Solarscorecard.Pdf
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
w w w S OLARS CORECARD .COM The industry is already dedicated to the goal our vision of environmental sustainability - we hope As the global economy transitions toward more renew- that it will be able to meet the high able sources of energy, solar photovoltaics (PV) will “environmental standards it has set for itself. play an increasingly prominent role. Because the generation of electricity from solar power produces no greenhouse gas emissions, it is widely considered to be “clean” energy. However, the solar PV industry still faces serious issues that must be addressed if the industry is to be truly “clean and green” and socially just. These include po- tential environmental, health, and safety (EHS) hazards responsibility for the impact of their products. We plan to update the scorecard resulting from the manufacture and disposal of solar annually to reflect the dynamic nature of the industry. panels. In addition, the industry must ensure safe and equitable working conditions throughout solar supply SVTC will continue to support and engage the solar PV industry on these issues. chains. The industry is already dedicated to the goal of environmental sustainability—we hope that it will be able to meet the high environmental standards it has set for In January 2009, the Silicon Valley Toxics Coalition itself and develop a strong reputation for corporate responsibility. (SVTC) launched a campaign to address these issues with the release of Toward a Just and Sustainable We envision a solar PV industry that: Solar Energy Industry. This report detailed the hazards 1. Pursues innovative approaches to reducing the toxic chemicals used in panel related to the manufacturing and disposal of solar PV manufacturing. panels. 2. Implements and monitors equitable labor standards throughout its supply chains. SVTC’s 2010 Solar PV Company Survey and Score- 3. Takes responsibility for the environmental and health impacts of solar prod- card builds on the recommendations of that report. In ucts throughout their lifecycles, including adherence to a mandatory policy for 2009, we surveyed over 200 solar PV companies to ob- responsible recycling. tain a clearer picture of industry practices and standards related to environmental health and safety, sustainability, Responsible recycling is essential to the future of the solar PV industry—without and social justice. Our research revealed that approxi- it, improperly discarded panels will become a new wave of toxic electronic wa- mately 30 percent of the companies surveyed were in sate (e-waste), and many valuable materials will be lost. While a voluntary take- commercial production and the remainder were in pilot back program called PV Cycle exists in the European Union (E.U.), there are no production or the research and development stage. The laws in the E.U., the U.S., or anywhere else in the world, that require solar panel survey results are summarized here, and we have also manufacturers to take back their panels and recycle them responsibly. In addition, compiled a scorecard that evaluates solar PV companies no existing laws support companies that demonstrate good recycling practices. based on their responses. For the solar PV industry to be truly sustainable, a regulatory framework must be This is the first solar PV scorecard, and it is an initial put in place that supports sustainable practices, including reductions in the use of step in measuring companies’ commitment to take toxic materials and mandatory takeback and recycling by industry. 1 Silicon Valley Toxics Coalition | SolarScorecard.com | 2010 the purpose of the survey The goal of SVTC’s Solar PV Company one who wants to be sure that the solar We want to ensure that the solar PV Survey is to encourage a truly just and PV panels they purchase are produced by industry does not leave the same legacy of sustainable solar PV industry. We com- companies that are responsible stewards waste and injustice that has characterized piled a list of solar PV companies based throughout product lifecycles. The survey the electronics industry. Most e-waste is on trade show literature, web searches, also enables companies to see where they sent to landfills, improperly recycled in and industry association directories. We rank relative to their competitors and prisons, or exported to developing nations sent out the survey in October 2009, col- where they need improvement. such as India, Nigeria, Ghana, and China lecting results through January 2010. The for dismantling. Many of the communities survey addressed a range of critical issues, We see this as a first step in working together to including extended producer responsibil- share information to improve practices that ity, supply chain monitoring, green jobs, protect communities, workers, and the environment. chemical use, and lifecycle analysis. “ We asked companies to self-report on We greatly appreciate the efforts of the where such dangerous low-tech disman- toxic chemical use and reduction and on companies that chose to respond fully to tling is done are experiencing serious how they address worker justice and envi- the survey. We see this as a first step in health problems due to high levels of ronmental health. Based on the responses, working together to share information, to lead, indium, and other toxic compounds. we have rated companies using the Solar improve practices, and to protect com- While solar PV panels have much longer PV Company Scorecard. The scorecard munities, workers, and the environment. life spans than typical consumer e-waste, serves as a resource for institutional pur- This collaboration will help build a firm it is essential that we act now to ensure chasers, investors, and consumers—any- foundation for the long-term growth of long-term sustainability. the sector. overview of the solar PV industry The solar PV industry is expected to grow monly manufactured, but emerging thin new types of panels incorporated into significantly over the coming years. Sup- film solar PV modules based on cadmium facades and rooftop shingles and tiles. ported by government tax incentives and telluride (CdTe), copper indium gallium All of these technologies raise questions the rapid introduction of new technolo- selenide (CIGS), and other newly devel- regarding the environmental and worker gies, cumulative solar PV module installa- oped materials are poised to gain market impact of the manufacturing and recycling tions grew by 42 percent in 2009, adding share as they become more cost effective. processes. Thin films utilize novel chemi- 6,370 MW1 to bring total global installa- The development of thin film solar PV cal compounds and manufacturing pro- tions to 21,500 MW by the end of 2009.2 will be hastened further with the rise of cesses (such as nanotechnology) for which building-integrated PV, which integrates there is little data about worker safety or Conventional solar PV modules based on solar panels into building design through community health impacts. crystalline silicon remain the most com- conventional rooftop panels or by using 1 Electric power industries like solar PV use watts, kilowatts (kW), and megawatts (MW) to measure 2 http://www.solarbuzz.com/Marketbuzz2009-intro.htm the peak electric power production of their PV modules and systems, as well as to quantify factory http://www.solarbuzz.com/News/NewsNACO1047.htm production and capacity. Solar modules measure peak power output in watts. 1 kW equals 1,000 watts http://www.researchandmarkets.com/reports/1071386/global_solar_photovoltaic_market_report_2009 and is the unit used to denote the size of rooftop systems and arrays. 1 MW is equivalent to one million watts and is the typical unit used to measure solar PV power plants or factory output. 1 MW can provide power to 700 to 1,000 homes. 2 Silicon Valley Toxics Coalition | SolarScorecard.com | 2010 the key Scoring Criteria for Module Manufacturers: SVTC used a 0 to 100 point scale. Points were awarded in the following four areas. This company is an This company has taken This company responded to This company did not This company currently has industry leader and is some big steps toward the survey but has not taken respond to our invitation to a takeback program and has on the right track. creating a clean solar PV any significant steps toward participate in the survey. policies against exporting industry. A few more com- creating a clean solar PV waste and using prison mitments to the environ- industry (or did not com- labor to dismantle end-of- ment and workers will help pletely fill out the survey). life panels. the sun come out. the standards Extended Producer Supply Chain Monitoring Chemical Use Disclosure Responsibility (EPR) and Green Jobs and Life-Cycle Analysis Corporate claims about being and Takeback Green jobs protect workers from Solar PV manufacturing currently “green” are increasingly com- EPR requires that manufacturers be exposure to toxic chemicals and relies on a number of hazardous or mon—but there are few ways responsible for the impacts of their ensure a living wage. There is toxic chemicals. By using lifecycle for the public to confirm those products on the environment and no guarantee that companies are analysis, risk assessment, and other claims. Transparency is impor- on communities throughout product providing green jobs if they do not tools, the solar PV industry can tant to verify whether compa- lifecycles. monitor their supply chains. move away from the most toxic and nies are implementing EHS hazardous inputs. In the E.U., using standards, takeback programs, Requirements Requirements a risk assessment framework, the and responsible recycling. for a ‘Sunny’ Score for a ‘Sunny’ Score Restriction on Hazardous Substanc- By providing information on Company has a takeback and re- Company requires suppliers and es (ROHS) directive lists maximum their practices, companies can cycling program that is adequately sub-suppliers to follow a code of concentrations of several toxic demonstrate their performance financed and free to the consumer.