Registered with the Reg. No. TN/CH(C)/374/15-17 Registrar of Newspapers Licenced to post without prepayment for India under R.N.I. 53640/91 Licence No. TN/PMG(CCR)/WPP-506/15-17 Publication: 15th & 28th of every month Rs. 5 per copy (Annual Subscription: Rs. 100/-) WE CARE FOR MADRAS THAT IS CHENNAI INSIDE • Short ‘N’ Snappy • What’s OSR? • Lakes of Madras – 4 • 60 years a bilingual writer • Farewell, Anandan
Vol. XXV No. 24 MUSINGS April 1-15, 2016 25 years & still Know your Fort going strong better
(By The Editor) ime for us to pat ourselves stepped in just as the going ap- Ton the back. Madras that is peared to be tough and prom- Chennai turned 375 a couple of ised to get us enough sponsors years ago. Fort St. George at- to ensure our continuity. tained that venerable age last Where would we be without year. We don’t know how old our dedicated band of writers, Mylapore, Tiruvallikeni and photographers, cartoonists, re- Tiruvottriyur are. We do know searchers and heritage enthusi- that the High Court of Madras asts, all of whom saw Madras turned 150 in 2012, the Madras Musings as the perfect medium Chamber of Commerce & In- for their thoughts, findings and dustry is 180 this year and that expression? And what about the Corporation of Madras Pace Systems, now Mot Juste, completed 325 in 2013. Com- that does our layouts and main- pared to all that, we are small tains our website or for that The state Wellesley House is in today. fry, but when we look below our matter Lokavani Southern masthead and discover Madras Printers who initiated Madras Musings has completed 25 years, Musings and has printed it since A last and lingering look we do feel a particular sense of Our first issue, April 16-30, 1991. inception? And we cannot for- satisfaction and happiness. get Broadgate Technical Ser- G Stepping out of Fort Museum into the sunshine and humidity This landmark would not vices, which handles our ac- that our city is known for, we return to the 21st Century. Our tour have been possible without the Chennai Heritage – that dedi- counts and mailing lists. of the Fort is done and it is time to go home. We walk back through support of all you readers. Your cated band of corporate houses Over the years we have high- the narrow pedestrian bridge over the moat on to the steps and encouragement, feedback, con- that has seen value in what we lighted several issues concern- the main road, where a pedestrian signal light, the only one tributions by way of stories, are doing and has generously ing our city’s heritage, both working in the whole of the city, helps you to cross the road to the ideas and donations is what has kept us financially solvent. On built and natural. We cannot parking lot. kept us buoyed up all these this occasion, we also look back claim to have made much of an There is lots more to see in the Fort – the Garrison Theatre in years. At the same time, we with happiness on the day when which the army staged its plays and invited outside troupes to thank our principal sponsors, N. Sankar of the Sanmar Group (Continued on page 7) perform for their entertainment, there is a building rather intrigu- ingly called Clive’s Library with which he had nothing to do, and there are the Navy’s offices. All of these are no doubt wonderful buildings but none of these is open to the public, which is all rather sad. For that matter, there is a lot more to be seen in the Fort that Waiting for the link, we cannot really access. To get an idea of the acreage that is out of bounds you need to view a rather ugly but functional model of Fort St George made Metro and MRTS out of wood, which is on display in the Fort Museum. Nobody is clear as to when this was made, not even D M Reid who in his t long last those in control by private vehicles. However, between. Today, it runs be- Story of Fort St George merely speculates that it could have been Aof our public transport sys- all of this may take quite a while tween Velacheri and Beach commissioned sometime late in the 19th Century. This was till the tems appear to be waking up to before becoming reality. Stations, the fate of the exten- 1940s in a room beside St Mary’s together with the display of the the possibilities. Five years after The MRTS, originally sion to St Thomas Mount being church’s plate. When the museum was commissioned in 1946, it it was proposed by the Tamil planned to link Beach Station, uncertain owing to land acqui- was moved there. Viewing this model you come to realise that Nadu State Government, the sition issues and the rest of it almost 50 per cent of the Fort cannot be accessed, which means we Indian Railways has given an in- abandoned owing to the Metro G also do not know what has happened to the historic buildings that principle nod to the merger of by A Special Rail project. When planned it Correspondent stood/stand there. We do know that Clive’s Library is in a precari- its Mass Rapid Transport Sys- was estimated to carry 6 lakh ous state and may crumble at any time. Proposals for its restoration tem (MRTS) with Chennai passengers a day but at present move forward at a snail’s pace. Its owner, the Navy, cannot seem Metro Rail (CMRL). This, as Velacheri, St Thomas’ Mount, handles around 1 lakh chiefly to make up its mind. and when it takes place, will Villivakkam and Ennore, was because of several deficiencies mean greater connectivity and conceptualised in the 1970s. in its execution – the most im- Which brings us to the core problem of Fort St George – it optimal utilisation of both sys- Work however did not begin till portant being the lack of last suffers from multiple ownership. The Army, the Navy, the Legisla- tems of public transport, 1984 and proceeded thereafter mile connectivity with other ture, the Tamil Nadu Government and the Archaeological Survey thereby taking pressure off the at a leisurely pace till 2007 with forms of transport. It is also an all occupy parts of it and claim complete suzerainty over the areas roads that are at present choked much escalation of cost in (Continued on page 7) (Continued on page 8) CMYK 2 MADRAS MUSINGS April 1-15, 2016 GWhat you need to know about: Carnatic in any other place Open space hose of you who follow the moneyed monarchs. Or so opened, however, MMM was Tmusings in Madras of The MMM thought. All these no- transported to Mylapore. The Man from Madras Musings tions were dashed to the queue was abandoned and ev- (MMM) do know that if at all ground when last fortnight eryone rushed in. Around ten reservation he has a weakness (and here MMM travelled to a faraway minutes later peace of a kind amoogam, Samudhayam, powered to issue demolition no- people like the Chief and land where the temperatures was established. The curtains S Aanmeegam are the three tice under Section 56 along with MMM’s good lady, who is also were frigid. Carnatic music was went up and the artistes re- main concerns in life for S. Sri- Section 85 of Town and Country known as She Who Must Be the last thing he had in mind, ceived thunderous applause. nivasan of Kottivakkam. He is Planning Act 1971, requiring Obeyed, can no doubt list but sure enough it flourished But if MMM thought the con- a retired Gazetted Officer from demolition of unauthorised con- several), it is for good Carnatic there as well. On a performing cert was about to begin, he was the Madras High Court. He struction put up without ap- music. MMM frequents places tour was a diva who is a close much mistaken. The sabha started independent practice proval of the Planning Commis- where ye goode South Indian friend of MMM’s and she was Secretary who had earlier been classical art is performed. kind enough to invite him to in jeans and T-shirt and who from 2011. He does free legal sion and restore the OSR land to Sometimes he goes to spots her concert. And so MMM had now changed into a bro- counselling services for needy its original position. where not so goode South went. caded Indian suit came on to people and also conducts free Is there any penalising of the en- Indian classical art is also The programme was sche- stage to read out the curricu- medical camps for the economi- croachers home owners / viola- performed but that is neither duled to begin at 7.00pm. A lum vitae of the artistes. This cally weaker section. He talks to tors? here nor there. mini blizzard was blowing out- was of course largely down- M. Rajini and R. Sumathi, and Yes. The Tamil Nadu Town Most of these performances side the venue, but in the audi- loaded from the internet and enlightens readers on OSR, the and Country Planning Act follow a standard pattern and torium foyer all was warmth to it was added some extem- rights of residents in a colony, 1971 contemplates restoration by that MMM does not refer to and gaiety. The best and bright- pore material from the and the norms to fight against of OSR land to the original the concert format, which is est in computer land were Secretary’s fertile imagination. encroachment. state. If the illegal occupants fail pretty much a given. He al- present. You could not have All this lasted ten minutes and What is OSR? to comply within the period ludes to the way such program- moved a bit without running the concert then began. OSR stands for Open Space specified in the demolition or- mes are conducted. In most into an emperor/empress of The music was fine for the Reservation. According to der, the Appropriate Planning places, barring a few locations embedded software or a mobile first ten minutes. But it was such as the Music Academy, technology maharajah/maha- too good to last. The violinist CMDA’s development and Authority may itself take such they rarely begin on time. The rani. Conversation varied – the was the first off the mark in control rules, 10 per cent of an measures and recover the cost audience will be made to wait humblest were discussing making eye contact with the area should be reserved as com- thereof from the offenders as at the entrance of the hall or sound technician. He wanted munal and recreational open arrears of Land Revenue. Fur- on occasion be allowed to take SHORT his mic volume to be incre- space before the actual approval ther, the offence committed is its seats and then while away ased. The chief percussionist of any layout under the provi- to be treated as a continuing time for ages before the artiste ’N’ was next. The singer contin- sions of Town and Country one, till the offending structure of the day makes his/her ap- ued singing – but only till the Planning Act. is demolished. pearance and begins the con- SNAPPY end of the first piece. At the What is the significance of this? What is the ruling of the Courts cert. Once the music starts, a end of it, the sound man, who With large scale rural exodus on the inaction of the Public Au- sideshow of sorts will also com- about how they fixed a bug in a had no doubt fiddled with and rapid urbanization, open thority? mence – this being a running code even as the middle rung some controls, managed to battle between the artistes on talked of stock options. In a shut off all the feedback moni- spaces become a necessity not a G The Chennai Corporation stage and the man who is in refined corner were a few who tors and so the chief performer mere amenity. It not only serves and The Chennai Metropolitan chatted about multiple levels of as lung space but also meets the Development Authority charge of the sound. Every ar- could not hear a word of what tiste, including the person funding and IPOs. In short, the she was singing. The necessary commercial and recreational re- (CMDA) have failed to take strumming the pitch, will be- atmosphere was far removed adjustments took another 15 quirements of the inhabitants. proper and effective steps to halt gin gesticulating and demand- from our own December sea- minutes. The music resumed In modern planning and devel- such unauthorised develop- ing through signs and gestures son sabha-s. but even after that the inter- opment, it occupies an impor- ments and no follow-up action that the mic closest to them be actions with the mic man tant place in social ecology. No was taken. The Government, increased in volume while that The Carnatic code continued. town planner would prepare a which has administrative con- of all other artistes be brought If you took heart at the fact blueprint without resourcing trol over these authorities, is ac- down as far as possible. In fact ut how strongly adhering that the person strumming the open space. Town planning de- tually aiding and abetting the if each of the performers had Bto tradition we are as a pitch had remained silent after velopment acts of different violators. The Supreme Court of his/her way, everyone else on people became more than all, it was because there was no States require even private India has directed the Govern- stage would at best be a mime manifest within a few minutes. person strumming the pitch. artiste. This ongoing battle for Seven o’clock came and went This being the software capi- house owners to have open ment of Tamil Nadu and other and there was no sign of the spaces in front and back for authorities to take effective supremacy usually subsides by tal, a gadget was assigned the around half time. concert beginning. The crowd task. The sound man was spa- lawn and fresh air. measures to check at the root milled around the auditorium level. But hold it just there. In red of at least one more level Can land specified for public pur- case you thought this is when door and some enthusiasts of interaction that way. Half- pose be used for any other pur- G This mess is due to the in effi- people like MMM sit back, re- formed a queue. At around way through the concert, pose? ciency, callousness and the fai- lax and enjoy the music you 7.15 a rather hassled volunteer which by the way was of a high The Apex Court and the lure of the statutory functionar- are much mistaken. For mid- announced that all was well standard, peace was esta- Madras High Court, in numer- ies to perform their obligation way through the concert is and that the concert would be- blished with the sound man ous cases, has held that the under the Act; it is high time when the Sabha secretary will gin in five minutes. The reason and everyone focused on the open space earmarked for pub- that remedial measure was waddle on to stage, grab a mic for the delay he said was the music. But not for long. lic purpose cannot be altered. taken up by the State. and begin giving a speech. This late handing over of the hall to the organisers and so the Can the Corporation claim G The number of unauthorised will usually have two parts – Tailpiece ownership of the OSR land constructions increase manifold the first being a wholly unnec- artistes needed time for doing essary reading of the artiste’s their sound checks. ust as the concert reached a gifted to them for development primarily due to lack of respon- This pleased MMM no end. cruising stage the Secretary of a park or play ground? sibility shown by statutory au- profile, normally cribbed from J some completely erroneous Such wonderful professional- was back. He had some an- As held by the Supreme thorities, who deliberately turn ism he thought to himself. The nouncements to make, he Court Directive, the answer is a blind eye to such violators, source on the world wide web. The second half will be an ap- concert was going to be a plea- said, and went on to make ‘No’. The space transferred to even though they are vested peal on behalf of the sabha and sure he reflected. No battles them. The performance, he the local body, through a gift with sufficient powers to launch how it would be able to build with sound technicians during said, was organised in aid of a deed, shall be used for beneficial criminal prosecution against an auditorium for itself if only the performance, he thought. temple fund. It was the dear- and enjoyment of the residents the violators. audiences could see their way MMM also mentally congratu- est wish of the organisers, he said, that a temple be built in of the colony. The local body G The State Government and to loosening their purse lated the musically inclined for would only be the custodian of the concerned authorities are strings. MMM has often won- forming a queue so that they this computer-loka and if only the land and cannot claim to be required to act diligently and dered whether it would not be could enter the venue in an the audience would loosen its the owner. prevent recurrence of such kind a more befitting ambition for organised fashion. Back in In- purse strings… these sabha-s to get a good dia, reflected MMM, all hell MMM came away with a What are the duties of the custo- of unlawful activity in future feeling that all that was miss- dian of the OSR land? and deal with the violators with sound technician on board. would break lose the moment the doors opened. ing was a sabha canteen. But The mandatory duty of the an iron hand. Be that as it may. Nothing is really going to change these The five minutes stretched he need not have worried. In public authority is to maintain G In the landmark T’Nagar sabha-s and the way they oper- to another 15 and it was only the foyer was a man selling the open space and to put it to Usman Road’ case, the Madras at around 7.35 that the doors pre-packed dinners in plastic use for the purpose for which it High Court directed the Gov- ate, at least not in India. MMM being aware of such organisa- were opened. This was pre- trays. MMM’s good lady was earmarked and for the ben- ernment and authorities con- tions now existing overseas ceded by a couple of the volun- bought one and later declared efit of the residents of the colony cerned to file an affidavit justify- hoped that these were run on teers giving each other high that, like the music, it was top only. If the OSR land is en- ing their inaction all these years. better lines. After all, sitting on fives – these being for the suc- class. The Carnatic tradition croached in and developed with S. Srinivasan can be con- their boards would be software cessful completion of the lives on. illegal construction etc., the tacted at 97910 19450 – (Cour- czars, technical potentates and sound tests. Once the door – MMM public authority has been em- tesy: Adyar Times.) April 1-15, 2016 MADRAS MUSINGS 3
help of “helpful labourers” is a moot question. For example, the stretch from AVM Avenue 2nd Main Road via St John’s School up to Flood learning Bone-rattlers Arcot Road through Radha- krishnan Salai has about 12 t was good to be back to get down to processing the 250 per day as parking charges he Mylapore walkway I home after The Flood. The claim for the car insurance for cars towed away. But why speed breakers of various levels electricity had been restored first. On informing the garage, did they tow them away when T (MM, March 16th) is not and at very short to medium dis- the only problem created by the and the phones were working. the tow truck came promptly. there were not enough me- tances (particularly at the en- We even had someone come The two front tyres were mer- chanics to work on them and so-called authorities who trance to the school men- should be maintaining and and collect our names for cilessly immobilised with locks why did they not inform car tioned) with sewage water ooz- compensation from the gov- and the huge fork lifted only owners before towing their monitoring our roads and side- ing out from a broken crevice ernment for the loss suffered, the front half of the car to tow cars away? I wondered to walks to ensure the comfort of on the road that adds to the which of course never came! it away. I objected, on behalf whom I should address these the public. misery of users. Everybody was feeling good. of the car, to this mistreat- questions – neither the car Instead of looking the other Chennai is famous for its “Chennaiites had handled the ment. I asked why the car dealer nor the insurance com- way, they should be looking at roads without pavements; now crisis in an exemplary fash- could not be taken atop the pany personnel picked up the ion,” “see the spirit of tow truck, which was empty. I phone! Slowly it sank in – it the speed-breakers that come it is gaining the status of a city up at random overnight at a dis- Chennai,” etc. You had to ad- was told that space was re- was not going to be easy and a with roads which are them- mit the public had done a great served only for the VIP cat- long, difficult road lay ahead. tance of five to ten steps! They selves like speed-breakers with only end up breaking and rat- job of rescuing people, provid- egory of cars – Mercedes, The employees of the car additional bumps called speed ing food, water, shelter and BMW, Audi, etc. I had to dealer and the insurance com- tling the bones of the two- breakers on which the leaders’ other essentials. swallow the implied insult. panies were overworked and wheeler riders. Whether they posters and banners stand with It was now time to assess After a week the newspa- drowning in a sea of claims. serve the purpose for which benign smiles on their faces! the damage and take action. A pers broke the news that com- They themselves were not they were created overnight major inconvenience was panies were charging any- sure how to handle a crisis of (mostly by the locals with the Kanchana Ravi damage to the car; so I decided where between Rupees 150 to this magnitude. kanchanarravi2372gmail.com The estimate for repair was almost equal to insured value, with no guarantee that it would be restored to its origi- Autonomy before monotony nal condition – a not-so-subtle pressure to go for total loss. I recently read an article wherein Rev. Xavier Alphonse, former lenge of the Autonomous College (1976). Obviously this idea had was told very casually that de- IPrincipal of Loyola College (Madras) and now in retirement in been fermenting in John’s mind for many years and he could possi- claring the car a total loss St Joseph’s College (Tiruchi), lamented that no significant progress bly share this with another equally liberated thinker, the late would get me about 60 per- cent of the insured value. I just has been made on the front of autonomous colleges in the last few Malcolm S. Adiseshiah, the then Vice-Chancellor of the Univer- did not understand the logic. years. I have not been following this aspect of Indian education for sity of Madras. It so happened that Adiseshiah could suggest that Then why state the insured several years now, since I no more belong to the system. Neverthe- idea to the managements of Loyola and Madras Christian Colleges value in the document? I was less, the lament of Rev. Alphonse brought a few aspects of college in Madras, and Lady Doak and American College in Madurai in desperately looking for some- autonomy to my mind, since I was one of those young lecturers the mid-1970s*, which were convinced to take up the challenge one to educate me on the nu- who was excitedly involved in the planning of autonomy for Loyola and work towards it earlier than John could promote the concept ances of negotiating with the College in the mid-1970s, under the leadership of the late Joseph in Rajasthan or elsewhere in Northern India. Malcolm Adiseshiah insurance company. Kuriakose, S.J., the then Principal. gets the full credit for bringing the concept to fruition, by convinc- A month went by and I was I had the good fortune of being in the close company of the late ing the principals of these institutions in Tamil Nadu, under the still clueless. I could not reach anyone from the insurance D. Shankar Narayan for several years, until I moved to Australia aegis of the University of Madras. company. Then the break- for good. Shankar Narayan was the Additional Secretary of the The University Grants Commission, convinced of the concept, through happened – my sister- University Grants Commission in the 1970s. He officiated as the entrusted the responsibility to Shankar Narayan to develop it fur- in-law said that a relative of relieving Secretary of the UGC in the 1980s. After retiring from ther for launch. Shankar Narayan developed the blueprint (the my husband’s cousin is a sur- the UGC, he worked as Professor of Higher Education and Educa- guidelines) for the early experimenters: Loyola, Madras Christian, veyor. I clutched on to this tional Planning, Indian Institute of Management, Bangalore, until Lady Doak, and the American College*. What needs to be fac- piece of information like a his end. tored in is that the blueprint developed by Shankar Narayan in the drowning person clutching a Considerable confusion prevails today while referring to the ar- 1970s, the actual launch year being 1978, was just one-and-a-half straw. I called him and broke chitect of college autonomy. The concept in its entirety belongs to pages long, with a few generic points. When I had the opportunity the ice by explaining how I the late Vadekedath Varkey John (V. V. John, 1910-1991), who to interact with him closely, when he chaired a review committee was related to him. He was a surveyor for major projects was a Professor of English in the early years of his career and later a to assess Loyola’s performance as an autonomous college in 1988- and not for automobiles. My dynamic Vice-Chancellor of the University of Jodhpur (now Jai 1989, I asked him how come the set of guidelines developed by him heart sank but I quickly recov- Narain Vyas University). For his brilliant, original thinking on this in 1970s was so very brief, whereas the one introduced by the UGC ered and requested if there concept, please read his vibrant book Freedom to Learn: The Chal- in 1988-1989 ran to several pages, with hair-splitting details simi- was any way he could help. He lar to the Indian Penal Code! Shankar Narayan answered me with was very courteous and prom- a smile and said: “The intent was to give freedom and not to cur- ised to find out through his tail.” That meant volumes to me then. I have no clue how these contacts how I could speed up CHENNAI HERITAGE guidelines are today; maybe they have become worse than a legal the claim process. By now it was over two months since No. 5, Bhattad Tower, 30, Westcott Road, Royapettah, Chennai 600 014 document. The Floods. When Rev. Nicholas Casimir Raj, S.J., was the Principal of I am already on your mailing list (Mailing List At last there seemed some Loyola, we convened in 1983 a five-day workshop inviting princi- hope of claim papers moving. No...... ) / I have just seen Madras Musings and pals and teachers from various operational autonomous colleges The signs came when my calls would like to receive it hereafter. (then only in the State of Tamil Nadu). At the workshop we were picked up by the Claims G I/We enclose cheque/demand draft/money order for thrashed out significant outcomes; we disinterestedly analysed our Department. At the time of failures and successes. Close to 100 participants attended the work- writing this – that is three and Rs. 100 (Rupees One hundred) payable to CHENNAI shop, which included many discussion forums. General lectures in- half months after the floods – I HERITAGE, MADRAS, as subscription to Madras cluded inspirational presentations by V.V. John and Malcolm managed to get the full insured Musings for the year 2015-16. Adiseshiah. Casimir Raj brought out the proceedings as Five Years value. After this experience, I G of Autonomy (1984). As token of my support for the causes of heritage, now have my own four Maha- environment and a better city that Madras Musings I need to confess that by the time I left Loyola, in the late 1990s, vakyas: I could see that the spirit of innovation – the backbone of college espouses, I send Chennai Heritage an additional 1. Life is like Chennai roads – autonomy – was dwindling. People were becoming uninterested. you don’t know when you Rs...... (Rupees ...... ) Please In fact, Xavier Alphonse as the Principal of Loyola, playing on will hit a speed breaker. keep/put me on your mailing list. words remarked, “Autonomy has turned into monotony.” 2. Never take anything at Name : ...... It would indeed be good if a comprehensive evaluation of this face-value – even legal concept is done, given that many institutions across the nation documents. Address: ...... have taken this challenge on. Has any progress been achieved? If 3. In modern times, family is ...... yes, how, and what mechanisms have been used? John dreamt that those who are there for you during a crisis...... autonomous colleges will one day become universities by their own 4. Finally and most impor- rights. Is this still a possibility? tantly – remember, this too ...... Anantanarayanan Raman will pass. All cheques to ‘Chennai Heritage’. DD/Cheque should be ([email protected]) * – Lalitha Ramachander sent by Speed Post only. I may have missed a few other names; I seek readers’ generosity of forgiveness at this instance. [email protected] 4 MADRAS MUSINGS April 1-15, 2016 April 1-15, 2016 MADRAS MUSINGS 5