THE SENATE OF DEBATES

OFFICIAL REPORT

Thursday, May 02, 2013 (93 rd Session) Volume V, No. 01 (Nos. 01)

CONTENTS

Paes 1. Recitation from the Holy Quran……………………………. 1 2. Panel of Presiding Officers…………………………………. 2 3. Motion for Suspension of Question Hour………………….. 2 4. Leave of Absence…………………………………………... 2-3 5. Point of Order Regarding Attack on INP's Office………….. 4-8 6. Presentation of Report Regarding Non-cooperative Behaviour of Managing Director, Pakistan Security Printing Corporation (PSPC) and Insulting Behavior of Chief Executive Officer of SEPCO……………………………… 9-14 7. Point of Order Regarding Use of Impertinent Language by the Former Chief Minister Against President of Pakistan…………………………………………………….. 15-57 8. Discussion on Law and Order Situation and Statement by 58-67 the Caretaker Interior Minister…………………………......

Printed and Published by the Senate Secretariat, Islamabad.

Volume-V SP.V(01)/2013 No.01 15 SENATE DEBATES Thursday, May 02, 2013 The Senate of Pakistan met in the Senate Hall (Parliament House) Islamabad, at thirty five minutes past five in the evening with Mr. Chairman (Syed Nayyer Hussain Bokhari) in the Chair. ------Recitation from the Holy Quran „ fl‚ Í „ fl‚ fl ‚Í ‡ „ ‡ fl o3· · ∑ï…â∞3· ∑¥·· ¼¾“ `c;øú3· „ fl‚ Í Ó fl‚ ‚Í „   s· · Ć ∑µs· Ć ¼¾“· Ć ≥Ö · · ‡ ‚Í fl fl flfl ‚fl‚ fl fl ÓÓfl ÓÒflÓfl ‚Í fl fl flÓ ‡ Ó fl flÍ fl fl Ó Ó ‡Ó fl fl fl ‡ ‚Í fl fl fl ¼¾“3 K`$ `¥ M & b…ï∞3· · ∑¥· j…d*+3· ,-µ»· /0s ª…±3· 4∏3 `¥ 673 8-π:Xµ∞3· · <|…∞· ¼¾“3 K`$ `¥ ÓÓ‡‡Ó‡‡Ó fl‡‡‡‡‚ fl‚‚ÍÍÍ fl fl fl‚ ÓÓfl ÓÓfl Ó fl fl fl‚ Í fl fl Ó fl fl Ó ‡ fl Ó ‡ 3øA:Xg·· K3· M C DEÑ<ÁÁ·· M ¼¾“`c··· 3øA:`§ H -TâK ∑¥ DEÑ< ∑¥ /Lh· NO ¼¾“3 ∑PQ· M b…°· ∞3 673 ≥≠ù±ï…∞· · fl Ò fl Ó ‡ ‚ ‹ Ó fl fl ‡ ÓflÓ ‡ ‚Í͇‚‡ Í flfl Ó ‡ fl Ófl fl Ó ‚fl fl fl Ó fl fl fl › Ó fl Ó fl Ó ‡ fl fl Ó ‡ fl‚ fl fl & _`∞ 3i-w ø º DEë§Á · ∑¥· ¼¾“3 _`g3 `µc· Kabcd» ∑» |∞3· 8eÖfO Œ M ˘ˇł¦ Ðôú· ~o3› ≥P±§ 3ø©hg M fl fl‡ ‚‚›ÍÍflÓÍfl ÓÓ flÍ Í fl ‚‡ flÓ fl flfl ÓÓflÓ ‡ fl flfl ‡ fl‚fl ‡ flÓ ‡ ‚Ó ‚ fl fl ‡ fl `µc··· ¼¾“3 M & A<Œ 3 M 5øµÖ∞3·· 63i-¥·· ¼¾“·· M & ≈µ…©∞3 Jø» ªcÁ 3ab*q· `¥ Kø®øï…Ñ & _`∞ st øº Øc ›Ó fl fl Ó ‡ fl Ó fl ˘Ł¯x¦ Ð i-dw· Kabµùg 7 Q Q 7 7 R I R Q 7 :^F:_a :`5 5[ := Tb ( \] F:AB ):Y:3:ZM8 5[ :@ G:;<=JM6 :>NOP :3:?@M8 H :AB:3 S :C:=T U K :D=@ L 4 VWX :EB: N P (! A@mo B:2mX @ n :;B ):2i :>N P :D@k :2:cN a :EB: Q [ ( g€wo :g K :Y :g K :` 5 Nwx):gzb}l @:g{MH [ :g :D==o • <:g| w 8 B:EB:>Q ~Nm :;e j 7 7 7 7 I o 7 Q ƒ Q R ƒ Q „gzb :…B=5 L :B358 :g€ w :;<@PyR := L :F3 K :<@N m OH B:†‡= ‰ L :NO B:g L :EB:=:> 5[ N O U•sT :g L 3:‹K 5O :> N :g€ wl 8 e:g :> N O s ( \o Fe:F:?@ s):AB:Š=o :=5 [ :58NNN :• :g :DB:2:2N a •‘5a :˘>3::2:?@ K a NNm[ :C’P5 :> :• :g| w B:=:‹ K :AB:3:C S T U :^F:gz bl :@ m K :@ v x :g 7Q ƒ Q Q Q •5R O s [ Q Os OPR 7 :D=:gzTbb <:g L 3:‹K :^F:>N :Z5 :@:gG L @:@@5 HamN ˜MR :•=:@:?@:AB – —s ( >N :g uG ) >N B:`X @Nm“ :Q NOs <:

1 Panel of Presiding Officers [ 6 L Mr. Chairman: „YN• 3o B:>Q † ¦ 3 o B:EB:Y ¥ 5 In pursuance of sub-rule (1) of Rule 14 of the Rules of Procedure and Conduct of Business in the Senate, 2012, I nominate the following members in order of precedence to form Panel of Presiding Officers for the 93rd session of the Senate of Pakistan:-

i) Senator Aitzaz Ahsan

ii) Senator Ilyas Ahmed Bilour

iii) Senator Malik Muhammad Rafique Rajwana ƒ Q ƒ [ Q suspension of rules for question :˘`5 [ @« :_N m8 @:•F<@: a ¬ :>Q NOs C’mN M :…@5 m5[ hour. Motion for Suspension of Question Hour Senator Farooq Hamid Naek: I beg to move that under Rule 263 of the Rules of Procedure and Conduct of Business in the Senate, 2012, the requirements of Rule 41 of the said rules regarding Question Hour be dispensed with. Mr. Chairman: It has been moved that under Rule 263 of the Rules of Procedure and Conduct of Business in the Senate, 2012, the requirements of Rule 41 of the said rules regarding Question Hour be dispensed with. (The motion was carried)

Leave of Absence 7 j Q 8 7 j Q QQK7 X ¯ Q I Q ±5R Q ƒ [ Q :>N F: 92 :2ml 3:3:@SM 8 mm58 :c:…@N Ž FC° :cBe::`@5[ «H :=f@:ZNL a M :‚=:…@ X 5 m 5[ ::>NOs C’mN M :…@5 m5[ Q 7 Q Q Q R R 7 j I :DB:gQ L :D=˜R B:g€ wo :AB:˘g J :g ~k :3:>KNNOP :\CK ³ :> O s :A²B:=:‹3B:Z5H K Na M 8 NOa B:

2 j 7 Q Os 4ºs 7 Q QQK7 X ¯ »œ V ¹ Q ƒ [ Q ::>N ::A²B::‹5H :2ml 3:3:@SM 8 mm5 8Ž :c:…@N FC° :cBe:`@5 [ « :e=¦ :2 †• :…@5 m 5 [ ::>NOs C’mN M :…@5 m5[ Q 7Q º s 7 j Q Q Q 7 7 j :c:`K ¸[ <:glwK :DB=B:g€Q NLo ::g :A²B:‹5H 4 :2ml 3:gS L :D= ˜ R B:g€ wJ~ o :AB:˘gR :gk :3:> K NO P R :\CK ³ ¶ Q Q Q X 7K 7 ˚gzb :<=· w :`¸[ <:@NmK :„gz b :c:` l B=N F:92 :2ml 3:3:@SM 8 m58 :c:…@N m Ž FC° :cB e:`5 [ @« :_m[ :…@5N ml :BqB:…@ t 5 m 5 [ ::>NOs C’mN M :…@5 m5[ Q Q Q Q R 7 j 7 Q :DB:gQ L :D=˜R B:g€ wo :AB:˘g ~k :3:>KNNOP :\CK ³ :> O s :A²B:‹3B:Z5H Na M 8 NOa B::@:2=a •• :2<=:DB H X Q NOs C’mN M :…@5 m5[ Q 7 j ƒ Q Q Q :g~k :3:>K NNOPR :\C:>K ³ O s :A²B:=:™5H K •X :¾:2H <=X :½ˆB:N8 F 92 QQQ Q Q Q 7 7K 7 K 7 QQoR 7 o R :`¸[ <:@NmK :„gzb :c:` l B=NOs C’mN M :…@5 m5[ ¶ Q QQQ X7K 7 K 7 Q o ˚gzbw :<=· :`¸[ <:@NmK :„gz b ::c:` l B=NOs C’mN M :…@5 m5[ ¶ Q Q Q Q ƒ X 7 K 7K 7 [ Q o •X ˚gzb :<=· w :`¸[ <::@NmK :„gz b :c:`l B=[ NOs C’mN M :…@5 m5[ ¶ Q QQQ X777K K Q o 4º s ˚gzbw :<=· :`¸[ <:@NmK :„gz b :c :` l B= [

3 7 Q Q Q 4ºs Q K7 X ¯ V 6 Q Q ƒ [ Q :‹ :2N mo @3:@HM8 m58 :c:…@N m Ž FC° ::cBe:g L :`@5 [ « :™n :Á²:™@:…@n 5 H5 m 5[ : :>NOs C’mN M :…@5 m5[ ¶ Q QQQ X7K 7 K 7 Q o ˚gzbw :<=· :`¸[ <:@NmK :„gz b :c:` l B=N :f@T U WmX :…@5 5[ ::>NOs C’mN M :…@5 m5[ ¶ Q QQQ ƒ X7K 7 K 7 Q o •X ˚gzb :< =·w :`¸[ <:@NmK :„gz b :c:` l B=CN Â’• :2C ¿ ::>NOs C’mN M :…@5 m5[ ¶ Q QQQ ƒ X7K 7 K 7 Q o •X ˚gzbw :<=· :`¸[ <:@NmK :„gz b :c :` l B=N :qÄ· :fN m l :…@5 m 5[ ::>NOs C’mN M :…@5 m5[ ¶ Q QQQ ƒ X7K 7 K 7 Q o •X ˚gzbw :<=· :`¸[ <:@NmK :„gz b :c:` l B=NOs C’mN M :…@5 m5[ ¶ Q QQQ X7K 7 K 7 Q o ˚gzbw :<=· :`¸[ <:@NmK :„gz b :c:` l B= [ Q NOs C ’NmM[:…@5 m5[ Point of Order regarding Attack on INPãs Officer Q ƒ Q 7 š ƒ [ Q œ I l ::„>NTOUT :gzb <:3:2K ‘G :`± :c@¯ ´5 R :™@t •Æ :;<@ 4 › ! >Q NOs C’mN M :…@5 m5[ ::‹f:fNa n 4 » :™@:C56 H ’mN ONm Q Q ƒ Q Q È 7 Os R 7Oa I 7 8 »R :gL :D==:ÇSoM±’¬ :3:CM8 e:g K :AB:>N :e@ˆB:Á²5ak B:=:¼<@:Z KN a´ N @R B:˘gz b :@3:@ am K N ˜œ :>C N5 ’É := 5 [ :INP :^N T :gzb <:3 K :Á@ —mË :@MT8 B:3 K :@o :`wNOa :C@:;<@ U 5 a•aM N 5 :^F:½ˆB:„@ 5 N e:² 5H :=K :C ’¬ e:g K :DB: a N :?@ m[ :;CN ’¿ :˘gz b :e= 5[X = :`X = ~H :‡<=M L :D@ P 56 :˘> N 7 8 7 › [O4T› o I Q R [ R 7 :3S B:„gzb :ÍB:^F:g• S :>3N K :…@5a:Y:3:Z:˘gzTM8 5b :@²:>Na5 aN :g€ wKN :g :;fm5± B:Z:q 5 JM :=:gzL b :@ m ~k :=:2 Tb “ BF

4 7 yš 7Q Q 7 7 ƒ J» ›OU7 7 š K › 7 H O s ¯ t Æ :gw { :Y:TTTNNTT :g L 3:`f:`K Xs ± :c:AB:Y:˘@=:@ambN K :=:g L L @:‹:>5 H5 :ŠˆB:AB:c@ ´•45 R :™ @ :;<@ › 7 7 Q K ƒ O „;e:ÇR’¿ @k :BCN : N UT Q Q 6 7 yš O Q O ƒ M[ Q ƒ Q I O l :gL :`@5[ « :‹f:™@:2:D=:@Na n 5 Hi Tb m J 5» :> N s ! >N s C’mN :…@5 m5[ ::_N m8 @a :f@s H :•F<@ ¬ :C ’mN Nm 7 Q Q Æ Q Q Q b •8 O4T› K7 Æ K 7 •± :@²:=:3@e:ga5H K 8 ¬K :DB:2i :2:g€z a w @:™M H N e:: protection :>N :=:‡eB<ˆB:cK :\@t • :2i :gzb :c :…@5a:¼ N 7 7 Q 7 Q Q :gus @ X :AB:2i :D=@3:`Tb[ a K l B= Q NOs : N O UT :e= 5 [X =:`5 [ @« :2‘ HBe:3N8 N T :culprits :™5 :=5[ :N T :gz b <:3K :walk out :™@• ::‹f:fNa n 4 » :™@5 H :C ’mN Nm Q O• 4 ºs 7 •8 ƒ Q Q O ƒ [ Q „>N :3K :‹ :…@:™5aM B:…ˆB:`M 5 [ @ «a¬ :_N m8 @:•F<@::>N s C’mN M :…@5 m5[ Q Q R Q 7 ƒ Q I l ::gzb :B=:D@TbQ Œ ‰ L :™Ÿ5 :=5 [ :2i :@:DF3:Ðq GK ¡ :> NOs :…@:‡C a ³ Fe: :_m8 @ :f@s :•F<@ :C ’mN ONm 5 Q N a H ¬ QQR7 R j ¶ :D@QQQŒ—‰L :@:DB:™Ÿ5 :=5[ :˘> NOUT :ÑN wo @ ÒL :™ Ÿ 5 := 5 [ :cK :DB:„;3:c@qK ¯ a · L :3 M8:AB:Ministry of Information ƒ Q ƒ Oa7 O s 7 7 „>NN @5Ha :‡e:…@NN BfTU :> :;<@5 a :AB:=K :…@ n ²¹ B:…NT :gz b <:3:Á@:gKN— LJ =:gT b € :> N :`wNOa :™@ • :=:…@:‡C 5 [ 5 a  Q ƒ 7 ¶ Q ƒ ¯Q K 7 »yš Os J È Q Q :cˆB:Ímo F<:gl :Óq:c:…ˆB:2 – M i :D=:@TTbmJ5 :>N :g L =:g b w <:q·L f:=:DFCs KMN ’É :DB:N @:g5allbl :DB:3:@:gK5 H :3eB:Ç ÌM± :˘gz :• :g :\@ •—´W :@:c@5R :f@TU X :˘>N T :g wu :g| H :c@ ´•H 5 R :™@ :„g€z w @ M j ƒ 7 7 OQ 8 „23N a ~k :`˜5R :` ˜ 5R :„>NNa ˆB:go :3:@ KmX :3 K j ƒ Q „`5[ @« :EB:f@T U W X :™:56:>Q NOs C’mN M[ :…@5 m5[ Q 7 Q ƒ Q ¸ÀL I Q O ƒ M[ Q Q Q j I O l :N sC’mN :…@5 m5[ ::D@H :EB:f@TU W X :C ’mN Nm ƒ Q Q Q Q Q ¯7 7 Q ssj O•8 ŸR O s K 7 a 6 :h@mPmHakl =}Ž B:c@•8 B:2i :D=:@ Tb bT @:@3:‹@M K :>NN :AB: :˘gzb :c :…@:g5 a«H L :`5[ @ :‹f:™@N n 5 7 4ºs 7 Q O s Ÿ5R :Š=:^F:„gzob :@NNmamS :@e:3:^@K5 8 :3:<=:‹M 8 –K :=:C’¬ e:g Kb :DB:„gz :B=:>T bN :e@ˆB: 5 a Á² k B:™ :^F:Q ~Nm :˘>NN OTTU :™ Ÿ 5 :gwS :A@:g a«n K :DB:`Q 5 [ @ :…@²¹ B:3N8 O U :g L=:gTb J €5 :3::M8 footpath M 7 ƒQ ƒ Q 7Q I 7 R Q R 7 :cK gÔ“ BF:AB:„gz b :B=:gTTb l :Óq– :c K :2‘H Be:…NOP :hN UT :Š=:\q:go5 N8 ] Kb := • ˘gz :2‘m} :@:<@

5 Q 7 Q I Q ƒ Q¥O5 • NR 7 7 Q •8 O•k Q O s 7 8 :DB:˘gzbb :™ B:_B:2:„gzN a N a :\F:@:…@@] —a•5 B:˘>NN :3:Á@:@K —mM8 B:3:Ç K •NO5a :> :DFC ’¬ e:g| wL B:^F:2i :g @5 Hm :@N K 7 7 Q K › I 7 Q •8 :c:gus @ X :AB:2:gzi b :25 m o @ v X :2N a:@:D==:Á@—4S oR :Y:„:gzT b :N •k :3 K Òo Q O ƒ [ Q anybody else who wants to talk on this :3M8 :AB:‹ @5a ::>N s C’mN M :…@5 m5[ Q I Q j 5R „`5[ @« :=f@:ZNL a M H ± :‚=: X issue. Q j j Q Q j K 7 a 6 7 I Q ±5R I O l :EB:f@TUWX :˘gzb :c:…@:g5 a L :`@ 5[ «H :‹f:™@:˘23N n 5 N a ~k :` ˜ 5R : :=f@:ZNL a MH : ‚=X :C ’mN Nm QQ KÆ ŸR7 K7 Ÿ Rƒ Q K 7 Ÿ R :c:D=NwŽ @•k :™5 :Ç@R :;CN ’¿ :„gzb :c:…@:™5 a 5 :g L :`@5[ «a :_N m8 @:NNNNNT :c3:™K N :=:>Lw @:25aaH•a =N K :@@:>5 :>:‹N :>:„gzb :…@:h@ 5 am l = }bŽ B:‡3:2:„gz5 8 N a b :c=T :…@ 5 a IIIIIIÙ 7 Q K Q ŸR Q :D=S = o :;3588 :;3 5 :˘D@Nm~4 e:‡3 5 88 :‡3 5 :˘gK @ 4Ù e:;3 5 88 :;3 5 :„gz b :ÇR @ k :g K :NNN :Ç5± :…@:=:gz5aL b :> :> :?FC ’m :3B:gS K :2 ‘ H Be:…N B:= K j ƒQ Q 7 ƒ ƒ Q I OQ O}Q Q~a ¯ OR 7 I •8 ¯ O :=:DFCKMNN’É :‡3:>58 NNNNs• :?@m[ :;C ’¿ :˘> :2:>aN B:c=:…ˆB:2 KM i :gzb :> P :…@:‡3:™ a 58 B:c=: Kb2::„>N a UT :g w S = T N I Q 5 ƒ 77 7 ÈQ È 7 I :„gL @:=:?@TbL5R :=:e@•x B:B<@ ›TNNN :2 i @:>O• :3:™:c=K›T ¯ JLM 6 :Y: O PR :> O s :Z:g5L K :…ˆB:3M S B:˘3 K:<= JM6 5H • 4 4a Q ¯ I „c @5a CÊœ :‡3 58 7 yš ƒ Q :representation of each political party :2:D=:@i Tb mJ5» :>:NOs:>Q NOs C’mN M[ :…@5 m5[ Q j 6 o 7 a 6 :‡fP¥X :™5 : we give the opportunity to MQM :gzb :c:3:…@:gK 5a L :`@5[ « :‹f:™@N n 5 H „`5 [ @ « j Q Q O Q O ƒ M[ Q j [ I O l on behalf :> N s ! >CN s ’mN :…@5 m5[ :23N a ~k :‡fP¥X :>Q NOW :C@:fT U ¹ m l ( )< :‹a 3K :C ’mN Nm ƒ N I È I Q 7 [ ƒ : Q NOW :Ó@ vo B:f@:;Ca Ú ’¿ : of ƒ 5 7 Q I Q 7 › I Q R full :™•M8 B:gl :Óq:c– K :`wX F=:™=:^fX œ “ ••X :YT :˘>NOUT :>Q ˜5R :_B: N O s :`NwONm l := 5[ :™Ÿ @ k :;C N ’¿ ƒ N 5 Q 7 7 O NR Q :2:=:gzi 5[b :c=:¯ T b conspiracy :=:Ç@5[R k :gK :DB:˘>Q NOTU :g€ w 8 e:=:: K INP :˘:™¥ 5• B:eB<ˆB : AB: support ƒ Q Q 7 ¯ VØœ Q Q › Q ŸR :c=:™THTbMH :Y :_B:Ó²:gN a K :½=M •wb :eB<ˆB:2•a =N K :gz b :™<:=:T conspiracy :Ó²H :gK :DB:2i :™ :reported Q Q Q QQQ O‘s Oa 7 È :D@Œ—ma‰HL :@:>N :ZN5 :˘@NNS :@²:g 5 lLKb :‡e

6 ƒ ƒ Q 7 Os :;<@4T› :„gL @:@5 HN m K :rehabilitate :˘gL @:@5HN m K :compensate :‡f‘5H ::=K :DB:2i :D=:@T b mbT @M H :>N :„gzb :B =Tb ƒ ƒ :„gL @5H :‡e:protection :=K :D=N w 8 @´5 R :™t @ • Æ Q 7 7 Q I š OUJÈ Q O Õ NL › 7 Æ Q ƒ [ Q :‡eB<ˆB:D@NNmam48 <@:™M @ l :Á@R :˘>NNT :gw <:> :`5 l :Y:3:\@T M8 t • :eB<ˆB: :>NOs C’mN M :…@5 m5[ 7 I O ¯ 7 for democracy in our :gzb : important element :B3:2:„>58N a N UT :c3 K : believe :3M8 :\t @ •Æ Q t Æ 7Os 7 a 6 :™@•G :^F:2i :@:DF3:`Kl B=[ N :gl :`@5 [ «a :3@:EB:`q:NNNa ˆB:3:gKo :> s :‡3 uNm :ZBF:=:DB: M K a @5H :A@:gM a K :D=N w 8 @ ´ 5 R discuss on law and order situation, subsequently this incident is Q :@ˆB:™nVn :‹@::™:s — 5 6 concerned with the Interior Minister and he is here. you represent your party. „`5 [ @ « Q ƒ Q you represent your party. :˘`5 [ @« :@ˆB:™ nVn :‹@s — :™:5 6 :>Q NOs C’mN M[ :…@5 m5[ 7 Q j Q L R »MR 7 Q O ƒ M[ Q Q I O l :•u :@:g—Û q:g¡ K :?@:¼@:g kaM M u ´ | :_:D@a P56 :„>CN s ’mN :…@5 m 5[ :23N a ~ k : :@n ˆB:™Vn :‹@s — :C ’mN Nm ¶ Os 7 7 I Ü :@Na : political victimization :>N :N :„™<:>T N :e= 5 [Xw =:_:f:c:D=a H K <@ —m :™ @N l Q j K IIK Q 7 Q 7 b :eFfH :c :e@ˆB:Á²5a k B:Ó² H :gK : news agency :‡3:g58l :`5 l :c :D@m}K @:2M a “ BF:B3 N 7 š I O »y › R 7 7 Q Q K O Q O ƒ M[ Q :2i :>N UT :gwJ { :Y:2TT i :gz b :_N mJ :2: N s ! >N s C’mN :…@5 m5[ Q 7 Q Q 7 7 Q :=K : law and order :>NOUT : duties :cK :DB:2Q i ::@mOH5 :g€zwb @:@3::M H a K expect :™:@›T m8 B:gl :`=X ~H :DB3Q ßa Q Q ƒ ] K 7 Q Ü Os Q È R :™@F:5aN :_‘s :;<=:@M L mJ <:Y@ Ú 7 ] QQ›OQ 8 › K 7] O 7 Ü :™@F:2¬ ia¿ :gzb :2:‡NNNs :D=3:YB:c8 TH• :`=X ~ :™ @¬ F:> s :` X = ~ BNs : Tb N s :N s C’mN M :…@5 m5[ :…@ a :h@ a A=}Ž B:„g€w zb @MH :@ a =T b :hN :notice

7 Q QQQ Q 7 OsQ ¥O5•NR O 4 T› :…@²B:3N :AB:˘gz bL :@e:Ï:gN a [ :D=BF:™ o B:> N := 5 [ :2N a 7Q Q 7 Os L Q 7 7 Q Q ~mo O U :>N :g· { B<:Ç@R k :g K :DB:2‘H Be:…N :>N T : in touch :ÇR @k :;<@ 4 T› ƒ 7 ƒ Q Q Q Q O L 7 ŸR QQ 7 Os O P R :2i :gL @:@5HN m K :> N :@:…@:AB:NN : j ƒ Q 7 Q ¯ 7 Q K „23NNNa~k :`˜5R :„gzb :‡ a N ::D@H :fB<:fTU 4 » :C ’mN Nm 7 Q I Q 7 7b Q 7 Q ~mo Q 7 j :gKb :e@ˆB:Á²5akT B:gz :B=:2b “ BF:B3:@58 m´Ha8 B:2 i :@R :g€z w @:@=:3M TbLK Ì eB:==:`5[ @ «n ::…@² ¹ B:3N 8 N :gz b :De:@ ´k R =M [ :f@N a ƒ Q Q 7 Q ¯ 7 ŸR OsI • žNL O s „gzb :@Nmo :action :c=:_:™Ka 5 B:gL :D= ˜R B:@NmK :=:> L NN :`NwK <@:C s M ’k :™ :> :?e Mr. Chairman: Zahid Khan sahib , direction has been given now and certainly they will look into it but Interior Minister sahib , this is Federal Capital Islamabad, it is your domain, Q OPR ŸR OU K ŸR :3S B:˚gzb :B=TTb :>N :@Na :gz b :B= b :½<5 e:2¿ fÕX :™5 B:3:AB:2M8 i :>N T :gzb <:@:g€5H w :concerns show :™5 B:=5[

8 morning we had a meeting with the Prime Minister on law and order and particularly this issue came under discussion. We are fully alive to the situation and we will make sure that we respect the journalist community and carry out proper investigation and lay hand on the culprits. I assure the House that I respect their sentiments and I think we must condemn such act of lawlessness and I must admit that our police force will be very very actively pursuing this matter and I will be calling the meeting regarding the progress of this case and submit report in the next hearing. Mr. Chairman: In the meantime, you must look into it that what relief can be given to INP also. Now, we move on to item No.2, Col. Mashhadi sahib , may move item No.2. Presentation of Report Regarding Non-cooperative Behaviour of Managing Director Pakistan Security Printing Corporation (PSPC) and Insulting Behaviour of Chief Executive Officer of SEPCO Senator Col. (R) Syed Tahir Hussain Mashhadi: Sir, I, the Chairman, Committee on Rules of Procedure and Privileges, move that under Rule 194(1) of the Rules of Procedure and Conduct of Business in the Senate, 2012, the delay in presentation of report of the Committee on the privilege motion moved by Senator Saeed Ghani regarding non-cooperative behaviour of Managing Director, Pakistan Security Printing Corporation (PSPC), be condoned till today. Mr. Chairman: It has been moved that under Rule 194(1) of the Rules of Procedure and Conduct of Business in the Senate, 2012, the delay in presentation of report of the Committee on the privilege motion moved by Senator Saeed Ghani regarding non-

9 cooperative behaviour of Managing Director, Pakistan Security Printing Corporation (PSPC), be condoned till today. (The motion was carried.)

Mr. Chairman: Senator Col. (R) Syed Tahir Hussain Mashhadi may move item No.3. Senator Col. (R) Syed Tahir Hussain Mashhadi: Thank you sir. I, the Chairman, Committee on Rules of Procedure and Privileges, present the report of the Committee on the privilege motion moved by Senator Saeed Ghani regarding non-cooperative behaviour of Managing Director, Pakistan Security Printing Corporation (PSPC). Mr. Chairman: Report stands presented. 7 Q Q OU b Q È •x because it is your issue. >N T :gzw @:@MH m˜È :ÇM± :…ˆB:@M N m K ! `5[ @« :™ :f N m žl Q Q Q I Q 7 › Os Q •x Oml :„@´R :@N m K : move :™:gT L :>:N privilege motion :2N a ! ‚BF:…@5 m5[ ::™ :fNmžl :C ’mN N O Q Ž 7 IIQ 7 :=5[ :˘> N UT :DBC B:gK :Finance Department :=5[ :;<@4› T :2i :gzb :@3:@ amM8˜È :2:Ç@N a R k :g K :A= } Ž B:;3 5 8 Q I Q Q ƒ ¯ Q L 7 •O4È Os :c @NNm58 :Ïun :N :meeting :3M8 :D@TU F Q j j Q O K• K :move :=K :‡N s ::Motion :2:„cN a :Z =:cK :gL BF3:Kclose :=K :issue :AB:gK 3 K ƒ 7 I Q 7 œ R R È 7 ::^F:Ó²:gHTK :2¿ C’• :Z5[ :„c=:=:¯ b K 2013 :½<@::M s 19 :^F:™ Ÿ meeting :™VPM :c:™K • NO4 :=:Q ~Nm :>NNN Oa ˆB:> O P :>: O s meeting :AB:= L:^F:@´R : privilege motion Q Q 7 7 ŽQ Q premature retirement :gL :25 m[ @« :MD PSPC :=K :½<@:M s16 :2i :@@Na m58 :2:gN a L :C B:D=@:_BL H N a 7 7 Q ŸR K 7 O ŸR 7 :^F:=L :gzb :@mK :apply :3B:2S i :™ :c :raise :…@:2:gaN a L :>N s :™5 :\F:AB:„gz ] b :@e:3 a K :apply :g€wo :g K : Q N 5 ƒ N Q 7 o ƒ 7 R 7 7 R :>NOPR :\] F:AB:^F:>Q ~Nm :g€w8 ²5a :=K :DB:=Q L :˘c S :D= Tb :3M8 : job :™Ÿ5 B:=L :^F:˘c S=:c=:>TTb ¯ bNOPR :=: L allow :™Ÿ5 B I ƒ 8 › O•O4È O O Establishment Division :gS :>3:N Krefer :YT :issue 2:2NNa i :B=:gTb – :2:> a NNNs :™N :> s :f 5L :„> a ˆB Q 7 7 ŸR 7 Q Q :=:2:25[ NNa i :@´R :@@N a m 58 :™5 :2:g a L :Finance Division :\] F:AB:N :Y:Tb NN :^F:>N :> :gL 3:K adopt := K

10 Q 7 Q È :‡ <@4T› :`5 5[ :=K :‹3B::Na M8 10 :NO´ < N Q ƒ ƒ R R 7Q 7 :NNOa ˆB:> O P :™Ÿ5 :qJMR :D=@Q LH :^F:=:c=: L¯ T b meeting Q Q ƒQ ƒ 6 Q O4T› Q ~mo ¯ O P R Q ¯ ŸR :=:g5[L :D= ˜ R B:™:2:gz5 i b : notification :_B:2:˘@N a NNaNNmS :@e:Ï:2:> a [ a NN :>N :cˆB:> :CN ’MÉ :c=:™ K 5 ƒ ƒ •S K Q Oa I 7 o :gzb :™ :=Tb : retirement accept :c :DB:=K :½<@:ZM sN @ ´R B:˘@ ´m R :@N K :apply :g€w :g K :: retirement QQQ 7 OR7 Q KQQQ Q OOO R 7Q K 7 7 :„gzb :>NNNNP :… UPsT :> :> :`<²:cX s :D@ m}K @:`=M a X ~ H :^F:…B:M8 N C’mN :=: K issue :AB:g€w :AB:>N T :™ :=Tb : retire :2:2NNa i :@=MH • :2:™ a 5 :gL :> N Q 7 Q R o Q :f 5L :gK :retirement :D=Q L @H :^ F:™Ÿ5 :½ˆB:>5 Q ~Nm :@e:3a K :close :gL :D=˜R B:„>e:3N8 K :wind up :=K :AB:˘>NOUT @ MH N I •Oa Q :„>NNOUT :™Ÿ N 5 :>: O s office :g|w8 B Mr. Chairman: Saeed Ghani sahib , it means you do not agree with the report which has been laid by the Chairman of the Committee. If you read para 20 of the reportÉ. j Q Q I Q 8 K Q Ÿ5R Q S Q •x Oml :^<@5a Fe:N 3 :2a : close :™ B:=K :AB:2 i:gzb :ANOTU :gL 3K :D=NwK :mislead :NOUT :gwo = 5L :D=N wK :…= J 56 :g w X @ k Mr. Chairman: Saeed Ghani sahib , this is a report and you are confronting the report itself. Para 20 says åthe apology was tendered and you accepted that.ç If you want to raise an issue regarding the report and if you have any objection to the report, that is something different. If you want to raise that issue that she is still working over there, you may move a privilege motion for that but now this report stands laid before the House. This is the report of the Committee signed by the Chairman of the Committee which says that you have accepted apology tendered by her. I Q Q I Q 7 K Os Q R •x Oml „D=Tb :@mN8 e:3 :move :^<@5a Fe:> N ! …@5 m5[ :gzb :_N mJ :™ :fNmžl :C ’mN N Mr. Chairman: We may move to Item No. 4. Senator Col. (R) Tahir Mashhadi may move item No. 4.

11 Senator Col. (R) Syed Tahir Hussain Mashhadi: Thank you sir. I the Chairman, Committee on Rules of Procedure and Privileges, to move that under rule 194(1) of the Rules of Procedure and Conduct of Business in the Senate, 2012, the delay in presentation of report of the Committee on the privilege motion moved by Senator Mukhtiar Ahmed Dhamrah @ Aajiz regarding insulting behavior of Chief Executive Officer of SEPCO, be condoned till today. Mr. Chairman: It has been moved that of rule 194(1) of the Rules of Procedure and Conduct of Business in the Senate, 2012, the delay in presentation of report of the Committee on the privilege motion moved by Senator Mukhtiar Ahmed Dhamrah @ Aajiz regarding insulting behavior of Chief Executive Officer of SEPCO, be condoned till today. (The motion was carried)

Mr. Chairman: We may move to Item No. 5. Senator Col. (R) Tahir Mashhadi may move item No. 5. Senator Col. (R) Syed Tahir Hussain Mashhadi: I the Chairman, Committee on Rules of Procedure and Privileges, to present report of the Committee on the privilege motion moved by Senator Mukhtiar Ahmed Dhamrah @ Aajiz regarding insulting behavior of Chief Executive Officer of SEPCO. Mr. Chairman: Report stands presented. Senator Col. (R) Syed Tahir Hussain Mashhadi: Thank you very much sir. I have a very important matter for which I need your permission. Three political parties of Pakistan, the most important political partiesÉ.

12 Mr. Chairman: Col. sahib , this House was requisitioned for discussing law and order situation and you are one of those signatories. ƒ „gL @5H :ˆB:motion :3M8 :AB (Interruption)

Mr. Chairman: It can be discussed over there › O „@G :=Tb :discuss :™T :>N s :law and order :2N a 7 Q ( ( `uH Bf s) Mr. Chairman: Farooq Naik sahib , what is your opinion? 7 Q OQ l O T› R ƒ Q Q œ I O l „>NN• :>:=:>L 4 :guP |:g l :`@5 [ « :_N m8 @:•F<@ a ¬ ! …@5 m5[ : :‹f:fNa n 4 » :™@:C56 H ’mN Nm 6 7 7 Q ƒ X :B=:2Tb‘4 :3:AB:˘@M8 ´UR :@<:=:2T Tb Wu5H :B<@ 4PmaT› :D@N R :˘@NNS :@e:²:C5 H ’¬ e:@:DB:„gz —b :ÍB:• 2 ‘ m } :@: — Law and order I 7 š KQQ 7 ƒ X ~mo „„„:=:D=KN w8 <@:™MMam @N l :c :D@ ma } K @:2i :gzb :ÍB:=:2• L ‘m} :2:>N a N O È ƒ 6 ƒ [ Q „>N • =J :_N m8 @:@:`@s—5[ « :‹f:™@:N a n 5 H :>Q NOs C’mN M :…@5 m5[ Q I 7 Q 7 OR 7 Q Q O œ I O l :…²@s X :gK : election :^F:2i :g zb :>NNP :…<@B:=:D=5HKN w 8 <@:>M a a ::‹f:fNa n 4 » :™@:C56 H ’mN Nm Q I Os 7 7 ] O•R O s :=Tb : elections :>N :g{L =Û :_B:2N a i :gz b :@mWß• :@NL B:„gz b :…<@B:=:D=5 H KwN 8 <@:™@:M aa5 NN :2 Œ [ :<=qM L J5 :> 7 Q j OUb Q 7 › O P R Os] O U :_k :g{L :…ˆB:„>M NNT :gz w @MH :@3:…@:3:AB:Y:„gz aK5 a M 8 TT b <:=:>b :elections :>N :D== 5L Û :™@:5a N T :gzb < ƒ Q ƒ Q ƒ 8 ŸR › •S ŸR • l •S • l Q 7 O• ƒ Q :>3:™N K 5 :: walkout :Y:˘™T :™5 :™ :@:Na ™ :™ :2:…@:‡<@a 5a4TN› :3B:„>S :gL B<:g l :`@5 [ «a :_N m8 @ „g S Q Q O ƒ [ Q „`5 [ @« :‡<=x :3@:585 a :>N s C’mN M :…@5 m5[ Q Q 7 Q Os ƒ M[ Q Q Q I O l issue :@— :law and order :2i :gzb :2:…@N a 5a ! >N C’mN :…@5 m5[ ::‡<=x :D@H :358 @ a :C ’mN Nm 7 Q 5 OWX 7 7 7 •±Æ :@:‹5m‰ :gK :D@Q }NK @:\F:AB:„gz] bL :c:…@:¼K :g :`@5[ :‹f:™@:˘gza n 6 b :@<:=:Tb discuss — maM 5 aNT «HU7 5 7 7 ‰OWX 7 :D@Q m}K @:g al :>:D=NOs wx @ 4 56 : secular forces and liberal :B:;B::gNNUT w~k :g o :2Œ[ :>: s elections :2N a :2 i :‡e:3K :draw :CN ’• • :_B:gN a L :DFfm}ML :@P• 8 B:

13 7 Q 7 O~k OR O O O 7 Q :„>NNNm :go :> P :2Œ[ :>: s forces election :2:N aNNUT :gw~k :g o :2 Œ [ :>: s election :`l Fe:gK :DB Q ƒ ƒ Q Os O • O U ¯ ¯ :3:DB:>M8 NNN :?@Nm[ :;CN ’¿ :„> :go :^F:˘>T :c=:cˆB:Tb adjournment motions :=:g5[l :g o B=:AB [ ƒ ƒ Q 7 7 Q Q 7 :parties :3:AB:2M8 i :gL @:5Hmessage :2:=:ÁB=N aK x :gK :D@maa}K @:2M i :@:gz b :‡N T :c =Tb :c BF3K :r :adjournment motions :g L ƒ Q ƒ [ Q „`5 [ @« :_N m8 @:•F<@: a ¬ :>Q NOs C’mN M :…@5 m5[ Q 7 Q ƒ Q I O l sentiments with : gK : D=Ok Fe: ;C N ’¿ ! …@5 m5[ : :_N m8 @:f@as H :•F<@:C ¬ ’mN Nm 7Q 7I 7 7 Q Q Os•8 › Q O a ¯ :3:D=:Ç@ßs TTbRk :gKb :DB:>N :„gz ::3:2M 8 ×HN5 :™M B:^F:˘gz b :™<:=:Ç@T bw[ R kaa :g K :D=8 <@:>M N:= 5 :c e@<:N regard to specially the situation :3:„>NN8 K O UT :g w ~k :3: K discuss :=KM :DFCNN’É :Á@4R :DB:`Q l Fe:;C ’¿ ::in ƒ Q Q X Q OU 7 Q 7 Minister for Interior and :„gL ˆB:g w @k :CN ’MÉ :C:˘>TM UN T :D@NNNN ma8 e@<:CNN ’MÉ :‡<@k :2:„>N a NUT :e= 5 [ =: X Minister for Law to answer the relevant questions j 7 K7 È O ¯ O Q :3:AB:„gzM8b :@<:=:gTUTb l :25H F:c :‡e3 S :`} Tb e:Ç M± :`5 l :2:N a NN UT :c@5 H :ˆB:> s :;q<œ :g K :law and order QQ7 ƒ Q Q R j R :=:CKMNNN’É :C:`T Ul Fe:;C ’¿ :„cS :>NOa @:ˆB:g5HkwX @ :>C N 8 ’ MÉ :`5 l :N T :g w k:3K : discuss ƒ Q Q 7 „cS :gL @:=::C5H TbMN ’É :C:3:ë=T U M8 ÛX =:AB:=:g L S :>3:N8 K start Mr. Chairman: Let us have a view of sahib . Q j 7 ¯ Q O´È L 6 what is your view?:`5[ @«a« :c@<:@5 <:„>N <:ÑCN L  :…ˆB:˘`M 5 [ @ «H :™@5 7 Q I Q 7 š Q Oa7 »yš O s Q ¯ Q Oml :single out :=:D=K wx @456 :™@N ml :>NN :2:D=:@i T b m J 5 :> ! …@5 m5[ :c @5a<:@ « <:D@N m X :C ’mN N 7 j ŸR uL ¡ » œ O U7 7 b Q law and :™5 :• :@— :AB:3:<=MM8– :™ = ¦5 :N T :gzb <:=:…@T b “ BF:g K :‡e3 ST8 :`} e:3:DB:˘gz b :@<:@T UHm5 :@N K 7 j j R 7 :>Q NNOa :DB:gQ uPR | : 8 e:B3K ::ëFC ³ :`± 5 :3M 8 :law and order :3:<=M8 – :‡<=:…ˆB::„gz Ž M b :™›T :Ç@R k :g K :order ƒ 7 Q Oa ŸR 6 Os 8 “ Q Q ƒ 7 :>N @5H :ˆB:™5 : issues :Á@4R :2:NN :AB:„>e:r=X := K : senators :@Na :D@ G f m8@4R :gK :D=wx @ 4 5 6 Q 7 j :„@G :=Tb :`5 l @ m X :=:>e:BF3 L N8 K :ëFC³ :debate :3M8 :<=– :‡<= Ž :…ˆB:3M S B::„g S

14 j ƒ Q I will give floor :„>N8 e:3K :motion move :…ˆB:˘`M 5[ @« :‡f P ¥X ::>Q NOs C’mN M[ :…@5 m5[ Q 7 O• 7 R Let start with the :„>N :3 K:…@5a :NO• :3K : motion move :…ˆB:M motion on law and order situation. opportunity to you and Haji Adeel sahib . 7 Q ( ( `uH Bf s) 7 ƒ ƒ Q :„D=:@TTbmN8 e:r=:=“ XK :…ˆB:qM JMR :gL @5 H :=: b motion move :guP |:R:>Q NOs C’mN M[ :…@5 m5[ 7 Q ( ( `uH Bf s) Mr. Chairman: Please, we have to go by rules. Q 7 K Os V I O l I am on point of :„D=:@<:3Tb TUK :…@:c5 a : rules : >N : :½=M u5a :™n :3@58« :C ’mN Nm order. ƒ [ Q :2N a :what is the violation of the rules?:˘`5 [ @« :½=M u5a :3@58 « ::>Q NOs C’mN M :…@5 m5[ 7 sahib È j j 7 Baloch has raised a point of :„>NNO´ <:ÑCN L ÂL :˘`@5[ « :‡f P ¥ X :„>e:@ 8 m 58 order. What is the violation of the rules? Point of Order Regarding use of Impertinent Language by the Former Chief Minister against President of Pakistan. j Q K Q O ƒ M[ Q I O l : clause 41 :c :Constitution :…ˆB:„2M N a 3 ~k ! >N s C’mN :…@5 m5[ :½=M u5a :™Vn :3@58« :C ’mN Nm º Clause 41 says :„> NO´ Nae åThere shall be a President of Pakistan who shall be the head of the state and shall represent the unity of the republic.ç This is what the Constitution says. ƒ Q Q ƒ 7 Q ¯ 7 Q Oa O U8 7 7 O s Q :c @P•8 B:=K : office :gK :NNN ˆB:2i :>T :g w @:`5H 5 l :2 i :D=:@ˆB:3:…@:AB:>Tb aM8 5 a :…B5 ! …@5 m5[ ¶ :AB:gl :ì@:g•Ü K :;fP¡ :g K :NOs :Article 248(2):„gzb :@PÈ :respectable and superior ƒ 7 Q O Q ¯ ŸR :unity of republic :3:D@M8 PN R :2i :D=:@Tb mHmbT @M :@ ˜ È :2:>N a N s ! ‚BF:…@5 m5[ :„gzb :c=:‡e:™Tb 5 :immunity := K

15 L K The then Chief Minister, Ex-Chief :„gzb :@<:@:@TU5 HN m K : disregard :gl :g€ ” q:Z:=– K Q 7 7 QQ7 j j •8 OU Q u wX Q 7 Q :™M B:^F:˘>N T :gL 3K :?@4ÔOk B:D @<:=:•5a5[ :gK :D@ ma}K @:N UT :g L 3:`@K 5 – • :gl :g€ ” q:Z–5 :=:D@K m}K @:N s :DF3qN8 ” L Q Q O I Q •o :N UT :2Œ[ :@:`—w¦N <@:ABM a 7 O KQ QO K I Q •o :>N s : personal and official capacity :c :AB:=:aK N UT =:c L :`w¦N <@:‡<=M a M L QQj Q Q L [ I OsQ ~mo 7 O P R :<@5m˜š :gl” :g€ q:Z:2:gz– 5 i b :@ ´ºNa e:2×H5 :C:˘gzT U b :@3:>:DF<@ ímM8 NN 5 [~K B:g L :…ˆB:>M N :@ mHmk :@:@5 N :> :discuss Q Q j Q Q ƒ ∗ 7 7 Q j ¯ OU Q Q :^F:`5 5[ :2i :gzb :@PÈ :e=[ :g L :ÑCN L ³ :N T :gL 3::?@K 4ÔOk B:D@<:‡f5 a mS :ÑCN L ³ 7 7 7 œQ j 7 R 5 R Q j 7 Q š œ 7 7 :gL 3:A=K} ± :cfS mX C:`³ ˜5R :™Ÿ5 :g| » :>:qNOs Jñ:;CN ’¿ :„gzb :c=:cf¯Tb S mX C:` ³ ± :g{ J» :=:> L NOUT :g L 3:3qKN 8 ”L 7 7 7 Q O O :@3aK :ÁBC’É B:`˜5R :@ — :D=S =:g o K :Í N mo ( )D :>N s : this is what Nawaz Sharif says.:> N UT 7 7 ƒ •8 QQ7 V »œ Q ~o O »Vk º • I he :=:gzLb :™N e:3:BfK mS :=:…‚@:;<=:™ KL5 a M ´ M :‡f m S :_B:>N a Nm :>N UT :Š=:g ob LJJÌ =:g{TT :NOa ˆB:3M8 :pattern Q Q j j O´ºNa QQ }NO4È } ~ mo 7 :g€L e code of conduct :gL :D=˜R B:˘>N e:=:> K :>N B:2:gzi b :2::…@:‡CFeN a 5a ³ 7 ƒ ¡ 7 7 L X :‹4 e<:@:DB:=:>3:…@:™—Q L N8 K a ¥N B:• u w :gK :Chief Election Commissioner :2:3a S B:„>NOUT :gL = Tb ƒ 5 N ¯ Q 7 œ I Q 7 :c=:=:`K K 5 [ @« :‡N ;3K :fm}MML :2:@:;3a N a K :f m } L personally 7 7 j Q j Q j 7 Os O U 7 u wX Q OU ±š žX :AB:>NN :„>T :gL 3K :…@5a :[****] • :gK :DB:`@5 [ « ::ÑC:N L ³<@5m˜š :„>:òN T :C5 ’m :gl :`:g5 l K Q j j 7 Os Q 7 Q 6 QQ}NO4È } ~ mo O s ƒ :>N :˚gzb :@Nmoaction :@k :D=K :gL :…ˆB:2M i :D=:@TbmHmbT @:@M J M =:gM Ll :> :>N B:g l :Ï=:gl L K :…ˆB::>:AF@M N T U Q Q 6 ¥K 7 R Q 7 :gK :¼:™5 5 :g K :…ˆB:2M ml B=± Bf:3B:2:D=:@H S i T bmJM6 =:gM L l Chief Justice of Supreme Court Q j 7 7 ƒ 7 ±š OU O 7 š 7 ¯ u wX :3:@:2K 5H ×H5 :C:òT U :2:„>N a N T :g€w• :g o suo-motu notice :\F:™] B:…ˆB:=:=M LT b :…@:c5a = K :• j Q Q 7 7 Os Q j K 7 œ „23N a ~k :˚gzb :@Nmonotice :@k :D=K :gL :…ˆB:3M M8 :…@5 a :AB:„gz b :@ a 3 K [****] ::>N :D@k :c :`~‘4 N :gzb <:;3:\3 :2:<@:‡CNNa5a  :2 a ! >N C’mN :…@5 m5[ ::^@k :™n qÄ– :fNml :C ’mN N OU Ÿ•K „>N T :gzb <:3:@K NmK :2:N a[****] :™5 :[****]

∗ [Expunged as ordered by the Chairman]

16 7 7 8 j Q O ƒ [ Q :…@5a :=L gS :>N 3 Kdiscuss :3 M8law and order :` 5 5[ ! `@5 [ « :^@ k ::>N s C’mN M :…@5 m5[ j Q •o motion : Š= o: …ˆB:M you may move the motion.!`@5[ « :‡f P ¥X :‹3:„@:g€{a K G w±N :3 K 7 Q „D=TTbXK :@mN8 e::r“ = := :…ˆB:>M NNOs :qJMR :˘> 8 e:gL = b move Senator Col. (R) Syed Tahir Hussain Mashhadi: I beg to move that Under Rule 263 of the Rules of Procedure and Conduct of Business in the Senate, 2012, the requirement for Rules 25, 26, 29, 30 and 133, read with Rule 218 of the said Rules be dispensed with in order to move the following motion:- åThe House may discuss the law and order situation in the country, especially in Karachi.ç Mr. Chairman: It has been moved that Under Rule 263 of the Rules of Procedure and Conduct of Business in the Senate, 2012, the requirement for Rules 25, 26, 29, 30 and 133, read with Rule 218 of the said Rules be dispensed with in order to move the following motion. åThe House may discuss the law and order situation in the country, especially in Karachi.ç (The motion is carried.) j 7 Q ƒ Q „`5[ @« :EB:f@T U WXT :™:„D=:@56 b m N8 e floor :=K :…ˆBM ! :`@5 [ « :‹3:a K:>Q NOs C’mN M[ :…@5 m5[ Q Q ¡ QQOƒ M[ Q•[ ¦ 6 ¥ 5 L Q Q j I O l :\5 N8 q¡ : F: ` 5 Nw5± ! >CN s ’mN :…@5 m5[ :„YN 3B:>o 3B:EB:Y o : :D@H :EB:f@TU W X :C ’mN Nm ƒ I 7 O ¶ ¶ Q Q OQ O ƒ [ •8I „>N a @qs t :2v[ ² s:ì@áo B:gK :DB:BNNUT :`5 [ @ « :> s C’mNMM :™ e:2:˘gzN a b :?@ • R <= Û j j Q Q Q j I Q ±5R I O l „„„„gzb :@<:2TUPÈ :ÑCN L ³ :<@5 m ˜š :2:N a :=f@NLa MH :Z ‚= X :C ’mN Nm Mr. Chairman: Order in the House, no cross talk. 8 7 j „>N 3K :…@5a :…ˆBM ! `5[ @« :f@T U W X Q 7 QI I Q 7 K 7 R ¶Q ¶ 8 Q Q j Oml :D=˜R B:˘gzb :…@:c5a :N :?@ 4 ÔOk B:™5 :ÏÀo :c @4N•o <@CM a N ’Þ :c=K :_:½ˆB:ga 5 L

17 Q ƒ j Q Q K7 ¯ Q I Q ±5R I O l „gzb :c :…@5a :2N a :g L :c @ ´ 5 R :g K :DB::=f@NLa MH :Z ‚= X :C ’mN Nm 7 Q ( ( `uH Bf s) Mr. Chairman: Chandio sahib , please no cross talk. 7 Q :AB:…ˆBM you will get the opportunity to respond :=:gzL b :A@:gMa K :DB floor :` 5 5[ Q „>N8 3K :2a :½q – Q QQQ Q È Q Q Q j I l :D=@:˘>3QQLÚNNN8K :Ó= [ :@ — :BfH :ÇM± :˘> OUT :gzb <:D=@3 L Ú N 8 O s :™ Æ@:…ˆB:s M :D@Q :EB:f@U X :C ’mN ONm HT W Q „„„„:c¯ BqyºH :c K Mr. Chairman: Mushahid Ullah sahib , please address the Chair. 7Q ƒ Q j I Q 7 K ¯ ¯ 7 7 Q KQ S Os Q Q j Oml :2i :gzb :…@:c5a :ce@<:c@N aP•8 B:2:2NN ai :D=:@ Tb mHabT @:@3:AM a N : :D@H :EB:f@TU W X :C ’mN N 7 Q Q 7 Q Q Os « › K Q Q •8 I œ :@<:ˆB:C@:^F:gzTUaT U5 b :2mNOi :@ — :?e:=5[ :> N :‹ B:˘gz b :™T <:@5 H4 :c :?@ ÔOkB:D@5a <:‡fmS :™ B:Ó²H :gK :DFNOPR :…B= 5[LL :@:D==3:gK ow @:g|8 B= 5 [ :> N O UT :Š=:;<@ o :^F:2:2 :gz b :2:…@:> N O s« :‹ B:„gz b j 5 —— kNNa i a 5 a ƒQ Q Q R ƒ œ Q j Ll±š K MR uLJb´»M 7 »OPR U O s Q } ~Nmo w o :g @:@5HËsL @:g :ò :Z:…@7 5 W—ka[ :@:D=@o :¼@:gM | :2:gi @:@@ 5HamN 58 :g{ :„gz <:ˆB:>NN :C@:T 5 a > :> B:g€ Q ƒ Q Q Q 7 OPR •uWL Ž I O U OPR :D=NNwK :˘@´mR :@N K :>NN :YN :D= w K :2‘ŒNw :@:…<= —U ~˜Nm8 @:gT L :D=R B:„>T :gz b <:ˆB:e@:`@N a«5 [ :N B:½ˆB:„@5 G Q Q Q ¶ ¯• 8 Q o 7 Os 7 :ÏÀo :@:c@—•Um¹5 5M :N :` l @ m l 7 7 Q 7 Q 7OU¶ 6I R 7 O P R :ÑN wuÒL :=:DB:\F:AB:˘>K]N T :ì@ámo B:g| J B:;3:2:@5 8 N a NNK :˚g Jb :gz <:= • :…ˆB:\F:AB:˘M ] @ m4 K :>N :?@ÔOk B 7QQ 7 7 Q 7 KOU˜È ¯8¯8• • II Q Ÿ•K O U ˜ È ŸŸ› • K R O P R :AB:`²:c:•@F:@X n ¬mN K :„>NNNTT :gw :c@55 ••MM :c@ 5 5 :3:<@K ËË5L :<@ 5 L :2mX :™5 :˘‡==:>o X :g w :™ 5 :˘™ :™T <:=T b :> ƒ Q 7 7 7 »œ R yš 7 7 7 S :˘;=uNa <:½ˆB:25 i :>NNOa @m58 :g{J :„g ~k :> O P :@ ´5 » :=:`²:c KLX nK :•@F:=:\F:AB:…ˆB:„gz ¬ ] M b :c ¯3:=K ß m À :c K :½q – Q Q Q O• Q 7 :^fm58 : @mM8 B: …ˆBM :˚>N :2:ga l :`@5 [ « :‡ NOP leadership :c=:˘>¯ KNNOUT :gL =:gT b S @´5 R :Š=:;<@ o k :=:g L K :…ˆB:„>3M 8 Knominate Q Q 7 Q Q ƒ R 8 Os7 Q •8 Q ƒ OOJO PUsR ñ :@:?@—ka :¼@:g|M MMw B:>NNNN :…@@5 a• B:^fm8 ˆB:2i :gz bb :Á=u XT :=:…ˆB:„gz KMM <:@:3:> aK :2 ‘ 5a @ Õ X :…ˆB:˘> :g L} =T b :g :> 7 Q „gw~k :;e:>NOPR :…B=5 5[ Q j a 6 j Q ƒ [ Q „`5[ @« :‡f P ¥X :‹3:™:„@K 5 N m S:ˆB:…B=5 5[ :@— :…ˆBM ! `5[ @« :EB:f@T U W X :>NOs C’mN M :…@5 m5[ 7 Q ( ( `uH Bf s)

18 Mr. Chairman: I will look into all those words. Col. Mashhadi sahib , floor is with you. Senator Col. (R) Syed Tahir Hussain Mushhadi: Thank you Mr. Chairman, I am really grateful. j Q Q ƒ 7 II Q Q 7 Q – 8 › I 6II6 ¯¯Q 66 Q :3:ëFCKK³ :@3:?@aNN m—ma[ :@ :D@ }K @:>M F:;<@ m M 8 :g|w B::YT :3 SK B:3 :<=JKMMM :=:DF3ß´5 :cB3:cBe:g o L = JJ :g L = :DB 7 › Talbanization Oi Q – 8 :™T <=Tb : of the election :g€} :˘gz b :@<:=:@TUmkTb NNK :Ç@R :g K :>F:;<@ m M 8 :AB:2i :>eN I 7 7 Q ¯Q NOQQa 7I I QOa K 7 8 8 › :=5[ :c<@3MMMMauMm M :D@ mama}K @:˘:D@N 8 <@:‡3:>5 8 N :c :D@ ma } K @:½ˆB:„>e:2=:35 N 5H L M 8 future :gK :ÁB=x :g| w B:Y:˘gzT b 7 I I Q œ •X K Q 7 ¯ I :AB:˘`wX F=X :™ = “ :^f • third largest party :c :D@m}K @:fM a 5L :gK :A B:NNUTT :ì@áo B:gL =:gTb J :3:a Ú N a U Q j QQOs Q } ~mo 7 K 7 OU :_B:gN a L :D@5m¹o @:>::>N N B:AB:N T : and tolerant 7 Q Q j › Q O Q :gL 3K :‡<@a :g L @ P 5R :2WNO4T :g€ wKo :g :DB:^F:˘>N UT : apologist :=5[ gK :DB:„gz b :‡e:3K :Bf NmM8polarization 5 Q Q 7 7 R :3S B ! =e3:„>o 58NOUT :3 Ì f iAmericans :2i :D=:@@Tb a m58 :>NOs :„gzb :@ W N L B:g l :2F:c:25 HK • aN qBœ ! ™:>56 NNOP :2i :> O UT 7 7 Q 7 Q Q 7 7 › :D@m}K @M a :˘=Tb :gL B3 Sbombs :D=NwK :3:ÁB=M8 x :\q5 N8 ¡ :gK :D@m}K @:˘F<@M a s:= KAmericans :3K :@5H :=L :gzb :` ¦T Q 7 QQ7Q K 7 I œ j :D@ma}K @:˘gzMMb :Ím5[ :c:D@ maP } K @:2:2:@N a i È :g L :Ó@ m l :™<ˆB:ÓˆB:ÑN wM [L :„=:gTb 3:fK Nm˜š :D=NN wKwŽK :=:D=5 [ =:g K 7 Q Q 7 j OU ˜È È V´È QQQ}QTb Q K :3:K NT :gw ::²´ ::Y = 5[ :D@5m¹o @ :^F:„gz bK :Ó²:g H :D@ 5 m¹ o @ :DB:˘gz bK :Ó²:g H :DFe3ß m e:DB:Ím5[ :c 7 7 7 Q[OU ¯ O UIIQ KQ 7 Q O a OU :>5 :NTT :c3:<@K NNNmM8 :gl :ÁB=x[ := 5 :˘> N :D@ ma 8 <@:fMMMm}ML :Á:B= x :c :D@ mama }8K @:= 5 [ :D@ <@:> N :2 i:>N T :gL @´È e:g K I Q ƒ QQQ j 7 Q ¯OPR 8 OO} Ps R Q ~mo Q O U ::ÍmONmX :3<@:˘A=8 — uK5H :2Wu5H :c=:>NNNNN B:˘g SL :>e:g ˆB:> :>:>N B:=:DB:˘> KT :g Ll 3:<@K Nm M8 :ÁB= x :g 7 Q Q I R R :„=Tb :gzb}b <:B3N 8 Kbomb blast :3:DB:e:gNN8 L 3 K :> O P Q Q j Q I Q o 7 6 X K•8 ¯ Q NOQa 7 :DFN T :;3:g o l dictators :2:˘>N a NNT :c :D@q:>5a] @ 5 H j Q Q Q Q OU Q OU O P R SQ Q o :˘>N T :gzb <:=Tb :fNm˜š :2a BNNT :> :Š=:goow BF:g @´5 R :2:˘gzN a b :@e:D=N a [ :@ m M8 B:g€ wK :g :ÁB= x Q 7 Q Q I œ •X OU KQQ o 7 86 KQ7 K Q Ÿ 5R :gK :`wX F=:™=:^fX“• „>N T :g€ wwK :D@q:g€5a] :g :\<=N ˜y5 ::c:D@ ma—}K @:><@:DF :D=wÀT :Fe:‡3[ ˆB:DB:N a N T :g w :g€ w bomb blast :˘gzb :@NNmS :@ m K :‹ :g l :™

19 Q Q 7 7 OOR QQ8I 6 Q O ˜È Q 7 O b 7 6 :>NNNNPs :=:`f:g|K5sTTbw B:> :˘FCNN’´M :2:=:`f:;Ca K 5s b ’¿ :2 i :> UTT :g wKw :ÁB=:g x :D@m}K @:„>M a U :gz @:M H \N8 <= ˜ y5 7 7 › Q 7 O IIQ I 6 :„gzb : ™T <: = Tbmovement repeat :D@ma}K @:=:2:„>M LN a N TU :gzwb @M H :Á²k B:a ÚN :Ó²:gHK :Y Bf@:D@ ams ÚmaPN 8 <@:fM } ML @• 8 B:ß s :™ :D@ maama}K @@:MM=K :D@ } K @ :˘>N Q Q Q 8 ¯ 7 Ÿ5R Q :foot steps follow :gK :BeBe:…@:g|M 5a w B:2i :gz b :Ðq:@:c@t —ma}K @:C:™M T U :½ˆB„@5 N m K :reject :=K :D= S = o :DB j ƒ K Q QQI QQQ }NLQ protection :c :D@5mo @ ¹ :2N a :guarantors :gK :D@5m¹o8 @ :2NNNa :D@N ma <@M :fm}ML :D@ 5 m¹ o @ :2 a : 38 @ am¹ @ 5 o @ :2 a „;3 K Q j Q Q Q I ~ o „>NOUT :Š=::goow BF:go @ÒL :A= u5H :g }K uH {:g :D= J ÈQ ‚:˘:DFo }ONm B:>N s : I I j 7 ¯ I Q › ¯¥L K :ad :‡F:c gK:`wX :_B:„:gzN a b :™TN <:ˆB:3:‡F:c:CM8 ’P :c :g| L F<:D=N e:…B=5 5 [ :™5 :@— :?B= • :AB:˚@ˆB:gNal :D@ PÈ :@ W NOMa :2:N a:„ >N T :g€w • :@NmM8 F<:ÇK ‚:ö3e:3N8 u m :g€w :g K QQQ7 K7 K 7 8 ŸR :D==:DB:`=So~XH :c :D@ma}K @:˘:½=:cMM5 Ž :D@ ma } K @:`5 5 [ „>e:…B=N5 5 [• :™5 :@:?B= — :AB:gzb :@<:3T U K : protect 7 7 Q 7 Os OU 7 K Q › Q :B=Tb :@´º• :>N :Article 6:=:>L N T :gL 3:…@:cK 5a :Article 6:2a B ¹ N T :gw :™ :Š=:2:o N a using force against the Constitution of Pakistan. 7 7 7 Q OU ˜È Ÿ•K 8 QQ› OU˜ÈŸ•K O U6 O U ˜ È Ÿ • K OO UP R :>:gN T w :™5 :„gS :>N 3 Kevoke =:DB:Y:2K T i :>NNNNNTTTT :gw :™5 :˘> :g| J B:D@5mo @:> ¹ :g w :™ 5 :˘> :> ƒ Q 7 È •K L › safe : =K : DB:Q in return :NOUT :gw˜È :ÇM± :™Ÿ5 : „gS :>NOa ˆB:g o :ZBF:=:½=:™M K5 Ž •M8 B:3:@:Y:2K 5H T i Q ƒ OQ 7 u H Æ Q ¯ :F3:>KNs :D@m}K @:;<=::A=M aMLu 5H :˘F3:g K } {:gz b :™ q:=œ 5 [ :…ˆB:2M i :gz b :@ P È :2:=:DB:N a K „gzb :c =Tb :‡e:passage Q 7 › QQK O PR 7 [Q O U I Q :YT :„gzb :B<@Òu• :=:>:2Ki :>N :@ m M8 :2:=:>N a K 5 „gzb :B=:@@TMbNNaËko :Ç@R :g K :N LKNT :D@ ma8 <@:fM m}L :ÁB= x[ := 5 :TTNNNTT :g Ll 3:<@K m M 8 :g :ÁB=:™ x B:ÓC:Y:˘Ö :> :> :g L P :2:Y:N a T „>N UT N NQ Q 7 I 7L › R 7 R Q :‹HM :@mM8 :=K :DB:e:ÇQQNN8K <:3K :@ m X := KL :DB:=:> O ‘ Ò :YT :3 S B:™Ÿ5 :½ˆB:=5 L :>NNOP :> O UT :gzb <:3:33:gKN 8 S l :D==• u 5H :g } u H { j QQjƒ 7 j ƒ 7 b QQ}NLQ Q OU } ~ mo « :`}T e:gLK :…ˆB:˘gM 3:> K8 3@@am¹5 o @:g LK :…ˆB:3B:f M S 5L :g :AB:N T :@N m K :g L =:>Tb N B:‹ B:2:gi L @ 5 H ¶ Q Q õx Q QQ¯V ¦š K I :Y B3N8 KN P :`l Be3:™5 8 5 :Á=:2:F@ “JL a 5H :?=5 :=:gzb :@ a ˆB :3K :g o 7 7 I QQ š II •S j :3:=e:=:`K5LKKw•K5l :=:D=N X @=a :˘:=:DF

20 j 7 7 O K Q 7 Ÿ6 Q • 8 :=K :\t BC³ :‡<@ 4T›:2:3:>NNNaßs N UT :gzb <:<@Òu• :=:Z:2:2K ai :g€€z@:@=:@ wlOMU M HamT bM8 :g :½q:™–N B:2:=:DB„gz a K b :™ e:ÇK < 7 Q K OyšQQ7 6 O y š :=:`f:cKxX H :ÁB= :‡<@4TNTN› :2:„>NNaUTT :gzb <:Ç5± :‡ a U :gz b <:Ç 5 ± :‡NNUTT :gzb <:Ç5± :2N a : U :gz b <:Ç 5 ± :‡N :™ 5 Q 7 8 j › o K :½ˆB:35 S B:„gzb :@3a K :turn :3M8 :masters :gw | B:…B:25 WNO4T :monster :^F:˘c:ef:cs :monster :@NNa ˘:@ m K :create QQ7 Q 7 7 7 7›R 7 › 7 R R7 › :…ˆB:„gzM b :`¦TT :>NTNNOs :D==:;<@S o4› :™•OH5 :gz b :> O P :` ¦ :™ • 8 B:=:> L O s :Y:< FB gS :=:Š=:Y:‹TTb o— :=:> L NO UT :Y 7 Q 7 I Q OI œ •X ¯ Q 8 ¯ Q NOQa 7 OR Q O :A@:;<@Ma ´ yR :„gzb :>NNs :`wX F=:™=:^fX “ • :B:;M B:˘:c<@:3MMauMm M :D@ m}K @:= a 5[ :gzb :> NP :2f:^F:>5 a 5H N s ƒ Q 7 I Q 7 ¯ OOUPR R OO Us OOK UP R Q :c@´5 R :Ce:^F:˘:>NN’•NTTT :> N :go @N ma´5[ :Ce:^F:A@:;<@ ’• MM y :„> N :> N :D=Nw8 <@:‡<@ a4 T› := 5 [ :> N :> N :> <@ — :^F:= L I QQ Q OO OOR OOO R ˜5R „>NUsTTT :> N :D=Nw8 <@:‡<@Ma 4 T› :2i := 5 [ :> N UP :> N :Š=:Ce:^F:˘:> o N ’• N UPm :> N :> N ƒ ƒ S R I ( ( gw :g L @:_5•5 WNL e ) I ƒ Q I Q O• yš j Q O [ I Oml :@<:=:@TUTbN m K :2:2NNa i :>N :Ç5± :2:Š=:…ˆB a o M :‡fP¥X :>N W :C@:fT U ¹ Nml ( e38 @m8N < ):‹a 3KN :C ’mN 7 Q Q j ƒ OLH H 7 KQ } NLQ Q :g€{:gz}b}b :@<:‹:g€TNUWm4M B:@NOMa „gz :@N K :?@ Ô Ok B:2:gNNa Lb :D=˜R B:– 3@@8 am¹5 o @:2:„gz a b j 7 Q ¥L O u :‡CN ’P :g|L F<:D=5L NUT :gz b <:=:½3T bM [ :3:gM 8 }LbH { :_B:_B:g|NNTa a F<:D= :>N B:B<@ 4 TN› :„:>UT :gzb <:=Tb :½3M [ :3M 8 :Y j j j Q 7 — Q Q QQ}NO4ÈI } ~ mo Law and :2i :gzb :@m˜È :‹:^F:„:gz b :A=@:^F: :>NMM B:@ ´ M 6 B:B3:_B:3:½=58N a K •:½= • :g L I j Q I 8 Q Q I Q ~ o R :‡3S e:™V 5[ :˘:<= MM[:Z~Nm :˘:<= [ :2« q:˘=Be:˘:<=] K[ :„gzb :@B3:>aK Q }Nm B:Á@:B<@ —4TNT› :˘gz b :> O P :Á@:B<@ —4 › : Order Q Q Q 7 Q OsQ I O P R :2i :gzb ::@e:;e:Na certificate :@— :>NN B: : ban :gL :…ˆB:=M L := K :D= o BF j 7 7 O O}QQ~mo OO :gK :\@:AB:…B: oN aNNNNUTT :gz bo <:g :2 Œ [ :> s :> N B: Us :> B: N T :gwk :2PÈ :™N :Y:„:>TNNTT :g w k :2 P È :@NNmK :Y: T :g w k 3:@K m K :Ó² H ¶ ¶ ƒ j Q 7 õxƒ õ x ƒ •S Q K Q 7 :Óq:_B:N :>NM B:AB:3:ÇK5± :½=:;3:g• 5 8 L :…ˆB:„gzM b :> 3@@ 8 am¹5 o @:2N a :NN @:…e:˘:c:> 5H5 @:q 5H œ:=:D@LNma8 <@:>MMN :2:2N a •a =N wK gzb :@@ a• 5 := K R • K› 7 QQQ Q › :…ˆB:™M ŸŸ5 :™ 5 :Y„gTTS :>e:e 8 :;e:D@5 H :™• M8 B:g€ w o Q › 7 O Q Oƒ [ QQ7 7 Q O8O R :™T :`˜5R :@— :…ˆB:>M N s ! >CNNNNs’mN M :…@5 m´mHm5[ :„@R :@ bT @:@M N 8 e:Á@ NwM:2:>:„g 8 N a sS :>3:>K P :@=e:g — Ì l :D== S o

21 Q 7 Q Q j 8 »œ Q Oi “ »œ X g g wB:g{ J :g L :>N BQ NOs C’mN M[ :…@5 m5[ ƒ 7 Q ƒ 7 R „gS :>NOUT @MH :@ mN8 e:ë²¹ B:c=¯ K := K :AF@:=:g U L J Q T ƒ X › 7 Q j ƒ Q œ I l :gum} :YT B:\@N8 PR :2i :D=:<= Tb ~ W X :@:…ˆB:> — M NOs ! >Q NOs C’mN M[ :…@5 m5[ ::‹f:fNa n 4 » :™@56 H :C ’mN ONm 7 7 7 Q Q »œ ‰OWX 7 Ü L [ „‡e:…<@B:c:g5HKwo =:g{5L Jblo „gz :g :g B=:g [ K :‹5m :NOs C’mN M :…@5 m5[ 87 O s „>NN e:@m58 :> :;<@5 a ƒ Q ƒ 7 7 Q •SR 7 }NO a I O U ˜È O´R 7 j K Q œ 6 I O l :˘:™ =:¼<@:>Tb N a @ ´ R B:½ˆB:25i :>N T :gw :^F:„:>N :…@Na @ Ò l :c :DB::‹f:fNa n 4 » :™@:C5 H ’mN Nm ƒ 7 ƒ 7 QQQ › › o R j 7 Q :=:c:25[K×H5 :AB:2:>3:Á@:@a N8K — mM8 B:Y:2T i :™:2Vs × H 5 :‡CFe:c=:>³ ¯ K N O4T :2:> a Q ~Nm :gJ :g L ‚:ÑCN L  L :…@n ²¹ B:3N8 N :`X = ~ B:gN uW :g K compensation :c :AB:gzb :c=:™Tb T @5m8 ƒ I Q OQ O L ŸR O •O5a Q Q 7 œ Q :gS :>NNa ‚e:> Õ N :™5 :@:—compensation :=K :…ˆB:2:>M N aN UT :gJ € :D@PNR ::2 ‘ HBe::3NNT F:\F:AB:Y:„g ]T S :>3:8 5H5[ NTT :™ :=:5 N :c:> N @:c:Y5 a :AB:ÇM± :g L 7 7 Q :g{L :Š=:\q:go5 N8 ] KKS := •[ :=5 :g :DB:2QQi @:ga :>e:=:DB:3:Ç N8 KLK M[ =:gM l :…@² n ¹ B:3N8 NNN• :@M• :gS ˆB:>C5 ’É :^F:> s :D=e:gL K :>N B:N UT :gwS :=:<@Tb G NNTTU :gL ‚:3:@KmX :=:DB:…ˆB„>K M U :g L ˆB:g o :ÑCN L  :^F:„23N a ~ k : :>Q NOs C’mN M : …@5 m5[ R :AB:…ˆB:™M Ÿ5 B:™5 6 : direction has already been given to the Interior Minister. ƒ „>NOa @5H :ˆB:3M8 :motion Q ›[ ƒ X › I Q O ƒ M[ Q œ I O l :3K :discuss :YTT :½ˆB:=5 K :Z5 :gzb :2‘m} :Y B:B3:258 N a ! >N s C’mN :…@5 m5[ :‹f:fNa n 4 » :™@56 H :C ’mN Nm ƒ Q j II Q R I 6 ¯¥K OPR 7 b ¯¯6 ƒ X O U :_mNO´M :3~Na 3:@:@ K NNNa mS :@e:<= a JM :bomb :c=:2K×H5 :™ :2gzib :>NN :‡e3:`ST} e:c=:c= X J M :2 ‘m} :2:„>N a T :gz b < ƒ Q I 7 ŸR Os u H ¥K • S o Q Q j ¥K :;3:`58˜5R :™5 :2:„:@N a NNmS :@e3: a K blast :>N :g} {:2×H5 :™ :@:™Na :‡e:<@:c=: s S 3:@K mW58 :2@a L :=:™K :@:@NNN ama S :@e ƒ Q j 7 7 Ou OQ Q › O 7 Q :gL =:fTbNm˜š :Š=:C o ’k :˘:C ’k :>NTNNs :g }H {:_B:_B:;<@NNa a 4› „> UTT :;<3:gS l :DB:Y:T U : …@ a@ Œ ‰L

22 ƒ ƒ Q Q OKOjQ Oa y 6Q I OOu»MR O :„>NNNNTNUTT :gL =:fTTbNm˜šN :><@:Z—5 : U :g L =:™ b <::eBqB:Ç@t R k :> ss ::> :g }uH {:_B:;<@N a 4 › :D= L e:g ´ | „> UT Q Q R R 6 Q :AB:qJM :„@Nmo :@M •5 :=:<=K u 5a :f46 B:Á²:™@: n 5 H candidate for National Assembly :;<@4T› :gL :Bf H ƒ j Q ~mo S R Q L Os[ O s 6 :gK :^<@:Ae:>5aN :g w :¼:D@M 5 5 H :CN ’W 5 :;<@ 4 TNN› :> :Z5 :B=:2TTb “ BF:_B:>NNa :™B3:˘:B=:2MK b “ BF:N a N s :DF@:™a <=NNwL8 =:2 i :@ ´ºNa e:gL :…ˆB:„gM L =:™TT bo <:Š=:™ :<@ — :\5 N8 q ] ƒ j 7 7 Os Q [ R 5R 7 :>N :^fk <@:„gMHL =:fTboN m ˜š :Š=:\q:g5 N8 ] K :>5 N :DBeq„B=œ :2 ‘ 4 :3:3@e:;<@M8 8 ¬4 T› 7 Q Q 6 O Q 7 Q ¥O•QNR [ 6O Q 6 :s :D@ m l 3N s :D= w 58 „B= b :2 ‘ 4 :3M8 :DB:gzb : N :e@ˆB: N :Ó²H :;<@ 4 T› :ÓC:Ö˘>N T :gL =:…@Tb “ BF:;<@ k :`˜5 R :g K :½q:AB:„@– NN mmmS :@ K :^@5 8 7 7Q 7 7 K 6j QQR7 MR Ÿ R 7 R R R :=:?@LÛH :…<= :c :™B3:„@MKNN maS :@e:3:f K NN m˜š :=:DB:g KwJ :D=± :™5 :^F:g l :•@ á L B:m @ 5 :D=wNOa :„gzb :g wX @ k :g K :…ˆB:?@M • <= Û :c :™M B3 K Q Q Q u X R R :D=˜R B:„>NOUT :cK :press conferences :f 5L :gK :g L 3:Kmeetings :De:Fe:‹Q W W :gL :YB:=NNNwK :YB:N :g€w :ZN :…@k fH :g w | B:g L ƒ Q Q •S •}‰L š Q 7 « Q Os ƒ M[ Q :D@5mo @ ¹ :„gzb :™ :‡e3:BfK NmM8 :YN :™ @Nml :_B:2N a i :gz b :h@q a·[ :=:…@:‹5[ 5 a B ! >N C’mN :…@5 m5[ Q 7 j QQ8I 6 OR 7 Q O 7 Q K 7 :gKS :DB:˘g :><=NNNJM :>P :=:D= K w x @456 :> a :DB:2i :gz bl :@ˆB:Á@ a Nw M:_B:g8N a :Óq:c:DFe – 3ST :`} b e:NNNP :=:DF3:gK4 :3:DFCe:gM 8 ’¬ KS :DB:˘g :>3:‹ K m :=:K candidates Q Q Q 7 8 OPR ŸR Q 8 I 6 :D=}u5H :g K :DB:2:@iNmS :@ PÈ :gl :D==:_:D@Soa P RN :2 •‘5a :g SL :>e:gNNN 3:>K :™5 :2 W u5H :=:DB:<= M j j 7 Q8 [ › Ÿ R QQ O s :AB:„gzb :@Nm—K :@:D==:gSow[ K :D=x @ 456 :DB:2i :=5 :g S :>3:C NK  :™F:™T 5 :@:…ˆB:2 N 7 ƒ 7 j Q 7 QOa QQ}Q ¯ K Tb 7 Q :>N :gK :DB:2:cˆB:gi l :Óq:c:D@–5m¹o @:NN B:3:>M8 5 :˘>T :guarantors ƒ Q Q 7 Q ¯OO}PR yš 4T› Q[ œ 7 Oa Q † ¦ 6 Œ Ž :2:cˆB:>i NN :Ç5± :> :„@NNmm—«S :@ o :@:`@5[ :> :<=wX :gK :™²k B:ø`@ x 456 :BC  N : 3B o :‹ 7 j OUI O UI O U }Tb › :=:˘>5[ NT :gzbuK <:…@:g—m4G :g :D=N w[bT @M l :;<@› T :=:˘> 5 N T :gz bl <:3:go :½=:‡<@ 5 Ž[ 4 T› :=:> 5 N T :e3 ß m e:™T F:2N a :@N m K 7 7 Q 7 7 Q OU6 O s O U 7 •¦N•“ OU 6 O5 a :>NTT :gL 3:2K‘4 :>:^q@:=:˘> Nœ — 5[ N :g L 3: K ^@5mP48 :<@56 :™ :;<@TNT› :T :gL 3:2K‘4 :3:Z M 8 N :?=Nw8 :‡<@ 4 › ƒ Q 7 Q 7 ¯ OPR 7 › ŸR 7 O U 7 •¦N•“ :2:c=:>iTbNN :`¦T :2:™N a 5 :=:…<@ K ´5 R :„>T :gL 3:^@K 5 m 8 : assets :;C³ Fe:N s :Z:=:D=5 KN w 8 @m}K @:N s :D= ß m5[ :c:1971 :

23 Q IIQQI j Q Q Q ƒOaNOm}L ƒ O a œ Q K R 7 MR :<=:CK ’mNN q:T a N T :gwb e:=:D=K±LM 5 :^F:=:gz :@@:@aHm—45 N K :@@Ù e:Z:e=:`:„g [55[ L =:f Tbo•N m ˜š :Š=:=:LjB:g R K :c <@M a :‡C N ’¿ 7ºa I Q 7 ºa 7 „>NOTTU :gwJN e:=K :D= Ì <=:™ 5 L ›T :2:a N O U :g w J N e:=K :D= L <= x Q Q Q ŸR ¯ Q Q I Q Æ I Q Os ƒ M[ Q :™5 :½ˆB:25 i :@PÈMM :gL :c@N mK :?C’5É :˘ÑN wM [ :DB:N C’mN :…@5 m5[ 7 j Q 7 JÈ Os7 bP OR Q O U ˜È È :gw <: soft corner :>NNTN :;<@:g5aK :DFe3:`ST} e:^F: :Ím5[ :‡<@ 4 › :2:2N a i :>T :g w :Š=:Ço M± QQ Q RI 7 7 R 7 “ › › 7 R :>NNOP :3:Ç@oR k :gK :DB:˘gQ w ~k 3:> K O P :‹ m :=:D=@K L 4 VWX :Y TT:˘>NNNOUT :D@Q 4VWX :Y :2i :> OU T :gw˜È :Š=:^F:™o Ÿ5 :½ˆB:„> 5 O U T 7 7 7 OR OQ QQ O~Q mo :gK 3:fKNm“ :=:D=KwN bT @Mm4s4l :;<@TNTNNT› :˘>UTT :g L <@:=:D= K±M 5K8 :;<@ › :˘> U :g L 3:2Œ 5w“ :3:>M s <:‡<@ 4 › :^F:>N :g w ~k j 7 7 j Q 7 Q¦š OOON•J5R KQQI O K O :> e:3B:2Si :gzb :2:=:>N a L NNNNNsUk :Á²k B:„>TT :g{ w± :> ‚:c :DB:3:…@:> K— a e3:c S :DB:qJMR: U :g Lo @5 H :g 7 Q Q 7 7Q ƒ Q Q•± š • 8 7 QQ O w“ ŸR :2:ga l :™ :™ B:Ç@:gRTU KL :AB:„=:gTb @ ´È :e=:…ˆB:@@ [M a´ È :=:Fe:@@5 [ a´ È :^F:g lL B:˘g ˆB:>N s :g¸ { :g K :…ˆB:™M 5 7 Q QQR › OPR 6 Q ~ mo Q :‡<@44TTNT› :2: K :Y<:3:D= 8 N wbT @M m4l :;<@ › :^F:>N :=:eT bÌ t :2:2N a i :>T :g w :g l :3± :;3:q5 8 J M :„3:D=BfM 8 Lml @NN ml :@:D=<= a L x Q 77 7 QQQ 7 7 Q 7 › OOOPmaR ˜È •[ O m x Q š 7 O U :gK :D@ma}K @:Y:˘>M T NNNNN :2i :> : 3:½@K55 • B:M 8 @ 456 :D=wNOa :2:De:™N a B:2 i :@ ´m R :?@N [ :BCN ’¿ :„> T Q j 7 I Q »œ Q R 77 Tb › 7 :gzb :@3:@aM8 m ˜È :g l :Çe:g{K J „>NOUT :guarantors :gK :DB:™:2:Q›T a NNOP :Ç@Rk :g K :DFe3ßm } e:Y:˘>T O UT :Ç@ R k j QQQQj K 7 Q š Q 7 Q o 7 Q š Q „c :<@NmOH B:™ =@X H :D=Nw˜bKK :gL :D=R B:2i :@=:@GmT M8 :=:DB:„c3:<@K N m O H B:™ =@:g X˜ H L :D= R B:2 i Q j Q j j Q 7 Q KQI }~mo L Q 7 Q}NO4È Q } ~ mo • 8 :=5[ :‡e:…<@B:c5H :gL 3:>o N B:=:D==:g€ KSo } B:50 :gL :D@m}K @:ÓˆB:>M a :>N B:g l :…@5 5 • M : Q 7 j 7 QO7KQ } Tb O K 7 :…@fs ÕX :Ó²:gH K :DB:>NNs :D=wo Bf:c n :‡e3ßm e:„> UT :g| ~H :^<:<:g K :D= w x @45 6 :Áf o @:2 — i 7 Q 7 7 Q 8 O R 7 wX R 7 O :AB:=:gL S :>e:<@:>NNs P B :2i :@´UHPR :@<@:@T 5 È :•u :;<@ 4TTN› : UT 7 Q 7 7I 7 7 OŸR OOOOR ˜È JR O x 7 :Ç@R k4k4 :;<@TNTNNNNTN› :2:„>NNNaUT :™ @ :;<@ › :2:˘> a Pmms[ :> : B::>:•:;<@ 44 ›6 :> m @5 :2:\F a ] 7 7 › 7 È 7 :cK :D@QQQma}K @:>NNNNOOs• :…<=Û :AB:„gS :> :g l :…ˆB:2f:@M • a —G :DB:YTT :=:@ LbK =:ÇM± :3S B:= :DB:„> OO UsT :gz b <:> :DFe@ • R B M 5 7 j Q È Q :„c¯ =Tb :N U :…@² ¬ m[B:;<@4T› :Ç@R k :gK :YB:=NNNwK :YB Q Q j ›7 › › o 77 7 :=:@=:™F:C5[G—T b›TNÂ[ :@:`5 l :Y:=:gz TT L b <:ÍB:Y:3B:2• Si :@ ´ºa e:g L :Y:> TmQ ~Nm :>NT O TU :…@² ¬4[ B:;<@› :3:…²@M 8 s X I I 7 j Q ƒI 7 7 j ŸR¯ K QQQ O Ÿ R Tb S•K› o O b } T b :™5 :c<@:cMaH :D@:DBqy ¡ :>NTNs :Ç•K B:AB:2i :™ :ZB=[ :‡<@ 4› :„gwJw =:gTT b B:Y:g€ :AB:„> UT :gz w @:e3M H ß m e

24 7 7 7 OT› Q ~ o ¯jŸR œ7 7 ¦56 ¯ j Ÿ R VWX ¯ j :Çe:>K N 4 :>Nm :c=:‹@Tb sk :™5 :™² k B:ø`x @ 4456 :N :`¦T :> N :DB:c:g ww =:q 5L JM :@:>Na NTT :gk :> :2:a N :g wbb k :Ç~Na e:2:2:2N aai :gz :@ mß•:@ W NL B:˘gz 7 jQ ƒ 7 j }TTb•Oa Q j K } b O Q O ƒ M[ Q :‡e3 ßm e:™N ˆB:2i :=5[ :@G :D=T b @M Hm :@N8 e:?@ m X :M N s ! >N s C’mN :…@5 m5[ Q Q 7 Q ƒ I I lV¦š œ 7 •Os ¦š ¯ :g€Lll e:…FF:g B:g :`NwONm : N B:>N :>N T :g L @ 5H 7 7 Q j OU~ s 7 š ¥K › Q OU~ O PR O s4 ¡ :;<@4TN› :@N m K :„>T :gw k :‹:gl :D==:gS o K :`@x 456 :™@N m l :™ :™:2:T a NNNT :g w k =:>T b :_C:>:‹N a ³ I j ƒ Q 7 Q 7 Q j 7 Q •O5a š oX OU•O s O s N•Oa Q } ~ mo • x Q 7 :gJ € :3:™3:cBF:ÓCM8 K  :^F:@NmK :˚>NNT :g L»K =:`Tb 5± :>:g{ :g :>N B:™ @ 4ma56 :CN ’Þ :N a N a NNNTTT :gJ € :3:™MM8K 3:c :D@:†™HmN :^F:@NNK :˚> :g J € :3:™ 8K 3:c :D@ Hm :…= 5 NL B:^F:@ K :˚> Q j ¶ Q ƒ I 7 j L œ 7 K ¯ Q NOMa } Tb :‡Ns :q J :g| w 8 B:™5 :½ˆB:^F:@5 ´nR :`5Û @:= 5[ : N s :NNNs ::˘>e:2:‡eB<ˆB:_ a k g{L :> 4 :…ˆBM ! >N s C’mN M :…@5 m5[ Q Q Q j j 7 Q 7 RN•8QQ}O 4 È } ~ mo 7 ¶ R OT› O R › :@mM8 :=:…ˆB:„gzKM b :@<:@T UM • :3:D=M8 N w uËL B:™M B:> :>N B:=:`=KX ~ H :AB:„;e:ÏÀ± :>NN4 :2i gzb :> P :™:‹@T 5 a Ú 7 j j Q j Q Q VWX Q 7 7 Q R KQ Q}N O4È Q } ~ mo ± š [ › ( )D :ÍN mo :Y :D@ma´}K @:^F:˚@M R :^e3:3=KN 8 5± :@:Z:^F:@@ —N am 5 8 :> :>N B:ÑN wM[ ::=:ò K :Z:g5 L :Y:2T i:gz b Q 7 › • X 7 I 7 › 7 Q R :3K ˆB: under pressure :gL :Y:=:fTT5[ 5L :g K :YNN 3:>=<@8 N8 Ìb´aR B:2:gzi b :@=:Çe:>K N O 4T :„@ ´ R :^e3:3= K 8 5 ± :@ — Q j Q 7 7 Q QQQ }~mo Ø Q R O • X 8 8 :;<@k :gL :…ˆB:˘B=:D²B:@:>M Tb n —N B:™R =5 [ :„gz b :B=:Á@@:23 Tb —a—5 a 5± :@:DB:˘> N i :YN B3 8 :>=NN}NNO5a := } O a B Q yš 7 ƒ ƒ Q OsJ» 7 6 ¯ a7 7 j K ŽQO s 7 :>N :gw { :=:…²@Ks X :g l B:=:@:g LGma L ˆB:™:cˆB:@5 NN8 :3B:…B:„@e3:‹fS5 K N5m8 :=:\C K N8 ’i B:c :DFC  B:>N :D@ ma } K @M Q 7 ƒ Q 7 6 8 Oו Q Oa Q :;3 58:g|JK] B:g :g ²:g|n wl B:g B:=:@:gL G L ˆB: Capital Chief :@Nm8 :„gS :>N :=:De:ZL N 5 :˘^NN :ÇM± :…ˆB:=:gzM Lb :™ :ŠˆB:> :e@ˆB:Á²5aG—k B:„@=:<@NN :‹=:‹Tb :™ @:h@:g—M a L :D= ˜ R B:„>T :candidates :Fe:gK :`x @456 :‡<@ 4TN › :> :e@ˆB:Á²5 a k B:„g w k 3 K I Q I Q 7 Q I j Q Q L Q R ñ QO O LI K b K 7 :3S B:2i :²:Z=:=s L K :DB:guP |:g w O´ :>N a :„g€L e:g€|:ZBFfB:=:D=BF:‹=:„c } aNa Ko a T b :ZB=T [ :c :g L 3:ë@K 4•5[ B I 7 Q œ 8R Os a › ¯ Q 8 :;<@4T› :čB<= 5w5± :„gS :>e:Ç<:Y:> NK 5 N :‹=:gT bL K :…ˆB:Y:=:@e:gM TN a L 3:A²B:=:D=BF:K 5 H Ko cM : > N B: ;B 7 Q OsQ O s Q ˚@Gm— =:@TbNNK :@ :D= ˜Lù5H :T Ua TkHb NN :e@ˆB:Á²5 B:2:„@N a mmH K58 :A² B:@MT B:3K @5 :> :DBfNmX :CU @ 5 a :g L :candidates j 7 Q 7 j j Q 7 Q › O ¶ 7 7 Q Q ¦È Q }~mo :D@ml FfmbT :Y:A@:„>T —N UT :g€w8 e:?f:25 a N mX @ v w8 B:‡< =:…ˆB:=:gzMLM Lb :@ˆB:D=:@:Ca Ž — ’W :>N B:ÑN wM [ j ƒ Q Q Q 7 7 j Q Q}~mo ¯ ¯ O U bŽ › 7 u ‰L :gK :>N B:Á@:c=:@—WaÚKNL B:@:c=@CN LNT’Þ :^F:„>N T :gz wKwK <:C  B:™F:g :`=X ~ H :D@F:2T U i :gH | :3M8 :ÁfÚ :øZ :g 7 Q 7 j ¥KOs Ž ƒ 7 š ¥ K [ ~ O P R Q :@´R :_k :3:™M8 :gl :>:DFCNTN B:;<@ 4¬4m› :3B:„=:^f@:=:`@ STba K x 5 6 :™@N l :™ :g l :Z:g5 w k 3:> K :DB

25 7 Q j K 7 š ¥ K 7Os 7 :AB:_k g{L :=:gzL b :@<3TU K :ef:cs :candidate :@:`@NNa4mx 56 :™@l :™ :˘gzb :@T U <3K :`uH Bf:>s N :` l @Nml ::^F:2 i I 7 7 7 Q l › Q~mo 8 ¯ K :?f:‡335a8 ~Nm :Á=Tb :˘@NmS :‚f:= 5 a K IGP :™T :gL ˆB:>N :g€ w e:?f:g5a l B:…ˆB:SNNT :gzb <:> :ZN =:=:…ˆB:˚gzMLL M b :•Bf:@sNmK :2:3N a [ ˆB:„g wL :g€ e:?f:NN 3:@K NNmUK :D@F:…ˆB:=:gTNNNM L L @:@e:¼5 Ha 5 :g€ wKw :g :g z:_B:>:ga ]w ²:gn :_B: a _ a@MH B:=K :…ˆBM Q j j »MR 7R 7 Q 7¶ 7 OÈ ~ o :™V´M :„gz b :c:`=KKKQQX~H :AB:2•‘5a :>NTOP :=:‡<@ L 4› :‡ }N 4 :> } Nm B j Q 7 Q Q }~mo K 7 7 I R 7 :>N B:ÑN wM[ :˚gz b :@NmK :g L :Z: withdraw :^F:˘@NmK :Á@ 4•bT B:`˜5R :B<=J :=5 [ :@: — security :gL :D=wX = ~ H Q Q j ¦È ::„gzb :@NmK :g L :C ’W Q Q › 7 Q ƒ Q :AB:2i :gzb :@3:2aK ‘ ŒNwŽ :g L :`5l :Y:½ˆB:D=:@TT5 b m˜È :g ll :…ˆB:gM :‡ NOs ! >Q NOs C’mN M[ :…@5 m5[ Q ƒ 7 Q •8 R OUb O P R Q R Q 7 :=K :…@5 5• M :…ˆB:½ˆB:NNT :gz w @:…ˆB:3B:„>MHM S :@:gzN aa• b :@@MM 5 :=:D@K ma}K @ Q Q Q Q Q 7 Q •8 R 7 MR [ I QQ7QQOU b 7 ] :@3:ÍB:gaK • l :…@5 5 • M :=:B=K ± = w ± :C5 ’mN :N T :gzw @:@3:ÍB:gM HaK • l :D@ maa } K @:™@M 5 Q Q j j7 7 7 7 ÒUsL Ÿ5ROuO Ÿ 5 R H •8 V ¡ Q L 7 R O U b :‹ :™ :A=ub5HT :˘>NNNT :gzb} <=:™ :g {:> :…@5 5•M :3:<=:™M8 –4 :„gz b :h@:Z= aaN }LL L :…@:=:q 5 JM := :>T :gz w @ M H Q 7 7 j L ñ › OQ Oñ ŸR I O :‹Ò :gl :DFqJ :D@F:Y:2TUT•5m5[ :˘>NNN UUTTT :g wwo @ Ò L :A=u5 H : :g ~ k :Á= J :™5 :3:ÇK•NO 5a :3:D=M 8 }o K <:Š= :˘> U :gz b < j j Q 7 7 Q O~4¥K ¡ › O O 5 R O Oñ Q O R :>NNNTs :Z :`5Nw5± :_B:`N a 5 l :Y:„>T UT :> s :;q·[ :g|» :;<@4› :„>NNNUT :gw~k :^<:> s :DFqJ :2: P j Q 7 O}sQQ~mo ›7 O a › 8 O4T› O U :2Œ[ :>:>NN B:Y:2:@TT iPÈ :gL :D=wx @ 456 :> N :Y:e=F@:g 5 [ 5 a K :AB:2:>3: i N K appreciate :>NN :…ˆB:„>M T I 7 7 Q j Q OO•mNNOkÈ 8O m O H5 › O P R KQ }~mo › O • :2:@:>aNaNNNNN :> :ÇM± :˘><@:˘>T U :Y:„gT L 3:>K ::25 m o @ v—X :@:postponement :c :>N B:YT :„gS :> N Q j 7 R 7 Q }~mo O s OUb › Q ~mo O • „=:=Tb K :¼<@:^<@N aN m S :>N B:>N :_‘s :AB :2i :>NNT :gzw @MH :Y:>T N :> 7 I 7 7 :„>NNNOUT :gL @:g|5H u H :3:<=KJM6 :_:Š=:=:>:…‚@:DB:2:>3:‘s o L O s H Q i 8 K appreciate …ˆBM 7 Q › Q ~mo OUo O s ¥K K :D@PNR :Y:>T N :>NNT :gLuwKL @:g|5 HH :g€ :g :g 3:<@F<@:>:_:;CFe:™K 5 a— ‘s ³ :g l :2F:c:5H security Š= o j Q 7 7j Q ƒ I KQ }~mo 7 OŸR OO Ÿ R › O I :c :>N B:3M8 :<=– :2N mÀ[ := K :…B< :˘>NNNNUTTT :™5 :gzwb <:D@F::˘>TU Us :g L @:™5 H 5 :> :DFCÊš :g| w 8 B:Y:„>TT U :g LL =:gb e 7 7 R Øœ „>NOUT :gL @5H :door to door :NOTU :gL ²MH :™Ÿ5 :Y ƒ 7 ¦6 7 Q O ¯ ŸR Q O ƒ [ Q :˘go BF:`Nwž 5 :2:D=:@iTb m˜È :3:gK o :Á@:>:˘c@ aNTs ´5 R :2:;<@N a 4 › :™5 :½ˆB5 ! >N s C’mN M : …@5 m5[ Q 7 QQj j 7 R V WX Q 7 œ 7 :2@a5aWkk4L :2@ :Ç@R :;<@T› :2:3B:gN a So BF:Ó@ Œ L B:_3NNa ± :˘g o BF:Í m o :Y :D@ ma}K @:˘gM o BF:™² k B:`x @ 4 56 Q I Q 7 ƒ R bT 7 Q K •X Os Q I È :gulLP |:g :`5 l :g :3um :2:D=:@i TbmHabT @:@‚e:e@:c:gM N a ÔK“ BF:_B:gN a :™ 3:=:…ˆB:5 [ K M >N :=:gLL =:2:;qT b a J 7 ƒ Q 7Q 7 ¯ K R OPR O sÜ O s 6 :=L :c ˆB:‡<@5a :c :protestants :qJM :˘D=:>Tb˜LNNN :‡e=NKNR :=:> :Ef4» B:2i :@PÈM :gL :> :=:@ LN m :2 ‘ 4 :3:D=e=8 N L˜ R Q Q Q Q Os R R OPR Os O s :2i :@PÈ :gL :>N :˘B<@:=s K :communists qJM :gL :AB:˘@NmS :¼M 5 :N :protestant :>NN :2i :@PÈ :gL :>

26 Q Q ƒ7 ƒ Q I ¯o ¯ K Q ~mo O PR Os :gL @´R B:5 5[ N :D=:> Tb N :communist :> N ƒ I Q Q ƒ 7 7 Q Q 7 K LR wKo¥K ¯ K OUT w b Q 7 K R O P R :D@maWm´}K7 @:@M NL B:…ˆB:@M N :˚g @ B:2: i NN :gz @:D@M HmaWm´ }K @:@M NL B:…M ˆB:@N :˘@ :> :‚BF •u L Ü Q 7 QQQ R [ 7 :YN :3:@:>K 5HNOs :D= 5± @:^F:2 — i :=:2T b a :…<@B:c5HK :CN ’MÉ :AB:=:D= KwN M±5 :Os :Z 5 :2i :> O UT :gzwb @ M H 7 Q Q OUb Q 7 O •ÒkL ñœ L OO ••« k k :>NNNNT :gzw @:D@MHmaWm}K @:@M NL B:…ˆB:@M N K :˚> :‹ :C@:gT U5 a l :qJ :g K :Á3± :CN ’ 5 : :3:<@F<@ K 5 a—:˘> 3:‹ K @ H Q Q j Q 7 Q 7 •Os 7 Q š › Q 7 R :D@ma}K @:^F:™M 5 :3:\a ÚNTU :M NNs :Z5 :2i :> UT :gz w b @ MH åYou are free; you are free to go to your temples, you are free to go to your mosques or to any other place of worship in this State of Pakistanç. The time will come, there will be no Christian, no Muslim and no Hindu, all are equal and state is not supposed to do anything with the religion. This is not the duty of the state to do something against religion.ç ¶ QQ7õx ƒ OU O s 7 K › Q Os ƒ M[ Q :˚gzb :D@ma—}K @:@:YMM Bf@:2:@a ÚmN a N K :˚>NNT :gz b <:^<:> :D@ ma } K @:Z:D@ P NR :Y T ! >N C’mN :…@5 m5[ ƒ Q Q Q ƒ j Q 7 OOsQ aQQQ7 7 O P R ¯ Q ± 5R QV 7 o :>NNN :> ˆB:gK :D@ma}K @:gM L :D=˜R B: :2ÕuH :c=:@ K m—M 8 B:@:DB:2 i :g } :=:Á= K[ q:D@œ Hm:™n :\] @N o :†c @ L :EB j Q Q ƒ Q Q š › Q Q Oa±sÜ Q O[8 s j 8 Q •b :NNNN ˆB:gL :• B:¸@ m Û :> :f 5L :g{ } :> e:3:‹@K k :>CN ’MÉ :™5 T f s 7 QQ7 QQ Q X Os[ 8 Q m “ XQQ XOs[ O U b 7 X :D@4VW :>NN :Z5 :„>3:2:‹K a :=:DK =@L44VW :D@ V W :>:Z:˘>NN5 T :gzw @:D@M Hma—4m}K @:@:D=@M L V W :?@N [ :eB<ˆB 7Q 7 Q 7 j R 7 u › 7 “ :=::>L NNNNOOOUTTT :2 NOk :…ˆB:3B:„>MMS UP :gL 3:> K :•@áL B:g lÄK :g} ¬ g :…ˆB:Y:2:>T i O Um :g L 3:‹ K :g€ w o :AB:=K :D= L @ 4 VWX R7 7› R 7Q 7 › :™Ÿ5 :=:>LuNNNNOUTT :‡=Na 3:…ˆB:3B:˘g58SKMMMMS :>3:‹ 8 m“ :=:…ˆB:Y:™ KL T Ÿ 5 :qJMR :=:> O8 U :™ • l :…ˆB:˘g S :>3 K :‹ m “ := K :…ˆB:Y T Q 7 ƒ I R Q 7 Q :„>NNNNOO~UTT :> P ::‡CN ’á a :…ˆB:2MM•a =NwK :gS :><@:= 8s K :…ˆB:=:> L O U :‡fm58 =e:…ˆB:3NL MMS B:˘cS :gL @5H :c ¯ @ — :De3Q S :c K :…ˆB j 7 Q Q R Q }~Nmo j 7 R O s Q :3B:˘=:2:^<@Fe:A²B:2:gS THTbaa5a5N uP |:g l :> B:AB:f@Na k :2 im :D=:@ b m ˜ È :qJM :25 8 q:‡3 œ [ ˆB:> N ! ‚BF:…@5 m5[ 7 Q Q Q Q 7 87œ•8ŸR R 7 MR O U b 7 œ Q 7 K :˘:>3:`NNK 5w± :Ç@R k• :gK :…@5 5 M :™5 :g o BF:B=±w =± :2:>i T :gz wbl @:3:`NNK5w± :gl :AB:™ :Š=:g ou K :D@ m } M[ =5 a :3:` K 5 w ± :gl :AB:™5 :Š=:go K :@@a ¬ 7 I Q Q I ¶ R R OPR •8 bQ R o „Ï@:EB:qŽ HJM :=:@:gL GJ B:>NT :…@5 5 •M ::3B:N s C’mN M :…@5 m5[ 7 Q ( ( `uH Bf s)

27 ƒ Q Q Q j j S •l Òo 7 K Q O ƒ [ Q ! `5[ @«H :D@:EB:f@T U WX :˘` 5 [ @ «k :^@ :˘c :g L @:™5H :‹ @:…@:c5 a 5 a :…ˆB:M :>N s C’mN M :…@5 m5[ 8 “ Òo The issue was this that they wanted to discuss :„gS :>e:r=:‹N X @:=:…ˆB5a K M the other issues with law and order. I gave opportunity to MQM, I ƒ I S ¯ Q NOa we will give it to the :f 5L :gK :AB:˘c :g L ˆB:c<@:3Ma uMm M gave opportunity to ANP, 7 Q 7 OU b Q 7 › „>N T :gzw @:@3:…@:™F:D=MH aK 5 a T wNOa :2:N aPML then. 7 Q ( ( `uH Bf s) j Q ƒ Q ƒ [ Q :gzb <:3K : issues discuss :=5[ :^F:2i :gzb :2:AQ NOs C’mN M :…@5 m5[ 7 Q 7 7 Omx š R are being targeted and if they want to respond, I >N @456 :™@N m l :D=wNOa :2:gi J 7 :`5 [ @« :3@:585 a EB:`[ q twill give them opportunity, they should respond to it, ¶ 6O•7j V O • 7Q Q j OO s•R 7 :3@:™:„>58K5a5 NNNN 3:…@:`@ 5 a«ka5[ :^@ :™n :qÄ– :@:>N 3:…@:`@ K 5 a«HW 5U [ :D@:EB:f@T X :> :f 5L :q J M :> 3 K :…@ 5 a „`5 [ @ « 7 Q b Q 7 7 Q Os ƒ M[ Q 7 I O l :gzw @:@3:…@:`MHaaK5 l Fe:;CN ’¿ :g l :D@F:3BT U S ! >N C’mN :…@5 m5[ ::358 @a :EB:`[ qt :C ’mN Nm 5 Q ƒ R Q 7» œ 7 „@G :DFe:…B=5 5[ :@ — :AB:> NOOOssP :f 5L :> N :˘> N :ÐBC’Þ B:c¯ = K :gJ { := L :> N O UT j ¶ ƒ Q „`5 [ @« :^@ k :™Vn :qÄ– :™:5 6 :>Q NOs C’mN M[ :…@5 m5[ j j ¶ I Q ~Ÿ5R 8 7 Q Os ƒ M[ Q ~ j V Oml :„23N a k :™ :@:`—5 [ @ « :3@:EB:`5 5 a [ q t ! >CN ’mN :…@5 m5[ :˘23N a k : :^@k :™n :qÄ– :fNml :C ’mN N 7 Q 7 Q Q Q Òo 7 Q •8 Q 7 7 R ¶ 6 R Q :fmM[ :‹@:…@@5aa•nma 5 B:Á@:gK :D@}K @:`MM± :g K :Á@ vL :‡<=˜y5 ::f 5L :g KÛK :g q:g¡ :?@ ka :¼@:½ˆBM 5 ! ‚BF:…@5 m5[ Q 7 ƒ 7 »MR › Q K¥“ ¡ K ùa O :gl :D=wÀTb :Fe:g u´ | :2N a :N a LN UT :gwS :^<:3:D=fM8 X Ú Q Q ƒ Q ƒ Os L Os QOsƒ M[ Q O P R 7 •8 ¯ › :BN :AB:3S B:N :…B5 ! >NN C’mN :…@5 m5[ :„gzb :> :…@:™5 a :c=:2:˘gzK N a b :™<ˆBT 7 Q ƒ 8 Q Q »œ Ÿ5RL õun ¯ Ÿ 5 R :„>e:?@N ÒL :C@:gT U5 a l :DB=B:gNL J { :…ˆB:2M i :gz b :prerogative :™ :g€} F:@— :…ˆB:=:=:™M LT b :c= K ::™ 7 Q ( ( `uH Bf s) Q I ¶ Q OUÈ Q O s ƒ M[ •8I Q ¶ 6 j V I O l :^F:>NT :g˜ :g L :`@5 [ « :>C N’mNM :™ e:…@5 m5[ :ì@ á o B:=: 5[ :3S B:˘™5 : :^@k :™n :qÄ– :fNml :C ’mN Nm ƒ Q QQQQ Q ƒ 7 7 ƒ ¯ › Q OOR¶ ¯ ¯ O RŸR O R Q :c=K :gL :Y T ! ‚BF:…@5 m5[ :„>NNNNUPT :> :ì@ á4ao B:c@N•o <@CN ’Þ :c=:2:˘gKNNaw~ k =:>TT b P :™5 :2:=:g a Lb L =:> P :Óf H M Q O•k 7 › [Ÿ5R 7 »yš O sP o K O R „>NTNN :3:…@:Y:2K 5aTTi :gzb :•:™ :B<@ 4› :2 i :D=:@b m J5 :2:>N a :g€ w :AB:c:> :interruption Q O´È 7 •8 Q O ƒ [ Q „>N <:‡ <@5H :…@5 a :™M B:…ˆB:M :>N s C’mN M :…@5 m5[

28 7 Q Q Q ¶ I Q 7Os K •[ 7 8 Q j V Oml :…@:g5aUl :D@F:>T N :˘c :Y ::…@:g 5 a L :D=˜R B:3:D@M P 5 6 ! ‚BF:…@5 m5[ ::^@k :™n :qÄ– :fNml :C ’mN N Q 7 ƒ j ¡M6 ¯ 7œ ƒ »N • 8 O ::A=}Ž B:N s :f 5L : N :½ˆB:N B:2:2NNa i :D=:@TbmbT @:@M H m J M6 =:2:3:M L a M8<=:g–K :C5 ’4 :_B:gNNa KK :`NwONm :˘g :‡C Êš :_B:<= a · 5 L :> N s ! ‚BF:…@5 m5[ ƒQ 7 ƒ j j O Q Øœ KQ }~mo :=K : process :AB:˚>N UT :gL =:De:gTTb wOi :g L =:ëFC b ³ :2:N a nomination papers :˘Y :c :>N B:N :™ B:˘D=:@<:3:…@:cTb TUK 5 a : record :> N ! ‚BF:…@5 m5[ :„gL =:>TTbN :™5 :De:ZN 5 :g L =:ëFC b ³ 7 Q Q 7 7 Q Q Q R 7 Q R R 7 7 Q 7 :•u L :@:†™— Vn B3NOs :3q:K œ N O s :D== 5 LÛ :>Q N O a :™Ø R B:˘c K :D= w x @ 4 56 7 j 7 7 R Q 7 :`@5 [« :<=:Cu5aN ’W 5L :gK :`@ x 456 :c:™B:=:gKš L J :†™B3B:;BM ¯ Q N8 VWX 7 7 Q 7 :c K ( Q )D :Ímo :Y :@mUK :3:D@F:\F:AB:„;3M8] K :…q Ä žX :cK :DB:†c@Q o L :EB:˘@mm S :@ K :assassination @— NTNNN 7 7 :˚™ŸR :`X = ~H 7 7 7 ŸR KQ K 7 R Q V Q Q Q O ƒ [ Q :˚™ :c :D=S =:>:`= oX ~ H :‡e@•R B:˚gJ :D =K :†™n B3N8 N s C’mN M :…@5 m5[ 7 I 7 Q ŸR Q ŸR 7 KR R ¯ Q8 ¯Q NOQa 7 7 Q O Ø R :™5 :½ˆB5 ! ‚BF:…@5 m5[ :„™ :`=X ~H :c :YB:=NNN wK :YB:B:;B:˘c<@:3M NNMM ama4uMmM :D@ } K @:˘D= w x @5 6 :>a :™ B 7 7 Q Q »MR Q O Q 7 Q [ :^C:gN ’au ´ | :=:3<=:gL8 S K :öfml :2=5 a Û :N UT : nominated :gK :3q:…BCKœ ° :3<=:g 8 S K :D==5 L Û :DF<@ MH 7 Q Q 7 Q :Ç@Rk :gK :AB:SNOUT :3:;fM 8P¡ :gK :3<=:g 8 S l :D=@ o k Q 7 Q 7 Q 7 K OPR •[ Os Q 7 R :2¿ e:c :AB@NmK ::=:gL ~k 3K:>N :Y :=:K target killings or terrorism :>N :öfml :`=X ~H :‡e@• B V¦š œ Q [ 7 K ŸR Os Q K Q :@— :™5m B:™=:De:Z“5 :2i :D=:@<:3T b T UK :…@:c5 a :record :™5 :2N a :> N ! ‚BF:…@5 m5[ :˚gzb :c :DB=NL B::AB:‡N m @456 :D=wNOa :2:=:™N a L :™<:=:T T b dissolve ™5m B:™ =“ :˘@´R :De:‡3[ ˆB ƒ 7 7 7 ¯ O R › O R › R :c=:gKl :e@•R B:B<@ 4 TN› :…B:25 i :>´ :™<:=:Bf:T T b 5H politically :N ´ :™T <:3K ::ëBe=B:=o K :;C³ Fe:_B:gN a u P | QQ7ƒ 7 ƒSQQ 7 x Q 7 R7 R ::…B:„>5NNNNTNOOms :™VMH :>:D=²:g|“n w8 B:g| w 8 B:> OO m @4 56 :D= wNOa :„> Pu :• L :c=:g¯ K l :e@ •R B:B<@ 4 › :…B:˘ 5 > O Pu :• L Q Os I ñ O• »MR Mr. Chairman, with due respect to President of :˚B=:@TbNNmK :>:D=N w O´ :ZN @ m 5 8 :gu ´ | I 7 8 »œ j 7Q 7 K Os :„>e:h=:gN LJ { :…ˆB:_M k :g{ L :=:DF3 LK :…@:Ï5aun :3 S B: N Pakistan, Q Q I 7 wX I Q[ ¯Q NOQQMa 7u L Q [ 7 Q :gzbL :@NmK :r :g :2N mo f:‡3:_B:=:>:˘gzn 58N a K 5 bl :g :c<@:3MMM ama—mam uMm :D@ }}[K @:• :@:>:D@ 5 K @:ø

29 Q :…@5 m5[ :according to the Constitution, you can not take part in politics.2i Q 7 7 I ƒ OPR O U˜È O U Q u 8 ¯Q 7 K :>NNN :@NNmmK :˘>TT :gw :@ K :˘> :g L 3:D=K ÀNwNm :=:c@ K ´vm5 R :Ó@o B:…@5 5 [ :^F:2:gzi b :…@:c:5 a record :2N a ! ‚BF 7 I 8 7 o Q QQ7 »œ 7 :™š B:„ >NOUT :gL 3:D=K Q ÀNwuNm :^F:2i :gz b :…@:c:a Krecord :>Q ~Nm :gzbw :@PÈ :gX @ k :;CN ’¿ :2:N :@ m M 8 :T K NN :…@:™5 a :>:2N a ! >N C’mN :…@5 m5[ j QQQ7 K O O 7 7 :‡CÊš :Á@:@:D@n—ma}K @:gM l :2F:c5H :DB:NNUT :g| ~~ H~H :Ç• :˘:>U T :g| :2 PÈ :2:‡<@N a ´kº• :;<@:`˜5 R :g K :D@ ma} K @M Q Q Q Q Q Os 7 7 R 7 wX K law and :gK :_‘s :…ˆB:˘gzMM b <:>N :NOUT :gzb <:…@ — :ÇM± :™›T F:…ˆB:½ˆB:gM 5 Jw :gS :3K =:= 5L[ 5 :K NOUT :gz bl <:3:gK :…@ 5 •ama • 8 :2= a Û :@:Ímo :Y :DQ @} K @:2 ‘ G 5NNƒ I 5 5 N M uH O s ¯Q ¯¯¯ Q VWX Q 7 8 Q Osu H :g} {:>N :g K :c:gMM K :3:2:2N Ka W u5H :…ˆB::3ˆBM K ::>N :g ” 7 Q Q K 77 j I QQOU8 7 › O P R :2:2N a i :gzb :c :…@:AB:\@5aÒN8 l :‡3:=:DB:˚>58KNNT :g€ w e:`l B= [ :„>NOUT :guarantor 7 Q ( ( `uH Bf s) ¶ Q 8 Q Q j V I O l :„>3N K :2a :½q– :AB:`5[ @« :fB<:T U :^@k :™n :qÄ– :fNml :C ’mN Nm Mr. Chairman: Zahid Sahib no cross talk. j :„>N8 3K :address :=K :chair :…ˆB:˘`M 5 [ @« :^@ k ¶ Q OPÈ Q Q j V I O l „>N :gl :DB:…ˆB:…@M 5 m5[ :^@k :™n :qÄ– :fNml :C ’mN Nm Q Q Os 6 Q ƒ [ Q „gzb :@Na e:hF<:=K :DB:g L :>N :˘™5 :>NOs C’mN M :…@5 m5[ Q 7 ¶ I Q Q K OPR 7 O 4 T› Q Q Os ƒ M[ Q j V Oml :Á@:@:²:Z:2:2a—5a N a i :>NN :@ mM8 :=:>L :˘D@5 m¹ o @ ! >N C’mN :…@5 m5[ : :^@k :™n :qÄ– :fNml :C ’mN N 7 Q 7 ˜È 7 7 7 QQQ [ O U :2:giawbL :2:3B:^F:˘gzN S :<@Nm8 :=:gK 3:` K NwM[ :…@:25 a •Na qB:Ñœ N w uKH :@:DB:Ç@ —k R :g :>:˘2:5 N a >N T :D= K :N a ³N :>N T :<@Nm8 :g€ wKL :g :g 3:` KNwM[ :…@:Y:Ç@5 akT R :g K :`= X ~ H :c:c<@:3MM ama uMm :D@} K @

30 Q j I 7 I Q 7 ¥K I QQQ±š ¯8•8 Q Q Q O Q 7 :@— :™ :˘gzb :e<@ ÒNL<:@mm—MMTT88 B:@ B@:ò C:e:™ 5 L NN <@:a :2gN a K :D@ ma } K @ Q Q 7 OU 7 K ¥K I :gL :D=˜R B:3S B:˘>N T :g L 3 K :…@5a :c so called guarantor :…ˆB:„gzM b :@W—NNOi :@:™ :˘gz b :@ WÒ O i :e<@NL < Q 7 7Q I Q 7 õun OQ Oƒ [ Q O R • 8 › K :™ :>NNNs :AB:˘> s C’mN M :…@5 m5[ :=:gL w~k :;e:> P :™ <@:Y:c GT :e@ • R B:AB:NN B:;B:@Na :=K :c :> B:;B:@NmK :„^F NNN :qJ :g|w B:2Wu5H :c@5• B:^F:3B:3:2:2S K aW u 5H :c@ 5 •Hm•m B:> :^fk <@:^F:2M i :gz b :@NNK :r :g L :…@5 5 M =:…e@K “ 7 7 Q Q NOMa Q 7 Q Os ƒ M[ QQb 7 Q ~ OPR ŸR :3 uMm D@mam}KK @:@M N :˘>N C’mN :…@5 m5 [ :„g€zw @:@M Hm 8N e:;e: resign gl :`@lNml :=:DB:=:gK L w k 3:>K N :™ 5 7 Q Q Q Q I ŸR OsQQQII 8¯Q • 8 O s wX •87 K ¯ :2Wu5H :™5 :>NNN :2@<‚:^F:3B:3:2:2 a—S K aW u 5H :c@5 • B:> :2@<‚: a — 2i :gzb :@NNmK :r :g L :…@5 5 •M :=:…e@K ma “ :c:c<@M Q ƒ QQ7 7 7 8 lRK R Q Os ’m M[ QQ w b l7 OPR w ~k K O P R :\@N PR g :YB:=NN7 Nw :YB:˘>N CN :…@5 mHm5[ :„g€z @:@M 8N e:;e:resign :g :`@lNml :>NN B:=:gL 3:> 7 7 •uWL ŸR O O È j › Q 7 7 :D=:@3Tb aK :YN :™5 :>NNs : UT :gw˜ :²3:^F:M TUNNUTT :gL 3:2 K Wu5H :@:Ç‚:Ae:Y:…@ —K T 5 m 5[ :2 i :> U :g w˜ :^F:2 i :gz b :credit :B358 :A@Ma :gK :DB:2N a :2 i 7 QQ 7 QQI 6 wX K Q OPR7 O P R Ÿ R :…ˆB:=:B<@MMLkm :™B3:˚gzM Kb :@N K :r :g L :Z:=:…ˆB:˘2 KWu5H @: K NN :D=N w K :½5ˆB:„@ m O ´M R :> :™ 5 j Ò}X Q 7 Q Osƒ M[ Q 7 O s [ :=5[ :gzb :?B= • :‹ :@m8 B:2:@N a N m K :˚gz b :@N a NN C’mN :…@5 m5 [ : :• :g K Q yš › :„g~k ˆB:2:Ça 5 ± :> NO4T 7 ƒ KI R QOs ƒ M[ Q •S K 7 :judgement :c :…<=:YCKN M’k :˘>N C ’mN :…@5 m 5[ :=:™ L :^<::c :militant groups :…@5a Q Q KQ K ¥K VWX Q 7 K I R ŸºNa OR O :c:><:™ :gK :: JUF :@:ÍaN mo :Y :D@ m}K @: a judgement :c :…<=:YCK N M ’k :˘:™ e:>NNP :gL :> s N M Q 7 I 7 ºa R militant :gK :D=wx @456 :‡3:>58Q NNOa :DB:>Q O s :™B3:2M6 K i :g zb :B=:@Tb ´º• :>:NOs judgement :AB:„™Ÿ N e:> NOP Q QQ Q O R Q 8O7 8 O :=:DB:MaNP :=@:3: 5 L Ú M8 militant groups :DB:gw | B:>NNs : UT : groups 7 Q 7 Q Q hurdles :>NOs :election campaign :cK :DB:½ˆB3Q 5 S B:…B:„:@5 ´R :B=Tb :@ ´ È <:g€wo :g K :‡<= [ :2m J 5R :g L :D= ˜ R B Q Q 7 Os Q 7 •8 Q Osƒ M[ Q O U › :>NT :öfml :2=5 a Û :gL :`@x 456 :‡<@ 4 › :˚gzb :<=¸“ :@— :…@5 5 • M :2:˘>N a N C’mN :…@5 m5[ ::=:>LN T :™<=:T T b create Q Q Q Osƒ M[ Q ŸR K uH O s 7 K uH :=K :DB:@NmK :˘>NN C’mN :…@5 m 5 [ :„gzb :B=T b :2Wu5H :™5 :½ˆB: KPK gL :…e@Nm“ :‡<@ 4 T› :˘g€ w :g } { ƒ Q Q Q ¯ OPR Os Q 7 b K¥“ o :D@F:˚c=:>TU Tb N : terrorism Ó²:;<@H4TN› :> :D@ mm} M[ =u5 a :@N K :˚g€zw @:M H protection :c :Y :cB3 8 7 ƒ I 7I O4T › ŸR O P È •O´R ¯ I ¯ :@=:A=a TTb }Ž B:B3:>5 8 NN :=:™ b 5 :> :terrorism :„@Nms•S :B<@:@5 N 5 :Q QNOs C’mN M[ :…@5 m5 [ :> Q ~Nm :gz b :`f:‹@:=:Ó²:gX s 5 a Ú Tb H K :ò ± :™¥ : terrorism :˘gzb 7 j Q ƒ Q O}Q ~mo Q OQ 7 K O O R :>:gNNNNsOKk BN B:eB<ˆB:g oL BF:g =:>:D@TTb sm}K @:½q:Z:2:„>g a– N a UPT Lul =:g b s :g :D@ P È :> ƒ M R Q QQQQ O´È O U :YBq¡ :gK :…ˆB:2M i :;3K :2:Bf aH :˘:;3 K :2:Bf a H :½ˆB:35 S B:>NN <:e@::„>Na T :gzb <3 K:hurdles create

31 Q Q Q 7 Q Q ƒ ¯¥“ ¥K 7 Q • 8 OsQ 7 O a :barrier :c=@CLÚ—N ’Þ :@::Y ::™ :gSK ˆB:g :…@@5 a• B:g oL BF:g =:>:D@TT bNN ma}K @:½ˆB:3B:˘>M 5 S @=:…@5 Hm— b 5 N X @ Q Q Q Q 7 R OsŸR O s 7 R Q :¼@:AB:ÓC:>M MaÖNN :2i :DFe3:ÐqK¡ :™5 :2:>N a :„gzb :@NN mo :Ç ~Na e:g K :3:`= K X ~H :?@ kamÒ :¼@:gM M L :…ˆB:=MN L @ S @ wO ´ M R Q Q V 7ŸR KOs7 O P R 7 K7 K :˘†™n B:3 5 NN :2•‘5a :@ ´UR :@<:3:> K :…@:c 5 a :`=X ~ H :c :?@ k ƒ ƒ I Q OUKQQQQ¯ Q 8 O U K OW 5[ :…@5 m5[ ::„>NNNTT :gLwK =:g€TTb :eq@:gœ a :c:>B:;B:2::˚>M N a :g Lw =:g€ b :eq@:;C œ am«¹N ’¿ :@N K :`@5 [ :•<@ :Z I ƒ Q ¯ Q NOa OU K V Q Q Os ƒ M[ :gK :c<@:3Ma uMm M :^F::˚>N T :gL =:g€Tb w :N C ’mN Q Q ƒ K QQ OsQQ O s7 š O U K :g€wL :eq@:gœ a :>NNN :D@5 m«[ @ :3<=:DF<@:g8 SM Hm Kb :½ˆB::@5N K :˘gz :> :D@ m } M[ = u5a :½q:™– B:„> T :g Lw =:g€ Tb : NOUT Q I ¶ Q »œ Sahib :½ˆB:25 i :gzb :™›T <:ˆB:q·L :government :c:c<@:3K ¯ a uMmNOMa :g{J :my brother Farooq Naek , ƒ M I O7 O ¯ ¯ Q NOQa 7 Leader :½ˆB:^F:˘>5NNU T :ÁBC’É B:‹5 a @Ú U T :c @ ´ 5 R :;CN ’¿ :law Minister :2Õ5L @k :gK :c <@M a :3uMm M :D@ m }K@Ma 7 yš 7 I 7 ƒ Q :2i :D=:@TbmJ5» :`˜5RT :B<= JKRQ :=:>NNNNOa ˆB:Q L Ú O s :˘D=:` ov5 u X :@ m— K :@:AB:> OO sU :„> : of the House I N K ¯ Q NOQa 7 ŸR K X :„gzb :c:c<@:3MMauMm M :D@ m}K @:™ a 5 :caretaker government :c :½ˆB:25 i :gzb :2N a :`5 uv :@— :AB j j Q O ƒ [ Q :=5[ :N s C’mN M :…@5 m5[ j Q X „„„:…ˆB:‡CM ’mN } ƒ ¯Q Q K Q Q Q O ƒ ( ( ‡e:c @ml :N s :AF@T U :3M8 ::2‘H q œ :AB ) 7 Q 7 j ƒ Q ::guPR |:g l :break ::˚gS :>N8 3K :consume :Q NOs C’mN M[ :…@5 m5[ :˚gS :>NO• 3:Kconclude ¶ I Q K Os j V Oml :„D=Tb :@TU <:3 :wind up :>N ::^@ k:™n :qÄ– :fNml :C ’mN N j ƒ [ Q „23N a ~k :>Q NOs C’mN M :…@5 m5[ j ¶ Q « ««Q ~mo X O s j V I O l :‹ B:=5[ :N :D=:<=T b~ W :@ — :…ˆB:>M N ::^@k :™n :qÄ– :fNml :C ’mN Nm 77 7 Ÿ•K Ÿ R j ¯¡ š 7 K I Os I :B=:™TTb5 :™ 5 :Ç@Rk4k :;<@›T :f@Na ::gzb :c3:B=:č@=K b¦ sk :Ç@ R :g K :D==:™ So @N ml :2:gzN a b :…@5 a :c :N :` NwM8 Q j Q Q 7 7 R 7 Q Q Os ƒ M[ Q Ÿ•K Q ƒ :`=X ~H :;CN ’Þ :\CK ³ :²:?@5 a k :¼@:;<=:gM M aM LL :D= w x @ 4 56 :DB:˘>N C ’mN :…@ 5 m5[:„=Tb :™5 :^fm8 ˆB:@N a :;3 K QQQ Q K „„„„:A@MMa :gK :DB:2‘H Be:˘A@ a :g K :DB:finance :˘A@Ma :gK :DB:defence ::

32 Q j 7 ¶ I Q Q È »œ 8 •8 Q O´È L j V Oml :2PÈ :=:@Tbm˜È :ÇM± := 5 [ :gJ { :3:‡<@:™M 5aM B:…ˆB:„@:>MM a N <:ÑCN L  :…ˆB:…B:5 :^@k :™n :qÄ– :fNml :C ’mN N š Q :™M» :„>NOUT :gzb <:<@:smilitant groups :gK :…ˆBM „>NNOUTT :gzb <:<@:…ˆB:=sM KSo :D= =:˘> O U :gz b N 3K :…@5a :3M 8 :turn :™M B:„>NNN @:Ç5H•NO5a :˘> :2:>a @5 a 7 Q ( ( `uH Bf s) ¶ Q Q Os ƒ M[ Os j V I O l :>N C’mN : who are you to stop me? :˘@G :DF3K :>N ::^@k :™n :qÄ– :fNml :C ’mN Nm 7 Q 7œ a6 O U 7 O P R Q O4T› 7 :3:…@:gK5aÚlK :Ç5± :‹@:g :™B3:2:„>M KNNaNNT :gz b <:3:…@:@ K 5 amN K :2:„gz a b :> :f m }ML:>N :…@:25a N a ! `5 [ @ « ƒ I Q Q ƒ L Oa I 6 8 7 •8 Q ¯ OU :Z:„>5 N @:Ç5H•NO5a :˘F<=JM :„>3:…@:3:‡<@:™ NK5 aamM 8 5 M B:2:gzN a b :@˜È := 5 [ :gL :AB ! ^BF:c @´5 R :^BF:„>N T :gzb < :„>N8 3 K Q Q ƒ Q :„>e:gN8 L 3:Kconclude :=K :DB:„@Q G :gus :r“ = X := K :…ˆBM ! `5 [ @« :‡<=x :>Q NOs C’mN M[ :…@5 m5[ ƒ Q ¶ I Q L Oa yš ¯ o Q Q Os ƒ M[ Q j V Oml :Z:„>5 N @´5 » : practice :c@4N• <@:=:DBM a K ! >N C’mN :…@5 m5[ : ^: @k :™n :qÄ– :fNml :C ’mN N ƒ ƒ I •S 7 K Oa :„gzb :™ :=Tb :…@:c5a :…ˆB:„>M N @5 H :Ç •NO5a j ƒ Q :„>NO• :3K :conclude ! `@5 [ « :^@ k :>Q NOs C’mN M[ :…@5 m5[ 7 ¶ I Q K Os Q Os ƒ M[ Q j V Oml :„D=Tb :@<:3TU :>N := L :conclude ! >N C’mN :…@5 m5[ :^@k :™n :qÄ– :fNml :C ’mN N 7 7 Q Q 7 OsR O U b o Os Q O ƒ [ Q :…@5a :>NN :f 5L :…ˆB:q M JM :=L :> T :gzw @MH :…ˆB:3M S B::„DFe:3 K :2á“ F:g€ w :g K :<@ 4 R :>N ::>N s C’mN M :…@5 m5[ :„>NO• :3 K ¶ I Q K7 Os O s O • K 6 j V Oml :„@G :D=:3o :…@:>5 a NNN :f 5L :> :˘> :3 :2á“ F:…ˆB:™ M 5 ::^@k :™n :qÄ– :fNml :C ’mN N Mr. Chairman: The proceedings are suspended for fifteen minutes for ä Maghrib" Prayers . ------[The House was then adjourned for "Maghrib" Prayers for fifteen minutes] j Q QQ Q Q R Q OW[ Q Os ƒ M[ Q 7 Q ( ( B=Tb :ëFC³ :^<@5a Fe ( ‡<@•5 :>N :CN ’a :f Nml)>N C’mN :…@5m5[ :…Q NOs C’mN M :…@5 m5[

33 7 7 j ¶ I Q Q Oa ŸR › 8 7 Q Os ƒ M[ Q ~ j V Oml :>N :2i :™ :™<:=:3:D@T Tb MPN R :…@5 a ! >CN ’mN :…@5 m5[ :„23N a k : :^@k :™n :qÄ– :fNml :C ’mN N 7 Q Q Q 7 Q •8 R Os Q Os ƒ M[ Q 7 :D=f:fXÚ m M[ :…@@5a • B:2i :D=:@T b ÒM[ :3:ÐqK ¡ :guP |:> N ! >N C’mN :…@5 m5[ :„g zb :@<:@:@TU5 HN m K :target :=K :D= w x @ 456 Q 7 ƒ Q 7 œ È “ O :democratic system gK :D@ma}K @:Š=:Ð=M o¸± :ÇM± :3:D@MRMM8 PN :3:r=:AB:=:> 8 XL N UT :g wuKS :^<:3:g 8 « @:g ¬ 7 Q 7 Ÿ5R R ¯ OPR yš »œ O U b Q 7 Q :™ :guP |:=:5[unholy alliance :2:2NNa i :cˆB:>N :Ç5± :2:g{ a J :„> NT :gz w @:@3:e@3:F:^@MHaamK55 8 5 8 :3:Ç K 5 [ =:D@:= 5L5 H K Q Q Os Q Osƒ M[ Q O s R I ñ È 7 unholy alliance :> N ! >N C’mN :…@5m5[ :˘gzb :@ˆB:>N a N :e= 5[ F:ÐqÔX :^<@Fe:2:g5 a N a u P± |:D= w O´ :ÇM :…B:N :;<@5ama :g :D@}K @M :í58 NO×m M :c:`K 5w± :qJMR :_@B:½ˆB:„gza M H 5 b : diversion :‡3:>58 NOs :;<@:ga K : thoughts Q 5 K ¥“QQÈ ÈOPR È QQ7 O s O U :=5[ :gzb :language :c :Y :AB:ÇM± :NNN :@:gzN am b :@ J <:=:D@K ma } K @:2M i :gz b :2::>N a :DB: T 7Q 7 7 I 7 7 R :cK :…@ “ BF:;3:>58 QNNNNNOOas :> : O s :„gzb :™<:@:c› 5 H4m4 K :?@ÔOk B:^F:@~k :3:>K OO Ps:?@ Ô O k B:> Q j 7 Q OU 7 K Q 7 KO U ƒ K Q :N T :gzb <:3K :…@5a :c :D=[ :F :`} :˘>N T :gzb <:2PÈ :2N a :g o BF:ANP :½ˆB„@5 G :DF‚e:25H =L :c :…@5 m5[ :\5 8 @ 5 H 7 L 7 K7 KQ Os O U7 K 7 Q m “ :ZBF:…ˆB:2M M i :D=Tb :@m˜È :2:=N a K :ANP :c :½ˆB:g5l :`– @km F:c :…@5 5[ :>NN :„> T :gz b <::3K :…@:c5 an :…<@ :F:‹ ƒ 7QQQQQQQQQ ƒ[ 7 o ƒ [ K O :˘@´HáR :D@:<@žo Bf5max :D@:f@:@:Z HÚ—5 :N a @5H :guH | I ƒ ƒ 7 ¯ Q NOQQa 7 O K 8 I 6 O :Ç@R k :gK :c<@:3MM auMm M :D@ ma}K @:=:DB:½ˆB:„>K 5N U T :g w S ˆB :…ˆB:ÓqM – :Z :2:˘>e:<=NNaN JM :2: a ˘>N a @:g|5H uH :Óq:AB– Q ƒ Q Os ƒ M[ QQŸR 7 Q › • S 7 œ I ! >CN ’mN :…@5 ma5[ :2:gzi b :e@:™N 5 :\F:^F:˘gz ] bblLb :@ ´mºN a e:˘gz :@ l :g :DB:g :Y:˘gzT :™ ˆB:e@:`N a 5w± :‡3 58 Q I ØR77 Ø R 7 7 Ü QOQ7 Ø R ¯ Q N Ma 7 :™NNN :˘@´am´R :ë@:\@5 ]N o :™ :˘@ R :`=X ~• Ba 5 NOa @5H :g|uH :™M6 B3 K ! >Q NOs C’mN M[ :…@5 m5[ j QQQ ƒ X ŸROPR7 OO sP R7 Ÿ R 7 O P R »œ Q Q :<=˜¥ :^F:2i :gzb :2 ‘G :™5 :2:>N a NNNN B:„DF3:…@:3:AB:>K5aM 8 :˘gz b :> :\F:™ ] 5 B:˘@ mM8 :> :g{ Jb :˘gz :3@@:@ 8 5 HaaN Q 7 Q j •8 Q Ÿ R Q L Q Q }NL I s Q Q :‡CÊñ ::™ B:_@a MH B:½ˆB:˘gz5 b :2‘G :™5 :@ — :AB:=:DB:˘@K —«a :`5 [ @ :3@:EB:585 CN ’Œ :?C ’5É :˘> 3ˆB:‡CM8 ’‘ :2@<@:™@—N m l :_BN a ! >NN C’mN :…@5 m5[ :„>T :gßw • :g€• :Á@:@:D@ a—ma } K @:gzM b :3~k :˘™ :™:3:<=:gT M 8 – K Q ¶ Q [ 6 R V R Os Q 7 »œ :@:Z:˘f—5 5L :gKKb :N :D@}K @:2 i :gz bJ:@<ˆB:qT ·L :g{ : =5[ :g l I 7 I ¯Q NOQa 7 Q~mo IIIII 7 7 O •O• ¯ Q NOQa 7 :go BF:c<@:3MMMMamauMm M :D@}K @:>N :gz b :…f3:B3:`NNa K85 ˜5R :˘D=:@Tb m 8N e:>N s :˘gz b :™N :c<@:3 ama uKMm M :D@ } K @ :…f a 3 7 7 7 7 7 7 ƒ OU b Q 7 X s È R b Q L Q I I :˘>N T :gzw @:@3:^@MHamK 5 8 :=:g€K u m :Á@ 4 R :3 K:‹:Ç@Rk :gK :D=Ok Fe:

34 Q 7 O6š O I K [ › 6 7 :<‚@k :2M ml :gK :D@ m}K @:>M a NNs :fP56 Ff:‡<=5 H ˜y5 :™ B:½ˆB:˘>5U T :gz b <:ö3:Óq:c58 – :Z5 :Y:½ˆB:T 5 =:q K Ä l :‡<= ˜ y 5 :Á@ 4 R 7Q ƒ Q ŸR OO7 O¶ 6 Q 7 O œ È Ÿ R :™5 B:˘>NUaTRT :> N @:‡<@ak :`˜5 ::„gzb :> N s :Á@ vL :‡<=˜y5 :‹:@:‹@ Ha —WmaX :g K :D@}K @:2M i :> N U :<= 5 w 5± :3M8:g w ˜ :2N a :™ 5 5 I Q KQOQ7 7 ¯Q N Ma 7 Os Q ~ mo 7 Os O P R 7 :gl :`5 l :2:c:D@N ama}K @:2MMM i :D=:@Tb m ˜È :=:c<@:3 K auMm :D@ ma } K @:>N :>N :D F3K :…@:3:AB:>5a M 8 NN :gzb :> :\F] 7 O 8O8O6 Q I 8u 7 I :2:˘>N aNNNNNNUT :gw~k :3:…ˆB:3:>KKKKMMM s :™B3:˘>3:2M Wu5H :> s :2@<‚:…ˆB:˘>3:g a — K}H {:…ˆB:„gz b :`x @ 4 56 :‡3 5 8 QQ ƒ Q ƒI 7 R R 7 :Q NNNNNOs C’mN M[ :…@5 m5[ :˚> O UT :gwS :3:D=M8NwK :> O s :Á@:AB:…ˆB:„g —MM w ~ k 3:> K OO PP :…ˆB:2i :> :…@ a N I 5 Q I R Q [ 7 K ¯ Q NOQa 7 ŸR :`5 [ @« :‡N :„gzb 7 Q Q 7 ƒ Os 7 Q •8 I 8 [ QQ [ ¯ :>N :…@5a @ • B:;358 :gw B:^F:½ˆB:˘B=5 Tb : assassinate :@@:@s s — :Z5 :˘B=Tb : assassinate :@@:@a a — :Z5 :˘c = Tb 7 7 7 Q È ¶ œ Q K o È ¶ œ o Øœ ¯Q • 8 :‡CN ’¿ :˘gJ <:ì=À± := K :D@5H :c :AB :†c @ L :EB:˘gJ <:ì=À± := K :AB :†c@ L :EB:˚gzb :D=NwK :C@:T U5 a gl :Y :c5 @ • B Q I œ È ¯ Q NOQa 7 conflict of :˘gzb :@´È <:3:A=K5wK± :=:AB:g LK :D==:Ç So M± :g :c<@:3MM amav uMm M :D@}K @:•@5L X :g K :ë²B¹ 7 Q I O :@mHabT @M :@‚:3:e<@M8 Ò NL <:D@PNRM :>N s :NNNTT :_B:=:‡N a LL58TTT :=:c@ ma } K @:Y:>M N ::> :• :c=:g Kl :`@x 4 56 :c:DB:BCN ’¿ :˘D= b 7 ƒ I Q QO ƒ MN[ QQŸR ¯j Ÿ R7 ¥ŸK • K ¯Q OQa 7 Q Q K ! >CNTs ’mN :…@5 mm45[ :„™ :c@ l ˆB:™5 :‡<@› :\F:™ ] :™ 5 :gl :c<@:3MM amaauM m M :D@ } K @:˘:g –KL @:g :g =:><@Tb — Q I Q 7 I R Q 7 K ¯ Q NOQa 7 I ¶ Q Oa O s :‡NN :2:>N a ƒ j j ¶ R 7 Q 7 ~o ~ o Q R Q Q R Q :>NNOs :ì@áo B:> O s :gS :D=:@Tb mK :¼@5 m 8 :g K :AB:=Lf 5L :gK :>Q}Nm B:@:ga uPR |:g l :> Q } N m B:˘@ ••M ˜ :f3:™ aS Ÿ 5 :BNOP :D@Q m 5 8 Q N Q Oƒ [ Q O R ƒX7 Q ƒ X Q O ƒ [ Q ! >CNNs’mN M :…@5 m5[ :„gzb :> P :2‘m} :@:…Be:‡C —N ’¿ :˘gz b :2 ‘ m } :@: — tickets :2N a ! >N s C’mN M :…@5 m5[ Q 7 ƒQ ƒ I •8 7 QQ¯Q OPR ¯ I ¥K 7 ¥ K :‡3:™58S B:3B:„gzb :@mËa~k :@:‡fo m58 @:c=:2:˘gzMMKa b :>N :‡f m 58 @:c=:3: N :@:>NaNNT :D=:D@K 4¹m¹ÒÜ @ :˘D@5 o @ :2i :D=:@T bM[ :3:ÐqK ¡ :guP |:> :˘gz b :^q · [ :@ m 8 B:=:DB:?= K‰ 5LgK :D =wx@456 ƒ Q Q Q O 87› Q ~mo 7 7 R Q K 7 R O :˘>N a @5H :A@M a :gK :ÁB= x:˘>3:`N K ¦T :½ˆB:>5 N :@=:@GmTb5KM8 :C’P :=:DB:˘gzb :c :`= X ~ H :?@ ka :¼@:gM M L :D= ˜ R B:˘> N UT j ƒ I 7 Q 7 O O ¶ œ Q I :M N a @ 5 >N s :‡5N T :M N T Q Q Q Q 7 ƒ 7 V bT 7 6 Os O s R 7 MR [ o Q ŸR •S yš »œ :™Nm :^F:@´R :B=:2Tb‘4 :>NN :^fk <@M H :˘> ::B= ± = w ± C5 ’mN :3:`M8 5[ @« :cF:<@:fN a m Àl B:™ :™ ˆB :Ç5± :gJ { :=:^F::˚gzL b :g l Q ƒ ƒ j 7 I OPR 7 ¯ O ‘ MH L I :„>NN :…@:c=:>5aK :˘gL ˆB:g o :ÑCN L  ::e@ˆB:Á² 5 ak B:3:ÇK •NO5a :3:CM 8 ’aM @ —

35 7 7 KQQ 7 [ O O x XI X Q O ƒ M[ Q :Á@4R :c:D@ maa}K @:A@:gMM K :>:˘5 >N UT : >Nm @456 :?= 5w‰ :˘N s C’mN :…@5 m5[ 7 I Q 7 I ¯Q NOQa 7 ¯ Q 8 R R 7 :DB:˘gzb :`x @456 :‡358 :_N a B:=:c<@:3LMMauMm M :D@ m}K @:˘c:>B:;B:˘YB:= a M N NNN w K :YB:„gzb :leverage @— :`l @N m l 7 7 O Ÿ•K Ÿ • K “ Q Oƒ [ Q OŸR O Ÿ R :EB ˘>N UT :gL ˆB::™5 :™ 5 :r B= X:2N a ! >NNNs C’mN M :…@5 m5[ :„> UTT :gw~k :™5 :3K :;=x e:^F: U :™ 5 :;= x e:g K ƒ j Q •X “ 77 ¥5L 7 š K QQ7 7 o 7 ::„@:™—ma :^<@NNNS ::@e:r=:2:gXwN a K :D=x @ 4456 :Á@ R :?= ¦Kw :=:D= x @ 4mmama 5 6 :™@ l}} :c:D@K @:˘=:DMM K @ K @:gL :†c @ L Q Q K I Q 8 o 7 7 Os :c:gL 3:`:=:K Tb K5/11 :3S B:˘@NmS :>5 :…Bf5 n :g€w :;<@ 4 T› := 5[:@´R :9/11 :@— :2•Na qB:_B:2œ N a i :D=Tb :@ m ˜È :²3:2:> s 58 N a N I 7 Q 7 7 j j Q •}l QQ 7S ¯I 7 7 7 »yš Os K • ¥K :Y :gK :D@ma}K @:˘c=:ce@<:‡3:`MMTTbN a58 ˜5R :Ç@R kma :g K :D@ } K @:2:2:D=:@N a i bLK m J 5 :>:=:c:Z=:gN L :™ QQ 7ƒ 7 Q 7Os 7 Q O a Q 7 ! ‚BF:…@5 mGHH5[ :„@:D=@:…<@B:gTb M 5 l :…ˆB:>M NN :3:2KPÈ :…@:‡35 a [ ˆB:„Ç@R k :g KKK :> ˆB:g :D@ mak} K @M :˘Ç R @ :g Q Q ƒ I 7 •S K 7 :qJñ :^F:˘gzb :B=Tb :@´• NO5a :: usurper :^F:2i :@PÈ :2:gN a L :`l Fe:‹« @:;C ¬N ’¿ :3:D@ M8 P RN :˘™ :c :`=X ~H :3:D@M8 PN R ƒ I Q Q 7 I S 6Ÿ5R 7 • J 5R Q [ R Q [ R Òo I :˘gw :<=JM :™ :^F:@´R :@5 • N :g l :5 :=: K usurper :A B:_N mJ :‹ @:„gz5ab :B=:@Tb ´• NO5a ƒ Q Q 7 »œ 7 6Q Os S I 6 ŸR 7 Q [ R Q [ :g{J :2:D=:@i TbmJM =:gM L l :…@5 m5 [ :>:„gN w :<= J M :™5 :^F:@ ´mR :@N K : receive :gl : 5 ƒ I ƒ 7 ƒ 7 ƒ :Z5[ :„=:™Tb•S :cK :ÑqN L ÔL :ÍB:c=:c• ¯ K K :caretaker government :>NNNOs :Z5[ :> O a @m58 :‹ Ò Nw8 <ˆB:^F:@ — :> Q O aˆB j I Q X 87Q }NO•NmÀ Nw8 O s :@:AB:2—i :gzb :2::`N a 5 uv :@: — caretaker government :2i :˘>e:@NNm58 :> =:^F:@:˘=:@LNN amPT b S :@È :2:>N a 7 :3 M8:D@PNR : Leader of the House :2iP :D=:@<:2TTbUÈ :g€wo :AB:…@:2:> a aNOs :½ˆB:„=:2:˘2:5 b aa mandate 7 T 5 NNN 7 L Q ŸR K O j L caretaker :2:˘gzN a b :•u :@:DB:™— 5 :g l :law :N UT :@qs t :ÑN L C  7 7 Q •8QQ • ˜ È Os 7 I R :;<@4mTN› :…@5 5[ :2i :gzb :™N e:D@N m 58 :2:˘gzNN a b :™ :2:> a :D@ ma } K @:ÓˆB:…<=:YCM K N M ’k :3:@:K 5 H government Q Q ƒ QQ7 R 7 :@ MH:@m˜È :gl :`@– k F:c:…@K 5 m—5 [ :>::„@:gNOs L 3:Kinvoke :=K :Article 6:gzb :>NOP :mandate :c¯ =K := L :A@ a Q M I Q R :ÑN wM[ :g K :`w¦ <=:AB:N :> N ˆB:AB:= 5 [ :gz b ::Ñu H :™T F:^F:˘gz bL :@N m o ::Ñ u H := 5 [w:g :=~Na 3BßNa 7 I 7 O O ¯Q NOQa 7 7 K ¶ R :˘>N UT : usurper:^F :2 i:>N UT gzb <:2PÈ :2:‡e@N a •R B:g K :c<@:3 auMm M :D@ maa}K @:@:`=X ~H :c :½ˆB:˘ 5 gzb :@<@TU5 H :@ a e:Ï À± Q MM N N OPR Q › 7 K Os :>N :mandate :A@:;<@Ma4mTN› :…@5 5[ :2i :gzb :™<:2T PÈ :2:D=N a NwK :`=X ~ H :c :…ˆB:>M :;<@:g5 a K :usurper Q Q I Q I R 7 ƒ Q :gus :;f aBe :D@PÈ :D@ P È :gK :Z:Z:>K K NOP :@ m M8 ! >CQ NOs ’mN M[ :…@5 m5[ :„@:g — L 3:KArticle 6 invoke :gzb Q Q ƒ¶ ƒ 7K 7 6 XO U :@G :D=˜È :gl :…<@5H B:c :…ˆB:…@:‡3M 5 a[ ˆB::„g LK @ 5Ha´ :@@N È :Y <:3:ÁB=M 8 xub :g :AB:N T :g L = T Q Q Q I Q Q ¯SKR R R R ¯Q¯8 Q NOQa 7 :2i :gzb :^N B:;B:˘c <@ ama :3 uMm M :D@}K @ :½ˆB:25 i Q Q Q Q I 7 7 7 R Q :>NOs :;CN ’í fB:½q:Z:Z:=:DB:„gza – K K KuxQ b :@mK :NOTU :gw8 € e:;CN ’í fa B:½ q– :ZK :˘gzb :‡e:h=J5R :½q – :Z K :˘>NOUT :g€ w 8 e:Y <:½q – :Z KK :Z ::3K :ÇK <

36 7 Q j j Q O ƒ [ Q „`5[ @«a :3@:EB:`585 [ q:…@t 5 m5[ :„` 5 [ @ «k :^@ :˘23N a ~ k :>N s C’mN M :…@5 m5[ Q j I Q »œ QQOs ƒ M[ Q~•[ o† ¦ 6 o ¥ 5 L 7 Oml :gJ { :g L :…ˆB:2M i ! >N C’mN :…@5 m5[ :23N a k :„YN 3B:> 3B:EB:Y ::358 @5a :EB:`[ qt :C ’mN N ¶ Q j Q j V 7 œ 7 8 Q Os “ 7 › :2i :@:`—«k5 [ @ :^@ :™n :qÄ– :ÁC’• :` l Fe:g|w B:D=:N :„@e:r=:@:gN a—a X L 3:…@: K85 3M :motion :YT B:AB Q j Q Q Q Os 7 Æ œQ K 7 R œ :;e:…B=5 5[ :@— :DB:>N :2 i@a:@e:3NaK :¼ BF:3:ÇM 85± :=K•S :D= = :DB:NaœN :2:BCN a N ’¿ :3:>K := ß m :c:`@ 5 [ « :^@ k :™ n :q Ä – :ÁC ’• ! >N C’mN :…@5 m5[ :„D= ~k Q Q j š QQ › R j Q »y 7Q 7 7 R :‹« B:gL :Y::„gzT b <:3::>K NO P :Z=:c:• K K gwJ { :=:K issue :‹« B:3:<=:2MM8–m}L Be@:@:3:<=:2a a 8 – m } L Be:_:™a Ÿ5 B QN R yš R „gzb :>NOP :™:@›T ´5 » :™ Ÿ 5 B:=:Kissue Honestly Mr. Chairman, until I heard the honourable Senator, I thought that this House would be unanimous on the understanding of the basic issue that is confronting us today. I was very disappointed with the speech of the honourable Senator which convinced me that well, we have settled to travel a long distance in order to know what the issue is. Q 7 K KO K O R Q O ƒ M[ Q :D@F:3B:NNs :g{ L = Û :Z:2i :gz b :> P :2:N a Issue ! >N s C’mN :…@5 m5[ Q Q 7 7 7 7 I ŸRKR R Ÿ R7 K ¯ Q 8 Ÿ R 7 K ¯ Q NOa :=:AB:gKL :D= ˜LR B:=:™ :c:YB:=NNN wK :YB:@:™NNa :`=X ~ H :c:c:>B:;B:@:™M N a : `=X ~H :c :c<@:3Ma uMm M 777 7 7 Q Q ŸR › O´RK R OO ´m R X 7 OO sP R :™5 :2:=:Y:˘>N aLLTHTNNTNNN :c :D=e@N • B:˘> :‡<@ 4› :> = ~b :D@F:2T U i :D=:@ msm8 @:> :˚@N K :> :D=N w K::control Q Q 7 Q O R QQOƒ [ Q ~o O R › O :>N P :2N a : issue ! >CNNs’mN M :…@5 m5[ :>Nm :g~ k :3:>K P : control :=K : situation :AB:Y:2T i :>N UT :gw8 @ s Q Q QQƒ Q ƒ Q O R ŸR Q O ƒ M[ Q :DB=B:f@:˘D=@:3N P :™5 :2:N a issue ! >N s C’mN :…@5 m5[ :„gzb 7MR 7 ƒ Is this the issue? :„gzb :extension :cKQ :`=X~H :™V´M» :`= X ~[X H :^e=5 =:g€ wo :AB: NOUT :g w S :> 5 8 7 7 Q Q ƒ j ¶ 7 œ I can :=:>LNOUT :gzwb @:@MHmO5a :DB=B:f@:`@Q N L a Ú 5 [ «k :^@ :™Vn :qÄ– :ÁC’• :3B:S This is not the issue. say, Mr. Chairman, that I will also recommend him, why not? Farooq Naek is there to regulate the business of the House. He is not there to defend the Government. He will not be required to Q Q Q •8 › OPR ŸR Q Os ƒ M[ Q :gL :…@5 5• M :=:YK T :@NmK :2:gzib :>N :™5 :2N a issue !>N C’mN :…@5 m5[ :defend the Government. Q Q j QQQQQQ Q ¯• 8 8 Q OOs PRwX uH › • 8 O P R w X :c@5 5•M :g|w B:D=::„:@NNNN mK :> :r :g lL}L :g 3:A= K u 5 :g {:=:Y:g K :…@5 5 •mM :„> :„g bz :@N K :r 7 Q Q 7 Q Q 7 7 Q Osƒ M[ Q O P R wX › :`5 5[ :\] F:AB:2i :gzb :2N a :=L : issue ! >CNN’mN :…@5 m5[ :„@N m K :> :r :=:Y:=:gKLT L :D= ˜R B:„@:D= — O k Fe

37 7 7 Q 7 ƒ Q È Q 7 Q OU•~k O s 7 Q • 8 I •S » •NO´ Æ K7 Q • 8 :>NNT :™ :go :2Œ[ :>:…@@5a • B:=:D@L Nma8<@:2:2M N a i :gzb :™ :™M :CN ’• • :¼ BF:_B:˘gzN a b :fˆB:fˆB:c s s :…@@5 a• B 7 Q 7 Q OOOm~k PR s 7 Q •8I Q ~ mo :„ :„ >NNN:go :> :2Œ[ :> :…@@5a• B:D@N ma8 <@:2:2:>M NN a a N Mr. Chairman, the battle lines have now been drawn very clearly. Never before the ideological battlegrounds have been drawn so clearly and so definitely as they have been drawn on the eve of 2013 Elections. Q › O R L •±Æ Q ŸR › :Y:N P :g l :g€ ” q:¼– N :=:Klines :DB:Ns C’mN M :…@5m5[ :=:gL~ k :3:2:A²:‹:N C’mN :…@5 mam—5[ :˘@@N l :2 “ BF:@:YN :Ím 5[ :‡CFe:g ³L :`@5[ «H :‹f:™@:` N n 5 l Fe:;C N ’¿ Q ¶ Q 7 ƒ Q Q •·x Q :ÓfU :=K : trade unionists :gulP |:gR :`5l :g L :D=˜R B:=:g L L ˆB:‡<@:>a NOs :YN :Ím 5[ :‡CFe:`:2 ³ 5 5 [ i T 7 ¶ Q ŸR õL K j j X Q : 2i :™ :Y :c :q¡ @k :<=˜¥ :N P ::trade unionist :>NNs :2•a =NwK :@TU <:A= X @ H :> s :˘gL ˆB:Óq– :c :trade unionists :^F ã åThen they came for the Roman Catholics, I did not say anything because I was not a Roman Catholic.ç 7 Q Q Q 7 •[ ŸR „@e:3:YNa K :™5 :=:KRoman Catholics :gL :D=˜R B:= L åThen they came for the Communists, I did not speak up because I was not a Communistç 7 Q Q Q 7 •[ ŸR „@Na e:3K :Y :™5 :=:KCommunists :gL :D=˜R B:= L åThen they came for the Jews, I did not speak up because I was not a Jew.ç 7 Q Q Q •[ ŸR Q „@Na e:3K :Y :™5 :=K :Jews :gL :D=˜R B:Bf †P Ü One by one, they finished the trade unionists, the Roman Catholics, the Communists, the Jews.

38 åFinally when they came for me, there was no one to speak up.ç 7 Q 7 7 Q Q ~ o R Q QQ•X 7 7 O Q O ƒ [ Q :> Nm gJ :‡<@:gaK :™ 35[ :=:^F:2Li :D=:@T b mHambT @:@@M 5 8 :2:=:D=N a KO k Fe:g| w 8 B:> N s ! >N s C’mN M :…@5 m5[ 7 Q ¶ 7 »œŸR j V 7œ ÔL I » œ O QQQ Q 7 :=:g{LJL :2i :@PÈ :™5 :2:gN a :`@5[ «k :^@ :™n :qÄ– :ÁC’• :`:B=:` 55 [ Tb 5 5 ± :B3:g{58 JK :N UT :D@ m¹amao @ :‡<@:g :D@ } K @ 5 Q M OUQQ O P R 7 „>NNT :D=:D@K 5mo @ ¹ :2i :> :@ m M 8 Mr. Chairman, these Talibans are the replicas of what the Nazis were doing in the 2 nd World War. ¶ Q j I Q wNO5a 7 œ 7 Q Oi ¯ Q NOQQa 7 R :CN ’v :2C¿ ’• :fNm˜ š :=:3=K58 w K B: 18 :˘@@Nam58 :Óf:g€TU } :=:c<@:3KMM auMm M :D@ ma } K @:g L :D==:DB:g S o u P | 7ƒ Q 7 7 QQQ~mo •S R SQ K O R QQO ¯ L 7 I R :179 :Ç R@k :gK :DB:>N :™ :¼:cM 5 f<:ca :DB:„ >N ´:^F:ÓfTU :²PMR :@— :DB:˘>N UT :c ˆB:ZM BF:D@ m}K @M a := wJ5 ¶ Q j ƒ j I R wNO5a 7 œ ƒ š QQOs ƒ M[ Q S K :=:=K wJ5 :CN ’v :2C¿ ’•š :fNm˜ :f@:‡<@ a Ú 4 T› :=:C K 5 ’4 e: 27 !>CN ’mN :…@5 m5[ :„gw :=:fTb Nm˜ š :><@:g — o @N m 5[ Q Q ƒ j Q Q 7 j Oi S Q :g} € :=K :ANP :gL :D=˜R B:„g w :=:fT b Nm˜š :<@5m8 @:;<@5 H 4 T› :: 83 :Ç@Rk :gK :DB:˘@NN mS :@e:3:f a K Nm˜ š :actually ƒ j j Q Q Oi Q ¯ 7 j KQ [L O U I NOQk Q Q j :g} € :=K :DB:˘c =T b :…e@ Pš:c:>:<=5u5a :C N ’W5 :„>N T :g|~ H :=:fT b Nm˜ š : workers :DF3~m :gK :DB:„@@Na m58 :2@a W L 7 7 7 j Q j Ÿ›R OsR 6 — š 7 »œ :=:™Lb :™<:=:\qT T5 N8 ”L :_B:>NNa N :=N w K :¼B:™:`M 5 5 5[ :D= • 3:@:‹:2MM8NNNai :gzb :™ = [ :3:…@:AB: 8 5 ag{ J :„@ mmS :@ K :f N m ˜š 7 j Q j O´ºNa R R OMa7 Ÿ R L O s :>NTN e:=:D=KOwk Fe:gK :YB:=NNN K :YB:;<@4mm› : :AB 7 7 Q 7 › ŸR OsL O m x š Q O4T› Q Os ƒ M[ Q :™<:™T 5 :<@ÒNwM8 C3:>:ZˆB:=:>³ 58 NNML @ 45 6 :™ @N m l :D= w NOa :2:2N a i:gzb :@<:@:@e:2TU5 HN a mž– :2:>N a N :½ˆB5 ! >N C’mN :…@5 m5[ Q j Q 7 [7 ±œ šI Q R šOU › Òo O U :_:f:Z:„gzaH5b :Ñum :g l :;CFe:_B:<=³ NT a }O s :™ @NNml :˘Bf m 5± N B:™ @ m4 l :B<@TNN› :˘>TT :™<:‹@:DT 5 aU@ :„> Q 7ƒ 7 I Q OPRQ X Q ~Omo UuŸ5R Q OO UUH› ~ •K › :D@5mo @:2 ¹i :>NNNN :3C:`S T U5uv :2:@:AB:>N a — N :gSw :>TTT <:gH |:™ :^f m 8 ˆB: :g| u H ::Y:˘>TT:g wJ k :‹:gM B:Y Q 7 ƒ O R R 8 Q “ :gwi :g K :YB:=NNNwK :YB:;<@4TN› :„>3:K eliminate :=K :DB:: one by one :^F:2i :gL @5H :@Na e:r =X :2N a := K ƒ 7 O 6j Ÿ R :„>:™B3:gN s MK L =:fTb N m ˜š :™ @ k Q OPR 7 ŸR › I 7 »œ Q Os ƒ M[ Q :>N :identify :=K :threat :_:™a 5 B:YTT :2i :B=b :ÇK e:B3:3:…@:AB:g58M 8 5a J { ! >N C’mN :…@5 m5[ Q Q 7 OR ÈQ ~ o ŸR7 K O Ÿ R R Ø :3S B:˘@mK :>N P :ÇM± :gL :…ˆB:>M Nm :™ :`=X ~H :c :…ˆB:>M Ns :D== 5 L Û :Fe:™5 :guP |:2i :@<:™UNR :2F<:B<@N a 4 T› :3S B:„g ~ k :3 K N 77 T 7 I 7 œ 7 RR 7 7 x Q 7 R :g }€Oi @ ´•KB:`5w± :c:D@K Q ma}K @:=:Y:…B:˘>K5NNNO´ :<@ ÒwM8 C3:>:ZˆB:=:>³ 58 O sML L O m @ 4U 5 6 :D= w NOa :Y:2:@<:2:2F:DB=B:f@:`Q 58 Q NL [ @ :_8 @:•F<@:…@5[ :2i :gz b :2: a issue :B<@ :2i :=:2F<:B<@Tb a T› :3S B: „c¯ @ 3 K aÚ 5 «N m a ¬m5 N k7 N 4 Ma 7 ÔL »œ ƒ Q it is such a serious intellectual debate :2:gzi b :@=:`a Tb 5 5± :g{ J ! >Q NOs C’mN M[ :…@5 m5[ bearing on the security of Pakistan, bearing on the integrity of the country, bearing on the future of our generation, when this debate is trivialized and I use the words, such a debate is trivialized by the

39 kind of comments that I just heard from across the aisle. All that I can say Mr. Chairman, that I was extremely disappointed with those comments but Mr. Chairman, I have not lost hope, I have not lost hope because we are determined to fight. We will fight to the last, we will fight to the finish. No matter that some people support us or not, we will fight the Taliban, we will fight their collaborators because this is a fight for the survival of

:2N a : Pakistan. This is not the fight of survival of any political party. Q QQI 7 QQQš Os QQK K K 7 :gKLK :DB:˘g :D=wK <@:g— :D=N w 8 <@:™M a @N ml :D= w N O a :DB:>N :Ím5[ :c :@ Õ5L :AB: 5 NN :D@ ËNw8 B<:=:D=KN w 8 @q:c5 a ] :DB:˘>T :‡e Mr. Chairman, one last comment I want to make, is Q 7 7 8 X 67 6 › All :„>N 3K :ì= 5wKL“˜¸ := :D= = :‡<=y5 :NOs :˘@: — democracy 7 Q Q 7 R :DB=B:™Q NL š B:˘g€zwb @:@²:2MH aMH ¿ fÕX :@:‡ Q 7 ƒ 7 7 7 ƒ j 7 m“ QO a I š K ¯ OM a Os :‹5 :N :„gL @:@@5HamNNbT :g l :D=<@L 4¡ :™ @ m4 l :Á@ R :=:3F@ KN8 Œ LT :c:AB:2i :gz b :c=:Z b N :eBe N Q 7 Q j Q ƒ OPR O s Øœ ¯Q • 8 ¥K 7 7 X Q Q Ž I ¯ j :go :>NN :2Œ[ :>:Y :c@5 • B:™ :…@N m[ :@:ÓC a  :3F3:?CN8M 8 ’5É : 2i :@Na e :@NmK :2‘ŒNw :gL :…<=:c@:NNN :„g w ~k :=:>T b P : s :…@5 • • B:™ :^F:˘g w ~ k trial of the century because we have now to decide that there are no two sets of laws, no two sets of regulations, one for the civilians and the other for the military personnel. Q 7 Q Q 7 Q [ •M˜R 7 Q Q ¡ ¯Q • 8 •Os :=:Z:gzK 5 b :@M• :_:N T :gL =:;fT m8 @4R6R :g K :D= wx @ 4m4Pm5 :™@NNl :Á@ :D@56 :D@ u5m ¦ B:c@=5 a Û¦ :?= :D@ 4amaN • o <@:c:D@MM } K @ Q Q Q 7 Q Q Q m8 6 L Q 7 Q K • Os L I :‹N 35[ :™=:•@5 Ž5 k :_B:ÓqN a – :‡C³ Fe:

40 ƒ Q Q Os [ Ž I R Os[Q O a [ :‚@:DB=B:>5aNLN :;<@:g 5 a K :Z5 :˘=T b :2 ‘ŒNw :@— :…<=:YCKN M ’k :>NN :;<@:g5 aK :Z5 :˘@N msaK :?@@:=M K :> ˆB:g L :Z 5 Q ƒ Q OaQ Ž I 8 j O s [ 8 K :BC5 ’¿ :gl :>NNN B=:DB:=:AB:˘=:2“KbT‘ŒNw :2N m o @:@:…<=H— ~N m @: :;<@:g5 a K :Z5 :˘D=: Tb > eBeQQNNOa B=:>“ 5 [ :@m~k :@5 H :@ ´ È <:> O P ƒ 7 7 Q 7 Q j j I Æ »œ ƒ Q :@mbT @:@‚:3:M H a M8 record :>NOs :=:ZK5[ :c=:Z=¯ T bN L } L:‡<=JRQ :>NOs :> ¦ :AB:g{J ! >Q NOs C’mN M[ :…@5 m5[ 7 ƒ Q Q ƒ j Q S O Q I 8 XQ :gK :e@ˆB:Á²5ak B:=:gLb w :=:TbN :\<:ZtN :c=:_:™ Ka 5 B:3:AB: N :…<=:YCN M ’k :gL : IG police Q Q 7 j 7 Q Q Q Q :@PÈ :gL :D=˜R B:„>N8 3K :^@ G ˆB:= K :DB=Q N L B::gl :\t <:Z NOMa:AB::^F:2i :@G :DF3K :`l B=[ ¬ NO s j Q Q 7 QQ 7 j X 7 Q R › •N8 X Q :=:ÓCK :^F:CN ’mN :…@5 m5[ :„gw :g o :™ e3<:g58 l :D@FT U Q Q7 ƒ Q Q 7 R S •N8 RO I R K Q 7 :gL :D=˜•5[ :˘g Jwo :g :g :<35± <:=:AB:2 Ki :gz b :@<:2TU PÈ :2:3:<=:‡33N a M 88± –KNN :>N s :…<=:Y CM ’k :c:D@m}K @M a 7 ƒ Q O› 8Q È O Q O ƒ [Q R R I :NNNUT :™T <:ˆB:> s :BC ³ Fe ! >CN s ’mN M :…@5 m5[ :„gJLw :g =:gTb˜ |:;C M ’i :g K :D= uN m K F j Q Q Q 7 7OPR tQ Q ±œ o Ì I 4Ua ¡ 6 O › O :BfNmM8 :2N a :3 8@:_B:˘gzaN a b :>NNN :™@:BC:F:B3:ò — ³ 5 [ :g€ wKwS :g :g 3:g 5 8 ˆB:‹ :‡<=˜y5 :2i :>T :™<:=:T T b > @:25a N a K O Q O ƒ M[ Q Q Q Q :c :½q– :AB:3M8 : floor of the House :> N s ! >N s C’mN :…@5 m5[ :„=:2:BCTb a ³ :F:B3:25[ i :gzb :@<:@:@T UHm5 K 7 N 7 yš 7 ¶ 7 ¶ R Q :‡<=˜y56 :3B:2Si :D=:@TT bmJ5» :Tb NNOP :Z 3:gM8 l :AB:_:` a 5 5[ :˘@:gG o @ ´ 5 •Ok :> O P :‹ 4 :eqt :_ a Mr. Chairman: Babar sahib , thank you. I I Q Ÿ5R Os R Q Os ƒ M[ Q 7 Oml :™ :>NT :;<@:g5aK :`5 [ @ « :=wJ5 :?F²:;<@5a 4 › ! >N C’mN :…@5 m5[ :358 @5a :EB :`[ qt :C ’mN N Q 7 Q I ƒ l Os Øœ ¯• 8 R Ž 7 R J»œ ¯ 7 :g :2F:AB:>5HN :Y :c@ 5 • B:`@5 [ « :=wJ5 :?F²:2 5a i :@N m S:@PÈ :2:`N a 57 5[ :B=:A= Tb } B:` ˜ 5 :g{ :„c=:…@:_B Tb 5 a N a Q I Q O 7 O•}‰L KI I ¯ O R Mr. Chairman, how the >N UT :Ó²m[ B: >:YNNsN :c:D=w~a :c<@:2:gzMa ib <:g o :> P :2 Œ [ 7 Q › OR O I R :™F:2:=:gzT N a L b <:ˆB:>NNP :> s :public :`5 [ @« :=wJ5 :?F²:3B:5a S whole issue is being trivialized? Q Q š L I I R › 7 [ :½q:™– B:g€Ô NOUT :gzb <:g o : leaders :;CFe:;<@³ 4TNN› :½q:Z:˘>– 5[ OUT :gzb <:g o :2Œ[ :>:Y O s :c@5¯ • • 8 B Chairman, for Godãs sake I would urge my friends that do not trivialize the serious, sensitive issues bearing on national security.

41 Thank you. Mr. Chairman: Thank you. Raza Rabbani sahib . I have to see the strength of the parties also. That must be kept in mind that what is the strength of each political party sitting over here. Raza Rabbani sahib . Afrasiab Khatak sahib . Shahi Syed sahib . j I Q ‰ ‰ ‰ ~ Q Os ƒ M[ Q › j Oml „ „  ª≈ª‹‚  „ ‚  ‚ ‚ „ ‚     fl ş ‡ ‚ „  ‚ „2N a 3 k ! >N C’mN :…@5 m5[ :fNml :™T @k :C ’mN N 7 Q ( ( `uH Bf s) 7 j Q O ƒ [ Q I want to give opportunity to :2i :gzb :2:…@:`N a 5a5 [ @ « :^@ k ::>N s C’mN M :…@5 m5[ every political party who have representation but I have to see the strength of the party also. 7 Q ( ( `uH Bf s) Mr. Chairman: He can object Q OUI O s Ÿ5R K › That is not the issue. Press „>NNT :g|~H :ö3:>M8 :<@5m[ B:™ : statement :c :…ˆB:YM T : Q Q 7 Q „gzb :CN ’MÉ :N :2i :D=:@Tb mbT @M Ham :@@5 8 :2:>NNaN :„23 a k ! >N C’mN :…@5 m5[ ::fNml :™@T k :C ’mN N Q Q Q j Osºa Q O sQ 8 œ Q O P R ±š :‡CN ’¿ :N :2i :gJ €e:3:_@Ka ´m5 6 :> N :D@5 N 8 3:g| S w B:™eˆB:C:2T U • a =N w[KK :@:DFe: G > N :…B=5 5 := :ò Q ¶ Q Q Q I •·x Q › j o 8 Os ¯ :Á²k B:`f:@:AB:Y5sTb—N :gl :` 5 l :_e3:gN a 8 K :fN m l :™@T kG :2i :@:D=˜È :N ::„gz :@N maK :c<@M 7 OO8 ºH »œ O8Q ƒ Q Q 7 :AB:>Ns :˘> N UTT :g€w e:Y := 5[ :g{ J :^F:„> N U :>f@:‡3q:; N a Ú K œ CN ’¿ :f 5L :gK :AB:NNN :?@ :¼@:gM M uL´ | :g :…ˆB:2i :>T :gz b <:;e:g w :> :Š=::„Do=:@3:T b a Kfollow := K Q 7 Q I 7 ƒ ƒ I 6ŸR 7 Q R QQ ¯Q NOa Q Q 8 R :‡<=JM :™5 :…@:A@:g aa K :YB Q ƒ Q Q 7 7 QQO8s »œ R QQ ll ž– I ñ 7 R »MR ŸR :@mN8 e:2mž– :=:e=:>K [NN :˘>e:2 mi5 ž – :g{J :Š=:2 o :g KL :AB:g @5 • :˘3:> K :> :g wl :2:gN a :D=wO´ :C’P 5 :gu ´ | :„™ Q Q QSSK~mo Q ›77 V »MR 7 » y š O s K :>N :c:=:N :˚gz b :@N m K :25 H F:c :AB:3ßs :D= b 7 Q 7 7 I œ ŸR O R KQ [ R O•MR O a ¯ Q NOQa 7 :čB<= 5w5± :˘™ :>N P :‡<=:eBfML L :c :> 5 :˘g J MNAs :ZNNM :@:Za5 :=:_B:g• N a K :c<@:3 amauMm M :D@}K @ 7 Q N Q MM › ¥L 8Q È Ÿ R O R 7 Q I ¯ Q :D=:™<:™TbTNN B:>CN’ MÉ :ÇM ± :˘™ :> NP :`=X ~w H :ì= 5 ¸ X :_BN a :=5[ :‡3M8 :c @ m58 coalition government ¶ ƒ Q Q OV¹ Q O7 š L Q O S :_B:@N a mÒo @L :glK :>NNNs :AB:=:YK :g :DFqˆB:˘@‚:>œ aH s :\@:™o B:ZBF:gM KK :3:?@K • 5R :=:> K a ˆB:g :1973 :„c

42 7 R 7 j Q Q Q •X 7 I 7 Q :B<=ML := K :DB:˘>Q NO´ :…@WTb B=[•S :cK :D= 3:c58 K :D=<3:;<@ 5 8 4T› := 5 [ :g€ÔL = 8 N8 Ì <@ ´´a—R B:„@ R :2¿ @<@ Q Q Q o ¶ 6 7 V R O R 7 K Q 7 I Q :@WNL B:_B:g€NNa wK :g :Á@ vL :‡<=˜y5 :g oL BF:g ˆB:25 m8 q:™œ PM :>:¼<@:c:D@N s ama}K @:3:ö3:gM K5 8 l :`5 l::_:AB:2:g€NNOs‘s i wo :AB:˚g€ w o :Z:^F:˘>K O a @m58 : setup : DB3ßa : ˘>N8 3 K Q 7 7 š 7 Q ~o 8– O T› R »y › ŸR Ø O T› :>Nm :gSw :>e:gNNž :>4 :Š=:2:go i Jw :g J { :Y:˘T ™ :fNmX B:™ NR:> N 4 :„D=Tb :transparent elections 7 Q 8 I I Q 7 › ŸR Q O 2i :gS :>e:‡CN ’aM : a NTs :ë@e:;<@ s4 › 7 7 Q j Q R ƒ Q › Q Q 7 7 j Q :NO´ :™•S :^<:D@ a NOs :Y T ]N n :>Nm :c :=:‡ 3 K 7 7 Q Q ƒ O OONmM8 O Q :=5[ : Election Commissioner :2:˘>a NOUT :gwS :^<:De:ZQ NNNa :NOUT :gzb <:<@5H :g w S 7Q 7 Q Q ƒ ¯wX O T› Q Q ¯ wX 7 Q Q 7 Q 7 :N 4 :2N mo f:eB<ˆB::2:˘gzn a b :c3 K :r :`=X ~H :DB3ßa :2:˘gza b :@@a Ë o :ban :^F:˘@m58 :gl :g L B<:•@ á L B I 7 7 ¶ Q 7 j ¯Q NOQa 7 I QOa ¯ O4T› •·w8 7 b :˘c<@:3MMMauMm M :D@ mama}K @:˘D@N 8 <@:>N :2:2N a i :gzb :c3: K warn :gK :3:Kaddress :>N :YN :e3:`ST} e:_BN a 7 7 Q Q 7 8 › O•Q O s 7 Q •8 ¯ Q 8 I œ •X :„gS :>3:N Kbomb blasts :YT :=:@LNmo :3S B:„>NNN :2:2a Œ [ :> :…@@5 a • B:cM :>B:;B::gNNOUT L 3:gK K @4Ù e:>: O s corner meetings :˘>NNOP :>:g O s } u H {:;358 :;<@4T› :^F:„‡e:;e:‡3 8 :˘= uMH QQQ RII7 Q 7 R 7 R Q Q 7 7 Q › :2•‘5a :>NNNNNOP :‡3:c@: O P :2 Wu5H :B3:…ˆB:˘g5 MM w ~ k :@:>5 Hmm OO Ps :> :;<@5[ :=:…ˆB:2L im :gz b :@ u s :2ž – :> O 4 T :q J MR j Q 7 Os Q Q Q 7 Q ŸR Q »œ :f Nm˜š:Š=o :^<@5a :>N :AB:F3K :Ó= [ :@ — :Bf H ! ;fm58 :gK :Bf::„@ H ´ÒR :@wNO´M R :3~Na 3:=:^F:2:@ KL iNN maS :@e:™5 :2 ma ž – :2:g{N J j Q Q Q ƒ Ok I OOPsR O UI O s 7O• 7 :@<:@TTU´È e:>N ‚:=K :…ˆB:@fM N aNmX :eB<ˆB:2•‘5a :@<:2 U P È :>NNNN:> :2:„>N a T :;3:>M8 :?@mMOWTb :Š=:ZoN @ m O mN M 8 ::3N ~MH :gKK :<@: N :D@ V W :™5 :gz b :^F:˘@=:> aTb N :BfmJ :?e:@:AB: — 3M8 :AB:„gz b 7 ƒ Q Q 7I O I Q È 7 7 7 ¯ŸR K 7 :„@´R :@ mJMR :>Ns :‡fmK :B3M± :=:@ 5[ ´ R :3~KNa 3:=:2:2:gzLN a i b :@m˜È :g K ::3:\3:c=:‡3:™ K[SKT b 5 :g l :f:c:`H Nw8 @ W L B Q Q O Q Q Q QK › 7 [ Q :>NUT :gzb <:@Ëo :‡fm58 @:=M a 5[ :2:2N a • a = N w Kgzb :@mM[ = •:q– @H :c :Á²k B:3:>N o N B:D@NNmaH8 <@:<@M M :2i gzb :@ˆB:D@ a m 5 8 :o N : elections :Y :2 i ƒ Q 7 7 Q ŸR O œ 7 ¯ R Q VWX Q 7 :`5 l :2:2NNa i :D=:@Tb m8 @:™ s5 :2:> a N s :„™² k B:` x @ 4 56 :˘cˆB= NLg{6 :˘Ó@ŒL B:_N a 3± :˘ ( )D Í:YN mo :D@m}K @M a Q 7 Q 7 ƒ 7j 7 Q OR › •8 j OO}QTb 7 OOR Ÿ •K 6 :>NNNNNP B:ÑN wuÒL :™:™T B:f@Na k :„> as ˆB:e3 ß m e:>:D@ ma}K @:2:gM i S :D=:gzTb w b @:>M H PU :™5 :2:˘>N a T :Š=: o‡<= ˜ y5 7 j Q Q 7 Q Q ~ o I o » œ R :AB˘q@:c:g– H KQwLOm €5[ :> }N m B: QS ~Nm :gz bJ :g{ :™•OH5 :c :=:™T b Ÿ 5 ƒ QQ j I 7RQ Q 7 7Q »œ 7 R Q 7 Tb :3:NNNNOOPs :> :;<@m5[ :=:…ˆB:2 L i :> O UT :g€ wJw8 e:2 mž – :g{ :2 • ‘5a :g€ 8 e:> O P :…B5 = 5[:3:2M8mX :=:e3 K ß m} e Q 7 ƒ O 7 Q K QQI O ƒ :gwbOi :>N s :_‘s :AB:„gz :@ˆB:@F<:3:½=aaM8M • :c :DB:˘gz b :Á@ Õ— X :@ :ÇK e:N s :AF@T U :DeBq œ

43 7 QQQ7Q ƒ 7 Q 7Q 7 ƒ •OiQQ QOa•[ • O i O m 58 š • O i Prime :25 m8 q:™œ :D=:˘gzKb :^f<:D=:˘>a KNN =:YT b :™ :˘> :D@Nmu5m¦ B:™ :˘g L ˆB MNAs ƒ 7 ¯ ù• Q ƒ Q 8 ŸR Q :c =Tb :™ :@Nm8 e::™5 H5 5 :…B:˘@5 m 5 8 Minister Q Q 7QQƒ 7 7 j Q I šROPR •[7 Ÿ 5R Q ~ mo • [ }T b :@@:3:<=:Ð@: KN :Y :_:™a B:^F::>N :g L @:=5 H Tb :Y :‡e3 ß m e:2i :gz b Q 7 Q 7 j 7 Q 7 7 7 I »œ OPR •[ }Tb R Q Q •JÈ QOÕNL j ¯ K Q Q :g{J :„@NmK :>N :Y :=:e3Kßm e:=: L gL :Y:2i :@<@:2as mž– :2:gN a l B:˘gz b :™ <:>N :3:efM 8 WL :Áf:=:c<@:c:D@ n 5[ M aH Q Q 7 87 yš OOO 7 I R Q ŸR K Q Q :>=NNNN}bNOi B:2:2N a i :D=:@T mJ5» :>s :˘@@ a ´ R B:> P :•Ffm58 :> s :„gzb :A= }•oL Ž8– B:™5 :3:½=:c:D=BF:M M g€ w 8 e:2m ž :DB:= 7Q  j ƒ 7 Os S•O K • X OsQ O a I :>N : g{L =Û :_B:N :D== 5LÛ :> N :3B:˘gzS b :e= 5 [X =:@fNa NmX :˘gz b :‡f « Q ƒ Q 7 7 Q  I Ÿ5R •8 OU S•O K :˘gzb :™ :B<@4•TN› :…@5 5 M :˚>T ::;eB•N aNm :gL @• 5R :g l :…Bf:g5 n K :‡e3ßm e:AB:™5 :=:D= Kw¦ e:;<@ 4 ›TN :˘;3:2:² Ka m5Os :>s :ÑN wu Ò L := K M Q I I 7 O O R ¯ Q NOa ƒ X O R :2:2NNa i :D=:@Tb m˜È :2 m ÀuH :3 M8floor :AB:>NNs :„gzb :> P :@:c<@3—M a uMm M :N ´ B ƒ ƒ ƒ yš Q Q »œ7 » œ Ü ¯ Q 7 R ƒ X ::gL @´5 » :g€ ÔKJL N :„@ G :DFe:<=JM :senatorship :>NN :2i :gzb :^B=S BfH :=:D=:@<:2 LT b TU P È :Ïun :> :3S B 7 7 j Q 87 »œ Q ~ o ƒ Q 8}Tb ŸR O OR Q O :3Ì f iCivil society :„>e:=:†‡=N L w Ž :g{J :>Nm :@:G DF@:>:e35H5 ßm e:™5 :>NNNs :˘@:DF3:> G K P :^@ m S :2:>N a s 7 Q j Q Q K › 7 [ R I OU I :D@F=:gzTUTb b <:@5 H :Óq– :c :™T @5 m 8 :Z5 :Y ! =Ok :ÁB= x :N T :3Ì fi :<=} L Be:˘gzb :3 Ì f i :@fNa N m X :eB<ˆB:˘gz b 7 j ƒ Q ƒ I }TbOa O s I • o R • N8 OU Q :DFe3ßm e:^F:gS :>NN ˆB:> :`w¦N <@:Š=:=Ma o 5[:N T :;CN ’í fa B Q ƒ ÆK Oa Q š „gzb :™ q:cœ :…ˆB::…B„gM 5 S :>N ²PÈ :ÍF:™a @Nml :g K j Q 7 7 7 7 :>NOs :Ze:2NL ‘Ëw58 :`5 5[ :„ >NOUT g: L=:Ç@TbR k :g K :AB:ÁB= xb :`5 5[ :gz b :c=:…@¯ T 5 mX @:\F:AB:½= — ] 5 Ž ƒ ƒ N Q 7 Q 7 Q › 7 7 7 :=:gzLbb :c=:c@¯¯KTTX @:c :½=:>5 ŽL•bOs :C’a =:S ¯ œ O 4 T :=: L gJR :>OPR :ÁB=x :Ç@R :g K :½=5 Ž 5 Nm—NN 7 5 —a N N k j Q Q 7 Q 7 OMa QOW±R ¯ 7 O s Q QQj j › :;<@4TNN› :2:D=:@3:Zi Tb aKN :> :½B3:=:½=:c@5 [ K 5 Ž ma}K @:>:„gzM b :@e:Ç@N ak—Wk R :@:DB:2@a 5L :2 a @ :g L :Y T Q j 5R 7 Q :cK :DB:Q ˘gzb :cBF:go L =Tb :‡e@k :f 5L :^@:Fe:˘?@ s k 24, 25 :qy¡ :˘g|» :…<=¸5L = [ :½q:c – K :?= J M R ::˘ Captains ƒ j Q ƒ 7 Q j › •S Q OKRQQ Ou« ¥K 7 OOO 7 »œ ¯¯I I :YTT :„D=b :™ :2:>aNNNNNk ‚:c:D==o J M :DB:>:r s :™ :gK :D@mam}K @:2:>M i aUk @5 8 :g{ J :„>T :c3:c@M8 ´ R B:> ‚ I ƒ I Q Q Q j :3:BqKJÈ :>NO8Os :>‚:˘>Q N UT :gzb <:…@:>— N O a e3:c S K :D=B=L[ 5 :g K :ZNO• =:OUT :gzb <:@ m Ž e:> O k ‚ Q 7 Q j Q Q I OU7 O s I •o › :„@B3:DFNT :g @ m 58 :> N :`w¦N <@:AB:Y:„gzM aT b :@<:@:@T UHm5 N K :fNm˜š :=:DK:= L B= 5 [ :g K FC :g K Q ƒ yš Q Os O a yš »œ Os Q 7 7 Q :„ D= Tb:Ç 5± @a :B NN:˘> @´5 » :gJ { :> N :;<@:g5amaK :D@}K @:

44 7 7 j O O7 O È j L j ƒ [ Q :˘>NNNTU :> s :‡f‘5H :`˜5 R :=:…ˆB:˘>L M ´ <:ÑCN L  ! `@5[ « :EB:f@T U W X :„23N a ~k :>Q NOs C’mN M :…@5 m5[ Q I I j Q OUyš 8 O U •O5a Os OU •O5a Os Q } N L there is :˘>NNTT :gzb <:Ç5± :@NmK :=:…ˆB:g|K M w B:˘> : gJ € :> N treasury :˘>N T : gJ € :>N :> <=B:…ˆBML M nobody in opposition, there is nobody in the treasury benches, except that of the caretaker Ministers who are sitting there. Donãt 7 È j I understand my obligations and ˘>NO´ <:ÑN L CÂL :…ˆB:M give me dictations. Q ¯ Q 6 time 2i :gzb request :g l honourable Senators :‡CN ’¿ :„`5 [ @« :c@<:@5 a « <:™:5 my duties. limit is ten minutes, one has to conclude within 10 minutes. Senator Mian Raza Rabbani: Sir, I have not even started consuming your given time. Mr. Chairman: I want to convey that what the rules says. Senator Mian Raza Rabbani: Then you should have applied the rules on everybody. Q I Q 6 Q ƒ [ Q It was for every ! `@5[«« @ <:„:`@ 5 [ « :_m[ :…@5 N m l BqB:™: t 5 :>NOs C’mN M :…@5 m5[ ƒ I Q Q we have to conclude also, the „>NOUT :gwS :Ç•NO5a :3:=:ÐB<@:…ˆBK Tb a M member, ƒ Q 8 7 S Q „>N 3K :…@5a :…ˆB:˘gMMw :=Tb :ÐB<@ a :…ˆB Ministers are sitting here, Senator Mian Raza Rabbani: Why that? You should have applied the rules on everybody. Mr. Chairman: Raza sahib , I conveyed for everybody. j 7 floor is with you.`5[ @« :EB:f@T U WX :™:„>56 NO• :3K :…@:…ˆB a M Q 5 II QQOƒ M[ Q•[ ¦ 6 ¥ 5 L Q Q j I O l :‡358 :‡3 5 8 :½ˆB:D@5 PNR ! >N s C’mN :…@5 m5[ :„YN 3o B:> 3 o B:EB:Y : :D@H :EB:f@TU W X :C ’mN Nm 7 7 Q OU › 8 ¯ „>NNT :™T <:=:>3qTb N8 ”L :c@f5a 5H Mr. Chairman: Mushahid Ullah sahib , only ten minutes for you. I have to apply that rule. Now I will apply that rule, only ten minutes.

45 7 7 I Q 7 R 8 K Ÿ5R 8 ] S 7 Q Q j Oml :@´M 6 B:`˜5 :=:g€L w e:3 apply :™ :3:D=M S =:™@:2:3B:2 o 5aNNa i :gzb :2:…@: a 5 a :D@H :EB:f@TU W X :C ’mN N 7 „@ ´R Q Q OPR 7 š ¯ Q Q O ƒ [ Q „gzb <:?=:>5L N :3:…@:™M8 5a B:`5 [ @ «a« :c@<:@ 5 <::>N s C’mN M :…@5 m5[ I will give you only ten minutes, rules say this. I will follow the rules now. Q ¶ Q 8 I ñ Q j V I O l „>N e:;e:2mO´ :@í eˆB:…@5 m 5 [ :^@k :™n :qÄ– :fNml :C ’mN Nm Mr. Chairman: Shah sahib , do you want that I should adjourn this House now? If the honourable members want this. I am giving you the opportunity and you are degrading the Chair. Ten minutes for you. QQ7 Q Q I ¦Ü" Æ Ø R K O‘MH Q Q j I O l :D=L @k :gL :D@N m 8 =5 L :D= L :g{ w :2i :gzb :™ q:™œ N :c :…ˆB:3B:˘>M S N ::D@H :EB:f@TU W X :C ’mN Nm j Q Q 7 j 7 Q Q Os Q Os ƒ M[ Q " Oa 8 Q I •8" ŸR " :@mbT @M H :@ a 3K :A N ! >N C’mN :…@5 m5[ :„ >N :gzb <:>f@Na ´È :D@N m8 =:?@ 5L k :¼ 5 M „@:g|G uH :™5 :2:=N a L B<= • j Q Q j Q I Q }NL › H 7 7 R military :˘@fNa NmX :˘> <=B:˘=:™<:‹:`=MLT bTNM X ~ H :_B;CN a ’Þ :\C:²:?@K ³ 5 a k :¼ M @:`Ma 5 5[ :2i :D= Tb ƒ I ¯ •MVJ6 È › I 6 Q :=5[ :@:_—‘s ::e= 5 [ F@:g5 a K :AB:˘=:c=:‡e:™TTT bb :™´ :=:AB:˘:=:™<:C Kb TN ’´ M :2:ga l B:2N m ofn :N a N a N m @:gMH LL =:g€Tb F<:Fe:f 5L :g KL :g 3 Kcomplete :?@ka :¼M @M :„gzb :g wX @ k :g K :…ˆB:^F˘B=M Tb :?@ H j Q Q j Q 8 › 8I O4T› Q } ~mo K 7 Q › :<=}Os :g|wb B:YTT :2i :gz :2:BCN a ³ Fe:„>e:…FF:^<@Fe:>NN5a :…ˆB:˘gzM bb :@<:=T U b :>N B:NTN :3:…@ K5 O H B:B<@ › :˘g ~ k :3:> K8 :‹ :3 7 QQ7 7 Q 7 7OU 7j › › ›¯ ¥ K K 7 :`5 [ @« :358 @5 a :E B:`q:„>[t N T :gL 3:`f:2K XsWNO4T :Y:=:=:™<:=:ce@<:Ç@ TL TbT Tb Na R k :g K :™ :3B˘gz S b :c:`f X s QQ¶7 7 7 j ÔL »œ Q 6 7 j :2:@e:2iPaÈ :gL :`@5[ «k :^@ :™Vn :q Ä– :2:gz ii bJL :` 5 5 ± :g{ :2:@ P È :g :D=˜R B:˘>NOUT :g L 3:3qKN 8 ” L :™ ŸM B:™ ›T :` ˜ 5 R :2 W NO 4 T› N Q 7 K › Os bQ OPR o Q ~ mo ÔL 7 OU QQ :c :™T :…ˆB:>M N 1995 :2:g€zi w @:@=:>MH aTbN :g€ w :AB:>N :=:` Tb5 5± :gz b :@ m ~k :=:=:…ˆB: TbK M ˚>N T :D=K :D@5mo @ ¹ 7 Q Q j I 7 jj R Q 7 L 7±š I 7 K ¯ :2ml <:gK :…ˆB:^F:fM Na @k :NNaT :g|» :;CN ’¿ :D@5 m¹´Po @:2:2 a i :@R :@È :g L :D=˜R B:˘>N T :™5 :NNT :™<:=:>T Tb @:5a ™ :`˜5R :˘@:DF3:…@:CGK 5 a° :>N :„g€zw @:@=:`M Ha Tb 5 5 ± I 7 Q Q ƒ Q8 7 Q7 š ¯ Q N O Ma › ¯ :D@5m¹o @ :2:½ˆB:„gN a 5 S :>3:…@:gN K 5 am¹ l :D@ 5 o @ :`Nw¦ :c<@3M a uMm :Y:2TÀTi :@PÈM :3:<=:28 – Õ wX :gL :D=Fe:˘c= L b APC 7 j Q ƒ R ›}Tb OU 8O U • J5R O U Q :…ˆB:gM ubP |:„gz :™T <:=:‡e3Tb ßm e:2i :>NNNNTTT :gz b <:2 P È :3: KK Ö :gz b <:3:™ :@´M 6 B:˘> :gz b <:3:D@ K 5 mo @ ¹

46 Q 7 7 7 7 j Ÿ5•K OU7 O U 7 —• O }Tb :™ :gL :…ˆB:„>M NNNT :g L 3:…@:‡CK5a³ Fe:½ˆB: 5 T :g L 3:…@:_B:‹ K 5 a N a :˘> 3:= K Ldefine :=:e3K ßm e Q Q Os Q 8 :„ :„ @ÒL @ ´5 6 :>:D@N 5 m N8 3:g|S w B ƒ Q j Q OabQ Q O sQ 8K 7 Ÿ M6 ›7 O s › j ::>NNN @:`:„g€zsHm´m5 5[w @:@M ~a @5 6 :> :D@5N 8 3:g|S w B:2i :c:…@:™ 5 a B:™:`TT ˜ 5R :> :ëFC::g³ L :fNm l :™ @ k 7 Q Q 7 Q JR 7 QO a Q Q I K 6O ´R › :gw {:`:˘@5 5[ ´UHmR :@<:@:@T 5 N K :>N × <:g lKL :D=:g[SoKK :D==:^@ m S :g{ :=:D=C:c:™B3:`:˘³ MK 5 5[ :>N :™<:@T P 5R := } L ˆB j 7 7 O O R › K R :3M8 :D=K <@Ma : >NNs :DFCÊš :gK :_‘s :AB:`5 5[ :˘> ´ :™<:@:cT 5H : target killings :`:˘g5 5[ J :gz b <:@:g€5H w o 7 7 Q •8 RN•58 Q I Q R K w“ :@5H :@M • NN5 :=K :;= ua <:˘:= K :Steel Mills :`:˘g5 5[ Jb» :gz <:@:g|5H :3:@K m58 :…²:gM a K :DB:T Tb 3:>K N :NICL :`55[ :˘@´UHa•R :@<:@:@@TTT5 N M :3:gM8 L @e:g U K :™@T 5 m8 :=:;B:cˆB:c:`K M 5 5 [ :˘@ ´U R :@< Q Q 7 Q j O 7 š ±š :AB:‡e:ef:>s N s :gwS @´5 R :=K :AB:g L :`=X ~ H:AB:M N „gzb :…@:™5 a T :c :‹ :=:2 L N a ! =Nw8 @´5 R :;CN ’¿ :˚@ˆB:>NN aN :?@ m [ :=:…ˆB:\F K M I Q ¯Q NOa ¯ Q 8K R RI È O I R š :gK :c<@:3Ma uMm M :B:;B˘:gM NN L ::‹Nm F:g K :YB:=NNNNwbK :YB:3:=:;q K TTJ :> s :…<=: KY CM ’k :™ B„D= b Q j Q Q Q 7 R 7 b ¯ Q 8 R R O´ºNa QI m K :˘@PÈ :<=[ :2mJ5 :˘@ P È :e3:`ST} e:=:c:>B:;B:g KM N L :YB:=N N w K:YB:>N N e:3:?@K ÒÒL :e<@N L <:BBM N :;B:„:@ P È :target killer ƒ Q Q ¯ O O I R I QQ :_N a B:…ˆB:`M 5 5[ ! c@´5 R :„>NUT :e= 5[XK =:> N s :…<=:YCN M ’k :e<@ ÒNL <:gK :D= uNmK F:g K :DB:„@ P È :=:D=Fe:DB:g KL L Q 7 j 7 7 j Q •8 R 7bK ¥ K R O U ˜È 7 b :™M B:gubulP |„gz :ÑN w Ò L :@NmK :=:…ˆB:gKM :‡e3:` ST} e:c : L N T :g w :e3:` S }T :e=[ := K :;C³ Fe ƒ Q I 7 j 7 j Q Os O •R 7 b :\] F:AB:…ˆB:gM L =Tb :<@Òl :@ — :target killing :Š=:oT U LNN :_‘s :AB:„> :3KST :_N m J :=:D@e3 L Na :`} e 7 7 7 Q I I OU ˜È R I QK7 Q K •O4 È : : 2:>i N T :gwJL :„g :g 3:@KNmK :\@:NT :g L 3:…@ K 55 ••MM :…@ 5 5 :…ˆB:½ˆB:=:„:c@ 5 5[ Ë o :> N :g L :Y:ŠˆBT :2N a Q 7 7 7 Q 7 Q › Òo 7 j 7 œ O U O a Q •Oi R :AB:Y:„‡e:‹T @:˘‡e:…e@5aPš :gL :2¿ C’• :2 i :>NNT :g L 3:>K @:„;<3:Ç@ 5 ak S R :g K :DFfNmX B:™ :?@ ka :¼@M M 7 O7 j 7 œ I R O 7 j :˘:>NNUTT :gzb <:²:<@MHP• l B:g K :2C¿ ’• :– N a U :g L 3:Á²K k :=:…e@ K P š ::N s1971 :2 Ž e:_B:„^BF:„^BF„>N a N UT :gzb <:2 P 5R :g œ q<:g œ K :`5w± :½ˆB:N :gz b <:@ m 5[ :` 5 w ± :™ B:g l :;CFe ³ :_N a B:D= wNOa 7 7 Q 7 Q Q :2i :@´R :@ P È :guLwPR |:`˜5RT :g :>NNNOs :„> O U :g~a =JÌ56 :?= e:> O s :D= Jo º a ˆB:Š=:…ˆB:D=M N w K :gz b

47 j Q Q 7 I C³ F:CN ’É ::<@Os B:gl :2×H5 :Z 5[ :=:@Tb S :` X NNm¶ m j ƒ 7 Q V¹ j K CÂ5L :C:=:‹@:3:…F@T UTb a sM8 5L :N :A= x ˆB:c :q ÄK Q Q OmbT K 8 >N N @:gMHOk 3:358 ~ m :D@FT U ! =uNm5 @5a B:;B Q Q bT 7 >NONm @:gMMHOk 3:q58JM•8 :˘g€z w b @:c3:•3 H ¯ S 5 8 7 Q QQQX7 ŸR 7 Q K O 7 :…ˆB:„@3MMMa•s´——K :?@5R :D@B:F:> B:@R :Á@ :@ :…ˆB:˘™ :N s :ÇR@T U :gK :…ˆB:` 5 5[ 7 “ 7 Q j 7 :gK 3K :`M M[ :…ˆB:Q X B:= KL :D=CN Êš :g K :_‘s :AB:2i :@ ´——R:Á@ :@ 7 7 7 Q Q I O8s O U¯ Q O ‘Pm58 R O R7 • O 5 a :>NNNNN :„:>3:2K ‘5a @ÕX :…B:„>5 TN :c@ ´—mÈ e:Á@:@M8 B:=:>L @B:q5 aaJ M :=:@ˆB:> LNN :?@ m [ :=:…ˆB:\ K M ]F:AB:„gzb <:g J € Q Q 7Q 7 ŸR Os O U I 7 7 Q K ¯ Q 8 :2i :D=:@Tb mHamb8T @:@@M 5 :™5 :2:>N aNNN :T :‡e:D@N ma 8 @q:‡3:g5 ] 58L :AB:2 i :D=:@3:…@:Tb aam K 5 č@N O ÕNL :c :c:>B:;BM Q Q 7 7 j Q j ¶ 7 K j R Q ñ L :…ˆB:2:@M iPÈ :gL :2N m X @ vw8 B:c:N UT :;qJ :Ç@Rk :gK :;C ³ Fe:_B:Y:2NTa T i :g€ wwo :AB:g S :^F:>Nm :>N a ˆB:2:D@F:…ˆB:gz a UM b :^q· [ :=K :D@5 H :c 7 7 Q R 7 › Q Q o : : 2i :gJL :g 3:@KPÈ :\F:AB:Y]T „:gz b :@ m N8 e:…B=55[ :…B:g 5 L :…ˆB„>3:2:^BqMM N8 K a y ñ :=:ÁB= K x :…ˆB:> Q ~Nm Q Q R › Fe:gL ˆB:…@5 W[T :NOUT :`M M[ :™Ÿ5 B:Y QQ › gzb :@mmNN8K e:@NN :gz b :@ mm OK• :@ :g zb :Á=u X := K :Y T j 7 QQ Òl K I 7 Q R :@=aaÌ e:@F<:3:ÇK~Na e:‹ :c :C ’k @:=:gz saH L~b :@@::?=5 k :g K 3:2:Á@:` K a —5 5[ :2M • 5 „gz b :@ˆB:N aW:…@5 [ :Á=N L ::½ˆB5 j Q Q 7 7 Q Q j QQ ~ OPR O ´ ºa Q 7 7 :@e3:ëFC:@=NaaaK ³ Ì e:@F<:gLw :D= ˜LR B:=:gk :>NN :²:>s ˆB:g lK :ÁB= x :g :D@ mam}K @:2:…B:M N a 5 „gz b :@ 8N e3K :ëFC ³ 7 Q 7 7 7 — 7I 7 R R ƒ R O4T› Q O U :@NmK :@ — :C5 ’• a :NN :…@5 m 5[ :2 i :> :gL F<„gz b I 7 7 Q 6OQ ¯ O 6 R Q Q 7 Ü :glK :ÁB=x :g :™B3:2:½ˆB„>MMKNNa5NNU T :gz b <:Í@:c<=a s ~Nml :> s :™B3:2:½ˆB:„g K a 5 Jwl :gßa @:^@ smM8 :g :DB:Š= o :˚@ ´nR :Y @ Q 7R ¡ 7 7 Q Q :„gw~k 3:>K NNNOP :^Bqyñ :=:D==:…ˆB„‹KSoM 4U :…@@¬ÒX :> OTT g w ˜ È :=:AB:„> K O U :gz b <:Í@:^@a sm M8 I ƒ Q 7 ¯ OQ 7 O 6 O 7 Q O Q O ƒ M[ Q :c<@:‡<@Ma 4TNN› :>:D@s m } M[ =u5a :„> UT :gL =:gT b u4 :g w i :2 i:D=:@Tb mbT @M H :@ m ˜ È :2:>N a N s ! >N s C’mN :…@5 m5[ ƒ Q j j Q Q ¯ 7±š I KQ 7 š OU 6 8 ƒ :c =Tb :target :`NNw¸ :‡3:C:c58 T U :_‘s :AB:` w ¦ :ÑCN L ³ :NNT :g|~ H4 :=:gT b u :Fe:3:>f@:gM8 a Ú K Q ƒ I Q Q ¯7 Q O~O Qo O K R :gL :…ˆB:=:CM KMN ’É :‡<@k :AB:c@ ´5 R :2i :D=:@T b mHmbT @:@M ˜ È :2:>N a NsU :>Nm :> NT :e==:> 5 [XLO N a <=<:c:DM =N W O 5•N B:N P :gL :…ˆB:>M N :c3:2:™:…NNN e:> = •b :™M B:…ˆB::˚@MMNNNmS :=: :g L :…ˆB:„@ m K 7 ƒ 7 7 7 K 7 Oa OO U4˜ÈNT› O mX I Q O ´ ºa :c:…ˆB:=:@M L´—4R :B=:@@T b Ù e:_B:˘:>N a NNNNN @:g|5 HuH :C@:>T U 5 a T :g w :> :„gz bL <:g ²:>M H =~ H :e=: o ‡3N8 B:„> e

48 Q ƒ 7 Q ƒ ›I ÈOI 7 •Ÿ›ùK R R OR • R •8 :gK :½q:AB:„™<:‡q–TT J :…B35 [ ::>NNUT F:‡<@::_:?@Ga k :™ q J M : P :™:™ :guP | :g l :™5 e:_N a 3 58 j Q Q ƒ Q Q ~ o Q 7 7 OR j ¯ O 8 Q – :>Nm :gzb :@3:2aÕ—K‘5a @X :@:‡e3:` ST}bs e:AB:3:‹:g K Lb :D==:Á@S o 4 R :2 ima :gz :>NNN Ps :25 l :c=:> K :AB:„> e:2 :g w ž jQ j j 8I 8}QQMML7 O}PR L 7 b :AB:˘> NNN3:<@:…=:˘:>3:>KKKKSTso 3:Óq:_B:…ˆB:„@– N a M mHm~k @:@5 N K :> :gl :> 3:2‘5a @ Õ—X :@:‡e3:`} e ƒ j š Q }L O»y 8 I K :gL @:=:5HTb M 3:gK l5KK :D@ PNRM :2i :>N´ :2:…ˆB:fN a M 5L :g :AB:<@:g N s Be:3:D= 8 5wNOH5 :c :ÁB= x :g K :_ ‘s 7 7 Q o7 OU ˜ ÈN O ´ºa Q •~k O P R S : g€w :g K :`=X ~HT :AB:>NNNT :g w :@NmK ::ÁB= x :> e::˘‚BF:…@5 m 5 [ :„™ =:> b ˘c Q Q j j Q OR ŸR QQ l l ²ÒL :>N P :™5 :=u P MR :_B:>N a F<:@:>— F<:½< Q Q 7 R R Q R » yš Q › ²ÒTL :>NOP :™Ÿ5 :=wß 5H :^F:gJ :g{ J :f@:=:Z:Ya MH K 5[ Q Q 7 I › K È O 8 Q :3:ÇK ~Na e:=:CK ’k @:Y:gsT l :2F:c5H :AB::„gz b :@ m K :Ç M ± :=5 [ : >N s:…@5 ••M gL :D==:DB:gzS o b :@ m K :=:2 L N a N QQ5 N I ƒ X OOORQQ OO› OO R I „gzb :@k :@ í fNNNml :B3:258 ‘m} „>NNNNNNNUPsTTT :> :> :DBf m X :…ˆB„>M Us :> :DBf m X :Y:˘>T UP :> :;N s C’mN M :…@5 m5[ Q I I Q › OPR 7 Q 7 Q Q j Oml :™TN <:2PÈ :@NmK :>N :@ maM 8 „?@:ÁB<ˆB:D@B:‡C s ’¿ : @:Ç5H•NO5a :„„gzb :2:…@:N a 5 a :D@H :EB f@TU WX :C ’mN N „gzb Mr. Chairman: Khan Sahib, kindly address to the Chair. QQI Q 7 Q OORK ¯ K OO R wX Q Q Q j I O l :>NNNNPU B:„>TT :c :c<@:cMa :…ˆB:^F˘:>MM UP :gzb <:3K :> :r :=:=L K :DB:…ˆB::D@H :EB f@TU WX :C ’mN Nm Q 7 Q 7 Q Ol•Q7 K j O P R •Ok 8 wX „>NNN :> :…@:c5a :…ˆB:f@M Na k :> :™ :=:‡CL N ’¿ :˘:>3K :r Q ƒ Q „>NO• 3K :conclude :…ˆBM ! `5 [@« :D@Q H ::>Q NOs C’mN M[ :…@5 m5[ I Q uH R K Q 77 Q O s 7 Q Q j Oml :g} {:2i5 :gz b :@5• :c :DB:…@:2:„D=:@ 5 aNN aTb mHmbT @:@M ˜ È :2:> a N :…@:‡C 5 a ³ Fe::D@H :EB f@TU WX :C ’mN N 7 7Q 7 Q Q •˜È R R Q~Omo 7 7 s7 K ¯ Q 8 O P R :2i :gzb :™ :=:YB:=LwNNN K :YB:>N :D=:@T bm8 @:…@:> s5 a NNN :=:_:f:c L a H :c:>B:;B„gzM b <:;e:g L 3K :> Q 7 »MR Q Q 7 % :?@k :^CN ’a :gu ´ | :3<=8 S :˘:gz b :@— :…ˆB:†™MMVn B3M N 3K :conclude :gK 3:c@CK 5a Êœ!`5 [ @« :D@H :EB fTU @WX : :>N s C’mN M :…@5 m5[ QQQ R Please order in the !`@5[« :‹3„™:„>aK56 NNO P :=:`@K 5 [ « :‹3:˘>3: a K 8 K address : = K Q „`5 [ @« :D@Q H :™56 :House.

49 Q ƒ ƒ 7 Q I Q ±Ü 8 ¯ O a 7 R Ÿ5R OaK ± Ü Q Q j Oml :• B:¸@NmÛ :3:D@M P´N R :c@ 5 R :„>N =:‡<@Tb k :`˜5 :™ :>N @:c:•B:¸@5aN m Û :D@H :EB f@TU WX :C ’mN N I 7 Q K ¯Q NOMa ±Ü Q › ŸR K 7 a 6 :c::c<@:3MauMm :`:gz55[b :•B:¸@NN mÛ :™F:2„™T NNa :c:…@:2:g5 a a L :`@ 5 [ «H4mP :‹f:™@:;<@ N n 5 ›T :„@ S ˆB:g l :D@ È Q ŸR 7 Q Q 7 :™5 :`@5 [ «m :…@5 NNl BqB:;<@t 4´amT› :˘:@R :@@5 8 : tribunal :e@ˆB:NNa BC³ :c :fNm“ :qy¡ :3:@Km58 : P:=:ÏL un :>NN s :c@´5 R :;CN ’¿ :„gJ :> s :AB 7 Q Q Q I 7 m“ O •I K O s 7 š ¯ Q NOMa 8 :f 5L :gK :AB„:@´mn—R :@NNNK :Á@:‹ :@:…ˆB:˘:> MN :½=:D@ML m 8 =:c 5 L :…ˆB:> M N :ë@:\@5 am ] o :™ B:gL :c<@:3M a uMm :„:>e N Q 7 7 Os OPR O s 7 QQ o 7m 5[ 7 ± Ü Q ØR :> N :˘:@<:3:>TUK NN :ÑqN L ÔL :> :„@ ´R :@N m K :lunch :Ç@R k :gK :`5 [ @ «H :D@:cF: H NN :‹:>M : proceedings :2:qN a JM :=:gL S :>3N K :½q – :AB:…ˆB:3M S B I Q „c:gS us :opportunity :=K :…ˆBM ! `@5[ « :=f@„>NL a M H NO• 3:Kconclude :gK 3 K ƒ ∗ Q O yš Q Q Q j I O l „>N a @´5 » =K : [*****] :DB:…ˆB:M :D@H :EB f@TU WX :C ’mN Nm 7 8 O Q ¶ ƒ [ Q :…ˆB:„>M N 3K :conclude :…ˆB„>M N TU :gL @:g€5H w K :Óf:ì@H á o B *[*****] 2N a ::>Q NOs C’mN M :…@5 m5[ :please conclude :…ˆB„:>M NOUT :gzb <:3K : address :D=NwK := K :DB:…ˆB:˘:>Q M N8 3K : address :=K : Chair Q Q ƒ yš j „@G :DFe3K :fm58 :mic :>NNOs :2a O a @´5 » :…ˆBM ! `5 [ @« :^@ k „>NO• 3 K Q 8 Q Q Q Q j I O l :>N 3K : fm58 : BCN ’¿ : mic : Q NOs C’mN M :…@5 m5[ I ƒ 7 Q Q 7 O •O5a Q Q •[ › :˘> N UT :gJ € :D@P«GHNR :`@5[ :2‘HM Be:33:YN K :™„gz5 b :™ :…@:c5a :DB:g L :Y T

∗ [Expunged as ordered by the Chairman ]

50 ƒ I Q I Q ¯Q K 7 ŸM6 › 7 R Q Q j Oml :c@´5 R :;CNT’¿ :`@5[ «H :=f@„gzNL a M b :c:…@:™5 a B:™:` ˜ 5 :g L :…ˆB:M :D@H :EB f@TU WX :C ’mN N QQ 7 Q Q OOPPR7 7 È R R ›QQ V ¡ Q OO UU :>NNNN :@@:@ˆB:ÇaHa5 M± :> B:˘gJ :™:`@T 5 [ «a :DB=B:3@:3:<=:™x585 M 8 –4 :2•a ‚@:> HTT :gz b <:D=@: L Ú 3N 8 7 Q I 7 7 o „> „> NN83:ÁBCK ’É B:@:D=@:@—Q L Ú k :B<= JRQ :=:> L OUT :gzb <:> ~Nm gz b 7 Q ( ( `uH Bf s) Q 7 j ƒ Q Be :„D=TTb :2:…ˆB::˚>a M NOUT :gL = b :detrack :D=NwK :…ˆBM ! `@5[ « :EBf@T U W X :>Q NOs C’mN M[ :…@5 m5[ Q O• 7 •8 „>N 3K :conclude :=K :…@5a :™M B:…ˆB:M vigilant. 7 Q j 7 Q o j ƒ Q Q Oa Q Q j I O l :e@:˘†c@Na L :EB:¸@ WLT B:2i :@ G =b :conclude :@WNL B:N ::D@H :EB:f@TU W X :C ’mN Nm 7 Os O s O s Q 8 :>NNN :˚@NmK :B=:>Tb :_‘s :AB:„@:DF3:> G K :gl :½ q:AB:=:gz– L b :@3:a K conclude : …B:5 „gS : >N 3 K Q ¶ Q Q QQQ ›7 ¥ “ K Q L R R :AB:Y:2T i :@´P´R :@È :3:@K È :Y :c:D=:g[KLu :CN ’v g{ :g P |:?@ ka :¼@:gM M L :D= ˜R B:„D=:@:gT b Ë o L 3K : conclude I Q Q I › »R ƒ :D@B:F:>B:˘gQQsQX8SSS :>e:D@NNNN Ò X :˘g :>e:BC 8M ’i :˘g :>e:cF<:Y 8 ¯ T :˘g S :> O ´M =:=:DF=MLK }LˆB:g KK :ÁB= x :g :_ ‘s Q Q Q ƒ j 7 S ¯Q S 7 O X ] Q 7 8 : : 2i :2:@N a NmK :gL :D=˜R B:„c =T b :eN II•8QXQQ o • 8 O ˘‚Be:¼MNN 5 :> <:˘cBe:¼ M 5 :>N s < II•8Q • 8 ‚Be:¼MN 5 :Df 5a :˘‚Be:¼ M N 5 := ˜Ü j j u Be=• :@:g—l :C:cT UKQ :>} G :;CN ’¿ :@ m K j N II•8Q ¦M6 • 8 š ‚Be:¼MNN 5 :> :˘‚Be:¼ M 5 :3 5± Q 7 QQ R ;fn F:gK :D=L @ÒX :D= w NOs <:g J :g€ w K ƒ I •8 K ‚Be:¼M 5 :>Q Ä :˘fq:gÚ œ L @H :‡C N ’¿ N 5I Ü OI O¯ O @TU <:@ ´ 5 » B:> NNNs:DFCM ’i :> s :c F<:> s Q ∗ I •8 Q – ‚Be:¼MN 5 :> F:BCN ’¿ :g L [*****] :hB Q I Q ƒ I II Q j 5R ƒ Q :3:`M8 NOk :™•M8 B:…ˆBM ! `@5[« :>CQ NOs ’mNMM[ :™•8 e:„`@ 5 [ « :=f@:ZNL a M H ± :‚=: X :>Q NOs C’mN M[ :…@5 m5[ j 7 „g€wJÈ <:ÑN L C ÂL

∗ [Expunged as ordered by the Chairman]

51 7 ∗ Q Q Q Q ¶ Os Q V I O l :gl B:˘gz b :@NmK :?@ 4 ÔOk B [*****] ÏÀo :>N :3[ ˆB:gL :D=˜R B ! …@5 m5[ :½=M u5a :™n :3@58« :C ’mN Nm ƒ „gL @:@5HN m K :expunge j Q I Q ±5R 6 7 Q ƒ [ Q „`5[ @«H :=f@:ZNL a M :‚=:™:„gz X 5 b :@@ aH5 :@NmK :expunge :gl B::>NOs C’mN M :…@5 m5[ Q j j Q Q I O l Q 7 Q Q ƒ [ I Q ±5R I l :C ’mN Nm ):„D=Tb :M NOs ! `@5 [ « :>CNOs ’mN M : :=f@NLa MH :Z :‚= X :C ’mN ONm 7 ƒ ƒ 7 7 KQ O ¯ I j K j :3qN8”L :gzb :…e@:cn :DB:˘>N UT :c@ ´ 5 R :;3:;C5 8 N ’¿ :2N a ( gL =:gTb L 3:^<@K k B:Óq:c:`@– 5[ « :EB:f@T U W X I Q Q 7 Q 7 O•O5a OR O ŸR Ÿ R 7 K Q O OR O :>NNN´N :> P :2:„>N a UT :gzb <:Š@ ´5 R:™5 :™ 5 B:„gzb :…e@:c:DB:2:„>nN a NNNUTT :> P :g wLKOk :˘> U :g @:Š@5 H ´ 5 R :g 3 K QI7 Q I Q OU˜È › Øš OO8 m´Nl •O5a 7 ] bQ • O a Q „>NNNNT :gßw• :g :@NmK :Y:™T :=:>L :˘> :˘>3:…B3:™²B:„g€zK5 [ H wS @:@M H m J N5 :=:DB:„g K QQQQQ ƒ »œ Ÿ5R 6 Q Q OOOPsPRÈ • ˜È R 7 ¯ O s :g{Ju :™ B:„@:D=G˜È :g4 {:fmM[ :ÓC:˘@ Ö m˜È :>NNNN :ÇM ± :g L :> :˘™ :> :…@:c=: Q Q Q 7 QQ R 7 Q R 7 :cK :gwOk :>NOs :DB:NOs := 5[ :„gzb :> N O P :… N O s :˘g :gz <:?=:` 5 L l Fe:;C ³ Fe Q Q Q 7 7 6 OR 7 K Q 7 I O R 7 :‡<=:…f:gMLsL :\<=N8 ˜ y5 :_B:>NNa NNs :¼<@:ca :D@ m}K @:˘fM a 5L :g KÛbb :g q¡ :;3:258i :gz :2:^F:˘N a gz :> P :…B3 5 [ Q Q Q Q 7 R•M7 K Q ˜R 8 7 6 K :¼<@:c:_:AB:fN a‘s 5L :gKbw :D=e:fL m M[ :˘gz :@ ÒM[ :¼M :3:½Fq:g|M8 5 ¡ B:?@5 m—‰Ok B:@:\<=N8 ˜ y5 :‡C³ Fe:˘gz b :c Q Q 7 ƒ I 8› O s S7 š L QX S :@fNaNNmX :‚BF:gL 3:fK m ‰ w :3:Y:>:gM 8 T N u s @ X :AB :˘c:gL ˆB:`=X ~H :™@Nml :_B:gNa l” :g€ q:>B3:„c:g– M8 o f 5a j 7 7 › Q Q }5[ OU˜È 7 º a O s Ÿ R :2i :gzb :™<:@T mX :> :Á=:„gz“ bw :@N m4 S =:?@TT bÈ :2 i :>NNT :g :^F:˘D=:@ b m J N e:ÁB3F3:>SM 8 :„gz b :@<3T U K :ÑqN L ÔL :™ 5 7ƒQ 7 ƒ Q QQ¯OR › L ¯ › 7 7 6 :2¿ @<@:@:D==:DB:=:2:„cˆB:>a — — SoLNN aN P :=:™:g€ LTT} B:c=:2:„gz K a b :™<ˆB:Ç@Rk :g K :D= ~˜k :\N8 <=y5 :‡C ³ Fe j ƒ Q j R LQ ›7 › o 7 :Ç‚:^F:„>K NNNOUTT :QQ }OO~N <=B:Y:>ML TT s :AB:2i :> U :g w˜È :Y:>Nm :g S :D=:>TbNOs :`=X ~ H := 5 [ :@:gG L ² P È j 7 j j Q I Ÿ6O Ÿ R OQ O~8È ›Qo • K › :™M B:3B:„>S NNNNUTT :_C:™N a ³ 5 :…ˆB:>M s :gœ @<@:AB:2a — i :> U :g wS ˜ :Y:>TTNm :g :>3:Z=:c:gK K wl O U z::>NNNN B:C:„>TTUTT :gLLL =:…@TTTbXJ “ BF:g =:g =M :>:> B:C:„> U :g L 3:ÑqK N L ÔL :Y:=:gz Lb b :c=:…@5a 7 7 j 7 Ÿ¥ŸR•RK K Q~Omo U ¯ Ÿƒ j O}O s Q ~mo U 6 Ÿ R :™5 :™ :™ 5 :>N :>NNNTT :c=:™TTb 5 :D@Nm8 BF<<@:ef — WL 3:>:>MM8 N B:C:˘>T U :gL =:g b u 4 :™ 5 :3:DFN : N B 7 ƒ j j7 j Q Q OU ¯ ƒ j Q ~mo :_‘s :;<=ML := L :>N T :c =T b :ëFC ³:D@Nm—8 BF<<@ :=5[ :˘gzb :B=:ëFCT b³ :efWL := 5 [ :<@:AB:>5 aN :gz b :A<@ k :Ó² H :g K j Q QQ j Q ¥L Q 7 6 È :™N B:`:„gz5 5[ b :A<@k :Ó²:g H K :_:M a 5 :qJM :=:˘> L NNT :> :Ó² H

∗ [Expunged as ordered by the Chairman.]

52 QQƒ 7o7R 7 K 7 R R È :3:…@:AB:ÓC:>M8 aÖ NO~OsP :>QNm :@ mN8 e:> N :…B=5 5[ :c=:@:…@:c ¯ K —am K :™¥ :> N OOO sPs :˘@ ˜ È :> N :™ Ÿ 5 :ÇM± :> N Q 57 5 R ¶ 7 ¶ R Q R R I I 7 :>NOP B:2i :;3:<@KPÝ B:@:…@ — vÀ± :g|w8 B:YB:=NNNwK :YB:3B:2 S i :D=:B=:BqTTT bbJÈ :ÇB:>R NO s :g€ w o :g K :Z5[ :˘D=:@ b•m M[ = Q Q 7 Q 7 j 8 ¯ Q 8 S Q ŸR Q Q j }Tb :go BF:g L =Tb :3M8 FB:g w | B:cM :>N B:;B:3 S B:„ c :;e:…B=5 5[ :Í N mo ä ãD :™5 :=:gzL b :@<@:@@TUHam5 N 58 :2@a W—L :@:‡e3ßm e 7 I 7 ¶ O 8ŸR7 j ¯ Q NOa 8 Ÿ R Q 7 V¹ :>Ns :„>e:…B= N5 5[ :2:™NNa58 :=:;3:\@ LKN Òl :c<@:3M a uSMm M :3B:„>e:…B= N 5 5 [ :2:™ a 58 :\:˘;3:^5 KK3 fa :@ — :Y 7 QQQQ R 8 K 7Os 7 7 Q 6 :2:qN aJM :@:=:g€NNaTHHTb[w e:…B=5 5 :…ˆB:2M i :gz b :c :ÍNNm o : N :`= X ~LbL :Í m o :e:…B=N5 5[ :2:™N a 5 :=:c L :Y :gL =:3FB:g|T b M8 w B:>NN 3K :…@5a :YT :3 S B:2i :>T :D@ 5 mo @ ¹ :Í N mo ä ãD 7Q ¶ KQ K j OUQQQ O U º :‡<=:cML :DB:˘c :3qN8 ”L :gL :`5 [ @«k :^@ :q Ä – ::˚=:gzT b[w b <:;e:…B=5 5 :D=N K :…ˆB:˘>M NTT :D@5 m¹o @ :2a :˘> N :DBq y H I Q Q 7 ›¯Q NOa R R ¯ Q 8 O • I :YT :`5 5[ :„@—a—— :c<@:3M uMm M :B:;B:gzMNb :@e:…B=N a5 5 [ :g L :D= ˜ R B:˘> N :Ç~Na e:e<@ Ò—N L <:@ :3q8 ”L 7Q 7 7 ¶ 7 R OOUUQQQQº O UQ O U 7 ¶ R :D=NwK :qJM :˘>NNNNTTTT :D@5m¹o @ :2:˘>a :DBq y H :2:…ˆB:„> a MM :gL =:ÐB<@:D=T bwL aN K :…ˆB:=:> :g L 3:K<@ P ÝB:@— :…@ v À± :˚>NOUT gzb <:² MH 7 7 Q 7 QQQ j ¯ K8 7 K :gzb <:;e:D@:EBf@HWTUX :…B=5 5[ :=:gz L b :c@:c:f5 HN m ‰w :3:D@M85 m¹o @:3B:2 S i :gz b :…@:c 5 a4 :?@È :2N a ƒ R 7 j j¶ 7 R R j Q :…ˆBM ! ™•J5 :„>NOUT :gL =:D@TbQQW«kN L 3:`@M85[ :^@ :™Vn :qÄ– :=:g LLw o =:YB:= 5NNN K :YB:3B:„gz S b :D@ k :c:Bf:„>K H NO UT Q 7 j ƒ 7 “ 7 7 7 ¯ š O Q j :D=ua @:˘fÚ 5L :gKL :g 3:‹Km :=:` Kbwl 3:•:2MM 8 [i :gz b :@=:…= a—•4W T58 :@:c@M :2:„gzNN a b :?@È :2:˚> a N UT :D@N L 3 8 :D= N w K Q Q 7 7 7 7 ±Ü Q j ƒ Q O UPaU OR › O o ŸR Ÿ R :gL :•B¸@NmÛ ::˘fqFC:gkœ N ’aM KK :f@:g a Ú :DB:„>NTT :> N :Ç@:g R kÚ K :‹@:Y:2:>T i N :g wK =:™ 5L 5 :™ @ k :g ¶ Q 7 7 Q L 7 K OU O áNL K IIR m “ R V :25 m[ @« :CN ’v g{L :2:„gzN a b :…@:c:?@5 a 4 È:2:„>NNaNNT :gzb <3:>K qÔL :c:=wJ5 :2:½ˆB:˘@ a 5 NmK :‹ :=:= K w J 5 :™n :<@ Õ Ào BFe › 7 ƒ Q 7 „>NNOUT :gzbwK <:qœ :g€o :g :c5¯ :c 5¯ :YT :2i :> O U T :g wwo ˜È :½ˆB:˘g 5 S :g :3M8 :DF X H N ::=f@NLa MH :Z :‚= X :C ’mN Nm Q 7 Q Os QQQK K :DB:…B::„D=5 Tb :@mbT @M Ha´ :@@È e:2:>N a N :˘gzb :@TTU<:?=:D=5LK :gl :Óq– :c :D@5 m¹Uo @ :˘gz b :@<:?=:D= 5 LK :g l :Óq – :c Q Q › OsQ 7 O s ¯j K :Y:3B:2:>:gTS i NNL @´maÈ e:=:D@KLbb}K @:;<=:D=:@M M TT Òm—M[ =:…@5 N X @:>:„gz b :c@ WN La 3:c:`@M8 5 [ « :?F²5 := K 7QQ7j 7 7 QQŸR87KX › OU Ÿ R 8 7 K ± Ü Q :gL =:ÐB<@:2:™TTTbLaNNa5 :=:>3:…@:cNNNK5 a :ÓC :Y:˘>T :g L =:ÐB<@:2:™ bL a a 5 :=:>3:…@: K 5 amc :• B¸@N Û Q 7 ¶ Q 7 Q 7 Q ŸR 87 K L › O U Q ŸR 87 K I R › O U :ÐB<@:2:™aN a 5 :=:>3:…@:cL NNK 5 a :CN ’v g{L :Y:˘>T T :g L =:ÐB<@:2:™TTbaN a 5 :=:>3:…@:c LNNK 5 a := w J5 :Y :˘> T j 7Q 7 7 KQ ¦š 7 6 [ [ › OUQ ŸR 87 K Q › O U :c :> e:gK :\<=N8˜y5 :Z5 :Z 5 :Y:„>TTTTNNNTT :g L =:ÐB<@:2:™ bLaN a 5 :=:>3:…@:cK 5 am¹ :D@ 5 o @:Y:˘> :g L = b Q 7Q 7 OUQ Ø OO PUR Q O U 7 „>NNNNTTT :gzb <:D@M•MR :> B:Š=:„>o :g L =:ÐB<@:2:˘>T b aN a :g L 3:…@K 5 a

53 7 Q 7 QQ 7 •[ •8 7 Os :„D=Tb :@3aK8 :Y :3qN ”L :™M B:3 K :2P È :…@:‡35 a [ ˆB:> N 7 Q (`uH Bf s) Mr. Chairman: Shah sahib , please, you are objecting. Should I show you the record how many minutes you have consumed? Should I should show the record to Mushahid-Ullah how much time he consumed? Chandio sahib , please conclude. Q j Q Q OPR 7 Ÿ5R ¥ K O 4 T› Os 6 I Q ±5R I O l :>NN :…@:™5a :gl :™ :> :„D=:@<:3:Tb T U K conclude :>N :™:5 :=f@NLa MH :Z :‚= X :C ’mN Nm Q Q j Q Q 7 Q Q Q KKKQ ŸROOsPR7 j œ Ÿ R OO Ps È • 8 O s ¯ :c:DB:™5 B:gL :>:˘c:>NNNNN :\@N 8Òl :c:ÑC: :>:3qN8”L :™M B:gL :>::„c 3 K 77 7 7 I 7 Q VŸR R¯I Os ƒ ŸŸ R ¯QK 8 R VWX K O P R 7 :™PM :„™ :c@:3:>5HaM8 N :DF@:gM K :qˆB:C::^F:˘™œTTU :c@:>:™ 5HU5 ‚:c :Ç@:g RTN K :qˆB:C: œ U Ím o :Y :„c:>N :…@5 a QQII j Q › Q ¯š ¯ Q œ 7 :…ˆB:`@M 5 [ «mm :D@NNNNXK :2i :@ :?=5w“ :gL :Y:˘@@T amam5 8 :c<@:™MM @ l :=:c<@:AB:g K a L :ÑCN L ³:NTNN :½ˆB:2:gz5i b :™5 :‡<@4a› :…@:_B:>5 NNaN :> T :g w :=:…@Tb5 NN m—X @:>:g L @ mam5 8 :c<@:™@M l :=:Í K m o :Y 7 ƒQ j 7 j QQQOO•žX }~mo OO j 7 :>Naa ::2:˘gN a SLK :> N @:=:™5HTb :g{ :>N B:g :3:ÍB:=:D==KST• KLÛ 5 :> N aUb :˘> N T :<@ Òl :@:‡e3:` — } e:g{ L = Û Q j ƒ OR Q }~mo Q 7 O „@:;3:>GK NP :?= 5w“ :=:> K N B:AB:D@ maH}K @:„gM S :> N a @ 5 :=Tb :Í• B:g{L = Û I Q I Q j Q ƒ [ Q „`@5[« :_m[ :…@5 N ml BqB:„`@ t 5 [ «H :=f@:˘23NL a M N a ~k :>NOs C’mN M :…@5 m5[ Q j Q I Q •l › 7 »yš Os Q Os ƒ M[ Q ~ I Oml :^fNm5± :_B:Y:2:D=:@N a TTi b mJ5 :> N ! >CN ’mN :…@5 m5[ :˘23N a k : :_m[ :…@5 Nml BqB:Ct ’mN N ƒ Q O O ƒ }Xœ Q ¶ yš 7 š œ O j R :>NNs : UT g um:™=:2:„g€z“N a wb @:@3:^C@MHaKT U v—X :@:‡N TU :g L ˆB:g L 3:` K ± 5 ƒQ Q j ƒ ƒ Q VOPR •¦š V 7Q ~mo 77[ O s 7 7 »y š :™a @5m“ :gl B:N :™ e:™ a @ 5 m “ `@lNNmml~ :>N :gzb :@k =:gTb L B<:Ó² m B:>:`@N l mm lJ :2:D=:@i Tb 5 Q Q j Q Q R š :„g€zwb @:@@MH a m 58 :>NOP :™•¦ e Q ƒ j OUI O PR ¯7 O} s Q ~Nmo Q :^F:˘>NNNT :D@Nma8 <@:2:2M NNa i :gzb :> :2:?B= a • :„gz b :c=:…@:>T b 5 aa :;<@:g 5 K :> B ! ‚BF:…@5 m5[ j QQŽ Os 7 Q ƒ K 7 OsQ }~mo « O U I :;3:D=:2K K‘ŒNw :>N :;<@:g5aK :`=X ~ H :^fm8 ˆB:c:D@ m }K @MMa:>NN :>N B:2i :gzb :2:?B=N a • :‹ B:˘>T :D@N m8 <@ a Q j Os «O s 87 b 8 Q 7 :>N :„gzb :2N a : issue :‹ B:>NNN :?@NNm[ :;CN ’¿ :˚gS :>3:e3:`KST} e:@:g a S ::>3:ÁB= K x :g K :D@ maG } K @:˚@M Q 7 I QQOsR O sQ b O 4 ›T 7 » y š :3B:M 8 NNTN :qJ5 :@N m8 e:> :;<@:;<@5 a4› :2•a =N wK :g€z w @:@ˆB:M HaÓq – :AB:> :2 i :D=T b :@ m J 5 ƒ j Q OaŽ Q 7 b › :D²:D²:2¬ ¬ i ::>N BF3:2K ‘ŒNw :3:Ç<:•Ff KKm58 :3:CM 8 ³ :gK :Á=:e3:`“ S} T e:D@P RN :2 i :@NmK :?=5w“ :=:AB:g K L :Y T ƒ ƒ 7 Q QQII S R j ¥NL QQO R :=:c5[b :gL @:=:Y@:?@5HÚmTX :™ B:_B:gN a l :AB:=:@3:> Lw aK N P :g L :D=NN8 <@:D²:D²:˘gzMM a ¬ ¬ bL :@3:g a K :D= w 8 <@ a Q Q Q ØŸR R Os—sQ 7 Q OS O P R œ › 7 Q 7 ::D=3:˘@:=:™•M8 GT b N :™5 :>NNN :D@ m}L @ Ž B:‹:> :?@Nm [ :;CNT’¿ :2•‘5a :c:gzb <:> :eFf• :™:_:D@a ma } K @M :ÓC Ö

54 ƒ Q o Os Os O s Q ¦ NR :_B:2:g€N a N a w :AB:„@G :g L @5 H ˆB:>N :e= 5[ F:model :@Nm8 :_B:2:˘@N a NNa GWs :=:@TLTbN B:>NN :2 m o @= Û :f 5L :gK :AB:˘@ G :=:> b :> I :„gzb :serious issue :B3 58 7 Q Q OU˜È Q O s R › Q :2:>iNNT :gwlb :^@mS :2:gN a B:3B:˚gzS :@NNN mm KK :@ :>:D=@o ka :¼@:gM M L :Y:2:@T i mPP S :@È :D@ RN ! ‚BF:…@5 m5[ Q I Q Q 7 j Q 7 j l O • 7 Q 7 O 7 :D@m}K @:gM a l :D=OWNOm B:ZN =:N s :…B= • :` 5 5 [ Q QQ7 Q 7 OPR › 7 Q Q I Q œ Q 7 R 7 I Q 6 :>N B:gL :Y:„@T ´aR :@e:BF3:fN Km58 :@ mÌ 3:2B3:™=:@:D@M 8a 8 “ —maU } K @:D@F:gM T LJLK :D:= ˜ R B:„g :g€ e:<@ a B:;fm J 5 :g j 7 ƒ j Q 8 Q I Q œ I Q 6 Q 7 7 ~ :>B:;B:2:˘@N N aNNmmmSKÌ :@ :ëFC³ :@ 3:2B3:™=:^<@Fe:D@F:˘gM8 a 8 “ 5 aUTTL BC:;f Ê Ü mJ5 :g K :D@ maU } K @M :D@ F:5N :@<:>TUNNNN :2‘Wuk :^F:…B:˘@ 5 ´aHaR :@@:@e:3:>F²:>5NNK5H :˘@ ´aHa R :@@:@e:3:f 5 K m58 :> :D=uN m5[ :> :2:@i ´a R :@= T b j j Q j 7 7 yš O› • K È O T › Q 7 :`˜5R :2:2N a i :D=:Tb@mJ5» :>NNs : 4 :g€ ÔKL N UT :™<:@:c:BfT 5H NmM8 : fault lines :c :½q– :Fe:>N s :AB::„gzb : serious issue Q Q 7 Q Q 7 Q Q 7 Q ¯ ¶ :=Tb :D@m}L @ Ž B:Talibanized :˘@=:@GWTb N O i :D@ m}L @ Ž B:@:f— 5L :gK :2014 :2i :gzb :2:eBq:gN a œ l :AB:N a N a NN :D=wÀT :<@:>MH gu´ | :N s :„gz b :c=:Bf b NmM8:fault line Q 7 ƒ ƒ OU › K Os Æ •¦¥“ ¯ ¯ :>N T :™T <:theories :c :½q– :AB::>N :™ @ s:D@PNR ::gl :™ f:„gz5a b :c=:BfTb N m M8 :fault line c @5a =Û ::‡C³ Fe 7 j Q Q 7 O Q 7 ŸR K OM a R :Fe:>N s :D@m}K @:2M a i :™ :c:ZN : theory :_N a B:gL :D=˜R B:˘g J : experts :gK : security :Š=:=o5 [ :2 i :?@H CÊ5R :@ — : Core area „gzb : periphery area :_a B:NOUT : areas N I N o I QQ7 R • 8 periphery area :>Q ~Nm :;3:@3:?@M8a4 KÔOk B:Y:Y5 N B:g€wKo :g :AB:gz b @:gzM Ha¬ b :@3:ë@e K j ƒ j 7 bI •K 7 Q j X 7 È O s :DFe3:`S} T e:@@:ga¬kl :D=@o :™ :2ml 3:č² S m :˘gz b :@=:Ç aT bM± :=:>5 [ N :;<@:g5 a Kb :AB:˘gz :dispensable 7 Q QQO O ~ o 7 Q ~o O w“ :>NNa :> s :AB:…B:>5 Nm :gzb :@m~k :=Tb :2N a :˘gz b :periphery :˘gzb :dispensable :2:>N a Nm :gzb :>N s :g ¸ { :g K ƒ j j7 ƒ •S 7 Q L I 7 yš O O j :™ :=Tb :BfNmM8 :?@H :…<= Û}:h@:Z=aN L :‡3:g5 8 l :AB:2i :D=:@TT b mJ5» :>NNs :g€ wwL o :AB:˘> UT :g S :=:‹@ bÛ s k :g{ = 7 II ƒ 7 SH¯¯OU•uM I Ü Q O s K o :˘c :>NNT <:™ :D@Nmaa8 <@:˘c<@:D²:˘c<@:D²:2MMM¬ a ¬ i :gL @:@5 H´5 » B:2:> a :D=@:cL5 a :½q:– AB:g€ w :AB:„gz b 7I Q ƒ 7 7 j › ¯I I OPR 7 ¯ Q ~Omo U ¯ŸR O U ¯ Ÿ R 7 Q } ~m o I :2:Y:„c3:…=:>N a T M8 LNNN :`@XNm“ :c=:g K l :AB:>N :>TT :c@:™5 HaH5 :<@:5 :c@:™ 5 5 :`N w 5[ :> N B:D@N ma8 <@M j 7 Q 7 7 b8Q Q ~ mo [ Òo Q I O 4T› O U ˜È :DFe3S :`} T e:2iaa :>3N K :2:=:2:>LNNN :gzb :• :@— :ÁB= x :2:‹ a @:˘@e:2:…FF:>5aN a aNN :gL :ÁB=x :3S B::2 i :>T :g w

55 ƒ 7Q j Qj 7 j Q QQ}~mo 7b O m NOH 5 } ~ m o :gK :?=Û B:AB:„g L @:@5HmN K :Á@ 4—•bT B:@:g LÔK <@:>T U NN B:g€L N :> B:g€ ÔK L 5 aN :;<@ 5 a Q 7 7 7 › I 7 »yš Os Q Os ƒ M[ Q :…@:g5aL :D=Ok Fe:;<@ 4PTN› :D@NR :2i :gz b :2:…@:YB:‡3:2N a 5 aTT58 i :D=:@ b m J5 :> ! >N C’mN :…@5 m5[ 7 Q j Q Q 6 7 I O O O 7 7 R › K :@mJM =:Ç@MLR k :gK :ÁBC ’É B:;3:>58 NNNs :˘> UT :gz b <:> s :`=X ~ H :;CN ’Þ :ø\C²:?@K ³ 5 ak :¼@:YM M a T :2i :gzb :c Q ƒ ƒ Q ¯ ¯ Os O U L •– 7 :fP56 Ff:c²5 H 5 ÕHTL B:c=:>:@=KNNNNamN wo =:2:@ 5 L NNaK :˚> NT :gL ˆB:ZBF:gM l :™ F²:` 5l Fe:2:;<@ a 4mGH T › @ K ::2 i :@ :D=@b M 7 Q Q ƒ 7 Q 7 Q ~OOmo R R 7 ] R O L R :D@m}K @MMa:>N :gJ :>NNNP ::> s :`=X ~H :™@F:?@ ¬ka :¼@:^F:˚>M UT :g L ˆB:ZBF:D@M P NR :f 5L :g KJb :AB:N a NN :„>T :gz bLLo <:g 3:`=KX ~Û H :3:g{M 8 = :g BF:‡e@5 akˆB:fŒNwŽ :ÇR @ :g K j 7 Q Q Os7 Q 7 bUsQ [OOL7 Q • 8 R :DB:>NNN :D=wo Bf:˘gzn b :ÁB3B:@:‡e3:`o— ST8} e::3:>M 5 :>T :gz bo <:g :2Œ[ :> :…@@5 a•• B:Š=o :g }l € B:A@M M :g QQQ 7 Q Q OPRI Q •8 O~O P R Q mo U 7 :…ˆB:NNN B: B:>N :>T :…@f s ÕX :Ó²:gH K 7 ¶ Q OU O a K O8´ºNa Q 6 › o OO U H 7 :3S B:NNT :> @5a :c :record :2:˘>N aNNN e:„>3:2:2K a ‘ 4 :3:Y:…ˆB:g€M 8 T M w :AB:˘>T :g€{:_B:…@q }N a Na ·L :g K 7 j 7 Q o › Q ~mo 7 Ÿ5R Oi O a ¥ NL › :g€w :AB:D@PNR :YT :>N :gz b :e=5[ = X :record :B<@k :`˜5R :™ :A@:;<@M a4TNN› :=:>L :ëFC³ :> @:™5 a B:gL :Y T 7 ƒ ƒ Q ‰OWX Q 7 O ¦56› O OR ¦ 56 :2:˘gzNNab :?:B=:@:‹• —5m :g K :D@ m}K @:2:2:>M a a i N UT : gL =:rTTTb :g€ wo :AB:D@PNR :Y:2•‘5a :>NNUT :g L =:> b P :r 7 j „gzb :?B=• :@— :‡e3ST :`}b e j Q Q Q Q 7 bƒ X « Q 7 ¯ :Ím5[ :‡<@4T› :2:TTN T :g ˆB:g :Y :…@5 a :2N a :„gz b 7 7 OOO¥X Q 7 Q O È › O 6 › ::>NNNTNsUs :DFf5• :˘>TT :gL q:Š=:>œo :D@m}K @„gzM a b :Ím5 [ :‡<@ 4 › :2:2:>N a i U :g w ˜ :Y:N UT :g€wK :g u 4 :3:YM8 T 7QQ 7 7 OOOssUQ O s O U :gLK =:gTTTTb @4Ù e:>NNNNN :DF5 a :DF<@ m5[ :˘>TT :g LK =:g bbb @ 4 Ù e:> :D=@<@:Á@B:˘ Gas 5 >:g LK =:g @ 4 Ù e Q j 7 O Q 7 › Q K Q 7 O :>N s :„g€zwb @:@MH m NO• :stand :Ó²HT :gK :DFe3ST :`}b e:=K :`5 l :Y ::„gz b :Ím5[ :‡<@4TN› :M a N a L UT ƒ7 ƒ Q ƒ 7 Q QQ OOOsas O mX •8 O a 7 Q •87 Q K 7 Q :>N :˘> N ˆB:> N :e= 5[~b F:> N =HTT :™ : N @=:…@@5Ha•5 B:2:gN al :\CN8 NN’É :C ’ É :2 i :;3:Bf:cK H :D=:@ b mHbT @M :@ m˜È j j Os O s7 bb 7 QQ6 R :2:>NNaNN ::˚gzb :2F<:@ aNmaK :> :;<@:g5 K :DFe3STST :`} e:M aN :DB:2 i :D=@T b mHmbT @ :@ ˜ È :™ QQQQj Q j O}ORQ ~mo R I Q OO}Q Q ~ m o › :gL =:>TbNNNNPP :>N B:2:@iPÈ :> :g LwKS :D= ˜ R B:g€o :g :`wX :_B:„gN a :> •s :2 Œ[ ::>Ö N B:Y:2:T i gz b Q j Q Q Q Q › ›8}OI ƒ Q ~mo › PR o I O m bT :Y:2:@TTTiPÈ :gLS :Y:„g :>3:…@NNNK Òa—PNw8 @:@:>5 N B:Y:2:@ i È :> :g€ wKL :g :`wX :_B:gN a :D=˜RN B:˘> @ M H Q Q Q j j O› Q ~o O •l QQ}~mo O O} ~ m o :>NNs :;q·[ :=:ÁB=K x :g|w8 B:Y:>T Nm :> UT :^fNm5± :½ q:‡<=:g€– ML wo :g K :>NN B:NN• :2Œ[ :>:> s B Q QQ Q RI › 7 Q I R :™•M8 B: gÔ €L KNNOP :g } uH {:;3:Y:˘gz5 8 T w b @:@MH m o Be:> O P

56 ƒ L »œ Q › È :2:gzibJb :>Q NNNOÕN :g{ :˘gz :2 k FqJ5R :3:ÁB=:g|M8 x w8 B:> O 4T :„> O UT :g LJ =:gT b <:‡<@:5H election campaign I Q Q Q ~mo 8« O m NOk R j › Q OÕNL »œ 8I O 4 T› :>N :gS :>3:‹NNK @:>H :^e@<:gN a l :g u P | :EB¸@WLT B:Y:2i :gzb :>NNN :g{ J :˘g S :>e:…FF:> :ÁB= x Q Q Q OmbT ¯ O P R 7 :„>NNN @:c=:>MHTb :D@NN m8 e@<:= 8NN}N O 5a :2:D=:@ iT b mHm bT @:@M ˜ È :™5 :2:>N a 7 yš O 7 V »MR K ::2i :D=Tb :@mJ5» :>N s : transition :gl :`=:™X ~H ´ M :qJMR : transitions :c :½q– :Fe:2N a :NOUT : ;qJ5R B: : loopholes :ÇM± :> NOs: AB ƒ j OU7 •K O s Q :gK :?@mX :„>NNT :…‚B=• :™ ::> :;<@:AB:˘gz5 a b :Ï<:@5L NN mm K :D@ X :>NN B:˘gz bL :@ P È :g :> :> B:2:@ i N mPS :@ È :N T :…‚B=:g• K :½q:AB:˘gz– b :@NmK :2‘ŒNw :g L :Caretaker Government :2N a :@PÈ :> N V »MR 7 yš O S 7 7 ¶ Q ~o O :™´M :credit :B<@k :2:2N ai :D=:@TTb m J5» :>N s ::„c :D=:T U ¹ Nm :>N UT :areas Q j¶ Q 7 Q Q ›O•l K[ K X • X 8 [ 7 I •o transition :_B:Y::½ˆB:>:™N a T 5 NNs F<:c:Z::˘c:<=5·w :YN 3:>=8 }N O 5 a :g L :Z:gz 5 b :@@:=:`a5 H K w¦N <@M a Q QQ Q I •o LsO O Uo j 5R › O U Q :@:`—akmw¦N <@:•@M 5 :2:>N a NNN :?@N [ :;CN ’¿ :„>T :eB<ˆB:g€wKL :g :g 3:`K ± :D@ P NR :Y:½ˆB:T 5 T :gz bl <:<3 S :g Q Q :„g€zwb @MH :@ m us :N a N s ! >N s C’mN :…@5 m5[ Q Q Os 8Q 8 Os O s :>NNN ::„> 3K :2a :½q– :AøB: 3 K :½q – :AøB:^F:2 i :@ PaÈ:>NN :;<@:g5K : :;<@ 5 Q Q j  o R 7 Q › Q 7 Q 7 7 I :A B:>Q ~Nm :>NN OUT :> O P :Š=:goo BF:g L 3:™B3:ÁB3B:Y:2K8oš TT•a =N wK :D=:@ b mHmbT @:@M ˜ È :Ç@:gR k K :ÁBC ’É B:;3 5 8 ƒ QQQ Q Q Q ƒ ¯ I Q I Os Q ¥NL 77 Q 7 I :AB:=5[ :c Ba a N :DFCN ’ MÉ :™ B:gLL :AB:˘g€ e:…B<@NN maOH B:^e@<:g l :…N :;<@g5a K :Ye:N ë@‚@:g5a—L :AB:„@ ´R :>N :Á@:@ —— KOs7 K wŽ O s Q :C@:gT U5amml :eFf:c:AB:=:@H 5[ NNo :2Œ[ :> N :`l @ l :c:_:g‘s lLuK :½q:_B:˘g€– N a e:gŒ € ::> N :;<@5 a :g :DFC N ’MÉ Q ƒ 7 ƒ 7 yš :D@PHa—56 :„g€zwLwbb @M :@3:Á@K :g =:gzTTb <:>NNNOs :eFfH :cKQ :> O a ˆB:=:DF O s :g€ wb :AB:„gz Q Q ƒ Q ƒ 8 7 ›Q 5 R O ÒL KQ O •Oa :>3:`N Kl B=[ N ‘ :g l :eFf: H c :>N a ˆB:;:„>NNNT <:>:<@N m O H B:^3Be:g|8 w B:g| wB:^F:2 i :g S ƒ j 7 R K š Q bQ s bQ s › o :gKL :;C³ Fe:_B˘gN a @5•5 :c :™ B3:ÁB3B:˘g€z8o w @:@3:Á@:3:‹:

57 7 7 Q R Q 7 7 j Ž :_‘s :AB:™Ÿ5 :_ ‘ s :DFCQQN ’a5 :LNNNOTU :gL 3:e3:`KST} b e:2•‘5 a :g L 3:> K O PR :ÁB= x :g u Œ w € :> O s j ƒ S O 7 j I „2N a 3~k :„c :>N a @5H =Tb :BfNmM8 :…² Ò }X :‡35 8 :g€wo :g K j Q Q ±Ü ƒ [ Q „`5[ @« :D@ H :` 5N O W Bf 5 m x :˘2N a 3~k ::>Q NOs C’mN M :…@5 m5[ Discussion on Law and Order Situation and Statement by the Caretaker Interior Minister j I Q »œ R Q Os ƒ M[ Q ~ Q Q ±Ü Oml brain :g{:2:gJi uP |:g l :AB ! >CN ’mN :…@5 m5[ :˘23N a k : :D@:`H 5 NOW Bf5m x :C ’mN N ƒ 7 Q Oa Ÿ5R Oa Q 7 Os “ »œ 7 :˘>N =Tb :™ B:>N @:=5a 5[ ! ‚BF:…@5 m5[ :„DF3K :…@:>5 aaN :2i :@e:r=:gN XJ { :g L :…ˆB:˘@@M aH5 :=:T b hemorrhage Q 7 Q 7 ƒ Q OPuR L 7 Q Q [OO Ua › 7 I Q ¯ 7 :>NNN :• :glK :…‚@:h<@:gHa— :½ˆB:@:>:>55 T :gz b <:3:> K8Ž @:^F:Y:25 aTi :gz bl :@3:@ amM˜È :g :A=} B:c @ P • 8 B j ƒ 7 ƒ 7 ƒ ƒ Q 7 Oa j OQ R ¯ 7 Q O O 7 • OH5 : : 2i :@:DF3:ZGKNM ::qÔl :_B:gN a LwK =:gzTb b <:>NNNs :;3Be:g 8 :CN ’4 :c@ PÕP• 8 B:> s :˘> a =:3<@ Tb N 8 L :™ :D@ RN ::„gz b Q Q ƒ Q >N8 3K :<=x :B3:ÐqN8 K ¡ :ÇM± :Y ƒ 7 j I Q •S I QO}a › I Q~mo ¯ O PR 7 Q O s ƒ M[ :™ :=:D@Tb Nma8 <@:>MMNNN :T o N B:c<@:_B:2 aN a i :gz b :> :2:…@:˘`@N a 5 a«5 [ :> C’mN 7 j QOOOa ´ºNa U Q Q }~mo › K 7 O U :>N :3B:2S i :> N e:…ˆB:„>M NT :gzb <:=:N B:2: N T 7 ƒ jQ 7 Q j › Osa O}8QQ~mo O}O PsR ~ m o :YTT ::„@G =:@b N m K :turnover >N :AB:=:>Lb N @:=:>5HTTNN B:2i :>3:Ðq:@:g NK t N a L =:> b N :> B:> N :D== 5 LÛ j ƒ Q % % % OsQ }~mo O a turnover 5 , 10 , 15 and :>NTN :>N B:D@:;<@TU4› :2i :gS :> @ ´mÈ e:@NNK :=:D=BF:@K o m 8 e ƒ j KQ 7 S QQR 7 Q }~mo L % :c :D@ma}K @:N B:g€ } B:@ m K :„gz b :20 ƒ Q 7 ¥“ O I È 7 Q 7 O R 7 Ü :2i :D=:@TTbm˜È :3:@K ´ È :Y :>N s ::˘:gzb :B= b :BqJ :3:gzMM8b BN P :Ó3 [ :3:` 8 Nw¦ @ k ƒ j7 jQ 7 Q j Q QQQQ}~O}O~moo ~ m o7 R › Q } ~ m o :gL =:2:>TTTTba NNN B:3B::>S Nm g S :D=:> bNNs :?@:C:=:>HT U Lb B:„@=:> a P :BfNmM8 :™:?B=T •Lb :=:@:g — L =:2:>a B :D@ PNR Q 7 O R 7 Q QQ7Q S7 K 7 :gzb :>N P :^F:economic position ::\F:AB:3:™:gNNM8T L BF3:> KN B:=:…ˆB:„>K • 3: K survive De:^NN :g€ wKL :g :g BF3:> K NM B:2i :> :½= • ƒ :gl :…ˆB:>M NNOs :„g S :> O a BF3:K fair election ::3:N8 K law and order maintain ƒ Q R 7 7 QQœ 7 7 7 :g·l BF:g K :Bf::„>H NOUT <:Y@:3:AB:2ÚM8i :D=:@3:`Tb a K l B =[

58 7 ƒ Q ƒ š 7 L ñ J»y K Q 7 :\F:AB:Š=:=] o[L5 :=:gL ˆB:‹Ò :g l :DFqJ :Š=:3B:„g o S w { : economic condition :c :D@m}K @M a ƒ Q Q ROa•M˜R 7 ñ Q O U R j :˚@=:@GmTb NNK :qJM :„gS :>NN @:¼5 HM :_:DFqa J :g KbL :DB:^F:>T :gz <:@5 •ak5 :g @e@ Q I Q ƒ OPR OaQI O P R 7 R ¯ 7 :::„@<:;e:>TU N :g€|:=:…ˆB:_}K MMm58 :`NwOk :˘@<3:>TUK N :…@:g5 a l :…ˆB:ÑB:YB:cˆB:\F:ABN L N ] 7 Q QQ Ü Q 7 :^F:2i :>NOUT :problems :gwwK8 B:g X @k :g :AB: Go NNNNP :`wX :Ae:> sU :„>T :gzb <@:3:> a K P : law and order maintain I 7 Q 7 Q Q K O Q O l Q •[ 7 O I :c :D=Nw8 <@Ma :2N a :˘> N UT :g€L e3:ÍB:g{K• L =Û :>N a :g L :…ˆB:=M 5 [ :2:gN a ·K BF:g :Bf:2H i :@:DF3G K :Y :…@a :>N s :` wX I 5 Q K¯Q NOMa ››QQQ7 K¯Q8 › K R R › O PR 7 :c :c<@:3MauMm :™TTTT :2:B:;B:2:gzM NN a b :™ <=:c bwb :YBNN:=N K :YB:2:˘™ a <:=:> :…@5a Os ›K 7 › :conducive atmosphere :>N :D== 5LÛ :DF<@MMH ::„gzb :™TT <:=:cTT bLÛ :D== 5 :<@ H :…@:2:25 a N a • ‘5a :gz b :™ <= b Q 7 ƒ Q ƒ Os R Q 8 [I O a Ò L ñ ±NR :message 2:>N aNN :@Nm8 e::qJM :23 a K :?@ 4ÔOkB:• :@ — :…FF:N ˆB:3K :‹ :gl :DFqJ :Š=o :D@ P 56 :g w { e ƒ 7 ƒ ƒ I % OQ O I % O :„gwS :g o Be::15 vote :>Ns :D== 5L Û :> N a ::g{N s L =Û :_B:2@:gN a i G L @ 5 H 7 Q Q OU8 7 R O s R :„>NNT :gw @5H :C’P5 :…ˆB:2:>M N a :?@NN m[ :;CN ’¿ :˘@=:@ GmT b K :q JM Q 7 ƒ R I Q 7 Q ƒ :D==5LÛw :D=NOa : Q NOs C ’mN M[ j Q Q j O Q QQ7 7 MR O› O O :>N k ‚:D@TU F:˘=Tb :öfml :^F:gzb @MMM HmH :˘= Tbu :D@} M[ =5 a :^F:gz b @ :˘= Tb[w :B= :D=± :^F:gz b @ H:˘>NNUT :™T <:3S :> k ‚:D@ P 56:> N s 7j 7 Q Q Q}~mo QQ¡ O›Q K Q O › :Tb LN B:qJMR =:@F<:2:‹ L —a4 :2:gN a L :…ˆB:3B:„>MSNN UTT :™<3:3:e@TT S8M m O 5a :c :2 a B U :™ <:3 S Q Q N ƒ O R 7 R ŸR o Q 7 OR 7 R ŸR R 7 Q Q ~ mo :D=:>TbN P :C’P 5 :™5 :g€w :g K :D@ m}KM a ˘@:: gS :D=:>TTbN P :C’P 5 :™5 :g€ wKo :g :…ˆB:¼@M 5 m8 :g K :AB:>N :g S :D= b Q Q 7 7 Q OPR Ì I ŸR R S R Q :>NT :gw 3:™MM85 :2• @:3:DFC:‡<@¬ 8 5 ’Ú 4 › :youngsters ::;<@4TT› :NTNa ˆB:g€o :g :g K =J :3:DFC:‡<@M 8 5 ’Ú 4 › :2 • ‘5a :g S :> a ˆB Mr. Chairman: Yes, Zahid Khan Sahib , you would be the last speaker now and then the Interior Minister is here to conclude it. Q Q 8 7 ŸR j 7 »œ Q Q Q œ I O l „„„„„„::3:`N K uH Bf:™s5 :` 5 [ @« :^@ k :2i :gz b :@ m M8 :g{ J :D@H :fB<:fTU 4 » :C ’mN Nm I ¯ K Q Q Q Q ƒ [ Q :@NmS ˆB: point of view :@— :c <@:cM a :…ˆB:M already ::`5[ @« :D@ H :fB<:T U :>NOs C’mN M :…@5 m5[ Q Q 7 R O• 7 Ÿ5R :2‘HM Be:3L N 3 K :…@:™5a :…ˆB:M and I am giving you the opportunity :gzb :„gS :>N8 e:;e:…B=5 5[ :`5 [ @ « Senator Muhammad Zahid Khan: Thank you sir.

59 j Q Q 7 b a 6 QQ7 ¡ :gK :D@5m¹ao @ :@:DFe3:`N ST}[[ e:g L :`5 @ «Hm :‹f:™@:` N88 n5 55 :@5 :\F:AB:^F:N s :„gJ B=Tb :…q5 ·¸X :^F::N :1982-83 :`@5[«km :^@ :2i :@˜È :>NN :g€w :AB:> :;<@:g5 a K :`@ 5 [ « 7 7 7 R 7 RI R 7 O :_N a 3 ± :2N a:\] F:AB: „gJ :fq@:;<@Na œ —4TTN› :2:s : MRD movement :2 i 7 7 R R R 7 o R 7 :>NOs :?fe:=• K :_‘s :AB:˘> N O UT :e= 5 [ = X :™Ÿ5 :™ Ÿ 5 B:™ Ÿ @:gk K :Z:5[dictator @::\F:AB:>— ] Q ~Nm :gJ :>N O s :?²ÕOk B QQ Q Q I j 77 L 7 7 Q :…eB:;3:`5 585[ @«kUas :^@ :N :Z5 :c<@:cBF:\F:AB:cM a] :…ˆB::ÇM R @ k :g K Q 7 Q Q ›OU œ š • 5[ Q 8 ±Ü Q O U ŸR :=:…ˆB:Y:K MMT N T :™eˆB:™ @NNml :…ˆB::„@ m o :Y :gl :>::g K : •B:¸@NmÛ :AB::gL :D=˜•5[ :>N T : :™ 5 Š=o : N :>N T :g w @:™eˆB:™ @N l 7 7 Q 7 7 R I OŸR O Ÿ R ::„gJ :fq@Na œ — :=:…ˆB:2L M i :@ P È :g€ w o :AB::2N agLbL :>NNs :„gz <:g @:™5H5 :> s :D=uNm5[ :N :> N :`w¦N <@:=:\F:AB:=MaL] 5 [ :Š=:Ç o M± :™ 5 :…B:^:F²:g5 nK :…ˆB:`M 5 [ @ «ka :^@ : N T :g L 3K :…@:Y5 T 7 7 Q Q 7 OsQ [7 Q 6 Q O s R R OPR O sI •o O U :`@x 456 :>:>:D=:@NN5 Tb mHmbT @:@M J M =:gM L l :DB:>: ˘gJ :C@:2T U5a•‘5a :g J :>N :>:` Nw¦N <@:^e==:@:>M a 5[ X N a N T Q Q Q 7 ƒ K R Q O4T› O H O U QQQ R ¯ œ :c :…ˆB:?@MMkaa :¼@:2M M i :@e:2N m ž– :gL :…ˆB:>NN :g€{:˘> }T :D@:DBq Hy¡ :g K :Ó@ Œ LB:_N a 3± :N :˘> NT :gz b <:…@B=:@=:@ —am bLN 5 M 8 B:…M ˆB:g w :AB:™T <:c Bq yºH I 7 j Q ºa 7 R •Oa 7 :Á@4R :gK :f 5L :g K :AB:N8M 8 NO´ N e:=:™L Ÿ5 :Óq:AB::gz– bJK <:g €5 :Ç@ R k :g 7 Q Q QQQ ƒ QQQI 7 ¶ R 7 ¯•Oa ¯ Q NOa Os 7 :@:@NNNa´aR :@e:ÏÀ± :=:…@BfB:c=@CK sÚÚ L NN’Þ : N :=K :…@Bfs Ú B Q 7 Q OUœo œ O U œŸR œ O s 7 Q :3S± B:2i :>NNNTT :Á35 :g€w :AB:^e@<:gNNa l :Ç5± :^F: :Á3 5 ± :™5 :^F:=:D=:Á3LbT 5 ±S :> :3 B:„@ ´R :@e:g a L :D= So =:DB 7 j j Q 7 ±Ü Q ŸR XQ 7XQ 7 ±Ü Q :• B¸@NNmÛ :NNNNTTT :gzb <:3K :…@:35a K :ÇB:^F:…B:„>R 5 :Š=:™o @N ml :=:Y LTT :˘D=:> b :2: :…ˆB:2:˘gM a J :™ @ k :g K QQƒ ›OsQ j II Q O U › I •J5R 7 :gzb <:@5Hs :;<@:D=NwK :YTT :½ˆB:>5N :D3Fe:fN8 mK ‚@:„> s N T :gz bLL <:Y :…@ —a´a :g :…ˆB:@=:MMNN 5 L™ :˘@R :@=:g 5 L :…ˆB 7 7 Q Q R › OPR o OOl4T› •Q j O U :Ç@R km¹ gK :D@5 o @:_3N a ± :Y:`:˘gzT5 5[ b <<@:> s N :g€ w :AB :^F:>NNN :2i :> :> :…ˆB:`M 5 [ @« :^@ k :„> T QQ 7 ƒ 7 ŸR »œ O 5[ QQ V WX ƒ Q R I :@´PR :@È ::™5 :g{JLb g :AB:˘gz :>Ns :‹N m :½ˆB:=5 5[ :D@:Y HPÚ ˘@ È :2:gN a L :f@:;Ca N ’¿ :De:AB:˘g Jb :gz <3K :Š²Nm8 Be Q 7 X › OU 7 Q Q :\F:AB:˚gz] b :`5 uv :@Nm—´K :@:AB:2i :@M 6 =:gM L L :Y:˚>T NTT :gz b <:hF<:D=N w K :2 m l B<:B<@ 4 › :…ˆBM ! `5 [ @« :D@ H :2 i Q Q ƒ Q O4T› X 7 Q j II Q j 7 6 ¯I • 8 :>N ::2i :@PÈ :gL :AB:g w @ k :g K :AB:@ ´—R :@:D3Fe:fN8 mK ‚@:@:@ saíN e=CS³ :f@N a k :=5 [ :@ ´R:™5 :c ˆB:‡e:@ —• :…@5 5 M 3M8 :D@T U F

60 QQ QQQ [ 87 8RII K • 8› 8O s • 8 :Z5 :>3:`=NNNNK X~HT :glSl :ÁB<ˆB:…ˆB:e@5•5 :` wNN8 B:g :` w 8 B:c :…@5 5 •MM :Y˘>e:g L @:>5 H•:…@ 5 5 ƒ Q Q Q j O ›7 › O Q R R R R :gL =:fTTTb Nm˜š :>N s :AB:Y :N UT :;N :g L =:r@ b « :>NNs :AB:?@: a @5 :‡<@ T›:aNN :…@:2:…ˆB:=˘>5aN aMML T :gzb <:2 P È :…ˆB:½ˆB:g€{:g 5 }Jw :gk :M a N :g€wL8 e:g ²:YMH :>N B:g l :ÁB<ˆB:™ 5 :>N 4 :^F:˘g w ˜ I 7 I Q j Q Q 7 Ÿ•NO5a Kj ¯ }NOa œ7 O R › :@ml B<:=Kb :…ˆB:^F: N P :™:= T b Q 7 QQ Q 7 7 •8 j 8RII K O s • 8 :3B:2S i :DFe@ma58 :…@:™5 B:˘`5 [ @ «k• :^@ ::„>e@NN 5 5 :` wNN8 B:gl :` w 8 B:c :AB:3@K 5 H• :> :…@5 5 M :…ˆB:2M i :;e:;e ƒ ƒ Q 7 I 7 Q ~Omo UJMR OO H a Q Os•8 O ´ R :\F:^F:>] N :>NNT :gL =:g€Tb um :^F:g€{:g }S :> @:@5H ´ È :^fm58 :_ N aB:_N a B :@— :…ˆBM :>NN :…@5 5• M :^F:=:gL S :> B:…ˆBM 7 ƒ Q I ƒ OºNa 7 R R O R I O :_‘s :AB:2i:gS :>NNN´ e:…ˆB:=:@:gM LG Lw ˆB:\F:@:g] —O´M :Y:2:`5 N a 5 5[ ::„> UTT :gz b <:Ç~NNa e:=:Y@:˘> K a U :gz b <:Ç ~ a e:= K Q 7 Q 7 › •M[ I QOa o o 7 :™<:¼T N :D@Nm8 <@:>M aN :2:g€NNawbL :AB:˘gz :cBF:g ˆB:?@:…<= H Û :2:f a 5L :g K : 2014 LMMßsNTTOUT :…@ “ =:‡<@ L4 › :glL :…ˆB::„@:g G´ @R B: NOUT 7QQ 7 Q Q ~OOmo U PRŸ5R I ] O P R I o :Ç@Rk4 :;<@TNNTNT› :=:…ˆB:>K M N :>T <:;e:> :Ç@ R k4maa :B<@ › :™ :D@N 8 <@:™@:„gzM 5 b <:> :@ ´R B:Nm :>NNNNN´Ns :> :`=X ~H : am ˆB:…ˆB:˘>MM :…ˆB:>N B:2i :> P :2:„@N a ´R :g€zwb @:@M H m J • N5 as :3:‹K 7 Q j 7 Q › O È ŸRƒ S Ÿ R ¯ S Ÿ R Q } NLQ Q R :2:Y:2aTTTT i :>NUT :gw˜ := 5[ob :Š=:^F:„@=:™GU5 :AF@:2: <=B:=:gzM LL b :@@ a•M 5 QI7QQQ 7ƒ 7 j QQOI KQ7 QQ OOO 7 6 :2k =:Á3:g€S8 wKwo8 :g :DB:…ˆB:˘>M NNNNUTTT :g @:=:`s KNwOk :c:D@ mas}K @:2:>M a UaU :g w 88 @:=:> KK˜ ˆB:2:˘> a :g w @:= s :\<=N8 y5 7 È ::„gzb :D=NwK :@WNL B:˘>NOUT :g w J < Æ Q OU•± Òo 7 O s Os :3:…ˆB:„>KM NNT :gzb <:2PÈ :¼N :‹ @:˘D=:@3:25aTb a K W u5H :3@:> K 5 H :g{ L = Û :g K :…ˆB:>MMN :2i :@PÈ :gL :…ˆB Q 7 R 7 7R Q 7 :@‚=:NOUT g: w~k3:2K Wu5H :>NNOs :g{ L =Û :;CN ’¿ :™Ÿ5 :D@:DBqQQH y ¡ :„> O UT :g w ~ k Q Q 7 Q Osñ Q O 4T› 7 OO PsR OU ~ ŸR Q † ¦6 ŒŽ :>NNNN :DFqJ :…ˆB:2MMi :@e:2Na m ž– :> :gL :…ˆB:„D=@Tb m ~k 3:> K :D=N w K :> :„ >N T g: w k3K :™5 :> 3o B:‹ ƒ 7 ƒ I Oa O s Q ~8mo Q 8j OO4T› U •O5a 6 :>NN @:>:25H Wu5H : workers :;<@4TNNNN› 3B:>S N :><@:2:@:><@:f@ saska N Na :=:>L ::„>T :gL =:T b gJ € :3K :` M JM 7Q 7 7 I Q KQQ 7 ›Oj K I I R R :q@:c:D@– Hma}K @:AB=:gM LL :Y:„>TTNTUT :g L @=:f5 H— bNm˜š :><@:=:ö3e:=:;<@ ••LN8 4› :=:g w J |:Y:_5 NTaB:3M 8 :D@ U FN UT :‹ G @:…ˆB:`@Ma«HM 5[ :D@:2giJwJ :g˜ :g{ :f 4» :™=Û :2<@:=:LjB:˘…@ —kk • R :g Ì <@ Q Q Q Q Q › 7 KQQ7 MR ŸR Os • 8 7 :_‘s :ÍB:Y • TT :N ::˚gzb :@<:@T UmN K:;e:= K :…ˆB:…@M 5 5 •maM :NNNNNTTT :3:e<@M8 ÒakNL <:> @:2:„>5 N a :Ç@R :g K :…ˆB:YMM :„>3: K c Bqy H :…ˆB: :g L @ m 58 › I 7 › › :<@:>s NNO4T :^F:g€wo :AB:> O UT :;qJÈ :3K :>:NNNOs :gOKk B<:g :DB:Y:„>Q T O UT :gz b <<@:>s O 4 T :^F:g€ wbo :AB:gz

61 ƒ 7 Q j Q › R :^F:3S B:2i gL ˆB:\] F:^F:2 i :;3 K :2 a :EB: !`@5 [ « :^@ k :„:>NNNOUTT :gzb <:;e:g wž– :> O 4T :™Ÿ5 :…ˆB:„>M O U :gz b < Q ƒ 7 ƒ SOPR ¯ O s o š OH S :2•‘5a :c=:>TbNN :2×H5 :c=:>:_:AB:g€ K ‘ s w :g K :workers :™ @NNml :g€{:…ˆB:N P :2×H5 :c= K:™ 5 :g€wKo :g :D==:gS o LJ =:gT b € :>:N sAF@TU :AB:˘Š=o :gL =T b :g J € :>N s :bed rooms :D@ PNR Q 7 QQQ › R j [ Q :™:™›TNN •8 B:>NNOs :„gzb :@´´ºa e:g L :Y:@TTT º a e:> O P :g L :D==:…ˆB:^CSoM ÊM6 :™ ¥ F:@:D==:DB:„c — SobQ S = :c K <@ a B:^F:„c S = b 7 7 R 8 b QQ7sO 4 T› 7 7 „gzb :@m~k :¼:_M 5 ‘s :2:\:g€zN a5 w @:@3:2MM HaÕ—HK ‘5a @ X :@:?@:…<=Û :AB:3:‹:> KN :2 i :D=:@T b mHaabT @:@ 3 K :…@5 Mr. Chairman: Thank you. 7 R ƒ Q sense ::3B:gS J :motions and resolutions under Rule 218 :=5[ :`5 [ @« :_N m8 @:•F<@ a ¬ 7 :=L =T b ::of the House We can defer these for the next session. ƒ I Q 8 K ] 6 Q Oml :„>N e3 :defer :=K :™ @:D@:™5aT U 5 ::_N m8 @a :f@s H :•F<@ ¬ :C ’mN N ∗ Mr. Chairman: The Notices, Questions, Resolutions and Motions under Rule 218 received for the current session and not taken up in the House shall be taken up in the next session. Senator Farooq H. Naek: Thank you sir. Mr. Chairman: Yes, Interior Minister sahib , the concluding speech on law and order situation. Malik Mohammad Habib Khan (Minister for Interior): Mr. Chairman, sir, the honourable members of the Senate, I am grateful to you that you have allowed me to brief the honourable House on the law and order situation which is prevailing in the country with regard to the general elections. I am, at the same time, grateful to the honourable members of the House for having given me a very exhaustive input on the security concern. I stand right today on the floor of the House to perceive the security

∗ [The Questions & their replies, Notices, Resolutions and Motions are deferred for next session as ordered by the Chairman]

62 concerns and in the context of some of the political parties, I may like to submit that the role of Ministry of Interior is to support the provincial governments in maintaining law and order and security in the light of the 18th Amendment. The basic role is that of the provincial governments and our role is to provide them the support of the Civil Armed Forces which are at the disposal of Ministry of Interior. In addition to that, we provide the intelligence input which we receive from the National Security Services. I am sure that we are all well aware of National Security Services like the ISI V etc. ery recently, I have gone through across the country to meet the Chief Ministers and their team members. I have gone to Balochistan, across the border, the arrangements which have been made by Civil Armed Forces and in the light of the information that we received from the intelligence that the flow of some of the undesirable elements might take place just before the elections to create unrest and frustrate our efforts to hold elections. I was glad to see the arrangements made by the civil armed forces, the F.C. Balochistan was determined and their morale was very high. Their deployment was very effective to carry out their responsibilities to keep a check and preempt any such movement across the border which is according to our intelligence report is designed for any nefarious activities before the polling or during the polling. At the same time, I may like to submit that my visit to Karachi was very exhaustive, I have gone through the meetings with all political leaders across the board. I had a very valuable input and in the light of that, then I had the meetings with the law enforcing agencies; a comprehensive contingency plan was presented by the Government and in that contingency plan, before that, I had a meeting with the Rangers D.G. who had given his view point on the operation that is being conducted in Karachi. I

63 assure you, the D.G. Rangers is a very upright officer and I found him very well versed with the situation. He is conducting that operation across the board without any discrimination. Meeting with the law enforcing agencies, and then with the political leaders, has given me enough space and enough sense of understanding of security problems to reconcile the whole situation in the overall context of security in Karachi. I assure you, the security situation in Karachi will be conducive to the extent that we will be able to hold polls. I appreciate the steps taken by and the announcement made by three parties which have been targeted unfortunately by the militants, the terrorists which is their outlook and mindset. I donãt think that anybody has to back them off in the country because the other day I was attending the Shuhada Day in GHQ and we all heard the Chief of Army Staff, his view point was very clear that it is our war and we are fighting against them as law enforcing agencies on the front and of course, the Army is on the front fighting with the support of the public. We are all on one page to fight against terrorism, extremism and against all these undesirable elements. So, there is no doubt that we as a nation, need a collective wisdom and the Chief of Army Staff General Kayani has clarified the whole position. I think, after his speech we should be very clear on one point that as a nation you are all one and there is no discrimination whatsoever in fighting against terrorism. I would like to make a statement for record on the floor of the House because we are passing through a very critical juncture in the history of Pakistan. We have been watching this whole situation for the last four decades. It has emerged from a situation that of course, I need not to emphasize, the 9/11 incident and then subsequent developments. But now, we are at a stage that the enemy is a terrorist and the enemy from within and we have to

64 fight against this enemy. It is our war and we will have to fight it out. I will read this little statement just to put it on record. I have no hesitation in saying that the overall environment prevailing in the country for the last 12 years as we reached at a point where we need the collective wisdom to assist the law enforcement agencies and armed forces. This also entails public support and confidence for fighting the war against terrorists. Mr. Chairman, sir, we are facing a post generation war. This is a war which is aimed to destabilize the State and to bring public at clash against the national security forces. I must also inform this august House that the hostile elements in the country, who are accelerating the process through clandestine means, must be frustrated by public support. The law enforcing agencies at our command are fully committed to fight against this menace. Mr. Chairman: Thank you. Malik Mohammad Habib Khan: With this statement, I will just add one thing more that the contingency plan which has been presented by the respective provincial governments is comprehensive and the support of civil armed forces and the army deployment has been worked out in coordination with the military authorities. The Secretary Defence was present in one of the meetings with the Election Commission. Of course, we are all on board. We have to work as a team for this national cause. The deployment of army is fully worked out particularly in Karachi in certain areas, where there are certain apprehensions that law and order might be disturbed during the polling or before polling. In Balochistan province, particularly in certain districts, there are eight to ten districts where the army is going to be deployed. I have no doubt that we are able to conduct the polls. It is not all peace

65 during the elections as there are odd incidents taking place in which nobody can help, but certainly, we will be able to hold the elections and allow the people to go to the polling. The security environments; if you look at it genuinely, last three or four days with the contingency plan, the nefarious designs of the militancy, the undesirable elements have been pre-empted and they are not allowed to carry out their major operations, whereas they are designed to carry out major operation and we have intelligence reports. With this, I will sum up and not take your time, we have a complete contingency plan and we are going to hold meeting in this regard. The Prime Minister has held the meeting today and the final meeting is going to take place on the 4 th of this month to finally monitor and see if there is any loophole in the contingency plan, we will try to make up that and Mr. Chairman thank you very much and the honourable members of the Senate, I am grateful that I have been provided this opportunity to brief you on law and order. Thank you very much. Mr. Chairman: Thank you. Keeping in view the concerns of the members of the House, the Caretaker Government is hereby asked to provide level playing field to all democratic political forces, parties for participation in general elections to be held on 11 th of May. Yes, Leader of the House. Senator Farooq H. Naek (Leader of the House): Thank you. Sir, as far as my appointment as the Leader of the House is concerned, I must tell Shah sahib is a good friend of mine, that I was asked to take up this position. I made it very clear that I would be here to regulate the business of the Senate or whatever the Governmentãs policies are, the Minister would be there to

66 defend them. I am not an extension and because of my experience as a Chairman Senate; it was thought that I would be able to regulate the business of the Senate and the proceedings of the Senate. Its proof is this that this is the first time Mr. Chairman that you should see the presence of such number of Ministers. You are the Chairman and I also had been the Chairman, about 14 or 15 Ministers are there in the Caretaker Cabinet and out of them now 8 Ministers are present. It shows that the Senate business is being regulated very well. The apprehensions of Shah sahib I would like to put them at rest and I am not defending anybody. Thank you sir. Mr. Chairman: Thank you. We appreciate your efforts. In the exercise of powers conferred by clause (3) of Article 54 read with Article 61 of the Constitution of the Islamic Republic of Pakistan, I hereby prorogue the Senate on the conclusion of its business on Thursday, the 2 nd May, 2013. Sd/- (Syed Nayyar Hussain Bokhari) Chairman Senate

------[The Senate was prorogued sine die]

------

67