Mulciber Ltd Lunnon Farm, St Mary's , TR21 0NZ Diccon Rogers Tel: 0845 5143123 / 07785 520274 Email: [email protected] [email protected] Vat Reg No 900 9655 28

Existing Use of Pendrethen Quarry 2003 to 2015 Quarter (Q) dates: Q1 – January 1st – March 31st ; Q2 –April; 1st – June 30th; Q3 –July 1st – September 30th; Q4 – October 1st –December 31st. Year Date Activities/Key Information Mulciber Invoice No. or other Evidence Please note: this is a table of activities based principally on issued and paid invoices. For every sale of recycled aggregates and materials from Pendrethen Quarry, there will also be extensive processing works ongoing throughout to produce the material. 2003 Q2 – Deposit of inert C&D waste in pit of quarry for future recycling by DoC Photographs Q3 2004 Importation to site, stockpiling, processing, exporting to local markets throughout the year Q1 28th January Chestnut paling fence to be erected around Pendrethen Quarry by Duchy Contractors, working alongside Mulciber 30th March Clearance work begins by Mulciber Work & production records Q2 4th June Scrap metal clearance and recycling at Quarry by Mulciber Ltd 143 & 145 onwards First supplies of local recycled ram and sand from Quarry from Mulciber Ltd, recovered from old stockpiles and cleaned, graded and supplied for new building at St Mary’s Riding Centre. 154 Q3 Clearance and recycling operations continue Q4 November Crusher unit salvaged from redundant quarry plant, refurbished and converted to mobile crusher by Mulciber Ltd. On Correspondence hire around St Mary’s, including at Star Castle Hotel providing crushing and recycling services. Crusher used at (Mulciber Ltd & Pendrethen Quarry for recycling. Crusher based at Pendrethen Quarry. mainland crushing equipment suppliers as to performance improvements of mobile crusher).

Further supply and delivery of quantity of recycled ram from Pendrethen Quarry to new building of St Mary’s Riding 151 Centre 1st December Additional supplies of crushed/graded recycled aggregates from Pendrethen to local market. Quantities supplied to 152 Garrison Campsite.

1

Mulciber Ltd Lunnon Farm, St Mary's Isles of Scilly, TR21 0NZ Diccon Rogers Tel: 0845 5143123 / 07785 520274 Email: [email protected] [email protected] Vat Reg No 900 9655 28

2005 Importation to site, stockpiling, processing, exporting to local markets throughout the year Q1 24th February Supply quantity of crushed graded recycled rubble from Pendrethen Quarry for land drainage at St. Mary’s Riding 158 -2nd March Centre. March 4th- Supply crushed recycled aggregate from Pendrethen Quarry (mixed grades) to Star Castle Hotel 155 15th March Supply further block rubble and process into crushed recycled aggregate; sources include Duchy of Waste at 158 Longstone Farm and further supplies from Pendrethen Quarry. General movements of materials. Q2 19th April At Garrison, St Mary’s; Mulciber Ltd breaking out and removing degraded concrete road, hauling away arisings to 156 Pendrethen Quarry, screening and crushing arisings at quarry, resupply to Garrison site and relay as new track, and supply additional crushed recycled aggregate from Pendrethen Quarry to complete new track. 27th April Supply quantity of graded cleaned topsoil from Pendrethen Quarry for new garden area at Star Castle Hotel. 159 May Supply quantity of 20mm-dust graded crushed recycled aggregate from Pendrethen Quarry to Star Castle 159 4th June Supply and deliver bagged recycled aggregate from Pendrethen Quarry to new parking area at Star Castle. 161 30th June Continuation of supply of local recycled aggregate for ongoing construction of St. Marys Riding Centre; during this 166 period large volumes and tonnages of material supplied from CIOS Moorwell tip as raw crusher feedstock for processing at stables construction site and at Pendrethen Quarry. Q3 24th August Supply of crushed recycled aggregate from Pendrethen Quarry to Ray Warnes at McFarlands Down; road repair to 164 McFarlands Down track outside Ray Warnes house Continued As above, continuation of supply of local recycled aggregate for ongoing construction of St. Marys Riding Centre; 166 from Q2 during this period large volumes and tonnages of material supplied from CIOS Moorwell tip as raw crusher feedstock for processing at stables construction site and at Pendrethen Quarry. During this project large tonnages of cleaned recycled crushed aggregates and recyclates were supplied. Q4 Continued As above completed supply of local recycled aggregate for ongoing construction of St. Marys Riding Centre; during this 166 from Q2 period large volumes and tonnages of material supplied from CIOS Moorwell tip as raw crusher feedstock for processing at stables construction site and at Pendrethen Quarry. October Brian Sandford and Diccon Rogers/Mulciber Ltd working together at Porthcressa on a hard rock granite removal 165 project using equipment and techniques formerly employed at Pendrethen Quarry; some materials from site are Witness statement removed to Pendrethen for recycling. 21st Supply of quantity of bagged recycled crushed aggregate 20mm-dust from Pendrethen Quarry to private 168

2

Mulciber Ltd Lunnon Farm, St Mary's Isles of Scilly, TR21 0NZ Diccon Rogers Tel: 0845 5143123 / 07785 520274 Email: [email protected] [email protected] Vat Reg No 900 9655 28

November client/agricultural client of St. Agnes. 21st Supply of quantity of bagged recycled crushed aggregate from Pendrethen Quarry to the Council of the Isles of Scilly, 171 November St. Mary’s Airport for use in airside concrete apron extension

2006 Importation to site, stockpiling, processing, exporting to local markets throughout the year Q1 16th – 19th Supply of quantity of crushed graded recycled aggregate from Pendrethen Quarry to Chiverton Builders St. Marys. 175 February March Supply recycled/recovered facing granite/walling stone from Pendrethen Quarry to Building contractors, St. Marys. 178 March Relocate mobile rock crusher from Pendrethen Quarry to St. Martins waste management site Highertown, St Martins 182 to the order of Duchy of Cornwall, Council of the Isles of Scilly and ReZolve Kernow in new initiative to resurface and reconstruct the St. Martins site. At site provide crushing services working with on island contractor crush and lay large quantities of block and stone into new surface. Q2 April Supply quantity of cleaned graded topsoil from Pendrethen Quarry to Star Castle for use in garden landscaping 185 April-May Provide demolition and recycling services to building contractor for local housing project at Branksea House; supply 188 crushed cleaned recycled aggregate from Pendrethen Quarry for local housing project. June Supply quantity of graded crushed recycled aggregate from Pendrethen Quarry to building contractor for use in local 189 housing project. Q3 14th July Supply quantity of crushed recycled aggregate from Pendrethen Quarry to private client for development work at 190 Porthmellon Industrial Estate. 17th August Supply and deliver quantity of cleaned recycled topsoil from Pendrethen Quarry to Star Castle staff accommodation. 198 Q4 1st October Improved trommell screen purchased from mainland Cornwall for refurbishment and use in Pendrethen Quarry. Also Receipts improved screening system and conveyor system purchased from wharves at Truro, ex Cornish Calcified Seaweed, shipped to Scilly by landing craft and installed at Quarry. New systems installed allow different grades of recycled aggregate to be produced. 13th October Supply quantity of cleaned crushed recycled aggregate from Pendrethen Quarry to building contractor for local 208 housing project. October Supply mobile electric recycling conveyor from Pendrethen Quarry to Tresco estate. 210 October- Supply quantity of cleaned crushed recycled aggregate from Pendrethen Quarry to building contractor for use in St. 212 November Marys housing project 1st November Application by Mulciber Ltd to Isles of Scilly Area of Outstanding Natural Beauty (AONB) for grant funding for Application by Mulciber screening machinery for rubble recycling to work alongside mobile rock crusher. Grant application cites >800 tonnes Ltd to ANOB SDF.

3

Mulciber Ltd Lunnon Farm, St Mary's Isles of Scilly, TR21 0NZ Diccon Rogers Tel: 0845 5143123 / 07785 520274 Email: [email protected] [email protected] Vat Reg No 900 9655 28

building waste currently stored in pit at Pendrethen Quarry St. Mary’s and note intention in grant application is stated as a focus on ‘providing high quality local recyclates for use as construction aggregates, sub-base and fill… [ and ]… to establish picking out of quality building granite from screened waste where possible. This will be stockpiled for reuse in construction projects.’ Application is successful and funding received. LJH tipsaver 200 mobile box screen duly purchased new and shipped to islands in early 2009. Screen unit goes straight to work at Pendrethen Quarry. Winning of clean graded recycled aggregate production from pit is accelerated for use in local projects December Demolition of redundant agricultural building at Normandy Farm St. Mary’s for redevelopment of site for local 213 housing; block and other C&D material hauled to Pendrethen Quarry for screening, crushing and recycling. Much material is “closed loop” recycling and is resupplied to the construction project after processing. 2007 Importation to site, stockpiling, processing, exporting to local markets throughout the year Q1 February Supply facing granite/walling stone from Pendrethen Quarry for work at new gig sheds St. Mary’s. 216 March Supply facing granite/walling stone from Pendrethen Quarry to specialist contractor for use in local heritage projects. 226 January – Supply quantity of crushed recycled aggregate from Pendrethen Quarry to building contractor for redevelopment of 227 March local housing at Normandy Farm, St Mary’s. Q2 27th June Provide large grade recycled aggregate from Pendrethen Quarry for drainage and soakaway works on St. Mary’s. 241 Q3 July Supply 90-50mm grade crushed recycled aggregate from Pendrethen Quarry to building contractor, St. Martin’s for 254 use in building project September Supply quantity of cleaned crushed recycled aggregate from Pendrethen Quarry for use in road repairs 258 September Supply facing granite/walling stone from Pendrethen Quarry to specialist contractor for use in local heritage projects. 259 September Hire of 25 te excavator from BAM Nuttall Off Island Quays and relocation via ISSCo landing craft to Bar Point; Various discharge the excavator and transit to Quarry; use of excavator to accelerate recycling of material deposited in pit Q4 November Supply quantity of cleaned recycled topsoil from Pendrethen Quarry for local garden construction 269 December Supply quantity of cleaned recycled topsoil from Pendrethen Quarry for local garden landscaping 276 December Supply facing granite/walling stone from Pendrethen Quarry to specialist contractor for use in local heritage projects. 277 December Completion of supply of various grade crushed recycled aggregate from Pendrethen Quarry to building contractor for 277 Normandy Farm local housing project; December Supply quantity of crushed recycled aggregate from Pendrethen Quarry for local road repairs on roads and tracks. 282 December Haul in and process quantity of block wall demolition arisings from site to Pendrethen Quarry and recycled. 283 2008 Importation to site, stockpiling, processing, exporting to local markets throughout the year

4

Mulciber Ltd Lunnon Farm, St Mary's Isles of Scilly, TR21 0NZ Diccon Rogers Tel: 0845 5143123 / 07785 520274 Email: [email protected] [email protected] Vat Reg No 900 9655 28

Q1 January Supply and lay clean graded ram from Pendrethen Quarry to Higher Moors Nature Trail and compact and lay as trail 285 pathway. 23rd-25th Dredge St. Mary’s harbour intersection area between Old Quay and Main Quay. Haul away to Pendrethen Quarry, 287 January screen crush and recycle quantity of intertidal cobbles/stones. February Supply quantity of graded crushed recycled aggregate from Pendrethen Quarry for St. Agnes Quay approach road and 295 drainage scheme on St. Mary’s. March Further dredging of St. Mary’s harbour for Duchy of Cornwall. Haul away to Pendrethen Quarry, screen crush and 301 recycle quantity of intertidal cobbles/stones. Q2 7th April Supply from Pendrethen Quarry quantity of recycled cleaned crushed aggregate for drainage project St. Mary’s. 306 May-June Supply clean graded recycled aggregate from Pendrethen Quarry for redevelopment works at Green Farm St Mary’s. 323 June Demolition activities at Green Farm. Haul away arising materials and crush/recycle at Pendrethen. 324 June Supply quantity of hardcore, crushed recycled aggregate from Pendrethen Quarry for hard standing adjacent to 325 machinery sheds farm buildings St. Mary’s Various Various supplies of crushed recycled aggregate from Pendrethen Quarry to off island Quay projects. Various 15th/16th Visit by Duchy Mineral Agent to advise on site clean-up proposals & recommencement of quarrying activities. Existing Sworn Statement April quarry stock witnessed as being recovered from base of quarry. Screener & excavator at site. Q3 14th July Document prepared by Duchy to assist Chief Planning Officer of CIOS in the understanding of what is ongoing at Correspondence & plan Pendrethen. July Extensive removal of scrap metal from Pendrethen Quarry, extracted and cleaned by Mulciber Ltd and exported to 326 mainland recycling centre via landing craft. This further clearance of pit area allows further space for recycling of C&D waste. July Supply quantity of crushed recycled aggregate from Pendrethen Quarry for use in local building projects 329a July Supply quantity of crushed recycled aggregate from Pendrethen Quarry to building contractor for local housing 328 project. August Supply quantity of various grades crushed recycled aggregate to engineering contractor from Pendrethen Quarry for 329b improvement works at local power station St. Mary’s. August Supply quantity crushed graded recycled aggregate from Pendrethen Quarry for local farm track repair work. 339 September Acquisition of further plant for recycling including air compressor and tooling, International tractor, and Liebherr 16 te Purchase invoices and tracked excavator from Tresco for use at Quarry in recycling and other activities. Excavator delivered by Landing Craft payments to Bar Point and transited to Quarry. September Supply quantity of graded ram from Pendrethen Quarry for road repair work. 340 September Supply deliver and lay quantity of crushed recycled graded aggregate from Pendrethen Quarry for local track and road 341

5

Mulciber Ltd Lunnon Farm, St Mary's Isles of Scilly, TR21 0NZ Diccon Rogers Tel: 0845 5143123 / 07785 520274 Email: [email protected] [email protected] Vat Reg No 900 9655 28

repairs. September Supply deliver and lay quantity of crushed recycled aggregate from Pendrethen Quarry for Porthlow boat park track 341 (2) improvements. September Supply deliver and lay quantity of crushed recycled aggregate from Pendrethen Quarry for local track and road repairs 342 Lenteven and Q4 October Supply quantity of various grades crushed recycled aggregate from Pendrethen Quarry for use in the extension works 337 of the Town Hall for the Council of the Isles or Scilly, St. Mary’s. October Supply and deliver quantity of local graded ram from Pendrethen Quarry for road repairs at Garrison, St. Mary’s. 340 October Completion of St. Agnes Quay rock armour and completion of supply of ancillary materials to engineering contractor 347 from Pendrethen Quarry 6th November Press article in ‘Cornishman’ newspaper referring to repairs to Portloo slipway requiring 1,000t rock, 60t cement & Cornishman newspaper, 180t sand, with materials “salvaged” from Pendrethen Quarry. & Duchy possibly seeking EU Convergence funding. Scilly page (6th Reports of CIOS Planning Meeting, including discussion of blasting at Quarry and condition of road. Material to be November 2008) moved by road from Pendrethen Quarry with comment from CIOS Chief Planning Officer regarding logistics of material Minutes of Council movement & timescales. Publicity of CIOS awareness of sourcing material from Pendrethen Quarry. Planning Meeting November Supply further crushed recycled aggregate from Pendrethen Quarry to engineering contractor for local power station 345 improvement works 2nd December Management Plans under discussion with CIOS Planning December Supply of cleaned topsoil from import and cleaning from Pendrethen Quarry for footpath works St. Mary’s 352 2009 Importation to site, stockpiling, processing, exporting to local markets throughout the year Q1 January Hire of rock breaking quarry equipment from Pendrethen Quarry for works on St. Mary’s Quay – C&D recycling 355 equipment active in specialist operations within islands. Q2 April-May Improvement works at Porthmellon Industrial Estate utilizing Pendrethen Quarry plant equipment and operatives; 371 supply ram and crushed recycled aggregate from Pendrethen Quarry; hauled away arising sand as dug to Pendrethen Quarry, cleaned screened and recycled. May Dig and lay field drainage weeper system for McFarlands Down/ houses for Duchy of Cornwall using 16 359 tonne excavator tracked directly from Pendrethen Quarry; use of larger excavator enabled efficient work at faster pace. Surplus arising rock removed to Pendrethen Quarry and crushed/recycled. Q3 August Mulciber Ltd Quarry operatives using plant and equipment from quarry work in conjunction with Duchy of Cornwall to 364 carry out repairs to McFarlands Down road, St. Mary’s. Quantity of graded local ram from Pendrethen Quarry supplied for trackway repair material.

6

Mulciber Ltd Lunnon Farm, St Mary's Isles of Scilly, TR21 0NZ Diccon Rogers Tel: 0845 5143123 / 07785 520274 Email: [email protected] [email protected] Vat Reg No 900 9655 28

September Supply quantity of local graded ram from Pendrethen Quarry for track repairs. 364 September Supply additional quantity of local graded ram from Pendrethen Quarry for track repairs 365 Q4 October Hire of rock breaking quarry equipment from Pendrethen Quarry including compressor for hard rock works on St. 372 Mary’s November Haul away to Pendrethen Quarry and recycle arising concrete rubble from reconstruction of lifeboat slip at St. Mary’s 376 Harbour December Haul away to Pendrethen Quarry and recycle further arising concrete rubble from reconstruction of lifeboat slip at St. 384 Mary’s Harbour 2010 Importation to site, stockpiling, processing, exporting to local markets throughout the year Q1 February Supply quantity of graded ram and recycled aggregate from Pendrethen Quarry and lay and compact for new trackway N392 Q2 April Haul away to Pendrethen Quarry and recycle arising concrete rubble from Trenoweth Road. N390 Q3 July Supply quantity of clean graded recycled aggregate and clean graded top soil from Pendrethen Quarry for new N396 drainage works July Supply quantity of clean graded recycled aggregate from Pendrethen Quarry for new drainage works N402 July Supply quantity of clean graded recycled aggregate from Pendrethen Quarry for new drainage works N403 August Haul away to Pendrethen Quarry and recycle large granite boulders from construction site N408 10th Sept Isles of Scilly Area Outstanding Natural Beauty’s Planning Consultative Panel (PCP) report to CIOS Chief Planning Copy AONB letter. Office. Supporting the use of sustainable local raw materials & recycling/reuse of materials from development projects, until such a time that they can be reused. Note is made of Pendrethen’s potential role. Q4 October- Supply quantity of various recycled aggregates from Pendrethen Quarry for various road and track repairs Various December December Haul away to Pendrethen Quarry and recycle arising stone N418 2011 Importation to site, stockpiling, processing, exporting to local markets throughout the year Q1 January Supply quantity of graded ram from Pendrethen Quarry for works on St.Agnes N421 Q2 Throughout Work ongoing – processing Work records Quarter Q3 August Supply quantity of various civil engineering materials from Pendrethen Quarry for sea defence and road repair N448 September Haul away to Pendrethen Quarry and recycle sand from Porthloo Boat Park N451 September Excavate haul away and recycle top soil at Pendrethen Quarry from garden of house ‘Jedi’, McFarlands Down N452 September Supply quantity of crushed recycled aggregate from Pendrethen Quarry for hardstanding at Porthloo Boat Park N454

7

Mulciber Ltd Lunnon Farm, St Mary's Isles of Scilly, TR21 0NZ Diccon Rogers Tel: 0845 5143123 / 07785 520274 Email: [email protected] [email protected] Vat Reg No 900 9655 28

September Further supplies of quantity of various recycled materials from Pendrethen Quarry for hardstanding at Porthloo Boat N455 Park Q4 October Excavate, haul away to Pendrethen Quarry and recycle large granite boulders arising from agricultural field N456 improvements, St. Mary’s October Supply and deliver quantity of crushed recycled aggregate from Pendrethen Quarry for various works St. Mary’s N457 December Supply and deliver quantity of crushed recycled aggregate from Pendrethen Quarry for council of the IOS water N461 treatment plant works St. Mary’s 2012 Importation to site, stockpiling, processing, exporting to local markets throughout the year Q1 February Supply quantity of crushed recycled aggregate from Pendrethen Quarry for construction of new industrial unit N465 Porthmellon Industrial Estate St. Mary’s February Supply and deliver quantity of clean graded ram from Pendrethen Quarry for works at Porthcressa N469 February Urgent requests from CIOS to Pendrethen operator to receive inert C&D arising materials from Porthcressa Emails Regeneration Project at Pendrethen as there are “no other available sites” 22nd Feb Email from CIOS Strategic Investment Manager to Operator stating CIOS happy for use of Porthcressa arisings at Emails Pendrethen, subject to condition of track being made good & that activities are disclosed to local residents first 23rd Feb Correspondence from Mulciber Ltd (Operator) to CIOS Chief Planning & Development Officer setting out terms for Letter Lawful Use of Pendrethen for receiving, reprocessing, selling & hauling non-hazardous waste, as follows: i 1000 cubic metres will be received from Porthcressa, excavated by Council’s contractor. i Council agreed that Mulciber Ltd will receive this at Pendrethen to continue the clean-up of the quarry (as per agreed management plan, including perimeter bunding); grade/crush/screen the material for resale locally as recyclate/secondary aggregate. i Will receive arisings as long as it is not a one-off activity and fully understood and entered into on the basis that the use of the premises was a lawful and established Use of the quarry providing affordable, green recycled aggregates product to the local market. i Will receive materials without delay to the Council commencement date and in recognition that there is no Planning or general compliance risk to the operations of those involved. i Suggests Council “may wish to formalise” by the grant a Certificate of Lawful Use (10 years); i Will carry out the work/receive the materials if y the price received is based on Mulciber Ltd not needing to undertake any compliance permitting work; y The situation with regard to Planning/Lawful Use (including permitting) is no more complex

8

Mulciber Ltd Lunnon Farm, St Mary's Isles of Scilly, TR21 0NZ Diccon Rogers Tel: 0845 5143123 / 07785 520274 Email: [email protected] [email protected] Vat Reg No 900 9655 28

than that outlined in the letter & DR’s understanding Agreement understood from CIOS & material delivered & deposited at Pendrethen Quarry in accordance with agreement by Council’s contractor from 27th Feb onwards 27th Feb Receipt of quantity of arisings (sand, gravel, boulders) at Pendrethen Quarry from CIOS Porthcressa development. Photographs & Delivery and deposition by CIOS appointed contractor (Kier Ltd). correspondence 29th Feb Various support from local construction trade for acquisition of new mobile crusher by Mulciber – evidence for Letters of support continued support for products from local market 1st March Correspondence received from the Chief Technical Officer (CTO) of the CIOS supporting the application by Mulciber Letter Ltd Ltd for a LAG grant for the acquisition of a new mobile rock crusher to ‘enable the enhanced production of local recycled secondary aggregate, which offers to many construction applications an excellent, environmentally sound and cost-effective alternative to importing aggregate from the mainland.’ The CTO further states that he is ‘confident that my parent committee would also support the potential to recycle arisings on local construction sites, which can reduce costs via promotion of on-site production of secondary aggregates and reduce traffic movements.’ And adds that ‘The conversion of waste into a recognised raw material is clearly in accordance with established best practice and complementary to the Islands waste management strategy.’ CIOS support for processing materials from local construction sites to produce recycled aggregates. 27th March Instruction from CIOS to receive at Pendrethen Quarry a minimum of 700m3 specified arisings from Porthcressa N472 ORDER NUMBER Regeneration Project and recycle (to the order of the Head of Economic Development, relevant senior council officers, 98506 and the Head of Planning. Q2 April Supply quantity of sand from Pendrethen Quarry for drainage works St. Mary’s N475 Q3 March-April LAG grant received for purchase of Komatsu BR100 mobile crusher in order to process inert construction & demolition Receipt wastes & site arisings at local sites and Pendrethen Quarry. Figures in application stated as 3700 te aggregates, 10000 te ram, soil. July Receipt of tarmac from CIOS for temporary storage at Pendrethen Quarry until such a time that it can be re-used for Emails & photographs road maintenance. July Supply and deliver quantity of clean recycled top soil from Pendrethen Quarry for landscaping and paving works on St. N490 Mary’s 10th August Instruction from CIOS to receive at Pendrethen Quarry a further 257 tonnes of specified arisings from Porthcressa INVOICE N494 REF: Regeneration Project and recycle ORDER NUMBER 100714 August Trial crushing and screening of construction and demolition waste from school project, at Moorwell waste Emails (conditions of management facility using Mulciber Ltd mobile plant. Instruction from CIOS with intention of product removal for acceptance & agreement storage at Pendrethen Quarry and resale to local market. Environment Agency inspection of aggregate products. with CEO CIOS 10th Aug.

9

Mulciber Ltd Lunnon Farm, St Mary's Isles of Scilly, TR21 0NZ Diccon Rogers Tel: 0845 5143123 / 07785 520274 Email: [email protected] [email protected] Vat Reg No 900 9655 28

Works progress emails to 22nd Aug). Photographic record of works. September On-going storage of CIOS tarmac at quarry and intention for re-use on CIOS sites elsewhere on the islands. CIOS pay Email correspondence & for storage of material at quarry. payment receipt. September Supply quantities of various recycled aggregates and materials from Pendrethen Quarry for footpath works St. Mary’s N499 Q4 October Storage at Pendrethen Quarry of tarmac arisings from Porthcressa N503 October Storage at Pendrethen Quarry of tarmac arisings from Porthcressa N509/1 October Haul away and recycle at Pendrethen Quarry quantity of arising top soil from new agricultural barn, St. Mary’s N506 11th October Meeting between Operator, Duchy, CIOS Chief Planning & Development Officer. CIOS Local Planning Authority (LPA) is CIOS meeting minutes aware that current use includes waste transfer 11th October Correspondence from CIOS Strategic Investment Manager to Operator to request that Pendrethen receives another 12 Email skips (4 lorries) of sand. 22nd October Correspondence from Operator to CIOS Strategic Investment Manager to confirm definition of ‘use’ for Porthcressa Email arisings at quarry. Operator states will be for creation of bunds and/or reprocessing for sale at his discretion. Also limiting liability for making-good the track to Porthcressa traffic only. Request Council ‘note’ contents of this email as instruction for works 12th Nov Correspondence from Operator to CIOS Chief Executive Officer, Planning & Development Officer & Duchy Confirming Email quarry has held for use at Pothlow slipway for many years, attaching 2008 Cornishman & Magazine articles on this which refer to previous Planning Committee notes on this subject. States Committee notes encourage, where possible, all materials to be sourced from salvaged materials at Pendrethen & suggests that nothing has changed since then, apart from greater emphasis on sustainable practices. CIOS approved Environmental Plan for construction of Slipway notes Pendrethen materials. November Supply quantity of crushed recycled aggregate from Pendrethen Quarry to contractor for use in Porthcressa N507 redevelopment temporary works St. Mary’s Oct/Nov Supply quantity of crushed recycled aggregate and clean graded ram from Pendrethen Quarry to building contractor N508 for various works St. Mary’s November Storage at Pendrethen Quarry of tarmac arisings from Porthcressa N514 December Supply quantity of crushed recycled aggregate from Pendrethen Quarry for use in new concrete at CIOS desalination N509/2 plant St. Mary’s December Storage at Pendrethen Quarry of tarmac arisings from Porthcressa N515

10

Mulciber Ltd Lunnon Farm, St Mary's Isles of Scilly, TR21 0NZ Diccon Rogers Tel: 0845 5143123 / 07785 520274 Email: [email protected] [email protected] Vat Reg No 900 9655 28

December Storage at Pendrethen Quarry of tarmac arisings from Porthcressa N516 2013 Importation to site, stockpiling, processing, exporting to local markets throughout the year Q1 January Supply quantity of additional crushed recycled aggregate from Pendrethen Quarry to building contractor for use in N516 new concrete at CIOS desalination plant St. Mary’s January Supply quantity of crushed recycled aggregate from Pendrethen Quarry for use in works at CIOS Buzza Reservoir site, N520 E St. Mary’s January Storage at Pendrethen Quarry of tarmac arisings from Porthcressa N521 February Supply of quantity of crushed recycled aggregate from Pendrethen Quarry for works on St. Mary’s N524 February Supply of quantity of crushed recycled aggregate from Pendrethen Quarry for use in sea defence works and road N526 repair Old Town, St. Mary’s February Supply quantity of crushed recycled aggregate from Pendrethen Quarry for use in works at CIOS Buzza Reservoir site, N527 St. Mary’s February Supply quantity of crushed recycled aggregate and various materials from Pendrethen Quarry for use in road repairs, N528 St. Mary’s February Storage at Pendrethen Quarry of tarmac arisings from Porthcressa N529 February Supply quantity of crushed recycled aggregate and various materials from Pendrethen Quarry for use in road repairs, N531 St. Mary’s February Supply quantity of crushed recycled aggregate and various materials from Pendrethen Quarry for use in road repairs, N532 St. Mary’s February Supply quantity of crushed recycled aggregate and various materials from Pendrethen Quarry for use in road repairs, N533 St. Mary’s March Supply quantity of crushed recycled aggregate from Pendrethen Quarry for use in swimming pool repairs, St. Mary’s N535 March Storage at Pendrethen Quarry of tarmac arisings from Porthcressa N538 March Supply of crushed recycled aggregate and various materials from Pendrethen Quarry for use in paving and N539 landscaping, St. Mary’s March Supply quantity of crushed recycled aggregate from Pendrethen Quarry for use in drainage works St. Mary’s N541 March Storage at Pendrethen Quarry of tarmac arisings from Porthcressa N542 March Supply and deliver quantity of crushed recycled aggregate and various materials from Pendrethen Quarry for use in N542 water course works, St. Mary’s Q2 April Storage at Pendrethen Quarry of tarmac arisings from Porthcressa N546 April Storage at Pendrethen Quarry of tarmac arisings from Porthcressa N547

11

Mulciber Ltd Lunnon Farm, St Mary's Isles of Scilly, TR21 0NZ Diccon Rogers Tel: 0845 5143123 / 07785 520274 Email: [email protected] [email protected] Vat Reg No 900 9655 28

May Storage at Pendrethen Quarry of tarmac arisings from Porthcressa N550 Q3 July Re-handling at Pendrethen Quarry of tarmac arisings from Porthcressa N554 2014 Importation to site, stockpiling, processing, exporting to local markets throughout the year Q1 February Supply quantity of clean graded crushed recycled aggregate from Pendrethen Quarry for construction works, St Mary’s N566 February Supply quantity of clean graded crushed recycled aggregate from Pendrethen Quarry for drainage works, St Mary’s N567 February Haul away and recycle quantity of rubble arisings at Pendrethen Quarry from road and track works, St Mary’s N568 February Supply quantity of clean graded crushed recycled aggregate from Pendrethen Quarry for road and trackway works, St N569 Mary’s March Supply quantity of clean graded crushed recycled aggregate from Pendrethen Quarry for road and trackway works, St N571 Mary’s March Supply quantity of crushed stone from Pendrethen Quarry used for road creation & hard base for asphalt plant, N572 Lagan's site, St. Mary's. Paid for by Lagan Construction (main contractor to CIOS for airport construction works). March Supply clean graded ram from Pendrethen Quarry for road repairs works, St Mary’s N574 Q2 April Crushing and stockpiling of Pendrethen stone, sourced in accordance with the Management Plan & as per the Various requirements of the Duchy construction contract, to provide hardcore and sub-base material for repairs to the Porthloo slipway. Reconstruction of Porthloo Slip and redevelopment of Porthloo Boat Park uses extensive amounts of crushed recycled aggregate from Pendrethen, stockpiled, imported and processed. Q3 July/August Mobile crusher from Pendrethen Quarry working at St. Mary’s airport, providing extensive onsite recycling of arisings N579 for airport runway resurfacing project. Materials to / from Pendrethen. August Agreement from Duchy & notification to EA of receipt of some small packages of clean inert non-hazardous concrete Email block rubble to crush and recycle at the quarry & recover in track repairs under an Environment Agency U1 Exemption (granted 2nd Sept). Q4 October Provision of quantity of stone & aggregate products from Pendrethen Quarry to a number of local Various invoices/receipts onwards – engineering/construction projects, including: December i Large local granite stones >100kg weight for sea defence works at Porth Minnack, St. Mary's. Mulciber contract with CIOS. i Hard core/ aggregate used for several projects, such as sub-base for floor of new de-salination plant on St. Mary's. CIOS/Wright Construction (main contractor to CIOS). December Extensive supply of crushed recycled stone and aggregate from Pendrethen to Duchy of Cornwall road projects, St Various invoices Agnes. Concrete cube tests carried out on concrete made from recycled stone aggregates; results excellent. including N591

12

Mulciber Ltd Lunnon Farm, St Mary's Isles of Scilly, TR21 0NZ Diccon Rogers Tel: 0845 5143123 / 07785 520274 Email: [email protected] [email protected] Vat Reg No 900 9655 28

2015 Importation to site, stockpiling, processing, exporting to local markets throughout the year Q1 Until Continuation of above – St Agnes road materials supply for Duchy of Cornwall Various invoices February including N592 March Break out and remove concrete from temporary works related to St Mary’s airport. Recycle at Pendrethen Various including N 596 March At Pendrethen Recycle and supply crushed recycled aggregate and ram from/for CIOS Innovation Centre (former Various including N597 Wholesalers), St Mary’s Q2 April Supply recycled stone chippings from Pendrethen N599 April Supply crushed recycled aggregate for road repairs, St Mary’s N 600 June Further extensive supply of crushed recycled stone and aggregate from Pendrethen to Duchy of Cornwall road Various including N604 projects, St Agnes June Supply crushed recycled aggregate for road repairs, St Mary’s N 605 Q3 July Extensive supply of crushed recovered/recycled stone aggregates via Pendrethen for reconstruction of N 606 drainage leat following storm damage. June / July Processing of waste stone from roadworks at Pendrethen N 607 July Supply graded recycled aggregate and fill from Pendrethen to drainage and septic tank works, St Mary’s N 612 July Supply large graded recycled aggregate and fill from Pendrethen for roadworks, St Mary’s N613 August Supply graded recycled aggregate and fill from Pendrethen for roadworks, St Mary’s N617 August Supply graded recycled aggregate and fill from Pendrethen to drainage and septic tank works, St Mary’s N619 August Supply graded recycled aggregate and fill from Pendrethen to drainage and environmental works, St Mary’s N620 September Supply graded recycled aggregate from Pendrethen to general works, St Mary’s N622 September Supply graded recycled aggregate from Pendrethen to general works, St Mary’s N 623 September Supply graded recycled aggregate from Pendrethen to construction works, St Agnes N 624 September Supply graded recycled aggregate from Pendrethen to general domestic construction works, McFarlands Down, St N 625 Mary’s September Supply graded recycled aggregate from Pendrethen to works, St Agnes N 626 Q4 October Supply recycled aggregate and fill for redundant well capping works, St Mary’s N 628 October Recycle at Pendrethen inert concrete subsea cable protection arisings in relation to inter- island /mainland HV mains 630 power network by request DNO WPD and subcontractor

13