DOCSLIB.ORG

Cultural Study of Three Highland Villages in Phỏng Lái Commune, Sơn La

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Cultural Study of Three Highland Villages in Phỏng Lái Commune, Sơn La MEASURING SMALLHOLDER LAND INVESTMENTS IN NORTHWEST VIETNAM: A CROSS- CULTURAL STUDY OF THREE HIGHLAND VILLAGES IN PHỎNG LÁI COMMUNE, SƠN LA PROVINCE by RICHARD CHRISTOPHER OWENS (Under the Direction of Bram Tucker) ABSTRACT In this dissertation, I investigate the connection between land tenure and the conservation of natural resources in the northwestern uplands of Vietnam (Sơn La province) through a focus on the political and economic forces that shape smallholder investment practices. Within a historically-informed context, I analyze and compare smallholder land use decisions among Kinh, Hmông, and Thái groups considering identity, cultural practices, and household economics. Recently, Vietnam has banned swidden agriculture in favor of the intensification of upland agriculture. To that purpose, it has provided technology, subsidies, and extension services targeted to lowland majority development models. During the course of this dissertation, I analyze soil conservation activities in three villages (between and within designs) and across the commune at the household level. Results from investment activities (short-term, long-term and household rate categories) show that smallholders’ long-term investments are significantly smaller in relation to household investments. I contend that there are a number of social, economic, and environmental reasons for why Hmông, Thái and Kinh are not making significant soil conservation investments. State policies aimed at suppressing swidden agriculture have been replaced with intensive upland farming, leading to increased erosion and land degradation. Traditional swidden systems do not require inputs, hence they are not receiving long-term investments. Upland farming is possible through the use of inorganic fertilizers that are necessary for HYV maize production. Examining the failure of the property rights to conserve natural resources this research makes a significant contribution to the theory of property rights This study considers the socio-cultural and economics dynamics of land title and natural resource management. INDEX WORDS: Vietnam, property rights, Red book Certificate, Investments, smallholders, northern highlands, ethnic minority, agriculture, Kinh, Thái, Hmông MEASURING SMALLHOLDER LAND INVESTMENTS IN NORTHWEST VIETNAM: A CROSS- CULTURAL STUDY OF THREE HIGHLAND VILLAGES IN PHỎNG LÁI COMMUNE, SƠN LA PROVINCE by RICHARD CHRISTOPHER OWENS BS, University of California Santa Barbara, 1997 MA, University of Nebraska Lincoln 2003 A Dissertation Submitted to the Graduate Faculty of the University of Georgia in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree DOCTORAL OF PHILOSOPHY ATHENS, GEORGIA 2013 © 2013 RICHARD CHRISTOPHER OWENS All Rights Reserved MEASURING SMALLHOLDER LAND INVESTMENTS IN NORTHWEST VIETNAM: A CROSS- CULTURAL STUDY OF THREE HIGHLAND VILLAGES IN PHỎNG LÁI COMMUNE, SƠN LA PROVINCE By RICHARD CHRISTOPHER OWENS Major Professor: Bram Tucker Committee: Ted. L. Gragson J.Peter Brosius Jean Michaud Electronic Version Approved: Maureen Grasso Dean of the Graduate School The University of Georgia December 2013 iv ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS First, I would like to thank my major advisor, Bram Tucker, and my advisory committee members, Ted Gragson, Jean Michaud, and Pete Brosius. Thank you for your encouragement and valuable time throughout the years. I greatly appreciate the late Dr. Robert Rhoades for encouraging me to study at the Department of Anthropology at UGA. His sudden death came as a surprise for me and I am thankful for the department in helping me adjust and prepare the way for my dissertation. I am indebted to my committee for their encouragement, expertise, and mentorship that helped me throughout the entire process. I am also grateful to the students and staff provided me with a multiple resources, feedback and ideas that helped me every step of the way. I am thankful for Jeremy Reynolds in Sociology for his expertise in statistical analysis and his sincere interest in understanding my data set and research design. To those outside of UGA who have influence my research along the way, I would like to thank Professor Tay Bac and the Southeast Asian Summer Studies Institute (SEASSI) for their patience and encouragement I struggled to master Vietnamese. I am thankful for the Library of Congress Asian Library and the National Agriculture Library in Washington DC. I am grateful to the Institute of Anthropology in Hanoi for providing institutional and logistical support, especially Tran Hong Hanh, Nguyen Hong Ngan, and Tinh Vuong. I am very grateful to the people of Phỏng Lái commune who provided me with a place to stay and invited me into their homes on a regular basis. Your kindness and towards a stranger was greatly appreciated, for your patience with my lengthy survey and rather clumsy questioning. v This research project was funded by a Fulbright Research Grant and would not be possible with out the generous support. I greatly appreciate the effort to keep all the scholars connected throughout the year of living abroad and for providing an opportunity to present in a regional conference in Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia. Finally, a special thanks goes out to my family and closest friends who have supported me along the way. I am thankful for Grandpa Thomas who gave me a lifetime subscription to National Geographic Society and to Grandma Lolly, who encouraged me to be free and to explore the world. Her love of Asia influenced me beyond measurement. I am thankful for Beth Anderson for being my friend through the long and many steps of this journey, travel buddy, sounding board and financier. vi TABLE OF CONTENTS Page ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS ........................................................................................................................................ iv LIST OF TABLES ........................................................................................................................................................ x LIST OF FIGURES ..................................................................................................................................................... xii CHAPTER 1 INTRODUCTION: MEASURING SMALLHOLDER INVESTMENT PRACTICES IN NORTHWEST VIETNAM ................................................................................................................... 1 Introduction ................................................................................................................................... 1 Property Rights and the Link to Long-term Investments .......................................... 2 Research Questions ................................................................................................................. 14 Theoretical Framework ........................................................................................................ 14 Field Site Description and Methods .................................................................................. 36 Outline of Dissertation ........................................................................................................... 41 2 CONDUCTING FIELDWORK IN HIGHLAND SOCIALIST VIETNAM ............................. 43 Introduction ....................................................................................................................................... 43 Entry into the Field ......................................................................................................................... 47 Positionality, Issues of Power, Hierarchy and Identity ............................................ 49 Totalitarian Regimes and Protectionist Respondents .............................................. 52 Conclusion .................................................................................................................................. 70 3 HISTORY OF PROPERTY RELATIONS IN HIGHLAND VIETNAM ................................. 72 vii Introduction to Land Reform in Vietnam……………………………………….. .............. 72 Theories of Land Tenure and Land Management ....................................................... 80 Historical Property Rights in Vietnam ............................................................................ 87 Induced Intensification in Phỏng Lái post-Đổi Mới.………………………………....124 Conclusion: Influence of Changing Land Tenure Systems .................................... 126 4 HIGHLAND CULTURAL AND ECONOMIC INTERACTIONS ........................................... 128 Introduction .............................................................................................................................. 128 Geography of Sơn La Province, Northwest aVietnam ............................................. 131 Upland Ethnic Diversity ....................................................................................................... 140 Environmental Effects of Socialist Policies ................................................................. 162 Conclusion……………………………………………………………………………….……………172 5 CROSS-CULTURAL COMPARISON OF AGRICULTURAL INVESTMENT STRATEGIES ..................................................................................................................................... 176 Introduction .............................................................................................................................. 176 Theoretical Framework ....................................................................................................... 180 Field Site and Background .................................................................................................
Load more

Recommended publications
  • I Politics and Practices of Conservation Governance and Livelihood Change in Two Ethnic Hmong Villages and a Protected Area In
    Politics and practices of conservation governance and livelihood change in two ethnic Hmong villages and a protected area in Yên Bái province, Vietnam. Bernhard Huber Department of Geography McGill University, Montreal A thesis submitted to McGill University in partial fulfillment of the requirements of the degree of Doctor of Philosophy © Bernhard Huber 2019 i Abstract What happens in a remote village of traditional shifting cultivators and hunters when, in the course of twenty years, traditional livelihood practices are banned, alternative income opportunities emerge, a protected area is established, and selected villagers are paid to patrol fellow villagers’ forest use? In this thesis, I aim to investigate how ethnic Hmong villagers in Mù Cang Chải district, Yên Bái Province, Vietnam, and their livelihood practices have intersected with outside interventions for rural development and forest conservation since 1954. Addressing five research questions, I examine historical livelihood changes, contemporary patterns of wealth and poverty, the institutionalisation of forest conservation, the village politics of forest patrolling and hunting, as well as the local outcomes of Vietnam’s nascent Payments for Ecosystem Services (PES) program. I find that these aspects vary significantly within and between two Hmong villages, in which I collected most of my data. The forced transition in the 1990s from shifting cultivation to paddy cultivation increased food security, but has also resulted in new patterns of socio-economic differentiation, as some households had limited access to paddy land. More recently, socio-economic differentiation has further increased, as households have differently benefited from PES, government career opportunities and bank loans. These sources of financial capital are increasingly relevant to peasant livelihoods elsewhere in Vietnam, but remain largely under-studied.
    [Show full text]
  • Special Issue 2, August 2015
    Special Issue 2, August 2015 Published by the Center for Lao Studies ISSN: 2159-2152 www.laostudies.org ______________________ Special Issue 2, August 2015 Information and Announcements i-ii Introducing a Second Collection of Papers from the Fourth International 1-5 Conference on Lao Studies. IAN G. BAIRD and CHRISTINE ELLIOTT Social Cohesion under the Aegis of Reciprocity: Ritual Activity and Household 6-33 Interdependence among the Kim Mun (Lanten-Yao) in Laos. JACOB CAWTHORNE The Ongoing Invention of a Multi-Ethnic Heritage in Laos. 34-53 YVES GOUDINEAU An Ethnohistory of Highland Societies in Northern Laos. 54-76 VANINA BOUTÉ Wat Tham Krabok Hmong and the Libertarian Moment. 77-96 DAVID M. CHAMBERS The Story of Lao r: Filling in the Gaps. 97-109 GARRY W. DAVIS Lao Khrang and Luang Phrabang Lao: A Comparison of Tonal Systems and 110-143 Foreign-Accent Rating by Luang Phrabang Judges. VARISA OSATANANDA Phuan in Banteay Meancheay Province, Cambodia: Resettlement under the 144-166 Reign of King Rama III of Siam THANANAN TRONGDEE The Journal of Lao Studies is published twice per year by the Center for Lao Studies, 65 Ninth Street, San Francisco, CA, 94103, USA. For more information, see the CLS website at www.laostudies.org. Please direct inquiries to [email protected]. ISSN : 2159-2152 Books for review should be sent to: Justin McDaniel, JLS Editor 223 Claudia Cohen Hall 249 S. 36th Street University of Pennsylvania Philadelphia, PA 19104 Copying and Permissions Notice: This journal provides open access to content contained in every issue except the current issue, which is open to members of the Center for Lao Studies.
    [Show full text]
  • Dress and Identity Among the Black Tai of Loei Province, Thailand
    DRESS AND IDENTITY AMONG THE BLACK TAI OF LOEI PROVINCE, THAILAND Franco Amantea Bachelor of Arts, Simon Fraser University 2003 THESIS SUBMITTED 1N PARTIAL FULFILLMENT OF THE REQUIREMENTS FOR THE DEGREE OF MASTER OF ARTS In the Department of Sociology and Anthropology O Franco Amantea 2007 SIMON FRASER UNIVERSITY 2007 All rights reserved. This work may not be reproduced in whole or in part, by photocopy or other means, without permission of the author. APPROVAL Name: Franco Amantea Degree: Master of Arts Title of Thesis: Dress and Identity Among the Black Tai of Loei Province, Thailand Examining Committee: Chair: Dr. Gerardo Otero Professor of Sociology Dr. Michael Howard Senior Supervisor Professor of Anthropology Dr. Marilyn Gates Supervisor Associate Professor of Anthropology Dr. Brian Hayden External Examiner Professor of Archaeology Date Defended: July 25,2007 Declaration of Partial Copyright Licence The author, whose copyright is declared on the title page of this work, has granted to Simon Fraser University the right to lend this thesis, project or extended essay to users of the Simon Fraser University Library, and to make partial or single copies only for such users or in response to a request from the library of any other university, or other educational institution, on its own behalf or for one of its users. The author has further granted permission to Simon Fraser University to keep or make a digital copy for use in its circulating collection (currently available to the public at the "Institutional Repository" link of the SFU Library website <www.lib.sfu.ca> at: <http://ir.lib.sfu.ca/handle/1892/112>) and, without changing the content, to translate the thesis/project or extended essays, if technically possible, to any medium or format for the purpose of preservation of the digital work.
    [Show full text]
  • Hydropower Dam and Hydrological Alteration on the Da River in Son La, Vietnam
    Management of Forest Resources and Environment HYDROPOWER DAM AND HYDROLOGICAL ALTERATION ON THE DA RIVER IN SON LA, VIETNAM Chao Thi Yen1, Lorenzo Picco1, Bui Xuan Dung2, Tran Quang Bao2 1University of Padua, Padua, Italy 2Vietnam National University of Forestry SUMMARY The Da River basin, the largest tributary of the Red River, has experienced a rapid development of hydropower dams, of which Son La hydropower plant is the biggest and the most complex dam project ever built in Vietnam. The study was aimed to examine the hydrological alterations after the construction of Son La hydropower dam in downstream of the Da in pre- and post-dam period. The flow regime information from 1961 to 2016 was obtained from the Vietnam Meteorological and Hydrological Administration. The hydrological alteration was quantified by using IHA (Indicators of Hydrologic Alteration). The Kruskal – Wallis test was applied to examine the changes of hydrological regime between pre- and post- dam period. The results showed that 4 groups of IHA had significant change and one group had no significant difference in pre- and post-dam period. Particularly, the flow in rainy season decreased between 5% and 43% and increased average 71.6% in dry season in the post-impact period. Minima and maxima of 1-, 3-, 7-, 30-, and 90-days flow had a broad fluctuation with a reduction of mean flow between 37% and 90%, except 30- and 90-day minimum having an upward trend of 6% and 129%, in the order. The low and high pulse count increased 40% and 100% in post-2010, respectively, whereas the low pulse duration decreased 60% in the post-dam period.
    [Show full text]
  • © 2000 Institute of Southeast Asian Studies, Singapore a a Notice For
    ISEAS DOCUMENT DELIVERY SERVICE. No reproduction without permission of the publisher: Institute of Southeast Asian Studies, 30 Heng Mui Keng Terrace, SINGAPORE 119614. FAX: (65)7756259; TEL: (65) 8702447; E-MAIL: [email protected] 328 Index Index A amphetamine 211 A Notice for Further Liberalizing the An Giang 237 Border Towns and countries of Ananda Thera 147 Nanning, Kunming City, Pingxiang Annam 42, 106 Town, Ruili, and Hekou Country by Annamites 261 the State Council 77 Announcement of Several Problems acculturation 116 Pertaining to Border Trade 91 Achang 51 anthropologists 254 ADB 126 anthropology 7 Admiral Zheng (Ma) He 223 anti-communist 108 aggression 115 anti-government armed forces 63 agricultural development 197 anti-Manchu 32 agricultural products 132 Anti-Rightist Campaign 55 agriculture 90, 204, 209 Arabic 228 AIDS 170 Arakanese 227 aiguo zhuyi 294 Archibald Colquhoun 105 airports 136 Argentina 114 Akha 2, 3, 99 arms trafficking 185 Akha caravan 206 Asia Inc 11 Akha entrepreneurs 206, 212 Asia Times 12 Akha oral texts 206 Asia Watch 260 Akha traders 207 “Asian capitalism” 2 Akha-Chinese 217 Asian Danube 234 Alavi 147 Asian Development Bank 126 alcohol abuse 190 Asian economic crisis 1 America 116 “Asian Economic Miracle” 1 Americans 104, 109 Asian Megatrends 13 © 2000 Institute of Southeast Asian Studies, Singapore Index 329 Asian “tigers” 8 Bianzu Yaozu Zizhiqu 293 Asoka 147 bilateral trade 237 assimilation 5, 32 Binh Tien Plastics Company 246 Association of Overseas Chinese (Hoi biodiversity 51 Kieu Lien) 247 biological
    [Show full text]
  • Shamans and Rebels: the Batchai (Meo) Rebellion of Northern Laos and North-West Vietnam (1918-21)
    107 Journal of The Siam Society SHAMANS AND REBELS: THE BATCHAI (MEO) REBELLION OF NORTHERN LAOS AND NORTH-WEST VIETNAM (1918-21) A largely misrepresented ethnic minority, the Meo 1 have most recently drawn the attention of outsiders - social workers, international civil servants and journalists among others - as a concomitant of the refugee exodus from Indochina in the post 1975 period. Similarly, as both protagonists and victims in the Second Indochina war and as objects of the post-revolutionary social restructuring of Indochina, the Meo as a minority have been consistently treated by state actors down through history as a problem group worthy of administrative or worse military attention. They have seldom been beneficiaries of informed sympathy much less admiration. How then did this people whose origins lie in China - some would contend, central Asia - come to be historically inserted in the northern salient oi the Indochinese peninsula? What relationships did the Meo enter into with the host populations at the frontiers of their southward thrusting migrations across southwest China, northwest Vietnam (Tonkin) and northern Laos? How did this nomadic people react in their first confrontation with the modern world, namely that contingent _upon the entry of Laos and Tonkin - as French colonial protectorates - into a broader world system? Thus in this article on the 'Batchai' (Meo) rebellion of 1918-1921 - which at its high point tied down units of crack colonial troops over an expanse of 40,000 square kilometres spanning northern Laos and northwest Vietnam - we seek to throw light on these questions, while acknowledging that the answers might best be addressed by Meo researchers themselves.
    [Show full text]
  • Thai Entourage Politics in the Socialist State of Vietnam
    7 Thai Entourage Politics in the Socialist State of Vietnam Ha Viet Quan Introduction We arrived at Lò Vi An’s house in Châu La Biên,1 a northwest province, quite late from Hà Nội because the lunch-stop at Châu Quỳnh town took much longer than we had planned. Lò Vi An seemed a bit tired from the rice wine during lunch but he was satisfied with the warm hospitality provided by Cầm Chung, a Thai leader of Châu Quỳnh District, and his entourage. Lò Vi An’s house impressed me with its luxurious interior: a big garage, digital security camera system, elevator, and other modern appointments. However, as soon as I crossed the living room with its Western-style furniture, such as a leather sofa, crystal glasses, and gold-plated tea set, I was surprised by the kitchen with its traditional Thai cooking utensils, including several rice baskets (cam khao), wooden rice steamers (mo nuung khao), and bamboo vegetable steamer (mo nuung phac). In a corner of the kitchen, I saw Toàn, an adopted son of Lò Vi An, roasting a piece of dried buffalo skin in a wood-fired stove. As I already knew Toàn, I greeted him and the others in the kitchen by saying how impressed I was by one of the dishes they were preparing: ‘Wow! It looks like 1 Châu La Biên is a pseudonym. All place names relating to Châu La Biên and the names of Thai cadres and their associates in this chapter are pseudonyms. 239 CONNECTED & DISCONNECTED IN VIET NAM we are going to have nom nang quai [a Thai-style buffalo skin salad].
    [Show full text]
  • 1. History of Thai Song Dam Satienkoses (1966) Said the Words
    1. History of Thai Song Dam Satienkoses (1966) said the words “Song, So-ong, Soeng” have the same definition which means black trousers (sueng). This is the Laotian language (meaning ‘trousers’). The words Laos Song Dam or Laos Song signify people who wear black dress. Pra Boriharndhepthanee (1837) wrote in Thailand’s chronicle (historical record). When we called people who reside in Petchaburi and Ratchaburi ‘Thai Song Dam’, we mean ‘Laos Song’ or ‘Lao Song Dam’ which means the same—the people who like putting on black trousers. Luang Wichit Watakarn (1969) wrote a book about one ethnicity of Thai people who are called ‘Thai Song Dam’. Its meaning is derived from the dressing style, especially their favorite color. They like black trousers. Their ancestors’ favorite color since the long history ago was dark blue. Thai Song Dam was originated from Thai race. This ethnicity group was a traditional race of Thai people over the past centuries. M. Sributsara (1987) said Thai Song Dam or Thai Dam originally resided in central China, in which was an abode of Thai ethnicity group, then they immigrated to live in the south to settle down near the Ou River that flows to join Mae Klong River at Luang Prabang in the Sip Song Chau Tai (twelve provinces of the Dai – an area in the north-west of French Indochina, now Vietnam), in which Trang or Dien Bien Fu (currently belonging to Vietnam) is the capital and the northern outskirt. This area is extended to the North of the Kingdom of Laos, bordering on North Korea.
    [Show full text]
  • The Development of the Southeast Asian-Chinese Border Zone
    The Development of the Southeast Asian Border Zone A Social Theory Inaugural-Dissertation zur Erlangung der Doktorwürde der Philosophischen Fakultät der Rheinischen Friedrich-Wilhelms-Universität zu Bonn vorgelegt von Florian Anderhuber aus Graz Bonn, 2019 Gedruckt mit der Genehmigung der Philosophischen Fakultät der Rheinischen Friedrich- Wilhelms-Universität Bonn Zusammensetzung der Prüfungskommission: Prof. Dr. Stephan Conermann, Institut für Orient- und Asienwissenschaften (Vorsitzende/Vorsitzender) Prof. Dr. Christoph Antweiler, Institut für Orient- und Asienwissenschaften (Betreuerin/Betreuer und Gutachterin/Gutachter) Prof. Dr. Dr. Manfred Hutter, Institut für Orient- und Asienwissenschaften (Gutachterin/Gutachter) Prof. Dr.Ralph Kauz, Institut für Orient- und Asienwissenschaften (weiteres prüfungsberechtigtes Mitglied) Tag der mündlichen Prüfung: 30.10.2019 Table of contents I. Theoretical background………………………………………………………………………… 7 1. Introduction and questions………………………………………………………….………….7 1.1. Terminology…………………………………………………………………….……….11 1.2. Theoretical background…………………………………………………………...……..12 1.2.1. The state of border studies…………………………………………………...…...12 1.2.1.1. Basic constructivism and spatial dimensions in border studies……..........13 1.2.1.2. Temporal dimension of border studies……………………………….......20 1.2.1.3. Criteria of demarcating space…………………………………………….23 1.2.2. Considerations of the role of the state……………………………………………27 1.2.3. The nexus between social and state borders……………………………….……..29 1.2.4. Borders as result of state-formation and territorialization………………………..32 1.2.5. State-sanctioned performance of otherness…………………………………........36 1.3. States and borders as social actions……………………………………………………...38 1.4. Agency of borders…………………………………………………………………….…39 1.5. Integrating borderlands: state-action within the national and international system……..44 1.6. The nexus of border-creation and institutionalization………………………..………….48 1.7. The case for Southeast-Asian – Chinese borderlands: a global perspective………...…..51 1.7.1.
    [Show full text]
  • 15 Hmong in Exile
    Chinese Southern Diaspora Studies, Volume Seven, 2014-2015 南方華裔研究雜誌, 第七卷, 2014-2015 HMONG IN EXILE: the double diAsporA of A non-HAn minority populAtion ©2015 Nick TApp I An OriginAry DiAsporA The Hmong number some three million people in the southern Chinese provinces of Guangxi, Guizhou, Sichuan, and Yunnan. They are one of three to four major ethnic-linguistic groups, such as the Hmu and A Hmao (see below) classified by the Chinese under the ancient term of “Miao” owing to remote linguistic and historical connections between them. Since the early 1950s the Chinese government has pursued a policy of positive discrimination towards the 55 peoples or groups of peoples officially classified as ethnic or national minorities under the minzu shibie project of national identification (see, for example, Mullaney 2011). The category of “Miao” is one of these 55.1 The Miao have a long record in Chinese history, and were considered by some to be the aboriginal or indigenous Chinese, having inhabited the present lands of China before the ancestors of the Han. Whether the present-day genetic-linguistic people classified as Miao really had ancestors who were the same as those people referred to by the ancient Chinese documents as “Miao”, we have no means of telling. However, given the extraordinary admixture of peoples, cultures and languages which has taken place in southern China (Schafer 1967), and the fact that for large parts of modern history, even up to the late nineteenth century and sometimes still today in ordinary parlance, the term “Miao” has been used in a very loose sense to refer to all the non-Han “barbaric” tribal peoples of southern China (Ruey 1962), the balance of probability is that those people classified as Miao today did have ancestors who were among those classified as Miao in the ancient records.
    [Show full text]
  • French Missionary Expansion in Colonial Upper Tonkin
    287 Journal of Southeast Asian Studies, 35 (2), pp 287–310 June 2004. Printed in the United Kingdom. © 2004 The National University of Singapore DOI: 10.1017/S0022463404000153 French Missionary Expansion in Colonial Upper Tonkin Jean Michaud This article examines the circumstances and logic of French Catholic missionary expansion in Upper Tonkin. It explores how, over a few decades, the missionary push in the mountainous outskirts of the Red River Delta was conceived, how it unfolded, and how it came to a standstill in the 1920s before its decline towards the final exit of the French in the late 1940s. The age of the uncompromising antipathy between a number of academic anthro- pologists and missionaries is over. With many authors making a case for acknowledging the contribution of non-academic ethnographers to the discipline of anthropology, examination of missionaries’ work as part of the wider category of non-professional ethnographers has become critical for the discipline.1 Is it not true that historically anthropologists have made great use of missionary writings – though perhaps more privately than publicly? Peter Pels has noted, for instance, that ‘before the advent of the professional fieldworker [in the first decade of the twentieth century], British anthro- pologists mainly used data collected by government officials and missionaries, while a segment of the missionary movement drew on ethnology as a tool in developing missionary methods’.2 This observation emphasises even more the contested boundaries between the two worlds. Colonial missionary ethnography was for the most part conducted by nonspecialists for whom this activity was accidental, performed in the course of their apostolic mission.
    [Show full text]
  • 6061 Ethnohistory / 47:2 / Sheet 55 of 234
    The Montagnards and the State in Northern Vietnam from to : A Historical Overview Jean Michaud, University of Hull 6061 Ethnohistory / 47:2 / sheet 55 of 234 Abstract. This article provides an overview of the recent interactions between the highlanders of northern Vietnam and the successive powers that controlled the state between and: Imperial Vietnam until, the French colonial state until , and the Democratic Republic of Vietnam after that date. Ignored for a long time, courted during wartime, subject to strong acculturation policy since the in- dependence of the North, these highland societies are facing a constant challenge to their cultural survival. The Socialist Republic of Vietnam is a land of human diversity. Today ethnic Kinh, the lowland Vietnamese majority, account for approximately percent of the national population. The remaining percent belong to one or another of the remaining forty-eight ethnic denominations regis- tered in the country in the census.1 These are grouped under the ap- pellation of National Minorities. Of these National Minorities twenty-four different groups are found in northern Vietnam, amounting to percent of the National Minority population and percent of the national popula- tion (Table ). Their habitat is part of the northern reaches of the Annam Cordillera and includes a large portion of the southern part of the mainland Southeast Asian Massif (Figure ). This article provides an overview of the recent interactions between the montagnards of northern Vietnam and the successive lowland powers that controlled the state between and .2 The written documen- tation used in this article comes from secondary sources, either in French or English, or is translated into one of these languages from, chiefly, Viet- namese and Chinese.
    [Show full text]