CHANGESCHANGES PROJECTPROJECT –– MILESTONEMILESTONE 33 WP2 WP2 – – CHANGES PROJECT CHANGES PROJECT experiences previous of Conceptualization CHANGES PROJECT CHANGES PROJECT experiences previous of Conceptualization

Foppoli Moretta e Associati consulting engineers - (SO) - [email protected] www.foppolimoretta.it StudyStudy areasareas

Zillis Munstair S. Romerio Two very different study areas :

Valtellina: Mountain territory Country environment Stone masonry Stone roofs Cremona Plain territory WP2 Town environment WP2 – – Brick masonry Shingles roofs

If it is of interest it is possible also to analyze some case history out of EU in Switzerland (Graubünden region – very close to ) CHANGES PROJECT CHANGES PROJECT experiences previous of Conceptualization CHANGES PROJECT CHANGES PROJECT experiences previous of Conceptualization

The project will be carried out in two areas in the northern and in the southern part of Lombardia: the territory of Valtellina and the town of Cremona AnAn overalloverall viewview ofof previousprevious experiencesexperiences inin ValtellinaValtellina Project Period Buildings nr. Activities

L 102/90 1996-2003 70 Restoration works (reconstruction after Total amount 1987 flood) € 30.000.000

Cultural District of 2011-2015 40 General inspections Valtellina Educational activities

CPRE Interreg project 2013-2014 30 Structural inspection LV1 Educational activities

Innovative 2009-2014 Besta Palace Dignosis and WP2 WP2

technologies Besta Manor monitoring – – Ponte S. Ignazio church Masegra castle

PPC 2009-2014 Teglio Besta Palace Conservation plan (ITALY) Sondrio Masegra castle S. Antonio monastery

PPC 2009-2014 Zillis S. Martino church Conservation plan CHANGES PROJECT CHANGES PROJECT experiences previous of Conceptualization (SWITZWELAND) Mustair S. Giovanni monastery CHANGES PROJECT experiences previous of Conceptualization

FMeA will support Politecnico to collect informations concerning with activities related with PPC carried out in Valtellina and Graubünden region in the last 20 years TheThe beginning:beginning: reconstructionreconstruction afterafter 19871987 floodflood

• FOLLOWING THE FLOOD OF 1987 RECONSTRUCTION HAS BEEN FUNDED UNDER A SPECIAL LAW (CALLED “LEGGE VALTELLINA”) WHICH AMONG OTHERS PROVIDED FINANCING FOR HERITAGE BUILDING RESTORATION WORKS. • THE RESTORATION WORKS WERE CARRIED ON IN THE YEARS BETWEEN 1997 AND 2002 • OVERALL HAVE BEEN FINANCED IN TOTAL 67 WP2 RESTORATION WORK WP2 – – • WITH AN ADDITIONAL SPECIAL FUND OTHER 12 BUILDINGS HAVE BEEN RESTORED.

Total amount of the project: 35 MLNs Financing with own resources 25% CHANGES PROJECT CHANGES PROJECT experiences previous of Conceptualization CHANGES PROJECT CHANGES PROJECT experiences previous of Conceptualization

CONSERVATION WORKS TheThe beginning:beginning: reconstructionreconstruction afterafter 19871987 floodflood

62 61 60 59

57 58

56 54 55 WP2 1 2 53 WP2 – 3 52 – 63 64 65 79 51 50 4 47 46 49 48 21 45 77 44 34 35 41 42 25 27 29 8 9 13 31 38 43 69 12 33 36 78 5 22 23 24 26 32 40 7 11 37 39 LEGENDA: 14 19 20 70 71 6 67 68 30 15 16 72 73 74 76 BUILDINGS OF 66 10 17 18 LEGGE VALTELLINA CHANGES PROJECT CHANGES PROJECT experiences previous of Conceptualization 75 CHANGES PROJECT experiences previous of Conceptualization 28

CONSERVATION WORKS TheThe beginning:beginning: reconstructionreconstruction afterafter 19871987 floodflood

ALL THESE MEASURES ARE THEREFORE BEEN MADE: IN A LIMITED PERIOD OF TIME •WITH SIMILAR TECHNOLOGY AND CRITERIA •WITH MONITORING OF COMPETENT SOPRINTENDENZE •WITH THE SUPERVISION OF THE PROVINCIAL ADMINISTRATION WP2 ALTHOUGH THEIR POSITIVE EFFECT, THE RESULTS OF THOSE WP2 – OPERATIONS WERE NOT SUBJECT TO A GOOD PPC – APPROACH.

CONSEQUENTLY IN SPITE OF THE RELEVANT INVESTIMENT, RESTORED BUILDINGS HAVE NOT PROVIDED APPROPRIATE INCENTIVE FOR THE PROMOTION AND DEVELOPMENT OF THE TERRITORY. CHANGES PROJECT CHANGES PROJECT experiences previous of Conceptualization CHANGES PROJECT CHANGES PROJECT experiences previous of Conceptualization TheThe developmentdevelopment ofof ideaidea ofof PPCPPC inin ValtellinaValtellina

OVER THE YEARS AFTER 2002 HAS BEEN DEVELOPED, EVEN WITH THE SUPPORT OF FOUNDATION CARIPLO, MANY PROJECTS THAT HAVE A POSITIVE APPROACH WITH PPC METHODOLOGIES INVOLVED THE LAND AND OVERALL MAY BE ENTERED IN THE CONTEXT OF PLANNED PRESERVATION.

‹ “ANTICA PIEVE DI MAZZO ” PROJECT YEARS 2006-2009

‹ “INNOVATIVE TECHNOLOGIES ” PROJECT WP2 WP2 – YEARS 2009-2010 –

‹ “CULTURAL DISTRICT ” PROJECT YEARS 2011-2015

‹ “INTERREG CPRE ” PROJECT YEARS 2013-2015 CHANGES PROJECT CHANGES PROJECT experiences previous of Conceptualization CHANGES PROJECT CHANGES PROJECT experiences previous of Conceptualization TheThe developmentdevelopment ofof WWideaideaP2P2 ofof PPCPPC inin ValtellinaValtellina

CONSERVATION WORKS

THE REGION WP2 WP2 – – CHANGES PROJECT CHANGES PROJECT experiences previous of Conceptualization CHANGES PROJECT CHANGES PROJECT experiences previous of Conceptualization

PATNERS OF THE PROJECT “ANTICA PIEVE DI MAZZO” : Comunità Montana Valtellina di Tirano, minucipality of Mazzo, , , , several parishes, local associations and social cooperatives. DevelopmentDevelopment ofof territoryterritory throughthrough thethe WWP2P2 integratedintegrated managementmanagement ofof culturalcultural heritageheritage

ENHANCEMENT OF SKILLS ‹ enhance the usability of the historical- artistic heritage; ‹ insert the proposal into a larger cultural

PROVENIENZA DEI CONTRIBUTI touristic offer that includes innovative ways of enjoyment of landscape and environmental goods;

L.Regionali Provincia ‹ identify synergies to promote both the 0,4% 21,0% cultural and environmental heritage either some products of excellence in the

partner pubblici area; 26,9% Altro ‹ development accommodation facilities in WP2 40,9% WP2 – the area to respond to the needs of the – partner privati 14,0% target which it intends to address the CARIPLO 37,7% offer.

Total amount of the project: € 1,991,000 CHANGES PROJECT CHANGES PROJECT experiences previous of Conceptualization Financing with own resources 41% CHANGES PROJECT experiences previous of Conceptualization InnovativeInnovative technologiestechnologies forfor plannedplanned WWP2P2 conservationconservation ofof historicalhistorical buildingsbuildings

MAINTENANCE ACTIVITIES

Spesa complessiva Cofinanziamento

Comune di Bianzone € 67.315 € 9.134

Direzione Regionale € 87.455 € 87.455 Soprintendenza di Milano

Parrocchia S.Stefano € 80.318 € 3.500 Associazione Antica Pieve di Mazzo WP2

Comune di € 110.296 € 50.296 WP2 – –

SOMMANO € 345.384 € 150.384

Total amount of the project: € 345,000 Financing with own resources 44% CHANGES PROJECT CHANGES PROJECT experiences previous of Conceptualization CHANGES PROJECT CHANGES PROJECT experiences previous of Conceptualization

Buildings involved: Palazzo Besta di Teglio Palazzetto Besta di Bianzone Battistero di Mazzo Chiesa di S. Ignazio di Ponte InnovativeInnovative technologiestechnologies WWP2P2 BestaBesta PalacePalace TeglioTeglio (SO)(SO) PARTNERS INVOLVED: MAINTENANCE ACTIVITIES - REGIONAL DIRECTORATE FOR CULTURAL HERITAGE AND LANDSCAPE OF LOMBARDIA - ANTICA PIEVE DI MAZZO – CULTURAL ASSOCIATION WP2 WP2 – – CHANGES PROJECT CHANGES PROJECT experiences previous of Conceptualization CHANGES PROJECT CHANGES PROJECT experiences previous of Conceptualization ACTIVITY 'PLANNED : Surveys on the structure and surfaces Structural and the surface degradation monitoring Environmental and microclimate monitoring Maintenance activities Maintenance Plan InnovativeInnovative technologiestechnologies WWP2P2 BestaBesta ManorManor BianzoneBianzone (SO)(SO) PARTNERS INVOLVED: MAINTENANCE ACTIVITIES - MUNICIPALITY OF BIANZONE (SO) - REGIONAL DIRECTORATE FOR CULTURAL HERITAGE AND LANDSCAPE OF LOMBARDIA WP2 WP2 – – CHANGES PROJECT CHANGES PROJECT experiences previous of Conceptualization ACTIVITY 'PLANNED : laserscanner relief Investigations on the structure and surfaces CHANGES PROJECT experiences previous of Conceptualization Structural and the surface degradation monitoring Stratigraphic research and surveys of the characters of the plaster materials Environmental monitoring and microclimate Maintenance activities Preliminary project of restoration works InnovativeInnovative technologiestechnologies WWP2P2 S.IgnazioS.Ignazio ChurchChurch PontePonte inin Valtellina(SO)Valtellina(SO) PARTNERS INVOLVED: MAINTENANCE ACTIVITIES - MUNICIPALITY OF PONTE IN VALTELLINA(SO) WP2 WP2 – – CHANGES PROJECT CHANGES PROJECT experiences previous of Conceptualization ACTIVITY 'PLANNED : laserscanner relief Investigations on the structure and surfaces CHANGES PROJECT experiences previous of Conceptualization Structural and the surface degradation monitoring Geoelectric surveys Stratigraphic research and surveys of the characters of the plaster materials Environmental monitoring and microclimate Reflectometric analysis Maintenance plan Preliminary project of restoration works AA changechange ofof stepstep:: WWP2P2 CulturalCultural DistrictDistrict ofof VALTELLINAVALTELLINA (CDV)(CDV)

THE PROJECT "CULTURAL DISTRICTS" WAS DEVELOPED BY THE CARIPLO FOUNDATION TO WP2 SUPPORT THE OPPORTUNITY OF WP2 – ENHANCE CULTURAL HERITAGE – AS A PULSE FOR ECONOMIC AND SOCIAL GROWTH OF THE TERRITORY PROMOTING AND IMPLEMENTING INTEGRATED VALORISATION PROCESS (INCLUDING ECONOMIC) OF CULTURAL HERITAGE CHANGES PROJECT CHANGES PROJECT experiences previous of Conceptualization CHANGES PROJECT CHANGES PROJECT experiences previous of Conceptualization AA changechange ofof stepstep:: WWP2P2 CulturalCultural DistrictDistrict ofof VALTELLINAVALTELLINA

THE “CULTURAL DISTRICT OF VALTELLINA” AIMS TO: VIDENTIFYING THE ROLE THAT THE LANDSCAPE, MONUMENTAL AND ARTISTIC HERITAGE HAS IN THE DEVELOPMENT STRATEGY OF TERRITORY. VDEVELOP THE IDENTIFICATION AND AWARENESS OF LOCAL COMMUNITIES. WP2 WP2 – VENHANCE CULTURAL HERITAGE . –

VMAKE A SYSTEM OF CULTURAL ACTIVITIES .

Total amount of the project: € 8,290,000 CHANGES PROJECT CHANGES PROJECT experiences previous of Conceptualization Financing with own resources 57% CHANGES PROJECT experiences previous of Conceptualization AA changechange ofof stepstep:: CulturalCultural DistrictDistrict ofof VALTELLINAVALTELLINA

CONSERVATION WORKS

MAINTENANCE ENHANCEMENT ACTIVITIES WP2 CULTURAL DISTRICT OF VALTELLINA WP2 – –

PLANNED CONSERVATION CHANGES PROJECT CHANGES PROJECT experiences previous of Conceptualization CHANGES PROJECT CHANGES PROJECT experiences previous of Conceptualization CulturalCultural districtdistrict ofof VALTELLINAVALTELLINA WWP2P2 TheThe WAYWAY OFOF TERRACESTERRACES (WP1)(WP1) WP2 WP2 – –

DATA Prov. SO DCV

SURFACE 3.200 km 2 2.760 km 2 POPULATION 180.000 155.000 C.MONTANE 5 4 CHANGES PROJECT CHANGES PROJECT experiences previous of Conceptualization MUNICIPALITY 78 65 CHANGES PROJECT experiences previous of Conceptualization CulturalCultural districtdistrict ofof VALTELLINAVALTELLINA WWP2P2 TangiblesTangibles AssetsAssets WPsWPs (2(2 --6)6) CONSERVATION WORKS WP2 WP2 – – CHANGES PROJECT CHANGES PROJECT experiences previous of Conceptualization CHANGES PROJECT CHANGES PROJECT experiences previous of Conceptualization WP 2 – MASEGRA CASTLE - SONDRIO WP 3 – CLOISTER OF SAINT ANTHONY - MORBEGNO WP 4 – CIRCUIT OF THE CASTLES AND HISTORIC BUILDINGS IN THE AREA OF TIRANO WP 6 – THE WAY OF WATER AND ENERGY CulturalCultural districtdistrict ofof VALTELLINAVALTELLINA WWP2P2 IntangiblesIntangibles AssetsAssets WPsWPs (7(7 --10)10)

ENHANCEMENT OF SKILLS WP2 WP2 – – CHANGES PROJECT CHANGES PROJECT experiences previous of Conceptualization CHANGES PROJECT CHANGES PROJECT experiences previous of Conceptualization

WP 5 – TECHNOLOGIES FOR INTEGRATED PROMOTION WP 7 – THE "GOOD PRACTICE" OF RESTORATION: CRITICAL ANALYSIS AND PROPOSALS WPs 8/9/10 – TRAINING ACTIVITIES ADDRESSED TO TEACHERS, SCHOOLS AND PROFESSIONALS CulturalCultural districtdistrict ofof VALTELLINAVALTELLINA WWP2P2 IspectionsIspections andand criticalcritical analysisanalysis

MAINTENANCE ACTIVITIES

62 61 60 59

57 58

56 54 55 WP2 1 2 53 WP2 52 –

3 – 63 64 65 79 51 50 4 47 46 49 48 21 45 77 44 34 35 41 42 25 27 29 8 9 13 31 38 43 69 12 33 36 78 5 22 23 24 26 32 40 LEGENDA: 7 11 37 39 14 19 20 70 71 6 67 68 30 15 16 BUILDINGS OF 72 73 74 76 66 10 LEGGE VALTELLINA 17 18 75 CHANGES PROJECT CHANGES PROJECT experiences previous of Conceptualization 28 ISPECTIONS CARRIED CHANGES PROJECT experiences previous of Conceptualization ON BY DCV

WP 7.1 – ISPECTION SERVICE FOR THE CRITICAL ANALYSIS OF THE CURRENT STATUS OF HERITAGE BUILDINGS RESTORED AFTER 1987 FLOOD. (40 BUILDINGS) WWP2P2 TheThe UNESCOUNESCO aa CHANCECHANCE OfOf COOPERATIONCOOPERATION WP2 WP2 – – CHANGES PROJECT CHANGES PROJECT experiences previous of Conceptualization CHANGES PROJECT CHANGES PROJECT experiences previous of Conceptualization

RAETHIAN RAILWAY IN THE ALBULABERNINA LANDSCAPE ApproachApproach toto PPCPPC inin GRAUBUENDENGRAUBUENDEN WWP2P2 (SWITZERLAND)(SWITZERLAND) CHURCH OF S.MARTINO ZILLS (GR) WP2 WP2 – – CHANGES PROJECT CHANGES PROJECT experiences previous of Conceptualization CHANGES PROJECT CHANGES PROJECT experiences previous of Conceptualization CPRE:CPRE: PlannedPlanned conservationconservation inin thethe commoncommon WWP2P2 RhaetianRhaetian areaarea PARTNERS

•• FONDAZIONEFONDAZIONE DIDI SVILUPPOSVILUPPO LOCALELOCALE ITALIANITALIAN LEADERLEADER

ï COMUNE DI SONDRIO ïCOMUNE DI TIRANO ïPOLITECNICO DI MILANO ï ï

•• REGIONEREGIONE VALPOSCHIAVOVALPOSCHIAVO •• SWISS SWISS LEADERLEADER WP2 WP2 – – ïDenkmalpfleige ï POLO POSCHIAVO ïTgira da monuments ïServizio monumenti

SUPPORTERS

ï PROVINCIA DI SONDRIO CHANGES PROJECT CHANGES PROJECT experiences previous of Conceptualization CHANGES PROJECT CHANGES PROJECT experiences previous of Conceptualization CPRE:CPRE: AIMSAIMS TRAINING TRAINING KNOWLEDGE KNOWLEDGE WP2 WP2 – – VALORIZATION VALORIZATION CONSERVATION CONSERVATION ï history of buildings ï of materials ï of building ï systemic assesment ï increase in trade technologies ï vision of pro-active ï technicians ï increase job protection ï of the local context ï craftsmen opportunities ï conservation plans ï correlation between ï integrated ï growth of tourism buildings and cultural ï collaboration with multidisciplinary ï creation of a pool of landscape

UNESCO CHANGES PROJECT experiences previous of Conceptualization approach expertise CHANGES PROJECT experiences previous of Conceptualization CPRE:CPRE: PLANNEDPLANNED ACTIVITIESACTIVITIES

CONSERVATION WORKS

•XENODOCHI DI S.PERPETUA •E S.ROMERIO •CASTEL MASEGRA •Comune di Tirano •Comune di Sondrio •Servizio Monumenti GR WP2 KNOWLEDGE AND WP2 – CONSERVATION – WORKS

•STAZIONE DI ALP GRÜM •STAZIONE FERROVIARIA •Tracciato ferrovia Retica CHANGES PROJECT CHANGES PROJECT experiences previous of Conceptualization CHANGES PROJECT CHANGES PROJECT experiences previous of Conceptualization •Comune di Tirano •Servizio Munumenti GR CPRE:CPRE: PREVENTIVEPREVENTIVE SEISMICALSEISMICAL ASSESSMENTASSESSMENT

MAINTENANCE ACTIVITIES

62 61 60 59

57 58

56 54 55 1 2 53 WP2 WP2 3 52 – 63 – 64 65 79 51 50 4 47 46 49 48 21 45 77 44 34 35 41 42 25 27 29 8 9 13 31 38 43 69 12 33 36 78 5 22 23 24 26 32 40 LEGENDA: 7 11 37 39 14 19 20 70 71 6 67 68 30 BUILDINGS OF 15 16 72 73 74 76 LEGGE VALTELLINA 66 10 17 18 75 ISPECTIONS CARRIED CHANGES PROJECT CHANGES PROJECT experiences previous of Conceptualization 28 ON BY DCV CHANGES PROJECT experiences previous of Conceptualization

CPRE LV1 ANALYSIS

PREVENTIVE SEISMICAL ASSESSMENT OF HERITAGE BUILDINGS RESTORED AFTER 1987 FLOOD. (36 BUILDINGS) CPRECPRE :: EFFECTSEFFECTS ONON THETHE TERRITORYTERRITORY

∑ DEVELOPMENT AND APPLICATION OF ADVANCED AND INNOVATIVE TECHNOLOGIES IN THE AREA OF VALTELLINA / VALPOSCHIAVO ∑ DEVELOPMENT AND SHARING OF THE PRACTICE OF PLANNED MAINTENANCE AND PRESERVATION OF CULTURAL HERITAGE ∑ INCREASE OF THE INTER-BORDER COOPERATION IN THE TECHNICAL FIELD ∑ COMBINED TRAINING OF OPERATORS AND TECHNICAL VIEW TO A POSSIBLE WP2 INTER-BORDER MOBILITY WP2 – ∑ CREATION OF USEFUL COMPETENCE FOR THE EXCHANGE OF QUALIFYING – EXPERIENCES IN THE ALPINE CONTEXT ∑ CREATION OF USEFUL COMPETENCE FOR THE EXCHANGE OF QUALIFYING EXPERIENCES IN THE UNESCO CONTEXT

Total amount of the project: € 1.570000 CHANGES PROJECT CHANGES PROJECT experiences previous of Conceptualization Financing with own resources 56% CHANGES PROJECT experiences previous of Conceptualization

ENHANCEMENT OF SKILLS ANAN OVERALLOVERALL ECONOMICALECONOMICAL VIEWVIEW

Total Knowledge Conservation Maintenance Enhancement Projects Amount Works Activities Management DCV+CPRE €8.940.400 €565.400 €6.147.036 €145.284 €1.551.990 €530.690 WP2 6,3% 68,8% 1,6% 17,4% 5,9% WP2 – Pieve di mazzo €1.991.019 €74.799 €1.621.303 €7.461 €262.280 €25.175 – 3,8% 81,4% 0,4% 13,2% 1,3% IT Besta+SIgnazio €345.383 €217.186 €0 €66.335 €24.240 €37.623 62,9% 0,0% 19,2% 7,0% 10,9%

SOMMANO €11.276.802 €857.385 €7.768.339 €219.080 €1.838.510 €593.488 7,6% 68,9% 1,9% 16,3% 5,3% CHANGES PROJECT CHANGES PROJECT experiences previous of Conceptualization CHANGES PROJECT CHANGES PROJECT experiences previous of Conceptualization