BASIS SAFETY CONTROLS for HOT WATER and LOW-PRESSURE STEAM BOILERS By: Tom Vana, Factory Representative, Mcdonnell & Miller, Inc
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Service Application Manual SAM Chapter 630-36 Section 20 BASIS SAFETY CONTROLS FOR HOT WATER AND LOW-PRESSURE STEAM BOILERS By: Tom Vana, Factory Representative, McDonnell & Miller, Inc. HOT WATER SPACE HEATING BOILERS SAFTETY RELIEF VALVES Good engineering tells us that every hot water boiler must have a safety relief valve that will keep the pressure at or below the maximum allowable working pressure of the boiler. But until recently the methods of accomplishing this objective were not clearly understood. Figure 70F51A shows one method of attempting to provide protection against over-pressure which is unsafe for these reasons: 1. The relief valve does not comply with the ASME Boiler code requirements. 2. Its capacity is unknown. 3. It is installed in the wrong location. 4. It can inadvertently be isolated from the boiler due to lime or scale build-up in boiler feed line. 5. The function of a relief valve has nothing in common with a pressure reducing type fill valve. A combination of the two units is based on price consideration—not performance. The first basic step in providing correct safety control for a hot water boiler is to make sure that an ASME relief valve is installed. The ASME Code states: “Every hot water heating boiler shall have at least one officially rated pressure relief valve set to relieve at or below the maximum allowable working pressure of the boiler… Relief valve shall be connected to the Copyright © 1966, 2009, By Refrigeration Service Engineers Society. -1- top of boilers with the spindle vertical if possible…. No shutoff of any description shall be placed between the relief valve and the boiler, nor on the discharge pipe between such valve and the atmosphere.” Figure 70F51B shows the correct and safe installation of the relief valve. CONDITIONS REQUIRING SERVICE 1. Waterlogged or undersized expansion tank—It may be necessary to drain the expansion tank so that a new air cushion may be created in order to allow for thermal expansion. Should this not remedy the situation, it may be necessary to determine if the expansion tank is of the proper size for the system. 2. Pressure setting of relief valve too low—Check the boiler manufacturer’s instruction manual or boiler nameplate to determine maximum boiler pressure. Actual operating pressure of the boiler should be several pounds below the relief valve setting. 3. Improperly sized relief valve—Btu capacity of relief valve may be less than the gross boiler output, therefore unable to provide full relieving capacity. 4. Excessive pump or head pressure. 5. Excessive overfiring of fuel burner. 6. Leaky hand fill valve. 7. Valve not installed on top of boiler. 8. Valve installed backwards. 9. Relief Valve discharge pipe capped or plugged. PERFORMANCE AND FUNCTION OF ASME RELIEF VALVES To understand how a relief valve should perform, it will be helpful to analyze just what a relief valve on a hot water boiler is supposed to do. Basically of course, its job is to keep the boiler pressure within the designed working pressure of the boiler—usually 30 pounds. But to accomplish this properly the relief valve must be capable of performing satisfactorily under two quite dissimilar conditions: 1. Relieving pressure by discharge of water (Thermal Expansion). 2. Relieving pressure by discharge of steam (Emergency Condition). Copyright © 1966, 2009, By Refrigeration Service Engineers Society. -2- Relieving pressure by discharge of water is made necessary by the thermal expansion of water in the boiler, and is considered a normal operating condition. But the relief of pressure by the discharge of steam is the result of abnormal operation and is usually referred to as an “emergency condition.” The more critical demand placed on a safety relief valve is during the emergency stage, when it must discharge both high temperature water and steam. Whenever the temperature in the boiler is about 212°F, and the relief valve discharges, the sudden pressure drop causes the higher temperature water to flash to steam. Thus the discharge capacity of an ASME relief valve is tested and rated on steam. Basically the emergency stage is caused by an over-firing of the burner. The heating system cannot dissipate the heat energy as fast as it is developed in the boiler, and temperatures and pressures continue to rise. Over-firing may be caused in numerous ways, such as: 1. Failure of a limit control to stop the burner. 2. Mechanical failure of a fuel valve. 3. Burner on manual operation. 4. Residual heat with coal firing. 5. Burner considerably over-size for boiler and system. The vast difference between discharging water and discharging steam from a relief valve is illustrated in Figure 70F52. One pound of water occupies a space of only approximately 27.7 cubic inches, whereas a pound of steam at atmospheric pressure occupies more than 1600 times as much space— approximately 26.8 cubic feet. Therefore it is necessary that the relief valve have a very large capacity and yet close drip tight. ADDITIONAL RECOGNIZE NEED FOR ADDITIONAL BASIC SAFETY CONTROLS Many consulting engineers and utility companies have been consistently recommending certain basic controls for hot water boilers beyond an ASME relief valve. Many local codes and federal specifications insist on them. Perhaps the best verification of this sound engineering principle is outlined in an excerpt from an article published in a leading trade magazine: “Then there’s the problem of avoiding firing dry boilers, especially boilers in hot water heating plants. Fired continuously by a run-away burner and carrying no heating load, the boiler may not explode because it has a modern mechanical device (ASME relief valve) to protect against explosion caused by excessive pressure. But the boiler may be ruined because it goes dry, or tries to operate as a steam boiler though it is not arranged for this. “In these connections, excellent arguments come up regarding the need to increase safety of boiler operation through the increased use of automatic feeders and low-water controls, not only for steam boilers but also for the boilers used in both open-type and closed hot water heating plants.” Therefore it can be seen that while ASME rated pressure relief valves are absolutely essential to boiler safety, there is also a great need for boiler feeders and cut-offs. Copyright © 1966, 2009, By Refrigeration Service Engineers Society. -3- LOW WATER CUT-OFFS Can a low water condition occur in a hot water boiler? Emphatically, yes! The record clearly indicates that most hot water boiler damage and boiler losses can be traced to low water. Essentially the construction of a hot water boiler and a steam boiler are the same. Most of the reasons why low water can occur in a steam boiler will also hold true for a hot water boiler. It is a common misconception that a pressure reducing valve, used to fill a hot water system initially, will keep the boiler and system full under all circumstances. But when it is realized that a pressure reducing valve is normally set at 12 or 18 pounds, and a safety relief valve opens at 30 pounds and closes at 26 pounds, it becomes obvious that the pressure reducing valve is ineffective during the time the relief valve is functioning. Figure 70F53A shows an ASME relief valve discharging due to excessive pressure in the boiler; without makeup water replacing the loss through the relief valve a hazardous low water condition can result. If a hand fill valve is used, then of course any leak in the system can quickly cause a low water condition. Here are some of the reasons why a hot water boiler and system can lose water so that a low water condition can result; 1. Loss of water due to carelessness. • draining boiler for repair or summer lay-up without eliminating possibility of firing. • drawing hot water from boiler. 2. Loss of water in distribution system. • leaks in piping caused by expansion breakage or corrosion. • leaks in boiler. • leaks through pump or other operating equipment. 3. Relief valve discharge caused by over-firing. Figure 70F53B shows the action of the low water cut-off when an emergency condition arises. The falling boiler water line and simultaneous falling of the water line in the float chamber causes the float to drop, thus opening the electrical circuit and stopping the automatic burner. Copyright © 1966, 2009, By Refrigeration Service Engineers Society. -4- CONDITIONS REQUIRING SERVICE 1. Improper wiring isolating cut-off from circuit—Check manufacturer’s wiring diagrams and trace circuits to insure proper electrical hook-up. 2. Switch overload causing fused contact points— Excessive electrical load due to a short or improper wiring may cause burnt or fused switch contact points. 3. Switch damaged by water—Water residue or water itself may be present in the switch causing improper switch performance. 4. Fuel valve stuck open thus allowing burner to remain operative. FEEDER CUT-OFF COMBINATIONS The following statement, which is based on considerable experience in the heating field, appears in a booklet on “Recommended Practices for Installation,” published by a leading utility company: “A low water cut-off which will cut off the fuel supply before the water level reaches a low danger point, or a water feeding device with cut-off, shall be attached to all steam and hot water boilers.” If we could rely absolutely on the low water cut-off to stop the automatic burner each time a low water condition developed, then the problem would be solved completely. However, experience has proved that under certain circumstances the low water cut-off cannot fulfill its duties.