• Abstract and Figures
• Public Full-text

Design of an on-chip superconducting microwave circulator with octave bandwidth Benjamin J. Chapman,1,2, ∗ Eric I. Rosenthal,1, 2 and K. W. Lehnert1, 2 1JILA, National Institute of Standards and Technology and the University of Colorado, Boulder, Colorado 80309, USA 2 Department of Physics, University of Colorado, Boulder, Colorado 80309, USA (Dated: September 25, 2018) We present a design for a superconducting, on-chip circulator composed of dynamically modulated transfer switches and delays. Design goals are set for the multiplexed readout of superconducting qubits. Simulations of the device show that it allows for low-loss circulation (insertion loss < 0.35 dB and isolation > 20 dB) over an instantaneous bandwidth of 2.3 GHz. As the device is estimated to be linear for input powers up to −65 dBm, this design improves on the bandwidth and power- handling of previous superconducting circulators [1–3] by over a factor of 50, making it ideal for integration with broadband quantum limited amplifiers [4–6]. I. INTRODUCTION to bandwidth and linearity, this represents a 50-fold im- provement over other near-lossless superconducting cir- Sophisticated signal-processing often requires that culators [1–3], well-suited for integration with broadband Lorentz reciprocity—the scattering symmetry of an quantum-limited amplifiers [4–6]. electromagnetic system under exchange of source and detector—be broken. In particular, directionally-routing propagating electromagnetic modes without adding noise II. THEORY OF OPERATION or incurring loss is vital for quantum information process- ing with superconducting circuits. The proposed circulator is composed of two transfer Although Maxwell’s equations place no restrictions on switches connected by a pair of delay lines (Fig. 1a). the bandwidth over which lossless non-reciprocity can oc- The transfer switches have four ports, and are dynam- cur, synthesis of low-loss on-chip circulators and gyrators ically modulated with period T , toggling between their has mostly been limited to narrow-band devices [1–3, 7] “through” and “crossed” states. Figure 1b shows how the (fractional bandwidth < 1%). Ferrite circulators [8] pro- two switches are periodically actuated by square waves vide octave bandwidths, but their large magnets make with a relative phase of θ = π/2. The delays are chosen them difficult to miniaturize or integrate with supercon- to have duration τ = T/4. ducting circuits. Given the large number of qubits re- To see how the circulation is created, consider how a quired for fault-tolerant quantum computation [9], and right-propagating wave packet (e.g. a signal-burst inci- the standard use of non-reciprocity in qubit readout, cir- dent on ports 1 or 3) will be scattered by the network. culator performance metrics such as loss, added noise, Figure 1c shows how the two switches will route the inci- bandwidth, dynamic range, and size must be simultane- dent signal, depending on the portion of the modulation ously optimized. period in which it arrives. For example, if the signal ar- To address this optimization problem, we propose the rives in the first quarter-period of the modulation (the superconducting implementation of a recent concept for yellow time-window), the left (blue) transfer switch will broadband circulation based on active modulation and be in its through state. But by the time the signal exits delay [10–14]. The approach requires that the delay be the delay line, the right (red) transfer switch will be in commensurate with the modulation frequency, but im- its crossed state. Signals incident on port 1 are there- poses no constraints on the frequency of the input signal. fore routed to port 2, and signals incident on port 3 are arXiv:1809.08747v1 [quant-ph] 24 Sep 2018 This aspect is responsible for the concept’s bandwidth, routed to port 4. This process may be continued for the allowing for operation all the way down to dc [14]. It entire modulation period. One observes that the port-to- improves on previous designs [15–18] for broadband ac- port signal-routing is independent of the incident signal’s tive circulators by engineering the desired circulation in arrival time, despite the fact that the signal may travel a hardware efficient manner, which may in principle be along different paths before exiting the network. lossless. Such schemes are complementary to supercon- The non-reciprocal character of the network may be ducting travelling-wave isolators, which provide an alter- verified by repeating this analysis for left-travelling wave nate path to compact broadband non-reciprocity [19]. packets (e.g. signals incident on ports 2 or 4), as depicted When modeled as a superconducting integrated circuit, in Fig. 1d. Again, the port-to-port signal-routing is inde- simulations with realistic parameters show our design pendent of the signal’s arrival time: signals incident on allows for low-loss circulation (< 0.35 dB) with octave port 2 are always routed to port 3, and signals incident bandwidth and nW scale power-handling. With respect on port 4 are always routed to port 1. The scattering of the network is not invariant upon exchange of source and detector. It forms a four-port circulator. ∗ [email protected] This graphical time-domain representation of the 2 (a) (b) through 1 4 !/4 time 3 2 switchstate crossed 0 !/4 !/2 3!/4 ! (c) 0 !/4 !/2 3!/4 ! (d) T 3!/4 !/2 !/4 0 time 1 4 1 4 3 2 3 2 1 4 1 4 3 2 3 2 4 1 4 1 4 4 3 2 1 3 3 2 1 3 1 4 1 4 2 3 2 3 2 2 FIG. 1. Circulation with actively modulated transfer switches and delays. (a) A four-port circulator is constructed from two dynamically modulated transfer switches and a pair of delay lines. The left (blue) switch is shown in the crossed state, and the right (red) switch is shown in the through. The delay is set to one quarter of the modulation period τ = T/4. (b) The left and right switches are modulated with period T and a relative phase of π/2. For visual clarity, the modulation period is divided into quarter-period intervals indicated by the pastel background colors. (c) The schematics depict the way the switches will route a right-propagating signal, depending on its arrival time. Signals incident on port 1 are always routed to port 2, and signals incident on port 3 are routed to port 4. Note that these are not “snap-shots” of the switches’ configurations, as the signal is delayed by a quarter-period of the modulation as it propagates through the network. (d) The same depiction as (c), but for left-travelling waves incident on ports 2 or 4. To keep the device’s orientation the same as in (b), time flows from right to left in this diagram. circulator may be complemented by a quantitative an odd-excitation of the network’s first and third ports: frequency-domain analysis in which all m sidebands (de- its interference with the transmission of an even excita- tuned by integer multiples of the modulation frequency tion creates the desired circulation. Such a representa- Ω=2π/T ) are treated as ports of the network. The tion is useful in quantifying the effect of imperfections scattering of a signal incident on the first physical port and in evaluating the device’s linearity. (Absent nonide- may then be expressed as alities, Eq. (1) yields perfect four-port circulation when m Ωτ = π/2, θ = π/2, for which rm = δm,0). Ap- S11 =0, (1) pendix A includes± the full multi-frequency scattering± ma- m 1 trix derivation, and extension of Eq. (1) to include the S = (δm,0 rm), 21 2 − effects of group delay dispersion, finite modulation band- m S31 =0, width, and loss. m 1 The device’s sensitivity to these non-idealities depends S41 = (δm,0 + rm), 2 on the modulation rate Ω: Equation (1) shows that group − 4 ejkΩτ ej(m k)θ delay dispersion becomes problematic an Ω/(2π) shift in rm , ≡−π2 (m k)k frequency causes a delay variation on the scale of τ. Sim- k X − ilarly, a finite bandwidth Ωb of the square-wave modu- where the sum on k runs over all odd integers, δ is the lation truncates the sum in Eq. (1) at kmax = Ωb/Ω. Kronecker-delta, and m is an index denoting effective Both of these considerations prejudice the design in fa- ports at different frequencies, which is taken to be zero vor of longer delays and modulation rates which are much at the frequency of the input signal (e.g. m = 2 de- smaller than the frequencies of the circulated signals. notes the scattering of signals detuned from the− input Slow modulation also facilitates filtering, allowing sup- by 2Ω). The term rm describes the transmission of pression of spurious coupling between the modulation − 3 and signal lines. through crossed The benefits of slow modulation, however, do not come t ≪ c t ≫ c without a price. Slow modulation is only possible with long delays, which in the context of integrated circuits or typically entails greater loss and circuit size and/or re- duced bandwidth. In a superconducting design space, though, vanishing conductive losses make long, low-loss, (a) broadband delays possible [20–23], and circuit size is the 1 4 only remaining penalty. We leverage this fact in the pro- & & posed superconducting implementation of a broadband, c low-loss, on-chip circulator, the topic of the following sec- tion. t 3 2 & & III. PROPOSED SUPERCONDUCTING IMPLEMENTATION (b) 0 #21 We set design goals for our circulator by anticipat- # ing its use in superconducting qubit readout.

Load more

  12

Copy Link