Emotional Practices of the Tudor Court in Early Modern Literary Culture
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Copyright by Bradley James Irish 2011 The Dissertation Committee for Bradley James Irish Certifies that this is the approved version of the following dissertation: Powerful Feelings: Emotional Practices of the Tudor Court in Early Modern Literary Culture Committee: Frank Whigham, Supervisor Wayne A. Rebhorn Marjorie Curry Woods Brian P. Levack James N. Loehlin Jason Powell Powerful Feelings: Emotional Practices of the Tudor Court in Early Modern Literary Culture by Bradley James Irish, B.A., M.A. Dissertation Presented to the Faculty of the Graduate School of The University of Texas at Austin in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree of Doctor of Philosophy The University of Texas at Austin December 2011 Dedication To Mom and Dad, for helping me start. To Jenny and Olivia, for helping me finish. Acknowledgements My deepest debt is to Frank Whigham, my mentor, advocate, and friend; his patient guidance, unflagging encouragement, and remarkable mind have shaped my intellectual, professional, and personal development in ways impossible to enumerate. I cannot thank him enough. Wayne Rebhorn has guided me throughout the entirety of my graduate career; his careful attention to my work has greatly sharpened my thinking and my prose. Jorie Woods has inspired me with her curious, daring, and meticulous scholarship; her advice and support have been invaluable. Jason Powell has been generous beyond belief with his time, energy, and expertise; I hope one day to be able to repay him. James Loehlin has taught me much about Shakespeare—but he has taught me more about how to engage any text with an agile and penetrating eye. Brian Levack has helped me develop the skills of a professional scholar, and has enabled me to see my work in new and exciting ways. In addition to the members of my committee, my colleagues, instructors, and friends at the University of Texas at Austin have been instrumental to the development of this work. I especially thank Sam Baker, J. K. Barrett, Mary Blockley, Douglas Bruster, Elizabeth Cullingford, Ann Cvetkovich, Linda Ferreira-Buckley, Greg Foran, Beth Hedrick, Wayne Lesser, Jason Leubner, Eric Mallin, Lindsey Schell, Patricia Schaub, Molly Schwartzburg, Amy Douglas Stewart, and Hannah Wojciehowski. I have benefited enormously from the generosity of scholars elsewhere. I owe much to William Carroll, Jean Deathridge, Victoria Goodwin, Steve Gunn, Paul Hammer, Peter Herman, Paulina Kewes, Scott Lucas, Chris Martin, Steve May, Gail Kern Paster, Will v Rossiter, Gary D. Sherman, Ray Siemens, James Siemon, Alan Stewart, Owen Williams, and Heather Wolfe. I am especially indebted to the friendship of Hala Herbly, Jessica Kilgore, and Noël Clare Radley, each of whom have made finishing this project possible. This dissertation is dedicated to my family. vi Powerful Feelings: Emotional Practices of the Tudor Court in Early Modern Literary Culture Bradley James Irish, Ph.D. The University of Texas at Austin, 2011 Supervisor: Frank Whigham Uniting literary analysis, theories of affect from the sciences and humanities, and an archival-based account of Tudor history, this project examines how literature reflects and constructs the emotional dynamics of life in the Renaissance courtly sphere—with hopes of showing why emotionality, as a primary mode through which historical subjects embody and engage their world, should be adopted as a fundamental lens of social and textual analysis. Spanning the 16th Century, chapters on John Skelton and Henrician satire, Henry Howard, Earl of Surrey, Sir Philip Sidney and Elizabethan pageantry, and the Essex circle demonstrate how the dynamics of disgust, envy, frustration, and dread guide literary production in the early modern court. By aligning Renaissance discourses of emotion with current trends in empirical and theoretical research, the study provides a new context for an "affective" analysis of literature. vii Table of Contents Textual Notes ................................................................................................................................................................. x Introduction .................................................................................................................................................................... 1 Chapter 1: The Emotional Practice of Disgust: The Rise and Fall of Thomas Wolsey .............................. 14 "FROM THE DONGE CARTE" – THE RISE OF CARDINAL THOMAS WOLSEY................................................. 15 A BRIEF HISTORY OF DISGUST ........................................................................................................................... 22 THE DISGUSTING WOLSEY .................................................................................................................................. 32 THE FALL OF CARDINAL WOLSEY ..................................................................................................................... 47 Chapter 2: The Emotional Practice of Envy: Surrey, Richmond, and the Rivalrous Emotions .............. 62 THE LIFE AND DEATH OF HENRY FITZROY ...................................................................................................... 66 THE PRACTICE OF ENVY ...................................................................................................................................... 74 THE PRACTICE OF JEALOUSY .............................................................................................................................. 84 FINDING GRIEF ...................................................................................................................................................... 89 Chapter 3: The Emotional Practice of Frustration: Leicester, Sidney, and the 1570s ............................. 95 WHY SO FRUSTRATED? ....................................................................................................................................... 98 INTO THE WILD ..................................................................................................................................................109 The Forester ..............................................................................................................................115 Robin Hood ................................................................................................................................119 The Wildman ............................................................................................................................125 Hercules ......................................................................................................................................134 LEICESTER AND SIDNEY, ENTERTAINERS .......................................................................................................141 Kenilworth, 1575 .....................................................................................................................141 Woodstock, 1575 .....................................................................................................................151 The Lady of May, 1578 ..........................................................................................................155 IN FROM THE WILD ............................................................................................................................................165 viii Chapter 4: The Emotional Practice of Dread: The Earl of Essex and the 1590s ...................................... 170 THE LAST FAVORITE ..........................................................................................................................................177 COSMIC DREAD ...................................................................................................................................................182 SOCIAL DREAD ....................................................................................................................................................193 The Earl of Essex and His Friends .....................................................................................198 The Earl of Essex and His Enemies ....................................................................................211 INNER DREAD ......................................................................................................................................................231 References .................................................................................................................................................. 243 ix Textual Notes List of Abbreviations: AEP George Puttenham, The Art of English Poesy, ed. Frank Whigham and Wayne A. Rebhorn (Ithaca: Cornell University Press, 2007). A&P Frank Whigham, Ambition and Privilege: The Social Tropes of Elizabethan Courtesy Theory (Berkeley: University of California Press, 1984). BL The British Library, London. CP Cecil Papers, Hatfield House, Hertfordshire. CSPF Calendar of State Papers, Foreign Papers, of the Reign of Elizabeth, ed. Allan James Crosby et al., 23 vols. (London, 1863-1950). CSPS Calendar of State Papers, Spanish, ed. G.A. Bergenroth et al., 13 vols. (London, 1862-1954). CSPV Calendar of State Papers and Manuscripts Relating to English Affairs, Existing in the Archives and Collections of Venice and in Other Libraries of Northern Italy, ed. Rawdon Brown et al., 40 vols. (London, 1864– 1947). Folger Folger Shakespeare Library, Washington D.C. HMC Salisbury Calendar of the Manuscripts of the Most Honourable