a quarterly journal of THf JOURNAL Of philosophy EDITOR: P. S. Schievella ICRITICAL ANALY~I~ CONSULTANTS Razid Ahelson. William P. AIstoll. John Anton, Bertram Bandman, Monr<>e Beardsley, Antony Flt'w, L~wi..; Hahn, Sidlwy Hook, John Hospers, Joseph Margolis, Willis !\Ioore, Parviz '\Iorewedg~, SidllPY :'Ilorgenbesst'r, Gerald Myers, Ernest Nagel, Willard Van Orman Quint', Israel Scheffler, Evelyn Shirk, Fred Sommers. Victorino Tejera, \Iarx W. Wartofsky. Vo!tIlBe V, N umher 1 Kai Nielsell Wh at Egoism Distortedly Asks Mi .. ha,,) Sean Quinll Mustn't God Create For The Best'! Louise Horowitz Indexical and Referential Charaeteristic.s of '1' John Til'tz Al,ility and Opportunity .J ult's L. Coleman J ustice and Preferential Hiring Ti!.or l\Iachan Human Rights: Some Points of Clarifieation Critical Review Joseph l\Iargolis Crime or Disease'~ Antony Flew AntollY Flew A Note in Reply The Jvurnul vI Critical ATlalysis is oriented, philosophically, toward Critical Analysis and Critical Naturalism in its various forms. However, contributions of signilicant intere4 dealing with otber perspectives will be al'cepted for publication. Single eopie,.;: $4.00. Annual suhscription rates: Individuals: $10.00; Librarie; and Educational In-titutions: $12.00. Corporations: $25.00. Sent to all memhers of The National Couneil for Critical. Analysis without additional charge. Postage: 25e Canada: 50c foreign. The Journal of Critical Analysis, Department of Philosophy 20.39 Kennedy Blvd., Jersey City State College, Jersey City, N. J. 07305

PHILOSOPHIA PHtLOSOPHICAL QUARTERLY OF ISRAEL Edited by Asa Kasher

Phi/osophia publishes articles, discussion notes, critical studies and book reviews in analytical philosophy. The 1975 volume of Phi/osophia includes, among other issues: • An issue on Language and Logic, to honour Y. Bar·Hillel on his sixtieth birthday, with papers by A. Ayer, L.J. Cohen, P. Geach, H. Herzberger, J. Hintikka, J.J. Katz, R. Martin, R. Stalnaker, R. Thomason, and P. Woodruff. • An issue on Identity, with papers by: D. Wiggins, L Henkin, M.J. Cresswe", J. Woods, H.N. Castai'ieda, and S. Körner. The 1974 volume of Phi/osophia included, among other issues, one on Formal Ontology, with papers by: H.N. Castai'ieda, N. Cocchiare"a, R. Eberle, and B. van Fraassen. The 1976 volume (first issue) will include papers by Don Locke and Kai Nielsen, critical studies by Gilbert Ryle (Platol. W.W. Bartley (Popper). M.J. Cresswell (Montague), J. Agassi (Fayerabend) and many other contributions. Published by Bar·"an University, Ramat Gan, Israel. Subscriptions: $10.00/year for individuals; $14.00/year for institutions. Editorial and business address: Department of Philosophy, Bar·"an University, Ramat Gan, Israel. British Journal for the Philosophy of Science

Volume 24, Number 2, June 1973

Articles

E.G.ZAHAR Why did Einstein's Programme supersede Lorentz's? (1) B. ELLIS The Logic of Subjective Prob ability

Discussions

C. HOWSON Must the Logical Probability of Laws be Zero? A. F. CHALMERS On Learning From Our Mistakes K. JONES Verisimilitude Versus Probable Verisimilitude B. COHEN and Harre and Non-Logical Necessity E.H.MADDEN

Reviews

J. C. GRAVES on R. S. Cohen and M. W. Wartofsky (eds.): Boston Studies in tbe Pbilosopby of Science, 5; J. L. MACKIE on Y. Bar-Hille! Aspects of Language; 1. C. JARVIE on S. Andreski Tbe Soda! Sciences as Sorcery

Programmes of Meetings

Single issues i 2.50 net (U.S. $ 8.00 in U.S.A. and Canada) 1973 Subscription price i 7.00 net (U.S. $ 22.00 in U.S.A. and Canada) Subscription price for members of the British Society for The Philosophy 01 Science i 4.50 (U.S. $ 14.00 in U.S.A. and Canada)

CAMBRIDGE UNIVERSITY PRESS Bentley House, 200 Euston Road, London NW 1 2 DB American Branch: 32 East 57th Street, New York, N.Y. 10022