DOCSLIB.ORG

17. the Theater-Of-Film of Hans-Jürgen Syberberg: Parsifal and Die Nacht

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
17. the Theater-Of-Film of Hans-Jürgen Syberberg: Parsifal and Die Nacht R. J. CARDULLO1 17. THE THEATER-OF-FILM OF HANS-JÜRGEN SYBERBERG: PARSIFAL AND DIE NACHT Two works by Hans-Jürgen Syberberg best exemplify what I describe in my title as the “theater of film”: Parsifal (1982) and Die Nacht (The Night, 1985). Let’s begin with the earlier picture, whose subject should be no surprise if one knows Wagner’s Parsifal (1882) and if one has seen Syberberg’s Our Hitler (1977; a.k.a., Hitler, A Film from Germany). (The connection between Wagner and Hitler is the fact that the Führer venerated Wagner’s works and saw them as embodying true German ideals.) No, you should not be surprised by Syberberg’s choice to make a film of Wagner’s work; nor should you be surprised by this director’s general approach to his subject. But this Parsifal, among its fascinations, does have a surprising new aspect—to which I shall return. Syberberg’s obsession with Wagner has long been familiar. The first film of his to be shown in the United States, The Confessions of Winifred Wagner (1975), was a 104-minute condensation of the five-hour interview, made for German television, which he conducted with her. Wagner, musically and otherwise, is present in several other Syberberg films. And one of the most vivid images in postwar German cinema occurs in Our Hitler: the toga-clad Hitler rising from a grave that has a stone marked “RW.” In Syberberg’s view, then, Parsifal must be the most representative of Wagner’s works, the most beautiful but silly, exalted yet pretentious, noble at the same time it is vicious—all the contradictions that Syberberg patently finds in German character and behavior. Wagner himself, of course, is prototypical of a great deal that both repels and fascinates about Germany. On the one hand there is Wagner, the maniacal, blood- and-iron, anti-Semitic Teuton. On the other hand, there is Wagner, the titanic genius whom the young Nietzsche saw as the new Prometheus restoring Dionysian flame to a pallid civilization. (And the older Nietzsche never really recanted. As Thomas Mann remarked, “Nietzsche’s polemic against Wagner pricks our enthusiasm for the composer rather than tames it.”)2 Eric Bentley, in that masterwork The Playwright as Thinker (1946), goes as far as to pair Wagner with Ibsen as one of the two great modern exponents of tragedy. Yet this is, inseparably, the same Richard Wagner who inspired Adolf Hitler, and whose anti-Semitism is sometimes seen as Syberberg’s own. Wagner’s score for Parsifal, which (I think) Syberberg uses uncut, is a succession of marvels that coalesce into a gigantic marvel; yet the libretto, or poem as Wagner R. J. Cardullo (Ed.), Hans-Jürgen Syberberg, the Film Director as Critical Thinker, 205–215. © 2017 Sense Publishers. All rights reserved. R. J. Cardullo called it, is itself less than completely cogent. The atmosphere may be as spiritual as anything in Wagner, but he explicitly intended the work as an Aryan, anti-Semitic allegory. (Admittedly, the first conductor was a Jew.) Moreover, it is an allegory that idealizes (again) Wagner’s view of male innocence beset by the temptations of woman: as in Tannhäuser’s enslavement within the Venusberg in Tannhäuser; or in Siegfried’s cutting open the armor of the sleeping Brünnhilde, in the third part of Der Ring des Nibelungen (The Ring of the Nibelungs, 1876), and exclaiming naïvely, “Das ist kein Mann!” Be that as it may, the Parsifal-Kundry encounter in Act II is still one of the most perceptive sexual rites of passage in drama. (Kundry entices Parsifal by speaking of his mother—more than a decade before Freud.) Writing from Bayreuth in 1889, Bernard Shaw had this to say on the subject: “And that long kiss of Kundry’s from which [Parsifal] learns so much is one of those pregnant simplicities which stare the world in the face for centuries and yet are never pointed out except by great men.”3 Figure 40. Parsifal, dir. Hans-Jürgen Syberberg, 1982 No wonder, then, that Syberberg, only one of a number of German artists who have simultaneously loved and loathed their country, should respond to Parsifal. Nonetheless, a question persists. Not the question of Syberberg’s alleged anti- Semitism or ultra-nationalism, the political nature of which does not interest me. The question that persists is an aesthetic one, and one that leads to the surprise mentioned earlier. Why did he film a work that was already famous in another medium? His previous films had been entirely his own creations. Why this co-creation? Here, Syberberg did begin with a new recording of Parsifal, but, except for bits of music rehearsals under the credits and a few snatches of random voices after the finish, he simply supplied visuals to accompany that recording. Again, why? 206.
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Reviving Hitler's Favorite Music
    Click here for Full Issue of EIR Volume 9, Number 35, September 14, 1982 Reviving Hitler's favorite music In Seattle, the Weyerhaeuserfamily is promoting Wagner's Ring cycle as a wedgefor the "new dark age" within the U.S. , writes Mark Calney If you want to see true Wagner you must go to Seattle. greeted not by the presence of our local Northwestpatricians -Winifred Wagner in black tie, which one would expect during the German cycle, but rather the flannel shirt and denim set. There were It was precisely 106 years ago in the ancient Bavarian forest cowboys from Colorado, gays from San Francisco, the on the outskirts of the German village of Bayreuth, that the neighborhood Anglican priest, and what appeared to be the first complete cycle of Richard Wagner's The Ring of the entire anthropology department from the local university, Nibelungs was performed. It was a most regal affair. This dispersed among the crowd. I overheard conversations in was to be the unveiling of mankind's greatest artistic achieve­ Japanese, German, Spanish, and Texan. A number of these ment, a four-day epic opera concerning the mythical birth pilgrims came from around the world-from Switzerland, and destiny of Man, depicting his various struggles amidst a South Africa, Tasmania, Chile, Indonesia, Saudi Arabia­ flotsamof dragons, dwarfs, and gods. Who was to attend this from 25 different countriesand from every state in the union. festival heralding the "New Age" in Wagner's "democratic For some it was their eighth sojournto this idyllically under­ theater?" populated part of America, to participate in the revelries of The premier day of Das Rheingold found the Bayreuth the only festival in the world which contiguously performs theater stuffed to the rafters with every imaginable repre­ the German and English cycles of the Ring (14 days), and sentative of the European oligarchy from Genoa to St.
    [Show full text]
  • Inside the Ring: Essays on Wagner's Opera Cycle
    Inside the Ring: Essays on Wagner’s Opera Cycle John Louis DiGaetani Professor Department of English and Freshman Composition James Morris as Wotan in Wagner’s Die Walküre. Photo: Jennifer Carle/The Metropolitan Opera hirty years ago I edited a book in the 1970s, the problem was finding a admirer of Hitler and she turned the titled Penetrating Wagner’s Ring: performance of the Ring, but now the summer festival into a Nazi showplace An Anthology. Today, I find problem is finding a ticket. Often these in the 1930s and until 1944 when the myself editing a book titled Ring cycles — the four operas done festival was closed. But her sons, Inside the Ring: Essays on within a week, as Wagner wanted — are Wieland and Wolfgang, managed to T Wagner’s Opera Cycle — to be sold out a year in advance of the begin- reopen the festival in 1951; there, published by McFarland Press in spring ning of the performances, so there is Wieland and Wolfgang’s revolutionary 2006. Is the Ring still an appropriate clearly an increasing demand for tickets new approaches to staging the Ring and subject for today’s audiences? Absolutely. as more and more people become fasci- the other Wagner operas helped to In fact, more than ever. The four operas nated by the Ring cycle. revive audience interest and see that comprise the Ring cycle — Das Wagnerian opera in a new visual style Rheingold, Die Walküre, Siegfried, and Political Complications and without its previous political associ- Götterdämmerung — have become more ations. Wieland and Wolfgang Wagner and more popular since the 1970s.
    [Show full text]
  • WAGNER and the VOLSUNGS None of Wagner’S Works Is More Closely Linked with Old Norse, and More Especially Old Icelandic, Culture
    WAGNER AND THE VOLSUNGS None of Wagner’s works is more closely linked with Old Norse, and more especially Old Icelandic, culture. It would be carrying coals to Newcastle if I tried to go further into the significance of the incom- parable eddic poems. I will just mention that on my first visit to Iceland I was allowed to gaze on the actual manuscript, even to leaf through it . It is worth noting that Richard Wagner possessed in his library the same Icelandic–German dictionary that is still used today. His copy bears clear signs of use. This also bears witness to his search for the meaning and essence of the genuinely mythical, its very foundation. Wolfgang Wagner Introduction to the program of the production of the Ring in Reykjavik, 1994 Selma Gu›mundsdóttir, president of Richard-Wagner-Félagi› á Íslandi, pre- senting Wolfgang Wagner with a facsimile edition of the Codex Regius of the Poetic Edda on his eightieth birthday in Bayreuth, August 1999. Árni Björnsson Wagner and the Volsungs Icelandic Sources of Der Ring des Nibelungen Viking Society for Northern Research University College London 2003 © Árni Björnsson ISBN 978 0 903521 55 0 The cover illustration is of the eruption of Krafla, January 1981 (Photograph: Ómar Ragnarsson), and Wagner in 1871 (after an oil painting by Franz von Lenbach; cf. p. 51). Cover design by Augl‡singastofa Skaparans, Reykjavík. Printed by Short Run Press Limited, Exeter CONTENTS PREFACE ............................................................................................ 6 INTRODUCTION ............................................................................... 7 BRIEF BIOGRAPHY OF RICHARD WAGNER ............................ 17 CHRONOLOGY ............................................................................... 64 DEVELOPMENT OF GERMAN NATIONAL CONSCIOUSNESS ..68 ICELANDIC STUDIES IN GERMANY .........................................
    [Show full text]
  • Accidental Tourism in Wagner's Bayreuth
    1 Accidental Tourism in Wagner’s Bayreuth An Analysis of Visitors’ Motivations and Experiences in Wagner’s Bayreuth. Myrto Moraitou Master Thesis Dissertation Accidental Tourism in Wagner’s Bayreuth An analysis of visitors’ motivations and experiences in Wagner’s Bayreuth Master Thesis Name: Myrto Moraitou Student number: 433480 Supervisor: Prof. Dr. S. L. Reijnders Date: June 12th 2018 Erasmus School of History, Culture and Communication Arts, Culture and Society Erasmus University Rotterdam Accidental Tourism in Wagner’s Bayreuth An analysis of visitors’ motivations and experiences in Wagner’s Bayreuth Abstract This research offers an analysis of the motivations and experiences of visitors in Wagner’s Bayreuth. Wagner’s Bayreuth is a great example of music tourism as it is maybe the first site where music lovers from around the world visited in order to listen and experience classical music. Taking as a starting point the theories developed on music tourism studies on sites related to popular music such as the ones of Connell and Gibson (2003), Gibson and Connell (2005, 2007) and Bolderman and Reijnders (2016), this research will try to identify whether these theories apply also on the classical music field, based on the example of Wagner’s Bayreuth. This paper addresses four visitor elements; the motivation, the expectation, the experience and evaluation of the above. The personal ‘identity’ of each visitor plays also an important role on their motives and evaluation procedure of the experience, as it defines the relationship between the visitor and the place and also the way of evaluation through their personal story. Through the analysis of these elements, using a qualitative approach with in depth interviews based on these elements, the findings suggest that there are some similarities in the behavior of the visitors between Wagner’s Bayreuth and previous researches on popular culture sites.
    [Show full text]
  • The Nuremberg Party Rallies, Wagner, and the Theatricality of Hitler And
    University of Hawai‘i at Hilo HOHONU 2015 Vol. 13 Cathedral of Light: The his imagery and music by the Nazi Party.7 Hitler was obsessed with Wagnerian operas. It was the only type of Nuremberg Party Rallies, music he listened to with any enthusiasm, and he could Wagner, and The Theatricality be heard whistling it perfectly.8 He was witnessed to be visibly calmed by the music of Wagner when agitated. of Hitler and the Nazi Party According to Goebbels, Hitler had a “strong inner need Stacey Reed for art,” and was known to, in the middle of important History 395 political negotiations or tactical battles to go by himself Fall 2012 or with a few comrades, to sit in a theater and listen to “the heroically elevated measures of a Wagnerian music The National Socialist, or Nazi, Party was drama in artistic unison with his political being.”10 This keenly aware of the power of the arts, the elements of was a tendency that began long before his appointment the theatre, and the power of spectacle on the minds and as Chancellor. Already a passionate follower of Wagner's attitudes of the German people. This was especially true works, Hitler was further directed on his path towards of music, and they found fertile ground in the minds of Führer when, upon meeting Wagner's son-in-law at the people through the imagination of Richard Wagner his Villa Wahnfried in Bayreuth in September, 1923, and his great, nationalistic Operas. The Nazi Party the master of the house told him that he saw in Hitler, engaged with the political philosophy of the composer Germany's savior.11 Hitler would go on to make Wagner and elevated the enjoyment of his art to a key ritual of a central part of his Nazi Mythos, incorporating his works the cult of Nazism.
    [Show full text]
  • Zenetudományi Folyóirat Li
    ZENETUDOMÁNYI FOLYÓIRAT LI. évfolyam, 4. szám . 2013. november Magyar Zene ZENETUDOMÁNYI FOLYÓIRAT – 2013/4 Szerkesztô / Editor: Péteri Judit Szerkesztôbizottság / Editorial Board: Dalos Anna, Domokos Mária, Eckhardt Mária, Komlós Katalin, Mikusi Balázs, Péteri Lóránt, Székely András, Vikárius László Tanácsadó testület / Advisory Board: Malcolm Bilson (Ithaca, NY), Dorottya Fabian (Sydney), Farkas Zoltán, Jeney Zoltán, Kárpáti János, Laki Péter (Annandale- on- Hudson, NY), Rovátkay Lajos (Hannover), Sárosi Bálint, Somfai László, Szegedy- Maszák Mihály, Tallián Tibor A Magyar Zenetudományi és Zenekritikai Társaság lapja • Felelôs kiadó: a Társaság elnöke • Levelezési cím (belföldi elôfizetés): Magyar Zene, Magyar Zenetudományi és Zenekritikai Társaság, 1064 Budapest, Vörösmarty utca 35. ([email protected]) A folyóirat tartalomjegyzékét lásd: www.magyarzene.info, archívumát lásd: http:// mzzt.hu/index_HU.asp (Magyar Zene folyóirat menüpont) • Kéziratot nem ôrzünk meg, és csak felbélyegzett válaszborítékkal küldünk vissza • Külföldön elôfizetés- ben terjeszti a Batthyány Kultur- Press kft., telefon/telefax (+36 1) 201 88 91, (+36 1) 212 53 03; e- mail: batthyany@kultur- press.hu • Elôfizethetô a terjesztôktôl kért pos- tautalványon. Elôfizetési díj egy évre 2400 forint. Egyes szám ára 600 forint • Megje- lenik évente négyszer • Tördelés: graphoman • Címlapterv: Fodor Attila • Nyom- tatta az Argumentum Könyv- és Folyóiratkiadó kft. Budapesten • ISSN 0025- 0384 355 TARTALOM – CONTENTS TANULMÁNY – ARTICLES 357 KÖVÉR GYÖRGY A történész és
    [Show full text]
  • The Political Ramifications of Hitler's Cult of Wagner
    Hans Rudolf Vaget THE POLITICAL RAMIFICATIONS OF HITLER’S CULT OF WAGNER aus: Zum Gedenken an Peter Borowsky Herausgegeben von Rainer Hering und Rainer Nicolaysen (Hamburger Universitätsreden Neue Folge 3. Herausgeber: Der Präsident der Universität Hamburg) S. 103-127 IMPRESSUM DER GESAMTAUSGABE Bibliografische Information Der Deutschen Bibliothek Die Deutsche Bibliothek verzeichnet diese Publikation in der Deut- schen Nationalbibliografie; detaillierte bibliografische Daten sind im Internet über http://dnb.ddb.de abrufbar. Diese Publikation ist außerdem auf der Website des Verlags Ham- burg University Press open access verfügbar unter http://hup.rrz.uni-hamburg.de. Die Deutsche Bibliothek hat die Netzpublikation archiviert. Diese ist dauerhaft auf dem Archivserver Der Deutschen Bibliothek verfügbar unter http://deposit.ddb.de. ISBN 3-9808223-6-2 (Printausgabe) ISSN 0438-4822 (Printausgabe) Beratung: Eckart Krause, Hamburg Umschlaggestaltung: Behrooz Elmi, Hamburg Typografie: Benno Kieselstein, Hamburg Erstellt mit StarOffice / OpenOffice.org Druck: Uni-HH Print & Mail, Hamburg Der Bildabdruck erfolgt mit freundlicher Genehmigung von Hans Liermann, Hamburg. © 2003 Hamburg University Press, Hamburg http://hup.rrz.uni-hamburg.de Rechtsträger: Universität Hamburg GESAMTINHALTSVERZEICHNIS 9 Zeittafel Peter Borowsky 15 Vorwort 17 TRAUERFEIER FRIEDHOF HAMBURG- NIENSTEDTEN, 20. OKTOBER 2000 19 Gertraud Gutzmann Nachdenken über Peter Borowsky 25 Rainer Nicolaysen Trauerrede für Peter Borowsky 31 GEDENKFEIER UNIVERSITÄT HAMBURG, 8. FEBRUAR 2001
    [Show full text]
  • Press Release
    27. April 2015 Press Release Grand Opening Richard Wagner Museum Haus Wahnfried in Bayreuth Photograph: RWM National-Archive, Post-card Haus Wahnfried, around 1915 Richard Wagner's ‘Haus Wahnfried’ and the Richard Wagner Museum Bayreuth are re-opening to the public. After almost three years of construction and 20-Million Euro investment in the restoration of Haus Wahnfried and the new Museum building the work has now reached it´s finishing straight. The project was made possible due to prestigious grants from the Federal State, State of Bavaria, as well as other public grant donors such as the Upper Franconia Foundation, the Bavarian ‘Landesstiftung’ and the ‘Landesstelle’ for non-governmental museums in Bavaria. 1 On 26 July 2015 Bayreuth and the Richard Wagner Foundation opens the new and most significant Museum of the City. The Museum in Haus Wahnfried, which first opened for visitors in 1976, will be presented anew with an extension and three thematically different permanent exhibitions. The Richard Wagner Museum doubled its permanent exhibition space with three substantive priorities in the future: Visitors will experience the most authentic place of documentation about the life, works and achievements of Richard Wagner in Haus Wahnfried. The ground floor opens with a complete insight into the time around 1880 and the world of Richard Wagner for the first time. Many friends and celebrities were guests here. Documents from manuscripts and graphic collections from the National Archives will be presented in changing exhibitions on the mezzanine floor. Architect Staab, Design of the New Building 2013 2 The extended building, designed from the well-known Berlin museum architect Volker Staab, is dedicated to the performance history of the Bayreuth Festival from its beginnings to the present.
    [Show full text]
  • The Effect of Richard Wagner's Music and Beliefs on Hitler's Ideology
    Musical Offerings Volume 7 Number 2 Fall 2016 Article 1 9-2016 The Effect of Richard Wagner's Music and Beliefs on Hitler's Ideology Carolyn S. Ticker Cedarville University, [email protected] Follow this and additional works at: https://digitalcommons.cedarville.edu/musicalofferings Part of the European History Commons, Fine Arts Commons, Musicology Commons, and the Music Performance Commons DigitalCommons@Cedarville provides a publication platform for fully open access journals, which means that all articles are available on the Internet to all users immediately upon publication. However, the opinions and sentiments expressed by the authors of articles published in our journals do not necessarily indicate the endorsement or reflect the views of DigitalCommons@Cedarville, the Centennial Library, or Cedarville University and its employees. The authors are solely responsible for the content of their work. Please address questions to [email protected]. Recommended Citation Ticker, Carolyn S. (2016) "The Effect of Richard Wagner's Music and Beliefs on Hitler's Ideology," Musical Offerings: Vol. 7 : No. 2 , Article 1. DOI: 10.15385/jmo.2016.7.2.1 Available at: https://digitalcommons.cedarville.edu/musicalofferings/vol7/iss2/1 The Effect of Richard Wagner's Music and Beliefs on Hitler's Ideology Document Type Article Abstract The Holocaust will always be remembered as one of the most horrific and vile events in all of history. One question that has been so pervasive in regards to this historical event is the question of why. Why exactly did Hitler massacre the Jewish people? Why did he come to the conclusion that the Jews were somehow lesser than him, and that it was okay to kill them? What and who were his influences and how did they help form Hitler’s opinions leading up to the Holocaust? Although more than one situation or person influenced Hitler, I believe that one man in particular really helped contribute to Hitler’s ideas, especially about the Jewish people.
    [Show full text]
  • Houston Stewart Chamberlain
    HOUSTON STEWART CHAMBERLAIN COSIMA WAGNER, NÉE DE FLAVIGNY ANNA CHAMBERLAIN, NÉE HORST 1855-1927 1837 - 1930 1846 - 1924 English writer, private scholar, German by choice, Illegitimate daughter of Marie d’Agoult and Franz Met Chamberlain in Cannes in 1874, married in anti-Semite. After breaking off his scientific Liszt, married from 1857 to 1869 to the conductor Geneva in 1878, no children. The couple lived studies, he contacted the Wagner family, Hans von Bülow, two daughters: Daniela and in Geneva and Dresden. In 1905, Chamberlain separated from his first wife Anna Horst and Blandine. From 1863 on, love affair with Richard separated from Anna by letter, refused direct married Eva Wagner in 1908. The Foundations of Wagner, whom she married in 1870, three contact from that time on and communicated the 19th Century, his main work on race theory, illegitimate children: Isolde, Eva and Siegfried. with her only through a lawyer. In 1905 last was an influential bestseller in the early 20th After Wagner’s death in 1883, she directed the meeting when visiting Anna’s sickbed. The century. Bayreuth Festival until 1907. marriage was divorced in 1906. SIEGFRIED “FIDI” WAGNER WINIFRED WAGNER, NÉE WILLIAMS EVA CHAMBERLAIN, NÉE VON BÜLOW 1869 - 1930 1897 - 1980 1867 -1942 English orphan, festival director 1930 - 1944. Composer and conductor, youngest child Wagner’s second daughter, wife of Houston Her adoptive father, the Wagnerian and Wagner and only son of Richard Wagner, homosexual. Chamberlain (marriage: 1908 - 1927) and an friend Karl Klindworth, with whom she grew up Besides his engagement for the Bayreuth enthusiastic National Socialist.
    [Show full text]
  • Famous Composer Richard Wagner in Bayreuth
    today 1883 1872 Richard Wagner conducts Beethovens ninth Synphonie on 22 May The Festival Theatre 1876 (G. Bechstein) The funeral procession with Wagner‘s casket, 18.2.1883 World Heritage Opera House Festspielhaus on the Green Hill Arrival at the Station Richard-Wagner-Stops in Bayreuth Tourist-Information Richard Wagner’s Tannhäuser was performed here already in 1860, in the Nowhere else in the world is there an opera house built specifically for the When Wagner and his family moved to Bayreuth in 1872, they arrived at Festspielhaus Richard Wagner Museum Tourist-Information presence of King Maximilian II of Bavaria. And in 1870, when Wagner was works of just one composer. This was a dream that Richard Wagner had to the old railway station. In 1876, the year of the first Festspiele, the second Villa Wahnfried Trustees: & Bayreuth Shop still living in the Villa Tribschen in Switzerland and was on the lookout for a fight for. In those days copyright was still in its infancy and many theatres laid railway line connecting Bayreuth to Nuremberg and the new station were Festival House Richard-Wagner-Stiftung Bayreuth Opernstrasse 22 / 95444 Bayreuth venue for his Festspiele, the conductor Hans Richter recommended it to him on performances with almost no rehearsals at all and singers who were not still under construction. They finally opened in 1879, and Cosima noted in Grüner Hügel Director: Dr. Sven Friedrich Tel. +49-(0)921-885 88 on account of its unusually large stage. But when Richard and Cosima visited particularly good at singing, let alone acting. Musicians were paid servants’ her diary entry for 23 September: “Drank beer at the new station, which R.
    [Show full text]
  • 2. Politics, Aesthetics, and Patriarchy in the Confessions of Winifred Wagner
    MARCIA LANDY1 2. POLITICS, AESTHETICS, AND PATRIARCHY IN THE CONFESSIONS OF WINIFRED WAGNER In The Confessions of Winifred Wagner (1975), Hans-Jürgen Syberberg has made a contribution to the history of film form and theory in his conception and execution of the film essay. He has also made a contribution to a theoretical understanding of the politics of culture by invoking the relationship between politics, aesthetics, and patriarchy. Through a close examination of Winifred Wagner’s role as a woman and as a powerful public force in the German culture establishment, he elicits the common elements in the preservation and maintenance of the symbolic order in both the public and private dimensions of her life. Common to both spheres are the expressions of patriarchy as exemplified in the family, social roles, and artistic creation. The Confessions of Winifred Wagner poses formidable challenges for its audiences. A work that can be dismissed as visually uninteresting and politically mystifying to those who are accustomed to established types of nonfiction films or to more direct forms of political statement, the film is difficult to view and raises, even if it does not answer, complex questions about art and politics. Without giving any direct information or examples of Richard Wagner’s art, it taxes its audience to recollect, infer, and probe the role of that art and of Bayreuth as a dominant phenomenon in the perpetuation of German culture and, in particular, in the creation and triumph of Nazism. The audience is forced, moreover, to confront Winifred Wagner as an important agent in the preservation and transmission of that culture, and, through her, to confront the absent, though central, reality of Adolf Hitler and his influence on German art and politics from 1923 to 1945.
    [Show full text]