“Regionalization of Russian Foreign and Security Policy” Project organized by The Russian Study Group at the Center for Security Studies and Conflict Research Andreas Wenger, Jeronim Perovic,´ Andrei Makarychev, Oleg Alexandrov
WORKING PAPER NO.23 MARCH 2002
External Relations of Tatarstan: Neither Inside, Nor Outside, But Alongside Russia
DESIGN : SUSANA PERROTTET RIOS
As one of the most rebellious Russian republics, Tatarstan has been at the center of By Andrei S. Makarychev and Vasilii N. Valuev debates about Russian sovereignty and territorial integrity. This paper demonstrates the profound effect that Russia’s constituent parts can have on the stability of the Russian Federation as a whole and the corresponding influence that they can bring to bear on Moscow. By examining Tatarstan’s quest for independence and its bar- gaining tactics with the federal center, the authors expose the limits of President Vladimir Putin’s re-centralization policies and show that there is room for optimism concerning a new approach to sovereignty in the new Russia.
Contact: Center for Security Studies and Conflict Research ETH Zentrum SEI CH-8092 Zürich Switzerland
Andreas Wenger, head of project [email protected] Jeronim Perovic´ , project coordinator [email protected] Oleg Alexandrov [email protected] Andrei Makarychev [email protected];
Order of copies: Center for Security Studies and Conflict Research ETH Zentrum SEI CH-8092 Zürich Switzerland [email protected]
Papers available in full-text format at: C ENTER FOR http://www.fsk.ethz.ch/ S ECURITY STUDIES AND
Layout by Marco Zanoli and Karin Fink C ONFLICT RESEARCH -`\MZVIT:MTI\QWV[WN *a)VLZMQ;5ISIZaKPM^IVL>I[QTQQ6>IT]M^ ?WZSQVO8IXMZ6W $PODMVTJPO 'PSFJHOFDPOPNJDSFMBUJPOTBVUIPSJUBSJBOFOUSZJOUPDBQJUBM (BQTJOJEFOUJUZ $POTUSVDUJOHBOEJOUFSQSFUJOHUIFNFBOJOHTPGTPWFSFJHOUZ ɨF5BUBSTUBOJQPMJUJDBMSFHJNFBVUIPSJUBSJBOJTNiHPJOHHMPC *OUSPEVDUJPO 'PSFXPSE DONDQPFUPJNBEJTDJJT &DPOPNJDQSPUFDUJPOJTNBOEJUTDSJUJDT ɨFHFOFSBMQJDUVSF *TMBNSFEJTDPWFSFE )JTUPSZBTEJTDPVSTF *EFOUJUZUISPVHIUIFQSJTNPGHMPCBMJ[BUJPO 4PWFSFJHOUZBOEGPSFJHOQPMJDZJTTVFT 4PWFSFJHOUZJORVFTUJPO5BUBSTUBOXJUIJOUIFDPOUFYUPG1 ɨFWFSCBMCBUUMFGPSTPWFSFJHOUZBNCJHVJUZBTQPMJUJDBMT )JTUPSZPG5BUBSTUBOTSFMBUJPOTXJUIUIFGFEFSBMDFOUFS MCM[UPBBJNBFOGPBBTB (MPCBMJ[BUJPOQBSBEJHNBTTFFOGSPN5BUBSTUBO 3FHJNFBTTFTTNFOUiUIFXJOOFSUBLFTBMMw SOU USFOHUI UOTSGST VUJOTSFGPSNT JTN JTN M BMw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ĊFDUUIBU3VTTJBTDPOTUJUVFOU QBSUTDBOIBWFPOUIFTUBCJMJUZPGUIFGFEFSBUJPOBTBXIPMFBOE UIFSFGPSF UIFJOnV FODFUIBUUIFZDBOFYFSUXJUIJOJU#ZFYBNJOJOH5BUBSTUBOTRVFTUGPSJOEFQFOEFODF BOEJUTCBSHBJOJOHUBDUJDTXJUIUIFGFEFSBMDFOUFS UIFBVUIPSTIFMQUPSFWFBMUIFMJNJUT PG1SFTJEFOU7BMEJNJS1VUJOTSFDFOUSBMJ[BUJPOQPMJDJFTBOETIPXUIBUUIFSFJTIPQFPG BOFXVOEFSTUBOEJOHPGTPWFSFJHOUZFNFSHJOHJO3VTTJB ɨFTUVEZJMMVTUSBUFTIPX5BUBSTUBOTWJSUVBMEFDMBSBUJPOPGJOEFQFOEFODFJOUIF FBSMZTXBTJOMBSHFQBSUBUBDUJDBMNPWFPOUIFQBSUPGUIFSFQVCMJD BJNFEBU SFTUSVDUVSJOHJUTSFMBUJPOTIJQXJUI.PTDPX"TUIFBVUIPSTQPJOUPVU 5BUBSTUBOTQPMJUJ DBMNBOFVWFSJOHQSPWFESBUIFSTVDDFTTGVM.PTDPXBHSFFEUPBOVNCFSPGDPODFTTJPOT BOEFWFOUVBMMZDPODMVEFEBQPXFSTIBSJOHUSFBUZXJUI,B[BOJO5BUBSTUBOIBT TJODFFOKPZFEBNVDIHSFBUFSEFHSFFPGGSFFEPN QBSUJDVMBSMZJOUIFBSFBTPGGPSFJHO FDPOPNJDSFMBUJPOT ɨFTVCTFRVFOUWBHVFOFTTPG5BUBSTUBOJTPWFSFJHOUZBQQFBSTUPIBWFTVJUFECPUI HPWFSONFOUT8IJMFUIFGFEFSBMDFOUFSIBEOPEFTJSFUPTIBSQFOEJĊFSFODFTCFUXFFO .PTDPXBOE5BUBSTUBO HJWFOUIFSFQVCMJDT*TMBNJDMFBOJOHTBOEVTFGVMOFTTPG1SFTJ EFOU .JOUJNFS 4IBJNJFW BT B QPUFOUJBM CBSSJFS UP SFMJHJPVT FYUSFNJTN BOE QPMJUJDBM EFTUBCJMJ[BUJPO UIFQPMJUJDBMFMJUFJO,B[BOXBTNPSFJOUFSFTUFEJOTUSFOHUIFOJOHJUT CBSHBJOJOHQPTJUJPOTWJTËWJT.PTDPXUIBOJOBDIJFWJOHBCTPMVUFTPWFSFJHOUZ );5ISIZaKPM^IVL>6>IT]M^ %FTQJUFFĊPSUTBUSFDFOUSBMJ[BUJPOVOEFS1SFTJEFOU7MBEJNJS1VUJO ,B[BODPO UJOVFTUPUBLFBWFSZQSBHNBUJDBQQSPBDIUPJUTTPWFSFJHOUZ"GUFSJOJUJBMJOEJHOBUJPO BU1VUJOTSFGPSNT 4IBJNJFWJTOPXTFFLJOHQPMJUJDBMDPNQSPNJTFTUPUIFEJĊFSFODFT CFUXFFOUIF5BUBSTUBOJBOE.PTDPXBVUIPSJUJFT CBTFEPODIBOHFTUPUIFDPOTUJUVUJPOT PGSFQVCMJDTCFJOHDPNQMFNFOUFEXJUISFWJTJPOTPGUIFGFEFSBMDPOTUJUVUJPO8IJMFUIF PVUDPNFPGOFHPUJBUJPOTCFUXFFO.PTDPXBOE,B[BOIBTZFUUPCFTFFO UIF5BUBSTUBOJ TUSBUFHZGPSHSFBUFSBVUPOPNZXJUIJOUIF3VTTJBO'FEFSBUJPOSFQSFTFOUTBOJOUFSFTUJOH UFTUDBTFGPSMJNJUFEGFEFSBMBOESFQVCMJDBOTPWFSFJHOUJFTJO3VTTJB ɨJTQBQFSJTUXFOUZUIJSEJOBTFSJFTPGXPSLJOHQBQFSTXSJUUFOJOUIFDPOUFYU PG UIF QSPKFDU i3FHJPOBMJ[BUJPO PG 3VTTJBO 'PSFJHO BOE 4FDVSJUZ 1PMJDJFT *OUFSBD UJPOCFUXFFO3FHJPOBM1SPDFTTFTBOEUIF*OUFSFTUPGUIF$FOUSBM4UBUFwɨFQSPKFDUJT GVOEFECZUIF4XJTT'FEFSBM*OTUJUVUFPG5FDIOPMPHZ &5) ;VSJDI"MMQBQFSTJOUIF TFSJFTBSFBWBJMBCMFJOGVMMUFYUBUIUUQXXXGTLFUI[DI ;VSJDI +BOVBSZ 1V\ZWL]K\QWV /P3VTTJBOTUBUFIBTCFFODMPTFSUPUIFFQJDFOUFSPGIFBUFEEFCBUFTBOEDPOUSPWFSTJFT 1SPG%S"OESFBT8FOHFS UIBO5BUBSTUBOɨFQPMFNJDTBSPVOE5BUBSTUBOBSFGPDVTFEPOJTTVFTUIBUBSFDPSFGPS 3VTTJBBTBXIPMFUIPTFPGJUTJOUFHSJUZ DPIFTJWFOFTT BOEUIFBCJMJUZUPTQFBLXJUIB %FQVUZEJSFDUPSPGUIF$FOUFSGPS4FDVSJUZ4UVEJFT TJOHMFWPJDFJOUFSOBUJPOBMMZɨJTSFHJPONJHIUBMTPQSPWJEFVTFGVMJOTJHIUTPOUIFMJNJUT BOE$POnJDU3FTFBSDI PG1SFTJEFOU7MBEJNJS1VUJOTSFDFOUSBMJ[BUJPOQSPKFDU ɨF DBTF PG 5BUBSTUBO DMFBSMZ EFNPOTUSBUFT UIF OBSSPX MJOF EJWJEJOH 3VTTJBT EPNFTUJDBOEGPSFJHOQPMJDJFT*OEFFE POFPGUIFNBKPSDIBMMFOHFTGBDJOH3VTTJBJTUP MFBSOUPMJWFXJUIUIFSFWJUBMJ[FEXPSMEPG*TMBN CPUIPO3VTTJBTTPVUIFSOQFSJQIFSZ BOEXJUIJOJUTPXOCPVOEBSJFTȝ5BUBSTUBOJTBHPPEJMMVTUSBUJPOPGUIFXBZJOXIJDI UIF CPVOEBSZ CFUXFFO EPNFTUJD BOE JOUFSOBUJPOBM TQIFSFT JT CFDPNJOH JODSFBTJOHMZ CMVSSFE ɨFBJNPGUIJTQBQFSJTUPDMBSJGZUIFQFDVMJBSGFBUVSFTPGUIF5BUBSTUBOJTUSBUFHZ GPS JOUFHSBUJPO JOUP HMPCBM QPMJUJDBM BOE FDPOPNJD TUSVDUVSFT UIF NBJO BEWBOUBHFT BOE JNQFEJNFOUT PG UIF SFQVCMJDT JOUFSOBUJPOBMJ[BUJPO BOE UIF GVUVSF QSPTQFDUT PG 5BUBSTUBO8FCFHJOXJUIBOBQQSBJTBMUIFOBUVSFPGUIF5BUBSTUBOQPMJUJDBMSFHJNFBT TFFOGSPNUIFWJFXQPJOUPGHMPCBMJ[BUJPO8FUIFOUVSOUPUIFJTTVFPGTPWFSFJHOUZBT WJFXFE GSPN EJĊFSFOU BOHMFT XIJDI MFBET VT UP UIF QSPCMFN PG5BUBSTUBOT JEFOUJUZ 'JOBMMZ UIFQBQFSPĊFSTBOBOBMZTJTPG5BUBSTUBOTFDPOPNJDQFSGPSNBODFJOUIFJOUFS OBUJPOBMBSFOB 5SFOJO %NJUSJDzF&OEPG&VSBTJB3VTTJBPOUIF#PSEFS#FUXFFO(FPQPMJUJDTBOE(MPCBMJ[BUJPO .PTDPX.PTDPX$BSOFHJF$FOUFS Q 8FDPOTJEFSUIBUBOBOBMZTJTPG5BUBSTUBOTJOUFSOBUJPOBMTUBOEJOHTIPVMECFHJOXJUI EPNFTUJDQPMJUJDBMJOTUJUVUJPOT TJODFUIFZSFWFBMNVDIBCPVUXIPBSFUIFNPTUJNQPS UBOUQPMJUJDBMBDUPSTJOUIFSFHJPOTBOEXIBUUIFJSJOUFSFTUTBSF :MOQUMI[[M[[UMV\"t\PM_QVVMZ\ISM[ITTu "TTFTTNFOUTPGUIF5BUBSTUBOQPMJUJDBMSFHJNFWBSZTJHOJmDBOUMZ4PNFFYQFSUTUSFBUJUBT BNPEFMGPSBMM3VTTJBTJODFJUQSPWJEFTCBEMZOFFEFETUBCJMJUZTJODF GPSFYBNQMF UIFSF BSFOPPQFOJOUSBFMJUFDPOnJDUTJOUIFSFQVCMJDȞɨPTFQSBJTJOH5BUBSTUBOBVUIPSJUJFT GPSUIFJSJOEFQFOEFOUTUBODFEFFNUIBUUIFNPSFJOTJTUFOUMZUIJTSFQVCMJDEFBMTXJUI UIFGFEFSBMDFOUFS UIFNPSFDIBODFUIFSFJTPGDPOTUSBJOJOHUIFGFEFSBMCVSFBVDSBDZ BOESFNPWJOHUIFMFHBDZPGFNQJSF3BGBFM,IBLJN UIFMFBEJOHIJTUPSJBOBOEQPMJUJ DBMDPVOTFMPSUP1SFTJEFOU.JOUJNFS4IBJNJFWPG5BUBSTUBO BSHVFTUIBU i5BUBSTUBOIBT BMXBZTSFHBSEFEUIFEFDFOUSBMJ[BUJPOBOEGFEFSBMJ[BUJPOPG3VTTJBBTBXBZUPFMJNJOBUF UIFJNQFSJBMTUSVDUVSFTBOEQSPHSFTTUPBHFOVJOFMZEFNPDSBUJDTPDJFUZwȟ 0UIFSTBSHVFUIBUBOPMEGBTIJPOFE 4PWJFUTUZMFDPOTFSWBUJWFFMJUFSVMFT5BUBSTUBO XIJDIJTPWFSUMZOPOEFNPDSBUJDȠ4FSHFJ.BSLPW EJSFDUPSPGUIF.PTDPXCBTFE*OTUJ (FMNBO 7MBEJNJSi3FHJPOBM3FHJNF5SBOTJUJPOTJO3VTTJB"DUPST *OTUJUVUJPOT BOE6ODFSUBJOUZw "WBJMBCMFBUIUUQHFPHBSJ[POBFEV_XFCSSXHEFNPDSBDZIUNM i'VUVSF PG 'FEFSBMJTN JO 3VTTJBw SFTFBSDI QSPKFDU XFC TJUF BU IUUQGFEFSBMJTNTPSPTLTVSV QVCMJDBUJPOTLIBLJNPWIUN 0TPCBJB[POBWZCPSZW5BUBSTUBOF 4QFDJBM;POF&MFDUJPOTJO5BUBSTUBO 6MZBOPWTL*OUFSOBUJPOBM )VNBO3JHIUT"TTFNCMZ ,B[BOCSBODI QQo );5ISIZaKPM^IVL>6>IT]M^ -`\MZVIT:MTI\QWV[WN UVUF GPS 1PMJUJDBM 4UVEJFT DBMMT UIF 5BUBSTUBO QPMJUJDBM SFHJNF iBVUIPSJUBSJBOw BOE MFBE1SPGFTTPS7BMFOUJO#B[IBOPW UIFIFBEPGUIF1PMJUJDBM4DJFODF%FQBSUNFOUBU6MZ iFUIOPDSBUJD wȡ TJODF QPMJUJDBM DBSFFST JO UIF SFQVCMJD BSF QSFEFUFSNJOFE CZ QFSTPOBM BOPWTL4UBUF6OJWFSTJUZ UPEFTDSJCF5BUBSTUBOBTBDPOUSJCVUPSUPQPMJUJDBMJOTUBCJMJUZJO MPZBMUJFT .BSZ .D"VMFZ EFTDSJCFT UIF5BUBSTUBOSVMJOH FMJUF JO UFSNT PG iQBUSPOBHF 3VTTJBUIBUXPVMEHFOFSBUFTFQBSBUJTUUSFOETJOUIFGVUVSFȝȡ QPMJUJDTwBOEiDMBOUIJOLJOHw5BUBSTUBOJBVUIPSJUJFT JOIFSWJFX BSFiBMNPTUFOUJSFMZ %FTQJUFUIJTEJWFSHFODFJOBQQSBJTBMT JUJTIBSEUPEJTBHSFFUIBU4IBJNJFWJTPOF DPODFSOFEXJUIHBJOJOHSFTPVSDFTGPSUIFNTFMWFT wDPOUSPMMJOHQSJDFT EJTUSJCVUJOHUIF PGUIFNPTUBVUIPSJUBUJWFPGBMMSFHJPOBMMFBEFSTJO3VTTJB)FXBTUIFNBJOMPCCZJTUPG QSPmUTGSPNSFHJPOBMFOUFSQSJTFT BOEEFDJEJOHPOUIFPXOFSTIJQPGNBKPSJOEVTUSJBM UIFBMM3VTTJBMFHJTMBUJPOPGUPBMMPXUIFSFHJPOBMDIJFGFYFDVUJWFTUPSVOGPSSFFMFD VOJUTȢ0MFH#FMHPSPETLJJ UIFIFBEPGUIFMPDBMPċDFPGUIFi8F"SFUIF$JUJ[FOTw UJPOBGUFSUXPUFSNTJOPċDFȝȢ DPBMJUJPOEFTDSJCFTUIFFMFDUPSBMQSPDFTTJO5BUBSTUBOBTBDPNQFUJUJPOCFUXFFO4IBJNJ FWTTVCPSEJOBUFTUPBSUJmDJBMMZJOnBUFIJTWPUFSFTVMUTȣ +PVSOBMJTUTIBWFVODPWFSFEUIBU4IBJNJFWTDMPTFTUSFMBUJWFTIPMEUIFNPTUQSPG /TWJITQbI\QWVXIZILQOUI[[MMVNZWU :FUUIFDVSSFOUTUBUFPGJOUFSOBUJPOBMMBXEPFTOPUDPNQMFUFMZTBUJTGZ5BUBSTUBOJ 5BUBSTUBO TJODFUIFHPWFSOJOHFMJUFJTNVDINPSFNPEFSBUFBOEQSBHNBUJD 'PSFYBN MFBEFST ɨVT BDDPSEJOH UP ,IBLJN iQMFBEJOH UIF QSJODJQMF PG OPOJOUFSGFSFODF JO QMF BDUJWJTUTPGUIFi5BUBS1VCMJD$FOUFSw POFPGUIFOBUJPOBMJTUHSPVQT EFTDSJCFUIF JOUFSOBMBĊBJST UIFJOUFSOBUJPOBMDPNNVOJUZQSFGFSTUPMFBWFUIFTPMVUJPOPGTFMGEFUFS DBMM GPS CPZDPUUJOH UIF GFEFSBM NJOJTUSJFT JO5BUBSTUBOBT iJOTUJUVUJPOT PG GPSFJHO NJOBUJPOQSPCMFNTUPUIFEJTDSFUJPOPGUIFTUBUFTJOWPMWFE y ɨFNPTUSBEJDBMTUFQ TUBUFwȞȡ-PDBMOBUJPOBMJTUTDPNNFNPSBUF0DUPCFS UIFEBZXIFOUIFBSNZPG*WBO UPXBSETBSFOFXBMPGJOUFSOBUJPOBMSFMBUJPOTXPVMECFUPFTUBCMJTIBTFDPOEDIBNCFS UIF5FSSJCMFNJMJUBSJMZ TVCEVFE ,B[BO JO BT POF PG OBUJPOBM NPVSOJOH ɨF JOUIF6OJUFE/BUJPOT POFXIJDIXPVMESFQSFTFOUQFPQMFBOEOPUTUBUFTɨJTXPVME ,VSVMUBJ $POWFOUJPO PGUIF5BUBS1FPQMFBQQFBMFEUPUIFJOUFSOBUJPOBMDPNNVOJUZ DIBOHFUIFTUSVDUVSFPGNBOZJOUFSOBUJPOBMPSHBOJ[BUJPOT JODMVEJOHUIF*OUFSOBUJPOBM DMBJNJOHUIBU5BUBSTUBOJT3VTTJBTDPMPOZBOEIBTUPCFBMMPXFEGVMMnFEHFEJOUFSOB $PVSUPG+VTUJDFwȞȜ UJPOBMQBSUJDJQBUJPO"NPOHUIFNPTUSBEJDBMQSPQPTBMTPGUIF,VSVMUBJEFMFHBUFTXBT TUJHNBUJ[JOH JOUFSFUIOJD NBSSJBHFT FTUBCMJTIJOH DPOUBDUT XJUI OBUJPOBM MJCFSBUJPO *O IJT GPSFJHO QPMJDZ 4IBJNJFW USJFT UP NBJOUBJO B CBMBODF CFUXFFO 8FTU BOE NPWFNFOUTXPSMEXJEF BOEBQQMZJOHGPS5BUBSTUBOTNFNCFSTIJQUP/"50ȞȢ4PNF &BTUɨF5BUBSTUBOJBVUIPSJUJFTNBJOUBJOiTQFDJBMSFMBUJPOTwXJUI.VTMJNDPVOUSJFTUIBU SBEJDBMFYUSFNJTUT GSFRVFOUMZDBMMFEiOPOUSBEJUJPOBM*TMBNJDHSPVQT wCBDLFECZMJLF GPDVTNBJOMZPODVMUVSBMBOEQPMJUJDBMJTTVFT XIJMFSFMBUJPOTXJUIOPO.VTMJNDPVO NJOEFETQPOTPSTGSPN1BLJTUBO "MHFSJB 4BVEJ"SBCJB :FNFO -FCBOPO BOEPUIFS USJFTBSFNBJOMZBJNFEBUJNQSPWJOHFDPOPNJDUJFT"HPPEDPOUJOVBUJPOPG5BUBSTUBOT *TMBNJDDPVOUSJFT BSFJNQMFNFOUJOHTPNFPGUIFTFUIFPSJFTCZSFDSVJUJOHWPMVOUFFSTGPS QPMJDZPGCBMBODFXBTUIFQSPKFDUPGSFTUPSJOHUIFiHSFBU7PMHBSPBE wUIBUIJTUPSJDBMMZ $IFDIFOSFCFMTBOEQSFQBSJOHUFSSPSJTUBUUBDLTȞȣ IBTQSPWFOJUTFċDBDZJODPOOFDUJOHUIFOPSUIFSOBOEXFTUFSOQBSUTPG3VTTJBXJUI $BTQJBOBOE#MBDL4FBQPSUTȞȝ 4IBJNJFWIBTQPJOUFEPVUUIBUi8FTUFSO&VSPQFJTUIFMBOENBSLGPS5BUBSTUBOw 5BUBSTUBOJMFBEFST IBWF FYQSFTTFE UIFJS EJTTBUJTGBDUJPO XJUI JODSFNFOUBM BOUJ8FTUFSO BUUJUVEFT BNPOH 3VTTJBO QPMJDZNBLFST "U UIF TBNF UJNF QPMJUJDBM BOE JOUFMMFDUVBM MFBEFSTJO5BUBSTUBOIBWFSFQFBUFEMZFYQSFTTFEUIFJSEJTBQQPJOUNFOUXJUIUIFQPMJDJFT PG8FTUFSODPVOUSJFTɨVT 8FTUFSOTUZMFSFGPSNTBTJNQMFNFOUFECZUIFHPWFSONFOU PGGPSNFS3VTTJBOQSJNFNJOJTUFS:FHPS(BJEBSJOUIFFBSMZTBOEUIFTIPDLUIFS BQZNPEFMFEPO"NFSJDBOBEWJDFXFSFSFCVĊFEJO,B[BO-PDBMFYQFSUTDPOTJEFSUIBU UIF8FTUBEIFSFTUPTFMFDUJWFTVQQPSUPGIVNBOSJHIUTCZJHOPSJOHUIFCMPPETIFEJO $IFDIOZBBOESFGVTJOHUPQPMJUJDBMMZSFDPHOJ[FUIFTFQBSBUJTUTȞȞ*OEJSFDUDPOnJDUXJUI UIF8FTUFSOQPMJDZPGFDPOPNJDTBODUJPOTBHBJOTU4BEEBN)VTTFJOTSFHJNF 5BUBSTUBO JTDPPQFSBUJOHJOUFOTJWFMZXJUI*SBRJOPJMFYUSBDUJPOBOEQSPDFTTJOHȞȟ 0QJOJPOQPMMTJO/BCFSF[IOZF$IFMOZIBETIPXOUIBUPOMZPGJUTQPQV MBUJPOXPVMETVQQPSUGPTUFSJOHNBSLFUSFGPSNTPOUIFCBTJTPGQPMJUJDBMSBQQSPDIFNFOU XJUIUIF8FTU*OUIFNJOETPGNBOZ .VTMJN 5BUBST QSP8FTUFSOQPMJDZBUUJUVEFT NJHIUMFBEUPUIFTUSFOHUIFOJOHPG$ISJTUJBOJOnVFODFJOUIFSFQVCMJDȞȠ *OTJEF5BUBSTUBOUIFSFBSFFWFONPSFSBEJDBMGPSFJHOQPMJDZBUUJUVEFT PGDPVSTF XF TIPVME OPU FYBHHFSBUF UIF QPMJUJDBM JNQPSUBODF PG UIPTF SBEJDBM WJFXQPJOUT GPS i'VUVSF PG 'FEFSBMJTN JO 3VTTJBw SFTFBSDI QSPKFDU XFC TJUF BU IUUQGFEFSBMJTNTPSPTLTVSV QVCMJDBUJPOTLIBLJNPWIUN /F[BWJTJNBJBHB[FUBXFCTJUF BUIUUQSFHJPOTOHSVQSJOUFEGBS@WPMHB@XBZIUNM "NJSLIBOPW 0QDJU Q 1SPWJOUTJJBPOMJOFJOGPSNBUJPOBHFODZ BUIUUQXXXQSPWJODFSVOFXTIUNM 1FSTIJO 7JLUPS i7JUTFQSF[JEFOU *SBLB QPTFUJM 5BUBSTUBOw *SBRJ 7JDF 1SFTJEFOU )BT 7JTJUFE ;B[OBFW 0MFHi%JOBNJLBQPMJUJDIFTLPHPQSPUTFTTBW3FTQVCMJLF5BUBSTUBOw %ZOBNJDTPG1PMJUJDBM 5BUBSTUBO &8*3VTTJBO3FHJPOBM3FQPSU WPM OP 1SPDFTTJO3FQVCMJDPG5BUBSTUBO 7PTUPDIOPFWSPQFJTLPFLPOTUJUVUTJPOOPFPCP[SFOJF OP .BLBSZDIFW "OESFJ FE )BSE BOE 4PGU 4FDVSJUZ $IBMMFOHFT JO UIF 7PMHB 'FEFSBM %JTUSJDU Q /J[IOJJ/PWHPSPE/J[IOJJ/PWHPSPE-JOHVJTUJD6OJWFSTJUZBOE*3&91SPGFTTJPOBMTGPS$PPQFSB /F[BWJTJNBJB HB[FUB XFC TJUF BU IUUQSFHJPOTOHSVQSJOUFEHVCFSO@ UJPO"OBMZUJDBM3FQPSU HVFSJMMBTIUNM );5ISIZaKPM^IVL>6>IT]M^ 5BCMFJMMVTUSBUFTTPNFPGUIFTFEJWFSHFOUBTTFTTNFOUT 5BCMF%JWFSHFOUBTTFTTNFOUTGSPNUISFFWJFXQPJOUT 3VTTJBOGFEFSBM *TTVF 3BEJDBMOBUJPOBMJTUT 5BUBSTUBOJHPWFSONFOU BVUIPSJUJFT 5SBOTJUJPOGSPNiDPMP OJBMEFQFOEFODZwUPGVMM 4PWFSFJHOUZJTnFYJCMFBOE nFEHFEJOEFQFOEFODF 4PWFSFJHOUZCFMPOHTUP 4PWFSFJHOUZ EJWJTJCMF JUNJHIUCFTIBSFE XIJDIXBTJOUFSSVQUFE 3VTTJBBTBXIPMF CFUXFFO5BUBSTUBOBOE3VTTJB CZ3VTTJBTNJMJUBSZ JOUFSGFSFODFJO ɨFQSJODJQMFPGUFSSJUP 5FSSJUPSJBMJOUFHSJUZJTBO 5FSSJUPSJBMJOUFH SJBMJOUFHSJUZNJHIUTUSBJO 5BUBSTUBOEPFTOPUTFFLGVMM VODPOEJUJPOBMQPMJUJDBM SJUZPG3VTTJB FUIOJDBOESFHJPOBM TFQBSBUJPOGSPN3VTTJB QSJODJQMF EFWFMPQNFOU 5BUBSTUBOTiGPSFJHODPO OFDUJPOTw BTEJĊFSFOU $PNQMFUFMZJOEFQFOEFOU 5BUBSTUBOJTBTUBUFBTTPDJBUFE GSPNUIFiGPSFJHOSFMB 'PSFJHO GPSFJHOQPMJDZ JODMVE XJUI3VTTJB BOEJTFRVBMUP UJPOTwPGUIFGFEFSBMDFO +WV[\Z]K\QVOIVLQV\MZXZM\QVO KPIX\MZ QPMJDZ JOHBQQMZJOHGPS/"50 3VTTJB BOEJOUIJTDBQBDJUZJT UFS BSFCBTFEPOUIFUSFBUZ NFNCFSTIJQ BTVCKFDUPGJOUFSOBUJPOBMMBX PGUIFEJWJTJPOPGQPXFST \PMUMIVQVO[WN[W^MZMQOV\a CFUXFFOUIFSFHJPOBMBOE UIFGFEFSBMBVUIPSJUJFT 5BUBSTUBOJMBXTIBWFQSJPSJUZ 4PWFSFJHOUZJTUIFDPSFJTTVFGPSVOEFSTUBOEJOHIPXUIFGPSFJHOSFMBUJPOTPG5BUBSTUBO $PIFSFODFBOEJOEJWJT -FHBM 5BUBSTUBOPVHIUUPIBWF PWFS3VTTJBOGFEFSBMMFHJTMB JCJMJUZPGUIFMFHBMGPVOEB BSFPSHBOJ[FEɨJTDIBQUFSCFHJOTXJUIBDISPOPMPHJDBMBDDPVOUPGUIFMFHBMSFMBUJPOT DPMMJTJPOT JUTPXOMFHBMTZTUFN UJPO BTSVMFECZ5BUBSTUBOT UJPOTPG3VTTJB CFUXFFO5BUBSTUBOBOEUIFGFEFSBMDFOUFSɨFTFDPOEQBSUPGUIFDIBQUFSJTNPSFJTTVF $POTUJUVUJPOBM$PVSU PSJFOUFE BOEXJMMDPNQBSFCBTJDBQQSPBDIFTUPTPWFSFJHOUZGSPNCPUITJEFTJOWPMWFE 4JOHMF3VTTJBODJUJ[FOTIJQ (SBEVBMBDDFQUBODFPGEVBM *OEFQFOEFOUPG3VTTJB 5BUBSTUBOJTBMMPXFEUP $JUJ[FOTIJQ 3VTTJBOBOE5BUBSTUBOJ DJUJ DJUJ[FOTIJQ JTTVFBOBEEJUJPOBMSVCSJD [FOTIJQ GPSJUTSFTJEFOUT 0Q[\WZaWN %FGFOEJOHFUIOJDJOUFS 4USFOHUIFOJOHUIFFUIOJDGBD &UIOJDJUZBOE %FNPDSBDZIBTUPCFCVJMU FTUTJTNPSFJNQPSUBOU UPSJTBQSFDPOEJUJPOGPSEFN EFNPDSBDZ POBOPOFUIOJDCBTJT 5BUBSTUBOHPWFSONFOUXFCTJUF BUIUUQXXXUBUBSSVBQQFOEIUNM UIBOEFNPDSBDZ PDSBUJDEFWFMPQNFOU i#FMBJB LOJHB 5BUBSTUBOB 1VU L TVWFSFOJUFUV ow ɨF 8IJUF #PPL PG 5BUBSTUBO ɨF3PBEUP4PWFSFJHOUZ o 1BOPSBNB'PSVN OP TQFDJBMJTTVF Q );5ISIZaKPM^IVL>6>IT]M^ -`\MZVIT:MTI\QWV[WN ɨFSFGFSFOEVNIFMEJOUIFSFQVCMJDPO.BSDIDPOmSNFE5BUBSTUBOT XBT UIF i5SFBUZ PO 1PXFS 4IBSJOHw TJHOFE PO 'FCSVBSZ XIJDI5BUBSTUBO TPWFSFJHOUZBOEJUTJOUFOUJPOUPCVJMESFMBUJPOTXJUI3VTTJBBOEPUIFSDPVOUSJFTPOUIF WJFXTBTSFHVMBUJOHSFMBUJPOTCFUXFFOUXPTUBUFT*UJOWPLFTUIBUiBTBTUBUF 5BUBSTUBO CBTJTPGFRVBMJUZBOESFDJQSPDJUZ)PXFWFS UIF4VQSFNF4PWJFUPG5BUBSTUBOIBEPċ JTVOJUFEXJUIUIF3VTTJBO'FEFSBUJPO wȟȣBOEUIFSFGPSFIBTBOVNCFSPGBTTPDJBUFE DJBMMZTUBUFECFGPSFIBOEUIBUUIFSFTVMUTPGUIFSFGFSFOEVNTIPVMEOPUCFJOUFSQSFUFE SJHIUT FH UPFTUBCMJTIJUTDJUJ[FOTIJQ UPDPOEVDUGPSFJHOFDPOPNJDBDUJWJUJFT BOEUP JOUFSNTPGTFDFTTJPOPSOPOTFDFTTJPO TJODF5BUBSTUBOEPFTOPUFODSPBDIVQPOUIF TFUVQUIFSVMFTPGBMUFSOBUJWFNJMJUBSZTFSWJDFGPS5BUBSTUBOJSFTJEFOUT +PJOUKVSJTEJD OBUJPOBMJOUFHSJUZPG3VTTJBBOEXJTIFTUPTUBZXJUIJOUIF3VTTJBOiFDPOPNJDBOEHFP UJPOJTTVFTJODMVEFEFGFOTFPGTPWFSFJHOUZBOEUFSSJUPSJBMJOUFHSJUZ TVQQPTFEMZPGFBDI QPMJUJDBMTQBDFwȟȜɨFDPSFJTTVFPGUIFSFGFSFOEVN BDDPSEJOHUPUIJTEFDMBSBUJPO XBT PUIFS JNQMFNFOUBUJPOPGNPCJMJ[BUJPOQMBOTJOFNFSHFODZTJUVBUJPOT DPPSEJOBUJPO UPSFTUSVDUVSFUIFSFMBUJPOTIJQXJUI3VTTJB*OBTFQBSBUFTUBUFNFOUPO.BSDI PGJOUFSOBUJPOBMDPOUBDUT DPOEVDUPGNPOFUBSZQPMJDZ NBOBHFNFOUPGUSBOTQPSUBUJPO UIF4VQSFNF4PWJFUPG5BUBSTUBOIBESVMFEUIBUUIFSFQVCMJDJTTVQQPTFEUPQSPWJEF OFUXPSLT FDPMPHJDBMNPOJUPSJOHJOBDDPSEBODFXJUIJOUFSOBUJPOBMOPSNTBOEQSPDF iEVBMDJUJ[FOTIJQwGPSJUTSFTJEFOUTȟȝ EVSFT UIF DPVSUT TZTUFN BOE MBOE VTF *U XBT TUJQVMBUFE UIBU 3VTTJB IBT VOEFS JUT KVSJTEJDUJPO TVDI JTTVFT BT IVNBO SJHIUT BOE NJOPSJUJFT QPMJDZ TUBUF QSPQFSUZ MFHBM "DDPSEJOHUPUIF$POTUJUVUJPOPG5BUBSTUBOBEPQUFEJO QSJPSUPUIFDVSSFOU GPVOEBUJPOPGUIFDPNNPONBSLFU GFEFSBMCVEHFU FOFSHZTZTUFNT DPNNVOJDBUJPO 3VTTJBO$POTUJUVUJPO JUJTUIFTVCKFDUPGJOUFSOBUJPOBMMBXBOEBTPWFSFJHOTUBUF BTTP JOGSBTUSVDUVSF XBSBOEQFBDFJTTVFT EFGFOTFBOETFDVSJUZ BOECPSEFSDPOUSPMȟȤ"TB DJBUFEXJUI3VTTJB BOEIBTGVMMZnFEHFEQPXFSTUPDPOEVDUGPSFJHOQPMJDZɨFMBXTPG SFTVMUPGDPNQSPNJTF UIFQPXFSTIBSJOHUSFBUZJODMVEFEOPNFOUJPOPGiTPWFSFJHOUZw 5BUBSTUBOBSFTVQFSJPSPOJUTUFSSJUPSZ BOE5BUBSTUBOJTBCMFUPTVTQFOE3VTTJBOGFEFSBM BOEiJOUFSOBUJPOBMMBXw5BUBSTUBOTFOUJUTSFQSFTFOUBUJWFTUP3VTTJBT'FEFSBM"TTFNCMZ MBXT*UTDPOTUJUVUJPOBMMPXT5BUBSTUBOUPIBWFEJQMPNBUJDBOEDPOTVMBSNJTTJPOTJOGPS POMZBGUFSUIJTUSFBUZXBTTJHOFE FJHODPVOUSJFTȟȞ*UJTBMTPJNQPSUBOUUPSFNFNCFSUIBU5BUBSTUBOoBMPOHXJUI$IFDI OZBoSFGVTFEUPTJHOUIF'FEFSBM5SFBUZPG " OVNCFS PG JOUFSHPWFSONFOUBM BHSFFNFOUT XFSF CBTFE PO UIF QPXFSTIBSJOH USFBUZ*UXBTPċDJBMMZTUBUFEPO'FCSVBSZUIBUUIF/BUJPOBM#BOLPG5BUBSTUBO :M[XWV[M[NZWU\PMNMLMZITKMV\MZ XBTBQBSUPGUIF$FOUSBM#BOLPG3VTTJBȟȥ:FUBOPUIFSEPDVNFOUoTJHOFEUIFTBNF EBZoBMMPXFEFYDJTFDIBSHFTSFMBUFEUPBMDPIPM PJMBOEHBT MBOESFOU BOESFWFOVFT ɨFJOJUJBMSFBDUJPOTPGUIFGFEFSBMDFOUFSUPUIFTFBNCJUJPOTXFSFSBUIFSNVUFEBOE GSPN QSJWBUJ[BUJPO UP CF JODMVEFE JO 5BUBSTUBOT CVEHFUȠȜ " QPXFSTIBSJOH BHSFF DPNQSPNJTFESJWFO ɨF BHSFFNFOU CFUXFFO UIF 3VTTJBO BOE 5BUBSTUBOJ HPWFSO NFOUSFMBUFEUPUIFFDPOPNZ UIBUXBTDPODMVEFEPO'FCSVBSZ MFGUTFWFSBMBU NFOUTPG+BOVBSZTUBUFEUIFQFPQMFPG5BUBSTUBOQPTTFTTUIFMBOEBOEUIFOBUVSBM 5BUBSTUBOTPXOEJTDSFUJPO JODMVEJOHTJHOJOHFDPOPNJDDPPQFSBUJPOBHSFFNFOUTXJUI SFTPVSDFTPGUIFSFQVCMJDɨFEPDVNFOUTUBUFTUIBUUIFUXPQBSUJFTDPOEVDUUIFJSPXO GPSFJHOSFHJPOTBOETUBUFT UBLJOHTUBUFBOEDPNNFSDJBMDSFEJUT GPSNJOHJUTPXONPO GPSFJHOFDPOPNJDBDUJWJUJFT FYDFQUGPSQSPEVDUJPO XIJDISFRVJSFTMJDFOTJOHBOERVPU FUBSZGVOE QBSUJDJQBUJOHJOJOUFSOBUJPOBMPSHBOJ[BUJPOT DSFEJUJOHGPSFJHOQBSUOFST BOE JOHȟȟ'PSFYBNQMF UIFBHSFFNFOUCFUXFFOUIF3VTTJBOBOE5BUBSTUBOJHPWFSONFOUTPG DSFBUJOHGSFFFDPOPNJD[POFTJO5BUBSTUBOȠȝ +VOFTUBUFEUIBUUIFWPMVNFTPGPJMFYUSBDUJPOBOEPJMEFMJWFSZIBWFUPCFTQFDJ mFEFBDIZFBSJOCJMBUFSBMOFHPUJBUJPOTɨJTEPDVNFOUHJWFTUIF5BUBSTUBOJHPWFSONFOU " TQFDJBM BHSFFNFOU SFHVMBUFT NJMJUBSZ JOEVTUSZ JTTVFT ɨF GFEFSBM DFOUFS IBT UIFSJHIUUPDPODMVEFTFQBSBUFUSFBUJFTXJUIGPSFJHODPVOUSJFTPOUIFUSBOTQPSUBUJPOPG EFMFHBUFEUPUIF5BUBSTUBOJHPWFSONFOUUIFSJHIUUPDPOUSPMBOEPWFSTFFUIFEFGFOTF MPDBMMZFYUSBDUFEPJMȟȠ"OPUIFSBHSFFNFOU TJHOFEPO+VOF DPOmSNFEUIBU JOEVTUSZXJUIJOUIFGSBNFXPSLPGTQFDJBMQSPHSBNT QSPWJEFEUIBUUIFZDPNQMZXJUI 3VTTJBBOE5BUBSTUBOGPSNBOJOUFHSBUFEDVTUPNTBSFBȟȡ 3VTTJBO TUBOEBSET /P TQFDJBM QSPWJTJPOT DPODFSOJOH BSNT TBMFT XFSF BHSFFE VQPO BOE UIF BQQPJOUNFOU PG EJSFDUPST PG NJMJUBSZ FOUFSQSJTFT GFMM JOUP B KPJOU TQIFSF PG ɨFDPNNVOJRVÏPG+VMZTJHOFECFUXFFOUIF3VTTJBOBOE5BUBSTUBOJHPWFSO KVSJTEJDUJPOȠȞ NFOUT TUBUFE UIBU UIFJS SFMBUJPOTIJQ JT CBTFE PO5BUBSTUBOT TPWFSFJHOUZ BOE JOUFSOB UJPOBMQPTJUJPOȟȢ:FUUIFNPTUJNQPSUBOUEPDVNFOUTIBQJOHUIFJSCJMBUFSBMSFMBUJPOT ɨFUXPHPWFSONFOUTIBWFBHSFFEUIBUJUJTUIFQSFSPHBUJWFPG3VTTJBOBVUIPSJ UJFTUPSFHVMBUFNJMJUBSZQFSTPOOFMUSBJOJOH*OFYDIBOHF UIF5BUBSTUBOJHPWFSONFOU *CJE Q ɨF$POTUJUVUJPOPG5BUBSTUBO "SUJDMF JEFOUJmFTUIJTSFQVCMJDBTiBTTPDJBUFEXJUIUIF3VTTJBO *CJE Q 'FEFSBUJPOw JF OPNFOUJPOPGCFJOHiVOJUFEw *CJE Q *CJE QQo *CJE Q *CJE Q *CJE Q *CJE Q *CJE Q *CJE Q *CJE Q *CJE Q );5ISIZaKPM^IVL>6>IT]M^ -`\MZVIT:MTI\QWV[WN SFDFJWFEDPODVSSFOUQPXFSTSFMBUFEUPEFGFOTFNPCJMJ[BUJPONBUUFSTJOJUTUFSSJUPSZ BT *U XBT 1SFTJEFOU #PSJT :FMUTJOXIP mSTU PĊFSFE TFMGSVMF BOE TFMGNBOBHFNFOU XFMMBTSFDSVJUNFOUPGTFSWJDFNFOGSPNUIFSFQVCMJDUPUIFBSNFEGPSDFT.JMJUBSZTFS UP5BUBSTUBO4JODFUIBUUJNF EJĊFSFOUJOUFSQSFUBUJPOTPGTPWFSFJHOUZIBWFBQQFBSFE WJDFCZ5BUBSTUBOJSFTJEFOUTCFZPOE3VTTJBOUFSSJUPSZCFDBNFQPTTJCMFPOMZXJUIUIFJS JODMVEJOHiUBYBUJPOTPWFSFJHOUZ wiFDPOPNJDTPWFSFJHOUZ wiEVBMTPWFSFJHOUZ wiTIBSFE DPOTFOU8JUIUIFBQQSPWBMPGUIF5BUBSTUBOJHPWFSONFOU QBSUTPG5BUBSTUBOJUFSSJUP TPWFSFJHOUZ wiEJTUSJCVUFETPWFSFJHOUZ wBOEiEJWJEFETPWFSFJHOUZw.PTUPGUIFTFJOUFM SJFTNJHIUCFNBEFBWBJMBCMFUPUIF3VTTJBO%FGFOTF.JOJTUSZ QSPWJEFEUIBUOPUFTUT MFDUVBMJOWFOUJPOTBSFTVCKFDUUPEJĊFSFOUJOUFSQSFUBUJPOTBOEPQFOGPSGVSUIFSEJTDVT PGNBTTEFTUSVDUJPOXFBQPOTBSFDBSSJFEPVUɨF3VTTJBONJMJUBSZDPNNBOEIBTUP TJPO/POFPGUIFNTIPVMECFUBLFOGPSHSBOUFE CFDBVTFUIFTFBSFFTTFOUJBMMZQPMJUJDBM OPUJGZUIFHPWFSONFOUPG5BUBSTUBOBCPVUBMMQMBOOFENJMJUBSZFYFSDJTFT BTXFMMJUIBTUP oSBUIFSUIBOMFHBMoJTTVFT SFRVFTUBQQSPWBMGPSSFMPDBUJPOPGNJMJUBSZCBTFTBOENJMJUBSZFRVJQNFOU BOEUSBOTQPS UBUJPOUISPVHIUIFSFQVCMJDPGOVDMFBSBOEDIFNJDBMXFBQPOTɨFBHSFFNFOUTUJQVMBUFT *CJE QQo /(0TPCBJBQBQLB OP 'FCSVBSZ Q 8BMLFS &EXBSE i4PCBLB LPUPSBJB OF MBJBMB 5BUBSTUBO J BTZNNFUSJDIOJJ GFEFSBMJTN W 3PTTJJw )UUQXXXOOTSVJOUFSWJOUIUNM ɨF %PH8IJDI /FWFS #BSLFE5BUBSTUBOBOE "TZNNFUSJDBM 'FEFSBMJTN JO 3VTTJB 1BOPSBNB /F[BWJTJNBJBHB[FUBXFCTJUF BUIUUQOHSVQSJOUFETQFDmMF@TVWFSFOJUFUIUNM 'PSVN OP o Qo .VLIBSJBNPW /BZM i3FTQVCMJLB 5BUBSTUBO ,ISPOJLB QPMJUJDIFTLPHP QSPUTFTTBw 3FQVCMJD PG /JLSBWFTI #BCBL i2VFCFD BOE5BUBSTUBOJO *OUFSOBUJPOBM -BXw DzF 'MFUDIFS 'PSVN PG8PSME 5BUBSTUBO$ISPOJDMFPG1PMJUJDBM1SPDFTT 0DDBTJPOBM1BQFSTPOUIF&MJUFPGUIF.JE7PMHB&UIOJD "ąBJST WPM OP XJOUFSoTQSJOH Q 3FQVCMJDT OP+BQBO4MBWJD3FTFBSDI$FOUFS )PLLBJEP6OJWFSTJUZ Q );5ISIZaKPM^IVL>6>IT]M^ -`\MZVIT:MTI\QWV[WN "MMUIFMFHBMJSSFHVMBSJUJFTBOEJNQFSGFDUJPOTEFTDSJCFEBCPWFNJHIUIBWFSFNBJOFE "TTPDJBUFESFMBUJPOTBSFUSFBUFEBTUIPTFPGUIFIJTUPSJDBMBMMJBODFPG5BUBSTBOE3VTTJBOT EVSBCMFCFDBVTFOFJUIFSUIFGFEFSBMDFOUFSOPS5BUBSTUBOXBTJOUFSFTUFEJOFTUBCMJTIJOH VOJUFEPSHBOJDBMMZCZUIFWFSZOBUVSFPGWJDJOJUZBOENVMUJQMFDPNNVOJDBUJPOTȡȤ DMFBSBOEUSBOTQBSFOUSFMBUJPOTIJQNFDIBOJTNT#PUIQBSUJFTXFSFXJTIJOHUPMFBWFBT "TGPSUIFMFHBMBTQFDUT BDDPSEJOHUPUIFGFEFSBMMBXPG+BOVBSZiPODPPS NVDISPPNGPSiVOEFSUIFDBSQFUwCBSHBJOJOHBOEQFSTPOBMEFBMTBTQPTTJCMFȡȞ EJOBUJPOPGJOUFSOBUJPOBMBOEGPSFJHOFDPOPNJDBDUJWJUZPG3VTTJBO'FEFSBUJPOTDPO *UJTUSVFUIBU5BUBSTUBOTVDDFFEFEJOJOGPSNBMMZMPCCZJOHJUTJOUFSFTUTVTJOHBWBSJ TUJUVFOUQBSUT w3VTTJBOSFHJPOTDBOOPUTJHOBHSFFNFOUTXJUIGPSFJHODFOUSBMBVUIPSJUJFT FUZPGQPMJUJDBMBSHVNFOUT)PXFWFS OPUBMMPGUIFNXFSFDPOTJTUFOU BOEBMNPTUBMM VOMFTTUIF3VTTJBOHPWFSONFOUBQQSPWFTUIFNɨJTQSPWJTJPOGPSNBMMZSVOTBHBJOTU BSFPQFOUPNVMUJQMFJOUFSQSFUBUJPOTɨVT UIFDIBJSNBOPGUIF-BX%FQBSUNFOUJO UIFQPXFSTIBSJOHUSFBUZCFUXFFO3VTTJBBOE5BUBSTUBOɨF$POTUJUVUJPOBM$PVSUPG UIF5BUBSTUBOJ4UBUF$PVODJM 4IBLJS:BHVEJO JOUFSQSFUTUIFMFHBMVODFSUBJOUJFTTPBTUP 3VTTJBIBTJTTVFEUXPTUBUFNFOUTPO5BUBSTUBO PO.BSDIBOE+VOF NBLF5BUBSTUBOiUIFTUBUFXJUIJOUIFTUBUFwȡȟ%FTDSJCJOHJUTOBUVSF 4IBJNJFWEFmOFT UIBUJOEJDBUFEoJOEFmBODFPGNVMUJQMFEPDVNFOUTTJHOFECFUXFFO.PTDPXBOE,B[BO JUBTiUIFTUBUFPGBMMQFPQMFTMJWJOHJOPVSUFSSJUPSZ wBOETJNVMUBOFPVTMZBTiUIFTUBUF oUIBUMBXTQSPDMBJNJOH5BUBSTUBOTTPWFSFJHOTUBUVTXFSFVODPOTUJUVUJPOBM PG5BUBSTwȡȠ)FXBOUTJOEFQFOEFOUQPXFSTCVUQMFEHFTOPUUPVOEFSNJOFUIFVOJUZPG %FTQJUFBMMUIFTFJODPOTJTUFODJFTGSPNCPUIQBSUJFTJOWPMWFE JUJTJNQPSUBOUUIBU 3VTTJB1SFTFOUJOHIJNTFMGBTBGFEFSBMJTU 4IBJNJFWPQUTJOGBDUGPSUIFiVOJPOTUBUFXJUI GSPNUIFCFHJOOJOHPGUIFT TPWFSFJHOUZXBTTFFOJO,B[BOBTBQSPDFTTUPCF UIFFMFNFOUTPGDPOGFEFSBUJPOwȡȡ)FJTJOGBWPSPGSBJTJOHUIFTUBUVTPG3VTTJBOPCMBTUT EFWFMPQFEPOBOBEIPDCBTJT*O4IBJNJFWTXPSET iXFEPOUUIJOLUIFTPWFSFJHOUZJT XJUIJOUIFGFEFSBUJPO CVUPQQPTFTHSBOUJOHUIFPCMBTUTUIFTBNFSJHIUTBTUIPTFFOKPZFE BOBCTPMVUF OFJUIFSXFQVTIJUGPSDFGVMMZJOUIPTFEJSFDUJPOTXIFSFUIFSFJTOPXBZUP CZUIFSFQVCMJDTȡȢ*OPVSWJFX BMMUIFTFTUBUFNFOUTBSFCBTFEPOQPMJUJDBMTZNCPMJTN HPoGPSFYBNQMF JOEFGFOTFPSmOBODJBMNBUUFST4IPVMEUIFDJSDVNTUBODFTDIBOHF XF SBUIFSUIBOPOUBSHFUJOHUIFSFBMJTTVFTUIBU5BUBSTUBOIBTUPGBDF TIBMMSFBDUwȡȥ"HBJO UIJTJTBHPPEFYBNQMFPGBQVSFMZQPMJUJDBMBQQSPBDIUPTPMWJOH UIFMFHBMDPOUSPWFSTZ,IBLJNIBTFYQMJDJUMZBDLOPXMFEHFEUIBUiXFXFSFJOEFQFOEFOU .MLMZITXWTQKQM[ POMZPOFEBZ )VNBO3JHIUT"TTPDJBUJPOXFCTJUF BUIUUQXXXISJHIUTSVUFYUC$IBQUFSIUN *CJE i'VUVSF PG 'FEFSBMJTN JO 3VTTJBw SFTFBSDI QSPKFDU XFC TJUF BU IUUQGFEFSBMJTNTPSPTLTVSV DPOGFSFODFTFNJOBSKBHVEJOIUN *CJE 4QJSJUVBM)FSJUBHFUIJOLUBOLXFCTJUF BUIUUQXXXOBTMFEJFSVPCP[/@@IUN i0ULPOGSPOUBUTJJLOBWFEFOJVNPTUPWw 'SPN$POGSPOUBUJPOUP#SJEHJOHUIF(BQT 1BOPSBNB 'PSVN OP TQFDJBMJTTVF Q *CJE ɨJTJTEFUFSNJOFEJOBDDPSEBODFXJUIUIF$POTUJUVUJPOPSUIFQPXFSTIBSJOHCJMBUFSBMBHSFFNFOUT *CJE 4UPMJBSPW .JLIBJM i.F[IEVOBSPEOBJB EFJBUFMOPTU TVCFLUPW GFEFSBUTJJ JOUFSFTZ QSBWB WP[NP 4IBLISBJ 4FSHFJi'FEFSBMJTNQPLB[BOTLJw 'FEFSBMJTN ,B[BOT8BZ /(0TPCBJBQBQLB OP [IOPTUJw *OUFSOBUJPOBM"DUJWJUJFTPGUIF4VCKFDUTPG'FEFSBUJPO*OUFSFTUT 3JHIUT 0QQPSUVOJUJFT 'FCSVBSZ Q 1BOPSBNB'PSVN TVNNFS Q );5ISIZaKPM^IVL>6>IT]M^ -`\MZVIT:MTI\QWV[WN ;W^MZMQOV\aQVY]M[\QWV" 5BUBSTUBOJMFBEFST JTTVFE B OVNCFS PG TUBUFNFOUT UP DPVOUFSBDU UIJT ɨF mSTU (BMFFW .BSBU i4PWSFNFOOJF UFOEFOUTJJ SB[WJUJB GFEFSBMJ[NB J SFGPSNZ HPTVEBSTUWFOOPJ WMBTUJ W3PTTJJw $VSSFOU5SFOETJO%FWFMPQNFOUPG'FEFSBMJTNBOE4UBUF1PXFS3FGPSNJO3VTTJB "WBJMBCMFBUIUUQGFEFSBMNDBSULTVSVDPOGFSFODFLPOGFSHBMFFWIUN 7SFNJB./ +VOF :BHVEJO 4IBLJS i1SPCMFNZ TVCTJEJBSOPTUJ SPTTJJTLPHP GFEFSBMJTNB OB QSJNFSF 3FTQVCMJLJ 5BUBSTUBOw ɨF 1SPCMFNT PG 4VCTJEJBSJUZ PG UIF 3VTTJBO 'FEFSBMJTN UIF $BTF PG 5BUBSTUBO 7PMHB'FEFSBM%JTUSJDUXFCTJUF BUIUUQXXXQGPSVNBJOOFXTQIUNM JE BUIUUQGFEFSBMNDBSULTVSVDPOGFSFODFLPOGFSKBHVEJOIUN 4USBOBPOMJOFJOGPSNBUJPOBHFODZ BUIUUQWPMHBTUSBOBSVQSJOUIUNM 4USBOBPOMJOFJOGPSNBUJPOBHFODZ BUIUUQWPMHBTUSBOBSVQSJOUIUNM /(3FMJHJJ .BSDI QQ "CESBLINBOPW 3BmLBOE(VMTVN1VHBDIPWBi1FSTQFLUJWZGFEFSBMJTNBW3PTTJJw 1FSTQFDUJWFT /J[IOJJ/PWHPSPEPOMJOFJOGPSNBUJPOBHFODZ BUIUUQXXXJOGPOFUOOPWSV .BZ PO'FEFSBMJTNJO3VTTJB "WBJMBCMFBUIUUQGFEFSBMNDBSULTVSVQVCMJDBUJPOTQVHBDIIUN 4USBOBPOMJOFJOGPSNBUJPOBHFODZ BUIUUQWPMHBTUSBOBSVQSJOUIUNM 4USBOBPOMJOFJOGPSNBUJPOBHFODZ BUIUUQWPMHBTUSBOBSVQSJOUIUNM );5ISIZaKPM^IVL>6>IT]M^ -`\MZVIT:MTI\QWV[WN HPWFSONFOUBHSFFEUPKPJOUMZGVOETPNFQSPKFDUTUIBUXFSFQSFWJPVTMZGVOEFEFYDMV GFEFSBMCVEHFUUIBUUIFZSFDFJWFGSPNJU UPIBWFBOVNCFSPGBEKBDFOUXFBLFSQSPWJODFT TJWFMZGSPNSFQVCMJDBOCVEHFUTȣȟ VOEFSUIFJSmOBODJBMQBUSPOBHFɨFTFSFHJPOBMHSPVQJOHTDFOUFSFEPOTFWFSBMMFBEFST JODMVEJOH5BUBSTUBOJUTFMG DPVMECFUIFOVDMFJPGGVUVSFOFXSFHJPOBMBHHMPNFSBUJPOT ɨFTFGBDUTDMFBSMZJOEJDBUFUIBUUIFQPMJUJDBMFMJUFTIPXTBHSFBUEFBMPGTPCFSOFTT JO3VTTJBȤȝ BOENPEFSBUJPO BOETUSBUFHJDBMMZMPPLTGPSQPMJUJDBMTFUUMFNFOUPGUIFJSEJTBHSFFNFOUT XJUIUIFGFEFSBMDFOUFS4JODFBVUVNO4IBJNJFWIBTTQPLFOPGBiTFMGTVċDJFOUw 4IBJNJFWJTTUJMMUIFQPMJUJDBMmHVSFUIBUUIFGFEFSBMBVUIPSJUJFTIBWFUPUBLFNPSF BOEOPUiTPWFSFJHOw 5BUBSTUBOiɨFPċDFTPGGFEFSBMBHFODJFTIBWFCFHVOUPPQFO TFSJPVTMZUIBONPTUPUIFSSFHJPOBMDIJFGUBJOT 1VUJOIBTQVCMJDMZDPOGFTTFEUIBUJUXBT JO,B[BO BOE.PTDPXIBTSFJNQPTFEDPOUSPMPWFSUBYDPMMFDUJPOBOETQFOEJOHɨF 4IBJNJFWUPXIPNIFmSTUPĊFSFEUIFQPTUPGUIFIFBEPGUIF7'% ȤȞ*OUIFPQJOJPO JOUSPEVDUJPOPGUFBDIJOHVTJOHUIF-BUJOBMQIBCFUIBTCFFOQPTUQPOFE XJUIFYJTUJOH PG1SPGFTTPS7MBEJNJS3B[VWBFW iJOUIFMJHIUPG5BMJCBOTVDDFTTFTJO"GHIBOJTUBOBOE QSPKFDUT MBCFMFE FYQFSJNFOUBMwȣȠ ɨF $PNNVOJDBUJPO #PBSE PG5BUBSTUBOXBT JOUF QPTTJCMFAEPNJOPSFBDUJPOBMMBDSPTT$FOUSBM"TJB .PTDPXUSFBUT4IBJNJFWBTBNVDI HSBUFEJOUPUIFGFEFSBMVOJUȣȡ4PNFMPDBMFYQFSUTIBWFTUBSUFEEJTDVTTJOHUIFDPOEJ OFFEFEMFBEFSXIPDPVMEIBWFCFFOVTFEBTBCBSSJFSUPSFMJHJPVTFYUSFNJTNBOEQPMJUJ UJPOTGPS5BUBSTUBOTFOUSZJOUPBOFOMBSHFESFHJPO TIPVMEUIFGFEFSBMDFOUFSUBLFUIJT DBMEFTUBCJMJ[BUJPOwȤȟ4IBJNJFWXBTBQQPJOUFEUPUIFTFWFOHPWFSOPSQSFTJEFODZPGUIF EFDJTJPOȣȢ4IBJNJFWTWJFXXBTUIBUUIFSFXBTTVċDJFOUTQBDFGPSCBSHBJOJOHXJUIUIF OFXMZDSFBUFE4UBUF$PVODJMBTBTZNCPMPGFBTJOHUFOTJPOTCFUXFFO5BUBSTUBOBOE3VT GFEFSBMBVUIPSJUJFTɨJTTUSBUFHZPGDPNQSPNJTFXBTSFJOGPSDFECZQPMJUJDBMNFTTBHFTIF TJBȤȠ*OUIF4UBUF$PVODJM 4IBJNJFWDIBJSFEUIFBEIPDHSPVQSFTQPOTJCMFGPSFMBCPSBU XBTSFDFJWJOHGSPN.PTDPX CBTJDBMMZTJHOBMJ[JOHUIBU1VUJOJTOPUJOUFOEJOHUPVOTFBU JOHQPXFSTIBSJOHJOUIFKPJOUKVSJTEJDUJPOJTTVFTPG3VTTJBBOEUIFSFHJPOTɨFNBJO 4IBJNJFW BJNPGIJTQSPKFDUXBTUPGVSUIFSSFEJTUSJCVUFDPODVSSFOUQPXFSTCFUXFFOGFEFSBMBOE SFHJPOBMBVUIPSJUJFT:FUUIF,SFNMJOTSFBDUJPOUP4IBJNJFWTSFQPSUUPUIF4UBUF$PVO 5BUBSTUBOJBVUIPSJUJFTBSFMPPLJOHGPSQPMJUJDBMDPNQSPNJTFTCBTFEPODIBOHFTUP DJMXBTRVJUFSFWFBMJOHJUXBTXJUIESBXOGSPNUIFBHFOEBBUTIPSUOPUJDF ȤȡXIJDIJOEJ UIFDPOTUJUVUJPOTPGSFQVCMJDT JODMVEJOH5BUBSTUBO CFJOHDPNQMFNFOUFECZBEFRVBUF DBUFTUIBUUIFGFEFSBMDFOUFSJTOPUZFUSFBEZUPEJTDVTTUIFTFJTTVFTJOEFQUI SFWJTJPOTPGUIFGFEFSBMDPOTUJUVUJPOȣȣ:FU 5BUBSTUBOTFFNTUPCFVOXJMMJOHUPHJWFVQ JUT DPOWJDUJPO UIBU 3VTTJB IBT UP SFNBJO BO BTZNNFUSJDBM GFEFSBUJPO BOE OFFET UIF ɨFHPPEOFXTGPS5BUBSTUBOXBTUIBUUIFGFEFSBMDFOUFSGPVOEPVUUIBUUIFSFXFSF $IBNCFS PG /BUJPOBMJUJFT BT B QBSU PG JUT QBSMJBNFOUȣȤ 4IBJNJFW TUSPOHMZ TVQQPSUT SFHJPOBMMBXT MJLF5BUBSTUBOT-BOE$PEF ȤȢUIBUXFSFFJUIFSCFUUFSUIBOUIFGFEFSBM LFFQJOHUIFIFBETPGUIFTVCKFDUTPGGFEFSBUJPOTQPQVMBSMZFMFDUFE XIJMTUBQQPJOUJOH POFTPSVOJRVF,JSJFOLPIBTDPODFEFEUIBUJUJTOFDFTTBSZUPVTFSFHJPOBMFYQFSJFODF UIFIFBETPGUIFNVOJDJQBMVOJUTȣȥ BOENBLFBNFOENFOUTPSBEPQUOFXMBXTBUUIFGFEFSBMMFWFMɨJTJTBHPPEFYBNQMF PGUIFSFHJPOTBCJMJUZUPJOnVFODFGFEFSBMQPMJDZBOEMBXNBLJOH 5BUBSTUBOTUJMMIBTSFTFSWBUJPOTSFHBSEJOHUFSSJUPSJBMSFGPSNT4IBJNJFWJTPOFPG UIFNPTUWPDJGFSPVTDSJUJDTPGUIFXJUIESBXBMPGSFHJPOBMMFBEFSTGSPNUIF'FEFSBUJPO ,JSJFOLP IBT IJHIMZ QSBJTFE5BUBSTUBOJBVUIPSJUJFT PO TFWFSBM PDDBTJPOT *O IJT $PVODJMȤȜ*OBOBUUFNQUUPTUBSUBQVCMJDEFCBUFPOUIFFĊFDUJWFOFTTPGBOFXSFHJPOBM XPSET iPOF EBZ UIFSF XJMM CF B NPOVNFOU UP 4IBJNJFW CVJMUwȤȣ *O B DPODJMJBUPSZ EJWJTJPOPG3VTTJB 4IBJNJFWQSPQPTFEEJWJEJOHFBDIPGUIFGFEFSBMEJTUSJDUTJOUPTFWFSBM NBOOFS IF BENJUUFE UIBU UIF UBY QSJWJMFHFT PCUBJOFE CZ5BUBSTUBO GSPN UIF GFEFSBM UFSSJUPSJBMFOUJUJFTFBDIDPNQSJTJOHUXPPSUISFFTVCKFDUTPGGFEFSBUJPO*OIJTPQJOJPO DFOUFSXFSFQSPQFSMZVTFEUPIFMQUIFSFQVCMJDTFDPOPNZȤȤ,JSJFOLPQSBJTFE5BUBSTUBOJ iTNBMMSFHJPOTwXJUIJOPOFGFEFSBMEJTUSJDU BTJOUIFDBTFPGUIF7%' JTUPPNBOZ 5P EFWFMPQ UIFTF JEFBT GVSUIFS JO "QSJM 'BSJE .VLIBNFUTIJO DBNF VQ XJUI &8*3VTTJBO3FHJPOBM3FQPSU WPM OP UIFQSPQPTBMUPPċDJBMMZBMMPXUIFiEPOPSwSFHJPOT UIPTFDPOUSJCVUJOHNPSFUPUIF /F[BWJTJNBJB HB[FUB XFC TJUF BU IUUQSFHJPOTOHSVQSJOUFEHVCFSO@ HPWFSOPSIUNM /F[BWJTJNBJBHB[FUBXFCTJUF BUIUUQSFHJPOTOHSVQSJOUFEGBS@UBUBSTUBOIUNM 4USBOBPOMJOFJOGPSNBUJPOBHFODZ BUIUUQWPMHBTUSBOBSVQSJOUIUNM 4IBJNJFWXBTPOFPGUIFMFBEJOHNFNCFSTPGi'BUIFSMBOE"MM3VTTJB wUIFQPMJUJDBMBMMJBODFTIBQFE +BDL "OESFXi3FQVCMJD#SPVHIUCBDLJOUP-JOFXJUI.PTDPXw'JOBODJBM5JNFT "QSJM JOTVNNFSQSJPSUP3VTTJBTQBSMJBNFOUBSZFMFDUJPOTɨJTHSPVQJOHDPOTJTUFEPGPUIFSQPX Q7* FSGVM QPMJUJDJBOT JODMVEJOH GPSNFS QSJNF NJOJTUFS :FWHFOZ 1SJNBLPW NBZPS PG .PTDPX :VSJJ -V[ILPW HPWFSOPS PG 4U 1FUFSTCVSH "MFYBOES :BLPWMFW i'BUIFSMBOE"MM 3VTTJB w JO EJTUJODUJWF 4USBOBPOMJOFJOGPSNBUJPOBHFODZ BUIUUQXXXTUSBOBSVQSJOUIUNM PQQPTJUJPOUPUIF,SFNMJO IBECFFOJOUIFMFBEVOUJMUIFQSP1VUJOi6OJUZwQBSUZXBTGPSNFE:FU *TLIBLPW %BNJSi1FSTQFLUJWZGFEFSBMJ[NBW3PTTJJW[HMJBEJ[5BUBSTUBOBw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aKPM^IVL>6>IT]M^ -`\MZVIT:MTI\QWV[WN BVUIPSJUJFTGPSUIFJSVOEFSTUBOEJOHPGUIFOFFEUPCVJMEVQiJOUFHSBUJPODIBJOTwXJUI BTUIF$BSSPMM'PVOEBUJPO 6OJUFE,JOHEPN UIF0QFO4PDJFUZ*OTUJUVUF QBSUPGUIF PUIFSSFHJPOTJOPSEFSUPCFDPNQFUJUJWFBCSPBEȤȥ)FDPNQBSFE5BUBSTUBOXJUIBWFSUJ 4PSPT'PVOEBUJPO BOEUIF&YQPSU*NQPSU#BOLPGUIF64 DBMMZTUSVDUVSFEDPSQPSBUJPO CVUDPNQFUJOHSBUIFSFĊFDUJWFMZXJUIPUIFSQPMJUJDBMBOE %FCBUFT BCPVU 5BUBSTUBOJ JOUFSOBUJPOBM QBSUJDJQBUJPO XFSF TZNQUPNBUJDBMMZ FDPOPNJDBDUPSTVTJOHBWBSJFUZPGMFHJUJNBUFNFBOTi*BNOPUTBZJOHUIJTXBTUIFSJHIU FYUFOEFE UP DJUJ[FOTIJQ JTTVFT "HSFFNFOUT CFUXFFO 3VTTJB BOE TFWFSBM SFQVCMJDT UIJOHUPEP XIBU*BNTBZJOHJTUIBUJUXPSLFEwȥȜ"UUIFTBNFUJNF ,JSJFOLPUFSNFE JODMVEJOH5BUBSTUBO IBEGPSNBMMZTUJQVMBUFEUIBUDJUJ[FOTIJQJTTVFTPVHIUUPCFUBDL UIF5BUBSTUBOJEFNBOEGPSJOUSPEVDJOHBiOBUJPOBMJUZwSVCSJDJOOFXQBTTQPSUTBTBiWJP MFECZUIPTFSFQVCMJDTUIFNTFMWFTɨFDPOnJDUVOGPMEFEBTTPPOBTUIFJNQMFNFOUBUJPO MBUJPOPGIVNBOSJHIUTwȥȝJOIJTWJFX JOBEFNPDSBUJDTPDJFUZJUJTOPUNBOEBUPSZGPS PGUIPTFQSPWJTJPOTCFHBOɨFGFEFSBMDFOUFSJTGFBSGVMUIBUJOUSPEVDUJPOPG5BUBSTUBOJ QFPQMFUPJOEJDBUFUIFJSFUIOJDBċMJBUJPO DJUJ[FOTIJQXPVMETJHOJGZUIFBQQFBSBODFPGUIFEVBMDJUJ[FOTIJQUIBUJTVOBDDFQUBCMFUP /FWFSUIFMFTT UIF JOUFMMFDUVBMT JO5BUBSTUBOFYQSFTTFE HSFBU DPODFSOT SFHBSEJOH .PTDPXɨFIFBEPGUIF-FHBM%FQBSUNFOUPGUIFBENJOJTUSBUJPOPGUIFQSFTJEFOUPG 1VUJOTJOUFOUJPOTUPTVCEVFUIFSFHJPOTȥȞɨFWFSZFTUBCMJTINFOUPGUIFGFEFSBMEJT 5BUBSTUBO 3BJTB4BLIJFWB IBTBTTVSFEOFWFSUIFMFTTUIBUIFSHPWFSONFOUTUJMMBEIFSFTUP USJDUTXBTQVUVOEFSRVFTUJPO TJODFMPDBMFYQFSUTBSHVFEUIBUUIFGFEFSBMHPWFSONFOU UIFQSJODJQMFPGDPNNPODJUJ[FOTIJQ CVUSFTFSWFTUIFSJHIUUPTFUTQFDJBMSVMFTSFMBUFE BMSFBEZQPTTFTTFEBEFRVBUFJOTUSVNFOUTGPSPWFSTFFJOHUIFSFHJPOT FH DPVSUT BOE UPDJUJ[FOTIJQ BTXFMMBTHSBOU5BUBSTUBOJDJUJ[FOTIJQUPUIPTFJOEJWJEVBMTXIPEPOPU NJOJTUSJFTPGKVTUJDF BOEUIFSFXBTOPHVBSBOUFFUIBU1VUJOTTZTUFNXPVMEXPSLBOZ IPME3VTTJBODJUJ[FOTIJQȥȠ CFUUFS 4IBJNJFW FNQIBTJ[FT UIBU 5BUBSTUBO XJMM OPU FODSPBDI VQPO GFEFSBM QPXFST JO EFGFOTF JTTVFT CPSEFS EFNBSDBUJPO BOE DVTUPNT BOE FDPOPNJD QPMJDJFT :FU JO ;W^MZMQOV\aIVLNWZMQOVXWTQKaQ[[]M[ 5BUBSTUBOIBE TJHOFE UIF5SFBUZ PO 'SJFOETIJQ BOE $PPQFSBUJPO XJUI "CLIB [JB BOBVUPOPNPVTUFSSJUPSZJOOPSUIXFTUFSO(FPSHJBTFFLJOHGVMMJOEFQFOEFODFɨJT 5BUBSTUBOVTFTBOVNCFSPGBSHVNFOUTJOJUTBTQJSBUJPOTGPSBGSFFBOEBVUPOPNPVT BDU QSPWPLFE QSPUFTU GSPN CPUI (FPSHJB BOE 3VTTJB TJODF JU XBT JOUFSQSFUFE BT BO GPSFJHOQPMJDZ'JSTU UIFQPXFSTIBSJOHBHSFFNFOUTJHOFEXJUIUIFGFEFSBMDFOUFSTUJQV FODSPBDINFOUVQPOUIFUFSSJUPSJBMJOUFHSJUZPG(FPSHJBȥȡ MBUFTUIBU5BUBSTUBOJTBOBTTPDJBUFETUBUFɨJTQSPWJTJPOEJTUJOHVJTIFT5BUBSTUBOGSPN BMMPUIFS3VTTJBOTVCKFDUT 5BUBSTUBOIBTEFNPOTUSBUFEUIBUJUTBQQSPBDIFTUPGPSFJHOBOETFDVSJUZQPMJDJFT BSFWFSZEJĊFSFOUGSPNUIPTFPG3VTTJB5BCMFPVUMJOFTUIFTFEJĊFSFODFT 4FDPOEMZ JOUFSOBUJPOBMUSBOTSFHJPOBMJTNQSBDUJDFTBSFBTUSPOHTPVSDFPGJOUFS OBUJPOBMTFMGBTTFSUJPOɨVT 7MBEJNJS1VTUPHBSPW BTFOJPSTDIPMBSBUUIF*OTUJUVUFPG UIF4UBUFBOE-BX 3VTTJBO"DBEFNZPG4DJFODFT BTTVNFTUIBUJUJTWFSZIBSEUPMFHBMMZ EFmOFXIBUJTNFBOUCZBiTVCKFDUPGJOUFSOBUJPOBMMBXw*OIJTPQJOJPO OPBEEJUJPOBM SFDPHOJUJPOPSDPOmSNBUJPOJTOFFEFEJGUIFNFNCFSPGUIFGFEFSBUJPOTIPVMEXJTI UPQBSUJDJQBUFJOJOUFSOBUJPOBMFYDIBOHFT8IBUJTNPTUJNQPSUBOUJTUIBUUIFQPXFST PGUIFSFHJPOJOJOUFSOBUJPOBMJTTVFTPVHIUUPDPSSFTQPOEUPUIFOBUJPOBMDPOTUJUVUJPO BOEJOUFSOBUJPOBMPCMJHBUJPOTPG3VTTJBȥȟɨFTFBSFUIFNPTUDVTUPNBSZMJNJUBUJPOT JNQPTFEPOUIFTPWFSFJHOUZPGUIFGFEFSBMVOJUTJOPUIFSGFEFSBUJPOT 5BUBSTUBOBTQJSFTUPDPOEVDUGPSFJHOQPMJDZJOJUTDBQBDJUZBTBTUBUFSBUIFSUIBO POFPGUIF3VTTJBOSFHJPOT*UEFWFMPQTFYUFSOBMSFMBUJPOTXJUIBXJEFSBOHFPGEJĊFS FOUJOUFSOBUJPOBMBDUPSTXJUIEJĊFSFOUXFJHIUTBOETUBUVTFT"NPOHUIFNBSFOPUPOMZ OBUJPOTUBUFT CVU BMTP PUIFS SFHJPOT TVDI BT 2VFCFD $BOBEB 4BYPOZ (FSNBOZ #VLIBSB 6[CFLJTUBO .BESJE 4QBJO BOE4PVUI"VTUSBMJB BOEPSHBOJ[BUJPOTTVDI 3FHJPOZ3PTTJJ OP .BSDI Q 3FHJPOZ3PTTJJ OP "QSJM Q i'VUVSF PG 'FEFSBMJTN JO 3VTTJBw SFTFBSDI QSPKFDU XFC TJUF BU IUUQGFEFSBMJTNTPSPTLTVSV 7PMHB'FEFSBM%JTUSJDUPċDJBMXFCTJUF BUIUUQXXXQGPSVNBJOOFXTQIUNM JE DPOGFSFODFTFNJOBSTBLIJFWBIUN i3FHJPOTSVwPOMJOFJOGPSNBUJPOBHFODZ BUIUUQXXXSFHJPOTSVOFXTIUNM i%PHPWPS P ESV[ICF J TPUSVEOJDIFTUWF NF[IEV 3FTQVCMJLPJ5BUBSTUBO J 3FTQVCMJLPJ "CLIB[JBw 1VTUPHBSPW 7MBEJNJSi(PTVEBSTUWFOOJJTVWFSFOJUFUJNF[IEVOBSPEOPFQSBWPw 4UBUF4PWFSFJHOUZ 5SFBUZ PO 'SJFOETIJQ BOE $PPQFSBUJPO CFUXFFO 5BUBSTUBO BOE "CLIB[JB 1BOPSBNB 'PSVN BOE*OUFSOBUJPOBM-BX 1BOPSBNB'PSVN OP QQo OP QQo );5ISIZaKPM^IVL>6>IT]M^ -`\MZVIT:MTI\QWV[WN 5BCMF3VTTJBO5BUBSTUBOJEJĊFSFODFTPOGPSFJHOQPMJDZJTTVFT JOUIF,PTPWPmHIUJOHɨPTFQSPKFDUTXFSFTBJEUPEJWJEF3VTTJBBMPOHFUIOJD MJOFTBOEMFBWFUIFWPMVOUFFSTXJUIPVUBEFRVBUFMFHBMBOETPDJBMQSPUFDUJPOȥȥ *TTVF 3VTTJBOTUBOEQPJOU 5BUBSTUBOJPċDJBMTUBOEQPJOUȥȢ *O BOPUIFS TUBUFNFOU PO UIF #BMLBOT DSJTJT UIF 4UBUF $PVODJM PG5BUBSTUBO 4FSCTBSFSFTQPOTJCMFGPSFUIOJD DBMMFEUIFEFDJTJPOUPTFOE3VTTJBOQFBDFLFFQJOHUSPPQTUP,PTPWPBTiTFOTF :VHPTMBWJBJTUIFWJDUJNPG/"50 #BMLBOT DMFBOTJOHTBOETIPVMEOPUCF MFTT wiJNNPSBM wBOEiVOBDDFQUBCMF wTJODFJUEJWFSUFETDBSDFmOBODJBMSFTPVSDFT BHHSFTTJPO TVQQPSUFE GSPNEPNFTUJDOFFETȝȜȜ-BUFS4IBJNJFWTUBUFEUIBUGFEFSBMQPMJUJDJBOTTIPVME 8BSJOUIF/PSUIFSO$BVDBTVT HJWFVQUIFJMMVTJPOUIBUi&VSPQFXPVMEOPUTVSWJWFXJUIPVU3VTTJB wCBDLJOH $POnJDUJO$IFDIOZBJTB3VT IBTHMPCBMDPOTFRVFODFTTJODF $IFDIOZB 3VTTJBTIBOETPĊQPMJDZJO,PTPWPBOE$IFDIOZBJOTUFBE4IBJNJFWBSHVFE TJBOEPNFTUJDJTTVF $IFDIOZBXBTEFGBDUP UIBUi&VSPQFXJMMVOEPVCUFEMZTVSWJWF XIJMF ,IBLJN 3BGBFM i3PTTJJB J5BUBSTUBOV JTUPSJDIFTLPHP QFSFLSJPTULBw 3VTTJB BOE5BUBSTUBOBU B )JTUPSJDBM$SPTTSPBET 1BOPSBNB'PSVN OP Q 5BUBSTUBOHPWFSONFOUXFCTJUF BUIUUQXXXUBUBSSVIUNM *CJE 5BUBSTUBOHPWFSONFOUXFCTJUF BUIUUQXXXUBUBSSVIUNM *TLIBLPW %BNJSi.PEFM5BUBSTUBOB[BJQSPUJWw 5BUBSTUBOT.PEFM1SPTBOE$POT 1BOPSBNB 3FHJPOZ3PTTJJ OP +BOVBSZ Q 'PSVN OP Q 5BUBSTUBOHPWFSONFOUXFCTJUF BUIUUQXXXUBUBSSVIUNM );5ISIZaKPM^IVL>6>IT]M^ ɨ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ȝȜȟ5BUBSTUBOPċDJBMTUSJFEUPNFEJBUFCFUXFFOUIF3VTTJBOTBOEUIF$IFDI FOT QSPQPTJOHUIFQSJODJQMFPGiEFMBZFETPMVUJPOwXIJDIXBTQBSUMZJNQMFNFOUFEJO UIFi,IBTBWJVSUBHSFFNFOUTwPGBOETVCTFRVFOUOFHPUJBUJPOTXJUIUIFHVFSJMMBT *O UIF4UBUF$PVODJMPG5BUBSTUBOCBOOFEUIFQSBDUJDFPGTFOEJOHDPOTDSJQUTGSPN 5BUBSTUBOUPUIF/PSUI$BVDBTVT PSEFSJOHUIBU5BUBSTUBOJSFTJEFOUTDPVMECFSFDSVJUFE BTTPMEJFSTPOMZPOBWPMVOUBSZCBTJTȝȜȠ*UJTBMTPLOPXOUIBU5BUBSEFMFHBUJPOTKPJOFE 6/SFQSFTFOUBUJWFTUPOFHPUJBUFXJUIUIFMFBEFSTPGUIF5BMJCBOPWFSUIFSFMFBTFPGB DBQUVSFEBJSMJOFSDSFX BOEEJTDVTTFEQSPTQFDUTGPS3VTTJBOQPMJDZJOUIF"GHIBODJWJM XBSȝȜȡ /IX[QVQLMV\Q\a KPIX\MZ ɨF 3VTTJBO HPWFSONFOU IPXFWFS JHOPSFE 5BUBSTUBOT JOUFSOBUJPOBM QPUFOUJBM ɨFJTTVFPGJEFOUJUZIBTTQFDJBMJNQPSUBODFJOUIFBOBMZTJTPG5BUBSTUBOTJOUFSOBUJPOBM JODMVEJOHGPSFYBNQMFBOJOUFSFTUJOHBOEVOVTVBMBUUFNQUUPDPOWFOFBOJOUFSOBUJPOBM JOWPMWFNFOU TJODF DVMUVSBM GBDUPST o JO DPOKVODUJPO XJUI JOUFSFTUT BOE JOTUJUVUJPOT GPSVNUPEJTDVTTFUIOPQPMJUJDBMDPOnJDUTJOQPTU4PWJFUSFQVCMJDTɨJTJEFBXBTJNQMF oBSFBQPXFSSFTPVSDFGPSHSPVQDSFBUJPO QPMJUJDBMNPCJMJ[BUJPO BOETFUUJOHQPMJUJDBM NFOUFEJOUIFGPSNPGUIFi)BHVF*OJUJBUJWFwUPCSJOHUPHFUIFSMFBEFSTGSPN5BUBSTUBO BHFOEBTȝȜȣ*O"SCBLIBO.BHPNFEPWTEFTDSJQUJPO SFHJPOBMFMJUFTJO5BUBSTUBOTIPVME (FPSHJB .PMEPWB BOE6LSBJOF BTXFMMBTBHSPVQPGFNJOFOUJOUFSOBUJPOBMFYQFSUTJO CF USFBUFE OPU POMZ BT QPMJDZNBLFST CVU BMTP BT HFOFSBUPST BOE DPNNVOJDBUPST PG DPOnJDUSFTPMVUJPOȝȜȢ QPMJUJDBMJEFBT*OUSZJOHUPmOEUIFEFFQNFBOJOHTVOEFSMZJOHSFHJPOBMQPMJUJDBMEJT DPVSTFTJOUIFNBSLFUQMBDFPGJEFBT POFIBTUPSFGFSUPUIFDVMUVSBMBOEDJWJMGPVOEB UJPOTPGSFHJPOBMJEFOUJUZQPMJDJFTȝȜȤ 1LMV\Q\a\PZW]OP\PMXZQ[UWNOTWJITQbI\QWV &UIOJDBOESFMJHJPVTJEFOUJUJFTNJHIUQSPWJEFBGPDVTGPSUIFBċMJBUJPOBOEBMMFHJBODFPG QFPQMF BOEHJWFUIFNBTUSPOHFSTFOTFPGCFMPOHJOHUPBTQFDJmDDVMUVSBMBOEUFSSJUP SJBMFOWJSPONFOUȝȜȥ*UJTXJEFMZQSFTVNFEUIBUDVMUVSFBOEJEFOUJUZBSFWBSJFE nFYJCMF BOEnVJEɨFDBTFPG5BUBSTUBOEFNPOTUSBUFTUIBUJEFOUJUJFTDBOCFSFDPOTUSVDUFEBT TPDJBMBOEQPMJUJDBMPQQPSUVOJUJFTDIBOHF5BUBSTUBORVJUFTVDDFTTGVMMZBTTFSUFEJUTDVM UVSBMTQFDJmDJUZBOEBVUPOPNZ*OGBDU JUJTPOFPGUIFGFX3VTTJBOSFHJPOTUIBUIBTB DPOTJTUFOUBOEDPIFSFOUWJTJPOPGJUTJEFOUJUZ BTEJTUJODUGSPNUIBUPG3VTTJBɨFDPO TUSVDUJPOBOENBJOUFOBODFPG5BUBSTUBOTJEFOUJUZJT UPBTJHOJmDBOUFYUFOU GVFMFECZ #VMBUPW 3BTIJE i(VNBOJUBSOBJB EFJBUFMOPTU 3FTQVCMJLJ 5BUBSTUBO W 4FWFSP,BWLB[TLPN SFHJPOFw )VNBOJUBSJBO "DUJWJUJFT PG 5BUBSTUBO JO UIF /PSUIFSO $BVDBTVT 1BOPSBNB 'PSVN 1FUSP /JDPMBJBOE-BXSFODF3PCFSUTPOi*TTVFTPG$VMUVSFBOE*EFOUJUZA$VMUVSBM&OUSFQSFOFVS TVNNFS QQo TIJQJO3VTTJBT3FHJPOTw"WBJMBCMFBUIUUQDMJNBUFHFPSBSJ[POBFEV_XFCSSXHDVMUVSFIUNM 5BUBSTUBOHPWFSONFOUXFCTJUF BUIUUQXXXUBUBSSVIUNM .BHPNFEPW "SCBLIBO i3FHJPOBM *EFPMPHJFT JO UIF $POUFYU PG *OUFSOBUJPOBM 3FMBUJPOTw /JLSBWFTI 0QDJU Q 1BQFSQSFTFOUFEBUUIF$POGFSFODFPOi3VTTJBO3FHJPOTJO*OUFSOBUJPOBM4FDVSJUZ&OWJSPONFOUw .F[IEVOBSPEOZJ PQZU VSFHVMJSPWBOJB FUOPQPMJUJDIFTLJLI LPOnJLUPW *OUFSOBUJPOBM &YQFSJFODF PG ;VSJDI$FOUFSGPS4FDVSJUZ4UVEJFTBOE$POnJDU3FTFBSDI o+VMZ 3FTPMWJOH&UIOP1PMJUJDBM$POnJDUT ,B[BO ,BTTJBOPWB "MMBi*EFOUJUZJO*OUFSOBUJPOBM3FMBUJPOTw"WBJMBCMFBUIUUQXXXJSPOMJOFPSH );5ISIZaKPM^IVL>6>IT]M^ -`\MZVIT:MTI\QWV[WN UIFWFSZTUSPOHBOEJOnVFOUJBMJOUFMMFDUVBMFMJUFJOUIBUSFQVCMJD FTQFDJBMMZXIFODPN ɨFGPSUIDPNJOHMBUJOJ[BUJPOPGUIF5BUBSBMQIBCFU XIJDIIBTIBEBUSBOTJUJPO QBSFEUPPUIFSSFQVCMJDTȝȝȜ*UJTUIFJOUFMMFDUVBMT FH TDIPMBST KPVSOBMJTUT BOEXSJUFST QFSJPEPGZFBST JTJOUFSQSFUFEJO.PTDPXBTBOPUIFSFĊPSUCZ5BUBSTUBOUPMFBWF XIPHFOFSBUFJEFBTBOEDJSDVMBUFUIFNBNPOHUIFUPQQPMJDZNBLFST UIF3VTTJBODVMUVSBMTQIFSFBOENPWFDMPTFSUPUIF&VSP"UMBOUJDDJWJMJ[BUJPO7BMFSJJ 5JTILPW EJSFDUPSPGUIF*OTUJUVUFPG&UIOPMPHZBOE"OUISPQPMPHZ 3VTTJBO"DBEFNZ 4FFNJOHMZ XFmOEBQFDVMJBSNJYPGNZUIT TZNCPMT TMPHBOT BOESJUVBMT XIJDI PG4DJFODFT GPSFDBTUTUIBUUIFTIJGUUP-BUJOMFUUFSTXJMMQSPWPLFTPDJBMBOEQPMJUJDBM BSFPGUFOJSSBUJPOBM oTPNFUJNFTVOEFSUIFHVJTFPGiSFHJPOBMJEFPMPHJFT wiEPDUSJOFT w BMJFOBUJPOJOUIFSFHJPOBMTPDJFUZ XJEFODVMUVSBMHBQT BOETIBSQFOUIFMBUFOUTPDJFUBM PSiNPEFMTwoUIBUBSFCPSOFJUIFSBTUIFJOTUSVNFOUPGBSFHJPOTTFMGBTTFSUJPOWJTË DPOnJDUTȝȝȢ WJTUIFGFEFSBMDFOUFS PSBTBSFBDUJPOUPBQSFTVNFEMPTTPGFUIOJDPSSFMJHJPVTEJT UJODUJWFOFTTJOUIFFSBPGHMPCBMJ[BUJPO*OBHMPCBMJ[JOHXPSME 5BUBSTUBOJTDPODFSOFE BCPVUQSFTFSWJOHJUTFUIOJDJEFOUJUZ XSBQQFEJOSFMJHJPVTDPMPSTȝȝȝɨBUJTXIZTPNF 0Q[\WZaI[LQ[KW]Z[M TFFNJOHMZUFDIOJDBMJTTVFToTVDIBTUIFJOUSPEVDUJPOPGOFX3VTTJBOQBTTQPSUTXJUI OPNFOUJPOPGiOBUJPOBMJUZwPGUIFIPMEFSoQSPWPLFIBSTISFBDUJPOTJOUIJTSFHJPO 5BUBSTUBOTJEFOUJUZQPMJDZJTWFSZNVDIDFOUFSFEBSPVOETZNCPMJDBMMZDPOTUSVDUJOHBOE ɨF5BUBSTUBOJ4UBUF$PVODJMPSEFSFEUIBUOFXQBTTQPSUTOPUNFOUJPOJOHUIFCFBSFST SFJOWFOUJOH UIF IJTUPSJDBM QFDVMJBSJUJFT BOE TQFDJmD NFOUBMJUZ PG5BUBSTUBO1SPGFTTPS OBUJPOBMJUZTIPVMEOPUCFJTTVFE BOETUBUFEUIBUJUGFMUBHHSJFWFEUIBUUIFZXFSFQSJOUFE .JLIBJM (VCPHMP EFQVUZ EJSFDUPS PG UIF *OTUJUVUF PG &UIOPMPHZ BOE "OUISPQPMPHZ POMZJO3VTTJBOɨF5BUBSTUBOJFMJUFGFMUUIBUUIFTFPNJTTJPOTSPCCFE5BUBSTUBOPGJUT 3VTTJBO"DBEFNZPG4DJFODFT DPOTJEFSTUIBU5BUBSTUBOJJEFOUJUZQPMJDZBTDSJCFTFUIOJD TUBUVTBTBOFUIOJDSFQVCMJDXJUIUXPPċDJBMMBOHVBHFTȝȝȞ5PBDFSUBJOFYUFOU UIJT NFBOJOHTUPQPMJUJDBMFWFOUTBOEQIFOPNFOB BOEJNQPTFTFUIOJDBMMZPWFSMPBEFENBSL SFBDUJPOTIPXFEUIBUGPS5BUBSTUBOBOFUIOJDJEFOUJUZJTBTPSUPGiDPMMFDUJWFUIFSBQZGPS FSTPOUIFSFHJPOBMTPDJFUZȝȝȣ TPDJBMUSBVNBPG4PWJFUUPUBMJUBSJBOJTNwȝȝȟ )JTUPSJDBM BSHVNFOUT BSF PG USFNFOEPVT JNQPSUBODF JO5BUBSTUBOT TUSVHHMF GPS ɨFEFDJTJPOUPTXJUDIGSPNUIF$ZSJMMJDUPUIF-BUJOBMQIBCFUXBTPOFPGUIFNPTU BVUPOPNZBOETFMGSVMFɨFNBKPSJUZPGMPDBMIJTUPSJBOTUFOEUPUSFBU5BUBSTUBOTIJT UFMMJOHFYBNQMFTPG5BUBSTUBOTQPMJDZUPXBSETJEFOUJUZJOUIFFSBPGHMPCBMJ[BUJPOɨF UPSZBTCFJOHPQQPTFEUP3VTTJBOIJTUPSZ*UJTXJEFMZBTTVNFEUIBUUIF5BUBSTUSBEJUJPO JEFBXBTBSUJDVMBUFEJOUIF8PSME$POHSFTTPG5BUBSTDPOWFOFEJO*OUIFWJFX PG TUBUFIPPE JT BT SJDI BT UIPTF PG (FPSHJB 6LSBJOF "[FSCBJKBO BOE PUIFS OFXMZ PG5BUBSTUBOJFMJUF UIFUSBOTJUJPOUPUIF-BUJOBMQIBCFUXBTNPEFMFEBGUFSUIFFYQFSJ JOEFQFOEFOUTUBUFT,IBLJNBTTVNFTUIBUUIFMFHBDZPG3VTTJBOTUBUFIPPEPVHIUUP FODFPG5VSLFZ "[FSCBJKBO 5VSLNFOJTUBO 6[CFLJTUBO ,B[BLITUBO BOE,ZSHZ[TUBOȝȝȠ CFEFSJWFEGSPNUIFUJNFTPGUIF(PMEFO)PSEFXIPTFTVDDFTTPSXBT.VTDPWJUF3VT ɨFNBJOBSHVNFOUPGUIFQSPQPOFOUTPG-BUJOMFUUFSJOHJTUIBUUIFVTFPGUIF$ZSJMMJD TJB)FBSHVFTUIBUUIF.POHPMTZTUFNXBTBOBEWBOUBHFGPS3VTTJBOTUBUFTTJODFUIFZ BMQIBCFUJTMFTTDPOWFOJFOUJOHMPCBMJOGPSNBUJPOOFUXPSLT)PXFWFS UIFTVQQPSUFSTPG SFDFJWFEQPMJUJDBMBOENJMJUBSZQSPUFDUJPOWJTËWJTUIF8FTUȝȝȤ*OEVT5BHJSPWBTTFTTFT UIF$ZSJMMJDBMQIBCFUDMBJNUIBUJUTVTFXJMMIFMQ5BUBSTUBOUPCFDPNFPOFPGUIFMFBEFST UIBU UIF UBYBUJPO QSBDUJDFE CZ UIF (PMEFO )PSEF JT NJOJTDVMF JO DPNQBSJTPO JOJOGPSNBUJPOUFDIOPMPHJFTGPSUIFDPNNVOJUZPG5VSLJTIOBUJPOTȝȝȡ$PNQVUFSQSP UPXIBUUIFGFEFSBMDFOUFSUBLFTGSPNUIFSFHJPOTOPXBEBZT.PSFPWFS UIF3VTTJBO HSBNTUIBUUSBOTGPSN$ZSJMMJDUFYUJOUP-BUJOUFYUIBWFBMSFBEZCFFODSFBUFEJO,B[BO 0SUIPEPY$IVSDIVOEFS(PMEFO)PSEFEPNJOBUJPOXBTUIFPOMZTPDJBMJOTUJUVUJPO UIBUFOKPZFENFBOJOHGVMQSJWJMFHFT JODMVEJOHmOBODJBMPOFTȝȝȥ *UJTRVJUFTZNQUPNBUJDUIBU5BUBSTUBOUSJFEUPQFSTVBEFUIFGFEFSBMBVUIPSJUJFTUP DBODFMUIFPċDJBMDFMFCSBUJPOPGUIFBOOJWFSTBSZPGUIFGBNPVT,VMJLPWP1PMFCBUUMF JO XIJDIUIF3VTTJBOQSJODF%NJUSJJ%POTLPJIBEEFGFBUFEUIFBSNZPG.BNBJ XIJDI NBSLFE UIF CFHJOOJOH PG 3VTTJBT MJCFSBUJPO GSPN UIF5BUBS.POHPM ZPLF5XPMFU UFSToPOFGSPN4IBJNJFWBOEBOPUIFSPOFGSPNUIF7BUBOQBSUZoXFSFBEESFTTFEUP %SPCJ[IFWB -FPLBEJBi$PNQBSJTPOPG&MJUF(SPVQTJO5BUBSTUBO 4BLIB .BHBEBOBOE0SFOCVSHw 1PTU4PWJFU"ą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i5WPZB NPZB OF QPOJNBZw * %POU 6OEFSTUBOE :PV ,PNTPNPMTLBJB FLHNFUPESVQVCJOPFHVCQSOIUNM QSBWEB 0DUPCFS Q ,IBLJN 3BGBFM i*TUPSJB UBUBS J 5BUBSTUBOBw ɨF )JTUPSZ PG 5BUBST BOE 5BUBSTUBO 1BOPSBNB ,IBTBOPWB (VMOBSB i-BUJOTLJJ BMGBWJU o UBUBSBNw -BUJO "MQIBCFU GPS5BUBST /( o 0TPCBJB 'PSVN OP TQFDJBMJTTVF QBQLB OP 'FCSVBSZ Q /F[BWJTJNBJBHB[FUBXFCTJUF BUIUUQOHSVQSJOUFETQFDmMF@QFPQMFIUNM );5ISIZaKPM^IVL>6>IT]M^ -`\MZVIT:MTI\QWV[WN IJTUPSJDBMFWFOUNJHIUPĊFOEUIFGFFMJOHTPGUIFCVMLPGTPMEJFSTBOEPċDFSTPG5BUBS ɨFDPSFEJĊFSFODFTCFUXFFOUIFUXPBQQSPBDIFTBSFJMMVTUSBUFEJO5BCMF PSJHJOȝȞȜ 5BCMFi&VSPJTMBNwBOE&VSBTJBOJTNDPNQBSFE :FUUIJTJTPOMZQBSUPGUIFTUPSZɨFTFDPOEHSPVQPGJOEJHFOPVTIJTUPSJBOTSFJO UFSQSFUUIFIJTUPSZPG5BUBSTBOE3VTTJBOTJOCBTJDBMMZNVUVBMMZDPNQMJNFOUBSZUFSNT &VSBTJBOJTN i&VSPJTMBNw BWPJEJOHDPVOUFSQPTJUJPOJOHUIFUXPQFPQMFT5BUBSTBSFUSFBUFEBTBOPSHBOJD JOUFHSBM 3VTTJBJTPWFSXIFMNJOHMZBO0SUIPEPYOBUJPO 5BUBSTUBOJTBQBSUPGUIFOPO0SUIPEPYXPSME QBSUPGUIF3VTTJBOOBUJPO$FSUBJOUJNFToTVDIBTEVSJOHUIFSFJHOPG,BUIFSJOF** ɨFSFJTOPDJWJMVOJGPSNJUZJO3VTTJB UIF3VT ɨF3VTTJBODJWJMJ[BUJPOJODBSOBUFTBTJOHMF JOEJ XIPBMMPXFENPTRVFTUPCFCVJMU BOEUIFmSTUZFBSTPGUIF4PWJFUSFHJNF XIFSFUIF TJBOTUBUFJTBCMFUPVOJUFEJĊFSFOUQFPQMFPOMZ WJTJCMFEFTUJOZGPSBMMQFPQMFTPGUIFDPVOUSZ 5BUBSTBVUPOPNZmSTUBQQFBSFEBOEOFXPQQPSUVOJUJFTGPSDVMUVSBMSFWJWBMXFSFPQFOFE CZGPSDF oBSFQSBJTFEJO5BUBSTUBONPSFUIBOPUIFST TVDIBTUIFTFJ[VSFPG,B[BOCZ*WBOUIF &VSPQF EPFT OPU SFQSFTFOU BOZ NFOBDF UP )JTUPSJDBMMZ&VSPQFXBTBUISFBUUP3VTTJB 5FSSJCMF CVUFWFOUIFIBSEUJNFTJOUIFIJTUPSZBSFVTVBMMZSFGFSSFEUPJOBSBUIFSDPO 5BUBSTUBO DJMJBUPSZXBZ $PMMFDUJWJUZ BOE DPNNVOJUBSJBO TPMJEBSJUZ BSF *OEJWJEVBMJTN BOE FOUSFQSFOFVSTIJQ XPVME EPNJOBOUGBDUPSTJO3VTTJBOTPDJFUZ PQFOVQ5BUBSTUBOUPUIFXPSME 1[TIUZMLQ[KW^MZML 3VTTJB JT PWFSNJMJUBSJ[FE BOE QSPOF UP TPMWF .JMJUBSZGPSDFJTBQSFSFRVJTJUFGPSOBUJPOBMQSJEF DPOnJDUTCZGPSDF XIJDINJHIUUVSOJOUPDBUBT BOEHMPSZ 5BUBSTUBOXBTUIFOPSUIFSOPVUQPTUPG*TMBNGSPNoNPSFUIBOIBMGBDFOUVSZFBS USPQIF MJLFUIBUPOFJO$IFDIOZB MJFSUIBO3VTTJBBDDFQUFE0SUIPEPY$ISJTUJBOJUZ0WFSUIFDFOUVSJFT5BUBSTUBOJ*TMBN 3FHJPOTQFDJmD BQQSPBDIFT BOE UIF TVSWJWBM PG FWPMWFEJOUPi&VSPJTMBNw BMTPSFGFSSFEUPBTi+BEJEJTNw BSFMJHJPVTJEFPMPHZBEBQUBCMF 8JTIFTUPBTTJNJMBUFOPO3VTTJBOFUIOJDHSPVQT UPNPEFSOJ[BUJPOBOEFDPOPNJDJOOPWBUJPOTɨF5VSLJTITFDVMBSJ[FENPEFMJTQSPCB 5BUBSFUIOJDJUZBSFJNQPSUBOU CMZUIFCFTUSFQSFTFOUBUJWFPGUIF&VSPJTMBNQPMJUJDBMJEFBM&VSPJTMBNJTPOFPGUIFNPTU 3VTTJB IBT UP SFDPHOJ[F UIF JOEFQFOEFODF PG iɨF3VTTJBOXPSMEwFNCFETBMMDPVOUSJFTPGUIF JUTGPSNFSTBUFMMJUFTBOEMFUUIFNMJWFUIFJSPXO JOnVFOUJBMoCPUIQPMJUJDBMMZBOEJOUFMMFDUVBMMZoTDIPPMPGUIPVHIUJO5BUBSTUBO XIPTF GPSNFS4PWJFU6OJPO JNQPSUBODFNJHIUCFDPNQBSFEXJUI&VSBTJBOJTNJO3VTTJB XIJDIJTPOUIFSJTF MJWFT 3VTTJBT EFDFOUSBMJ[BUJPO XPVME IFMQ UP TPMWF 3VTTJBDBOCFBTUSPOHDPVOUSZPOMZPOUIFCBTJT &VSPJTMBNBUUFNQUFEUPJOUFHSBUFoBTEPFT&VSBTJBOJEFPMPHZJO3VTTJBoUIF UIFNPTUBDVUFJTTVFT TVDIBTDSJNFBOECPSEFS PGDFOUSBMJ[BUJPO BEIFSFODFUPUIF"TJBOIJTUPSJDBMMFHBDZXJUIBDDFQUBODFPGNPEFSO&VSPQFBOUIJOLJOH TFDVSJUZ ZFUJUDIBMMFOHFTCBTJDBTTVNQUJPOTPG&VSBTJBOJTNJONBOZXBZT.BOZJO5BUBSTUBO UIJOLUIBUUIF&VSBTJBONPEFMXBTGPSNFEVOEFSBTUSPOHJOnVFODFPG0SUIPEPYSFMJ HJPOBOEIFODFMFBWFTOPTQBDFGPSBDIBSBDUFSJTUJD5BUBSTUBOJJEFOUJUZ0SUIPEPYDVM -PDBMBDUJWJTUTGPSB5BUBSSFWJWBMUSBEJUJPOBMMZWJFX*TMBNBTBNFBOTPGLFFQJOHUIF UVSF BT JOUFSQSFUFE JO 5BUBSTUBO JT BOUJEFNPDSBUJD JMMJCFSBM BOE JNQSBDUJDBM BOE DVMUVSBMBVUPOPNZPGMPDBMSFTJEFOUTTVQQSFTTFECZ3VTTJBOT"UUIFTBNFUJNF UIBOLT IFODF VOBCMF UP NFFU UIF DIBMMFOHFT PG NPEFSOJUZ BOE UIFSFGPSF JT VOTVJUBCMF GPS UP*TMBN 5BUBSTBSFBCMFUPFYQFDUEFFQFSQBSUJDJQBUJPOBOEJOWPMWFNFOUJOUIFXPSME 5BUBSTUBOȝȞȝ3VTTJB BDDPSEJOHUPUIFTFWJFXT JTVOBCMFUPFċDJFOUMZQMBZUIFSPMFPGB DPNNVOJUZPGOBUJPOTɨJTJTXIZ&VSPJTMBNJTWFSZTVQQPSUJWFPGJOUFOTJWFDPOUBDUT CSJEHFCFUXFFO&VSPQFBOE"TJBCFJOHEPNJOBUFECZ0SUIPEPYZJUJTPQQPTFECZUIF CFUXFFOSFMJHJPVTHSPVQTPG5BUBSTUBOBOEUIF8FTU &BTU BOECFJOHPTUFOTJCMZJMMJCFSBMJUJTBMTPOPUXFMDPNFJOUIF8FTUȝȞȞ*OUSZJOHUP 4IBJNJFW FOEFBWPST UP VOJUF BMM .VTMJNT JO5BUBSTUBO BOE FWFOUVBMMZ UP UVSO SFCVĊUIFWJTJPOPG3VTTJBBTUIF0SUIPEPYOBUJPOCVJMUVQFYDMVTJWFMZCZBOFUIOJDBMMZ ,B[BO JOUP 3VTTJBT *TMBNJD DBQJUBMȝȞȠ ɨJT DPODFQU JT CBTFE VQPO UIF EVCJPVT QSF 3VTTJBOQPQVMBUJPO 4IBJNJFWTJEFEXJUIUIFIFBETPGUXPPUIFSSFQVCMJDTo.VSUB[B TVNQUJPOPGUIFJOUFSOBMDPIFSFODFPGUIF5BUBSFUIOJDDPNNVOJUZ BOEJUTBCJMJUZUPBDU 3BLIJNPWPG#BTILPSUPTUBOBOE.JLIBJM/JLPMBFWPG:BLVUJBoUPJTTVFJOBKPJOU BTBTJOHMFQPMJUJDBMBDUPS)PXFWFS UIJTBNCJUJPVTTUSBUFHZFODPVOUFSTDSJUJDBMPCTUBDMFT PQFOMFUUFSUP:FMUTJO EFNBOEJOHNPSFSJHIUTGPSFUIOJDSFHJPOTȝȞȟ UIBUTUFNGSPNUIFNVMUJDPOGFTTJPOBMOBUVSFPG5BUBSTUBOJTPDJPQPMJUJDBMTQBDF )UUQXXXHB[FUBSVQSJOUUBUBSZUSFCVVTIUNM .BHPNFEPW "SCBLIBO .JTUFSJB SFHJPOBMJ[NB .ZTUFSZ PG 3FHJPOBMJTN .PTDPX .0/' 4DIPMBSMZ1BQFST OP ,IBLJN 3BGBFMi3PTTJBJ5BUBSTUBOVJTUPSJDIFTLPHPQFSFLSJPTULBw 3VTTJBBOE5BUBSTUBOBUUIF 4BGSPOPW 4FSHFJ i*TMBN QPJTLJ PSHBOJ[BUTJPOOZLI GPSN J NFTUB W QPMJUJDIFTLPJ [IJ[OJw )JTUPSJDBM$SPTTSPBET 1BOPSBNB'PSVN TQSJOH OP Q *TMBNJO4FBSDIPG0SHBOJ[BUJPOBM'PSNTBOE*UT1MBDFJO1PMJUJDBM-JGF *O3VTTJBO3FHJPOTJO i'VUVSF PG 'FEFSBMJTN JO 3VTTJBw SFTFBSDI QSPKFDU XFC TJUF BU IUUQGFEFSBMJTNTPSPTLTVSV "O"OOVBM4VQQMFNFOUUP3VTTJBT1PMJUJDBM"MNBOBD$BSOFHJF&OEPXNFOUGPS*OUFSOBUJPOBM1FBDF DPOGFSFODFTFNJOBSESPCJ[IFWBIUN Q );5ISIZaKPM^IVL>6>IT]M^ -`\MZVIT:MTI\QWV[WN 'JSTUPGBMM UIF5BUBSTUBOJSFMJHJPVTFMJUFJTWFSZGSBHNFOUFEBOEMBDLTDPIFTJPOȝȞȡ 5PHFUIFS UIFTF GBDUT PĊFS B QMBVTJCMF FYQMBOBUJPO BT UP XIZ UIF 5BUBSTUBOJ JUJTEJWJEFEBNPOHBEIFSFOUTPGEJĊFSFOUWFSTJPOTPG*TMBN FH 5VSLJTI *SBOJBO BOE FMJUF IBE PQUFE GPS B SFMBUJWFMZ MJCFSBM BOE DJWJMJ[FE GPSN PG OBUJPOBMJTN5BUBSTUBOJ 4BVEJ"SBCJBO $PNQFUJUJPOBOEUFOTJPOTCFUXFFOEJĊFSFOU*TMBNJDHSPVQTBSFOPU BVUIPSJUJFTBSFOPUFBHFSUPPQFOUIFEPPSTUPSBEJDBMJTN BTPDDVSSFEJO$IFDIOZBȝȟȟ SBSF&YQFSUTUFTUJGZUIBUUIFBMVNOJPGGPSFJHO*TMBNJDJOTUJUVUJPOT JODMVEJOHFUIOJD 4IBJNJFWTJOUFOUJPOBMQPMJDZJTUPNBSHJOBMJ[FoJOPOFXBZPSBOPUIFSoFYUSFNJTU 5BUBST UIBU DPNF UP5BUBSTUBOGPS NJTTJPOBSZ BDUJWJUJFT BSF QPMJUJDBMMZ JOEPDUSJOBUFE SFMJHJPVTHSPVQT0OOVNFSPVTPDDBTJPOTPċDJBMTJO,B[BOIBWFFYQMJDJUMZTUBUFEUIBU XJUIBOUJ3VTTJBOGFFMJOHT BOECFDBVTFPGUIJTGBDFPQQPTJUJPOGSPNMPDBM.VTMJNTȝȞȢ UIFSFJTOPSPPNGPSWBIIBCJTNJO5BUBSTUBOȝȟȠ0OFPGUIFTUSPOHFTUBSHVNFOUTBHBJOTU QBO*TMBNJTNJTUIBUJUSFKFDUTUIFFUIOJDBOEDVMUVSBMTQFDJmDJUZPGFBDIJOEJWJEVBMFUI 4FDPOEMZ PGBMM5BUBSTSFTJEFPVUTJEF5BUBSTUBO BDSPTT3VTTJBBOEUIF$*4 OJDHSPVQ DPVOUSJFT BT XFMM BT JO5VSLFZ $IJOB 1PMBOE 'JOMBOE UIF 64 "GHIBOJTUBO $BO BEB BOE "VTUSBMJB +PIO $PBLMFZ DIBSBDUFSJ[FT5BUBSTBT UIF MPDBMMZ XFBL UFSSJUPSJ 5BUBSTUBOTTFBSDIGPSBOJEFOUJUZCFHTBOPUIFSJNQPSUBOURVFTUJPOoUIFFYUFOU BMMZEJTQFSTFEHSPVQȝȞȣ.PSFPWFS UIFZDPOTUJUVUFPOMZPGUIFQPQVMBUJPOJO UPXIJDIFUIOJDOBUJPOBMJTNJTDPNQBUJCMFXJUIUIFMJCFSBMWBMVFT*UJTTUJMMVOEFSEJT 5BUBSTUBO DVTTJPOXIFUIFS5BUBSTUBOJTIFBEJOHGPSUIFFTUBCMJTINFOUPGBDJWJMPSFUIOJDOBUJPOBM JEFOUJUZȝȟȡ6QUPOPX SFMJHJPVTJTTVFTJO5BUBSTUBOSFQSFTFOUFEEFFQDMFBWBHFTCFUXFFO .PSFPWFS 5BUBSToBTTIPXOJO4VTBO(PPESJDI-FINBOOTTUVEZoBMPOHXJUI UIF3VTTJBOTBOE5BUBSTɨFSFBSFTPNFTPDJPMPHJDBMHSPVOETGPSFYQFDUJOHUIBUUIF #BTILJSTEJTQMBZUIFMPXFTUMFWFMPGCPUISFMJHJPVTCFMJFGBOEQSBDUJDFBNPOHBMM3VTTJBO DPODFQUPGBDJWJMJEFOUJUZXJMMQSFWBJMJOUIFMPOHSVO TVDIBTUIFQTZDIPMPHJDBMQSPY .VTMJNTȝȞȤ3BmL.VLIBNFUTIJO EFQVUZEJSFDUPSPGUIF5BUBS&ODZDMPQFEJB*OTUJUVUF JNJUZPGUIF3VTTJBOTBOEUIF5BUBST BOEJOUFSFUIOJDMPZBMUZȝȟȢ BENJUTUIBUiUIFSFUVSOPG*TMBNJDWBMVFTUP5BUBSTUBOJTPDJFUZJTOFJUIFSTUFBEZOPSTUB CMFwȝȞȥ4IBJNJFWIJNTFMGBENJUTUIBUIFJTOPUB.VTMJN ȝȟȜBOE'BSJE.VLIBNFUTIJO IBEKVTUSFDFOUMZTUBSUFEMFBSOJOH5BUBSMBOHVBHFȝȟȝ ɨJSEMZ UIFSFJTBXJEFTQSFBEGFFMJOHBNPOH5BUBSTUBOJQPMJUJDBMBOEJOUFMMFDUVBM FMJUFTUIBUBOFYDFTTJWFJOnVFODFPGSFMJHJPVTJOTUJUVUJPOTNJHIUFOEBOHFSUIFJOUFSOBM TUBCJMJUZBOEUIFESJWFGPSNPEFSOJ[BUJPOȝȟȞɨFHPWFSONFOUJTOPUBNPOHUIFNPTU MBWJTITQPOTPSTPGSFTUPSJOHNPTRVFToUIFGVOETGPSUIJTQVSQPTFCBTJDBMMZDPNFGSPN BCSPBE 'PVSUIMZ MJWJOH GPS DFOUVSJFT XJUI UIF DMPTFTU UJFT UP 3VTTJB NBLFT5BUBSTUBOJ *TMBNBEKVTUFEUP3VTTJBODVMUVSFBOEOBUJPOIPPE*OGBDU 5BUBSTUBOJ*TMBNJTBiCPSEFS QIFOPNFOPOwJOUIFTFOTFUIBUJUVOGPMETBUUIFFEHFTPGUXPDJWJMJ[BUJPOT0SUIPEPY BOE*TMBNJD $BSOFHJF&OEPXNFOUXFCTJUF BUIUUQQVCTDBSOFHJFSVCPPLTOQBTQ i*TMBNTLJJGBLUPSw *TMBNJD'BDUPS 7NFTUF OP Q $PBLMFZ +PIO FEDzF5FSSJUPSJBM.BOBHFNFOUPG&UIOJD$POnJDU-POEPO'SBOL$BTT Q (PPESJDI-FINBOO 4VTBOi*TMBNBOE&UIOJDJUZJOUIF3FQVCMJDTPG3VTTJBw1PTU4PWJFU"ąBJST WPM OP Q .VLIBNFUTIJO 3BmL i*TMBN W PCTIDIFTUWFOOPQPMJUJDIFTLPJ [IJ[OJ 5BUBSTUBOBw *TMBN 4IBSBGVUEJOPWB (VMOB[i$IFDIOZB7FSTVT5BUBSTUBO6OEFSTUBOEJOH&UIOPQPMJUJDTJO1PTU$PN JO 4PDJBM BOE 1PMJUJDBM -JGF PG 5BUBSTUBO *O &UOJDIOPTU J LPOGFTTJPOBMOBJB USBEJUTJB W 7PMHP NVOJTU3VTTJBw1SPCMFNTPG1PTU$PNNVOJTN WPM OP Qo 6SBMTLPNSFHJPOF3PTTJJ &UIOJDJUZBOE$POGFTTJPOBM5SBEJUJPOJO7PMHBBOE6SBMT3FHJPOPG3VTTJB 4PDJP&DPOPNJD #BDLHSPVOE PG &UIOP1PMJUJDBM 1SPDFTTFT JO UIF 3VTTJBO 'FEFSBUJPO .PTDPX.PTDPX$BSOFHJF$FOUFS Q $POnJDU%JBMPHVF$PPQFSBUJPO.PTDPX*OUFSOBUJPOBM$FOUFSGPS4USBUFHJDBOE1PMJUJDBM4UVEJFT /(o0TPCBJBQBQLB OP 'FCSVBSZ Q #VMMFUJO OP Q /F[BWJTJNBJB HB[FUB XFC TJUF BU IUUQXXXOHSVQSJOUFETQFDmMF@ $BSOFHJF&OEPXNFOUXFCTJUF BUIUUQQVCTDBSOFHJFSVCPPLTBNMEBTQ GFOPNFOIUNM i'VUVSF PG 'FEFSBMJTN JO 3VTTJBw SFTFBSDI QSPKFDU XFC TJUF BU IUUQGFEFSBMJTNTPSPTLTVSV %SV[ICBOBSPEPWKPVSOBMXFCTJUF BUIUUQNZJOGPBSUSVNBHB[JOFESV[ICBOWPSPOIUN DPOGFSFODFTFNJOBSNVTJOBIUN .WZMQOVMKWVWUQKZMTI\QWV[" KPIX\MZ I]\PWZQ\IZQIVMV\ZaQV\WKIXQ\ITQ[U' "GUFS IBWJOH BOBMZ[FE 5BUBSTUBOT JEFOUJUZ QPMJDJFT XIJDI IBWF CFFO IFBWJMZ CJBTFE UPXBSETTZNCPMJDJOUFSQSFUBUJPOT XFIBWFUPUVSOUPFDPOPNJDBTQFDUTPG5BUBSTUBOT TFBSDIGPSJUTQMBDFJOUIFXPSME ,BSVTI 4BSBIiɨF3PBE-FTT5SBWFMFEwDzF3VTTJB#VTJOFTT3FWJFX /PWFNCFS &YQFSU OP 0DUPCFS 5BUBSTUBOHPWFSONFOUXFCTJUF BUIUUQXXXUBUBSSVBQQFOEIUNM );5ISIZaKPM^IVL>6>IT]M^ -`\MZVIT:MTI\QWV[WN " MBX SFMBUFE UP JOWFTUNFOU BDUJWJUJFT JO5BUBSTUBODBNF JOUP GPSDF JO +BOVBSZ "QQSPYJNBUFMZPG5BUBSTUBOTFYQPSUTBSFSFMBUFEUPUIFPJMJOEVTUSZȝȠȝɨF "DDPSEJOHUPUIJT FOUFSQSJTFTSFDFJWFBUFNQPSBSZFYFNQUJPOGSPNUBYBUJPOPO SFHJPOTMFBEJOHPJMDPNQBOZ i5BUOFGU wXBTBNPOHUIFmSTU3VTTJBOmSNTUPTUBSUUSBE QSPmUEVSJOHUIFJSmSTUZFBSPGPQFSBUJPO.PSFPWFS QSPQFSUZJTMFWJFEXJUIPOMZ JOHJUTTIBSFTPOUIF/FX:PSL4UPDL&YDIBOHF*OUIFi'JOBODJBM5JNFTwNBS UBY"MBXPOUIFTUBUVTPGBQQSPWFEJOWFTUNFOUQSPKFDUTXJUIGPSFJHOJOWFTUPSQBSUJDJ LFUDBQJUBMJ[BUJPOSBUJOHPG&BTUFSO&VSPQFBODPNQBOJFT 5BGOFGUSFDFJWFEUIFIJHIFTU QBUJPO XIJDIDBNFJOUPGPSDFJO.BSDI FYUFOETUIFQFSJPEPGCFOFmUTGPSJOWFT SBUJOHBNPOHBMM7'%FOUFSQSJTFTȝȠȞ*O.BSDIUIFi'JUDIwJOUFSOBUJPOBMSBUJOH UPST4VDIQSPKFDUTSFDFJWFFYFNQUJPOTPOWBSJPVTUBYFTGPSoZFBST XJUIQPTTJCMF BHFODZSBJTFE5BUOFGUTSBUJOHGSPN$$UP# XIJDIJTJOEJDBUJWFPGUIFDPNQBOZTTUB TVCTFRVFOUQSPMPOHBUJPO"EFDSFFCZUIFQSFTJEFOUPG5BUBSTUBOPO0DUPCFS UP CJMJUZȝȠȟ5BUOFGUIBTBMTPSBUIFSBNCJUJPVTJOUFSOBUJPOBMQMBOT NBJOMZSFMBUFEUP*SBR FODPVSBHFGPSFJHOJOWFTUNFOUJOUP5BUBSTUBO HSBOUTBEEJUJPOBMUBYQSJWJMFHFTUPFOUFS ɨFDPOUSBDUTJHOFEBOBHSFFNFOUXJUI*SBRJBVUIPSJUJFT BOEBQQSPWFECZUIF6/JO QSJTFTXIFSFUIFQBSUJDJQBUJPOPGGPSFJHOJOWFTUPSTJTOPUMFTTUIBOFJUIFSPS64 TQSJOH UIBU TUJQVMBUFT EFMJWFSZ UP *SBR PG PJM QSPDFTTJOH FRVJQNFOU BOE KPJOU NJMMJPOɨF5BUBSTUBOJQBSMJBNFOUDSFBUFEUXPGSFFFDPOPNJD[POFTJO i"MBCVHBw FYQMPJUBUJPOPGPJMEFQPTJUTȝȠȠ4JNJMBSOFHPUJBUJPOTXJUI*SBO +PSEBO .POHPMJB -JCZB BOEi,BNTLJF1PMJBOZ wXJUIBMJGFUJNFPGZFBSTȝȠȜ BOE7JFUOBNBSFBMTPVOEFSXBZȝȠȡ 5BUBSTUBO JOUSPEVDFE B iMBOE DPEFw JO XIJDI QSPWJEFE GPSFJHOFST XJUI 0OFDBOOPUFYQFDUJOUFOTJWFDPOUBDUXJUIUIF*SBRJSFHJNFUPCFBQQMBVEFEJO BDDFTTUPUIFSFHJPOTMBOENBSLFU4BMFTUPGPSFJHOFST IPXFWFS XFSFSFTUSJDUFEUPQVS UIF8FTU FTQFDJBMMZTJODFPUIFSMPDBMFDPOPNJDBDUPSToUIFi,BN";wDBSNBOVGBD DIBTFTGSPNUIFTUBUF BOEUIFSFGPSFGPSFJHOFSTXFSFVOBCMFUPCVZMBOEIFMEJODPN UVSFS UIFi,B[BO)FMJDPQUFS'BDUPSZ wBOEUIFi/J[IOFLBNTLTIJOBwUJSFNBOVGBDUVSFS NPO CZ SVSBM SFTJEFOUT *O +BOVBSZ 4IBJNJFW CFDBNF UIF DIJFG QSPQPOFOU PG oBSFBMTPDPPQFSBUJOHXJUI#BHEBEȝȠȢ)PXFWFS XIBUJTJOUVOFXJUI8FTUFSOQPMJDJFT JOUSPEVDJOHUIFDPODFQUPGQSJWBUFQSPQFSUZPOMBOEUISPVHIPVU3VTTJB SFGFSSJOHUP JTUIFBTTPDJBUFESFEVDUJPOJOUIFJNQPSUBODFPGNJMJUBSZQSPEVDUJPO UPXIJDINBOZ UIFOFFEUPJNQSPWFUIFHFOFSBMJOWFTUNFOUDMJNBUF SFHJPOBMQPMJDZNBLFSTJO5BUBSTUBOBSFWFSZNVDIJOGBWPS*O(BMFFWTWJFX FYDFTTJWF NJMJUBSZCVJMEVQJNQFEFTFDPOPNJDSFTUSVDUVSJOHȝȠȣ 5BUBSTUBOJTPOFPGUIFSFHJPOTUIBUFTUBCMJTIFEXPSLJOHDPOUBDUTXJUIUIF'PS FJHO*OWFTUNFOU1SPNPUJPO$FOUFS '*1$ PG3VTTJBɨJTJOTUJUVUJPOXBTTFUVQJO VOEFSUIFBVTQJDFTPGUIF&DPOPNZ.JOJTUSZ BOEIBTFTUBCMJTIFEUIFOFUXPSL -KWVWUQKXZW\MK\QWVQ[UIVLQ\[KZQ\QK[ PGPċDFTBCSPBEɨF'*1$GBDJMJUBUFTUIFTIBQJOHPGSFMBUJPOTIJQTCFUXFFO3VTTJBO SFHJPOTBOEGPSFJHOJOWFTUPSTɨJTFOBCMFT5BUBSTUBOUPVUJMJ[FUIFTFSWJDFTPGUIF'*1$ "UmSTUHMBODF 5BUBSTUBOTFFNTUPCFPOFPGGFXJTMBOETPGSFMBUJWFTUBCJMJUZBOEQSPTQFS XIFOTFBSDIJOHGPSJOWFTUNFOUQSPKFDUQSPQPTBMT4JNVMUBOFPVTMZ MJLFNPTUPG3VTTJBT JUZJOUIFTFBPGBTIBLZ3VTTJBOFDPOPNZ:FU UIFi5BUBSTUBOJFDPOPNJDNJSBDMFwIBT SFHJPOT 5BUBSTUBOEFWFMPQTJUTPXOCVTJOFTTQSPNPUJPODFOUFSTɨVT UIF5BUBSTUBO TUJMMBMPOHXBZUPHP*OTQJUFPGTJHOJmDBOUQSJWJMFHFTGPSEFWFMPQJOHJUTPXOFYUFSOBM $FOUFSGPS*OWFTUNFOUT1SPNPUJPODPPSEJOBUFTUIFBDUJWJUJFTPGHPWFSONFOUBM mOBO SFMBUJPOT 5BUBSTUBOEFGBDUPJTGBSGSPNCFJOHDBMMFEBiHBUFSFHJPOwUPUIFJOUFSOBUJPOBM DJBM BOEOPOmOBODJBMJOTUJUVUJPOTJOUIFJOWFTUNFOUQSPDFTT BOEGBDJMJUBUFTUIFBEPQ FDPOPNZ UJPOBOESFBMJ[BUJPOPGJOWFTUNFOUQSPKFDUT &WFOJOUIFMBUFT PGBMMTBMFTUSBOTBDUJPOTJOUIFSFQVCMJDXFSFCBS "DDPSEJOHUPUIF$PNNJUUFFPO4UBUJTUJDTPG5BUBSTUBO UIFoQFSJPE UFSPQFSBUJPOT5BUBSTUBOIBTPOFPGUIFXPSTUSFDPSETGPSXBHFBOEQFOTJPOBSSFBSTJO XBTUIFNPTUTVDDFTTGVMJOBUUSBDUJOHGPSFJHOJOWFTUNFOU0OMZCZIBEUIFSFQVC UIFDPVOUSZɨF5BUBSTUBOJBVUIPSJUJFTJNQPTFEQSJDFDPOUSPMPOGPPEJO BOEJO MJD NBOBHFE UP TNPPUI PVU UIF OFHBUJWF DPOTFRVFODFT PG UIF "VHVTU mOBO /PWFNCFSPGUIBUZFBS5BUBSTUBOCFDBNFUIFmSTU3VTTJBOSFHJPOUPEFGBVMUPOJUTGPS DJBMDSBTIɨFJOnPXPGGPSFJHOJOWFTUNFOUTJOUIFmSTUIBMGPGUPUBMFE64 FJHOmOBODJBMPCMJHBUJPOTȝȠȤ NJMMJPO i3FTQVCMJLB 5BUBSTUBO HMB[BNJ [BSVCF[IOPHP JOWFTUPSBw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i, PTOPWBN SB[WJUJJB WOFTIOFFLPOPNJDIFTLJLI J WOFTIOFQPMJUJDIFTLJLI TWJB[FJ 5BUBSTUBOBw 0O UIF 'PVOEBUJPOT PG 'PSFJHO &DPOPNJD BOE 1PMJUJDBM 3FMBUJPOT PG 5BUBSTUBO 1BOPSBNB'PSVN OP Q 5BUBSTUBOHPWFSONFOUXFCTJUF BUIUUQXXXUBUBSSVBQQFOEIUNM 0SUUVOH 0QDJU QQo );5ISIZaKPM^IVL>6>IT]M^ -`\MZVIT:MTI\QWV[WN "DDPSEJOH UP (BMFFW POF PG UIF CBTJD DIBMMFOHFT GPS UIF 5BUBSTUBOJ FDPOPNZ ɨFSFBSFBMTPTFWFSBMFYBNQMFTPG5BUBSTUBOJFDPOPNJDQSPUFDUJPOJTN4IBJNJFW JT UIBU iBHSJDVMUVSF JT UIF VODPOEJUJPOBM QSJPSJUZ JO5BUBSTUBOwȝȠȥ :FU PUIFST UIJOL XBTPOFPGUIFNPTUBSEFOUPQQPOFOUTPGUIFiTIPDLUIFSBQZwBOEUIFMJCFSBMSFGPSNT UIBUUIFBHSBSJBOTFDUPSBTJUFYJTUTOPXBEBZTJTEPPNFEUPEJTBQQFBSȝȡȜ$SJUJDJTNJT FYFNQMJmFECZUIF(BJEBSGFEFSBMHPWFSONFOUEVSJOHo*O4IBJNJFWTXPSET BMTPCFJOHIFBSEJOPUIFSBSFBT7JLUPS.BMHVJO QSPGFTTPSPGUIF,B[BO*OTUJUVUFGPS iXFIBWFDIPTFOUIFTPGUFOUSZQBUIPOUPUIFNBSLFU wȝȡȣXIJDICSPVHIUQBMQBCMFSFTVMUT 'JOBODFTBOE&DPOPNZ EFTDSJCFTUIFFYQPSUTUSVDUVSFPG5BUBSTUBOBTJSSBUJPOBM TJODF GPSSFHJPOBMBVUIPSJUJFT1SJWBUJ[BUJPOEJEOPUBMMPXUIFNPTUWJBCMFJOEVTUSJFT FH 5BU JUJTEPNJOBUFECZDSVEFPJMTBMFT 5BUBSTUBOMBDLTJUTPXOSFmOFSJFT *OIJTBTTFTTNFOU OFGUBOE,BN"; UPGSFFUIFNTFMWFTPGUIFDPOUSPMPG5BUBSTUBOJBVUIPSJUJFT3FHJPOBM UXPUIJSETPG5BUBSTUBOTJOEVTUSZTIPVMECFFJUIFSDMPTFEPSSBEJDBMMZVQHSBEFEȝȡȝ'VS FMJUFTEFGFOEMPDBMFOUFSQSJTFTGSPNDPNQFUJUPSTJOPUIFSSFHJPOT BOEBQQMZBWBSJFUZPG UIFSNPSF TQFDJBMJTUTEPVCUXIFUIFSUIFEFGFOTFJOEVTUSZNJHIUCFDPOTJEFSFEBTUIF BENJOJTUSBUJWFNFBTVSFTUPPWFSTFFUIFBDUJWJUJFTPGFYQPSUPSJFOUFEFOUFSQSJTFT FOHJOF PG5BUBSTUBOJFDPOPNJD QSPHSFTT ȝȡȞ TJODF OPOF PG UIF SFHJPOT EFGFOTF FOUFS 4UBUFDPOUSPMJTFTQFDJBMMZUJHIUJOUIFPJMBOEHBTJOEVTUSZ'PSFYBNQMF BMMPJM QSJTFTJTMJDFOTFEUPTFMMBCSPBE FYQPSUTGSPN5BUBSTUBOHPUISPVHIUIFi4VWBSwDPNQBOZ XIJDIJTFNQPXFSFEUPDPO 3JOBT ,BTICSB[JFW B QSPGFTTPS BU UIF ,B[BO 4UBUF 6OJWFSTJUZ DMBJNT UIBU UIF EVDU B TJOHMF FDPOPNJD QPMJDZ JO GPSFJHO NBSLFUT ɨF HPWFSONFOU PG5BUBSTUBOJT JOWFTUNFOUQSPDFTTJO5BUBSTUBOJTJODSJTJT TJODFUIFCVMLPGFOUFSQSJTFTBSFFJUIFSFDP FNQPXFSFEUPDSFBUFUIFiSFQVCMJDTGVOEGPSPJMBOEHBTSFTFSWFTwȝȡȤ"DDPSEJOHUPUIF OPNJDBMMZXFBLPSJOTPMWFOUȝȡȟ*O UIJTSFHJPOSFDFJWFE64NJMMJPOJOGPS 1SFTJEFOUJBM%FDSFFPG.BSDI BMMPJMDPNQBOJFTSFHJTUFSFEJO5BUBSTUBOBSFTVQ FJHOJOWFTUNFOU CVUGPSFJHOEJSFDUJOWFTUNFOU '%* NBEFVQPOMZ64NJMMJPO QPTFEUPTFMMPGUIFJSTIBSFTUPUIFTUBUF XIJDIJTDPOTJEFSFEOFDFTTBSZUPTFDVSF PSPGUIJTUPUBM"CTPSCJOHPG'%*JOnPXJO3VTTJBUIBUZFBS 5BUBSTUBO UIFFDPOPNJDJOUFSFTUTPGUIFSFQVCMJD*OFYDIBOHF UIF5BUBSTUBOJHPWFSONFOUQMFEHFE SBOLTPOMZTJYUIBNPOH3VTTJBOSFHJPOTJOUFSNTPGDVNVMBUJWF'%*ȝȡȠ"DDPSEJOHUP UPSFOEFSTVQQPSUUPUIFSFHJPOBMPJMBOEHBTDPNQBOJFTBOEEFGFOEUIFJSJOUFSFTUTȝȡȥ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ȝȡȡ QSPQFSUZ BOE QPXFS BOE B IFBWZ SFMJBODF PO iSFHJPOBM mOBODFTw *O GBDU *MBMEJOPW 5BUBSTUBOJT LOPXO GPS B VOJRVF DPNCJOBUJPO PG MJCFSBM BOE QSPUFDUJPOJTU FDP BTTVNFTUIBU5BUBSTUBOJTCVJMEJOHBOE"TJBOTUZMFFDPOPNZQSPOFUPTUBHOBUJPOȝȢȜ OPNJDQPMJDJFT'PSFYBNQMF 4IBJNJFWIBTBOPċDJBMQPMJDZPGTUJNVMBUJOHUIFEFWFM 0CTFSWFSTIBWFBMTPFYUFOTJWFMZDPNNFOUFEPOUIFGBJMVSFPG5BUOFGUUPTFSWJDF PQNFOUPGTNBMMCVTJOFTTFT XIJDIVOEPVCUFEMZJTBOJNQPSUBOUQBSUPGUIFMJCFSBM JUTGPSFJHOEFCUT XIJDIBSFBUUSJCVUFEUPUIFFYDFTTJWFEFQFOEFODFPGUIJTPJMDPNQBOZ FDPOPNJD BHFOEB CVU BU UIF TBNF UJNF TNBMM BOE NFEJVNTJ[FE5BUBSTUBOJFOUFS POHPWFSONFOUQPMJDJFTȝȢȝ'PSFJHOJOWFTUPSTDMBJNFEUIBUUIFHPWFSONFOUPG5BUBSTUBO QSJTFTBSFGPSDFEUPTFMMBOBHSFFETIBSFPGUIFJSQSPEVDUJPOUPMPDBMFDPOPNJDPQFSBUPST NJTVTFE5BUOFGUGVOETȝȢȞ*O 5BUBSTUBOGBJMFEUPSFUVSO64NJMMJPOUP*/( SFHBSEMFTTPGCFUUFSPĊFSTGSPNPVUTJEFUIFSFQVCMJDȝȡȢ #BSJOHT UIF%VUDICBOLUIBUIBEDSFEJUFE5BUBSTUBOT&VSPCPOETQSPKFDUɨF3PVOE 5BCMFPG5BUBSTUBO BOBTTPDJBUJPOPGEJĊFSFOUQPMJUJDBMCMPDLTBOENPWFNFOUT GSPN DPNNVOJTUTBOETPDJBMEFNPDSBUTUPUIFQSPMJCFSBMi%FNPDSBUJD$IPJDFPG3VTTJBw IBTBDDVTFEiUIFDMBOPG4IBJNJFWwPGFDPOPNJDJOFċDJFODZBOEQFSTPOBMFOSJDINFOUȝȢȟ i'VUVSF PG 'FEFSBMJTN JO 3VTTJBw SFTFBSDI QSPKFDU XFC TJUF BU IUUQGFEFSBMJTNTPSPTLTVSV ɨFPOMJOF'SFF-BODF#VSFBVBHFODZBDDVTFTUIFi4IBJNJFWDMBOwoXIJDIJODMVEFT DPOGFSFODFTFNJOBSHBMFFWIUN *TLIBLPW %BNJSi.PEFM5BUBSTUBOB[BJQSPUJWw 5BUBSTUBOT.PEFM1SPTBOE$POT 1BOPSBNB 4IDIFESJO 7MBEJNJSi5BUBSTUBO8BJUTGPS3FBM'FEFSBMJTNw#VTJOFTTJO3VTTJB OP 4FQUFNCFS 'PSVN OP Q Q i'VUVSF PG 'FEFSBMJTN JO 3VTTJBw SFTFBSDI QSPKFDU XFC TJUF BUIUUQGFEFSBMJTNTPSPTLTVSV 5BUBSTUBOHPWFSONFOUXFCTJUF BUIUUQXXXUBUBSSVBQQFOEIUNM DPOGFSFODFTFNJOBSNBMHJOIUN 5BUBSTUBOHPWFSONFOUXFCTJUF BUIUUQXXXUBUBSSVBQQFOE@JIUNM i3FTQVCMJLB5BUBSTUBOHMB[BNJ[BSVCF[IOPHPJOWFTUPSBw 3FQVCMJDPG5BUBSTUBOJOUIF&ZFTPG'PS *MJMEJOPW *MJBT i&LPOPNJDIFTLBJB SFGPSNB W 5BUBSTUBOF USFUJJ QVU w &DPOPNJD 3FGPSN JO FJHO*OWFTUPS 1BOPSBNB'PSVN TVNNFS Q 5BUBSTUBOɨFɨJSE8BZ 1BOPSBNB'PSVN TVNNFS QQo i'VUVSF PG 'FEFSBMJTN JO 3VTTJBw SFTFBSDI QSPKFDU XFC TJUF BU IUUQGFEFSBMJTNTPSPTLTVSV $BSOFHJF&OEPXNFOUXFCTJUF BUIUUQQVCTDBSHFHJFSVCPPLTOQBTQ DPOGFSFODFTFNJOBSLBTICSB[JFWIUN 4VTBSPW "OESFJ i5BUBSTUBO W w *O 3VTTJBO 3FHJPOT JO "O "OOVBM 4VQQMFNFOU *CJE UP3VTTJBT1PMJUJDBM"MNBOBD.PTDPX$BSOFHJF$FOUFS Q 0SUUVOH 0QDJU 1PMJUJDBM *OGPSNBUJPO "HFODZ XFC TJUF BU IUUQXXXBQOSVEPDVNFOUT 4USBOBPOMJOFJOGPSNBUJPOBHFODZ BUIUUQXXXWPMHBTUSBOBSVQSJOUIUNM IUN );5ISIZaKPM^IVL>6>IT]M^ -`\MZVIT:MTI\QWV[WN OVNFSPVTSFMBUJWFTPGUIFIFBEPGUIFSFQVCMJDoPGQSBDUJDJOHTIBEPXZCVTJOFTTPQFSB PSEFS FYQPSUBOEJNQPSUPGTUSBUFHJDBMMZJNQPSUBOUJUFNT FDPMPHZ BOEBOUJUSVTUNFB UJPOT NBJOMZBTTPDJBUFEXJUIPJMFYQPSUBUJPOȝȢȠ*UBMTPIBTSFQPSUFEOVNFSPVTDBTFTPG TVSFTɨF4UBUF$PVODJMJTFNQPXFSFEUPFTUBCMJTISFTUSJDUJPOTGPSGPSFJHODBQJUBMiJO NJTNBOBHFNFOUPGQVCMJDGVOETBOEFDPOPNJDQBUFSOBMJTNJOUIFSFHJPOȝȢȡ UIPTFJOEVTUSJFTIBWJOHWJUBMJOUFSFTUGPSUIFSFQVCMJDwȝȣȟ "OPUIFS FYBNQMF PG FDPOPNJD QSPUFDUJPOJTN JT UIBU UIF FDPOPNJD TUSBUFHZ PG :FU TPNFHPPEDIBOHFTBSFOFWFSUIFMFTTVOEFSXBZɨFmSTUZFBSPG5BUBSTUBOT 5BUBSTUBOJTBJNFEBUSFMJBODFVQPOJUTJOEJHFOPVTSFTPVSDFTɨVT CVJMEJOHJUTPXO JODMVTJPOJOUIF7'%HBWFSJTFUPNPSFMJCFSBMBQQSPBDIFTUPFDPOPNZQPMJDJFT*OBO PJMSFmOFSZXBTDPOTJEFSFEBTUIFGPSFNPTUFDPOPNJDQSJPSJUZȝȢȢ4PNFFYQFSUTQSP BEESFTTUPUIF4UBUF$PVODJMJO 4IBJNJFWBDLOPXMFEHFEUIBUUIFTUBUFSFHVMBUJPO QPTFUIBU5BUBSTUBOJOWFTUSFTPVSDFTJOQSPEVDJOHQFDVMJBSUZQFTPGHPPET FH i.VT PGFDPOPNJDBDUJWJUJFToXJUIUIFFYDFQUJPOPGTPNFNPOPQPMJFToCFDBNFPCTPMFUF MJNTUZMFw BDDFTTPSJFT DSFBUJOH i5BUBSPSJFOUFEw FDPOPNJD JOTUJUVUJPOT FH B5BUBS BOEJO5BUBSTUBOUIFDPOEJUJPOTBSFSJQFGPSSFEVDJOHTUBUFDPOUSPMPWFSUIFFDPOPNZȝȣȠ OBUJPOBMCBOLUPBDDVNVMBUFUIFGVOETPG%JBTQPSB BOEBi.VTMJNJOGSBTUSVDUVSFw 5BUBSTUBOXBTIPNFUPUIFmSTUiTJOHMFXJOEPXwDFOUFSGPSCVTJOFTTSFHJTUSBUJPOoPOF JODMVEJOHTQFDJBMGPPETUPSFTBOENFEJDBMJOTUJUVUJPOT ȝȢȣɨF1SFTJEFOUJBM%FDSFFPG UIBUJOUFHSBUFTOVNFSPVTBHFODJFTJODIBSHFPGJTTVJOHCVTJOFTTMJDFOTFTɨJTiSJHIUPO .BSDISVMFEUIBUUIF5BUBSUBOJ.JOJTUSZPG.BTT$PNNVOJDBUJPOTTIPVMESVO UIFTQPUwVOJUJTBJNFEBUEJNJOJTIJOHDPSSVQUJPO BOESFMJFWJOHFOUSFQSFOFVSTGSPN BQVCMJDSFMBUJPOTDBNQBJHOUPBEWFSUJTFMPDBMQSPEVDUTBOETUJNVMBUFQPTJUJWFQVCMJD IBWJOHUPNBLFNVMUJQMFBQQMJDBUJPOTUPEJĊFSFOUCVSFBVDSBUJDFOUJUJFTJOPSEFSUPTUBSU QFSDFQUJPOTPGMPDBMQSPEVDFSTȝȢȤ4PNFFYQFSUTEFFNUIBU5BUBSTUBOTFDPOPNJDTUSBU BCVTJOFTTȝȣȡ FHZJTPOFPGEJĊFSFOUJBUJOHGSPNJUT3VTTJBODPNQFUJUPST FH /J[IOJJ/PWHPSPEBOE &LBUFSJOCVSH ȝȢȥBOECBTJDBMMZDPSSFTQPOETUPUIFHMPCBMi*TMBNmOBODFTwDPODFQUȝȣȜ 5BUBSTUBOJ FDPOPNJD QPMJDZ BMTP JOWPMWFT MPCCZJOH .PTDPX GPS UBY QSJWJMFHFT GPS UIPTF DPNQBOJFT UIBU USBEF JO GPSFJHO NBSLFUTȝȣȝ ɨF FDPOPNJD TPWFSFJHOUZ PG 5BUBSTUBOXBTWFSZNVDICBTFEVQPOUIFQSFGFSFOUJBMUSFBUNFOUJUSFDFJWFEGSPNUIF DFOUSBMHPWFSONFOU"TMPOHBHPBT 5BUBSTUBOSFDFJWFEUIFSJHIUUPIBWFBUJUTEJT QPTBMBMMFYDJTFTGPSBMDPIPMJDCFWFSBHFT PGBMM7"5DPMMFDUFEJOUIFSFQVCMJD BOE UIFSFWFOVFTGSPNPJMFYQPSUUPiGBSBCSPBEwDPVOUSJFT NJMMJPOUPOTQFSZFBS ȝȣȞ %FTQJUFXJEFMZQVCMJDJ[FEiFDPOPNJDPQFOOFTT w5BUBSTUBOJMFHJTMBUJPODPOUBJOT BOVNCFSPGSBUIFSSFTUSJDUJWFDMBVTFTɨVT UIF+BOVBSZ-BXPO'PSFJHO*OWFTU NFOUTJOUIF3FQVCMJDPG5BUBSTUBOEPFTOPUHVBSBOUFFQSPUFDUJPOPGQSJWBUFJOWFTUPST GSPNOBUJPOBMJ[BUJPOPGUIFJSQSPQFSUZɨFMBXEPFTOPUTFDVSFJOWFTUPSTJOUFSFTUTJO DBTFTPGDIBOHJOHUIFMFHJTMBUJPOJOTVDIBSFBTBTEFGFOTFBOEOBUJPOBMTFDVSJUZ QVCMJD 'SFF-BODF#VSFBVXFCTJUF BUIUUQXXXnCSVSTIUNM 'SFF-BODF#VSFBVXFCTJUF BUIUUQXXXnCSVQGPEKIUNM "LINBEVMJOB "MFOBi;IFMF[OZJ#BCBJw #BCBJUIF*SPO 1SPmM .BSDI QQo *TLIBLPW %BNJSi.PEFM5BUBSTUBOB[BJQSPUJWw 5BUBSTUBOT.PEFM1SPTBOE$POT 1BOPSBNB 'PSVN OP Q 5BUBSTUBOHPWFSONFOUXFCTJUF BUIUUQXXXUBUBSSVBQQFOE@DIUNM i3FTQVCMJLB5BUBSTUBOHMB[BNJ[BSVCF[IOPHPJOWFTUPSB wQ $PNNJTTJPO PO UIF 4QBUJBM %FWFMPQNFOU PG UIF 7PMHB 'FEFSBM %JTUSJDU XFC TJUF BU IUUQ PLSVHNFUPESVCPPLTJTMBN*TM'JOHFUJOEFY /BUJPOBM/FXT4FSWJDFXFCTJUF BUIUUQXXXOOTSVSFHJPOZUBUBSTUIUNM "LINFUPW 3(i,BN"; V[FMQSPUJWPSFDIJJNF[IEV.PTLWPJJ,B[BOJVw ,BN"; UIF,OPU PG$POUSPWFSTJFTCFUXFFO.PTDPXBOE,B[BOC *O"TJNNFUSJDIOBJBGFEFSBUTJBW[HMJBEJ[UTFOUSB ,PWBMTLBJB (BMJOB i4MBCPTU TJMOPJ WMBTUJw ɨF 8FBLOFTT PG 4USPOH 1PXFS *UPHJ SFTQVCMJLJPCMBTUFJ "TZNNFUSJDBM'FEFSBUJPO0VUMPPLGSPNUIF$FOUFS 3FQVCMJDTBOE0CMBTUT FE- .BSDI QQ .%SPCJ[IFWB Q.PTDPX*OTUJUVUFPG4PDJPMPHZ $FOUFS GPS 4USBUFHJD 3FTFBSDI XFC TJUF BU IUUQXXXDTSSVBCPVUQVCMJDBUJPOT 5BUBSTUBOHPWFSONFOUXFCTJUF BUIUUQXXXUBUBSSVBQQFOEIUNM TFHHIUNM +WVKT][QWV 4VNNBSJ[JOHPVSSFTFBSDIm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ȝȣȢ ɨJSEMZ 5BUBSTUBOJQPMJDJFTNBZMFBEUPBOFXVOEFSTUBOEJOHPGTPWFSFJHOUZJO 3VTTJB POFUIBUSFDPHOJ[FTUIBUFBDITPWFSFJHOUZoCFJUUIBUPGUIFSFQVCMJDTPSUIF GFEFSBUJPOToIBTJUTMJNJUBUJPOT6OGPSUVOBUFMZ UIFGFEFSBMQPMJDZUPXBSE5BUBSTUBOXBT BOETUJMMJT SBUIFSJOEJTUJODUBOEBNCJWBMFOU#BTJDBMMZXIBUJTDBMMFEiQPMJDZwJTBTFUPG JNQSPWJTBUJPOTBOESBOEPNNFBTVSFTMBDLJOHBTZTUFNJDWJTJPOPGUIFQSPCMFN)PX FWFS JGUIFGFEFSBMDFOUFSSFGVTFTUPNBJOUBJOBTFMGDPOTUSBJOJOHBQQSPBDI SFQVCMJDT TVDIBT5BUBSTUBOXJMMCFGPSDFEJOUIFMPOHSVOUPMPPLGPSHSFBUFSJOEFQFOEFODFȝȣȣ 'PVSUIMZ XFNBZDPODMVEFUIBUHMPCBMJ[BUJPOCSJOHTOPUPOMZOFXPQQPSUVOJUJFT CVUBMTPOFXDIBMMFOHFTGPS5BUBSTUBO*OQPMJUJDBMUFSNT 3VTTJBTJOUFHSBUJPOJOUPUIF JOUFSOBUJPOBMMFHBMTZTUFN KPJOJOHUIF$PVODJMPG&VSPQF GPSFYBNQMF XJMMNBLFB /JLSBWFTI 0QDJU QQ i0ULPOGSPOUBUTJJLOBWFEFOJVNPTUPWw 'SPN$POGSPOUBUJPOUP#SJEHJOHUIF(BQT 1BOPSBNB 'PSVN OP TQFDJBMJTTVF QQo );5ISIZaKPM^IVL>6>IT]M^ WBSJFUZPGQSPDFEVSBMOPSNTUIBUFYJTUJOUIFSFQVCMJDPCTPMFUFɨVT UIFXJEFMZVTFE 1BQFSTQVCMJTIFEJOUIFTFSJFT QSBDUJDF PG SFTUSJDUJOH PQFO QPMJUJDBM EJTDVTTJPOT VOEFS UIF HVJTF PG iEFGFOEJOH UIF IPOPSBOEEJHOJUZPGUIFQSFTJEFOUwJTJODMFBSDPOnJDUXJUIUIFNPTUSFDFOU&VSPQFBO $PVSUSFHVMBUJPOTBJNFEBUQSFWFOUJOHBOZLJOEPGQPMJUJDBMDFOTPSTIJQ3FHJTUSBUJPO /P+FSPOJN1FSPWJD*OUFSOBUJPOBMJ[BUJPOPG3VTTJBO3FHJPOTBOEUIF$POTFRVFODFT SFTUSJDUJPOTBQQMJFEUPOPO5BUBSTUBOJNFEJBXJTIJOHUPPQFSBUFJOUIFSFQVCMJDBMTP GPS3VTTJBO'PSFJHOBOE4FDVSJUZ1PMJDZ"QSJM DPOUSBEJDUUIF&VSPQFBO$POWFOUJPOPO)VNBO3JHIUTBOE#BTJD-JCFSUJFTȝȣȤ /P"OESFJ 4 .BLBSZDIFW *TMBOET PG (MPCBMJ[BUJPO 3FHJPOBM 3VTTJB BOE UIF *O DVMUVSBM UFSNT HMPCBMJ[BUJPO o XJUI JUT VOJmDBUJPO PG CBTJD TPDJBM QSBD 0VUTJEF8PSME"VHVTU UJDFT OPSNT BOESVMFToJTBMTPBDIBMMFOHFUPFUIOJDBOESFMJHJPVTJEFOUJUJFT XIJDI /P"MFYBOEFS " 4FSHPVOJO &YUFSOBM %FUFSNJOBOUT PG 3VTTJBT 3FHJPOBMJ[BUJPO BMXBZTDMBJNUIFJSPXOFYDMVTJWFSJHIUT TQFDJmDOFFET BOEQFDVMJBSTUBUVTFTɨJTJT 'FCSVBSZ B DPOUSBEJDUJPO UIBU NBOZ PUIFS NVMUJFUIOJD DPVOUSJFT IBWF BMSFBEZ FYQFSJFODFEȝȣȥ /PX JU JT 3VTTJBT o BOE JUT SFQVCMJDT o UVSO UP SFEJTDPWFS BOE SFBDU BEFRVBUFMZ UP /P"MMB $IJSJLPWB /BUBMJB -BQJOB 3FHJPOBM &MJUF " 2VJFU 3FWPMVUJPO PO B UIFTFDIBMMFOHFT 3VTTJBO4DBMF.BSDI /P0MFH#"MFYBOESPWɨF3PMFPGUIF3FQVCMJDPG,BSFMJBJO3VTTJBT'PSFJHOBOE 4FDVSJUZ1PMJDZ.BSDI /P"OESFJ 4 .BLBSZDIFW ɨF 3FHJPO BOE UIF 8PSME ɨF $BTF PG /J[IOJJ /PWHPSPE"QSJM /P0MFH # "MFYBOESPW ɨF $JUZ PG .PTDPX JO 3VTTJBT 'PSFJHO BOE 4FDVSJUZ 1PMJDZ3PMF "JNTBOE.PUJWBUJPOT"QSJM /P4FSHFJ7(PMVOPW3FHJPOTPGUIFi3FE#FMUwJOUIF1SPDFTTPG*OUFSOBUJPOBMJ[B UJPOɨF$BTFPG7PMHPHSBE0CMBTU"QSJM /P(SJHPSZ - 0MFLI /PWPTJCJSTL 0CMBTU 1SPCMFNT PG (MPCBMJ[BUJPO BOE 3FHJPOBMJ[BUJPO.BZ /P4FSHFJ 7 4BSZDIFW 3FHJPOBMJ[BUJPO PG 3VTTJBO 'PSFJHO BOE 4FDVSJUZ 1PMJDZ ɨF$BTFPG,VSTL0CMBTU.BZ /P"OESFBT 8FOHFS &OHBHJOH 3VTTJB BOE JUT 3FHJPOT $IBMMFOHFT BOE 0QQPSUVOJUJFTGPSUIF8FTU4FQUFNCFS /P"SCBLIBO,.BHPNFEPW3FHJPOBM*EFPMPHJFTJOUIF$POUFYUPG*OUFSOBUJPOBM 3FMBUJPOT4FQUFNCFS /P-FPOJE#7BSEPNTLJZ'PSFJHO&DPOPNJD3FMBUJPOTPG3ZB[BO0CMBTUJOUIF $POUFYUPGB/FX4FDVSJUZ&OWJSPONFOU4FQUFNCFS /P.JLIBJM " "MFYTFFW (MPCBMJ[BUJPO BU UIF &EHFT PG *OTFDVSJUZ .JHSBUJPO *OUFSFUIOJD 3FMBUJPOT .BSLFU *ODFOUJWFT BOE *OUFSOBUJPOBM &DPOPNJD *OUFSBDUJPOTJO3VTTJBT#PSEFS3FHJPOT.BSDI 'BDVMUZPG+PVSOBMJTN .PTDPX4UBUF6OJWFSTJUZ XFCTJUF BUIUUQXXXNFEJBMBXSVQVCMJDBUJPOT CPPLTWPJOPWIUNM /P7BMEJNJS",PMPTTPWi*OUFSOBUJPOBMJ[BUJPOwPS"EBQUBUJPO )JTUPSJDBM-FHBDZ %BLIJO "OESFJi3FHJPOBMOBJBTUSBUJmLBUTJBJUFSSJUPSJBMOBJBUTFMPTUOPTUQPJTLGPSNVMZOPWPHP (FPQPMJUJDTBOE#PSEFS$PPQFSBUJPOJO#FMHPSPE0CMBTU.BSDI NJSPWPHPQPSJBELBw 3FHJPOBM4USBUJmDBUJPOBOE5FSSJUPSJBM*OUFHSJUZ*O4FBSDIPGUIF'PSNVMBGPS UIF/FX8PSME0SEFS *O$PNQBSBUJWF3FHJPOBMJTN3VTTJB$*4UIF8FTU FE"OESFJ.BLBSZDIFW /P%FSFL - "WFSSF 4FDVSJUZ 1FSDFQUJPOT "NPOH -PDBM &MJUFT BOE 1SPTQFDUT GPS /J[IOJJ /PWHPSPE */5"4 /J[IOJJ /PWHPSPE 4UBUF 6OJWFSTJUZ 1SPDFFEJOHT PG *OUFSOBUJPOBM $PPQFSBUJPO"DSPTT3VTTJBT/PSUIXFTUFSO#PSEFS.BSDI 3FTFBSDI1SPKFDU QQo /P*OHNBS0MECFSH,BMJOJOHSBECFUXFFO.PTDPXBOE#SVTTFMT.BSDI /P.JLIBJM""MFYTFFW*OTUSVNFOUBM*OUFSOBUJPOBMJ[BUJPO3FHJPOBM'PSFJHOBOE 4FDVSJUZ1PMJDZ*OUFSFTUTJO1SJNPSTLJJ,SBJ.BSDI /P0MFH # "MFYBOESPW BOE "OESFJ 4 .BLBSZDIFW 0O UIF 8BZ UP (MPCBM J[BUJPO "ENJOJTUSBUJWF BOE /FUXPSLJOH 4USBUFHJFT PG 3VTTJBT 3FHJPOT .BSDI /P(SBFNF1)FSE'PSFJHOBOE4FDVSJUZ1PMJDZ*NQMJDBUJPOTPG3VTTJBT%FNP HSBQIJD$SJTJT.BSDI /P4UBOJTMBW - 5LBDIFOLP 3FHJPOBMJ[BUJPO PG 3VTTJBO 'PSFJHO BOE 4FDVSJUZ 1PMJDZɨF$BTFPG4U1FUFSCVSH.BSDI /P"MFYBOEFS"4FSHPVOJOBOE.JLIBJM*3ZLIUJL'PSFJHOBOE4FDVSJUZ1PMJDJFT BTB-FHBM1SPCMFNCFUXFFO$FOUFSBOE3FHJPOT.BSDI /P"OESFJ 4 .BLBSZDIFW 7BTJMJJ / 7BMVFW &YUFSOBM 3FMBUJPOT PG 5BUBSTUBO /FJUIFS*OTJEF /PS0VUTJEF #VU"MPOHTJEF3VTTJB.BSDI 4QFDJBM "OESFJ.7BWJMPWBOE+PBOOB.4DIFNN3VTTJBBOEUIF8FTU UIF8FTUBOE *TTVF 3VTTJB.BSDI Online version provided by the International Relations and Security Network A public service run by the Center for Security Studies at the ETH Zurich © 1996-2004