The Establishment of National Rites and Royal Authority During Early Chosŏn
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
International Journal of Korean History(Vol.9, Dec. 2005) 89 The Establishment of National Rites and Royal Authority during Early Chosŏn Han Hyung-ju (Han Hyŏngju)* Introduction Confucian rites and ceremonies can be regarded as the symbolized expressions of a conceptual and abstractive political and social ideology that was based on a perception of Confucian classics (kyŏnghak) which was given substance through ritual activities (haengnye). In the pre- modern era, rulers in East Asia perceived the need to use the symbolism of rites (禮, ye) rather than physical compulsion to effectively generate and maintain political authority. The <Shuowenjiezi (說文解字, Elucidations of the Signs and Explications of the Graphs)> Compiled by Xu Shen explains the etymology of ye as the description of a person worshipping a god by dedicating an offering in sacrificial vessels. 1 Along with exhibiting the religious attributes of rites (ye), such an explanation makes evident that the process of rites (ye) was used as symbolism to convey the fact that the person who played the leading role in the ritual ceremony had in effect received a mandate from heaven. The diversified and magnificent processions, as well as the solemnity of the ritual process associated with national ceremonies, and in particular national rites, were used to naturally reflect the dignity of the king as the * Research professor, Institute of Korean Culture, Korea University 90 The Establishment of National Rites and Royal Authority during Early Chosŏn ruler and master of religious rites. In addition, such ceremonies were used to showcase the symbolic fact that the ruler had been granted a mandate from the heavens to rule over the human world. To this end, from early on, rulers tended to focus a high percentage of their energies on rites. In this regard, during the period in which national ceremonies revolved around the five traditional rites of the Tang dynasty of China (五禮); the Gillye (吉禮, auspicious rites), Garye (嘉禮, felicitous rites), Hyungnye (凶禮, funeral rites), Binnye (賓禮, guest rites), and Kunnye (軍禮, military rites), the utmost importance tended to be attached to the auspicious rites (Gillye). This Chinese experience began to exercise an influence on Korean history in the aftermath of the transmission of Confucianism to the Korean peninsula during the Three Kingdoms Era. The selection of Confucianism as the basis of the state governance system during the Koryŏ dynasty was followed by the identification of the five rites as the cornerstone of the national rituals. These national rituals were further developed during the Chosŏn dynasty, with the <Kukchooryeŭi> (國朝五禮儀, Five State Rites)> finally compiled during the reign of King Sŏngjong. In the present study, an attempt is made to analyze the process through which national rites were established during early Chosŏn, as well as periodic trends, by linking it to the notion of royal authority. Many studies have already been conducted on the topic of national rituals during early Chosŏn. In fact, the author of this study has himself conducted a couple of work on this subject.2 However, the majority of existing studies has been concentrated on the 15th century, and have dealt with the determination of the characteristics of individual rituals and the establishment of the ritual system from a methodological standpoint. Therefore, although an analysis of the institutional history of national rituals has been conducted, it has remained difficult to deconstruct the manner in which the establishment of the ritual system was connected to the notion of royal authority. In this regard, the researcher intends to, while also reflecting the results of existing studies, analyze the correlation between national rituals and royal authority from three different vantage points. Han Hyung-ju (Han Hyŏngju) 91 First, the researcher intends to analyze the correlation between the institutional establishment of Confucian rites and royal authority. The rulers of Chosŏn advocated Confucian rites-based governance (禮治, yech´i) as the basic principle of state management. To this end, both the king and meritorious retainers recognized the necessity to establish proper Confucian rites. However, both parties came into conflict with one another when it came to the details of these rites. Thus, while the king emphasized the inevitability of using the rites for the Son of Heaven (Ch´ŏnjarye), the meritorious retainers accentuated the need to utilize rites appropriate for feudal lords(Chehurye). Chosŏn’s early national ritual system was thus established through negotiations between these two camps. However, the contents of these rituals varied from ruler to ruler. Second, this study analyzes the conflicts between the two parties over the implementation of the Chech´ŏnnye (祭天禮, ritual to heaven) ceremony conducted in conjunction with the Ch´ŏnjarye. While a quasi- negotiated settlement of this issue remained in place between the two sides from the foundation of the kingdom until the reign of King Sejong, King Sejo’s unilateral implementation of the Chech´ŏnnye during his reign resulted, at the behest of the gravely aggravated meritorious retainers, in the abolishing of this ceremony outright following his death. Third, this study delves into the actual participation of Chosŏn kings in national rituals during the early period of the Chosŏn dynasty. If the king’s intervention in the process of establishing ritual ceremonies can be likened to the passive expression of rites, then the king’s participation in these national rituals, despite the burden occasioned by such a decision, can be regarded as a more active expression of these rites. Any king who desired to take part in a national rite was subjected to a seven-day ablution process and to intricate ritual procedures that often began early on the morning of the actual ceremony. To this end, the majority of ritual ceremonies involved ministerial level officials attending on the behalf of the king (sŏphaeng), rather than the king directly participating in such rites (ch´inhaeng). In this regard, the analysis of the frequency with which kings’ participated in rites, and the types of rites in which they 92 The Establishment of National Rites and Royal Authority during Early Chosŏn participated firsthand, represents a pertinent methodology with which to understand the ulterior motives of those kings who decided to submit themselves to such intricacies. Using the above-mentioned three vantage points, an attempt is made to find a link between the royal authority and national rituals during the reign of each king of early Chosŏn, and to analyze periodic trends. Moreover, by combining these factors, an effort is made to gain a more precise understanding of the general characteristics of national rituals during early Chosŏn. The transformation towards Confucian-style national rites during the reign of King T´aejong and royal authority National rituals before the Chosŏn era Wishes for the well-being of the royal family and general peace and prosperity through national-level rites first emerged during the early stages of the Three Kingdoms Era. Examples of such early rituals include the shrine rituals for the founders of each kingdom, and worship rituals to the Heavens such as the Dongmaeng(東盟),Muchŏn(舞天) and Yŏnggo(迎鼓).3 Such rituals continued to be conducted until the final stages of the Three Kingdoms Era. In addition to such traditional rituals, Confucian-based national rituals began to make their way into Korea as a result of the growing exchanges with China during the state formation period. The <Samguksagi(三國史記, Chronicles of the Three Kingdoms)> contains a passage in which we discover that the construction of the Chongmyo (ancestral shrine) and Sajik (altar for worshiping gods of the earth and grain) had become widespread in the case of Koguryŏ by the 3rd-4th centuries.4 It also reveals that in the case of Silla, ancestral shrine rituals for the five generations which followed King T´aejo were first conducted during the 7th Year of King Sinmun (687), and that the Confucian-style five Han Hyungju 93 ancestral rites based on ancestral tablets beginning with King Mich´u were developed during the reign of King Hyegong (765-780).5 Here, we can see that Unified Silla’s Chongmyo system was implemented based on the ancestral grave rites (myoje) found in the <Lichi (禮記, Book of Rites)>, which consisted of seven ancestral rites for the Son of Heaven and five ancestral rites for feudal lords (chehu),. Confucian-style national rituals became more structuralized during the Koryŏ era. As Koryŏ adopted Confucianism rather than Buddhism as the basis for its state management, it possessed an in-depth knowledge of Confucian classics (kyŏnghak) and naturally accepted Chinese-style Confucian national rites. This process became more pronounced with the establishment of the Hwan´guje (圜丘祭, a ritual designed to inform the Heavens of the start of a new reign) and the Chŏkchŏnje (籍田祭, ritual conducted at the beginning of the year during which time a good harvest was prayed for) during the 2nd Year of King Sŏngjong6; of the Omyoje (五 廟制, five ancestral rites system) during the 7th Year of King Sŏngjong7; and the construction of the Sajik during the 10th Year of King Sŏngjong.8 While a national ritual system based on that of the Tang dynasty was established following the reign of King Munjong, Ch´oe Yunŭi compiled fifty volumes of the <Sangjŏngkogŭmnye (詳定古今禮, Ritual Texts of the Past and Present)> during the reign of King Ŭijong. Although