Fernando Armstrong-Fumero Julio Hoil Gutierrez Legacies of Space
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Archaeology, Ethnohistory, LEA G CIES OF and the Politics of Cultural SPACE AND Continuity in the Americas INTANGIBLE edited by Fernando Armstrong-Fumero HERITAGE Julio Hoil Gutierrez LEGACIES OF SPACE AND INTANGIBLE HERITAGE LEGACIES OF SPACE AND INTANGIBLE HERITAGE A rchaeology, Ethnohistory, and the Politics of Cultural Continuity in the Americas EDIT ED BY F ernando Armstrong-Fumero and Julio Hoil Gutierrez University Press of Colorado Boulder © 2017 by University Press of Colorado Published by University Press of Colorado 5589 Arapahoe Avenue, Suite 206C Boulder, Colorado 80303 All rights reserved Printed in the United States of America The University Press of Colorado is a proud member of The Association of American University Presses. The UniversityP ress of Colorado is a cooperative publishing enterprise supported, in part, by Adams State University, Colorado State University, Fort Lewis College, Metropolitan State University of Denver, Regis University, University of Colorado, University of Northern Colorado, Utah State University, and Western State Colorado University. ∞ This paper meets the requirements of theA NSI/NISO Z39.48-1992 (Permanence of Paper). ISBN: 978-1-60732-571-0 (cloth) ISBN: 978-1-60732-659-5 (paperback) ISBN: 978-1-60732-572-7 (ebook) Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Names: Armstrong-Fumero, Fernando, editor. | Hoil Gutierrez, Julio, editor. Title: Legacies of space and intangible heritage : archaeology, ethnohistory, and the politics of cultural continuity in the Americas / edited by Fernando Armstrong-Fumero and Julio Hoil Gutierrez. Description: Boulder : University Press of Colorado, [2017] | Includes bibliographical references and index. Identifiers: LCCN 2016056647| ISBN 9781607325710 (cloth) | ISBN 9781607326595 (pbk) | ISBN 9781607325727 (ebook) Subjects: LCSH: Cultural landscapes—America—Case studies. | Cultural property—Protection— America—Case studies. | Cultural property—America—Management—Case studies. | Historic sites—Conservation and restoration—America—Case studies. | Historic sites—America— Management—Case studies. Classification: LCC GF500 .L44 2017 | DDC 973—dc23 LC record available at https://lccn.loc.gov/2016056647 An electronic version of this book is freely available, thanks to the support of libraries working with Knowledge Unlatched. KU is a collaborative initiative designed to make high-quality books open access for the public good. The open accessI SBN for the PDF version of this book is 978-1-60732-700-4; for the ePUB version the open access ISBN is 978-1- 60732-720-2. More information about the initiative and links to the open-access version can be found at www.knowledgeunlatched.org. Front-cover photographs: Taperinha Plantation (top), Cavern of the Painted Rock, Monte Alegre (bottom), courtesy of Anna C. Roosevelt. Contents List of Figures vii List of Tables ix C hapter 1. Introduction Fernando Armstrong-Fumero and Julio Hoil Gutierrez 3 C hapter 2. Settlement Patterns, Intangible Memory, and the Institutional Entanglements of Heritage in Modern Yucatán Fernando Armstrong-Fumero and Julio Hoil Gutierrez 15 C hapter 3. Hopisinmuy Wu’ya’mat Hisat Yang Tupqa’va Yeesiwngwu (Hopi Ancestors Lived in These Canyons) Maren P. Hopkins, Stuart B. Koyiyumptewa, Saul L. Hedquist, T. J. Ferguson, and Chip Colwell 33 C hapter 4. Designs on/of the Land: Competing Visions, Displacement, and Landscape Memory in British Colonial Honduras Christine Kray, Minette Church, and Jason Yaeger 53 v vi CONTENTS C hapter 5. Cultivating Community: The Archaeology of Japanese American Confinement at Amache Bonnie Clark 79 C hapter 6. Indigenous House Plans and Land in Mexico City (Sixteenth Century): Reflections on the Buying and Selling, Inheritance, and Conflicts Surrounding Houses and Land Keiko Yoneda (translated by Hannah Becker) 97 C hapter 7. The Archaeology of Place in Ebtún, Yucatán, Mexico Rani T. Alexander 131 C hapter 8. Names, Naming, and Person Reference in Quiahije Chatino Emiliana Cruz 163 C hapter 9. A Culturescape Built over 5,000 Years, Archaeology, and Vichama Raymi in the Forge of History Winifred Creamer, Jonathan Haas, and Henry Marcelo Castillo 189 C hapter 10. Interpreting Long-Term Human-Environment Interaction in Amazonia Anna C. Roosevelt 209 Contributors 239 Index 241 Figures . 3.1 Hopitutskwa as imagined as a pilgrimage route 36 3.2. Hopi Reservation in relation to Black Mesa, Glen Canyon, and US Highway 160 41 3.3. Hopi project participants and anthropologists at Glen Canyon 43 3.4. Toko’navi (Navajo Mountain) 44 3.5. Pictograph at ancient site in GLCA 46 3.6. Warrior images at GLCA 47 3.7. Sample of places with Hopi names on Highway 160 47 4.1. British Honduras in late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries 54 4.2. Valentín Tosh and Ementerio Cantún of San José Nuevo 57 4.3. Fragment of incendiary rocket 60 4.4. Jamaica Ginger bottles 62 4.5. Ceramics from San Pedro Siris 63 5.1. War Relocation Authority camps 80 5.2. Amache showing internee landscaping 84 5.3. Block 9L at Amache 85 5.4. Garden Plot in Block 9L 86 vii viii FSIGURE 5.5. Excavation crew chief and former internee volunteer talk 91 6.1. Plan 9 99 6.2. Plan 9 bis 107 6.3. Toponymic glyph 110 6.4. Architectural complex at Cholula 111 6.5. Plan 7 113 6.6. Plan 18 115 7.1. Map of Eastern Yucatán 134 7.2. Census document from Kaua in 1841 138 7.3. Shrine at Tzaab 148 7.4. Cenote at Bubul 150 8.1. Kitchen interaction 165 8.2. Cieneguilla seen from San Juan 165 8.3. Map of location-based names 167 8.4. The rstfi plane that landed in Cieneguilla 168 8.5. Map of Cieneguilla and San Juan Quiahije 169 8.6. Map of San Juan Quiahije, Cieneguilla, and Juquila 170 9.1. Map of the Norte Chico region 191 9.2. Maize, yuca, and pepino 193 9.3. Huancas 194 9.4. Figure of a woman 195 9.5. Photo of U-shaped layout of Caballete 198 9.6. Pageant at Fortress of Paramonga 202 10.1. Tropical forest at Taperinha 212 10.2. Floodplain and floodplain forest, Monte Alegre 214 10.3. Santarem period cultural black soil 218 10.4. Cavern of the painted rock 220 10.5. Paleo-Indian camp layer, Cavern of the Painted Rock 221 10.6. Taperinha Plantation 223 10.7. Cultural Forest, Marajó Island 224 10.8. Anthropic acai grove, Marajó Island 232 10.9. Paleo-Indian point curated by Cayapo community 233 Tables 7.1. Maya social organization 136 7.2. Population distribution in the study area 140 7.3. Household change in 1841, 1883, and 1890 141 7.4. Comparison of household size 142 7.5. Most numerous male surnames in 1841 144 7.6. Marriage patterns in 1841 144 7.7. Most Numerous Male Surnames in 1883 145 7.8. Marriage patterns in 1883 146 8.1. Teknonymy 173 8.2. Consanguinity terms 175 8.3. Coparenthood 177 8.4. Autonym 177 8.5. Ethnonym 177 8.6. Names derived from Spanish 179 8.7. Distribution of family names and place-names 180 8.8. Tones 183 8.9. Place-names 183 ix LEGACIES OF SPACE AND INTANGIBLE HERITAGE 1 Introduction Fernando Armstrong-Fumero and Julio Hoil Gutierrez Whether on the scale of a household, of a community, or of a much larger regional environment, spaces of human habitation are both historical records of our past and a key element in reproducing the knowledge and values that define our lives in the present. This process of cultural reproduction can be endangered when migra- tion, displacement, or changes in property regimes limit communities’ access to sites where they have important historical connections. Around the world, formal legal statutes, grassroots organizations, and local acts of resistance can play differ- ent roles in reasserting these connections between people and place. Accordingly, the claims that contemporary stakeholders make on archaeological sites and related landscape features extend beyond the simple desire for conservation or site preser- vation and include the rights to visit, inhabit, and even alter the physical composi- tion of these spaces. The essays in this volume are an interdisciplinary exploration of these intersec- tions between the study and management of physical sites and the reproduction of intangible cultural legacies. Some chapters focus on more abstract theoretical insights into societies’ relationship to different places and how this relationship fig- ures in the reproduction of cultural continuities amidst processes of social change. Other essays turn to more pragmatic ways in which these insights figure in contem- porary negotiations through which different groups seek greater access or control over culturally significant sites and landscapes.A s a group, they are meant to pro- vide a comparative body of case studies that explore the different ways in which DOI : 10.5876/9781607325727.c001 3 4 A RMSTRONG-FUMERO AND GuTIERREZ place is mediated by social, political, and ecological processes that have deep his- torical roots and that continue to effect the politics of heritage management today. The close relationship between physical space and more ephemeral manifesta- tions of culture and social organization are a common thread joining diverse currents of anthropological and archaeological research. Since the rise of New Archaeology in the 1960s and 1970s, archaeological research has focused on recon- structing long-term patterns of culture and social structure. Working “up” from the material traces of human behavior, the processualists and their various intellectual successors and competitors have been keenly attuned to the intimate and dynamic relationship between the materiality of space and the more intangible dimensions of human behavior and experience. In cultural and linguistic anthropology, a num- ber of theoretical currencies that focus on the intersections of space and culture gained prominence in the 1990s and 2000s. These range from studies of the spatial- ization of collective memory that were inspired by the work of Pierre Norá (1989), to linguistic analyses of the intimate relationship between patterns of reference and the social organization of space (Hanks 1990), to studies of environment that focus on the intimate ties between evolving ecosystems and patterns of settlement and subsistence (Ford and Nigh 2015; Gordillo 2004; Wright 2014).