<<

FORDHAM LAW REVIEW Published in January, May and November

VOLUME IV JANUARY, 1935 NUMBER 1

Subscription price, $2.00 a year Single issue, 75 cents

Edited by the Students of the Fordham EDITORIAL BOARD JuL-us APPELMAN Editor-in-Chief FRAcS J. POHL JOHN J. KLEIN Comment Editor Associate Decisions Editor JOHN B. COMAN JOHN A. ALBERT Decisions Editor Book Review Editor SAMUEL J. WORMS VILIAM H. ARxIN Legislation Editor Business Manager THOMAS V. O'Kszrs Associate Business Manager ANTouo A. BENED=r EDWARD J. FRIMAN GORDON W. MCKAN MAX BENxo FRANCIS J. GASPARNI JOSE'Hz F. ONoRATo JosEPH E. DOT RIcHARD H. JACXSON JoHn B. SABEL ELIZABETH M. DurFY IRA C. LAMBERT JoHlN S. SmL'LA JOHN J. DUNNE Louis LEvY STANLEY WOLDER MILDRED FiscHER ADOLPH S. ZiEOLER WALTER B. KENNEDY Faculty Adviser Editorial and General Offices, ,

CONTRIBUTORS To TIs Issur FREFmRCK EvAN CRANE, LL.B., 1889, , School of Law; LL.D., 1921, St. Lawrence University; LL.D., 1923, Columbia University; LLD., 1930, St. John's College; LL.D., 1931, . County Judge, Kings County, 1901-1907. Justice of the Supreme Court of New York, 1907-1917. Judge of the Court of Appeals of New York, 1917-1934. Chief Judge of the Court of Appeals of New York, 1933. Author of numerous essays and articles. WI.LmM D. GUTHuRi, A.M., 1909, Yale University; LL.D., 1916, . Storrs Lecturer at Yale University, 1907-1908. Ruggles Professor of Constitutional Law, Columbia University, 1911-1921. Argued many famous cases before United States Supreme Court including Income Tax Cases and Oregon School Law Case.t. Author of several books of essays and addresses. Former President of the New York State Bar Association and of the Association of the Bar of the City of New York. IGNATrus M. WILKnsoN, A.B., 1908, College of St. Francis Xavier, New York; LL.B., 1911, Fordham University, School of Law; AM., 1913, LL.D., 1924, Fordham Uni- versity. Lecturer in Law, 1912-1916, Assistant Professor of Law, 1916-1919, Pro- fessor of Law, 1919 to date, Fordham University, School of Law. Dean, 1923 to date, Fordham University, School of Law. EDWARD H. FOLEY, JR., LL.B., 1929, Fordham University, School of Law. Attorney for Reconstruction Finance Corporation, 1932. Assistant General Counsel, Public Works Administration, 1933. Director, Legal Division, Public Works Administration, Wash- ington, D. C., 1934. OsmouN K. FRAmEL, A.B., 1907, as of 1908, AM., 1908, Harvard University; LL.B., 1911, Columbia University; member of the New York Bar; author of THE SACco-VANzLTrI CASE (1931); THE CURSE OF BIGNESS, MISCELLANEOUS PAPERS OF JUSTICE BnANDLIS (1934); Concerning Searches and Seizures (1921) 34 HARv. L. REV. 361; The Su- preme Court and the Taxing Power of the States (1934) 28 ILL. L. REV. 612; Pro- cedural Aspects of Arbitration (1934) 83 U. O PA. L. REv. 226, and numerous other articles in various periodicals. WALTE B. KENNEDY, A.B., 1906, AM., 1912, Holy Cross College; LL.B., 1909, Harvard University, School of Law. Member of the New York, Massachusetts and District of Columbia Bars. Professor of Law, Fordham University, School of Law. Author of CASES ON PERSONAL PROPERTY (1932); Garnishment of Intangible Debts in New York (1926) 35 YALE L. J. 689; The New Deal in the Law (1934) 68 U. S. L. REv. 533, (1934) 2 U. S. L. Week 41, and other articles in law reviews.

HeinOnline -- 4 Fordham L. Rev. 72 1935 FORDHAM LAW REVIEW Published in January,May and November

VOLUME IV MAY, 1935 NUMBER 2

Subscription price, $2.o a year Single issue, 75 cents Edited by the Students of the Fordham Law School EDITORIAL BOARD JuLius APPELmA Editor-in-Chief FRANcs, J. Poni, JoHN B. ComAm Comment Editor Decisions Editor JoHN J. KLMN JoHN A. ALrT Legislation Editor Book Review Editor WnzTrA H. ARx=r Business Manager ANTONro A. BErNEm FRANCIS J. GASPA1RNI JosEaPI F. ONoRATo MAX BENxO Ricm.A H. JACKSON DAVID REICh JOSEPH E. Doll IRA C. LA=ERT Jom B. SABEL EI.ImnrAu M. Dur= Louis LEvY JonN S. STELA JOHN J. DuNnE GORDON W. McKEAr STANLE WOLDER MILDRED FiscnER THomAs V. O'KEEr ADOLPI S. ZIEOLER WALTER B. KENNEDr Faulty Adviser Student Contributors to This Issue EDWARD V. GROSS MLTON HARAWXTZ Editorial and General Offices, Woolworth Building, New York

CONTRIBUTORS TO Tms ISSUE VERY REvEREw A oYsius J. HOGAN, SJ., A.B., 1908, St. Joseph's College, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania; 1908, Entered Society of Jesus; A.M., 1915, Woodstock College, Wood- stock, Maryland; Ph.D., 1927, Cambridge University, England. Professor of Classics, Boston College, 1915-1920; Dean of Studies, Jesuit Normal College, Poughkeepsie, New York, 1928-1930; Dean of Studies, Jesuit Normal College, Wernersville, Pennsylvania, 1930; President, Fordham University, 1930-. JAdES A. DEEuArTY, LL.B., 1898, LL.M., 1899, New York Law School. Judge of the Court of General Sessions, New York County, 1916; Surrogate of New York County, 1935-. IGNATIUS M. WILKINsON, A.B., 1908, College of St. Francis Xavier, New York; LL.B., 1911, Fordham University, School of Law; A.M., 1913, LL.D., 1924, Fordham University. Lecturer in Law, 1912-1916, Associate Professor of Law, 1916-1919, Professor of Law, 1919 to date, Fordham University, School of Law. Dean, 1923 to date, Fordham University, School of Law. BERNAR L. SIENTAG, A.B., 1904, College of the City of New York; A.M., LL.B., 1908, Columbia University. Industrial Commissioner, State of New York, 1923. Justice of the City Court of the City of New York, 1924-1930; Justice of the Supreme Court of New York, 1930-. Author of The Opinions and Writings of Judge Benjamin N. Cardozo (1930) 30 COL. L. REv. 597; The Trial of a Civil Jury Action in New York, N.Y.L.J., March 25-30, 1935, and various other legal essays. Jo-" F. X. FINN, A.B., 1920, College of the City of New York; LL.B., 1923, Fordham University, School of Law. Member of the New York and Federal Bars. Associate Professor of Law, Fordham University, School of Law. Co-author CARMODY'S NEw YORK PRACTICE, CoMPACr EDITION, 1935; KEENER'S CASES ON CONTRACTS (3d ed. 1934); COM7ACT MANUAL OF NEW YORK CIVIL PRACTICE STATUTES (1933). Author of The Forging of Good Unilaterals Out of Bad Bilaterals (1933) 3 L. REV. 6, and other articles. FRirz MosEs, 1920, University of Berlin; Dr. juris, 1922, University of Halle-Wittenberg. Judge at the Landgericht Berlin, 1923. Author of GERmAN BUSINESS LAW: Fltal Solu- tion of Germany's Revaluation Problem (1931) 17 A. B. A. J. 57; Protection of Trade with Soviet Russia by Treaty (1934) 20 A. B. A. J. 207, and other articles,

HeinOnline -- 4 Fordham L. Rev. 272 1935 FORDHAM LAW REVIEW Published in January, lay and November

VOLUME IV NOVEMBER, 1935 NUMBER 3

Subscription price, $2.00 a year Single issue, 75 cents

Edited by the Students of the Fordham Law School

EDITORIAL BOARD 'MILDRED FISCHER Editor-in-Chief WILL. H. AR=IU EDWARD J. FRIEDMAN Comment Editor Decisions Editor STANLEY WOLDER PUaMP JONES Legislation Editor Book Review Editor JOHN T. RICE Business Manager ANTONIO A. BENEDETI FAInE M. McMULLEN PAUL J. SHINE ROBERT R. BERMAN JOSEPH F. ONORATO IRv0a L. SPANxa JOSEPH E. DoTI BERTRAM SAYmON JoHN S. STnLLA VICTOR FmrnoLD NORMA F. SHAPmO HAROLD P. SUSSMAN WILLIM J. FLEMING HERBERT WnYMAX A~mAND F. MACmANUS ADOLPH S. ZIEOLER WALEr B. KENNEDY Facdty Adviser Student Contributor to This Issue RsicHAR H. APPERT Editorial and General Offices, Woolworth Building, New York

CONTRIBUTORS TO THIs ISSUE BRENDAN F. BROWN, A.B., 1921, LL.B., 1924, Creighton University; LL.M., 1925, J.U.B. and J.U.L., 1926 J.U.D., 1927, Catholic University of America; DPhil. in law, 1932, Oxford University, England. Instructor in Law, Catholic University of America, School of Law. Author, TirE CANONICAL JURISTIC PERsoNAIaI=; THE RO AN CONCEPTON Or Law. Author, THE CANONICaL JURlsTIc PERSONALITY; THE ROMAN CoNcEPTION or THE JURISTIC PERSON; THE LAW OF TRUSTS IN THE EIGHTEENTu CENTURY. Contrlbu- tor to law reviews.

GEORGE P. WOODRUFF, Investment Analyst, in charge of investment counsel, Bureau of Business Conditions, Alexander Hamilton Institute, New York. Editor, INVESTMENT BuLLEIz; financial editor, Business Conditions Service; co-author BAER AND WOOD- RuF, COmmOD= EXCHANGES (3d ed. 1935); contributor to financial journals. Mem- ber of the Bar. OsmoND K. FRAENxEr., A.B., 1907, as of 1908, A.M., 1908, Harvard University; LL.B., 1911, Columbia University; member of the New York Bar. Author of THE SAcco-VAN=r CASE (1931); THE CURSE OF BIGNESS, MISCELLANEOUS PAPERs or JUSTICE BRANDEIS (1934); Concerning Searches and Seizures (1921) 34 HARv. L. REV. 361; The Supreme Court and the Taxing Power of the States (1934) 28 h. L. REv. 612; Procedural Aspects of Arbitration (1934) 83 U. OF PA. L. REv. 226; Creditors' Rights in Life Insurance (1935) 4 FoRDuAm L. REV. 35, and numerous other articles in various periodicals.

HeinOnline -- 4 Fordham L. Rev. 456 1935