DOCSLIB.ORG

Volvo Ocean Race Independent Report Into the Stranding of Vestas Wind

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Volvo Ocean Race Independent Report Into the Stranding of Vestas Wind VOLVO OCEAN RACE INDEPENDENT REPORT INTO THE STRANDING OF VESTAS WIND The Vestas Wind Report (Version 1.2) An Independent Report that was convened by the Volvo Ocean Race following the stranding of the yacht Vestas Wind on 29 November 2014 on the Cargados Carajos Shoals 240 nm north east of Mauritius while competing in the 2014 – 2015 Volvo Ocean Race round the world. Chris Oxenbould, Stan Honey and Chuck Hawley 31 January 2015 0 Cover photo: Credit: Shane Smart/Volvo Ocean Race 1 Table of Contents Table of Contents .................................................................................................................................... 2 List of Acronyms ...................................................................................................................................... 5 INTRODUCTION ....................................................................................................................................... 8 Terms of Reference ............................................................................................................................. 8 Report Team ....................................................................................................................................... 8 DEDUCED FACTS ...................................................................................................................................... 9 The Race .............................................................................................................................................. 9 Race Organisation ............................................................................................................................. 11 VO 65 – One-design Concept ........................................................................................................ 12 Race Control .................................................................................................................................. 13 The East African Exclusion Zone.................................................................................................... 14 The Boat – Vestas Wind .................................................................................................................... 17 How the boat was raced ............................................................................................................... 18 Navigation setup onboard ............................................................................................................ 19 What happened to Vestas Wind – The Incident ............................................................................... 21 Cape Town to the Grounding ........................................................................................................ 21 The Grounding .............................................................................................................................. 23 The Night that Followed ............................................................................................................... 25 Abandoning Vestas Wind and the Rescue .................................................................................... 28 Emergency Management .................................................................................................................. 29 Experience of Other Yachts in the Cargados Carajos Shoals Area .................................................... 31 ANALYSIS and FINDINGS ....................................................................................................................... 32 Why did Vestas Wind run aground ................................................................................................... 32 The Reason Why ........................................................................................................................... 32 General Navigation ........................................................................................................................... 33 The Quality of Hydrographic Survey ............................................................................................. 34 Passage planning ........................................................................................................................... 36 Multi-Functional Display ............................................................................................................... 40 Radar ............................................................................................................................................. 42 Depth soundings ........................................................................................................................... 42 Visual lookout ............................................................................................................................... 44 2 The boat’s organisation ................................................................................................................ 44 Electronic Charts and Navigation Software Systems ........................................................................ 45 The types of Electronic Charts ...................................................................................................... 45 The supporting Navigation Systems.............................................................................................. 48 What was presented at the Cargados Carajos Shoals .................................................................. 48 What is required of a Chart Display System ................................................................................. 52 Current Developments and Opportunities ............................................................................... 52 What’s Next............................................................................................................................... 54 Some Suggested Guidelines .......................................................................................................... 54 Race Organisation – Administration, Procedures, Documentation .................................................. 55 Notice of Race ............................................................................................................................... 56 Resources Available to Race Director ........................................................................................... 56 Conduct of the Race .......................................................................................................................... 57 Changes to the Sailing Instructions ............................................................................................... 57 Shorter Port Stays with Increased Commitments ......................................................................... 58 Emergency Management .................................................................................................................. 58 Safety Equipment and Stowage ........................................................................................................ 58 Crew Report .................................................................................................................................. 59 LFP Batteries ................................................................................................................................. 59 Crews –Numbers and Training .......................................................................................................... 59 Numbers ........................................................................................................................................ 59 Safety at Sea Survival Training ...................................................................................................... 60 RECOMMENDATIONS ........................................................................................................................... 61 Navigation Practices .......................................................................................................................... 61 Electronic Charting ............................................................................................................................ 61 Matters Relating to the Conduct of the Race ................................................................................... 62 ANNEXURES .......................................................................................................................................... 63 Annexure A ........................................................................................................................................ 63 Terms of Reference – Volvo Ocean Race Independent Report into the Stranding of Vestas Wind ...................................................................................................................................................... 63 Annexure B ........................................................................................................................................ 65 Report Team – Short Resumes...................................................................................................... 65 Rear Admiral Chris Oxenbould AO RAN (Rtd) ........................................................................... 65 3 Stan Honey ................................................................................................................................ 65 Chuck Hawley ...........................................................................................................................
Load more

Recommended publications
  • HUGO BOSS Eyewear, Alex Thomson and the Transat Jacques Vabre HUGO BOSS Skipper Confirmed Guillermo Altadill As Co-Skipper for T
    HUGO BOSS eyewear, Alex Thomson and the Transat Jacques Vabre HUGO BOSS skipper confirmed Guillermo Altadill as co-skipper for the race that will start from Le Havre on October 30th. The duo will race aboard the boat that won the Route du Rhum 2010 Portsmouth, UK, September 2011 - Alex Thomson Racing announced that Guillermo Altadill, the celebrated Spanish round-the-world sailor, will be joining Alex aboard HUGO BOSS for the 2011 edition of the Transat Jacques Vabre race, which starts in Le Havre on Sunday October 30th. Skippers, boat and crew are supported by HUGO BOSS and HUGO BOSS Eyewear, the brand that includes ranges of optical frames and sunglasses produced by Safilo on license from the brand. The Sailing Project and the new BOSS Black Eyewear Collection As part of its “Sailing” Project, Safilo has expanded its BOSS Black Eyewear Collection range, and in April, launched an international ad campaign linked to the exhilarating Barcelona World Race, using the tagline “Follow Your Vision”. Now available in fine eyewear stores, the BOSS Black Eyewear Spring/Summer Collection 2011 – which still includes the “ALEX 99” (BOSS 0338/S and BOSS 0338/N/S), the official eyewear worn by skipper Alex Thomson and his crew – also presents new sports sunglasses especially developed by Safilo for the HUGO BOSS Sailing Project. Available in opaque blue, red, matt black, gloss black and aluminium, these styles are ideal for sports activities but also for everyday wear (BOSS 0392/S and BOSS 0393/S). HUGO BOSS Sailing Team at the 10th edition of Transat Jacques Vabre The Transat Jaques Vabre, first raced in 1993, retraces a route across the Atlantic which was th traditionally used by the coffee trade.
    [Show full text]
  • RYAN BREYMAIER Racing Your Brand Around the World
    RYAN BREYMAIER racing your brand around the world Partnership opportunity Join Ryan Breymaier, one of America’s most talented sailors, as tle sponsor to create an innovave markeng plaorm with a global reach. 2016 offers an exceponal year of IMOCA ocean racing with no fewer than three major events. This is the opportunity to develop a unique story, forming the basis of a powerful and compelling communicaons campaign delivering: § Consumer awareness among a high quality/affluent demographic § Significant internaonal PR value outside sporng press § An unique and highly engaging plaorm for VIP hospitality § Excing digital content reaching a significant global consumer audience § A brand ambassador with an incredible story of human adventure and endeavour 2 RYAN BREYMAIER The most prominent and successful American shorthanded offshore sailor on the ocean racing circuit today. Ryan discovered his passion and natural talent for sailing at St. Mary’s College, Southern Maryland. Over the next 10 years he developed his skills, compeng on inshore and offshore racing programs in the USA and Europe. In 2008 he moved to France to pursue his career on the professional short-handed circuits, notably the IMOCA class, the very top level of ocean racing. He has since competed in the very top races around the world as well as project managing and skippering three world record breaking aempts. Recent Highlights 2010-2011: 5th Place Barcelona World Race – a double-handed race around the world with no stops. Ryan’s first race around the world, in which he won first prize for video and photo communicaon during the race.
    [Show full text]
  • Dominique Wavrwe Mirabaud
    Dominique Wavre Barcelona World Race / December 2010 Transat Jacques Vabre / November 2011 VendéeGlobe / November 2012 Contents « Welcome aboard » p.5 A splash of salt water... and new horizons ! p.6 Dominique Wavre p.8 Co-skipper Michèle Paret p.10 The yacht « Mirabaud » p.12 A choice programme p.14 Barcelona World Race p.16 Transat Jacques Wabre p.18 Vendée Globe p.20 Mirabaud and sailing p.22 3 © DR « Welcome aboard » The Barcelona World Race, the Transat Jacques Vabre, and finally, the Vendée Globe. An extraordinary programme ! Today, it is with great joy that I announce this partnership with Mirabaud, giving the go-ahead to operations that will enable me to be at the starting line with Michèle in Barcelona on 31 December 2010, under the best condi- tions possible. One year later we will be in Le Havre, and finally, at the Sables d’Olonne in 2012 for the Vendée Globe. On the programme: one transatlantic, two round-the- world races, 200 days at sea and 90,000 nautical miles. Still, one might ask : why ? My answer is simple : after se- ven round-the-world races and over 360,000 nautical miles in my sailor’s log, my ambitions are intact and my thirst is as intense as ever ! Today, I embark on this three- year programme with enormous energy and enthusiasm. I am thrilled to be returning to sea on one of the Fabu- lous IMOCA Open 60 yachts and to complete a venture that I was forced to abandon in the southern seas during the last Vendée Globe.
    [Show full text]
  • Press Trip: 20 – 21 September 2018 Pays De Cornouaille >>> Golfe Du Morbihan – Vannes >>> Lorient PRESS TRIP BRETAGNE SAILING VALLEY 19-20-21 SEPTEMBER
    Press Trip: 20 – 21 September 2018 Pays de Cornouaille >>> Golfe du Morbihan – Vannes >>> Lorient PRESS TRIP BRETAGNE SAILING VALLEY 19-20-21 SEPTEMBER Wednesday 19th September 2018 Journalists arrive at Quimper train station (variable arrival times, according to individual travel arrangements) 8pm: Dinner Chez Max – Quimper / Presentation of Bretagne Sailing Valley (Carole Bourlon, mission manager for the Eurolarge Innovation programme at Bretagne Développement Innovation) 10pm: Hôtel Mercure - Quimper Thursday 20th September 2018 Pays de Cornouaille (Finistère) and Golfe du Morbihan – Vannes (Morbihan) 8.30am - 1.30pm: Pays de Cornouaille (Finistère) 8.10am: Leave from the hotel Mercure Quimper by coach: Quimper – Combrit 8.30am - 9.30am: Visit to the POGO STRUCTURES boatyard, Combrit POGO STRUCTURES is a yard employing more than 60 employees mass producing offshore racing yachts, including the Mini 6,50 and Class40. 9.35 - 9.45am: by coach Combrit - Port-la-Forêt 9.50 - 10.15am: reception at PÔLE FINISTERE COURSE AU LARGE, Port-la-Forêt Presentation of the national offshore racing skipper training centre (Figaro, Imoca, Ultim’) and the Bretagne - Crédit Mutuel sector of excellence. 10.15 - 11.15am: meeting with MerConcept, the MACIF race team and holder of the round the world solo record (Trophée Saint-Exupéry, 12/2017) 11.20 - 12.20am: meeting with companies (sailing club, Port-la-Forêt): - AIM 45: navigation data analysis for yacht performance and safety (structure, constraints); - INO ROPE: innovative textile rigging company; - MER AGITEE: innovative project for sail sensors 12.20 - 13.20pm: buffet lunch offered by Quimper Cornouaille Développement (sailing club) 1.30 - 2.55pm: transfer by coach: Port-la-Forêt (Finistère) – Tréffléan (Morbihan) 3pm - 9pm: Golfe du Morbihan – Vannes Agglomération (Morbihan) 3.00 - 4.00pm: visit to HEOL COMPOSITES, Tréffléan Presentation of the manufacturing process of patented hollow carbon parts recognised for their lightweight efficiency.
    [Show full text]
  • Yachts and Marinas
    YACHTS & MARINAS FINANCIAL TIMES SPECIAL REPORT | Friday May 27 2011 www.ft.com/yachts­marinas­2011 | twitter.com/ftreports Inside this issue Buyers and owners The rich are The new generation of the super­rich is not necessarily interested in the Riviera lifestyle Page 2 Superyachts The heady still af loat, days of bulging order books may never return Page 2 Interview Ed Dubois, but more the British naval architect, was a landlocked boy who felt discreetly the pull of the sea Page 3 Racing and regattas Organisers are hoping 1m the number of deliveries fell, the The latest challenge online gamers will take part in aggregate length of superyachts the 2011­2012 Volvo Ocean for the industry is produced rose slightly in 2010 to Race Page 3 buyers’ wariness about 8,008m because the average length increased from 40m to flaunting their riches. 45m. The ultra-wealthy, in other Marinas Berth prices have Victor Mallet reports words, are buying bigger yachts. risen fourfold in six years How can this be in times of at some of the most crisis? The answer is that the expensive facilities Page 4 t is no secret that the lux- very rich have, in many cases, ury yacht industry was an continued to get richer over the A home in early and prominent victim past three years. The main the Med of the economic crisis that obstacle to further growth in Big boats Ibegan with the collapse of Leh- the superyacht market, then, is battle for man Brothers in September 2008 not so much lack of money.
    [Show full text]
  • Guia ENG WEB.Pdf
    TITULO SECCIÓN I GS 1 SUMMARY GS3 THE RACE · 3RD EDITION OF THE BARCELONA WORLD RACE THE ADVENTURE BEGINS! 04 THE EDUCATIONAL RACE · EXCITEMENT REACHES THE SCHOOLS! 08 · COOPERATIVE WORK IN THE CLASSROOM 13 HUMAN BEING · THE IMPORTance of a good night’s sleep 16 · THE BALANCED DIET OF THE SAILORS 19 · THE PIONEERS 24 MAIN DOSSIER · LOS PROTAGONISTAS DE LA BARCELONA WORLD RACE 28 SAILING · THE PROTAGONISTS OF THE BARCELONA WORLD RACE 38 · GREEN ENERGY ON BOARD 40 · THE STRATEGY IN A TRIP AROUND THE WORLD 42 PLANET SEA · ANTARCTICA, NATURAL RESERVE FOR PEACE AND SCIENCE 44 · CLIMATE CHANGE IN THE SOUTH POLE 49 · AN OCEANOGRAPHER BEHOLDING THE MYSTERIES OF THE SEA 51 PRACTICAL GUIDE · SPORTS WITHOUT LIMITS 54 · THE SEA TEACHES 56 · PROPOSALS RELATED TO THE SEA 58 EDITORIAL Commitment to education and science The latest edition of the Barcelona World Race, organised humanistic and technologic Scientific Research (CSIC). The by the Barcelona Foundation for Ocean Sailing (FNOB), disciplines applied to and act of turning the IMOCA 60s into returns to the city. On this occasion, the event is developed during the Barcelona “scientific vessels” with sensors strengthening its commitment to the world of education, a World Race. that measure aspects such as the commitment most clearly evidenced through the school- Both initiatives serve to salinity, temperature and presence centred programme “Following the Barcelona World Race”. disseminate the scientific of microplastics in seawater Along these lines, in hopes of consolidating the race as a projects conducted by the race consolidates the Barcelona World tool to enhance education and help spread knowledge, in cooperation with specialised Race not only as a leading sporting we created the “Barcelona World Race Ocean Campus”.
    [Show full text]
  • Notice of Race 2010/2011
    Notice of Race 2010/2011 Published 23/12/09 Notice of Race 2010/2011 2 Notice of Race Barcelona World Race 2010/2011 Start on 31st December 2010 off Barcelona. Two-handed round-the-world yacht race, non-stop and without assistance. Open to IMOCA 60 monohulls. Organizing Authority : Fundacio Navegacio Oceanica Barcelona (FNOB) Edifici El Far C/Escar, 6 08039 Barcelona FNOB : + 34 93 221 74 57 Race management : + 34 608 27 70 53 E-Mails : General information : - [email protected] Competitor information : - [email protected] - [email protected] Race management information : - [email protected] www.barcelonaworldrace.org 3 Contents 1. Definition ............................................................................ 8 1.1 Notice of race ............................................................................................. 8 1.2 Barcelona World Race ............................................................................... 8 1.3 Organizing authority ................................................................................... 8 1.4 Times ......................................................................................................... 8 1.5 Participant .................................................................................................. 8 1.6 Crew ........................................................................................................... 9 1.7 Sponsors ...................................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Download Press
    Press Kit The Mission Our project has three main pillars, sailing science and education. Team Malizia was founded by Monegasque Pierre Casiraghi and German skipper Boris Herrmann in 2016 with the aim for Boris to perform at the highest level in the Vendee Globe 2020 race solo around the world. Beside the sporting aim, we have a strong message around climate change and ocean protection. Our ocean educators created a kids kit in 6 languages to educate kids around the world about what is happening in our oceans. We have partnerships with leading scientific bodies in order to further research on ocean Co2 and we carry an onboard ocean laboratory to measure valuable ocean data. In 2019 we hit world news by sailing Greta Thunberg emission free across the Atlantic to the UN Climate Action Conference. www.myoceanchallenge.org BORIS HERRMANN PIERRE CASIRAGHI The Skipper 39 year old Boris Herrmann has been dreaming of this challenge his whole life and on the 8th November 2020 he will become the first German to compete in the Vendee Globe. Born in Germany but raised on the water, Boris spent much of his life sailing with his family and took every free moment to sail or compete. Boris completed his first mini transit at 18 but rather than only pursue a career in sailing, he took the time to study and he obtained a Business MBA. Boris’ passion for sailing created his passion for the ocean which led to his desire to create The Ocean Challenge - to bring the oceans to the schools and to sensitise children to protect the ocean.
    [Show full text]
  • Latitude 38 March 2015
    VOLUME 453 March 2015 WE GO WHERE THE WIND BLOWS SPRING FEVER NO MATTER HOW LONG THE WINTER, F Prime deep water double-fingered concrete slips from 30’ to 100’. SPRING IS SURE TO FOLLOW! F Great Estuary location in the heart Celebrate the coming of the season on your boat. From of beautiful Alameda Island. Grand Marina you’ll be out on the San Francisco Bay F Complete bathroom and shower facility, heated and tiled. in minutes, then come back to a retreat…a perfect way F Free pump-out station open 24/7. to lift your spirits after a long winter! F Full-service Marine Center and haul-out facility. Spring into action, come to Grand Marina and check F Free parking. out our spring deals. F Free on-site WiFi. We are having a promotion on 30', 32', and 43' slips. And much more... Mention this ad when you contact us! Directory of Grand Marina Tenants Blue Pelican Marine ..................... 124 Boat Yard at Grand Marina, The ...14 Marchal Sailmakers .....................124 THE BAY AREA’S PREMIERE BOATING COMMUNITY MarineLube .................................. 116 New Era Yachts ............................. 128 510.865.1200 Pacific Crest Canvas ....................... 18 Pacific Yacht Imports .....................22 Leasing Office Open Daily Alameda Canvas and Coverings 2099 Grand Street, Alameda, CA 94501 Alameda Marine Metal Fabrication www.grandmarina.com UK Sailmakers GRAND MARINA GRAND The Cat and the Canary, er, the Black-Crowned Night Heron It took John Dukat five-and-a-half years to convert Critical Mass from a sloop to a cat- rigged boat. Starting as a mini-tonner, designed by Dave Mancebo to the old IOR measurement rule, Critical Mass was already fairly easy to handle, but John’s love of single-handed sailing and bird watching inspired him to reconfigure the boat as a single-sail-powered cat boat.
    [Show full text]
  • Driving Business Through Sport 2 Part One
    DRIVING BUSINESS THROUGH SPORT 2 PART ONE EUROPEAN SPORTS MARKETING DATA SIMON RINES ADDITIONAL RESEARCH BY HEATHER MILLER A Management Report published and distributed by International Marketing Reports Ltd Suite 7 33 Chapel Street Buckfastleigh TQ11 0AB UK Telephone: 44 (0) 1364 642224 www.imrsponsorship.com [email protected] Copyright 2007 by International Marketing Reports Ltd All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic, photocopying or otherwise, without the prior permission of the publisher and copyright owner. While every effort has been made to ensure accuracy of the information, advice and comment in this publication, the publisher cannot accept responsibility for any errors. The views expressed in this report are not necessarily those of the publisher. 2 THE AUTHOR Simon Rines has worked in the marketing communications industry for more than 20 years. He is author of the highly acclaimed and best selling report Driving Business Through Sport (edition one) and co-author of Football Sponsorship & Commerce. He is publisher of The International Journal of Sports Marketing & Sponsorship and is a regular commentator on the sponsorship industry at international events and in the media. He has had articles published in Sport Business, Hollis Sponsorship Newsletter, Marketing Week, Marketing, Campaign, Sunday Business, The Daily Telegraph, Marketing Director International, Marketing Business, Sales Promotion and Incentive Today. ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS The publishers would like to thank the following organisations for their assistance in producing this report. BMRB Cision Eurodata IFM Nielsen NetRatings SPORTFIVE Sports Marketing Surveys 3 TABLE OF CONTENTS 4 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY ....................................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • 2008S2009 VENDÉE GLOBE
    PRESS CONFEREN C E PRESENTATION OF THE 2008-2009 VENDÉE GLOBE Paris, Tuesday 16th September 2008 PRESS PA C K 2 2008/2009 EDITORIAL As it reaches its twentieth anniversary next year, the Vendée Globe is in four years, which goes way beyond the single-handed yachtsmen on Olympic form. It has never justified so strongly its reputation as one of their heroic three month long voyage beyond the horizon for the millions the most spectacular sporting and media events in the world, attracting of individuals, who passionately follow their adventure. the attention of sailing fans and lovers of amazing feats around the world several months before the starting gun is fired. It is the perfect event to allow the imagination to run wild, for dreams to be conjured up, for the hearts of young and old alike to beat that This sixth edition of the «Everest of the Seas» will be a record brea- little bit faster, as the conquerors find themselves in the middle of wide ker. A record number of entrants with thirty yachtsmen lining up at open spaces. the start. A record in terms of diversity with apart from the seventeen French entrants, thirteen foreign participants. A record of experience The Vendée Globe is also an event, where everyone becomes involved. and know-how: 14 participants have previously taken part in the race, There are the people of Vendée, around their Council and business including the two previous winners, Michel Desjoyaux and Vincent Riou leaders, who remain determined to keep «their» race, if anyone talks - some already twice or three times and even four in the case of one of of moving it elsewhere.
    [Show full text]
  • Race Starts and Finishes, Race Tracking, Solidaire Du Chocolat 2012
    Produced by Windreport’ In the last ten years sports sponsorship has become a powerful international media. It strengthens brand and image reputation thanks to the passion and excitement it conveys, both within and outside the company. But above all, it contributes to business development. This is why it must be part of the advertiser's development strategy. The goal of sports sponsorship is not to replace advertising, public relations or sales promotion campaigns. The advantages it offers are completely different. On the other hand, in the same way as these, it can and must be considered a tool in its own right, liable to further communication efforts within the framework of a defined marketing plan of action. Mars 2014 Shared values Audacity Endurance Innovation Technology Sustainable development Common challenges Team management Resource management Risk management A nature sport In touch with the elements That enjoys a positive image of a healthy sport A great generator of goodwill Become a sailing sponsor Dream Escape Passion Mars 2014 A profitable investment in the media for the sponsors The media coverage of sailing is advantageous to sponsors because the sponsor is referred to as often as the skipper. Exceptional media coverage The IMOCA 60’ monohull circuit offers sponsors the greatest media coverage in sailing. An exceptional investment to media play ratio The weighted media value of a standard 4-year monohull programme, without a win, is estimated on average at more or less €M 12 for an average investment of less than half of this. Mars 2014 An already impressive performance 2010, winner of the Mini Pavois, Trophée MAP, 6th in the Route du Rhum and German sailor of the year.
    [Show full text]