ORGANISED AND SUPPORTED BY:

MOSCOW SCHOOL OF POLITICAL STUDIES

POLISH CULTURAL CENTRE IN MOSCOW

COUNCIL OF EUROPE

OPEN SOCIETY INSTITUTE HIGHER EDUCATION SUPPORT PROGRAM (HESP)

CHARLES STEWART MOTT FOUNDATION

ROLF GROUP OF COMPANIES

GOVERNMENT OF THE REPUBLIC OF FINLAND

STOCKHOLM INSTITUTE OF TRANSITION ECONOMICS (SITE)

MINISTRY OF FOREIGN AFFAIRS OF

ALUMNI ASSOCIATION OF THE MOSCOW SCHOOL OF POLITICAL STUDIES

The Moscow School of Political Studies was established in 1992 as a non-governmental organisation with its mission to promote development of democratic institution and civil society in Russia Thursday, November 1st 9.30 – 10.00 Opening: Elena Nemirovskaya, Founder, Moscow School of Political Studies Wojciech Zajączkowski, Ambassador of the Republic of Poland to the Russian Federation

10.00 – 11.30 Session: Economy Post-social reforms in a benchmark study: lessons learnt Leszek Balcerowicz (Poland)

11.30 – 12.00 Coffee-break

12.00 – 13.30 Session: Politics and society How can we get on with democracy? Adam Michnik (Poland)

13.30 – 14.30 Lunch

14.30 – 16.00 Session: Local government Local government in Poland Krzysztof Herbst (Poland)

16.00 – 16.30 Coffee-break

16.30 – 18.00 Session: Culture and society Church and democracy Andrzej Brzeziecki (Poland)

18.00 – 19.30 Session: Culture and society New culture for coexistence, or bridging the democratic archipelago Krzysztof Czyżewski (Poland)

19.30 – 19.45 Coffee-break

19.45 – 21.00 Round table: Civic initiatives in RF cities (alumni projects) Alexander Sogomonov (Russia)

21.00 Dinner

2 Friday, November 2nd

10.00 – 11.30 Session: Rule of law Principle of legality and fundamental rights Tomas de la Quadra-Salcedo (Spain)

11.30 – 12.00 Coffee-break

12.00 – 13.30 Session: Rule of law Right to defence in the due circumstances Vadim Klyuvgant (Russia)

13.30 – 14.30 Lunch

14.30 – 16.00 Session: Society and business The state of things in modern Russia Nikolay Kovarsky (Russia)

16.00 – 16.30 Coffee-break

16.30 – 18.00 Session: Society and politics Russian society: reaction to irritants Alexey Makarkin (Russia)

18.00 – 18.30 Coffee-break

18.30 – 20.00 Session: Rule of law Russian police: job analysis and reforming plan Vadim Volkov (Russia)

20.00 – 21.00 Dinner

21.00 Round table: Civic life in Russian regions (projects and prospects) Alexander Sogomonov (Russia)

3 Saturday, November 3rd

9.00 – 10.30 Session: History and society Clerical-public relations in Russia in its historical perspective Nikita Sokolov (Russia) 10.30 – 12.00 Session: Law and faith Law and religion Andrey Zakharov (Russia) Maxim Trudolubov (Russia) 12.00 – 12.30 Coffee-break 12.30 – 14.00 Round table: Chronicles of the civic life in Russia Alexander Sogomonov (Russia) 14.00 – 15.00 Lunch 15.00 – 16.30 Session: Political culture The cultural contradictions of democracy Vladislav Inozemtsev (Russia) 16.30 – 17.00 Coffee-break 17.00 – 18.30 Session: Society Trust and distrust in society Lev Gudkov (Russia) 18.30 – 19.00 Coffee-break 19.00 – 20.30 Session: Global world World after crises: will it be a better one? Andrey Ryabov (Russia) 20.30 Closing ceremony: Elena Nemirovskaya, Founder, Moscow School of Political Studies Toby Gati, Member of the Advisory Council and Board of Directors of the Moscow School of Political Studies Yury Senokossov, Founder and Director of publishing programs, Moscow School of Political Studies 21.00 Dinner

4 EXPERTS

BALCEROWICZ, Leszek Polish economist, the Former Chairman of (Poland) the National Bank of Poland, Deputy Prime Minister and Minister of Finance in Tadeusz Mazowiecki’s government

BRZEZIECKI, Andrzej Editor-in-Chief, “New Eastern Europe” (Poland) (Nowa Europa Wschodnia)

CZYZEWSKI, Krzysztof Social activist, the Founder and Director of (Poland) the Borderland Foundation

De La QUADRA-SALCEDO, Professor of the University Carlos III, Tomas Madrid (Spain)

GATI, Toby Member of the Advisory Council and Board (USA) of Directors, Moscow School of Political Studies

GŁADYŚ, Justyna Third Secretary, Embassy of the Republic of (Poland) Poland to the Russian Federation

GUDKOV, Lev Director, “Levada-centre” (Russia)

HERBST, Krzysztof Urbanist, social activist (Poland)

INOZEMTSEV, Vladislav Professor of Economics; Director, (Russia) Centre for Post-Industrial Studies (Moscow); Publisher and Editor, “Svobodnaya Mysl” monthly

KLYUVGANT, Vadim Defense lawyer; Member of the Committee (Russia) of the Supreme Council of the Russian Federation on the issue of legality, rule of law and crime prevention; member of the Constitutional Commission (1990–1993) 5 KOVARSKY, Nikolay Member of the Club 2015 (Russia)

MAKARKIN, Alexey First Vice-President, Center of Political (Russia) Technologies

MICHNIK, Adam Editor-in-chief, “Gazeta Wyborcza” (Poland)

NEMIROVSKAYA, Elena Founder, Moscow School of Political Studies (Russia)

RYABOV, Andrey Political analyst; Member, Carnegie Moscow (Russia) Centre

SENOKOSSOV, Yury Founder and Director of publishing programs, (Russia) Moscow School of Political Studies

SOGOMONOV, Alexander Academic director, Centre for Sociological (Russia) and Political Education, Russian Academy of Sciences

SOKOLOV, Nikita Chief-editor, “Otechestvennye zapiski” (Russia) magazine; historian

TRUDOLUBOV, Maxim Editor, opinion page, “Vedomosti” daily (Russia)

VOLKOV, Vadim Vice-Chancellor for International Affairs, (Russia) The European University at Saint-Petersburg; Academic Director, Institute for the Rule of Law

ZAJĄCZKOWSKI, Wojciech Ambassador of the Republic of Poland (Poland) to the Russian Federation

ZAKHAROV, Andrey Editor, “Neprikosnovennyi zapas: debates on (Russia) politics and culture” magazine

6 PARTICIPANTS FROM THE RUSSIAN FEDERATION

ABADIYEV, Magomed Ingush State University, Management Chair, (Ingushetia Republic) Senior Instructor

ABRAMKINA, Marina Peoples Assembly of the Dagestan Republic, (Dagestan Republic) Committee for the Youth, Sport and Tourism Affairs, Chairperson

AIDRUS, Irina Arabic Research Center, Director (Moscow)

AKOPOVA, Tatiana Yaroslavl State University named after P. G. (Yaroslavl Oblast) Demidov, Lecturer

ALEKSEYENKO, Irina Dalnevostochnaya (Far East) TV Company, (Khabarovsky Krai) Special Projects Studio, Senior Editor

ALKHAZUROV, Magomed Parliament of the Chechen Republic, Deputy (Chechen Republic)

ANDRENKO, Ilya Smart Company, Director (Rostov Oblast)

ANTONOV, Valery Cheboksary Municipal Assembly of Deputies, (Chuvashia Republic) Committee for Housing and Utilities, Chairman

ANTSIFEROVA, Victoria Federation Council of the Federal Assembly (Arkhangelsk Oblast) of the Russian Federation, Assistant to the Member of the Council

ARISTOVA, Svetlana Public Chamber of Permsky Krai, Commission (Permsky Krai) for Social Control, Human Rights Protection and Living Standards, Chairperson

BAKLANOVA, Natalia Agrarnoye Stavropolje (Agricultural ) (Stavropolsky Krai) Publishing House, Correspondent

7 BALAKIREVA, Natalia Orlovsky Vestnik weekly, Editor-in-Chief (Oryol Oblast)

BOCHKAREV, Vasily Yunona Fund Urals Pharmaceutical Cluster, (Mariy El Republic) Vice-President

BODROVA, Olga Russian Peace Fund, regional branch, Board (Stavropolsky Krai) Chairperson

BREZHNEV, Aleksey Volgodonsk Municipal Duma, Deputy (Rostov Oblast)

BUCHAYEV, Yakhya Dagestan State Institute of Peoples Economy, (Dagestan Republic) Rector

CHABLIN, Anton Otkrytaya: Dlya Vsekh i Kazhdogo (Open: for (Stavropolsky Krai) All and Everybody) newspaper, Journalist

CHUDNETSOV, Alexander Astrakhan Oblast, Krasnoyarsky Village (Astrakhan Oblast) Council, Municipal Unit Head

DAMDINOV, Tsyrendorzhy Zabaikalsky Krai Legislative Assembly, Deputy (Zabaikalsky Krai)

DAURBEKOV, Isa Ingushetia Republic Ombudsman (Ingushetia Republic) Administration, Senior Expert

DOKHOLYAN, Sergey Regional Issues of Economic Transformation (Dagestan Republic) journal, Editor-in-Chief

DOLGIKH, Anton Peoples Freedom Party, regional branch, (Kirov Oblast) Chairman

FILATOV, Sergey Tula Municipal Duma, Deputy (Tula Oblast)

GALAYEV, Vitaly Ministry for Industry and Commerce of the (Permsky Krai) Russian Federation for Permsky Krai, Branch Supervisor

8 GAMZATOVA, Leila Novy Project (New Project) newspaper, Editor (Dagestan Republic)

GLUKHOVA, Anastasia Provintsia (Province) Publishing House, (Tyumen Oblast) Journalist

GOGIN, Sergey Independent Journalist ( Oblast)

GOLBAN, Yevgeny Our Talents Fund, Executive Committee (Moscow) Member

GONCHAROV, Yuri Vologda Oblast Administration, Information (Vologda Oblast) Policy Committee, Head

GORBATIN, Vyacheslav Kaluga Oblast Legislative Assembly, Deputy (Kaluga Oblast)

GORDIN, Aleksey Irkutsk Municipal Administration, Public (Irkutsk Oblast) Relations Department, Head

GORIN, Dmitry Russian Academy of Peoples Economy and (Bryansk Oblast) Public Service, Bryansk branch, Chair Head

GRANAT, Yulia Modern History Foundation, Expert in Ethnic (Omsk Oblast) and Confessional Issues

GREMIN, Alexander Tolyatti Municipal Duma, Deputy ( Oblast)

GRISHECHKINA, Margarita Kaliningrad Local Community Foundation, (Kaliningrad Oblast) Executive Director

GRUSHEVSKY, Dmitry Regional Economy and Social Projecting (Volgograd Oblast) Institute, Research Supervisor

ISTAMULOV, Abdulla Chechen Republic Parliament, Advisor to the (Chechen Republic) Chairman

9 ISTOMINA, Maria Expert TV channel, Democracy broadcast, (Sverdlovsk Oblast) Editorial Director

IVANOVA, Vyacheslavna State Duma of the Russian Federation, (Kabardino-Balkarian Assistant to the Deputy Republic)

KABANOV, Andrey Ivanovo Oblast Ombudsman (Ivanovo Oblast)

KALNINA, Svetlana Yaroslavl Oblast Youth Parliament, (Yaroslavl Oblast) Chairperson

KALYADIN, Dmitry Vesti PK Internet project, Owner and (Voronezh Oblast) Editor-in-Chief

KALYUTA, Mikhail Kaluga Municipal Duma, Deputy (Kaluga Oblast)

KARASTELEV, Vadim London School of Economics, Analyst, (Krasnodarsky Krai) Project PR Manager

KARIMOVA, Anastasia Kommersant Publishing House, Correspondent (Moscow)

KARMAK, Yekaterina Kaluga Oblast Presidential Program Alumni (Kaluga Oblast) Club, President

KAZAKOVA, Larisa Shelekhov Municipal Duma, Deputy (Irkutsk Oblast)

KHABAROV, Roman Honest City movement, Leader (Voronezh Oblast)

KHOLOPTSEVA, Yelena KIT Finance non-government pension fund, (Chuvashia Republic) Cheboksary branch, Director

KLEVTSOV, Dmitry Dorog Net (No Roads) Internet Project, Head (St. Petersburg)

10 KLIMENKO, Ludmila South Federal University, Lecturer (Rostov Oblast)

KNIGINA, Darya Reporter newspaper, Chief Editor of the Digital (Saratov Oblast) Version

KOLBANENKO, Roman Vecherny Novocherkassk Info newspaper, (Rostov Oblast) Journalist

KOSTERINA, Irina Heinrich Böll Foundation, Program (Moscow) Coordinator of Gender Democracy and grants for young researchers

KRYUCHKOV, Alexander National Academy for the Study and Research (Rostov Oblast) of Corruption Issues, Academic Council, Secretary

KURGENYAN, Alexander Dagestan Republic Presidential Administration (Dagestan Republic) for Territorial Development and Local Self-Governance, Department Deputy Director

LUBIN, Gleb Tort3 Company, Director (Kaliningrad Oblast)

LUKOVTSEV, Fedor Non-Government Pension Funds Association of (Sakha (Yakutia) Republic) Siberia and the Far East, President

LUKYANOVA, Irina Scat TV and Radio Company, Editor ()

MAGOMEDOMAROV, TROLL Advertising and Recruiting Company, Magomed Director (Dagestan Republic)

MAIN, Yevgeny and Vyatka Academy of Public Service, (Yaroslavl Oblast) Administration and Marketing Chair, Professor

MALENKO, Sergey Socially Conservative Politics Center, (Permsky Krai) Executive Director

11 MALYSHEV, Konstantin Legal and Election Technologies Center, (Altaisky Krai) Political Technology Expert

MALYUGIN, Igor Volgograd Academy of Public Service, Public (Volgograd Oblast) Relations center, Director

MARDANSHIN, Aidar State Duma of the Russian Federation, (Bashkortostan Republic) Assistant to the Deputy

MARDANSHIN, Rafael State Duma of the Russian Federation, (Bashkortostan Republic) Deputy

MASLYUK, Dmitry Regional Real Estate Center Company, (Stavropolsky Krai) Managing Director

MATSUKHOV, Ruslan United Caucasus Youth Assembly, Project (Kabardino-Balkarian Coordinator Republic)

MIKHALTSOVA, Tatiana Russian Geographical Society, Kostroma (Kostroma Oblast) branch, press service, Head

MITROFANOV, Yevgeny Consumer Rights Protection Foundation, (Novosibirsk Oblast) non-profit organization, Head

MOLEKER, Natalia The House of Youth state budget institution (Novosibirsk Oblast) of Novosibirsk Oblast, Director

MORDASOVA, Irina Novgorod.ru Internet portal, Editor (Novgorod Oblast)

MOZHEGOV, Dmitry Civic Initiatives Company, public movement, (St. Petersburg) Coordination Board, Member

MUZHAROVSKY, Vladimir Apatity Municipal Council of Deputies, Deputy (Murmansk Oblast)

NASONOVA, Olga Komi Republic Ministry of Culture, Project (Komi Republic) and International Work Sector, Head

12 NAUMENKO, Alexandra RIA Novosty Russian Agency for International (Stavropolsky Krai) Information, North Caucasus Federal District Correspondent

NAZAROVA, Natalia Young Entrepreneurs of Russia Association, (Penza Oblast) Deputy Chairperson

NEGEREV, Aleksey Astrakhan Oblast Duma, Deputy (Astrakhan Oblast)

NOEL, Maria Journalist (Moscow Oblast)

NOSKOV, Anatoly Kostroma Municipal Duma, Deputy (Kostroma Oblast)

OMAROV, Pakhrudin Dagestan Republic Presidential Administration (Dagestan Republic) for Territorial Development, Consultant

OZDOYEV, Jambulat Ingushetia Republic Ombudsman (Ingushetia Republic)

PANPURINA, Angelina Stavropolsky Krai State Duma Administration, (Stavropolsky Krai) Senior Expert

PAUTOVA, Natalia Yaroslavl Oblast Duma, Assistant to the Deputy (Yaroslavl Oblast)

PENENKOV, Denis Druzhba (Friendship) Public Foundation, (Nizhnii Novgorod Oblast) Board Chairman

PESKOV, Grigory Khotkovo Municipal Council of Deputies, (Moscow Oblast) Deputy

PLYUTA, Roman Tuapse District Municipal Council, Deputy (Krasnodarsky Krai)

POSTNIKOV, Maxim Kostroma Oblast Duma, Deputy (Kostroma Oblast)

13 POZDEYEVA, Yekaterina Arkhangelsk Oblast Assembly of Deputies, (Arkhangelsk Oblast) Assistant to the Deputy

PROKHOROV, Oleg Free People Group regional public charity (Nizhnii Novgorod Oblast) organization, President

PRONKINA, Vera Novosibirsk Oblast Government, Youth Affairs (Novosibirsk Oblast) Administration, Head

RADEVICH, Alexander Social and Education Initiatives Center, (Udmurtia Republic) Izhevsk municipal public organization, Council Chairman

RASKHODCHIKOV, Sociological Research Agency, Saratov, Aleksey Director (Saratov Oblast)

RAZLATAYA, Yevgenia Far East Institute of International Relations, (Khabarovsk Krai) autonomous non-profit organization, Dean

RENEV, Denis Right Cause political party, Primorsky Krai (Primorsky Krai) branch, Political Council, Member

ROZHKOV, Vladimir Ivanovo Oblast Internal Politics Department, (Ivanovo Oblast) Youth Policy Administration, Head

RUBANKOV, Kirill Kostromskaya Narodnaya Gazeta (Kostroma (Kostroma Oblast) Peoples Newspaper), Correspondent

RYABINTSEV, Roman Kostroma Regional Research Center, General (Kostroma Oblast) Director

RYKOV, Aleksey Abzats newspaper, Executive Secretary (St. Petersburg)

SAIKO, Yevgenia Tomsk State University, Post-Graduate Student (Tomsk Oblast)

14 SAVCHENKO, Ilya State Management University, Administration, (Stavropolsky Krai) Sociology, and Psychology Chair, Deputy Head

SCHASTLIVTSEVA, Yulia Magnitogorsky Metall newspaper, Columnist (Chelyabinsk Oblast)

SHABARDIN, Vladimir Kirov Oblast Children Ombudsman (Kirov Oblast)

SHANINA, Yekaterina Tobolsk Municipal Duma, Committee for the (Tyumen Oblast) Legal Support of Local Self-Governance and Youth Policy, Chairperson

SHKRETOV, Yuri Zabaikalsky Krai Legislative Assembly, (Zabaikalsky Krai) Committee for Economic and Investment Policy, Deputy Chairman

SHMELYOV, Alexander Entrepreneur (Moscow)

SHMELYOVA, Svetlana Khoroshevsky District of the Government (Moscow) of Moscow, Legal Department, Head

SHUMANOV, Ilya Kaliningrad Municipal Administration, (Kaliningrad Oblast) Economic, Finance and Control Committee, Economic Development Department, Head

SIMAKOV, Alexander Justice public organization, Board Chairman (Novgorod Oblast)

SIMONOV, Vladimir Oryol Municipal Duma, Deputy (Oryol Oblast)

SIROTIN, Pavel Voronezh Municipal Duma, Assistant to the (Voronezh Oblast) Deputy

SKUDAYEVA, Anna RIA Novosty Russian Agency for International (Kostroma Oblast) Information, Central Federal District, Correspondent

15 SMOLYAR, Arthur Siberian Health Corporation, Partner (Novgorod Oblast)

SOSINA, Yevgenia 100TV, TV channel, Correspondent (St. Petersburg)

STAFEYEV, Vyacheslav Court Bailiffs Service for Vologda, Head (Vologda Oblast)

STANSKIKH, Stanislav Constitutional History Center, Head (Omsk Oblast)

SUDAKOV, Alexander Nizhnii Novgorod Press Club, Coordinator (Kaluga Oblast)

TEREKHIN, Sergey Russian Car Owners Federation public (Yaroslavl Oblast) organization, Plenipotentiary Regional Representative

TERLYAYEV, Maxim Ulyanovsk Civil Education Club, autonomous (Ulyanovsk Oblast) non-profit organization, Director

TIKHONOV, Andrey Krasnoyarsky Krai Builders Union, Executive (Krasnoyarsky Krai) Director

TIMAKIN, Alexander The World Scout Commission of the World (St. Petersburg) Organization of the Scout Movement, Eurasia Region, Member

TIMOFEYEVA, Olga State Duma of the Russian Federation, Deputy (Stavropolsky Krai)

TITOV, Dmitry Rostov Regional Public Movement of the (Rostov Oblast) Victims of Chechen Conflict, Azov municipal branch, Board Chairman

VAFINA, Tatiana Molodezh Tatarstana (Tatarstan Youth) (Tatarstan Republic) newspaper, Editor-in-Chief

16 VAKHSHTAIN, Semen Penza Regional State TV and Radio Company, (Penza Oblast) Program Supervisor

VALKOV, Sergey Ivanovo Oblast Legislative Assembly, Deputy (Ivanovo Oblast)

VERESHCHAGIN, Aleksey Business Support Center, Director (Stavropolsky Krai)

VINOGRADOV, Dmitry Russian Academic Journal, Interdisciplinary (Tver Oblast) Research Expert

VISHNEVSKY, Konstantin Civil Education Center of Stavropol, Director, (Stavropolsky Krai) Training Programs Supervisor

VORONINA, Anna Voronezh Oblast Administration for Ecology (Voronezh Oblast) and the Use of Natural Resources, Deputy Head

YAKOVLEVA, Natalia Russian-American Association, Board Member (Yaroslavl Oblast)

YEVLIKOVA, Victoria Public Relations Development Company, (Yaroslavl Oblast) Mass-Media Group, Head

YEZHOV, Oleg Right Cause political party, Primorsky branch, (Primorsky Krai) Executive Secretary

YUDINA, Irina Gazeta Yuga, general interest periodical, (Kabardino-Balkarian Correspondent Republic)

ZAGVOZDKINA, Yulia A Just Russia political party, regional branch, (Ivanovo Oblast) Administration Deputy Head

ZUBAIRUYEV, Zubairu Dagestan Republic Presidential Administration, (Dagestan Republic) Information Policy and Press-Service Department, Head

17 ZVYAGINA, Natalia Transparency International – Russia (Voronezh Oblast) anticorruption network office in Voronezh, Director

PARTICIPANTS FROM THE ARMENIA REPUBLIC

GRIGORYAN, Artak Armenian Republican party, Political Council Member

KIRAKOSYAN, Artashes Armenia Republic Ministry of Labor and Social Affairs, Administration, Deputy Head

MANGASARYAN, Artak MAR group of companies, Board Chairman

PLUZYAN, Nune Armenia Republic Government Administration, Department for Territorial Administration and Local Self-Governance, Deputy Head

PARTICIPANT FROM THE UKRAINE

IGNATYEV, Aleksey ADFormer advertising agency, Director

18 PROGRAM BY Inna Berezkina

MODERATOR Andrey Zakharov

MANAGERS Anastasia Gontareva Marina Skorikova Svetlana Aristarkhova

INTERPRETERS Alexander Kazachkov Elena Shimanskaya Natalya Petrova Victoria Fyodorova

19 «MOSCOW SCHOOL OF POLITICAL STUDIES» Russia, 127006, Moscow, Staropimenovsky pereulok, 11, stroenie 1 Тel/fax: +7 (495) 699 01 73 e-mail: [email protected] http://www.msps.su