GAO-19-68, Missile Defense
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
United States Government Accountability Office Report to Congressional Committees December 2018 MISSILE DEFENSE Air Force Report to Congress Included Information on the Capabilities, Operational Availability, and Funding Plan for Cobra Dane GAO-19-68 December 2018 MISSILE DEFENSE Air Force Report to Congress Included Information on the Capabilities, Operational Availability, and Funding Highlights of GAO-19-68, a report to Plan for Cobra Dane congressional committees Why GAO Did This Study What GAO Found First fielded in 1976 on Shemya Island In its January 2018 report to Congress, the Air Force reported how the Cobra in Alaska, the Cobra Dane radar faces Dane radar and the Long Range Discrimination Radar (LRDR) have shared and growing sustainment challenges that unique capabilities to support ballistic missile defense and space surveillance DOD plans to address through missions. The report noted that the respective locations of both radar systems modernization projects. Anticipating affect their ability to provide those capabilities. The Department of Defense future needs, DOD began investing in (DOD) also has other radar investments—the Pacific Radar and the Space new radar systems that share Fence, which, according to DOD officials, may reduce DOD’s reliance on Cobra capabilities with Cobra Dane to support Dane to provide ballistic missile defense and space surveillance capabilities. ballistic missile defense and space surveillance, including the LRDR The Cobra Dane Radar on Shemya Island, Alaska (Alaska), the Space Fence (Marshall Islands), and the Pacific Radar (location to be determined). The conference report accompanying a bill for the National Defense Authorization Act for Fiscal Year 2018 included a provision that GAO review the Air Force’s report to Congress on the operation and sustainment of Cobra Dane. This report identifies information included in the Air Force’s report and describes additional information that GAO reviewed on (1) the capabilities of the Cobra Dane radar and other planned radars to meet The Air Force’s report to Congress noted that Cobra Dane met its requirement DOD’s mission requirements, (2) for operational availability, which refers to the percentage of time that the radar is Cobra Dane’s operational availability able to meet its missions. GAO found that the Air Force has developed and the plan to mitigate the effect on procedures to mitigate risks when Cobra Dane is not available. For example, those missions when Cobra Dane is U.S. Northern Command and Missile Defense Agency (MDA) officials stated that not available, and (3) DOD’s funding they can mitigate risks when Cobra Dane is not available by using the Sea- plan and project cost estimates for the Based X-band radar to provide support for ballistic missile defense. The Air operation and sustainment of Cobra Force would face some limitations in its ability to conduct space surveillance if Dane and its site at Shemya Island. GAO reviewed the Air Force report and Cobra Dane were not available, as Cobra Dane tracks objects no other radar can related documentation, and track. However, MDA officials noted there are no plans to take Cobra Dane interviewed relevant officials. offline long enough to compromise space surveillance. The Air Force and MDA plan to contribute total funding of $278.6 million for the operation and sustainment of Cobra Dane, according to their fiscal year 2019 budget plans. Specifically, the Air Force and MDA plan to share funding for the operation and maintenance of the Cobra Dane radar and for three modernization projects that make up their sustainment plan for the radar. Further, the Air Force report noted that the Air Force also plans to provide $140 million in funding for the sustainment and maintenance of operational access to Cobra Dane’s site at Shemya Island. In addition, GAO found that the Air Force developed a total cost estimate for one project—known as the transmitter group replacement—but not View GAO-19-68. For more information, for its other two projects. Air Force officials plan to complete cost estimates for contact Joe Kirschbaum at (202) 512-9971 or those two projects in conjunction with their fiscal year 2020 budget submission. [email protected]. United States Government Accountability Office Contents Letter 1 Background 4 Air Force Reported That Cobra Dane and LRDR Can Contribute to Various Missions, and We Found That Additional Radar Investments May Reduce Reliance on Cobra Dane 6 Air Force Reported That Cobra Dane Generally Meets Its Requirements for Operational Availability, and We Found That the Air Force Can Mitigate Radar Downtime for Its Missions 11 Air Force Reported That DOD Has Plans to Fund Cobra Dane and Its Site, and We Found That It Has Developed Cost Estimates for Some Projects 13 Agency Comments 16 Appendix I GAO Contact and Staff Acknowledgments 18 Tables Table 1: Selected Radar Systems that Provide Ballistic Missile Defense or Space Surveillance Capabilities 5 Table 2: Ballistic Missile Defense Capabilities of Cobra Dane and the Long Range Discrimination Radar 7 Table 3: Planned Air Force and Missile Defense Agency (MDA) Funding for the Operation and Maintenance of Cobra Dane (in millions) 13 Table 4: Planned Funding for the Three Projects in Cobra Dane’s Sustainment Plan (in millions) 14 Table 5: Funding Plan for the Operation and Sustainment of Shemya Island (in millions) 15 Figures Figure 1: The Cobra Dane Radar 2 Figure 2: Illustration of Tracking Coverage Overlaps among AN/TPY-2, Cobra Dane, and the Long Range Discrimination Radar (LRDR) 9 Page i GAO-19-68 Missile Defense Abbreviations DOD Department of Defense LRDR Long Range Discrimination Radar MDA Missile Defense Agency This is a work of the U.S. government and is not subject to copyright protection in the United States. The published product may be reproduced and distributed in its entirety without further permission from GAO. However, because this work may contain copyrighted images or other material, permission from the copyright holder may be necessary if you wish to reproduce this material separately. Page ii GAO-19-68 Missile Defense Letter 441 G St. N.W. Washington, DC 20548 December 17, 2018 Congressional Committees The Cobra Dane radar faces growing sustainment challenges that the Department of Defense (DOD) plans to address through modernization projects. The Air Force fielded Cobra Dane in 1976 on Shemya Island, Alaska. In subsequent years, Cobra Dane has undergone upgrades and changes to its mission. From 1977 to 1994, the Air Force used Cobra Dane to support a primary mission of intelligence gathering, and to provide early warning of missile threats and conduct space surveillance (tracking objects in space) as additional missions.1 In 1994, the Air Force stopped using Cobra Dane to support missile warning. The Air Force also ceased using Cobra Dane for space surveillance for 5 years, but continued to operate the radar in a limited capacity to support intelligence gathering. In 2004, the Missile Defense Agency (MDA) completed upgrades to Cobra Dane so that it could contribute to a new ballistic missile defense mission. Since MDA completed the upgrades, the Air Force has used Cobra Dane to support ballistic missile defense and space surveillance missions. In anticipating future needs, DOD began investing in new radar systems that will provide varying mission capabilities. However, DOD does not intend for any one of these systems to be a complete replacement for Cobra Dane. Radar investments include the Long Range Discrimination Radar (LRDR) at Clear Air Force Station in Alaska; the Space Fence at Kwajalein Atoll, Marshall Islands; and the Pacific Radar. See figure 1 for a photo of the Cobra Dane radar. 1Specifically, Cobra Dane was constructed to provide intelligence gathering to verify a treaty between the United States and the Soviet Union to limit the quantities of ballistic missiles armed with nuclear warheads. Page 1 GAO-19-68 Missile Defense Figure 1: The Cobra Dane Radar Congress has expressed interest in DOD’s plan to use Cobra Dane to meet various mission requirements and how it would maximize the radar’s reliability and minimize life-cycle costs. Specifically, the conference report accompanying a bill for the National Defense Authorization Act for Fiscal Year 2018 (“the Act”) included a provision that the Air Force, in coordination with MDA and U.S. Northern Command, submit a report on the Cobra Dane radar to the congressional defense committees with its fiscal year 2019 budget request.2 The report was to outline the capabilities of Cobra Dane and alternative radars, DOD’s plan for the operation and sustainment of Cobra Dane, and the costs to 2H.R. Rep. No. 115-404, at 1047 (2017) (Conf. Rep.). In addition, House Report 114-537, the House report accompanying a bill for the National Defense Authorization Act of Fiscal Year 2017, also contained a provision for U.S. Strategic Command to report on the Cobra Dane radar. Specifically, it contained a provision that U.S. Strategic Command report on the cost, schedule, and program plans to upgrade DOD’s ballistic missile defense and space surveillance assets to maintain and eventually replace Cobra Dane. U.S. Strategic Command submitted a briefing in May 2017 that asserted DOD would continue to require Cobra Dane until it could be replaced with a system that provided equal or greater capability for ballistic missile defense. Page 2 GAO-19-68 Missile Defense sustain Cobra Dane and its site at Shemya Island. The Air Force submitted the report in January 2018. The conference report accompanying the Act also included a provision that we review the Air Force’s report to Congress.3 This report identifies information included in the Air Force’s report and describes additional information that we reviewed on (1) the capabilities of the Cobra Dane radar and other planned radars to meet DOD’s mission requirements, (2) Cobra Dane’s operational availability and the plan to mitigate the effect on those missions when Cobra Dane is not operationally available, and (3) DOD’s funding plan and project cost estimates related to the operation and sustainment of Cobra Dane and its site at Shemya Island.