DOCSLIB.ORG

Lxx Isaiah Or Its Vorlage: Primary “Misreadings” and Secondary Modifications*

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Lxx Isaiah Or Its Vorlage: Primary “Misreadings” and Secondary Modifications* LXX ISAIAH OR ITS VORLAGE: PRIMARY “MISREADINGS” AND SECONDARY MODIFICATIONS* Donald W. Parry A number of factors associated with biblical Hebrew manuscripts during the last centuries before the Common Era presented distinct challenges for copyists and translators. These challenges included rare words (esp. hapax legomena), difficult-to-read bookhands, graphically similar characters and words, irregular or inconsistent orthography, incomprehensible scribal notations, irregular or inconsistent orthogra- phy, lack of vocalization, and more. Because of these and other factors, scribes and copyists made various (mechanical, unintentional) errors when making new copies of a text, as did translators when creating translations from the Hebrew. Examples of such errors exist in scrip- tural texts from Qumran, in Masoretic Text(s), in the Greek transla- tion of the Hebrew, and in other translations. This paper will deal with first-level errors in the Septuagint book of Isaiah that resulted in secondary modifications to various instances of parallelismus membrorum. By first-level errors in LXX Isaiah, I mean the inadvertent errors, or the so-called mechanical mishaps, that occurred during the translating process. Various handbooks, based on long-established text critical principles and methodologies, have set forth the categories of mishaps that have occurred during the transmission of texts.1 These include issues that are associated with the following general categories: pluses (e.g., dittography, conflation of readings), minuses (e.g., haplography, homoioteleuton, homoiarcton), * This article is written in honor of Professor James C. VanderKam, whose scholar- ship has enlightened so many of us and whose friendship deserves praise. 1 The most complete and up-to-date study of biblical Hebrew textual criticism is Emanuel Tov’s Textual Criticism of the Hebrew Bible (Minneapolis: Fortress, 1992). See also Christian D. Ginsburg, Introduction to the Massoretico-Critical Edition of the Hebrew Bible (London: Trinitarian Bible Society, 1897; repr. with prolegomenon by Harry M. Orlinsky, New York: Ktav, 1966); J. Weingreen, Introduction to the Critical Study of the Text of the Hebrew Bible (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1982). Com- pare also the more brief treatments of the subject by Julio Trebolle Barrera, The Jewish Bible and the Christian Bible (trans. W. G. E. Watson; Brill: Leiden, 1998), 367–421; and Ernst Würthwein, The Text of the Old Testament (trans. Erroll F. Rhodes; Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 1995), 107–22. 152 donald w. parry changes (e.g., misdivision of letters or words, ligatures, graphic similar- ity), and differences in sequence (interchange of letters or metathesis and transposition of words). This paper will not deal with other text- critical categories, such as exegetical pluses or late editorial additions, harmonizations, morphological smoothing, morphological updating, updating the vocabulary, euphemistic or dysphemistic changes, ortho- graphic variants, and phonetic differences. Nor is this paper concerned with translators’ stylistic approaches to the text, idiosyncrasies, and conventions. Examples of alleged, hypothetical, or assumed mechanical errors in LXX Isaiah include the following: 1. Misreadings occurred when there was confusion about what consti- tuted the correct Hebrew triconsonantal root letters (or the Hebrew morpheme), especially when one or more root letters were absent from the inflected forms (i.e., hollow verbs, I-yod, I-nun, III-he, doubly weak verbs, metathesis of sibilants in Hitpael, and so forth). Examples from the LXX as reconstructed into Hebrew include Isa 19:5; 23:1–2[2]; 28:26; 29:1, 14; 30:4, 20; 32:3; 63:14; 63:19[64:1]; 64:6[7]. 2. In a couple of instances, the translator erred through dittography of graphically similar words (Isa 3:10) or of a single character (Isa 8:14). 3. The translator at times erred when a letter was misread because of its likeness to another letter. Examples of graphically similar Hebrew letters include the following: bet/mem or bet/final mem (Isa 11:15; 40:29); bet/pe (Isa 34:4; 40:8[7]; 47:2); dalet/he (Isa 10:18); dalet/resh (Isa 5:17; 8:9; 8:20; 15:4; 16:11; 17:2; 23:10; 25:2, 4–5; 28:9; 33:14; 40:15; 44:14; 45:16 bis; 47:10; 53:10); he/khet (Isa 5:17; 21:15 bis; 22:1; 34:17; 47:2); he/ayin (Isa 41:24); he/resh (Isa 64:1[2]); vav/ resh (Isa 24:1; 28:10, 13); zayin/nun (Isa 30:12); zayin/resh (Isa 25:4; 50:11); yod/resh and khet/tav (Isa 44:24); kaf/pe (Isa 53:10); samek/ final mem (Isa 30:4); and sin/shin (Isa 7:20; 19:10, 13; 28:1, 3; 65:15; 66:9). 4. The translator read the correct Hebrew letters but understood a dif- ferent root meaning than the one intended. Examples include Isa 5:13; 9:15[16]; 28:10; 47:10. 5. The translator read the correct Hebrew letters but misinterpreted the intended vocalization. Examples include Isa 1:27; 5:13, 18; 9:7[8]; 17:11; 24:23 bis; 25:5; 28:24; 32:2; 33:1 bis; 33:2; 41:24; 42:10; 44:11; 48:14; 60:21; 62:7; 63:11; 66:5; 66:10..
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Hebrew Aleph-Bet and Letter As Numbers
    Hebrew Aleph-Bet and Letter as Numbers Letter Name in Hebrew Keyboard Letter Number Value aleph or alef t 1 bet (& vet) c 2 gimel or gimmel d 3 dalet s 4 hey or heh v 5 vav u 6 zayin z 7 chet or khet j 8 tet y 9 yud or yod h 10 kaf f 20 lamed k 30 mem n 40 nun b 50 samech or samekh x 60 ayin g 70 pey or peh (& fey) p 80 tzadi or tsadi m 90 kuf e 100 resh r 200 shin a 300 tav , (comma) 400 kaf sofit l mem sofit o nun sofit i fey sofit ; (semi-colon) tzadi sofit . (period) NOTE: the above English keyboard letter for the Hebrew letters are for the standard Hebrew keyboard. There are Hebrew fonts floating around that are non-standard. The sofit letters sound the same as the normal letters, but are used when they are the last letter in a word. For Bible code purposes. the regular letter and final letter are fully equivalent. In other words, in the code, a nun sofit could appear in the middle of a valid term and the regular letter nun could be at the end of a word. (discussion of numbers on the next page) If the Hebrew letters only go to 400, how can you look for higher number in the Bible code, like the year 1998 (5758)? When you have numbers over 1000, you use the thousands letter as a digit. For example, 1561 would start out with “aleph” which is 1.
    [Show full text]
  • Torah from JTS Worship, JTS
    Exploring Prayer :(בלה תדובע) Service of the Heart This week’s column was written by Rabbi Samuel Barth, senior lecturer in Liturgy and Torah from JTS Worship, JTS. Simhat Torah: Which Way When the Circle Ends Bereishit 5774 The annual celebration of Simhat Torah brings great joy to so many of us of all generations, and it is a fitting and triumphant conclusion to the long and multifaceted season of intense Jewish observance and focus that began (a little before Rosh Hashanah) with Selichot. In Israel and in congregations observing a single day of festivals, Simhat Torah is blended with Shemini Atzeret, offering the intense experience in the morning of Hallel, Hakkafot (processions with dancing) and Geshem (the prayer for Rain). At the morning service of Simhat Torah there are four linked biblical readings (three from the Parashah Commentary Torah), and the relationship among them invites us to think about the flow of sacred text in a multidimensional context. The first reading is Vezot HaBrakha, the last chapters of Deuteronomy This week’s commentary was written by Dr. David Marcus, professor of Bible, containing the final blessings from Moses to the community—and the account of the death of Moses, alone with God on Mount Nebo. To receive the final aliyah after everyone else present JTS. has been called to the Torah is considered a great honor, and the person with this honor is called up with a special formula (a short version is presented in Siddur Sim Shalom for Shabbat Bereishit with a Capital Bet and Festivals, 215) that affirms, “May it be the will of the One Most Powerful to grant abundant blessings to [insert the name of the one called] who has been chosen to complete the Torah.” With this week’s parashah, we once again commence the cycle of reading the Torah from the first chapter of Genesis, which begins with the Hebrew word bereishit.
    [Show full text]
  • ב Bet ה Heh ו Vav ט Tet י Yod ך מ Mem ם
    Exercise 1A: Writing the Hebrew Square Script Using the examples at the right, practice writing out the Hebrew characters on the lines provided for you. Be sure to accurately reflect the position of the letter in relation to the base line. Boxes are used to indicate final forms. Letter Name aleph א aleph bet ב bet gimel ג gimel dalet ד dalet heh ה heh vav ו vav zayin ז zayin .het ח ḥet tet ט tet yod י kaph כ yod ך kaph final kaph lamed ל mem מ lamed ם mem 3 Exercise 1A: Writing tHe Hebrew SquAre Script final mem Letter Name nun נ ן nun final nun samek ס samek ayin ע pe פ ayin ף pe final pe tsade צ ץ tsade final tsade qoph ק qoph resh ר resh שׂ sin sin shin ׁש shin tav ת tav NAme: __________________________________________________ Exercise 1A: Writing tHe Hebrew SquAre Script 4 Exercise 1B: Reading Proper Names In this exercise you will practice identifying the Hebrew consonants by reading familiar proper names. Write the English name in the space to the left of the Hebrew name. Since the alphabet has no vowels, you will have to provide vowel sounds to recognize each word. Start by trying an “a” vowel between each con- sonant. The “a” vowel is the most common vowel in Hebrew and, while it will not always be the correct one, it should help you recognize these names. לבן Laban יעקב אסתר אברהם עבדיה יצחק יחזקאל יׂשראל דוד רבקה נחמיה נבכדנאזר ירבעם ירדן מרדכי מׁשה דברה גלית יׁשמעאל עׂשו 5 Exercise 1B: ReAding Proper NAmes Exercise 1C: Hebrew Cursive (Optional) Using the examples shown, practice writing out the cursive Hebrew characters on the lines provided for you.
    [Show full text]
  • L2/20-246 Teeth and Bellies: a Proposed Model for Encoding Book Pahlavi
    L2/20-246 Teeth and bellies: a proposed model for encoding Book Pahlavi Roozbeh Pournader (WhatsApp) September 7, 2020 Background In Everson 2002, a proposal was made to encode a unified Avestan and Pahlavi script in the Unicode Standard. The proposal went through several iterations, eventually leading to a separate encoding of Avestan as proposed by Everson and Pournader 2007a, in which Pahlavi was considered non-unifiable with Avestan due to its cursive joining property. The non-cursive Inscriptional Pahlavi (Everson and Pournader 2007b) and the cursive Psalter Pahlavi (Everson and Pournader 2011) were later encoded too. But Book Pahlavi, despite several attempts (see the Book Pahlavi Topical Document list at https://unicode.org/L2/ topical/bookpahlavi/), remains unencoded. Everson 2002 is peculiar among earlier proposals by proposing six Pahlavi archigraphemes, including an ear, an elbow, and a belly. I remember from conversations with Michael Everson that he intended these to be used for cases when a scribe was just copying some text without understanding the underlying letters, considering the complexity of the script and the loss of some of its nuances to later scribes. They could also be used when modern scholars wanted to represent a manuscript as written, without needing to over-analyze potentially controversial readings. Meyers 2014 takes such a graphical model to an extreme, trying to encode pieces of the writing system, most of which have some correspondence to letters, but with occasional partial letters (e.g. PARTIAL SHIN and FINAL SADHE-PARTIAL PE). Unfortunately, their proposal rejects joining properties for Book Pahlavi and insists that “[t]he joining behaviour of the final stems of the characters in Book Pahlavi is more similar to cursive variants of Latin than to Arabic”.
    [Show full text]
  • Persian Language
    v course reference persian language r e f e r e n c e زبان فارسی The Persian Language 1 PERSIAN OR FARSI? In the U.S., the official language of Iran is language courses in “Farsi,” universities and sometimes called “Farsi,” but sometimes it is scholars prefer the historically correct term called “Persian.” Whereas U.S. government “Persian.” The term “Farsi” is better reserved organizations have traditionally developed for the dialect of Persian used in Iran. 2 course reference AN INDO-EUROPEAN LANGUAGE Persian is a member of the Indo-European Persian has three major dialects: Farsi, language family, which is the largest in the the official language of Iran, spoken by 50 world. percent of the population; Dari, spoken mostly in Afghanistan, and Tajiki, spoken Persian falls under the Indo-Iranian branch, in Tajikistan. Other languages in Iran are comprising languages spoken primarily Arabic, New Aramaic, Armenian, Georgian in Afghanistan, Iran, Pakistan, India, and Turkic dialects such as Azerbaidjani, Bangladesh, areas of Turkey and Iraq, and Khalaj, Turkemenian and Qashqa”i. some of the former Soviet Union. INDO-EUROPEAN LANGUAGES GERMANIC INDO-IRANIAN HELLENIC CELTIC ITALIC BALTO-SLAVIC Polish Russin Indic Greek Serbo-Crotin North Germnic Ltin Irnin Mnx Irish Welsh Old Norse Swedish Scottish Avestn Old Persin Icelndic Norwegin French Spnish Portuguese Itlin Middle Persin West Germnic Snskrit Rumnin Ctln Frsi Kurdish Bengli Urdu Gujrti Hindi Old High Germn Old Dutch Anglo-Frisin Middle High Germn Middle Dutch Old Frisin Old English Germn Flemish Dutch Afrikns Frisin Middle English Yiddish Modern English vi v Persian Language 3 ALPHABET: FROM PAHLAVI TO ARABIC History tells us that Iranians used the Pahlavi Unlike English, Persian is written from right writing system prior to the 7th Century.
    [Show full text]
  • Physical Education Vocabulary (K-12)
    Physical Education Vocabulary (K-12) A Acceleration The rate of change of velocity over time (where velocity is the rate of change of position with respect to direction). Aerobic Activity Steady activity in which the heart can supply all the oxygen the muscles need. "With Oxygen" Aerobic Endurance The body's ability to take in and use oxygen so the muscles can keep working. The most important element of fitness. Agility The ability to change the position of your body and/or its parts quickly and accurately. Anaerobic Activity "Without oxygen." Activities for which the body can't supply enough oxygen to keep going for long periods of time. Assessment of physical activities A process of judging/grading a persons level in relation to a set of criteria. In GCSE this involves a process of planning, performing, evaluating, analysing, and improving chosen physical activities. B Balance The ability of the body to maintain or regain stability. Bench Press Lay on bench, flat on back. Press from chest to full extension. Bicep Muscle The large muscle in the front part of the upper arm. Body Composition The relative proportions of fat and lean (non-fat) body mass. Body Mass Index (BMI) A formula that determines a healthy body weight based on height. C Cardiovascular Endurance The heart, lungs, and blood vessels work together as a team to allow one to stay active and exercise for a long period of time. Cardiovascular Fitness Ability of the heart, lungs, and blood vessels to function efficiently when a person exercises the body. Circuit Training Training that uses a circuit of exercises around a number of different work stations.
    [Show full text]
  • Rayut / Sacred Companionship: the Art of Being Human Rabbi Steven Kushner Rosh Hashanah Morning 5771
    Rayut / Sacred Companionship: the art of being human Rabbi Steven Kushner Rosh Hashanah Morning 5771 It’s a ‘‘sweet-sixteen’’ party. The grandmother, who personally related this story to me, notices that her 16-year-old granddaughter is sitting at a table, smart-phone in hand, busily typing away with her thumbs. ‘‘What are you doing?’’ the grandmother asks. ‘‘I’m texting my best friend,’’ the granddaughter replies. ‘‘Just a minute,’’ the grandmother objects. ‘‘Do you mean to tell me you didn’t invite your best friend to your sweet-sixteen party?’’ ‘‘Of course I did,’’ the granddaughter replies. ‘‘She’s sitting right over there.’’ Does this sound familiar? Do you have kids who now use their thumbs to talk, even when vocal communication is not merely possible but easier? That, of course, is the question. Does modern technology make communication easier------with cell phones, text messaging, twittering, emailing------or does it actually make it more complex? This dynamic, of impersonal electronic talking, should be alarming to us. Forget the fact that we’ve lost the ability to write longhand. (Kids, your parents will tell you what ‘‘longhand’’ means after the service.) Never mind that we’ve abandoned the beautiful art form of ‘‘correspondence’’. (My brother and I still have all the letters my parents wrote to each other during World War II.) No matter that we’ve forgotten what it’s like to have to wait to get to a gas station to call someone on the phone. The consequences of instant non-verbal communication may be, even in the short-term, devastating.
    [Show full text]
  • An Introduction to Spoken Kashmiri GLOSSARY
    An Introduction to Spoken Kashmiri GLOSSARY Braj B Kachru Kashmir News Network http://koshur.org/SpokenKashmiri A Basic Course and Referene Manual for Learning and Teaching Kashmiri as a Second Language PART II GLOSSARY BRAJ B. KACHRU Department of Linguistics, University of lllinois Urban, lllinois 61810 U.S.A June, 1973 The research project herein was performed pursuant to a contract with the United States Office of Education, Department of health, Education, and Welfare, Washington, D.C. Contract No. OEC-0-70-3981 Project Director and Principal Investigator: Braj B. Kachru, Department of Linguistics, University of Illinois, Urbana, Illinois, 61801, U.S.A. Disclaimer: We present this material as is, and assume no responsibility for its quality, any loss and/or damages. © 2006 Braj B. Kachru. All Rights Reserved. Kashmir News Network http://koshur.org/SpokenKashmiri Kashmir News Network http://koshur.org/SpokenKashmiri An Introduction to Spoken Kashmiri - GLOSSARY by Braj B. Kachru TABLE OF CONTENTS PREFACE ....................................................................................................1 GLOSSARY ...................................................................................................2 ABBREVIATIONS .........................................................................................3 1.0 KASHMIRI-ENGLISH ........................................................................ 1-4 2.0 ENGLISH-KASHMIRI ...................................................................... 2-32 3.0 A PARTIAL LIST OF ENGLISH
    [Show full text]
  • Psalm 119 & the Hebrew Aleph
    Psalm 119 & the Hebrew Aleph Bet - Part 14 The fourteenth letter of the Hebrew alphabet is called “Nun” (pronounced “noon”) and has the sound of “N” as in “now”. It has the numeric value of 50, the number of the Jubilee. There are two ways to write a Nun. A Nun appearing at the end of a word (sofit) looks like a Vav, but is longer, extending below the baseline. A regular Nun looks much like the Kaph, but is half its width. The Nun stands for FISH. In modern Hebrew, the letter Nun can appear in three forms: Writing the Letter: Nun – The Nun is half as wide as the Kaph Nun: Letter of Faithfulness Nun represents both faithfulness and the reward for faithfulness. Moses is seen as the iconic humble servant of Yahweh. The word “Nun” itself is spelled Nun-Vav-(final) Nun and looks as follows: The one who is humble before God will stand upright in the final Day. In the olam hazeh (present life), this means that the tzaddik (righteous man) will simultaneously affirm: “I am nothing but dust.” Humble yourself in the sight of Yahweh, and He shall lift you up (James 4:10). Nun Study Page 1 Spiritual Meaning of the Nun Nun = 50 and means “FISH” of Yahweh or “The SAVED”. Our Messiah could be called “The Chief FISHERMAN.” He told His disciples that He would make them “FISHERS of men”, (Mark 1:17). Like a FLOURISHING, darting school of FISH that continues to propagate, our Saviour’s Love causes us to multiply and grow in numbers as we share Him with others.
    [Show full text]
  • How Was the Dageš in Biblical Hebrew Pronounced and Why Is It There? Geoffrey Khan
    1 pronounced and why is it בָּתִּ ים How was the dageš in Biblical Hebrew there? Geoffrey Khan houses’ is generally presented as an enigma in‘ בָּתִּ ים The dageš in the Biblical Hebrew plural form descriptions of the language. A wide variety of opinions about it have been expressed in Biblical Hebrew textbooks, reference grammars and the scholarly literature, but many of these are speculative without any direct or comparative evidence. One of the aims of this article is to examine the evidence for the way the dageš was pronounced in this word in sources that give us direct access to the Tiberian Masoretic reading tradition. A second aim is to propose a reason why the word has a dageš on the basis of comparative evidence within Biblical Hebrew reading traditions and other Semitic languages. בָּתִּיםבָּתִּ ים The Pronunciation of the Dageš in .1.0 The Tiberian vocalization signs and accents were created by the Masoretes of Tiberias in the early Islamic period to record an oral tradition of reading. There is evidence that this reading tradition had its roots in the Second Temple period, although some features of it appear to have developed at later periods. 1 The Tiberian reading was regarded in the Middle Ages as the most prestigious and authoritative tradition. On account of the authoritative status of the reading, great efforts were made by the Tiberian Masoretes to fix the tradition in a standardized form. There remained, nevertheless, some degree of variation in reading and sign notation in the Tiberian Masoretic school. By the end of the Masoretic period in the 10 th century C.E.
    [Show full text]
  • Psalms 119 & the Hebrew Aleph
    Psalms 119 & the Hebrew Aleph Bet - Part 17 The seventeenth letter of the Hebrew alphabet is called “Pey” (sounds like “pay”). It has the sound of “p” as in “park”. Pey has the numeric value of 80. In modern Hebrew, the letter Pey can appear in three forms: Writing the Letter: Pey Note: Most people draw the Pey in two strokes, as shown. The dot, or “dagesh” mark means the pey makes the “p” sound, as in “park”. Note: The sole difference between the letter Pey and the letter Fey is the presence or absence of the dot in the middle of the letter (called a dagesh mark). When you see the dot in the middle of this letter, pronounce it as a "p"; otherwise, pronounce it as "ph" (or “f”). Five Hebrew letters are formed differently when they appear as the last letter of a word (these forms are sometimes called "sofit" (pronounced "so-feet") forms). Fortunately, the five letters sound the same as their non-sofit cousins, so you do not have to learn any new sounds (or transliterations). The Pey (pronounced “Fey” sofit has a descending tail, as shown on the left. Pey: The Mouth, or Word The pictograph for Pey looks something like a mouth, whereas the classical Hebrew script (Ketav Ashurit) is constructed of a Kaf with an ascending Yod: Notice the “hidden Bet” within the letter Pey. This shape of the letter is required when a Torah scribe writes Torah scrolls, or mezzuzahs. From the Canaanite pictograph, the letter morphed into the Phoenician ketav Ivri, to the Greek letter (Pi), which became the Latin letter “P.” means “mouth” and by extension, “word,” “expression,” “vocalization,” and “speech”.
    [Show full text]
  • A Sociolinguistic Study on the Diminishing Features of the Punjabi Lexicon
    International Journal of English Linguistics; Vol. 7, No. 3; 2017 ISSN1923-869X E-ISSN1923-8703 Published by Canadian Center of Science and Education A Sociolinguistic Study on the Diminishing Features of the Punjabi Lexicon Muhammad Din1 & Mamuna Ghani2 1 Govt. Postgraduate College Burewala, Pakistan 2 Chairperson of Department of English, The Islamia University of Bahawalpur, Pakistan Correspondence: Muhammad Din, Govt. Postgraduate College Burewala, Pakistan. E-mail: [email protected] Received: January 25, 2017 Accepted: February 15, 2017 Online Published: March 1, 2017 doi:10.5539/ijel.v7n3p152 URL: http://doi.org/10.5539/ijel.v7n3p152 Abstract This sociolinguistic study strives to bring to light the linguistic changes that seem to have occurred over a few decades in the Punjabi lexicon in Pakistan. The researchers have adopted two research strategies for underlining the assumed changes. This study has tried to get insight into the diminishing features of Punjabi lexicon by juxtaposing the current Punjabi lexicon with the lexicon used in the old Punjabi movies and songs. This has involved gleaning lexical items which are no longer used in the current public discourses from the old and famous Punjabi movies (Heer & MirzaSahiba) and their songs. To further substantiate the findings of the study, the researchers got a questionnaire filled by 110 educated Punjabi speakers who aged 40-50. In the questionnaire, the respondents were asked about their opinion regarding the perceived changes in Punjabi lexicon of public discourses that have occurred over the past few decades. The findings of the study reveal that there have occurred noticeable changes due to social, educational, industrial and technological advancement, and particularly the spread of electronic media in the Punjabi community in Pakistan.
    [Show full text]