<<

1996 Philip C. Jessup International Law Moot Court Competition

ERCOLA

V.

FILOVA

The Case Concerning The Military Personnel Database

COMPETITION RESULTS 1996 Philip C. Jessup International Law Moot Court Competition World Cup Championship Round

30 March 1996 UNITED STATES CEREMONIAL COURTROOM Washington, D.C., USA

1996 JEssup CuP WORLD CHAMPION THE UNIVERSITY OF SYDNEY, AUSTRALIA

1996 RUNNER-UP THE NATIONAL UNIVERSITY OF SINGAPORE

The University of Sydney v. National University of Singapore Australia Singapore

Mathew McLennan Kwan Song Eu Ben Kremer Heikel Khalio Bafana Ben Olbourne Shan Shan Blossom Hing Rebecca Kavanagh Lyn Lee Jane Doolan

Coach: Dr. Donald Rothwell Coach: Robert Beckman

BEST ORALIST IN FINAL ROUND (by Judge's vote)

Lyn Lee

Final Bench of the 1996 Jessup Competition Washington D.C., USA

Charles N. Brower President, American Society of International Law Washington D.C., USA

Prof. Catherine Kessedjian, Esq. , France

Stephen M. Schwebel Judge & Vice-President, International Court of Justice The Hague, Netherlands INTERNATIONAL LAW STUDENTS ASSOCIATION

2223 Massachusetts Avenue, N.W. CONGRESS OF Washington, D.C. 20008-2864 U.S.A. INTERNATIONAL LAW SOCIETIES PHILIP C. JESSUP 1-202-939-6030 INTERNATIONAL LAW CABLE "AMINTLAW ILSA MOOT COURT COMPETITION FAX 1-202-265-0386 CONFERENCE OF INTERNATIONAL LAW JOURNALS

1996 PHILIP C. JESSUP INTERNATIONAL LAW MOOT COURT COMPETITION

JESSUP WORLD CUP CHAMPIONSHIP ROUND United States Ceremonial Courtroom Washington, DC, USA

National University of Singapore v. University of Sydney, Australia

WORLD CUP CHAMPION University of Sydney, Australia

RUNNER-UP National University of Singapore

BEST ORALIST - WORLD CUP CHAMPIONSHIP ROUND Lyn Lee, National University of Singapore

SEMI-FINALISTS

National University of Singapore v. University of Georgia, USA National Law School of India v. University of Sydney, Australia

QUARTER-FINALISTS

University of Western Australia v. University of Sydney, Australia*' University of Georgia, USA v. Georgetown University, USA* Dr. Ambedkar Gov't Law College, Madras, India v. National Law School of India* National University of Singapore v. University of Leeds,

* Teams from the same country must compete against each other in the Quarterfinal Rounds. Semifinalist teams must represent four different countries. 1996 Philip C. Jessup International Law Moot Court Competition International Rounds

TEAM RANKINGS

QUARTERFINALISTS

Place Team No. School WinlLoss Raw SM

1. 108 University of Sydney, Australia 4/0 3296 2.* 141 University of Calgary, Canada* 4/0* 3279* 2. 466 National University of Singapore 4/0 3247.5 3. 107 University of Western Australia 4/0 3247 4. 213 Georgetown University, USA 4/0 3215 5. 268 University of Georgia, USA 4/0 3212 7. 431 University of Leeds, United Kingdom 4/0 2994 8. 360 Dr. Ambedkar Gov't Law College, Madras, India 4/0 2922 9. 351 National Law School of India 3/1 3257

PRELIMINARY RouND RANKINGS

6.** 263 University of North Carolina, USA** 2 4/0** 3120** 11. 244 University of Hawaii, USA 3/1 3231 12. 427 Law Society of Ireland 3/1 3184 13. 455 Universidad Catolica Andres Bello, Venezuela 3/1 3141 14. 487 University of Wellington, New Zealand 3/1 3127 15. 485 Universidad de Santiago, Chile 3/1 3110 16. 347 Arizona State University, USA 3/1 3103 17. 206 Fordham University, USA 3/1 3101 18. 150 Dalhousie University, Canada 3/1 3089 19. 459 Universidad de Costa Rica 3/1 3056 20. 476 Universidad de Puerto Rico 3/1 3017 21. 162 University of the Witwatersrand, South Africa 3/1 3015 22. 453 University of , Norway 3/1 3004 23. 208 Columbia University, USA 2/2 3273 24. 480 University of , Austria 2/2 3198 25. 473 Universidad de Buenos Aires, Argentina 2/2 3169

* Due to an error in tabulating penalties, the University of Calgary should have placed second and was therefore precluded from advancing to the Quarterfinal Rounds. For the official record, the University of Calgary placed second overall, ahead of the University of Singapore.

** Under the Official Rules of the competition, only two United States teams may advance to the Quarterfinal Rounds. United States teams placing third or lower among the United States schools, but within the top eight teams from the Preliminary Rounds, are ineligible to compete in the Quarterfinal Rounds. PRELIMINARY ROUND RANKINGS

Place Team No. School Win/Loss

26. 240 Chicago-Kent College of Law, USA 2/2 3133 27. 424 University of Utrecht, The Netherlands 2/2 3104 28. 225 University of - Hastings, USA 2/2 3089 29. 338 Boston University, USA 2/2 3087 30. 447 Ateneo University, The Philippines 2/2 3064 31. 391 University, Bulgaria 2/2 3050 32. 298 Indiana University - Indianapolis, USA 2/2 3017 33. 462 University of Botswana 2/2 2973 34. 123 Kyoto University, Japan 2/2 2878 35. 438 University of Seoul, Korea 2/2 2864 36. 354 Kerala Law Academy, India 2/2 2809 37. 307 University of Michigan, USA 1/3 3141 38. 467 Eoutas Lorand University (ELTE), Hungary 1/3 3024 39. 410 Universidad Nacional Autonoma de Mexico 1/3 3017 40. 464 Universite de Paris, France 1/3 3016 41. 186 Universitat zu , Germany 1/3 3009 42. 482 University of Hong Kong 1/3 2989 43. 285 Tulane University, USA 1/3 2982 44. 463 Universidad de Los Andes, Colombia 1/3 2899 45. 481 Univ. Notre Dame de la Paix, Namur, 1/3 2822 46. 120 National Taiwan University, Taiwan 1/3 2804 47. 465 University, Ukraine 1/3 2749 48. 452 Belarussian State University, Belarus 1/3 2718 49. 1001 University of , Slovenia 1/3 2675 50. 400 University of Malaya, Malaysia 1/3 2575 51. 475 University of Papua New Guinea 1/3 2528 52. 412 Charles University, Czech Republic 0/4 2898 53. 461 University, Lithuania 0/4 2871 54. 468 University of Thessaloniki, Greece 0/4 2819 55. 458 Makerere University, Uganda 0/4 2779 56. 416 Dokuz Eylul University, Turkey 0/4 2683 57. 460 Pontificia Univ. Catolica do Rio Grande do Sul, Brazil 0/4 2644 58. 477 Lapin Yliopisto, Finland 0/4 2533 INTERNATONAL LAW STUDENTS S.SOCIATIOiN

- 2223 Massachusetts Avenue, N.W. CONGRESS O Washington, D.C. 20008-2864 U.S.A. INTERNATIONAL LAW SOCIETIFE PHILIP C. JESSUP 1-202-939-6030 INTERNATIONAL LAy' I L-A COURT COMPETITION CABLE "AM INTLAW" MOOT CONFERENCE 0; FAX 1-202-255-038.-, INTERNATIONAL LAW JOURNALS

1996 PHILIP C. JESSUP INTERNATIONAL LAW MOOT COURT COMPETITION

INTERNATIONAL ROUNDS

BFr ORALIST5 (ToP 100)

P Oralist Team School Score*

KREMER, Ben #108 University of Sydney, Australia 97.33 McLENNAN, Matthew #108 University of Sydney, Australia 97 SCHWARZ, Jonathan L. #208 Columbia Law School, USA 96.67 MMEKWA, Banyatsi #462 University of Botswana 95.5 KELLY, Jeanne #427 Law Society of Ireland 95 KURZ, Barbara #480 University of Vienna, Austria 94.67 THORNTON, Sean M. #213 Georgetown University School of Law, USA 94.5 BRIGGS, Michael Donald #141 University of Calgary, Canada 94.17 REILLY, Ellen #208 Columbia Law School, USA 94.17 FAVILLA-SOLANO, Teresa #244 University of Hawaii, USA 93.67 HARIKE, Kerry #268 University of Georgia, USA 93.67 KHAN, Aasma Azhar #240 Chicago-Kent College of Law, USA 93.5 YUNG, Carman #107 University of Western Australia 93.5 ARBOLEDA, Julio #141 University of Calgary, Canada 93 FRENCH, Heather #213 Georgetown University School of Law, USA 93 GROSSMAN, Luca #473 Universidad de Buenos Aires, Argentina 93 KING, Leih #213 Georgetown University School of Law, USA 92.5 VALONI, Jose #473 Universidad de Buenos Aires, Argentina 92.33 ARCAYA, Maria Teresa #455 Universidad Catolica Andres Bello, Venezuela 92.33 AINSWORTH, Nicola #431 University of Leeds, United Kingdom 92.17 ADAMS, Emily Christine #263 University of North Carolina, USA 92 BENSON, Christina C. #263 University of North Carolina, USA 92 CABELL, Carrie Cartwright #240 Chicago-Kent College of Law, USA 91.83 STEIN, Anthony #162 University of the Witwatersrand, South Africa 91.67 SYFERT, Scott D. #263 University of North Carolina, USA 91.5 STICK, Stick L. #244 University of Hawaii, USA 91.5 HADLEY, Donald H. #141 University of Calgary, Canada 91.33 TIAPULA, Suzanne L. #244 University of Hawaii, USA 90.83 GANAPATHY, Arumugam #400 University of Malaya, Malaysia 90.83 HING, Shan Shan Blossom #466 National University of Singapore 90.83

* The score is an average score from twelve judges in two rounds. Oralists designate the two rounds for which they want to be judged prior to the Competition. MATOS, Andres #455 Universidad Catolica Andres Bello, Venezuela 90.5 WALTERS, Bryan #307 University of Michigan, USA 90.5 KIM, Jeanny #213 Georgetown University School of Law, USA 90.5 PALMER, Dawn L. #225 University of California - Hastings, USA 90.33 DOYLE, Tara #427 Law Society of Ireland 90.33 LEE, Lyn Tsen-yi #466 National University of Singapore 90.33 GURUSWAMY, Menaka #351 National Law School of India 90.17 PALMER, John David #487 Victoria University of Wellington, New Zealand 90 CHANG, S.Y. Allison #244 University of Hawaii, USA 89.83 PALMER, Terence James #107 University of Western Australia 89.67 MEW, Thomas J. #268 University of Georgia, USA 89.67 EDELMAN, James Joshua #107 University of Western Australia 89.33 HOWLETT, Catherine Jean #150 University of Dalhousie, Canada DAMIANOVA, Kalina Boianova #391 Sofia University, Bulgaria 89.17 LEYTON, Patrick #485 Universidad de Chile 89 NADARAJAN, Premkumar #400 University of Malaya, Malaysia 88.83 BANA, Krisztina #467 ELTE, Hungary 88.67 VICK, Kenneth #347 Arizona State University, USA 88.67 REIN, David Maxwell James #208 Columbia Law School, USA 88.5 LUDER, Susan L. #347 Arizona State University, USA 88.5 KRIEL, Ross #162 University of the Witwatersrand, South Africa 88.33 ZARTNER, Dana R. #338 Boston University, USA 88.33 MCDOOM, Omar #464 University of Paris I - Sorbonne, France 88.33 DOOLAN, Jane #108 University of Sydney, Australia 88.17 FAVA, Palmina #206 Fordham University, USA 88.17 GIROUX-GOUDIE, Elicia D. #347 Arizona State University, USA 88.17 DAVIS, Stephen Clifford #141 University of Calgary, Canada 88 RAGHAVAN,Vikram #351 National Law School of India 88 BLAYNEY, Michael #298 University of Indiana at Indianapolis, USA 88 THORNINGTON, Emma #431 University of Leeds, United Kingdom 88 POUCHOUS, Erwan #464 University of Paris I - Sorbonne, France 88 GORDON, Lisa Ann #285 Tulane University, USA 88 WEST, Matthew Thomas #307 University of Michigan, USA 87.83 VAN HUIJA, Willem Maarten #424 University of Utrecht, The Netherlands 87.83 BARR, Michael #427 Law Society of Ireland 87.83 SIMECEK, Jiri #412 Charles University, Czech Republic 87.67 MORRIS, Siu John #482 City University of Hong Kong 87.67 MHUNDWA, Francina #462 University of Bostwana 87.67 MARRERO, Maggie #476 Universidad de Puerto Rico 87.67 DENCKLA, Derek #206 Fordham University, USA 87.5 ARRIAGADA, Rene #485 Universidad de Chile 87.5 GARRO, Neftali #459 Universidad de Costa Rica 87.5 KUMAMOTO, Noriko #123 Kyoto University, Japan 87.5 BALUDA, Marc #225 University of California - Hastings, USA 87.33 AVILA, Alberto #410 Universidad Nacional Autonoma de Mexico 87.33 MCHERRON, Jason S. #487 Victoria University of Wellington, New Zealand 87.17 RADNER, David #338 Boston University, USA 87 DAVISON, Maria #473 Universidad de Buenos Aires, Argentina 87 ALTEA, Maria Pia #447 Ateneo de Manila University, The Philippines 87 STEINSCHADEN, Viktoria #480 University of Vienna, Austria 86.83 TODOROV, Tzvetomir #391 Sofia University, Bulgaria 86.83 ROMAN PORRAS, Victor V. #459 Universidad de Costa Rica 86.83 SEITH, Patricia #208 Columbia Law School, USA 86.83 MEJSTRIKOVA, Michaela #412 Charls University, Czech Republic 86.67 84. WAITE, Kenneth #298 University of Indiana at Indianapolis, USA 86.67 86. ELGANZOURI, Rasha #240 Chicago-Kent College of Law, USA 86.5 86. STEFANOV, Dimitri #391 Sofia University, Bulgaria 86.5 86. CHAN-GONZAGA, Jose Victor #447 Ateneo de Manila University, The Philippines 86.5 89. ZUCKER, James #206 Fordham University, USA 86.33 90. ALEXIOU, Natalia #468 Aristotle University of Thessaloniki, Greece 86 91. SOSA-PASCUAL, Tamara #476 Universidad de Puerto Rico 85.83 91. ZIMMER, Per Johan #453 Oslo University, Norway 85.83 91. BERISH, Bill #298 University of Indiana at Indianapolis, USA 85.83 91. BAGHDADI, Khaldoun #225 University of California - Hastings, USA 85.83 95. EBNER, Christian #480 University of Vienna, Austria 85.67 95. HIL, Michael #285 Tulane University, USA 85,67 95. ANDREWS, Michael Jeffrey #338 Boston University, USA 85.67 98. BALENDRAN, Lakshani #482 City University of Hong Kong 85.33 98. MARTINEZ, Omar #476 Universidad de Puerto Rico 85.33 100. KESSLER, Birgit #186 Universitat zu Kiel, Germany 85.17 100. GRANIER, Maria Clara #455 Universidad Catolica Andres Bello, Venezuela 85.17 100. ANGADI, Tara #464 University of Paris I - Sorbonne, France 85.17 100. HUSUNG, Pascal #424 University of Utrecht, The Netherlands 85.17 INTERNATIONAL LAW STUDENTS ASSOCIATION

2223 Massachusetts Avenue, N.W. CONGRESS OF Washington, D.C. 20008-2864 U.S.A. INTERNATIONAL LAW SOCIETIES PHILIP C. JESSUP 1-202-939-6030 INTERNATIONAL LAW CABLE "AMINTLAW" MOOT COURT COMPETITION ILSA CONFERENCE OF FAX 1-202-265-0386 INTERNATIONAL LAW JOURNALS

1996 PmLn, C. JE.SSUP INTERNATIONAL LAW MOOT COURT COMPETITION

INTERNATIONAL ROUNDS

PARTICIPANTS' RECORDS (ALPHABETCAL ORDER)

Team Schol Ave, Oral Score

ADAMS, Emily Christine #263 University of North Carolina, USA 92 AINSWORTH, Nicola #431 University of Leeds, United Kingdom 92.17 AKSAKOGLU, Burcu #416 Dokuz Eylul University, Turkey n/a ALEXIOU, Natalia #468 Aristotle University of Thessaloniki, Greece 86 ALTEA, Maria Pia #447 Ateneo de Manila University, The Philippines 87 ANDO, Shigemi #123 Kyoto University, Japan 80 ANDREWS, Michael Jeffrey #338 Boston University, USA 85.67 ANGADI, Tara #464 University of Paris I - Sorbonne, France 85.17 ARBOLEDA, Julio #141 University of Calgary, Canada 93 ARCAYA, Maria Teresa #455 Universidad Catolica Andres Bello, Venezuela 92.33 ARREGUI, Alexandre Z. #460 Universidade Catolica do Rio Grand. do Sul, Brazil 69.33 ARRIAGADA, Rene #485 Universidad de Chile 87.5 AVILA, Alberto #410 Universidad Nacional Autonoma de Mexico 87.33 BAEK, Buhmsuk #438 Seoul National University, Korea 76.5 BAFANA, Heikel Khalio #466 National University of Singapore 90.33* BAGHDADI, Khaldoun #225 University of California - Hastings, USA 85.83 BALAKTCHIEV, Gueorgui A. #452 Belorussian State University, Belarus 80.5 BALDARES, Maria del Mar #459 Universidad de Costa Rica 78.83 BALENDRAN, Lakshani #482 City University of Hong Kong 85.33 BALUDA, Marc #225 University of California - Hastings, USA 87.33 BANA, Krisztina #467 ELTE, Hungary 88.67 BARR, Michael #427 Law Society of Ireland 87.83 BASOGLU. Serra Ayse #416 Dokuz Eylu University, Turkey 77.17 BENSON, Christina C. #263 University of North Carolina, USA 92 BERISH, Bill #298 University of Indiana at Indianapolis, USA 85.83 BLAYNEY, Michael #298 University of Indiana at Indianapolis, USA 88 BOWMAN, Ray #298 University of Indiana at Indianapolis, USA n/a BRADY, George #427 Law Society of Ireland 83.5 BRANNAN, Martin #347 Arizona State University, USA 81.33 BREMER, Henrik #186 Universitat zu Kiel, Germany 81.5

* The oralist argued in only one round of the competition and is therefore ineligible for the Best Oralist Award. Under the Official Rules of the Competition, an oralist must argue two or more rounds to be eligible for Best Oralist determinations. Name Team School Avu. Oral Score

BRIGGS, Michael Donald #141, University of Calgary, Canada 94.17 BRUGGEMAN, Marcia #307 University of Michigan, USA 82 BRUSKE, Petra #186 Universitat zu Kiel, Germany 83.83 CABELL, Carrie Cartwright #240 Chicago-Kent College of Law, USA 91.83 CALBOS, Christy Elizabeth #268 University of Georgia, USA 83.83 CARRITHERS-GREGG, Sally #298 University of Indiana at Indianapolis, USA 81.17 CHAE, Ji Hynn #438 Seoul National University, Korea 83.17 CHAN-GONZAGA, Jose Victor #447 Ateneo de Manila University, The Philippines 86.5 CHANG, S.Y. Allison #244 University of Hawaii, USA 89.83 CHIN, Loi Sin #400 University of Malaya, Malaysia 78.17 CHOI, Nakhoon #438 Seoul National University, Korea 71.17 CHOU KIM, Christine #482 City University of Hong Kong p/a CHRISTOPOULOS, Georgios #468 Aristotle University of Thessaloniki, Greece 80.5 CHU, Albert #213 Georgetown University, USA n/a CLANTON, Matthew Wade #240 Chicago-Kent College of Law, USA 81.33 COFFIN, Elizabeth A. #338 Boston University, USA 84.5 CORONIL, Juan Cristobal #455 Universidad Catolica Andres Bello, Venezuela n/a DADUD, Carolina G. #460 Universidade Catolica do Rio Grande do Sul, Brazil n/a DAMIANOVA, Kalina Boianova #391 Sofia University, Bulgaria 89.17 DAVIES, Adam Rhys #431 University of Leeds, United Kingdom 78.5 DAVIS, Stephen Clifford #141 University of Calgary, Canada 88 DAVISON, Maria #473 Universidad de Buenos Aires; Argentina 87 DE FLEURIEU, Charles #464 University of Paris I - Sorbnne, France 74.17 DENCKLA, Derek #206 Fordham University, USA 87.5 DOOLAN, Jane #108 University of Sydney, Australia 88.17 DOYLE, Tara #427 Law Society of Ireland 90.33 DURUKAN, Begum #416 Dokuz Eylul University, Turkey 79.83 DZIEWCZAPOLSKI, Nadia #473 University of Buenos Aires, Argentina n/a EBNER, Christian #480 University of Vienna, Austria 85.67 EDELMAN, James Joshua #107 University of Western Australia 89.33 ELGANZOURI, Rasha #240 Chicago-Kent College of Law, USA 86.5 ELJURI, Elizabeth #455 Universidad Catolica Andres Bello, Venezuela n/a FAVA, Palmina #206 Fordham University, USA 88.17 FAVILLA-SOLANO, Teresa #244 University of Hawaii, USA 93.67 FERNANDEZ, Jose Luis #473 University of Buenos Aires, Argentina n/a FRENCH, Heather #213 Georgetown University School of Law, USA 93 FUNG SIUl LING, Janet #482 City University of Hong Kong 79.17 GANAPATHY, Arumugam #400 University of Malaya, Malaysia 90.83 GARAY, Amanda #150 University of Dalhousie, Canada 78.67 GARCIA, Jess Anthony #447 Ateneo de Manila University, The Philippines 84.17 GARCIA, Oscar #455 Universidad Catolica Andres Bello, Venezuela 84.5 GARRO, Neftali #459 Universidad de Costa Rica 87.5 GIROUX-GOUDIE, Elicia D. #347 Arizona State University, USA 88.17 GOELZER-LITON, Kaylynn #141 University of Calgary, Canada n/a GOHIL, Sanjay R. #263 University of North Carolina, USA 82.83 GOLOBIC, Joze #1001 University of Ljubljana, Slovenia n/a GORDON, Lisa Ann #285 Tulane University, USA 88 GOURINOVICH, Anna #452 Belorussian State University, Belarus 70 GRANIER, Maria Clara #455 Universidad Catolica Andres Bello, Venezuela 85.17 GROBLYS, Sigitas #461 Vilnius University, Lithuania 78 GROENN, Henriette S. #453 Oslo University, Norway n/a GROSSMAN, Luca #473 Universidad de Buenos Aires, Argentina 93 Name Team School Ave. Oral Score

GUISLAN, Barbara #410 Universidad Nacional Autonoma de Mexico 81* GURUSWAMY, Menaka #351 National Law School of India 90.17 HADLEY, Donald H. #141 University of Calgary, Canada 91.33 HAN, Hua-ju #120 National Taiwan University, Taiwan 74.5 HARIKE, Kerry #268 University of Georgia, USA 93.67 HASSAN, Sheik #360 Dr. Ambedkar Gov't Law College, Madras, India n/a HAUVA, Diego #485 University of Chile n/a HILL, Michael #285 Tulane University, USA 85.67 HING, Shan Shan Blossom #466 National University of Singapore 90.83 HOLLO, Imre #467 ELTE, Hungary 82.17 HOWLETT, Catherine Jean #150 University of Dalhousie, Canada 89:17 HUSUNG, Pascal #424 University of Utrecht, The Netherlands 85.17 HWANG, Kai-Sheng #120 National Taiwan University, Taiwan 81.5 JACOBSEN, Trond Audun #453 Oslo University, Norway 82.83 JAVELJEV, Max #461 Vilnius University, Lithuania 77 JONES, Charles B. #268 University of Georgia, USA 82.17 KAPLONYI, Adam #467 ELTE, Hungary 82.67 KAVANAGH, Rebecca #108 University of Sydney, Australia 94* KELLY, Jeanne #427 Law Society of Ireland 95 KENNEDY, Stephanie #427 Law Society of Ireland n/a KENNEDY, T.P. #427 Law Society of Ireland n/a KESSLER, Birgit #186 Universitat zu Kiel, Germany 85.17 KHAN, Aasma Azhar #240 Chicago-Kent College of Law, USA 93.5 KIM, Jeanny #213 Georgetown University School of Law, USA 90.5 KING, Leih #213 Georgetown University School of Law, USA 92.5 KISELYOVA, Tatiana #465 Donetsk State University, Ukraine 81.5 KOBAYASHI, Tomohiko #123 Kyoto University, Japan n/a KOSANOVIC, Aaese Larissa #453 Oslo University, Norway n/a KOSZEG, Fanni #467 ELTE, Hungary 82.83 KOUZNETSOVA, Ekaterina V. #452 Belorussian State University, Belarus 73.5 KREMER, Ben #108 University of Sydney, Australia 97.33 KRIEL, Ross #162 University of the Witwatersrand, South Africa 88.33 KUCHEROVA, Mariya #465 Donetsk State University, Ukraine 74.67 KUMAMOTO, Noriko #123 Kyoto University, Japan 87.5 KUO, Chia-Chiun #120 National Taiwan University, Taiwan 77.17 KURZ, Barbara #480 University of Vienna, Austria 94.67 LAMAR, Amanda #2 25 University of California - Hastings, USA 81.67 LAM HON MERN, Edmund #431 University of Leeds, United Kingdom n/a LANDRUM, Keva #285 Tulane University, USA 82 LATYPOV, Kim Uralovich #452 Belorussian State University, Belarus 75 LAWRENCE, Jason Neil #244 University of Hawaii, USA n/a LEE, Lyn Tsen-yi #466 National University of Singapore 90.33 LEECY, Louise #107 University of Western Australia n/a LEYTON, Patrick #485 Universidad de Chile 89 LIM, Yong Yohan #438 Seoul National University, Korea 80.33 LIMNILI, Emine Duygul #416 Dokuz Eylul University, Turkey 76.83 LONDONO URIBE, Santiago #463 Universidad de Los Andes, Colombia 84.667 LUBINDA, Moffat R. #462 University of Bostwana 81.17 LUDER, Susan L. #347 Arizona State University, USA 88.5 MALGAJ, Matjaz #1001 University of Ljubliana, Slovenia 76.33 MALIAKI, Salome #475 University of Papua New Guinea 72.67 MANTERE, Mikko #477 Lapin Yliopisto (University of Lapland), Finland 76.33 Name Teaim School Ave. Oral Score

MARQUES, Carlos Eduardo #460 Universidade Catolica do Rio Grande do Sul, Brazil 73.33 MARRERO, Maggie #476 Universidad de Puerto Rico 87.67 MARTINEZ, Omar #476 Universidad de Puerto Rico 85.33 MATOS, Andres #455 Universidad Catolica Andres Bello, Venezuela 90.5 McDOOM, Omar #464 University of Paris I - Sorbonne, France 88.33 MCHERRON, Jason S. #487 Victoria University of Wellington, New Zealand 87.17 McLENNAN, Matthew #108 University of Sydney, Australia 97 MEDEIROS, Fernanda L.F. de #460 Universidade Catolica do Rio Grande do Sul, Brazil n/a MEI FONG, Lai #400 University of Malaya, Malaysia n/a MEJSTRIKOVA, Michaela #412 Charles University, Czech Republic 86.67 MELECCHI, Lenora #460 Universidade Catolica do Rio Grande do Sul, Brazil n/a MEW, Thomas J. #268 LUniyersity of Georgia, USA 89.7 MHUNDWA, Francina #462 University of Bostwana 87.67 MMEKWA, Banyatsi #462 University of Bostwana 95.5 MOHAN, Dimple #354 Kerala Law Academy Law College, India 81 MOLINA, Claudia #410 Universidad Nacional Autonoma de Mexico 82.5 MONGKO, There #475 University of Papua New Guinea 80.83 MORRIS, Siu John #482 City University of Hong Kong 87.67 MUGENYI, Patrick Noel M. #458 Makerere University, Uganda 84.33 MUNUBE, Barbara #458 Makerere University, Uganda 75.67 NADARAJAN, Premkumar #400 University of Malaya, Malaysia 88.83 NAKANO, Yuki #123 Kyoto University, Japan 80.5 NAVARRO, Andrea #410 Universidad Nacional Autonoma de Mexico 80.67* NAVOKOBI, Vergil #475 University of Papua New Guinea 74.33 NFILA, Wada #462 University of Bostwana 83.17 NIGAM, N.S. #351 National Law School of India n/a NORKUS, Irmantas #461 Vilnius University, Lithuania 74.83 NUNEZ, Ana Cristina #455 Universidad Catolica Andres Bello, Venezuela n/a OLBOURNE, Ben #108 University of Sydney, Australia 84* OPEIDA, Zvenislava #465 Donetsk State University, Ukraine 79.17 OSBORNE, W. Michael G. #150 University of Dalhousie, Canada 80.5 OXMAN, Jason D. #338 Boston University, USA n/a OZYUNCU, Gaye #416 Dokuz Eylul University, Turkey 80.67 PADILLA, Hernando #463 Universidad de Los Andes, Colombia 78.17 PALMER, John David #487 Victoria University of Wellington, New Zealand 90 PALMER, Dawn L. #225 University of California - Hastings, USA 90.33 PALMER, Terence James #107 University of Western Australia 89.67 PARYS, Lorin #481 Universitaires Notre Dame de ia Paix, Namur. Belgium 83.83 PASANEN, Ville Petteri #477 Lapin Yliopisto (University of Lapland), Finland 66.67 PETROV, Roman #465 Donetsk State University, Ukraine 82.5 PIERRE-LOUIS, Lydie #206 Fordham University, USA 85.5 PINEIRO, Lorena #485 University of Chile n/a POUCHOUS, Erwan #464 University of Paris I - Sorbonne, France 88 POULAKKA, Pekka Erkki A. #477 Lapin Yliopisto (University of Lapland), Finland 72.33 PROKALAMOS, Andreas #468 Aristotle University of Thessaloniki, Greece 77.33 RADNER, David #338 Boston University, USA 87 RAGHAVAN, Vikram #351 National Law School of India 88 RAMAKRISHNAN, Murali #400 University of Malaya, Malaysia 76.67 RAMOS, Miguel #410 Universidad Nacional Autonoma de Mexico 79.17 REILLY, Ellen #208 Columbia Law School, USA 94.17 REIN, David Maxwell James #208 Columbia Law School, USA 88.5 RIVAS CAMPO, Jose Antonio #463 Universidad de Los Andes, Colombia 79.67 Name Team School Ava. Oral Score

ROMAN PORRAS, Victor V. #459 Universidad de Costa Rica 86.83 RUA, Javier #476 Universidad de Puerto Rico 83.17 RYCHAERT, David #481 Universitaires Notre Dame de ia Paix, Namur. Belgium 81.83 SALADIOUS, Jonas #461 Vilnius University, Lithuania 77.17 SANTHALINGAM, Sindhu #354 Kerala Law Academy Law College, India 75 SARMIENTO, Ma. Victoria #447 Ateneo de Manila University, The Philippines n/a SCHJATVET, Cecilie E. #453 Oslo University, Norway 84.33 SCHWARTZ, Benjamin #307 University of Michigan, USA 85.5 SCHWARZ, Jonathan L. #208 Columbia Law School, USA 96.67 SEITH, Patricia #208 Columbia Law School, USA 86.83 SHANKAR, Hari Krishnaswami #360 Dr. Ambedkar Gov't Law College, Madras, India 83.5 SHEPHERD, Fraser #487 Victoria University of Wellington, New Zaland SIMECEK, Jiri #412 Charles University, Czech Republic 87.67 SLAPAR, Andrej #1001 University of Ljubljana, Slovenia n/a SMITH, James Alan Neal #225 University of California - Hastings, USA n/a SNEEK, Tim #424 University of Utrecht, The Netherlands n/a SONG EU, Kwan Nicholas #466 National University of Singapore n/a SOSA-PASCUAL, Tamara #476 Universidad de Puerto Rico 85.83 STANG LUND, inger-Margrethe #453 Oslo University, Norway 82.33 STEFANOV, Dimitri #391 Sofia University, Bulgaria 86.5 STEIN, Anthony #162 University of the Witwatersrand, South Africa 91.67 STEINMANN, Wolfgang #480 University of Vienna, Austria 84.67 STEINSCHADEN, Viktoria #480 University of Vienna, Austria 86.83 STICK, Stick L. #244 University of Hawaii, USA 91.5 STRUYVEN, Olivia #481 Universitaires Notre Dame de la Paix, Namur, Belgium 76.5 SURANA, Vinod #360 Dr. Ambedkar Gov't Law College, Madras, India 80.17 SYFERT, Scott D. #263 University of North Carolina, USA 91.5 TAMADA, Dai #123 Kyoto University, Japan 81.83 TAMS, Christian #186 Universitat zu Kiel, Germany 84.67 THORNINGTON, Emma #431 University of Leeds, United Kingdom 88 THORNTON, Sean M. #213 Georgetown University School of Law, USA 94.5 TIAPULA, Suzanne L. #244 University of Hawaii, USA 90.83 TOCHKOVA, Desislava T. #391 Sofia University, Bulgaria 83.83 TODOROV, Tzvetomir #391 Sofia University, Bulgaria 86.83 TSADIRAS, Alexandros #468 Aristotle University of Thessaloniki, Greece 81 URGELLO, Melvin Rorie #447 Ateneo de Manila University, The Philippines n/a VALAS, Luka #1001 University of Ljubljana, Slovenia 74.5 VALONI, Jose #473 Universidad de Buenos Aires, Argentina 92.33 VALVEIDE, Pablo Javier #459 Universidad de Costa Rica 78* VALVERDE SOTO, Max #459 Universidad de Costa Rica 83.67* VAN HUIJA, Willem Maarten #424 University of Utrecht, The Netherlands 87.833 VAN GINKEL, Bibi T. #424 University of Utrecht, The Netherlands 82.67 VAN OVERBEKE, Magali E.P. #481 Universitaires Notre Dame de la Paix. Namur. Belgium 81.17 VANKOVA, Barbara #412 Charles University, Czech Republic 82.5 VICK, Kenneth #347 Arizona State University, USA 88.67 VOPATOVA, Gabriela #412 Charles University, Czech Republic 80.17 WA, Pei-Shi #120 National Taiwan University, Taiwan 74.5 WAITE, Kenneth #298 University of Indiana at Indianapolis, USA 86.67 WALTERS, Bryan #307 University of Michigan, USA 90.5 WARINIKI, Phillip #475 University of Papua New Guinea 79.83 WATTS, Bradley #285 Tulane University, USA 85 WEST, Matthew Thomas #307 University of Michigan, USA 87.83 WILSON, L. Siu Sing #482 City University of Hong Kong 84.5 WOLDBERG, Mira #424 University of Utrecht, The Netherlands 83.67 WRIGHT, Richard James #431 University of Leeds, United Kingdom 83.17 YEO, Melvin Poh Chuan #107 University of Western Australia n/a YUNG, Carman #107 University of Western Australia 93.5 ZANDVLIET, Christine #208 Columbia Law School, USA n/a ZARTNER, Dana R. #338 Boston University, USA 88.33 ZIMMER, Per Johan #453 Oslo University, Norway 85.83 ZUCKER, James #206 Fordham University, USA 86.33 INTERNATIONAL LAW STUDENTS ASSOCIATION

2223 Massachusetts Avenue, N.W. .H N'ONGR ESS' INTERNA1'0NAL 1AW S.CI- Washington, D.C. 20008-2864 U.S.A. PHILIP 0. JESSUP 1-202-939-6030 I LNTERNATIONAL LAW CABLE AMINTLAW" ILSA MOOr COUR1 COMPEf ILj. , FAX 1-202 265-0386 N AON 'RENOPI NTERNATiONAL IAW JP

1996 PHILIP C. JESSUP

INTERNATIONAL LAW MOOT COURT COMPETITION

INTERNATIONAL ROUNDS

MEMORIALUS

ALONA E. EVANS COMPETITION

Place Team No. School Score

1. 400 University of Malaya, Malaysia 568 2. 268 University of Georgia, USA 558 3. 466 National University of Singapore 544.5 4. 480 University of Vienna, Austria 544 5. 487 University of Wellington, New Zealand 541 6.* 141 University of Calgary, Canada* 540* 6. 208 Columbia University, USA 538 7. 108 University of Sydney, Australia 534 8. 307 University of Michigan, USA 533 9. 107 University of Western Australia 532 10. 485 Universidad de Santiago, Chile 530 11. 360 Dr. Ambedkar Gov't Law College, Madras, India 529 12. 150 Dalhousie University, Canada 526 13. 459 Universidad de Costa Rica 526 14.* 15. 427 Law Society of Ireland 522 16. 410 Universidad Nacional Autonoma de Mexico 519 17. 244 University of Hawaii, USA 518 18. 461 Vilnius University, Lithuania 515 19. 455 Universidad Catolica Andres Bello, Venezuela 514 20. 347 Arizona State University, USA 512 21. 225 University of California - Hastings, USA 509 22. 206 Fordham University, USA 508 23. 240 Chicago-Kent College of Law, USA 507 24. 467 Eoutuas Lorand University (ELTE), Hungary 503 25. 464 Universite de Paris, France 501

* Due to an error in tabulating penalties, the University of Calgary should have placed sixth in the Alona E. Evans Competition. For the official record, the University of Calgary placed sixth overall, ahead of Columbia University, USA. The remainder of the rankings remain unchanged. INTERNATIONAL LAW STUDENTS ASSOCIATION

2223 Massachusetts Avenue, N.W. CONG"RESS OF Washington, D.C. 20008-2864 U.S.A. INTERNA1I10AL LAW SS ES 1-20-9396030PHILIP c.JFSSUF1 1-202-939-6030 INTERNATIONAL LA, CABLE AMINTLAW" I LSA MOOT COURT COMPETll 11N FAX 1-202-265-0385 -- iW,.~ C.\-C(4PEnLNC[ C'- ~~IN'F-FINATS..tNA. LA.. Xx;:IiN.\'

1996 PHILIP C. JESSUP

INTERNATIONAL LAW MOOT COURT COMPETITION

REGIONAL / NATIONAL ROUNDS

MEMORIALS

HARDY C. DILLARD COMPETITION*

Place Team No. School Score

1. 400 University of Malaya, Malaysia 568 2. 112 University of Melbourne, Australia 552.5 3. 208 Columbia University, USA 538 4. 337 University of Texas - Austin, USA 536 5. 424 University of Utrecht, The Netherlands 534 6. 307 University of Michigan, USA 533 7. 485 Universidad de Santiago, Chile 530 8. 459 Universidad de Costa Rica 526 9. 150 Dalhousie University, Canada 525.5 10. 427 Law Society of Ireland 522 11. 410 Universidad Nacional Autonoma de Mexico 519 12. 234 American University, USA 518 12. 244 University of Hawaii, USA 518 14. 254 Emory University, USA 515 14. 202 University of Pennsylvania, USA 515 17. 183 Roprecht-Karls-Universiteit, Heidelberg 514.5 18. 455 Universidad Catolica Andres Bello, Venezuela 514 19. 240 Chicago-Kent College of Law, USA 507 20. 447 Ataneo University de Manila, Philippines 493 21. 304 South Texas College of Law, USA 490.5 22. 482 City University of Hong Kong 485 23. 473 Universidad de Buenos Aires, Argentina 483 24. 463 Universidad de Los Andes, Colombia 477 25. 277 University of Dayton, USA 475

* The top five teams receive awards and advance to the Richard Baxter Memorial Competition for Best Memorial in the World. INTERNATIONAL LAW STUDENTS ASSOCIATION

2223 Massachusetts Avenue, N.W. CONGRESS OF Washington, D.C. 20008-2864 U.S.A. INTERNATIONAL LAWSOCIETIES PHILIP C. JESSUP 1-202-939-6030 INTERNATIONAL LAW CABLE "AMINTLAW" I LSA MOOT COURT COMPE1 ITION FAX 1-202-265-0386 CONFERENCE OF INTERNATIONAL LAW JOURNALS

1996 PHILIP C. JESSUP INTERNATIONAL LAW MOOT COURT COMPETITION

BEST MEMORIALS IN THE WORLD

RICHARD R. BAXTER COMPETITION

BEST APPLICANT

University of Singapore

BEST RESPONDENT

University of Vienna, Austria