DOCSLIB.ORG

Nation Building in Russia a Study Into Secondary School Geography Education As Tool for Nation Building of the Youth in Russia

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Nation Building in Russia a Study Into Secondary School Geography Education As Tool for Nation Building of the Youth in Russia Nation Building in Russia A study into secondary school geography education as tool for nation building of the youth in Russia Jacques Bazen MSc 0 Colophon: Author: Jacob Cornelis Bazen MSc Student number: 9722432 Nation Building in Russia: A study into Secondary School Geography education as tool for nation building of the youth in Russia Cover illustration: Map of Russia in the world economic system, source: Dronov & Rom (2012), p. 55 Master thesis, for obtaining an MA degree in Geo-information and Communication at the Department of Human Geography, Faculty of Geosciences Utrecht University, The Netherlands Academic supervisor: Dr. L.J. Paul 1 Table of contents Summary ................................................................................................................................................. 7 Introduction ............................................................................................................................................ 8 1.1 Background ............................................................................................................................. 8 1.2 Introduction to nationalism and nation building .................................................................... 9 1.3 Relevance of the research..................................................................................................... 10 1.4 Research questions ............................................................................................................... 11 1.5 Structure of the report .......................................................................................................... 12 2 Research Methodology ................................................................................................................. 14 2.1 Introduction .......................................................................................................................... 14 2.2 Research type and design ..................................................................................................... 14 2.3 Research methods and operationalization of the conceptual model .................................. 15 2.3.1 Sub research question 1: The Russian national narrative ............................................. 15 2.3.2 Sub research question 2: The geography curriculum ................................................... 16 2.3.3 Sub research question 3: Developments in nation building activities in education ..... 16 2.3.4 Sub-research question 4: The role of the teacher ........................................................ 17 2.4 Response and non-response ................................................................................................. 17 2.5 Definitions and limitations of the research .......................................................................... 17 3 Nationalism and Education – theoretical framework ................................................................... 19 3.1 Introduction .......................................................................................................................... 19 3.2 Definitions of nationalism and nation building ..................................................................... 19 3.2.1 Origins of nationalism ................................................................................................... 19 3.2.2 Nationalism and nation building ................................................................................... 20 3.2.3 Nationalism and territory .............................................................................................. 21 3.2.4 Theories of nationalism................................................................................................. 22 3.2.5 Functions of nationalism ............................................................................................... 24 3.2.6 Types of nationalism ..................................................................................................... 25 3.3 Education and nation-building, a double edged sword ........................................................ 27 3.4 Conceptual model of nationalism and education ................................................................. 30 4 Russian history and development of nationalism ......................................................................... 33 4.1 Introduction .......................................................................................................................... 33 4.2 Russian history and the development of a national narrative ............................................. 33 4.2.1 Medieval history: Kievan Rus and the modern Russian and Ukrainian state ............... 34 4.2.2 The period of the Mongol “occupation” ....................................................................... 35 4.2.3 The formation of the Russian state ............................................................................... 36 4.2.4 “The times of troubles” ................................................................................................. 37 2 4.2.5 Russia becomes an empire ........................................................................................... 38 4.2.6 19th century reforms and the Russian revolution ......................................................... 40 4.2.7 The Great Patriotic War and the rise of the USSR as a superpower ............................. 43 4.2.8 The modern Russian Federation ................................................................................... 45 4.3 Russian nationalism in the context of Eastern Europe ......................................................... 49 4.4 Russian ethnic minorities and their national narratives ....................................................... 51 4.4.1 Ethnic minorities in Russia and their republics ............................................................. 51 4.4.2 Tatars ............................................................................................................................ 53 4.4.3 Ukrainians ..................................................................................................................... 54 4.4.4 Bashkir ........................................................................................................................... 55 4.4.5 Chuvash ......................................................................................................................... 56 4.4.6 Chechen ........................................................................................................................ 56 4.4.7 Armenians ..................................................................................................................... 57 5 Nation building in the Russian Education system ......................................................................... 59 5.1 Introduction .......................................................................................................................... 59 5.2 Characteristics of the Russian education system.................................................................. 59 5.3 Effectiveness of the Russian education system .................................................................... 61 5.4 From Soviet Union to Russia: Development of the Russian education system .................... 62 5.5 Geography in the Russian education system ........................................................................ 64 5.6 Description of the textbook contents ................................................................................... 68 5.6.1 Introduction of the textbooks ....................................................................................... 68 5.6.2 8th and 9th grade: Russia’s place in the world / Russian regions ................................... 69 5.6.3 10th and 11th grade: Geography of the World ............................................................... 98 5.6.4 Recent “Class Hour” teacher presentations on the enlargement of Russia ............... 102 6 Teachers and nation building – analysis of interviews ............................................................... 107 6.1 Introduction ........................................................................................................................ 107 6.2 Profile of the interviewees .................................................................................................. 107 6.3 Teachers and the development of the Russian national narrative ..................................... 108 6.4 Training and support for teachers ...................................................................................... 110 6.5 Education methods and ethnic diversity in class ................................................................ 111 7 Conclusions and discussion ......................................................................................................... 113 7.1 Conclusion ........................................................................................................................... 113 7.2 Discussion and recommendations for further research ..................................................... 114 Literature ............................................................................................................................................ 116 Annexes ............................................................................................................................................... 126 Annex 1. Structure of the Geographical
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Political Trends in Russia
    russian analytical russian analytical digest 60/09 digest analysis Fascist Tendencies in Russia’s Political Establishment: The Rise of the International Eurasian Movement By Andreas Umland, Eichstaett, Bavaria Abstract Aleksandr Dugin, a prominent advocate of fascist and anti-Western views, has risen from a fringe ideologue to deeply penetrate into Russian governmental offices, mass media, civil society and academia in ways that many in the West do not realize or understand. Prominent members of Russian society are affiliated with his International Eurasian Movement. Among Dugin’s most important collaborators are electronic and print media commentator Mikhail Leont’ev and the legendary TV producer and PR specialist Ivan Demidov. If Dugin’s views become more widely accepted, a new Cold War will be the least that the West should expect from Russia during the coming years. The Rise of Aleksandr Dugin course that must be taken seriously. Dugin’s numerous In recent years, various forms of nationalism have be- links to the political and academic establishments of a come a part of everyday Russian political and social life. number of post-Soviet countries, as well as institutions Since the end of the 1990s, an increasingly aggressive in Turkey, remain understudied or misrepresented. In racist sub-culture has been infecting sections of Russia’s other cases, Dugin and his followers receive more se- youth, and become the topic of numerous analyses by rious attention, yet are still portrayed as anachronis- Russian and non-Russian observers. Several new radi- tic, backward-looking imperialists – merely a partic- cal right-wing organizations, like the Movement Against ularly radical form of contemporary Russian anti-glo- Illegal Emigration, known by its Russian acronym balism.
    [Show full text]
  • Russia Country Report: Multicultural Experience in Education
    RUSSIA COUNTRY REPORT: MULTICULTURAL EXPERIENCE IN EDUCATION Leila Salekhova, Ksenia Grigorieva Kazan Federal University (RUSSIAN FEDERATION) Abstract The Russian Federation (RF) is a large country with the total area of 17,075,400 sq km. The RF has the world’s ninth-largest population of 146,600,000 people. According to the 2010 census, ethnic Russian people constitute up to 81% of the total population. In total, over 185 different ethnic groups live within the RF borders. Christianity, Islam, Buddhism, and Judaism are Russia’s traditional religions. Russia is a multinational and multicultural state. The large number of different ethnic groups represents the result of a complicated history of migrations, wars and revolutions. The ethnic diversity of Russia has significantly influenced the nature of its development and has had a strong influence on the state education policy. The article gives a detailed analysis of the key factors determining educational opportunities for different RF ethnic groups. A complicated ethnic composition of Russia’s population and its multi-confessional nature cause the educational system to fulfill educational, ethno-cultural and consolidating functions by enriching the educational content with ethnic peculiarities and at the same time providing students with an opportunity to study both in native (non-Russian) and non-native (Russian) languages. The paper provides clear and thorough description of Russian educational system emphasizing positive features like high literacy and educational rates especially in technical areas that are due to the results of the educational system functioning nowadays. Teacher education is provided in different types of educational institutions allowing their graduates to start working as teachers immediately after graduating.
    [Show full text]
  • The Fate of Russia: Several Observations on "New" Russian Identity
    THE FATE OF RUSSIA: SEVERAL OBSERVATIONS ON "NEW" RUSSIAN IDENTITY S. V. Kortunov Introduction Russia is going through a complicated historical period. A search is taking place for the optimal path of development and the best form of state structure. Social-economic ties are changing in a fundamental manner. Along with the not insignificant positive results of the political and economic reforms that are being carried out, negative processes in the economy, in the social sphere and in the relations between the center and the regions are becoming clearly evident. On the international arena, Russia is confronting the desire of a number of countries to use the transitional period to promote their economic and political interests, often to the detriment of Russians' national aspirations. Three overarching factors characterize the Russian domestic situation: the continuing systematic crisis in society, which began in the Soviet period; the country's development crisis, which appeared during the transitional period; and the difficulties of overcoming the residues of the former totalitarian regime. (These problems are in turn linked to the global crisis that has resulted from the collapse of the Cold War order.) It is obvious that the contemporary crisis is on a larger scale than the problems associated with the February and October 1917 Revolutions, the abolition of serfdom, and even the Time of Troubles. We are discussing a crisis that is comparable only to the epic transformation of the 13th century, when the collapse of one superethnos (Kievian Russ) occurred and a new nation, country, and civilization (the Russian superethnos) began to be born.
    [Show full text]
  • Second Report Submitted by the Russian Federation Pursuant to The
    ACFC/SR/II(2005)003 SECOND REPORT SUBMITTED BY THE RUSSIAN FEDERATION PURSUANT TO ARTICLE 25, PARAGRAPH 2 OF THE FRAMEWORK CONVENTION FOR THE PROTECTION OF NATIONAL MINORITIES (Received on 26 April 2005) MINISTRY OF REGIONAL DEVELOPMENT OF THE RUSSIAN FEDERATION REPORT OF THE RUSSIAN FEDERATION ON THE IMPLEMENTATION OF PROVISIONS OF THE FRAMEWORK CONVENTION FOR THE PROTECTION OF NATIONAL MINORITIES Report of the Russian Federation on the progress of the second cycle of monitoring in accordance with Article 25 of the Framework Convention for the Protection of National Minorities MOSCOW, 2005 2 Table of contents PREAMBLE ..............................................................................................................................4 1. Introduction........................................................................................................................4 2. The legislation of the Russian Federation for the protection of national minorities rights5 3. Major lines of implementation of the law of the Russian Federation and the Framework Convention for the Protection of National Minorities .............................................................15 3.1. National territorial subdivisions...................................................................................15 3.2 Public associations – national cultural autonomies and national public organizations17 3.3 National minorities in the system of federal government............................................18 3.4 Development of Ethnic Communities’ National
    [Show full text]
  • February 14Th 10.00 Sedov Vladimir Valentinovich (Moscow IA RAS
    February 14th 10.00 Sedov Vladimir Valentinovich (Moscow IA RAS) Principal outcomes of the excavation of the church of the Annunciation at Gorodishche near Novgorod in 2016-2017: archeology and architecture The paper presents the main results of the extensive architectural and archaeological excavation of the stone church of the Annunciation at Gorodishche, built in 1103 by Prince Mstislav the Great and rebuilt in 1342-1343. This latter church, having survived in part, was conserved, and the current plans for the museumification of the 1103 church allowed for its complete excavation, which provided an opportunity to assess the architecture of this second oldest stone church building of Novgorod (the Sophia of Novgorod being the earliest). We now see this monument as a transitive point in local architectural history. Its large size, common type and architectural details firmly link it to the south Russian tradition of Kiev. At the same time, it stands at the very beginning of the Novgorod architectural tradition. The paper also covers some of the most vivid details of the monument and the traces of its rebuilding, as well as information on the pre- church layers unearthed during the excavation. Gippius Alexey Alexeevich (Moscow, HSE, ISS RAS), Mikheev Savva Mikhailovich (Moscow, ISS RAS) Complex of the Glagolitic graffiti of the church of the Annunciation at Gorodishche The paper discusses ten 12th- century Glagolitic graffiti, one of them being the longest old Russian Glagolitic text. The inscriptions are of interest both in terms of their content and of their paleography, which has allowed us to presume the existence of a specific Novgorod school of Glagolitic writing in the 11th and 12th centuries.
    [Show full text]
  • Global Challenges and Trends in Agriculture: Impacts on Russia and Possible Strategies for Adaptation
    Global challenges and trends in agriculture: impacts on Russia and possible strategies for adaptation Ozcan Saritas and Ilya Kuzminov Ozcan Saritas is a Abstract Professor of Innovation & Purpose – This paper aims to analyse the mainstream and emerging global challenges and trends in Strategy at the National the global agriculture sector. The analysis leads to a discussion on the present state of the Russian Research University, agroindustry and possible future strategies for adaptation in the context of the rapidly changing global Higher School of environment. Economics, Moscow, Design/methodology/approach – The design of this study is based on the application of the core Russia. Ilya Kuzminov is methods of Foresight. First, a trend analysis is undertaken using reviews and expert methods. Trends a Senior Expert at identified are mapped using a social, technological, economic, environmental, political and value Foresight Centre, Institute (STEEPV) framework to ensure that a broad range of trends are covered, which may be stemming from for Statistical Studies and various factors affecting the agriculture sector. The analysis of the big picture of global trends and Economics of Knowledge, challenges, interacting with country-specific structural factors, translates are translated into the National Research opportunities and threats, which will in turn help to develop possible strategies for adaptation. University Higher School Findings – This study develops two adaptive strategies for the development of the Russian of Economics, Moscow, agroindustry that are feasible in different short- and long–term time horizons. The first strategy is Russia. considered to be the most likely choice for the period before 2020. It includes radical imports’ substitution (of commodities as well as machinery and high-tech components) for ensuring national food security with inevitable temporary setbacks in efficiency and labour productivity.
    [Show full text]
  • Is the Geography of Russia a Curse Or Benefit? Year 8
    IS THE GEOGRAPHY OF RUSSIA A CURSE OR BENEFIT? YEAR 8 Biomes in Russia: What is development? What Continent is Russia in? The biomes (areas of distinctive plant and animal groups, which are adapted to that The degree of wealth and material comfort Economy of Russia: particular environment) are very diverse in Russia. available to a person or community. High Russia is within the continents Europe and literacy Good Tundra: There is very little rainfall in the tundra. levels health Primary Sector - This is the process of Asia. Eurasia is the combined continental care HDI – a group of all countries development getting the raw materials together – landmass of Europe and Asia. The country There are shrubs and animals will include reindeer and Muscox. rates - In 2013, Russia had the world’s 55th 9.4% of jobs High shares its international boundaries with Use of Taiga: The taiga is characterized by a cold, harsh highest score. average sixteen sovereign republics of the world. 77% advanced climate, low rate of precipitation, and short Life expectancy – The amount of time people income technology Secondary Sector - This is the using the of the total landmass of Russia is in Asia while growing season. There are coniferous trees and are expected to live – In Russia it is 64 years. raw materials to create a new product – the rest is in Europe. animals include the Siberian Tiger. GDP – Gross domestic product - A measure Political 27.6% of jobs Ecosystem = an interconnected Living rights Steppe: Warm summers and really cold winters. of the total value of all the final goods and community of all of the living things - longer and Tertiary Sector - Using or selling this new Animals include rabbits and foxes.
    [Show full text]
  • Russia and Siberia: the Beginning of the Penetration of Russian People Into Siberia, the Campaign of Ataman Yermak and It’S Consequences
    The Aoyama Journal of International Politics, Economics and Communication, No. 106, May 2021 CCCCCCCCC Article CCCCCCCCC Russia and Siberia: The Beginning of the Penetration of Russian People into Siberia, the Campaign of Ataman Yermak and it’s Consequences Aleksandr A. Brodnikov* Petr E. Podalko** The penetration of the Russian people into Siberia probably began more than a thousand years ago. Old Russian chronicles mention that already in the 11th century, the northwestern part of Siberia, then known as Yugra1), was a “volost”2) of the Novgorod Land3). The Novgorod ush- * Associate Professor, Novosibirsk State University ** Professor, Aoyama Gakuin University 1) Initially, Yugra was the name of the territory between the mouth of the river Pechora and the Ural Mountains, where the Finno-Ugric tribes historically lived. Gradually, with the advancement of the Russian people to the East, this territorial name spread across the north of Western Siberia to the river Taz. Since 2003, Yugra has been part of the offi cial name of the Khanty-Mansiysk Autonomous Okrug: Khanty-Mansiysk Autonomous Okrug—Yugra. 2) Volost—from the Old Russian “power, country, district”—means here the territo- rial-administrative unit of the aboriginal population with the most authoritative leader, the chief, from whom a certain amount of furs was collected. 3) Novgorod Land (literally “New City”) refers to a land, also known as “Gospodin (Lord) Veliky (Great) Novgorod”, or “Novgorod Republic”, with its administrative center in Veliky Novgorod, which had from the 10th century a tendency towards autonomy from Kiev, the capital of Ancient Kievan Rus. From the end of the 11th century, Novgorod de-facto became an independent city-state that subdued the entire north of Eastern Europe.
    [Show full text]
  • Russian Viking and Royal Ancestry
    GRANHOLM GENEALOGY RUSSIAN/VIKING ANCESTRY Direct Lineage from: Rurik Ruler of Kievan Rus to: Lars Erik Granholm 1 Rurik Ruler of Kievan Rus b. 830 d. 879 m. Efenda (Edvina) Novgorod m. ABT 876 b. ABT 850 2 Igor Grand Prince of Kiev b. ABT 835 Kiev,Ukraine,Russia d. 945 Kiev,Ukraine,Russia m. Olga Prekrasa of Kiev b. ABT 890 d. 11 Jul 969 Kiev 3 Sviatoslav I Grand Prince of Kiev b. ABT 942 d. MAR 972 m. Malusha of Lybeck b. ABT 944 4 Vladimir I the Great Grand Prince of Kiev b. 960 Kiev, Ukraine d. 15 Jul 1015 Berestovo, Kiev m. Rogneda Princess of Polotsk b. 962 Polotsk, Byelorussia d. 1002 [daughter of Ragnvald Olafsson Count of Polatsk] m. Kunosdotter Countess of Oehningen [Child of Vladimir I the Great Grand Prince of Kiev and Rogneda Princess of Polotsk] 5 Yaroslav I the Wise Grand Duke of Kiew b. 978 Kiev d. 20 Feb 1054 Kiev m. Ingegerd Olofsdotter Princess of Sweden m. 1019 Russia b. 1001 Sigtuna, Sweden d. 10 Feb 1050 [daughter of Olof Skötkonung King of Sweden and Estrid (Ingerid) Princess of Sweden] 6 Vsevolod I Yaroslavich Grand Prince of Kiev b. 1030 d. 13 Apr 1093 m. Irene Maria Princess of Byzantium b. ABT 1032 Konstantinopel, Turkey d. NOV 1067 [daughter of Constantine IX Emperor of Byzantium and Sclerina Empress of Byzantium] 7 Vladimir II "Monomach" Grand Duke of Kiev b. 1053 d. 19 May 1125 m. Gytha Haraldsdotter Princess of England m. 1074 b. ABT 1053 d. 1 May 1107 [daughter of Harold II Godwinson King of England and Ealdgyth Swan-neck] m.
    [Show full text]
  • Russians, Tatars and Jews by Mark Tolts
    Ethnicity, Religion and Demographic Change in Russia: Russians, Tatars and Jews by Mark Tolts [Published in: Evolution or Revolution in European Population (European Population Conference, Milano 1995), Vol. 2. Milan: EAPS and IUSSP, 1996, pp. 165-179] 1. Introduction The Russian Federation is a multiethnic country. However, during many years Russia proper was only part of an even more variegated state — first the Tsarist Empire, and then the Soviet Union, which was dissolved in 1991. Therefore demographic transition was in the past studied mostly in the framework of the USSR and ethnic factors were discussed for this larger unit as a whole. This article is the first to compare ethnicity, religion and demographic change among Russians, Tatars and Jews in Russia alone. These three groups were chosen specifically because they represent distinctive religions, as well as greatly differing ethnic backgrounds and cultures. The Russians are a Slavic people whose traditional religion is Russian Orthodox Christianity. They were for many years the dominant ethnic group of the Tsarist Empire and the Soviet Union, and now form The research for this paper was funded in part by the Memorial Foundation for Jewish Culture. Background research is being supported by the Israel Interministry Fund ‘Tokhnit Giladi’. The author wishes to express his appreciation to Sergio DellaPergola for his advice and Evgeny Andreev and Leonid Darsky for their helpful suggestions. Mark Kupovetsky, Pavel Polian and Sergei Zakharov offered some statistical data and copies of important materials. The author is grateful to Judith Even, Eli Lederhendler and Shaul Stampfer for reading and editing an earlier draft, and to Philippa Bacal for careful typing.
    [Show full text]
  • Andreas Umland the FASCIST THREAT in POST-SOVIET RUSSIA an Investigation Into the LDPR-Ideology 1990-1993, and Some Tentative Su
    Andreas Umland THE FASCIST THREAT IN POST-SOVIET RUSSIA An Investigation into the LDPR-Ideology 1990-1993, and Some Tentative Suggestion on the Appropriateness of the `Weimar Russia' Metaphor Contents Abbreviations Part I: Fascist Tendencies in Zhirinovskii's Writings in the Newspaper Liberal 1. The Research Framework and Political Context of the Chapter Right-Wing Extremism and Peace Studies Zhirinovskii versus Gaidar 2. The `Whys' of Studying Fascism in Russia 2.1. The Significance of Zhirinovskii's Political Ideas The LDPR's Direct Influence on Russian Politics The LDPR's Indirect Influence on Russian Politics 2.2. `Fascism' - a Redundant Label? 2.3. `Fascism' in Post-Soviet Russia `Fascism' vs. `Right-Wing Extremism' The Moscow Anti-Fascist Centre `Fascism' as a Legal Term `Fascism's' Pre-Eminence 3. Identifying Fascism 3.1. Some Methodological Problems of Empirical Fascist Studies in Russia `Fascism' a Special Notion in Russia? Zhirinovskii a Fascist?: Pros and Cons My Approach to Zhirinovskii's Fascism The Procedure of this Inquir 3.2. Some Problems of a Theoretical Conceptualization of Fascism Generic Fascism as a Sub-Type of Right-Wing Extremism Concepts of Fascist Ideology 1 3.3. An Operational Definition of Fascism Griffin's `Fascist Minimum' A Note on Contemporary Russian Political Terminology 4. Palingenetic Ultra-Nationalism in Zhirinovskii's Articles in Liberal 4.1. The Newspaper Liberal 4.2. Zhirinovskii's Articles in Liberal Number 2-3, 1990 Number 4-5, 1992 Number 6-7, 1992 Number 8-9, 1992 Number 10, 1992 Number 1 (11), 1993 Number 2 (12), 1993 Number 3 (13), 1993 4.3.
    [Show full text]
  • Russia's Emergence As an International Conservative Power
    Russia’s Emergence as an International Conservative Power Russian Conservatism: An Ideology or a Natural Attitude? Paul F. Robinson Paul F. Robinson Graduate School of Public and International Affairs, University of Ottawa, Canada. Professor Scopus AuthorID: 57205126860 E-mail: [email protected] Tel: +44 (613) 562 5800 ext 4174 Address: 120 University, Ottawa, Ontario, K1N 6N5, Canada DOI: 10.31278/1810-6374-2020-18-1-10-37 Abstract Since Vladimir Putin’s return to the presidency in 2012 it has become common to talk of a “conservative turn” in Russian politics. Various commentators argue that this ideological shift applies to external as well as internal politics, with Russia becoming an international conservative power. This article seeks to determine what being an “international conservative power” actually means for Russia, by means of an examination of four different variations of Russian conservatism—Orthodox/Slavophile conservatism, civilizational conservatism, isolationist conservatism, and state/official conservatism. It argues that these are not all fully compatible with each other. If Russia truly is emerging as a conservative international power, this could lead both Russia and the world in one of several different directions, depending on which version of conservatism comes to dominate. Overall, though, it seems likely that the result will be a pragmatic, moderate 10 RUSSIA IN GLOBAL AFFAIRS Russia’s Emergence as an International Conservative Power variety of conservatism rather than the more radical versions associated with conservative ideologists. Keywords: Russia, conservatism, international power, Orthodoxy, Slavophilism, civilizations, isolationism ince Vladimir Putin’s return to the presidency of the Russian federation in 2012, it has become common to talk of a “conservative turn” in Russian politics (engström, 2014, p.
    [Show full text]