Valley Metro Comprehensive Operational Analysis
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Valley Metro Comprehensive Operational Analysis Final Report August 2018 Prepared for Greater Roanoke Transit Company Table of Contents Chapter 1: Introduction Introduction .................................................................................................... 1-1 COA Goals and Recommendations................................................................ 1-2 COA Draft Report and Methodology ............................................................... 1-2 Chapter 2: Transfer Analysis and Opportunities Introduction .................................................................................................... 2-1 Strategy #1 - Change the Route Network from Pulse to Direct....................... 2-2 Strategy #2 - Reduce the Number of Vehicles that Meet at the Same Time ... 2-5 Strategy #3 - Move the Transfer Facility ......................................................... 2-11 Strategy #4 - A Combined Approach .............................................................. 2-19 Chapter 3: Route Analysis and Recommendations Introduction .................................................................................................... 3-1 Detailed Operating Statistics and Analysis ..................................................... 3-1 Boarding/Alighting Data by Route and Stop and Proposed Route Changes ... 3-6 Potential New Routes ..................................................................................... 3-57 Chapter 4: Schedule Analysis and Recommendations Introduction ..................................................................................................... 4-1 Ridership by Run ............................................................................................. 4-1 Ridership by Time of Day ................................................................................ 4-2 30-Minute Frequency Recommendations ........................................................ 4-4 Change in Pulse Transfer ................................................................................ 4-6 Chapter 5: Passenger Facilities and Other Recommendations Introduction ..................................................................................................... 5-1 Passenger Facilities ........................................................................................ 5-1 Marketing and Advertising ............................................................................... 5-4 Service Planning ............................................................................................. 5-5 Appendix A: Ridership by Time of Day for Each Route Valley Metro Comprehensive Operational Analysis i Chapter 1: Introduction Chapter 1 Introduction INTRODUCTION The Greater Roanoke Transit Company, doing business as Valley Metro, provides fixed route public transit services within the cities of Roanoke and Salem and parts of Roanoke County, including the Town of Vinton. Complementary ADA paratransit, termed Specialized Transit – Arranged Rides (STAR) is provided by Unified Human Services Transportation Systems, Inc., Roanoke Area Dial-A-Ride (RADAR), under a contractual arrangement. Valley Metro also operates intercity bus service between the New River Valley and Roanoke (the Smart Way Commuter and the Smart Way Express). This report documents the Comprehensive Operational Analysis (COA) that has been conducted for Valley Metro. The COA was initiated in November 2017, with the draft recommendations provided in May 2018. The COA work was completed mid-way through the development of a Transit Development Plan (TDP), which is a six to ten-year transit plan required by the Virginia Department of Rail and Public Transportation (DRPT). KFH Group was under contract to DRPT to complete the TDP. During the TDP process, Valley Metro determined that a more comprehensive examination of the routes and schedules for the fixed route system than is typically conducted for a TDP was needed, and requested that the TDP study team also conduct a COA. Valley Metro and the Roanoke Valley Transportation Planning Organization (RVTPO) provided funding for the COA tasks that were above and beyond the task work being completed for the TDP. These transit planning projects follow the comprehensive Roanoke Valley Transit Vision Plan (TVP), which was completed over a three-year period and led by the RVTPO. The TVP included a significant outreach effort and developed short-term, mid-term, and long- term recommendations for improving public transportation in the region. While the process provided a detailed vision for the future of public transportation in the Roanoke Valley, an in-depth analysis of the functioning of each route was not conducted. The TVP recommendations include significant expansion and improvement of transit services for the entire Roanoke Valley region. The plan was completed in the fall of 2016. One of the recommendations within the TVP was “to evaluate individual routes for efficiencies and enhancements to save or maximize time and investment.” The COA recommendations serve to accomplish this task. Valley Metro Comprehensive Operational Analysis 1-1 Chapter 1: Introduction COA GOALS AND RECOMMENDATIONS The primary goals of the COA are to: 1. Improve and strengthen the operational foundation of Valley Metro’s existing service delivery network focusing on the adjustments needed to implement all three phases of the TVP. 2. Reduce transit vehicle and passenger congestion by reducing to the most practical level possible the number of buses currently terminating in downtown Roanoke at the Campbell Court Bus Station, thereby identifying plausible transfer opportunities outside of the downtown area. While the basic COA service recommendations are generally cost-neutral, there are a few system recommendations that will require additional investment. Because the COA recommendations are meant to improve the efficiency and effectiveness of the current routes, they do include reductions in the number of routes that offer 30-minute service. This is not in keeping with the recommendations contained within the TVP that serve to improve frequencies, but reflects the current ridership trends and the need to re-deploy the existing resources for higher ridership potential. The COA recommendations are short-term in nature and focus on improving the current transit network. The intent of the COA is to make the existing system as efficient as possible prior to starting the process of implementing the series of expansions called for in the TVP. The recommended expansions outlined in the TVP include a higher level of service for the current routes, including Sunday service, service later in the evenings, and an increase in service frequency. Geographic expansion of the transit network and connecting routes are also featured in the TVP. The second important goal of the COA, to reduce the number of vehicles that terminate in downtown Roanoke, was problematic to achieve given the road network, natural and man-made travel barriers, and size of the transit network. The recommendations do include significantly fewer vehicles meeting at one time, which partially achieves the goal and solves the short-term problem of limited capacity at the Campbell Court Station. COA REPORT AND METHODOLOGY The COA report is organized into the following sections: Chapter 1 – Introduction Chapter 2 – Transfer Analysis and Opportunities Chapter 3 – Route Analysis and Recommendations Chapter 4 – Schedule Analysis and Recommendations Valley Metro Comprehensive Operational Analysis 1-2 Chapter 1: Introduction Chapter 5 – Passenger Facilities and Other Recommendations Data used for the route and schedule analysis were derived from boarding/alighting counts and time checks conducted by the Roanoke Valley- Alleghany Regional Commission (RVARC) staff during FY2017 for the purposes of National Transit Database reporting. Data used for the transfer analysis and the ridership by run and time of day were provided by Valley Metro, as recorded through the GFI Genfare fareboxes. A ten-day sample from October 2017 was used for the transfer analysis and a ten-day sample from November 2017 was used for the ridership by run and time of day. All of the Valley Metro regular fixed routes that meet at Campbell Court were examined for the COA. Most of the recommended route changes are minor and serve to either improve running time or reduce the probability of vehicular conflicts or roadway safety hazards. There are more significant changes recommended for the 30 series, the 41/42, the 81/82, and the 91/92 to reflect ridership patterns. Two new routes are recommended for the short-term using existing resources and another two are proposed if expansion funds for services outside the City of Roanoke are available. There are also significant changes recommended for the pulse transfer so that fewer buses meet at the same time in downtown Roanoke. This change is necessary as Campbell Court is at capacity and the most recent buses purchased by Valley Metro are longer and wider than the buses that they are replacing. There are also recommendations with regard to the time of day that 30-minute service is provided, as well as which routes are served with 30-minute service. The final chapter addresses recommendations with regard to passenger facilities, marketing and advertising, and service planning. Valley Metro Comprehensive Operational Analysis 1-3 Chapter 2: Transfer Analysis and Opportunities Chapter 2 Transfer Analysis and Opportunities INTRODUCTION One of the important