Download (2MB)

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Download (2MB) Cunningham, Graeme James (2018) Law, rhetoric, and science: historical narratives in Roman law. PhD thesis. https://theses.gla.ac.uk/41030/ Copyright and moral rights for this work are retained by the author A copy can be downloaded for personal non-commercial research or study, without prior permission or charge This work cannot be reproduced or quoted extensively from without first obtaining permission in writing from the author The content must not be changed in any way or sold commercially in any format or medium without the formal permission of the author When referring to this work, full bibliographic details including the author, title, awarding institution and date of the thesis must be given Enlighten: Theses https://theses.gla.ac.uk/ [email protected] Law, Rhetoric, and Science: Historical Narratives in Roman Law. Graeme James Cunningham LL.B. (Hons.), LL.M., M.Litt. Submitted in fulfilment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy. School of Law, College of Social Sciences, University of Glasgow. September 2018 Abstract. The consensus of scholarship has upheld the view that Roman law is an autonomous science. A legal system, which, due to its systematic, doctrinal principles, was able to maintain an inherent and isolated logic within the confines of its own disciplinary boundaries, excluding extra-legal influence. The establishment of legal science supposedly took place in the late second to early first century BC, when the famed Roman jurist, Quintus Mucius Scaevola pontifex, is supposed to have first treated law in a scientific way under the guidance of Greek categorical thought. As quickly as Roman lawyers came under the stimulating influence of Greek thought, they are said to have abandoned it, convinced by the initial injection of systematisation that their field required nought thereafter but the careful curation of a specialised and professional group of trained jurists. This thesis argues that the above view results from the construction (conscious and unconscious) of historical narratives rooted in nineteenth century Germany, by the so-called Historical School. Seeking solutions to legal predicaments in their own time, German jurists ascribed modern conceptions such as scientific thought onto the Roman sources in order to validate their contemporary applicability. This narrative of science became dominant and restricted the understanding of Roman legal sources to a single methodological approach. At the same time, a narrative of continuity, which linked modern jurists to their ancient Roman forebears, enshrined the idea that ancient jurists approached the law by the same means as the modern professor. This idea, along with the narrative of science, led to Roman sources being read with little regard to the context of the Roman society in which they were written, and to the preclusion of extra-legal fields, particularly rhetoric, as a potential influence on the development of law. This thesis offers a challenge to these narratives, arguing that rhetoric was central to legal development in the late Republican period, even at the time in which Quintus Mucius Scaevola pontifex was thought to have transformed the discipline into an autonomous science. This thesis challenges the origin of the narratives of science and continuity, concluding that, by reading Roman sources within the context of Roman science, Republican Roman jurists were not isolated from engagement with extra- legal fields, and indeed, to varying degrees, were knowledgeable of them, particularly rhetoric. Through the lens of the lawyer and orator, Cicero, this thesis then explores the extent to which the once excluded field of rhetoric had an influence on legal development, drawing rhetorical sources, particularly Cicero’s Topica, into a discussion of praetorian law making, to reveal that, far from autonomous, Republican Roman law developed from rhetorical argument. The key to unlocking this development is an understanding of Roman society, as socially understood Roman ideals, such as pietas and aequitas, form the basis of the rhetorical, topical ii argumentation used before the praetor to form the locus for his ratio decidendi in changing the law. This thesis concludes that rhetoric is a key element in understanding the social development of law. iii Table of Contents. Abstract. ................................................................................................................................................. ii Table of Contents. ................................................................................................................................ iv Acknowledgements. ............................................................................................................................ vii Author’s Declaration. ........................................................................................................................ viii Abbreviations. ...................................................................................................................................... ix A Note on Translations. ........................................................................................................................ x 1. Introduction. .................................................................................................................................. 1 1.1. An Outline of the Argument by Chapter. ........................................................................... 2 1.2. Methodological Issues. .......................................................................................................... 7 1.3. A Note on the Definition of “Science”. ................................................................................ 8 2. The Challenge to Dogmatism: New Methods in Roman Law. ............................................ 10 2.1. The Reception of Roman Law, The Historical School and Legal Science. .................... 11 2.1.1. The Intellectual Context of the German Historical School. .......................................... 12 2.1.2. The Romanist Historical School. .................................................................................. 15 2.2. The Dogmatic Narrative: Legal Science in Modern Scholarship. .................................. 18 2.2.1. The Narrative of Continuity. ......................................................................................... 18 2.2.2. The Narrative of Legal Science..................................................................................... 21 2.2.3. Adherence to Narratives: Dogmatic Consensus. ........................................................... 22 2.3. Narrative Origins: The Mucian Foundation Myth. ......................................................... 30 2.3.1 The Mucian Revolution: Legal Science at Rome. ........................................................ 30 2.3.2 ‘The Big Bang’: Greek Science as a Singular, Revolutionary Event. ........................... 34 2.4. The Challenge to Narratives: “Beyond Dogmatics”. ....................................................... 35 2.4.2. The Law and Society Movement. ................................................................................. 37 2.4.3. A Fresh Approach: “Beyond Dogmatics”. .................................................................... 38 2.5. Rhetoric as a New Approach to Roman Legal Argumentation. ..................................... 39 2.5.1. Rhetoric in Roman Law: A Review of Current Trends. ............................................... 39 2.6. Summary of Findings. ........................................................................................................ 44 iv 3. The Orator and Jurist Dichotomy. ............................................................................................ 45 3.1. Roman Education in Law and Rhetoric. .......................................................................... 45 3.2. Cicero as a Student, a Case Study. .................................................................................... 50 3.3. The Imposition of Professionalisation. .............................................................................. 51 3.4. Legal Practice at Rome. ...................................................................................................... 56 3.5. Summary of Findings. ........................................................................................................ 60 4. “Cicero, the Insider”. .................................................................................................................. 61 4.1. Cicero, an Orator with Knowledge of the Law. ............................................................... 63 4.2. Summary of Findings. ........................................................................................................ 77 5. Rhetoric as a Theory of Legal Reasoning. ................................................................................ 79 5.1 The Development of Rhetorical Theory at Rome in the Late Republic. ........................ 80 5.1.1. Greek Origins of Rhetoric. ............................................................................................ 80 5.1.2. Early Roman Rhetoric. .................................................................................................. 84 5.2. Rhetorica ad Herennium, De Inventione, and Early Roman Rhetorical Theory, or ‘Graecia Capta Ferum Victorem Cepit et Artes Intulit Agresti Latio’. .......................................... 87
Recommended publications
  • IMPERIAL EXEMPLA Military Prowess, Or Virtus, Is but One Quality That
    CHAPTER FOUR IMPERIAL EXEMPLA Military prowess, or virtus, is but one quality that characterized an efffec- tive emperor. Ideally, a ‘good’ emperor was not just a competent general but also displayed other virtues. These imperial virtutes were propagated throughout the Roman Empire by means of imperial panegyric, decrees, inscriptions, biographies, and coins.1 On coinage in particular, juxtaposi- tions of AVG or AVGG with the virtue and/or the imperial portrait on the obverse would connect the virtues mentioned on the reverses directly with the emperor(s). Not all emperors emphasized the same virtues on their coinage. For example, Elagabalus seems not to have felt the need to stress virtus, whereas his successor Severus Alexander did try to convince the Roman people of his military prowess by propagating it on his coins. The presence or absence of particular virtues on coins issued by diffferent emperors brings us to the question as to whether an imperial canon of virtues existed. But before elaborating on this, the concept ‘virtue’ must be clarifijied.2 Modern scholars investigating imperial virtues on coinage consider vir- tues to be personifijications with divine power – in other words, deifijied abstractions or, as Fears puts it, ‘specifijic impersonal numina’.3 For many, the terms ‘personifijication’ and ‘virtue’ are interchangeable.4 Indeed, vir- tues can be considered personifijications. Yet, not all personifijications are 1 Noreña, “The communication of the emperor’s virtues”, p. 153. 2 ‘But if one is to compare coins with other sources, particularly philosopically inspired ones (i.e. in talking of the virtues of the ideal statesman) it is vital to distinguish what is a virtue and what is not’, A.
    [Show full text]
  • Paradigmatic Orientations of Mind Among Physicists
    ISSN 2039-2117 (online) Mediterranean Journal of Social Sciences Vol 5 No 23 ISSN 2039-9340 (print) MCSER Publishing, Rome-Italy November 2014 Paradigmatic Orientations of Mind among Physicists Herman J. Pietersen Professor, University of Limpopo, Turfloop Campus 0727, Republic of South Africa [email protected] Doi:10.5901/mjss.2014.v5n23p2110 Abstract A meta-theory was developed that brought together implicit premises or world views that constantly re-surface in human thought. It consists of four paradigmatic or root intellectual orientations, designated as type I, type II, type III and type IV respectively. The theory was found to be applicable across a wide range of thinkers, scholarly disciplines, and cultures. In the current paper the framework is presented in terms of its main components and dynamics. The aim of the paper is to apply the meta-philosophical framework in identifying unique but complementary intellectual predispositions or modalities of mind among physicists. For this purpose a brief sketch of some prominent figures in physics is provided, showing their different orientations of mind. David Bohm represents the type I (metaphysical or objectivist-empyrean) tendency; Albert Einstein, the quintessential type II (scientific or objectivist-empiricist) approach; Carl Sagan is primarily the type III (subjectivist-empiricist) figure; whilst Fritjof Capra is the type IV (reforming or subjectivist-empyrean) representative in this group. Keywords: paradigmatic modalities of mind, Bohm, Einstein, Sagan, Capra 1. Introduction It is probably safe to say that in twentieth century science, as well as in the mind of the informed public, physics served and continues to serve as the ultimate reference point of exactitude in knowledge, and of what the human intellect is capable of achieving.
    [Show full text]
  • Philoponus on Topos
    Philoponus on τόπος. Redefining Place in Late Antiquity D i s s e r t a t i o n zur Erlangung des akademischen Grades Doctor philosophiae (Dr. phil.) eingereicht an der Philosophischen Fakultät I der Humboldt-Universität zu Berlin und verteidigt am 25. October 2013 von Ioannis Papachristou Der Präsident der Humboldt-Universität zu Berlin Prof. Dr. Jan-Hendrik Olbertz Der Dekan der Philosophischen Fakultät I Prof. Michael Seadle, PhD Gutachter Erstgutachter: Prof. Dr. Christoph Helmig Zweitgutachter: Prof. Dr. Christian Wildberg The dissertation attempts to interpret afresh, on the one hand, the form, methodology and structure of Philoponus’ commentary on the Physics and, on the other hand, to study in depth his theory of place (topos). The book extends over five chapters and includes a preface, an epilogue and a bibliography. Philoponus attempts a double determination of place. He distinguishes between the place which is void, three-dimensional extension that is ontological different from bodies, and the concept of place that is filled by bodies. Philoponus wishes to redefine the relationship between place and body and he underlines the ontological difference that a bodiless extension should have from a bodily extension. The thesis also focuses on Philoponus’ critique of Aristotle’s definition of place and the Peripatetic tradition (Eudemus, Themistius) regarding the place of the heavens. The book concludes that, Philoponus’ strategy in the digressions of the commentary, but also in certain parts of his exegeses, can be seen in three stages: first, he repudiates the cogency of Aristotle’s and Themistius’ critique to the concept of local extension; second, he attacks the Aristotelian definition of place by showing its weaknesses and inconsistencies with the nature of things; and third, he establishes his own theory of place.
    [Show full text]
  • Duke University Dissertation Template
    A Sea of Debt: Histories of Commerce and Obligation in the Indian Ocean, c. 1850-1940 by Fahad Ahmad Bishara Department of History Duke University Date:_______________________ Approved: ___________________________ Edward J. Balleisen, Co-supervisor ___________________________ Engseng Ho, Co-supervisor ___________________________ Janet J. Ewald ___________________________ Timur Kuran ___________________________ Bruce S. Hall ___________________________ Jonathan K. Ocko Dissertation submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in the Department of History in the Graduate School of Duke University 2012 i v ABSTRACT A Sea of Debt: Histories of Commerce and Obligation in the Indian Ocean, c. 1850-1940 by Fahad Ahmad Bishara Department of History Duke University Date:_______________________ Approved: ___________________________ Edward J. Balleisen, Co-supervisor ___________________________ Engseng Ho, Co-supervisor ___________________________ Janet J. Ewald ___________________________ Timur Kuran ___________________________ Bruce S. Hall ___________________________ Jonathan K. Ocko An abstract of a dissertation submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in the Department of History in the Graduate School of Duke University 2012 Copyright by Fahad Ahmad Bishara 2012 ABSTRACT This dissertation is a legal history of debt and economic life in the Indian Ocean during the nineteenth and early-twentieth century. It draws on materials from Bahrain, Muscat, Bombay, Zanzibar and London to examine how members of an ocean-wide commercial society constructed relationships of economic mutualism with one another by mobilizing debt and credit. It further explores how they expressed their debt relationships through legal idioms, and how they mobilized commercial and legal instruments to adapt to the emergence of modern capitalism in the region.
    [Show full text]
  • Heads Or Tails
    Heads or Tails Representation and Acceptance in Hadrian’s Imperial Coinage Name: Thomas van Erp Student number: S4501268 Course: Master’s Thesis Course code: (LET-GESM4300-2018-SCRSEM2-V) Supervisor: Mw. dr. E.E.J. Manders (Erika) 2 Table of Contents List of Figures ............................................................................................................................ 5 Figure 1: Proportions of Coin Types Hadrian ........................................................................ 5 Figure 2: Dynastic Representation in Comparison ................................................................ 5 Figure 3: Euergesia in Comparison ....................................................................................... 5 Figure 4: Virtues ..................................................................................................................... 5 Figure 5: Liberalitas in Comparison ...................................................................................... 5 Figure 6: Iustitias in Comparison ........................................................................................... 5 Figure 7: Military Representation in Comparison .................................................................. 5 Figure 8: Divine Association in Comparison ......................................................................... 5 Figure 9: Proportions of Coin Types Domitian ...................................................................... 5 Figure 10: Proportions of Coin Types Trajan .......................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • New Mathematics for Old Physics: the Case of Lattice Fluids Anouk Barberousse, Cyrille Imbert
    New mathematics for old physics: The case of lattice fluids Anouk Barberousse, Cyrille Imbert To cite this version: Anouk Barberousse, Cyrille Imbert. New mathematics for old physics: The case of lattice fluids. Studies in History and Philosophy of Science Part B: Studies in History and Philosophy of Modern Physics, Elsevier, 2013, 44 (3), pp.231-241. 10.1016/j.shpsb.2013.03.003. halshs-00791435 HAL Id: halshs-00791435 https://halshs.archives-ouvertes.fr/halshs-00791435 Submitted on 2 Sep 2021 HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci- destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents entific research documents, whether they are pub- scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, lished or not. The documents may come from émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de teaching and research institutions in France or recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires abroad, or from public or private research centers. publics ou privés. New Mathematics for Old Physics: The Case of Lattice Fluids AnoukBarberousse & CyrilleImbert ·Abstract We analyze the effects of the introduction of new mathematical tools on an old branch of physics by focusing on lattice fluids, which are cellular automata (CA)-based hydrodynamical models. We examine the nature of these discrete models, the type of novelty they bring about within scientific practice and the role they play in the field of fluid dynamics. We critically analyze Rohrlich', Keller's and Hughes' claims about CA-based models. We distinguish between different senses of the predicates “phenomenological” and “theoretical” for scientific models and argue that it is erroneous to conclude, as they do, that CA-based models are necessarily phenomenological in any sense of the term.
    [Show full text]
  • 1 Curriculum Vitae Matthew B. Roller 11/2020 Professor, Department Of
    Curriculum Vitae Matthew B. Roller 11/2020 Professor, Department of Classics 113 Gilman Hall Johns Hopkins University 3400 N. Charles Street Baltimore, MD 21218-2685 USA (410) 516-5095 FAX: (410) 516-4848 Classics department office: (410) 516-7556 http://classics.jhu.edu/directory/matthew-roller/ https://orcid.org/0000-0002-8784-4112 e-mail: mroller (at) jhu.edu Research Interests: Roman cultural history, Latin Literature, Roman philosophy, Roman art Degrees: University of California at Berkeley: Ph.D. (Classics), 1994; M.A. (Latin), 1990 Stanford University: B.A., with distinction, Classics (Greek), 1988 Teaching Position: Johns Hopkins University, Department of Classics: Assistant Professor, 1994–2000; Associate Professor, 2000–2004; Professor, 2004– present Major Fellowships: Forschungsstipendium, Alexander von Humboldt Foundation, funding a year of research in the Institut für Altertumskunde–Alte Geschichte, University of Cologne, 2007–08 American Council of Learned Societies Junior Fellowship, 2000–01 Solmsen Fellowship, Institute for Research in the Humanities, University of Wisconsin- Madison, 2000–01 Mellon Dissertation Fellowship, 1992 (Fall) and 1994 (Spring) Mellon Fellowship in the Humanities, 1988–90 and 1993 (for graduate and dissertation work) Other Honors, Awards and Grants: Visiting Scholar, “Helden, Heroen, Heroizierungen” project (SFB 948) at the University of Freiburg (Germany), funded by the Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft, April – July 2019. Dean’s Award for excellence in Service, 2014 Dean’s Incentive Grant, Johns Hopkins University: 1999, 2000, 2003 1 H. Rushton Fairclough award, to the outstanding senior Classics major, Stanford University, 1988 Phi Beta Kappa, Stanford University, 1988 PuBlications: Monographs (the following are anonymously refereed): Models from the past in Roman culture: a world of exempla.
    [Show full text]
  • The Communication of the Emperor's Virtues Author(S): Carlos F
    The Communication of the Emperor's Virtues Author(s): Carlos F. Noreña Reviewed work(s): Source: The Journal of Roman Studies, Vol. 91 (2001), pp. 146-168 Published by: Society for the Promotion of Roman Studies Stable URL: http://www.jstor.org/stable/3184774 . Accessed: 01/09/2012 16:45 Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of the Terms & Conditions of Use, available at . http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp . JSTOR is a not-for-profit service that helps scholars, researchers, and students discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content in a trusted digital archive. We use information technology and tools to increase productivity and facilitate new forms of scholarship. For more information about JSTOR, please contact [email protected]. Society for the Promotion of Roman Studies is collaborating with JSTOR to digitize, preserve and extend access to The Journal of Roman Studies. http://www.jstor.org THE COMMUNICATION OF THE EMPEROR'S VIRTUES* By CARLOS F. NORENA The Roman emperor served a number of functions within the Roman state. The emperor's public image reflected this diversity. Triumphal processions and imposing state monuments such as Trajan's Column or the Arch of Septimius Severus celebrated the military exploits and martial glory of the emperor. Distributions of grain and coin, public buildings, and spectacle entertainments in the city of Rome all advertised the emperor's patronage of the urban plebs, while imperial rescripts posted in every corner of the Empire stood as so many witnesses to the emperor's conscientious administration of law and justice.
    [Show full text]
  • Examining Deaf Students' Language Ideologies Through English-To-ASL
    Languages, Literacies, and Translations: Examining Deaf Students’ Language Ideologies through English-to-ASL Translations of Literature by Ruth Anna Spooner A dissertation submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy (English and Education) in the University of Michigan 2016 Doctoral Committee: Professor Anne Leslie Curzan, Chair Professor John Anthony Albertini, National Technical Institute for the Deaf Professor Anne Ruggles Gere Professor Elizabeth Birr Moje © Ruth Anna Spooner 2016 Acknowledgements First of all, I must thank my brilliant and wonderfully supportive committee— particularly Anne Curzan and Anne Ruggles Gere, who were also the co-chairs of my program—who invested hours upon hours teaching me, reading my work, asking questions, talking through ideas, offering feedback, and challenging me to grow as a teacher-scholar. I am especially indebted to Anne Curzan, who in her capacity as committee chair, patiently and intrepidly mucked through all of the drafts for each chapter of this dissertation (including the earliest, messiest ones), always making the time to offer thorough, thoughtful feedback. Your encouragement and guidance has helped to shape this project into what it has become; I could not have done it without you. Also, the ongoing conversations that I have had over the past five years with Anne Curzan and Anne Gere about my research work, about composition and literacy, about all things teaching, and about what it means to be a teacher and a scholar—I cannot describe how valuable your guidance and wisdom have been for me. Thank you. Elizabeth Moje, you were one of the first professors I worked with here at Michigan, and right from the start, you were exuberantly enthusiastic about my ideas and my work, and I am deeply grateful for your unfailing encouragement and your willingness to make space for me in your schedule even as you took on the time- consuming responsibilities of being an Assistant Dean (and later Dean) of the School of Education.
    [Show full text]
  • Implications and Explications of Police Translation of Complainants' Sworn
    IMPLICATIONS AND EXPLICATIONS OF POLICE TRANSLATION OF COMPLAINANTS’ SWORN STATEMENTS: EVIDENCE LOST IN TRANSLATION? BY MONWABISI KNOWLEDGE RALARALA BA Hons, HDE (Arts) (UWC); PGD ALS (Ed) (UCT); MA, DLitt (Stell) Dissertation submitted in accordance with the requirements for the Degree of Doctor of Philosophy (PhD): Publishable articles, in the Faculty of Humanities, for the Department of Linguistics and Language Practice, at the University of the Free State. Date of submission: 01 July 2015 Promoter :Professor Kobus Marais Co-Promoter: Professor Russell Kaschula ii DECLARATION “I declare that the dissertation hereby submitted by Monwabisi Knowledge Ralarala for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy (PhD): Publishable articles at the University of the Free State is my own independent work and has not previously been submitted by me at another University/Faculty. I furthermore cede copyright of the thesis in favour of the University of the Free State.” Date: 01 July 2015 Copyright © (YEAR) University of the Free State All rights reserved iii ABSTRACT This interdisciplinary case study demonstrates that ‘retelling and rewriting’ of complainants’ legal narratives constitutes translation. The police officers’ (hereafter referred to as transpreters) exercise of translating such narratives from isiXhosa (ST) into English (TT) is quite essential in the administration of justice in a multilingual and multicultural environment such as South Africa, and specifically in the South African Police Service. The challenge (amongst others) in the current system is that traspreters are neither accredited nor posses the necessary credentials to perform this fundamental role and function. The key objectives of this study were investigated by means of scientific papers – both publishable and published as book chapters as well as journal articles in both international and accredited journals.
    [Show full text]
  • A Utopian Journey in Turkish: from Non-Translation to Retranslation Ceyda Elgül Boğaziçi University 2011
    A UTOPIAN JOURNEY IN TURKISH: FROM NON-TRANSLATION TO RETRANSLATION CEYDA ELGÜL BOĞAZİÇİ UNIVERSITY 2011 A UTOPIAN JOURNEY IN TURKISH: FROM NON-TRANSLATION TO RETRANSLATION Thesis submitted to the Institute for Graduate Studies in the Social Sciences in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Master of Arts in Translation by Ceyda Elgül Boğaziçi University 2011 Thesis Abstract Ceyda Elgül, “A Utopian Journey in Turkish: From Non-Translation to Retranslation” This study explores the role of translation in the evolution of new contexts for foreign works. It classifies non-translation, initial translation and retranslation as the three existential forms in which translation appears and proposes that each of these forms attributes the foreign work a different translational context. Benefiting from the favorable grounds provided by the journey of Thomas More’s Utopia in the Turkish literary system, this diachronic study embraces the pre- and post-translation periods synchronously with the period in which the translation first appeared.The study firstly investigates Utopia in the Turkish literary system as a work that appeared in the form of non-translation in the period between the Tanzimat and 1964 and questions what type of a culture repertoire this non-translation contributed to. Then, it focuses on the initial translation and seeks a position for this first translation in the context of the 1960s, referring to the social dynamics of the period in which the translation first appeared after a long phase of resistance. Here, the study touches on the agency factor and explores the historical significance of the first translation in relation to the external factors that concern the agents of the translation.
    [Show full text]
  • Virgil, Aeneid 11 (Pallas & Camilla) 1–224, 498–521, 532–96, 648–89, 725–835 G
    Virgil, Aeneid 11 (Pallas & Camilla) 1–224, 498–521, 532–96, 648–89, 725–835 G Latin text, study aids with vocabulary, and commentary ILDENHARD INGO GILDENHARD AND JOHN HENDERSON A dead boy (Pallas) and the death of a girl (Camilla) loom over the opening and the closing part of the eleventh book of the Aeneid. Following the savage slaughter in Aeneid 10, the AND book opens in a mournful mood as the warring parti es revisit yesterday’s killing fi elds to att end to their dead. One casualty in parti cular commands att enti on: Aeneas’ protégé H Pallas, killed and despoiled by Turnus in the previous book. His death plunges his father ENDERSON Evander and his surrogate father Aeneas into heart-rending despair – and helps set up the foundati onal act of sacrifi cial brutality that caps the poem, when Aeneas seeks to avenge Pallas by slaying Turnus in wrathful fury. Turnus’ departure from the living is prefi gured by that of his ally Camilla, a maiden schooled in the marti al arts, who sets the mold for warrior princesses such as Xena and Wonder Woman. In the fi nal third of Aeneid 11, she wreaks havoc not just on the batt lefi eld but on gender stereotypes and the conventi ons of the epic genre, before she too succumbs to a premature death. In the porti ons of the book selected for discussion here, Virgil off ers some of his most emoti ve (and disturbing) meditati ons on the tragic nature of human existence – but also knows how to lighten the mood with a bit of drag.
    [Show full text]