The Senate of Pakistan Debates
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
THE SENATE OF PAKISTAN DEBATES OFFICIAL REPORT Thursday, May 02, 2013 (93 rd Session) Volume V, No. 01 (Nos. 01) CONTENTS Paes 1. Recitation from the Holy Quran……………………………. 1 2. Panel of Presiding Officers…………………………………. 2 3. Motion for Suspension of Question Hour………………….. 2 4. Leave of Absence…………………………………………... 2-3 5. Point of Order Regarding Attack on INP's Office………….. 4-8 6. Presentation of Report Regarding Non-cooperative Behaviour of Managing Director, Pakistan Security Printing Corporation (PSPC) and Insulting Behavior of Chief Executive Officer of SEPCO……………………………… 9-14 7. Point of Order Regarding Use of Impertinent Language by the Former Chief Minister Against President of Pakistan…………………………………………………….. 15-57 8. Discussion on Law and Order Situation and Statement by 58-67 the Caretaker Interior Minister…………………………...... Printed and Published by the Senate Secretariat, Islamabad. Volume-V SP.V(01)/2013 No.01 15 SENATE OF PAKISTAN SENATE DEBATES Thursday, May 02, 2013 The Senate of Pakistan met in the Senate Hall (Parliament House) Islamabad, at thirty five minutes past five in the evening with Mr. Chairman (Syed Nayyer Hussain Bokhari) in the Chair. ---------------- Recitation from the Holy Quran „ fl‚ Í „ fl‚ fl ‚Í ‡ „ ‡ fl o3· · ∑ï…â∞3· ∑¥·· ¼¾“ `c;øú3· „ fl‚ Í Ó fl‚ ‚Í „ s· · ∑µs· ¼¾“· ≥Ö· · ‡ ‚Í fl fl flfl ‚fl‚ fl fl ÓÓfl ÓÒflÓfl ‚Í fl fl flÓ ‡ Ó fl flÍ fl fl Ó Ó ‡Ó fl fl fl ‡ ‚Í fl fl fl ¼¾“3 K`$ `¥ M & b…ï∞3· · ∑¥· j…d*+3· ,-µ»· /0s ª…±3· 4∏3 `¥ 673 8-π:Xµ∞3· · <|…∞· ¼¾“3 K`$ `¥ ÓÓ‡‡Ó‡‡Ó fl‡‡‡‡‚ fl‚‚ÍÍÍ fl fl fl‚ ÓÓfl ÓÓfl Ó fl fl fl‚ Í fl fl Ó fl fl Ó ‡ fl Ó ‡ 3øA:Xg·· K3· M C DEÑ<ÁÁ·· M ¼¾“`c··· 3øA:`§ H -TâK ∑¥ DEÑ< ∑¥ /Lh· NO ¼¾“3 ∑PQ· M b…°· ∞3 673 ≥≠ù±ï…∞· · fl Ò fl Ó ‡ ‚ ‹ Ó fl fl ‡ ÓflÓ ‡ ‚Í͇‚‡ Í flfl Ó ‡ fl Ófl fl Ó ‚fl fl fl Ó fl fl fl › Ó fl Ó fl Ó ‡ fl fl Ó ‡ fl‚ fl fl & _`∞ 3i-w ø º DEë§Á · ∑¥· ¼¾“3 _`g3 `µc· Kabcd» ∑» |∞3· 8eÖfO Œ M ˘ˇł¦ Ðôú· ~o3› ≥P±§ 3ø©hg M fl fl‡ ‚‚›ÍÍflÓÍfl ÓÓ flÍ Í fl ‚‡ flÓ fl flfl ÓÓflÓ ‡ fl flfl ‡ fl‚fl ‡ flÓ ‡ ‚Ó ‚ fl fl ‡ fl `µc··· ¼¾“3 M & A<Œ 3 M 5øµÖ∞3·· 63i-¥·· ¼¾“·· M & ≈µ…©∞3 Jø» ªcÁ 3ab*q· `¥ Kø®øï…Ñ & _`∞ st øº Øc ›Ó fl fl Ó ‡ fl Ó fl ˘Ł¯x¦ Ð i-dw· Kabµùg 7 Q Q 7 7 R I R Q 7 :^F:_a :`5 5[ := Tb ( \] F:AB ):Y:3:ZM8 5[ :@ G:;<=JM6 :>NOP :3:?@M8 H :AB:3 S :C:=T U K :D=@ L 4 VWX :EB:<FB : 2456 3 8 Q 7 Q uvX O yR Q 7 O R Q j K Q Q :@q:rs t :3:`M8 5 Nwx :> N P (! A@mo B:2mX @ n :;B ):2i :>N P :D@k :2:cN a :EB:<FB:˘;e:3K :2:Bf a 5H :gl :h@:=MM aaaK :h@@ 7 Q R 7 Vn Q o :gK :AB:<FB:EB:Y :=• :˘gz b ::@ mNMO•:> Q [ ( g€wo :g K :Y :g K :` 5 Nwx):gzb}l @:g{MH [ :g :D==o • <:g| w 8 B:EB:>Q ~Nm :;e j 7 7 7 7 I o 7 Q ƒ Q R ƒ Q „gzb :…B=5 L :B358 :g€ w :;<@PyR := L :F3 K :<@N m OH B:†‡= ‰ L :<FB:FˆB:g o :D@ 4NNRB:Y :3S B:<FB:˘F‚:D@ 4 R B:3M 8 :D=o = • < Q QQQ 7 Ž QQR R 7 :‹ŒP :g|w8 B:>NO B:g L :EB:=:> 5[ N O U•sT :g L 3:‹K 5O :> N :g€ wl 8 e:g :> N O s ( \o Fe:F:?@ s):AB:Š=o :=5 [ :<FB Q Q Q Os[Q 8Q 7 R O s[•8 5R Q :˘gzbK :B3:>58NNN :• :g :DB:2:2N a •‘5a :˘>3::2:?@ K a NNm[ :C’P5 :> :• :g| w B:=:‹ K :AB:3:C S T U :^F:gz bl :@ m K :@ v x :g 7Q ƒ Q Q Q •5R O s [ Q Os OPR 7 :D=:gzTbb <:g L 3:‹K :^F:>N :Z5 :@:gG L @:@@5 HamN ˜MR :•=:@:?@:AB – —s ( >N :g uG ) >N B:`X @Nm“ :<F<:\q5 N8 ”wx 7 Q L j Q Q :q:gœ K :`5 l :;<@PyR :™:g€›T }bL B:gz :_@:…B:g€{:™• s 5 } O H • žN )gzb :…<BF:@— :>Q NOs <:<FB:D=L @ 4 š ˆB:™›T :EB:<FB:˘g S Q 7 R „gzb :^@G ˆB:g l :D=X @ — :`5 l :;<@ P yR :EB:<FB:˘ (@:gzGb <:_@:™F:™• s›T Ÿ 5 :f 5L :g K :g L @ 5 H 7 Q 7 ( ( 180 „179 :…@Na ˆB::DBq y¡:?B:^<= •) 1 Panel of Presiding Officers [ 6 L Mr. Chairman: „YN• 3o B:>Q † ¦ 3 o B:EB:Y ¥ 5 In pursuance of sub-rule (1) of Rule 14 of the Rules of Procedure and Conduct of Business in the Senate, 2012, I nominate the following members in order of precedence to form Panel of Presiding Officers for the 93rd session of the Senate of Pakistan:- i) Senator Aitzaz Ahsan ii) Senator Ilyas Ahmed Bilour iii) Senator Malik Muhammad Rafique Rajwana ƒ Q ƒ [ Q suspension of rules for question :˘`5 [ @« :_N m8 @:•F<@: a ¬ :>Q NOs C’mN M :…@5 m5[ hour. Motion for Suspension of Question Hour Senator Farooq Hamid Naek: I beg to move that under Rule 263 of the Rules of Procedure and Conduct of Business in the Senate, 2012, the requirements of Rule 41 of the said rules regarding Question Hour be dispensed with. Mr. Chairman: It has been moved that under Rule 263 of the Rules of Procedure and Conduct of Business in the Senate, 2012, the requirements of Rule 41 of the said rules regarding Question Hour be dispensed with. (The motion was carried) Leave of Absence 7 j Q 8 7 j Q QQK7 X ¯ Q I Q ±5R Q ƒ [ Q :>N F: 92 :2ml 3:3:@SM 8 mm58 :c:…@N Ž FC° :cBe::`@5[ «H :=f@:ZNL a M :‚=:…@ X 5 m 5[ ::>NOs C’mN M :…@5 m5[ Q 7 Q Q Q R R 7 j I :DB:gQ L :D=˜R B:g€ wo :AB:˘g J :g ~k :3:>KNNOP :\CK ³ :> O s :A²B:=:‹3B:Z5H K Na M 8 NOa B:<FB:^<@´R B:DB<Fe:gQ K :A² 5H B ¶ Q QQQ Q X7K 7 K 7 Q o R 7 ˚gzbw :<=· :`¸[ <:@NmK :„gz b :c:` l B=<e:c:` [ ¸ [ <:g lwK :DB=B:g€N L± :g :D=N <@ a ƒ ¶ Q 7 Q ( ( ™•S :cK :<=·wX :`¸[ < ) 2 j 7 Q Os 4ºs 7 Q QQK7 X ¯ »œ V ¹ Q ƒ [ Q ::>N ::A²B::‹5H :2ml 3:3:@SM 8 mm5 8Ž :c:…@N FC° :cBe:`@5 [ « :e=¦ :2 †• :…@5 m 5 [ ::>NOs C’mN M :…@5 m5[ Q 7Q º s 7 j Q Q Q 7 7 j :c:`K ¸[ <:glwK :DB=B:g€Q NLo ::g :A²B:‹5H 4 :2ml 3:gS L :D= ˜ R B:g€ wJ~ o :AB:˘gR :gk :3:> K NO P R :\CK ³ ¶ Q Q Q X 7K 7 ˚gzb :<=· w :`¸[ <:@NmK :„gz b :c:` l B=<e [ ƒ ¶ Q 7 Q ( ( ™•S :cK :<=·wX :`¸[ < ) 7 Q 8 7 j Q Q K7 X ¯ Q I Q Q ƒ [ Q :>N F:92 :2ml 3:3:@SM 8 m58 :c:…@N m Ž FC° :cB e:`5 [ @« :_m[ :…@5N ml :BqB:…@ t 5 m 5 [ ::>NOs C’mN M :…@5 m5[ Q Q Q Q R 7 j 7 Q :DB:gQ L :D=˜R B:g€ wo :AB:˘g ~k :3:>KNNOP :\CK ³ :> O s :A²B:‹3B:Z5H Na M 8 NOa B::@:2=a •• :2<=:DB H X Q <Fe:gK :A² 5H B ¶ Q QQQ Q X7K 7 K 7 Q o R 7 ˚gzbw :<=· :`¸[ <:@NmK :„gz b :c:` l B=<e:c:` [ ¸ [ <:g lwK :DB=B:g€N L± :g :D=N <@ a ƒ ¶ Q 7 Q ( ( ™•S :cK :<=·wX :`¸[ < ) 7 Q 7 7 j Q Q K7 X ¯ Q •}[ œ œ •Ž Q Q ƒ [ Q :2ml 3:3:@SM 8 m58 :c :…@N m Ž FC° :cBe:`@5 [ «::™ :f4» f4» :¼ ::<BeC³ :…@5 m5[ ::>NOs C’mN M :…@5 m5[ Q 7 j ƒ Q Q Q :g~k :3:>K NNOPR :\C:>K ³ O s :A²B:=:™5H K •X :¾:2H <=X :½ˆB:<FB:‹5 Na 3M8 B:ZNOa B:<FB::^<fmM8 :DB<Fe:gQ K :A² 5H B :>N8 F 92 QQQ Q Q Q 7 7K 7 K 7 QQoR 7 o R :`¸[ <:@NmK :„gzb :c:` l B=<e:c:`[ ¸ [ <:g lwK :DB=B:g€N L± :g :D=N <@:DB:g a LwJ :D= ˜ R B:g€ :AB:˘g ¶ Q ˚gzb :<= · w X ƒ ¶ Q 7 Q ( ( ™•S :cK :<=·wX :`¸[ < ) 7 Q Q 4ºs Q K7 X ¯ Q V œ Q Q ƒ [ Q :‹ :2N mo @:3:@HmmM8 58 :c:…@N Ž FC° :cBe:gL :`@5[ « :f<:™ an :f 4 » :C N ’¿:…@5 m5[ ::>NOs C’mN M :…@5 m5[ ¶ Q QQQ X7K 7 K 7 Q o ˚gzbw :<=· :`¸[ <:@NmK :„gz b ::c:` l B=<e:c:` [ ¸ [ <:g lwK :DB=B:g€N L :g :A²B 5H ƒ ¶ Q 7 Q ( ( ™•S :cK :<=·wX :`¸[ < ) 7 Q Q QQK7 X ¯ Q I š œ Q ƒ [ Q ¾: :2<=:½ˆB:3:@H X 5M8 mm58 :c :…@N Ž FC° :cBe:gL :`5[ @ «•m :<Be:•@ B:f 4 » :…@5 5[ ::>NOs C’mN M :…@5 m5[ ¶ Q Q Q Q ƒ X 7 K 7K 7 [ Q o •X ˚gzb :<=· w :`¸[ <::@NmK :„gz b :c:`l B=[ <e:c :` ¸ <:gl :DB=B:g€N L w :g K :™ ƒ ¶ Q 7 Q ( ( ™•S :cK :<=·wX :`¸[ < ) 7 Q Q QQK7 X ¯Q o Q Q ƒ [ Q :2N mo @3:@HmmM8 58 :c:…@N Ž FC° :cBe:gL :`@5[ « :‡<fN m[ :<=Àž Bf5 m x :@‚=:…@ am X 5 5[ ::>NOs C’mN M :…@5 m5[ ¶ Q QQQ X777K K Q o 4º s ˚gzbw :<=· :`¸[ <:@NmK :„gz b :c :` l B= [ <e:c :` ¸ [ <:g lwK :DB=B:g€N L :g ::A²B:‹ 5H ƒ ¶ Q 7 Q ( ( ™•S :cK :<=·wX :`¸[ < ) 3 7 Q Q Q 4ºs Q K7 X ¯ V 6 Q Q ƒ [ Q :‹ :2N mo @3:@HM8 m58 :c:…@N m Ž FC° ::cBe:g L :`@5 [ « :™n :Á²:™@:…@n 5 H5 m 5[ : :>NOs C’mN M :…@5 m5[ ¶ Q QQQ X7K 7 K 7 Q o ˚gzbw :<=· :`¸[ <:@NmK :„gz b :c:` l B=<e:c:` [ ¸ [ <:g lwK :DB=B:g€N L :g ::A²B 5H ƒ ¶ Q 7 Q ( ( ™•S :cK :<=·wX :`¸[ < ) 7 Q Q Q QQK7 X ¯ Q OW[ j Q ƒ [ Q ¾: :2<=:½ˆB3:@H X 5 M8 mm58 :c:…@N Ž FC° :cBe:gL :`@5[ « ::fN ml :>N :f@T U WmX :…@5 5[ ::>NOs C’mN M :…@5 m5[ ¶ Q QQQ ƒ X7K 7 K 7 Q o •X ˚gzb :< =·w :`¸[ <:@NmK :„gz b :c:` l B=<e:c:` [ ¸ [ <:g lwK :DB=B:g€N L :g ::™ ƒ ¶ Q 7 Q ( ( ™•S :cK :<=·wX :`¸[ < ) 7 Q Q Q Q Q K7 X ¯mu5H Q 8 L 7 œ Q ƒ [ Q Ã: :<FB:¾:2<=:3:@HX M8 m58 :c:…@N m Ž FC° :cBe:gL ::25 m[ @ « :‹ N :>CN Â’• :2C ¿ ::>NOs C’mN M :…@5 m5[ ¶ Q QQQ ƒ X7K 7 K 7 Q o •X ˚gzbw :<=· :`¸[ <:@NmK :„gz b :c :` l B=<e:c [ :` ¸ [ <:g lwK :DB=B::g€N L :g :™ ƒ ¶ Q 7 Q ( ( ™•S :cK :<=·wX :`¸[ < ) 7 Q Q ¶ Q QQK7 X ¯j Q OW[ X Q ƒ [ Q :2H <=X :½ˆB35 M8:@mm58 :c:…@N Ž FC° :cBe::gL :`@5[ «k :^@ :>N :qÄ· :fN m l :…@5 m 5[ ::>NOs C’mN M :…@5 m5[ ¶ Q QQQ ƒ X7K 7 K 7 Q o •X ˚gzbw :<=· :`¸[ <:@NmK :„gz b :c:` l B=<e:c:` [ ¸ [ <:g lwK :DB=B:g€N L :g ::™ :¾ ƒ ¶ Q 7 Q ( ( ™•S :cK :<=·wX :`¸[ < ) 7 Q Q 4ºs QQK7 X ¯ Q Q ƒ [ Q :gK ::A²B:‹58ŽH :2N mo @3:@HmmM8 5 :c:…@N FC° :cBe:g L :`@5 [ «m ::^qy6 :…@5 5 [ : :>NOs C’mN M :…@5 m5[ ¶ Q QQQ X7K 7 K 7 Q o ˚gzbw :<=· :`¸[ <:@NmK :„gz b :c:` l B= [ <e:c :` ¸ [ <:g lw :DB=B:g€N L ƒ ¶ Q 7 Q ( ( ™•S :cK :<=·wX :`¸[ < ) ƒ Q „`5 [ @« :™@:™:56 H 56 :>Q NOs C ’NmM[:…@5 m5[ Point of Order regarding Attack on INPãs Officer Q ƒ Q 7 š ƒ [ Q œ I l ::„>NTOUT :gzb <:3:2K ‘G :`± :c@¯ ´5 R :™@t •Æ :;<@ 4 › ! >Q NOs C’mN M :…@5 m5[ ::‹f:fNa n 4 » :™@:C56 H ’mN ONm Q Q ƒ Q Q È 7 Os R 7Oa I 7 8 »R :gL :D==:ÇSoM±’¬ :3:CM8 e:g K :AB:>N :e@ˆB:Á²5ak B:=:¼<@:Z KN a´ N @R B:˘gz b :@3:@ am K N ˜œ :>C N5 ’É := 5 [ :INP :^<BeB:™5 :_N a B j Q I OU Q I •8 7 Q 6 :CÊš :e@ˆB:Á²5ak B:3S B::„>N T :gzb <:3 K :Á@ —mË :@MT8 B:3 K :@o :`wNOa :C@:;<@ U 5 a•aM N 5 :^F:½ˆB:„@ 5 N e:² 5H :=K :C ’¬ e:g K :DB:<FB :@NmK :2 ‘4 QQQ 7 ŸR Q I Os7 O s :2:D@F:˘gzNNaTUaab :@²PÈ :™5 :DF<:f<:^e@<:gNa NN lÌ :g eˆB:2:> a N :?@ m[ :;CN ’¿ :˘gz b :e= 5[X = :`X = ~H :‡<=M L :D@ P 56 :˘> N 7 8 7 › [O4T› o I Q R [ R 7 :3S B:„gzb :ÍB:^F:g• S :>3N K :…@5a:Y:3:Z:˘gzTM8 5b :@²:>Na5 aN :g€ wKN :g :;fm5± B:Z:q 5 JM :=:gzL b :@ m ~k :=:2 Tb “ BF 4 7 yš 7Q Q 7 7 ƒ J» ›OU7 7 š K › 7 H O s ¯ t Æ :gw { :Y:<FB:>TTTNNTT :g L 3:`f:`K Xs ± :c:AB:Y:˘@=:@ambN K :=:g L L @:‹:>5 H5 :ŠˆB:AB:c@ ´•45 R :™ @ :;<@ › 7 7 Q K ƒ O „;e:ÇR’¿ @k :BCN :<FB:;3K :`X f:cs :gu s @ X :AB:AF@:B<=TU ML :2i :> N