Best Value Review Social Inclusion Comparative Analysis Community Cohesion Indicators

Appendix 5

Best Value Review Social Inclusion Comparative analysis Community Cohesion Indicators 2001-02 BVPI Results (from bvpi.gov.uk) "Building a picture of community cohesion" Annexe B (other relevant best value performance indicators)

Using 9 closest CIPFA Nearest Neighbours (Unitary) as family group: Bath & N E Somerset, Blackpool, Bournemouth, Brighton & Hove, Isle of Wight, Poole, Portsmouth, Torbay, York Average Rank (1-10) = 5

Common Ranking amongst vision and Diversity Similar life Ref Indicator group Sense of appreciated opportunities (1 top) Belonging The level of the CRE Standard for Racial ü ü 7 to 10 (joint) BV 2 Equality reached The percentage of citizens satisfied with Unavailable the overall service ü 2001/02 BV 3 provided The percentage of top 5% of earners from Unavailable ethnic minority ü 2001/02 BV 11b communities % of staff from ethnic minorities compared with % of economically active 4 (doubts ethnic minorities in local ü expressed) BV 17 authority area % of pupils acheiving one or more GCSEs at 4 BV 39 grade G or equivalent ü

The percentage of pupils in schools maintained by the local education authority achieving 5 ü 5 GCSEs or equivalent at A*-G including English BV 40/41 and Maths No. of pupils per 1000 permanently excluded 7 BV 44 from primary schools ü % of unauthorised half days missed in 10 BV 45 secondary schools ü Satisfaction of council house tenants with the 4 BV 74 overall service ü Satisfaction of council house tenants with 4 participation in decision ü BV 75 making BV 120 Level of crime (using Unavailable (police) British Crime Survey) ü 2001/02 BV 121 Fear of crime (using Unavailable (police) British Crime Survey) ü 2001/02 Burglaries No. per 1000 2 BV 126 households ü Violent crimes per 1000 Unavailable population and 2001/02 BV 127 percentage detected ü Vehicle crimes No. per 3 BV 128 1000 pop ü Is the CRE Code of Practice applied in the 1 to 5 (joint) provision of rented ü BV 164 housing 1 to 4 (joint, % of racial incidents that doubts BV 175 resulted in further action ü expressed) The quality of teaching Unavailable for early years and 2001/02 BV 192 childcare services ü Average: 4 Average: 4.7 Average: 5.4 Average: 5 (to 1sf) 2 of 3 avail. 3 of 3 avail. 8 of 13 avail. 12 of 18 avail. 1 doubts expr. 1 doubts expr. 2 doubts expr. How often other authorities from family group outperformed Southend based on 12 indicators (excludes BV164)

Number of CIPFA model CIPFA rank (1 Authority % Indicators (0 closest) closest) Bath and N E Somerset 7 58.33% 0.229 8 Bournemouth 7 58.33% 0.155 2 York 7 58.33% 0.211 7 Brighton & Hove 5 41.67% 0.147 1 Poole 5 41.67% 0.205 6 Blackpool 4 33.33% 0.156 3 Isle of Wight 4 33.33% 0.176 4 Portsmouth 4 33.33% 0.2 5 Torbay 3 25.00% 0.155 2 Average 5 42.59%

Generally we do better than just over half of those in the family group- the closer the authority is to us within the group the better we perform by comparison. BV 2 The level of the CRE Standard for Racial Equality reached

Bath & N E Somerset 2 Brighton & Hove 2 Portsmouth 2 Unitary Top Quartile 2 Blackpool 1 Bournemouth 1 Poole 1 Unitary Median 1 Unitary Bottom Quartile 1 Isle of Wight 0 Southend-on-Sea 0 Torbay 0 York 0

2.5 2 2 2 2 2

1.5 1 1 1 1 1 1

0.5 0 0 0 0 0 t l t e e th le o th le n le h a y rk s v u ti o u o ia ti g e a o r o o r p o o d r i -S rb Y e H a k P e a W o m m u c m u f n T o & ts Q la e M Q o -o n r rn y d S o o p B r m le n E t P o u ta o s e h T o i tt I h N ig y B n o t r r U B u & B ta o h i ry S t n a a U it B n U % of staff from ethnic minorities compared with % of economically active ethnic minorities in local % of economically active people from authority area ethnic minorities in local authority area Brighton & Hove 3% 3.70% Unitary Top Quartile 2.70% 4.50% Bath & N E Somerset 1.60% 1% Unitary Median 1.30% 2.60% Portsmouth 1.28% 3.32% (doubts Southend-on-Sea* 1.25% 3.36% expressed) (doubts York* 1.10% 0.7%* expressed) Torbay 0.85% 0.53% Blackpool 0.71% 0.89% Unitary Bottom Quartile 0.70% 1.0% Poole 0.63% 1.11% Bournemouth 0.48% 1.89% Isle of Wight 0.40% -

% of staff from ethnic minorities compared with % of economically active ethnic minorities in local authority area

4% 3% 3% 2.70% 2% 1.60% 1.30% 1.28% 1.25% 1.10% 0.85% 1% 0.71% 0.70% 0.63% 0.48% 0.40% 0%

t t * l * h y e h e e n e t h t l k o l a m v a i r s a g u u o t o e i o i o r b o r t o o r t o p d S e e a H Y l k W - o o P e i

m m t u c n f m T r & B s M e a

o o Q o t l a

r - n n y r u r r S B e o p d

o l a t a u t Q o n t P s E i i I h o e T

n g n B h N i y t

r U r U u & B a

t o i h t S n a U B % of staff from ethnic minorities compared with % of economically active ethnic minorities in local authority area

4% 3% 3% 2.70% 2% 1.60% 1.30% 1.28% 1.25% 1.10% 0.85% 1% 0.71% 0.70% 0.63% 0.48% 0.40% 0%

t t * l * y h e e h e n e t h t k l l a o m v a i r s a g u t u o i e o o o r i b r o t o o r t o d p e S e H a Y l - k W o o e i P

m m t u c m n f T & B r M s e a

Q o t o o l a y

r - n n y r u S r r B o e p d o l a t a u t Q o n t P E s i i I h o e T

n g n B i N h y t

r U r U u & B a

t o i h t n S a U B BV 39 % of pupils achieving one or more GCSEs at grade G or equivalent

Bath & N E Somerset 99% Poole 97.30% Unitary Top Quartile 96% York 95.80% Southend-on-Sea 95% Unitary Median 95% Torbay 94.50% Bournemouth 94% Blackpool 93% Unitary Bottom Quartile 93% Brighton & Hove 92% Isle of Wight 92% Portsmouth 91.90%

100% 99% 98% 97.30% 96% 95.80% 96% 95% 95% 94.50% 94% 94% 93% 93% 92% 92% 91.90% 92% 90% 88% t t l n k h h e e a e y e r h l t o l e t l a v i i e i a o g s o u o t u t o i r r r d b S o Y o o p r - a e a e H k o W P n m u m u

c m T M o f e & s

a - Q o Q t l o n

r y

d r n r S B p o e n

u m o a l o t e t P o o E i s T t h h

I t t n B g N y i o u

r U r o B a & B

i S y h n r t a a U t i B n U BV 40 % of pupils achieving Level 4 or above in Key Stage 2 Maths

York 75% Bath & N E Somerset 74% Unitary Top Quartile 73.10% Blackpool 72% Bournemouth 72% Southend-on-Sea 71.30% Torbay 71% Unitary Median 70.70% Brighton & Hove 66.40% Isle of Wight 66% Unitary Bottom Quartile 66.00% Poole 64% Portsmouth 63.80%

78% 75% 74% 73.10% 72% 72% 73% 71.30% 71% 70.70%

68% 66.40% 66% 66.00% 64% 63.80% 63%

58% t l t k n h h e a e y e e r t l o t h l e l a i v i e a i o u t o u s g o t o i r r b d r S o o p o Y r - a e H a e k o W P n m u m u c

m T M f o & s e a

Q - t o Q l o

n r

y d

n r r S B o p e n o m u a l t o e P t o o E s i t T h h I t

B t n g N y i o u

r U r o B a & B

S i y h r n t a a U t i B n U BV 41 % of pupils achieving Level 4 or above in Key Stage 2 English

York 79% Bath & N E Somerset 78% Unitary Top Quartile 77.60% Torbay 76% Bournemouth 75% Southend-on-Sea 73.40% Blackpool 73% Brighton & Hove 73% Poole 72.90% Unitary Median 72.90% Isle of Wight 70% Unitary Bottom Quartile 70.00% Portsmouth 69.50%

84% 79% 79% 78% 77.60% 76% 75% 74% 73.40% 73% 73% 72.90%72.90% 70% 70.00%69.50% 69%

64% l t t n k h h a e e e y e r t t e o l h l l a i v i e a i o u s o o g t u t i o r r b d r S p o Y o o r - e a a H e k o P W

n m u m u c

T m M o f & s e a - Q Q o t l o

r y

d r n S r B p o e n

u o m l a o t e t P o o E s i T h t h I

t t n B g N y i o u

U r r o B a & B

i S y h n r t a U a t i B n U BV 44 No. of pupils per 1000 permanently excluded from primary schools

Bournemouth 0.33 Poole 0.56 York 0.56 Isle of Wight 0.6 Portsmouth 0.9 Unitary Top Quartile 0.9 Brighton & Hove 1.04 Southend-on-Sea 1.09 Torbay 1.09 Unitary Median 1.5 Blackpool 1.6 Bath & N E Somerset 1.7 Unitary Bottom Quartile 1.9 1.9 2 1.7 1.5 1.6 1.5 1.04 1.09 1.09 1 0.9 0.9 0.56 0.56 0.6 0.5 0.33

0 t t l e a e h h n y k e e l e l h o t t i i l r v e a s a t t o g i u u o o r r i r o b S d p o o o - e r a a Y H k e W o u n u P m m c m T f o & M e Q s Q - a o

o t l

n d r n y r S p B

r e o n m o u l o t a e E o o P s T t t h i I h t B t g n y N i o

r u r U a o B & B

i S y h n r t a U a t i B n U 1.9 2 1.7 1.5 1.6 1.5 1.04 1.09 1.09 1 0.9 0.9 0.56 0.56 0.6 0.5 0.33

0 t t l e a e h h n y k e e e l l h o t t l i i r v e a a s t t o g i u u o o r i r o r S b d o p o o - r e a a Y H e k W o u n u P m m c m T f o & e M Q s Q - a o

o t l

n r d n r y S p B r e o n m o u l o t a e E o o P s T t t h i I h t B t g n y N i o r u r U a o B & B t

i S y h n r t a U a t i B n U BV 45 % of unauthorised half days missed in secondary schools

Bath & N E Somerset 0.60% Isle of Wight 0.70% Unitary Top Quartile 0.70% Bournemouth 0.71% Poole 0.73% York 1.10% Unitary Median 1.10% Torbay 1.20% Blackpool 1.30% Brighton & Hove 1.40% Unitary Bottom Quartile 1.40% Portsmouth 1.80% Southend-on-Sea 1.90%

2.00% 1.80% 1.90%

1.50% 1.30% 1.40% 1.40% 1.10% 1.10% 1.20% 1.00% 0.73% 0.60% 0.70% 0.70% 0.71% 0.50%

0.00% t t l y e e a k h h e e n l l e l t i t r i o h a v e t a t s o i u u o o r g r b r o i S r d o o o p a Y a - e H e o k P

W u u n m m

m c T f o s M & e Q Q o t

- a

o l r n

y n d S p r

r B m o e n o l o u a t E o P t e s t

o T i h I t

h n N B g t o y i

r u r U B &

o B t y i h r S t n a a t U i B n U BV 74 Satisfaction of council house tenants with the overall service

Bournemouth 87% Brighton & Hove 86% Poole 80% Unitary Top Quartile 80% Southend-on-Sea 79% York 77% Unitary Median 77% Blackpool 75% Portsmouth 75% Unitary Bottom Quartile 73.50% Bath & N E Somerset - Isle of Wight - Torbay -

91% 87% 86% 86% 81% 80% 80% 79% 77% 77% 76% 75% 75% 73.50% 71% 66% l k e e a e n h h e l l l r o t i t i e v a t t o o i o u u r r o S p o d o Y o - a a k H e P n u

u m c m o s M & a e Q Q t -

r n y d n B r p r o m n o u o a t P o t e t o i T h t h n g t B o y i r u r U B

o a B t y i S r n a t U i n U 91% 87% 86% 86% 81% 80% 80% 79% 77% 77% 76% 75% 75% 73.50% 71% 66% l k e e a e n h h e l l l r o t i t i e v a t t o o i o u u r r o S p o d o Y o - a a k H e P n u

u m c m o s M & e a Q Q t - l

r n y d n B r p r o m n o u o a t P o t e t o i T h t h n g t B o y i r r u U B

o a B t y i S r n a t U i n U BV 75 Satisfaction of council house tenants with participation in decision making

Bournemouth 72% Blackpool 69% York 65% Unitary Top Quartile 64.10% Southend-on-Sea 64% Unitary Median 56% Poole 52% Brighton & Hove 48% Portsmouth 48% Unitary Bottom Quartile 48% Bath & N E Somerset - Isle of Wight - Torbay -

80% 72% 69% 65% 64.10% 64% 56% 60% 52% 48% 48% 48% 40% 20% 0% l e k a e h n e l h e l o r l i t t i e t a v t o i o o u r u r S o p d o o Y o - a a k H e P n u u m m c o s M & e a Q

Q t - l

r y n d n r B p r o m n o u o a t P o t e t o i T h t

h n g B t o y i r u U r B

o a B t y i S r n a t U i n U 80% 72% 69% 65% 64.10% 64% 56% 60% 52% 48% 48% 48% 40% 20% 0% l e k a e n h e l h e l o r l i t t i e a t v t o i o o u r u r S o p d o o Y o - a a k H e P n u u m m c o s M & e a Q

Q t - l

r y n d n r B p r o m n o u o a t P o t e t o i T h t

h n B g t o y i r u U r B

a o B t y i S r n a t U i n U BV 126 Burglaries No. per 1000 households

Isle of Wight 7.84 Southend-on-Sea 9.6 Poole 11.6 Unitary Top Quartile 12.7 Portsmouth 15.1 Brighton & Hove 15.4 Torbay 17.04 Bournemouth 17.3 Unitary Median 17.8 Bath & N E Somerset 21.6 Unitary Bottom Quartile 28.5 Blackpool 28.63 York 28.9

35 30 28.5 28.63 28.9 25 21.6 20 17.04 17.3 17.8 15.1 15.4 15 12.7 9.6 11.6 10 7.84 5 0 l t t n k h h a e e e y e r t o h l t e l l a v i e i a i o u o g o u s t t o i r r b r d S o o p o Y r - e a a H e k o W P n m m u u c

T m M f o s & e a

- Q Q t o l o n r

y d r n S r B o p e n u o m l a o t e P t o o E s i T h t h I

t t B n g N y i o u

r r U o B a & B

i S y h n r t a a U t i B n U 35 30 28.5 28.63 28.9 25 21.6 20 17.04 17.3 17.8 15.1 15.4 15 12.7 9.6 11.6 10 7.84 5 0 t l t n k h h a e e e e y r h l t t o e l l a v i e i a i o g u o o u s t t o i r r r b d S o o o p Y r - e a a H e k o W P n m m u u c T m M f o s & e a

- Q Q t o l o n r y d n r S r B p o e n u o m l a o t e P t o o E s i T h t h I

t t B n g N y i o u

r r U o B a & B

i S y h n r t a U a t i B n U BV 128 Vehicle crimes No. per 1000 pop

Isle of Wight 6.23 Torbay 14.4 Southend-on-Sea 14.5 Poole 15.1 Unitary Top Quartile 15.2 Brighton & Hove 17.84 Blackpool 18.27 Unitary Median 18.3 Portsmouth 19.2 York 20.3 Bath & N E Somerset 22.6 Bournemouth 24.3 Unitary Bottom Quartile 24.6

30 24.6 25 22.6 24.3 20.3 20 17.84 18.27 18.3 19.2 14.4 14.5 15.1 15.2 15 10 6.23 5 0 t t l k n h h e y a e e e t h l r t e l o l v i i a e a i o g t u u t s o o o i r r b r S d o r o Y p o - a H e a e o k

W P n m u u m

c T m f o & M e s a - Q Q t o l o n r d n y r S p r B o e n o

u m l o t a e P t o o E s T i h t h

t t B g n y i N o u r r

U o B a B & t

i S y h n r t a U a t i B n U 30 24.6 25 22.6 24.3 20.3 20 17.84 18.27 18.3 19.2 14.4 14.5 15.1 15.2 15 10 6.23 5 0 t t l n h k h y a e e e e h l r t t e l l o v i i a a e i g t u o u t s o o o i r r b r S d o r o Y o p - a H e a e o k

W n P m u u m

T c m f o & M e s a - Q Q t o o l n r d n y r S p r B o e n o

u m l o t a e P t o o E s T h i t h I

t t B g n y i N o u r r

U o a B B & t

i S y h n r t a U a t i B n U BV 164 Is the CRE Code of Practice applied in the provision of rented housing

Blackpool Yes Bournemouth Yes Brighton & Hove Yes Southend-on-Sea Yes York Yes Poole No Portsmouth No Bath & N E Somerset - Isle of Wight - Torbay - BV 175 % of racial incidents that resulted in further action

Bath & N E Somerset 100% York 100% Isle of Wight* 100% (doubts expressed) Southend-on-Sea* 100% (doubts expressed) Unitary Top Quartile 100% Blackpool 99% Unitary Median 99.00% Brighton & Hove 98.40% Unitary Bottom Quartile 96.60% Poole* 63% (doubts expressed) Bournemouth* 46.10% (doubts expressed) Torbay 33.30% Portsmouth 25.90%

100% 100% 100% 100% 100% 100% 99% 99.00% 98.40% 96.60% 80% 63% 60% 46.10% 33.30% 40% 25.90% 20% 0% t l * * * k n h * e e y e t r l t e l o v e h a a i i a l i t h o t u s t o o e r b r r o g d u r o Y p i H a e a o S e o o k

- u u m P c T m W n M & m s

a Q Q o t f o l e

r - y n o S n p r B o d o r

m a t o e n u P t o l E i h T t e

t s n g I h i N y B o t r

r U u B a B &

t o

i y h n S r t a U a t i B n U 100% 100% 100% 100% 100% 100% 99% 99.00% 98.40% 96.60% 80% 63% 60% 46.10% 33.30% 40% 25.90% 20% 0% t l * * * k * n h e e y e t e r l t l o v e h a i a i a l h i t s o t t u o o e r r b r o g d u r o p Y i e H a a S o e o o k

- u u m P c T m W n M & m s

a Q Q o t f o l e

r - y n o S n p r B o d o r m a t o e n u P t o E l i h T e t

t s n g I h N y i B t o r r U u B a & B

t o

i y h n S r t a U a t i B n U