sign in sign up
<<
Home , Bingley, Menston

Parish Council Planning Committee Meeting Thursday 2nd March 2017 at 8.00pm

MINUTES

Present: Councillors Gordon Metcalfe (Chairman), Philip Moore, Peter Finlay, Lilias McCulloch, David Naylor and Dale Smith

Clerk: Catriona Hanson

P2017/013 Apologies for absence Apologies for absence were received and accepted from Councillor Mackenzie.

P2017/014 Disclosures of interest Councillors McCulloch and Moore disclosed their membership of the Menston Action Group in relation to any discussions about the proposed developments on Derry Hill and Road.

P2017/015 Public consultation Six members of the public were present. One local resident attended the meeting to comment on the planning application for Moorland Crescent.

Steve Ellams had attended a meeting of Burley Parish Council to discuss two outline planning applications for land close to the Menston Parish Council boundary on Road at Burley in . Burley Parish Council had paid for a speed check exercise to be carried out on Bradford Road and used this data to support their objections to these applications.

Concerns were raised about traffic speeds on Bingley Road. It was agreed to write to Simon D’Vali at Bradford Council to express the Parish Council’s concerns, to advise him that Chartford Homes share these concerns and to ask Bradford Council to consider acting on these concerns. It was also agreed to approach Chartford Homes to ask if they would be interested in borrowing the Parish Council’s Speed Indicator Device to monitor traffic speeds passing their building site.

Councillor Metcalfe agreed to attend the joint Parish Council meeting at on 15th March, in place of Councillor Finlay.

P2017/016 Minutes of the previous meeting and progress report RESOLVED that the minutes of Menston Parish Council’s Planning Committee meeting held on 26th January 2017 be agreed and accepted and signed by the Chairman of the meeting. Proposed: Councillor Metcalfe

P2017/017 Outcome of previous planning applications The Clerk was asked to contact Bradford Council’s Planning Department to ask about the current position for 3 Park Dale and 99 Bradford Road.

Planning ref Site location Brief description of proposal Outcome no 16/07521/FUL Anley Clarence Demolition of existing garage Refused Drive Menston and construction of detached dwelling and garage/store/gym 16/08877/FUL 3 Park Dale Construction of detached Pending Menston dwelling with associated consideration parking 16/09138/HOU 20 Newfield Drive Single storey side and rear Granted Menston extensions West 16/09319/HOU Stone Lea Leathley Construction of single Granted Lane Menston extensions to sides and Ilkley second storey extension to the rear 16/09344/FUL High Ash Bingley Change of use of existing Granted Road Menston entrance and roadway from Ilkley agricultural to agricultural and business (in connection with change of use of existing building on adjoining site within Council District) 16/07754/FU High Ash Bingley Change of use of agricultural Pending (Leeds City Road Menston building to form office use consideration Council Ilkley application) The Parish Council objected to this application

16/09394/PNH Moelfre Burley Construction of single storey Prior approval not Road Menston rear extension of the following required Ilkley dimensions:- Depth of extension from original rear wall: 3.63m Maximum height of extension: 3.7m Height to eaves of extension: 3.0m 16/09442/HOU 2 And 4 Two storey side extension to Granted Westbourne Drive No 2. and double gable Menston Ilkley alteration to dormer and bay windows to rear (of Nos 2. and 4.) 16/09592/HOU 17 Buckle Lane Ground floor rear extension Pending Menston Ilkley and ground & first floor side consideration West Yorkshire extension. 17/00060/HOU 19 Walker Road Construction of ground floor Pending Menston Ilkley extension consideration West Yorkshire 17/00076/HOU 41 Ellar Gardens Rear extension to bungalow. Pending Menston Ilkley consideration West Yorkshire Planning ref Site location Brief description of proposal Outcome no

17/00091/HOU Pinfold Cottage 21 Construction of sunroom to Pending Main Street rear. consideration Menston Ilkley 17/00155/HOU 1 Bleach Mill Lane Single storey side extension Pending Menston Ilkley and new entrance gate consideration West Yorkshire 17/00098/FUL 99 Bradford Road Change of use to create four Pending Menston Ilkley residential units and consideration West Yorkshire construction of a side extension 17/00127/HOU Moorlands Moor Construction of single storey Pending Lane Menston side extension with external consideration Ilkley roof terrace

P2017/018 Planning applications considered

Planning ref no Site location Brief description of Outcome proposal 17/00271/FUL Malt Shovel 32 External and internal Menston Parish Council Main Street alterations and welcome the proposal to Menston Ilkley refurbishment including refurbish this property new window and door however question the openings, disabled adequacy of the parking access and ramp, provision because of the external lighting, loss of existing parking to smoking area and patio the front in order to to the front provide the seated area. The area to the south east of the rear carpark believed to be in ownership of the applicant is not included within the red line. This area would the shortfall of parking provision however confirmation of the intended use of this area should be sought. 17/00272/LBC As above As above

17/00524/HOU Hebden 2 Construction of single Menston Parish Council Moorland storey extension to rear recommends that the Crescent with balcony and porch plans should be amended Menston Ilkley to front with loft to show the dormer conversion and dormer window as a velux to rear window which is more in keeping with properties in the neighbourhood. Planning ref no Site location Brief description of Outcome proposal 17/00536/HOU 13 Newfield Drive Alterations and No objections Menston Ilkley construction of single West Yorkshire storey rear extension

17/00832/HOU 2 Newall Close Rear extension No objections Menston Ilkley West Yorkshire

17/00989/CLP 40 Moorland Loft conversion/rear The application drawing Drive dormers does not show the elevations correctly however the Parish Council concur with the Residents Association that the incorporation of two storey dormers on two storey houses is out of keeping with the immediate neighbourhood and therefore the application should be refused. 17/00729/HOU 9 Buckle Lane Single storey side and The Parish Council rear extension objects to this planning application as the side extension has the potential to create a terracing effect which it totally out of character with the rest of the street scene

P2017/019 Planning Panel None.

P2017/020 To report any progress on Bradford Council’s Local Plan None.

P2017/021 To receive an update about the Neighbourhood Development Plan A response had recently been received from Andrew Marshall at Bradford Council. It was agreed that Councillor Metcalfe would forward the response to David Rhodes and prepare a joint response.

P2017/022 Proposed Derry Hill/Moor Lane and Bingley Road developments This item was discussed under item P2017/021

P2017/023 Chairman’s remarks and correspondence None.

P2017/024 Date of next meeting It was agreed that the meeting will take place on Thursday 30th March 2017 following the Parish Council meeting which starts at 7.00pm in Room 17 at Kirklands.

There was no further business and the meeting closed at 9.25pm.