Relationships Between Lamb Carcass Quality Traits Measured by X-Ray Computed Tomography and Current UK Hill Sheep Breeding Goals
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Edinburgh Research Explorer Relationships between lamb carcass quality traits measured by X-ray computed tomography (CT) and current UK-hill sheep breeding goals. Citation for published version: Lambe, NR, Conington, J, Bishop, SC, McLean, KA, Bünger, L, McLaren, A & Simm, G 2008, 'Relationships between lamb carcass quality traits measured by X-ray computed tomography (CT) and current UK-hill sheep breeding goals.', Animal, vol. 2, pp. 36-43. Link: Link to publication record in Edinburgh Research Explorer Document Version: Publisher's PDF, also known as Version of record Published In: Animal Publisher Rights Statement: Copyright The Animal Consortium 2008 General rights Copyright for the publications made accessible via the Edinburgh Research Explorer is retained by the author(s) and / or other copyright owners and it is a condition of accessing these publications that users recognise and abide by the legal requirements associated with these rights. Take down policy The University of Edinburgh has made every reasonable effort to ensure that Edinburgh Research Explorer content complies with UK legislation. If you believe that the public display of this file breaches copyright please contact [email protected] providing details, and we will remove access to the work immediately and investigate your claim. Download date: 01. Oct. 2021 Animal (2008), 2:1, pp 36–43 & The Animal Consortium 2008 animal doi: 10.1017/S1751731107001061 Relationships between lamb carcass quality traits measured by X-ray computed tomography and current UK hill sheep breeding goals - N. R. Lambe1 , J. Conington1, S. C. Bishop2, K. A. McLean1,L.Bu¨ nger1, A. McLaren1 and G. Simm1 1Sustainable Livestock Systems Group, SAC, West Mains Road, Edinburgh EH9 3JG, UK; 2Roslin Institute (Edinburgh), Roslin, Midlothian EH25 9PS, UK (Received 21 May 2007; Accepted 16 October 2007) Genetic parameters were estimated between current UK hill sheep breeding goals and lamb carcass composition and muscularity traits derived using X-ray computed tomography (CT). To produce these estimates, a total of 648 lambs from two hill farms were CT scanned at weaning (ca 120 days of age), over 3 years, and total weights of carcass muscle (MUSC), fat (CFAT) and bone (BONE) and internal fat (IFAT) were predicted. Previously derived muscularity indices were also calculated for the hind leg (HLMI) and lumbar (LRMI) regions, to assess muscle shape. Data for current breeding goals (lamb performance and maternal traits) were also included from a total of 10 297 lamb records and 12 704 ewe records. Heritabilities were estimated for each trait and genetic and phenotypic correlations were calculated between each CT trait and other lamb or ewe traits. Moderate to high positive genetic correlations were found between CT-predicted tissue weights and breeding goals, which were also weights (lamb weaning weight, carcass weight, mature ewe weight, average weight of lambs reared by the ewe). CFAT was positively genetically correlated with ultrasound backfat depth at weaning (UFD) and subjective fatness grade at slaughter (MLCF), suggesting that carcass fat could be decreased using selection on any of these predictors. Ultrasound muscle depth at weaning (UMD) and subjective conformation score at slaughter (MLCC) had high genetic correlations with the muscularity indices (HLMI and LRMI), but correlations with MUSC were not significantly different from zero. This implies that selection to improve MLCC is likely to be increasing the ‘roundness’ of muscle shape in the high-priced carcass region, but having little impact on total lean meat yield. Correlations of CT traits with the other ewe traits (number of lambs weaned, number of lambs lost, longevity, fleece weight) were generally small or not significantly different from zero. The genetic parameters generated in this study can now be used in selection index calculations to assess the benefits of including lamb CT traits in future selection programmes for hill sheep. Keywords: body composition, carcass composition, computed tomography, genetic parameters, sheep Introduction progress observed is due to improvements in maternal traits, such as number of lambs weaned and lamb survival, Selection of an experimental line of hill sheep using a multi- alongside increased weights of lambs at marketing trait index that includes both maternal and lamb perfor- (Conington et al., 2004). However, improvements in carcass mance traits has resulted in economic improvements when quality traits have not been evident as a result of 7 years of compared with a control line, on two experimental hill selection on this index in the two experimental flocks. farms of contrasting environmental severity (Conington Minimal changes have been observed between the selec- et al., 2006a). This research has been used as the basis for tion and control lines in traits such as subjective fatness and recommendations to the UK hill sheep sector and com- conformation scores awarded at the abattoir (Conington mercial hill sheep breeding programmes have adopted this et al., 2006a), weights of fat, muscle and bone, or index for selection of breeding stock (www.bfelite.co.uk, muscularity traits as measured using X-ray computed www.scottishsheepstrategy.org.uk). Much of the economic tomography (CT) scanning (Lambe et al., 2007). At present, the breeding goal traits in the index include subjective - E-mail: [email protected] fatness and conformation scores, which are predicted from 36 Relationships of hill lamb CT traits with UK breeding goals ultrasound fat and muscle depths on live lambs at weaning. Table 1 Count of lambs scanned within each farm, genetic line and These previous studies have suggested that including CT- year and total number of sires represented within each line on each derived traits in place of subjective carcass grades as farm breeding goals would preferentially accelerate improvement Farm 1 Farm 2 of carcass traits. Heritabilities have been estimated for several CT-derived Total no. Total no. traits in hill lambs scanned at weaning, including predicted LINE 2003 2004 2005 of sires 2003 2004 2005 of sires weights of fat, muscle and bone in the carcass, internal fat, S 616350112419205 and muscle shape traits (Conington et al., 2006b). However, C 806654132520186 before these traits can be included in the selection index for I 1816546 0 hill sheep, genetic and phenotypic relationships with the R- 810154 8109 3 traits included in the current index must be estimated. The Total 167 155 173 34 57 49 47 14 aim of this study was therefore to estimate genetic para- -R 5 lambs born to matings with reference sires from Blackface Elite. meters for the current ewe and lamb traits in the index (using more animals and family groups that those originally average age (126 days at farm 1, 116 days at farm 2) and used by Conington et al., 2001), and to examine the rela- live weight (31 kg at farm 1, 26 kg at farm 2) at CT scan- tionships among these and CT traits. This information can ning, with similar standard deviations in each of these then be used to facilitate investigation into the relative variates in each line. merits of including CT-derived composition and muscularity The CT scanning procedures for these lambs, comprising traits in future selection programmes for hill sheep. cross-sectional reference scans and spiral scans, were described in full by Lambe et al. (2007). Previously derived prediction equations were used to estimate total weights of Material and methods carcass fat, muscle, bone, and internal fat from cross- Farms and sheep flocks sectional images (Lambe et al., 2006). Image analysis on Scottish Blackface sheep flocks from two SAC research hill spiral CT scans allowed calculations of muscle volume in the farms of contrasting severity, that have been described in hind leg and the lumbar region, as described by Navajas et al. detail previously (Conington et al., 2001 and 2006a), were (2006), and linear dimensions of the femur bone and spine, involved in the study. Both flocks were comprised of which were combined to produce values for muscularity approximately 600 ewes. Performance and pedigree data have indices in the hind leg (HLMI) and lumbar region (LRMI) for been collected at farm 1 since 1991 and at farm 2 since 1996. each lamb, following the method of Navajas et al. (2007). Within each flock, three genetic lines were run together: Increased values for these muscularity indices represented a the selection (S), control (C) and industry (I) lines. In the S greater volume of muscle relative to the length of the bone line, animals retained for breeding were selected according that it surrounds (De Boer et al., 1974; Purchas et al., 1991). to the highest score in a multi-trait selection index devel- oped by Conington et al. (2001, 2004 and 2006a). Animals were selected for breeding in the C line with average index Data set scores, and in the I line using normal commercial (visual) A summary of the traits studied, and the data available for means. Selection within these genetic lines began in 1998 each of these traits, is shown in Table 2. This included CT with the first lambs born into the lines in 1999. In addition, data from the 648 lambs, combined with further production on both farms, 40 ewes per year were mated by artificial data from 10 297 lambs from farm 1 and 5393 lambs from insemination to rams from the UK Blackface sire reference farm 2. Ewe production records were also included from scheme – Blackface Elite – to provide genetic links with farm 1 (7332 records) and farm 2 (5372 records). other commercial flocks (lambs referred to as line R). For one lamb with very low fat levels, carcass fat (CFAT) was predicted as negative, using the established prediction equation, and for another lamb internal fat (IFAT) was CT scanning predicted as negative. Since a negative tissue weight is not A sample of lambs from each farm were CT scanned in 2003, biologically possible, these two values were set to zero.