TAYSIDE VALUATION APPEAL PANEL LIST of APPEALS for CONSIDERATION by the VALUATION APPEAL COMMITTEE at Committee Room No 1, 14 City Square, DUNDEE on 22 June 2021

Home , Broughty Ferry, East Dock Street, Pitkerro, Tayside

TAYSIDE VALUATION APPEAL PANEL LIST OF APPEALS FOR CONSIDERATION BY THE VALUATION APPEAL COMMITTEE At Committee Room No 1, 14 City Square, DUNDEE on 22 June 2021

Assessor's Appellant's Case No Details & Contact Description & Situation Appellant NAV RV NAV RV Remarks

001 01WAO0102500 SITE CLOWES DEVELOPMENTS £59,200 £59,200 121229 0003 SITE 2 (SCOTLAND) LTD Update 2019 14 BAIRD AVENUE PER GRAHAM & SIBBALD 31 March 2020 DRYBURGH INDUSTRIAL ESTATE 40 TORPHICHEN STREET DUNDEE EDINBURGH DD2 3TN EH3 8JB 002 01WAO0102500 SITE CLOWES DEVELOPMENTS £59,200 £59,200 £29,600 121229 0004 SITE 2 (SCOTLAND) LTD Update 2020 14 BAIRD AVENUE PER GRAHAM & SIBBALD 30 September 2020 DRYBURGH INDUSTRIAL ESTATE 233 ST VINCENT STREET DUNDEE GLASGOW DD2 3TN G2 5QY 003 01WAO0102600 OFFICE TESCO STORES LIMITED £395,000 £395,000 £1 £1 304557 0003 BAIRD AVENUE PER AVISON YOUNG Update 2019 DRYBURGH INDUSTRIAL ESTATE SUTHERLAND HOUSE 29 March 2020 DUNDEE 149 ST VINCENT STREET DD2 3TW GLASGOW G2 5NW 004 01WAO0103500 WAREHOUSE MAGNET LTD £40,700 £40,700 £1 £1 121231 0003 BAIRD AVENUE PER CBRE LIMITED Update 2019 DRYBURGH INDUSTRIAL ESTATE 149 ST VINCENT STREET 27 March 2020 DUNDEE GLASGOW DD2 3TW G2 5NW 005 01WAO0104500 WAREHOUSE & OFFICE DECCO LTD £40,000 £40,000 £1 711003 0002 BAIRD AVENUE PER WYM RATING Update 2019 DRYBURGH INDUSTRIAL ESTATE 22 HANOVER STREET 30 March 2020 DUNDEE EDINBURGH DD2 3TW EH2 2EP

Page 1 Assessor's Appellant's Case No Details & Contact Description & Situation Appellant NAV RV NAV RV Remarks

006 01WAO0108000 SORTING OFFICE ROYAL MAIL GROUP LIMITED £64,800 £64,800 754675 0002 DUNDEE WEST DELIVERY OFFICE PER GL HEARN Update 2019 43 BAIRD AVENUE 3RD FLOOR 31 March 2020 DRYBURGH INDUSTRIAL ESTATE ONE GUILDHALL SQUARE DUNDEE SOUTHAMPTON DD2 3UX SO14 7FP 007 01WAO0469000 WAREHOUSE & SHOWROOM SAINT-GOBAIN £33,200 £33,200 772919 0002 UNIT 2, 3A & 3B PER CUSHMAN & WAKEFIELD Update 2019 EDISON PLACE ONE EDINBURGH QUAY 31 March 2020 DRYBURGH INDUSTRIAL ESTATE FOUNTAINBRIDGE DUNDEE EDINBURGH DD2 3QU EH3 9QG 008 01WAO0471100 DEPOT SCOT JCB LTD £39,600 £39,600 £1 £1 713027 0002 FARADAY STREET PER AVISON YOUNG Update 2019 DRYBURGH INDUSTRIAL ESTATE SUTHERLAND HOUSE 29 March 2020 DUNDEE 149 ST VINCENT STREET DD2 3QQ GLASGOW G2 5NW 009 01WAO0471500 WORKSHOP & OFFICE SCREWFIX DIRECT LTD £52,400 £52,400 £1 £1 190079 0003 FARADAY STREET PER COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL Update 2019 DRYBURGH INDUSTRIAL ESTATE 6TH FLOOR 18 March 2020 DUNDEE 2 WEST REGENT STREET DD2 3QQ GLASGOW G2 1RW 010 01WAO0471600 WAREHOUSE & SHOWROOM SAINT-GOBAIN BUILDING £84,100 £84,100 188995 0003 18 FARADAY STREET PER GERALD EVE LLP Update 2019 DRYBURGH INDUSTRIAL ESTATE 140 WEST GEORGE STREET 25 March 2020 DUNDEE GLASGOW DD2 3QQ G2 2HG 011 01WAO0472300 OFFICE & STORE LANGSTANE PRESS LTD £42,000 £42,000 752529 0002 FARADAY STREET PER F G BURNETT Update 2019 DRYBURGH INDUSTRIAL ESTATE 33 ALBYN PLACE 25 March 2020 DUNDEE ABERDEEN DD2 3QQ AB10 1YL

Page 2 Assessor's Appellant's Case No Details & Contact Description & Situation Appellant NAV RV NAV RV Remarks

012 01WAO0472400 DEPOT EDMUNDSON ELECTRICAL LTD £30,200 £30,200 £1 121419 0002 FARADAY STREET PER WYM RATING Update 2019 DRYBURGH INDUSTRIAL ESTATE 22 HANOVER STREET 30 March 2020 DUNDEE EDINBURGH DD2 3QQ EH2 2EP 013 01WAO0473100 WAREHOUSE & OFFICE WOLSELEY CENTRES LTD £51,700 £51,700 121426 0003 UNIT 1,2,3 & 4 T/A PLUMB & DRAINAGE CENTRES Update 2019 FARADAY STREET PER GRAHAM & SIBBALD 31 March 2020 DRYBURGH INDUSTRIAL ESTATE 40 TORPHICHEN STREET DUNDEE EDINBURGH DD2 3QQ EH3 8JB 014 01WAO0473200 STORE DUNDEE CITY COUNCIL £22,300 £22,300 £1 £1 121417 0002 UNIT 5 & 6 (DRYBURGH INDUSTRIAL ESTATE) Update 2020 FARADAY STREET PER AVISON YOUNG 17 December 2020 DRYBURGH INDUSTRIAL ESTATE SUTHERLAND HOUSE DUNDEE 149 ST VINCENT STREET DD2 3QQ GLASGOW G2 5NW 015 01WAO0473300 WAREHOUSE & OFFICE DUNDEE CITY COUNCIL £23,400 £23,400 £1 £1 188991 0002 UNIT 7 & 8 (DRYBURGH INDUSTRIAL ESTATE) Update 2020 FARADAY STREET PER AVISON YOUNG 17 December 2020 DRYBURGH INDUSTRIAL ESTATE SUTHERLAND HOUSE DUNDEE 149 ST VINCENT STREET DD2 3QQ GLASGOW G2 5NW 016 01WAO0478700 WAREHOUSE & OFFICE SIG ROOFING SUPPLIES LTD £30,500 £30,500 £1 £1 188097 0002 FARADAY STREET T/A ASPHALTIC ROOFING SUPPLIES LTD Update 2019 DRYBURGH INDUSTRIAL ESTATE PER COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL 18 March 2020 DUNDEE 6TH FLOOR DD2 3QQ 2 WEST REGENT STREET GLASGOW G2 1RW 017 01WAO0560000 DEPOT WOLSELEY UK £49,000 £49,000 300766 0002 3 GEORGE BUCKMAN DRIVE PER GRAHAM & SIBBALD Update 2019 DRYBURGH INDUSTRIAL ESTATE 40 TORPHICHEN STREET 31 March 2020 DUNDEE EDINBURGH DD2 3SP EH3 8JB Page 3 Assessor's Appellant's Case No Details & Contact Description & Situation Appellant NAV RV NAV RV Remarks

018 01WAO0561000 DEPOT A M PHILLIP TRUCKTECH LTD £54,600 £54,600 805195 0002 5 GEORGE BUCKMAN DRIVE PER RYDEN LLP Update 2019 DRYBURGH INDUSTRIAL ESTATE 130 ST VINCENT STREET 29 March 2020 DUNDEE GLASGOW DD2 3SP G3 5HF 019 01WAO0563000 FACTORY ALBACOM LTD £73,800 £73,800 £36,900 £36,900 804941 0001 9-11 GEORGE BUCKMAN DRIVE PER J & E SHEPHERD Update 2020 DRYBURGH INDUSTRIAL ESTATE 13 ALBERT SQUARE 03 April 2020 DUNDEE MEADOWSIDE DD2 3SP DUNDEE DD1 1XA 020 01WAO0948700 FACTORY JOINERY & TIMBER CREATIONS LTD £286,500 £286,500 121500 0002 27 HARRISON ROAD PER GRAHAM & SIBBALD Update 2019 DRYBURGH INDUSTRIAL ESTATE 40 TORPHICHEN STREET 31 March 2020 DUNDEE EDINBURGH DD2 3SN EH3 8JB 021 01WAO1111100 STORES,OFFICE & WORKSHOP SCOTTISH GAS NETWORKS £80,100 £80,100 715466 0002 6 MACADAM PLACE PROPERTY SERVICES Update 2019 DRYBURGH INDUSTRIAL ESTATE PER GRAHAM & SIBBALD 31 March 2020 DUNDEE 40 TORPHICHEN STREET DD2 3QR EDINBURGH EH3 8JB 022 01WAO1263000 STORE & YARD CASTLECROFT SECURITIES LTD RBS £94,900 £94,900 709453 0002 RUTHERFORD ROAD PER GRAHAM & SIBBALD Update 2019 DRYBURGH INDUSTRIAL ESTATE 40 TORPHICHEN STREET 31 March 2020 DUNDEE EDINBURGH DD2 3XH EH3 8JB 023 01WAO1265000 WAREHOUSE & OFFICE SAINT-GOBAIN £49,900 £49,900 716934 0002 UNIT 1/3 T/A THE BSS GROUP LTD Update 2019 RUTHERFORD ROAD PER CUSHMAN & WAKEFIELD 31 March 2020 DRYBURGH INDUSTRIAL ESTATE ONE EDINBURGH QUAY DUNDEE FOUNTAINBRIDGE DD2 3XH EDINBURGH EH3 9QG

Page 4 Assessor's Appellant's Case No Details & Contact Description & Situation Appellant NAV RV NAV RV Remarks

024 01WAO1266050 WAREHOUSE & OFFICE JOHN CLARK (ABERDEEN) LTD £16,800 £16,800 313492 0003 UNIT 4 PER GRAHAM & SIBBALD Update 2019 RUTHERFORD ROAD 40 TORPHICHEN STREET 31 March 2020 DRYBURGH INDUSTRIAL ESTATE EDINBURGH DUNDEE EH3 8JB DD2 3XH 025 01WAO1266100 WORKSHOP JOHN CLARK £15,600 £15,600 313493 0003 UNIT 5 PER GRAHAM & SIBBALD Update 2019 RUTHERFORD ROAD 40 TORPHICHEN STREET 31 March 2020 DRYBURGH INDUSTRIAL ESTATE EDINBURGH DUNDEE EH3 8JB DD2 3XH 026 01WAO1268000 WAREHOUSE & OFFICE JOHN CLARK (HOLDINGS) LTD £18,000 £18,000 728201 0003 UNIT 6 PER GRAHAM & SIBBALD Update 2019 RUTHERFORD ROAD 40 TORPHICHEN STREET 31 March 2020 DRYBURGH INDUSTRIAL ESTATE EDINBURGH DUNDEE EH3 8JB DD2 3XH 027 01WAO1270100 STORE OASIS GROUP LTD £45,500 £45,500 307471 0003 UNIT 10 & 11 PER WYM RATING Update 2019 RUTHERFORD ROAD 22 HANOVER STREET 31 March 2020 DRYBURGH INDUSTRIAL ESTATE EDINBURGH DUNDEE EH2 2EP DD2 3XH 028 01WAO1270100 STORE CASTLECROFT SECURITIES LTD £45,500 £45,500 307471 0002 UNIT 10 & 11 PER GRAHAM & SIBBALD Update 2019 RUTHERFORD ROAD 40 TORPHICHEN STREET 31 March 2020 DRYBURGH INDUSTRIAL ESTATE EDINBURGH DUNDEE EH3 8JB DD2 3XH 029 01WAO1358622 OFFICE BARNARDOS £1,400 £1,400 313640 0001 ROOM 08 PER GL HEARN Update 2019 TOWNGATE BUSINESS CENTRE 3RD FLOOR 31 March 2020 4-6 STAFFA PLACE ONE GUILDHALL SQUARE DUNDEE SOUTHAMPTON DD2 3SX SO14 7FP

Page 5 Assessor's Appellant's Case No Details & Contact Description & Situation Appellant NAV RV NAV RV Remarks

030 01WAO1358626 OFFICE BARNARDOS £850 £850 313642 0001 ROOM 11 PER GL HEARN Update 2019 TOWNGATE BUSINESS CENTRE 3RD FLOOR 31 March 2020 4-6 STAFFA PLACE ONE GUILDHALL SQUARE DUNDEE SOUTHAMPTON DD2 3SX SO14 7FP 031 02WAC0004475 WORKSHOP WEST RANGA (ARROL) LTD £92,400 £92,400 321012 0002 UNIT 1& 2 WSTR GOURDIE IND EST PER CBRE LIMITED Update 2019 ARROL ROAD 149 ST VINCENT STREET 26 March 2020 DUNDEE GLASGOW DD2 4TH G2 5NW 032 02WAC0828000 WAREHOUSE OASIS UK NORTH LTD £112,500 £112,500 738489 0001 WESTER GOURDIE ESTATE PER WYM RATING Update 2019 FULTON ROAD 22 HANOVER STREET 31 March 2020 DUNDEE EDINBURGH DD2 4SW EH2 2EP 033 02WAC1076000 WAREHOUSE & OFFICE ENCON INSULATION £119,000 £119,000 £1 £1 790430 0002 BLOCK 10 (PART) PER AVISON YOUNG Update 2019 MYREKIRK ROAD SUTHERLAND HOUSE 28 March 2020 DUNDEE 149 ST VINCENT STREET DD2 4TG GLASGOW G2 5NW 034 02WAC1177000 WAREHOUSE UPS LTD £73,000 £73,000 713028 0002 BLOCK 07 PER JONES LANG LASALLE Update 2019 NOBEL ROAD 150 ST VINCENT STREET 31 March 2020 DUNDEE GLASGOW DD2 4UH G2 5ND 035 02WAC1190000 WORKSHOP SPECIALIST CARS (ABERDEEN) LTD £22,500 £22,500 812593 0002 BLOCK 7B UNITS 1-3 PER GRAHAM & SIBBALD Update 2019 NOBEL ROAD 40 TORPHICHEN STREET 31 March 2020 DUNDEE EDINBURGH DD2 4UH EH3 8JB

Page 6 Assessor's Appellant's Case No Details & Contact Description & Situation Appellant NAV RV NAV RV Remarks

036 02WAC1192000 FACTORY RAUTOMEAD LTD £73,900 £73,900 £35,800 £35,800 736707 0002 WESTER GOURDIE IND ESTATE PER GRAHAM & SIBBALD Update 2020 NOBEL ROAD 40 TORPHICHEN STREET 27 April 2020 DUNDEE EDINBURGH DD2 4UH EH3 8JB 037 02WAC1192000 FACTORY RAUTOMEAD LTD £73,900 £73,900 736707 0003 WESTER GOURDIE IND ESTATE PER GRAHAM & SIBBALD Update 2019 NOBEL ROAD 40 TORPHICHEN STREET 31 March 2020 DUNDEE EDINBURGH DD2 4UH EH3 8JB 038 02WAC1192050 WAREHOUSE & OFFICE FORD RETAIL GROUP LTD £45,200 £45,200 £1 322711 0003 NOBEL ROAD PER WYM RATING Update 2019 DUNDEE 22 HANOVER STREET 30 March 2020 DD2 4UH EDINBURGH EH2 2EP 039 02WAC1192050 WAREHOUSE & OFFICE WEST RANGA (ARROL) LTD £47,700 £47,700 £1 £1 322711 0002 NOBEL ROAD PER CBRE LIMITED Update 2019 DUNDEE 149 ST VINCENT STREET 26 March 2020 DD2 4UH GLASGOW G2 5NW 040 02WAC1193900 WAREHOUSE COSGROVE METALS LTD £27,800 £27,800 793977 0002 WESTER GOURDIE IND ESTATE PER GRAHAM & SIBBALD Update 2019 10A NOBEL ROAD 40 TORPHICHEN STREET 31 March 2020 DUNDEE EDINBURGH DD2 4UH EH3 8JB 041 02WAC1194050 OFFICE NCR FINANCIAL SOLUTIONS £18,400 £18,400 314310 0001 UNIT 3 GROUP LTD Update 2019 WESTER GOURDIE IND ESTATE PER JONES LANG LASALLE 31 March 2020 14 NOBEL ROAD 9TH FLOOR DUNDEE 5 MERCHANT SQUARE DD2 4UH PADDINGTON LONDON W2 1BQ

Page 7 Assessor's Appellant's Case No Details & Contact Description & Situation Appellant NAV RV NAV RV Remarks

042 02WAC1195000 WAREHOUSE RAUTOMEAD £62,900 £62,900 300701 0003 BLOCK 7A PART PER GRAHAM & SIBBALD Update 2019 WESTER GOURDIE IND ESTATE 40 TORPHICHEN STREET 31 March 2020 NOBEL ROAD EDINBURGH DUNDEE EH3 8JB DD2 4UH 043 02WAC1195000 WAREHOUSE RAUTOMEAD £62,900 £62,900 £31,450 £31,450 300701 0002 BLOCK 7A PART PER GRAHAM & SIBBALD Update 2020 WESTER GOURDIE IND ESTATE 40 TORPHICHEN STREET 27 April 2020 NOBEL ROAD EDINBURGH DUNDEE EH3 8JB DD2 4UH 044 02WAC1201000 WORKSHOP OFFICE & STORES FIFE SCOTTISH OMNIBUSES LTD £39,800 £39,800 711934 0003 UNITS 1, 2 & 3 PER MONTAGU EVANS LLP Update 2019 1 SMEATON ROAD 302 ST VINCENT STREET 30 March 2020 DUNDEE GLASGOW DD2 4UT G2 5RU 045 02WAC1204000 DEPOT PARXON LTD £148,750 £148,750 716914 0003 5 SMEATON ROAD PER P S RIDGWAY LTD Update 2019 DUNDEE PER GRAHAM & SIBBALD 31 March 2020 DD2 4UT 40 TORPICHEN STREET EDINBURGH EH3 8JB 046 02WAC1208000 WORKSHOP NATIONWIDE CRASH REP CTRES LTD £54,000 £54,000 £1 £1 743204 0002 SMEATON ROAD PER CBRE LIMITED Update 2019 DUNDEE 149 ST VINCENT STREET 25 March 2020 DD2 4UT GLASGOW G2 5NW 047 02WAC1215000 GARAGE DFS TRADING LTD £42,200 £42,200 763770 0001 UNIT D PER GL HEARN Update 2019 SMEATON ROAD 3RD FLOOR 31 March 2020 DUNDEE ONE GUILDHALL SQUARE DD2 4UT SOUTHAMPTON SO14 7FP

Page 8 Assessor's Appellant's Case No Details & Contact Description & Situation Appellant NAV RV NAV RV Remarks

048 02WAC1284000 WAREHOUSE & OFFICE MENZIES (DISTRIBUTION) LTD £128,750 £128,750 £1 £1 776343 0002 WESTER GOURDIE IND ESTATE PER ERNEST & YOUNG LLP Update 2019 WADE STREET 1 COLMORE SQUARE 31 March 2020 DUNDEE BIRMINGHAM DD2 4SN B4 6HQ 049 02WAC1285000 DEPOT DUNDEE COLD STORES LTD £260,000 £260,000 121514 0002 WHITTLE PLACE PER GRAHAM & SIBBALD Update 2019 DUNDEE 40 TORPHICHEN STREET 31 March 2020 DD2 4TD EDINBURGH EH3 8JB 050 02WAC1289500 WAREHOUSE LYRECO £26,300 £26,300 £1 £1 307026 0001 UNIT 3 PER COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL Update 2019 WHITTLE PLACE 6TH FLOOR 18 March 2020 DUNDEE 2 WEST REGENT STREET DD2 4US GLASGOW G2 1RW 051 02WAC1294000 WAREHOUSE & OFFICE REMBRAND TIMBER LTD £62,800 £62,800 £31,400 £31,400 302749 0002 UNIT 7 PER ANDREW REILLY ASSOCIATES LTD Update 2020 WHITTLE PLACE 31 RUTLAND SQUARE 19 June 2020 DUNDEE EDINBURGH DD2 4US EH1 2BW 052 02WAH0549000 STORE DUNDEE CITY COUNCIL £440 £440 £1 £1 099372 0002 (07 EAST) PER AVISON YOUNG Update 2019 TWEED CRESCENT SUTHERLAND HOUSE 28 March 2020 DUNDEE 149 ST VINCENT STREET DD2 4DU GLASGOW G2 5NW 053 02WAK0533000 WORKSHOP & YARD ALLIANCE HEALTHCARE £30,500 £30,500 795379 0001 HERONS LANE (DISTRIBUTION) LTD Update 2019 DUNDEE PER GL HEARN 31 March 2020 DD2 3EW 3RD FLOOR ONE GUILDHALL SQUARE SOUTHAMPTON SO14 7FP

Page 9 Assessor's Appellant's Case No Details & Contact Description & Situation Appellant NAV RV NAV RV Remarks

054 02WAK0789000 WORKSHOP & YARD GAP GROUP LTD £46,200 £46,200 £1 £1 811674 0002 133 LORNE STREET PER AVISON YOUNG Update 2019 LOCHEE SUTHERLAND HOUSE 28 March 2020 DUNDEE 149 ST VINCENT STREET DD2 3HE GLASGOW G2 5NW 055 02WAK0801000 YARD GAP GROUP LTD £26,600 £26,600 798949 0002 114 LORNE STREET PER AVISON YOUNG Update 2019 LOCHEE SUTHERLAND HOUSE 28 March 2020 DUNDEE 149 ST VINCENT STREET DD2 3HF GLASGOW G2 5NW 056 02WAK0808000 WORKSHOP DUNDEE CITY COUNCIL £8,700 £8,700 £1 £1 726162 0002 UNIT 04 PER AVISON YOUNG Update 2019 MARYBANK LANE SUTHERLAND HOUSE 28 March 2020 DUNDEE 149 ST VINCENT STREET DD2 3DY GLASGOW G2 5NW 057 02WAK0909000 WORKSHOP & YARD ASPECT CONTRACTS LTD £6,000 £6,000 £1 756310 0002 42A PERRIE STREET PER WYM RATING Update 2019 DUNDEE 22 HANOVER STREET 30 March 2020 DD2 2RD EDINBURGH EH2 2EP 058 02WAK0909500 WORKSHOP & YARD ASPECT CONTRACTS LTD £7,300 £7,300 £1 310134 0002 42B PERRIE STREET PER WYM RATING Update 2019 DUNDEE 22 HANOVER STREET 30 March 2020 DD2 2RD EDINBURGH EH2 2EP 059 02WAK0911000 YARD DUNDEE CITY COUNCIL £3,500 £3,500 £1 £1 762170 0002 EAST SIDE OF PER AVISON YOUNG Update 2019 PERRIE STREET SUTHERLAND HOUSE 28 March 2020 DUNDEE 149 ST VINCENT STREET DD2 2RD GLASGOW G2 5NW

Page 10 Assessor's Appellant's Case No Details & Contact Description & Situation Appellant NAV RV NAV RV Remarks

060 02WAY0128000 DEPOT ATS EUROMASTER LTD £16,700 £16,700 106544 0002 328B CLEPINGTON ROAD PER GERALD EVE LLP Update 2019 DUNDEE 140 WEST GEORGE STREET 28 March 2020 DD3 8RZ GLASGOW G2 2HG 061 02WAY0130000 WAREHOUSE & OFFICE BKUK GROUP LTD £173,750 £173,750 £1 106555 0002 332-334 CLEPINGTON ROAD PER BNP PARIBAS REAL ESTATE Update 2019 DUNDEE FIRST FLOOR (SUITE 1) 30 March 2020 DD3 8RZ EXCHANGE PLACE GLASGOW G1 3AN 062 02WAY0164000 WHOLESALE WAREHOUSE BOOKER CASH & CARRY LTD £202,250 £202,250 763138 0002 DUNSINANE AVENUE PER GERALD EVE LLP Update 2019 DUNDEE 140 WEST GEORGE STREET 26 March 2020 DD2 3QF GLASGOW G2 2HG 063 02WAY0184000 WAREHOUSE & OFFICE DUNDEE CITY COUNCIL £14,700 £14,700 £1 £1 724764 0002 UNIT 2 BROOMHILL ROAD/ PER AVISON YOUNG Update 2019 DUNSINANE AVENUE SUTHERLAND HOUSE 28 March 2020 DUNDEE 149 ST VINCENT STREET DD2 3QN GLASGOW G2 5NW 064 02WAY0443000 NURSERY SCHOOL DUNDEE CITY COUNCIL £39,400 £39,400 £1 £1 739935 0003 WOODLEA NURSERY PER AVISON YOUNG Update 2020 45 HAREFIELD ROAD SUTHERLAND HOUSE 04 November 2020 DUNDEE 149 ST VINCENT STREET DD2 3JY GLASGOW G2 5NW 065 02WAY0507000 DEPOT DUNDEE CITY COUNCIL £210,000 £210,000 £1 £1 107294 0002 MARCHBANKS PER AVISON YOUNG Update 2019 34 HAREFIELD ROAD SUTHERLAND HOUSE 30 March 2020 DUNDEE 149 ST VINCENT STREET DD2 3JX GLASGOW G2 5NW

Page 11 Assessor's Appellant's Case No Details & Contact Description & Situation Appellant NAV RV NAV RV Remarks

066 02WAY0623350 CO-LOCATION BUILDING VODAFONE LIMITED £32,800 £32,800 £1 £1 312103 0005 10A KILSPINDIE ROAD PER COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL Update 2019 DUNSINANE INDUSTRIAL ESTATE 6TH FLOOR 18 March 2020 DUNDEE 2 WEST REGENT STREET DD2 3JP GLASGOW G2 1RW 067 02WAY0623400 WAREHOUSE WPC TRUFF 18-7 B V £28,400 £28,400 311072 0003 10B KILSPINDIE ROAD PER RYDEN LLP Update 2019 DUNSINANE INDUSTRIAL ESTATE 130 ST VINCENT STREET 29 March 2020 DUNDEE GLASGOW DD2 3JP G3 5HF 068 02WAY0623500 WHOLESALE WAREHOUSE WPC TRUFF 18-7 B V £45,200 £45,200 310110 0003 10C-10D KILSPINDIE ROAD PER RYDEN LLP Update 2019 DUNSINANE INDUSTRIAL ESTATE 130 ST VINCENT STREET 29 March 2020 DUNDEE GLASGOW DD2 3JP G3 5HF 069 02WAY0623600 WAREHOUSE PLUMBSTORE LTD £36,500 £36,500 £1 304177 0003 12D KILSPINDIE ROAD PER WYM RATING Update 2019 DUNSINANE INDUSTRIAL ESTATE 22 HANOVER STREET 30 March 2020 DUNDEE EDINBURGH DD2 3JP EH2 2EP 070 02WAY0634000 YARD & OFFICE DRIVING STANDARDS AGENCY £48,900 £48,900 107674 0002 BLOCK 23 (PART) PER CUSHMAN & WAKEFIELD Update 2019 KILSPINDIE ROAD ONE EDINBURGH QUAY 31 March 2020 DUNSINANE INDUSTRIAL ESTATE FOUNTAINBRIDGE DUNDEE EDINBURGH DD2 3QH EH3 9QG 071 02WAY0653000 WAREHOUSE PPG ARCHITECTURAL COATINGS UK £31,600 £31,600 £1 £1 762197 0001 UNIT 1 LTD T/A JOHNSTONES Update 2019 KINGS CROSS TRADE PARK PER COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL 18 March 2020 KINGS CROSS ROAD 6TH FLOOR DUNDEE 2 WEST REGENT STREET DD2 3NU GLASGOW G2 1RW

Page 12 Assessor's Appellant's Case No Details & Contact Description & Situation Appellant NAV RV NAV RV Remarks

072 02WAY0653250 WAREHOUSE YESSS ELECTRICAL £43,000 £43,000 £1 313494 0002 UNIT 2 3 & 4 PER WYM RATING Update 2019 KINGS CROSS ROAD 22 HANOVER STREET 30 March 2020 DUNDEE EDINBURGH DD2 3NU EH2 2EP 073 02WAY0653400 WAREHOUSE TOOLSTATION LTD £29,700 £29,700 £1 £1 309109 0001 UNIT 5 PER ALDER KING LLP Update 2020 KINGS CROSS TRADE PARK 15 PEMBROKE ROAD 21 September 2020 KINGS CROSS ROAD CLIFTON DUNDEE BRISTOL DD2 3NU BS8 3BA 074 02WAZ0634000 YARD & OFFICE DUNDEE CITY COUNCIL £6,000 £6,000 £1 £1 108098 0002 OLD KINGS CROSS ROAD PER AVISON YOUNG Update 2019 DUNDEE SUTHERLAND HOUSE 28 March 2020 DD3 6AH 149 ST VINCENT STREET GLASGOW G2 5NW 075 02WAZ0648000 STORE DUNDEE CITY COUNCIL £1,200 £1,200 £1 £1 108451 0002 11 WHORTERBANK PER AVISON YOUNG Update 2019 DUNDEE SUTHERLAND HOUSE 28 March 2020 DD2 3AA 149 ST VINCENT STREET GLASGOW G2 5NW 076 03WAJ0041000 YARD DUNDEE CITY COUNCIL £3,100 £3,100 £1 £1 792193 0002 UNIT 2,3 PER AVISON YOUNG Update 2019 ANNFIELD ROW SUTHERLAND HOUSE 28 March 2020 DUNDEE 149 ST VINCENT STREET DD1 5JH GLASGOW G2 5NW 077 03WAJ0552500 SORTING OFFICE ROYAL MAIL GROUP LIMITED £40,500 £40,500 727626 0002 DUNDEE CENTRAL DELIVERY OFFICE PER GL HEARN Update 2019 EDWARD STREET 3RD FLOOR 31 March 2020 DUNDEE ONE GUILDHALL SQUARE DD1 5ZZ SOUTHAMPTON SO14 7FP

Page 13 Assessor's Appellant's Case No Details & Contact Description & Situation Appellant NAV RV NAV RV Remarks

078 03WAJ0943000 WORKSHOP DUNDEE CITY COUNCIL £4,650 £4,650 757530 0002 UNIT 04 PER AVISON YOUNG Update 2019 PEDDIE STREET SUTHERLAND HOUSE 28 March 2020 DUNDEE 149 ST VINCENT STREET DD1 5LB GLASGOW G2 5NW 079 03WAJ0952000 WORKSHOP DUNDEE CITY COUNCIL £4,650 £4,650 £1 £1 785919 0002 UNIT 17 CITY DEVELOPMENT DEPARTMENT Update 2019 PEDDIE STREET PER AVISON YOUNG 28 March 2020 DUNDEE SUTHERLAND HOUSE DD1 5LB 149 ST VINCENT STREET GLASGOW G2 5NW 080 03WAJ1200000 GARAGE HALFORDS AUTOCENTRES LTD £10,300 £10,300 086681 0002 13 URE STREET PER GERALD EVE LLP Update 2019 DUNDEE 140 WEST GEORGE STREET 26 March 2020 DD1 5JD GLASGOW G2 2HG 081 03WAL0609160 FACTORY W L GORE & ASSOCIATES (UK) LTD £207,250 £207,250 £1 £1 736900 0002 MARINER DRIVE PER AVISON YOUNG Update 2019 DUNDEE TECHNOLOGY PARK SUTHERLAND HOUSE 29 March 2020 DUNDEE 149 ST VINCENT STREET DD2 1JA GLASGOW G2 5NW 082 03WAL2032000 WAREHOUSE & OFFICE BRAKE BROS LIMITED £178,500 £178,500 787592 0002 WRIGHT AVENUE PER GERALD EVE LLP Update 2019 RIVERSIDE BUSINESS PARK 140 WEST GEORGE STREET 30 March 2020 DUNDEE GLASGOW DD2 1UD G2 2HG 083 03WAL2033000 WAREHOUSE & OFFICE AMAZON UK SERVICES £225,750 £225,750 762789 0003 WRIGHT AVENUE LTD - LOGISTICS Update 2019 RIVERSIDE BUSINESS PARK PER GL HEARN 31 March 2020 DUNDEE 3RD FLOOR DD2 1UD ONE GUILDHALL SQUARE SOUTHAMPTON SO14 7FP

Page 14 Assessor's Appellant's Case No Details & Contact Description & Situation Appellant NAV RV NAV RV Remarks

084 03WAL2036000 FACTORY CROCODILE (DUNDEE) N0 4 LTD £132,000 £132,000 754674 0005 WRIGHT AVENUE PER GRAHAM & SIBBALD Update 2019 RIVERSIDE BUSINESS PARK 40 TORPHICHEN STREET 31 March 2020 DUNDEE EDINBURGH DD2 1UR EH3 8JB 085 03WAL2036500 YARD BARNETTS PROPERTIES LTD £11,400 £11,400 310277 0003 WRIGHT AVENUE PER MONTAGU EVANS LLP Update 2019 RIVERSIDE BUSINESS PARK 302 ST VINCENT STREET 31 March 2020 DUNDEE GLASGOW DD2 1UR G2 5RU 086 03WBD0235000 FACTORY TORRIDON DEVELOPMENTS LTD £36,500 £36,500 721338 0001 LOCARNO WORKS PER JOHN GIBSON Update 2020 BROWN STREET 56 TORRIDON ROAD 16 October 2020 DUNDEE BROUGHTY FERRY DD1 5EE DUNDEE DD5 3JH 087 03WBD0354050 WORKSHOP TORRIDON DEVELOPMENTS LTD £26,400 £26,400 311004 0001 1A DOUGLAS STREET PER JOHN GIBSON Update 2020 DUNDEE 56 TORRIDON ROAD 16 October 2020 DD1 5AJ BROUGHTY FERRY DUNDEE DD5 3JH 088 03WBD0375900 SHOWROOM MANORGATE LTD £24,400 £24,400 312094 0002 UNIT 1 T/A DIRECT FLOORING Update 2019 DOUGLAS STREET PER BUSINESS RATES ADVICE 31 March 2020 DUNDEE 70 WEST REGENT STREET DD1 5AN GLASGOW G2 2QZ 089 03WBD0376000 WORKSHOP FIFE AUTOCENTRE LTD £30,300 £30,300 £15,150 £15,150 740143 0003 UNIT 1B T/A TAYSIDE AUTOCENTRE Update 2020 DOUGLAS STREET PER ANDREW REILLY ASSOCIATES LTD 18 June 2020 DUNDEE 31 RUTLAND SQUARE DD1 5AN EDINBURGH EH1 2BW

Page 15 Assessor's Appellant's Case No Details & Contact Description & Situation Appellant NAV RV NAV RV Remarks

090 03WBD0376100 OFFICE R & C GREIG PROPERTY £7,700 £7,700 £3,850 £3,850 312095 0002 UNIT 1C/1 PER ANDREW REILLY ASSOCIATES LTD Update 2020 DOUGLAS STREET 31 RUTLAND SQUARE 19 June 2020 DUNDEE EDINBURGH DD1 5AN EH1 2BW 091 03WBD0376110 WORKSHOP R & C GREIG PROPERTY £7,700 £7,700 £3,850 £3,850 312324 0002 UNIT 1C/2 PER ANDREW REILLY ASSOCIATES LTD Update 2020 DOUGLAS STREET 31 RUTLAND SQUARE 19 June 2020 DUNDEE EDINBURGH DD1 5AJ EH1 2BW 092 03WBD0376200 WAREHOUSE EASITYRE LTD £20,600 £20,600 £10,300 £10,300 312096 0003 UNIT 2 PER ANDREW REILLY ASSOCIATES LTD Update 2020 DOUGLAS STREET 31 RUTLAND SQUARE 18 June 2020 DUNDEE EDINBURGH DD1 5AN EH1 2BW 093 03WBD0416000 WORKS D C THOMSON & CO LTD £256,500 £256,500 084339 0002 WEST WARD WORKS PER F G BURNETT Update 2019 19 GUTHRIE STREET 33 ALBYN PLACE 26 March 2020 DUNDEE ABERDEEN DD1 5BR AB10 1YL 094 03WBD0564000 WORKSHOP DUNDEE CITY COUNCIL £4,450 £4,450 £1 £1 810680 0002 UNIT 03 PER AVISON YOUNG Update 2019 MILN STREET SUTHERLAND HOUSE 28 March 2020 DUNDEE 149 ST VINCENT STREET DD1 5DD GLASGOW G2 5NW 095 03WBD0565000 WORKSHOP DUNDEE CITY COUNCIL £9,600 £9,600 £1 £1 710630 0002 UNIT 04 PER AVISON YOUNG Update 2019 MILN STREET SUTHERLAND HOUSE 28 March 2020 DUNDEE 149 ST VINCENT STREET DD1 5DD GLASGOW G2 5NW

Page 16 Assessor's Appellant's Case No Details & Contact Description & Situation Appellant NAV RV NAV RV Remarks

096 03WBE0093000 SHOWROOM & OFFICE SALLY SALON SERVICES LIMITED £16,300 £16,300 £1 £1 728817 0007 HAWKHILL COURT UNIT A PER COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL Update 2019 MID WYND 6TH FLOOR 18 March 2020 DUNDEE 2 WEST REGENT STREET DD1 4JG GLASGOW G2 1RW 097 03WBE0093000 SHOWROOM & OFFICE WEST RANGA (DUNDEE) LIMITED £16,300 £16,300 £1 £1 728817 0006 HAWKHILL COURT UNIT A PER CBRE LIMITED Update 2019 MID WYND 149 ST VINCENT STREET 26 March 2020 DUNDEE GLASGOW DD1 4JG G2 5NW 098 03WBE0094050 WAREHOUSE WEST RANGA (DUNDEE) LIMITED £13,500 £13,500 £1 £1 313490 0004 UNIT B PER CBRE LIMITED Update 2019 HAWKHILL COURT 149 ST VINCENT STREET 26 March 2020 MID WYND GLASGOW DUNDEE G2 5NW DD1 4JG 099 03WBE0094100 WAREHOUSE WEST RANGA (DUNDEE) LIMITED £13,500 £13,500 £1 £1 313491 0004 UNIT C PER CBRE LIMITED Update 2019 HAWKHILL COURT 149 ST VINCENT STREET 26 March 2020 MID WYND GLASGOW DUNDEE G2 5NW DD1 4JG 100 03WBE0096000 WORKSHOP & SHOWROOM WEST RANGA (DUNDEE) LIMITED £22,800 £22,800 £1 £1 728820 0004 HAWKHILL COURT UNIT D PER CBRE LIMITED Update 2019 MID WYND 149 ST VINCENT STREET 26 March 2020 DUNDEE GLASGOW DD1 4JG G2 5NW 101 03WBE0097000 WORKSHOP WEST RANGA (DUNDEE) LIMITED £19,400 £19,400 £1 £1 772971 0004 HAWKHILL COURT UNIT E PER CBRE LIMITED Update 2019 MID WYND 149 ST VINCENT STREET 26 March 2020 DUNDEE GLASGOW DD1 4JG G2 5NW

Page 17 Assessor's Appellant's Case No Details & Contact Description & Situation Appellant NAV RV NAV RV Remarks

102 03WBE0098000 WORKSHOP WEST RANGA (DUNDEE) LIMITED £13,500 £13,500 £1 £1 737259 0004 HAWKHILL COURT UNIT F PER CBRE LIMITED Update 2019 MID WYND 149 ST VINCENT STREET 26 March 2020 DUNDEE GLASGOW DD1 4JG G2 5NW 103 03WBE0099000 WORKSHOP WEST RANGA (DUNDEE) LIMITED £18,100 £18,100 £1 £1 728823 0004 HAWKHILL COURT UNIT G PER CBRE LIMITED Update 2019 MID WYND 149 ST VINCENT STREET 26 March 2020 DUNDEE GLASGOW DD1 4JG G2 5NW 104 03WBE0100000 WORKSHOP WEST RANGA (DUNDEE) LIMITED £18,800 £18,800 £1 £1 728824 0003 HAWKHILL COURT UNIT H PER CBRE LIMITED Update 2019 MID WYND 149 ST VINCENT STREET 26 March 2020 DUNDEE GLASGOW DD1 4JG G2 5NW 105 03WBE0101000 WAREHOUSE WEST RANGA (DUNDEE) LIMITED £18,300 £18,300 £1 £1 730145 0004 HAWKHILL COURT UNIT J PER CBRE LIMITED Update 2019 MID WYND 149 ST VINCENT STREET 26 March 2020 DUNDEE GLASGOW DD1 4JG G2 5NW 106 03WBE0102000 WORKSHOP WEST RANGA (DUNDEE) LIMITED £17,900 £17,900 £1 £1 730146 0004 HAWKHILL COURT UNIT K PER CBRE LIMITED Update 2019 MID WYND 149 ST VINCENT STREET 26 March 2020 DUNDEE GLASGOW DD1 4JG G2 5NW 107 03WBE0105000 WORKSHOP DUNDEE CITY COUNCIL £6,900 £6,900 £1 £1 736864 0002 UNIT 03 PER AVISON YOUNG Update 2019 MID WYND SUTHERLAND HOUSE 28 March 2020 DUNDEE 149 ST VINCENT STREET DD1 4JG GLASGOW G2 5NW

Page 18 Assessor's Appellant's Case No Details & Contact Description & Situation Appellant NAV RV NAV RV Remarks

108 03WBE0106000 WORKSHOP DUNDEE CITY COUNCIL £6,900 £6,900 £1 £1 724604 0002 UNIT 04 PER AVISON YOUNG Update 2019 MID WYND SUTHERLAND HOUSE 28 March 2020 DUNDEE 149 ST VINCENT STREET DD1 4JG GLASGOW G2 5NW 109 03WBE0116000 WORKSHOP DUNDEE CITY COUNCIL £4,750 £4,750 £1 £1 727685 0002 UNIT 14 & 15 PER AVISON YOUNG Update 2019 MID WYND SUTHERLAND HOUSE 28 March 2020 DUNDEE 149 ST VINCENT STREET DD1 4JG GLASGOW G2 5NW 110 03WBE0117000 WORKSHOP DUNDEE CITY COUNCIL £2,450 £2,450 £1 £1 724616 0002 UNIT 16 PER AVISON YOUNG Update 2019 MID WYND SUTHERLAND HOUSE 28 March 2020 DUNDEE 149 ST VINCENT STREET DD1 4JG GLASGOW G2 5NW 111 03WBE0122000 WORKSHOP DUNDEE CITY COUNCIL £4,100 £4,100 £1 £1 724622 0002 UNIT 22 PER AVISON YOUNG Update 2019 MID WYND SUTHERLAND HOUSE 28 March 2020 DUNDEE 149 ST VINCENT STREET DD1 4JG GLASGOW G2 5NW 112 03WBG0541000 WORKSHOP DUNDEE CITY COUNCIL £14,200 £14,200 £1 710635 0002 LOGIE AVENUE PER AVISON YOUNG Update 2020 DUNDEE SUTHERLAND HOUSE 16 December 2020 DD2 2AS 149 ST VINCENT STREET GLASGOW G2 5NW 113 03WBG0554000 WORKSHOP DUNDEE CITY COUNCIL £8,700 £8,700 £1 £1 759561 0002 UNIT 2 PER AVISON YOUNG Update 2019 LOGIE AVENUE SUTHERLAND HOUSE 28 March 2020 DUNDEE 149 ST VINCENT STREET DD2 2AS GLASGOW G2 5NW

Page 19 Assessor's Appellant's Case No Details & Contact Description & Situation Appellant NAV RV NAV RV Remarks

114 03WBJ0349000 RETAIL WAREHOUSE NORTRUCK SERVICES LIMITED £20,300 £20,300 739745 0002 BALLINGALL AUTO CTRE UNITS 6,7 PER RYDEN LLP Update 2019 BREWERY LANE 130 ST VINCENT STREET 29 March 2020 DUNDEE GLASGOW DD1 5QW G3 5HF 115 04EBJ0140000 WORKSHOP & OFFICE DUNDEE CITY COUNCIL £4,550 £4,550 £1 £1 726875 0002 UNIT 06 ALEXANDER ST IND EST PER AVISON YOUNG Update 2019 ALEXANDER STREET SUTHERLAND HOUSE 28 March 2020 DUNDEE 149 ST VINCENT STREET DD3 7DA GLASGOW G2 5NW 116 04EBJ0142000 WORKSHOP & STORE DUNDEE CITY COUNCIL £2,350 £2,350 £1 £1 726931 0002 UNIT 08 ALEXANDER ST IND EST PER AVISON YOUNG Update 2019 ALEXANDER STREET SUTHERLAND HOUSE 28 March 2020 DUNDEE 149 ST VINCENT STREET DD3 7DA GLASGOW G2 5NW 117 04EBJ0144000 WORKSHOP & SHOWROOM DUNDEE CITY COUNCIL £2,350 £2,350 £1 £1 727709 0002 UNIT 10 ALEXANDER ST IND EST PER AVISON YOUNG Update 2019 ALEXANDER STREET SUTHERLAND HOUSE 28 March 2020 DUNDEE 149 ST VINCENT STREET DD3 7DA GLASGOW G2 5NW 118 04EBJ0148000 WORKSHOP DUNDEE CITY COUNCIL £2,350 £2,350 £1 £1 726880 0002 UNIT 15 ALEXANDER ST IND EST PER AVISON YOUNG Update 2019 ALEXANDER STREET SUTHERLAND HOUSE 28 March 2020 DUNDEE 149 ST VINCENT STREET DD3 7DA GLASGOW G2 5NW 119 04EBJ1167000 WORKSHOP & OFFICE DUNDEE CITY COUNCIL £6,400 £6,400 £1 £1 784449 0002 UNIT 20 PER AVISON YOUNG Update 2019 NORTH WELLINGTON STREET SUTHERLAND HOUSE 28 March 2020 DUNDEE 149 ST VINCENT STREET DD3 7DH GLASGOW G2 5NW

Page 20 Assessor's Appellant's Case No Details & Contact Description & Situation Appellant NAV RV NAV RV Remarks

120 04EBJ1169050 WORKSHOP DUNDEE CITY COUNCIL £5,700 £5,700 £1 £1 313391 0003 UNIT 22 PER AVISON YOUNG Update 2019 NORTH WELLINGTON STREET SUTHERLAND HOUSE 28 March 2020 DUNDEE 149 ST VINCENT STREET DD3 7EP GLASGOW G2 5NW 121 04EBJ1169100 WORKSHOP DUNDEE CITY COUNCIL £6,500 £6,500 £1 £1 313392 0002 UNIT 23 PER AVISON YOUNG Update 2019 NORTH WELLINGTON STREET SUTHERLAND HOUSE 28 March 2020 DUNDEE 149 ST VINCENT STREET DD3 7EP GLASGOW G2 5NW 122 04EBJ1183000 FACTORY LOW & BONAR DUNDEE LTD £187,250 £187,250 £94,000 £94,000 083174 0002 CALDRUM WORKS PER J & E SHEPHERD Update 2020 ST SALVADOR STREET 13 ALBERT SQUARE 28 April 2020 DUNDEE MEADOWSIDE DD3 7EU DUNDEE DD1 1XA 123 04EBO0502100 FACTORY DAY INTERNATIONAL (UK) LTD £260,000 £260,000 074819 0002 15A OLD GLAMIS ROAD PER PRESTON TAIT Update 2019 DUNDEE CRAIGBEITHE HOUSE 31 March 2020 DD3 8HN DUNKELD PERTHSHIRE PH8 0BW 124 04EBQ0375000 WAREHOUSE STEVENSWOOD LTD £11,100 £11,100 717019 0001 UNIT 02 PER CBRE LIMITED Update 2019 5 COLDSIDE ROAD 1 ALBYN TERRACE 31 March 2020 DUNDEE ABERDEEN DD3 8DF AB10 1YP 125 04EBQ0376000 WAREHOUSE STEVENSWOOD LTD £10,800 £10,800 717020 0001 UNIT 03 PER CBRE LIMITED Update 2019 5 COLDSIDE ROAD 1 ALBYN TERRACE 31 March 2020 DUNDEE ABERDEEN DD3 8DF AB10 1YP

Page 21 Assessor's Appellant's Case No Details & Contact Description & Situation Appellant NAV RV NAV RV Remarks

126 04EBQ0379000 WAREHOUSE PLUMBASE LTD £21,400 £21,400 £1 189857 0002 UNIT 06 PER WYM RATING Update 2019 5 COLDSIDE ROAD 22 HANOVER STREET 30 March 2020 DUNDEE EDINBURGH DD3 8DF EH2 2EP 127 04EBQ0380000 WAREHOUSE EDMUNDSON ELECTRICAL LTD £12,900 £12,900 £1 189858 0001 UNIT 07 PER WYM RATING Update 2019 5 COLDSIDE ROAD 22 HANOVER STREET 30 March 2020 DUNDEE EDINBURGH DD3 8DF EH2 2EP 128 04EBQ1099100 WORKSHOP DUNDEE CITY COUNCIL £10,500 £10,500 £1 £1 308185 0002 OLD GLAMIS ROAD EST UNIT 3 PER AVISON YOUNG Update 2020 40 OLD GLAMIS ROAD SUTHERLAND HOUSE 16 December 2020 DUNDEE 149 ST VINCENT STREET DD3 8JG GLASGOW G2 5NW 129 04EBQ1100000 WORKSHOP DUNDEE CITY COUNCIL £7,400 £7,400 £1 £1 753906 0002 OLD GLAMIS ROAD EST UNIT 4 PER AVISON YOUNG Update 2019 40 OLD GLAMIS ROAD SUTHERLAND HOUSE 28 March 2020 DUNDEE 149 ST VINCENT STREET DD3 8JQ GLASGOW G2 5NW 130 04EBQ1502000 WORKSHOP DUNDEE CITY COUNCIL £11,400 £11,400 £1 £1 112560 0002 UNIT C PER AVISON YOUNG Update 2019 207 STRATHMARTINE ROAD SUTHERLAND HOUSE 28 March 2020 DUNDEE 149 ST VINCENT STREET DD3 8PH GLASGOW G2 5NW 131 04EBQ1506000 WORKSHOP DUNDEE CITY COUNCIL £5,400 £5,400 £1 £1 112563 0002 UNIT H PER AVISON YOUNG Update 2019 207 STRATHMARTINE ROAD SUTHERLAND HOUSE 28 March 2020 DUNDEE 149 ST VINCENT STREET DD3 8PH GLASGOW G2 5NW

Page 22 Assessor's Appellant's Case No Details & Contact Description & Situation Appellant NAV RV NAV RV Remarks

132 04EBX0329000 WORKSHOP & OFFICE KEVIN MCGEE £31,600 £31,600 079874 0002 4 NORTH ISLA STREET T/A CITY BLINDS Update 2019 DUNDEE PER GRAHAM & SIBBALD 31 March 2020 DD3 7JQ 40 TORPHICHEN STREET EDINBURGH EH3 8JB 133 04EBX0336300 WORKSHOP CKS PROPERTIES LTD £5,700 £5,700 £2,850 £2,850 719479 0002 2C NORTH ISLA STREET KIRKTON ENTERPRISE CENTRE Update 2019 DUNDEE PER GRAHAM & SIBBALD 30 March 2020 DD3 7JQ 233 ST VINCENT STREET GLASGOW G2 5QY 134 04WAX0016000 STORES,OFFICE & WORKSHOP DUNDEE CITY COUNCIL £230,000 £230,000 £1 £1 108970 0003 PUBLIC WORKS DEPARTMENT PER AVISON YOUNG Update 2019 353-363 CLEPINGTON ROAD SUTHERLAND HOUSE 27 March 2020 DUNDEE 149 ST VINCENT STREET DD3 8PL GLASGOW G2 5NW 135 04WBA0004000 WAREHOUSE DINGBRO LTD £56,600 £56,600 106236 0002 56-60 BALFIELD ROAD PER RYDEN LLP Update 2019 DUNDEE 130 ST VINCENT STREET 29 March 2020 DD3 6AH GLASGOW G3 5HF 136 04WBA0625000 WAREHOUSE ETC ARMADILLO SELF STORAGE LTD £98,800 £98,800 724998 0002 UNIT 4 PER MONTAGU EVANS LLP Update 2019 30 LOONS ROAD 302 ST VINCENT STREET 30 March 2020 DUNDEE GLASGOW DD3 6AN G2 5RU 137 04WBN0963000 YARD EUROPEAN METAL RECYCLING LIMITED £15,600 £15,600 083029 0001 11 PATERSON STREET PER JONES LANG LASALLE Update 2019 DUNDEE 150 ST VINCENT STREET 31 March 2020 DD3 6QR GLASGOW G2 5ND

Page 23 Assessor's Appellant's Case No Details & Contact Description & Situation Appellant NAV RV NAV RV Remarks

138 04WBO0631000 STORE DUNDEE CITY COUNCIL £3,800 £3,800 £1 £1 736396 0002 STIRLING STREET PER AVISON YOUNG Update 2019 DUNDEE SUTHERLAND HOUSE 28 March 2020 DD3 6PH 149 ST VINCENT STREET GLASGOW G2 5NW 139 05EBF0322500 YARD ARNOLD CLARK AUTOMOBILES LTD £12,300 £12,300 304376 0004 MARKET STREET & PER MONTAGU EVANS LLP Update 2019 99 BROUGHTY FERRY ROAD 302 ST VINCENT STREET 30 March 2020 DUNDEE GLASGOW DD4 6JE G2 5RU 140 05EBF0555000 FACTORY PORT OF DUNDEE LTD £611,000 £611,000 048013 0002 EAST CAMPERDOWN STREET DUNDEE PORT OFFICE Update 2020 DUNDEE STANNERGATE ROAD 27 October 2020 DD1 3LG DUNDEE DD1 3LU 141 05EBF0568000 WHOLESALE WAREHOUSE SAINT-GOBAIN DELEGATION UK £97,000 £97,000 750971 0002 56 EAST DOCK STREET PER GERALD EVE LLP Update 2019 DUNDEE 140 WEST GEORGE STREET 25 March 2020 DD1 3JX GLASGOW G2 2HG 142 05EBF0995000 TRAINING CENTRE THE PRINCE'S TRUST £29,200 £29,200 £1 046230 0002 1B KEMBACK STREET PER WYM RATING Update 2019 DUNDEE 22 HANOVER STREET 30 March 2020 DD4 6ET EDINBURGH EH2 2EP 143 05EBF1123000 STORE DUNDEE CITY COUNCIL £10,200 £10,200 £1 £1 756803 0002 UNIT 4 MARKET MEWS PER AVISON YOUNG Update 2019 MARKET STREET SUTHERLAND HOUSE 28 March 2020 DUNDEE 149 ST VINCENT STREET DD1 3LA GLASGOW G2 5NW

Page 24 Assessor's Appellant's Case No Details & Contact Description & Situation Appellant NAV RV NAV RV Remarks

144 05EBF1125000 WORKSHOP DUNDEE CITY COUNCIL £10,200 £10,200 £1 £1 756805 0002 UNIT 6 MARKET MEWS PER AVISON YOUNG Update 2019 MARKET STREET SUTHERLAND HOUSE 28 March 2020 DUNDEE 149 ST VINCENT STREET DD1 3LA GLASGOW G2 5NW 145 05EBF1410500 YARD & STORE DUNDEE DECOMMISSIONING LTD £73,600 £73,600 £29,440 £29,440 310272 0001 STANNERGATE ROAD PER DM HALL LLP Update 2020 DUNDEE 17 CORSTORPHINE ROAD 20 October 2020 DD1 3LU EDINBURGH EH12 6DD 146 05EBG0132500 DEPOT ARNOLD CLARK AUTOMOBILES LTD £21,900 £21,900 043763 0003 EAST DOCK STREET PER MONTAGU EVANS LLP Update 2019 DUNDEE 302 ST VINCENT STREET 30 March 2020 DD1 3HA GLASGOW G2 5RU 147 05EBG0132550 GARAGE ARNOLD CLARK AUTOMOBILES LTD £72,300 £72,300 043738 0002 EAST DOCK STREET PER MONTAGU EVANS LLP Update 2019 DUNDEE 302 ST VINCENT STREET 30 March 2020 DD1 3HA GLASGOW G2 5RU 148 05EBG0132750 YARD CITY QUAY CAR SERVICES LTD £7,400 £7,400 £3,700 £3,700 305366 0003 FRUIT MARKET UNIT 5 PER J & E SHEPHERD Update 2019 EAST DOCK STREET 13 ALBERT SQUARE 30 March 2020 DUNDEE MEADOWSIDE DD1 3JN DUNDEE DD1 1XA 149 05EBG0132900 WAREHOUSE & OFFICE CITY QUAY CAR SERVICES LIMITED £14,500 £14,500 £7,250 £7,250 043761 0003 STANCE 5 THE FRUIT MARKET WEST END GARAGE (HONDA) LTD Update 2019 EAST DOCK STREET PER J & E SHEPHERD 30 March 2020 DUNDEE 13 ALBERT SQUARE DD1 3JN MEADOWSIDE DUNDEE DD1 1XA

Page 25 Assessor's Appellant's Case No Details & Contact Description & Situation Appellant NAV RV NAV RV Remarks

150 05EBG0152550 CAR PARK DUNDEE CITY COUNCIL £146,750 £146,750 £1 £1 310135 0003 MSCP PER AVISON YOUNG Update 2020 1 EAST WHALE LANE SUTHERLAND HOUSE 04 November 2020 DUNDEE 149 ST VINCENT STREET DD1 3JU GLASGOW G2 5NW 151 05EBG0570000 YARD DUNDEE CITY COUNCIL £10,100 £10,100 £1 £1 300118 0003 PRINCES STREET PER AVISON YOUNG Update 2019 DUNDEE SUTHERLAND HOUSE 28 March 2020 DD4 6BY 149 ST VINCENT STREET GLASGOW G2 5NW 152 05EBM0658100 FACTORY JOINERY & TIMBER £162,250 £162,250 312160 0002 UNIT 02 - 05 CREATIONS (65) LTD Update 2019 MANHATTAN WORKS PER GRAHAM & SIBBALD 31 March 2020 DUNDONALD STREET 233 ST VINCENT STREET DUNDEE GLASGOW DD3 7PY G2 5QY 153 05EBM0658100 FACTORY JOINERY & TIMBER £162,250 £162,250 312160 0003 UNIT 02 - 05 CREATIONS (65) LTD Update 2019 MANHATTAN WORKS PER GRAHAM & SIBBALD 31 March 2020 DUNDONALD STREET 40 TORPHICHEN STREET DUNDEE EDINBURGH DD3 7PY EH3 8JB 154 05EBM0668500 WAREHOUSE & OFFICE SHARP BUSINESS SYSTEMS UK PLC £19,300 £19,300 300866 0002 UNIT 09D PER CUSHMAN & WAKEFIELD Update 2019 MANHATTAN WORKS ONE EDINBURGH QUAY 31 March 2020 DUNDONALD STREET FOUNTAINBRIDGE DUNDEE EDINBURGH DD3 7PY EH3 9QG 155 05EBM0985000 FACTORY JACKSON STEEL £47,500 £47,500 £1 716955 0002 DENSFIELD WORKS STRUCTURES LIMITED Update 2019 TANNADICE STREET PER WYM RATING 30 March 2020 DUNDEE 22 HANOVER STREET DD3 7QP EDINBURGH EH2 2EP

Page 26 Assessor's Appellant's Case No Details & Contact Description & Situation Appellant NAV RV NAV RV Remarks

156 05EBY0483000 YARD DUNDEE CITY COUNCIL £4,400 £4,400 £1 £1 737800 0003 SOUTH SIDE OF PER AVISON YOUNG Update 2019 LANGLANDS STREET SUTHERLAND HOUSE 28 March 2020 DUNDEE 149 ST VINCENT STREET DD4 6SZ GLASGOW G2 5NW 157 05EBY0526000 DEPOT DUNDEE CITY COUNCIL £8,400 £8,400 £1 £1 760665 0002 19 MAITLAND STREET PER AVISON YOUNG Update 2019 DUNDEE SUTHERLAND HOUSE 28 March 2020 DD4 6RN 149 ST VINCENT STREET GLASGOW G2 5NW 158 05EXI0098000 STORE BOOTS UK LTD £1,800 £1,800 045396 0002 1/2 PER GL HEARN Update 2019 213 ALBERT STREET 3RD FLOOR 31 March 2020 DUNDEE ONE GUILDHALL SQUARE DD4 6QA SOUTHAMPTON SO14 7FP 159 05WBC0325500 STORE DUNDEE CITY COUNCIL £14,400 £14,400 £1 £1 309379 0002 12 CONSTITUTION ROAD PER AVISON YOUNG Update 2019 DUNDEE SUTHERLAND HOUSE 28 March 2020 DD1 1LL 149 ST VINCENT STREET GLASGOW G2 5NW 160 05WBC0373000 STORE DUNDEE CITY COUNCIL £270 £270 754635 0002 18 CRICHTON STREET PER AVISON YOUNG Update 2019 DUNDEE SUTHERLAND HOUSE 28 March 2020 DD1 3AN 149 ST VINCENT STREET GLASGOW G2 5NW 161 05WBC0765210 STANCE NOMINEE FOR OVERGATE £23,000 £23,000 £10 £10 324303 0001 OPPOSITE U15 (JERSEY) UNIT TRUST Update 2020 OVERGATE PER CBRE LIMITED 06 November 2020 DUNDEE 149 ST VINCENT STREET DD1 1UF GLASGOW G2 5NW

Page 27 Assessor's Appellant's Case No Details & Contact Description & Situation Appellant NAV RV NAV RV Remarks

162 05WBC0766200 STANCE PHOTO ME PLC £4,000 £4,000 803817 0004 UPPER MALL EAST GALLERY PER COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL Update 2020 OVERGATE 6TH FLOOR 20 May 2020 DUNDEE 2 WEST REGENT STREET DD1 1UG GLASGOW G2 1RW 163 05WBC1003000 SHOP MS LINDA P L LI £15,400 £15,400 £14,000 £14,000 086595 0002 17 UNION STREET PER FALCONER PROPERTY CONSULTANTS Update 2020 DUNDEE NETHERCRAIGS 17 February 2021 DD1 4BN ST DAVIDS MADDERTY CRIEFF PH7 3PJ 164 05WBC1327000 STORE THORNTONS LAW LLP £1,750 £1,750 302970 0002 STORE 1 & 2 PER J & E SHEPHERD Update 2019 FLOOR 2 WHITEHALL HOUSE 13 ALBERT SQUARE 31 March 2020 33-35 YEAMAN SHORE MEADOWSIDE DUNDEE DUNDEE DD1 4BJ DD1 1XA 165 05WBC1328000 STORE THORNTONS LAW LLP £1,150 £1,150 302971 0002 STORE 3 PER J & E SHEPHERD Update 2019 FLOOR 2 WHITEHALL HOUSE 13 ALBERT SQUARE 31 March 2020 33-35 YEAMAN SHORE MEADOWSIDE DUNDEE DUNDEE DD1 4BJ DD1 1XA 166 05WBC1328100 STORE THORNTONS LAW LLP £840 £840 312060 0002 STORE 4 PER J & E SHEPHERD Update 2019 FLOOR 2 WHITEHALL HOUSE 13 ALBERT SQUARE 31 March 2020 33-35 YEAMAN SHORE MEADOWSIDE DUNDEE DUNDEE DD1 4BJ DD1 1XA 167 05WBK0338000 DEPOT DUNDEE CITY COUNCIL £16,100 £16,100 £1 £1 801323 0002 GELLATLY STREET PER AVISON YOUNG Update 2019 DUNDEE SUTHERLAND HOUSE 28 March 2020 DD1 3DZ 149 ST VINCENT STREET GLASGOW G2 5NW

Page 28 Assessor's Appellant's Case No Details & Contact Description & Situation Appellant NAV RV NAV RV Remarks

168 05WBK0598000 DEPOT ENTERPRISE RENT-A-CAR £8,300 £8,300 780617 0002 MARY ANN LANE/ PER CUSHMAN & WAKEFIELD Update 2019 131 SEAGATE ONE EDINBURGH QUAY 31 March 2020 DUNDEE FOUNTAINBRIDGE DD1 2HW EDINBURGH EH3 9QG 169 05WBK0601007 YARD & STORE ARNOLD CLARK AUTOMOBILES LTD £37,200 £37,200 324355 0001 133-135 SEAGATE PER MONTAGU EVANS LLP Update 2020 DUNDEE 302 ST VINCENT STREET 17 February 2021 DD1 2HD GLASGOW G2 5RU 170 05WBK0777600 KIOSK PHOTO-ME INTERNATIONAL £10,000 £10,000 766614 0003 UNIT 11A LEVEL 2 PER COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL Update 2020 THE WELLGATE 6TH FLOOR 20 May 2020 DUNDEE 2 WEST REGENT STREET DD1 2DB GLASGOW G2 1RW 171 05WBK0781400 STORE ST JAMES'S PLACE UK PLC £2,250 £2,250 £10 £10 795280 0002 REMOTE STORE 2 PER CBRE LIMITED Update 2020 THE WELLGATE 149 ST VINCENT STREET 05 February 2021 DUNDEE GLASGOW DD1 2DB G2 5NW 172 06EAB0931000 OFFICE TRILLIUM (PRIME) LIMITED £353,000 £353,000 796896 0002 CLAVERHOUSE BUSINESS PARK PER CUSHMAN & WAKEFIELD Update 2019 6 JACK MARTIN WAY ONE EDINBURGH QUAY 31 March 2020 DUNDEE FOUNTAINBRIDGE DD4 9BZ EDINBURGH EH3 9QG 173 06EAS0090000 FACTORY MICHELIN SCOTLAND £2,020,000 £2,020,000 £500,000 £500,000 062402 0004 BALDOVIE ROAD INNOVATION PARC LTD (MSIP) Update 2020 DUNDEE PER RYDEN LLP 19 February 2021 DD4 8UQ 25 ALBYN PLACE ABERDEEN AB10 1YL

Page 29 Assessor's Appellant's Case No Details & Contact Description & Situation Appellant NAV RV NAV RV Remarks

174 06EAS0090000 FACTORY MICHELIN SCOTLAND £2,020,000 £2,020,000 £500,000 £500,000 062402 0005 BALDOVIE ROAD INNOVATION PARC LTD (MSIP) Update 2020 DUNDEE PER RYDEN LLP 19 February 2021 DD4 8UQ 25 ALBYN PLACE ABERDEEN AB10 1YL 175 06EAS0090000 FACTORY MICHELIN SCOTLAND £2,020,000 £2,020,000 £250,000 £250,000 062402 0006 BALDOVIE ROAD INNOVATION PARC LTD (MSIP) Update 2020 DUNDEE PER RYDEN LLP 19 February 2021 DD4 8UQ 25 ALBYN PLACE ABERDEEN AB10 1YL 176 06EAS0236000 LICENSED CLUB ETC MICHELIN SCOTLAND £29,400 £29,400 £5,000 £5,000 062421 0003 BALDOVIE HOUSE INNOVATION PARC LTD (MSIP) Update 2020 DRUMGEITH ROAD PER RYDEN LLP 19 February 2021 DUNDEE 25 ALBYN PLACE DD4 8UZ ABERDEEN AB10 1YL 177 06EAS0301000 REFUSE PLANT DUNDEE CITY COUNCIL £133,000 £133,000 £1 £1 717059 0002 FORTIES ROAD PER AVISON YOUNG Update 2019 BALDOVIE INDUSTRIAL ESTATE SUTHERLAND HOUSE 28 March 2020 DUNDEE 149 ST VINCENT STREET DD4 0NS GLASGOW G2 5NW 178 06EAS0304000 FACTORY REMBRAND TIMBER LTD £60,000 £60,000 £30,000 £30,000 062417 0002 SITE 2 PER ANDREW REILLY ASSOCIATES LTD Update 2020 WEST SIDE OF 31 RUTLAND SQUARE 17 June 2020 FORTIES ROAD EDINBURGH BALDOVIE INDUSTRIAL ESTATE EH1 2BW DUNDEE DD4 0NS

Page 30 Assessor's Appellant's Case No Details & Contact Description & Situation Appellant NAV RV NAV RV Remarks

179 06EAS0685000 YARD DUNDEE CITY COUNCIL £2,800 £2,800 £1 £1 812771 0002 SOUTH SIDE PER AVISON YOUNG Update 2019 PIPER STREET SUTHERLAND HOUSE 28 March 2020 BALDOVIE INDUSTRIAL ESTATE 149 ST VINCENT STREET DUNDEE GLASGOW DD4 0NT G2 5NW 180 06EAS0690000 REFUSE RECYCLING CENTRE DUNDEE CITY COUNCIL £28,200 £28,200 £1 £1 300980 0002 PIPER STREET PER AVISON YOUNG Update 2019 BALDOVIE INDUSTRIAL ESTATE SUTHERLAND HOUSE 28 March 2020 DUNDEE 149 ST VINCENT STREET DD4 0NT GLASGOW G2 5NW 181 06EAS0692000 WAREHOUSE & OFFICE EDEN SPRINGS UK LTD £10,400 £10,400 302979 0003 BLOCK 2 UNIT 1 PER RYDEN LLP Update 2019 PIPER STREET 130 ST VINCENT STREET 31 March 2020 BALDOVIE INDUSTRIAL ESTATE GLASGOW DUNDEE G3 5HF DD4 0NT 182 06EXA0026000 SCHOOL DUNDEE CITY COUNCIL £110,250 £110,250 £1 £1 070601 0003 MILL O' MAINS PRIMARY PER AVISON YOUNG Update 2020 BARNS OF CLAVERHOUSE ROAD SUTHERLAND HOUSE 04 November 2020 DUNDEE 149 ST VINCENT STREET DD4 9RD GLASGOW G2 5NW 183 06EXA0029000 FACTORY SAFEHOUSE HABITATS £109,500 £109,500 770859 0002 UNIT J (SCOTLAND) LIMITED Update 2019 STRATHMORE HOUSE PER WYM RATING 31 March 2020 CHARLES BOWMAN AVENUE 22 HANOVER STREET DUNDEE EDINBURGH DD4 9UB EH2 2EP 184 06EXA0030000 ARCHIVE DUNDEE CITY COUNCIL £177,000 £177,000 £1 £1 761115 0002 UNIT G PER AVISON YOUNG Update 2019 THE CHALMERS BUILDING SUTHERLAND HOUSE 28 March 2020 CHARLES BOWMAN AVENUE 149 ST VINCENT STREET DUNDEE GLASGOW DD4 9UB G2 5NW

Page 31 Assessor's Appellant's Case No Details & Contact Description & Situation Appellant NAV RV NAV RV Remarks

185 06EXA0033000 OFFICE & STORE DUNDEE CITY COUNCIL £102,250 £102,250 £1 £1 783362 0002 UNIT T PER AVISON YOUNG Update 2019 CHARLES BOWMAN AVENUE SUTHERLAND HOUSE 28 March 2020 DUNDEE 149 ST VINCENT STREET DD4 9UB GLASGOW G2 5NW 186 06EXA0150000 WORKSHOP DUNDEE CITY COUNCIL £15,000 £15,000 £1 £1 760936 0002 SLESSOR COURT UNIT 2 CITY DEVELOPMENT DEPARTMENT Update 2020 HIGHLAND CHIEF WAY PER AVISON YOUNG 15 December 2020 DUNDEE SUTHERLAND HOUSE DD4 9UA 149 ST VINCENT STREET GLASGOW G2 5NW 187 06EXA0152000 STORE & OFFICE DUNDEE CITY COUNCIL £18,500 £18,500 £1 £1 760938 0002 SLESSOR COURT UNIT 4 PER AVISON YOUNG Update 2019 HIGHLAND CHIEF WAY SUTHERLAND HOUSE 28 March 2020 DUNDEE 149 ST VINCENT STREET DD4 9UA GLASGOW G2 5NW 188 07EAM0263000 TELEPHONE ENGINEERING CENTRE B T GROUP PLC £74,300 £74,300 £1 £1 073927 0002 LONGTOWN ROAD PER COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL Update 2019 DUNDEE 6TH FLOOR 18 March 2020 DD4 8JU 2 WEST REGENT STREET GLASGOW G2 1RW 189 07EAM0264000 DEPOT NIXON HIRE £65,400 £65,400 £100 £100 781018 0002 LONGTOWN ROAD PER KNIGHT FRANK Update 2019 DUNDEE 4 ALBERT STREET 30 March 2020 DD4 8JU ABERDEEN AB25 1XQ 190 07EAM0269000 CONCRETE PLANT BREEDON AGGREGATES £24,000 £24,000 073966 0002 LONGTOWN STREET SCOTLAND LTD Update 2019 DUNDEE PER GERALD EVE LLP 30 March 2020 DD4 8LQ 140 WEST GEORGE STREET GLASGOW G2 2HG

Page 32 Assessor's Appellant's Case No Details & Contact Description & Situation Appellant NAV RV NAV RV Remarks

191 07EAM0274000 WAREHOUSE EURO CARPARTS LTD £33,300 £33,300 £1 713428 0003 UNIT A PER TURNER MORUM LLP Update 2019 LONGTOWN STREET 32-33 COWCROSS STREET 30 March 2020 DUNDEE LONDON DD4 8LQ EC1M 6DF 192 07EAM0274000 WAREHOUSE ALEXANDER D THOMSON £33,300 £33,300 713428 0002 UNIT A PER RYDEN LLP Update 2019 LONGTOWN STREET 130 ST VINCENT STREET 29 March 2020 DUNDEE GLASGOW DD4 8LQ G3 5HF 193 07EBC0069500 WAREHOUSE & SHOWROOM BARNARDO'S £24,800 £24,800 309062 0001 UNIT 3 & 4 PER GL HEARN Update 2019 142 ARBROATH ROAD 3RD FLOOR 31 March 2020 DUNDEE ONE GUILDHALL SQUARE DD4 7PU SOUTHAMPTON SO14 7FP 194 07EBC0908500 GARAGE D C THOMSON & CO LTD £116,000 £116,000 310104 0002 84 KINGSWAY EAST PER F G BURNETT Update 2019 DUNDEE 33 ALBYN PLACE 30 March 2020 DD4 8ED ABERDEEN AB10 1YL 195 07EBC1074800 WORKSHOP & OFFICE ARNOLD CLARK AUTOMOBILES LTD £65,700 £65,700 313589 0002 2 MID CRAIGIE ROAD PER MONTAGU EVANS LLP Update 2019 DUNDEE 302 ST VINCENT STREET 30 March 2020 DD4 7RH GLASGOW G2 5RU 196 07EBC1075000 FACTORY ASHTEAD PLANT HIRE CO LTD £28,000 £28,000 £1 £1 074065 0002 5 MID CRAIGIE ROAD PER COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL Update 2019 DUNDEE 6TH FLOOR 18 March 2020 DD4 7RH 2 WEST REGENT STREET GLASGOW G2 1RW

Page 33 Assessor's Appellant's Case No Details & Contact Description & Situation Appellant NAV RV NAV RV Remarks

197 07EBC1080000 STORE & OFFICE SAINT-GOBAIN DELEGATION UK £30,600 £30,600 £10 £10 074068 0002 MID CRAIGIE ROAD PER LAMBERT SMITH HAMPTON Update 2020 DUNDEE 2ND FLOOR 17 June 2020 DD4 7RN 41-51 GREY STREET NEWCASTLE UPON TYNE NE1 6EE 198 07EBC1082000 WAREHOUSE ETC KEYLINE BUILDERS MERCHANTS LTD £87,200 £87,200 074064 0002 MID CRAIGIE ROAD PER CUSHMAN & WAKEFIELD Update 2019 DUNDEE ONE EDINBURGH QUAY 31 March 2020 DD4 7RH FOUNTAINBRIDGE EDINBURGH EH3 9QG 199 07EBC1281000 FACTORY DUNDEE CHEMICALS LTD £39,800 £39,800 804999 0002 SHED 34 PER WYM RATING Update 2019 PRINCE CHARLES WHARF 22 HANOVER STREET 30 March 2020 STANNERGATE ROAD EDINBURGH DUNDEE EH2 2EP DD1 3NA 200 07EBC1281050 WORKSHOP AUGEAN NORTH SEA SERVICES £93,900 £93,900 £40,000 £40,000 321360 0001 SHED 1 & 2 PER RYDEN LLP Update 2020 STANNERGATE ROAD 25 ALBYN PLACE 06 October 2020 DUNDEE ABERDEEN DD1 3NA AB10 1YL 201 07EBC1281100 WORKSHOP AUGEAN NORTH SEA SERVICES £92,700 £92,700 £40,000 £40,000 321361 0001 SHED 36 PER RYDEN LLP Update 2020 STANNERGATE ROAD 25 ALBYN PLACE 06 October 2020 DUNDEE ABERDEEN DD1 3NA AB10 1YL 202 07EBD0769000 STORE DUNDEE CITY COUNCIL £1,350 £1,350 £1 £1 726151 0002 SOUTHAMPTON ROAD PER AVISON YOUNG Update 2019 DUNDEE SUTHERLAND HOUSE 28 March 2020 DD4 7PN 149 ST VINCENT STREET GLASGOW G2 5NW

Page 34 Assessor's Appellant's Case No Details & Contact Description & Situation Appellant NAV RV NAV RV Remarks

203 07EBS0177500 DEPOT DUNDEE CITY COUNCIL £1,150 £1,150 £1 £1 061305 0002 BALUNIE DRIVE PER AVISON YOUNG Update 2019 DUNDEE SUTHERLAND HOUSE 28 March 2020 DD4 8UX 149 ST VINCENT STREET GLASGOW G2 5NW 204 07EBS0178000 WAREHOUSE & SHOWROOM GRAFTON MERCHANTING GB LIMITED £99,500 £99,500 £1 189801 0002 BALUNIEFIELD INDUSTRIAL ESTATE PER WYM RATING Update 2019 BALUNIE DRIVE 22 HANOVER STREET 30 March 2020 DUNDEE EDINBURGH DD4 8XE EH2 2EP 205 07EBT0474010 WORKSHOP & YARD ASHTEAD PLANT HIRE COMPANY LTD £33,000 £33,000 £1 £1 811003 0002 UNIT 4B PER COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL Update 2019 BALUNIEFIELD INDUSTRIAL ESTATE 6TH FLOOR 18 March 2020 BALUNIE DRIVE 2 WEST REGENT STREET DUNDEE GLASGOW DD4 8UT G2 1RW 206 07EBT0475010 WAREHOUSE & OFFICE REMBRAND TIMBER LTD £18,900 £18,900 313496 0002 UNIT 5 PER ANDREW REILLY ASSOCIATES LTD Update 2020 BALUNIEFIELD INDUSTRIAL ESTATE 31 RUTLAND SQUARE 18 June 2020 BALUNIE DRIVE EDINBURGH DUNDEE EH1 2BW DD4 8UT 207 07EBT0475050 WAREHOUSE & OFFICE REMBRAND TIMBER LTD £23,200 £23,200 313497 0002 UNIT 6 & 7 PER ANDREW REILLY ASSOCIATES LTD Update 2020 BALUNIEFIELD INDUSTRIAL ESTATE 31 RUTLAND SQUARE 18 June 2020 BALUNIE DRIVE EDINBURGH DUNDEE EH1 2BW DD4 8UT 208 07EBT0475100 WAREHOUSE REMBRAND TIMBER LTD £14,600 £14,600 £7,300 £7,300 313498 0002 UNIT 8 PER ANDREW REILLY ASSOCIATES LTD Update 2020 BALUNIEFIELD INDUSTRIAL ESTATE 31 RUTLAND SQUARE 03 February 2021 BALUNIE DRIVE EDINBURGH DUNDEE EH1 2BW DD4 8UT

Page 35 Assessor's Appellant's Case No Details & Contact Description & Situation Appellant NAV RV NAV RV Remarks

209 07EBT0475150 WAREHOUSE REMBRAND TIMBER LTD £17,600 £17,600 £8,800 £8,800 313499 0002 UNIT 9 PER ANDREW REILLY ASSOCIATES LTD Update 2020 BALUNIEFIELD INDUSTRIAL ESTATE 31 RUTLAND SQUARE 18 June 2020 BALUNIE DRIVE EDINBURGH DUNDEE EH1 2BW DD4 8UT 210 08ACD0002000 WAREHOUSE & OFFICE GILLIES OF BROUGHTY FERRY LTD £54,900 £54,900 733917 0002 9 AINSLIE STREET PER GRAHAM & SIBBALD Update 2020 WEST PITKERRO INDUSTRIAL EST 233 ST VINCENT STREET 21 January 2021 DUNDEE GLASGOW DD5 3RR G2 5QY 211 08ACD0002500 OFFICE NATIONAL OILWELL VARCO UK LTD £48,700 £48,700 311130 0003 11 AINSLIE STREET PER BNP PARIBAS REAL ESTATE Update 2019 WEST PITKERRO INDUSTRIAL EST FIRST FLOOR (SUITE 1) 31 March 2020 DUNDEE EXCHANGE PLACE DD5 3RR GLASGOW G1 3AN 212 08ACD0006000 WORKSHOP & OFFICE EASTERN WESTERN MOTOR GROUP LTD £65,800 £65,800 796962 0003 UNIT 2A PER MONTAGU EVANS LLP Update 2019 AINSLIE STREET 302 ST VINCENT STREET 30 March 2020 WEST PITKERRO INDUSTRIAL EST GLASGOW DUNDEE G2 5RU DD5 3RR 213 08ACD0007000 WAREHOUSE & SHOWROOM GILLIES OF BROUGHTY FERRY LTD £162,500 £162,500 737254 0002 UNITS 1-6 PER GRAHAM & SIBBALD Update 2020 AINSLIE STREET INVERALMOND HOUSE 21 January 2021 WEST PITKERRO INDUSTRIAL EST 200 DUNKELD ROAD DUNDEE PERTH DD5 3RR PH1 3AQ 214 08ACD0167000 BAKERY GOODFELLOW & STEVEN GROUP LTD £51,800 £51,800 737659 0002 FOWLER ROAD PER GRAHAM & SIBBALD Update 2019 WEST PITKERRO INDUSTRIAL EST 40 TORPHICHEN STREET 31 March 2020 DUNDEE EDINBURGH DD5 3RU EH3 8JB

Page 36 Assessor's Appellant's Case No Details & Contact Description & Situation Appellant NAV RV NAV RV Remarks

215 08ACD0168000 DEPOT ABF GRAIN PRODUCTS LTD £89,800 £89,800 795573 0002 FOWLER ROAD PROPERTY DEPARTMENT Update 2019 WEST PITKERRO INDUSTRIAL EST PER JONES LANG LASALLE 31 March 2020 DUNDEE 150 ST VINCENT STREET DD5 3RU GLASGOW G2 5ND 216 08ACD0169000 FACTORY METALTECH UK LTD £55,400 £55,400 791488 0002 UNIT 6 PER GRAHAM & SIBBALD Update 2019 FOWLER ROAD 40 TORPHICHEN STREET 31 March 2020 WEST PITKERRO INDUSTRIAL EST EDINBURGH DUNDEE EH3 8JB DD5 3RU 217 08ACD0171000 FACTORY MALCOLM OGILVIE & CO LTD £195,250 £195,250 765588 0002 FOWLER ROAD T/A RAVENSBY GLASS CO LTD Update 2019 WEST PITKERRO INDUSTRIAL EST PER GRAHAM & SIBBALD 31 March 2020 DUNDEE 40 TORPHICHEN STREET DD5 3RU EDINBURGH EH3 8JB 218 08ACD0172900 YARD JACKSON STEEL STRUCTURES LTD £9,600 £9,600 £1 312081 0002 FOWLER ROAD PER WYM RATING Update 2019 WEST PITKERRO INDUSTRIAL EST 22 HANOVER STREET 30 March 2020 DUNDEE EDINBURGH DD5 3RU EH2 2EP 219 08ACD0175000 WORKS BROWN & TAWSE STEELSTOCK LTD £310,000 £310,000 785038 0003 FOWLER ROAD PER GRAHAM & SIBBALD Update 2019 WEST PITKERRO INDUSTRIAL EST 40 TORPHICHEN STREET 31 March 2020 DUNDEE EDINBURGH DD5 3RU EH3 8JB 220 08ACD0175000 WORKS BROWN & TAWSE STEELSTOCK LTD £310,000 £310,000 £162,000 £162,000 785038 0002 FOWLER ROAD PER GRAHAM & SIBBALD Update 2020 WEST PITKERRO INDUSTRIAL EST 40 TORPHICHEN STREET 06 May 2020 DUNDEE EDINBURGH DD5 3RU EH3 8JB

Page 37 Assessor's Appellant's Case No Details & Contact Description & Situation Appellant NAV RV NAV RV Remarks

221 08ACD0179000 WORKSHOP & OFFICE METALTECH UK LTD £59,700 £59,700 805454 0002 UNIT 2 PER GRAHAM & SIBBALD Update 2019 FOWLER ROAD 40 TORPHICHEN STREET 31 March 2020 WEST PITKERRO INDUSTRIAL EST EDINBURGH DUNDEE EH3 8JB DD5 3RU 222 08ACD0180000 WORKSHOP & OFFICE MALCOLM, OGILVIE & CO LTD £71,100 £71,100 798460 0002 CONSTABLE WORKS PER GRAHAM & SIBBALD Update 2019 FOWLER ROAD 40 TORPHICHEN STREET 31 March 2020 WEST PITKERRO INDUSTRIAL EST EDINBURGH DUNDEE EH3 8JB DD5 3RU 223 08ACD0182000 FACTORY ANGUS DECORATING COMPANY LTD £29,100 £29,100 300984 0003 PITKERRO PARK UNIT 1 PER GRAHAM & SIBBALD Update 2019 FOWLER ROAD 40 TORPHICHEN STREET 31 March 2020 WEST PITKERRO INDUSTRIAL EST EDINBURGH DUNDEE EH3 8JB DD5 3RU 224 08ACD0183000 WORKSHOP & OFFICE ANGUS DECORATING COMPANY LTD £30,200 £30,200 303278 0002 PITKERRO PARK UNIT 2 PER GRAHAM & SIBBALD Update 2019 FOWLER ROAD 40 TORPHICHEN STREET 31 March 2020 WEST PITKERRO INDUSTRIAL EST EDINBURGH DUNDEE EH3 8JB DD5 3RU 225 08ACD0184000 WORKSHOP ANGUS DECORATING COMPANY LTD £20,800 £20,800 303279 0002 PITKERRO PARK UNIT 3 PER GRAHAM & SIBBALD Update 2019 FOWLER ROAD 40 TORPHICHEN STREET 31 March 2020 WEST PITKERRO INDUSTRIAL EST EDINBURGH DUNDEE EH3 8JB DD5 3RU 226 08ACD0185000 WAREHOUSE & OFFICE ANGUS DECORATING COMPANY LTD £27,300 £27,300 303280 0002 PITKERRO PARK UNIT 4 PER GRAHAM & SIBBALD Update 2019 FOWLER ROAD 40 TORPHICHEN STREET 31 March 2020 WEST PITKERRO INDUSTRIAL EST EDINBURGH DUNDEE EH3 8JB DD5 3RU

Page 38 Assessor's Appellant's Case No Details & Contact Description & Situation Appellant NAV RV NAV RV Remarks

227 08ACD0186000 WAREHOUSE & OFFICE ANGUS DECORATING COMPANY LTD £21,900 £21,900 303281 0003 PITKERRO PARK UNIT 5 PER GRAHAM & SIBBALD Update 2019 FOWLER ROAD 40 TORPHICHEN STREET 31 March 2020 WEST PITKERRO INDUSTRIAL EST EDINBURGH DUNDEE EH3 8JB DD5 3RU 228 08ACD0221000 SORTING OFFICE ROYAL MAIL GROUP LIMITED £60,100 £60,100 750740 0002 IVORY PLACE PER GL HEARN Update 2019 WEST PITKERRO INDUSTRIAL EST 3RD FLOOR 31 March 2020 DUNDEE ONE GUILDHALL SQUARE DD5 3RY SOUTHAMPTON SO14 7FP 229 08ACD0259000 FACTORY DUNDEE CITY COUNCIL £38,500 £38,500 £1 £1 795662 0004 BLK 1 (3) PER AVISON YOUNG Update 2019 PEARCE AVENUE SUTHERLAND HOUSE 28 March 2020 WEST PITKERRO INDUSTRIAL EST 149 ST VINCENT STREET DUNDEE GLASGOW DD5 3RX G2 5NW 230 08ACD0260215 WAREHOUSE & OFFICE DRS MOVING & STORAGE LTD £23,300 £23,300 313309 0002 BLOCK 2 UNIT 1D PER GRAHAM & SIBBALD Update 2019 PEARCE AVENUE 40 TORPHICHEN STREET 31 March 2020 WEST PITKERRO INDUSTRIAL EST EDINBURGH DUNDEE EH3 8JB DD5 3RX 231 08ACD0414000 WAREHOUSE & OFFICE HILLCREST HOMES £47,100 £47,100 797050 0002 CHALMERS HOUSE PER GRAHAM & SIBBALD Update 2019 5 TOM JOHNSTON ROAD 40 TORPHICHEN STREET 31 March 2020 WEST PITKERRO INDUSTRIAL EST EDINBURGH DUNDEE EH3 8JB DD4 8XD 232 08ACD0444000 STORE CASTLECROFT SECURITIES LTD £123,600 £123,600 800956 0003 KEEPSAFE STORAGE CENTRE PER GRAHAM & SIBBALD Update 2019 4 TOM JOHNSTON ROAD 40 TORPHICHEN STREET 31 March 2020 WEST PITKERRO INDUSTRIAL EST EDINBURGH DUNDEE EH3 8JB DD4 8XD

Page 39 Assessor's Appellant's Case No Details & Contact Description & Situation Appellant NAV RV NAV RV Remarks

233 08ACD0444000 STORE CASTLECROFT SECURITIES LTD £131,250 £131,250 800956 0004 KEEPSAFE STORAGE CENTRE PER GRAHAM & SIBBALD Update 2020 4 TOM JOHNSTON ROAD 233 ST VINCENT STREET 27 January 2021 WEST PITKERRO INDUSTRIAL EST GLASGOW DUNDEE G2 5QY DD4 8XD 234 08ACD0448000 FACTORY RAVENSBY GLASS CO LTD £265,000 £265,000 783162 0002 8 TOM JOHNSTON ROAD PER GRAHAM & SIBBALD Update 2019 WEST PITKERRO INDUSTRIAL EST 40 TORPHICHEN STREET 31 March 2020 DUNDEE EDINBURGH DD4 8XD EH3 8JB 235 08ACD0453000 OFFICE & WORKSHOP 5SR PROPERTY HOLDINGS LTD £63,300 £63,300 801094 0001 S R HOUSE SR HOUSE Update 2019 18 TOM JOHNSTON ROAD 18 TOM JOHNSTON ROAD 31 March 2020 WEST PITKERRO INDUSTRIAL EST WEST PITKERRO INDUSTRIAL EST DUNDEE DUNDEE DD4 8XD DD4 8XD 236 08EAW1099000 GARAGE & YARD STEPHEN RUSSELL £17,300 £17,300 £8,650 £8,650 053166 0001 WEST SIDE OF PER J & E SHEPHERD Update 2020 PANMURE STREET 13 ALBERT SQUARE 04 February 2021 BROUGHTY FERRY MEADOWSIDE DUNDEE DUNDEE DD5 2ER DD1 1XA

Page 40