On the Extreme Points of Two Polytopes Associated with a Digraph and Applications to Cooperative Games

A Service of

Leibniz-Informationszentrum econstor Wirtschaft Leibniz Information Centre Make Your Publications Visible. zbw for Economics

van den Brink, René; van der Laan, Gerard; Vasil'ev, Valeri

Working Paper On the Extreme Points of Two Polytopes associated with a Digraph and Applications to Cooperative Games

Tinbergen Institute Discussion Paper, No. 04-069/1

Provided in Cooperation with: Tinbergen Institute, Amsterdam and Rotterdam

Suggested Citation: van den Brink, René; van der Laan, Gerard; Vasil'ev, Valeri (2004) : On the Extreme Points of Two Polytopes associated with a Digraph and Applications to Cooperative Games, Tinbergen Institute Discussion Paper, No. 04-069/1, Tinbergen Institute, Amsterdam and Rotterdam

This Version is available at: http://hdl.handle.net/10419/86248

Standard-Nutzungsbedingungen: Terms of use:

Die Dokumente auf EconStor dürfen zu eigenen wissenschaftlichen Documents in EconStor may be saved and copied for your Zwecken und zum Privatgebrauch gespeichert und kopiert werden. personal and scholarly purposes.

Sie dürfen die Dokumente nicht für öffentliche oder kommerzielle You are not to copy documents for public or commercial Zwecke vervielfältigen, öffentlich ausstellen, öffentlich zugänglich purposes, to exhibit the documents publicly, to make them machen, vertreiben oder anderweitig nutzen. publicly available on the internet, or to distribute or otherwise use the documents in public. Sofern die Verfasser die Dokumente unter Open-Content-Lizenzen (insbesondere CC-Lizenzen) zur Verfügung gestellt haben sollten, If the documents have been made available under an Open gelten abweichend von diesen Nutzungsbedingungen die in der dort Content Licence (especially Creative Commons Licences), you genannten Lizenz gewährten Nutzungsrechte. may exercise further usage rights as specified in the indicated licence. www.econstor.eu TI 2004 -069/1 Tinbergen Institute Discussion Paper On the Extreme Points of Two Polytopes associated with a Digraph and Applications to Cooperative

Games

René van den Brink 1 Gerard van der Laan1 Valeri Vasil’ev2

1 Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam, and Tinbergen Institute, 2 Sobolev Institute of Mathematics, Novisibirsk, Russia.

Tinbergen Institute The Tinbergen Institute is the institute for economic research of the Erasmus Universiteit Rotterdam, Universiteit van Amsterdam, and Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam.

Tinbergen Institute Amsterdam Roetersstraat 31 1018 WB Amsterdam The Netherlands Tel.: +31(0)20 551 3500 Fax: +31(0)20 551 3555

Tinbergen Institute Rotterdam Burg. Oudlaan 50 3062 PA Rotterdam The Netherlands Tel.: +31(0)10 408 8900 Fax: +31(0)10 408 9031

Please send questions and/or remarks of non- scientific nature to [email protected]. Most TI discussion papers can be downloaded at http://www.tinbergen.nl. ? |i , |hi4i L?|t Lu AL L*)|LTit ttLU@|i_ | @ #}h@T @?_ TT*U@|L?t |L LLTih@|i B@4it

+i?i @? _i? h?!5 Bih@h_ @? _ih w@@?6 V@*ih V@t*

a?i c 2ffe

Wklv uhvhdufk lv sduw ri wkh Iuhh Xqlyhuvlw| Uhvhdufk Surjudp _Vwudwhjlf dqg Frrshudwlyh Ghflvlrq Pdnlqj% dqg kdv ehhq grqh zkloh wkh wklug dxwkru zdv ylvlwlqj wkh Wlqehujhq Lqvwlwxwh dw Iuhh Xqlyhuvlw|/ Dpvwhugdp1 Ilqdqfldo vxssruw iurp wkh Qhwkhuodqgv Rujdql}dwlrq iru Vflhqwlf Uhvhdufk +QZR, lq wkh iudphzrun ri wkh Uxvvldq0Gxwfk surjudpph iru vflhqwlf frrshudwlrq/ lv judwhixoo| dfnqrzohgjhg1 Wkh wklug dxwkru zrxog olnh wr dssuhfldwh dovr qdqfldo vxssruw iurp wkh Uxvvldq Ohdglqj Vflhqwlf Vfkrrov Ixqg +judqw ;31533619, dqg Uxvvldq Kxpdqlwduldq Vflhqwlf Ixqg +judqw 350350334;Gh Erhohoddq 4438/ 43;4 KY Dpvwhugdp/ Wkh Qhwkhuodqgv1 H0pdlo= mueulqnCihzhe1yx1qo J1 ydq ghu Oddq/ Ghsduwphqw ri Hfrqrphwulfv dqg Wlqehujhq Lqvwlwxwh/ Iuhh Xqlyhuvlw|/ Gh Erhohoddq 4438/ 43;4 KY Dpvwhugdp/ Wkh Qhwkhuodqgv1 H0pdlo= joddqCihzhe1yx1qo eY1D1 Ydvlo*hy/ Vrerohy Lqvwlwxwh ri Pdwkhpdwlfv/ Survs1 Nrsw|xjd 7/ 9633<3 Qrylvleluvn/ Uxvvld/ H0pdlo= ydvlohyCpdwk1qvf1ux Mt|h@U|

W? |t T@Tih i _itUhMi |i i |hi4i TL?|t Lu |L U*Lti*) hi*@|i_ TL*)|LTit |@| @hi @tt}?i_ |L @ _}h@T Ai ht| TL*)|LTi t |i ti| Lu @** t@h?} iU|Lht Ei*i4i?|t uhL4 |i ?| t4T*i tU |@| i@U ?L_i }i|t @| *i@t| @t 4U @t i@U Lu |t tUUittLht Ai tiUL?_ L?i t |i ti| Lu @** u33) iU|Lht Ei*i4i?|t Lu |i ?| UMi | T@h|UT@|L? h@|it Lu T*@)iht tMLh_?@|i_ |L |i hi*@|L?tTt ThitUhMi_ M) |i _}h@T `i @*tL _tUtt tL4i @TT*U@|L?t ? ULLTih@|i }@4i |iLh) ki)Lh_tG TL*)|LTic _hiU|i_ }h@Tc ?| t4T*i c ?| UMic ULLTih@|i }@4i

5 tMiU| U*@ttU@|L?G D2fD EL4M?@|Lh@* ThLTih|it Lu TL*)|LTitc b2 ELLTih@|i }@4itc D2f E#hiU|i_ }h@Tt a,w UL_iG . ELLTih@|i }@4itc Sf E@|i4@|U@* i|L_t @?_ hL}h@44?}G Bi?ih@* W?|hL_U|L?

W? |t T@Tih i _itUhMi |i i |hi4i TL?|t Lu |L U*Lti*) hi*@|i_ TL*)|LTit |@| @hi @tt}?i_ |L @ }i? _hiU|i_ }h@T E_}h@T L? |i ti| Q W UL?tt|?} Lu q ' mQm ?L_it `i @tt4i Q ' i> ===> qj ?*itt t|@|i_ L|ihti W? iUL?L4Ut @?_ }@4i |iLh) tU _}h@Tt Lu|i? hiiU| Lh}@?3@|L?@* t|hU|hit L? |i ti| Lu @}i?|tc hitTiU|i*) T*@)ihtc uLh ?t|@?Ui |i ih@hUU@* t|hU|hi |? @ h4 `|? tU @? iUL?L4U Lh }@4i |iLhi|U ti||?}c @ @*i iU|Lh t @? q_4i?tL?@* iU|Lhc ? U |i l| UL4TL?i?| }it tL4i @*i |L @}i?| Lh T*@)ih lc l ' > = = = > qc uLh ?t|@?Ui |i @}i |L |i l| @}i?| |? |i h4 W? |t T@Tih @ @*i iU|Lh t U@**i_ @ t@h?} iU|Lh u @** UL4TL?i?|t @hi ?L??i}@|i @?_ |i t4 Lu |i UL4TL?i?|t t i^@* |L L?ic i |i iU|Lh Mi*L?}t |L |i ?| t4T*i W? t|@|L?t |@| |i UL@*|L? Lu @** q @}i?|t U@? _t|hM|i tL4i Lh|c @ t@h?} iU|Lh }it |L i@U @}i?| @ ?L??i}@|i t@hi Lu |@| Lh| @*i iU|Lh t U@**i_ @ u33) iU|Lh u @** UL4TL?i?|t @hi ?L??i}@|i @?_ iih) UL4TL?i?| t Mi|ii? 3ihL @?_ L?i Ai l| UL4TL?i?| Lu @ u33) iU|Lh U@? Mi ?|ihThi|i_ @t |i T@h|UT@|L? h@|i Lu @? @}i?| ? tL4i ThLiU|c uLh ?t|@?Ui |i T@h|UT@|L? h@|i Lu @? @}i?| t |i T@h| Lu t i@*| |@| i ?it|t ? tL4i UL44L? ?it|4i?| ThLiU| `|? |t ?|ihThi|@|L? @ u33) iU|Lh hiiU|t @ u33) UL@*|L? E@ i**!?L? UL?UiT| |? iUL?L4Ut @?_ }@4i |iLh)c i |i iU|Lh )i*_t |i T@h|UT@|L? h@|it Lu |i @}i?|t ? uLh4?} @ UL@*|L? Ai ht| _}h@T TL*)|LTi< |@| i UL?t_ih ? |t T@Tih |L Mi U@**i_ |i t@h?} TL*)|LTi @tt}?t |L @ }i? _}h@T |i ti| Lu @** t@h?} iU|Lht tU |@| i@U ?L_i @t @ t@hi |@| t @| *i@t| @t } @t |i t@hi Lu i@U Lu |t tUUittLht ? |i _}h@T `|? ULLTih@|i }@4i |iLh)c |t |)Ti Lu TL*)|LTit @TTi@ht |L Mi ih) 4TLh|@?| |L @_@T| |i tLU@**i_ O@ht@?) ti| Etii V@t*

i**!?L? |@| _L4?@|L? EhiiU|L? Lu Uih|@? L|UL4it M) |i u33) UL@*|L?t T*@)t @ UhU@* hL*i ? |i ULLTih@|i U@h@U|ih3@|L? Lu |i i^*Mh@ ? Thi UL4Ti||i iUL?L4it Etii i} M? Eb.b w!i ? ULLTih@|i }@4i |iLh)c ? Uih|@? iUL?L4U t|@|L?t | 4@) Mi hi@tL?@M*i |L |@!i ?|L @UUL?| |i ih@hUU@* t|hU|hi Mi|ii? |i iUL?L4U @}i?|t i? UL?t_ih?} |i UL**iU|L? Lu @** ui@tM*i u33) UL@*|L?t Oi?Uic | t Lu ?|ihit| |L !?L |i t|hU|hi Lu |i u33) TL*)|LTic _itUhM?} |i UL**iU|L? Lu @** ui@tM*i u33) UL@*|L?t uLh @ }i? _}h@T L? |i ti| Lu @}i?|tc ? Lh_ih |L }i| @ 4Lhi _i|@*i_ _itUhT|L? Lu |i i^*Mh@ ?c t@)c @ }h@Thit|hU|i_ 4@h!i| E@ 4@h!i| | tL4i i*i4i?|t Lu ih@hU) Ai U@h@U|ih3@|L? Lu |i i |hi4i TL?|t Lu |i u33) TL*)|LTi @TTi@ht |L Mi 4U 4Lhi i@t) |@? uLh |i t@h?} TL*)|LTi iih|i*ittc |i hit*| E}i? ? AiLhi4 e2 Mi*L t ^|i ?|ihit|?} W? T@h|U*@hc | |h?t L| |@| |i i |hi4i TL?|t Lu |i u33) TL*)|LTi @hi }i?ih@|i_ M) |i UL**iU|L? Lu @** UL4Thii?ti uhL4 @MLi ti|t Lu ?L_it Lu |i }i? _}h@T 5?Uic ? UL?|h@t| | |i t@h?} TL*)|LTic uLh |i u33) TL*)|LTi UL??iU|i_?itt Lu |i tM}h@Tt t ?L| hi^hi_c ? }i?ih@* |i ?4Mih Lu |t i |hi4i TL?|t 4@) Mi 4U }ih |@? |i ?4Mih Lu i |hi4i TL?|t Lu |i t@h?} TL*)|LTi }@?c *!i ? U@ti Lu AiLhi4 ec AiLhi4 e2 |L}i|ih | |i _itUhT|L? Lu |i u33) TL*)i_hL? |ti*u 4@) Mi UL?t_ihi_ @t |i tL*|L? Lu |i *?i@h3@|L? ThLM*i4 uLh |i _tUhi|i LT|43@|L? Lih |i UL4Thii?ti uhL4 @MLi tM}h@Tt Lu @ }i? _}h@T Ai T@Tih t Lh}@?3i_ @t uL**Lt W? 5iU|L? 2 tL4i }h@T|iLhi|U Thi*4?@hit @hi }i? 5iU|L? t _iL|i_ |L |i 4@? hit*|c UL?Uih??} |i _itUhT|L? Lu |i i |hi4i TL?|t Lu |i t@h?} TL*)|LTi EAiLhi4 e 5iU|L? e _i@*t | |i @?@*L} Lu AiLhi4 e uLh |i u33) TL*)|LTi EAiLhi4 e2 5iU|L? D UL?|@?t tL4i iUL?L4U @?_ }@4i|iLhi|U @TT*U@|L?t Lu |i hit*|t LM|@?i_

2 hi*4?@hit

_hiU|i_ }h@T Lh _}h@T t @ T@h EQ> G ihi Q W t @ ?|i ti| Lu ?L_it @?_ G Q Q t @ M?@h) hi*@|L? L? Q t 4i?|L?i_ ? |i ?|hL_U|L?c i @tt4i Q ' i> ===> qj ?*itt t|@|i_ L|ihti 6Lh G Q Q @?_ l 5 Q |i ?L_it ? im 5 Q m El> m 5 Gj @hi U@**i_ |i tUUittLht Lu l ? Gc @?_ |i ?L_it ? im 5 Q m Em> l 5 Gj @hi U@**i_ |i Thi_iUittLht Lu l ? G 6Lh l> m 5 Q @ T@| Mi|ii? l @?_ m ? G t @ ti^i?Ui Lu ?L_it El> = = = > lp tU |@| l ' l> lp ' m> @?_ iEln> lnn> Elnn> lnj _ G 9' > uLh n ' > = = = > p ti| Lu ?L_it W Q t UL??iU|i_ ? _}h@T EQ> G u |ihi t @ T@| Mi|ii? @?) |L ?L_it ? W |@| L?*) tit @hUt Mi|ii? ?L_it ? W c i u uLh iih) l> m 5 W |ihi t @ T@| El> = = = > lp Mi|ii? l @?_ m tU |@| il> = = = > lpj W 6Lh tL4i V Qc |i _}h@T EV> GEV | GEV ' iEl> m 5 Gmil> mj Vj

2 t U@**i_ |i tM_}h@T Lu V ? EQ> G tMti| V Q t @ UL4TL?i?| Lu Q u |i tM_}h@T EV> GEV t 4@ 4@**) UL??iU|i_c i EV> GEV t UL??iU|i_ @?_ uLh @?) m 5 Q q Vc |i tM_}h@T EV ^ imj> GEV ^ imj t ?L| UL??iU|i_ *i@h*)c uLh @?) _}h@T EQ> Gc |i UL**iU|L? Lu UL4TL?i?|t Lu Q uLh4t @ T@h||L? Lu Q `i U@** |t T@h||L? |i _iUL4TLt|L? Lu Q ? EQ> G 6?@**)c |i |h@?t|i U*Lthi Lu _}h@T EQ> G t |i _}h@T EQ> wuEG | El> m 5 wuEG u @?_ L?*) u |ihi i t|t @ _hiU|i_ T@| uhL4 l |L m ? Gc i |ihi i t|t @ ti^i?Ui Lu ?L_it El> = = = > lp tU |@| l ' lc lp ' m @?_ Eln> lnn 5 G uLh @** n 5 i> ===> p j

, |hi4i TL?|t Lu |i t@h?} TL*)|LTi

W? |t tiU|L? i }i @ U@h@U|ih3@|L? Lu |i i |hi4i TL?|t Lu |i t@h?} TL*)|LTi ?_Ui_ M) @ _}h@T EQ> G ? i*i4i?| Lu |i t@h?} TL*)|LTi t @ t@h?} iU|Lh ? |i ?| t4T*i tU |@| uLh iih) l |i t@hi Lu ?L_i l t @| *i@t| @t 4U |@? |i t@hit Lu q q q i@U Lu |t tUUittLht wi| X Mi |i q_4i?tL?@* ?| t4T*i c i X ' i{ 5 U m{l Sq f> l ' > = = = > q> @?_ l' {l ' j

#i?|L? Ai t@h?} TL*)|LTi @ttLU@|i_ | _}h@T EQ> Gc Q 9' >c t |i TL*)

|LTi SG }i? M)

q SG ' is 5 X m sl sm u El> m 5 Gj=

W? @TT*U@|L?t ? iUL?L4Ut @?_ }@4i |iLh) | t tiu* |L @i @? i T*U| U@h@U|ih3@|L?

Lu |i i |hi4i TL?|t Lu SG W| @TTi@ht |@| |iti i |hi4i TL?|t @hi _i|ih4?i_ M) |i UL**iU|L? Lu @** ?L?i4T|) tMti|t V Lu Q t@|tu)?} E V t UL??iU|i_ ? |i _}h@T @?_ E uLh iih) ?L_i ? V | L*_t |@| @** |t Thi_iUittLht Mi*L?} |L V AL Mi 4Lhi ThiUtic i ?|hL_Ui |i uL**L?} uLh4@* _i?|L? @?_ ?L|@|L?t

#i?|L? 2 ti| Lu ?L_it V Q t UL4Thii?ti uhL4 @MLi ? _}h@T EQ> G u dm 5 V @?_ El> m 5 Go 4T*it |@| l 5 V

Ai UL**iU|L? Lu @** UL4Thii?ti uhL4 @MLi ti|t Lu ?L_it ? _}h@T EQ> G t _i?L|i_ M) DEG 6Lh i@ti Lu t4T*U|)c ? |i ti^i* Lu |i T@Tih i tLh|*) U@** @ tMti| UL4 Thii?ti i? | Mi*L?}t |L DEG 6h|ih i _i?L|i M) FEG |i UL**iU|L? Lu @** UL??iU|i_ ti|t Lu ?L_it ? _}h@T EQ> G Mtihi |@| ML| DEG @?_ FEG UL?|@? |i i4T|) ti| `i U@** @ tMti| Lu ?L_it UL4T*i|i i? | t ?L?i4T|)c UL4Thii?ti @?_ UL??iU|i_

#i?|L? ti| Lu ?L_it V t UL4T*i|i ? _}h@T EQ> G u V t ?L| i4T|) @?_ Mi*L?}t |L DEG _ FEG

Ai UL**iU|L? Lu @** UL4T*i|i ti|t Lu ?L_it ? _}h@T EQ> G t _i?L|i_ M) DFEG 6?@**)c uLh @?) ?L?i4T|) V Q i _i?i |i iU|Lh dV 5 UQ M) + u l 5 V dV ' V l f u l 5 Q q V=

`i @hi ?L hi@_) |L t|@|i |i 4@? hit*| Lu |t tiU|L?c ?@4i*) |@| |i ti| H{ESG Lu V i |hi4i TL?|t Lu |i t@h?} TL*)|LTi SG t i^@* |L |i ti| Lu iU|Lht d LM|@?i_ uhL4 UL4T*i|i ti|t ? EQ> G

V AiLhi4 e 6Lh iih) _}h@T EQ> G | L*_t |@| H{ESG ' id mV 5 DFEGj

`i ThLi |t |iLhi4 ? |hii t|iTt hiiU|i_ ? |i uL**L?} |hii *i44@

V wi44@ D 6Lh iih) _}h@T EQ> G @?_ iih) V 5 DEG | L*_t |@| d 5 SG

V S V V hLLu ) _i?|L? Lu d i @i lMQ dl ' @?_ dl f uLh @** l 5 Q A@!i l> m 5 Q V V tU |@| El> m 5 G Wu il> mj V |i? dl ' dm ' V Wu l 5 V @?_ m 5 Q q V |i? V V dl ' V A f ' dm Wu l 5 Q q V |i? M) V Mi?} UL4Thii?ti uhL4 @MLi ? EQ> G | V V V V 4t| L*_ |@| m 5 Q q Vc @?_ |t dl ' dm ' f 5Lc dl dm u El> m 5 G At i @i V tL? |@| d 4ii|t @** UL?_|L?t |L Mi*L?} |L SG

V i | i tL |@| uLh @?) UL4T*i|i Vc |i iU|Lh d t @? i |hi4i TL?| Lu SG

V wi44@ S 6Lh iih) _}h@T EQ> G @?_ iih) V 5 FEG | d 5 SG | L*_t |@| V d 5 H{ESG

V hLLu wi| V 5 FEG Mi @ tMti| Lu ?L_it | d 5 SG @?_ *i| e> f 5 SG Mi tU |@| V V d ' 2 Ee n f AL it|@M*t |i ?U*tL? |@| d 5 H{ESGc | t tUi?| |L ThLi |@| e ' f ' dV uLh @?) tU e @?_ f AL |t i?_c *i| t 4i?|L? ht|c |@| _i |L |i i^@*|it V dl ' f uLh @** l 5 Q q V i @i |@| 2 Eel n fl ' f uLh @** l 5 Q q V 5?Ui e> f f i |i? @i

el ' fl ' f uLh @** l 5 Q q V= E

5iUL?_c tTTLti |@| l> m 5 V @hi tU |@| El> m 5 G 5?Ui e> f 5 SG i @i M) _i?|L?

Lu SG |@| el em @?_ fl fm 5TTLti |@| @| *i@t| L?i Lu |iti |L ?i^@*|it t t|hU|

e V V V V Ai? dl ' 2 Eel n fl A 2 Eem n fm ' dm c U UL?|h@_U|t | dl ' dm ' V uLh @** l> m 5 V 5Lc

el ' em @?_ fl ' fm uLh @** l> m 5 V | El> m 5 G E 2

?t |i ThLLu Lu AiLhi4 e i @i |L tL |@| iih) i |hi4i TL?| Lu SG U@? Mi LM|@?i_ @t @ iU|Lh dV uLh tL4i UL4T*i|i V wi44@ . 6Lh iih) _}h@T EQ> G @?_ iih) d 5 H{ESG |ihi i t|t @? V 5 DFEG tU |@| d ' dV

d hLLu wi| d 5 H{ESG #i?L|i M) V ' il 5 Qmdl A fj |i tTTLh| Lu d L|i |@| d S d V 9' > t?Ui lMQ dl ' `i ht| ThLi |@| V 5 DFEG d 6Lh l> m 5 Q | El> m 5 Gc d 5 SG 4T*it |@| dl dm 5Lc dm 5 V @?_ El> m 5 Go 4T*it |@| l 5 Vdc i Vd t UL4Thii?ti uhL4 @MLi AL tL |@| Vd t UL4T*i|i | |i? t tUi?| |L tL |@| Vd t UL??iU|i_ ? |i UL?|h@h)c tTTLti |@| Vd t ?L| d d d d d UL??iU|i_ Ai? |ihi t @ _iUL4TLt|L? iV > ===> Vpj Lu V ? tM_}h@T EV > GEV d | |i ?4Mih p Lu UL4TL?i?|t @| *i@t| i^@* |L |L 5?Ui Vn t 4@ 4@**) UL??iU|i_ ? EVd> GEVdc M) UL4Thii?ti?itt uhL4 @MLi Lu Vd i @i |@| iih) UL4TL?i?| d d Vn ? |t _iUL4TLt|L? t UL4Thii?ti uhL4 @MLic @t i** 5Lc Vn 5 DFEG uLh @** n 5 i> ===> pj Lc UL?t_ih |i iU|Lht dnc n ' > ===> pc }i? M) + d n dl u l 5 Vn dl ' d f u l 5 Q q Vn >

S n d d d @?_ _i?i n ' d d uLh @** n 5 i> ===> pj ) iV > ===> V j Mi?} @ _iUL4TLt|L? Lu V lMVn l p d d @?_ ?L?i4T|)?itt Lu V | uL**Lt M) _i?|L? |@| |i ti|t Vn c n 5 i> ===> pjc 4ii| |i d p d d d d UL?_|L?tG E V ' ^n'Vn c E Vn 9' > uLh @** n 5 i> ===> pjc @?_ E Vn _ Vo ' > uLh @** Sp n> o 5 i> ===> pj | n 9' o | |i? n A f uLh @** n 5 i> ===> pjc @?_ n' n ' #i?i

D n n n d n d d ' d uLh iih) n 5 i> ===> pjc i d ' dl u l 5 V @?_ d ' f u l 5 Q q V Ai? n l n n l n d d n o Vn _ Vo ' > uLh @** n> o 5 i> ===> pj | n 9' oc 4T*it |@| d 9' d uLh @** n> o 5 i> ===> pj d d | n 9' oc @?_c 4LhiLihc | 4T*it |@| min 5 i> ===> pjml 5 Vn jm ' uLh @** l 5 V | Sp n Sp n d Sp n Sp |i? n' ndl ' n' dl ' dl uLh @** l 5 V Atc d ' n' nd | n' n ' @?_ n f> n 5 i> ===> pj n AL }i| @ UL?|h@_U|L? | d 5 H{ESG | t tUi?| |L ThLi |@| d 5 SG uLh n S n @** n 5 i> ===> pj 5?Uic d f @?_ lMQ dl ' c | t tUi?| |L ThLi |@| El> m 5 G n n 4T*it |@| dl dm uLh @** n 5 i> ===> pj AL _L tLc tL4i El> m 5 G @?_ n 5 i> ===> pj `i _t|?}t |i uL**L?} |L U@tit

d d d E 5TTLti |@| m 5 Vn 5?Ui Vn 5 DFEG i @i l 5 Vn c @?_ |t | d 5 SG | uL**Lt |@| dn ' dl dm ' dn l n n m

d n n n E 5TTLti |@| m 5@ Vn 5?Ui d f i @i dl f ' dm

Sp n 5Lc i @i tL? |@| |i iU|Lh d t i^@* |L |i UL?i UL4M?@|L? n' nd | n n o p 2c n A f uLh @** n 5 i> ===> pjc d 5 SG uLh @** n 5 i> ===> pjc @?_ d 9' d uLh d @** n> o 5 i> ===> pj | n 9' oc U UL?|h@_U|t | d 5 H{ESG L?ti^i?|*)c V t UL??iU|i_ ? EQ> G 5?Ui i @*hi@_) ThLi_ |@| Vd t UL4Thii?ti uhL4 @MLic i @i tL? |@| Vd 5 DFEG

d i | i ThLi |@| @** UL4TL?i?|t dl Lu d | l 5 V @hi i^@* |L i@U L|ihc d i dl ' dm uLh @** l> m 5 V ? |i UL?|h@h)c tTTLti |@| |t t ?L| |i U@ti #i??} d d ' 4?idlml 5 V j @?_ ' 4@ idlml 5 V j i |i? @i ? L?t_ih |i iU|Lht d @?_ d }i? M) + + u l 5 Vd d u l 5 Vd d ' @?_ d ' l l f u l 5 Q q Vd> l f u l 5 Q q Vd=

S 5?Ui f ? ? i @i d > d f @?_ d ' d n d #i??} ' lMVd dl @?_ S ' lMVd dl i LM|@? uhL4 d 5 SG |@| > 5 Ef> @?_ n ' LhiLihc d i @i d ' d n d | d ' d @?_ d ' d 6Lh l 5 V | dl ' i @i S S dl ' A f @?_ dl ' f 5Lc d 9' d @?_ lMQ dl ' lMQ dl ' AL }i| @ UL?|h@_U|L? d | d 5 H{ESGc | t tUi?| |L tL |@| d > d 5 SG A@!i El> m 5 G= Wu m 5@ V > d |i? _i |L d > d f @?_ dm ' dm ' f i @i |@| dl dm @?_ dl dm Wu m 5 V |i?c M) |i @tt4T|L? |@| d 5 SGc i @i dl dm @?_ |t dl ' ' dm @?_ dl ' Edl Edm ' dm Oi?Uic ? ML| U@tit d > d 5 SG At u@U|c |L}i|ih | d 9' d @?_ |i @MLi4i?|L?i_ i^@*|) d ' d n d | > 5 Ef> > t ?

UL?|h@_U|L? | d 5 H{ESG d S Atc dl ' dm uLh @** l> m 5 V 5?Ui lMQ dl ' i @i dl ' ' ' Vd uLh @** l 5 Vd L?U*_?} i @i Vd 5 DFEG @?_ d ' dV | V ' Vd

S Ai uL**L?} i @4T*i tLt |@| ML| UL4Thii?ti?itt @?_ UL??iU|i_?itt @hi ?iUitt@h) uLh |i hit*| Lu AiLhi4 e

, @4T*i H L?t_ih |i _}h@T EQ> G | Q ' i> 2> j @?_ G ' iE> > E2> j 6Lh |t _}h@T i @i DFEG ' iij> i2j> i> 2> jj @?_ |t SG ' L?iE> f> f > Ef> f> > E > > j Etii 6}hi

3 4 3 E F C 3 D DD.. 3 4 D . 4 D . D . E F C DD . D . T B 3 4 D ?? . 3 4 4 D ?? . 3 E F D?? . E F C 3 DDB? 3 B4 .CB 4 D 3 2 3 E F C 2 D 3 6}hi

t2> Ai ti| i2> j t UL??iU|i_ M| t ?L| UL4Thii?ti *i@h*)c |i iU|Lh d ' Ef> 2 > 2 t2> t2> _Lit ?L| Mi*L?} |L SG t?Ui d ? d @*|L} E> 5 G Ai ti| i> 2j t UL4Thii?ti uhL4 @MLi M| t ?L| UL??iU|i_ *i@h*)c |i iU|Lh t>2 d ' E 2 > 2 > f Mi*L?}t |L SGc M| t ?L| @? i |hi4i TL?| Lu SG

`i i?_ |t tiU|L? M) _tUtt?} tL4i tTiU@* U@tit @?_ i @4T*it 6ht|c i UL?t_ih @ _hiU|i_ |hii EQ> Gc i E Q t UL??iU|i_ ? EQ> Gc E El> l 5@ G uLh @** l 5 Qc E mim 5 QmEm> l 5 Gjm uLh @** l 5 Qc @?_ E |ihi t @ ?^i ?L_i E|i hLL| l 5 Q

| im 5 QmEm> l 5 Gj ' > #i?L|?} WV ' V ^ im 5 QmEm> l 5 wuEG uLh tL4i l 5 Vj uLh @** V Qc | |i? uL**Lt |@| DFEG ' iWVmV Qj AiLhi4 e |i? )i*_t |i uL**L?} ULhL**@h)

V V V q LhL**@h) b Wu EQ> G t @ _hiU|i_ |hii |i? H{ESG ' V\Q iw jc | w 5 U }i? V V M) w ' u m 5 WVc @?_ w ' f L|ihti m WV m

. , @4T*i f L?t_ih |i _}h@T EQ> G | Q ' i> 2> > ej @?_ G ' iE> 2> E> > E > ej Ai? ; A ij u V ' ij A A i> 2j u V 5 ii2j> i> 2jj A ? i> j u V 5 ii j> i> jj W ' V A A i> 2> j u V 5 ii2> j> i> 2> jj A A i> > ej u V 5 iiej> i> ej> i > ej> i> > ejj =A i> 2> > ej u V 5 ii2> ej> i> 2> ej> i2> > ej> i> 2> > ejj

Oi?Ui DFEG ' iij> i> 2j> i> j> i> 2> j> i> > ej> i> 2> > ejj Ai ULhhitTL?_?} i |hi4i TL?|t Lu |i t@h?} TL*)|LTi @hiG E> f> f> f c E 2 > 2 > f> f c E 2 > f> 2 > f c E > > > f c E > f> > c E e > e > e > e

i | i UL?t_ih |L tTiU@* U@tit Lu _hiU|i_ |hiit 6ht|c i UL?t_ih *?i}h@Tt #}h@T EQ> G | Q ' i> ===> qj t @ *?i}h@T u G ' iEl> l n ml 5 i> ===> q jj Eu ULhtic

|i *@Mi*?} Lu |i ?L_it U@? Mi |@!i? _gihi?| Ai? DFEG ' iWtlml 5 Qj |

Wtl ' i> ===> lj AiLhi4 e E@?_ LhL**@h) b )i*_ |i uL**L?} ULhL**@h)

V tl tl q LhL**@h) Wu EQ> G t @ *?i}h@T |i? H{ESG ' lMQ iw jc | w 5 U }i? tl tl M) wm ' l u m lc @?_ wm ' f u m A l

, @4T*i 2 L?t_ih |i *?i}h@T EQ> G | Q ' i> 2> j @?_ G ' iE> 2> E2> j Ai? DFEG ' iij> i> 2j> i> 2> jj @?_ |t SG ' L?iE> f> f > E 2 > 2 > f > E > > j Etii 6}hi 2

3 4 3 E F C 3 D DD.. 3 4 D . 4 D . D . E F C DD . D . T B 3 4 D ?? . 3 4 4 D ?? . 3 E F D?? . E F C 3 DDB? 3 B4 .C 4 D 3 2 3 E F C 2 D 3 6}hi 2 H 5iUL?_c i UL?t_ih t|@h}h@Ttc i _}h@Tt EQ> G | Q ' i> ===> qj tU |@| |ihi

t @ ?L_i lf | G ' iElf> lml 5 Q q ilfjj 5?Ui WV ' V ^ ilfjc i @i DFEG ' iW

Qmlf 5 Wj AiLhi4 e E@?_ LhL**@h) b )i*_ |i uL**L?} ULhL**@h)

V V LhL**@h) Wu EQ> G t @ t|@h}h@T | |i Ui?|ih lfc |i? H{ESG ' V\Q iw jc lfMV V q V V | w 5 U }i?c @t i@h*ihc M) wm ' V u m 5 Vc @?_ wm ' f L|ihti

, @4T*i e L?t_ih |i t|@h }h@T EQ> G | Q ' i> 2> j @?_ G ' iE> 2> E> j Ai? DFEG ' iij> i> 2j> i> j> i> 2> jjc @?_ |t SG ' L?iE> f> f > E 2 > 2 > f > E 2 > f> 2 > E > > j Etii 6}hi 3 4 3 E F C 3 D DD.. 3 4 D . 4 3 4 D . E 2 F D . E F B ? C 3 D D ?. C D D ? . B ? 3 4 2 D . 3 4 4 D . 3 E F D . E F C 3 DDB 3 B4 .C 4 D 3 2 3 E F C 2 D 3 6}hi e , |hi4i TL?|t Lu |i u33) TL*)|LTi

W? |i ThiLt tiU|L? i @ttLU@|i_ |L iih) _}h@T EQ> G |i t@h?} TL*)|LTi SGc Mi?} @ tMti| Lu |i ?| t4T*i W?t|i@_ Lu hit|hU|?} Lhti*it |L |i ?| t4T*i c ? q q q |t tiU|L? i hit|hU| Lhti*it |L |i ?| UMi L ' df> o ' is 5 U m f sl uLh @** l 5 Qj #L?} tLc i LM|@? |i u33) TL*)|LTi

#i?|L? e Ai u33) TL*)|LTi @ttLU@|i_ | _}h@T EQ> Gc Q 9' >c t |i TL*)|LTi

NG }i? M)

q NG ' is 5 L m sl sm u El> m 5 Gj=

AL }i @ t4*@h U@h@U|ih3@|L? Lu |i i |hi4i TL?|t Lu NG @t }i? ? |i ThiLt V q tiU|L? uLh SGc uLh @?) V Qc ?U*_?} |i i4T|) ti|c i _i?i |i iU|Lh h 5 U M) + u l 5 V hV ' l f u l 5 Q q V=

b V W| @TTi@ht |@| |i ti| H{ENG Lu i |hi4i TL?|t Lu NG @hi i @U|*) |i iU|Lht h |@| ULhhitTL?_ |L UL4Thii?ti tMti|t V Lu Q ? |i _}h@T EQ> G E?U*_?} |i i4T|) ti|c i |i ti|t V 5 DEG Mtihi |@| ? UL?|h@t| | |i t@h?} TL*)|LTi | t ?L| hi^hi_ |@| |i UL4Thii?ti ti| t UL??iU|i_

V AiLhi4 e2 6Lh iih) _}h@T EQ> G | L*_t |@| H{ENG ' ih mV 5 DEGj

V hLLu `i ht| ThLi |@| uLh @?) V 5 DEG | L*_t |@| h 5 H{ENG 5?Ui |i iU|Lht V q q h @hi i |hi4i TL?|t Lu |i UMi L > @?_ NG L > |i L?*) |?} i @i |L UiU! t |i V 4T*U@|L? V 5 DEG , h 5 NG AL _L tLc @? @hM|h@h) V 5 DEG> El> m 5 Gc @?_ ?L|i |@| M) UL4Thii?ti?itt uhL4 @MLi Lu V | L*_t |@|G m 5 V 4T*it l 5 Vc @?_ V V i?Uic hl hm = t |L |i U@ti m 5@ Vc |i ?i^@*|) hi^hi_ t |h@**) @*_ _i |L |i ?L??i}@||) Lu hV= V t |L |i ?ihti ?U*tL? H{ENG ih m V 5 DEGj> *i| t 4i?|L? ht| |@| i@U d 5 H{ENG t @ 3ihLL?i iU|Lhc i dl 5 if> j uLh @?) d 5 H{ENG @?_ l 5 Q=

5TTLtic |L |i UL?|h@h)c |@| QEd ' il 5 Q m dl 5 Ef> j 9' > uLh tL4i d 5 H{ENG=

A@!i ' 4@ idl m dl 5 QEdjc QEd ' il 5 QEd m dl ' jc @?_ + 4@ id m l 5 QEd q Q Edj> u QEd 9' Q Ed> ' l f> u QEd ' QEd= 6 tL4i 5 Ef> tU |@| ML| ?4Miht n @?_ Mi*L?} |L |i ?|ih@* E> c @?_ _i?i |i iU|Lht d @?_ d @t uL**Lt + n > u l 5 QEd> dl ' dl> u l 5 Q q QEd> + > u l 5 QEd> dl ' dl> u l 5 Q q QEd=

q W| t U*i@h |@| M) UL?t|hU|L? Lu d @?_ d | L*_tG d > d 5 L c @?_ dl dm / dl dm / dl dm uLh @?) l> m 5 Q= 5?Ui d 5 NGc ML| iU|Lht d @?_ d Mi*L?} |L NG= 5?Uic LMLt*)c d 9' d @?_ d ' 2 Ed n d c i }i| @ UL?|h@_U|L? | Lh @tt4T|L? d 5 H{ENG= Atc uLh @?) d 5 H{ENG | L*_t QEd ' > @?_c UL?ti^i?|*)c i |hi4i

TL?|t Lu |i TL*)|LTi NG @hi 3ihLL?i iU|Lht

L?t_ih @? @hM|h@h) d 5 H{ENG @?_ T| VEd ' il 5 Q m dl ' j= 5?Ui d ' hVEd> |i L?*) |?} i @i |L ThLi t |i ?U*tL? VEd 5 DEG= | |i *@||ih uL**Lt 44i_@|i*) uhL4 |i ?U*tL? d 5 NG=

5?Ui |i i |hi4i TL?|t Lu |i u33) TL*)|LTi ULhhitTL?_ |L |i UL4Thii?ti tMti|t Lu Q ? EQ> G @?_ |i i |hi4i TL?|t Lu |i t@h?} TL*)|LTi ULhhitTL?_ |L |i UL4T*i|i

f tMti|t Ei ?L?i4T|)c UL4Thii?ti @?_ UL??iU|i_ tMti|t Lu Q ? EQ> Gc |ihi 4@) Mi @ UL?t_ih@M*i _gihi?Ui Mi|ii? |i ?4Miht Lu |i i |hi4i TL?|t Lu |i _}h@T

TL*)|LTit SG @?_ NG AL **t|h@|i |tc *i| t UL?t_ih |i uL**L?} i @4T*i

, @4T*i e wi| EQ> G Mi @ hiihti t|@h | Q ' i> = = = > qj tU |@| |ihi t @ ?L_i lf | G ' tl iEl> lf m l 5 Q q ilfjj #i |L AiLhi4 e @?_ AiLhi4 e i @i H{ESG ' id m Q V Q l 5 Q q ilfjj ^ id jc @?_ H{ENG ' ih m V Q q ilfjj ^ ih j Oi?Uic |i U@h_?@*|) q3 Lu H{ENG i^@*t 2 n > *i H{ESG UL?|@?t L?*) q i*i4i?|t

D TT*U@|L?t |L ULLTih@|i }@4it

W? |t tiU|L? i UL?t_ih tL4i @TT*U@|L?t ? ULLTih@|i }@4i |iLh) Lu |i |L TL*) |LTit ?_Ui_ M) @ _}h@T AihiuLhi i ht| ?|hL_Ui tL4i UL?UiT|t uhL4 ULLTih@|i }@4i |iLh) ULLTih@|i }@4i | |h@?tuih@M*i |*|)c Lh t4T*) @ AN}@4ic t @ T@h EQ> y | Q ' i> = = = > qj @ ?|i ti| Lu T*@)iht @?_ yG 2Q $ W+ @ U@h@U|iht|U u?U|L? L? Q t@|tu)?} yE> ' f 6Lh @?) UL@*|L? V Qc yEV t |i Lh| Lu UL@*|L? Vc i |i 4i4Miht Lu UL@*|L? V U@? LM|@? @ |L|@* T@)Lg Lu yEV M) @}hii?} |L ULLTih@|i @?) iUL?L4U @?_ _iUtL? t|@|L?t U@? Mi _itUhMi_ @t ULLTih@|i AN}@4itc uLh ?t|@?Ui @U|L? t|@|L?tc @tt}?4i?| ThLM*i4tc *?i@h ThL_U|L? t|@|L?tc ti^i?U?} t|@ |L?tc @|ih _t|hM|L? ThLM*i4tc *@?_?} uii ThLM*i4tc @?_ L?| ?i?|Lh) t|@|L?t2 `i _i?L|i |i UL**iU|L? Lu @** U@h@U|iht|U u?U|L?t L? T*@)ih ti| Q M) JQ tTiU@* U*@tt Lu }@4it @hi |i ?@?4|) }@4it 6Lh i@U ?L?i4T|) W Qc |i ?@?4|) }@4i EQ> xW t }i? M) xW EV ' u W Vc @?_ xW EV ' f L|ihti W| t i**!?L? |@| |i ?@?4|) }@4it uLh4 @ M@tt uLh JQ @?_ |@| uLh i@U y 5 JQ i @i |@| [ y ' {VEyxV> VMlQ ihi lQ t |i UL**iU|L? Lu @** ?L?i4T|) tMti|t Lu Qc @?_ |i ULiUi?|t {VEy @hi |i tLU@**i_ O@ht@?) __i?_t Etii O@ht@?)c bDbc U U@? Mi uL?_ hiUhti*) uhL4 |i t)t|i4 [ yEV ' {W Ey> V 5 lQ = EDe W \V

4Lq wkh vhtxho zh dvvxph zlwkrxw orvv ri jhqhudolw| wkdw +Q> y, lv }hur0qrupdolvhg/ l1h1 y+ilj, @ 3 iru doo l 5 Q1 5Pruh frpsoh{ hfrqrplf vlwxdwlrqv/ olnh h{fkdqjh hfrqrplhv/ fdq eh prghoohg dv frrshudwlyh jdphv zlwkrxw wudqvihudeoh xwlolw|1

T@)Lg iU|Lh Lu @? qTihtL? AN}@4i t @? q_4i?tL?@* iU|Lh { 5 Uqc }?} T@)Lg

{l |L T*@)ih lc l ' > = = = > q T@)Lg iU|Lh t U@**i_ @? 4T|@|L? u | t iUi?| E4i@??} |@| |i |L|@* T@)Lg t i^@* |L yEQ @?_ ?__@**) h@|L?@* E4i@??} |@| i@U T*@)ih l }i|t @| *i@t| |t L? Lh| yEilj ' f 5Lc |i ti| W4Ey Lu 4T|@|L?t t }i? M) + , [ W4Ey ' { 5 Uq { ' yEQ = n l lMQ tL*|L? I L? JQ @tt}?t @ ti| I Ey Uq Lu T@)Lg iU|Lht |L iih) U@h@U|iht|U u?U|L? y 5 JQ e i**!?L? ti|@*i_ tL*|L? t |i Lhic ?|hL_Ui_ ? }@4i |iLh) M) B**it EbD Ai ULhi @tt}?t |L iih) y 5 JQ |i ETLttM*) i4T|) tMti| Lu 4T|@|L?t }i? M) + , [ FEy ' { 5 W4Ey { yEV uLh i@U V Q > l lMV i FEy t |i ti| Lu ?_L4?@|i_ E4i@??} |@| i@U UL@*|L? }i|t @| *i@t| |t L? Lh| 4T|@|L?t 5Lc |i ULhi t |i ti| Lu 4T|@|L?t |@| @hi t|@M*i @}@?t| @?) TLttM*i _i@|L? M) UL@*|L?t W| t i**!?L? |@| FEy t ?L?i4T|) u @?_ L?*) u |i }@4i EQ> y t@|tit |i tLU@**i_ M@*@?Ui_?itt UL?_|L? Etii i} L?_@hi@ EbS @?_ 5@T*i) EbS. ?L|ih i**!?L? tL*|L? t |i 5i*iU|LTic tii #ih!tc O@**ih @?_ i|iht E2fffc @*tL U@**i_ |i O@ht@?) 5i|c tii V@t* y ' tl { Ey> l 5 Q> tVMlQ lMV

t Q i |i T@)Lg kl Ey |L T*@)ih l 5 Q t |i t4 Lih @** UL@*|L?t V 5 l UL?|@??} V V lc Lu |i t@hi tl { Ey Lu T*@)ih l ? |i O@ht@?) __i?_ Lu UL@*|L? V `i |ihiuLhi

6Zh dvvxph wkdw wkh wrwdo sd|r lv pd{lpl}hg li doo sod|huv frrshudwh wrjhwkhu1 7D vroxwlrq lv fdoohg vlqjoh0ydoxhg li wr hyhu| jdph lw dvvljqv h{dfwo| rqh sd|r glvwulexwlrq/ rwkhuzlvh lw lv d vhw0ydoxhg vroxwlrq1

2 U@** tU @ iU|Lh ktEy @ O@ht@?) T@)Lg iU|Lh Mtihi |@|c _i |L |i i^@*|) S V S t Q yEQ ' VMlQ { Eyc | L*_t |@| lMQ kl EQ> y ' yEQ uLh i@U t 5 T c @?_ |t i@U O@ht@?) T@)Lg iU|Lh t iUi?|D L |i 5i*iU|LTi Lh O@ht@?) 5i| t |i ti| KEy @tt}??} |L iih) y 5 JQ |i ti| Lu @** O@ht@?) T@)Lg iU|Lhtc i

KEy ' iktEQ> y m t 5 TQ j=

*i@h*)c M) _i?|L? i @i |@| KEy 9' > uLh i@U y L|i |@|c uLh i @4T*ic |i 5@T*i) @*ic Mi?} |i t?}*i@*i_ tL*|L? U _t|hM|it |i O@ht@?) __i?_ Lu iih) UL@*|L? V i^@**) Lih |i T*@)iht ? Vc @*@)t Mi*L?}t |L |i O@ht@?) ti|S W| uh|ih L*_t |@| FEy KEy | i^@*|) u @?_ L?*) u y t @*4Lt| TLt|i Ei {VEy f i? mVm 2c tii i} #ih!t i|@* E2fff Lh V@t*

D O@ht@?) ti| uLh }@4it | Lh_ihi_ T*@)iht

`i @hi ?L hi@_) |L @TT*) |i hit*|t Lu |i ThiLt tiU|L? |L AN}@4it | Lh_ihi_ T*@)iht @t t|_i_ ? @? _i? h?!c @? _ih w@@? @?_ V@t* y> G t |i UL**iU|L? Lu @** O@ht@?) T@)Lg iU|Lht tU |@| |i _t|hM|L? Lu |i __i?_t |@!it ?|L @UUL?| |i ih@hUU@* Lh_ih Lu |i T*@)iht M) hi^h?} |@| ? @?) UL@*|L? V UL?|@??} |L T*@)iht l @?_ mc |i t@hi Lu T*@)ih m ? |i __i?_ Lu UL@*|L? V t ?L| 4Lhi |@? |i t@hi Lu T*@)ih l ? {VEy u El> m 5 G Q V AL uLh4@*3i |tc uLh iih) V 5 l c *i| SG Mi |i t@h?} TL*)|LTi @t _i?i_ ? 5iU|L? V c |@| t @ttLU@|i_ |L |i tM_}h@T EV> GEVc i SG t |i tMti| Lu |i ?| t4T*i ? |i mVm_4i?tL?@* tT@Ui }i? M) + , [ S V ' s 5 UV s ' c @?_ s s u El> m 5 GEV > G n l l m lMV ihi UV t |i hit|hU|L? Lu Uq |L |i UL4TL?i?|t | hitTiU| |L |i T*@)iht ? V Ai O@ht@?) ti| KEy> G Lu |i }@4i | Lh_ihi_ T*@)iht EQ> y> G t ?L _i?i_ @t uL**Lt

#i?|L? D Ai O@ht@?) ti| Lu |i }@4i | Lh_ihi_ T*@)iht EQ> y> G t |i ti| KEy> G }i? M)

t Q V V Q KEy> G ' ik EQ> y m t 5 T tU |@| t 5 SG uLh i@U V 5 l j=

8Krzhyhu/ kt+y, grhv qrw qhhg wr eh dq lpsxwdwlrq1 9Wkh Vkdsoh| ydoxh # dvvljqv wr dq| y 5 Jq wkh sd|r yhfwru #+y, jlyhq e| #+y, @ S 4 V iV5 Q ml5Vj mVm +y, iru doo l 5 Q1

*i@h*)c t?Ui |i UL**iU|L? Lu TLttM*i t@h?} iU|Lht t hit|hU|i_ M) |i hi^hi4i?| |@| V V uLh @?) UL@*|L? V |i t@h?} iU|Lh t 5 SGc | uL**Lt 44i_@|i*) |@| KEy> G KEy uLh @?) _}h@T EQ> G E| i^@*|) i? G ' > 6h|ihc ?L|i |@| |i ti| KEy> G t @ TL*)|LTi `i ?L @TT*) AiLhi4 e |L ?_ |i i |hi4i TL?|t Lu |t TL*)|LTi AL _L tLc i ti |i u@U| |@| |i O@ht@?) ti| t @ _tL?| @__|i tL*|L?c tii @? _i? h?! i| @* E2ffe. 6hL4 |i _tL?| @__||) | uL**Lt |@| uLh @?) }@4i EQ> y> G | L*_t |@| [ KEy> G ' {VEyKExV> G> VMlQ i |i O@ht@?) ti| Lu |i }@4i EQ> y> G t |i i}|i_ t4 Lu |i O@ht@?) ti|t Lu |i ?@?4|) }@4it | Lh_ihi_ T*@)iht | i}|t i^@* |L |i O@ht@?) __i?_t 6hL4 uLh4*@ EDe | uL**Lt |@| |i __i?_t Lu @ ?@?4|) }@4i xV @hi }i? M) {W ExV ' u W ' V @?_ {W ExV ' f L|ihti Lc uLh s 5 Uqc *i| sV Mi |i hit|hU|L? |L UVc i V s t |i mVm_4i?tL?@* iU|Lh UL?|@??} |i UL4TL?i?|t slc l 5 Vc Lu s Ai? | uL**Lt |@|

V q V V Q KEx > G ' is 5 X m sl ' f u l 95 Vc @?_ s 5 SGj> V 5 l >

i KExV> G t |i ti| Lu @** iU|Lht s ? X q | 3ihL UL4TL?i?|t uLh |i T*@)iht ?L| ? V V V @?_ | |i hit|hU|L? s ? |i t@h?} TL*)|LTi SG @ttLU@|i_ |L EV> GEV @t _i?i_ @MLi Lc uLh V 5 lQ c *i| DFVEG Mi |i UL**iU|L? Lu @** UL4T*i|i tMti|t Lu T*@)iht ? |i tM}h@T EV> GEV Ai? AiLhi4 e )i*_t |i uL**L?} ULhL**@h)

LhL**@h) D2 6Lh V 5 lQ @?_ G 5 GQ c |i i |hi4i TL?|t Lu KExV> G @hi }i? M) dW 5 Uqc W 5 DFVEG

5Lc |i ULhL**@h) }it |i i |hi4i TL?|t Lu |i O@ht@?) ti|t Lu |i ?@?4|) }@4it ) t?} |i _tL?| @__||)c |t 4@) Mi @TT*i_ |L U@*U*@|i |i i |hi4i TL?|t Lu KEy> G ? 4Lhi }i?ih@* t|@|L?tc @t **t|h@|i_ ? |i ?i | i @4T*i

, @4T*i D L?t_ih |i }@4i | Lh_ihi_ T*@)iht EQ> y> G | Q ' i> 2> jc y ' xt>2 n xt> @?_ G ' iE> > E2> j @t }i? ? , @4T*i H 6Lh |t }@4i | Lh_ihi_ T*@)iht i ?_ DFt>2EG ' iij> i2jj @?_ DFt> EG ' iij> i> jj UULh_?} |L LhL**@h) D2 |i ti| Lu i |hi4i TL?|t Lu KExt>2> G t iE> f> f> Ef> > fj @?_ |i ti| Lu i |hi4i

:Iru jdphv zlwk rughuhg sod|huv/ d vroxwlrq I vdwlvhv glvmrlqw dgglwlylw| li I+Q> y . z> G, @ Q I+Q> y> G, . I+Q> z> G,/ zkhqhyhu y+W ,z+W , @ 3 iru doo W 5 1 +Zkhq G @ >/ zh rewdlq glv0 mrlqw dgglwlylw| iru vwdqgdug WX0jdphv/ zklfk lv d zhdn yhuvlrq ri dgglwlylw|1,

e t> t>2 t> TL?|t Lu KEx > G t iE> f> f > E 2 > f> 2 j 544?} T KEx > G @?_ KEx > G )i*_t KEy> G ' L? E2> f> f> E> > f> E > > > E > f> > 2 2 2 2 tii 6}hi e 3 4 3 E F C 3 D DD.. 3 4 D . 5 4 D . E 2 F D . C 3 D D . D . 3 42 BD B . 3 4 5 DDDDDDDDDDDDD . 3 E F DDDDDDDDDDDDD . E F C 3 DDB DDDDDDD3DDDDDB4 .C 5 D 3 4 3 E F C 4 D 3 6}hi e

D2 Lhi uLh u33) }@4it | Lh_ihi_ T*@)iht

W? |i @TThL@U @MLi i @_@T|i_ |i O@ht@?) ti| uLh t|@?_@h_ AN}@4it |L }@4it | Lh_ihi_ T*@)iht M) |@!?} |i ih@hUU@* t|hU|hi L? |i ti| Lu T*@)iht |L hit|hU| |i ti| Lu @**L@M*i T@)Lg _t|hM|L?t `i? @TT*)?} |i ULhi tL*|L? |L }@4it | Lh_ihi_ T*@)iht | tii4t |L Mi 4Lhi hi@tL?@M*i |L hit|hU| |i ti| Lu @**L@M*i _i@|?} UL@*|L?t W? T@h|U*@hc ? t|@|L?t |@| |i _}h@T EQ> G hiiU|t @ ih@hUU@* t|hU|hic | 4@) @TTi? |@| @ T*@)ih ?ii_t Tih4ttL? Lu t Thi_iUittLht |L ULLTih@|i | L|ih T*@)ihtc i @ E4*|T*i T*@)ih UL@*|L? V Q 4@) uLh4 u @?_ L?*) u uLh iih) T*@)ih ? |i UL@*|L? | L*_t |@| @** |t Thi_iUittLht ? |i _}h@T EQ> G Mi*L?} |L |i UL@*|L? 5Lc |i ti| Lu ui@tM*i _i@|?} UL@*|L?t t }i? M) |i UL**iU|L? Lu @** t?}*i|L?t @?_ @** UL4Thii?ti 4*|T*i T*@)ih UL@*|L?t DEG 5?Ui | t t|** hi@tL?@M*i |L @tt4i |@| @?) t?}*i T*@)ih U@? LM|@? @| *i@t| |t L? Lh|c |i ULhi uLh @ }@4i EQ> y> G | Lh_ihi_ T*@)iht ?L MiUL4it + , [ FEy> G ' { 5 W4Ey { yEV uLh i@U V 5 DEG > EDD l lMV i | t |i tMti| Lu |i 4T|@|L? ti| |@| U@? ?L| Mi _L4?@|i_ M) @ UL4Thii?ti UL@*|L? W? UL?|h@t| |L KEy> G KEyc i ?L @i FEy FEy> Gc t?Ui |ihi @hi 4Lhi ?i^@*|it |L Mi t@|ti_ ? FEy |@? ? FEy> G

D W? |i tiî* i @hi }L?} |L Thiti?| @? @TT*U@|L? Lu AiLhi4 e2 M) UL?t_ih?} |i @?@*L} Lu |i ti| FEy> G ? U@ti Lu u33) }@4it | Lh_ihi_ T*@)iht Ai U*@tt Lu ULLTih@|i }@4it | u33) UL@*|L?t EtLh|*) u33) }@4it @?_ |i ULhhitTL?_?} UL?UiT| Lu |i ULhi uLh tU }@4it t ?|hL_Ui_ ? M? Eb.b u33) UL@*|L? L? q q @ T*@)ih ti| Q ' i> = = = > qj t @ iU|Lh v 5 L ' df> o c ihi UL4TL?i?| vl t |i T@h|UT@|L? h@|i Lu T*@)ih l u33) }@4i t @ T@h EQ> i ihi |i U@h@U|iht|U q u?U|L? i @tt}?t @ @*i iEv |L @?) u33) UL@*|L? v 5 L | iEv ' f i? vl ' f uLh @** l 5 Q Mtihi |@| v ' hV _i?L|it |i U@ti |@| |i T*@)iht ? V @i T@h|UT@|L? h@|i i^@* |L L?i @?_ |i L|iht 3ihL 5Lc |i hit|hU|L? Lu i |L |i iU|Lht hV 5 Lq ?_Uit @ t|@?_@h_ AN}@4i EQ> yi c @*tL U@**i_ UhtT }@4ic | U@h@U|iht|U u?U|L? yi 5 JQ }i? M) yi EV ' iEhVc V Q }@? i @tt4i ? |i tiî* |@| |i }@4i t 3ihL?Lh4@*3i_c |t iEhtl ' yi Eilj ' f uLh @** l 5 Q Ai ULhi EM?c b.b Lu @ u33) }@4i EQ> ic |L Mi _i?L|i_ M) I Eic t |i ti| Lu @** 4T|@|L?t { 5 Uq U @hi t|@M*i @}@?t| @?) TLttM*i _i@|L? M) u33) UL@*|L?tc i + , [ I Ei ' { 5 W4Ei v { iEv uLh i@U v 5 Lq > l l lMQ S q Q i ihi |i ti| Lu 4T|@|L?t t }i? M) W4Ei ' { 5 Un lMQ {l ' iEh ' y EQ ì ?L UL?t_ih @ u33) }@4i | Lh_ihi_ T*@)iht EQ> i> Gc ihi G t |i _}h@T L? Q hiiU|?} |i Lh_ih?} UULh_?} |L |i @TThL@U @MLic ? tU @ t|@|L? | 4@) Mi hi@tL?@M*i |L hit|hU| |i ti| Lu ui@tM*i _i@|?} UL@*|L?t E?L*?} 4*|T*i T*@)iht M) hi^h?} |@| UL@*|L? v 5 Lq E| @| *i@t| |L TLt|i UL4TL?i?|t 4@) L?*) _i@|i

i? vl vm u El> m 5 Gc i ? @ ui@tM*i UL@*|L? | 4*|T*i TLt|i T@h|UT@|L? h@|it |i T@h|UT@|L? h@|i Lu l t @| *i@t| @t } @t |i T@h|UT@|L? h@|i Lu m i? m t _L4?@|i_ M) l At )i*_t |i ULhi uLh u33) }@4it | Lh_ihi_ T*@)iht }i? M) + , [ I Ei> G ' { 5 W4Ei v { iEv uLh i@U v 5 N > l l G lMQ

ihi NG t |i u33) TL*)|LTi @t _i?i_ ? 5iU|L? e AL _i4L?t|h@|i @? @TT*U@|L? Lu AiLhi4 e2 |L |i _itUhT|L? Lu |i ULhi I Ei> G> i ?|hL_Ui ht| @ tTiU@* U*@tt Lu u33) }@4itc U 4@) Mi Lu ?|ihit| ? |ti*u `i t@) |@| @ u33) }@4i EQ> i t ThLTih UL?i u iEv n E w iEv n E iEw uLh @** 5 df> o @?_ v> w 5 Lq= ||?} _gihi?|*)c @ u33) }@4i EQ> i t ThLTih UL?i u i G Lq $ U t @ UL?i u?U|L? i*Lc @? i^@*i?Ui hit*|c hi*@|i_ |L |i ULhit Lu |i u33) @?_ Lh_?@h) }@4it | Lh_ihi_ T*@)iht t }i? W? T@h|U*@hc |t hit*| ThL_it @ t4T*i_ _itUhT|L? Lu |i ULhi I Ei> G ? U@ti EQ> i t @ ThLTih UL?i u33) }@4i

S LhL**@h) De wi| EQ> i> G Mi @ ThLTih UL?i u33) }@4i | Lh_ihi_ T*@)iht Ai? + , [ I Ei> G ' FEyi > G ' { 5 W4Eyi { yi EV uLh i@U V 5 DEG = l lMV

hLLu ) _i?|L? Lu I Ei> G @?_ FEyi > Gc i @i I Ei> G FEyi > G= AL ThLi |i LTTLt|i ?U*tL? TU! tL4i { 5 FEyi > G @?_ UL?t_ih @? @hM|h@h) u33) UL@*|L? v 5 NG= #i |L AiLhi4 e2 i @i @ hiThiti?|@|L? [ V v ' Vh EDS VMDEG S | V f> V 5 DEG> t@|tu)?} i^@*|) VMDEG V ' = Oi?Uic | L*_t [ [ [ [ [ [ [ V vl{l ' Vhl {l ' V{l ' VE {l ED. lMQ lMQ VMDEG VMDEG lMV VMDEG lMV

i S i 6hL4 { 5 FEy > G | uL**Lt |@| lMV {l y EV uLh @?) V 5 DEG= L?ti^i?|*)c M) i^@*|) ED. i @i [ [ i vl{l Vy EV= lMQ VMDEG

Ai *@||ih ?i^@*|)c |L}i|ih | |i UL?i |) Lu i @?_ hiThiti?|@|L? EDS )i*_t [ [ [ V V vl{l ViEh iE Vh ' iEv= lMQ VMDEG VMDEG S Oi?Uic uLh @?) v 5 NG | L*_t lMQ vl{l iEv> U ThLit |i ?U*tL? { 5 I Ei> G= #i |L |i @hM|h@h?itt Lu { 5 FEyi > G | uL**Lt |@| FEyi > G I Ei> G=

Ai ULhL**@h) t@)t |@| |i ULhi I Ei> G Lu @ ThLTih UL?i u33) }@4i EQ> i> G | Lh_ihi_ T*@)iht UL?U_itc ? u@U|c | |i ELh_?@h) ULhi FEyi > G Lu |i }@4i EQ> yi > G | Lh_ihi_ T*@)iht L?ti^i?|*)c @? 4T|@|L? t ? |i ULhi Lu |i ThLTih UL?i u33) }@4i | Lh_ihi_ T*@)iht u @?_ L?*) u | t t|@M*i @}@?t| @?) _i@|L? M) @ UL4Thii?ti uhL4 @MLi UhtT UL@*|L?

D +i*@|i_ *|ih@|hi L? }@4it | ih@hUU@* t|hU|hi

AL UL?U*_i |t T@Tih i @?| |L t|hitt |i _gihi?Ui Mi|ii? |t @TThL@U ? U |i ih@hUU@* t|hU|hi hit|hU|t |i ti|t Lu ui@tM*i UL@*|L?t @?_ |i @TThL@U @t _ii*LTi_ ? B**itc i? @?_ @? _i? h?! Ebb2c B**it @?_ i? Ebbec @? _i? h?! @?_ B**it EbbS @?_ @? _i? h?! Ebb. uLh AN}@4it | @ Tih4ttL? t|hU|hi W? u@U|c ? |i @TThL@U @MLi i @_@T|i_ |i tL*|L? |L |i t|@|L? Lu Lh_ihi_ T*@)ihtc *i

. ? |t *|ih@|hi |i }@4i t @_@T|i_ @?_ t|@?_@h_ tL*|L? UL?UiT|t @hi @TT*i_ |L |t @_@T|i_ }@4i L| @TThL@Uit @i ? UL44L? |@| @*tL ? |t *|ih@|hi ULLTih@|L? t hit|hU|i_ ? |i ti?ti |@| T*@)iht ?ii_ Tih4ttL? uhL4 |ih Thi_iUittLht MiuLhi |i) @hi @**Li_ |L ULLTih@|i OLiihc |t Tih4ttL? t|hU|hi t ti_ |L LM|@? @ hit|hU|i_ }@4i ? |i ti?ti Lu }h@Thit|hU|i_ }@4it @t ?|hL_Ui_ ? )ihtL? Eb.. ? |i UL?|i | Lu E?_hiU|i_ UL44?U@|L? }h@Tt UULh_?} |L |i UL??U|i Tih4ttL? @TThL@U | t @tt4i_ |@| i@U T*@)ih ?ii_t Tih4ttL? uhL4 @** |t Thi_iUittLht MiuLhi | t @**Li_ |L ULLTih@|i | L|ih T*@)ihtH 5Lc @ UL@*|L? V U@? L?*) hi@*ti |i Lh| Lu |i *@h}it| tMti| Lu V |@| UL?|@?t @** |t Thi_iUittLhtc i @ UL@*|L? V U@? L?*) hi@*ti |i Lh|

Lu |t *@h}it| UL4Thii?ti tMUL@*|L?c _i?L|i_ M) GEVc @?_ }i? M)

GEV ' ^iW 5 DEG m W Vj=

Mtihi |@| E GEV t @ ETLttM*) i4T|) tMti| Lu V ? DEGc E GEV ' V u @?_

L?*) u V 5 DEG @?_ |t E GEQ ' Qc t?Ui Q 5 DEG Ai *@||ih ThLTih|) 4T*it |@| yGEQ ' yEQ 6Lh @ UhtT }@4i | Lh_ihi_ T*@)iht EQ> y> Gc |i UL??U|i hit|hU|L? Lu y L? G t |i U@h@U|iht|U u?U|L? yGG 2Q $ W+ }i? M)

G y EV ' yEGEV uLh @** V Q= 5Lc EQ> yG t @ EUhtT }@4i LM|@?i_ uhL4 EQ> y> G M) |@!?} ?|L @UUL?| |i UL??U|i Tih4ttL? t|hU|hi hit|hU|?} |i ULLTih@|L? TLttM*|itb tMU*@tt Lu tU }@4it t |i U*@tt Lu Tiih}hLT }@4itc tii h @?3ic 6h@}?i** @?_ At E2ff2 Lc @** tL*|L? UL?UiT|t uLh AN}@4it U@? Mi @TT*i_ |L |i hit|hU|i_ }@4i EQ> yG |L LM|@? @ tL*|L? uLh |i }@4i | Lh_ihi_ T*@)iht EQ> y> G TT*)?} |i Lhi @t @ tL*|L? )i*_t |i tL*|L? }i? M) + , [ FEy> G ' FEyG ' { 5 W4EyG { yGEV uLh i@U V Q = l lMV 5?Ui yGEQ ' yEQ uLh iih) _}h@T Gc i @i |@| W4EyG ' W4Ey @?_ |t FEy> G t @ tMti| Lu |i ti| Lu 4T|@|L?t Lu |i }@4i EQ> y `i? EQ> y t 4L?L|L?ifc i G @i |@| y EV ' yEGEV yEV MiU@ti GEV Vc @?_ |t FEy F Ey> G L?Uih??} |i _gihi?Ui Mi|ii? FEy> G @t _i?i_ ? i^@|L? EDD @?_ FEy> G ' FEyGc LMtihi |@| |i uLh4ih t LM|@?i_ M) hit|hU|?} |i ti| Lu ui@tM*i _i@|?} UL@* |L?t E|t M) @_@T|?} |i tL*|L? UL?UiT|c *i |i *@||ih @TT*it |i t|@?_@h_ ULhi tL*|L? |L |i @_@T|i_ U@h@U|iht|U u?U|L? yG +i4@h!@M*)c |i uL**L?} ThLTLt|L? t@)t |@| ML| ti|t @hi i^@* ;Dowhuqdwlyho|/ lq wkh glvmxqfwlyh shuplvvlrq dssurdfk lw lv dvvxphg wkdw hdfk sod|hu qhhgv shuplvvlrq iurp dw ohdvw rqh ri lwv suhghfhvvruv ehiruh lw lv doorzhg wr frrshudwh1 , @ 3/ vr wkdw +Q> yG, lv }hur0qrupdolvhg li +Q> y, lv }hur0qrupdolvhg1 43D WX0jdph +Q> y, lv prqrwrqh li y+V, y+W , zkhqhyhu V W Q1

H hLTLt|L? DD wi| EQ> y> G Mi @ 3ihL?Lh4@*ti_ }@4i | Lh_ihi_ T*@)iht Ai? FEyG ' FEy> G

hLLu 5?Ui GEV ' V u E@?_ L?*) u V 5 DEGc @?) hit|hU|L? ? FEy> G @*tL @T Ti@ht ? FEyG Oi?Ui FEyG FEy> G AL tL |i hiihtic *i| { 5 FEy> Gc i S S {l yEV uLh i@U V 5 DEG AihiuLhi {l yEGEV uLh @** V Q lMV lMGEV S S 5?Ui EV Vc | uL**Lt | { f uLh @** l 5 Q |@| { { G l lMV l lMGEV l G G yEGEV ' y EV uLh @** Vc 4T*)?} |@| { 5 FEy

Ai ThLTLt|L? tLt |@| @? 4T|@|L? t ? |i ULhi FEyG Lu |i hit|hU|i_ }@4i EQ> yG u @?_ L?*) u { t t|@M*i ? EQ> y @}@?t| @?) _i@|L? M) @ UL4Thii?ti uhL4 @MLi UL@*|L? ? |i }h@T EQ> G 5Lc |t 4@) *i@_ |L @ tMt|@?|@* hi_U|L? Lu |i ?4Mih ui@tM*|) UL?t|h@?|t |L Mi UiU!i_ i|ih Lh ?L| @? 4T|@|L? t ? |i ULhi Lu EQ> yG

+iuihi?Uit do M?c a Eb.b @|i4@|U@* i|L_t Lu B@4it @?_ ,UL?L4U AiLh)c 4t|ih_@4i vLh! uLh_G Lh|OL**@?_ d2o L?_@hi@c EbS c 5L4i @TT*U@|L?t Lu *?i@h ThL}h@44?} 4i|L_t |L |i |iLh) Lu ULLTih@|i }@4itc hLM*i4) kMih?i|!c fc b b E? +tt@? d o h @?3ic +c # #4|hLc @?_ 5 At E2ff2c L?i u33) }@4it @?_ T@h|UT@|L? 4L?L|L?U @**LU@|L? tUi4itc 633) 5i|t @?_ 5)t|i4tc bc 2S.2H deo h @?3ic +c V 6h@}?i**c @?_ 5 At E2ff2c Ahii UL??iU|i_ Tiih }hLT t|@|L?t @?_ Tiih }hLT }@4itc @|i4@|U@* i|L_t Lu Tih@|L?t +iti@hUc DDc b fS dDo h?!c + @? _i? Ebb.c ? L4@|3@|L? Lu |i #t?U|i ih4ttL? V@*i uLh B@4it | @ ih4ttL? 5|hU|hic W?| a B@4i AiLh) 2Sc 2.e dSo h?!c + @? _i?c @?_ B**itc + EbbSc L4@|3@|L?t Lu |i L??U|i ih 4ttL? V@*i uLh B@4it | ih4ttL? 5|hU|hitc B@4it @?_ ,UL?L4U i@ 2c 2S d.o h?!c + @? _i?c B@? _ih w@@? @?_ VV@t*

b dHo h?!c + @? _i?c B@? _ih w@@? @?_ VV@t*LL*i@? 6?U|L?t @?_ B@4i AiLh) W Lhi ,*i4i?|t @?_ 5@T*i) V@*ic @iht _ ,+c bc Db.S deo a O@ht@?) EbDbc M@h}@??} 4L_i* uLh ULLTih@|i qTihtL? }@4itc ?G ` AU!ih @?_ +# wUi Ei_tc L?|hM|L?t |L |i AiLh) Lu B@4it WV Eh?Ui|L? N?iht|) hittc h?Ui|L? ac TT 2D DD dDo + )ihtL? Eb..c Bh@Tt @?_ ULLTih@|L? ? }@4itc @|i4@|Ut Lu Tih@|L?t +iti@hU 2c 22D22b dSo 5@T*i)c w EbS.c ? M@*@?Ui_ ti|t @?_ ULhitc @@* +iti@hU wL}t|Ut "@h|ih*)c ec eD eSf d.o 5Uhih EbHSc AiLh) Lu w?i@h @?_ W?|i}ih hL}h@44?}c Uit|ihi vLh! htM@?iALhL?|L5?}@TLhiG aL? `*i) : 5L?t dHo V@t*