J He Is a Friend to the Defeated, Too, Except That They Never Return This Friendship
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
FRIENDSHIP IN THE LIFE AND POETKY OF EDWIN ARLINGTON ROBINSON APPROVED: fh$U/.A~ Jh Major Professor Minov Professor g. j>. * Directo •* of the Department of English Demi of the Graduate School FRIENDSHIP IN THE LIFE AND POETRY OF EDWIN ARLINGTON ROBINSON THESIS Presented to the Graduate Council of the North Texas State University in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements For the Degree of MASTER OF ARTS By- Don Ballew Graham, B. A. Denton, Texas August, 1964 TABLE OF CONTENTS Chapter Page I. INTRODUCTION 1 II. ROBINSON AND HIS FRIENDS ..... T HI. THE THEME OF FRIENDSHIP IN THE SHORTER POEMS 46 IV. THE THEME OF FRIENDSHIP IN THE LONGER POEMS 30 V. CONCLUSION 178 BIBLIOGRAPHY 188 iii CHAPTER I INTRODUCTION Friendship occupies an extremely significant place in. the life and poetry of Edwin Arlington Robinson, There is indeed a vital connection between, the role friendship played in his life and the poetry he published. For without the help of a great number of friends, Robinson would prob- ably n«ver have written as much as he did. Friends aided him in a variety of ways: they provided companionship, encouraged his high sense of purpose, secured Mm publishers, wrote in praia© of his work, found him jobs and living quarters, and gave him money. Few men have ever owed as much to their friends as Robinson owed to Ms, Friendship, or what Ridgely Torrence has called the "cult of friendship,1,1 pervades the two realms of hie existence s his life and his art. As a concrete basis for his survival and as oae of the highest values in his life, friendship overflowed quite naturally into Robinson's poetry. His first two volumes. The Torrent and the Night Before (1896) and The Children of the Night (1897)? contain several poems like "Dear Friends, " "An Old Story, " and "On the Night of a Friend's Wedding" ^Ridgely Torrence, Introduction to Selected Letters of Edwin Arlington Robinaon (New York, 1940), p. viii. which deal with the nature, problems, and complexities of friendship. These short poems introduce aspects of the friendship theme that recur in poem after poem down the long stretch of Robinson's productivity. An early narrative like Lancelot (1920) poses the question of betrayal, and Robinson's last work, King Jasper (1935), poses the same question. From the beginning to end, over a span of forty-odd years of poetic creativity, the friendship theme is present and often supremely important in Robinson's works. The fact of friendship as a main force in Robinson's personal development has received much attention from biographers. Robinson's 2 3 primary biographers, Hermann Hagedorn and Emery Neff, have shown clearly the many valuable services that friends performed for Robinson. They have also revealed the qualities that made Robinson himself such a good friend. In addition, they have held up individual poems such as "Dear Friends" and Captain Craig as examples of poetic expression having ©merged from incidents revolving around friendship in Robinson's life. Neither writer, however, has probed beyond the sur- face the theme of friendship as a constant, continuing thread running through a large number of the poems. Other biographical material about 2 Hermann Hagedorn, Edwin Arlington Robinson: A Bioeraphv (New York, 1938), pp. 112, 187, 2l7, 247. — 3 Emery Neff, Edwin Arlington Robinson (New York. 1948). dd. 111. 130, 139, 171. ^ ~ Robinson ha® also centered upon friendship in the life rather than in the poetry. Several of Robinson's close friends have written useful pieces about him. (Hagedorn, incidentally, was also a close friend, J Walter Rollo Brown's Next Door to a Poet, Esther Willard Bates's Edwin Arlington Robinaon and His Manuscripts, and Laura E. Richards'8 E. A. R. all stress aspects of Robinson's personality, his shyness and reserve for instance, without throwing much light on friendship in either his life or poetry, Two other biographical articles, Denham Sutcliffe's intro- duction to Untriangulated Stars : Letters of Edwin Arlington Robinson to Harry de Forest Smith, 1890-1905 and Ridgely Torrence's introduction to Selected Letters of Edwin Arlington Robinson, comment upon friendship in the life but do not mention friendship in the poetry. Although there has been considerable and fruitful effort on the part of biographers to show the importance of friendship in Robinson's life, there has been almost no attempt by either biographers or critics to illuminate friendship as a major theme in the poetry. Critics have dealt profusely with other dominant themes, such as those of failure, the assertion of spiritual values over material values, and the quest for the Light, and have mentioned friendship only in relation to poems ob- viously concerned with the subject, such as "Reunion" and "Ben Jons on Entertains a Man from Stratford. » Critical works by Lloyd R. Morris, Ben Ray Redman, Mark Van Doren, Charles Cestre, Estelle Kaplan, 4 and Yvor Winters have all overlooked friendship as a theme worthy of separate consideration. Only Ellsworth Barnard in his book Edwin- Arlington Robinson: A Critical Study has devoted any time at all to the thematic implications of friendship in the poetry. Scholarship of Robinson1® works in periodicals has been confined mostly to interpre- tations of individual poems; and, as compared with the numerous articles appearing steadily on such poets as T. S. Eliot and Robert Frost, there has not been much scholarly interest in any aspect of Robinson's art. The theme of friendship has been almost wholly neglected, Barnard's comments on the importance of friendship in Robinson's poetry are worth looking at; the seven pages he has written about this subject are the fullest treatment of the theme of friendship in print, Barnard finds in the poems recurring emphasis on elements such as these: a belief in human brotherhood, the virtue of loyalty in friendship, the inevitable widening of friendships as the friends grow older, the need for helping others, a respect for the individuality of friends, and the 4 8in of self-centeredness. Values such as altruism and loyalty are identified by Barnard as having their direct source in Robinson's adrair- 5 able relationships with Ms friends, In hi® discussion Barnard mentions the following poems as illustrative of friendship acting as a principal 4 Ellsworth Barnard, Edwin Arlington Robinson; A Critical Study (Hew York, 1952), pp. 242-248. ^ 5Ibid., p. 244. concern: "Alma Mater, " The Glory of the Nightingales, Roman Barthoiow, Captain Craig, "The Long Race, " "Reunion, " "Clavering, " "The Cor- ridor* M "Flammonde, " "Glass Houses, " and "Two Gardens in Linn dale. " As will be seen later, these are but a handful of this poems that deal meaningfully with friendship, Barnard has provided a starting point; he has recognised friendship as a concern of several poems. Still, however, he does not nam# friendship as a dominant theme. And, while he doe® mention some of the narratives in connection with friendship, he does not elaborate upon friendship as an independent, vital theme in the narra* tives. Moreover, he does not even register one of the pervading and powerful motifs of the theme—betrayal. These omissions by Barnard ax® common to every critic of Robinson; not one has examined the subject of friendship in either the short poems or in the narratives as completely as the theme merits. The aim of this thesis is twofold! to recapitulate the influence® o£ friendship upon Robinson's life and to explore in depth the theme of friend- ship as it is revealed in the short poems and in the narratives, Little attempt will be made to correlate specific poems with specific incidents in Robinson's life. One does not, after all, always gain very much from the searching for the roots of a poem. Robinson himself in a letter to L» M* Chase (July 11, 1917) commented on the fruitlessnesa of such en- deavor in regard to his works : I do not recall anything of mine that is a direct transcription of experience. The second chapter will confine itself primarily to a sketch of how friends helped shape Robinson's life and how he himself behaved as a friend to others. The third chapter will attempt to elucidate the friendship theme in the short poems. The fourth chapter will analyze friendship in the narratives, in which the theme receives its most comprehensive expression. It is hoped that from this study two things will emerge: a clearer understanding of a humane and civilized Individual who had, as a friend said, a "genius for 7 friendship, " and, above all, a deeper knowledge of the poetry Robinson's friends helped bequeath to the world. 6 Edwin Arlington Robinson, Selected Letters of Edwin Arlington Robinson (New York, 1940), p. 103. ?Laura E. Richards, £. A. R. (Cambridge, Mass. , 1936), p. 26. CHAPTER II ROBINSON AND HIS FRIENDS E, A. Robinson possessed a rare ability to make friends. Yet there was an essential paradox in this gift of friendship. He was not, as one might expect, an extrovert, a backslapper, but was instead the very oppo- site. His shyness at the height of his fame was almost legendary. In a crowd--a crowd for Robinson being any group of over eight people he seldom spoke; when he did, what he said was often inane. And he was lonely much of his life; he never married; women at close range generally mortified him. Yet this lonely, inordinately shy man was able to make an exceptional number of lifetime friends. Despite his shyness and in* articulateness, he had qualities that meant something. He once said of the colors of hia poetry, when they were termed as browns and blacks and grays by a critical acquaintance at MacDowell's, that they were pretty fast colors.