 Sara Bowen Malama Hule'ia PO Box 662092 Lihu'e, Hawaii 96766 Re: SUPPORT FOR MALAMA HULE'IA and THE TRUST FOR PUBLIC LAND'S EFFORTS TO PURCHASE & PROTECT ALAKOKO FISHPOND inNIUMALU & HA'IKU. KAUAI To whom it may concern, I strongly support both the Trust for Public Land and Malama Hule'ia efforts to purchase and protect tlie Alakoko Fishpond Property in Niumalu and Ha'iku, Kauai, also coiTimonly known as the Menehune Fishpond. Protecting Alalcoko would provide impactfi.il community benefits: -restoring a healthy watershed, river and native wetland ecosystem -preserving a beloved cultiiral and historic site -preserving an outdoor classroom for students to learn the science and technology ofHawaiian aquaculture -increasing sustainable food production and food security for Kauai As someone that calls Kauai home, I want to protect as much of the island as possible. The Menehune Fishpond is a treasm'e to this island. It has been enjoyed by Hawaiians and visitors and has much folklore and history attached to it. This must be protected and supported! Please allow this purchase to happen so that it can save the security ofthis most wonderful area ofKauai. I support the efforts of the Trust for Piiblic Land and Malama Hule'ia in the purchase and protection ofthis most special place. Mahalo and aloha, Andrea Slevin PO Box 802 Kilauea, HI 96754 Febmary 7, 2021 Reyna Ramolete Hayashi The Trust for Public Land 1003 Bishop Street, Suite 740 Honolulu,Hawai'i 96813 Sara Bowen MalamaHule ia P.0. Box 662092 Lihu'e, Hawai'i 96766 Re: Support for Malama Hule'ia and the Trust for Public Land's efforts to Purchase and Protect Alakoko Fishpond in Niumalu and Ha'iku, Kaua'i Aloha, I, Clayton Egan, strongly support The Tmst for Public Land and Malama Hule'ia's efforts to protect and purchase the Alakoko Fishpond Property in Niumalu and Ha'iku, Kaua'i, also known as Menehune Fishpond. For over two years I have been part ofateam ofvolunteers using chainsaws to manually remove invasive mangrove trees from the pond and the riverbank along the fishpond wall, where large equipment could not be used because ofthe danger to the historic wall. Each ofus has put in over a thousand man hours on fhis project, adding up to several thousand man hours. This is a large personal investment to support the many purposes ofMalama Hule'ia. I am very concemed that all of the current and fature restoration and preservation efforts at Alakoko Fishpond would be in vain, if the property were to be sold for residential or commercial use. It is my hope that the purchase ofthis property will preserve this important piece ofKauai heritage for generations to come. Mahalo, Clayton Egan 3786 Waha Road Kalaheo, HI 96741 (808) 320-3245 [email protected] February 7, 2021 Reyna Ramolete Hayashi The Trust for Public Land 1003 Bishop Steeet, Suite 740 Honolulu,Hawai'i96813 Sara Bowen MalaiiiaHule'ia P.0. Box 662092 Lihu'e, Hawai'i 96766 Re: Support for Malama Hule'ia and the Trust for Public Land's efforts to Purchase and Protect Alakoko Fishpond inNiumalu and Ha'iku, Kaua'i Aloha, I, Gary Hofacker, strongly support The Trust for Public Land and Malaina Hule'ia's efforts to protect and purchase the Alakoko Fishpond Property in Niumalu and Ha'iku, Kaua'i, also kaown as Menehune Fishpond. I believe the Alakoko Fishpond protection and restoration project will have a positive impact on the community and society. One ofmy main focuses for Malama Hule'ia is to foster Hawaiian values among the youth living in Hawaii and create an awareness among them ofthe eternal and priceless Hawaiian spiritual heritage and ofthe richness ofHawaiian cultural traditions. For over two years, I have been part ofthe team who have been using chainsaws to manually remove invasive mangrove trees from the pond and the riverbank along the fishpond wall, where latge equipment could not be used because ofthe danger to the historic wall. To me Malama Hule'ia is an outstanding example ofwhat a community is capable ofachieving through dedication and volunteerism. It is my hope that the purchase ofthis property will preserve this important piece ofKaua'i heritage for generations to come. Mahalo, Gary Hofacker 3786 Waha Road Kalaheo, HI 96741 (808) 320-3245 gai ananafaiearthlink.net Hannah Kihalani Springer Kukui'ohiwai, Ka'upulehu 72-3403 Mamalahoa Highway Kailua, Kona, Hawai'i HI 96740 February 9, 2021 Reyna Ramolete hlayashi The Trust for Public Land 1003 Bishop Street, Suite 740 Honolulu, O'ahu HI96813 Sara Bowen Malama Hule'ia P.0. Box 662092 Lihu'e, Kaua'i HI 96766 Re: Support for Malama Hule'ia and the Trust for Public Land's efforts to Purchase and Protect Alakoko Fishpond in Niumalu and Ha'iku, Kaua'i Me ka ha'aha'a, I, Hannah Kihalani Springer strongly support The Trust for Public Land and Malama Hule'ia's efforts to protect and purchase the Alakoko Fishpond Property in Niumalu and Ha'iku, Kaua'i. Protecting Alakoko would provide valuable community benefits: restoration of a seaward section of a watershed, including stream and native wetland ecosystems; preservation of a beloved cultural and historic site; the continuation and expansion of an outdoor classroom for students to learn the science and technology of Hawaiian aquaculture; and the increasing of sustainable food production and food security for Kaua'i. My family and I are involved in malama 'aina efforts in our home ahupua'a of Ka'upulehu on Hawai'i Island. We understand and advocate for the stabilization and restoration of rare and precious ecotypes from the top of our mauna, Hualalai, to the shoreline fisheries, with the cloud-forest, dry- forest and anchialine pond resources in between. We recognize the beauty 'aina. of the communities that arise when kanaka come together to malama We know the beneflts to physical and mental health that follow from being outside and paying attention while working together on restoration projects, which turn into growth opportunities for individuals and collectives alike. I have sat on our Hawai'i Island Public Access, Open Space, and Natural Areas Preservation Commission and have seen the way that partnerships, such as the one envisioned here, between The Trust for Public Lands and Malama Hule'ia encourage the local, residents of an area. Given the property's natural and cultural characteristics, the highest and best use for Kaua'i and the people of Kaua'i, would not be high-end residential or commercial use, but rather the envisioned collabaration. 'aina, From the far end of the pae our family at Ka'upulehu would benefit "from Alakoko Fishpond being restored, and stewarded by the 'aina-based protected community for education, Hawaiian cultural practice, sustainable aquaculture, food production, and as a native wetland habitat for fish and endangered water birds" ... by simply knowing that it is there with those who have aloha for it.. Our family's prayer is that Alakoko will long be there with those who hold it dear. 'O au no me ka 'oia'i'o, Hannah Kihalani Springer February 8, 2021 Reyna Ramolete Hayashi The Trust for Public Land 1003 Bishop Street, Suite 740 Honolulu, Hawai'i 96813 Sara Bowen MalamaHule'ia P.0. Box 662092 Lihu'e, Hawai'i 96766 Re: Support for Malama Hule'ia and the Trust for Public Land's efforts to Purchase and Protect Alakoko Fishpond in Niumalu and Ha'iku, Kaua'i Aloha, I strongly support The Trust for Public Land and Malama Hule'ia's efforts to protect and purchase the Alakoko Fishpond Property in Niumalu and Ha'iku, Kaua'i, also known as Menehune Fishpond. Protecting Alakoko would provide impactful community benefits: restoring a healthy watershed, river, and native wetland ecosystem; preserving a beloved cultural and historic site and an outdoor classroom for students to learn the science and technology ofHawaiian aquaculture; and increasing sustainable food production and food security for Kaua'i. As a native kanaka born and raised on the island ofKaua'i, I have witnessed the extreme overgrowth ofmangrove and simply unkept area known as Alakoko Fishpond over the years. I have heard stories of how fruitful and plentiful the 'aina once was, but have never witnessed it in my lifetime. However, when Malama Hule'ia stepped in to 'ohana become stewards ofthe land and bring back what once was, my and I witnessed and was blessed to be a part ofthe restoration ofAlakoko Fishpond. We only live a few minutes from tlie area and are able to get our hands dirty and make the connection to the 'aina that has fed our kupuna and hopefully one day feed us as well. 'ohana 'aina My is shocked that this property is for sale and may end up in the wrong hands like so much ofour here 'aina on Kaua'i and in Hawai'i as a whole. We are losing our very precious resources and that provides water, food, and a cultural connection to our 'aina. With outside buyers come increases in the cost ofour land, higher taxes, and native 'ohana moving away and losing their connection to the home and the 'aina that feeds us. Should it be sold to a private owner, our kanaka will never reap the benefits. I would like OUR keiki to enjoy the fruits oftheir labor. IfMalama Hule'ia and the Trust for Public Land are allowed to purchase Alakoko Fishpond, I am sure that this amazihg place will be well protected. I know that their goal is to return the fishpond to the community for fish pond and wetland restoration, education, and to grow fish and feed the community for generations to come. I fully support their mission and ask for your support as well. Mahalo, 'Ilima Hose February 9, 2021 Reyna Ramolete Hayashi The Trust for Public Land 1003 Bishop Street, Suite 740 Honolulu, Hawai'i 96813 Sara Bowen Malama Hule'ia P.0. Box 662092 Lihu'e, Hawai'i 96766 Re: Support for Malama Hule'ia and the Trust for Public Land's efforts to Purchase and Protect Alakoko Fishpond inNiumalu and Ha'iku, Kaua'i Aloha mai kakou, I am writing to show my support for the efforts of The Trust for Public Land and Malama Hule'ia to protect and purchase the Alakoko Fishpond Property in Niumalu and Ha'iku, Kaua'i, also known as Menehune Fishpond. The protection ofthis culturally significant site would provide so many benefits to the commimity, which include but are not limited to the following: restoring a healthy watershed, river, and native wetland ecosystem; preserving a beloved cultural and historic site and an outdoor classroom for students to learn the science and technology of Hawaiian aquaculture; and increasing sustainable food production and food security for Kaua i. As an instructor ofHawaiian Studies at Kaua i Community College, I can't begin to express how valuable Alalcoko Fishpond has been to my classes. It has provided experiences that cannot be replicated in the classroom. Tlirough Malama Hule ia's efforts, my students have had hands-on experiences that are truly valuable to their education. Because Al^koko sits within the same ahupua a boundaries as Kaua'i CC, it allows me to incorporate place-based learning. Students are able to work in the lo i on our campus and then malce their way down the ahupua a to the "ma "ma fishpond, giving them a sense of uka" to kai" connection. Nowhere else in the world are we able to learn about Hawaiian culture than in Hawai i; and with that in mind, Alakoko has provided another level to their education that can't be taught or learned anywhere else. Through the efforts ofMalama Hule ia, my students and many others have had an opportunity to leam more about their home and their culture. In addition to being an educator, I am Kanaka Maoli, born and raised on Kaua i. Growing up here, I have always been drawn to Alakoko. It broke my heart to see the place covered in mangrove and unattended for. I could see, even as a child, the tremendous opportunities that Alakoko could offer our community in the form offood production and sustainable practices. It's been such a blessing to see the restoration work at Alakoko, to be able to see what can be done when many hands and many hearts come together. As a mother, I am so filled withjoy when I see my own son's hands plaiiting native plants back into the soil and to see his eyes light up whenever we retum to Alakoko. Malama Hule ia and Alakoko have given him opportunities that will stay with him for the rest ofhis life. His little brother is still too young to join us, but one day I hope that they both will be able to share these experiences with their own children. Thank you for your time and consideration. Me ke aloha, Puali ili imaikalani Rossi-Fuldno Assistant Professor, Hawaiian Studies Kaua i Community College [email protected] Aletha G. Kaohi P.0. Box 109 Waimea, Kaua'i, Hawai'i 96796 Febmary8,2021 Reyna Ramolete Hayashi The Trust for Public Land 1003 Bishop Street, Suite 740 Honolulu,Hawai'i 96813 Sara Bowen Malama Hule'ia P.0. Box 662092 Lihu'e, Hawai'i 96766 Re: Support for Malama Hule'ia and the Tmst for Public Land's efforts to Purchase and Protect Alakoko Fishpond in Niumalu and Ha ikii, Kaua'i Welina mai kakou apau, I'm Aletha Kawelukawahinehololioolimaloa Goodwin Kaohi, born and reared at Pailuli, ancestral land, Waimea Valley. A native Hawaiian, daughter of William KapahukaniolonooKainoahou Goodwin and Margaret Kamala Kamai. My papa, a historian who in 1929 was the guide for Dr. Kenneth Bennett, Bishop Museum, to document Kaua i s historic sites. Dr. Bennett author ofKauai Archeology. I grew up surrounded by taro fields which instilled the culture ofthe early Hawaiians. I was always interested "things in Hawaiian." A retired public librarian after tturty-seven years and seven years Hawaiian Culture Lecturer at Kaua i Cormnunity College. Presently manager/ Hawaiian Cultural Consilltant for West Kaua i Heritage Center, formerly West Kaua'i Visitor Center. As a kupuna, ninety years old, who support preservation ofhistoric and legendary sites. Once these sites get into private hands, who knows what will happen tp these wahi pana. For the past eight years I serve as President ofthe Friends ofKing Kaumuali'i whose mission is to erect a statue ofKaumuali'i at Pa'ula'ula, the royal compound, known as Fort Ellizabeth Russian Fort. The statue dedication is on March 20 . I strongly apono The Trust fpr Public Land and Malama Hule'ia's efforts to protect and purchase the Alakoko Fishpond Property in Niumalu and Ha'iku, Kaua'i, also known as Menehune Fishpond. Protecting Alakoko would provide impactful community benefits: restoring a healthy watershed, river, and native wetland ecosystem; preserving a beloved cultural and historic site and an outdoor classroom for students to learn the science and technology of Hawaiian aquaculture; and increasing sustainable food production and food security forKaua'i Two Hawaiian words, malama, is to preserve/care and kuleana, is the responsibility of all people who aloha the aina, who will preserve Alekoko Fishponds. If I can be of further help, please don't hesitate to contact me. 'Owau iho no ke aloha. Aletha G. Kaohi P.0. Box 109 Waimea,HI 96796 Phone; 808-338-1447 (H) or 808-338-1332 (0) From: Stevan Yee Aloha. My name is Stevan Yee. I have been a resident ofLihu'e, Kaua'i, for the past 26 years. For the entire duration ofmy residence in Lihu'e, I have also been an active member ofttie Kaiola Canoe Club, and I currently serve as one ofthe coaches for recreational (non-competitive) padding. My participation in Kaiola Canoe Club activities is relevant to the subject ofmy testimony because the paddling club was initially located directly adjacent to the Alakoko Fishpond, and it is now located less than a mile from the fishpond downstream along the Hule'ia River. So all Kaiola paddlers are familiar with the fishpond. We regularly paddle on the river past Alakoko and can observe first hand all the changes occurring with the fishpond and its enviromnent. One major change, affecting not only the Alakoko Fishpond, but the whole Hule'ia River ecosystem, became mpre than obvious to me after several years ofpaddling. It was the destructive invasion ofthe area by the alien red mangrove plant. When mangrove trees began to encroach on the beach where we launch our canoes at Kaiola, I decided that something had to be done about it and started a Kaiola Canoe Club project to eradicate the invasive plant. Six ofus formed a steering committee, and I applied for and got two consecutive one year grants for this aiTibitious project. We named the project Malama Hule'ia. After 2 years ofmostly volunteer effort and strong community support, Malama Hule'ia succeeded in clearing mangrove and other alien plants from about 2.5 acres ofwetland adjacent to the canoe club hale, the Niumalu Beach Park. and the Pu'ali Stream. The cleared areas were then replanted with native and canoe plants. After this success, in 2014, Malama Hule'ia was incorporated as a separate non-profit organization, and its new Board of Directors spent the first year getting organized, developing a long range strategic plan and hiring an Executive Director. I was the first Board President, and Sara Bowen has been the Malama Hule'ia Executive Director since 2015. She hired Peleke Flores as Field Operations and Cominunity Outreach Manager. At the end of 2018,1 retired from the Board. But I remain connected to the organization as its webmaster and as a volunteer field worker. So I am still familiar with its current leadership team and what they have accomplished. With this background, I offer three major reasons to support ofthe acquisition ofthe Alakoko Fishpond by Malama Hule'ia' and The Tmst for Public Land: 1. The Alakoko Fishpond is a prime example of a special ecosystem that is also a very valuable Hawaiian cultural asset. Malama Hule'ia has always worked to simultaneously conserve both the natural environment and the Hawaiian culture. In addition to working to restore the Hule'ia and Alakoko from destruction by invasive alien plants, and replacing the alien plants with more appropriate native Hawaiian species, Malama Hule'ia has educated people about the history ofthe area and the fishpond, and about relevant cultural practices and beliefs. This dual focus is just what will be required to complete the restoration ofthe fishpond and to preserve it for many generations ofthe Kauai community. 2. Malama Hule'ia has achieved a track record of success, and its current leadership and staffare fully capable ofcontinuing this success. The Alakoko Fishpond work has involved several complex phases and tasks: negotiating a 20 year lease with the current owners; getting all the necessary government permits for the work; winning a large govemment grant to fand the work; planning for and deploying heavy equipment and their volunteer operators; perfonning community outreach; holding public events and traditional ceremonies; giving school children hands-on learning opportunities in both environmental science as well as Hawaiian history; and managing a workforce for all of the required field work. The Kaua'i community would be very fortunate to have such a proven organization willing to take on responsibility for stewardship of a valuable public place like the Alakoko Fishpond. 3. Malaina Hule'ia could not have achieved the success that it has without tremendous community support. The Pu'ali wetland and Alakoko Fishpond have been completely cleared ofthe dense mangrove jungles,and much ofthese places have been replanted by hand. This entailed himdreds ofcommunity volunteers and special "Menehune" crews laboring for hundreds ofhours. It also involved other local organizations, private companies and individuals donating needed services and dollars. All ofthis support shows how much value the community sees in the preservation ofthe Hule'ia watershed and especially the Alakoko Fishpond. Undoubtedly, there is great aloha for these places. The Alakoko Fishpond should therefore not be allowed to fall into private ownership again. MalaiTia Hule ia in partnership with The Trust for Public Land should be enabled to purchase and protect the Alakoko Fishpond for the Kaua'i community. Mahalo for allowing me to share my thoughts. Stevan Yee 2645 Apapane St., Lihue, HI 96766 February 8, 2021 Reyna Ramolete Hayashi The Trust for Public Land 1003 Bishop Street, Suite 740 Honolulu, Hawai'I 96813 Sara Bowen Malama Hule'ia P.O.Box 662092 Lihu'e, Hawai'I 96766 Re: Strong support for Malama Hule'ia and the Tmst for Public Land's efforts to purchase and protect Alakoko Fishpond Aloha, I caa't emphasize too strongly how truly important and beneficial it would be to support The Trust for Public Land and Malama Hule'ia's efforts to purchase the Alakoko Fishpond. Every person on Kauai would benefit firom the preservation and protection ofthe area - also future generations would benefit. People I know and deeply respect have poured their love ofthe land, malama aina, into clearing the mangroves in order to retum the fishpond to the community, to grow fish and feed the community for generations to come through fishpond and wetland restoration. The support and caring ofthose in Malama Hule'is has been extremely strong, unselfish and deeply moving in their efforts to care for the healfh ofthis beautiful fishpond. I feel that support for the acquisition ofthe fishpond would result in many benefits to Kauai and those ofus who live here. Although it may seem a bit far fetehed, I can imagine that, as director ofthe Hospice Choir, I might be able to experience singing with our group in this beautiful, natural place. Mahalo, Sylvia Partridge Director, The Hospice Choir, Kauai 3800 Kamehameha Rd., # 22 Princeville, ffl 96722 808-635-6415 February 9, 2021 Reyna Ramolete Hayashi The Trust for Public Land 1003 Bishop Street, Suite 740 Honolulu,Hawai'i 96813 Sara Bowen Malama Hule'ia P.0. Box 662092 Lihu'e, Hawai'i 96766 Re: Support for Malama Hule'ia and the Tmst for Public Land's efforts to Purchase and Protect Alakoko Fishpond in Niumalu and Ha'iku, Kaua'i Aloha, I, Kalikolehua Goo-Labuguen strongly supports The Tmst for Public Land and Malaina Hule'ia's efforts to protect and purchase the Alakoko Fishpond Property in Niumalu and Ha'iku, Kaua'i, also known as Menehune Fishpond. Protecting Alakoko would provide impactfiil community benefits: restoring a healthy watershed, river, and native wetland ecosystem; preserving a beloved cultural and historic site and an outdoor classroom for students to learn the science and technology ofHawaiian aquaculture; and increasing sustainable food production and food security for Kaua'i. As a Hawaiian-focused charter school teacher for over 14 years, I have witnessed the positive 'aina impact that (land)-based education can have on a child's educationaljourney. For the small Hawaiian-focused charter school at which I currently work, Alakoko has been influential in involving our students in stewardship towards the restoration of a functioning Hawaiian fish pond ecosystem. Alakoko provides a place in which students can engage in a variety of cultural practices and increase academic understanding, all while manifesting a kuleana (responsibility) to protect, sustain, and restore cultural traditions and places. Furthemiore, Alakoko has also been insU'umental in my efforts to develop Hawaiian culture-based mathematics curriculum, where students can develop mathematical comprehension relevant to their cultural practices and traditions. As my students are the ones who will carry-on the traditions oftheir ancestors, I have included a few oftheir voices in this letter oftestimony below. "Ina 'aole makou malama i na mea a na kupuna i kiikulu ai, 'a'ole e maopopo ana makou i ka 'ike o ko kakou mau kupuna."-M.A. 3rd grade "Ifwe don 't carefor things that were built by our ancestors, we will not have the knowledge of "- our ancestors. M.A. 3rd grade "He 'o kaiaulu Alalcoko. Hiki i na keiki ke a'o i ka alu like e kokua i ka loko i'a"-H.L. 4th grade "Alakoko is a community. We children can learn to worktogether andrestore theflshpond."- H.L. 4th grade "'Oiai malama 'ia ka loko i'a no kekahi wa, ua ho'i mai na meakanu a me na manu 'oiwi. 'Ike 'ana 'alae 'ula."-K.S-F. makou i ka ulu o ka makaloa a me ka 5th grade "Because -we started to carefor thefishpond, the native and birds have returned. We see 'ala'ulatoo.plants"-K.S-F. the makaloa plant/lourishing and the native Sthgrade "He waiwai keia loko 'i'a 'o Alakoko no na kanaka 'o Hawai'i. Ua malama 'ia na kupuna i ka loko i'a a malama ka loko i'a i na kupuna. Ua hanai 'ia keia wahi i ko makou mau kupuna, ina malama kakou i ka loko 'i'a, e hanai 'ia ana ka makou mau hanauna o Hawai'i. Pono kakou e malama i ko makou mau loko 'i'a o Hawai'i nei. Ina a'ohe loko 'i'a, a'ohe i'a, 'a'ohe meakanu, 'a'ohe hana ku'una no na kanaka. Loa'a ka 'ike Hawai'i ma ka loko 'i'a. 'O keia ko kakou aina, 'Alakoko!"-K.H-T. ko kakou wahi pana, ko makou mau a'a. E malama kakou ia 6th grade "Alakoko is an important place for native Hawaiians. Our ancestors caredfor thisplace, and in return they were caredfor by thisplace. This our ancestors and ifwe continue to care placefed 't, for it, it will feed future generations. We need to take action and carefor this place. Ifwe don we lose our nativefish, our native plants, and our traditions. The flsh pond gives us intelligence. This is our land, our sacredplace, ourroots. Weneedto carefor Alakoko!"-K.H-T. 6thgrade Should the property be sold to a private buyer, I fear that my students, and any keiki (children) will lose a classroom imperative to developing a relationship to their unique cultural traditions. Alakoko serves as a reminder ofhow our wahi pana (signifigant places) are vital to our children's future. I envsion Alakoko as a thriving ecosystem, where the next generation can connect to their cultural traditions while developing a relationship with this special place. Mahalo, Kalikolehua Goo-Labuguen Teacher PO BOX 880 Hanapepe,HI96716 808-652-8545 February 9, 2021 Reyna Ramolete Hayashi The Trust for Public Land 1003 Bishop Street, Suite 740 Honolulu, Hawaii 96813 Sara Bowen Malama h-lule'ia P.0. Box 662092 Lihu'e, Hawai'i 96766 Re: Support for Malama Hule'ia and the Trust for Public Land's efforts to Purchase and Protect Alakoko Fishpond in Niumalu and Ha'iku, Kaua'i. Aloha, My 'ohana and 1 strongly support The Trust for Public Land and Malama Hule'ia efforts to protect and purchase the Alakoko Fishpond Property in Niumalu and Ha'iku, Kaua'i, also known as Menehune Fishpond. Protecting Alakoko would provide impactful community benefits; restoring a healthy watershed, river, and native wetland ecosysterh; preserving a beloved cultural and historic site and an outdoor classroom for students to learn the science and technology of Hawaiian aquaculture; and increasing sustainable food production and food security for Kaua'i. 1 am also a teacher at Waimea High School where our mission is to provide an education in an environment conducive to learning, teaching, and growing so that all students become productive, responsible citizens and lifelong learners. 1 have taken my special education students in grades 9-12 to Alakoko Fishpond where they were able to see firsthand the positive impact a community has on the native and natural resources of a place. They were able to benefit from this place that holds so much history and knowledge which is essential for the keiki's of Kaua'i to know. It is so important that this aina-based learning environment be protected and restored so my keiki's at home and school have an opportunity to participate in a "loko 'ia", cultural practice learn about sustainable aquaculture, food production, and contribute to the native wetland habitat within our school and family lessons and projects. Mahalo nui, , Kealakai Lindsey-Meyer Waimea High School Teacher and Makua P.0. Box 357 Kalaheo, Hawai'i 96741 Kanieliamelia Scliools- February 6, 2021 Reyna Ramolete Hayashi The Trust for Public Land 1003 Bishop Street, Suite 740 Honolulu,Hawai'i96813 Sara Bowen MalamaHule'ia P.0. Box 662092 Lihu'e, Hawai'i 96766 Re: Support for Malama Hule'ia and the Trust for Public Land's efforts to Purchase and Protect Alakoko Fishpond in Niumalu and Ha'iku, Kaua'i Aloha, Kamehameha Schools strongly supports The Trust for Public Land and Malama Hule'ia's efforts to protect and purchase the Alakoko Fishpond Property in Niumalu and Ha'iku, Kaua'i, also known as Menehune Fishpond. Protecting Alakoko would provide impactful community benefits: restoring a healthy watershed, river, and native wetland ecosystem; preserving a beloved cultural and historic site and an outdoor classroom for students to learn the science and technology ofHawaiian aquaculture; and increasing sustainable food production and food security for Kaua'i. K.amehameha Schools' mission is to fulfill our founders, Ke Ali'i Pauahi's desire to create educational opportunities in perpetuity to improve the capability and well-being ofpeople of Hawaiian ancestry. Education has been the foundation of our organization since our inception, however, equally important has been the responsibility to steward our 'aina. During 2018, Kamehameha Schools Kaua'i region made the strategic decision to invest in Malama Hule'ia as a community partner. Together an MOA was executed with goals to extend and create long-lasting programs, curriculum, and virtual educational modules along with DOE schools in the Kaua'i complex. 'aina-based Kamehameha Schools knows that learning is a platform for all aspects oflearning from literacy and communication skills, to STEM and project managements, to history and political science, and beyond. In particular, Alakoko provides a unique foundation on Kaua i where 'oiwi learners can strengthen and deepen their identity, kuleana and capacity to become 'aina. local and global servant leaders tbrough Ifthe property were sold to a private buyer for high end residential or commercial use, this would be impossible. Alakoko is Kaua'i's largest loko i'a, a culturally, historially rich classroom and source of sustenance that should be protected and held in perpetuity for the fature kamali i ofKauai. Mahalo, 'm^^lt' Laurdn Nabine VP Strategy & Transformation 77/^ZA^ T^ua^s. T. Ka'eo Duarte VP Community & 'Aina Resiliency K.amehameha Schools 567 South King St. Suite 200 Honolulu.HI 96813 JenniferAcoba Marissa Ornellas & Ohana Ren Becker Brittny Perez Patricia Blair [email protected] Barbara Bradish Nicole Relacion Meredith Buck Sharnelle Renti Cruz Chuck Brady Puanani Rogers Aaron Char Leilea Satori Bill Collins [email protected] Brandi Corpuz Meg Schofield Helen Cox Aniel Shyles Collin Dana Susan Sobel Megan Deets Lee Anne Spencer Tiele-Lauren Doudt MaryC Summers Sasha Fernandes JimmyTrujillo Alberto T. Genovia Lori K Walker Kaniho Giminiz Maria Walker Kahealani Hamakua Kahiau Wallace Hui Aloha Kiholo Larry and Linda White Hui Malama Polihale Llewellyn Woodward Jessica Hyde Kealaonaona lopa Ke Kula Hoamana O Kawaikini Isaiah Kaauwai Amber Kaihenui Carol Lee Kamekona Tayler Kanoho Tanya Kapuy D. KaleKaui Daryl Keamoai Joni Keamoai Kilauea Neigh. Assoc. Tina Kinimaka Kelii Kotubetey Terry J Low Kainoa Lum Mariko Strickland Lum Makaloa CouncilofKCC Jerrae Manasas Kristie Matias Meghann Matsuda & Keive Kauakahi Alexis Miles "Ali" Alessandra Novak 3.a.V^. Duke Nakamatsu From: JenniferCole-Conner CAUTION: This email originated from outside the County ofKauai. Do not click links or open attachments even if the sender is known to you unless it is something you were expecting. Hi there, I am writing in support ofAlakoko fishpond preservation and protection ofthis amazing natural resource. Though I am not native Hawaiian, my husband and children are and I would like them to have the opportunity to visit this very special place and see the rare natiiral inhabitants, floral and fauna ofthis area. I strongly support the trust for public lands and Malama Huleia in their efforts to help the Kauai community purchase this property. I urge our county leaders, our county council, and other programs utilize whatever funds and actions are necessary to preserve this for Kauai's future keiki. Thank you, Jermifer Acoba Get Outlook for iOS Duke Nakamatsu From: K Becker CAUTION: This email originated from outside the County of Kauai. Do not click links or open attachments even if the sender is known to you unless it is something you were expecting. Aloha Commissioners, I sto-ongly support the The Trust for Public Land and Malama Huleia 's efforts to help the Kauai community purchase and protect the Alakoko Fishpond. Alakoko is a teacher and can teach about Hawaiian native/endemic wildlife and plants and the historical past and culture ofthe people ofKauai and the importance ofHawaiian values such as malama aina. Protecting Alakoko keeps this knowledge alive and future generations powerful with knowledge. I urge the Commission to renew their recommendation to County Council that Open Space funds be used to protect and acquire Alakoko Fishpond for community benefit. Sincerely, Ren Becker Duke Nakamatsu From: Patricia Blair CAUTION: Thisemailoriginatedfrom outsidetheCountyofKauai. Do not click links oropen attachments euen ifthe sender is known to you unless it is something you were expecting. Patricia Blair, Kailua Sent from my iPad Duke Nakamatsu From: Barbara Bradish CAUTION: This email originated from outside the County of Kauai. Do not click links or open attachments even if the sender is known to you unless it is something you were expecting. Aloha, 1 am in favor of the county acquiring the Alekoko Fish pond. This property has value historically and needs to be preserved for our community. The County Council has the authority to do so and should follow through with the funds allocated for this purpose. Mahalo, Barbara Bradish Duke Nakamatsu From: Meredith Buck CAUTION: Thisemail originated from outsidethe CountyofKauai. Do notclick links oropen attachments even ifthe sender is known to you unless it is something you were expecting. Aloha, MV name is Meredith Buck and 1 live in Kailua Kona. 1 am writing to express my interest in and support of the public acquisition of Alakoko Fish Pond. I've seen fish ponds in restoration here on Hawai'i Island and understand that protection under Public Access, Open Space, and Natural Resources Preservation Fund Commission would be supportive to the ecological and cultural value of such a site. Please consider my message of support as you convene around this issue onThursday. Mahalo nui loa for your time, Meredith Buck 96740 Duke Nakamatsu From: Brady, Chuck CAUTION: This email originated from outside the County of Kauai. Do not click links or open attachments even ifthe sender is known to you unless it is something you were expecting. Aloha Honorable Members ofthe Kauai Open Space Commission: 1 have been a resident of Kauai and an employee of the Kauai Marriott Resort & Beach Club since 1994. Over the past 25+ years, 1 have learned the history ofAlekoko Fishpond, have enjoyed the amazing sunsets from the Alekoko Lookout, taken visitors to the Alekoko lookout to admire Kauai's history, taken rest breaks during my runs (and now walks) at the Alekoko lookout, and kayaked up the Huleia River in awe of the history Alekoko Fishpond represents. Over the past 25+ years, 1 have truly enjoyed the Alekoko Fishond area. When my kids were in middle school, we began volunteering with Malama Huleia at Niumalu with the understanding that one day, the group would be behind the effort to remove the red mangrove from Alekoko. This past summer, my daughter, on her summer break between her junior and senior years of college, again volunteered with Malama Huleia, this time at Alekoko Fishpond! The Alekoko Fishpond is very special to me, and my family, as 1 know it is to many of Kauai's residents and visitors. In 2002, I voted in favor of establishing Kauai's Open Space and Natural Resources Preservation Fund. My hope, in 2002, was that this fund would be used to bring the treasures of Kauai, both natural & manmade, into the public realm so we, Kauai's current residents and Kauai's future residents would be able to enjoy them in perpetuity. While there are many places on Kauai that are deserving of Open Space Funds, 1 cannot prioritize any higher than The Alekoko Fishpond. We have before us a generational opportunity to add one of Kauai's most revered landmarks to the publicdomain. 1 hope you agree with me and will recommend to our County Council that Open Space Funds be used to acquire, and thereby protect for future generations, the beauty and history that is Alekoko Fishpond. Thank you for your service to Kauai, your time, and your consideration, Chuck Brady Director of Human Resources office 808.246.5186 [email protected] Kauai Marriott Resort and Beach Club 3610 Rice Street, Lihue, Hl 96766 www.kauaimarriott.com Xwm This communication contains Snformation from Marriott internattonaf, Snc. (Ritz-Carlton or Gaylord Hoteis as applicable^ that may be confidential. Exceptfor personal use by the intended redpient, or as expressly authonzed bythe sender, any person who recesves thss Jnformation is prohibited from disdosmg, copying, dsstnbuting, and/orusing st. ifyou have recesved thss communication m error, ptease immediately delete it and al! copies, and promptly notffy the sender. Nothing in this communication is intended to operate as an electronic signature under applicabie law. Duke Nakamatsu From: Aaron Char CAUTION: This email originated from outside the County of Kauai. Do not click links or open attachments even ifthe sender is known to you unless it is something you were expecting. Testimony In supportofagenda itemJ(2) Aloha,open space commission. l,Aaron Ekolu Char, residentofWaimea, Kaua'i,very much supportthetrustforpublic land and Malama Hule'ia. 1 believe they are an awesome non-profit organization that has the community's best interests (and support) in mind. 1 know iftheycan, and are ableto purchase Alakoko fishpond, theywill be responsible stewards ofthefishpond land and restorethe loko i'a and lo'i kalothatourancestors had there. 1 also believe thattheywill 'ike provide a lot of forfuture generations to come. Sent from my iPhone Duke Nakamatsu From: Bill Collins <[email protected]> Sent: Tuesday, February 9, 2021 7:17 PM To: Open Space Commission Subject: Testimony in Support of Agenda Item J(2) CAUTION: This email originated from outside the County ofKauai. Do not click links or open attachments even ifthe sender is known to you unless it is something you were expecting. Aloha, Commissioners: I strongly support The Trust for Public Land and Malama Hule'ia's efforts to help the Kaua'i Community purchase and protect Alakoko Fishpond. [Insertyour connection to Alakoko, the impact it has had on you, & why it should be protected.] I urge the Commission to renew their recomraendation to the County Council that Open Space Funds be used to protect and acquire Alakoko Fishpond for community benefit. Mahalo, BU1 Collins Koloa, Kauai [email protected] Duke Nakamatsu From: Brandi Corpuz CAUT10N: This email originated from outside the County of Kauai. Do not click links or open attachments even ifthe sender is known to you unless it is something you were expecting. Aloha, My name is Brandi Corpuzarid I am from Kihei Maui. 1 am in supportofthe Kauai communityto be ableto purchase and maintain thesevalued cultural and natural resources. I believethatthecommunitywill bethe beststewardsofthis land and should be given the opportunity to show the world how it can and should be done. This area is a valued treasure and I believethatallowingthe communityto takethis on astheirkuleana could be a shiningexampleofwhatcan "experts"to happen whenyou allowthe dothatworkthat needsto bedone. Thank you, Brandi Corpuz Sent from Mail for Windows 10 Duke Nakamatsu From: Helen Cox CAUTION: This email originated from outside the County ofKauai. Do not click links or open attachments even ifthe sender is known to you unless it is something you were expecting. Dear Open Space Commission, Please act quickly in securing open space funds to acquire Alekoko Loko I'a for our community and for future generations. Alekoko is an important, historical and culturally rich site that needs to be preserved in perpetuity for our island food security and cultural education. Thank you. Helen Cox Kalaheo Duke Nakamatsu From: Scott Sato Sent: Tuesday, February 9, 2021 1:14 PM To: Kaaina Hull; Nani Sadora; Duke Nakamatsu Subject: FW: Please preserve Alekoko From; Collin CAUTION: This email originated from outside the County ofKauai. Do not click Unks or open attachments even ifthe sender is known to you unless it is something you were expecting. Dear Open Space Commission, please make sure that this priceless piece of history and culture is protected,for the sake ofgenerationsyettocome, and in the honorofthose long past. Mahalo~ ~Collin Dana PO Box 1329 Lawai, Hl 96765 Duke Nakamatsu From: Megan Deets CAUTION: This email originated from outside the County ofKauai. Do not click links or open attachments even ifthe sender is known to you unless it is something you were expecting. Aloha. I m writing to state my support of the Open Space Commission s acquisidon ofAlakoko Fishpond. Alakoko is a culturally rich site that should be preserved for the native Hawaiian people and for the perpetuation oftheir culture. My children are descendants of native Hawaiians and I hope Alakoko will be a place they can access and help to malama throughout theif lifetimes. Mahalo, Megan Deets Duke Nakamatsu From: Tiele Doudt CAUTION: This email originated from outside the County ofKauai. Do not click links or open attachments even ifthe sender is known to you unless it is something you were expecting. 9 February 2021 E na komikina no Kaua'i nui kuapapa, aloha nui no kakou. My name is Tiele-Lauren Doudt and I strongly support the mission ofTrust for Public Land in 'Alekoko partnership with Malama Hule'ia to preserve the area encompassing fishpond, located in the Niumalu ahupua'a of Kaua'i. I do truly believe that any investment that the County Council is to use with Open Space funding would return to the resident Kaua'i community tenfold. Although my mother and grandmother raised me in Kilauea, my father spent most ofhis teenage years living in Niumalu, surfing and fishing in the KalapaKi area. When I reached intermediate school, I was sent to Kamehameha Schools Kapalama and graduated from there as a boarding student from the island of Kaua'i. Immediately thereafter, I attended the University of Hawai'i at Manoa on O'ahu, gaining two Bachelor ofArts degrees in Hawaiian Studies and Hawaiian Language, and later a Master ofArts degree in Hawaiian Studies. After more than a decade spent on O'ahu, I was finally ready to return home to re-engage with the communities that had fed and raised me as a child. Last year, a few months after coronavirus hit Hawai'i, I was brought on as an intern at Malama Hule'ia through a partnership with Huliauapa'a and AmeriCorps Hawai'i. My position focuses mostly on education, research, and community outreach - our most recent project includes designing a virtual fishpond curriculum in partnership with the Kamehameha Schools Kealapono Division. In the past few months spent learning and training with Peleke Flores and Sara Bowen, it has become eloquently clear that their leadership is more than capable of ensuring that 'Alekoko is held in perpetuity as an significant community outlet. From an educational standpoint, there might arguably be no other kuapa fishpond as famous and storied on our island of Kaua'i. Furthermore, restoring its production capabilities as a fishery will also contribute significantly to local food sustainability, economic growth and stimulation, as well as insight pride upon Native Hawaiian fishing communities throughout Hawai'i. I sincerely urge the Commission to renew their recommendation to County Council that Open 'Alekoko Space funds be used to protect and acquire fishpond for community benefit. Mahalo, Tiele-Lauren Doudt tiele(c)malamahuleia.org Tiele-Lauren Doudt Na Kama a Ha'upu Intern 'Alekoko Malama Hule'ia | Fishpond Duke Nakamatsu From: [email protected] Sent: Wednesday, February 10, 2021 9:00 AM To: Open Space Commission Subject: Testimony in Strong Support ofAgenda item J2 CAUTION: This email originated from outside the County ofKauai. Do not click links or open attachments even ifthe sender is known to you unless it is something you were expecting. Aloha 1 strongly support the Trust for Public Land and Malama Huleia's efforts to help the Kauai community purchase and protecfthe Alakoko Fishpond. Mahalo, Sasha Fernandes Ahupuaa Puna O Kaua'i organization February 9, 2021 Reyna Ramolete Hayashi The Trust for Public Land 1003 Bishop Street, Suite 740 Honolulu, Hawai'i96813 Sara Bowen Malama Hule'ia P.0. Box 662092 Lihu'e, Hawai'i 96766 Re: Support for Malama Hule'ia and the Trust for Public Land's efforts to Purchase and Protect Alakoko Fishpond in Niumalu and Ha'iku, Kaua'i Aloha, Ahupuaa Puna o Kaua'i organization strongly supports The Trust for Public Land and Malama Hule'ia's efforts to protect and purchase the Alakoko Fishpond Property in Niumalu and Ha'iku, Kaua'i, also known as Menehune Fishpond. Protecting Alakoko would provide impactful community benefits: restoring a healthy watershed, river, and native wetland ecosystem; preserving a beloved cultural and historic site and an outdoor classroom for students to learn the science and technology of Hawaiian aquaculture; and increasing sustainable food production and food security for Kaua'i. Ahupuaa puna o Kaua'i orgs: is to establish a healthy, sustainable watershed for future generations to enjoy. Ahupuaa from the mountain to the sea is the protection our island place of Hawaiian life style like Alakoko Fishpond? What ever is relative, that is generated from the heavens is our relationship of stewardship with Malama Hule'ia, Ahupuaa Puna o Kaua'i org: was created to provide these opportunities for ancient innovative Integrated farming systems, which included aquaculture, arose on Kauai with the help of local community from near by, these on-island projects in the areas of small business, technology, transportation, agriculture, local manufacturing, circular economy and tourism that contribute toward both short and long term economic development. This supports the County's long term vision for a more economically diverse and sustainable future in generating long term economic growth and diversification in Kauai County. It's an ancient registered historical site and has always provide sustenance for our culture community and families of Kaua'i. It's an injustice industry of greed and corruption of ownership and negative practices of occupation! We have recreated through our community stewardship practices for this illegal practice of occupation of HA'OLE organizations take over to this benefit for greed and corruption. Alakoko 'aina-based Fishpond being protected restored, and stewarded bythe communityfor education, Hawaiian cultural practice, sustainable aquaculture, food production, and as a native wetland habitat for fish and endangered water birds? Our organization's vision or wish for the property? Is stop this desecration to cultural stewardship practices of this place once known as paradise. Mahalo, Alberto T Genovia CEO.Ahupuaa Puna o Kaua'i organization 4432 lliwai street, lihue, Hawaii 96766 Phone number: 808-652-3760 Duke Nakamatsu From: Niho G CAUTION: This email originated from outside the County ofKauai. Do not click links or open attachments even ifthe sender is known to you unless it is something you were expecting. Febmary 9, 2021 Re: Support for Malama Hule'ia and the Trust for Public Land's efforts to Purchase and Protect Alakoko Fishpond in Niumalu and Ha'iku, Kaua'i Aloha, I, Kaniho (Randell) Giminiz strongly support The Trust for Public Land and Malama Hule'ia's efforts to protect and purchase the Alakoko Fishpond Property in Niumalu and Ha'iku, Kaua'i, also known as Menehune Fishpond. Protectmg Alakoko would provide impactful community benefits: restoring a healthy watershed, river, and native wetland ecosystem;preserving a beloved cultural and historic site and an outdoor classroom for students to learn the science and technology ofHawaiian aquacultiire; and increasing sustainable food production and food security for Kaua'i. Ifthis is being read... I'd like to extend a mahalo nui to you all and appreciate you folks taking time to do the work. Although I hold no title's that bear any weight, I felt led to share as a cultural practitioner and someone who was able to actually put my hands in the ground there. A few of us were given an amazing opportunity through the Aloha Aina Workforce Program to experience Ka loko i'a 'o Alakoko and all its lessons. Although 'ike short, the gained from being in the space will forever be with me. That, is due to the fishpond and all things that dwell there both physically and spiritually. I couldn't see any positive things coming out from allowingjust anyone to purchase it. Unless said person, organization, ete. has an understanding for the importance ofthis place and basically Hawaiian culture or at least the idea of sustainable living. Ancient places like these I feel are what our people used to cultivate aloha. The process of working and maintaining these wahi, plus the amount of lessons to be leamed and shared is how I feel you would enforce aloha. Notjust anyone should be able to control that or even change it. Alakoko is an amazing teacher and teaching tool. Also, it's a big cooler that holds food. Real food, spiritual food too. For us, for all the flora and fauna, and even our kupuna alive and for those past. Please don't allowjust anyone to have it. I would just like to continue to kokua and not lose an amazing resource. Mahalo Nui for your time. Blessings on you all. Kaniho Giminiz P.0. Box 3937 Lihue, HI96766 cel:(808)634-1889 Get Outlook for iOS Duke Nakamatsu From: Kahealani Hamakua CAUTION: This email originated from outside the County ofKauai. Do not click links or open attachments even ifthe sender is known to you unless it is someflung you were expecting. Aloha to whom it may concern, Please see my Support for Malama Hule'ia and the Trust for Public Land's efforts to Purchase and Protect Alakoko Fishpond in Niumalu and Ha'iku, Kaua'i Testimonial Letter attached to this email. Mahalo nui for your time and consideration, Kahealani Hamakua February 10,2021 Reyna Ramolete Hayashi The Trust for Public Land 1003 Bishop Street, Suite 740 Honolulu,Hawai'i96813 Sara Bowen Malama Hule'ia P.0. Box 662092 Lihu'e, Hawai'i 96766 Re: Support for Malama Hule'ia and the Trust for Public Land's efforts to Purchase and Protect AIakoko Fishpond in Niumalu and Ha'ikii, Kaua'i Aloha, My name is Isaiah Ka'auwai, and I strongly support The Trust for Public Land and Malama Hule'ia's efforts to protect and piu-chase the Alakoko Fishpond Property in Niumalu and Ha'iku, Kaua'i, also known as Menehune Fishpond. Protecting Alakoko would provide impactful community benefits: restoring a healthy watershed, river, and native wetland ecosystem; preserving a beloved cultural and historic site and an outdoor classroom for students to learn the science and technology ofHawaiian aquaculture; and increasing sustainable food production and food security for Kaua'i. I personally support the Malama Huleia group as a community member because ofthe hard work and numerous hours that the hui has put in to restore that area for now and into the future generations. The hui provides educational, Hawaiian cultural information and practices that our kupuna can be very proud of. I have volunteered a few times and what I have done is nothing compared to what this has committed and one over the last several They are very group 'ohana,years. focused and hospitable to all who come to volunteer. They project laulima, kokua, hanalima, oia i o,, and they feed you, too. The negative impact in selling the property to buyers generally leads to and 'aina. private greed, profit more destmction ofour It also impacts property values that are already sky-high and would continue to make it unaffordable for local people. Same old story! I am employed at Kaua'i Community College and have had the opportunity to volunteer at Niumalu and Alakoko. Also, I do know that our students have had the same opportunity to "give volunteer over the last several years. As most students know, it is one opportunity to back to our Kaua'i community; yet, in their giving back, they receive mo'olelo ofthe area and for some, learn new skills even ifit's pulling invasives. Yes, there are other sites such as Waipa which I enjoy and have volunteered there as well. I know there are other sites in Waimea as well 'ohana, where students and others can kokua and give back but also learn about the place and try to envision how our kupuna thrived without technology and machinery although it doesn't hurt to have those. I envision that the area remain with the hui because of their commitment to stewarding the property. I have heard that some organizations have/or would like to implement an ecotourism program for their projects/business. Ifthis can help to sustain the area, I support it. I truly believe that the hui will make the best decisions for the property. Mahalo nui for allowing me to share. Isaiah Ka'auwai 4550 Mamane St. Kapaa,HI 96746 KAWAIKl N1 9, Pepeluali, 2021 Reyna Ramolete Hayashi The Trust for Public Land 1003 Bishop Street, Suite 740 Honolulu,Hawai'196813 Papa3 Ke Kula Ho'amana o Kawaikini (Kawaikini NCPCS) 3-1821 Kaumualii Hwy, Lihue, HI 96766 Re: Support for Malama Hule'ia and the Tmst for Public Land's efforts to Purchase and Protect Alakoko Fishpond in Niumalu and Ha'iku, Kaua i Aloha, 'O 'o makou ka papa 3 o ke kula Kawaikini, kako'o piha makou i ka mana'o o The Trust for Public Land a me Malama Hule'ia. We strongly support The Trust for Public Land and Malama Hule'ia's efforts to protect and purchase the Alakoko Fishpond Property in Niumalu and Ha'iku, Kaua'i, also known as Menehune Fishpond. Protecting Alakoko would provide impactful community benefits: restoring a healthy watershed, river, and native wetland ecosystem; preserving a beloved cultural and historic site and an outdoor classroom for students to learn the science and technology ofHawaiian aquaculture; and increasing sustainable food production and food security for Kaua'i. 'O makou ka Papa 'Ekolu o ke kula ho'amana 'o Kawaikini. He kula 'olelo Hawai i o Kawaikini a kupa'a makou ma hope o ka 'olelo makuahme o keia 'aina a me ka 'ike kupuna o ko 'O "Me 'ike kakou lahui Hawai'i. ko makou ala nu'ukia o keia kula, ka pa'a ma ka kupuna ma 'olelo 'o ka Hawai'i, e malama ai ke kula Kawaikini (M-12) i kaiapuni kako'o a i kaiapuni a'o, ma ka 'olelo Hawai'i a me ka 'olelo Pelekania no ho'i, kahi e minamina, ho'ohana, a ho'omau 'ia ai no ho'i ka 'ike ku'una 'oiwi". Pili ko makou ala nu'ukia ia Alakoko, no ka mea, 'o Alakoko kahi 'ike ku'ima 'oiwi i malama 'ia e na kupuna. Ma ka makahiki nei, ua hele makou i Alakoko e a'o i na mea like 'ole i laila. Ma ko makou kula, ho'omahele 'ia na moku 5 o Kaua'i mawaenao nahaumEuiapapamalaa'o a ikekulaki'eki'e. Ma keia wa, aia makou ma ka Papa 'Elua a na makou a me ka Papa 'Ekahi ka mea e a'o i ka moku 'o Puna. Aia 'o Alakoko ma ke ahupua'a o Ha'ikii ma ka moku o Puna, no laila, ua huaka'i pinepine makou i laila a a'o i na mea like 'ole e like me na i'a, na manu, na meakanu 'oiwi a me na meakanu 'oiwi ole. Eia ko makou mana'o e pili ana i keia wahi 'O pana: Alakoko, he loko i'a, noho na i'a ma ka loko i'a, he pahu hau ka loko i'a no na kanaka o keia 'aina. 'Ai na kanaka i ka i'a, hopu 'ia ka i'a ma ka loko i'a ina makemake na kanaka e 'ai. Ina malama kakou i ka loko i'a, e malama ana kakou i na kanaka mai keia wa a me na kanaka ma ka wa e hiki mai ana. Ina 'a'ole kakou malama i ka loko i'a, 'a'ohe i'a, ina 'a'ohe i'a, 'a'ohe mea'ai no na kanaka. Ma ko makou wa i huaka'i ai i Alakoko, ua huki makou i ka mangrove he nui, he meakanu i ho'omake i na meakanu 'oiwi ka mangrove, 'a'ole kupono keia 'ano meakanu no na meakanu 'oiwi e like me ka 'a'awa. Ma kekahi huaka'i 'e a'e i Alakoko, ua kanu makou i ka a awa, nui na mea 'oiwi ma keia wahi. Pono makou e malama a ho'opalekana i keia mau mea no na wa e hiki mai ana. 'ana Hanai ka loko i'a i na kanaka, he mea nui ka malama i keia wahi pana i mea e a'o ai i na keiki ma ka wa e hiki mai ana. E malama ho'i kakou i ka loko i'a i mea e malama ai ia kakou,na kanakaho i. Mahalo nui loa no ka heluhelu 'ana i ka makou leka kako'o. Na makou me ka mahalo, Ka Papa Ekolu o Kawaikini 'o Ke Kula Ho'amana Kawaikini (Kawaikini NCPCS) 3-1821 Kaumualii Hwy, Lihue, HI 96766 Duke Nakamatsu From: Nahaku Kalei CAUTI01>T: This email originated from outside the County ofKauai. Do not click links or open attachments even ifthe sender is known to you unless it is something you were expecting. Aloha mai kakou, Please find the attached document in support ofthe purchase and protection ofAlakoko fishpond. Mahalo nui loa, Nahaku Kalei Executive Director [email protected] 808-313-0765 Hui ffhha.Tdholo www.Kiholo.org On Fri, Feb 5, 2021 at 5:33 PM Brenda Asuncion Aloha e na hoa loko i'a, 'ohana Hope this message finds you and your healthy and in good spirits!!! I fcnow it's a Friday evening so also hoping you are heading into a restful weekend:) This email is about Alakoko fishpond on Kaua'i, and an effort to acquire and protect it. (The last kahea like this for Wailau was less than 12 months ago, and that gives me a good feeling that there continues to be growing interest and opportunity to malama loko i a in this way!) Malama Hule'ia (Sara and Peleke) and the Trust for Public Land (Reyna copied here) are partnering to try to purchase and protect Alakoko. The owners recently listed the property for sale, and ifit's sold, Malama Hule'ia's lease could be temiinated. Our shared hope is to return the fishpond to the community through ownership by Malama Hule'ia for fishpond and wetland restoration, education, and to grow fish and feed the community for generations to come. They are applying for funding through the County's Open Space Fund, the State Legacy Land Conservation Program, the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, and other private foundations. First up is a presentation before the Comitv Open Space Commission on Thurs. Februarv 11 . 2021 at 9:30 am. Letters of support and testimony are very compelling for decision makers who decide how to allocate these funds. A support letter template, factsheet and map are attached for more info. The letter is addressed to TPL and MH so it can be for multiple purposes. We know it's a tight turnaround, but ifcan, could you send a letter by Tues Feb 9? You can send to me to pass on, or include their gang copied here. I'd imagine the most interesting and impactful statements continue to be about how important your loko is for 'aina your commuiiity, and also how you think Alakoko is a part ofthe movement across the pae to revive people and food in these spaces. Mahalo nui for considering this kahea!! Aloha no, b and all us guys at KUA ^;i|t4:^^4:^;^;^!(!^:^!!}<^;^;^^;)j;^;^;^:)|t^}i!>|;S|;S{!!}(s|;^^;^;^^;^;^;^t^: Brenda Asuncion, Hui Malama Loko I'a Coordinator (808) 291-2340, [email protected] "As 'a a result ofparticipating m hw gatherings, I've increased my knowledge and confidence in restoring hko i andfmding ways to support the hui collectively. - Participanl at 261S Hui MSlaina Loko I'a ea_fhermz Kua aina Ulu Auamo (K.UA), grassroots gj-owing throagh shared responsibifity www.kuaiiawaii.ore c/o KEY Project 47-200 Waihe'e Road Kane'ohe,m 96744 ^Ut Our mfssion isto protect, perpetuate and preservethe cultura! and natural landscape ofthe Kiholo Bay area through collaborative management and actlve communitystewardship. February 9th, 2021 Kauai Planning Reyna Ramolete Hayashi Sara Bowen & Peleke Flores Department TheTrustfor Public Land Malama Hule'ia [email protected] [email protected] [email protected] [email protected] Re: Support for Malama Hule'ia and the Trust for Public Land's efforts to Purchase and Protect Alakoko Fishpond in Niumalu and Ha[iiku,::Kaua'i Aloha mai kakou, Hui Aloha KIholostronglysupportsTheTrustfor Public Land's and Malama Hule'ia'seffortsto protect and purchase Alakoko fishpond in Niumalu and h-la'iku, Kaua'i. Just as h-lule'ia river brings freshwater and life to our lands and waters, Alakoko fishpond brings life to the people of Hawai i as a living, breathing cultural kipuka. Hui Aloha KTholo is a 501(c)(3) non-profit organization whose missions is to preserve, protect, and enhancethe cultural and natural landscapeofthe KTholo bayarea through collaborative managemenf and active community stewardship. Our stewardship of KIholo bay,;North Kona, Hawaii Island.through a Curatorship agreementwith Hawaii Division ofState ParRs has resulted in over a decadeofcare ofover 2,000 acres ofcoastline at a levfel far beyond whatfhe State could have done on its own. The benefits to KTholo's cultural an;d natBral resourcesj'lineal descendants, families, community,visitors, and partners have been im-mensg, and we gladly anticipate similar fruitsofthis URComii-ig MH -TPLcollaboratiein. KTholo is also home to a loko pu'uone, Ka Loko o KTholo. HAKworks in close par]tnership with the Nature Conservancy to restore the fishpond, and has witnessed first-hand the positive impact of these hana maika'i (good works). Thefollowing highliightsthe main reasons HuiAloha KIholosupportsa conservation purchase and permanent protection ofAlakokofishpond: • Protects a treasure ofHawaiian culture.There is no pono (proper) higher utilization ofthis land than its return to community ownership, and its restoration as a thriving fishpond. • Enablestheconnection of, and activestewardship by, lineal descendants, knowledgeable 'aina kupuna, and malama (stewards) oftoday and tomorrow. • Stands as a modern example offood production and development which enhances rather than depletes natural resources. Functioning fishponds require a deep knowledge of ecology as well as ecological integrity, which supports watershed restoration efforts, and provides prime native habitat for fish, limu (seaweed), endangered Hawaiian water birds, and coastal vegetation. • Symbolizes cultural identity & pride. Built hundreds ofyears ago, the foundations of Alakoko fishpond represent a marvel of kupuna engineering, which is continuously revealed to those who work the land. • Createsa networkofconnected habitatas itsits adjacentto Hule'ia National Wildlife Refuge. P.0. Box 1868 | Kamuela, Hl 96743 j www.huialuhakiholo.org Our mission isto protect, perpetuate and preservethe cuitural and natural landscape ofthe KTholo Bay area through coflaborative management and active communitystewardship. Hui Aloha KTholo commends and mahalo's Malama Hule'ia for the important work they do. Their track record speaks to passionate dedication to place and community. In an era of population explosion, urban expansion, and mass species extinction, it is more important than ever to create 'aina spaces such as Alakoko fishpond where malama efforts restore the vibrancy of people and place. Hui Aloha KTholo urgesyou to support Malama Hule'ia and theTrustfor Public Land in the successful completion ofthis land acquisition and protection. Mahalo nui loa, tOKis^o Nahaku Kalei Executive Director, Hui/^l@ha Kiholo P.0. Box 1868 [ Kairiuela, Hl 96743 | www.huiaiohakiholo.org From: QnceiagDl@gmail,cpm To: Sara Bowen; Reyna Ramolete; Peleke Flores Subject; [External] Support forAlakoko Fishpond Oate: Tuesday, February 9, 2021 9:43;34 PM . CA1^][jG|^:'%s,ematl:originated^'©|^^^ ^attaclim^t&|tffilegs^||ure(;ogru •::^^. Aloha to you, o Cherished Members of great organizations aimed to keep our Hawaiian Culture intact and progressing oiir Keiki to become the Masters ofNature. Mahalo for your focus and effort to keep the Vision going. Aloha, my name is Daryl Hoku Keamoai and I'm a great friend and supporter ofPeleke Flores and the things that he is doing in the community and on this island ofKaua'i. Although we have never met, Sarah and Reyna, I am honored to be writing this letter in support ofwhat you are doing for the island ofKaua'i and our People. Mahalo nui. 'Aina, I am in support ofyour principles ofMalama respecting Nature and taking in what it abundantly offers. I am in support ofyour principles ofbuilding with our Keiki on the sturdy foundation that our Kupuna have laid down. I am in support of your Vision of sustain ability ofnot only our physical place but our mental and spiritual place as well. Our principles seem to be aligned perfectly. In a turbulent time such as today where ideals and principles are challenged, I know that one thing remains true for us: That if we do no thing, especially about Alakoko Fishpond, then it is not only we who live with the consequences, it is our Keiki and our Mo'opuna who will defmitely feel its generational effects. Mahalo, Mahalo, Mahalo. Aloha, Daryl Hoku Keamoai onceago 1 @gmail.com (702) 408-8746 Duke Nakamatsu From: Keli'i Kotubetey CAUTION: This email originated from outside the County ofKauai. Do not click links or open attachments even ifthe sender is known to you unless it is something you were expecting. Aloha, PIease accept my letter of support for TPL scad Malama Huleia's efforts to purchase the Alakoko Fishpond property. Thank you, Keli'i Kotubetey Assistant Executive Director Paepae o He'eia PO BOX 6355 Kane-ohe, HI 96744 808-236-6178 www.paepaeoheeia.org fiS - e'eia 1-le'eia Fishpoiid, He'eui O'ahu February 10,2021 Reyna Ramolete Hayashi The Trust for Public Land 1003 Bishop Street, Suite Honolulu, Hawai'i 96813 Sara Matama Hul&ia P.0. Box 662092 Lihu'e, Hawat'l 96766 Re: Support for Malama Hule'ia and the Trust for Public Land's efforts to Purchase and Protecf Alakako Fishpond in Niumalu and Ha'iku, Kaua'i Aloha, Paepae o He'eiastrongiy supportsThe Trust forPublioLand and Malama Hule'la's • efforts to protect and purchase Ihe AlakakoFishpOnd Property inNlumalu andHa'iku, t. Paepae o He'eia is a community-bassd non-profil organi.zatton founded in 2001 to maiama He'eia Fishpond alang Ihe shores of Kane'ohe Bay on O'ahu. It is an 800-year olct fishpond and is currently the second largest sctive flshpond in Hawai'i at 88 acres in size. The mission of our organization is to utlllze the lessons and teachingsfrom our loko i'a to provlds physlcal, intellectual, and spiritual susfenance for ourcommunities, With humble beginnings nearly 20 years ago, wa have grown to tlie point where we provide regulsr employmBnt for 10 people ahd, in pre-pandemic times, hosted over 10,000 volunteers and learnsrs on our slte every year. tll.' ¥», '^ - A crffical part ofour organizatlon's success overlheyears has been the support and inspiration from our networks of like minded kia'i loko (fishpond guardians) across the pae'aina. These acts of kokua somatinnfis are as simple as a shared curriculum for fishpond visils or contacls for purchasing fishpond tools or o(f (chants) and mete (songs) ;s-: composed to help breathe life into our Othsrtimes the support has come in the ponds. ^"fW-V ^ form of50+ skilled fishpond workers helping to rebuild parts ofthe tospa (fishpond wall) t -*,..!.... > overthe GOLtrseofafewdays. Espeeiallyforsmallerandgrowingfishpondrestoration e'Bbrts, thesafomiaofaupport both big and small are immensely Importantto the sustalnabiltty and coinmunity impaGtofthelr programs. Our organizatlon has definitely benefited from these acts ofkokua and we are committad to su|3portlng all flshpond eflbrts aeross ths pae'aina iBoluding Malama Hule'ia's vision ofa revitalized Alak&ho Flshpond. Alakoko Fishpand is truly a Jewel among our Hawaiian fishponds in tsrms of tts jBneatogY, atoried histoty, and unjque oonslruction. It Is our wish that Alakoko Fishpond 'ffl,-, remaln in the hands of thosfl who not only wish to preserva Itbut those who wish to fe-* perpetuate its uniqueness thru a^lye stewardship and management. As we have seen in many other fishpond projects around the islands, the Gommtinities atound the ponds thrive as they sre put bask into production. The blological communfties inetudlng native birds, fish, and plantsthrive and repopulatethe areas cteared ofinvasive species. The human communities thriva as they regain sn appreclation for and ttevelop deep connections with their storied tandscape. The spiritual comffiunities thrive as aur kupuna, 'v.i who still dwell around these places reafnrmthe good work belng done through positlve 'alna ho'ailona (signs). Ashisttirian Samuel Kamakau noted In 1869, an (tand) with 'aina flshponds is Known as momona (fertile land) and we know that protection of Alakoko Fishponii witlmoveus eloser tothat end. •^' Kell'iKotubetey Assistant Executive Director Paepae o HB'eia PO Box 6355 Kane'ohe, H1 96744 keliil@>pa8Daeoheeia.or< Ph: 808-236.6178 Duke Nakamatsu From: Scott Sato Sent: Tuesday, February9, 2021 10:31 PM To: Kaaina Hull; Duke Nakamatsu; Nani Sadora Subject: Fwd: Protect Alekoko (Menehune) Fishpond Scott K. Sato Office ofthe County Clerk | Council Services Division 4396 Rice Street, Suite 209 | Lihu'e, HI 96766 Phone: (808) 241-4810 | Fax: (808)241-6349 From: Kirstie Matias CAUTION: This email originated from outside the County ofKauai. Do not click links or open attachments even ifthe sender is known to you unless it is something you were expecting. Aloha e Open Space Commission, 'ohana. For many generations people of Hawai'i have depended on tourism to provide for their We have relied on the industry to stimulate our incomes and sustain our households. In this time of a pandemic, where no one is able to travel, tourism is NOT reliant or a dependable industry for Hawai'i. What does sustain our families? Food that comes from the land and knowledge that is shared through education. I believe that the restoration 'aina, program at Hule'ia encourages not only a healthy family and community but a healthy mind, body and soul. 'ike Saving Alakoko for our generations to come will ensure food security and for all who live and visit Kaua i. It is a sacred place and should be respected as so. Mahalo nui for your time and consideration, Pi'ikea Matias Vice President Hui Malama Polihale Duke Nakamatsu From: Jessica Hughes CAUTION: This email originated from outside the County ofKauai. Do not click links or open attachments even ifthe sender is known to you unless it is something you were expecting. Aloha, I was bom and raised on kaua'i and have known about the fish pond my whole life but not to muchjust to stay out and the menehunes built it. You could never see into the fish pond from the river mangroves took over the historic wall and blocked any and all Entrances to the pond for people and fish. So people didn't really Acknowledge it much. The invasive plants continued to seal the pond offfrom the main river and the mangroves slowly creeping into both sides ofthe river making it narrower and cutting offaccess to water making it stagnant and inaccessible in certain areas. My family goes crabbing down the river and catehes the purple Samoan crabs and enjoys the beautiful river. Since they have started the project they have seen a remarkable increase in fish population and they have removed thousands ofpounds ofinvasive species. They've discovered many fresh water springs and other fish ponds. That may connect to more historic discoveries ofancient Hawaiian civilizations. Looking at the fish pond from The top you can see the hard work sweat and love put into this place. They are doing this for there community, culture and ancestors. It is a way for community s or corporations to come together and work on something they are all Connected to. It is one ofthe main tourist attractions and look outs on the island, the first place most stop on the way to and from The airport it should be taken care of. It is so much more than a fish pond! It is culture, appreciation, passion and history. It is absolutely incredible and I hope I can be a part ofthere amazing team. one day. I have never worked on the fish pond but watehing and hearing through the coconut wireless and social media led me to writing this novel to you. It is important for our community It must continue and should have more support. Mahalo, Jessica Hyde Duke Nakamatsu From: Kealaonaona lopa CAUTION: This email originated from outside the County ofKauai. Do not click links or open attachments even ifthe sender is known to you unless it is something you were expecting. To: openspace(S),kauai.gov Fr: Kealaonaona lopa, kealaonaona.iopa@,gmail.com Subject: Testimony in SUPPORT ofAgenda Item J(2) Aloha, Commissioners: I sti'ongly support The Trust for Public Land and Malama Hule'ia's efforts to help the Kaua'i Community purchase and protect Alakoko Fishpond. I grew up here learning the verbal history of this place and would love to continue to tell it to generations to come. I urge the Cormnission to renew their recomniendation to the County Council that Open Space Funds be used to protect and acquire Alakoko Fishpond for community benefit. Duke Nakamatsu From: Amber Kaihenui CAUTION: This email originated from outside the County of Kauai. Do not click links or open attachments even ifthe sender is known to you unless it is something you were expecting. Aloha, Commissioners: 1 strongly support The Trust for Public Land and Malama Hule'ia's efforts to help the Kaua'i Community purchase and protect Alakoko Fishpond. 'Aina It is our duty as kanaka to gain knowledge, share, and educate our future leaders to protect our and cultural traditions. It's more than just a pond, it's our lifeline. I urge the Commission to renew their recommendation to the County Council that Open Space Funds be used to protect and acquire Alakoko Fishpond for community benefit. Mahalo, Amber Kaihenui ams [email protected] Oahu resident Duke Nakamatsu From: carol lee kamekona CAUTION: This email originated from outside the County of Kauai. Do not click links or open attachments even if the sender is known to you unless it is something you were expecting. Aloha Commissioners, 1 appreciate you convening this meeting to discuss this very important matter before you. The purchase ofAlakoko "Menehune" Fishpond. A 600 year old treasure filled with so much history which in my belief needs to be preserved. The culture and traditions 'aina. ofthe indigenous peoples ofthis 'aina Across our ko pae there are other opportunities such as this, whereby you could be the precedent setter. You could start the Ball rolling by saying....WE will protect and preserve this treasure now and forever for all of Hawai'i nei. 'ia Currently we have a hui in Kula Kai Maui that is restoring our loko (fishpond). 1 hope the collaboration between huis allows for the continued support of perpetuating the history and culture of our host peoples....Kanaka Maoli. 1H 'ia 1 am in support of the purchase in perpetuity of Alakoko Loko and 1 hope you are too. Mahalo for considering my testimony. Ke aloha nui, Carol Lee Kamekona Sent from my iPhone Duke Nakamatsu From: Tayler Kanoho CAUTION: This email originated from outside the County of Kauai. Do not click links or open attachments even ifthe sender is known to you unless it is something you were expecting. Aloha corrunissioners, I strongly support the trust for public land and malama Hule'ia's efforts to help the Kaua'i community purchase and protect Alakoko Fishpond. As a 10 year 5th grade teacher, now teaching at Kapa'a Elementary, I have always tried to integrate cultural education into my curriculum. I have 4 major science domains to teach, fishponds have helped me to teach both Earth and Space and Life and environmental science standards. For years I used O'ahu's He'eia Fishpond as a model to teach every science standard in those domains. But I was never able to take my students there, to really Kilo (observe) in person. We relied on videos and pictures. Over the past two years, we have been blessed with the opportunity to yisit Alakoko on our very own island. I cannot tell you how much of a difference it has made in my students understanding ofthe concept, and more importantly fostering deep connections to our 'Aina. After introducing fishpond ecosystems and exploring vocabulary in class, we actually visit the pond. That is where the aha moments hit. They get to see it, touch it, feel it! They kilo, observe, Talk about what wonderings they have, ask questions and then go out and FIND their own answers. We work on site, get dirty, and learn by 'Ike. 'ohana doing. Ma ka Hana ka My students then get right to work on their projects, constmcting their very own 3D models ofaloko i'a, making sure they include science terms such as producers and consumers. Along with 'Ike Hawai'i terms like balance, harmony, and kuleana. It is our kuleana to perpetuate our culture. It is our kuleana to prepare our keiki for the future. In the right hands, Alakoko can help us to fulfill that Kuleana. Alakoko is the heart and soul of my science curriculum. Please help us to keep it that way. I urge the commission to renew their recommendation to county council that open space funds be used to protect and acquire Alakoko Fishpond for community benefit. Duke Nakamatsu Froin: Scott Sato Sent: Tuesday, February 9, 2021 2:21 PM To: Kaaina Hull; Duke Nakamatsu; Nani Sadora Subject: FW: Protect Alekoko (Menehune) Fishpond From; Tanya Kapuy CAUTION: This email originated from outside the County ofKauai. Do not click links or open attachments even ifthe sender is known to you unless it is something you were expecting. Dear Open Space Commission, Please act quicklyin securingopen spacefundstoacquire Alekoko Loko I'a forourcommunityand forfuture generations. Alekoko is an important, historical and culturally rich site that needs to be preserved in perpetuity for our island food security and cultural importance. In addition, making efforts to revitalizethe loko i'a will beableto open up more optionsforfood sustainability.There are movements happening in Hawai'i towards that goal and to not be dependent towards imported food. It will also ensure the health of future generations as nutrition and diet can be integrated into any programs the fish pond would have. Thank you for your time and consideration. Sincerely, Tanya Kapuy Duke Nakamatsu From: Kale at Kahua Consulting Services CAUTION: This email originated from outside the County ofKauai. Do not click links or open attachments even ifthe sender is known to you unless it is something you were expecting. Aloha nui, Commissioners: 'aina Mahalo for this opportunity to testify. Your time and aloha for our and its People are appreciated and acknowledged. I, too, add my voice of strong support for Malama Hule'ia's and the Trust for Public Land's efforts to help our Community purchase and protect Alakoko Fishpond. 'ike This wahi pana is an incredible resource and historical link to our past, connecting the of our kupuna to the piko of today's rising generation. At a critical time when the sustainable future of this fishpond seems bleak, we turn our eyes and hearts to you, our Commissioners, as trusted advocates to malama Alakoko into perpetuity. "ice Few beloved places remain on Kaua'i as massive as this 100+ acre box" of natural resources and sustenance for our lahui kanaka. Here is an opportunity for Kaua'i County Leaders to do right by our people; to pono this process by appropriating funds to save our fishpond from lucrative "sight landowners who are scooping properties unseen." We simply cannot afford to lose this beloved wahi pana, and time is ofthe essence. Therefore, I urge the Commission to renew their recommendation to the County Council that Open Space Funds be used to protect and acquire Alakoko Fishpond for the community's benefit. This swift action is a worthy investment for our people, our honua, and our future keiki. 1 mau ke aloha 'aina, D. Kale Kau'i Wailuanuiaho'ano, Kaua'i kalekaui(S),gmail.com Duke Nakamatsu 'mzjonee From: CAUTION: This email originated from outside the County ofKauai. Do not click links or open attachments even ifthe sender is known to you unless it is something you were expecting. Aloha, Written Testimony is attached! Mahalo, Joni Keamoai Subject: Testimony in Support ofAgenda Item J [2) Aloha Commissioners, My name is Joni Keamoai, born and raised on the Westside of Kaua'i. I write in support ofagenda item J (2), the Trust for Public Land and Malama Hule'ia's efforts to help the Kaua'i community purchase and protect Alakoko Fishpond. Preservation and of 'aina is not only a but it s protection 'aina,given, a must. For when you preserve and protect the you also preserve and protect its culture, language, livelihood and it's people. The past two years, we have seen natives and residents alike defend the 'aina, with all that they have. Sending a resounding message far across the pae'aina ofjust how important 'aina is, not only to the natives but those who reside 'o 'aina here as well. The keiki ka should also be given the opportunity to learn at Alakoko, and the opportunity to work in its waters and soil. By renewing the recommendation to County Council that Open Space funds be used to protect and acquire Alakoko Fishpond for community benefit. You also teach the keiki and the people of Kaua'i and abroad, what it really means to Aloha Aina! Mahalo Nui, Joni Keamoai Duke Nakamatsu From: Jeremy Burns CAUTION: This email originated from outside the County ofKauai. Do not click links or open attachments even ifthe sender is known to you unless it is something you were expecting. Aloha Kauai Open Space Commission, Please find attached the Kilauea Neighborhood Association testimony in support of acquiring the Alekoko fishpond property. Mahalo, Jeremy Bums Secretary - Kilauea Neighborhood Association KILAUEA NEIGHBORHOOU ASSOCIATION U KOMO MAI ! President February 9, 2021 Yoshlto L'Hote Shaylyn Klmura, Chair Public Access, Open Space & Natural Resources Preservation Fund Commission c/o County of Kaua'i Planning Department 4444 Rice St., Suite A473 President Vice LThu'e, Hl 96766 Beryl Blalch RE: Alekoko Flshpond Property Aloha, Chairperson Kimura and Members ofthe Kaua'i Open Space Gommission, Secretary The KTIauea Neighborhood Association supports County Kaua'i ofthe Jeremy Burns (KNA) strongly df purchase Alakoko fishpond property. This most special heritage place completely merits permanent protection. We are depending upon you, the hardworking and respected Open Space Commission, to express the public's affirmation of this acquisition by recommending that the Treasurer County Open Space Preservation Fund be applied to this acquisition. Gary Pacheco The Alakoko parcel is most assoclated with its ancient and legendary fishpond. However, the paroel also encompasses river frontage - on two sides ofthe Hule'ia river - scenic, historic, agricultural, ecologlcal and recreational resources. From bad and good experiences in the Sergeant-at-Arms comparably resource endowed KTIauea River Valley, the KNA knows how critical the combination of land trust know-how, rapid action and available fundlng are to significant Bill Chase preseroing places. It is rare in the land conservation arena (indeed almost magical) when the following required elements come together: PTSA Rep • a landownerwho is eager to sell an extraordinarily endowed parcel at a reasonable priee Sonrisa Stepath • the highly.experienced Trust for Public Land is on board • the property is already stewarded by a respected community nonprofit • the public Is totally enthusiastic Dlrectors • a substantial pot of dedicated money is available to apply to acquisition Stephenle Brown Because of the track record of Malama Hule'ia, the KNA trusts that the entlre island will benefit from acquiring Alakoko. We anticipate enjoying managed access to the land and the river, seeing Thomas Daubert the rockwork ofthe amazing fishpond and participating in contlnued restoration work. We look forward to eating Alakoko 'ama'ama wlth Hanalel Emily Dunn poi. Mlke Latif Commlssioners, forthe people QfKaua'i, especially our keiki and na keiki ofthe future, please recommend to the County Council and the Mayor that substantial Open Space Preservatlon Charlle Martln funding be expended to acquire the Alakoko property. Don McConnell Sincerely, Ron Paul Sonrisa Stepath Yoshito L'Hote President, KTIauea Neighborhood Association PO Box 283, KIIauea, Kaua'i, Hawai'i 967S4 www.kna-kauai.org | [email protected] Like us on Facebook: Facebook.com/kna.kauai Duke Nakamatsu From: Tina Kinimaka. CAUTION: This email originated from outside the County ofKauai. Do not click links or open attachments even ifthe sender is known to you unless it is something you were expecting. 9. Pepeluali. 2021 9. February. 2021 Subject: Testimony in Support ofAgenda Item J (2) Aloha Commisioners, 1 strongly support The Trust for Public Land and Malama Hule ia efforts to help the Kaua i community purchase and protect Alakoko Fishpond. Due to the pandemic, it has forced organizations, such as Malama Hule'ia to create innovative 'ohana. means to serve their community and As such, its allowed my involvement in a collaborative partnership with Malama Hule'ia in creating a virtual curriculum as an avenue to 'ohana continually support teachers, students and in connecting learners to this place and using Alakoko as a classroom. Instilling a sense of belonging, responsibility, excellence, aloha and Hawai'i. Furthermore, in preserving Alakoko, this space would provide impactful community benefits and a place that creates a sense of belonging, responsibility and total well-being for an individual. Such benefits include: restoring a healthy watershed, river and native wetland ecosystem; preerving a 'aina-based beloved cultural site and outdoor classroom for education; and increasing sustainable 'ohana aquaculture and food security for and communities of Kaua i. 1 urge the Commission to renew their recommendation to County Council that Open Space funds be used to protect and acquire Alakoko Fishpond for community benefit. MekeAloha, Tina Kinimaka me ke Aloha, Tina Kiniinaka Duke Nakamatsu From: Terry Low CAUTION: This email originated from outside the County ofKauai. Do not click links or open attachments even ifthe sender is known to you unless it is something you were expecting. Aloha Kakou, I would urge the County Council to take advantage of a chance to purchase the Alakoko Fish Pond at this time. I do see this as a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity that will ensure that this property is preserved in perpetuity. Please support Malama Hule'ia in their efforts. Mahalo, Terry J Low Duke Nakamatsu From: Kainoa Lum CAUTION:Thisemail originated from outsidetheCountyofKauai. Do not click links oropen attachments even ifthe sender is known to you unless it is something you were expecting. Aloha Commissioner's, 1 strongly support The Trust for Public Land and Malama Hule'ia's efforts to help the Kaua'i community purchase and protect the Alakoko fishpond. The fish pond is one of my favorite scenic spots to just relax, listen to the peacefulness and enjoy the sunset with the Ha'upu mountain range from the lookout. There's no where else like that exists on the island and I'm sure it's a special place notforjustthe people ofKauai butespeciallyforthosewholive inthe Nawiliwili area. Especially nowthatwith community efforts majority of the mangroves have been removed, I'm sure the pond might have a chance to flourish like it did back in the days. This could be the turning point for an area where it can once again provide sustenance and educational purposesforouryouth. I urge the commission to renew their recommendation to the County Council that open space funds be used to protect and acquire Alakoko Fishpond for community benefit. Aloha Kainoa Lum Sent from my iPhone Duke Nakamatsu From: Mariko Lum CAUTION: This email originated from outside the County ofKauai. Do not click links or open attachments even ifthe sender is known to you unless it is something you were expecting. Aloha Commissioners, I strongly support The Trust for Public Land and Malama Hule'ia's efforts to help Kaua'i community purchase and protect Alakoko Fish pond. A few months ago I had the pleasure of spending an afternoon with Peleke Flores interviewing him about the work being done at Hule'ia. At that time the removal ofmangroves was nearly complete and they were making plans to tackle the reconstruction ofthe wall. His knowledge ofhow a fish pond works, confidence in restoration, and passion to complete the project regardless ofthe possibility in knowing the land could one day be sold, was nothing short ofinspiring. Malama Hule'ia took the approach ofinvolving community members from schools to business owners, to individuals, allowing all walks of life to reconnect to a place we all feel deeply connected to as a community. With modem day development of our harbor my concern was whether or not a traditional fish pond could flourish like it did back in time. Peleke's confidence with manini showing up and the work they've accomplished thus far was enough for me to believe in the vision and future goals. The amount ofprogress they have accomplished in a short amount oftime gives me confidence with the continued stewardship under Malama Hule'ia, Alakoko could flourish to be a community hub for culture, connectivity, education, and food. I urge the commission to renew their recommendation to County Council that open space funds to be used to protect and acquire Alakoko Fishpond for community benefit. Aloha, Mariko Strickland Lum Duke Nakamatsu From: Malia Chun CAUTION: This email originated from outside the County ofKauai. Do not click links or open attachments even ifthe sender is known to you unless it is something you were expecting. Aloha kakou, Attached is a letter on behalfofthe Makaloa Council ofKaua'i Community College in strong support ofthe ,Trust for Public Land and Malama Hule'ia's efforts to help the Kaua'i community purchase and protect Alakoko Fishpond. Mahalo for your time and consideration, Malia Chun on behalfofthe Makaloa Council ofKaua'i Community College Malia Chun Na Pua No'eau Site Coordinator (808)245-8387 KAUA'I COMMUNITY COLLEGE UniYersily ofHawaiti February 8, 2021 Reyna Ramolete Hayashi The Trust for Public Land 1003 Bishop Street, Suite 740 Honolulu, Hi. 96813 Sara Bowen Malama Hule'ia P.0. Box 662092 LThu'e, Hl 96766 Re: Support for Malama Hule'ia and The Trust for Public Land's Efforts to Purchase and Protect Alekoko Fishpond in Niumalu and Ha'iku, Kaua i. Aloha kakou, The Makaloa Council of Kaua'i Community College strongly supports the Trust for Public Land and Malama Hule'ia's efforts to protect and purchase the Alakoko Fishpond Property in the ahupua'a of Niumalu and Ma'iku, Kaua'i, alsoknown as Menehune Fishpond. Protecting Alakoko would provide impactful community benefits: restoring a healthy watershed, river and nativewetland ecosystem; preserving a beloved and cherished cultural and historical site and outdoor classroom for our entire kaiaulu (community) to learn the science and technology ofan ancient Hawaiian aquaculture system; increasing sustainable food production and food security for the island of Kaua'i. The Makaloa Council was created to provide support services to KCC students, of Hawaiian Ancestry, in all aspects oftheir educationaljourney at KCC. Through the many stewardship and cultural opportunities offered through Malama Hule'ia at Alakoko, KCC students, faculty, and staff have had the opportunity to be exposed to a multitude ofcareer and college pathways in the Natural Sciences, Math, Education, Conservation and participate in various staff development workshops. Alakoko is truly an example of an ideal outdoor classroom and space of ancestral knowledge that our entire community can benefitfrom. As an institute of higher education on Kaua'i that perpetuates indigenous knowledge, it is our kuleana to support the continued protection, restoration and revitalization of Alakoko fishpond. It is for these reasons that the Makaloa Council supports IVIalama Hule'ia and The Trust for Public Land's Efforts to Purchase and Protect Alekoko Fishpond for future generations. Me ke aloha pumehana, The Makaloa Council of KCC Joseph M. Daisy, EdD Lahea Salazar Kaua'i Community College Chancellor Program Coordinator Wai'ale'ale Project Kalei Carvalho Student Support Shaunte Sadora The Wai'ate'ale Project Student Services Academic Counselor Isaiah Ka'auwai Title IX Coordinator & EEO / AA Officer Puali'ili'imaikalani Rossi-Fukino Assistant Professor Hawaiian Studies Malia Kahale'inia Chun Program Director Na Pua No'eau Kaua'i Evelyn Kamai Secretary Duke Nakamatsu From: Scott Sato Sent: Tuesday, February9, 2021 10:31 PM To: Kaaina Hull; Duke Nakamatsu; Nani Sadora Subject: Fwd: Protect Alekoko tMenehune) Fishpond Scott K. Sato Office ofthe County Clerk | Council Services Division 4396 Rice Street, Suite 209 | LThu'e, HI 96766 Phone: (808) 241-4810 | Fax: (808) 241-6349 From: Kirstie Matias CAUTION: This email originated from outside tlie County ofKauai. Do not click links or open attachments even ifthe sender is known to you unless it is something you were expecting. Dear Open Space Commission, Please act quickly in securing open space funds to acquire Alekoko Loko I'a for our cormnunity and for fature generations. Alekoko is an important, historical and culturally rich site that needs to be preserved in perpetuity for our islaad food security and cultural education. Thank you. Duke Nakamatsu From: JarraeTehani Puni CAUTION: This email originated from outside the County of Kauai. Do not click links or open attachments even if the sender is known to you unless it is something you were expecting. Aloha Commissioners, 1 write infavorto supportTheTrustfor Public Land and Malama Huleia effortsto helpthe Kaua'i communitypurchase and protect Alakoko Fishpond. Protecting Alakoko would provifle impactful community benefits such as restoring a healthy watershed, river and native 'aina wetland ecosystem, based education, food security and preservation ofa cultural significant site. I strongly encourage the Commission to renew their recommendation to County Council that Open Space funds be used to protect and acquire Alakoko Fishpond for community benefit. Mahalo, JarraeTehani IVIanasas Aloha! Feel free to use the template below as you prepare your testimony to the Commission. It doesn't have to be long, and you can delete the middle portibn in bold/italics if you don't have a specific connection to Alakoko Fishpond at this time. When pau, copy-paste your message in an email to [email protected] by Wednesday, Feb. 10 at 9:00 am. IVIahalo! Testimony: Support for Agenda Item J(2) Open Space Funds forAlakoko Fishpond To: openspace(a)kauai.ciov Fr: meghann matsuda & keive kauakahi Subject: Testimony in SUPPORT of Agenda Item J(2) Aloha, Commissioners: 1 strongly support The Trust for Public Land and Malama Hule'ia's efforts to help the Kaua'i Community purchase and protect Alakoko Fishpond. Alakoko has not only been around for many generations and also has much history to the Hawaiian people. This fishpond will help us to reuse it again one day 1 restoring it and giving it back to the people. The people who will use it. The people who will care for it. The people who passes down generations to come. The state has taken much from the hawaiians and this should be left in the hawaiians hands. Allow us to take the burden off your handsof maintaining yet and spending government money. Allow the community to help restore it. / love the people to once again gain a historical site. I urge the Commission to renew their recommendation to the County Council that Open Space Funds be used to protect and acquire Alakoko Fishpond for community benefit. Mahalo, Duke Nakamatsu From: Meghann Matsuda CAUTION: This email originated from outside the County ofKauai. Do not click links or open attachments even ifthe sender is known to you unless it is something you were expecting. Aloha let me know ifthis is good Sent from my iPhone Duke Nakamatsu From: Alexis Miles CAUTION: This email originated from outside the County ofKauai. Do not click links or open attachments even ifthe sender is known to you unless it is something you were expecting. Aloha Commissioners, I strongly support The Trust for Public Land and Malama Hule'ia's efforts to help the Kaua'i community purchase and protect Alakoko Fishpond. It is essential that Hawai'i is sustainable and restoring Alakoko is a great way to accomplish this. When it was functioning properly, the amount offish it produced could sustain the entire population ofKaua'i. It is also culturally significant as the fishpond is 600 old and sacred to Hawaiians. Preserving it and making it years 'Alae 'Ula, public is essential to the community. Beyond that, an endangered endemic species found nowhere else in the world, have been seen there at the beginning oftheir mating season. Restoring Alakoko will restore habitat for these birds. I urge the Commission to renew their recommendation to County Council that Open Space funds be used to protect and acquire Alakoko Fishpond for community benefit. Duke Nakamatsu From: Alessandra Novak CAUTION: This email originated from outside the County ofKauai. Do not click links or open attachments even ifthe sender is known to you unless it is something you were expecting. Aloha Commissioners, I sti'ongly support The Trust for Public Land and Malama Hiile'ia's efforts to help the Kaua'i Community purchase and protect Alakoko Fishpond. As a non-Hawaiian member ofthe Kaua'i community, I believe it is ofutmost importance that the preservation of culturally important sites be a priority. Not only is the Alakoko Fishpond important historically, it offers an opportunity to teach critical lessons firsthand today, utilizing the vast knowledge Hawaiians have of sustainable, ecologically sound practices that will benefit our island and our planet. I urge the commission to renew their reconunendation to the County Council that Open Space Funds be used to protect and acquire Alakoko Fishpond for community benefit. Mahalo Alessandra "Ali" Novak MS, ATC (pronouns: she/they) 7457 Kuhio Hwy, Ha'ena 510.220.5637ceu Duke Nakamatsu From: Marissa Leimakanalani Omellas CAUTION: This email originated from outside the County ofKauai. Do not click links or open attachments even if the sender is known to you unless it is something you were expecting. Dear Open Space Commission, I write to urge you to please act quickly in securing open space funds to acquire Alekoko Loko I'a for our community and for future generations. Alekoko is an important, historical and culturally rich site that needs to be preserved in perpetuity for our island food security and cultural education. Marissa Ornellas & ohana Duke Nakamatsu From: Brittny Perez CAUTION: This email originated from outside the County ofKauai. Do not click links or open attachments even ifthe sender is known to you unless it is something you were expecting. To: [email protected] Fr: Kulanui Naliipoaimoku Subject: Testimony in SUPPORT of Agenda Item J(2) Aloha, Commissioners: 1 strongly support The Trust for Public Land and Malama Hule'ia's efforts to help the Kaua'i Community purchase and protect Alakoko Fishpond. Alakoko is a legacy of our ancestors, a legacy stolen by the plantation era and continued illegal occupation of hlawai'i. Our people have been working to restore Alakoko so that our keiki and generations to come after them may benefit from the use of the land and resources. This legacy is held in perpetuity to our people, stop the illegal sales of lands using unclear titles. I urge the Commission to renew their recommendation to the County Council that Open Space Funds be used to protect and acquire'Alakoko Fishpond for community benefit. Mahalo, Brittny Kulanui Naliipoaimoku Perez Duke Nakamatsu From: Jen R CAUTION: This email originated from outside the County ofKauai. Do not click links or open attachments even ifthe sender is known to you unless it is something you were expecting. Aloha mai kai kou, I am writing from the island of O'ahu to express my support for the public acquisition of the Alakoko "Menehune" Fishpond. 1 am a long time Hawaii resident, work in the public schools, and a Hawaiian focused charter school. It is clear to me that preserving, protecting and nourishing our aina and cultural resources is one of the only ways we can secure a stable and sustainable future for all people ofthese islands and for this to be done by the public is essential. 1 urge you to allow public acquisition of the Alakoko Fishpond. Mahalo nui, Jennifer Duke Nakamatsu From: Nicole Relacion CAUTION: This email originated from outside the County ofKauai. Do not click links or open attachments even ifthe sender is known to you unless it is something you were expecting. Aloha e Commissioners, I strongly support The Trust for Public Land and Malama Hule'ia's efforts to help tiie Kaua'i coinmunity purchase and protect Alakoko Fishpond. As a Native Hawaiian who grew up on Kaua i, Alakoko Fishpond was one of the first stories of my people that I learned ofas a kid and one ofthe first examples ofhow industrious our people were and still are. The knowledge ofhow our ancestors were able to create sustainable systems to feed their community has inspired me as I have gotten older to work towards that in our current day. This past year and the impact that COVID-19 has had on our island further highlights how creating these sustainable systems are a necessity. The work that Malama Hule ia has done to restore Alakoko has been critical to these sustainability efforts and their ability to bring in others to kokua has allowed that knowledge to spread through our community. Malama Hule'ia's work with Kaua'i's youth has been particularly important as it has educated them on our island's history, how to properly stewards these lands, and strengthen our Native kamali'i's ties to their culture. K.amali'i like my own nieces and nephews who have leamed while playing in those waters, watching their parents restore the fishpond that fed their ancestors. In my caieer as a social worker, I have seen firsthand how cridcal cultural connection and self-efficacy are in positively impacting the mental health and well-being ofour young people. For these reasons and many more, I believe that Alakoko should be protected and be stewarded by and for our community. I urge the Commission to renew their recommendation to the County Council that Open Space funds be used to protect and acquire Alakoko Fishpond for community benefit. Mahalo, Nicole Relacion Duke Nakamatsu From: Mokihana Renti Cruz CAUTION: This email originated from outside the County ofKauai. Do not click links or open attachments even ifthe sender is known to you unless it is something you were expecting. Aloha Commissioners, I strongly support The Trust for Public Land and Malama Hule'ia's efforts to help the Kaua'i community purchase and protect Alakoko Fishpond. As someone bom and raised on Kaua'i, Alakoko fishpond is a legacy for me as well as my community. It is a reminder of our past, the works of our ancestors and a testament to the way of life and connection to the past residents ofKaua'i and Hawai'i. Alakoko fishpond is a historical site with deep roots in Hawaiian culture, history, and can be used as an educational tool. It is a representation oftiie mo'olelo or stories ofMenehune, which Kaua'i has deep ties to, proving their existence and Native Hawaiian means of sustainability, resource management, and aquaculture production. Similar sites are still being maintained and used to feed communities such as Hale o Lono in Keaukaha, Hawai'i island, Waiahole fishpond and He'eia fishpond on O'ahu. The structure ofthe fishpond also contains Kaua'i identity and history unique.to the world and is something we should be proud ofand try to maintain. Therefore, I urge the Commission to renew their recommendation to County Council that Open Space funds to be used to protect and acquire Alakoko Fishpond for community benefit. Mekaha'aha'a, Shamelle Renti Cruz P.0. Box 824 Kekaha, HI 96752 Duke Nakamatsu From: Puanani Rogers CAUTION: This email originated from outside the County ofKauai. Do not click links or open attachments even if the sender is known to you unless it is something you were expecting. Aloha, Commissioners: 1 strongly support The Trust for Public Land and Malama Hule'ia's efforts to help the Kaua'i Community purchase and protect Alakoko Fishpond. This loko i'a is a public trust for our Kauai community. It was built by our na Kupuna and left for us as a legacy. Okada Trucking needs to show clear title to this wahi pana, Its a criminal act to even think of selling or auctioning off this sacred place. We must honor our ancestors intention to create a fishpond for all the people and not for private ownership. I urge the Commission to renew their recommendation to the County Council that Open Space Funds be used to protect and acquire Alakoko Fishpond for community benefit. Mahalo, Puanani Rogers (808) 652-1249 Duke Nakamatsu From: lalasun designs CAUTION: This email originated from outside the County of Kauai. Do not click links or open attachments even if the sender is known to you unless it is something you were expecting. Dear Open Space Commission, Please act quickly in securing open space funds to acquire Alekoko Loko I'a for our community and for future generations. Alekoko is an important, historical and culturally rich site that needs to be preserved in perpetuityforourislandfood securityand cultural education. Thankyou. Sincerely Leilea Satori Sentfrom my iPad Duke Nakamatsu From; Scott Sato Sent: Tuesday, February 9, 2021 4:04 PM To; Kaaina Hull; Nani Sadora; Duke Nakamatsu Subj'ect: FW: Protect Alekoko (Menehune) Fishpond From: S Shore CAUTION: This email originated from outside the County ofKauai. Do not click links or open attachments even ifthe sender is known to you unless it is something you were expecting. The only way to preserve a culture's history and the environment that supports it is to, actually, keep these practices of our ancestors functional. To teach our children to keep each precious biodiverse habit free and clear of pollution or contamination means, we, their predecessors must fight for it, and do it! Dear Open Space Commission, Please act quickly in securing open space funds to acquire Alekoko Loko I'a for our community and for future generations. Alekoko is an important, historical and culturally rich site that needs to be preserved in perpetuity for our island food security and cultural education. Thank you. Duke Nakamatsu From: meg schofield CAUTION: This email originated from outside the County ofKauai. Do not click links or open attachments even ifthe sender is known to you unless it is something you were expecting. Aloha Commissioners, I am writing you today in support of the public acquisition of this unique and valuable piece of Kauai's 'aina. history, culture, and It certainly seems as ifthere is passionate interest in thefishpond being restored and turned into a research and education center - a potentially incredible teaching and demonstration resource for Hawaiian aquaculture! Partnerships among agencies and organizations with the community interest highest in mind (vs a private party assuming ownership) surely ought to put wind in the sails ofthis worthy endeavor! Thank you for giving it your highest consideration. Sincerely, Meg Schofield Waipouli Rd., Kapaa Sent from Yahoo Mail on Android February 10,2021 Reyna Ramolete Hayashi The Trust for Public Land 1003 Bishop Street, Suite 740 Honolulu,Hawai'i 96813 Sara Bowen MalamaHule'ia P.0. Box 662092 Lihu'e, Hawai'i 96766 Re: Support for Malama Hule ia and the Trust for Public Land's efforts to Purchase and Protect Alakoko Fishpond in Niumalu and Ha'iku, Kaua'i Aloha, I, Daniel Shyles, strongly support The Trust for Public Land and Malama Hule'ia's efforts to protect and purchase the Alakoko Fishpond Property in Niumalu and Ha'iku, Kaua'i, also known as Menehune Fishpond. Protecting AIakoko would provide impactful community benefits: restoring a healthy watershed, river, and native wetland ecosystem; preserving a beloved cultural and historic site and an outdoor classroom for students to learn the science and technology of Hawaiias aquaculture; and increasing sustainable food production and food security for Kaua'i. I was a science teacher at Waimea High School from 2017-2020, and had thejoy ofbringing my students to Alakoko Loko I a to leam from its bountiful teachings. Alakoko is inherent in its importance as a connection to the Islands' ancestral past, a natural laboratory for leaming natural science and humanity's irrevocable connection with nature, and is an example to this and future generations ofHawai'i's ability to be self-sustaining and food-sovereign by reinvigorating a reciprocal relationship with nature. Alakoko is the best-preserved example of this form of aquaculture on Kaua'i, and the work that Malama Hule'ia has done toward its restoration is exemplary and a source ofleaming for the community for committing to and acting upon our shared responsibility to malama 'aina. For these reasons, it is essential that Alakoko Loko I'a be protected in perpetuity through the purchase ofthe Alakoko Fishpond Property by The Trust for Public Land and Malama Hule'ia. Mahalo, Daniel Shyles Science Teacher 435 Edgewood Lane PortAngeles,WA 98363 Duke Nakamatsu From: Susan Sobel CAUTION; This email originated from outside the County of Kauai. Do not click links or open attachments even ifthe sender is known to you unless it is something you were expecting. I'm in favor of county acquiring the Menehune Fish Pond Thank You Susan M Sobel Sentfrom myiPhone Duke Nakamatsu From; Lee Anne Spencer CAUTION:Thisemailoriginatedfrom outsidethe County ofKauai. Do notclick links oropen attachments even ifthesender is known to you unless it is something you were expecting. Aloha- 1 am writing in support ofthe proposal to purchase the Hule'ia Fishpond. As someone who has been paying local property taxes since 2004,1 feel this is a very good use of our money. I have been a full-time resident of Kauai'i for the lasteightyears, buteven when 1 wasatourist, I wasawarethatthis place isveryspecial. Manyvisitorsgettheirfirst education about menehune andthesustainabletraditionsofthis island becauseofthefishpond. IVIore importantly,the fishpond can be restored and used to benefit the local population. This is a unique opportunity - please pursue this purchase with all haste. Mahalo, Lee AnneSpencer 2731aOhanaAina Place Kalaheo, Hl 96741 Duke Nakamatsu From: Malia Chun CAUTION: This email originated from outside the County ofKauai. Do not click links or open attachments even ifthe sender is known to you unless it is something you were expecting. Letter ofsupport for Alakoko on behalfofMolly Summers, Associate Professor at Kaua'i Community College. Malia Chun Na Pua No'eau Site Coordinator 1245-8387 KAUA'I COMMUNITY COLLEGE University ofi-Iawai i February 8, 2021 Reyna Ramolete Hayashi The Trust for Public Land 1003 Bishop Street, Suite 740 Honolulu,Hi.96813 Sara Bowen Malama Hule'ia P.0. Box 662092 LThu'e, Hl 96766 Re: Support forlVlalama Hule'ia and The Trust for Public Land's Efforts to Purchase and Protect Alekoko Fishpond in Niumalu and Ha'iku, Kaua'i. Aloha kakou, As a resident of Kaua'i and educator at Kaua'i Community College for the past 39 years, 1 strongly support the Trust for Public Land and Malama Hule'ia's efforts to protect and purchase the Alakoko Fishpond Property in the ahupua'a of Niumalu and Ha'iku, Kaua'i, also known as Menehune Fishpond. Protecting Alakoko would provide impactful community benefits: restoring a healthy watershed, river and native wetland ecosystem; preserving a beloved and cherished cultural and historical site and outdoor classroom for our entire kaiaulu (community) to learn the science and technology of an ancient Hawaiian aquaculture system; increasing sustainablefood production and food security for the island of Kaua'i. Through the many stewardship and cultural opportunities offered through Malama Hule'ia at Alakoko, KCC students, faculty, and staff have had the opportunity to be exposed to a multitude of career and college pathways in the Natural Sciences, Math, Education, Conservation and participate in various staff development workshops. Alakoko is truly an example of an ideal outdoor classroom and space of ancestral knowledge that our entire community can benefit from. As an instructor of higher education on Kaua'i who perpetuates indigenous knowledge, it is my kuleana to supportthe continued protection, restoration and revitalization of Alakoko fishpond. It is for these reasons that1support Malama Hule'ia and The Trust for Public Land's Efforts to Purchase and Protect Alekoko Fishpond for future generations. Me ke aloha pumehana, Mary C. Summers Associate Professor, Kaua'i Community College Duke Nakamatsu From: JimmyTrujillo CAUTION: This email originated from outside the County ofKauai. Do not click links or open attachments even ifthe sender is known to you unless it is something you were expecting. Aloha Commissioners, Please add my name to the list ofresidents asking for the protection ofAlakoko. This historic and culturally significant site is deserving of special consideration for purchasing and keeping it OPEN SPACE and accessible to community and preserved as a cultural and enviromnental pu'uhonua in perpetuity. Ua mau ka ea o ka aina i ka pono ! Mahalo for your consideration and I urge you to take immediate action to help Malama Huleia continue to restore this honua for our community. With respect and aloha, Jaipes G Trujillo PO BOX 33 Kapa'a, HI 96746 James G Tmjillo Constmction Academy Kaua'i Community College Duke Nakamatsu From: Lori Walker CAUTION: This email originated from outside the County ofKauai. Do not click links or open attachments even ifthe sender is known to you unless it is something you were expecting. Aloha nui Commissioners, 1 strongly support the Trust for Public Land and Malama Huleia's efforts to help the Kauai community purchase and protect Alakoko Fishpond. I work in land management with the State of Hawaii and we are responsible for over 28,000 acres on several islands. Protecting and preserving our natural and cultural resources is challenging and necessary work. Malama Huleia is committed to this work and your continued support of organizations and projects such as this helps to sustain the models and practices of land management from which we all need to be learning. They are our allies and they are our leaders. I respectfully urge the Commission to renew their recommendation to County Council that Open Space funds be used to protect and acquire Alakoko Fishpond for community benefit. Me ka haahaa, Lori K. Walker Duke Nakamatsu From: Maria Walker CAUTION: This email originated from outside the County ofKauai. Do not click Unks or open attachments even if the sender is known to you unless it is something you were expecting. Aloha to the Kaua'i Open Space Commission, I am writing to you to communicate my enthusiastic support for the recommendation to acquire Alakoko lolo i'a . This site, more than 600 years old is of enormous importance historically and culturally, and it is critical that we make every effort to preserve and protect what remains of Kaua'i's Hawai'ian heritage. Alakoko can not only teach us much about the sustainable cultural practices ofthe Hawai'ian people, but can help us leam how to use ancient knowledge in today's context to build our food security for the future. There is always much to learn from our forebearers to help us in the present and future. Malama Hule'ia has worked with patience and persistence to restore the area, remove all invasive mangrove, and reestablish the loko i'a and native wetland flora and fauna. Over the years, this site has served to educate both keiki and adults about the historical and cultural importance and usefulness ofthe fishponds, and it has taken a years long effort by many members ofthe community to bring it to the healthy ecosystem it is today. My daughter worked there on school service trips, and my husband has volunteered many hours there to help Malama Hulei'a. Alakoko is an expression of love, honor, and commitment from Kaua'i residents to both the past and the future, and it is ofthe utmost importance that it is preserved in perpetuity by the county for the people ofKauai. Mahalo for hearing my testimony. Maria Walker 1728HuluRd. Kapa'a, HI 96746 (808) 821-0732 Duke Nakamatsu From: ahiu1983 CAUTION: This email originated from outside the County ofKauai. Do not click links or open attachments even if the sender is known to you unless it is something you were expecting. Aloha Commissioners, I strongly support the Trust for Public Land and Malama Hule'ia efforts to help the Kaua'i community purchase and protect Alakoko Fishpond. I am a kia'i loko i'a on the island ofO'ahu, in the moku ofKo'olauloa, ahupua'a o Kahana and belong to Huilua loko i'a. As a kia'i loko we support the continued efforts to protect and revitalize loko i'a as it is a part ofrestoring balance to our ahupua'a ecosystems to restore 'aina sustainability. We have been able to work alongside kia'i loko i'a from Alakoko Fishpond through our Hui Malama Loko I'a network. We have learned many valuable lessons from Alakoko pertaining to fishpond wall restoration, loko i'a maintenance and management, and commimity engagement. Fishponds are a reflection ofcommunity and as fellow kia'i loko i'a we support all efforts to uplift the Kaua'i community through the protection ofAlakoko Fishpond. I urge the Commission to renew their recommendation to County CouncU that Open Space funds be used to protect and acquire Alakoko Fishpond for community benefit. Mahalo nui, Kahiau Wallace President, Ho'ala 'Aina Kupono PO BOX 300 304 Ka'a'awa, HI 96730 Duke Nakamatsu From: Linda White CAUTION: This email originated from outside the County of Kauai. Do not click links or open attachments even if the sender is known to you unless it is something you were expecting. My husband and 1 would strongly encourage the County of Kauai to purchase the Menehune Fish Pond to preserve the Hawaiian cultureand historyofourlsland home. Respectfully, Larry and Linda White Sentfrom myiPad Duke Nakamatsu From: Llewellyn Woodward CAUTION: This email originated from outsidetheCountyofKauai. Do notclick linksoropen attachments even ifthe sender is known to you unless it is something you were expecting. Aloha commissioners I strongly support trust for public land and Malama Hule'ia's efforts to help the Kauai community purchase and protect Alakoko fishpond. 1 work down at Alakoko fishpond as the Kupu member under malama hule'ia. Working at Alakoko fishpond haschanged me in manyways, beingable toseefirst hand the rejuvenation, and restoration ofa SOOyearold wahi pana isvery humbling. The amountofcommunityeffortthat has been putintothis movementisa bigpartofthe restoration process. I have witnessed hundredsofstudents, parents, and volunteers puta little bitofthemselves into the fishpond when they've come to experience it themselves. 1 believe that the fishpond should be protected to further push and educatechildrenon notjustculture butaswell asfood systems, waterquality, micro bacteria, plankton, fish, birds, plants, canoes, names of the wind, names of their surrounding mountains, fishponds, taro patches, and the whole ahupua'a system.Allofwhich can fit into and mold in withthe schoolcurriculum to build and raisea more aware generation of people who understand more about their land. 1 urge the commission to renew their recommendation to county council that open space funds be used to protect and acquire Alakoko fishpond for community benefits.