The European Sky-God
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Folklore ISSN: 0015-587X (Print) 1469-8315 (Online) Journal homepage: http://www.tandfonline.com/loi/rfol20 The European Sky-God. Arthur Bernard Cook To cite this article: Arthur Bernard Cook (1904) The European Sky-God., Folklore, 15:3, 264-315, DOI: 10.1080/0015587X.1904.9719411 To link to this article: http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/0015587X.1904.9719411 Published online: 06 Feb 2012. Submit your article to this journal Article views: 4 View related articles Full Terms & Conditions of access and use can be found at http://www.tandfonline.com/action/journalInformation?journalCode=rfol20 Download by: [University of California, San Diego] Date: 25 February 2016, At: 14:53 THE EUROPEAN SKY-GOD. BY ARTHUR BERNARD COOK. IN a series of six articles contributed to The Classical Review, 1903-1904, under the title of " Zeus, Jupiter, and the Oak," I attempted to determine the original character of the chief Graeco-Italic deity and the nature of his cult. The materials that I accumulated for this purpose, when pieced together, formed a reconstruction so unorthodox in its outlines that I should have hesitated to publish it, had I not found that in several important points it agreed well with the main argument of Dr. Frazer's Golden Dough. Encouraged by this support I pushed on ; and further study has convinced me that my conclusions with regard to Zeus and Jupiter hold good for the corresponding gods of the Celtic, the Germanic, and the Letto-Slavonic peoples, if not for those of all branches of the Indo-European stock. I must, however, at the outset frankly confess that beyond the limits of the classical field I have no claim to speak as an expert. Scholars who have specialised in any of the mythologies of northern Europe will, I doubt not, find much to criticise in my remarks. Indeed, it is precisely in order to "draw the fire" of such criticism and thus to test the validity of my hypothesis that I have ventured to put pen to paper. I propose, first to restate (with some modifica tions) my general conclusions with respect to the ancient Greeks and Italians, and then to deal with apparently similar phenomena among the Celts, Germans, Slavs, &c, in each case considering how far cults evidenced by the literature or the monuments or both afford a real analogy to Downloaded by [University of California, San Diego] at 14:53 25 February 2016 the results obtained in the Graco-Italic area. The European Sky-god. 265 THE GREEKS. The supreme deity of the Greeks was essentially a sky- god.1 As such he was called the " Bright" One, his name Zetie being referable to a root that means " to shine " and implies the " daylight."8 Thus—to give but one example —the Iliad links together " the clear air and the rays of Zeus," where, as the scholiast ad loc. observes, by "the rays of Zeus" the poet means the sky.8 Empedocles* speaks of elemental fire as Zeii<s apyiji, i.e., " Zeus the brilliant" ; and it is probable that Argus, a hero who figures largely in Greek mythology,6 was at bottom none other than the " Brilliant" sky-god.8 This primary conception of Zeus as a sky-god developed in two secondary directions. On the one hand, the sky is 1 See eg. Preller-Robert, Griechische Mythologie, p. Its ff., Gruppe, Grie. chische Mythologie u. Religionsgeschichle, p. liooff. a O. Schroder, Reallexikon der Indogermanischen Altertumskunde, p. 670, K. Brugmann, Kurse vergleichende Grammatik der Indogermanischen Sfrathen, P- 313, alii. Two misleading explanations may here lie noted, (J) E. II. Meyer, Germanische Mythologie, pp. 182, aao, holds that Zt&t denotes properly the "hurlcr" or "discharger" of rays (cf. II. Grassmann, WSrtcrbuck turn Rig. *>eda, p. 600, s.v. div) and infers that he must have been the lightning-god, not 83 is commonly supposed the god of bright daylight. But the frequent use of the word dyaus in the Rig>veda for " sky " or " day " (A. A. Macdonell, Vedic Mythology, p. 31) and the existence of the Latin dies beside Diespiter are conclusive in favour of the common view. (3) Against Dr. Frazer's sugges tion (The Golden Bough,1 iii. 456 f.) that Zeus was named " Bright" as being the oak-god, i.e. god of the tree whose wood was used in fire-making, I have elsewhere protested (Class. Rev., xvi. 373), as has Gruppe (of. cit, p. 1100, n. 3), Downloaded by [University of California, San Diego] at 14:53 25 February 2016 * ll-, 13. 837 with schol. B. * "Emped.frag. 6 Diels. ' Argus the builder of the ship Argo is identified With Argus U*rirms, the eponym of Argos, by Jessen (Roscher, Lexikon dor Griechischen u, RSmischen Mythologie, iii. 1549) and Wernicke (rauly-Wissowa, Real-encyclopddit der 'lassischen AUertumswissenschaft, ii. 797 f.). ' Class Rev., xviii. 75, 83, The adjective ipyh denotes " brilliant," 266 The European Sky-god. not always bright and brilliant. As the rustic Corydon puts it in an idyll of Theocritus :7 %u> Z(i)C iiWoica fiiv iriXei aWpiog, itWoKa i' vu. Ay, Zeus is sometimes fine and sometimes wet. Hence the Greeks at a very early date extended the notion of Zeus as a bright sky-god to cover that of Zeus as a weather god.H The man in the street said : " Zeus rains," " Zeus snows," " Zeus sends the hail." 9 The minstrel in the palace-hall was ready with high-sounding epithets : " He of the dark clouds " (<ce\aive<pii<}), " He that rumbleth aloud" (epvySown-os), "He that hurleth the thunderbolt" (repmKepavvo<;). In various localities Zeus was worshipped under special weather-titles, e.g. Zeus "the Thunderer" (Hpovr&v), Zeus "of the Fair Wind" (Euai/e/xo?), " Zeus of the Rain " ('Teno?).*" Marcus Aurelius 11 has preserved the Athenian equivalent of our prayer " In the time of Dearth and Famine " : it runs as follows:— vaav, iaov, S> <j>l\e Zsv, icari riji Apoipac n/c 'A6t\valuiv ical rSiv mtiiav A'ain, rain, dear Zeus, On Athens' tilth and Athens' plains. The same conception found an expression in art. On the Athenian acropolis PausaniasV1 saw " an image of Earth praying Zeus to rain upon her." And a bronze coin i Theocr., 4, 43. • rreller-Rubert, pp. 117 ff.; Gruppe, pp. mo ff. j L. R, Farnell, The Cults of the Greek States, i,, 44 ff. » Eg. 11., 12. 25 f., it S' ipa ZiAc I avv«xk; Babr., 45. 1, ivtiptv i Zeic; Downloaded by [University of California, San Diego] at 14:53 25 February 2016 Eur., Tro., 78 f., Kal Zsic bpfipov ml %a\ayav Hantrov j ff^ifet tvoQutn r' alOtpoc Qvatiuara, »° On Zeus Upavrtiv of Phrygia, Galatia, Sc., see Cumont in Bauly-Wissowa, iii. 891 f. On Zeus UWVJ/JO* of Sparta, Frellcr-Robert, p. 118. On Zeu 'Xinoc of Lebadea, Argos, Cos, &c„ Gruppe, p. mo, tt. a. " Marc. Aur., 5. 7. ,a Paus., 1. 24. 3, with Frazer's n. The European Sky-god. 267 of Ephesus13 struck under Antoninus Pius shows on its reverse side Zeus 'Te'no? enthroned on a rocky summit (Trachea) and pouring from his raised right hand a shower °f rain upon a recumbent mountain-god (Pion). Now in polished classical times the thunderbolt was commonly regarded as a weapon flung by Zeus.11 But in by-gone animistic days Zeus had been identified with his own bolt." Similarly in the historical period rain was " water from Zeus," or " the shower of Zeus."18 But there were not wanting expressions that hinted at a closer connection. Matron, the parodist of Homer, dubbed rain " the child of Zeus";" Orphic writers spoke of it as "the tears of Zeus " ;18 Aristophanes more sua as the water of Zeus.19 Indeed.it is probable that Zeus had originally been thought to come down himself in the form of rain. This belief may underlie the usage of ffiviov or $vtov &$ap, i.e., "Zeus- water," as a term for rain-water in magical formula).80 It would account for the extraordinary significance attached 11 Brit. Mus. Cat. Gk. Coins Ionia, p. 79> pl> >3, 9- Eumelus (frag. 18 Kinkei) ap. Lyd, de mens., 4. 48, states that on the top of Mount Tmolus was a place called originally Toval At&c 'Ysriov, later bevaiov. 14 On Zeus Kepavvoj36\ac, lyxiutipav»os, l\aaijip6vTns, &c, see the references collected by Gruppe, p. 1111, ». 3. " See Farnell, 1, 4S f., who cites the Zeus Kipavvoe of Mantinea, the Zeus Koro(/34r»ic of Olympia and elsewhere, the Zeus Koirirwrac of Gythium, &c. M 'E* £ubc,Mwp Hdt., 3. 13 ; Ap. Rhod., a. ma j Plut. qvastt. not., 3: Ai&c iuPpas, Od.g. in j Theocr., 17. 78. " Matron ap. Athen., 3. 64 c, <2c iv %tp<"p Optyi AiAe wate <S«riroc 18 Clem, Alex, strom., $. 8. 50, 'Enrylvuc Iv Tip repi rijc 'Oppiwc iroijjtfiwc rii Widjovra wap' 'OpiptX UrMpevSe . • • tdicpva Aide rbv fyPpov Downloaded by [University of California, San Diego] at 14:53 25 February 2016 in\ouv. Aristoph. nub., 373, Kai'roi wpinpav rbv At' dXi}0we tpfinv tti nooxivov "bptlp. * Wessely, Griechisthe Zauberpapyrus von Paris u. London, Wien, 1S88, P»p. Paris. 235, lav p,lv T<% litavpavlovs Qtovc *XjfZj? M/nov (.se. fidXi M<u/>)j Wessely, Ncue Grieehische Zauberpapyri, Wien, 1893, p. 41, 630, Znvlov Uarog. 268 The European Sky-god. to a downpour, not only in legends, but in actual life,8 where a sudden storm was called Bioa^la, " a sign from Zeus," and a few rain-drops might suffice to postpone a public assembly.23 It would also explain more than one incident belonging to an early stratum of Greek mythology.