DOCSLIB.ORG

Phonetics and Phonology Phonétique Et Phonologie

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Phonetics and Phonology Phonétique Et Phonologie PHONETICS AND PHONOLOGY PHONÉTIQUE ET PHONOLOGIE PHONETIC MOTIVATION FOR VARIATION IN SPANISH TRILLS 1. Introduction The vibrant, or trilled, [r] is a rather uncommon sound found in few contemporary languages (LADEFOGED et al. 1977: 49). It represents a highly salient pronunciation feature of Spanish which non-native speak- ers immediately recognize, but seldom master without great effort. The demanding production requirements of the vibrant make it the final speech gesture to be fully developed by native children (JIMÉNEZ 1987: 361). In the prestige dialect of Castile the trill consists of a series of brief occlusions made by the tongue tip against the alveolar ridge while the vibrating vocal cords sustain voicing (NAVARRO TOMAS 1967: 122). The acoustic impression of the trill is that of a vowel-like sound whose spectral characteristics approximate the vocalic segment it anticipates interrupted periodically by a non-aspirated stop element. In Spanish it is phonologi- cally distinct from the simple tap, also produced in the alveolar region, as illustrated below: (1) Spanish gloss Spanish gloss [koÍo] “choir” [koro] “I run” [paÍa] “for” [para] “vine” [qeÍo] “zero” [qero] “hill” Outside of Northern Spain and other conservative Spanish speech communities, the vibrant has undergone a wide range of phonetic adjust- ments resulting in articulations quite different from the norm. Two main variant forms serve as key features in the classification of regional speech habits. The assibilated phone [r] occurs when the tongue-tip gesture does not give rise to multiple occlusions, but rather creates a narrowing at the alveolar ridge with accompanying audible frication, similar in nature to the Czech fricative trill (LADEFOGED et al. 1977: 49). Palatographic evidence of speakers of Puerto Rican Spanish shows extensive lingual alve- olar contact in the lateral regions for [r], which suggests that the frication is centrally released (NAVARRO TOMAS 1966: 89). Alternatively, the point 52 K. WIDDISON of articulation may shift to the extreme back of the vocal tract resulting in a uvular phone produced as a vibrant [R], fricative [x], or approxi- mant [™] sound, depending on the degree and type of constriction. Unlike the normative trill, both of these phonetic variants, the assibilated and uvular phones, tend to devoice (CARDENAS 1958: 407; NAVARRO TOMAS 1966: 89). The phonetic metamorphosis of the Spanish vibrant affects a wide cross- section of language users. Field research shows the assibilated variant to be quite common in highland dialects including Paraguay, Ecuador, Peru, Bolivia, most of Argentina and Chile, Costa Rica, Guatemala, and the Mexican plateau (cf. CARDENAS [1958] for a detailed discussion of the distribution of [r]). While a velarized pronunciation of the vibrant is most often associated with Puerto Rican Spanish (NAVARRO TOMAS 1966: 94), it has also been found in other Caribbean dialects such as Cuba, Panama, and coastal Colombia and Venezuela (CANFIELD 1962: 91-92; CUÉLLAR 1971: 19). Within these speech communities, variant forms of the vibrant are found among diverse segments of society to a degree, at times, approaching majority status (GORDON 1987: 722-723; MORENO DE ALBA 1972: 366-367; TERRELL 1982: 62-63). The variation observed in Spanish vibrants may be described in terms of phonological processes such as assibilation, velarization, and devoic- ing. Yet these descriptive labels do not address the more interesting question regarding the root causes behind such shifts in pronunciation. There is wide agreement that the vagaries of the trill are the result of phonetic erosion occasioned by articulatory weakening, yet little more is known about the precise physical nature of the problem. Within many current linguistic theories, phonetic details are often considered irrelevant when conjecturing about the higher level forces that instantiate change. Moreover, research into the assibilation, velarization, and devoicing of the Spanish trill has been conducted as though these were separate, dis- connected issues. In this paper I set forth a phonetic basis for explaining the weakening of the Spanish vibrant by examining some of the key production aspects of trills and considering the interaction of these in the communicative process that requires language forms to be encoded and subsequently decoded. The working hypothesis is that changes occurring in place, manner, and voicing of the apical vibrant stem from natural physiologi- cal limitations in producing the aerodynamic event that characterizes the sound and that the resulting allophonic consequences are closely related. Before proceeding with this analysis, I will briefly review other accounts of the problem(s) and discuss the nature of general phonetic tendencies as they relate to the manifestation of sound change in particular language systems. PHONETIC MOTIVATION FOR VARIATION IN SPANISH TRILLS 53 2. Models of /r/ variation and change Formalist phonological theory maintains that the reasons for phonetic change transcend the mechanical operation of the speech and hearing appa- ratus. It is presumed that change occurs at a broader, systemic level of lin- guistic function independent of the day to day interaction of speaker-hearers. The stimulus for system-wide change may be internal, such as the exis- tence of structural imbalances or the development of cognitive processing inefficiencies, or external, as in the adoption of the language by new users with different linguistic backgrounds and communicative needs. A fairly common extralinguistic account ascribed both to /r/ velarization and assibilation centers on the influence of languages in contact with Spanish. The uvular [R] predominate in the Caribbean has been attrib- uted variously to French, African, and indigenous populations (CUÉLLAR 1971: 20). Likewise, the assibilated [r] is claimed to have arisen due to contact between Spanish and other systems such as Basque, English, and Native American languages (CARDENAS 1958: 412). Evidence for this assertion is rather tenuous due to the geographic spread of the phenom- ena when compared to the historical settlement patterns of these groups. For example, it has been found that in those areas where the adstrat influence was greatest, phonetic variation of the trill is minimal and vice-versa (NAVARRO TOMAS 1966: 94). One advantage of analyzing the data system-internally is that it pro- vides a more uniform account of phenomena that affect large groups of Spanish speakers. For example, DE GRANDA argues that the standing quantitative correlation between the tap and trilled alveolar phones, the latter viewed at least conceptually as a multiple occurrence of the for- mer, does not fit well with other contrasts in the adjoining phonological space (1969: 4). MALMBERG claims that the assibilation of the normative vibrant follows the historical pattern in Spanish to convert the Latin sim- ple-geminate distinction into one of quality, a change already realized on nasal and lateral sounds (1950: 142). With respect to [™], GUITART (1982) suggests that this articulatory backing conforms with a larger ten- dency affecting other phonemes in the system, such as commonly occurs in the case of s-aspiration (/s/ → [h]) and nasal velarization (/n/ → [∞]). Similar arguments appealing to general organizational principles that oversee the representation and retrieval of language forms may account for the same variation. For example, velarization of /r/ in Spanish may be analyzed as an adjustment in phonological rules and/or a simplifica- tion in the specification of features that introduce economies into the system. In either case, since the variation is motivated by factors which affect the entire language system it becomes easier to justify the wide- spread variation apparent in the data. 54 K. WIDDISON However, nonphonetic models such as those outlined above fall short of adequately explaining the variation exhibited by the Spanish trill in two important ways. First, they fail to recognize parallel developments in vibrant sounds occurring in other language systems. For example, velarization of trills is not unique to dialectal Spanish but also occurs in many areas of contemporary Brazilian Portuguese. In Parisian French, a uvular1 phone of recent historical origin has acquired prestige status while the older alveolar trill persists in the provinces. In fact, the same directional shift has occurred in dialects of many other European lan- guages for which the primitive form of /r/ was undoubtedly the vibrant, including German, Dutch, Danish, Swedish, Norwegian, and Northern Italian (MALMBERG 1963: 46). This cross-linguistic correspondence sug- gests that the causal forces motivating the pattern likely represent gen- eral phonetic tendencies constraining all language systems. A narrow, language-internal perspective runs the risk of missing this important generalization. It should be noted that a phonetic universal constraint that favors the velarization of alveolar trills does not imply that such a course of action must be realized in all relevant language systems. This is no more nec- essary than a claim that language-specific pressures must result categor- ically in a given variant throughout the entire speech community. A gen- eral phonetic tendency merely provides the impetus for eventual sound change to occur if the emerging habit gains societal acceptance. The fact that the change is carried out completely in some languages, incom- pletely in others, and not at all in others, is strictly
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Phonological Domains Within Blackfoot Towards a Family-Wide Comparison
    Phonological domains within Blackfoot Towards a family-wide comparison Natalie Weber 52nd algonquian conference yale university October 23, 2020 Outline 1. Background 2. Two phonological domains in Blackfoot verbs 3. Preverbs are not a separate phonological domain 4. Parametric variation 2 / 59 Background 3 / 59 Consonant inventory Labial Coronal Dorsal Glottal Stops p pː t tː k kː ʔ <’> Assibilants ts tːs ks Pre-assibilants ˢt ˢtː Fricatives s sː x <h> Nasals m mː n nː Glides w j <y> (w) Long consonants written with doubled letters. (Derrick and Weber n.d.; Weber 2020) 4 / 59 Predictable mid vowels? (Frantz 2017) Many [ɛː] and [ɔː] arise from coalescence across boundaries ◦ /a+i/ ! [ɛː] ◦ /a+o/ ! [ɔː] Vowel inventory front central back high i iː o oː mid ɛː <ai> ɔː <ao> low a aː (Derrick and Weber n.d.; Weber 2020) 5 / 59 Vowel inventory front central back high i iː o oː mid ɛː <ai> ɔː <ao> low a aː Predictable mid vowels? (Frantz 2017) Many [ɛː] and [ɔː] arise from coalescence across boundaries ◦ /a+i/ ! [ɛː] ◦ ! /a+o/ [ɔː] (Derrick and Weber n.d.; Weber 2020) 5 / 59 Contrastive mid vowels Some [ɛː] and [ɔː] are morpheme-internal, in overlapping environments with other long vowels JɔːníːtK JaːníːtK aoníít aaníít [ao–n/i–i]–t–Ø [aan–ii]–t–Ø [hole–by.needle/ti–ti1]–2sg.imp–imp [say–ai]–2sg.imp–imp ‘pierce it!’ ‘say (s.t.)!’ (Weber 2020) 6 / 59 Syntax within the stem Intransitive (bi-morphemic) vs. syntactically transitive (trimorphemic). Transitive V is object agreement (Quinn 2006; Rhodes 1994) p [ root –v0 –V0 ] Stem type Gloss ikinn –ssi AI ‘he is warm’ ikinn –ii II ‘it is warm’ itap –ip/i –thm TA ‘take him there’ itap –ip/ht –oo TI ‘take it there’ itap –ip/ht –aki AI(+O) ‘take (s.t.) there’ (Déchaine and Weber 2015, 2018; Weber 2020) 7 / 59 Syntax within the verbal complex Template p [ person–(preverb)*– [ –(med)–v–V ] –I0–C0 ] CP vP root vP CP ◦ Minimal verbal complex: stem plus suffixes (I0,C0).
    [Show full text]
  • The Role of Morphology in Generative Phonology, Autosegmental Phonology and Prosodic Morphology
    Chapter 20: The role of morphology in Generative Phonology, Autosegmental Phonology and Prosodic Morphology 1 Introduction The role of morphology in the rule-based phonology of the 1970’s and 1980’s, from classic GENERATIVE PHONOLOGY (Chomsky and Halle 1968) through AUTOSEGMENTAL PHONOLOGY (e.g., Goldsmith 1976) and PROSODIC MORPHOLOGY (e.g., McCarthy & Prince 1999, Steriade 1988), is that it produces the inputs on which phonology operates. Classic Generative, Autosegmental, and Prosodic Morphology approaches to phonology differ in the nature of the phonological rules and representations they posit, but converge in one key assumption: all implicitly or explicitly assume an item-based morphological approach to word formation, in which root and affix morphemes exist as lexical entries with underlying phonological representations. The morphological component of grammar selects the morphemes whose underlying phonological representations constitute the inputs on which phonological rules operate. On this view of morphology, the phonologist is assigned the task of identifying a set of general rules for a given language that operate correctly on the inputs provided by the morphology of that language to produce grammatical outputs. This assignment is challenging for a variety of reasons, sketched below; as a group, these reasons helped prompt the evolution from classic Generative Phonology to its Autosegmental and Prosodic descendants, and have since led to even more dramatic modifications in the way that morphology and phonology interact (see Chapter XXX). First, not all phonological rules apply uniformly across all morphological contexts. For example, Turkish palatal vowel harmony requires suffix vowels to agree with the preceding stem vowels (paşa ‘pasha’, paşa-lar ‘pasha-PL’; meze ‘appetizer’, meze-ler ‘appetizer-PL’) but does not apply within roots (elma ‘apple’, anne ‘mother’).
    [Show full text]
  • Assibilation Or Analogy?: Reconsideration of Korean Noun Stem-Endings*
    Assibilation or analogy?: Reconsideration of Korean noun stem-endings* Ponghyung Lee (Daejeon University) This paper discusses two approaches to the nominal stem-endings in Korean inflection including loanwords: one is the assibilation approach, represented by H. Kim (2001) and the other is the analogy approach, represented by Albright (2002 et sequel) and Y. Kang (2003b). I contend that the assibilation approach is deficient in handling its underapplication to the non-nominal categories such as verb. More specifically, the assibilation approach is unable to clearly explain why spirantization (s-assibilation) applies neither to derivative nouns nor to non-nominal items in its entirety. By contrast, the analogy approach is able to overcome difficulties involved with the assibilation position. What is crucial to the analogy approach is that the nominal bases end with t rather than s. Evidence of t-ending bases is garnered from the base selection criteria, disparities between t-ending and s-ending inputs in loanwords. Unconventionally, I dare to contend that normative rules via orthography intervene as part of paradigm extension, alongside semantic conditioning and token/type frequency. Keywords: inflection, assibilation, analogy, base, affrication, spirantization, paradigm extension, orthography, token/type frequency 1. Introduction When it comes to Korean nominal inflection, two observations have captivated our attention. First, multiple-paradigms arise, as explored in previous literature (K. Ko 1989, Kenstowicz 1996, Y. Kang 2003b, Albright 2008 and many others).1 (1) Multiple-paradigms of /pʰatʰ/ ‘red bean’ unmarked nom2 acc dat/loc a. pʰat pʰaʧʰ-i pʰatʰ-ɨl pʰatʰ-e b. pʰat pʰaʧʰ-i pʰaʧʰ-ɨl pʰatʰ-e c.
    [Show full text]
  • Palatals in Spanish and French: an Analysis Rachael Gray
    Florida State University Libraries Honors Theses The Division of Undergraduate Studies 2012 Palatals in Spanish and French: An Analysis Rachael Gray Follow this and additional works at the FSU Digital Library. For more information, please contact [email protected] Abstract (Palatal, Spanish, French) This thesis deals with palatals from Latin into Spanish and French. Specifically, it focuses on the diachronic history of each language with a focus on palatals. I also look at studies that have been conducted concerning palatals, and present a synchronic analysis of palatals in modern day Spanish and French. The final section of this paper focuses on my research design in second language acquisition of palatals for native French speakers learning Spanish. 2 THE FLORIDA STATE UNIVERSITY COLLEGE OF ARTS AND SCIENCES PALATALS IN SPANISH AND FRENCH: AN ANALYSIS BY: RACHAEL GRAY A Thesis submitted to the Department of Modern Languages in partial fulfillment of the requirements for graduation with Honors in the Major Degree Awarded: 3 Spring, 2012 The members of the Defense Committee approve the thesis of Rachael Gray defended on March 21, 2012 _____________________________________ Professor Carolina Gonzaléz Thesis Director _______________________________________ Professor Gretchen Sunderman Committee Member _______________________________________ Professor Eric Coleman Outside Committee Member 4 Contents Acknowledgements ......................................................................................................................... 5 0.
    [Show full text]
  • Chapter XIII: After the French Invasion
    Chapter XIII: After the French Invasion • Introduction • 1066 Battle of Hastings (William the Conqueror) • The Norman Invasion established French as the language of England. • The Normans were originally Vikings (Norman= North + Man) • William established himself as King William I. • Redistributed the lands among his supporters. Ling 110 Chapter XIII: After the 1 French Partition Introduction • Consequently, Norman French became the prestige language in England (government, justice, & education). • English was spoken by only second class citizens. • This social situation had significant consequences for the English language- penetrated the lexicon and the grammar. • English lost the inflectional morphology characteristic of the Germanic languages. • The word order of English came to resemble French word order more than Germanic. Ling 110 Chapter XIII: After the 2 French Partition Introduction con’t • Social stratification can be observed when comparing native words and French borrowings from the same semantic domain. Example: • English French • pig pork • chicken poultry • cow beef • sheep mutton • calf veal The animal is English; the food is French. Illustrating who was tending the animals and who was eating them. Ling 110 Chapter XIII: After the 3 French Partition Introduction con’t • English has borrowed continuously from Latin. • Beginning in the Middle English period, from French. • This pattern of borrowing establishes the opportunity for English to borrow the same word at different points in its history. • Example: English borrowed humility from Latin. The word developed in French and was borrowed again into English as humble. • Two changes have occurred: – The i of humil has been deleted. – A b has been inserted between m and l.
    [Show full text]
  • Assibilation in Trans-New Guinea Languages of the Bird's Head Region
    Assibilation in Trans-New Guinea languages of the Bird’s Head region Fanny Cottet Department of Linguistics College of Asia and the Pacific The Australian National University [email protected] Before enlarging the scope to other TNG languages of the Abstract region, the phonological and acoustic properties of Mbahám Previous studies have shown that assibilation of voiced stops assibilation are presented. Mbahám has been tentatively is less common than assibilation of voiceless stops, the former classified as a TNG language of the Bomberai sub-branch. Iha requiring complex and competing aerodynamic conditions to is the only language to which Mbahám is directly related; be produced. The present study reveals that voiced assibilation extended relations to other TNG languages are still under is found synchronically in various Trans-New Guinea investigation. The author is currently working on the phonetic languages of the Bird’s Head region, with the Mbahám and phonological description on the northern variety of the peculiarity that assibilation affects prenasalized voiced stops, a language spoken in the Kokas area (app. 200 speakers). case which has not been described previously. This paper reports new empirical data from previous understudied 2. Mbahám assibilation languages and provides evidences for a new treatment of the phonological inventory of these languages. 2.1. Phonological description In Mbahám, /t/ and /ⁿd/ assibilate before a sequence of two Index Terms: assibilation, Papuan languages, phonology, vocoids whose first segment is [+high]. Examples are given in phonetics, reconstruction. table 1. The triggering segment is realized either in a stressed or an unstressed syllable. In the latter case, the vocoid does not 1.
    [Show full text]
  • Asymmetries and Generalizations in the Repair of Early French Minimally-Rising Syllable-Contact Clusters Francisco Antonio Montaño, Lehman College (CUNY)
    Asymmetries and generalizations in the repair of early French minimally-rising syllable-contact clusters Francisco Antonio Montaño, Lehman College (CUNY) The Gallo-Romance (GR) (5th-10th c.) reflexes of Late Latin syncope (Pope 1952; Dumas 1993; Hartkemeyer 2000) provide a unique perspective into the interaction of sonority and phonotactic markedness constraints with faithfulness constraints within the phonology. With the deletion of a pre-tonic or post-tonic short vowel in GR syncopated forms, the preservation, modification, and loss of stranded consonants and neighboring segments occurring in unique clustering permutations reveal a range of repairs on resulting syllable-contact clusters (SCCs). While falling-sonority (manica > manche 'sleeve') and sufficiently-rising obstruent-liquid clusters (tabula > table 'table') unsurprisingly resyllabify without issue into either licit hetero- (SCC) or tautosyllabic (onset) clusters, preserving all consonantal material in the syncopated output, minimally-rising clusters whose final segment is a sonorant undergo diverse repairs to escape eventual total loss, attested only for SCCs containing obstruent codas via gemination then degemination, in avoidance of obstruent-obstruent SCCs (radi[ts]ina > ra[ts]ine 'root', debita > dette > dete 'debt'). Minimally-rising clusters (obstruent-nasal, sibilant-liquid, nasal-liquid), unharmonic both as heterosyllabic clusters due to rising sonority and as onset clusters due to an excessively shallow rise in sonority, undergo a range of phonological repairs including assibilation (platanu > pla[ð]ne > plasne 'plane tree'), rhotacization (ordine > ordre 'order'), and stop epenthesis (cisera > cisdre 'cider'; cumulum > comble 'peak'; camera > chambre 'room'; molere > moldre 'grind.INF' but cf. /rl/ without epenthesis, e.g. merula > merle 'blackbird', evidencing its falling sonority), in order to conform to licensing requirements within the syllable and phonological word (Montaño 2017).
    [Show full text]
  • 21. Vowel Height : the Blackwell Companion To
    Bibliographic Details The Blackwell Companion to Phonology Edited by: Marc van Oostendorp, Colin J. Ewen, Elizabeth Hume and Keren Rice eISBN:21. Vowel 9781405184236 Height DouglasPrint publication Pulleyblank date: 2011 Sections 1 Introduction 2 Phonetics of vowel height 3 Vowel height typology 4 Phonological height patterns 5 Features for height 6 Conclusion Notes ACKNOWLEDGMENS REFERENCES 1 Introduction While all languages have vowels, and all vowels can be described as having a height,1 actually defining vowel height turns out to be a rather interesting problem (see also CHAPTER 1919: VOWEL PLACE). Consider the systems in (1). It would be fairly uncontroversial to assume that a two-vowel system such as (1a) distinguishes between two vowel heights and that a five-vowel system such as (1b) distinguishes between three heights (although see below). The number of “heights” in the seven- and ten-vowel systems, however, depends on various factors. One view of a ten-vowel system such as (1d) is that it involves three “heights” (high, mid, low) cross-cut by a tongue-root feature; an alternative is that such a system involves a highly differentiated height feature with six heights. A seven-vowel pattern such as (1c) presents more analytic indeterminacy. One possibility is to analyze such a pattern as a simplified version of the ten-vowel system: a three-height system with a tongue-root distinction in the mid vowels, or a four-height system with a differentiated height pattern as in (1d), but with four rather than six distinctions. An additional possibility is to consider the seven-vowel and ten-vowel systems to be qualitatively different: while a ten-vowel inventory like (1d) could be analyzed as involving three heights plus a tongue-root distinction, a seven-vowel inventory like (1c) could be seen as involving four heights (and no tongue-root distinction).
    [Show full text]
  • Dissertation FINAL
    Gradience and Variability of Intervocalic /s/ Voicing in Highland Ecuadorian Spanish Dissertation Presented in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree Doctor of Philosophy in the Graduate School of The Ohio State University By Christina Marie García Graduate Program in Spanish and Portuguese The Ohio State University 2015 Dissertation Committee: Dr. Terrell A. Morgan, Advisor Dr. Rebeka Campos-Astorkiza, Advisor Dr. Scott Schwenter Dr. Anna M. Babel Copyright by Christina Marie García 2015 ABSTRACT This dissertation focuses on Highland Ecuadorian Spanish (HES), more specifically in the city of Loja, exploring how linguistic and social factors interact to condition a sound change in progress. While Lojano Spanish has many distinctive features, I examine intervocalic /s/ voicing, that is the variable pronunciation of /s/ as [s] or [z] (for example [losamiɣos] ~ [lozamiɣos] ‘the friends’). This feature has been attested in a few modern dialects of Spanish, most prominently in HES (cf. Robinson 1979) and Catalonian Spanish (McKinnon 2012, Davidson 2014). The present work provides a comprehensive look at this feature in Lojano Spanish by investigating both production and perception. First, I analyze the production of this feature by carrying out a detailed acoustic analysis of 31 recordings with native Lojanos. These recordings were collected during two fieldwork trips spent in Loja in 2010 and 2013. The recordings include both sociolinguistic interviews, as well as a reading task. I measured over 2,969 tokens of /s/ for percent voicing and examined the influence of the following factors: word position, stress, speech rate, preceding/following vowel, and participants’ age and gender. Voicing is analyzed as both a continuous dependent variable (percent voicing) as well as a categorical variable (voicing category).
    [Show full text]
  • UC Berkeley Phonlab Annual Report
    UC Berkeley UC Berkeley PhonLab Annual Report Title Turbulence &amp; Phonology Permalink https://escholarship.org/uc/item/4kp306rx Journal UC Berkeley PhonLab Annual Report, 4(4) ISSN 2768-5047 Authors Ohala, John J Solé, Maria-Josep Publication Date 2008 DOI 10.5070/P74kp306rx eScholarship.org Powered by the California Digital Library University of California UC Berkeley Phonology Lab Annual Report (2008) Turbulence & Phonology John J. Ohala* & Maria-Josep Solé # *Department of Linguistics, University of California, Berkeley [email protected] #Department of English, Universitat Autònoma de Barcelona, Spain [email protected] In this paper we aim to provide an account of some of the phonological patterns involving turbulent sounds, summarizing material we have published previously and results from other investigators. In addition, we explore the ways in which sounds pattern, combine, and evolve in language and how these patterns can be derived from a few physical and perceptual principles which are independent from language itself (Lindblom 1984, 1990a) and which can be empirically verified (Ohala and Jaeger 1986). This approach should be contrasted with that of mainstream phonological theory (i.e., phonological theory within generative linguistics) which primarily considers sound structure as motivated by ‘formal’ principles or constraints that are specific to language, rather than relevant to other physical or cognitive domains. For this reason, the title of this paper is meant to be ambiguous. The primary sense of it refers to sound patterns in languages involving sounds with turbulence, e.g., fricatives and stops bursts, but a secondary meaning is the metaphorical turbulence in the practice of phonology over the past several decades.
    [Show full text]
  • Phasebased Constraints Within Match Theory
    Phase­based Constraints within Match Theory Natalie Weber Yale University 1 Introduction Research on prosodic phonology over the past 40 years has shown that prosodic structure is closely related to syntactic structure, but may mismatch in ways that are phonologically optimizing (cf. Downing, 1999; Inkelas, 1990; Ladd, 2008; Nespor & Vogel, 2007; Selkirk, 1986, 2011; Truckenbrodt, 1999). One aspect of this research concerns the syntactic constituents which are relevant for prosodic structure. In general, lexical heads (X0 in X­bar theory; Jackendoff 1977) correspond by default to prosodic words, and maximal projections (XP) correspond to phonological phrases. However, there are phonological and syntactic reasons to extend theories of phrasal correspondences “below the word”. In terms of phonology, many languages have phonological domains which correspond to morphological units smaller than the inflected word. Because of this, many theories of the syntax­phonology interface allow correspondences between morphological constituents like the stem and morphophonological constituents like the Prosodic Stem (e.g. Downing, 1999; Inkelas, 1990; McCarthy & Prince, 1993a; Nespor & Vogel, 2007). In terms of syntax, Bare Phrase Structure (Chomsky, 1995) erases any distinction between X0 and XP. Because of this, recent constructionist theories argue that complex words are constructed using the same syntactic principles which underlie phrases (Borer, 2013; Halle & Marantz, 1993; Marantz, 1997; Starke, 2009). These developments in phonology and syntax raise the possibility that phrasal and word­internal prosodic constituents could be defined by correspondence to phrasal syntactic constituents, without relying on language­specific morphological definitions. This paper takes this idea seriously by analyzing the prosodic and syntactic structure of the verbal complex in Blackfoot (Algonquian; Frantz 2017), a polysynthetic, strongly head­marking language.
    [Show full text]
  • Phonological Aspects of Western Nilotic Mutation Morphology
    Phonological Aspects of Western Nilotic Mutation Morphology Habilitationsschrift zur Erlangung des akademischen Grades Dr. phil. habil. der Philologischen Fakultat¨ der Universitat¨ Leipzig eingereicht von Dr. Jochen Trommer geb. 13.12.1970, Neustadt an der Waldnaab angefertigt am Institut fur¨ Linguistik Beschluss uber¨ die Verleihung des akademischen Grades vom: 24. Juli 2011 “Can there be any rebirth where there is no transmigration?” “Yes there can” “Just as a man can light one oil lamp from another “but nothing moves from one lamp to the other” “Or as a pupil can learn a verse by heart from a teacher “but the verse does not transmigrate from teacher to pupil” Chapter 1 Problems It is the cornerstone of non-traditional linguistics that a lexicon of a language consists of ar- bitrary pairs of morphological and phonological representations: morphemes. In this book, I want to defend the hypothesis that the interface of Phonology and Morphology is essen- tially blind to this arbitrariness: Morphology is not allowed to manipulate the phonological shape of morphemes. Phonology is barred to access the identity and idiosyncratic features of morphemes. Morphology may not convey diacritic symbols to Phonology allowing to iden- tify (classes of) morphemes, or control the operation of phonological processes for the sake of specific morphemes (see Scheer 2004, Bermudez-Otero´ 2011, for similar positions). This excludes many theoretical devices which are standardly used to derive non-concatenative mor- phology: Word Formation Rules (Anderson 1992): Morphological rules equipped with the full power of derivational phonological rules in classical Generative Phonology (Chomsky and Halle 1968). Readjustment Rules (Halle and Marantz 1993, Embick and Halle 2005, Embick 2010): Phono- logical rules which are triggered by the morphosyntactic context and a standard means in Distributed-Morphology to capture ablaut and similar patterns.
    [Show full text]